Tracks and Trails Strategy - Bass Coast Shire Council 2022 2032 - Engage Bass Coast
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
Contents 1.0 Introduction 5 1.1 Background 6 1.2 Approach 7 1.3 Shire Overview 8 2.0 Market Analysis 9 2.1 Industry Trends 10 2.2 Wider Context 12 2.3 Local Context 14 3.0 Strategic Context 17 FT 3.1 Literature Review 18 3.2 Consultation 20 A 3.3 Trail Network Vision 21 R 3.4 Trail Levels of Service 22 D 4.0 Existing Trail Network 25 4.1 Existing Trails Network 26 4.2 Challenges and Opportunities 27 5.0 Implementation 28 5.1 Implementation 29 5.2 Trail Prioritisation Tool 30 5.3 New Trail Projects 34 5.4 Investment 44 5.5 Funding 45 5.6 Marketing 46 5.7 Conclusion 47 6.0 Appendices 48 Appendix 1 Literature Review 49 Appendix 2 Levels of Service 54 Appendix 3 Trails In Bass Coast 61 Bass Coast Tracks and Trails Strategy 3
Executive Summary • recreation trends and preferences Bass Coast Shire Council is responsible for the • existing trails network gaps management of a diverse range of trails, located • physical linkages/connections in both coastal and urban environments. Within • trails market segments the scope of this project, the existing trails • gaps in the provision network on land managed by the Shire currently • opportunities to improve community health extends to 167km of recognised trail, comprising and wellbeing outcomes 272 discrete trails that provide opportunities for • opportunities to develop the visitor walking and cycling. economy (and the Shire’s trails offer) Beyond the scope of this project, on land To effectively prioritise the development of the managed by Parks Victoria, Department of Land, proposed trail network a trail prioritisation Water and Planning and Phillip Island Nature framework has been developed. New trail Park, there exists a further network of on and projects were assessed based on a set criteria and off-road walking and cycling trails within Bass the overall score each trail received determined FT Coast Shire. the trail priority order and whether trails were classified as high, medium or low priority. The demand and appetite for trails is growing A rapidly. Recent circumstances relating to the High level cost estimates have been assigned to global COVID-19 pandemic have had largely each project to help guide Council’s long term R unforeseen influences on the value people financial planning. Costs indicated are purely place on trails, resulting in significant increased construction costs and does not include design, D utilisation of these amenities. With this demand, planning or permits. Bass Coast Shire Council has an important role to play in creating a healthy and connected The total investment needed for new trail community through trail provision. projects detailed in this strategy is $42.2 million, broken down into: A Tracks and Trails Strategy was developed in 2022 with the aim of creating a trail network • High Priority - $21.40 million that “offered a connected and accessible trail • Medium Priority - $17.3 million network that supports active and healthy • Low Priority - $3.5 million communities, showcases and protects the natural environment and encourages increased visitation to the region.” Throughout the strategy development, importance has been placed on trails that provide connectivity, health and wellbeing outcomes, accessibility, tourism and connection to nature. This strategy identifies 38 new trail opportunities to expand the trail network that have been identified during the development of this strategy, (emerging from background research, existing plans and key stakeholder consultation) and respond specifically to: Bass Coast Tracks and Trails Strategy 4
1.1 Background Bass Coast Shire Council is responsible for the • Identify priority trail connections between management of a diverse range of trails, located townships, and key visitor destinations in both coastal and urban environments. • Develop an implementation plan that will guide Council’s decision-making and Xyst was engaged by Bass Coast Shire Council delivery of tracks and trails for a 10 year to develop a “Tracks and Trails Strategy” with period. the overall purpose of creating a diverse and accessible trail network that caters for a variety A series of recommendations of short, medium of user groups. The purpose of this Strategy is and long term opportunities on how Bass to: Coast can improve its trail network has been developed. These recommendations relate to • Consolidate all the historical and current new trails opportunities identified. work related to tracks and trails within the Shire to ensure that all previous A 10 year capital works program based on FT planning and consultation is taken into assessment scores, including costing estimates consideration when establishing new and overall experience to the trail user has priorities been developed for Bass Coast. A • Establish clear and transparent processes / framework for council to develop, deliver, Council’s Role in Tracks and R promote and maintain tracks and trails Trails within the Shire D • Identify major themes and common issues Bass Coast Shire Council has an important noted across the trail network to inform role to play in creating a healthy and connected priorities community through trail provision. • Analyse current and future demographics of Bass Coast to understand future Figure 1 sets out the roles that Council plays demand in the provision of trails for the Bass Coast • Understand trends in trail usage to predict community. future demand Council’s Role Description Council provides information to the community about trail opportunities Information Provider via promotion and marketing. Council advocates for state and federal government funding and Advocate investment in new trail projects. Council ensures that trails are provided and used in accordance with the Regulator local law, policies and procedures. Council plays a key role in maintaining trail networks located on Council Maintainer managed land. Figure 1. Council’s Role in Tracks and Trails Bass Coast Tracks and Trails Strategy 6
1.2 Approach 1. Research and Analysis Desktop research Literature review Key industry trends Current trail mapping Key visitor destinations FT 2. Collaborative Visioning Deep dive interviews key with stakeholders Internal workshop A Levels of service framework R Identify needs and gaps in existing network D 3. Opportunity Exploration Identify opportunities On-ground assessments Develop assessment tool Assess trail opportunities 4. Develop Strategy Trail concept plan development Implementation plan Proposed trail mapping Cost estimates 5. Community Review Public exhibition Adoption Bass Coast Tracks and Trails Strategy 7
1.3 Shire Overview Bass Coast Shire is located about 130 kilometres municipalities with tourism and agriculture south-east of Melbourne and is predominantly as the two major industries. Cattle and dairy a coastal municipality with a unique coastline farming are the area’s agricultural backbone. complemented by a beautiful hinterland. Bass Coast is home to a population of 33, 581 Bass Coast Shire has a vast array of recreation (ABS estimated resident population 2016) and reserves, parks, community spaces, sports by 2036, the population for Bass Coast Shire stadiums, an aquatic facility, a network of off-road is forecast to increase to over 47,000, at an trails including the iconic and popular George average annual change of two per cent. The Bass Coastal Walk and Bass Coast Rail Trail, and Shire encompasses a total land area of 865 some of the most valued coastal environments square kilometres, including over 100km of in Victoria. Of note, Bass Coast was declared coastal shore lines. as a distinctive area and landscape to protect coastal environment, further highlighting the Bass Coast is home to many small coastal or value of this coastal environment. agricultural villages, with some larger townships FT scattered amongst them. Established as a coal The Shire has significant waterways including mining town in the early 1900s, Wonthaggi is Screw Creek, Powlett and Bass Rivers along today a large regional centre not only for Bass A with protected wetlands. Phillip Island hosts Coast, but for surrounding areas, and is the major tourist attractions including the world main source of employment within the Shire, R famous little penguins and a number of natural particularly in health, education, community attractions including a national surfing reserve. service and construction. D Bass Coast Shire offers a unique lifestyle in Many of the coastal villages are also characterised beautiful natural surrounds. Ever improving by large numbers of holiday homes. Whilst the transport links, paired with Melbourne’s permanent population of the Shire has been continuous expansion, means the northern parts growing strongly in recent years, the population of the Shire are included within the commuting also swells significantly to well over 70,000 belt of Melbourne’s outer south eastern suburbs. during holiday periods. The Shire is visited by Bass Coast is one of the few Victorian 35 per cent of Melbourne’s total international visitors each year. Figure 2. Location of Bass Coast Shire Council Figure 3. Bass Coast Shire Council Towns and Suburbs Bass Coast Tracks and Trails Strategy 8
2.1 Industry Trends Increasing Demand become active again, and it is likely that over the The demand and appetite for trails is growing coming decade their use will equal or exceed rapidly. This is largely driven by an increase the use of traditional bikes and will increase in unstructured recreational activities such the number of people cycling for recreation as walking and cycling. In Australia, walking and commuting, particularly in aging population is currently ranked as the most popular group. recreation activity, whilst cycling is the fifth most popular and bush walking the sixth most Economic Benefits popular (Sports Australia AusPlay Survey, 2021). While participation is increasing in trail related activities, there is also growing evidence of the Other trail related activities and sports are also economic benefits that trails bring to a region. starting to become more popular such as trail A trail success story is that of Derby, a small running or ultra-running. A survey conducted town in North-East Tasmania. The Blue Derby found participation in trail running events mountain bike trail network opened in 2014 has increased by 1676% in the last 23 years and has since transformed the whole region. In worldwide (RunRepeat, 2020). New forms of just a few years, Derby has gone from a ghost FT trail use are also starting to come online such as town to a thriving town. The $3.1 million, 80km ‘forest bathing,’ a trend popular in Japan which network is reportedly attracting more than involves walking in any natural environment and 30,000 visitors every year, who, on average, A consciously connecting with what’s around you. spend four to five nights in the area, creating R an annual economic impact of approximately Technological Advances $18 million for the region. The town of Derby D Technological advances have enabled more has seen new businesses open; accommodation people to take up recreational activities on beds increase (from 12 rooms to more than trails. With the influence of the internet, social 70 rooms) and a wave of residential and media, smart phones and apps, people are able commercial real estate acquisitions. to obtain information, communicate with each other and provide feedback on their recreation Government Investment experience at any time. A large proportion of Not only are local Councils realising the people choose where to go and what to do economic benefits trails can bring, so too are based on the information they see online via State and Federal Governments. The level the internet, social media, blogs and forums. of investment in recent years in trail related Changes in technology and equipment are also projects is significant. In Queensland, the encouraging more people to recreate on trails, Australian Government has recently invested particularly in the sport of cycling. The growth $36 million for the Wangetti Trail in Tropical of e-bikes (electronic bicycles) has enabled North Queensland. In Victoria, the Warburton people to overcome barriers that might face Mountain Bike Project has received $11.3 with a traditional bike. Riders can now go million in Government funding, making it the further, ride longer and are more comfortable largest funded mountain bike trail project with gradients meaning planning trail networks potentially in the Southern Hemisphere. needs to account for this. Electric bikes are starting to drop in price making them more The benefits of trails continue to be recognised affordable for more people. They are seen as critical to delivering community health and as potential gateways for inactive people to wellbeing outcomes. This is referenced in State Bass Coast Tracks and Trails Strategy 10
and Federal strategic policy approaches, and or ecological heritage experts) will enable early also at a local government level in strategic identification of issues and opportunities and documents such as Health and Wellbeing assist in avoiding unnecessary delays, financial Strategies, Recreation and Open Space costs and environmental impacts. Strategies. Rise in Use of Trails Trail Industry Events There has also been a recent trend for Council’s Events within the trail industry contribute to develop active transport strategies, with the significantly to the economic benefits of trails aim of encouraging their communities to walk and these are also increasing with popularity. or cycle as an alternative to car travel. These Not only is the number of participants in strategies incorporate the use of recreation events generally increasing but so too is the trails and can increase the number of people number of trail related events. In trail running using them which may put additional strain on in 1996, only 14% of runners participated in capacity and potential for user conflict. multiple races a year, now 41% of participants run more than one event per year (RunRepeat Recent circumstances relating to the global 2020). Big events such as Ultra-Trail Australia, COVID-19 pandemic have had largely Buffalo Stampede, the Taupo Ultra and unforeseen influences on the value people Moonlight Shotover Marathon are some of place on the parks and trails network, resulting FT the popular trail running events out of many. in significant increased utilisation of these Within the sport of mountain biking, big events amenities. Usage data from the Lilydale to such as UCI/ Union Cycliste Internationale, Sea Warburton Rail Trail reflects a 49% increase A Otter Classic and Crankworx bring enormous in trail use during September 2020 when amounts of participants and visitors to a region compared to trail use during September 2019. R to watch and enjoy the event. D More and more trail projects are being initiated Professionally Built Trails as Councils capitalise on the Government The trails industry is also evolving, particularly grants available, utilise professional trail builders in the sport of mountain biking. Historically, and seek to reap the benefits trails can bring to there has been a strong culture of informal/ a region. unauthorised mountain bike trail construction (without land manager consent). These trails The 2013 CSIRO report for the Australian are often built in unsafe and unsustainable ways Sports Commission identified six megatrends which cause damage and lead to significant likely to shape the Australian sports sector relationship issues with land managers and the over the next 30 years and remains relevant community. today. The industry is now shifting towards A number of these ‘mega trends’ are relevant professionally built and planned trails. to trail-based recreation activities, notably the Companies now exist that plan and build ability to participate in these activities at your sustainable trails in a safer and environmentally own convenience (‘A Perfect Fit’), with some sensitive way and focus on delivering trail activities likely to be considered as lifestyle, experiences that meet identified demand. adventure or alternative sports, requiring Early engagement of qualified professionals in complex/advanced skills with an element of their respective fields (whether that be trail danger and/or thrill-seeking (‘From Extreme planning, design, construction, cultural, historic to Mainstream’). The benefits to mental and physical health and wellbeing are also recognised (‘More than Sport’). Bass Coast Tracks and Trails Strategy 11
2.2 Wider Context National Recreation Participation Key findings of the report include: Four of the top six recreation activities • There has been a national increase in adult participated in by Australians are directly participation in sport and physical activity related to trail-based pursuits; recreational at higher frequencies, which appears to be walking (47%), running and athletics (19.8%), driven by women cycling (14.3%) and bush walking (8.6%). • An increase in high frequency walking for females Fitness/gym (37.4%) and swimming (17.1%) • Sustained increase in participation in also feature in the top six activities, with yoga many physical activities, the top five of (6.9%), soccer (5.5%), golf (5.4%) and tennis which are identified as ‘endurance/health’ (5.0%) round out the top ten activities. activities; walking (recreational), running/ jogging/athletics, cycling, bush walking and swimming Trail Destinations FT A review of established and proposed prominent (although not exhaustive) trail destinations and experiences across Australia A is summarised in table 1. For each destination, the core product/market is identified, together R with the destination’s proximity to local, regional and state (capital) population centres. D Visitation data relating to the use of trails across Australia is limited. Forecast and estimated annual visitation data for each destination has been derived from a variety of sources including media releases and strategic planning documents (e.g. feasibility studies, economic impact assessments, trail strategies and master plans). Few current trail destinations are able Figure 4. National Recreation Participation Rates to report accurately on trail usage data. The inclusion of this data is provided as a general guide only, to assist with informing Impacts of COVID-19 future recommendations through comparison Recent impacts on physical activity participation of relative scale/nature of trail development, rates relating to COVID-19 continue to distances from population centres and emerge and evolve and, while questions estimated visitation volumes. remain as to the long and short term impacts, it appears that COVID-19 has accelerated forecast megatrends, in particular ‘A Perfect Fit’, which highlighted the rise of individualised activities, such as recreational trail use. (Ongoing impact of COVID-19 on sport and physical activity participation June 2021 update, SportAus Ausplay). Bass Coast Tracks and Trails Strategy 12
Table 1. Trail Destinations: Walk/Cycle/Rail Trails Trail Experience: Proximity to Population Centres Forecast/ Walk/Cycle/Rail Trail Centre (population, travel time by car) Estimated Annual Visitation Destination Product/Market Local Regional State Murray to Melbourne 100km walk, cycle, Wangaratta Mountains - (5.2.M, 315,500 bridle rail trail (30,000) VIC 165 mins) Murray River 1,400km walk and Melbourne Echuca Adventure cycle trail, 1,000km - (5.2.M,, 110,000 (15,000) Trail VIC paddle trail 165 mins) Great Melbourne 134km walk, cycle Tallarook Mansfield Victorian Rail (5.2.M,, 92,000 and bridle rail trail (750) (3,500) Trail VIC 75 mins) Perth FT Bibbulmun 1,000km long dis- Kalamunda - (2.M, 80,000 Track WA tance walk trail (7,000) 35 mins) A Otago Middle- Dunedin Christchurch 152km walk and Central Rail march (134,000, (395,000, 65,000 cycle rail trail Trail NZ (160) 60 mins) 290 mins) R Dunsbor- D Busselton Perth Cape to Cape ough 135km walk trail (40,000, (2.M, 44,000 Track WA (5,350, 35 mins) 180 mins) 15 mins) Grampians Stawell Melbourne 160km multi-day Dunkeld Peak Trail (6,000, (5.2.M, 34,000 hike (13 days) (700) VIC 20 mins) 180 mins) Launceston Hobart NE Rail Trail Scottsdale 26km rail trail. (124,000, (250,000, 23,000 TAS (2,400) 60 mins) 190 mins) East Melbourne 100km walk, cycle, Bairnsdale Gippsland - (5.2.M, 22,500 and bridle rail trail (15,000) Rail Trail VIC 200 mins) 48km walk trail (4 Port Arthur Carlton/ Hobart Three Capes days). Pay-to-use. (250, Dodges Ferry (250,000, 12,000 Track TAS Visitor numbers 10 mins by (3,600, 90 mins) controlled. boat) 50 ins) Cradle Moun- 65km walk trail (6 Queenstown Hobart tain Overland days). Visitor num- - (2,500, (250,000, 9,000 Track TAS bers controlled. 75 mins) 150 mins) Bass Coast Tracks and Trails Strategy 13
2.3 Local Context In 2016, the region overall had a population of The 40-64 age cohort is the largest across just over 32,000 people. Accurate population the region (34.2%), with a median age of 50 forecasts across the region are not available, years. This differs from Victoria and Australia however, 2020 Estimated Residential Population demographic data where the 15-39 age cohort numbers indicate an increase of approximately is the largest (34.8% and 33.9% respectively). 4,641 people (~3%) for the Bass Coast Region. While the percentage of the region’s 0-14 year Between 2021 and 2036, the population of Bass old population are slightly lower to state and Coast Shire is forecast to increase by 10,346 national figures, there is a notable difference people (28.7 per cent growth) at an average between the region’s 15-39 year old population annual change of 1.7 per cent. (21.7%), state figures (34.8%) and national figures (33.9%). The region’s proportion of the There are more females than males across the oldest cohort 65+ years of age (27.7%) is also region (52% to 48%), which is also true for each considerably higher than state figures (15.6%) individual Council area, with the exception of the and national figures (15.8%). FT Westernport and Rural Townships. A R 2016 D Age Age Age Age Age Population Male Female Census 0-14 15-39 40-64 65+ Median Phillip Island 10,685 48.8% 51.2% 17.6% 21.6% 36.2% 24.6% 48 San Remo 1,264 47.7% 52.3% 14.2% 15.8% 34.4% 31.7% 53 Westernport 3,954 50.4% 49.6% 17% 21.1% 36.3% 25.6% 52 Townships Wonthaggi 6,272 49.7% 50.3% 17.9% 24.7% 31.8% 25.6% 46 Inverloch 5,465 47.9% 52.1% 17% 19.7% 32.2% 31.2% 52 Rural 2,658 50.9% 49.1% 18.8% 23.9% 38.6% 18.7% 45 BASS COAST 32,804 48.5% 51.5% 16.3% 21.7% 34.2% 27.7% 50 Victoria 5,926,624 49.1% 50.9% 18.3% 34.8% 31.4% 15.6% 37 Australia 23,401,886 49.3% 50.7% 18.7% 33.9% 31.9% 15.8% 38 Table 2. Bass Coast Population and Age Groups Source: ABS 2016 Census QuickStats Bass Coast Tracks and Trails Strategy 14
Median weekly household income across Bass 7% of the Bass Coast workers work from home, Coast averages at $927, well below both the significantly higher than the state average (4.6%) state ($1,416) and national averages ($1,431). and the national average (4.7%). With Covid, it is expected this figure has significantly risen. 71% of Bass Coast residents travel to work by car, either as driver or passenger, slightly higher Key points and implications: than state (67%) and national averages (67.7%). • Limited public transportation infrastructure provision and utilisation across the region Public transport use by commuters averages • Reliance on private vehicles for transport at 1% across the region, which is significantly (noting a significantly higher proportion of lower than the state average (12.4%) and the the population work from home compared national average (11.4%). to state and national averages) • Relatively high proportion of the community 3.9% of the Bass Coast workers walked to walk to work (compared to state average) work, slightly higher than the state average (3.2%) and the national average (3.5%). This data is based on 2016 census data; up-to- date data will become available from June 2022, 0.8% of the Bass Coast workers cycled to work, based on August 2021 census data. FT slightly lower than the state average (1.2%) and the national average (1%). A R Median Travel to Work D Weekly 2016 Population House- Public Work Census hold Walk/ Car Trans- from Income Cycle port Home BASS COAST 32,804 $927 71% 1.1% 4.7% 7% Victoria 5,926,624 $1,416 67% 12.4% 4.7% 4.6% Australia 23,401,886 $1,438 67.7% 11.4% 4.5% 4.7% Table 3. Bass Coast Income and Commuter Metrics Bass Coast Tracks and Trails Strategy 15
Regional Visitation Tourism is an important industry for Bass Coast, particularly Phillip Island. Analysis of available data collected over the course of recent years reveals the following: • The region received approximately 2.7 million domestic (overnight and day trip) and international overnight visitors combined (pre-COVID) • Visitors spent an estimated $578 million in the year ending December 2019. • The region received approximately 1.1 million overnight visitors per annum • Phillip Island attracts the highest number of visitors in the Shire due to its tourism offerings and longstanding tourism reputation FT • The average length of stay for domestic visitors is three nights • The most common activities while visiting A the region was to visit the beach (65%), eat out (61%), sight seeing (36%), bush R walking (22%) and shopping and markets (20%) D Source: National and International Visitor Surveys and Regional Expenditure Model Region Domestic International TOTAL Visitation Day trip 1,517,000 1,141,000 2,658,000 Visitors Day trip $137 million - - Expenditure Overnight 1,084,000 57,000 1,141,000 Visitors Overnight $416 million $26 million $442 million Expenditure Table 4. Bass Coast Region Visitation 2019 Bass Coast Tracks and Trails Strategy 16
FT A R D 3.0 Strategic Context Bass Coast Tracks and Trails Strategy 17
3.1 Literature Review The following documents were reviewed to provide strategic context to the project and inform future recommendations and options in relation to the trails network in Bass Coast. Relevant details from these documents are outlined in Appendix 1. Table 5. Strategic Documents Document Instruct Inform Support Bass Coast Dinosaurs Trail Masterplan 2021 x Yallock-Bulluk Marine and Coastal Park Draft x Access and Infrastructure Plan 2021 Cowes Access and Movement Study May 2021 x FT Wonthaggi Access and Movement Study July x 2020 A Gippsland Tracks and Trails Feasibility Study x (September 2019) R Active Bass Coast 2018-2028 x D Bass Coast Shire Aspirational Network x Pathways Plan 2016 Bicycle Infrastructure Action Plan 2012 to 2022 x Summerland Peninsula Trails Master Plan x (January 2017) Road Asset Management Plan 2019 -2023 x Cowes Activity Centre Plan 2015 x Rhyll Traffic Management Plan February 2015 x Phillip Island and San Remo Visitor Economy x Strategy 2035 August 2016 Bass Coast Tracks and Trails Strategy 18
Document Instruct Inform Support Phillip Island South and North Coast Key Area x Plan October 2014 San Remo Access Strategy 2013 x Bass Coast Bicycle Strategy Volume 1 2000 x Towards 2030 Gippsland Destination x Management Plan & Appendix Gippsland Odessey Trail x Council Plan 2021-2025 x Open Space Asset Management Plan x Healthy Communities Plan 2021-2025 x Bass Coast Community Vision x FT Access Equity and Inclusion Plan x A Climate Change Action Plan 2020 – 2030 x R Urban Roads and Drainage Improvement Policy x 2019 D Victorian Cycling Strategy 2018-28 x Bass Coast Municipal Road Safety Committee x Strategic Plan 2018 - 2021 Victoria’s Trails Strategy 2014–24 x Safe to School Maps 2015 x Phillip Island Integrated Transport Study 2014 x George Bass Coastal Walk: Trail Site Visit x Report July 2016 Victoria’s Cycling Strategy 2018-2028 x Road Safety Plan x Bass Coast Tracks and Trails Strategy 19
3.2 Consultation Stakeholders As part of the project, various Council Connectivity stakeholders were engaged with to understand Stakeholders citied the opportunities to their views on the trail network within Bass improve connections between existing Coast. recreational trails, townships and the footpath network. The following internal teams from Bass Coast Shire Council were consulted with: Investment • Recreation and Leisure Stakeholders are enthusiastic about investing • Asset Management in the trail network. Investment in trails over • Visitor Economy the next 10 years is a priority for Council. As • Placemaking evidenced by a $1M per year commitment to • Major Projects new trail capital projects. FT The following external groups from Bass Coast Shire Council were consulted with: Mountain Biking A The lack of formalised mountain bike trails • Phillip Island Integrated Transport Study in Bass Coast is an issue. Stakeholder raised R Group concerns, in particular, about the informal trails D • Phillip Island Nature Parks constructed by the community and their impact • Parks Victoria on native vegetation. • Destination Gippsland • Wonthaggi Desalination Plant • Visit Phillip Island Public Land It was acknowledged that Bass Coast has very little public land to accommodate new trails. Key Themes Additionally, a large proportion of the current trail network is located on and managed by other public land managers, such as Parks The following key themes were identified Victoria and Phillip Island Nature Parks. throughout stakeholder consultation: Stakeholders indicated that it will be difficult to connect some parts of the trail network due to Active Transport private land ownership. Bass Coast’s recreational trails provide active transportation opportuntites for locals. Stakeholders indicated that some on- road cycling infrastructure, primarily used for commuting on Phillip Island, is in need of improvement. On-road commuter trails can complement recreational trails by helping build connections, however planning for on-road bike lanes is outside the scope of this project. It is recommended that an Integrated Transport Study be considered as a separate project to address on-road cycling networks. Bass Coast Tracks and Trails Strategy 20
3.3 Trail Network Vision Bass Coast offers a connected and accessible trail network that supports active and healthy communities, showcases and protects the natural environment and encourages increased visitation FT to the region. A R D The following principles will guide the delivery and management of trails through this Strategy; Connectivity – Trails provide links between Tourism – Trails attract visitors from all over townships and key destinations to enable users Australia and internationally, encouraging to explore all Bass Coast has to offer. tourism spend in the local townships. Health and Wellbeing – Trails enable Connection to Nature – Trails showcase and and encourage more people to get active, allow users to connect and engage with the contributing to a healthier and happier natural environment and unique landscape of community. Bass Coast. Accessibility – Trails are easily accessible, free to use and safe which encourages intuitive exploration of the expansive landscapes around Bass Coast. Bass Coast Tracks and Trails Strategy 21
3.4 Trail Levels Of Service The primary purpose of levels of service is to shared trail with many additional features define a standard and expectation for what is including rubbish bins, signage, bike racks, to be delivered to the the trail user. exercise equipment etc. Defining and documenting levels of service is a The following points sumarise the process fundamental business process that can be used undertaken to establish suitable levels of to drive and influence all activities and decision service for Bass Coast tracks and trails. making relating to the services provided. Trail Categories This process determines the quantity, quality and range of services to be provided in a Identifying trail categories assists in planning financially sustainable manner. When setting for trail networks and clearly communicating out to develop a new trail or upgrade an existing primary uses of individual trails to the one, it is important to have first determined the community. level of service Council are aiming to achieve. FT The following trail categories have been For instance, a shared use recreation trail such developed as outlined in Table 6. as a rural rail trail has quite different levels of A service when compared with an urban sealed R D Alternative Typical Trail Category Primary Purpose Names Characteristics Trails that provide • Either sealed or unsealed Shared Use, Dual opportunities for recreation for • Dual-use, shared path- Shared Use Use, Rail Trail, multiple users including but ways Trail Walk, Cycle, not limited to walkers, runners • Wider widths Commuter and cyclists • Can be in an urban setting Trails that are generally • Unsealed (gravel), natural located within a natural setting Bushland, surface (dirt/earth/grass) Walking Trail (most often bushland), with a Coastal, Hiking • Within a bushland, farm- natural surface, typically used land or coastal setting for hiking and trail running Trails that are generally • Unsealed, natural surface Equestrian located through open pasture Bridle, Horse • Within a bushland, farm- Trail and bushland, with a natural land or coastal setting surface • Unsealed, natural surface Either a single trail or net- Mountain Bike Unsealed trails in natural Off Road work of trails Trail terrain, often single track • Within a bushland, off-road setting • Unsealed, natural surface, Beach Access Trails primarily used to gain typically sandy Trail access to the beach. Within a coastal and beach setting Table 6. Recreational Trail Categories Bass Coast Tracks and Trails Strategy 22
Quality Standards Categorising Bass Coast Trails Trail category levels of service are further Once the set of trail categories and quality categorised into different quality standards. A standards were defined, current Bass Coast general premise of this approach is that the trails are each assigned into a category and higher the level of utilisation, the higher the quality standard. level of quality and the greater the level of asset provision/embellishment. When looking at trails with multiple uses, the principal activity/characteristic associated with To establish the levels of quality standards, a trail was the key focus. For example, a walking industry trail standards or classification systems trail that is principally used by hikers, may also have been adapted. get secondary use by horse riders but should still be classified primarily as a walking trail. The use of industry standards provides consistency of understanding for multi- The level of utilisation is a key factor in jurisdiction trails and users generally. determining the appropriate quality standard. For example, in bush walking, there are five industry recognised classes of trail, therefore Asset Provision five quality standards have been established for bushland trails that correspond with the The last step in developing the levels of service existing classifications. framework was to define the range of assets provided, their quality and quantity. A distinct hierarchy of quality standards provides transparency and clarity for the The range of assets such as bike racks, drinking community, along with an understanding of fountains, furniture, etc. that are required to what they can expect when using a higher support the trail networks have been itemised quality standard trail vs a lower quality standard (refer appendix 2). trail. They will vary between different trail categories, Using a tiered quality standard approach (as and the number, quality and range of assets opposed to the same standard everywhere) decrease or increase depending on the quality will help improve efficiencies and better meet (and levels of utilisation) of the trail. community expectations. The highest standard of trails will be the most expensive to operate and maintain as they usually cater for the highest number of users. To make the overall network affordable, a second tier of trails has a lower, moderate level of service applied. A third tier of trails, the largest in number, have lower standards and lower levels of use. Bass Coast Tracks and Trails Strategy 23
Trail Quality Description Category Standard Shared Use Trail A high use shared/dual use trail, often sealed. A large range and number of high Trails that provide QS1 quality assets provided, and maintained to the highest standard. opportunities for recreation for A moderate use recreation trail, either sealed or unsealed. A good range and multiple users QS 2 number of quality assets provided, and maintained at a high standard. including, but not limited to walkers, runners and A low use recreation trail, often unsealed with few basic quality assets provided QS 3 cyclists. and maintained to a basic standard. No bush walking experience required. Flat even surface with no steps or steep sections. Maximum slope of 1:14 ( 7.14% or 4.1 degrees). Suitable for wheelchairs QS 1 designed for outdoor use or wheelchair users who have someone to assist them. Width of 1200mm or more. Walks no greater than 5km. No bush walking experience required. The track is a hardened or compacted Walking Trail surface and may have a gentle hill section or sections and occasional steps. QS 2 Trails generally Generally no steeper than 1:10 (10% or 5.7 degrees). Width of 900mm or more. within a bushland Walks no greater than 10km. or coastal setting, Suitable for most ages and fitness levels. Some bush walking experience with a natural recommended. Tracks may have short steep hill sections a rough surface and QS 3 surface, typically many steps May exceed 1:10. Width variable but less than 1200mm. Walks up to used for hiking and 20km. FT trail running. Bush walking experience recommended. Tracks may be long, rough and very QS 4 steep. May include long steep sections to a maximum of 1:8 (12.5% or 7.1 degrees). Directional signage may be limited. A Very experienced bush walkers with specialised skills, including navigation and QS 5 emergency first aid. Tracks are likely to be very rough, very steep and unmarked. R May include long steep sections exceeding 1:8. Walks may be more than 20km. A horse riding trail, designed to be used by beginners. Most likely to be access D tracks or wide single tracks (3m-3.7m) with a gentle gradient (not exceeding 10%), Equestrian Trail QS 1 smooth surface and a relatively obstacle free, hardened natural surface Main- Trails generally tained to the highest standard maintained to the highest standard. through open A horse riding trail, designed to be used by intermediate riders. Most likely to be a pasture and QS 2 combination of single trail and/or fire road with obstacles, variable surface, and a bushland, with a moderate slope with a width of 1.5m to 3.7m. Maintained to a high standard. natural surface, typically used for A horse riding trail, designed to be used by advanced riders. Most likely to consist horse riding. of challenging single trail and/or fire road with many obstacles, variable surface, QS 3 and steep sections with a width of 1.5m to 2.5m. Some trail routes may not be marked at all. Maintained to a basic standard. A mountain bike trail, designed to be used by beginners. Likely to be a combination of fire road or wide single track (900mm) with a gentle gradient, QS 1 Mountain Bike smooth surface and relatively free of unavoidable mountain bike features and Trail obstacles. Maintained to the highest standard. Unsealed trails A mountain bike trail, designed to be used by intermediate riders. Likely to be a in natural terrain, QS 2 single trail (600mm) with moderate gradients, variable surface and mountain bike typically used for features.. Maintained to a high standard. mountain biking. A mountain bike trail, designed to be used by advanced riders. Likely to be a QS 3 challenging single trail (300mm) with steep gradients, variable surface and many mountain bike features. Maintained to a basic standard. Beach Access Trail Typically DDA Accessible, firm stabilised surfaces or permanent wearing course QS 1 Trails located on and 2m+ wide with lookouts, railing, seating, shower and water.. the coast, primarily used to gain access to the QS 2 A moderate use beach access trail, maintained to a high standard. beach. Table 7. Trail Quality Standards Bass Coast Tracks and Trails Strategy 24
FT A R D 4.0 Existing Trail Network Bass Coast Tracks and Trails Strategy 25
4.1 Existing Trails Network Within the scope of this project, the existing trails network on land managed by Bass Coast currently extends to 167km of recognised trail, comprising 272 discrete trails that provide opportunities for walking and cycling. There are 50 recreation trails (118km), 38 walking trails (36km) and 184 beach access trails (13km). Currently there are no Council developed mountain bike or equestrian trails located on Council managed land. A full list of Bass Coast Trails and assigned levels of service can be found in Appendix 3. Beyond the scope of this project, on land managed by Parks Victoria, Department of Land, Water and Planning and Phillip Island Nature Park, there exists a further network of on and off-road walking and cycling trails within Bass Coast Shire. Table 8. Existing Trails Network Number and Kilometre Shared Use Walking Mountain Equestrian Beach Access Trail Trail Bike Trail Trail Trail FT No. Km No. Km No. Km No. Km No. Km BASS COAST A 50 118 38 36 0 0 0 0 184 13 TOTAL R Phillip Island 20 43.3 8 11.6 0 0 0 0 102 8.2 D Kilcunda, Anderson & 7 8.8 5 5.6 0 0 0 0 20 1.4 San Remo Grantville & 6 9.6 9 9.4 0 0 0 0 21 1.1 Surrounds Wonthaggi 11 26 2 233m 0 0 0 0 1 306m Cape 1 2.5 5 4.5 0 0 0 0 7 373m Paterson Inverloch 5 5.5 10 4.9 0 0 0 0 35 1.8 The breakdown of current trails against identified quality standards of trails is: QS1 QS1 QS1 15% 45% QS2 50% 90% QS2 27% QS3 35% QS4 0% QS2 10% QS3 28% 0% QS5 SHARED USE WALKING BEACH ACCESS Bass Coast Tracks and Trails Strategy 26
4.2 Strategic Challenges and Opportunities The following outlines the key strategic challenges and opportunities identified in regards to Bass Coast’s trail network. Opportunities Challenges 1. Deliver strategic linkages that will connect 1. Limited provision of diverse and varied trail the Shire with the emerging regional trails experiences across the region. For example, network and other neighbouring LGA’s no formal mountain biking or equestrian 2. Growth in e-bike use means more people trails capable of tackling more challenging and 2. Fragmented trail network with limited trail longer experiences connectivity between townships 3. Bass Coast, particularly Phillip Island already 3. Limited trail connectivity with adjoining LGAs established as a tourism destination 4. Land tenure complexities in delivering longer- 4. Application of prescribed levels of service distance cross-region or coastal trails within a quality standard framework 5. Distances from major population centres and to deliver a consistent and quality trail travel distance for visitors (from a regional, experience state, national and international perspective) FT 5. Establish clearly defined trailheads/strategic 6. Increase in single day tourism resulting in nodes from where trail users can access prioritisation of tourist attractions and the trails network (and find trail-related experiences over trail exploration A information) 7. Balancing environmental considerations. Much 6. Collaborate with land managers and of the land in the Shire is environmentally R owners to deliver a network of sustainable significant and whilst this can contribute to trails across various land tenures (where the experience of trails, it also can make D appropriate) planning and gaining planning approval for 7. Strengthen current regional approaches to trails a much more complex and contentious, develop the trails network across the region often creating expensive environmentally (i.e. Destination Gippsland) sustainable solutions 8. Celebrate the diverse range of natural 8. Lack of public Bass Coast managed land to environments of the region (ocean/coastal, build new trails heathland, farmland, etc.) 9. Large portion of the current trail network 9. Promote the region as a recreational trails located on and managed by other public land destination during off peak seasons managers 10. Capitalise on the region’s international 10. Lack of consistency in trail design, materials, reputation as a tourism destination signage, etc across different land managers for recreational activities and outdoor 11. Difficulties connecting parts of the trail recreational pursuits network due to private land ownership 11. Strong long term commitment from Council 12. Managing trail user/vehicle conflict, in to invest in trail development and ongoing particular non-motorised vs motorised trail maintenance over the next 10 years and pursuits beyond 13. Limited marketing, promotion and general 12. External funding opportunities available and awareness of the region’s trails network ability to advocate for trail development 14. Lack of way finding signage 15. Limited resources available for trail maintenance as trail network increases resourcing to maintain also need to increase 16. Increasing cost of trail construction Bass Coast Tracks and Trails Strategy 27
FT A R D 5.0 Implementation Bass Coast Tracks and Trails Strategy 28
5.1 Implementation This strategy identifies a broad range of and reprioritised as part of the next iteration opportunities to expand the trail network. of this Strategy. 38 trail projects have been identified during High level cost estimates have been assigned the development of this strategy (emerging to each project to help guide Council’s long from background research, existing plans and term financial planning. Cost estimates take key stakeholder consultation) and respond account of the estimated length of the trail, specifically to: trail tread specification and the level of asset • recreation trends and preferences embellishment proposed (to deliver desired • existing trails network gaps levels of service). Estimated costs are for • physical linkages/connections construction only and do not include any • trails market segments planning costs (design, planning, permits, CHMP, • gaps in the provision etc.) • opportunities to improve community health FT and wellbeing outcomes • opportunities to develop the visitor economy (and the Shire’s trails offer) A Some of the larger scale trail projects identified R may require significant lead-in time in order D to undertake initial scoping, feasibility studies or on-ground investigations and survey work. Such projects (where they are considered to be of significant strategic importance to the Council’s trails network) have been identified within the high priority category within the implementation program. While planning for these projects may occur in the short term, it is likely construction will occur later in the implementation program. Priority projects are identified for implementation within the 2022-2032 implementation period of this strategy. The delivery of a number of projects may fall outside of this period (2032+). These ongoing and longer term projects should be revisited Bass Coast Tracks and Trails Strategy 29
5.2 Trail Prioritisation Tool To effectively prioritise the development of the proposed trail network a trail prioritisation Prioritisation Criteria framework has been developed. • Reduces amount of road crossings Safety • Separates users from fast moving vehicles A series of criteria to assess proposed trails • Increases passive surveillance against was developed through staff workshops • Connects to key destinations and stakeholder consultation. This criteria also • Provides links to the broader region/ took into account the guiding principles as Connectivity townships • Connects into existing/future trails outlined in Section 3.3 and links to existing • Provides a missing link strategies. • Creayes a circuit or stacked loop • Meets a community need There were nine broad categories used within Community • Delivers a benefit to the community Trail benefits all levels of skill the assessment that proposed trails were Benefit • • Encourages social connectedness scored against, producing an overall score for • Accessible to people of all abilities FT that category. These included: • Variety of landscape experiences • Safety User • Interesting sights/stops • Connectivity Experience • Unique journey that will attract visitors A • Benefits from shade and shelter • Community Benefit • User Experience R • Minimal impact on the existing landscape • Technical Feasibility Technical • Easy to construct D • Take advantage of existing supporting • Tourism and Economic Value Feasibility infrastructure • Environmental and Cultural Value • Situated on Council owned/public land • Strategic Support • Contribute to diversifying tourism offerings • Cost • Walk or cycle between key tourism Tousim and destinations Economic • Contribute to establishment of new A weighted score system was used, meaning Value business some categories had a more value of importance • Pass through shopping/ eating precincts placed on them. For example, connectivity, • Showcade local landscape features community benefit and tourism and economic Environ- • Opportunity to learn about local value were weighted higher than the other mental and • landscapes Have minimal impacts on the environment/ Cultural categories. Value cultural areas • Minimal future impacts on sea level rise and coastal erosion New trail projects were assessed based on the following criteria outlined in table 11. • Strategic support from partner organisations • Identified in a key Council stratgic Strategic The overall score each trail received determined Support document Identified as a key priority as part of the trail priority order and whether trails were • Destination Gippsland/ Gippsland Tracks classified as high, medium or low priority. and Trails Feasibility Study • Strong liklihood to secure funding Trails that scored lower (60%), were classified as high priority. Trails Table 11. Trail Assessment Criteria with scores that sat in the middle (40-60%) were classified as medium priority. Bass Coast Tracks and Trails Strategy 30
6.1.1 High Priority Trail Projects Map Trail LoS Locality Priority Ref Name Classification Wonthaggi/ 0 Wonthaggi to Inverloch Trail Shared Use, QS1 High Inverloch Woolamai to Nyora Rail Trail 3 Shared Use, QS1 Bass Coast High Extension 18 Ozone St to Goroke St Shared Use, QS1 Inverloch High Cowes to Ventor Cowes 8 Shared Use, QS2 High Foreshore Trail West,Ventnor Table 12. High Priority Trail Projects FT A R D Bass Coast Tracks and Trails Strategy 31
6.1.2 Medium Priority Trail Projects Map Trail LoS Locality Priority Ref Name Classification 15 Screw Creek Connection Loop Walking, QS2 Inverloch Medium 6 Coronet Bay to Corinella Shared Use, QS3 Coronet bay Medium 4 Cape Paterson Loop Shared Use, QS3 Cape Paterson Medium 17 Gippsland Odyssey Trail Shared Use, QS1 Inverloch Medium 40 The Esplanade Surf Beach Shared Use, QS3 Surf Beach Medium 1 Screw Creek Loop Walking, QS2 Inverloch Medium Cowes/ 10 Gossard Point to Nobbies Shared Use, QS2 Ventnor/ Medium Summerlands 38 Back Beach to Phillip Island Rd Shared Use, QS3 San Remo Medium 47 Coal Point to Cape Paterson Shared Use, QS3 Wonthaggi Medium FT 27 Berry's Beach to Summerlands Shared Use, QS3 Phillip Island Medium A Phillip Island Rd to George Bass Coastal 39 Shared Use, QS3 San Remo Medium Walk R 11 Dalyston To Rail Trail Connection Shared Use, QS3 Dalyston Medium D Baxter Drive to Harmers Haven (Part of 42 Shared Use, QS3 Wonthaggi Medium Yallock-Bulluk) 79 Coghlan Rd to Redwood Drive Shared Use, QS2 Cowes Medium 13 Pier Rd to Dalyston-Glen Forbes Rd Shared Use, QS3 Grantville Medium 34 The Colonnades to Woolamai Beach Rd Shared Use, QS3 Phillip Island Medium 80 Grossard Point to Cowes Shared Use, QS2 Phillip Island Medium Wonthaggi to Inverloch Trail to Cape Pater- 5 Shared Use, QS3 Cape Paterson Medium son (Part of Yallock-Bulluk) Baxter Wetlands to Neil's Outlook (Part of 50 Shared Use, QS3 Wonthaggi Medium Yallock-Bulluk) 33 Cowes to Pyramid Rock Shared Use, QS3 Phillip Island Medium 7 Anderson Rd to Thompson Ave Shared Use, QS2 Cowes Medium 36 Smiths Beach car park to YCW car park Shared Use, QS3 Phillip Island Medium 14 Rail Trail to W Area Rd Shared Use, QS3 Grantville Medium 41 Ventnor Rd to Smiths Beach Rd Shared Use, QS3 Ventnor Medium 81 Pump Track- Phillip Island Phillip Island Medium Table 13. Medium Priority Trail Projects Bass Coast Tracks and Trails Strategy 32
6.1.3 Low Priority Trail Projects Map Trail LoS Locality Priority Ref Name Classification Glen Forbes Recreation Reserve to Bass 12 Shared Use, QS3 Grantville Low Valley Primary 37 Churchill Rd coastal access Shared Use, QS3 Phillip Island Low 35 Grossard Pt Coastal Access Shared Use, QS3 Phillip Island Low 44 McKenzie St to McGibbonys Rd Shared Use, QS3 Wonthaggi Low Rifle Range to Campbell St (Part of Yal- 49 Shared Use, QS3 Wonthaggi Low lock-Bulluk) 30 Newhaven Loop Shared Use, QS3 Phillip Island Low 2 Bass River Trail Walking, QS3 Bass Low 9 Rhyll Inlet to Cowes-Rhyll Road Shared Use, QS3 Cowes/Rhyll Low FT 31 Berrys Beach Road/ Troutmans Track Shared Use, QS3 Phillip Island Low A Table 14. Low Priority Trail Projects R D Bass Coast Tracks and Trails Strategy 33
5.3 New Trail Projects 5.3.1 Phillip Island East and San Remo FT A R D Figure 6. Phillip Island East Trail Trail Land Ref Details Considerations Name Length Tenure Rhyll Inlet to Rhyll Inlet to Watson Part of trail located in Vegetation 9 Cowes-Rhyll 699m BCSC Street through Rhyll Park Protection Overlay. Road Would be extremely difficult to get a trail along the foreshore. Trail from San Remo Minimal roadside space, Bridge, along Newhaven Newhaven vegetation, cliff drop offs in 30 2,243m foreshore, connecting BCSC Loop points, coastal erosion in future back to Phillip Island Rd Part of trail in Vegetation via Boys Home Road. Protection Overlay and Land Subject To Inundation Overlay. From Woolamai Beach The Road, down Lantana Established parking already Colonnades Road to The Colonnades, located at The Colonnades 34 1,269m BCSC to Woolamai to create a loop network Trail located in Vegetation Beach Rd with the Hot Springs Protection Overlay. Loop Trail. Bass Coast Tracks and Trails Strategy 34
Trail Trail Land Ref Details Considerations Name Length Tenure Established parking already located at both Smiths Beach Smiths Trail from YCW Car Park and YCW. Beach car 36 592m to Smiths Beach Car Trail located in Significant BCSC park to YCW Park. Landscape Overlay and car park Environmental Significance Overlay. Just enough room to put a trail along road, possibly left hand From Phillip Island Road, Churchill side (going towards Phillip down Churchill Road to 37 Rd coastal 1,460m Island Road). BCSC Churchill Beach to create access Part of trail in Significant a loop network. Landscape Overlay and Erosion Management Overlay. Phillip Island Road to Back Beach Part of Yallock-Bulluk/Dinosaur Potters Hill Road Beach 38 to Phillip 1,265m Trail. Trail located in Significant BCSC Access Track via Pottters Island Rd Landscape Overlay. Hill Road. Phillip Island Phillip Island Road to FT Part of Yallock-Bulluk/Dinosaur Rd to George start of George Bass 39 1,464m Trail. Trail located in Significant BCSC Bass Coastal Coastal Trail, via Punch Landscape Overlay. Walk Bowl Road. A Trail from Phillip The Island Road, along the Trail located in Vegetation 40 R Esplanade 3,295m BCSC Espanade to Sunderland Protection Overlay. Surf Beach Bay Carpark. D Investigate the Phillip Island Recreation Precinct as a Pump track located on 81 Pump Track possible location for the pump BCSC Phillip Island. track, but other suitable sites should also be investigated. Bass Coast Tracks and Trails Strategy 35
You can also read