THE SECOND MEETING OF THE SECOND SESSION OF THE TWELFTH PARLIAMENT MONDAY 01 FEBRUARY 2021 ENGLISH VERSION - HANSARD NO: 201

Page created by Travis Wilson
 
CONTINUE READING
THE SECOND MEETING OF THE SECOND SESSION OF THE TWELFTH PARLIAMENT MONDAY 01 FEBRUARY 2021 ENGLISH VERSION - HANSARD NO: 201
THE SECOND MEETING OF THE SECOND SESSION OF
          THE TWELFTH PARLIAMENT
        MONDAY 01 FEBRUARY 2021

           ENGLISH VERSION
               HANSARD NO: 201
THE NATIONAL ASSEMBLY
                                                     SPEAKER
                                       The Hon. Phandu T. C. Skelemani PH, MP.
                                                 DEPUTY SPEAKER
                                     The Hon. Mabuse M. Pule, MP. (Mochudi East)

Clerk of the National Assembly                                                  -   Ms B. N. Dithapo
Deputy Clerk of the National Assembly                                           -   Mr L. T. Gaolaolwe
Learned Parliamentary Counsel                                                   -   Ms M. Mokgosi
Assistant Clerk (E)                                                             -   Mr R. Josiah
                                                     CABINET
His Excellency Dr M. E. K. Masisi, MP.                   - President

His Honour S. Tsogwane, MP. (Boteti West)                - Vice President

                                                         - Minister for Presidential Affairs, Governance and Public
Hon. K. N. S. Morwaeng, MP. (Molepolole South)
                                                           Administration

Hon. K. T. Mmusi, MP. (Gabane-Mmankgodi)                 - Minister of Defence, Justice and Security
Hon. Dr L. Kwape, MP. (Kanye South)                      - Minister of International Affairs and Cooperation
Hon. E. M. Molale, MP. (Goodhope-Mabule )                - Minister of Local Government and Rural Development
Hon. K. S. Gare, MP. (Moshupa-Manyana)                   - Minister of Agricultural Development and Food Security
                                                         - Minister of Environment, Natural Resources Conservation
Hon. P. K. Kereng, MP. (Specially Elected)
                                                           and Tourism
Hon. Dr E. G. Dikoloti MP. (Mmathethe-Molapowabojang) - Minister of Health and Wellness
Hon. T.M. Segokgo, MP. (Tlokweng)                        - Minister of Transport and Communications
Hon. K. Mzwinila, MP. (Specially Elected)                - Minister of Land Management, Water and Sanitation Services
                                                         - Minister of Youth Empowerment, Sport and Culture
Hon. T. M. Rakgare, MP. (Mogoditshane)
                                                           Development
Hon. A. M. Mokgethi, MP. (Gaborone Bonnington North)     - Minister of Nationality, Immigration and Gender Affairs
Hon. Dr T. Matsheka, MP. (Lobatse)                       - Minister of Finance and Economic Development
Hon. F. M. M. Molao, MP. (Shashe West)                   - Minister of Basic Education
                                                         - Minister of Tertiary Education, Research, Science and
Hon. Dr D. Letsholathebe, MP. (Tati East)
                                                           Technology
                                                         - Minister of Mineral Resources, Green Technology and
Hon. L. M. Moagi, MP. (Ramotswa)
                                                           Energy Security
Hon. P. O. Serame, MP. (Specially Elected)               - Minister of Investment, Trade and Industry

                                                         - Minister of Employment, Labour Productivity and Skills
Hon. M. Balopi, MP. (Gaborone North)
                                                           Development

Hon. M. Kgafela, MP. (Mochudi West)                      - Minister of Infrastructure and Housing Development

                                                         - Assistant Minister, Presidential Affairs, Governance and
Hon. D. M. Mthimkhulu, MP. (Gaborone South)
                                                           Public Administration
                                                         - Assistant Minister, Local Government and Rural
Hon. K. K. Autlwetse, MP. (Specially Elected)
                                                           Development
                                                         - Assistant Minister, Local Government and Rural
Hon. S. N. Modukanele, MP. (Lerala -Maunatlala)
                                                           Development
                                                         - Assistant Minister, Agricultural Development and Food
Hon. B. Manake, MP. (Specially Elected)
                                                           Security
Hon. S. Lelatisitswe, MP. (Boteti East)                  - Assistant Minister, Health and Wellness

Hon. N. W. T. Makwinja, MP. (Lentsweletau-Mmopane)       - Assistant Minister, Basic Education

Hon. M. S. Molebatsi, MP. (Mmadinare)                    - Assistant Minister, Investment, Trade and Industry
                                                         - Assistant Minister, Youth Empowerment, Sport and Culture
Hon. H. B. Billy, MP. (Francistown East)
                                                           Development
Hon. M. R. Shamukuni, MP. (Chobe)                        - Assistant Minister,Tertiary Education, Research, Science and
                                                           Technology
MEMBERS OF PARLIAMENT AND THEIR CONSTITUENCIES

Names                                                                 Constituency

                                  RULING PARTY (Botswana Democratic Party)
Hon. L. Kablay, MP. (Government Whip)                                 Letlhakeng-Lephephe
Hon. Dr U. Dow, MP.                                                   Specially Elected
Hon. P. Majaga, MP.                                                   Nata-Gweta
Hon. J. S. Brooks, MP.                                                Kgalagadi South
Hon. C. Greeff, MP.                                                   Gaborone Bonnington South
Hon. T. Letsholo, MP.                                                 Kanye North
Hon. T. F. Leuwe, MP.                                                 Takatokwane
Hon. T. Mangwegape-Healy, MP.                                         Gaborone Central
Hon. S. N. Moabi, MP.                                                 Tati West
Hon. T. Monnakgotla, MP.                                              Kgalagadi North
Hon. P. K. Motaosane, MP.                                             Thamaga-Kumakwane
Hon. O. Regoeng, MP.                                                  Molepolole North
Hon. J. L. Thiite, MP.                                                Ghanzi North
Hon. P. P. P. Moatlhodi, MP.                                          Tonota
Hon. A. Lesaso, MP                                                    Shoshong
                                                     OPPOSITION
                                         (Umbrella for Democratic Change)
Hon. D. Saleshando, MP. (Leader of the Opposition)                    Maun West
Hon. M. G. J. Motsamai, MP.                                           Ghanzi South
Hon. D. L. Keorapetse, MP.                                            Selebi Phikwe West
Hon. Y. Boko, MP                                                      Mahalapye East
Hon. Dr K. Gobotswang, MP.                                            Sefhare-Ramokgonami
Hon. C. K. Hikuama, MP.                                               Ngami
Hon. K. K. Kapinga, MP                                                Okavango
Hon. G. Kekgonegile, MP.                                              Maun East
Hon. T. B. Lucas, MP.                                                 Bobonong
Hon. K. Nkawana, MP.                                                  Selebi Phikwe East
Hon. O. Ramogapi, MP.                                                 Palapye
Hon. Dr N. Tshabang, MP.                                              Nkange
Hon. D. Tshere, MP.                                                   Mahalapye West
Hon. M. I. Moswaane, MP.                                              Francistown West
                                             (Botswana Patriotic Front)
Hon. T. S. Khama, MP.                                                 Serowe West
Hon. L. Lesedi, MP.                                                   Serowe South
Hon. B. Mathoothe, MP.                                                Serowe North
Hon. M. Reatile, MP.                                                  Jwaneng-Mabutsane
                                              (Alliance for Progressives)
Hon. W. B. Mmolotsi, MP.                                              Francistown South
TABLE OF CONTENTS
                                        THE SECOND MEETING OF THE SECOND SESSION
                                               OF THE TWELFTH PARLIAMENT
                                                MONDAY 01 FEBRUARY, 2021

CONTENTS										                                                                                                                                            PAGE (S)

SPEAKER’S ANNOUNCEMENT............................................................................................................................1

Suspension of Standing Orders
   Motion....................................................................................................................................................................1

GOVERNMENT BILL
Appropriation (2021/2022) Bill, 2021 (No. 2 of 2021)
  First Reading..........................................................................................................................................................2
  Second Reading.................................................................................................................................................2-17

TABLING OF PAPER
Financial Statements, Tables And Estimates of
The Consolidated And Development Funds Revenues 2021/2022.............................................................................2
Monday 1st February, 2021                                          SUSPENSION OF STANDING ORDERS
                                                                               Motion

             Monday 1st February, 2021                       SUSPENSION OF STANDING ORDERS
         THE ASSEMBLY met at 2:00 p.m.                                             Motion
           (THE SPEAKER in the Chair)                       LEADER OF THE HOUSE (MR TSOGWANE):
                                                            Sorry Mr Speaker. Mr Speaker…
                    PRAY E R S
                                                                                   …Silence…
                        ****
                                                            MR SPEAKER: Honourable Leader of the House,
     SPEAKER’S ANNOUNCEMENTS                                Honourable Tsogwane.
                                                                                   …Silence…
MR SPEAKER (MR SKELEMANI): Honourable
Members, can we please stand up and observe a moment        MR TSOGWANE: Hello! Mr Speaker, can you hear
of silence to respect those of our fellow countrymen and    me?
women who have departed.                                    MR SPEAKER: …(Inaudible)…
   …A MOMENT OF SILENCE OBSERVED…                           MR TSOGWANE: …(Inaudible)… The people who
                                                            were supposed to activate this from your side, did not
MR SPEAKER: Thank you Honourable Members, you
                                                            do it. So I could not unmute my computer this side. I am
may take your seats.
                                                            sorry. Can I continue Mr Speaker?
                      …Silence…
                                                            MR SPEAKER: Please.
MR SPEAKER: Honourable Members, because we
                                                            MR TSOGWANE: Thank you Mr Speaker. Mr
are starting to run the House virtually, I thought it
                                                            Speaker, I beg to move in terms of Standing Order 130.1
will be necessary to inform you that we have allowed
                                                            that Standing Orders 14.1, 40, 46, 51, 127 and 129 be
the Information Technology (IT) officers to enter the       suspended for convenience of a virtual meeting. I thank
Chamber and Honourable Members’ houses or offices           you and move accordingly Mr Speaker.
to assist …(Inaudible)…during the virtual meeting of
our Parliament. We saw it necessary to do so, so that       MR SPEAKER: Thank you Leader of the House.
when you need help, it will be handy.                       Honourable Members, the question is that the Motion
                                                            be agreed to.
Honourable Members, there would be a virtual General
                                                                                   …Silence…
Assembly meeting tomorrow, Tuesday 2nd February
2021 at 8:30 a.m. Please try your best to attend on time    MR SPEAKER: … you can show on your screens
because we are going to consider the Standing Orders        either by hand or by… I am counting. Honourable
which we think will facilitate the virtual meeting of the   Lucas, Honourable Kapinga, we are taking the count.
budget sitting; this meeting.                                                     …Silence…
According to Standing Order 7.3, I have received a          MR SPEAKER: Honourable Members, this will take
correspondence from Honourable Lesaso, Member               a little time because we are going to get the yes and the
of Parliament for Shoshong informing me that he has         noes. Now, we are looking for the ayes.
resigned from the Umbrella for Democratic Change
                                                                                  …Silence…
(UDC) and joined Botswana Democratic Party (BDP).
                                                            MR SPEAKER: Honourable Tshere, I see you,
  Honourable Members, we have been all affected
                                                            Honourable Kapinga, I see you, Lesedi, I see you,
by COVID, this scourge, we have no choice but for
                                                            Honourable Kablay, Leuwe, I have seen you. Honourable
Parliament to …(Inaudible)…virtually, this will require
                                                            Saleshando, are you holding your…(inaudible)… for
amendments in some of our Standing Orders to facilitate
                                                            voting? I wanted to see you. Hold it up or down so that
this Legislature. Let me now call upon the Leader of
                                                            it can …
the House, Honourable Vice President, Honourable
Slumber Tsogwane, to move for the suspension of some                              …Silence…
of the Standing Orders …(Inaudible)…
                                                            MR SPEAKER: The ayes; 30, the noes;13. The Ayes
                       …Silence…                            have it.

                                                                                                   Hansard No 201       1
Monday 1st February, 2021                                               APPROPRIATION (2021/2022) BILL, 2021
                                                                               (NO. 2 OF 2021) Second Reading

                  Question put and agreed to.                     was upbeat about the economic and financial prospects
                                                                  for the 2020/2021 Financial Year. Such confidence, Mr
    MR SPEAKER: Thank you Honourable Members.                     Speaker, was based on the positive global and domestic
                          …Silence…                               economic outlook at the time. This positive outlook
                                                                  came against the backdrop of a fresh political mandate
                  TABLING OF PAPER                                and presented a golden opportunity to embark in earnest
                                                                  on a pragmatic agenda to transform this country to high
    The following paper was tabled:                               income status. Hence, my bold commitment to use the
      FINANCIAL STATEMENTS, TABLES AND                            2020/2021 Budget as a platform for implementing the
     ESTIMATES OF THE CONSOLIDATED AND                            national priority areas of promoting export led growth,
    DEVELOPMENT FUNDS REVENUES 2021/2022.                         ensuring more efficient Government spending and
                                                                  financing, building human capital, and provision of
      (Minister of Finance and Economic Development)              appropriate infrastructure. These national priority areas
                                                                  Mr Speaker, have not changed, and are clearly laid out
                         First Reading                            in the Mid-Term Review of National Development
                                                                  Plan (NDP) 11 recently passed by this House for
     PRESENTATION OF A GOVERNMENT                                 implementation from 2020 to 2023.
                 BILL
                                                                  However, Mr Speaker, the advent of COVID-19
    The following Bill was presented and read a first time.       pandemic in March 2020 threw everything into disarray
                                                                  as countries the world over, including Botswana, moved
    APPROPRIATION (2021/2022) BILL, 2021 (NO. 2
                                                                  into survival mode. Both human and financial resources
                   OF 2021)
                                                                  were channelled towards the fight and containment of
      (Minister of Finance and Economic Development)              COVID-19.

                  Second Reading-Forthwith.                       Mr Speaker, as part of the preamble for this Budget
                                                                  Speech presentation, let me share a few insights on the
                             BILL                                 impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on the domestic
                                                                  economy. I will also touch on some key underlying
       APPROPRIATION (2021/2022) BILL,
                                                                  factors that underpin the 2021/2022 Budget.
            2021 (NO. 2 OF 2021)
                                                                  COVID-19 and the Economy
                      Second Reading
                                                                  Mr Speaker, COVID-19 has brought a once-in-a-
    MINISTER OF FINANCE AND ECONOMIC
                                                                  century shock to Botswana, Africa and the entire world.
    DEVELOPMENT (DR MATSHEKA): Mr Speaker,
                                                                  Not only is it the largest health and economic challenge
    let me start by first acknowledging the exceptional
                                                                  in living memory, but it is also the first pandemic to hit
    circumstances created by the COVID-19 pandemic as
                                                                  the whole world indiscriminately.
    evidenced in the virtual presentation of this Budget
    Speech, which is however, unavoidable in order to             Mr Speaker, the impact of the pandemic on economies
    protect lives. In these same weeks and months, many           around the world has also been devastating, with
    Batswana have lost their lives to the pandemic. The rising    a range of negative impacts, including reduced or
    numbers of death touches all of us. In this instance Mr       even negative economic growth, increased rates of
    Speaker, I would love to express my deepest sympathy          unemployment, poverty and balance of payments
    to those that have lost their loved ones and urge all of us   pressures. Notwithstanding the negative impact of this
    to look after ourselves.                                      pandemic, there are also opportunities that we could
                                                                  take advantage of.
    Mr Speaker, I have the honour this afternoon to present
    to the National Assembly, the Budget Proposals for the        Mr Speaker, Botswana has experienced a large negative
    2021/2022 financial year.                                     economic shock as a result of the pandemic. Our
                                                                  economy contracted by nearly one quarter in the period
    Mr Speaker, when I stood before this House last year at       from March to June 2020, and over the year as a whole
    around this time to present the 2020 Budget Speech, I         will experience a deep recession. Besides slower growth

2   Hansard No 201
Monday 1st February, 2021                                              APPROPRIATION (2021/2022) BILL, 2021
                                                                          (NO. 2 OF 2021) Second Reading

Mr Speaker, the economic impact manifested in balance        are down as economic activity, and incomes have fallen
of payments and fiscal deficits, and the drawdown of         and tax payments have been deferred to ease cash flow
the foreign exchange reserves and Government savings.        pressures on businesses. On the other hand, expenditures
Fortunately, our past record of prudent macroeconomic        are up as Government spends on controlling the disease
management meant that we had accumulated financial           and supporting firms and households. The resultant
buffers that enabled us to respond quickly and mitigate      budget deficits need to be financed, whether from
the negative economic impact of the pandemic. These          domestic or external sources, while guarding against the
buffers Mr Speaker, have now been depleted, and need         risks of excessive debt accumulation.
to be rebuilt so that we are well-placed to deal with
potential future shocks.                                     As a result, Mr Speaker, we need to improve the
                                                             effectiveness and efficiency of our public finance
Mr Speaker, many sectors of the economy have been            systems. We need to modernize our tax collection
adversely and severely impacted by public health             systems and make them more efficient; raise some tax
restrictions that had to be instituted to fight the spread   rates, and explore new sources of tax revenue. I will
of the disease. Indeed, some sectors such as tourism, the    present more detailed proposals on these later in this
entertainment and arts sectors, including bars and liquor    speech, Mr Speaker.
outlets were closed right from the onset of the pandemic,
and activities such as meetings and conferences, which       We also need to review our public service delivery
are key for the hotel industry have not been taking place    model to ensure that taxpayers and citizens are getting
as regularly as would have been the case under normal        value-for-money. To this end, it is essential that we
circumstances. The mining and transportation sectors,        address issues relating to wastage and inefficiency,
and some personal services, also suffered a major blow.      poor productivity in the public sector, and inefficient
                                                             procurement processes. We also need to improve the
In recognition of these unprecedented challenges Mr          selection and management of public investment projects.
Speaker, Government acted decisively and launched            In doing so, we intend to open up for the private sector to
a series of fiscal and financial packages to address the     play a much stronger role. We can improve public sector
health emergency needs, to ease liquidity pressures on       project management by utilising private sector skills
businesses, and to safeguard jobs and household incomes.     and techniques to ensure that projects are implemented
Ultimately, Government launched a comprehensive              on-time and within budget. In the coming year, we will
Economic Recovery and Transformation Plan (ERTP)             also be creating opportunities for the private sector to
to fast track recovery and transformation, as well as        actually deliver some major investment projects. At
enhance medium to long-term economic resilience.             the same time expecting Ministries, Departments and
                                                             Agencies (MDAs) to deliver on their commitments in
Mr Speaker, the pandemic has also shown us that
                                                             the future without expecting additional resources each
“business as usual”, is not a sustainable strategy going
                                                             year.
forward. We have to change and transform the way we
have been running our economic affairs. In the past,         Mr Speaker, let me reiterate the fact that there will
we have perhaps been slow to implement the changes           continue to be much uncertainty about many issues
required, but COVID-19 has dramatically shortened            relating to our own economic pathway. However, this
the period available to us and made the challenge of         Government’s key objective is to ensure that economic
transformation much more urgent.                             policy does not compound these uncertainties, but rather
                                                             help to manage and mitigate the economic impact of
Background to the 2021/2022 Budget
                                                             the economic slowdown on households and businesses
Mr Speaker, the 2021/2022 Budget was prepared under          throughout the country.
extraordinary circumstances. A Budget Speech, Mr
                                                             Nevertheless, Mr Speaker, I would like to reassure
Speaker, is fundamentally about public finance and the
                                                             the nation that as a responsible Government, we are
Government’s intentions regarding public spending,
                                                             tackling these challenges with great determination and
generating the revenues to pay for that spending, and
                                                             zeal to ensure that this situation does not turn into a
financing any deficit that results. Currently, the public
                                                             catastrophe.
finance challenges facing most countries including
Botswana, are more acute than ever before. Revenues          This Mr Speaker, will be made possible by our good

                                                                                                     Hansard No 201        3
Monday 1st February, 2021                                               APPROPRIATION (2021/2022) BILL, 2021
                                                                               (NO. 2 OF 2021) Second Reading

    record of prudent macroeconomic management, the               a totally new approach to project implementation.
    support and solidarity of the nation, and, more than
    anything else, the hard work, dedication and resilience       Monetary Policy        and   Exchange      Rate    Policy
    of Batswana.                                                  Developments

    (II) MACROECONOMIC                  REVIEW           AND      Inflation and Monetary Policy
         OUTLOOK                                                  In December 2020, headline inflation was 2.2 per
    Mr Speaker, the International Monetary Fund (IMF)’s           cent and has been below the lower end of the Bank of
    January 2021 World Economic Outlook estimated                 Botswana (BoB) objective for more than a year. This
    that global output contracted by 3.5 per cent in 2020.        low inflation rate is mainly a reflection of reduced
    However, the global economy is projected to recover           domestic fuel prices, following a fall in international
    and grow by 5.5 per cent in 2021, underpinned by a            oil prices, combined with subdued domestic demand
    gradual recovery in consumption and investment.               and sluggish economic activity. In the medium term Mr
                                                                  Speaker, inflation is expected to remain within the Bank
    The IMF further estimates that output in Sub-Saharan          of Botswana’s objective range.
    Africa contracted by 2.6 per cent in 2020, compared
                                                                  Mr Speaker, since the advent of the pandemic in the first
    to a growth of 3.2 per cent in 2019. Moreover, fiscal
                                                                  quarter of 2020, the bank rate has been reduced twice
    deficits worsened in 2020. As a result Mr Speaker, debt       in an effort to boost economic activity, as the cost of
    levels for most countries are forecast to increase. In line   borrowing is lowered. The decision came as a result of
    with these developments, the general standard of living       the current state of the economy and the outlook for both
    in many countries was expected to deteriorate, with a         domestic and global economies.
    lower per capita Gross Domestic Product (GDP) in 2020
    than in 2019.                                                 Balance of Payments and Foreign Exchange Reserves

    However, Mr Speaker, growth in Sub-Saharan Africa is          Mr Speaker, for the first nine months of 2020, the
    anticipated to recover modestly to 3.2 per cent in 2021.      balance of payments recorded an overall deficit of P14.8
    Key drivers of this growth range from an improvement          billion, compared to a deficit of P5.8 billion in the same
    in exports and commodity prices as the world economy          period in 2019. The significant deterioration of the
    recovers.                                                     overall balance of payments was largely driven by a fall
                                                                  in the level of exports of goods and services, which were
    On the domestic front, Mr Speaker, the hardest-hit            valued at P35.21 billion over this period, compared to
    sectors were mining, trade, hotels and restaurants,           P50.83 billion in the first nine months of 2019.
    construction and manufacturing. On a more positive
    note, several sectors experienced a subsequent recovery,      Mr Speaker, the fall in the level of exports reflects the
    such that GDP was only 6 per cent smaller in the third        slowdown in global diamond sales, as well as a fall in
    quarter of 2020 than in the same period in 2019. Overall,     global and regional economic activity more generally.
    the domestic economy is projected to contract by 7.7          The non-diamond exports have also been growing
    per cent in 2020 as a whole, mainly due to significant        more slowly than GDP as a whole for some time. This,
    contraction in the tourism and mining sectors.                in turn, indicates that Botswana has a competitiveness
                                                                  challenge, which needs to be addressed as a matter of
    Mr Speaker, the outlook for the domestic economy              urgency. Despite this Mr Speaker, Government remains
    is, however, positive, with growth rate of 8.8 per            resolute in pursuing the policy priority of export-led
    cent projected for Botswana in 2021. Achieving this           growth, as it continues to be critically important.
    positive growth will depend on the trajectory of the
    recovery of the global economy and indeed a successful        In support of export-led growth, Government has made
    implementation of policies, programmes and projects           key commitments for both international and domestic
    outlined in the Mid-Term Review (MTR) of National             firms, including improving the issuance of work permits
    Development Plan (NDP) 11. With the implementation            for investors and skilled employees to reflect business
    of the Economic Recovery and Transformation Plan              needs and provide firms with the certainty required to
    (ERTP) and Government initiatives, we should achieve          support investment, production and trade. The issuance
    a robust recovery in 2021. This Mr Speaker, will require      of visas for short-term visitors will also be improved

4   Hansard No 201
Monday 1st February, 2021                                             APPROPRIATION (2021/2022) BILL, 2021
                                                                         (NO. 2 OF 2021) Second Reading

through the implementation of online visa issuance          These include tertiary education financing at P2.26
system (e-Visas) that is currently being developed.         billion, National Service Scheme at P135.72 million,
                                                            Youth Development Fund at P104 million, and Internship
Mr Speaker, as at the end of November 2020, the             Programme at P98.83 million, to mention just a few.
official foreign exchange reserves amounted to P58.7
billion, equivalent to 10.9 months of import cover.         Mr Speaker, according to the Quarterly Multi-Topic
This represented a 10 per cent decrease from P65.2          Household Survey, the unemployment rate for the
billion in December 2019. The substantial decline           quarter ending December 2020 was 24.5 per cent. This
was largely a result of the drawdown on the foreign         is slightly higher than the 23.2 per cent unemployment
exchange reserves attributable to payments for imports,     rate recorded in the first quarter of the year. Hence
Government external obligations and net capital flows.      unemployment has only risen slightly as a result of the
As at November 2020, the Government Investment              lockdown periods and other disruptions experienced
Account portion of the reserves was valued at P5.6          during the course of 2020.
billion, compared to P17.8 billion as at the end of 2019.
                                                            Mr Speaker, I had mentioned in my previous Budget
I want to repeat this one, as at November 2020, the         Speech that my ministry was developing a National
Government Investment Account portion of the reserves       Employment Policy (NEP) in order to deal with this
was valued at only P5.6 billion, compared to P17.8          developmental challenge. The draft Policy has been
billion as at the end of 2019.                              undergoing intense interrogation within my ministry
                                                            to assess its adequacy in promoting productive, gainful
Exchange Rate Movements                                     and decent employment for Batswana based on national
Mr Speaker, consistent with our exchange rate policy        Employment Policy will be finalised in the first half of
objective, Government adjusted the downward rate of         2021.
crawl of the Pula exchange rate from 1.51 per cent to
                                                            Population and Development
2.87 per cent per annum, in May 2020. The Pula basket
weights were maintained at 45 per cent for the South        Mr Speaker, the national Population and Housing
African Rand and 55 per cent for the IMF’s Special          Census planned for August 2021 has been postponed to
Drawing Right for the duration of 2020. After a review
                                                            next year, due to the movement restrictions in place to
of these exchange rate parameters, a decision was taken
                                                            control the pandemic. However, I would like to assure
to maintain them for 2021.
                                                            the nation that given the importance of the census to
Mr Speaker, the Real Effective Exchange Rate (REER)         our development planning and democracy, Government
depreciated by 1.5 per cent in the twelve months to         will strive to undertake the exercise mid-next year and
November 2020. The depreciation of the REER suggests        provide the results by the end of the year.
that some gains could be made in Botswana’s export
competitiveness, which may contribute to economic           Mr Speaker, following the Demographic Dividend
growth and employment creation. Nevertheless,               study carried out in 2018, my ministry is developing
concerns remain over the competitiveness and low            a Demographic Dividend Roadmap, which will
productivity of Botswana firms, given the slow growth       identify priority projects to help Botswana harness
of non-diamond exports.                                     the demographic dividend. The study recognises four
                                                            focus areas being; Employment and Entrepreneurship;
Employment and Human Resources                              Education and Skills Development; Health and
                                                            Wellbeing; as well as Human Rights, Governance and
Mr Speaker, one of the major developmental challenges
                                                            Youth Empowerment. Appropriate interventions will be
facing this country is the high rate and level of
                                                            critical in enabling us to harness the benefits of a bulging
unemployment, especially among the youth. The Youth
                                                            working-age population, and to unleash the potential of
Empowerment Drive continues through investment in
                                                            the youth. The roadmap will be completed during 2021.
education and the implementation of a number of national
schemes targeting this group. The sizeable investments      Performance of State-Owned Enterprises
in this category, amounting to approximately P2.6 billion
in total during the coming financial year, demonstrates     Mr Speaker, last year, I mentioned that Government
Government’s unwavering commitment to invest in the         would undertake a comprehensive review of parastatals
youth of this country.                                      and State-Owned Enterprises (SOEs), with a view to

                                                                                                     Hansard No 201        5
Monday 1st February, 2021                                              APPROPRIATION (2021/2022) BILL, 2021
                                                                              (NO. 2 OF 2021) Second Reading

    addressing some of the shortcomings in their governance      have been considerable achievements in terms of
    and performance. I am pleased to report Mr Speaker,          implementing aspects of the 2020 budget.
    that a comprehensive rationalisation strategy covering
    all parastatals has been developed. Implementation of        Amongst        these     achievements,       Information,
    the strategy will address issues such as duplication of      Communication and Technology (ICT) infrastructure
    activities and overlapping mandates. Some parastatals        has been expanded, with an additional 2,202 Fibre-
    have also been identified for privatisation, while           to-the-Premises connections achieved nation-wide,
    others could be closed. This will reduce undoubtedly         bringing the total number of connections to 5,953. The
    Government spending on these entities. The review will       National Cyber-Security Strategy was also approved in
    also make proposals for improvements in SOE corporate        October 2020. Furthermore, Mr Speaker, there has been
    governance. It is my intention that decisions will be        a substantial reduction in the price of mobile broadband
    made on rationalising, restructuring, privatisation and      in 2020, making Botswana one of the most competitive
    liquidation of SOEs in the first half of 2021.               countries in Africa in terms of mobile data pricing.

    The problems in the SOEs space are unfortunately             Mr Speaker, the reduction of mobile broadband prices
    confirmed by the continued poor financial performance        is consistent with the aspirations of the Broadband
    of many of them. Even though some SOEs registered            Commission for sustainable development, making
    profits in the 2019/2020 Financial Year, these were in       Botswana one of the most competitive countries in
    most cases lower than in the previous year, the exceptions   Africa in terms of mobile broadband internet. Mr
    being the Botswana Housing Corporation and the               Speaker, these initiatives will enhance our ability to
    Botswana Communication Regulatory Authority.                 harness and take full advantage of ICT in the era of
                                                                 COVID-19. They will not only support our priority
    Some State-owned Enterprises continued to register           of enhancing efficient Government spending, but will
    unsustainable losses. These include Botswana Power           also promote efficiency in the provision of Government
    Corporation, Botswana Post and Botswana Agricultural         services.
    Marketing Board (BAMB). The BPC’s loss reflected             Mr Speaker, in order to improve access to, and ensure
    increased power imports due to the poor performance          reliability in the power supply, Government has
    of Morupule B power station, whereas Botswana Post’s         completed some key transmission and distribution
    loss was due to a rise in other operating expenses, and      infrastructure projects. These include the extension of
    comes even after Government paid substantial grants          the high voltage transmission grid to the North West
    to Botswana Post to support the post office network          of the country, as well as transmission reinforcement
    nationwide, whereas BAMB’s loss was attributable to          works in Ramotswa and Gaborone. The North West
    an impairment loss and substantial increase in cost of       project will unlock mining investments that have been
    sales.                                                       suppressed due to lack of access to power grid, in
                                                                 addition to reducing dependency on power imports from
    Mr Speaker, these results indeed illustrate the critical
                                                                 the neighbouring countries.
    importance of restructuring the SOEs sector, including
    potentially closing down perennial loss-makers, as we        Mr Speaker, a draft National Energy Policy has been
    cannot continue bailing out these companies from our         prepared and is ready for submission to Parliament
    scarce tax revenues. In future, SOEs will be required to     for adoption. In addition, an Integrated Resource
    follow the best principles of corporate governance, for      Plan (IRP) for electricity sector development has
    instance by providing audited accounts on time.              been developed and was launched in December 2020.
                                                                 The IRP provides a roadmap for achieving a reliable,
    REVIEW   OF    THE                  2020       BUDGET
                                                                 safe and affordable electricity supply, with a target
    IMPLEMENTATION
                                                                 of achieving a 15 per cent contribution of renewable
    Mr Speaker, the COVID-19 pandemic has had a                  energy by 2030, from the current 2 per cent. You can say
    major impact on the implementation of the 2020/21            it is an ambitious programme. Implementation of these
    budget. Inevitably, it forced us to adjust our spending      two documents will ensure energy security of supply to
    plans, and re-think our priorities going forward.            support economic growth, and will also see Botswana
    Nevertheless, despite this and the difficulties posed        transforming from being a net importer of electricity to
    for the implementation of development projects, there        being a net exporter.

6   Hansard No 201
Monday 1st February, 2021                                              APPROPRIATION (2021/2022) BILL, 2021
                                                                          (NO. 2 OF 2021) Second Reading

Mr Speaker, the 600 megawatts Morupule B Power               organisations in the public sector, parastatals and Non-
Plant is currently undergoing comprehensive remedial         Governmental Organisations (NGOs).
works to address deficiencies, which are scheduled for
completion by 2023. As per the agreed schedule for the       Mr Speaker, an amount of P1.3 billion was approved in the
remedial works, the first unit should have been handed       Supplementary Budget for the Industry Support Facility
over to Botswana Power Corporation in September              (ISF), which provides soft loans for existing businesses
2020. However, the process suffered delays on account        across the economy. The loans are administered through
of travel restrictions which affected the movement of        Citizen Entrepreneurial Development Agency (CEDA),
contractors from China. The work is largely complete         National Development Bank (NDB) and Botswana
and will be commissioned in June 2021.                       Development Corporation (BDC), depending on the
                                                             size and sector of the borrowing enterprises. Of the
Mr Speaker, in the agricultural sector, Government           total, P900 million is provided for general industry,
continued to finance various activities and programmes.      while there are dedicated sums of P200 million for
However, results have been mixed, and high levels of         tourism enterprises and P100 million for agricultural
agricultural spending have not yielded the anticipated       enterprises. An additional P100 million has been made
results in terms of increased output and efficiency.         available to provide small grants to informal sector and
Therefore, there is an ongoing review and evaluation of      micro enterprises registered with the Local Enterprise
agricultural subsidy schemes such as Integrated Support      Authority (LEA).
Programme for Arable Agricultural Development
(ISPAAD) and the Livestock Management and                    Mr Speaker, updates on the implementation of the ISF
Infrastructure Development (LIMID) Programme. It is          by the relevant organisations will be provided as part of
anticipated that going forward, subsidies and support        the Committee of Supply presentations by the respective
will be tied to the achievement of output rather than        ministries.
simply subsidising inputs and support for commercially-      IV. STRATEGIC INITIATIVES                  FOR      THE
focused agriculture.                                         2021/2022 FINANCIAL YEAR

Meanwhile, Mr Speaker, in order to promote agribusiness      Mr Speaker, there is need for a new line of thinking,
and food self-sufficiency, import restrictions have been     borrowing largely from key deliverables of the Mid-
imposed. These are facilitated through border closures       Term Review of NDP 11 and ERTP. Specifically, I
and regulation of imports of grains and cereals through      would like to focus on what is achievable during this
local purchase requirements thresholds. The coverage         coming financial year. I will give particular attention to
and threshold of these regulations are reviewed from         policy measures and growth strategies that will support
time to time, considering the production capabilities of     the restoration of economic activity and incomes, as
local producers.                                             well as economic transformation.
Mr Speaker, this Government is committed to continue         Mr Speaker, the problem of “poor value-for-money”
its quest to provide employment opportunities,               associated with some ministries has featured prominently
especially for the youth. To this end, several initiatives   in previous Budget Speeches, and is worth repeating
have been put in place to create employment. As stated       here. Public Expenditure Reviews are useful ways of
in the 2020 State if the Nation Address (SONA), 1,954        identifying means of improving spending efficiency and
jobs were created through the Youth Development              will be acted upon. Coupled with this, is the issue of
Fund (YDF), and an additional 1,918 jobs were created        poor expenditure outcomes; for example, an assessment
through other youth funding programmes, while                of Public Investment Management by the International
Citizen Entrepreneurial Development Agency (CEDA)            Monetary Fund (IMF) in 2017 revealed that 37 per cent
and Botswana Investment and Trade Centre (BITC)              of public expenditure on infrastructure goes to waste in
created 3,883 and 4,382 jobs, respectively. Government       Botswana.
continues to provide a platform for graduates to
acquire work skills to enhance their marketability           Mr Speaker, as a way of enhancing the efficiency of
and employability, through the National Internship           Government spending, my ministry introduced the
Programme and National Service Scheme (Tirelo                Zero-Based-Budgeting (ZBB) approach during the
Sechaba) by placing them in various departments in           preparation of the 2021/2022 budget. This has provided

                                                                                                    Hansard No 201        7
Monday 1st February, 2021                                                 APPROPRIATION (2021/2022) BILL, 2021
                                                                                 (NO. 2 OF 2021) Second Reading

    a framework to assist Thematic Working Groups                   2021. Once completed, the grain silos will enhance
    (TWGs) and Ministries, Departments and Agencies                 the capacity of grain management and storage to meet
    (MDAs) to work out their funding needs from scratch             domestic demand.
    and thus, enabling them to determine the full cost of
    their budgetary requirements. This will also assist in          Mr Speaker, Pandamatenga is one of the Special
    appropriately prioritising spending plans by directing          Economic Zone projects that are expected to attract
    resources to where their greatest areas of need are,            both domestic and foreign investment and diversify
    guided by what Government can afford.                           the economy and export base beyond mining, thereby
                                                                    creating job opportunities. In Gaborone, the development
    Furthermore, Mr Speaker, in responding decisively to the        of the Sir Seretse Khama International Airport Special
    adverse economic impact of COVID-19, Government                 Economic Zone has commenced, with the construction
    proposed that P14.5 billion be allocated as additional          of the 1.8 kilometer three lane Boulevard One road,
    fiscal resources for the ERTP, with P7 billion budgeted         which is expected to be completed in May 2021.
    for the 2021/2022 financial year. To ensure that our
    efforts are focused and aligned to the identified priorities,   Mr Speaker, concerning road infrastructure development,
    spending will be channelled towards the development of          the completion of the Kazungula Bridge across the
    economic clusters, such as agriculture, tourism, creative
                                                                    Zambezi and the Okavango Bridge in Mohembo are
    industry and manufacturing. Furthermore, projects …
                                                                    expected to boost the economy by facilitating both
    (Inaudible)… expected to be completed by May 2021.
    In addition, Government will develop the platform               transit trade and domestic trade. A number of new
    for on-line applications for Botswana passports in the          projects will be implemented in the 2021/2022 financial
    new financial year. The computerisation of borders is           year, on which I will provide more details under the
    ongoing as well. To this end, Government is currently           relevant ministries’ Development Budgets. Plans are
    carrying out computerisation of six Border Posts (Two           however underway, for developing tourism facilities
    Rivers, Bokspits, Makopong, Paarshalt, Zanzibar and             around dams such as Gaborone and Thune Dams, as well
    Mabolwe), which will be completed this financial year.          as, upgrading existing dry ports in Gaborone (Gabcon),
    Procurement of equipment for the six border posts has           Francistown (Francon) and Palapye (Palcon) and a new
    been done, and installation of the Passport and Border          dry port will be established in Kasane.
    Control System (PBCS) will be carried out during the            Mr Speaker, in terms of water supply, the following
    current financial year. The automation of all border            large scale water and sanitation projects will be executed
    posts in Botswana will ensure compliance with the               in the next financial year, with the largest share which
    requirements of the Public Key Directory (PKD) with             is 22 per cent, of the Development Budget allocated
    the International Civil Aviation Organisation (ICAO)            to water and sanitation. Among the major projects
    and hence validate the authenticity and integrity of            include; Lobatse Water Supply Master Plan, Masama-
    e-passports of other PKD member states.                         Mmamashia 100 kilometer Water Pipeline; Connection
                                                                    of Tswapong Villages to Mahalapye (Phase 2); Moshupa
    Mr Speaker, digitalisation will also be carried out
                                                                    Sanitation and the North South Carrier (NSC) 2.3, which
    in schools, through procurement of Information and
                                                                    consists of a water transfer scheme from Mmamashia
    Communication Technology (ICT) learning devices
                                                                    to Gaborone; as well as the upgrading of the existing
    for all learners and teachers from Standard 5 to Form 5
                                                                    Gaborone Water Supply Network.
    level. Connectivity to all schools, developing e-learning
    material and training teachers and school managers on           Mr Speaker, in order to meet our national electricity
    basic ICT skills will be carried out.                           demand at least cost and in an environmentally
                                                                    responsible manner, Government through the newly
    Mr Speaker, the experience of the last year with
                                                                    approved Integrated Resource Plan, will implement the
    restrictions on cross-border trade has demonstrated the
                                                                    following green technology projects; 100 MW of Solar
    need for improved domestic food production to achieve
                                                                    Power Plants (currently under procurement); the tender
    a higher degree of self-sufficiency in selected products.
                                                                    will be awarded to the successful bidder(s) in the first
    To this end, the design and construction of 12 steel
                                                                    quarter of 2021 and commercial operation is scheduled
    grain silos with an overall storage capacity of 60,000
                                                                    for third quarter of 2022. The two 50MW power plant
    metric tonnes is underway at the Pandamatenga Special
                                                                    sites are located in Selebi-Phikwe and Jwaneng. In
    Economic Zone and will be completed by August

8   Hansard No 201
Monday 1st February, 2021                                             APPROPRIATION (2021/2022) BILL, 2021
                                                                         (NO. 2 OF 2021) Second Reading

addition, a 12 Grid-tied Solar Photovoltaic (total 35       during the year.
MW) by 2022 would also be implemented. Tender
awards are scheduled for the first and second quarters      Projected non-mineral income tax revenue has also been
of 2021 and commercial operation to commence in the         revised downwards, by P2.37 Billion, reflecting tax
first quarter of 2022. These projects Mr Speaker, will      deferment concessions granted to alleviate the impact
be at Kasane, Molepolole, Tutume, Ghanzi, Tsabong,          of COVID-19. Revenue from the Bank of Botswana, on
Maun, Serowe, Bobonong, Shakawe, Lobatse, Mamuno            the other hand, increased by P2.96 Billion, from P1.16
and Kang.                                                   Billion to P4.12 Billion, due to an increase in the Bank’s
                                                            distributable net income in 2019. This was, however,
In order to ensure national security of fuel supply,        a once-off event, rather than indicating a sustained
construction of Ghanzi and Francistown Petroleum            increase.
depots at 30 Million and 60 Million liters capacities
respectively, will be undertaken in the coming financial    Mr Speaker, total expenditure and net lending for
year, 2021/2022.                                            2020/2021 is projected at P69.36 Billion, against the
                                                            original budget of P67.62 Billion. This includes P57.20
                BUDGET REVIEWS                              Billion for recurrent expenditure (both ministerial and
                                                            statutory), while P12.23 Billion is for the Development
2019/2020 Budget Outturn                                    Budget. This is expected to result in a revised budget
Mr Speaker, the overall fiscal balance for the 2019/2020    deficit of P21.03 Billion, or 11.61 per cent of GDP,
Financial Year was a deficit of P11.10 Billion, or 5.6      in 2020/2021. This represents an extremely serious
per cent of Gross domestic product (GDP), compared          deterioration in our fiscal position and has resulted in a
to a projected deficit of P7.93 Billion in the revised      rapid depletion of Government accumulated savings in
budget. The deterioration in the budget balance is          the Government Investment Account. It has also resulted
mainly attributed to underperformance of total revenues     in an increase in borrowing through the Bond Issuance
and grants, which came in at P54.30 Billion, or 10.56       Programme, which was approved by this House as well.
per cent below the revised budget figure of P60.71          The trend in the overall fiscal position is therefore not
Billion. Total expenditure and net lending for the period   sustainable and it is essential that it is reversed in the
ending 31st March 2020, on the other hand, amounted         2021/2022 financial year.
to P65.40 Billion, or 95 per cent of the revised budget     2021/2022 BUDGET PROPOSALS
estimate. While recurrent expenditure was largely in
line with the revised budget, development expenditure       Mr Speaker, for the financial year 2021/2022, another
underperformed by P3.39 Billion. However, the               deficit is anticipated. In that regard, financing measures
underperformance of the development budget was              need to be specified in advance. It is anticipated that this
outweighed by that of revenues, resulting in a              budget deficit will be financed through the issuance of
significantly larger deficit than originally budgeted.      domestic Government bonds and securities, together
                                                            with external borrowing.
2020/2021 Revised Budget Estimates
                                                            Given the reliance on debt funding, going forward,
Mr Speaker, in the current fiscal year, 2020/2021, total    there should be a conscious effort to gradually reduce
revenues and grants are projected to be P48.33 Billion      recurrent spending and allocate more resources to
in the revised budget, which is P14.06 Billion below        development spending, whilst improving the quality
the original budget of P62.39 Billion, approved by this     and impact of that development spending. This is going
House. The decrease is largely due to the near collapse     to be very important.
of mineral revenues, which dropped by P13.46 Billion,
or a decline of 67.2 per cent, from P20.02 Billion in the   Total Revenues and Grants
original budget to only P6.56 Billion. The revised budget
for Customs and Excise, on the other hand, showed an        Mr Speaker, in 2021/2022, total revenues and grants are
increase of P1.12 Billion, from P15.38 Billion to P16.50    budgeted at P64.58 billion. Mineral revenue is estimated
Billion. Value Added Tax (VAT) decreased from P8.55         at P23.20 billion or 36.33 per cent of total revenues,
Billion to P7.1 Billion, given reduced consumption          which is significantly higher than the revised budget
primarily due to lockdown measures implemented              of 2020/2021 of P6.56 billion. Non-Mineral Income
                                                            Tax is estimated at P13.78 billion, which is the second

                                                                                                     Hansard No 201        9
Monday 1st February, 2021                                               APPROPRIATION (2021/2022) BILL, 2021
                                                                                (NO. 2 OF 2021) Second Reading

     major source of revenue. Customs and Excise revenue           of the Basic Education Sector Public Expenditure
     is estimated at P13.52 billion, while Value-Added Tax         Review, the ministry will be expected to deliver on its
     (VAT) is estimated at P10.67 billion.                         commitments in the future without expecting additional
                                                                   resources each year; instead, it must address the clearly-
     Total Expenditure and Net Lending                             identified inefficiencies and like the whole of the public
                                                                   sector, do more with less.
     The Total Expenditure and Net Lending for 2021/2022 is
     projected at P70.61 billion. This includes P56.05 billion     Mr Speaker, the proposed budget for the Ministry
     proposed for recurrent expenditure (both ministerial          of Defence, Justice and Security is P8.39 billion, or
     and Statutory), while P14.75 billion is proposed for the      16.6 per cent of the total, making it the second largest
     Development Budget.                                           recommended Ministerial Recurrent Budget allocation.
                                                                   However, this represents a decline of P172.81 million
     Statutory Expenditure                                         or -2.0 per cent over the 2020/2021 approved budget.
                                                                   The recommended budget mainly comprises spending
     The recommended budget for Statutory Expenditure
                                                                   commitments for the Botswana Defence Force (BDF),
     for the 2021/2022 financial year is P9.20 billion, which
                                                                   Botswana Police Service (BPS) and Prisons and
     is a reduction of P1.40 billion or -13.2 per cent from
                                                                   Rehabilitation Services. The substantial allocation
     the current year’s budget. The decrease is because            demonstrates Government’s continued commitment to
     no Government bonds are due to mature in the next             ensuring adequate national security and maintenance of
     financial year, unlike in the previous financial year. This   the rule of law as the necessary elements for national
     recommended budget is intended to fund normal public          development as well as being supportive of the business
     debt servicing obligations, Government’s pension              environment. Other major cost drivers are service
     contribution for civil servants to the Botswana Public        charges, aviation fuel, maintenance of aircrafts, food
     Officers’ Pension Fund (BPOPF) and other statutory            rations, maintenance of facilities and equipment, as well
     commitments such as Specified Officer’s remuneration.         as other operational costs for the security forces.

     Ministerial Recurrent Budget                                  Mr Speaker, the third largest share of the proposed
                                                                   Ministerial Recurrent Budget of P7.90 billion or 15.6
     Mr Speaker, the proposed total Ministerial Recurrent          per cent, is recommended for allocation to the Ministry
     Expenditure for the financial year 2021/2022 is P50.66
                                                                   of Health and Wellness. The ministry has recorded
     billion, which is an overall decline of P714.74 million
                                                                   a growth of P165.32 million or 2.1 per cent over the
     or -1.4 per cent over the current year’s approved budget.
                                                                   current financial year approved budget. The proposed
     This is shared among ministries and departments as
                                                                   budget mainly covers the cost of the provision for drugs,
     follows:
                                                                   dressings and vaccines, including antiretroviral therapy
     Mr Speaker, the Ministry of Basic Education has               programme and laboratory supplies. Other substantial
     been allocated the largest share of 18.8 per cent of          budget items include medical specialist fees, budgetary
     the proposed ministerial recurrent budget amounting           provision for the Public Officers’ Medical Aid Scheme
     to P9.52 billion. The amount represents a growth of           and service charges as well as maintenance of health
     P510.84 million or 5.7 per cent over the current year’s       facilities.
     approved budget. The growth mainly comprises the
                                                                    Mr Speaker, additional funding has been included to
     budgetary provisions for creation of a total of 1 751
                                                                   further support Government’s response and interventions
     positions of teachers to align with COVID-19 protocols
                                                                   to contain the pandemic and to mitigate the risks of
     in terms of reducing class size and social distancing
                                                                   new infections, spreading or resurgence of the disease.
     in schools across the country. This proposed budget
                                                                   The funding comprises personal protective equipment
     is mainly driven by personal emoluments for teachers
                                                                   for public health personnel and other support frontline
     and service charges, especially water and electricity in
                                                                   workers, medicines for the fight against the pandemic,
     schools. Other costs associated with schools include
                                                                   quarantine costs and acquisition of vaccines in line
     provision of food, text books, materials for practical
                                                                   with the agreement with the World Health Organisation
     subjects as well as stationery. Having said that, Mr
                                                                   (WHO).
     Speaker, I must emphasise that, in line with the findings

10   Hansard No 201
Monday 1st February, 2021                                               APPROPRIATION (2021/2022) BILL, 2021
                                                                           (NO. 2 OF 2021) Second Reading

 Mr Speaker, the proposed budget for the Ministry of          subventions for the financial year 2021/2022. This will
Local Government and Rural Development is P7.14               hopefully incentivise local authorities to prioritise their
billion, which represents the fourth largest share of         internal revenue generation efforts and reduce costs.
14.1 per cent of the proposed Ministerial Recurrent
Budget. This represents a minor decline of P12.34             Mr Speaker, the Ministry of Tertiary Education,
million, or -0.2 per cent, over the current financial year.   Research, Science and Technology’s budget allocation
The recommended budgetary provision is to support             for the financial year 2021/2022 is P4.60 billion. The
among others, initiatives to improve local governance,        recommended budget represents the fifth largest share at
strengthen social development and promote local               9.1 per cent of the proposed Ministerial Recurrent Budget.
economic development. The main cost driver for the            It is likely driven by the tertiary students’ sponsorship
recommended budget is Revenue Support Grants (RSG)            programme which entails allowances, tuition fees and
to district and urban councils, which accounts for 57.6       medical expenses for Government-sponsored students
per cent of this ministry’s proposed Recurrent Budget.        enrolled in both public and private tertiary institutions.
The proposed budget also includes interventions such          The proposed budget also includes staff and operational
as preventative measures at primary schools and the           costs of tertiary institutions and parastatals under the
provision of psycho-social support services to the            ministry. The proposed budget allocation is geared
general public in response to the effects of COVID-19,        towards providing appropriate education and training
such as the rising number of Gender Based-Violence
                                                              to students so that upon completion of their studies,
(GBV) incidents against women and children. The
                                                              they could become active players in the transition of the
recommended budgetary provision for Old Age Pension
                                                              country to a knowledge-based economy.
Scheme which has registered a rising growth from the
increase in the number of beneficiaries by 11.2 per cent      The Ministry of Transport and Communications
from 124,078 in 2020/2021.                                    recommended budget of P1.82 billion includes fuel
Mr Speaker, with regard to subventions to local               and lubricants, road maintenance, computer systems
authorities, it is important to acknowledge that there has    consumables and maintenance, postal charges and
been insufficient attention paid to maximising potential      agency fees, office equipment maintenance and sub-
                                                              contracted repairs. Mr Speaker, the funding will mainly
revenue collection by local authorities. For example,
                                                              cover the operational costs of the ministry in order to
urban councils should exercise due diligence in collecting
                                                              drive the development and utilisation of Information
the property rates due to them, instead of relying on
                                                              and Communications Technology (ICT) and integrated
subventions from central Government to bail them
                                                              transport services in Botswana. The budget also includes
out. This is not sustainable and local authorities will be
                                                              subventions to Civil Aviation Authority of Botswana
expected, in future, to cover more of their expenditures
                                                              (CAAB) and to meet the Universal Service Programme
from revenues that they generate themselves. This
                                                              obligations, which entail Government support for loss
ministry which is the Ministry of Finance and Economic
                                                              making post offices under Botswana Post. I must also
Development has also engaged the Ministry of Local
                                                              add, Mr Speaker, that the CAAB also needs to become
Government and Rural Development on revenue
                                                              less dependent on Government subventions and should
maximisation initiatives by councils. Follow-ups are
                                                              devise means to generate more revenues and reduce
being made to ensure that the local authorities are
                                                              costs.
intensifying their revenue collection efforts, including
property rates, Self Help Housing Agency (SHHA)               Mr Speaker, the Ministry for Presidential Affairs,
loan repayments, and fees from recreational or other          Governance and Public Administration has been
facilities. The ministry will also undertake a valuation      allocated a proposed Ministerial Recurrent Budget
exercise for eligible properties outside of towns and         of P1.58 billion. The budget allocation is aimed at
cities, which will assist the effort to extend the rateable   supporting the ministry in its quest to safeguard and
property base and collect appropriate rates.                  promote good governance as well as to guide sustainable
                                                              socio-economic growth and development for the benefit
Mr Speaker, in order to compel local authorities and
                                                              of all citizens. The budget will mainly cover operational
land boards to play their part in budget sustainability, a
                                                              costs for Office of the President and it has been slightly
5 per cent efficiency factor was applied to reduce their
                                                              augmented to cater for the envisaged Constitutional

                                                                                                      Hansard No 201        11
Monday 1st February, 2021                                                APPROPRIATION (2021/2022) BILL, 2021
                                                                            (NO. 2 OF 2021) Second Reading

Review exercise. Included in the proposed allocation is        accounts for 57.8 per cent, covering mainly the wage bill
the budgetary provision for Directorate on Intelligence        and other running costs. These supports Government’s
and Security (DIS). Other costs include subscription           commitment to ensure access and availability of land
costs for access to the television satellite and maintenance   through demarcation and allocation of plots to support
of transmitter contracts, as well as subventions to the        economic development and growth.
Botswana Red Cross, 2036 Vision Council and Public
Enterprises Evaluation and Privatisation Agency                Mr Speaker, the remaining P5.41 billion is to be shared
(PEEPA).                                                       among the rest of the ministries and extra-ministerial
                                                               departments.
Mr Speaker, the proposed amount of the Ministerial
Recurrent Budget for the Ministry of Agricultural              Development Budget
Development and Food Security is P1.39 billion, which
                                                               A sum of P14.75 billion is proposed for the Development
is intended to support the agriculture sector in pursuit of
                                                               Budget in the 2021/2022 financial year. The proposed
improved domestic food production to achieve a higher
degree of self-sufficiency in agricultural products.           budget will finance programmes and projects crucial
The proposed budget mainly comprises subventions               for restoration of economic growth. My ministry has
to Botswana University of Agriculture and Natural              ensured that the proposed programmes and projects
Resources (BUAN) and National Agricultural Research            are aligned to the Mid-Term Review of the National
and Development Institute (NARDI). The latter                  Development Plan (NDP) 11 and Economic Recovery
includes both Department of Agricultural Research              and Transformation Plan (ERTP), as well as the
(DAR), National Veterinary Laboratory (NVL) and                approved Strategic Thrusts.
National Food Technology Research Centre (NFTRC),
which are really a merger of the institution. Mr Speaker,      Mr Speaker, in order to alleviate pressure on the
the recommended budget also covers costs of Foot and           Government budget in the short to medium term,
Mouth Disease (FMD) vaccinations, operational costs            other forms of project delivery, such as Public Private
for Botswana Meat Commission (BMC) Maun and                    Partnerships (PPPs), continue to be pursued to deliver on
maintenance of existing facilities, including camps,           planned projects. With respect to engaging of the private
plant and equipment and computer systems such as the           sector in the implementation of projects using the PPP
Botswana Animal Information and Traceability System            model, several ministries have already identified some
(BAITS).                                                       suitable projects. The Ministry of Land Management,
                                                               Water and Sanitation Services has invited the private
With regard to the Ministry of Investment, Trade and           sector to undertake the Reclamation and Treatment
Industry, Mr Speaker, it has been allocated an amount of       of the Wastewater project at Glen Valley, while the
P975.03 million. The recommended budget comprises              Ministry of Mineral Resources, Green Technology and
mainly transfers to parastatals under the ministry,            Energy Security has already pre-qualified bidders for
which accounts for 76.8 per cent of its recurrent budget.      the Coal to Liquid Project. Private sector partners will
These includes funding for the Citizen Entrepreneurial         be contracted, in the coming financial year, to finance,
Development Agency (CEDA) in the implementation of             construct and operate these projects.
its revised guidelines, and improved support for Citizen
Economic Empowerment (CEE) under the Local                     Mr Speaker, in addition, requests for Expressions
Enterprise Authority (LEA).                                    of Interest (EOI) to build, finance and operate the
                                                               following projects on a PPP basis will be issued in the
In terms of the allocation to the Ministry of Finance and      coming financial year: the Zambezi Agro-Commercial
Economic Development, it amounts to P966.92 million,           Development project and the Chobe-Zambezi Water
which includes operational costs for the ministry as well      Transfer Scheme; Tshele Hill Bulk Fuel Storage Facility;
as grants, subventions, other transfers to parastatal and      Sepopa Prison Farm; headquarters for Botswana Prison
other organisations under this ministry, which accounts        Services; Serowe Magistrate Court; the Offender
for 33.5 per cent of its recurrent expenditure.                Rehabilitation Centre in Lobatse; the Francistown-Nata
                                                               road; Maun-Mohembo road; and the Mmamabula-
Mr Speaker, the Ministry of Land Management, Water
                                                               Lephalale and Mosetse-Kazungula railways. These
and Sanitation Services is allocated a Ministerial
                                                               are projects that we expect the private sector to join
Recurrent Budget of P963.95 million. The budget mainly
                                                               Government in delivering.
covers transfers to land boards across the country, which

                                                                                                      Hansard No 201       12
You can also read