THE EFFECTS OF LOCKDOWN A PASSAGE TO THE NORTH EAST THE FUTURE OF BOAT PROPULSION - National Association of Boat Owners

Page created by Wanda Carroll
 
CONTINUE READING
THE EFFECTS OF LOCKDOWN A PASSAGE TO THE NORTH EAST THE FUTURE OF BOAT PROPULSION - National Association of Boat Owners
The Magazine of the National Association of Boat Owners
                                                     Issue 3 May 2020

THE EFFECTS OF LOCKDOWN
A PASSAGE TO THE NORTH EAST
THE FUTURE OF BOAT PROPULSION
THE EFFECTS OF LOCKDOWN A PASSAGE TO THE NORTH EAST THE FUTURE OF BOAT PROPULSION - National Association of Boat Owners
2
3

The NABO Council                               Regional Representatives:

                                               Anglian Waterways
Chair, Legal Affairs and BSS Rep.                                                             The magazine of the National Association of Boat Owners
                                               Vacant
Mike Rodd
07831 860199 nabochair@nabo.org.uk             East Midlands Waterways                        Issue 3 May 2020
Vice Chair                                     Vacant
Mark Tizard                                    London Waterways
                                                                                              Contents                                                             Next NABO News copy date
07818 757676 mark.tizard@nabo.org.uk           David Williams                                                                                                      Articles, letters, cartoons and photos are most
                                                                                                4   Editorial.
Treasurer                                      07813 496208 london@nabo.org.uk                                                                                     wel­
                                                                                                                                                                      come. Images in JPEG format please.
                                                                                                5   In the Chair.
Helen Hutt                                     Middle Level                                     7   Fly on the wall.                                               Please email or post your contributions
07831 682092 hontreasurer@nabo.org.uk          Vacant                                                                                                              by June 27th 2020. Our email address is
                                                                                                8   Around the regions: Wales and South-
NABO News Editor                                                                                                                                                   nabonews@nabo.org.uk
                                               North East, Yorkshire and Humber, Shared             West, North-West
Peter Fellows                                  Ownership Rep.                                   9   Membership: Membership renewals
19 High Street, Bonsall, Derbyshire, DE4 2AS   Howard Anguish                                       and Coronavirus. Review of GDPR
                                                                                                                                                                   Cover photo
01629 825267 nabonews@nabo.org.uk              01482 669876 yorks@nabo.org.uk, shareowners@         regulations.                                                   To remind you of what summer on the water-
Webmaster, NAG (Operations) and BSS Rep.       nabo.org.uk                                     11   News: Letter to Richard Parry.                                 ways used to be like, this month’s cover photo
David Fletcher                                 North Wales & Borders Waterways                 12   Towpath visitors.                                              was a scene taken by Helen Hutt in York.
07719 276659 web@nabo.org.uk                   David Fletcher (details left)                                                                                       Win a year’s free membership by having your
                                                                                               13   Impact of restrictions on waterway
Media Officer                                  North West Waterways                                 businesses.                                                    photo selected for the front cover of NABO
Alison Tuck                                    Ken Hylins                                      14   Meeting with CRT’s Head of Boating.                            News. Please email photos as JPEG attachments,
07450 108659 alison.tuck@nabo.org.uk           07852 911539 khylins@hotmail.co.uk              15   Meeting of National Inland Navigation                          ideally portrait format with a file size of 2MB or
Communications Officer, Moorings Rep.,                                                              Forum.                                                         larger.
                                               River Severn
Continuous Cruising Rep.                                                                       16   April updates by EA and CRT.
                                               Phil Goulding (details left)
Phil Goulding                                                                                  18   Boating: IWA looks to future boat
01271 865340 cc@nabo.org.uk                    River Thames
                                                                                                    propulsion.
                                               Graham Paterson
Promotion and Recruitment                                                                     21    On-board induction cooking.
                                               0118 986 3959 midthames@nabo.org.uk
Ken Hylins                                                                                    22    A passage to the North East.
07852 911539 khylins@hotmail.co.uk             River Trent
                                                                                              26    Yet more on CO.
                                               Vacant
Minutes Secretary                                                                             28    Techies’ Corner: What needs checking
Vacant                                         South East Waterways                                 when you get back to your boat?
                                               Geoff Wood                                     29    Rewind: Issue No 3, 2005.
General Sec. (External Relations)
                                               07968 491118 se@nabo.org.uk                    30    Letters . I name this boat.
Mark Tizard
07818 757676 gen@nabo.org.uk                   Southern Waterways, Welsh Waterways
                                               Mike Rodd (details left)
NABO Online                                    West Midlands Waterways
                                               Alison Tuck (details left)
         Mark Tizard
         facebook.com/master.nabo              Additional Contacts
         David Fletcher                                                                       NABO News is published by the
         Twitter @NABO_Official                Assistant for the Disabled                     National Association of Boat Owners
                                               Ken Hylins                                     PO Box 7366, Wolverhampton, WV1 9GQ
                                               07852 911539 disability@nabo.org.uk
                                                                                              For membership matters: 35 Williamson Drive, Nantwich, Cheshire, CW5 5GJ
                                               Administration
                                                                                              Editor: Peter Fellows       Production: Chris Pink
                                               Vacant
                                                                                              Whilst every care is taken to ensure that the contents of this newsletter are factually correct, we accept no liability for any direct
                                                                                              or consequential loss arising from any action taken by anyone as a result of reading anything contained in this publication. The
                                                                                              views expressed are not necessarily those of the Association. The products and services advertised in this publication are not
                                                                                              necessarily endorsed by the Association.

NABO News Issue 3 May 2020
THE EFFECTS OF LOCKDOWN A PASSAGE TO THE NORTH EAST THE FUTURE OF BOAT PROPULSION - National Association of Boat Owners
4                                                                                                                                                                                                                    5
The Editor’s Column                                                                                                                                                                                         In the Chair

                         T                                                                                   L
                                  he ramifications of the          And in other news                                  ike many of our members in        extension of licences—but it is also
                                  Coronavirus lockdown have        It’s not all Covid-19 though: David                self-isolation at home and        understandable that they have asked
                                  dominated the waterway           Fletcher reviews NABO’s progress                   unable to travel to our boats,    those of us who can afford it, to do-
                                  news for nearly eight weeks      with the data protection regulations,              it has really come home to        nate back to them the savings we
                         at the time of writing and these are      since they were introduced two years      us how much the canals and rivers          gain, and I encourage those who can,
                         widely reflected in this issue.           ago, and requests the small number        are an essential part of our lives. It     to do so.
                            CRT’s decision not to close tow-       of members who have not yet re-           also reminds us how precious these            I feel it is necessary for me, per-
                         paths to visitors initially caused        sponded to get in touch.                  waterways are, and how urgently we         sonally, to address the question of
                         an intensely negative response on             David also describes progress         need to ensure that they are pro-          the towpath usage. I am deeply con-
                         social media by some liveaboard           with a CO monitoring study that is        tected.                                    cerned that CRT has been seriously
                         boaters. NABO’s support for CRT’s         underway. For those of you dream-             This will be especially important      and often publicly abused for its ap-
                         decision is explained by Mike Rodd        ing about your next trip, Helen Hutt      in the days ahead, when our econ-          proach to the use of our towpaths
                                                                   recounts her last big adventure in        omy will look very different from          during these days of self-isolation.
                                                                   the first of two articles about her       the immediate past, with govern-

Mostly, but not all                                                travels on north-eastern waterways.
                                                                   Stephen Peters commends the ben-
                                                                                                             ments facing many horrendous
                                                                                                             difficulties in recovering from the
                                                                                                             financial wrecking balls caused
                                                                                                                                                        Mindful of the needs
about Coronavirus                                                  efits of induction hobs in the galley
                                                                   and I have reviewed a paper by
                                                                   IWA’s Bowman Bradley, looking into
                                                                                                             by the pandemic. And—of vital
                                                                                                             interest to all of us—at the same
                                                                                                                                                        of others
Editor Peter Fellows has news of other                             the future for boat propulsion, with      time as the Government will be             NABO Chair Mike Rodd considers some effects of
                                                                   additional comments by Mike Rodd.         trying to sort out this mess, CRT          the pandemic
developments, even though little is happening on                       As we ‘went to press’, the            and EA will be bidding for at least
the waterways                                                      Government announced some eas-            some essential government funding.         To me, it seems that there are two
                                                                   ing of the lockdown measures and          As I have said before, I just cannot       sides to the debate. For the many
                         in his Chair’s column. NABO also          CRT adjusted its restrictions to en-      see how either body will be able to        (6,000 plus?) folk living on their
                         welcomes CRT’s support: for high-         able non-liveaboard boaters to visit      continue without some level of gov-        boats, it would seem logical that,
                         risk liveaboard boaters who are           their boats to check that everything      ernment support, at least similar to       with most towpaths less than two
                         self-isolating; for the extra month’s     is OK. Tony Brooks describes what         that which has been received in the        metres in width and right up against
                         licence offered to all leisure boaters;   to look out for in his Techies’ Corner    past. However, I really can’t see such     their moored boats, CRT should
                         and its support for trade and hire-       article. However, boaters are still       bids being high on any government's        simply close the towpaths to all but
                         boat businesses, each reported upon       unable to cruise, except to visit es-     priorities. It is vital, therefore, that   the boaters. A logical argument, but,
                                  in this issue. In his regional   sential services, but everyone is         boater representative bodies, such as      what about the many folk who live
                                  rep’s report, Ken Hylins, who    hoping that the current movement          NABO and RBOA, get behind CRT’s            in tower blocks in a city where there
                                  is self-isolating on his boat,   restrictions will soon be safely eased.   and EA’s bids—even though we must          are no local parks to exercise in?
                                  describes the assistance he      It would be nice to think that we can     also continue to be critical friends       Where else can they go to walk the
                                  is being offered by CRT vol-     all be back on the water by the time      when needed.                               kids—except on the safe, local tow-
                                  unteers and local residents.     that the June issue of NABO News              I fear for so many of the water-       path? Or, what if your shortest route
                                  However, many small wa-          is published but, even if this is the     ways-related businesses who are            to (possibly essential) work is along
                                  terway businesses do not         case, I suspect that we are in for a      facing a devastating year with pos-        the towpath and the alternatives are
                                  qualify for the Government       long haul back to a new version of        sibly no income at all. I can also see     much longer walks or rides up steep
                                  assistance on offer and there    normality. The waterway ‘landscape’       that many boaters may be financially       hills (like those around Bradford-
                                  is a request for members to      will be changed, hopefully not ir-        challenged and unable to pay marina        on-Avon and Bath) on some
                                  contact their MPs to rectify     retrievably, by the effects of this       fees etc. If this causes them to move      cyclist-unfriendly roads? These folk
                                  this with additional financial   virus. In the meantime, if you have       their boats onto the towpaths, that        have legitimate needs too. So, per-
                                  support measures. If noth-       exhausted your supply of waterway         will further compound the marina           sonally, I agree with CRT's current
                                  ing is done, there is a real     books and magazines as you while          operators’ financial position, as well     policy (at the time of writing) of lim-
                                  risk that many boatyards,        away the lockdown hours, I hope           as (in most cases) CRT’s. If boaters       ited but shared and considerate use
                                  marinas, chandleries and         that you enjoy reading something          are additionally unable to pay their       of towpaths, to comply with social
                                  hire companies will go out of    new in this issue.                        licence/registration fees, this will       distancing restrictions.
                                  business.                            Stay safe.                            add to the impact on CRT’s and                 Unfortunately, of course, there
                                                                                                             EA’s finances. We welcome CRT’s            will always be a small number of
NABO News Issue 3 May 2020                                                                                                                                                                    NABO News Issue 3 May 2020
THE EFFECTS OF LOCKDOWN A PASSAGE TO THE NORTH EAST THE FUTURE OF BOAT PROPULSION - National Association of Boat Owners
6                                                                                                                                                                                                                    7
In the Chair                                                                                                                                                                 NABO Council meeting April 25th 2020

                         folk who then selfishly abuse the        be kept safe. This crisis has brought
                         situation—and go screaming down
                         a towpath on their racing bikes try-
                                                                  home to us all just how interlinked
                                                                  we are—and the use of towpaths is
                                                                                                           Fly on the wall
                         ing to beat the latest STRAVA speed      just one more example of how we          Observes proceedings at the Council
                         record. Or those whose exercise is       ought to be mindful of the needs of
                                                                                                           meeting in April
                         a 20 km run, normally with their         others, together with the vital need

                                                                                                           W
                         mates, along a lovely flat and well      to keep everyone as safe as we can. I
                         cared-for towpath. Unfortunately,        should add that the reports we have                    ith everyone still in      and it is not enough to put up
                         CRT’s approach to handling this          received from liveaboards with spe-                    lockdown at home, I        signs advising people to avoid
                         situation seems to have been to just     cial needs have been very positive                     again listened-in to the   moored boats with liveaboards,
                         tell its boating community what its      regarding the support they have all                    Council members’ tel-      with too much text for passers-by
                         policy is, and then put up signs. This   received from CRT staff.                 econference call.                        to stop and read. One liveaboard
                         is instead of going public and stating       Naturally, meetings with the sen-        Councillors welcomed CRT’s           Councillor reported people fish-
                         clearly, through the national press      ior management of the EA, relating       support for boaters by extending         ing next to his boat and groups
                         and other media, that towpaths           to their navigational responsibili-      their licences for a month and also      of long-distance walkers stopping
                         should be used by non-boaters            ties becoming less dependent on          developing payment plans for boat-       nearby for a rest, which he blamed
                         ONLY where absolutely essential,         government funding and exploring         ers who are experiencing difficulties    on people being confused by lack of
                         and then laying out the conditions       how to become more commercially          paying their licence fees—the indi-      clarity in the signage. Councillors
                         under which this may be done, so         viable, have ground to a halt. This      cations suggest that a lot are having    agreed that a simple message, such
                         that those who have no choice but to     also appears to have happened with       difficulties. CRT is also giving sup-    as ‘stay away from here’, and diver-     NABO calendar 2020
                         moor against the towpath can also        evaluating the tenders to oversee the    port to the hire industry with a         sionary routes around liveaboard         Council meetings are
Photo: Helen Hutt                                                                                          three-month licence rebate as an         boaters, where possible, should be
                                                                  management of all the EA’s Thames                                                                                          normally held at boat
                                                                  moorings. We know that there were        emergency measure.                       devised. But the real problem is not     clubs in the Midlands
                                                                  two experienced bidders for the              The Council agreed that boaters      local residents out for a stroll or a    area.
                                                                  contract, and they await a decision.     should continue to pay their licence     cycle-ride along a towpath; it is the    However, with Covid-19
                                                                  While this will only immediately af-     fee in the short-term, even though       lycra-clad runners and speeding          they will be held by
                                                                  fect boaters using the Thames, the       they are unable to use their boats,      cyclists, panting as they approach       teleconference in June,
                                                                  underlying concept of outsourcing        but this could become an issue in        unsuspecting walkers from behind,        September and October.
                                                                  moorings management is of vital in-      the medium-term. For those who           who, if infected, are potentially        Members are welcome
                                                                  terest to all of us, as I am sure CRT    moor in a marina, the mooring fees       spreading the virus to large numbers     to attend meetings and
                                                                                                           add to their problems and a conse-       of people. CRT should crack down         to join in those held by
                                                                  will be looking very closely at this                                                                                       teleconference; please
                                                                  approach!                                quence may be boaters moving to          on such selfish activity by banning
                                                                                                                                                                                             just let the Secretary or
                                                                      Your NABO Council continues to       towpath moorings to reduce costs.        running and high-speed cycling on        Chair know in advance
                                                                  meet regularly via teleconferences,      This will have a knock-on effect on      towpaths—after all, the roads are        (contact details inside
                                                                  and the sessions have proved to be       marina incomes and CRT should            now almost empty and perfectly safe      cover).
                                                                  very productive and well-attended.       be supporting marina owners to get       for these activities.                    The remaining dates for
                                                                  As in so many other areas where we       government assistance.                      CRT is using the ‘Boaters’            Council meetings in 2020
                                                                  are being forced to operate in differ-       NABO also supports CRT’s deci-       Update’ to communicate its distanc-      are as follows: June 20th,
                                                                  ent ways, I do wonder what we will       sion not to close towpaths, despite      ing requirements, effectively asking     September 5th, October
                                                                  be able to take from these experi-       the uproar on social media and           boaters to enforce these. It should be   10th and November 14th
                                                                  ences when the situation changes         abusive emails being sent by some        using the local and national press to    (includes AGM).
                                                                  back. Whilst face-to-face meetings       boaters to CRT’s Customer Services.      inform land-based residents of what
                                                                  are valuable, these teleconferences      Towpaths are important for local         they can, and cannot, do on tow-
                                                                  are less costly and can be very pro-     residents to get some exercise and       paths. It has also advised liveaboard
                                                                  ductive. Food for thought!               fresh air, especially in urban areas,    boaters to move to a quieter moor-
                                                                      Finally, despite these strange       but CRT’s promotion of towpath use       ing if they consider themselves to be
                                                                  times for all of us, I wish you eve-     at the start of the lockdown smacked     at risk, but other boaters see them
                                                                  rything of the best and, for those       of a ‘wellbeing’ PR exercise. There      moving and think ‘if they can move,
                                                                  unlucky ones who are not living on       are problems in physical distancing      so can I’ and lockdown restrictions
                                                                  their boats, I hope we all see our       where narrow towpaths are being          are starting to be ignored.
                                                                  boats again soon!                        used by large numbers of people,            Byeee until happier times.
NABO News Issue 3 May 2020                                                                                                                                                               NABO News Issue 3 May 2020
THE EFFECTS OF LOCKDOWN A PASSAGE TO THE NORTH EAST THE FUTURE OF BOAT PROPULSION - National Association of Boat Owners
8                                                                                                                                                                                                                    9
NABO News

                                                       challenged about their presence on the canal. I
Wales and the
South West
                                                       have moved to a more secluded spot and I am
                                                       now getting almost no people coming near the
                                                                                                              Membership matters
                                                       boat. There have been six boats that have passed       David Fletcher and the Membership Team
Mike Rodd                                              me, but their direction of travel is possibly to re-
With many boaters safely                               turn to their home moorings. I have had three
self-isolating, there is little                        emails from CRT, asking about my position and          Renewals and Covid-19
movement on the canals.                                what services I need to be open. A CRT volun-
    It was reported that                               teer has called three times to see how I am. The       Our May membership renewals have all gone out         team already under restrictions, we must avoid
there were scores of dead                              local community has offered to help with a free        to those with an email address. Some members          doing this. Bank standing orders are our prefer-
fish spotted in the Kennet & Avon in Devizes.                                                                 do not have standing orders in place and action       ence, but direct transfer or PayPal are good too.
The EA said the coronavirus lockdown has re-                                                                  is required by them to pay by direct transfer or      Perhaps someone could make the payment on
sulted in a drop in traffic and activity on the                                                               PayPal.                                               your behalf? Please use your membership num-
canal, and this has created a series of stagnant
pools between locks—resulting in the fish suf-
                                                       Around the                                                 The only paper documents being sent are
                                                                                                              to those very few people for whom we have no
                                                                                                                                                                    ber so that we can identify the receipt.
                                                                                                                                                                        Having said that, if there is no alternative, we
focating through a lack of oxygen. However, a                                                                 email address. We have also changed our corre-        ask that you give us a call, and we will sort out
local fish expert (also a medical professional)
commented that there had probably been a toxic         regions with                                           spondence address for all, to a personal one in
                                                                                                              Nantwich, so that we can better respond in these
                                                                                                              difficult times. If you get a paper letter, and you
                                                                                                                                                                    something, perhaps extending membership for a
                                                                                                                                                                    few months until this is over.
                                                                                                                                                                        Please be sure that we remain committed to
leak as the distribution is quite localised. Also,
the fish involved are stillwater animals and could
cope. A local boater said there had been a large
diesel spillage in the area, which may have led to
                                                       NABO’s                                                 have an email address, please let us know so that
                                                                                                              we can use it in the future.
                                                                                                                  We ask for members’ cooperation by avoiding
                                                                                                                                                                    supporting all members who don’t use the in-
                                                                                                                                                                    ternet and similar systems, but we need to use
                                                                                                                                                                    time-saving technology wherever possible so
the deaths.                                                                                                   payment by bank cheque if at all possible. It may     that we can concentrate our efforts on those who
    There have been reports that, on the K&A,
there have been some unfortunate conflicts
                                                       regional reps                                          be very convenient for you to write a cheque and
                                                                                                              post it, but that just transfers the problem to the
                                                                                                                                                                    really need a paper reminder.
                                                                                                                                                                        The membership team will really appreciate
where liveaboard boaters, who are understand-                                                                 membership team. A cheque is of no use if we          your cooperation to keep things going in these
ably very unhappy with the folks cycling or                                                                   cannot go to the bank and, with the membership        difficult times.
running along the towpaths, have taken mat-            electric hook-up and several local people have
ters into their own hands. However, there are a        offered to shop for me (I must be getting old!),
significant number of people who have almost           and I’m told that, if I need assistance, I should
no alternative but to use the towpath to get to        just ask.
work—including some working in Bath hospitals             David Fletcher adds: Following a wet
and care homes—perhaps a case of a small mi-           February, both March and April have been very          NABO Review of GDPR regulations
nority of thoughtless people spoiling things for       dry, particularly in the north. Due to this and
the majority?                                          some lower levels in reservoirs post-Toddbrook,
                                                                                                              An update on progress over the last year.             public knowledge or is about someone’s profes-
                                                       the Peak Forest, Macclesfield, Huddersfield and
                                                                                                              The General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR)         sional life can be personal data. Almost anything
North West                                             Leeds & Liverpool canals are closed for the fore-
                                                                                                              was introduced in May 2018, following the Data        we do with data counts as ‘processing’; including
                                                       seeable future. The aim is to save water so that,
                                                                                                              Protection Act 2018.                                  collecting, recording, storing, using, analysing,
Ken Hylins                                             when the system is reopened, we have some wa-
                                                                                                                  We concluded at that time that the regu-          combining, disclosing or deleting it.
I am at Appley Bridge, a                               ter to play with. There has been some comment
                                                                                                              lations do apply to ourselves, as we hold                We must regularly review our processing
suburb of Wigan on the                                 on social media about a blockage on the feeder to
                                                                                                              information about people for a ‘business or other     and, where necessary, update our documenta-
east Lancashire border.                                the Peak Forest from Coombes Reservoir. I un-
                                                                                                              non-household purpose’. The law applies to any        tion and our privacy information for individuals.
There have been signs put                              derstand that, although there is a blockage, this
                                                                                                              ‘processing of personal data’, and therefore covers   We must review and update our accountability
up about the limited use of                            is not the only problem and it could take some
                                                                                                              all organisations, whatever their size. ‘Personal     measures at appropriate intervals. This is done in
the canal towpath close to                             time to get this flow going again. The stoppages
                                                                                                              data’ means information about a particular liv-       April each year.
me.                                                    mean that the coal boats cannot pass and sup-
                                                                                                              ing individual. This might be anyone, including
    They have had little effect on towpath footfall    port those liveaboards on these waters.
                                                                                                              a customer, client, employee, partner, mem-           Our current position
as, in my estimation, there is a three- to four-fold      As we went to press, we heard that Ken is
                                                                                                              ber, supporter, business contact, public official       Review of the processing activities. There are
increase in its use. A policeman walked along the      scheduled to have major heart surgery; we wish
                                                                                                              or member of the public. It doesn’t need to be          no new activities and the procedure still ap-
towpath last Sunday afternoon, but nobody was          him well for a speedy recovery
                                                                                                              ‘private’ information—even information that is          plies.

NABO News Issue 3 May 2020                                                                                                                                                                 NABO News Issue 3 May 2020
THE EFFECTS OF LOCKDOWN A PASSAGE TO THE NORTH EAST THE FUTURE OF BOAT PROPULSION - National Association of Boat Owners
10                                                                                                                                                                                                              11
Membership matters                                                                                                                                                                                            News

                                                        tempted. It is possible that they have moved
After extensive chasing,                                house without telling us. It is proposed to
                                                        write again after the virus lockdown is over,
                                                                                                         Dear Richard
we are now down to                                      using recorded delivery. We have records to
                                                        demonstrate that we have attempted to get
                                                                                                         An open letter from NABO to Richard Parry

                                                                                                         D
                                                        agreement. Council may wish to consider the
five members who have                                   best course of action should we be unsuccess-               ear Richard.                    and will be at risk of closure, with
                                                        ful.                                                        Following NABO’s recent         the resultant loss of facilities and
not agreed the privacy                                  Statement on data security. Web security and
                                                        theft of computers are the prime concerns.
                                                                                                                    Council meeting, I have
                                                                                                                    been asked to write to you
                                                                                                                                                    moorings. We would support any
                                                                                                                                                    attempt by CRT to help the marina
policy                                                  These issues are addressed in the procedure
                                                        and will be further considered in the risk as-
                                                                                                         to raise the following concerns: we
                                                                                                         appreciate the efforts that CRT is
                                                                                                                                                    industry, either directly or through
                                                                                                                                                    Government. We would suggest that
                                                        sessment.                                        now making to limit the use of the         CRT considers temporarily forgoing
  Privacy policy adequacy. We have a policy in          Review of complaints. There have been no         towpath for exercise, specifically in      its 9% mooring levy for marinas that
  place and no amendment is proposed at this            complaints.                                      areas where there are moored boats,        are prepared to offer a mooring ‘hol-
  time. There have been no challenges.                  Review of data loss or disclosure events.        but we feel more needs to be done.         iday’ to those in genuine need.
  Review of the accountability of Association           There have been no losses of data in the year.      We are hearing of instances                 We urge CRT to start talking to
  officers. These are set out in the procedure                                                           (Nantwich and New Mills, to name           the insurance sector regarding the
  and no changes are recommended.                    Main action items identified in 2019                but two) where speeding cyclists and       requirement for the BSS, to arrive
  Review of access to data by Association offic-       Continue with initiatives to complete agree-      serious runners are putting the rest       at a general agreement that this re-
  ers. Access to data is limited to membership         ment by membership (to be continued).             of the towpath population at risk.         quirement is formally suspended.
  team members.                                        Write to life members and share the data we       Because they are exercising strenu-        Hopefully, there is an awareness and
  Procedure adequacy. The procedure has                hold (completed).                                 ously, they are inevitably exhaling        understanding that, once the lock-
  been checked against the Information                 Document the responsibilities of officers and     more forcibly than a gentle walker         down requirements are lifted, there
  Commissioner’s Office’ requirements and is           approve in Council (completed).                   or leisure cyclist; and this is why we     will need to be a substantial period
  considered adequate. The latest version is out       Document the data that we hold, including         feel that this particular group should     of time, months not weeks, for sur-
  for comment by Council.                              the archives. Say why we keep these and ad-       be told, not encouraged, to use al-        veyors to be able to deal with the
  Review of data holdings. We have completed           dress actions (audit completed and results in     ternative routes such as dedicated         backlog and for boatyards to be able
  a data survey to identify what we hold. There        procedures, completed).                           cycle paths, roads and wide pave-          to carry out any remedial work.
  were no surprises. The most significant data is      Make further efforts to retrieve archives held    ments where 2m distancing can be               Finally, there is growing con-
  held on the website and on membership team           by Richard Carpenter (completed).                 guaranteed. It is often too late if they   cern that the safety of some boats
  members’ computers. We have completed an             Write simple procedures and approve in            happen to see a poster once they get       moored on the towpath may be at
  impact assessment on data loss.                      Council (completed, further version with          to the towpath. We suggest a local         risk, either internally through the
  Statement on data minimisation. We have              Council for comment).                             radio campaign or a press release          state of batteries, bilges etc., or ex-
  completed the disposal of historical paper           Carry out a risk assessment and impact as-        sent to the relevant outlets and post-     ternally through the possibility of
  holdings and now concentrate on web-based            sessment on data loss, and address actions        ers within the nearby communities.         damage and vandalism. Some insur-
  data.                                                arising from it (risk assessment outstanding).       We welcome the extra month              ance policies insist that boats are not
  Statement of storage limitation. We have had         Consider in Council whether we have enough        given to leisure boat licences. We         left unattended for extended periods
  no requests for deletion of members’ data. We        expertise on this issue (no action taken, to be   suspect many boaters are likely to         of time. Should the lockdown be fur-
  have adopted a routine of data deletion from         considered).                                      face increased financial difficulties      ther extended, CRT should consider
  the live database in the year following a resig-                                                       in the coming months in meeting            granting permission for boaters to
  nation. Backups are retained.                      Proposed actions for 2020                           their licence and mooring payments         visit, but not move, their boats to
  Statement of members’ acceptance. After              Continue with initiatives to complete agree-      and hope that CRT will keep this           enable batteries to be recharged etc.
  extensive chasing, we are now down to five           ment by membership (five persons only).           under review the longer the cur-               In summary, our members are
  members who have not agreed the privacy              Update the procedure and approve in Council.      rent restrictions remain in place.         very appreciative of the steps CRT
  policy. These are all longstanding members           Complete a risk assessment on data loss and       We are concerned that boaters will         is taking to contact and protect vul-
  without email and may have limited under-            address actions arising from it.                  be tempted to vacate moorings              nerable boaters and the steps already
  standing of GDPR. They have been written to          Consider in Council whether we have enough        and move to the towpath to reduce          taken to cushion the effects of the
  several times, and phone calls have been at-         expertise on this issue.                          costs. Some marinas, already hit by        lockdown on the trade and on boat-
                                                                                                         loss of trade through chandleries,         ers generally.
                                                                                                         hire boats etc. will struggle to cope          Regards, Mike Rodd
NABO News Issue 3 May 2020                                                                                                                                                                NABO News Issue 3 May 2020
THE EFFECTS OF LOCKDOWN A PASSAGE TO THE NORTH EAST THE FUTURE OF BOAT PROPULSION - National Association of Boat Owners
12                                                                                                                                                                                                              13
COVID-19 News                                                                                                                                                                                        COVID-19 News

Towpath Visitors                                                                                            Impact of Restrictions on
...swapping tourist hotspots for local towpaths

Since the start of the coronavirus distancing          Brindley Place in Birmingham and Camden.
                                                                                                            Waterway Businesses
measures, CRT reports a shift in usage from busy           However, these percentage figures should         Write to your MP
tourist hotspots like Little Venice in London or       be treated with a degree of caution: the actual

                                                                                                            P
central Birmingham, to local less-used canal tow-      numbers of visits, pre-lockdown, in the top three
paths in residential areas, increased usage by less    inner-city areas are tiny compared to more popu-
                                                                                                                      lease write to your MP to What we want from                            You can find out who
affluent communities where green space may be          lar locations and, even now, during lockdown
                                                                                                                      raise concerns you may have Government:                                your MP is, and how
at a premium.                                          they are comparable to many other locations;                                                                                          best to contact them,
                                                                                                                      for the waterway businesses    A financial package, similar to
    The report gives data from towpath counters        some other popular locations; Stratford on                                                                                            by looking at the
                                                                                                                      and organisations in your      that offered to the fishing in-
around the country, who noted that the largest         Avon, Brecon show increased numbers of visits;                                                                                        Parliamentary website:
                                                                                                            local area.                              dustry, to enable navigation
percentage increases in numbers of visits were         and other inner-city areas; Coventry, Sheffield,                                                                                      members.parliament.uk/
                                                                                                                You may want to include some of      authorities to underwrite licence
in Burnley, Sandwell and Blackburn and other           Leicester and Leeds show falls in visitor numbers,                                                                                    FindYourMP.
                                                                                                            the following points as part of your     and mooring fees for waterway
inner-city areas. The three largest percentage falls   as towpaths are no longer being used for commut-
                                                                                                            letter, but it is best if each letter is businesses for this year. This
in numbers were recorded in Paddington Basin,          ing or lunchtime breaks.
                                                                                                            unique.                                  would relieve businesses of a
                                                             Average Daily Count                                                                     significant cost and allow navi-
                                                       Baseline before   Post lockdown                      The key issues                           gation authorities to continue to
                           Area                                                             % Change
                                                         lockdown          21st March                           The inland waterway leisure in-      maintain the waterways so that
                           Burnley                             97               350            261%             dustry is worth approximately        everyone can safely use them
                           Sandwell                            52               156            199%             £1.5bn to the economy but            when the restrictions are over.
                           Blackburn                          194               555            187%             waterway businesses are dispro-      Additional financial schemes for
                           Milton Keynes                       84               229            172%             portionately impacted because        the businesses that are still falling
                           Torfaen                            416              1028            147%             the majority do not qualify for      between the gaps of the grants
                           Wolverhampton                      125               291            132%             existing Government support.         and loans already on offer.
                           Walsall                             89               205            130%             They have little or no access to
                           Birmingham (Inner)                463               1024            121%             the grants, loan schemes or rates Please ask your MP to:
                           Tottenham Hale                    1051             2248             114%             rebates currently being offered by   Raise this matter with George
                           Ilkeston                           314               595            90%              Government. Business owners          Eustice MP, Secretary of State
                           Liverpool                         236               440              87%
                                                                                                                are wary of taking on loans which    for Environment Food & Rural
                           London (West)                     948               1424            50%
                                                                                                                would have to be paid back next      Affairs, and Rishi Sunak MP,
                           Pocklington                        126               171             36%
                                                                                                                year despite having lost this year’s Chancellor of the Exchequer;
                           York                              1557             2078              33%
                                                                                                                income.                              Attend the next meeting of the
                           Stratford-upon-Avon                361               471             30%
                           Brecon                            495                585             18%
                                                                                                                The high dependency on income        All-Party Parliamentary Group
                           Nottingham                        297                342             15%
                                                                                                                during the spring and summer         for the Waterways on this impor-
                           Manchester                         748               830             11%             means that the Covid-19 cri-         tant topic.
                           Brent                             1671              1740              4%             sis has hit at the worst possible
                           Stockton-on-Tees                  623                584             -6%             time, with annual expenditure for
                           Coventry                          208                186             -11%            maintenance and running costs
                           Devizes                            431               373            -13%             having already been paid out over
                           Saul Junction                      241               185            -23%             the winter.
                           Sheffield                         602                433            -28%             Most waterway businesses have
                           Leicester                         570               409             -28%             had to cease trading while the
                           Leeds                            2438               1561            -36%             current restrictions are in place.
                           Pontcysyllte WHS                  610                380            -38%             Some have already closed per-
                           London (Camden)                   5173             2729             -47%             manently, with many more at
                           Birmingham (Central)             2567               1241            -52%             significant risk of collapse before
                           London Paddington                11224             3094             -72%             the end of the year.
                                                                                                                                                     Photo: Bradford Wharf Services
NABO News Issue 3 May 2020                                                                                                                                                               NABO News Issue 3 May 2020
THE EFFECTS OF LOCKDOWN A PASSAGE TO THE NORTH EAST THE FUTURE OF BOAT PROPULSION - National Association of Boat Owners
14                                                                                                                                                                                                                          15
News                                                                                                                                                                                                                    News

NABO at the user groups                                                                                                                                                          NABO at the user groups

Meeting with CRT’s Head of Boating                                                                     National Inland Navigation Forum
Mike Rodd and Mark Tizard have a catch-up call with Matthew Symonds, CRT’s Head of Boating,            Mike Rodd reports back from the meeting
joined by his deputy, Rachel Haywood.

                                                                                                       T
  Approximately one third of CRT staff have          have a material financial effect on other engi-             he NINF met via a teleconference on          not been invited to recent meetings. The General
  been furloughed and the Trust is topping up        neering works, dredging etc.                                Saturday 28th March, with most member        Secretary would contact IWA about this fail-
  the 20% to ensure that all staff continue to re-   Matthew advised that it was too early to un-                organisations represented. This forum        ing. It was also agreed that having a separate
  ceive full pay.                                    derstand whether the current emergency                      continues to be a useful platform for the    Parliamentary Group covering the Thames was
  CRT has given trade/hire businesses a three-       would impact future Government grant fund-        various bodies to exchange views, bringing to-         not necessary.
  month rebate/refund on trade licence costs.        ing, but it was hoped that the importance of      gether the navigation bodies, CRT, EA and other            The question of creating additional residen-
  The trade rebate, the reduction in income          the towpath for exercise and ‘wellbeing’, and     waterways’ organisations having current active         tial moorings was discussed in some detail and
  from licences, friends and museums, and a          CRT’s management of its liveaboard custom-        members, including The Barge Association,              members strongly supported the view that this
  fall in property investment rentals/values         ers would be seen in a positive light.            the Association of Waterway Cruising Clubs,            should be encouraged, especially given that the
  have resulted in CRT facing some financial         CRT will continue to maintain the Bridgwater      NABO, the Great Ouse Boating Association,              (only?) growth in the number of boats being pur-
  constraints, which are difficult as yet to quan-   and Taunton canal but give up the lease on        the Historic Narrow Boat Club, the Commercial          chased was for use as prime residences. Indeed,
  tify.                                              Bridgewater Docks. There are ongoing dis-         Boat Operators’ Association, the IWA and the           this was probably the reason why many boat
  There are currently no plans to offer a pay-       cussions around CRT managing moorings.            Residential Boat Owners’ Association.                  builders were still in business!
  ment holiday for leisure licence holders as        BSS discussions are also ongoing with all in-         The meeting attempted to look positively to-           It was agreed to support the recent changes
  it is unclear how many have been impacted.         terested parties. CRT is concerned as a BSS       ward the future, but recognised that the present       promoting the use of smokeless coal and prop-
  CRT is asking all licence holders who are in       certificate is currently a condition to obtain    crisis would both be with us for longer than pres-     erly seasoned wood, by banning the sales of
  financial difficulty to get in touch to discuss    a licence (the same for most marinas and          ently anticipated and would inevitably impact          products that do not satisfy these requirements.
  a revised payment plan (note: this is a defer-     insurers). All agreed that there might be an      on the years ahead. The situation regarding the        It was also agreed to monitor the red diesel situ-
  ral not a withdrawal). Boaters are urged not       impact on licence/insurance/mooring renew-        future funding by Government for all waterways         ation, noting that the proposed changes could
  to cancel their direct debits, as this would       als if there is insufficient allowance made for   authorities meant that we, as the representatives      have serious impacts for many users, including
  cause difficulties for both CRT and the boat-      boaters to obtain a BSS certificate and to get    of most boating organisations, needed to be seen       effects on commercial boats.
  ers concerned, but to contact the Trust. CRT       any remedial work done once the lockdown is       to be joined together and getting behind the bids          Once again, the issue of short-term boat rent-
  will also offer advice on how to access other      withdrawn.                                        by CRT and EA.                                         als (mainly via Airbnb) was highlighted and it
  support if it is able to. These plans will be      Mike pointed out that the EA appeared to              Part of this had to be via direct contact with     was agreed that NINF would support all attempts
  reviewed should the lockdown continue for          be adopting many of CRT’s practices and           MPs and local councils and, once again, it was         by the navigational authorities to regulate this,
  longer than is currently envisaged.                Matthew confirmed that CRT is offering ad-        felt that all bodies should be invited to attend all   where possible. It was noted, however, that some
  With a few minor exceptions, the winter stop-      vice in many areas when asked. He was also        meetings of the All-Party Parliamentary Group          marina operators were actually encouraging the
  page programme has been completed. There           aware that the EA was tendering for manage-       for the Waterways, as it appeared that most had        present bad (and questionably illegal) practice!
  was some discussion about extending the            ment of moorings and enforcement and he
  boating ‘season’ by deferring winter stoppages     would look at the outcomes.
  to enable boats to cruise later in the year.       Mark noted that the virus had shown how im-       This is How Boaters’
  Matthew reported receiving many emails re
  towpath safety, many of which had been very
                                                     portant towpath services are, given that many
                                                     marinas had closed and some closures might
                                                                                                       Reps Should Work
  vociferous and often abusive. The issue had        be permanent. He hoped that CRT would                                                                                                   YOUR USE
  become more manageable with improved               take this into consideration in its thoughts
                                                                                                       Having seen the poster that CRT suggested                LIMIT YOUR                    OF CANAL TOWPATHS
                                                                                                       boaters should print out—a corporate blue back-          USE OF CANAL TOWPATHS
  posters and banners, which seemed to be            about the future provision of facilities (the     ground with a few white letters that is expensive
  working, and with CRT’s advice that livea-         internal report on this, which was due to be      in its use of ink and impractical, and obviously                                       Strictly for local use only
                                                                                                                                                                                              Please keep your distance from
  board boaters could move to quieter areas.         discussed, has been delayed). The two ten-        designed and approved by non-boaters—Mark                 #StayHomeSaveLives           other people and moored boats

  The work at Toddbrook is to be planned over        ders for removal of waste and maintenance of      Tizard contacted Helen. She passed the com-                  before...                         ...after
  several years, and other similar reservoirs        facilities are due to be awarded shortly. This    ments on and well done to CRT for taking them
  have been subject to inspection and lowered        should lead to improvements in areas such as      on board and changing it.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                   #ProtectTheNHS
                                                                                                                                                                                                               #StayHomeSaveLives

  water levels. This is not currently expected to    recycling.
NABO News Issue 3 May 2020                                                                                                                                                              NABO News Issue 3 May 2020
THE EFFECTS OF LOCKDOWN A PASSAGE TO THE NORTH EAST THE FUTURE OF BOAT PROPULSION - National Association of Boat Owners
16                                                                                                                                                                                                         17
CRT News                                                                                                                                                                                             CRT News

April Updates by the EA and CRT                                                                               Non-governmental agencies and charities that offer free help and advice
The strategic review of the EA boat registration     month from their current expiry date. With the
                                                                                                              Waterways Chaplain                                 The Money Advice Service
charges has been postponed and a new charge          crisis affecting the Trust’s income, it is asking
                                                                                                              Emergency contact through contact form             0300 500 5000
scheme will be delayed until 2022. Boaters who       those who are able to afford it, to donate the ex-
                                                                                                              at www.waterwayschaplaincy.org.uk                  www.moneyadviceservice.org.uk
are navigating rivers to access essential services   tra month’s licence fee back to the Trust, using
or facilities should take care in case of unmarked   the ‘donate’ button on its website.                      Shelter                                            Christians Against Poverty
hazards or obstructions to navigation, such as          CRT has adjusted its mowing regimes, with             0808 800 4444                                      01274 760720
fallen trees and shoals.                             cutting only at locks, landings and moorings             www.shelter.org.uk                                 www.capuk.org
    Reduced operations by its staff mean that the    (deemed essential for safe access). General tow-
EA is unable to respond to these as normal. EA       path grass cutting will be deemed non-essential.         Samaritans                                         Age UK
staff will not provide assisted passage at locks     Cutting from the nearest access point to towpath         116 123                                            0800 169 6565
that can be self-operated and they will only op-     moorings, to ensure access is maintained, will           www.samaritans.org.uk                              www.ageuk.org.uk
erate locks where they are obliged to provide        be from the water's edge to 500mm behind the
this service. From 9th April until further no-       towpath. (Mowing regime maps can be found at             Salvation Army                                     Civil Legal Advice
tice, the EA has introduced lock restrictions at     https://canalrivertrust.org.uk, search ‘Mowing           0207 3674500                                       0345 345 4345
Abingdon, Marsh, Hambleden, Cookham, Bell            regimes’.)                                               www.salvationarmy.org.uk                           www.gov.uk/civil-legal-advice
Weir, Sunbury and Teddington Locks. Passage
through locks at Hambleden, Cookham, Bell            Information for those living on their boat               Citizens Advice Bureau                             Silverline
Weir and Teddington is by prior arrangement          CRT is continuing to maintain essential boating          03444 111 444                                      24hr helpline for older people
and on an exceptional basis only. This can be        facilities, and services can be found at canalriv-       www.citizensadvice.org.uk                          0800 470 8090
sought by emailing WaterwaysThames@envi-             ertrust.org.uk/enjoy-the-waterways/boating/
ronment-agency.gov.uk or telephoning 03708           boating-services.
506 506, although there may be considerable              Pump-out cards can still be purchased from          that is compiling a list of the help available to   those who are experiencing financial hardship
delays in facilitating requests. Passage is not      CRT’s online shop at shop.canalrivertrust.org.          boaters around the network. There is also a range   due to the virus, more information on the CRT
possible through Marsh Lock, which has a tree        uk/shop. A list of privately-operated facilities        of support from the Government, available for       website tiny.cc/vlmloz.
blocking boat passage, and Abingdon Lock,            can be found at tiny.cc/fbmloz CRT will update
which has been damaged through misuse by a           the list of facilities that are open. If boaters know
boater. Sunbury Lock has a sunken boat in the        of facilities that are not listed, they should inform
main channel above the lock cut. These locks will    CRT via the online webform canalrivertrust.org.
be reopened when the EA operations teams are         uk/contact-us.                                          Uncertainty in Bridgwater
able to recommence their activities.                     There are increasing reports of fly-tipping
    CRT and the EA have extended BSS certifica-      and pollution incidents and CRT has reminded
                                                                                                             The future of Bridgwater Docks has
tion until 11th May for boaters whose certificates   boaters that, regardless of the usual method of
                                                                                                             become uncertain as CRT will not renew
have expired or are about to expire. The situation   disposal (pump-out, Elsan, composting etc.), un-
                                                                                                             the lease when it expires in July due to
will then be reviewed. Boat owners are advised to    der no circumstances should sewage be emptied
                                                                                                             the cost of maintaining the docks in the
check any implications for their boat’s insurance    into a waterway. If boaters see any instances of
                                                                                                             long-term. It will work with Somerset
cover, linked to the temporary waiver of BSS         fly-tipping or pollution, please report them at
                                                                                                             County Council to find alternative ways
certification, with their broker or underwriter.     canalrivertrust.org.uk/contact-us/reporting-lit-
                                                                                                             of managing the docks to safeguard their
For more information, visit the BSS website at       ter-weeds-and-pollution.
                                                                                                             future once the lease expires.
www.boatsafetyscheme.org. On the matter of               Self-isolating on a boat: CRT is proactively
insurance and any clauses relating to leaving a      contacting boaters who are known to be in a             Volunteers already have a role at the site
boat unoccupied for a length of time, CRT sub-       high-risk group, including those with equality ad-      and a voluntary group or organisation
sequently suggested that boaters should speak        justments, those who are pregnant, and those who        taking a more active role to manage
directly to their insurance provider, believing it   are over 70. Anyone who lives on their boat and         and maintain it is one possible option,
likely that insurers would not be unreasonable,      falls into one of these categories should contact       particularly as they may be able to bid for
given that boaters are following Government          CRT to obtain support at www.gov.uk/coronavi-           funding that’s not available to the County
guidelines not to visit second homes or make         rus-extremely-vulnerable. There is a Facebook           Council.
non-essential journeys.                              group          www.facebook.com/Boaters-Covid-          Bridgwater Mercury
    All CRT licences will be extended by one         Support-National-Network-102792934713394

                                                                                                                                                                 Photo: CRT
NABO News Issue 3 May 2020                                                                                                                                                           NABO News Issue 3 May 2020
THE EFFECTS OF LOCKDOWN A PASSAGE TO THE NORTH EAST THE FUTURE OF BOAT PROPULSION - National Association of Boat Owners
18                                                                                                                                                                                                                          19
                                                                                                                                                                                                                 Talking Points

                                                                                                                                                                amount of diesel used on inland
The IWA looks into the
                                                                                                                 The Existing Fleet
                                                                                                                 Boat diesel engines last a long time           waterways is relatively small, so
                                                                                                                 and owners are likely to be reluctant          this may be acceptable.
                                                                                                                 to convert from diesel to electric
future of boat propulsion                                                                                        drive unless required by legislation
                                                                                                                 to do so, which Bowman believes is
                               Peter Fellows reviews a recent report                                             unlikely.

                               B
                                                                                                                     So most existing diesel-powered
                                                                                                                 boats will be with us for many years.
The full report is                      owman Bradley, the leader          There are very few problems
                                                                                                                 If we don’t want boats to be made
available at www.                       of IWA’s steering group, has installing a battery bank in a narrow-
waterways.org.uk/blog/                                                                                           obsolete by legislation or owners
                                        produced a report on his boat: weight is not a problem; space
greening_our_waterways                                                                                           to be forced into expensive conver-
                                        vision for more sustainable is more available than in a car; and
                                                                                                                 sions, there needs to be a way of
                               boating.                                power requirements are well within
                                                                                                                 significantly reducing the environ-
                                   He acknowledges that the over- the range of the current technology.
                                                                                                                 mental impact of diesel engines.
                               all contribution of inland waterway The main drawback is cruising range
                                                                                                                 One such way is to use biodiesel,
                               craft to carbon emissions is small, and recharge times, but both will
                                                                                                                 which, while not being 100% ‘green’,
                               but it will inevitably come under improve. Batteries can be recharged
                                                                                                                 is an improvement over mineral die-
                               scrutiny and boaters have a social using a shoreline, or by on-board
                                                                                                                 sel. But using 100% biodiesel has a
                               responsibility to ‘do our bit’. His re- photovoltaic cells or wind turbines.
                                                                                                                 number of disadvantages:
                               port examines technologies that are Batteries can also be charged by
                                                                                                                     It is manufactured from veg-
                               currently available, or close to being hydrogen fuel cells. However, there
                                                                                                                     etable oil, commonly palm oil,
                               available, in three categories: new are environmental issues around the
                                                                                                                     which makes biodiesel thicker
                               build; the existing fleet; and refuel- manufacture, recycling and disposal
                                                                                                                     at UK winter temperatures. This
                               ling/recharging.                        of batteries.
                                                                                                                     is currently not a problem when
                                                                           Hydrogen is converted into elec-
                                                                                                                     it is used at low percentages in
Hydrogen fuel cell operating   New Build                               tricity in a fuel cell. The technology
                                                                                                                     mineral diesel, but it would be
principle                      Bowman believes that it is likely that is well developed and the size of ex-
                                                                                                                     a problem at 100%. Some bio-
Photo: ASU Renewable Energy    canal boats in future will be driven isting cells can propel a narrowboat.
                                                                                                                     diesels are now being produced
Center                         by an electric motor; the technology However, currently hydrogen is not
                                                                                                                     which can resist winter tempera-
energy.asu.edu.jo              exists and is mature.                   ‘green’ as it is mainly manufactured
                                                                                                                     tures, using a blend of oils.
                                                                       from hydrocarbons, but it could be                                                                                           Electric motor and battery
                                                                                                                     Pure biodiesel burns at a lower         Refuelling and Recharging
                                                                       made ‘semi-green’ with CO2 cap-
                                                                                                                     rate than mineral diesel, which         Significant capital investment will bank
                                                                       ture, or it could be manufactured
                                                                                                                     causes problems for high-revving        be required for refuelling with both Photo:  Mothership Marine
                                                                       from ‘green’ electricity. Like LPG, it                                                                                       mothershipmarine.com
                                                                                                                     road diesels, but canal boat en-        an electric recharging infrastructure
                                                                       can be used to power a conventional
                                                                                                                     gines are low-revving and so this       and a hydrogen refuelling infra-
                                                                       internal combustion engine, but
                                                                                                                     should not be a problem.                structure.
                                                                       there are some environmental issues
                                                                                                                     Some diesel engines have rubber            Commercial operators will not
                                                                       with this, such as NOx emissions.
                                                                                                                     seals in their fuel systems, which      invest until the boats exist to use it
                                                                       The combination of a battery bank
                                                                                                                     are not resistant to 100% biodies-      and private owners will not invest
                                                                       and hydrogen fuel cell gives flexibil-
                                                                                                                     el. This can be corrected at a cost,    in the boats until the infrastructure
                                                                       ity and reduces the cost of the total
                                                                                                                     and modern engines are biodiesel        is available. It is unlikely that gov-
                                                                       installation because of the reduced
                                                                                                                     resistant.                              ernment will provide the finance.
                                                                       size of the fuel cell. The cost would
                                                                                                                     Biodiesel manufacture requires          Electric charging already exists in
                                                                       currently be higher than a diesel en-
                                                                                                                     the use of a small amount of hy-        most marinas and this is adequate
                                                                       gine, but this will reduce and, in any
                                                                                                                     drocarbons and so is not 100%           for slow charging of batteries when
                                                                       event, the cost of a propulsion unit is
                                                                                                                     ‘green’, but it is significantly bet-   boats are moored. It would require
                                                                       not a high percentage of the cost of a
                                                                                                                     ter than mineral diesel.                upgrading for fast charging, in a
                                                                       new boat. Hydrogen would give the
                                                                                                                     Vegetable oils to make biodiesel        similar way to road vehicle charg-
                                                                       required range and the capability for
                                                                                                                     use land that could be given            ing stations, but it is difficult to
                                                                       fast refuelling.
                                                                                                                     over to food production but the         imagine every visitor mooring being
NABO News Issue 3 May 2020                                                                                                                                                                         NABO News Issue 3 May 2020
20                                                                                                                                                                                                                           21
Talking Points                                                                                                                                                                                                         Boating

                                                                                                                 On-board induction cooking
                                                                                                                 Stephen Peters is in the galley.

                                                                                                                 L
                                                      Fuel Cell
                                                                      Hydrogen
                                                                                                                          ike most boat owners, my          is that the lowest
                                                                       tanks                                              cooking requirements have         power setting, al-
                                                                                                                          until recently been met by        though satisfactory
                               Batteries and
                                                                                                                          using a gas cooker and/or         for simmering or
                                 control                                                                         microwave oven.                            heating-up soups, is
                                                                                                                     In my case, the cooker is an elder-    too hot for heating
                                                                                                                 ly Flavel Vanessa LPG stove with two       milk, which burns
                                                                                                                 burners, a grill and an oven. It still     and caramelises in
                                                                                                                 works well and is in good condition,       the pan. The answer
                                                                                                                 considering it is over 20 years old.       is to find a brand
                                                                                                                 However, it does not have flame-           with lower power
Yanmar trials a hydrogen-   equipped with such charging points.         powered buses!                           failure protection on the burners          settings.
fuelled propulsion system       Hydrogen refuelling is more                 Certainly—as NABO has said           (which is a requirement for all new            I have recent-
Photo: yanmar.com           problematic and currently does not          in the past—there are ways of cut-       cookers) and the pan-support grid          ly done precisely
                            exist on the system. It needs a dis-        ting the pollution caused by boats.      was starting to get rusty until I had it   that and bought a
                            tribution system, probably tankers,         Applying smokeless zone control          re-chromed. Not being a fan of using       ‘Tillreda’ induction
                            and will be more costly than red            requirements to all boats in all areas   LPG on-board, I acquired a port-           hob from IKEA,
                            diesel pumps, but the technology is         would certainly reduce pollution.        able electric induction hob, which         priced £39, which
                            available. It may be possible to devel-     Also, including emission tests dur-      now caters for most of my cooking          has lower power set-
                            op a network of hydrogen refuelling         ing the four-yearly BSS inspections      requirements. And I would recom-           tings and is far more
                            stations at hire fleet bases, if enough     would be very beneficial.                mend anyone with access to 240VAC          controllable       and
                            hire companies could be persuaded               However, a blanket require-          power to consider following my lead.       simpler to operate.
                            to use hydrogen boats.                      ment to move from diesel to electric         The model I have on my boat is a       The only problem
                                                                        power isn’t a catch-all panacea—         Tefal single-hob, which costs about        with this appliance
                            The views of Mike Rodd CEng                 particularly for existing boats. What    £49. It is small enough to sit on a        is its larger space re-
                            Whilst I enjoyed the technical con-         is normally (and conveniently) ig-       worktop and can be stored away             quirement, although
                            tent of this article from the IWA,          nored by the eco-warriors are the        when not required. It has a maxi-          it has provision for
                            I am concerned about its implied            considerable ecological costs in-        mum power requirement of 2100W             storing the cable and
                            support for the current barrage of          volved in extracting the required        and nine power levels that draw less       a handle which acts
                            emotionally-charged environmental           raw materials, many of them rare,        current. There are also a number of        as a hanger for storage. I use this one Portable induction hob
                            initiatives, led (for example) by the       that are needed to manufacture the       pre-set power settings for heating,        at home for my everyday cooking re- Photo: Ikea
                            Mayor of London.                            electronics and especially the batter-   stewing and frying. Most users will        quirements as I know it would take
                                The paper seems to imply how            ies, together with the environmental     prefer the controllable manual mode        up too much of my worktop area on
                            polluting our boats are, which sim-         cost of transporting them and in-        and, once a pan has reached boiling        the boat.
                            ply provides the eco-warriors with          stalling them. Also ignored is that      point, you can select a low setting for        Induction hobs will, of course,
                            ‘ammunition’, while ignoring the fact       boat engines have a long life, and       simmering.                                 only work with compatible sauce-
                            that the overall pollution created by       that replacing them sooner than              Experience has revealed a few          pans but this need not present a
                            boats, compared with other forms            necessary would simply increase          minor drawbacks—the first being            problem. Many pans are marketed
                            of transport and accommodation, is          their lifetime pollution costs.          the shiny ceramic hob, which could         as suitable for induction hobs and it
                            minimal.                                        Boaters are amongst the most         result in a pan sliding off if your boat   is possible to buy quite cheap stain-
                                Indeed, in London the overall           environmentally-aware communi-           rocked. I consider this not to be a        less-steel pans from many discount
                            pollution caused by all the boats           ties, so it’s senseless to attack them   problem when used on calm inland           stores. Induction cooking is fast, ef-
                            together is probably less than that         by encouraging regulations that will     waters but I could not recommend it        ficient, clean and safer than gas and I
                            derived from a handful of diesel-           be meaningless in the long term.         on tidal waters. The second criticism      can recommend it.
NABO News Issue 3 May 2020                                                                                                                                                                        NABO News Issue 3 May 2020
22                                                                                                                                                                                                                              23
                                                                                                                                                                                                                             Boating

                                                                                                                   versing out onto the river less so—I
        A passage to the North East                                                                                did an elegant 360° pirouette before
                                                                                                                   pointing in the right direction again
                    Part 1: Evesham to Ripon, the top of the network east of the Pennines.                         and fought the tide for the first hour
                                                                                                                   or so en route to Keadby Lock. So
                          Helen Hutt recounts her greatest challenge after 14 years of continuous cruising.
                                                                                                                   many power stations, pylons and

                              T
                                                                                                                   turbines made the more than four-
                                       o achieve this, the Trent had   my presence, the crew opened only           hour trip rather unattractive; then
                                       to be conquered. Tackling       one gate, at which point I realised         we had to dawdle for nearly an hour
                                       this great river single-hand-   they were novices. Waiting for them         waiting for the lock because only
                                       ed had always filled me with    to sort themselves out and open the         one sluice was working. So, plenty of
                              trepidation, despite having cruised      offside gate, Pipistrelle was dragged       time to practise in my head that up-
                              the Thames from Limehouse to             onto the weir overflow. After full          stream approach and positioning for
                              Lechlade, and the Severn, Wey and        throttling and two men trying in            the turn into Keadby Lock– tricky
                              Soar. I needn’t have worried.            vain to pull the boat into the lock, I      but successfully executed.
                                 Two and a half weeks after leav-      decided to back off and try again. I            The Stainforth & Keadby Canal,
                              ing my mooring in Evesham, via the       left them to it after the lock.             part of South Yorkshire Navigation,
                              Avon, Severn, Staffs & Worcs and                                                     was a revelation. It is so wide that,
                              Trent & Mersey, I reached Sawley         On the Trent                                even though moored on pins, one
                              Marina, filled up with diesel and        On the Trent, there was an hour’s           barely felt another boat passing—
                              bought the Trent and Ouse guide          hold-up at Holme Lock waiting for a         not that there were many! The
                              books. Moored overnight in Sawley        tug towing a barge to come through.         scenery wasn’t great, with Keadby
                              Cut, I hardly slept thinking of the         That was my first encounter with         power station seeming ever-present,
                              adventure to come. But on a glorious     a big barge on the river and I’m glad       but Vazon sliding railway bridge was
                              May morning I set off down the river     I didn’t have any more! Then, an un-        fascinating. Built in 1925, it is one of
                              into new territory, through two locks    eventful journey to Newark (where           only three in Europe, and clears the
                              and into Beeston Cut, and moored         a tour of the Castle ruins revealed it      water by a mere 2ft. Controlled from
                              on the outskirts of Nottingham for       wasn’t built as a castle at all, but as a   a signal box, winches slide the bridge
                              a couple of days (sadly Nottingham       residence for the Bishop of Lincoln,        deck sideways to clear the naviga-
                              Castle was closed for renovations).      in 1129) and on through Cromwell            tion. Luckily, I went through with
                                 On unfamiliar water, it’s always      Lock onto the tidal Trent—and               two other boats, whose crews took
                              comforting to buddy up with an-          the potentially scariest bit of the         turns to operate the ensuing swing
Leaving Cromwell Lock         other boat, so I was delighted to see    journey. Turning off the river into         bridges.
Photo: Helen Hutt             one pull out ahead of me towards         Torksey Cut for an overnight stop               My first overnight stop was at
                              Castle Lock. Despite acknowledging       was much easier than expected; re-          Thorne. The engine had seemed Waterways of the North East              Map: opencanalmap.org.uk/Google
                                                                                                                   noisy during the day, so I checked the
                                                                                                                   fan belts etc., and found the bolts on
                                                                                                                   the generator bracket had sheared.
                                                                                                                   Fortunately, there is a boatyard right
                                                                                                                   next to the visitor mooring, where
                                                                                                                   I was able to get the bolts replaced
                                                                                                                   the following day. But I’m not always
                                                                                                                   so blessed—reversing back into the
                                                                                                                   pontoon mooring, I got a jacket
                                                                                                                   wrapped around the prop.

                                                                                                                   Now for the Big Locks
                                                                                                                   Every one long enough to take an oil
                                                                                                                   tanker and electrically operated, but To allow boats to pass, the whole deck of the Vazon bridge slides
                                                                                                                   the control box always seemed to be sideways on rails, pulled by steel cables.
                                                                                                                   on the wrong side!                    Photo: Chris Allen/Geograph, Drawing by Helen
NABO News Issue 3 May 2020                                                                                                                                                                             NABO News Issue 3 May 2020
You can also read