Northern Ireland - Park University

Page created by Johnny Perkins
 
CONTINUE READING
Northern Ireland - Park University
IN THIS ISSUE

                                                                 • Comic books show “Challenges of War”

                                                                 • Dispatches from DRC, France, Spain, Zim-
                                                                 babwe, Myanmar

                                                                 • Nigerian press stirs religious animosity

   Special Report: PJ and Covid-19

                                         Discussing PJ, trauma, and reporting divided societies in

                                         Northern Ireland
A publication of the Center for Global Peace Journalism at Park University       Vol 9 No. 1 - April 2020
Northern Ireland - Park University
April 2020
                                                         Contents                                                                 Special Report: PJ and Covid-19
                                         3 Covid-19 and PJ    18 DRC, Somalia
 Cover photo--
                                         PJ principles inform Covid reporting      Comic books explore war
                                                                                                                              Pandemic coverage informed by PJ principles
 Paul Gallagher, WAVE Truama Cen-
 tre in Belfast, by Allan Leonard
                                         5 Northern Ireland                                                                   By Steven Youngblood                        ing path toward transformative jour-       A third PJ scholar and author, As-
                                         Trauma reporting workshop                                                                                                        nalism in Africa by imbibing pan-Afri-     soc. Prof. Dr. Metin Ersoy, faculty
                                                                                                                              There is no more challenging situ-
The Peace Journalist is a semi-                                                                                                                                           can institutional and methodological       of communication and media stud-
annual publication of the Center         6 Northern Ireland                                                                   ation for a journalist than covering
                                                                                                                              a traumatic event, especially when
                                                                                                                                                                          approaches and African philosophies
                                                                                                                                                                          of Utu (humanity), Umoja (unity), and
                                                                                                                                                                                                                     ies, new media and journalism and
                                                                                                                                                                                                                     department vice chair, Eastern Medi-
for Global Peace Journalism at Park      Social media, ethics, and PJ                                                         this event affects the journalist, her
University in Parkville, Missouri. The                                                                                                                                    Harambee (collective responsibility) as    terranean University, North Cyprus,
                                                                                                                              family, and her colleagues. Add to this
Peace Journalist is dedicated to dis-
seminating news and information
                                         8 Northern Ireland                        20 DR Congo                                difficulty the need for the reporter
                                                                                                                              to explain complex scientific infor-
                                                                                                                                                                          news values as opposed to copy and
                                                                                                                                                                          paste journalism that leads to sensa-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                     believes peace journalists should seek
                                                                                                                                                                                                                     guidance from three principles origi-
for teachers, students, and
                                         Event: Media in divided societies         Media training in North Kivu                                                           tionalism…” (2020-Routledge).              nally articulated by Dr. Johan Galtung,
                                                                                                                              mation, and the necessity of being
practitioners of PJ.                     10 Kansas City                            22 Nigeria                                 factual without creating panic, and
                                                                                                                              one sees the challenge that covering
                                                                                                                                                                          Giuliana Tiripelli, author of Media and
                                                                                                                                                                          Peace in the Middle East and senior
                                                                                                                                                                                                                     the originator of the concept of peace
                                                                                                                                                                                                                     journalism. These principles are truth
                                         Human rights, journalism event                                                                                                                                              orientation, people orientation, and
Submissions are welcome from all.                                                  Press stirs religious animosity            the Covid-19 pandemic creates for           lecturer in digital journalism and me-     solution orientation.
We are seeking shorter submissions
(300-500 words) detailing peace          12 Myanmar                                23 Venezuela, Spain                        journalists.                                dia discourse at DeMontfort Univer-
                                                                                                                                                                          sity, Leicester, UK, concurs, especially   Dr. Ersoy writes, “Peace journal-
journalism projects, classes, propos-    Rohingya reporting falls short            Documentary spotlights students            The principles of peace journalism,
                                                                                                                                                                          when it comes to the notions of col-       ists needed to uncover all cover-ups
                                                                                                                              as they do for so many other types of
als, etc. We also welcome longer
submissions (800-1200 words)             15 France                                 24 Cameroon                                reporting (about refugees, elections,
                                                                                                                              civic unrest, race, terrorism, etc.), can
                                                                                                                                                                          lectivity. She writes, “At this moment
                                                                                                                                                                          it is essential to bring hope and trust,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                     related with the Covid-19. The ‘pro-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                     paganda’ here means frightening
about peace or conflict sensitive        Disinformation, World Forum               #DefyHateNow campaign                                                                  and to avoid polarisation, and PJ has      people, giving false information, and
journalism projects or programs, as                                                                                           provide valuable guidance to report-
                                                                                                                                                                          a great role to play in this direction.    causing trauma in the public. Another
well as academic works from the
field. We do NOT seek general sub-
                                         16 California                             25 Afghanistan                             ers who are covering perhaps the
                                                                                                                              most difficult story of their careers.
                                                                                                                                                                          The best thing that journalists can do
                                                                                                                                                                          now is to make sure they inform the
                                                                                                                                                                                                                     problem of the journalists while they
                                                                                                                                                                                                                     are covering Covid-19 news stories is
                                         PJ at Rotary World Peace Conf.            Spotlight: Journalists’ safety                                                         public fully and clearly about how         ‘numbers.’ Instead of focusing on the
missions about peace projects, but                                                                                            Three peace journalism experts from
are instead focused only on articles
with a strong media angle.
                                         17 Cameroon                               27 Zimbabwe                                Kenya, the UK, and Cyprus offer some
                                                                                                                              interesting perspectives on the appli-
                                                                                                                                                                          they have to behave, but also focus on
                                                                                                                                                                          stories where similar challenges have
                                                                                                                                                                                                                     numbers, journalists should focus on
                                                                                                                                                                                                                     the people. We need more people-
                                         CCMN launches nationwide                  Celebrating World Radio Day                                                            been won by communities acting as          oriented stories about to Covid-19 to
                                                                                                                              cation of peace journalism to covering
Deadlines: March 3 (April edition);                                                                                           Covid-19. In email interviews, two of       a whole (e.g. Ebola, others), so that      understand the realities. However,
September 3 (October edition).                    What is Peace Journalism?                                                   these experts emphasize responsible
                                                                                                                              media’s role in supporting collectivity
                                                                                                                                                                          people believe that this challenge
                                                                                                                                                                          can be won, and adopt appropriate
                                                                                                                                                                                                                     journalists prefer to provide numbers
                                                                                                                                                                                                                     like in the election race,” he said.
Editor: Steven Youngblood, Director,     Peace Journalism is when editors and reporters make choices that improve the         and rejecting polarization.                 behaviours based on a strong sense of
                                         prospects for peace. These choices, including how to frame stories and care-                                                     community.                                 Ersoy continued, “My last sugges-
Center for Global Peace Journalism
                                         fully choosing which words are used, create an atmosphere conducive to peace         Prof. Fredrick Ogenga, Director of the                                                 tion for journalists is approaching the
                                         and supportive of peace initiatives and peacemakers, without compromising            Center for Media, Democracy, Peace          “Stories focusing on the community         health issues with more of a solution
Proofreading: Carol Getty, Ann                                                                                                                                            itself may also help to support a con-     orientation. During this process, the
Schultis, Park U. emeritae faculty       the basic principles of good journalism. (Adapted from Lynch/McGoldrick, Peace       and Security Rongo University, Kenya,
                                         Journalism). Peace Journalism gives peacemakers a voice while making peace           believes that peace journalists should      structive rediscovery of local identity    mass media broadcast public an-
                                         initiatives and non-violent solutions more visible and viable.                       apply traditional African principles to     and the benefits of interdependence        nouncements about the protection of
Contact/Social Media:                                                                                                                                                     (per Prof. Ogenga’s Utu, Umoja, and        Covid-19 virus. But if we look at the
steve.youngblood@park.edu                    A number of valuable peace journalism resources, including curriculum            Covid-19 reporting. “’We are in this
                                                                                                                              together’ (as reflected by these prin-      Harambee). It’s a massive cultural         news stories we may see that they are
Twitter-@Peace Journ                     packets, online links, as well as back issues of The Peace Journalist can be found
                                                                                                                              ciples) should be applied to coverage       shock to access this new dimension,        focusing on the numbers instead of
Facebook-Peace Journalism group          at www.park.edu/peacecenter.
                                                                                                                              of Covid-19,” Ogenga observed.              for many citizens who were supportive      the solutions. Journalists need to be
Center for Global Peace
Journalism, Park University               Center for Global Peace Journalism                                                  He recommends Covid-19 reporting
                                                                                                                                                                          of individualistic philosophies, and PJ
                                                                                                                                                                          needs to support a peaceful transition
                                                                                                                                                                                                                     highlight health initiatives, and give
                                                                                                                                                                                                                     voice to public, not elites only.
                                         The Center for Global Peace Journalism works with journalists, academics, and        using the principles of Utu (humanity),     ‘back to reality,’”Prof. Tiripelli said.
                                                                                                                              Umoja (unity), and Harambee (collec-                                                   “Journalists focus on the visible effects
                                         students worldwide to improve reporting about conflicts, societal unrest, rec-                                                   Steven Youngblood is director of the       of the Covid-19. Nevertheless, we also
                                         onciliation, solutions, and peace. Through its courses, workshops, lectures, this    tive responsibility). In the book Peace     Center for Global Peace Journalism
                                                                                                                              Journalism in East Africa, Ogenga                                                      need to focus on invisible effects of
                                         magazine, blog, and other resources, the Center encourages media to reject                                                       (Park University), author of Peace         the health issues and social isolation.
                                         sensational and inflammatory reporting, and produce counter-narratives that          elaborates about these principles.          Journalism Principles and Practices,
                                                                                                                              He writes, “The idea of using African                                                  They can give more voice to psycholo-
                                         offer a more nuanced view of those who are marginalized—ethnic/racial/                                                           and editor of the Peace Journalist         gists and experts on this issue. In so
   A Park University Publication                                                                                              lenses for peacebuilding and conflict       magazine.
                                         religious minorities, women, youth, and migrants.
                                                                                                                              (and trauma) reporting…is a refresh-                                                                        Continued on next page
pg 2                                                                                         www.park.edu/peacecenter         Vol 9, No. 1                                                                                                                 pg 3
Northern Ireland - Park University
Special Report: PJ and Covid-19                                                                                                         Special Report: PJ and Covid-19
Covid                          from Pg 3
                                              “peace journalism” or not. For ex-
                                              ample, the Ethical Journalism Network
                                                                                           the reporting they’ve seen thus far.

                                                                                           Dr. Ersoy observes a mixed bag when
                                                                                                                                        Covid                        from Pg 4
                                                                                                                                                                                   just started with the new policies. I
                                                                                                                                                                                   would say the coverage in the UK has
                                                                                                                                                                                   become more balanced and accurate
                                                                                                                                                                                                                              In conclusion, while there is excellent,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                              responsible virus reporting taking
                                                                                                                                                                                                                              place, there is no doubt that this
doing, journalists provide quality news       recommends that journalists:                 it comes to virus coverage. He writes,       Local radios may be pretty good at
                                                                                                                                                                                   now, and not exacerbating divisions,       reporting can be augmented using
for the public and contribute for the                                                      “There is huge misinformation and            showing aid and support available,
                                              --Avoid sensationalism and scaremon-                                                                                                 after governments have taken clearer       peace journalism principles.
public health in general,” he con-                                                         propaganda-oriented news stories in          because much of the first stage
                                              gering in language and images that                                                                                                   measures and put policies in place
cluded.                                                                                    new media and mass media. (Spe-              change has happened at the local                                                      If there was ever a time for reporters
                                              could heighten anxiety; for instance                                                                                                 that reassure people. However, a
                                                                                           cifically), Cyprus is a small island in      level. There is little success stories                                                and editors to carefully consider the
Aside from the truth orientation,             pictures of empty supermarket                                                                                                        stronger focus on countries which
                                                                                           the Mediterranean region. Our mass           in the mainstream news media, but                                                     consequences of their reporting, and
people orientation, and solution ori-         shelves, stockpiling – which can in-                                                                                                 have had more success so far will
                                                                                           media was very sensitive about the           this is unavoidable given the situation                                               report in the public interest, it is now.
entation discussed by Dr. Ersoy, there        flame tensions and create more panic                                                                                                 help,” she said.
                                                                                           language that they are using on Co-          and the fact that many countries have
are other principles of peace journal-

                                                                                                                                        Covering another epidemic: Ebola in 2014
                                              --Avoid racial profiling – you don’t         vid-19 news stories. However, some
ism, outlined in my textbook Peace
                                              need to repeat where the virus was           online media companies, which are
Journalism Principles and Practices,
                                              generated each time you report new           expecting to get more clicks, are using
that can offer useful advice.
                                              cases.                                       click bait strategies in news headlines.     By Rexford Johnson                         the communication abyss that existed       of the magazine-formatted message

                                               “
In reporting Covid-19, peace journal-                                                      Somehow, they publish either fake                                                       between key stakeholders and the           was persuasive as it appealed for safe,
                                                                                                                                        EDITOR’S NOTE: This article originally
ists should consider the consequences                                                      news about the solutions for Covid-19                                                   dying population continues to expand.      healthy practices. Soon radio became
                                                                                                                                        ran in the October, 2017 edition of
of their reporting (am I creating un-          Stories focusing on the                     or are giving false hope to readers          the Peace Journalist magazine. Note
                                                                                                                                                                                   Media had to switch its focus to a         the nerve centre in the fight against
necessary panic?); give a voice to the         community itself may also                   by writing headlines like, ‘vaccine                                                     collaborative role.                        Ebola.
                                                                                                                                        the emphasis on collaborative media
voiceless (how everyday people are                                                         found.’ We can say that Cypriot media
                                               help to support a construc-                 is doing more peace journalism on the
                                                                                                                                        roles, consistent with the discussion in   Role of the media                          Conclusion
impacted-hourly workers, the home-                                                                                                      the previous article on Covid-19.
less, inmates and their families); and         tive rediscovery of local                   health issues than online media. I can                                                  On July 26 2014, the Sierra Leone As-      Living in Ebola territory was a walking
                                               identity.                                   say that online media are exacerbat-                                                    sociation of Journalism established an     nightmare. Imagine a year with no
avoid inflammatory language (“dead-                                                                                                     On May 25 2014, Sierra Leone record-
                                                                                           ing the situation, frightening people,                                                  Ebola Response strategy to respond         Christmas holiday, no Easter break, no
ly,” “devastated,” “gruesome”) and             --Giuliana Tiripelli                                                                     ed its first confirmed case of Ebola
                                                                                                                                                                                   to the outbreak. Forty eight private

                                                                                 ”
images (unnecessarily graphic photos,                                                      giving false information, and causing        which was traced from neighbouring                                                    birthday celebration, no vacation, no
                                                                                           trauma in the public.”                                                                  and community radio stations across        social gatherings, hugs, handshakes
photos that exaggerate or misrepre-                                                                                                     Guinea. The virus would later spread
                                                                                                                                                                                   the country donated airtime to the         and sometimes no church gathering.
sent an event).                                                                                                                         exponentially to affect all regions,
                                              --Ensure you protect affected people:        As far as Kenya is concerned, Dr.                                                       network and run a daily simultane-         The fear of death was so strong you
                                                                                                                                        districts, and sectors of the nation.
As always, PJ looks to break away             do not identify names, images or iden-       Ogenga has been impressed with                                                          ous broadcast under the umbrella of        could almost touch it. Fear of con-
from mainstream narratives about the          tifying material without the permis-         the reporting thus far. He writes that       Communication problems                     the Independent Radio Network. The         tracting the virus, fear of touching a
pandemic and offer counternarratives          sion of the relevant people...               “Covid 19 coverage in Kenya is peace         At the initial stage of the outbreak,      objectives were; “to provide an early      door knob at the office, fear of using
(how retirement portfolios of every-                                                       journalism ‘par excellence’ using pan        government was unwilling to involve        response outlet for the Ministry of        headphones in the studio … fear of
                                              --Be accurate and report facts; avoid        African values of Utu or humanity and                                                   Health and the Social Mobilisation
day people have been gutted, how                                                                                                        media in its health education cam-                                                    headache, fever or worse.
                                              rumour and try not to speculate;             Harambee in the solidarity around dis-                                                  Committee, (and) increase the level of
and if small businesses will recover,                                                                                                   paign. Quoting the scientists, the
                                              there’s a huge amount of misinforma-         courses regarding the outbreak. There                                                   awareness and understanding of the         Radio was essential in relaying round
who might profit from the outbreak,                                                                                                     media reported Ebola to be an incur-
                                              tion circling, so be aware of how to         is that promise (in the coverage) of                                                    virus and educate the public...”           the clock info during the two major
on the impacts of social isolation, as                                                                                                  able disease. Society viewed infected
                                              spot and debunk misinformation.              ‘we will overcome.’”                                                                                                               countrywide lockdowns in Sept 2014
mentioned by Dr. Ersoy, etc.)                                                                                                           people as victims instead of patients
                                                                                                                                                                                   Programs were designed to raise            and Mar 2015 respectively. It was
                                              --Seek expert opinions – from medics                                                      which undermined efforts to mobilize
Also, peace journalism eschews pro-                                                        For example, in the Standard newspa-                                                    public awareness about then signs and      more than packaging reports and
                                              and scientists with relevant creden-                                                      the public to seek medical attention if
paganda, especially partisan political                                                     per from Kenya, recent virus report-                                                    symptoms of the virus, the role of the     anchoring programs; we were giving
                                              tials – but note that scientific advice is                                                they develop symptoms.
posturing (polarization, as mentioned                                                      ing included “we will overcome”                                                         key service providers, and the signifi-    hope to the nation.
                                              frequently changing                          stories like “No Coronavirus hitches at                                                 cance of new medical infrastructures.
by Prof. Tiripelli). PJ reports respectful-                                                                                             Communication strategies flopped
ly about victims, using the guidelines                                                     (Nairobi airport)” and counternarra-         as government sources differed with        Control activities like contact tracing,
                                              --Provide context and point people to                                                                                                                                            Rexford Johnson has over 15 years
we recently discussed at two trauma                                                        tive stories like “Coronavirus provides      information from international Medics      safe burial, surveillance quarantine,
                                              authoritative and credible information                                                                                                                                           of experience in Journalism. He
reporting seminars in Northern Ire-                                                        unexpected boost for Kenyan fisher-          on the frontline – like MSF. The public    and isolation and stigma issues were
                                              sources and resources (https://tinyurl.                                                                                                                                          is Programs Director at Believers
land. (See report on page 6).                                                              men.” (https://www.standardmedia.            was getting confused, fears were           also recurring program themes.
                                              com/w66pzu9)                                                                                                                                                                                       Broadcasting Net-
                                                                                           co.ke/)                                      heightened, rural communities were
In fact, Covid-19 coverage recommen-                                                                                                                                               Local media focused on informa-                               work and Produc-
                                              Problematic practice, best practice                                                       in information blackout, and myths
dations from other journalism organi-                                                      In analyzing Covid-19 coverage in                                                       tion and sensitization, not investiga-                        er at Independent
                                              While it’s too early to rely on any                                                       were riding the tide. With the situa-
zations reflect these peace journalism                                                     the UK, Prof. Tiripelli observes, “It                                                   tion. The radical / watch dog role                            Radio Network in
                                              quantitative or content analysis stud-                                                    tion rapidly deteriorating, journalists
and responsible trauma reporting                                                           depends on what media you follow.                                                       was rejected by the journalists who                           Sierra Leone.
                                              ies of Covid-19 coverage, the three ex-                                                   realised that we could not continue
principles, whether they’re labeled                                                                                                                                                themselves were beleaguered by the
                                              perts still have strong opinions about                                                    with traditional media functions while
                                                                                                               Continued on next page                                              deadly virus. The design and content
pg 4                                                                                                 www.park.edu/peacecenter           Vol 9, No. 1                                                                                                               pg 5
Northern Ireland - Park University
April 2020                                                                                                                          April 2020

Amid Covid threat, seminar analyzes trauma                                                                                        NI trauma                                          from Pg 6
By Kathryn Johnston                                                                                                               from Queens University Belfast, who had lost the use of his        promote ‘justpeace’ - the concept of justice aligned with
                                                                                                                                  legs during the troubles. Gallagher highlighted trauma and         peacebuilding pioneered by American Professor of Inter-
The overnight snow had frozen on my windscreen when I                                                                             victims, pointing out that victims are not homogenous,             national Peacebuilding at the University of Notre Dame,
left home at dawn on Thursday, 12 March 2019.                                                                                     before leading a stimulating discussion on how journalists         John Paul Lederach, a frequent visitor to Northern Ireland.
                                                                                                                                  may compound trauma, and how journalists can contrib-              After praising VIEWdigital’s Amnesty nominated Victims
As I drove through Derry, I passed the spot where almost                                                                          ute to creating a more trauma-informed society.                    and Survivors issue, he spoke of Lederach’s ‘justpeace’
a year ago my friend, colleague, and fellow member of the                                                                                                                                            approach.
National Union of Journalists, Lyra McKee, became the lat-                                                                        Dr. Jake Lynch from the University of Sydney, who is also a
est victim to die in the Northern Ireland Troubles. She was                                                                       Visiting Professor at Coventry University this year, shared        This concept was illustrated by Hands Across the Divide,
shot dead in Derry by a gunman from the New IRA while                                                                             insights from his ground-breaking work on media interven-          the sculpture unveiled in Derry in 1992 on the twentieth
observing a riot with other journalists.                                                                                          tions for peace during conflict.                                   anniversary of Bloody Sunday, when 13 unarmed protes-
Lyra, who was dedicated to investigating the unsolved                                                                             Lynch spoke of how the media could structure itself to                                                     Continued on next page
mysteries of the Troubles, would have thrived on these
two inaugural workshops where victims and survivors of
the troubles, students and practicing journalists, academics                                                                       Social media, ethics, PJ pondered in Belfast
                               and peace builders would                                                                            By Steven Youngblood
                               discuss the reporting of                                                                                                                                              My “glass half empty” response was that social media
                               trauma – and most impor-                                                                            Two events the week of March 9 helped to conclude a               will increasingly empower demagogues and authoritarian
                               tantly, hear how it could be                                                                        nearly year-long peace journalism project in Northern             regimes. My “glass half full” response was that an increas-
                               improved.                                                                                           Ireland sponsored by the U.S. Embassy-London and the              ingly media literate public will use social media as a tool
                                                                                                                                   U.S. Consulate-Belfast.                                           to build bridges and facilitate dialogues for peace.
                                 Her life and enthusiasm
                                 were at the forefront of my                                                                       The first, a roundtable discussion, was held at the consul-       My presentation was part of a conference at BelfastMet
                                 mind at both the Derry and                                                                        ate. I’ve had some interesting discussions about whether          that introduced participants, to a program called Live
                                 Belfast trauma and journal-                                                                       journalists should use the term “martyr,” but none so             Skills, which helps young people develop careers in fields
                                 ism workshops on 12 and                                                                           engaging as our interchange during this session.                  using digital technologies (creative media, digital art and
                                 13 March 2020.                                                                                                                                                      design, and digital marketing).
                                                                                                                                   In previous seminars in Kashmir and Beirut, journal-
                                 I spoke of Lyra’s vision, the                                                                     ists told me that they labeled anyone who died fighting
                                 trauma experienced by her,                                                                        Israelis or Indians a martyr. Here in Belfast, the discussion
                                 her partner Sara, and her                                                                         centered around those who self identify as martyrs as
family, before reflecting on the pain and grief of the years                                                                       they commit some heinous act like blowing themselves
when the political violence that almost tore these islands                                                                         up. Should the press call them martyrs, since that’s what
apart left around 3,700 people dead.                                                                                               they call themselves? Several attendees said yes, that it’s
                                                                                                                                   journalists’ obligation to use people’s self identification.
Many more thousands were injured. They, their families,          (Left)-Prof. Jakes Lynch at the trauma workshop in Derry.         I’m not so sure, I said. What if the bomber called himself a
friends and neighbours – and the greater population of           (Top)-Students analyze the role of media in trauma.               hero? Should the press repeat that label?
Northern Ireland who bore witness to the troubles - bear         (Above)-BelfastMet student Delyth Cook discusses her
the scars to this day.                                                                                                             We also had a vibrant talk about false equivalencies, and
                                                                 group’s findings. (Photos by Allan Leonard)
                                                                                                                                   the pitfalls they pose for journalists. This topic is especial-
Later I spoke of the bursary which will be established in        Lyra’s name to support young journalists engaged in in-           ly fraught here, given Northern Ireland’s history.
                                                                 vestigative journalism and exploring alternative platforms
 Kathryn Johnston is a journalist and researcher based                                                                             Another session was held during a conference sponsored
                                                                 where narrative and long form pieces might be published.
 in Northern Ireland. She is co-author of From Guns to                                                                             held at the Girdwood Community Hub, a former army
                                                                 Details are still being finalised but will be announced later
 Government: an unauthorised biography of Martin                                                                                   barracks during the Troubles repurposed as a community
                                                                 on this year.
                               McGuinness has worked                                                                               center. At the event sponsored by Belfast Metropolitan
                               for The Sunday Times, The         I was proud to speak in the company of Steve Youngblood           College, I spoke briefly about social media and peace
                               Daily Telegraph, The Bel-         from the Centre for Peace Journalism, who discussed               journalism. I led off with an interesting stat, a poll show-
                               fast Telegraph, Irish Times       socially responsible trauma journalism; Alan Meban and            ing that only 22% of Northern Irish trust social media.
                               and BBC. Kathryn is also          Allan Leonard from FactCheck NI; who spoke of the use of          My message was that social media can better serve the
                               a member of the Irish Ex-         emotive language and alternative websites for fact check-         public, and peace, using peace journalism principles.
                               ecutive Council -National         ing; and Paul Gallagher from WAVE Trauma, a PhD student                                                                       PJ events in March, 2020 were held at the U.S. Consulate
                                                                                                                                   In a vibrant discussion, the most difficult question thrown (top) and Belfast Met College in Belfast.
                               Union of Journalists.
                                                                                                         Continued on next page    my way asked me to predict the future of social media.
pg 6                                                                                            www.park.edu/peacecenter          Vol 9, No. 1                                                                                                        pg 7
Northern Ireland - Park University
April 2020

NI event looks at media in divided societies                                                                                    NI event
                                                                                                                                Tim Epple described five roles that
                                                                                                                                                                            from Pg 8
 By Allan Leonard                                                                    Al Jazeera they tried to show the view
                                           Allan Leonard is co-founder and                                                      media has played in peace agree-
A two-day international conference                                                   from the street, not centres of power.     ments: (1) media as a promoter of
                                           editor-in-chief at FactCheckNI,
examined the role that media plays                                                   “News organisations shouldn’t be           the values of human rights (citing
                                           Northern Ireland’s first and only
in divided societies and in creating                                                 there to report on the institutions of     the Nepal agreement (2015); media
                                           dedicated fact-checking service. He
more peaceful and stable communi-                                                    power. We need to cover civil society      as a protomer of the value of inclu-
ties. Organised by the Social Change                             is also editor of
                                                                                     and social media is leading on this,”      sion (citing the Belfast/Good Friday
Initiative in partnership with Concili-                          Shared Future
                                                                                     Nanabhay said. He added that speak-        Agreement (1998) and its call for                                                                                Nadine Hack
ation Resources and the University                               News, which
                                                                                     ing truth to power is not inconsistent     Irish language rights, including media                                                                           discusses
of Edinburgh’s Political Settlements                             reports on
                                                                                     with understanding wider societal atti-    provision); (3) media as a watchdog,                                                                             the safety of
Research Programme, the event was                                peacebuilding
                                                                                     tudes, saying, “Do this by reporting on    reporting on what protagonists do                                                                                journalists.
attended by journalists from South                               in Northern
                                                                                     the ground work; don’t report outrage      post-agreement; (4) media as dissemi-                                                                            (Photo by Al-
Africa, Colombia, Myanmar, Rwanda,                               Ireland.
                                                                                     all the time.”                             nator of information about the agree-                                                                            lan Leonard)
Turkey, the Middle East, the Balkans,                                                                                           ment to the public; and (5) media as
Kashmir, Somalia, Syria, Nepal, and       Mohamed Nanabhay explained the             The role of media in analysing             bulwark against propaganda (citing
Northern Ireland.                         Media Development Investment Fund.         peace agreements                           the Kenya agreement and monitoring
                                          The fund makes an equity investment        The Political Settlements Research         of hate speech).
Irish broadcaster Charlie Bird led a      in independent media companies, in         Programme at the University of Ed-
conversation with Mohamed Nanab-          order to earn interest income that is      inburgh presented new research on          Anup Kaphle described how recent
hay of the international Media Devel-     reinvested into the fund. It has clients   the role of the media in international     laws passed in Nepal run counter to
opment Investment Fund. Bird stated       globally, including South Africa, the      peace accords. Professor Christine Bell    the declarations made in its 2015
that we live in a society where free      Balkans, Hungary, and Poland.              led a conversation with programme          peace agreement. He explained this
and independent journalism is under                                                  research associate, Tim Epple, along       as a consequence of the Maoists and
threat, citing this year’s murder of      In a discussion with the conference        with Jeremy Adams (BBC Northern            Communists coming into power, with          telling, this effort of rewriting history   the Irish News took a stand against
Lyra McKee. “We have to be careful.       attendees, someone asked whether           Ireland’s Head of Television Current       their desire to police morality. Kaphle     will continue.”                             paramilitary violence.” He gave the
The fourth estate is so important for     it takes a revolution in order for news    Affairs) and Anup Kaphle (Editor-in-       said that media is fractured and highly                                                 example of the three Northern Ireland
us, with everything at stake,” he said.   media to notice the work of civil          Chief of Kathmandu Post).                                                              The role of the media in
                                                                                                                                partisan in Nepal, and the challenge is                                                 newspapers (Belfast Telegraph, Irish
                                          society. Nanabhay answered that at                                                                                                promoting peace
                                                                                                       Continued on next page   to write for the truth instead of politi-                                               News, News Letter) coming together
                                                                                                                                                                            Jonathan Cohen, Executive Director
Trauma                                         from Pg 7
                                                                                                                                cal or opinion journalism.

                                                                                                                                Jeremy Adams remarked that at the
                                                                                                                                                                            of the international peacebuilding or-
                                                                                                                                                                            ganisation, Conciliation Resources, led
                                                                                                                                                                                                                        during the multi-party talks (that con-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                        cluded with the Belfast/Good Friday
                                                                                                                                                                                                                        Agreement): “We had a phone-in for
tors were shot dead in Derry by the Parachute Regiment.         Ireland. This remains a touchstone for press freedom in         times of the paramilitary ceasefires        a discussion on whether media has
(Hands Across the Divide pictured below).                       Northern Ireland.                                                                                                                                       peace, with 160,000 received calls.”
                                                                                                                                in Northern Ireland, he thought that        a role in promoting peace and stabil-
                                                                                                                                                                            ity in divided societies. The panellists    Conclusion
                              The students who made up          The trauma reporting workshops in Belfast and Derry were        perhaps the role of media in reporting                                                  Padraic Quirk (Deputy Director at SCI)
                                                                                                                                the conflict there might diminish. On       were Vikki Cook (Director of Content
                              most of the body of the           the culimination of a nearly year-long peace journalism                                                     Media Policy at UK broadcast regula-        concluded the event by noting, “We
                              audience at the Belfast Met       project in Northern Ireland sponsored by the U.S. Embas-        the contrary, he sees at least as much                                                  need to think long and hard about
                                                                                                                                a role as before. “We have found a          tor, Ofcom), Noel Doren (Editor of the
                              on Friday 13 March also           sy-London and the U.S. Consulate-Belfast.                                                                   Irish News), and Milica Pesic (Exec.        how we can report the peace well and
                              heard from Angelina Fusco,                                                                        role. It’s now about corruption, finan-                                                 concentrate on the issues that are
                                                                                                                                cial incompetence, and accountability       Director of Media Diversity Institute).
                              the former BBC NI Head of                                                                                                                                                                 important to peacemaking in divided
                              News, who holds a presti-                                                                         to power,” he commented.                                                                societies.”
                                                                                                                                                                            Cook spoke about recent Ofcom
                              gious Ochberg Fellowship                                                                          Adams was asked whether the media           commissioned reports, particularly in
                              awarded by the Direct Ac-                                                                                                                     regards to how the UK public service        Quirk finished by declaring that SDI
                                                                                                                                should take a step back, at times of                                                    is very keen to engage and further
tion on Research and Training (DART) Centre on Journalism                                                                       its reporting, for the sake of a peace      broadcaster, the BBC, represents and
and Trauma.                                                                                                                                                                 portrays society. The findings were         this conversation around the role of
                                                                                                                                process. He answered, “If you sus-                                                      the media in deeply divided societies
                                                                                                                                pend a commitment to truth, you can         that accuracy of reportage has been
She was joined by the eminent film maker Sean Murray,                                                                                                                       maintained, as well as impartial-           by saying, “We will be reaching out
whose feature-length documentary investigates the role                                                                          exacerbate the festering of conflict.”                                                  to people to follow that up, both [in
                                                                                                                                This was also his rationale for the         ity (she added that neutrality is not
the British government played in the murder of over 120                                                                                                                     always required, for sound reasons).        Northern Ireland] and internationally
civilians in Counties Armagh, and Tyrone from July 1972                                                                         production of the latest Spotlight                                                      … It now has to be about some of the
                                                                                                                                programme, The Troubles: A Secret           Diversity is found in regional report-
to 1978, and Barry McCaffrey, an award winning journalist                                                                                                                   age, less so from London headquar-          doing, the practical things that can be
who, with Trevor Birney, whose film, No Stone Unturned,                                                                         History. That is, he observed that                                                      done as a result of having this exper-
                                                                                                                                Northern Ireland’s contested history        ters (which is seen as white and male).
an in-depth look at the unsolved 1994 Loughinisland                                                                                                                                                                     tise in the room.”
massacre, where six men were murdered while watching            Group discussion at the trauma reporting conference at          has become a contested present. Ad-                                                     This article first appeared on Shared
                                                                                                                                ams said, “Without some sort of truth       Noel Doran said media can help create
the World Cup at the local pub in Loughinisland, Northern       Belfast Met.                                                                                                a climate to progress peace.“ We at         Future News.
pg 8                                                                                         www.park.edu/peacecenter           Vol 9, No. 1                                                                                                                pg 9
Northern Ireland - Park University
April 2020                                                                                                                       April 2020

Event considers human rights, journalism                                                                                         Peacebuilding
                                                                                                                                 such as opportunity gaps for people
                                                                                                                                                                           from Pg 10
                                                                                                                                                                           activist, arguing that good opinion        When asked about Brexit, Johnston
By Janette Jasperson
                                                                                                                                 of color or the widespread belief that    pieces “need to be fact-based, not just    discussed the impact of a hard bor-
“Everyone has the right to freedom of                                                                                            the oppressed created the condi-          outrage pieces.”                           der. She said that this possibility
opinion and expression; this right in-                                                                                           tions of their oppression. According                                                 has already led to violent threats. If
cludes freedom to hold opinions with-                                                                                            to Diuguid, when journalists are silent   The final speaker was Kathryn John-        the hard border is established, she
out interference and to seek, receive                                                                                            on these issues, they reinforce the ac-   ston, veteran journalist and officer for   “fears” it will lead to a resumption
and impart information and ideas                                                                                                 tions and attitudes of the oppressors.    the National Union of Journalists in       of violence, and she voiced concern
through any media and regardless of                                                                                                                                        Northern Ireland. She decried cover-       that her community overall has been
frontiers.” – Article 19, The Universal                                                                                          Diuguid then presented information        age of conflict in Northern Ireland as     desensitized to violence.
Declaration of Human Rights (1948)                                                                                               about the functions of media, discuss-    “too binary. You’re either a victim or
                                                                                                                                 ing how these functions (surveillance,    a perpetrator.” This approach ignores      Steven Youngblood, Director of the
Student journalists, academics, and                                                                                              correlation, transmission, entertain-     perpetrators’ history of being victim-     Center for Global Peace Journalism at
interested community members gath-                                                                                               ment, economic) make some minority        ized themselves and overlooks the          Park University, concluded the after-
ered at Park University in Parkville,                                                                                            groups (Asians, Native Americans)         long history of inequality.                noon by pointing out four common
Missouri on Friday afternoon, Novem-                                                                                             invisible, while relegating other mi-                                                threads in all the presentations:
ber 1, to discuss “Human Rights and                                                                                              norities (African Americans, Latinos)     Johnston lamented that journalists
Journalism: Challenges and Opportu-                                                                                              to ne’er-do-well status--those who        too often settle for a “slick quote”       1. Journalists too often “strip people
nities.” This discussion was the second                                                                                          need to be watched closely (surveil-      rather than digging deeper into the        of their humanity” through the way a
session of the Greater Kansas City                                                                                               lance). Women of all ethnicities are      story. And she observed that journal-      story is reported.
Peacebuilding Conference, “Human                                                                                                 presented either as damsels in need       ists can re-victimize those who have
Rights: The Foundation of Peacebuild-     Lewis Diuguid and Bette Tate-Beaver discuss the media’s role in ongoing op-            of rescue or as suspicious characters     been traumatized, if they are not          2. Journalists play a constructive role
ing.”                                     pression during the peacebuilding conference at Park University.                       who must be watched (e.g., Hillary        sensitive to the impact of the story.      in advancing human rights by bringing
                                                                                                                                 Clinton). White men, however, are         This type of journalism “strips people     deserving stories to the public’s atten-
Journalists and human rights activists    da and maintain pressure for change.       • After the New York Times Magazine         positively and prominently featured in    of their humanity.”                        tion and keeping them there.
are “kind of like cousins,” said Sarah    Many abuses happen at the local            ran a front-cover story about civilian      all of the functions of media.
Margon, Foreign Policy Director at the    level, so the public will not hear about   casualties in Iraq, the Pentagon and                                                  Johnston noted that women have             3. People speak in different ways, so
Open Society Foundations and the          them without media involvement. In         Congress acknowledged the problem.          Journalist and syndicated columnist       been excluded from peace processes         journalists need to be representative
afternoon’s first speaker. “We’re both    three recent situations, journalists                                                   Mary Sanchez spoke next, further          and newsrooms in Northern Ireland,         of those voices.
trying to expose the truth.” Margon       have successfully pressured the U.S.       Why does reporting on human rights          emphasizing the importance of             to the detriment of both. She praised
                                          government:                                matter to individuals?                                                                Jo Berry, founder of Building Bridges      4. The principles of peace journalism
elucidated this relationship by an-                                                                                              diverse newsrooms. She noted that
                                                                                                                                                                           for Peace, who searched out the man        are essential for effective reporting on
swering three questions.                                                                                                         you “have to have connections to tell
                                          • Stories on the murder of Saudi           “Although we are super polarized in                                                   who had killed her father. Berry’s pur-    human rights, especially the principles
                                                                                     the United States,” Margon said, “the       real stories” inside the Latino commu-                                               of giving a voice to the voiceless and
Why do human rights matter                journalist Jamal Khasoggi have led to                                                  nity. She said that she’s used Human      pose was not to hear an apology but
to journalists?                           a “crack” in US support for the Saudi      threat of the truth can still hold us                                                 to see his humanity, an approach that      of offering counter narratives to those
                                                                                     together.” When journalists tell us the     Rights Watch for years as a reliable                                                 advanced by the dominant culture.
In the words of Article 19 of the         government, which human rights                                                         source of data. Sanchez also explored     journalists should take when covering
Universal Declaration of Human            activists are trying to exploit.           truth, we can develop an informed                                                     violence.
                                                                                     opinion and then take action.               the fine line between journalist and
Rights, journalists depend on the
fundamental right “to seek, receive       • Weeks of reports on the violence
                                          against the Rohingya in Myanmar            Lewis W. Diuguid (author, lecturer,
and impart information and ideas.”
                                          finally forced the U.S. government to      and journalist) and Bette Tate Beaver
Margon pointed out that journalists
                                          act.                                       (executive director of the National
cannot work effectively in countries                                                                                                                                                                                                        Sarah Margon,
                                                                                     Association for Multicultural Educa-
which don’t honor that right. At an                                                                                                                                                                                                         Foreign Policy
                                           Janette Jasperson is the Inter-           tion) continued the discussion by
operational level, journalists depend                                                                                                                                                                                                       Director at the
                                           national Education Coordinator            looking at media’s role in “continuing
on human rights organizations for                                                                                                                                                                                                           Open Society
                                           at Johnson County Community               oppression” in society. One root is
reliable information, both from the                                                                                                                                                                                                         Foundations,
                                           College in the Kansas City area.          the lack of diversity in newsrooms. In
organizations’ own research and from                                                                                                                                                                                                        discussed the
                                                              She is passion-        2016, minorities made up one-third
their local contacts in areas where                                                                                                                                                                                                         intersection of
                                                              ate about the          of the U.S. population, but only 17%
journalists cannot go (because of cost                                                                                                                                                                                                      human rights
                                                              importance             of newspaper journalists and 23% of
or access issues).                                                                                                                                                                                                                          and journalistm.
                                                              of introducing         on-line-only journalists according to
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            (Photo by Jon
Why do journalists matter to                                  college students       the ASNE Diversity Survey. As a result,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            Hokenson)
human rights organizations?                                   to the world be-       journalists often are silent about chal-
Margon called journalism a “force-                            yond American          lenges facing minority communities,
multiplier” that can help set the agen-                       borders.                                  Continued on next page
pg 10                                                                                          www.park.edu/peacecenter          Vol 9, No. 1                                                                                                           pg 11
Northern Ireland - Park University
April 2020                                                                                                                      April 2020

Rohingya reporting often ignores PJ approaches                                                                                  Rohingya                    from Pg 12
By Shameem Ara Sheuli                                                                                                           the repatriation process instead of         ing Pro-Myanmar national policy. On
                                                                                                                                discussing the flaws in the agree-          the other hand, the Indian daily, The
Despite the growing acknowledge-
                                                                                                                                ment signed between Bangladesh and          Hindu showed a neutral position in its
ment of peace journalism as a worthy
                                                                                                                                Myanmar authorities in November             coverage, balancing the two version of
concept to promote peace and non-vi-
                                                                                                                                2017. Sheuli’s study presumed this          narratives promoting by Bangladesh
olent solutions to conflict, newspapers
                                                                                                                                might have jeopardized the repatria-        and Myanmar authorities.
in Myanmar, Bangladesh, China and
                                                                                                                                tion process of Rohingya refugees,
India have largely chosen to follow                                                                                                                                         ARSA appeared as a terrorist organi-
                                                                                                                                which was postponed at the last min-
war journalism approach in reporting                                                                                                                                        zation in Myanmar newspapers who
                                                                                                                                ute and yet to begin.
the decades-long Myanmar-Rohingya                                                                                                                                           started the fighting, while Rohingyas
conflict, according to a new study.                                                                                             Contradictory Trends,                       were portrayed as accomplices of
                                                                                                                                Different Narratives                        ARSA. On the other hand, Bangladeshi
A little over 58 percent of the stories
                                                                                                                                This study identified some fascinating      media persistently reported that
published by the newspapers fol-
                                                                                                                                facts depicting a contrasting trend be-     Rohingyas are the victims of longtime
lowed war journalism style against
                                                                                                                                tween the two Myanmar newspapers            discriminations and persecutions
only 13.54 percent peace journalism,
                                                                                                                                and narratives of the conflict circu-       by Myanmar authorities. Myanmar
meaning those couldn’t act as peace-
                                                                                                                                lating by Bangladesh and Myanmar            newspapers, especially Global New
building tools and create an atmo-                                                                                                                                                                                   they demonized ARSA for provoking
                                                                                                                                media.                                      Light of Myanmar branded Rohingyas
sphere to engage the involving parties                                                                                                                                                                               the Myanmar military but branded
                                                                                                                                                                            as ‘extremist terrorists’ highlighting
in negotiation.                                                                                                                 It found Global New Light of Myanmar                                                 Rohingya citizens of Rakhine always
                                                                                                                                                                            the atrocities of ARSA for legitimat-
                                                                                                                                was on top of using war journalism          ing military campaigns of Myanmar.       as victims. Bangladeshi newspapers
Shameem Ara Sheuli, a Bangladeshi
                                          ponement of a repatriation process        gust 2017 following an offensive of         style while Myanmar Times showed            Newspapers highlighted sufferings        highlighted human rights abuses by
journalist conducted this study on
                                          of Rohingya refugees on 23 January        Myanmar military in retaliation to the      more peace journalism approach com-         of Buddhist and Hindu citizens of        Myanmar military against Rohingya
‘Reporting Myanmar-Rohingya Con-
                                          2018, in six English language news-       attacks on police posts in Northern         pared to coverage of other newspa-          Rakhine while ignored human rights       population quoting humanitarian
flict: War Journalism or Peace Journal-
                                          papers—two each from Myanmar              Rakhine by Arakan Rohingya Salvation        pers. The coverage of state-run Global      abuses against the Rohingya minor-       agencies. A large number of stories
ism?’ as part of her Masters Thesis at
                                          and Bangladesh and one each from          Army (ARSA), the latest study found         New Light of Myanmar was highly             ity population. Myanmar newspapers       covered sufferings of the refugees in
Swansea University following the war/
                                          China and India. The newspapers are       journalists in Bangladesh, Myanmar,         partisan while the coverage of pri-         criticized the international community   Bangladesh.
peace journalism model of Norwegian
                                          Myanmar Times and Global New Light        India and China mostly followed war         vately owned Myanmar Time showed            of deteriorating the situation.
scholar Johan Galtung.                                                                                                                                                                                               Can Peace Journalism
                                          of Myanmar from Myanmar, New Age          journalism style while writing their        a neutral stance.
                                                                                                                                                                            By contrast, Bangladeshi dailies por-    Bring Out Facts?
She analyzed 251 stories, published       and The Daily Star from Bangladesh,       stories and the trend continued till the
                                                                                                                                Both the Bangladeshi dailies tend to        trayed the Myanmar military and Ra-      Though this study detected over 13%
since the latest violence broke out       Global Times from China and The           postponement of a repatriation pro-
                                                                                                                                frame war journalism and less likely to     khine Buddhists as villains and blamed   stories published in six newspapers
on 25 August 2017 until the post-         Hindu from India.                         cess of Rohingya refugees scheduled
                                                                                                                                follow peace journalism, but New Age        them for attacking Rohingya Muslims.     followed peace journalism style in
                                                                                    for 23 January 2018.
                                          And surprisingly, her study revealed                                                  covered the least number of peace           They criticized the Myanmar leader       reporting Myanmar-Rohingya conflict,
 Shameem Ara Sheuli is a Bangla-                                                                                                journalism stories among the six                                                     the researcher claimed that those
                                          that the number of peace journalism       Reporters described clashes between                                                     Aung Sung Suu Kyi for supporting the
 deshi journalist with more than                                                                                                newspapers. The Chinese newspaper,                                                   stories failed to use strong language
                                          stories in war/conflict reporting by      Myanmar military and ARSA, the en-                                                      Myanmar military. To some extent,
 a decade of experience. She is                                                                                                 Global Times comes at second in fol-                                                 as required to comply with the peace
                                          newspapers of Asian countries was on      mity between Rakhine Buddhists and
 a founding member and former                                                                                                   lowing war journalism style while the                                                journalism concept though peace
                                          decline while the number of war jour-     Rohingya Muslims minority, focusing
 Executive Director of Institute of                                                                                             Indian daily, The Hindu was the other                                                journalism, in general, discourages
                                          nalism was increasing. Earlier studies    on human casualties and damages
 Communication Studies (ICS), an                                                                                                newspaper least likely to follow peace                                               journalists to use strong emotive
                                          that analyzed newspaper coverage of       of properties. News stories were
 organization dedicated to build                                                                                                journalism.                                                                          languages such as genocide or ethnic
                                          Kashmir dispute between India and         confined to a closed space and time,
 capacity of journalists. She is a Ful-                                                                                                                                                                              cleansing. It asks to preserve these
                                          Pakistan, Tamil Tigers Movement in        what was happening in the Northern
 bright Scholar of Erasmus Mundus                                                                                               It has been apparent from the study                                                  phrases for the gravest case.
                                          Sri Lanka, Maluku and Aceh conflict       Rakhine, Bangladesh Myanmar bor-
 Journalism with a specialization on                                                                                            that Myanmar and Bangladesh have
                                          in Indonesia and Muslim separatist        ders and Cox’s Bazar refugee camps at
 War and Conflict.                                                                                                              different versions about how the fight-                                              The latest situation of Rohingyas in
                                          movement in Mindanao in the Philip-       the moment of reporting. The areas of
                                                                                                                                ing started, who are the antagonists                                                 Rakhine was a gravest case. Human
                                          pines between 2005 and 2010, re-          agreement or peace initiatives were
                                                                                                                                and who are the protagonists. The                                                    Rights Watch claimed the military
                                          searchers found more than 30% of the      ignored while voices of victims and
                                                                                                                                newspapers, in general, sided with na-                                               in Myanmar carried out a campaign
                                          coverage followed peace journalism        soldiers in the field were not heard in
                                                                                                                                tional policies circulating their version                                            of ethnic cleansing against Rohingya
                                          style . It was more than two times the    reports.
                                                                                                                                of narratives.                                                                       Muslims. Satellite images released in
                                          latest study spotted in the coverage of
                                                                                    The media highlighted violence and                                                                                               September 2017 by Colorado-based
                                          Myanmar-Rohingya conflict.                                                            The newspaper coverage of the Chi-
                                                                                    insecurity expressing doubts over                                                                                                Digital Globe showed Myanmar
                                          After violence broke out on 25 Au-                                                    nese daily Global Times presented the
                                                                                                       Continued on next page   Myanmar version of narratives reflect-                                                                 Continued on next page
pg 12                                                                                         www.park.edu/peacecenter          Vol 9, No. 1                                                                                                           pg 13
Northern Ireland - Park University
April 2020                                                                                                                            April 2020
Rohingya                    from Pg 13                                                                                                          World Forum panelists counter disinformation
authorities torched empty Rohingya         military. They failed to bring out the                                                               By Steven Youngblood
villages as part of the campaigns even     facts which is not compatible with the
after ARSA called a ceasefire .            best practices of peace journalism.                                                                  Disinformation is a menace to democracies around the
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 Austin Aug-
                                                                                                                                                world. Yet, there are those around the world who are fight-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 be (right)
Amnesty International termed clear-        Giving the example of the Rwanda                                                                     ing disinformation using fact checking, literacy program,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 discusses
ance operations of Myanmar military        genocide, Sheuli warned of the failure                                                               and peace journalism.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 countering
as crimes against humanity while the       of reporting accurately and choosing
                                                                                                                                                These anti-disinformation efforts were detailed at a ses-                                                        disinfor-
UNHCR claimed that human rights            strong languages in conflict report-
                                                                                                                                                sion called “Mythbusters,” which was part of the Council of                                                      mation in
violation against Rohingya Muslims         ing. Referring to Schimmel’s study,
                                                                                                                                                Europe-sponsored World Forum for Democracy last week in                                                          Nigeria
in Rakhine is a ‘textbook example’ of      she said, its consequence is devastat-
                                                                                                                                                Strasbourg, France.                                                                                              duirng
ethnic cleansing .                         ing. She mentioned that local media
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 the World
                                           shaded the cruelty of the conflict in
The UN Human Rights Council in-                                                                                                                 My presentation was titled, “Disinformation, Democracy,                                                          Forum for
                                           Rwanda while the Western media
vestigation found evidence of geno-                                                                                                             and the Peace Journalism Solution.” I began by defining                                                          Democracy.
                                           downplayed the genocide as a ‘tribal
cide in Rakhine. Its report describes                                                                                                                                            disinformation, which is the
                                           war’ instead of describing it a sys-
indiscriminate killing, mass raping of                                                References                                                                                 use of lies, half-truths, and
                                           tematic and political project of ethnic     Maslog, C.C., Lee, S.T. and Kim, S.H. (2006) ‘Framing                                                                     forces stereotypes).
women and abuses of children. The                                                                                                                                                irrational content to ma-
                                           cleansing. It was one of the reasons       Analysis of a Conflict: How Newspapers in Five Asian
investigators allege that ‘the gravest                                                Countries Covered the Iraq War’, in Asian Journal of                                       nipulate public opinion. We
                                           international community did not pay                                                                                                                                   Other presenters in the “Mythbusters” session included
crimes under international law’ were                                                  Communication, Vol.16, No.1, pp. 19–39.                                                    discussed its purposes (dis-
                                           much attention and intervene in time        Lee, S.T. and Maslog, C. C. (2005) ‘War or Peace                                                                          Anna University (India) Prof. Sriram Arulchelvan. He
committed in Rakhine in August 2017                                                                                                                                              tracting, obscuring truth,
                                           which cost lives of 250, 000 Tutsi         Journalism? Asian Newspaper Coverage of Conflicts’,                                                                        discussed his university’s media information and literacy
according to a BBC report. Doctors                                                    in Journal of Communication, Vol.55, No.2, pp.            inspiring action, and shaping the information environment)
                                           population in 1994, Sheuli reminded .                                                                                                                                 program that helps high schoolers spot fake news.
Without Borders (MSF) estimated that
                                                                                      311–329.                                                  and characteristics (it works best when targeting pre-exist-
                                                                                       DW (2018) ‘Rohingya Crisis: Bangladesh Delays
at least 6,700 Rohingyas were killed       Hopes Still Alive                          Repatriation of Refugees to Myanmar’ [Internet],          ing divides and prejudices within a society). Disinformation     Austin Augbe, director of the Nigerian Centre for Democ-
in the violence . Therefore, journalists   One of the striking findings of the        22 January, available from  [Accessed                                                                               disinformation in Nigeria. He said that democracy is on the
guages.                                    neutrality in 75 percent stories and       January 2019]                                                                                                              “verge of collapse” in Nigeria, and that disinformation is
                                                                                       HRW (2019) ‘Rohingya Crisis’, in Website of Hu-          Then, I discussed how peace journalism is an effective
                                           ignored government instructions                                                                                                                                       one reason why. His center has a project to fight disinfor-
But Myanmar newspaper did not
                                                                                      man Rights Watch [Internet], 1 May, available             tool for countering disinformation. First, PJ’s principles, as
                                           in many instances. It did not term         from                                                                              mation through fact checking, training 500 fact checkers,
report human rights abuses by the                                                                                                               taught during hundreds of seminars around the world, are
                                           ARSA as a terrorist organization and       [Accessed May 2019]                                                                                                        spreading the word about a #StopFakeNews campaign, and
Myanmar military against the Ro-                                                       UN (2017) ‘UN Human Rights Chief Points                  antithetical to disinformation, including seeking to unite
                                           its members as extremist terrorists,       to Textbook Example of Ethnic Cleansing in                                                                                 conducting research on fake news.
hingya population in their articles.                                                                                                            parties (disinformation divides), carefully choosing lan-
                                           instead put words like ‘ARSA’ and          Myanmar’, in UN News,[Internet], 11 Septem-
The sufferings of the Rohingya citi-                                                  ber, available from[Accessed May 2019]
overlooked. They fled to Bangladesh        burning issue of the dispute.               BBC (2018) ‘Myanmar Rohingya: What You Need                                                                               San Marino, a small nation of 33,000 surrounded by Italy.
                                                                                      to Know About the Crisis’, [Internet], 24 April, avail-
and are now living in refugee camps in                                                able from  [accessed 12 January 2019]                                                                                  fostering cooperation among entities battling disinforma-
ing on foreign aids. Since the latest      Times when Reporters Without                Schimmel, N. (2011) ‘An Invisible Genocide: How the                                                                       tion, and sponsoring media literacy programs in schools.
                                                                                      Western Media Failed to Report the 1994 Rwandan
crisis began more than half of million     Border claims that media freedom is        Genocide of the Tutsi and Why’, in The International
Rohingyas crossed the Myanmar bor-         clearly not one of the priorities of the   Journal of Human Rights, Vol. 15, No. 7, pp.1125–                                                                          Wrapping up the session were respondents Titus Alexander
der and took refuge in Bangladesh. It      Myanmar government,” Sheuli said,          1135.                                                                                                                      and Matthew Golozia. Alexander suggested that universi-
                                                                                       RSF (2018) ‘Aung San Suu Kyi’s Shocking Betrayal’,
seems Myanmar newspapers tried to          adding, “This keeps the hope of pro-       in Website of Reporters Without Border [Internet],
                                                                                                                                                                                                                 ties should lead the way in fighting disinformation, and
cover up the cruelty of the Myanmar        moting peace journalism alive.”            available from  [Ac-                                                                          act as “intelligence agencies” for democracy. This would
                                                                                      cessed May 2019]                                                                                                           include changing the story (in PJ terminology, counternar-

                                             PJ Bookshelf
                                                                                                                                                                                                                 ratives), speaking truth to power, and following the truth.
            It’s Just                                                                  it and detailing its evolution and status
                                                                                       among scholars and practitioners.
                                                                                                                                                                                                                 Golozia concluded by opining that government regulation
                                                                                                                                                                                                                 of internet providers and cell phone companies is needed
        Good Journalism:                    About the book: Experts argue that                   Chapters include:
                                                                                                                                                                                                                 so that everyone has equal access to information.
                                                                                                 Constructive Journalism
Theory, Practice, and Effects of            the news media’s emphasis on prob-
                                                                                                 Civic Journalism
                                            lems has had a negative effect on the                                                                                                                                “Mythbusters” was hosted by the City of Strasbourg in its
Reporting Beyond the Problem                public, the press itself, and democ-                 Participatory Journalism
                                                                                                 Engagement Journalism
                                                                                                                                                                                                                 historic city hall in a room used for formal occasions and,
 Lang Publishing; Summer 2020 release       racy. This book provides an in-depth
                                                                                                 Explanatory Journalism                                                                                          frequently, for weddings.
                                            examination of socially-responsible
 Editors:                                   news reporting practices. Each chapter               Solutions Journalism                           The “Mythbusters” session was held in the historic Stras-
 Karen McIntyre and Nicole Dahmen           focuses on one reporting form, defining              Peace Journalism                               bourg city hall in a room used for formal occasions.
pg 14                                                                                               www.park.edu/peacecenter                    Vol 9, No. 1                                                                                                            pg 15
Northern Ireland - Park University
April 2020                                                                                                                      April 2020
PJ, Rotary peace initiatives discussed in California                                                                             Media network launches nationwide in Cameroon
By Steven Youngblood                       The other speakers were amazing.            The conference featured dozens of         By Tarhyang Enowbikah Tabe
Like most attendees at the Rotary                                                      examples of Rotarians working for         The Cameroon Community Media
World Peace Conference in January          Azim Khamisa’s son was killed by            peace. Rotarian Hardeep Girin from        Network, CCMN, has officially gone
2020 in Ontario, CA, I came away with      gang members 25 years ago. Instead          Australia discussed his initiative,       national with the appointment of a
mixed feelings. On the one hand, I de-     of retribution, he launched the Tarik       “World Made Good,” that produces          National Coordinator.
part deeply concerned about conflicts      Khamisa Foundation, dedicated to            free videos for NGO’s that tell stories
that plague our world. On the other        breaking the cycle of youth violence.       to benefit both the NGO and its clien-    Rose Obah Akah was appointed as the                                                                           Rose Obah
hand, I head home encouraged and           “There is nothing quite as painful as a     tele. An effervescent Barbara Muller      pioneer National Coordinator of the                                                                           Akah meets
inspired by the amazing work being         broken heart,” Azim Khamisa told the        discussed her initiative called peace-    Cameroon Community Media Net-                                                                                 with CCMN
done by Rotarians and others in the        approximately 1,000 attendees. “But         podcast.org, and urged her audience       work in Buea at the end of a crucial                                                                          members at a
cause of world peace.                      a broken heart is an open heart” that       to launch their own peace podcasts.       and very decisive workshop for the                                                                            recent work-
                                           can be taught to embrace empathy            She also                                  growth of the network.                                                                                        shop.
My presentation on the basics of           and compassion.                             encour-
peace journalism typifies this binary. I                                               aged her                                  The CCMN has now gone nationwide
started my presentation with a discus-     Dr. Ira Helfand spoke movingly about        audiences                                 with 8 branches in 8 regions. The
sion about low public approval ratings     the potential horrors of nuclear war,       to get                                    regional coordinators were also ap-
of the media, and the ills that plague     and of the need to eliminate all nucle-     involved in                               pointed. The Cameroon Community
the profession. Then my talk took          ar weapons. He urged the attendees          the Rotary                                Media Network has trained a battery
a hopeful turn as I described peace        to get involved in a group called Rotar-    E-Club for Peace—www.rotarye-             of journalists in peace journalism and
                                           ians for a Nuclear Ban. Helfand’s orga-                                                                                         of the Southwest and Littoral regions.     West chapter and a few months later
journalism and its ability to create                                                   clubofworldpeace.org. The E-Club          conflict resolution/ transformation.
                                           nization, the International Campaign                                                                                            Those were the only four regions that      the PCC appointed her as manager of
an atmosphere conducive to peace                                                       seeks to bring together experts and
                                           to Abolish Nuclear Weapons, won the                                                   According to reports from Buea, she is    had activities of the network before it    the Peace Journalism Project which
without compromising the principles                                                    peacebuilders to discuss problems
                                           2017 Nobel Peace Prize.                                                               tasked to coordinate the Network and      went national under the coordination       currently has over 60 journalists com-
of good journalism.                                                                    and solutions facing the world, and
                                                                                                                                 organize National Elections in 2 years.   of Rose Obah Akah.                         mitted to enhancing peace in their
                                           Dr. Fazim Alvi broke the attendee’s         encourages its members to create
A large, engaged audience showered                                                                                                                                                                                    communities through their reporting.
                                           hearts with horrifying, tragic stories      peace at home and in schools; be-                                                   Who is Rose Obah Akah?
me with perceptive questions both                                                                                                Her appointment has been received                                                    She is a media consultant; a peace
                                           about the Rohingya genocide in Myan-        come peace advocates at work and in                                                 Rosaline Obah Akah is a graduate from
during and indeed after the presenta-                                                                                            with a lot of joy and enthusiasm given                                               journalism, conflict transformation,
                                           mar. She has traveled on medical mis-       the world; and create understanding                                                 the University of Buea in Cameroon in
tion. One attendee wanted to know if                                                                                             the wealth of experience she possess-                                                “Do No Harm” and election reporting
                                           sions to refugee camps in Bangladesh        and collaboration among religions,                                                  2005 with a degree in Journalism and
anyone is practicing peace journalism.                                                                                           es in the field of community commu-                                                  trainer; and a promoter and advocate
                                           that house Rohingya refugees. Alvi is       among other things.                                                                 Mass Communication/Women and
I mentioned the Guardian, Nicolas                                                                                                nication and peace building.                                                         for equal gender and human rights.
                                           haunted by the unsanitary, dangerous                                                                                            Gender Studies. She is a professional
Kristof, and many radio journalists in                                                 A large exhibition hall featured doz-
                                           conditions there, and by the faces of                                                 Until her appointment, she was coor-      communicator and peace builder.            Award winner
Cameroon and Uganda as positive                                                        ens of Rotarians and others eagerly
                                           children she met in the camps, includ-                                                dinator of the Network for the North-                                                Between January and March 2019,
examples.                                                                              passing out brochures about their                                                   Her passion and go-getting spirit led
                                           ing one she calls simply “girl crying”                                                west and West regions, while Rev.                                                    Akah has received two awards for her
                                                                                       outstanding projects, including a                                                   to her appointment as Regional Com-
It was interesting to see many of          because she never got her name. “I                                                    Geraldine Fobah coordinated affairs                                                  efforts in peace building and Commu-
                                                                                       Russia-U.S. Friendship initiative; a                                                munication Secretary of the Presby-
the themes I touched upon in my            can still feel her pain. Her eyes tell me                                                                                                                                  nity Development together with other
                                                                                       variety of clean water projects; the                                                terian Church in Cameroon (PCC) in
talk echoed by other speakers at the       stories of injustice…Her face is driv-                                                                                                                                     recognitions received in the last few
                                                                                       Open World exchange program, the            Tarhyang Enowbikah Tabe is a            the Northwest region. Her commit-
conference. This includes the need to      ing me to do this advocacy work,” Alvi                                                                                                                                     years. Her works in peace building and
                                                                                       Rotary Malaria Symposium; Project           trained Journalist and Develop-         ment to work and outstanding output
reject “us vs. them” constructs, and       said. She urged the audience to pres-                                                                                                                                      community development has equally
                                                                                       Peanut Butter to battle malnutrition;       ment Communicator with over 20          compelled the PCC to appoint her the
to give a “voice to the voiceless” in      sure the Myanmar government to end                                                                                                                                         been recognized and featured in local,
                                                                                       Kherut, an anti-trafficking NGO; the        years of practical experience. He is    first Station Manager of the Christian
everything we do.                          the genocide.                                                                                                                                                              national, and international media.
                                                                                       Rotarian Action Group for Family            Publisher and Chief Executive Of-       Broadcasting Service (CBS) Radio
                                                                                       Safety; Creating Friendships for Peace;     ficer of The Advocate Newspaper,        Bamenda in 2016. She held the posi-        Akah has trained hundreds of youths,
                                                                                       Hands of Peace, an initiative uniting       Cameroons Pioneer Media Organ           tion of President of the Cameroon As-      men and women, media houses and
    Day one                                                                            Israeli and Palestinian youth; the Free     for the Civil Society and For the       sociation of English Speaking Journal-     practitioners, CSOs, and religious
  plenary at                                                                           Wheelchair Mission, and the Rotarian        Civil Society with                      ists NW for two successive mandates        leaders in the domains of peace and
  the Rotary                                                                           Action Group for Peace (https://www.        focus on the                            up to October 2018. She now serves         conflict transformation, human rights,
World Peace                                                                            rotarianactiongroupforpeace.org/).          Sustainable De-                         as an adviser to this vibrant journalism   digital rights, responsible use of social
 Conference                                                                                                                        velopment Goals                         association NW.                            media, stress management, volun-
                                                                                       While the conference underscored            and Resident
 in Ontario,                                                                                                                                                                                                          teerism, non-violent communication,
                                                                                       the great deal of work ahead for            Consultant with                         In 2018, she was elected as the
         CA.                                                                                                                                                                                                          mediation, humanitarian reporting,
                                                                                       peacebuilders, it was a valuable            the UNCHRD                              President of the Cameroon Commu-           SDGs, and other peace and commu-
                                                                                       reminder that those working for a           Central Africa.                         nity Media Network Northwest and           nity development-related areas.
                                                                                       peaceful world are not alone.
pg 16                                                                                            www.park.edu/peacecenter        Vol 9, No. 1                                                                                                           pg 17
You can also read