SHEFFIELD CITY KNIFE CRIME STRATEGY 2018/21 - South Yorkshire Police
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
2 Sheffield Knife Crime Strategy BY WORKING TOGETHER WE CAN CREATE RESILIENT, STRONG COMMUNITIES AND BE MUCH MORE EFFECTIVE THAN EVER BEFORE.
Sheffield Knife Crime Strategy 3 Contents Foreword 5 Partnerships 32 Operation Fortify 6 Delivery 34 Our beliefs 8 Challenges............................................. 34 Governance........................................... 34 Knife crime 11 Our vision.............................................. 35 Performance 12 Our aims................................................ 35 National overview.................................. 12 Our objectives 36 South Yorkshire overview...................... 14 Prepare.................................................. 37 Perception 16 Prevent.................................................. 38 Why have we seen a rise?..................... 16 Protect................................................... 39 Pursue................................................... 40 Problems 18 What is the relationship between Our outcomes 41 gangs and knife crime?......................... 18 Prepare.................................................. 41 Youth offending..................................... 20 Prevent.................................................. 41 Night time economy.............................. 21 Protect................................................... 42 Habitual knife carriers............................ 22 Pursue................................................... 42 People 24 Victim profile.......................................... 24 Offender profile...................................... 26 Place 27 Key locations......................................... 27 Serious violence in key locations.......... 28 Premise types........................................ 30
Sheffield Knife Crime Strategy 5 Foreword We are determined to do everything within We are pleased to introduce this our power to eradicate these problems strategy which sets out how we from our streets, neighbourhoods and intend to tackle knife crime across communities across the city. We are proud the city of Sheffield. of Sheffield and of the people who live and work here who continue unfalteringly to It builds on best practice from many other give us support. We want to send a clear parts of the country, and articulates our message to those individuals and gangs determination to keep the pressure on involved in knife crime that they are not criminals and to ensure this city continues welcome here. to be a safe place to live and work. Knife crime often affects those most vulnerable in our community. In Sheffield many families have been bereaved; many more have seen their loved ones severely Chief Superintendent injured. We know we speak for the Stuart Barton overwhelming majority in this city when we say this is absolutely unacceptable. It has to stop. Protecting those most in need, Cabinet member for must be a priority for us all. Neighbourhood and Community Safety At a time when we are all trying to do more Sheffield City Council with less, investing resources in the right Jim Steinke places and spaces has never been more important. It is clear that South Yorkshire Police cannot deal with this problem alone. Working collaboratively across the public sector in Sheffield alongside our partners in the private, voluntary and third sector will be key to long-term success.
6 Sheffield Knife Crime Strategy Operation Fortify organised criminality and violent crime in Operation Fortify is Sheffield’s all its forms and ensure active steps are partnership approach to dealing with taken to target, disrupt and prosecute serious violent crime and organised those individuals who participate in or criminality. indeed orchestrate this activity in our communities. A criminal justice-based response is not the sole solution to tackling this In addition to the traditional methods type of harm and criminal behaviour. used to tackle this type of criminality, this Responsibility for responding to it rests in team will also use a variety of regulatory working collaboratively across the public, tools and enforcement powers to target private and voluntary sector and crucially people and places where this criminality is alongside the community. In recognition taking place. of this, Operation Fortify was launched in Autumn 2018 to send a clear message to communities across the city that this type of criminality would not be tolerated and that working together, we can create resilient strong communities. Therefore be much more effective than ever before in stopping those that want to cause harm BY WORKING TOGETHER on our streets and in our neighbourhoods WE CAN CREATE and city. RESILIENT STRONG At the centre of Operation Fortify is a collocated multiagency team, which has COMMUNITIES AND BE the role of coordinating and monitoring MUCH MORE EFFECTIVE activity to tackle serious violent crime across Sheffield. It is the responsibility THAN EVER BEFORE. of this team to gather information and intelligence, to map and monitor
Sheffield Knife Crime Strategy 7 OPERATION FORTIFY Operation Fortify Gold Group Strategic Governance South Yorkshire Police Operation Fortify Strategic Safeguarding Tactical Tasking and Silver Group Tactical Board Coordinating Group Governance Operation Fortify Bronze Operational Delivery Group Operation Fortify Operation Fortify TFC Intel SPOC Analyst Detective Inspector Researcher PVP SPOC IOM SPOC NPT SPOC HMIC Health Professional Social Care Manager Partnership Coordinator Detective Sergeant Wellbeing Mental Health 2 x Youth 2 x Social Worker Sheffield Futures 6 x Detective Constables ASB Civil Injections PC Justice Workers South Yorkshire Fire 1 x 6 Uniform Tasking Immigration enforcement Housing and Rescue Service Team Trading Standards Immigration Officer
8 Sheffield Knife Crime Strategy Our beliefs Violence is and remains a public health problem. PREVENTION IS THE BEDROCK OF OUR We are committed to early intervention APPROACH AND THIS and prevention because we recognise and understand that whilst many survive IS WHY WE SHARE being exposed to violence, they will suffer physical, mental and/or emotional health RESPONSIBILITY problems throughout the rest of their lives. We are committed to getting upstream of the issue and stopping violence before it begins. We will do this by approaching violence as a public health problem. Our commitment is clear, we aim to deliver sustainable reductions in violence and improve the quality of life/health of all those people who live in our communities and depend on us to make a difference. Prevention is the bedrock of our approach and this is why we share responsibility, committing, across a range of agencies and with our families, schools and neighbourhoods, to prevent the damage that violence can cause in our county.
Sheffield Knife Crime Strategy 9 PATHWAY FOR SUCCESS OUR 5 STEP APPROACH TO VIOLENCE REDUCTION IN SHEFFIELD 1 Primary Prevention Seeking to prevent the onset of violence or to change behavior so that violence is prevented from developing 2 Secondary Prevention To halt the progression of violence once it is established - this is achieved by early detection or early diagnosis followed by prompt effective treatment 3 Tertiary Prevention The rehabilitation of people with established violent behaviour or affected as a victim 4 Enforcement and Criminal Justice Developing innovative criminal justice practices that reduce offending behaviour and racism 5 Attitudinal Change Changing attitudes and behaviors towards all types of violence at a societal community and personal leve
10 Sheffield Knife Crime Strategy WE AIM TO DELIVER SUSTAINABLE REDUCTIONS IN VIOLENCE AND IMPROVE THE QUALITY OF LIFE OF ALL THOSE PEOPLE WHO LIVE IN OUR COMMUNITIES
Sheffield Knife Crime Strategy 11 Knife Crime Knife crime has been defined as any In order to understand the nature offence which satisfies both of the and drivers of these offences, an following criteria: in-depth review in terms of Performance, People, Place, • Is classified as an offence of homicide, Problems, Perception and attempted murder, assault with intent to Partnerships has been completed. cause harm, assault with injury, threats to kill, sexual offences (including rape) and robbery; • Where a knife or sharp instrument has been used to injure, used as a threat, or the victim was convinced a knife was present during the offence. Knife possession offences have been defined as: • Having an article with blade or point in a public place (including school) • Threatening with a blade or sharply pointed article in a public place (including school) • Possession of offensive weapon • Using someone to look after an offensive weapon • Threatening with an offensive weapon
12 Sheffield Knife Crime Strategy Performance National Overview The police recorded 36,998 offences In order to understand these involving a knife or sharp instrument in the variations, work by Cardiff University, year ending June 2017, a 26% increase commissioned by the Home Office, compared with the previous year (29,476) examined the volumes of people and the highest number in the seven-year seeking treatment for violence. series (from year ending March 2011), the earliest point for which comparable data is This work reviewed the data of 152 available. emergency departments and found that a steady decrease is noted 4. The past three years have seen a rise in the number of offences involving a knife Partnership data from across or sharp instrument recorded, following Sheffield is referenced later in this a general downward trend in this series strategy. since the year ending March 20111. The majority of police forces (38 of the 44) recorded a rise in offences involving knives and sharp instruments compared with the previous year. The force that showed the largest volume increase was the Metropolitan Police (accounting for 47% of the increase in England and Wales)2. South Yorkshire is one of those forces showing an increase, with a 53% increase recorded in the year to June 2017. This is in contrast to the Crime Survey England and Wales to the end of June 2017 3 records that violence has not increased and that there has been no significant change in volumes compared to the previous year. 1 Office for National Statistics - Crime in England and Wales: Year ending June 2017 2 Office for National Statistics - Crime in England and Wales: Year ending June 2017 3 ONS – Crime in England and Wales: year ending June 2017. 4 Violence in England and Wales in 2016 – An Accident and Emergency Perspective - http://www.cardiff.ac.uk/__data/assets/ pdf_file/0009/734904/Violence-in-England-and-Wales-in-2016.pdf.
1 21-30% reduction 2 11-20% reduction 1 0-10% reduction 2 No change JUNE 2016 WITH YEAR JUNE 2017 5 0-10% increase 9 11-20% increase COMPARING YEAR TO 10 21-30% increase KNIFE CRIME ALL FORCES 5 31-40% increase 4 41-50% increase 1 51-60% increase 1 61-70% increase 1 71-80% increase 1 81-90% increase 1 Sheffield Knife Crime Strategy Over 100% increase 13
14 Sheffield Knife Crime Strategy Performance South Yorkshire Overview of weapons were used as a threat (49%) Within South Yorkshire, the volume of or carried but not used (26%). The most knife related offences has fluctuated common weapon type was knife / dagger month on month over the last five (42%), followed by kitchen knife (19%). years 5, increasing steadily, but at Other weapons included Stanley knife, lock a slow rate. In October 2016, knife knife, glass bottle and machete. crimes peaked significantly above volumes seen in the previous four Within both domestic and non-domestic years – most likely linked to the knife crime, threats, possession and GBH introduction of CDI 6. Volumes type offences have generally accounted have then continued to rise before for the majority of crimes. However, over fluctuating following the introduction the last 5 years, this make-up has shifted, of Connect 7. with threats accounting for an increasing proportion, whilst possessions are reducing There were 2,375 offences within the proportionally, as shown in the chart 12-month period 01/12/16 and 30/11/17, opposite. accounting for 2% of all crime committed in the Force in the same period. Knife This is indicative of the suggested impact related Violence Against Person (VAP) of CDI (in terms of threats) and reduced accounted for 5% of total VAP 8 in the stop and searches (potentially affecting period. Approximately 14% of offences possessions). In terms of assaults, were domestic and removed from much of GBH, ABH and common assaults have the analysis within this report due to being a all recorded increasing volumes whilst relatively well-understood area of offending reducing slightly proportionally. This in comparison to non-domestic incidents. suggests CDI is driving increases, as ‘lower The total number of non-domestic knife level’ offences, e.g. threats, are more likely crime was 2,047. to be affected by recording practices than ‘more serious’ offences, e.g. assaults, VAP offending accounted for the majority which are unlikely to be recorded differently of offences (70%), with offences ranging before and after the CDI Review. from possession to murder. Possession offences were the most common (25%), Despite the slight proportional drop in GBH, followed by assaults (22%) and threats rising volumes are still a concern, as CDI (19%). Serious violence, defined as GBH, is unlikely to have affected these figures, Attempted Murder and Murder accounted meaning the increase is an actual increase for offending. Most weapons are recorded in serious violence. This is reflected at a as ‘used’ (79%), whilst 21% refer to national level. weapons being ‘possessed’. The majority 5 01/12/2012 to 31/11/2017 6 Crime Data Integrity Inspections 7 SYP new computer system 8 Calculated as knife related VAP as a % of Total VAP committed in the period – based on Home Office Group and volume taken from SYP Performance Pages.
0 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 Q4 12/13 Q4 12/13 Q1 13/14 Q1 13/14 Pre-CDI Q2 13/14 Q2 13/14 Q3 13/14 Q3 13/14 KNIFE CRIME 01/12/2012 to 30/11/2017 01/01/2013 to 30-09/2017 Q4 13/14 Q4 13/14 Q1 14/15 Q1 14/15 Post-CDI Q2 14/15 Q2 14/15 Possession (Inc blade & offensive) MONTHLY VOLUMES OF Q3 14/15 Q3 14/15 Q4 14/15 Q4 14/15 Q1 15/16 Q1 15/16 TYPE OFFENCES AS A % TOTAL Linear (Pre-CDI Q2 15/16 Q2 15/16 QUARTERLY POSSESSION/THREAT Q3 15/16 Q3 15/16 Q4 15/16 Q4 15/16 Q1 16/17 Q1 16/17 Q2 16/17 Q2 16/17 Threats (Inc blade off & TTK) Q3 16/17 Q3 16/17 Q4 16/17 Q4 16/17 Q1 17/18 Q1 17/18 Sheffield Knife Crime Strategy Q2 17/18 Q2 17/18 15
16 Sheffield Knife Crime Strategy Perception Why Have We Seen A Rise? and more traditional media mediums have There are a number of interconnected undoubtedly all played their part. Coupling factors, which may speak to the this with the ready availability of knives reasons why, but the reality is from home, online or traditional retailers reasons offered are often anecdotal and the circumstance we are dealing with and not evidence based. is one which needs a much more nuanced approach than simply ‘enforcement based Police statistics are prone to changes in police response’. The majority of research counting rules and methods. As such, conducted into weapon carrying has better crime recording practices may pointed to self-defence and protection as a be a contributory factor. This, alongside key reason why young people carry knives. changes to Home Office counting rules in October 2017, has played it’s part in what Significantly, for people surveyed, protecting is increasingly being seen as a national themselves from others carrying weapons epidemic 9 10. was considered to outweigh the risk of being caught by police. However we also Across the UK, there have been significant recognise that the decision to carry or use increases in the use of knives to facilitate weapons is often more complex – in many related criminal activity for example cases knives are carried not for protection robbery, a high increase and volume but to intimidate others, to facilitate contributor. We have also seen an increase robbery, to deliberately injure or kill or in knife crime usage in sex crimes and simply for the perceived power and status domestic abuse (18% increase nationally). that the carrying of a weapon provides. Simple possession offences have also seen a substantial rise by 31%, 15,554 offences Although knife crime is on the increase, it is in total, which may speak to better targeted important to keep it in perspective. It is still police action since this is realised against relatively unusual for a violent incident to a back drop of a 28% fall nationally in Stop involve a knife, and rarer still for someone and Search11. to need hospital treatment. Most violence is caused by people hitting, kicking, shoving There is no doubt that we have seen an or slapping someone, sometimes during increased social acceptance amongst our a fight and often when they’re drunk; the young people towards carrying knives. police figures on violence also include Primarily, the explanation offered is that crimes of harassment and stalking. The they do so for ‘self-protection’. Gang Crime Survey for England and Wales, which culture and the ‘glamorising’ of carrying includes offences that are not reported to weapons through music videos, gaming police, indicates overall levels of violence 9 https://www.justiceinspectorates.gov.uk/hmicfrs/our-work/crime-data-integrity/ 10 in how we have recorded crime to include any instrument that pierces the skin not just knives has had an effect 11 Year ending March 2016
Sheffield Knife Crime Strategy 17 have fallen by 25% since 2013. Similarly, a Review of iQuanta data identifies a similar useful comparator is data collected by the trend as below, with SYP showing a notable NHS over a similar reporting period, which change in gradient from October 2016, shows a 7% increase in admissions for despite the Most Similar Group (MSG) assault with a sharp object. This has already average continuing on a steadier trend. been highlighted within this strategy. The Crime Survey England and Wales to the As well as the Crime Survey, end of June 2017 12 records that violence anecdotally it is proposed that has not increased and there has been no current media coverage is increasing significant change in volumes compared to public awareness of knife crime, with the previous year. Longer term, the report multiple reports of serious violence identifies a reduction in violent crime, incidents nationwide. This increased however it is noted that this is in contrast public awareness of knife-related to Police figures, which are recording and other violent crimes is likely to increases in violence. contribute to an increased sense of threat, which could in turn lead to In the last five years 13 the volume of knife upturns in regard to possession of related offences has fluctuated month on weapons. month; increasing steadily, but at a low rate. In October 2016, knife crimes peaked way above volumes seen in the previous four years, which correlates temporally with the Crime Data Integrity Review within SYP 14. This trend is illustrated on the chart below: QUARTERLY VOLUMES OF KNIFE CRIME 01/01/2013 to 30/09/2017 700 600 500 400 300 200 100 0 Q4 12/13 Q1 13/14 Q2 13/14 Q3 13/14 Q4 13/14 Q1 14/15 Q2 14/15 Q3 14/15 Q4 14/15 Q1 15/16 Q2 15/16 Q3 15/16 Q4 15/16 Q1 16/17 Q2 16/17 Q3 16/17 Q4 16/17 Q1 17/18 Q2 17/18 12 ONS – Crime in England and Wales: year ending June 2017. 13 01/12/2012 to 31/11/2017. 14 This is covered in more detail in the upcoming Knife Crime profile.
18 Sheffield Knife Crime Strategy Problems What is the relationship between gangs and knife crime? Research has shown a greater likelihood However, gang-related knife crimes are of carrying knives among gang members usually of a more violent nature than compared to non-gang members, with a other knife related offending. forty five significant difference in the percentage per cent, of the gang, affiliated offenders of people carrying knives between these were repeat offenders within the five year two groups. A review of survey data from period, accounting for 72% of OCG related the New English and Welsh Arrestee Drug offending. Repeat offenders committed Abuse Monitoring (NEWADAM) programme between 2 and 14 offences, highlighting at various custody suites across the the severity of the impact from these country found highly significant differences nominals. in weapon carrying between gang The chart below shows the monthly members and non-gang members, with a trend in volumes of knife crime, greater tendency to carry weapons among overlaid with monthly volumes of gang members. Recent data suggests that knife crimes involving mapped OCG the majority of knife crime is not gang- members: related. Gang flagged crime accounted for 2% of total knife crime and 6% of total named offenders in South Yorkshire. TOTAL KNIFE CRIME PER MONTH COMPARED TO OCG RELATED OFFENDING 300 14 250 12 10 200 8 150 6 100 4 50 2 0 0 Dec - 12 Feb - 13 Apr - 13 Jun - 13 Aug - 13 Oct - 13 Dec - 13 Feb - 14 Apr - 14 Jun - 14 Aug - 14 Oct - 14 Dec - 14 Feb - 15 Apr - 15 Jun - 15 Aug - 15 Oct - 15 Dec - 15 Feb - 16 Apr - 16 Jun - 16 Aug - 16 Oct - 16 Dec - 16 Feb - 17 Apr - 17 Jun - 17 Aug - 17 Oct - 17 Total OCG
Sheffield Knife Crime Strategy 19 As such, when considering our responses to knife crime in Sheffield, it is important to understand knife crime is much more than just gang related activity; focusing exclusively on gangs is not going to solve or adequately affect our knife crime challenges. This Strategy also recognises there has been a shift in offending patterns with a renewed emergence of group-related offending, a group of individuals who cannot be classified as being part of an organised group or gang. GANG-RELATED KNIFE It should also be recognised gang and CRIMES ARE USUALLY OF group violence is often linked to drug markets, and stabbings and knife crime A MORE VIOLENT NATURE can be associated with the control of drug supply both within and beyond Sheffield. TO OTHER KNIFE-RELATED These changing trends in offending OFFENDING. behaviour and patterns will continue to be monitored and responded to, whilst never losing sight of gang-related offending which continues to be a key priority. Approximately a third of OCG related offending was serious violence. We have identified that the illegal drug trade is a key driver of serious violence, with intervention at the first stage of offending crucial to prevent escalation. Therefore, OCG related offending (either mapped or unmapped) continues to be a significant factor in knife- related criminality. This may also explain why the Crime Survey has contrasting findings, with no significant change identified, as a lot of gang-related violence is hidden from the general public, who would be responding to the Crime Survey.
20 Sheffield Knife Crime Strategy Problems Youth Offending Twenty six per cent of named offenders Key locations for youth offending were under the age of 18, committing include: a range of offences from possession to murder. Proportionally, youth offenders • Norfolk Park, Sheffield (x9) are prevalent in terms of threats, public • Fitzalan Sq /Arundel Gate, Sheffield (x7) order offences, common assault, ABH and Offences including three robberies attempted robbery. committed by one offender. Twelve per cent of offences involving youths • Parsons Cross, Sheffield (x7) resulted in cautions, whilst 10% of youths Possession, threats and assaults at were charged, 4% summonsed and 9% ASDA. subject to a restorative justice / community • Sicey Ave, Shiregreen, Sheffield (x2) resolution outcome. The outcome rate for One of these offences was a public named youth offenders of knife crime is order offence involving eight different therefore 37%, which is roughly in line with youths. the 40% outcome rate observed in terms of overall named knife crime offenders. • Woodfield Rd, Balby, Doncaster (x5) Four of these relate to one incident in The majority of youth offenders were which four children were threatened male students of White – North European by three youths. ethnicity. Three youth offenders were mapped members of an OCG. 50% of youth offenders were linked to offending Five per cent of total knife crime took in the Sheffield area, followed by 22% in place in schools, with 16% of youth Doncaster, 17% in Rotherham and 11% in offending being identified as within a Barnsley. school. This highlights opportunities for crime prevention work within our schools. However, there are also the limitations to this, with the majority of offending being outside of the school environment, therefore wrap around support for youths from family, social services and other agencies is also required to prevent them becoming engaged in violent crime.
Sheffield Knife Crime Strategy 21 Problems Night-time economy The night-time economy is a key driver of economic and cultural regeneration and a magnet for RECENT RESEARCH SHOWS domestic and international visitors. THAT THE NIGHT-TIME Recent research shows that the night- ECONOMY CONTRIBUTES time economy contributes significantly to SIGNIFICANTLY Sheffield’s annual GDP and supports One in eight jobs. This figure is expected to TO SHEFFIELD’S rise to £28.3bn by 2029. Analysis of knife crime hot spots shows some cross over ANNUAL GDP with areas linked to Sheffield’s night-time economy. However, more work is needed to understand if these are directly linked or that this is a key driver of knife offending. Through further analysis we are seeking to gain a greater understanding of any impact knife crime has in areas related to the night-time economy. The vast majority of bottle-based attacks were reported to Northern General Hospital overnight, with 87% of injuries presented between 7pm and 7am and 63% presenting over the weekend. This suggests that bottle-based attacks are linked to the night-time economy. To tackle this type of offending, we will work with licenced premises to reduce the amount of glass available by providing polycarbonate alternatives.
22 Sheffield Knife Crime Strategy Problems Habitual knife carriers South Yorkshire Police (SYP) define The following key risk factors habitual knife carriers (HKC) as: have been identified in terms of possession offences: • “Any individual that has been identified at least twice as a suspect • Drug dependencies – as a driver on connect/lynx for Possession of towards acquisitive crime and Offensive Weapon / Knife / Bladed highlighting vulnerabilities; Article or a Knife Injury excluding • Other criminality – as a precursor to Domestic Abuse offence in the last carrying a knife, however the link is two years; unclear and the intended usage may AND range from a tool for acquisitive crime to a weapon for use in an assault; • At least one of the above offences in the last 12 months unless this subject • Domestic problems – linked to has been in prison for a period in the offending directly as perpetrator as last 12 months 16.” well as victims and witnesses who are impacted through exposure Within South Yorkshire, we believe to unacceptable behaviour and that there are a number of habitual criminality; and knife carriers as of yet unidentified. Dip • Mental Health – in terms of sampling of possessions found that over vulnerability. 18% of offenders were unknown to SYP prior to the offences within the sample, It is noted that of the 29 nominals presenting intelligence gaps in terms of identified as potential HKC, 7% were the drivers behind possession of knives. mapped OCG members and 28% were This is a key risk in that possessions are youths. This correlates with previous the precursor to all other knife crimes, findings and highlights the need for therefore intervention at this stage is methodologies such as this, to identify crucial to prevent escalation and protect those who would benefit from interventions the public. to prevent reoffending or escalation of In order to try to identify key nominals in offending. terms of possession of knives, the first part of the SYP definition has been applied to find the ‘Top Habitual Knife Carriers’ per district. 16 Metropolitan Police Service: Pan-London Knife Crime Problem Profile
Sheffield Knife Crime Strategy 23 In order to tackle knife crime at its roots, Stop & Search: Stop and Search volumes must increase One method of challenging HKC is in all districts, which could be supported through use of Stop and Search powers, by provision of a ‘Top 10’ each quarter. with a renewed vigour in a targeted This ‘Top 10’ would allow focus on key manner under the 2017/2018 SYP Knife nominals as well as allowing intelligence Crime Strategy. The chart below shows development in terms of the profile of Stop and Search data in the most recent HKCs. 12-month review period, broken down by district: Volumes of Stop and Searches have fluctuated in all districts with no clear trends in terms of increases or decreases. A review of the number of searches per 10,000 residents identifies that Sheffield had the highest rate, followed by Doncaster, Barnsley and then Rotherham, which completed less than 10 searches per 10,000 residents over the last 12 months. STOP AND SEARCH PER DISTRICT IN THE LAST 12 MONTHS 01/04/2017 to 31/03/2018 250 200 150 100 50 0 Apr-17 May-17 Jun-17 Jul-17 Aug-17 Sep-17 Oct-17 Nov-17 Dec-17 Jan-18 Feb-18 Mar-18 Barnsley Doncaster Rotherham Sheffield
24 Sheffield Knife Crime Strategy People Victim profile - non-domestic offences Doncaster and Barnsley both observe Four per cent of victims were recorded a similar victim profile as above, whilst against more than one offence in the Rotherham identifies slightly younger review period. Repeat victims therefore victims, with key ages between 12 and account for 6% of overall knife crime 23. There is also a notably smaller range in the last 12 months. Of the repeat between the oldest and youngest victims victims, three were named against three compared to other districts and the offences. Just one victim was identified force overall. When looking at Sheffield as having a victim-offender crossover, specifically, there was more diversity in whereby they were named as both a terms of ethnicity with 70% of victims victim and offender in the 12-month of White – North European compared review period. to 83%, 87% and 78% in Doncaster, Barnsley and Rotherham respectively. Victims ranged between 5 and 89 years Slightly older victims were also noted in of age, with 29% between the ages of 22 Sheffield, with 22% between the ages of and 31 and 18% between the ages of 15 17 and 22, compared to 19% force wide. and 20. 77% of recorded victims were male, with the most common ethnicity being White – North European (76%). The majority of victims were either unemployed or students. Generally, victims did not 77% OF RECORDED know their attacker (48%) or they were an VICTIMS WERE MALE acquaintance (27%). Approximately 12% of victims were under the influence of drink WITH THE MOST and / or drugs. A similar profile was also observed for males and females when COMMON ETHNICITY considered separately. BEING WHITE – NORTH EUROPEAN - 76% 17 Based on 1580 victims recorded Force-wide in CMS.
Sheffield Knife Crime Strategy 25 Despite this sample being non-domestic offences, 2% of victims were recorded as having either a family or partner / ex- partner type relationship with the suspect. A random dip sample of five incidents identified that all five offences involved minors between 14 / 15 years and a parent or uncle. Four of the five involve minors as suspects whilst one involves a mother with mental health issues. The incidents include threats, assaults or simply holding weapons during arguments. Current APPROXIMATELY 87% recording practices only include domestic OF VICTIMS WERE abuse where the suspect is over the age of 16, therefore four of these offences RECORDED AS would not qualify for the domestic flag, despite adolescent-to-parent abuse being HAVING SUSTAINED increasingly recognised as a form of AN INJURY. domestic abuse 18. Approximately 87% of victims were recorded as having sustained an injury. The majority record threats (56%), whilst slight injuries were noted in 22% of offences. Serious injuries were sustained in 10% of offences and less than 1% of victims were fatally injured. 18 Home Office – Information Guide: adolescent to parent violence and abuse (AVPA).
26 Sheffield Knife Crime Strategy People Offender profile - non-domestic offences When looking at Sheffield specifically, Thirteen per cent of suspects were there was more diversity in terms of recorded against more than one offence ethnicity with 53% of offenders of White in the review period. Repeat offenders – North European compared to 78%, therefore account for 21% of overall 81% and 75% in Doncaster, Barnsley knife crime in the last 12 months, an and Rotherham respectively. This is average of 2.37 offences per offender. roughly in line with the demographics Of the repeat offenders, 45 were named of each district, i.e. Sheffield has a against three or more offences, 15 larger BME population than the other against four or more and five against districts; however, the proportions are five offences. not representative, with BME groups much more prominent than they are in the Offenders ranged between 7 and 79 years general population. For example, 19% of of age, with 52% of offenders below the the population of Sheffield are from BME age of 26. Key ages were 17 – 19 years groups 21, compared to 47% of knife-crime and 23 – 25 years. It is noted that 3% of offenders. offenders were below the age of 12, which raises concerns in terms of very young offenders and a need for early intervention. Ninety per cent of recorded offenders were 90% OF RECORDED male, with the most common ethnicity being White – North European (66%). OFFENDERS WERE The majority of offenders were either MALE, WITH THE MOST unemployed (71%) or students (14%) 20. Generally, suspects did not know their COMMON ETHNICITY victim (53%) or they were an acquaintance (23%). Approximately 15% of suspects BEING WHITE – NORTH were under the influence of drink and / EUROPEAN - 66%. or drugs. A similar profile was observed for males when considered separately, however a larger proportion of females were between the ages of 12 and 14 (13%), and 19 and 23 (16%). A larger proportion of females were of White – North European ethnicity (75%) and / or under the influence of drink / drugs (23%). 20 This figure excludes the 26% of occupations that were not recorded. 21 https://www.sheffield.gov.uk/home/your-city-council/population-in-sheffield.html
Sheffield Knife Crime Strategy 27 Place Key locations Peak offending appears in the town centres of each district. In Sheffield this related to: Town Centre, Gleadless Valley, Spital Hill, Grimesthorpe and Southey Green. Eastwood / Clifton: 9 x Stainforth: offences - 9 x offences - 5 x Possession, 6 x VAP, 3 x VAP and 2 x Possession and Barnsley Town Centre: 1 x Public Order. 1 x Public Order. 13 x offences - 4 x VAP, 4 x Possessions, 3 x Public Order, 1 x Robbery and 1 x Sexual Offences. Burngreave: 11 x offences - 7 x VAP, 2 x Possession, 1 x Robbery and 1 x Public Order. Sheffield Town Centre: HMP Lindholme: 25 x offences – 7 x offences - 11 x VAP, 7 x Possession, 4 x VAP and 4 x Robbery, 3 x Misc. Crimes 2 x Public Order and (Possessions). 1 x Sexual Offences. Highfields: Doncaster Town Centre: 17 x offences – 20 offences - 8 x Robbery, 7 x VAP, 6 x Possession, 4 x VAP, 3 x Public Order, 3 x Public Order and 2 x Robbery,1 x Agg.Burg 2 x Possession. and 1 x Misc.(Possession).
28 Sheffield Knife Crime Strategy Place Serious violent crime in key locations Approximately 17% of total knife crime in the 12-month review period was serious violence 22, accounting for 22% of knife-related VAP offences. Longer term, serious violence has increased in volume whilst the proportion of total knife crime for which it accounts has reduced. Whilst APPROXIMATELY 17% this suggests increases in other crime types, the harm associated with this type OF TOTAL KNIFE CRIME of offending means it is a key risk for the Force. The increased volumes are IN THE 12-MONTH particularly concerning as it is unlikely REVIEW PERIOD WAS external factors, such as crime recording, are influencing the figures. SERIOUS VIOLENCE VOLUME AND PROPORTION OF SERIOUS VIOLENCE 01/01/2013 to 30/09/2017 120 25% 100 20% 80 15% 60 10% 40 20 5% 0 0% Q4 12/13 Q1 13/14 Q2 13/14 Q3 13/14 Q4 13/14 Q1 14/15 Q2 14/15 Q3 14/15 Q4 14/15 Q1 15/16 Q2 15/16 Q3 15/16 Q4 15/16 Q1 16/17 Q2 16/17 Q3 16/17 Q4 16/17 Q1 17/18 Q2 17/18 Serious % Serious 22 Including domestic and non-domestic offences and defined as GBH with or without intent, attempted murder and murder.
Sheffield Knife Crime Strategy 29 Non-Domestic Serious Violence • Sheffield Town Centre Twenty one offences, including a racial The most common offence within attack with four victims and NTE23 linked appears to be GBH with intent (section assaults. Approximately 1/3 of the 18 offences), accounting for 76% offences involved victims who would not of serious violence. Dip sampling of co-operate with police or declined to this crime type identified that often make a complaint. Some offences were victims of knife crime are involved in recorded at NGH24, where the victim other criminality, ranging from thefts to presented with injuries, as it was not OCG related criminality and domestic clear where the offence itself took place. violence. Another key driver of knife related GBH was involvement in the This is again linked to victims unwilling illegal drug trade, as either dependent to co-operate, which is a concern and or dealer. To tackle this, interventions at indicates lack of confidence in the police, lower levels of offending are crucial to together with the potential concealment avoid escalation. of further criminal activity (e.g. attacked as a result of a drug taxing). A&E data can be used to provide a richer picture Sheffield accounts for approximately 47% of those presenting with knife-related of non-domestic serious violence, however injuries in order to identify those who this is likely due to the demographics of may not report to the police. NGH data is the city, rather than other more notable currently shared and is covered in more factors. In the last 12 months, 10 hotspots detail in the Partnerships section of this for non-domestic serious violence were report. However, data from all six A&E noted across the Force and offences departments in the Force area is required within these areas reviewed. to fully understand offence volumes. • Sheffield Firth Park Fourteen offences involving solely male victims and offenders. One repeat suspect appears to have been responsible for four of these offences, including a murder 25, and is now in custody. Despite this, offences have continued, with 12 recorded in the quarter January to March 2018. Offences have, however, dispersed slightly rather than being centred around Spital Hill. 23 Northern General Hospital 23 Night time economy 25 K/120740/2017 refers.
30 Sheffield Knife Crime Strategy Place Premise types elements to suggest they may have been Premise types were considered to attempted drug taxings. Other offences see if specific trends were noted, with involved nominals threatening people in dwellings, schools and parks identified their home and asking for money to be as locations of note due to proportion paid. There may also be a link to drugs of offending. within these offences, e.g. drug debts owed. Dwellings Disputes between neighbours and Twenty one per cent of non-domestic flatmates or housemates were also offending in the 12-month review period common, with threats and assaults all took place within the home. The majority noted within the sample. It was also of offences were recorded as knives / noted that some offences were incorrectly kitchen knives with a usage of either recorded as dwellings (5% of the sample) threats or stabbing / slashing. whilst a further 12% were domestic offences that should have been flagged as Offences were generally VAP offences such. (56%), of which 16% was serious violence. Personal robberies were also common within the home (25%). Proportionally, the amount of serious violence within the 21% OF NON-DOMESTIC home is comparable to overall volumes of serious violence, with 22% of serious OFFENDING IN violence in the home and 21% of all THE 12-MONTH REVIEW offences taking place in the home. PERIOD TOOK PLACE A random dip sample of 10% of offences noted that knife crimes within dwellings WITHIN THE HOME. were varied in nature; however, some themes were identified. Robberies and aggravated burglaries are inevitably key offence types within dwellings; however, the proportion of those with a drug-related element is of concern. Approximately a third of robberies / burglaries have
Sheffield Knife Crime Strategy 31 Schools Parks Five per cent of offending in the 12-month Approximately 3% of offences took place review period took place in 69 named in parks, with the majority recorded as schools across the Force area. 25 of those knives / kitchen knives with a usage of schools saw multiple offences. either threats or stabbing / slashing. Offences took place in 38 named parks, The majority of offences were recorded as with six of those seeing multiple offences. knives / kitchen knives, which may suggest they were taken from home, with a usage A random dip sample of 10% of offences of either carried and not used or threats. noted offences often involve more than one offender, with group-style offending A random dip sample of 10% of offences such as robberies / fights, etc. observed. noted pupils as young as eight years Anecdotally parks are likely to have less old were using knives to make threats in CCTV due to the nature of the locations, schools. Other offences within the dip therefore possibly making them more sample included a 12-year-old male in attractive for offenders. Volumes remain possession of a multi-tool and an autistic low in these areas and crime prevention male who brought a knife in from home advice in terms of remaining in well-lit following a dispute with another pupil. areas and not walking alone at night Incidents were reported by fellow pupils, should reduce this even further. parents and school staff, which is a positive indication that monitoring is in place to identify those in possession of dangerous weapons within schools. It would be useful to consider offences in schools over a longer-term period to explore this data set in more detail and answer questions such as: • Is the use of knives in schools becoming more common / more severe? • If so, has the supply of knives in schools reduced, for example through increased Health and Safety, whilst the number of offences has increased? • Has the age of offenders changed / remained static?
32 Sheffield Knife Crime Strategy Partnerships under the age of 28. This suggests victims Knife-related assaults 24 account for who sustain injuries through knife crime approximately 13% of assaults reported are more likely to be younger than those to the Northern General Hospital (NGH) victims of, for example, threats. It should A&E department in the period January be noted, however, the NGH data is likely 2017 to March 2018 25. It is estimated to only represent a small portion of victims, 54% of victims presenting to NGH as NGH is one of six A&E departments in were also known to SYP 26, therefore the Force area. highlighting an intelligence gap of approximately 46%, or 95 victims. The NGH data shows knife related injuries have remained relatively stable, as illustrated opposite: This is in contrast to the trend identified through SYP data, which shows a steady increase. It is suggested the ‘real’ increase is likely to be somewhere in between the trends being reported by the two services. Although the NGH data represents the victims, dip sampling of GBH offences identified 72% of victims were engaged in other criminality. Therefore, victims of knife crime can also be reached through interventions at early stages of criminality under the public health model. In terms of victim profile, the NGH data correlates with that of SYP, with White – North European males presenting most commonly. It is noted, however, younger victims presented to NGH, with 57% 24 Those with a weapon of either bottle, glass, knife or other bladed or sharp object recorded. 25 This is the period of data available at the time of writing this report. 26 This is based on a review of those DOBs known to SYP and NGH. It is not certain that these will relate to the same person/victim however was the best method available in view of the data. 10 records were sampled 8 were found to correlate in terms of date and DOB and therefore are likely to be the same person.
Sheffield Knife Crime Strategy 33 A range of postcodes was recorded by identified within SYP data. This may those attending NGH with knife wounds, suggest some victims are not reporting with 10% of victims being from outside the bottle-based offences to police. Force area. The most common postcodes recorded were S2, S5 and S6, accounting The vast majority of bottle-based attacks for 30% of all victims. These postcodes were reported to NGH overnight, with correlate with the key areas identified 87% of injuries presented between 7pm within the SYP data, with volumes and 7am and 63% presenting over the remaining relatively stable in each of these weekend. This suggests bottle-based areas over the last 12 months. These attacks are linked to the night-time communities would particularly benefit economy. To tackle this type of offending, from interventions to reduce victimisation. licenced premises could reduce the amount of glass available by providing In the 12-month period 01/04/2017 plastic cups rather than glasses. to 31/03/2018, the majority of victims presenting at NGH arrived by ambulance Moving forward, data from all of the (58%), with a further 24% arriving in A&E departments in South Yorkshire is private transport, such as their own required to fully understand the impact vehicle. The main weapon noted was of knife crime in the Force area, as well a knife; however, bottles were used as as the demand that this places upon our weapons in 22% of injuries, which is partners. notably higher than the 2% proportion KNIFE RELATED INJURIES REPORTED TO NGH 01/01/2017 to 31/03/2018 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 Jan-17 Feb-17 Mar-17 Apr-17 May-17 Jun-17 Jul-17 Aug-17 Sep-17 Oct-17 Nov-17 Dec-17 Jan-18 Feb-18 Mar-18
34 Sheffield Knife Crime Strategy Delivery Challenges Governance Convening partnership is central to The challenges in delivering this the delivery of this strategy – no one strategy cannot be overstated. Knife organisation has the ability to solve the crime will not reduce without all problem of knife crime alone. In tackling partners and communities in Sheffield knife crime, we are using this power to pulling together to make changes and bring together all of our partners. We improvements. convene partners at Operation Fortify Violent Crime and Organised Criminality Arresting, sentencing, and even Reduction Board to drive joint working rehabilitating offenders will not stop knives with the most senior officers across all being accessible on the streets and nor our agencies. This group will meet once a will it stop young people making the quarter, co-chaired by District Commander choice to carry a knife for the first time. South Yorkshire Police and Sheffield City For long-term change, we need parents Council Chief Executive. This group will and families, schools and youth groups, hold specific plan owners to account for and communities to come together to delivery against this strategy. discourage and prevent knife carrying, as well as the media, businesses and other A monthly operational board will support influencers to do their part to make spaces this strategic level group, jointly chaired where young people spend their time – by police and local authority colleagues, online, at school, town centres, outdoors tasked with shaping and driving and at home – safe. operational delivery against set priorities articulated in this strategy. This strategy has been developed in close co-operation with SYP’s partner At a tactical level, a multi-agency co- agencies and communities. We have had located team will be established to drive a particular focus on ensuring the Strategy the daily decisions and information sharing continues to be shared and informed by required, ensuring this strategy makes the ‘youth voice’, and as such we will host a real and meaningful difference to the specific events to target young people, communities we jointly serve. including a youth roundtable event, workshops with young offenders in prison, and those on community orders under the supervision of youth offending teams.
Sheffield Knife Crime Strategy 35 Our vision Our aims TO MAKE SHEFFIELD • To ensure a comprehensive understanding of knife – enabled A HOSTILE crime in including who is involved and ENVIRONMENT where it is taking place. • To gather intelligence about knife- FOR THOSE WHO enabled crime from all relevant SEEK TO COMMIT stakeholders, including the community • To take a partnership approach to KNIFE-ENABLED disrupting knife-enabled crime and CRIME AND/OR BENEFIT bring offenders to justice. • To protect vulnerable people from FROM ALL FORMS knife-enabled crime. OF ORGANISED • To engage all our communities in CRIMINALITY. playing a more active role in tackling knife-enabled crime. • To raise awareness of knife-enabled crime with the public and all relevant professionals. • To work with all relevant stakeholders including the private sector, to tackle all forms of knife-enabled crime. • To support the development of appropriate rehabilitative interventions for those involved in knife-enabled crime.
36 Sheffield Knife Crime Strategy Our objectives The Home Office and National Crime Agency endorse the ‘Four P’ approach to THE HOME OFFICE AND tackling knife-enabled crime and organised criminality. Prepare, Prevent, NATIONAL CRIME AGENCY Pursue and Protect. ENDORSE THE ‘FOUR P A fifth ‘P’ partnership is embedded across APPROACH’ TO TACKLING everything we do in Operation Fortify and our objectives are as follows: KNIFE-ENABLED CRIME AND ORGANISED CRIMINALITY.
Sheffield Knife Crime Strategy 37 Our objectives Tackling Crime Protecting the Enabling Fair Prepare Vulnerable Treatment and ASB Consult with community through IAG, Social Media, Corporate X Comms, Stakeholder Map. Seek political engagement and support through local X X Councillors/MPs. Schools, Colleges, encourage collaboration, staggered finish Engage X X times etc. Youth Parliament, Youth IAG, well-known youth activists, role X models and other peers. Get young people’s voice. Businesses, especially big/youth brands, voluntary/third sector, X clubs and societies Reducing the impact of knife-related criminality where it takes place Knife crime discussed at strategic partnership level. X X Knife crime/violence as a feature of the Service Strategic X X Assessment. Up to date Problem Profile produced and periodically refreshed. X X Assess Intelligence picture, emerging issues identified and discussed X X X at TTCG. Overlay and assess Local Authority/Partner data i.e. schools, NHS. X X Consider academic/market research to help identify/assess the X X X causes. Consider impact of Local, National and International events. Youth events, festivals, fairs, high-risk events in pubs/nightclubs, funerals/ X anniversaries of murders. Ongoing operations at schools and transport hubs at times of X X greater tension (joint patrols at end of term etc.) Plan Explore possible funding streams/finance. Council, PCC joint X X X partnership initiatives. Ensure availability and access to assets (knife arches, wands, X grab bags). Future-proof all ideas and actions, benchmark against national best X X X practice, partnership and schools and PVP. Use intelligence and information from other forces (no borders). X X X Publicise/share assessments, profiles and plans where appropriate. X X X Stop & Search data (Stop & Search monitoring group). Encourage Share X intelligent debate. Promote two-way flow of information/intelligence with partners, X X ensuring agreements in place with NHS, GPs re KIV’s. Be pro-active not re-active regarding sharing of information. X X
38 Sheffield Knife Crime Strategy Our objectives Tackling Crime Protecting the Enabling Fair Prevent Vulnerable Treatment and ASB Use of Judicial Restrictions, CBOs, ASBOs, Violent Offender and X X other orders/injunctions to restrict movement and association. Home visits to known identified offenders, prison releases etc. X Control Disrupt Licensing objections/restrictions on problem NTE venues. X Target harden stores to prevent shoplifting of knives (e.g. placement X within the store). Appropriate use and enforcement of S.35 Dispersal Orders. X X Periodic knife arch operations at schools, colleges, transport hubs and other key locations. Combine activity across boroughs/MPS X (day of action). Intelligence lead Stop & Search, use DSU/forensics intelligence. X Authorisation of S.60 powers where justified (consider if X X Preventing people from engaging in knife crime responsibility can be devolved Supt/Ch Supt). Search on entry conditions (wands/knife arches) at NTE and other Disrupt Divert X key venues. Weapon sweeps on estates, HKC addresses, schools, Courts, within X footprint of NTE venues. Identification and removal of weapon hiding places/abandoned X vehicles etc. Local Authority resources – Wardens, Environmental Health, Trading X X Standards, CCTV Control Room. Police resources, School Officers, Transport Hubs, Source Unit (Intel). X Divert Task Default/Hot spot patrol – intelligence lead, high harm areas. X Use Community Assets, Faith patrols, Neighbourhood Watch, X X X volunteers etc. on operations, supporting police, engaging public. Greater focus on conflict resolution/mediation. X Holistic approach to offending, identify potential causes, abuse, drugs, alcohol and use targeted intervention. X X X (Troubled families etc.). Multi-agency referral pathway for people at risk or involved in knife X crime for early intervention. Use Stop & Search as an opportunity to intervene and refer those Task at potential risk. Change mind-set of positive outcome (Offenders X and victims). Promotion of extended services/activities at schools, especially those that may address the cause i.e. self-defence, boxing, X X X coping skills. Use of voluntary organisation for interventions and diversion activity X X X at key locations such as hospitals, prisons, custody.
Sheffield Knife Crime Strategy 39 Our objectives Tackling Crime Protecting the Enabling Fair Protect Vulnerable Treatment and ASB Refresher training for staff re knife crime, tactics, intelligence. X Additional training for officers specifically employed engaging X X X youths/offenders. Presentations delivered through schools, use GKTL FEARLESS for Educate impact/gravity/independence. Educate parents re behavioural changes/actions, use parental X influence, encourage surrender. Up to date briefings for staff regarding subjects, intelligence and X locations. Reinforce legislation/responsible retailer messages to businesses. X X X Internal communications focusing on knife crime, recoveries, good X news. Increase use of social media, fill the space. Promote activity using X #stopknifecrime, make it unacceptable/uncool. Increasing protection against knife crime Communicate Publicise ‘two strikes’ legislation for possession of knives. X Engage Local/National media on a strategic and operational level. More specific, targeting specific communicates where necessary. X Less broad brush. Create community ‘outrage’ promote social change to make knife carrying socially unacceptable. Use the communities to deliver the X X X message/s. Publicise locations and surrenders at knife bins. X Ensure appropriate response to KEV/Weapon related calls. X X Improve response to school related incidents/requests for support, X X weapon finds. Respond Ongoing and emerging THR managed via THRIVE. X Implement focus in DMM meetings to grip initial incidents. X Seek/utilise additional support and resources, OSU, SCS. X Establish local Serious Incident Response Protocol and review X mechanism. Repeat victims, target hardening, special schemes etc. X Focus on looked after children, better awareness/mapping of X children in care homes. Safeguard Ensure all staff have access, carry and wear appropriate equipment X when required. Ensure processes in place to monitor highest risk victims. X Development of Integrated Risk Management (IRM) or other multi- X X agency risk management hubs.
You can also read