Services for Tall Buildings Cost Model - For Building Magazine February 2018 - Alinea Consulting
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
Services for Tall Buildings Cost Model | For Building Magazine Cost Model Services for Tall Buildings Mechanical, electrical and plumbing systems are a particular challenge for tall buildings, with their own considerations and commercial drivers. We outlined the factors and costs for office buildings in an article for Building Magazine published on 23.02.2018. 01 / The world is getting taller Tall buildings are being delivered more than a million people on the – from perspectives of cost, value, in greater numbers, at greater planet urbanise each week.” operation and environment – all heights, and in more locations against the inherent challenges around the world: more than 70 London is not a premier league such buildings present. This article of 200the world’s tallest 100 buildings player in terms of numbers, but its outlines the key considerations and were completed in the last decade. skyline has changed dramatically commercial drivers in the design of 180 This premier league of towers has over the past 15 years, and its array mechanical, electrical and plumbing an average height of around 370m of high-quality tall architectural (MEP) services for tall buildings, 160 (the corresponding figure in 2000 forms and engineering solutions and provides a cost model for these was 285m). Last year, towers of least are admired around the globe. elements for a high-rise London 140 200m high were built in 65 cities The experience gained by the office building. across 120 23 countries, with 13 cities various professionals involved has seeing their first 200m-plus building. enabled them to export their talents As 100Antony Wood, executive director internationally. This includes London- of the Council on Tall Buildings and based M&E engineers, who can Urban 80 Habitat (CTBUH), puts it: “Tall demonstrate their skills in making buildings are becoming the accepted a landmark tower’s services as global 60 model for densification as effective and efficient as possible 40 20 Figure 1: Global completions of tall buildings 0 1960 1961 1962 1963 1964 1965 1966 1967 1968 1969 1970 1971 1972 1973 1974 1975 1976 1977 1978 1979 1980 1981 1982 1983 1984 1985 1986 1987 1988 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 200 # of 200m-plus completions # of 300m-plus completions # of 600m-plus completions 180 160 140 120 100 80 60 40 20 0 1960 1961 1962 1963 1964 1965 1966 1967 1968 1969 1970 1971 1972 1973 1974 1975 1976 1977 1978 1979 1980 1981 1982 1983 1984 1985 1986 1987 1988 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 # of 200m-plus completions # of 300m-plus completions # of 600m-plus completions 2
Services for Tall Buildings Cost Model | For Building Magazine Cost Model Services for Tall Buildings 02 / Early strategic decisions will determine efficacy Towers contend with a difficult of a tall office building. With plant the arrangement of services up and balance between risk and and risers accounting for up to 10% around the core. These decisions reward, and the margins between of total gross internal floor area, the should factor in not only capital commercial success and failure can stakes are high. costs and their various drivers (such be small. Success relies on achieving as buildability), but also operational the optimal balance between The design of MEP services will costs, ease of maintenance, cost, floor area and construction require some key strategic decisions spacetake and carbon impacts. efficiencies, which must be to be made early on, with careful considered in the initial development consideration and analysis of all With a limited pool of trade of massing and geometry. This relevant factors. Not least of these contractors having the capabilities applies to mechanical, electrical is the environmental strategy and and capacity to undertake larger and and plumbing (MEP) services just how it can support the orientation more complex towers, procurement as much as it does to any other of the building, the centralisation requires careful thought too, with element. MEP services generally or decentralisation of services, the early engagement advisable. constitute 20% to 25% of the total location of mechanical plant, the elemental (trade) shell and core cost distribution of incoming power, and 03A / Key decisions - plant location, hydraulics and air distribution Plant location the tall building where space is heat exchangers and pump tightest. Ideally, plant such as cooling sets to distribute further distances The predominant MEP considerations towers, boilers and generators would to higher floors. If more than 20 for tall buildings are the selection be roof-mounted, but most tall floors are served without the use of of main plant locations and how buildings have little or no such roof hydraulic breaks, higher-pressure- services are distributed up and down space to locate these key pieces of rated pipework and associated the building. plant, at heights that offer premium valves will be required – which could office rents and opportunities for result in the introduction of on-floor Tall buildings typically have multiple other valuable functions such as hydraulic breaks between the shell basements, which tend to suit the restaurants and viewing platforms. and core and fit-out installations. accommodation of the electrical high-voltage (HV) incoming Part of the answer often lies in The same issues apply with plumbing switchgear, water-cooled chillers, interstitial plant floors, which could services. Drainage in tall buildings cold-water tanks and sprinkler mean that a 60-storey building, in has to be dealt with in a particular tanks. This invariably requires the terms of MEP services provision, is way, with several high and low-rise fitting together of puzzle pieces to the equivalent of three buildings stacks rising next to each other achieve the most efficient fit with stacked on top of one another. serving different sections of the the smallest possible gaps. The building. There could be two to competition against other demands Hydraulic breaks three times the amount of pipework for these below-ground spaces has compared with a building of the become more intense in recent years Generally, the maximum vertical same total area but less height. with the proliferation of bicycles. The distribution distance for water Water services can serve a maximum London Plan, and its calculations systems tends be around 20 floors, of 150m because of the limitations based on the total gross internal area before a hydraulic break is required of WTAS approved fittings and the of a building, defies tall commercial on low temperature hot water practicalities of pressure on larger buildings to fit in vast numbers of (LTHW), chilled water (CHW) and towers: pressure breaks will therefore cycle spaces, lockers and showers. condenser water systems. The be required. requirement of hydraulic breaks However, it is at the other end of introduces an additional expense of This justifies a classic cost-benefit 3
Services for Tall Buildings Cost Model | For Building Magazine Cost Model Services for Tall Buildings analysis, with the capital cost and fresh air to the office floorplates. on the building management space-take implications of the Each of these strategies carries some system alternatives to be worked through important issues: • Involve connections through and compared, so that a decision can the facades for air intake and be made and schematics developed. Centralised AHUs: exhaust • Have larger ductwork risers • Need access to their on-floor Air distribution for the movement of greater plant rooms, and maintenance air volumes up and down the access may need to be allowed There are several ways of distributing building through tenants’ floor spaces air around a tall building, with no • Rely on a few larger pieces • Should make commissioning a obvious, preconceived answer for of kit to serve more floors, simpler process. any project (which is why both the raising questions of resilience current and proposed batches of (particularly in a multitenanted There are advantages and London’s tall buildings have adopted environment) disadvantages with either of these a variety of solutions). • Make it more difficult to install two options, but perhaps the large AHUs, with thought greatest factor in the decision is the That said, there are two principal required on issues of logistics effect on net internal floor area. The options: and buildability – especially options will usually involve more than for the plant at the top of the two strategies, as the extremes of a • Centralised air handling units building. completely centralised versus a floor- (AHUs) – possibly with interstitial by-floor solution are supplemented plant floors On-floor AHUs: by the option to provide intermittent • On-floor AHUs • Require the increased capital plant floors with their individual cost of additional CHW/LTHW AHUs. Figure 2 shows how these can be connections, power supplies, and respectively configured to supply additional points and interfaces Figure 2: Air distribution options CENTRAL AIR PLANT FLOOR BY FLOOR AIR HANDLING 4
Services for Tall Buildings Cost Model | For Building Magazine Cost Model Services for Tall Buildings 03B / Other key decisions Incoming electrical load building is more cost-effective but is at HV, in fire-protected routes, to deemed less resilient. There may also substations at a higher level in the Tall buildings demand a high overall be capacity issues with UKPN, but if building. The LV distribution thus electrical load. Given the additional these can be resolved at affordable becomes a combination of supplies requirements for resilience, the levels then this is a valid option. taken from these substations incoming power is often fed directly and distributed both up from the to the building from one of the The location of the UKPN basement and down from the higher main 132kV substations at 33kV, transformers requires careful substations. sometimes by dual supplies for consideration as the supplier insists resilience. on 24/7 access to their transformers; There is often the need for expensive recently we have seen UKPN pushing power distribution controls Utilising a high-voltage (HV) 33KV for these transformer rooms to be (“supervisory control and data incoming power supply not only adds located at ground floor level. acquisition”, referred to as “SCADA”) considerable capital cost but also to regulate and manage the start-up requires a large area to be set aside Electrical distribution of the generators and the complex for a UKPN 33kV transformer, which distribution of electrical loads. in turn steps down the supply to 11KV In most low-rise buildings the HV/LV before the power can be distributed plant is placed in the basement and Multi-tenant provisions around the building to the various power is distributed by low-voltage distributed substations. (LV) busbar up the building. In a tall Tall buildings normally have to be building it is normally commercially designed for a number of possible Introducing power at 11KV into the better to distribute up the building tenancies, large and small. MEP Figure 3: Electrical distribution of a dual 33kV incoming supply Figure 4: Amenity spaces and plant locations at 22 Bishopsgate ELECTRICAL DISTRIBUTION 5
Services for Tall Buildings Cost Model | For Building Magazine Cost Model Services for Tall Buildings systems therefore need to be top of the building, with oil storage the trend for individuals to be able designed with multiple service located in the basement, resulting in assess the quality of their working distribution risers to serve these distribution pipework and pumps to environment, a subject covered in a tenancies, requiring supply the generator sets, together Building article on the WELL Building multiple: with significant acoustic treatment Standard published in May 2017. and fire protection. • Soil and vent stacks for To facilitate smart buildings, kitchenettes Amenities more communication systems are • Cold water services for having to be brought into the base kitchenettes Increasingly, the developers specification. These include: • Chilled water risers of commercial towers look to • Low-temperature hot water risers incorporate amenity spaces, terraces, • Landlords’ fibre backbone • Supply ductwork risers viewing galleries, restaurants, • Wifi within landlord areas • Extract ductwork risers and other functions throughout • Wifi within lifts • Electrical busbar distribution the building, to differentiate their • Mobile boosting technology • IT containment risers. product and invest in features that • Meeting room booking systems have a direct influence on occupiers’ • Audiovisual display screens in All these distribution systems have health, happiness and productivity. landlord areas, not only a capital cost associated lifts, and so on. with them, but they also demand Each of these areas needs servicing extra space, eating into net internal with specialist air-conditioning Another provision found in tall floor areas, which must be balanced plant, ventilation, separate power buildings is the inclusion of a with the perceived value (lettability) requirements, drainage, specialist comprehensive blind control that they offer. waste disposal, gas, water and toilet system linked to the cladding provisions, and dedicated areas such system (particularly where “active” Enhanced specifications and as cool rooms and catering facilities facades are promoted). These can tenant provisions. – all needing to be incorporated into be controlled individually or set the design as efficiently by elevation as part of the BMS It is difficult to find space for as possible. Even if these areas installation. potential tenants’ plant and it are provided as shell-only with the is equally logistically difficult to incoming tenant responsible for the add plant at a later date. These fit-out, the developer has to allow for challenges, together with the multi- all the shell and core provisions to be tenancy letting profile of most tall incorporated into the overall services buildings, mean that they may be design, not least the infrastructure provided with a higher specification provisions for servicing these of MEP plant, including: spaces (including discrete access and egress). The logistics of these • fresh air provision fit-outs, and any potential overlap • electrical load with the base build programme, are a • cooling provision further factor to contemplate. • full building standby electrical back-up. Communications These specification and tenant Tall buildings have the opportunity enhancements not only have a to invest in smart infrastructure. We capital cost implication but they are starting to see links to security also pose some space planning access, lift calling, navigation around challenges within the building. An the building, control of the air- example of one of the challenges conditioning and lighting, all from associated with such enhancements a personal mobile device to give is the provision of full building people a seamless experience and electrical back-up. Generators personal control. This is part of would typically be installed at the 6
Services for Tall Buildings Cost Model | For Building Magazine Cost Model Services for Tall Buildings Residential Towers The fundamental commercial measures that underpin • Envelopes for residential towers typically focus a tall office building – cost, time and floor area on amenity spaces (such as balcony options) and efficiencies – are of equal importance in residential daylighting. This contrasts with the approach of tower developments. They may have their respective office towers, which are more likely to focus on areas of focus and their own cost and value profiles, making an architectural statement that also works but both can reference the key ratios of wall/floor and as part of the environmental strategy (in particular net/gross as clear indicators of viability (even if they addressing solar gain). perform differently in these terms, not least due to the more slender form of residential high rises as they seek • Localised ventilation through the facade is typical to optimise apartment sizes and daylighting). In MEP for residential towers, as opposed to the more terms, residential towers tend to demand a greater co- centralised form of ventilation typically used for ordination between the base build and fit-out designs. offices. Allied to this is the co-ordination of vertical services with unit mixes and the configuration of apartments • A low-voltage power network is used in residential around the core. Stacking is critical to achieving cost towers, compared with the combination of high and and construction efficiencies. Other notable differences low voltage used in office buildings. between the two typologies include: 04 / Preliminaries and site construction issues The extended construction the building, and from the workface their supplies of materials and plant programmes of tall buildings to welfare facilities. Some of this non- are managed correctly. Pressures on trigger higher preliminaries costs productive time has been reduced in programme may also compel some for the main contractor and trade recent times with the introduction of deliveries to be made out of hours, contractors – not least MEP trade jump lifts: they climb with the core which again attracts additional costs specialists, who also contend structure as it progresses, assisting not typically seen on other projects. with the involved co-ordination of the transportation of both labour their respective works with other and materials. Jump lifts do come The use of prefabrication is another contractors. Further, extended with a cost premium of £250,000- way in which site constraints can warranties are typically required £300,000 per jump lift, depending be mitigated and the programme as plant is usually brought to site on the solution and number of levels protected, by reducing site relatively early in the programme served, but this cost can be offset installation times, in turn easing in order to be incorporated into the by programme reductions. Main the number of operative hours on basement construction. This means contractors have also realised the site. Careful planning by the main that the plant requires maintenance importance of providing canteens contractor is needed with MEP up to practical completion and full and toilets at regular intervals prefabrication to ensure there warranty periods after it. At the throughout a tower, reducing is adequate hook time to drop other end of the programme, roof downtime inefficiencies. prefabricated risers and plant into mounted plant and equipment will position. It has been known for not be available until near the end of Higher plot ratios (more building prefabricated modules to lose out construction, causing additional costs area placed on a site) may ultimately in the competition for hook time to associated with water treatment and create value for backers, but they items that are on the critical path. additional commissioning. also imply restrictions on areas This would obviously erode the time for storage and staging. This has advantages, as a cost premium has Tall buildings also attract additional encouraged a “just in time” approach already been paid for breaking down cost premiums due to site constraints to deliveries, supported by the use the plant into modules and using and the simple fact of their height, of consolidation centres off-site. This multiple deliveries, plant handling, causing significant non-productive does require trades to have adequate installation and retesting on site. time in getting labour up and down resources in place to ensure that 7
Services for Tall Buildings Cost Model | For Building Magazine Cost Model Services for Tall Buildings Vertical Transportation This cost model focuses on MEP services: a separate article could be dedicated to vertical transportation in tall buildings. Lifts and escalators are a major part of the design and a key influence on net:gross floor area efficiencies as well as operational efficiencies. Together with MEP they can constitute up to a third of the total net trade costs in a tall building construction project. Getting the right solution from a number of strategic options (single or double decks, twin lifts, express lifts) and sub-options (number, speed and arrangement of lifts; destination control) is vital in optimising cost and space-take, interfacing with architecture, structure and services to achieve a tight core and workable main entrances. As occupancy rates and tenancy expectations have increased in recent years, this has put more pressure on lift systems to meet the current BCO waiting times. The advent of additional amenity provisions and specialist areas in towers often requires separate express passenger and goods lifts, which also need to be considered in the core design and often need their own lobby areas separate from the main passenger 22 Bishopsgate uses insterstital plant rooms lifts, with distinct servicing. 05 /Summary of the key cost drivers MEP services in tall buildings play • Hydraulic separation between provision and associated facilities a critical part in the commercial risers and plant or landlord and additional basement performance of the scheme. Making and tenant areas, and hydraulic plant often results in multiple the correct early decisions on some separation versus higher ratings basements and extensive crucial strategic options, and paying of pipework and valves. servicing and smoke extract close attention to the development systems of these design routes, will go a long • Increased plant provision due way towards mitigating the inherent to a lack of available space for • Construction issues produce challenges of high-rise schemes, tenants’ plant, which prompts higher contractors’ preliminaries ensuring best fit between capital an enhanced specifi cation of air costs due to extended costs, area efficiencies, construction provision, electrical loading and programmes and initiatives to programme and operational cooling provision, and very often reduce them: the use of jump lifts effectiveness. Tall building MEP key 100% standby generation (and and extensive welfare facilities, cost drivers can be distilled into: power management controls prefabrication techniques, to manage the complex power just-in-time deliveries using • Plant location – centralised distribution systems) consolidation centres, extended versus on-floor plant versus warranties and maintenance and interstitial plant rooms; efficient • More landlord areas to the larger commissioning. design of extensive plant in cores and split lift scenarios, the basement and on the roof, staircases, entrance areas and lift • Smart building technologies aiming to alleviate the increased lobbies, which all need servicing such as blown fibre, wifi, phone distribution of ductwork, boosting systems, blind control pipework and electrical systems • Greater proportion of bike systems and specialist waste 8
Services for Tall Buildings Cost Model | For Building Magazine Cost Model Services for Tall Buildings disposal systems are often incorporated into the 07 /About the cost model base specification to reflect a building of the highest quality and comfort for its occupants. This cost model is based on a generic 50-storey office tower (plus two basement levels) in central London, using current day fluctuating prices. It assumes a total gross internal floor area of 90,000m2 with a net 06 /Regulation changes internal floor areas of 60,000m2, and is designed for an occupancy of one person per 8m2 NIA. The building has The gestation period of tall buildings leaves them open 11kV incoming power, on-floor air handling units, 100% to changes in legislation, regulation and guidance. standby generator provision, water-cooled chillers in the Furthermore, the impacts of such developments may basement and roof-mounted boiler plant and cooling be substantial: given the size of the endeavour, large towers. quantities and the fact that components can be repeated thousands of times through the building mean that scale It is a base building cost that excludes any enabling can act as either an economy or a diseconomy. works and services infrastructure/diversions, fitting out beyond shell and core construction and tender price A recent example affecting MEP services, which has a inflation beyond first quarter 2018. substantial cost impact on commercial tall buildings – because of the volume of basement space usually involved – is the change to the regulations for smoke Acknowledgments extract ductwork (BSEN1366). This regulation has meant This article and cost model were prepared by that the capital cost of fire-rated ductwork (per metre Nick Mulholland, Rob Butler, Sophie Rogers and run) has increased by about 50%, together with the Kostas Dellas of alinea’s MEP team, together with additional scope requirements across both supply and Steve Watts, alinea partner and CTBUH chair. extract ductwork, including higher levels of insulation. 9
Services for Tall Buildings Cost Model | For Building Magazine Cost Model Services for Tall Buildings 08 /Generic MEP cost plan for a 50-storey office tower Total (£) £/m2 % Total (£) £/m2 % Sanitaryware installation Flues from boilers to atmosphere: 120m 72,000 included in toilet fit-out @£600/m package Space heating and air 11,955,000 132.83 23.7 Disposal installations 1,260,000 14.00 2.5 treatment Water cooled chillers: Rainwater installation 1,520,000 9,500kw @ £160/Kw including attenuation tank: 450,000 90,000m2 @ £5/m2 Closed circuit cooling towers: 10,900kw @ £110/ 1,200,000 Soil waste and vent to kw sanitary appliances (final 576,000 run-outs in toilet fit-out Condenser water package): 1,600nr @ £360 installation: 90,000m2 @ 810,000 £9/m2 Capped-off soil and vent stacks for tenants’ Chilled water including 99,000 kitchenettes and retail pumps, pressurisation units units, 2,610,000 pipework, risers, valves Allowance for condensate and fittings: drainage: 135,000 90,000m2 @ £29/m2 90,000m2 @ £1.5/m2 LTHW water including Water installations 1,635,000 18.17 3.2 pumps, pressurisation Allowance for incoming units, pipework, risers, 2,070,000 MCWS, storage tank, valves and fittings: booster, meter, water 325,000 90,000m2 @ £23/m2 conditioner and On-floor supply and distribution pipework 2,350,000 extraction AHUs Cold water service to Fresh air intake and sanitary appliances exhaust ductwork to 300,000 280,000 (risers only; run-outs in fit- on-floor AHUs out package) Supply and extract Central hot water ductwork for AHUs to generation and risers to 650,000 500,000 office floors, including fit-out area dampers Capped-off water supplies Air-conditioning to for future tenants’ 260,000 80,000 entrance area kitchenettes and retail areas Heating to stairs and 95,000 circulation areas Grey water installation to WCs (run-outs in fit-out 300,000 Supplementary DX cooling 75,000 package) systems Cooling to lift lobbies by Heat source 434,000 4.82 0.9 165,000 fan coil units Gas fired condensing Ventilation systems 2,610,000 29.00 5.2 boiler, primary pumps, pressurisation units, Central toilet air-extraction 212,000 560,000 dosing pot and primary system distribution pipework: 5,300kW @ £40/kW Toilet supply via makeup 130,000 from the office floors Heat pump, primary pumps, pressurisation Supply and extraction units and primary 150,000 AHU and distribution 135,000 distribution pipework: serving basement shower 600kW @ £250/kW area 10
Services for Tall Buildings Cost Model | For Building Magazine Cost Model Services for Tall Buildings Total (£) £/m2 % Total (£) £/m2 % Basement ventilation Gas installation 155,000 1.72 0.3 900,000 systems Gas installation to boilers Fire fighting lobby vent, and capped-off 155,000 mechanically assisted 600,000 services to retail unit BRE type system: 100 landings @ £6000 Protective installations 2,500,000 27.78 5.0 Capped-off ductwork for Wet riser installation: future tenants’ 60,000 420,000 permanent and temporary kitchenettes Sprinkler installations, A3 unit kitchen extract 225,000 complete with tanks, riser – fire rated pumps, 1,800,000 Electrical installation 14,645,000 162.72 29.0 risers and coverage to landlord areas: HV distribution: 11kV 90,000m2 @ £20/m2 incoming mains; Gas suppression in distribution through 1,350,000 communications rooms; building: 90,000m2 @ £15/ 100,000 protection to generator m2 room LV distribution, including Lightning protection: switchgear, cables, 180,000 4,050,000 90,000m2 @ £2/m2 rising busbars, etc: 90,000m2 @ £45/m2 Communications, security 6,570,000 73.00 13.0 and controls installations Full building back-up generation, including flues Fire detection and fire and oil storage: 4nr 4,240,000 alarm system: 1,080,000 generators @ 2,650kVA @ 90,000m2 @ £12/m2 £400/kVA Voice alarm system: 720,000 Power management 90,000m2 @ £8/m2 500,000 system (SCADA) Landlord’s data backbone Power to mechanical (landlord’s mobile 270,000 220,000 services: 90,000 @ £3/m2 boosting and wifi coverage excluded) Landord’s small power installations: 90,000 @ 180,000 Security/CCTV 350,000 £2/m2 installations Lighting to landlord areas, Turnstiles in reception: 250,000 circulation, lift lobbies, 10nr @ £25,000 each 2,200,000 shower areas, lighting Disabled alarm, refuge and control, etc 250,000 fire telephone installations Feature lighting to 450,000 Building management reception and energy management 3,700,000 Aircraft warning lights 80,000 system Allowance for feature General items 8,696,000 96.62 17.2 275,000 external lighting Allowance for testing and 836,000 Containment for security/ commissioning @ 2% CCTV/fire alarms/ 720,000 Subcontractor communications: 6,390,000 preliminaries @ 15% 90,000m2 @ £8/m2 Allowance for renewable Earthing and bonding: 1,470,000 180,000 technologies @ 3% 90,000m2 @ £2/m2 Allowance for power TOTAL 50,460,000 560.67 100.0 interfaces to PV 150,000 installations 11
Services for Tall Buildings Cost Model | For Building Magazine Cost Model Services for Tall Buildings Author contacts A culture of constant learning Applying learning from both live projects and research Steve Watts studies, and feeding them into each other, is how we Partner try to ensure that our clients and their teams get the best possible advice from us. This is why we have been steve.watts@alineaconsulting.com committed to research from the day we launched. Whilst data and information are the lifeblood of our business, we understand that they alone do not represent knowledge – which requires analysis, insight Rob Butlier and questioning. Partner For these reasons we involve everyone at alinea, and rob.butler@alineaconsulting.com we share our desire to innovate across borders: of discipline, geography and perspective. That way, we can learn from each other. Nick Mulholland Partner nick.mulholland@alineaconsulting.com Sophie Rogers Senior Project Surveyor sophie.rogers@alineaconsulting.com Kostas Dellas Assistant Surveyor kostas.dellas@alineaconsulting.com 12
alinea consulting LLP 90 Cannon Street London, EC4N 6HA alineacostconsulting.com
You can also read