Production of Hybrid Catfish

Page created by James Burns
 
CONTINUE READING
Production of Hybrid Catfish
Southern Regional                                                      SRAC Publication No. 190
                                                                                                                                      June 2012
                                                Aquaculture Center                                                                     Revision
                                    VI
                           PR

                                 Production of Hybrid Catfish
                                                                 Rex Dunham1 and Michael Masser2

     The mating or crossing of two different species is a                              ■■ tolerance of crowded growth conditions in ponds,
process called hybridization, with the offspring known                                 ■■ uniformity in size and shape,
as hybrids. When a hybrid has characteristics superior                                 ■■ higher dressout percentage and fillet yield,
to both parents it is said to have hybrid vigor or posi-                               ■■ increased harvestability by seining, and
tive heterosis, which, of course, is the ultimate breeding                             ■■ increased vulnerability to angling.
goal. Genetic enhancement programs attempt to develop                              The performance of the C×B hybrid has been confirmed
hybrids that are either superior to their parent species for                       on commercial catfish farms. Twenty years ago, C×B
individual traits or whose overall performance for several                         hybrid technology was not economically feasible. The
traits makes them economically more profitable than                                gametes (sperm and eggs) are compatible, but the two spe-
their parent species.                                                              cies seldom mate with one another because of behavioral
     Hybrids between the seven major species of North                              incompatibility, preferences in spawning environments, or
American catfish (ictalurids) were first researched and                            other factors. However, recent advances in artificial spawn-
evaluated in 1966. Of these 42 different interspecific                             ing and fertilization techniques have improved fry produc-
catfish hybrids (crosses between two distinct species),                            tion and made it economically feasible. Another important
only one has characteristics that would favor commer-                              development has been the use of different strains of chan-
cial application compared to the prominently cultured                              nel catfish and blue catfish to make the hybrid, which has
channel catfish (Ictalurus punctatus). That hybrid is the                          produced genetically distinct C×B hybrids with even more
channel catfish female × blue catfish (I. furcatus) male                           superior production characteristics.
(denoted as the C×B hybrid). It is important to note that
mating the male channel catfish with the female blue
catfish does not produce a hybrid with the same superior
                                                                                   Identifying the C×B hybrid
production characteristics as the C×B hybrid.                                           The channel catfish has a gentle slope from the tip
     Research on C×B hybrids has demonstrated that they                            of the snout to the base of the dorsal fin and is spotted.
are genetically improved for several commercially desir-                           It has high-set eyes; long, thick lateral barbels (whis-
able characteristics. This improved performance for many                           kers); and a rounded anal fin with 24 to 26 fin rays. The
commercial traits in a single cross is unusual, making the                         blue catfish has a steep slope from the tip of the snout
C×B hybrid the best example of genetic improvement ever                            to the base of the dorsal fin, giving it the appearance
attained in aquaculture in regard to overall performance.                          of a “hump.” It has no spots (except the Rio Grande
     The C×B hybrid is superior to channel catfish because                         strain); the eyes are set lower than in the channel; it has
of its                                                                             short, light colored, thin lateral barbels and a straight or
     ■■ faster growth,                                                             squared anal fin with 30 to 36 fin rays (Fig. 1). The C×B
     ■■ better feed conversion,                                                    hybrid looks much more like the blue catfish than the
     ■■ tolerance of low oxygen,                                                   channel catfish. The hybrid has a steep slope from the
     ■■ increased resistance to many diseases,                                     tip of the snout to the base of the dorsal fin, so it has the
                                                                                   “humped” appearance. It has few or no spots (unless the
Department of Fisheries and Allied Aquacultures, Auburn University
1
                                                                                   Rio Grande blue is used in the cross); the eyes are set low;
Department of Wildlife and Fisheries Sciences, Texas A&M University
2
Production of Hybrid Catfish
swim bladder (Fig. 2). Blue catfish have a long, narrow,
                                                                               bi-lobed swim bladder (two distinct chambers). The C×B
                                                                               hybrid also has a bi-lobed swim bladder, but the first cham-
                                                                               ber close to the head of the fish has a large, heart-shaped
                                                                               lobe while the second lobe is a small, attached protrusion.

                                                                               Production characteristics of C×B hybrids
                                                                               Growth and feed conversion
                                                                                    In early experiments, C×B hybrids grew about 20
                                                                               percent better than commonly cultured strains of channel
                                                                               catfish. However, recent research using selected parental
                                                                               strains of channel catfish and blue catfish have shown
                                                                               that the C×B hybrid can grow twice as fast as commercial
                                                                               strains of channel catfish, depending on environmental
                                                                               conditions. With good culture practices, an increase in
                                                                               growth rate of 25 percent or more is not unusual. This
                                                                               increased growth is due to a combination of increased food
Figure 1. External characteristics of channel catfish, blue catfish, and C×B   consumption and improved feed conversion efficiency.
hybrid catfish.                                                                     In general, C×B hybrids grow faster than channel
                                                                               catfish in both single-batch and multiple-batch (mixed size
                                                                               populations in the pond) systems. The growth advantage
the barbels are intermediate; and it has a straight anal fin
                                                                               of the hybrid increases when stocking density increases,
with an intermediate number of fin rays (usually 28).
                                                                               although the overall risk of fish loss will obviously increase
     With the increasing popularity of C×B hybrids, farmers
                                                                               with density. Fingerling C×B hybrids out-perform channel
may wonder how to verify that the fingerlings they purchase
                                                                               catfish fingerlings at all densities when grown to food-size
are actually F1 C×B hybrids. The morphological appearance
                                                                               fish. If fry are stocked at low densities (less than 60,000 per
described above is a good indicator of C×B hybrid identity,
                                                                               acre), the C×B hybrids grow at the same rate as or slower
but it may not be obvious to all fish culturists. The use of
                                                                               than channel catfish fingerlings until they reach a length
DNA analysis for identification is definitive.
                                                                               of approximately 6 inches; after that the C×B hybrids grow
     In the field, there is a quick, easy technique for verifi-
                                                                               faster. When stocked at 100,000 per acre or more, C×B
cation. Channel catfish have a single, lobed, heart-shaped
                                                                               hybrid fingerlings generally grow 50 percent faster than
                                                                               channel catfish fingerlings. In general, the C×B hybrid
                                                                               displays its superior growth in the second year, and this
                                                                               growth difference is even more pronounced at densities of
                                                                               7,000 to 22,000 per acre.
                                                                                    Experiments comparing channel catfish to C×B
                                                                               hybrids suggest that the hybrids grow faster because they
    Channel (female)           Blue (male)            Channel × Blue           start feeding earlier in the spring and because feed con-
                                                      (female) (male)          version in C×B hybrids averages 10 to 15 percent better
                                                                               than in channel catfish. On-farm feed conversion of C×B
                                                                               hybrids is 10 to 20 percent better than channel catfish.

                                                                               Effects of parental strain
                                                                                    The parental strain of channel catfish and blue catfish
                                                                               affects the performance of the C×B hybrid for several traits.
       Blue (female)        Channel (male)           Blue × Channel            In some experiments, the C×B hybrid did not grow as fast
                                                   (female)  (male)            as some strains of channel catfish or blue catfish not used
                                                                               to make the hybrid. When C×B hybrids are produced by
                           0    10 20      30 mm                               crossing superior strains of channel and blue catfish, these
                                                                               hybrids out-perform the parental strains for growth in open
Figure 2. Swim bladders.                                                       ponds. Hybrids always outgrow their parent strains.

2
The strain of the parents also affects characteristics       equipment is adjusted or designed for hybrids, the advan-
such as dressout percentage, body composition, seinabil-          tage of the hybrid may be increased even further.
ity, angling vulnerability, and tolerance to low oxygen.
                                                                  Harvestability
Uniformity                                                             One of the most important traits of the C×B hybrid is
     The uniformity of growth and body shape of hybrids           its seinability. The hybrid is generally two to three times
is superior to that of channel catfish but not superior to        easier to catch by seining than channel catfish. This makes
blue catfish. C×B hybrid fingerlings produced at high den-        the hybrid better suited for all open-pond culture sys-
sities (200,000 per acre) are not particularly uniform, but       tems, particularly where seining of large channel catfish is
fingerlings produced at lower densities have very uniform         problematic and ponds are seldom completely drained for
growth. Research has shown that the body shape, weight            harvest. Hybrids in hill ponds are also easier to trap than
and length of the C×B hybrid are more uniform than in             channel catfish and more susceptible to angling. In fact,
channel catfish.                                                  the C×B hybrid is about twice as easy to catch by hook-
                                                                  and-line as the channel catfish, a trait that has important
Survival and disease resistance                                   implications for fee-fishing and recreational fisheries.
     Many disease problems in the channel catfish industry             Commercial observations indicate that virtually all
could be reduced by culturing C×B hybrids because hybrids         of the hybrids in a pond can be captured in two or three
survive better in all growth phases. In 30 years of research      seine hauls, whereas five or more seine hauls will not har-
at Auburn University, hybrid fingerling survival has aver-        vest all of the channel catfish in a pond.
aged 80 to 85 percent and food-fish survival has averaged              Seinability is an undervalued trait. Harvest costs
90 percent. On-farm survival rates are similar. In contrast,      increase with each seining required. The efficient removal
the average survival of channel catfish fingerlings is 50 to      of fish maximizes the number that can be sold, alleviates
60 percent, and the survival of food-sized channel catfish is     the problem of leaving fish that will grow larger than the
approximately 70 percent. Although the C×B hybrid is not          desirable processing size, improves feed conversion effi-
totally resistant to disease, it is more resistant than chan-     ciency, and reduces losses from disease and predation.
nel catfish to columnaris (Flexibacter columnare), enteric
septicemia of catfish (Edwardsiella ictaluri), aeromonas          Potential harvest problems and solutions
(Aeromonas hydrophila), Ich (Ichthyophthirius multifilis),            Traditional seines and grading socks do not work
and channel catfish virus. Field observations indicate that       well with C×B hybrids if they do not match the size of the
the hybrid may be more vulnerable to E. tarda, but they           hybrids correctly. The hybrid has a small head and sharp
respond readily to treatment.                                     spines inherited from the paternal blue catfish. When
                                                                  hybrids are selectively graded by traditional equipment,
Carcass yield                                                     they tend to gill themselves in the netting, creating a han-
     Dressout percentage and fillet percentage are gener-         dling and stress problem (for both fish and people).
ally higher for the C×B hybrid than for channel catfish               This problem can be overcome in two ways. Seining
based on small-scale research and on data collected in            the pond with a 1-inch mesh seine followed by grading
processing plants. The hybrid has this advantage in all           with the side-panel grader developed by David Heikes at
months of the year.                                               the University of Arkansas at Pine Bluff (a 1-inch mesh
     The uniform body shape of the hybrid should increase         sock with flexible PVC grading panels on one side of the
dressout percentage in processing plants using automatic          sock) eliminates the gilling problem. In the case of a sin-
processing equipment because the equipment can make               gle-crop system, the problem is solved by using a smaller
more precise cuts and achieve maximum carcass yield.              mesh seine than normally used for channel catfish.
However, uniformity in body size could be a problem, as
fish that are too uniform will not use all the processing         Production expectations
lines simultaneously, which could reduce processing plant              Research and commercial trials in Alabama and
efficiency.                                                       Mississippi have shown that C×B hybrid fry stocked in
     There has been some concern that automated process-          May or early June at 100,000 fry per acre can yield 7,000
ing machines would have to be reset to accommodate the            to 10,000 pounds of fingerlings per acre by late October.
hybrid’s body shape. However, recent observations have            If these fingerlings (7+ inches) are stocked in a single-crop
shown that the hybrid can be processed by the same equip-         system at 3,000 fish per acre in the spring, 5,500 pounds
ment used for channel catfish without any adjustments, still      of marketable fish should be ready for harvest in the fall.
resulting in increased dressout and fillet yield. If processing   If stocked at 5,000 fingerlings per acre, 9,000 pounds of

                                                                                                                              3
marketable fish should be ready for harvest in the fall.        of the female channel catfish spawned. In these cases it
This production level requires near satiation feeding and       appears that the sexes were not properly identified (i.e.,
adequate aeration to sustain the fish.                          not only female channel catfish and male blue catfish
     Production will vary from pond to pond and farm to         were stocked) and fish of the same species were able to
farm depending upon environmental conditions, inputs            reproduce. Thus, no hybrids were actually produced.
(such as feed and aeration), depth of the pond, and the         Therefore, the open-pond spawning of channel catfish
skill of the farmer. However, it is not unreasonable to         with blue catfish to produce C×B hybrids cannot be
average 12,000 to 13,000 pounds per acre of C×B hybrid          recommended.
catfish with a stocking density of 6,000 fish per acre, and
7,500 to 9,000 pounds per acre should be easy to achieve.       Pen spawning
If split ponds or in-pond raceways are used, 20,000                  Pen spawning is a more consistent way of producing
pounds of C×B hybrid catfish per acre may be harvested.         C×B hybrids than open-pond spawning. Pens should be
                                                                similar to those used in traditional channel catfish spawn-
Production systems                                              ing. Spawning pens are constructed next to the bank
     Hybrids are well suited for a variety of production        of the pond, using treated lumber driven into the pond
systems currently used in the catfish industry. They are        bottom and plastic mesh or plastic-coated wire mesh for
advantageous in traditional multi-batch or modular sys-         sides. The mesh (1/2- to 2-inch) should allow for adequate
tems if the panel grader is used. They are almost essential     water circulation. Most spawning pens have dimensions
for split-pond and in-pond raceway systems to work prop-        of 4 x 6 or 4 x 8 feet. Spawning containers must be large
erly. They are particularly well suited for single-crop sys-    enough to accommodate the size of the male blue catfish.
tems, which are not widespread. More research needs to               Male blue catfish and female channel catfish are indi-
be done in this area. By altering the size of the fingerlings   vidually paired in pens when the water temperature at the
stocked, the stocking density, and the timing of stock-         depth of the spawning container is between 75 and 82 °F
ing, and coordinating this within a single farm or among        at sunrise. Male blue catfish should be placed in the pens
farms, a single-crop system should be able to produce a         a day or two before the female channel catfish. Female
year-round supply of C×B hybrids. This would yield even         channel catfish should show the classic signs of readiness
better feed conversion, production, and harvest efficiency,     for spawning, including a soft, distended belly and, prefer-
while providing the variety of sizes needed to efficiently      ably, a genital opening that is red and swollen. Female
use all production lines in a processing plant.                 channel catfish are injected with luteinizing hormone
                                                                analog (LHRHa) at 100 µg/kg to induce ovulation and
Spawning methods                                                mating with blue catfish.
                                                                     If mating occurs, spawns will usually be found 72
     There are three basic spawning techniques: open-           hours after the female is introduced into the pen. In
pond spawning, pen spawning, and artificial fertilization       rare cases, spawning has occurred up to a week after the
(induced ovulation followed by hand stripping). Artificial      female is introduced.
fertilization is the most productive and consistent tech-            Pen spawning success has been as high as 100 percent,
nique for making C×B hybrid catfish.                            but the usual result is 0 to 20 percent success. Average
     Most channel catfish do not become sexually mature         spawning success over 14 years of continuous research
until at least 3 years of age, and most blue catfish do         at Auburn University was approximately 15 percent.
not become mature until at least 5 years of age. Chan-          Therefore, pen spawning is not considered a dependable
nel catfish females 4 to 5 years old are the most reliable      method of producing C×B hybrid fry.
for hybridization early in the spawning season. Using                The strains of blue catfish or channel catfish used
younger females at the end of the spawning season can           affect the success of pen spawning because some strains
extend the season if brood fish are kept in deep, cool          are more likely to hybridize with the other species. Blue
ponds. If multiple year classes are prepared in the same        catfish males of the AU-1 strain have a high hybridiza-
pond and are underfed, the younger, smaller fish may not        tion rate with channel catfish females. For 2 consecutive
compete well and not become gravid.                             years these males had a high spawning and hybridization
                                                                rate (50 to 60 percent), but in the third year no spawn-
Open-pond spawning                                              ing occurred. Obviously, this is an unacceptable level of
    Open-pond spawning is not a consistent way to               risk, so pen spawning to produce C×B hybrids cannot be
produce C×B hybrids. Usually, no spawns occur, but              recommended.
there have been rare instances when up to 33 percent

4
Artificial spawning/fertilization                              production. The pituitary extracts are inferior to LHRHa
     Artificial fertilization technology made C×B hybrid       but have the advantage of synchronizing ovulation
production possible in the catfish industry. Ten years ago,    among females better than other spawning aids. Pituitary
approximately 1 million C×B hybrid fry were produced. In       extracts are powerful for ovulation and release of eggs, but
2011 that figure had risen to approximately 100 million. The   often the eggs are of lower quality and have a lower hatch
entire industry could be converted to hybrids in 2 years if    rate compared to LHRHa.
the industry demanded the change. If properly conducted,            LHRHa can be administered as an injection or an
the artificial spawning of female channel catfish should be    implant, although implants produce the overall best and
67 to 100 percent successful. The following protocol has       most consistent fry output. Implants are also advanta-
been the most successful in producing C×B hybrids.             geous late in the spawning season and require only a
     Female channel catfish brood stock should be fed a        single administration (injection of the implant), whereas
commercially manufactured 36 percent protein diet 3            injectable LHRHa is given in two injections several hours
days a week during summer and fall. During March-May           apart for best results.
they should be stocked at no more than 1,500 pounds                 LHRHa or pituitary extract should be administered
per acre and fed 3 to 5 days a week with a commercially        no more than 2 days after females are seined from ponds
manufactured 36 percent protein diet containing 500            and brought to the holding vats in the hatchery. In the
ppm vitamin C, 6 percent animal/fish protein, and 6 to         case of the injectables, the first injection (called the
10 percent marine fish oil. Male blue catfish should be        priming dose) should be made about 12 hours before the
stocked and fed in a similar fashion, but they also benefit    second injection or resolving dose. It is essential to weigh
from forage fish.                                              each female accurately in kilograms so that precise doses
     Females selected for injection should have soft, dis-     can be calculated.
tended bellies and, preferably, red, swollen genital open-          The first injection of pituitary extract at 2 mg/kg of
ings. Selected females are placed in spawning bags (the        body weight should be administered intraperitoneally
same as ¼-inch mesh laundry bags, Fig. 3) suspended in         (into the body cavity under the base of one of the pelvic
holding vats. Water flow and aeration in the vats should       fins). This can be done just before placing the female in
maintain total ammonia near 0 mg/L and dissolved oxy-          the spawning bag or the injection can be administered
gen above 6 mg/L. Ideal water temperature is 82 °F, but        through the mesh of the bag. Then the female should be
positive results can be obtained between 72 and 86 °F.         suspended in her bag, which is hung upon wooden dow-
     Females are induced to ovulate with LHRHa, carp           els, boards or other appropriate rods lying across the top
pituitary extract (CPE), or channel catfish pituitary          of the vat. The second injection is given 12 hours after the
extract (CCPE). The first ovulating agent used to spawn        first injection, at a dose of 8 mg/kg of body weight. Thirty-
catfish was human chorionic gonadotropin, but this             six hours after the first injection, most of the female
hormone yields unacceptably low ovulation and fry              channel catfish should be ready to ovulate and be hand
                                                               stripped if they have been held at 80 to 82 °F. Females will
                                                               begin releasing eggs into the bags. The bags are gently
                                                               lifted and examined in the water; if eggs are detected, the
                                                               female is ready for hand stripping. At colder temperatures,
                                                               the process of ovulation is slowed.
                                                                    The same procedure is used for LHRHa injections.
                                                               Early in the spawning season, the most effective dose
                                                               is 30 µg/kg for the priming dose and 150 µg/kg for the
                                                               resolving dose. Once the peak of the spawning season
                                                               is reached, the dose should be reduced to 20 µg/kg for
                                                               the priming dose and 100 µg/kg for the resolving dose.
                                                               LHRHa gives better fry output than pituitary extract, but
                                                               the timing of ovulation will vary more. The first ovula-
                                                               tions usually occur 40 to 44 hours after the first injection,
                                                               but some females will ovulate and produce high quality
                                                               eggs up to 60 hours after the first injection. Once peak
                                                               spawning is reached, the first check for eggs should be
                                                               done 34 to 36 hours after injection, as the earliest ovulat-
Figure 3. Spawning bags.                                       ing fish may release eggs at this time.

                                                                                                                          5
Fish given implants have the most consistent and the          eral rule, it takes one male to fertilize five to ten females,
overall best fry output for the entire spawning season,            depending on the size and quality of the male and the
but the timing of ovulation is the most variable. This is          number of eggs collected.
understandable, since the eggs are at different stages of               Place the testes in a low-speed blender with 10 mL of
readiness in each female. Thus, forcing all females to             0.9 percent saline per g of testes and macerate by blending
ovulate at the same time (which happens with pituitary             for three 45-second bursts. Then filter the sperm/testes
injections) would not allow time for all their eggs to prop-       solution with a 100-micrometer mesh to remove testicular
erly mature first. The dose for the LHRHa implants is 90           debris from the sperm solution.
µg/kg early and in the peak of the spawning season. Late                When females are ovulating they are removed from
in the spawning season, the best results will be obtained          the tanks and placed in an anesthetizing solution of
with a dose of 75 µg/kg. Implants are injected into the            MS-222 at a concentration of 250 mg/L. When a female is
muscle (intramuscularly) about 1 inch below and slightly           immobilized but the gills are still slowly moving, remove
behind the base of the dorsal fin.                                 her from the anesthetic and quickly rinse her with clean
     When implants are used early in the spawning season,          water to remove any remaining anesthetic. Carefully
the first fish begin ovulating about 44 hours after implan-        towel dry the female and wrap the towel around her head
tation. If the water is cold (75 to 77 °F, ovulation will be       and upper body. This is to remove moisture that might
delayed to 50 to 55 hours after implantation. After the first      prematurely activate the eggs and sperm. Hold the female
week or two of the spawning season, some females will              head up and tail down during the stripping process, with
begin ovulating as early as 36 hours after implantation, so        the genital opening just above a metal pie pan lightly
the first check of the bags should occur at this time. Slow        coated with vegetable shortening. Strip the eggs into the
ovulating females may still be giving high quality eggs as         pie pan. Feel the belly region to locate the roll (mass) of
late as 72 hours after implantation, but the vast majority         eggs in each ovary. Gently but firmly press the belly with
will have ovulated within 60 hours. If temperature cannot          strokes beginning at the top of one ovary (one side at a
be controlled and the water is 73 to 75 °F, good ovulation         time) and ending at the genital opening (Fig. 5). When
and hatching can still be obtained, but egg release will be        it becomes difficult to get eggs to flow out of one ovary,
greatly delayed and the average time of ovulation will be 75       begin stripping the other ovary and alternately strip each
to 80 hours after implantation.                                    ovary as needed. When no more eggs can be stripped or
      A few hours before stripping the females, the male           blood begins to come out of the genital opening, then
blue catfish must be sacrificed and their testes removed.          stripping is completed and the female should be returned
Males are usually euthanized and surgically opened with            to a vat for recovery.
an incision along the anal opening to about three-fourths               Then mix together the eggs and the sperm solution.
of the way to the head along the belly (without damaging           Add oxygenated water to the egg and sperm mixture to
the gut). The testes are removed by gently cutting them            activate fertilization, which is completed within 2 minutes
from the mesentery connective tissue. Try to minimize              after water is added to the gametes. After 2 to 5 minutes,
bleeding, as this will obscure the view of the testes and          add additional water to the pan. After a few more min-
make removal difficult (Fig. 4). Remove only the white
portion of the testes. Gently dry the testes with a paper
towel until all blood and moisture have been removed.
This prevents activation of the sperm when the testes are
macerated to release the sperm. Finally, weigh the testes
                                                with an accu-
                                                rate electronic
                                                gram scale.
                                                Approximately
                                                0.5 g is needed
                                                for each 100
                                                mL or g of eggs.
                                                If sperm counts
                                                are made, use
                                                65 million
                                                sperm per g of
Figure 4. Testes of male blue catfish.          eggs. As a gen-    Figure 5. Hand stripping of eggs from female channel catfish.

6
utes, move the eggs to a trough and allowed them to water         performance of these F2 and backcross hybrids is inferior
harden for about 15 minutes. Then transfer the eggs to a          to that of F1 hybrids and channel catfish. Therefore, pro-
traditional catfish egg hatching trough. After this point         ducing fry from C×B hybrid parents is not recommended.
the eggs and fry are handled like channel catfish eggs.           To obtain genetic improvement and hybrid vigor, chan-
     Artificial fertilization technology is labor intensive,      nel catfish females must be mated with blue catfish males
but efficient compared to open-pond spawning of channel           each year to produce F1 C×B hybrids for production.
catfish. By controlling temperature in the hatchery, the
hatchery operator can dictate the start of the spawning
season and prevent the cyclic nature of natural spawning,
                                                                  Management considerations
which has peaks as well as periods of little spawning. If         Genotype-environment interactions
brood stock are properly prepared and hybrid spawning                  The genotype-environment interaction is defined as
protocol is followed, a plan can be developed that will           the change in the value of a genotype when the environ-
allow the hatchery to operate at capacity continually until       ment changes. In other words, the best genetic type for
the hot weather at the end of the season over ripens the          one set of environmental conditions may not be the best
females and ends the season. Because artificial spawn-            genetic type for another set of environmental conditions;
ing is reliable and has guaranteed results virtually on           or, the advantage of the particular genotype may increase
demand, the number of brood stock and the amount of               or decrease in a second environment.
acreage devoted to brood stock can actually be decreased               Genotype-environment interactions occur for the
as compared to open-pond spawning of channel catfish.             C×B hybrid. The genetic advantage of the C×B hybrid
                                                                  relative to channel catfish or blue catfish increases with
Hormones                                                          increasing stocking density. The hybrid is superior to
    At the time this publication was written, there               channel catfish and blue catfish in earthen pond culture,
were no hormones or spawning aids approved by the                 large raceways, in-pond raceways, and split ponds. How-
Food and Drug Administration (FDA) for spawning                   ever, the hybrid does not grow well in small units, and
of catfish. Please check with your Extension fisheries/           channel catfish will grow faster than hybrids in aquaria,
aquaculture specialist for current registrations before           small hapas, and cages that are a cubic yard or smaller.
using these hormones. To produce C×B hybrid catfish,
one must participate in the program for Investigational
New Animal Drugs (INADs). The United States Fish
                                                                  Conclusion
and Wildlife Service (USFWS) administers permits                      The use of the C×B hybrid is a management tool. The
for LHRHa and carp pituitary extract. However, the                hybrid increases the likelihood of high production and
USFWS dose for the LHRHa INAD is restricted to a                  profitability, but it is not a solution to all problems. The
total of 100 µg/kg, which is less than the most effec-            performance, phenotype or production (P) of an individ-
tive dose. Auburn University and Eagle Aquaculture                ual or population is a result of the environment (E), geno-
administer a separate INAD for LHRHa injections and               type (G), and genotype-environment interaction (GE).
implants. This INAD allows injection doses of up to                                     P = G + E + GE
180µg/kg, as needed. USFWS administers the catfish                     The best genetic type of catfish in the world will
pituitary INAD.                                                   not perform well and reach its potential without a good
                                                                  environment or good farming practices. Of course, the
Hybrid fertility                                                  worst genetic type of catfish will not perform well even in
    The strains of channel catfish female and blue catfish        the hands of the best farmer. Under certain conditions,
male used to produce first generation (F1) C×B hybrids            C×B hybrids may experience disease outbreaks, feed
affects whether or not they can reproduce. Some F1 C×B            poorly, or exhibit other problems, but they are less likely
hybrids can spawn and produce large numbers of second             to have these problems than channel catfish. Because they
generation (F2) hybrids; other types of F1 C×B hybrids            have many superior characteristics and are suitable for a
have low fertility or are essentially sterile. With difficulty,   variety of culture systems, C×B hybrids can improve farm
F1 C×B hybrids can be crossed with a pure strain of chan-         production and profitability.
nels or blues to produce backcross hybrids. However, the

                                                                                                                             7
The views expressed in this publication are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect those of USDA or any of its
         subagencies. Trade names are used for descriptive purposes only and their use does not imply endorsement by USDA, SRAC,
         the authors, or their employers and does not imply approval to the exclusion of other products that may also be suitable.

    SRAC fact sheets are reviewed annually by the Publications, Videos and Computer Software Steering Committee. Fact sheets are revised
    as new knowledge becomes available. Fact sheets that have not been revised are considered to reflect the current state of knowledge.

                                                           The work reported in this publication was supported in part by the Southern Regional
                                                           Aquaculture Center through Grant No. 2008-38500-19251 from the United States
                                                           Department of Agriculture, National Institute of Food and Agriculture.

8
You can also read