Onehunga Primary School (Former), ONEHUNGA (List No. 7109, Category 1) - Heritage New Zealand

Page created by Ryan Marshall
 
CONTINUE READING
Onehunga Primary School (Former), ONEHUNGA (List No. 7109, Category 1) - Heritage New Zealand
New Zealand Heritage List/Rārangi Kōrero – Review Report for a Historic Place
Onehunga Primary School (Former), ONEHUNGA (List No. 7109,
Category 1)

    Onehunga Primary School (former) looking north.
    (Alexandra Foster, Heritage New Zealand Pouhere Taonga)

             Alexandra Foster
             DRAFT: Last amended 14 March 2019
             Heritage New Zealand Pouhere Taonga
Onehunga Primary School (Former), ONEHUNGA (List No. 7109, Category 1) - Heritage New Zealand
TABLE OF CONTENTS

PURPOSE OF REVIEW                                                                                                 3

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY                                                                                                 3

1.       IDENTIFICATION                                                                                           5
1.1.     Name of Place                                                                                             5
1.2.     Location Information                                                                                      5
1.3.     Legal Description                                                                                         5
1.4.     Extent of List Entry                                                                                      6
1.5.     Eligibility                                                                                               6
1.6.     Existing Heritage Recognition                                                                             6

2.       SUPPORTING INFORMATION                                                                                   7
2.1.     Historical Information                                                                                    7
2.2.     Physical Information                                                                                     17
2.3.     Chattels                                                                                                 22
2.4.     Sources                                                                                                  23

3.       SIGNIFICANCE ASSESSMENT                                                                                  23
3.1.     Section 66 (1) Assessment                                                                                23
3.2.     Section 66 (3) Assessment                                                                                25

4.       APPENDICES                                                                                               28
4.1.     Appendix 1: Visual Identification Aids                                                                   28
4.2.     Appendix 2: Visual Aids to Historical Information                                                        34
4.3.     Appendix 3: Visual Aids to Physical Information                                                          36
4.4.     Appendix 4: Significance Assessment Information                                                          43

Disclaimer

Please note that entry on the New Zealand Heritage List/Rārangi Kōrero identifies only the heritage values of
the property concerned, and should not be construed as advice on the state of the property, or as a comment
of its soundness or safety, including in regard to earthquake risk, safety in the event of fire, or insanitary
conditions.
Archaeological sites are protected by the Heritage New Zealand Pouhere Taonga Act 2014, regardless of
whether they are entered on the New Zealand Heritage List/Rārangi Kōrero or not. Archaeological sites include
‘places associated with pre-1900 human activity, where there may be evidence relating to the history of New
Zealand’. This List entry report should not be read as a statement on whether or not the archaeological
provisions of the Act apply to the property (s) concerned. Please contact your local Heritage New Zealand office
for archaeological advice.

             Heritage New Zealand Pouhere Taonga – List Entry Review Report for a Historic Place, List No. 7109        2
Onehunga Primary School (Former), ONEHUNGA (List No. 7109, Category 1) - Heritage New Zealand
PURPOSE OF REVIEW

The purpose of the review is to consider a change in the list entry category. The review is
being undertaken to assess the additional information about the place and its context that
has become available since initial listing in 1993. Also to assess the significance of the place
under the wider range of criteria that is now utilised for assessment and is likely to be
relevant in ascertaining the appropriate category.

The recommended outcome of the review is that the category of the entry for Onehunga
Primary School (former) be changed from a Category 2 to a Category 1 historic place as the
place has special significance for its aesthetic, architectural, historical and social values. The
review also recommends that the extent be reduced to primarily include the covenanted land
as well as the 1945 swimming pool.

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

Onehunga Primary School (former), a visual landmark in the historic settlement of Onehunga,
has special significance as a place closely associated with education during the twentieth
century, particularly in the widening of educational provision under the first Liberal
Government and changes in swimming education from the mid–twentieth century. Built in
1901, the size and scale of the building reflected the importance of the settlement with the
growth of the community over the century reflected in the changes to the physical fabric and
layout of the building. The swimming pool demonstrates the commitment towards swimming
education and water safety in the mid–twentieth century. The place also has importance for
its strong community links since construction, first as a primary and a high school, and
recently as a community facility that has been restored through the fundraising efforts of the
local community. A generally well-preserved place the building has potential for public
education through being a public venue as well as housing a museum collection related to
the school and district. The place forms part of a notable historic and cultural landscape
along with other buildings at Onehunga associated with the early decades of the township
and its development as the second largest settlement on the Tāmaki isthmus.

The first public school opened at Onehunga in 1873 and moved to Selwyn Street in 1876. As
the population of Onehunga grew and access to primary and secondary education was

 Heritage New Zealand Pouhere Taonga – List Entry Review Report for a Historic Place, List No. 7109   3
Onehunga Primary School (Former), ONEHUNGA (List No. 7109, Category 1) - Heritage New Zealand
widened under the first Liberal Government, the school site was enlarged and in 1899 an
infant block was added, followed by the main building two years later.

Designed by John Mitchell and Robert Watt, the main building is one of their largest surviving
school buildings from their time as architects for the Auckland Education Board. The building
is comprised of three main wings with gable ends on the main elevation and two additional
rooms at the rear. The design was broadly symmetrical with five large classrooms, two small
classrooms and two teachers’ rooms, as well as two rooms in the basement. The design used
Queen Anne-influenced architecture associated with progressive ideas and secular education
and the highly decorated main façade and belfry is a visual landmark in Onehunga. The
building was considered to be up-to-date with innovative heating, lighting and ventilation as
well as dedicated science facilities. The building was built by G.M. Handcock in 1901 and
opened in November that year.

For the next 80 years the main building was in constant use as part of the school. It was used
as a district high school from 1903 to 1912 before reverting to being part of the primary
school. Due to the increasing population in Onehunga the school was frequently
overcrowded and changes to the structure reflect the measures taken to address the need
for classroom space; all the large rooms were portioned from 1919 and some rooms being
extended with fibrolite additions in 1968. The belfry had been removed from the building in
1947. A learners’ pool was constructed east of the building in 1945 for swimming and water
safety education.

The community had been closely involved in running the school as part of the Onehunga
School Committee since 1873. The formation of the PTA in 1941 increased the community’s
contribution to the school. When the building was threatened with demolition in 1980 the
community rallied to save the place which became a public venue named the Onehunga
Community House. From the early twenty–first century the committee running the
community house fundraised nearly one million dollars for its restoration which they
completed in 2018.

 Heritage New Zealand Pouhere Taonga – List Entry Review Report for a Historic Place, List No. 7109   4
Onehunga Primary School (Former), ONEHUNGA (List No. 7109, Category 1) - Heritage New Zealand
1.     IDENTIFICATION1
1.1.   Name of Place

       Name:
       Onehunga Primary School (Former)

       Other Names:
       Onehunga School
       Onehunga District High School
       Onehunga Primary School
       Onehunga Community House
       Onehunga Primary School Senior Block
       Onehunga Primary School Main Block
       Onehunga Primary School Main Building
       Onehunga School Swimming Pool

1.2.   Location Information

       Address
       83-89 Selwyn Street
       Onehunga
       AUCKLAND

       Additional Location Information
       1758851.5 mE
       5912546.3 mN
       (NZTM Coordinates, QuickMap from approximate centre of building)

       Local Authority
       Auckland Council

1.3.   Legal Description

       Lot 1 DP 189657 (RT NA119C/8) and Pt Allot 6 Sec 19 Village of Onehunga (RT 223325, NZ
       Gazette 1971, p.111), North Auckland Land District

              1
                  This section is supplemented by visual aids in Appendix 1 of the report.

        Heritage New Zealand Pouhere Taonga – List Entry Review Report for a Historic Place, List No. 7109   5
Onehunga Primary School (Former), ONEHUNGA (List No. 7109, Category 1) - Heritage New Zealand
1.4.   Extent of List Entry

       Extent includes the land described as Lot 1 DP 189657 (RT NA119C/8) and part of the land
       known as Pt Allot 6 Sec 19 Village of Onehunga (RT 223325, NZ Gazette 1971, p.111), North
       Auckland Land District, and the buildings and structures known as Onehunga Primary School
       (Former) thereon, and their fittings and fixtures, and the following chattel: Sick Bay bed. It
       excludes the structure known as changing rooms and filter room. (Refer to map in Appendix
       1 of the List entry report for further information).

1.5.   Eligibility

       There is sufficient information included in this report to identify this place. This place is
       physically eligible for consideration as a historic place. It consists of a combination of land,
       buildings and structures that are fixed to land which lies within the territorial limits of New
       Zealand.

1.6.   Existing Heritage Recognition

       Local Authority and Regional Authority Plan Scheduling
       Auckland Unitary Plan, Operative in Part (Updated 22 February 2019), Schedule 14 Historic
       Heritage, 1841, Onehunga Primary School (former), Category A.

       Heritage Covenant
       Part of this place is covered by a Heritage Covenant: Onehunga Primary School (Former)
       Covenant 8879137.1, 8 July 2011; CFR NA119C/8. It includes all of the land described as Lot 1
       DP 189657 containing 2863m2 in CFR 119C/8 (North Auckland registry) and the building
       known as the Onehunga Primary School (Former) situated at 83 Selwyn Street, Onehunga.

       Other Heritage Recognition
       Auckland Council Cultural Heritage Inventory ID– 2868 Historic Structure – Onehunga Primary
       School Buildings (former)/ Former Onehunga Primary School.

         Heritage New Zealand Pouhere Taonga – List Entry Review Report for a Historic Place, List No. 7109   6
Onehunga Primary School (Former), ONEHUNGA (List No. 7109, Category 1) - Heritage New Zealand
2.           SUPPORTING INFORMATION
2.1.         Historical Information

              Early History of the Site

              Onehunga Primary School (Former) is located in the Auckland suburb of Onehunga on the
              lower slopes of Maungakiekie on the north side of Manukau Harbour. Forming part of a
              volcanic landscape associated with Mataaho, the god of earthquakes and volcanoes,
              Onehunga was an important place of Māori settlement over many centuries.2 In one local
              tradition the lagoon Te Hōpua was said to have been created by Mahuika, the goddess of fire,
              to warm Mataaho.3 The Tainui waka passed Onehunga and named one of the springs Te Puna
              a Taihaua.4 In the eighteenth century Waiohua had extensive kūmara gardens in the area and
              coastal kainga were established by Ngāti Whatua from later in the century, including the
              settlement of Āpihai Te Kawau (R11/99).5 A concentration of shell midden (R11/513) located
              on the property adjacent to Onehunga Primary School (former) is surviving evidence of
              Māori occupation in close proximity to the school.6 Onehunga was an important link
              between Tāmaki, Manukau and Waikato for Māori and formed part of a significant Māori
              trade network.7

              After early contact between Māori and Church Missionary Society missionaries in 1820, a
              small number of European settlers established themselves in the area from 1840.8 In 1847
              Governor Grey founded Onehunga as the first of four fencible settlements in south Auckland
              comprised of veteran former soldiers charged with defending the capital in Auckland in
              exchange for land grants.9 Linking the isthmus to Waikato, Onehunga continued to be an
              important trading centre from the earliest years of European settlement in Tāmaki where

2
    Bruce W. Hayward, Graeme Murdoch & Gordon Maitland, Volcanoes of Auckland: The Essential Guide, 2011, p. 43.
3
    Another tradition associated with Te Hopua is that it was created by a Waitakere tohunga to stop a war party from Hūnua.
     Dr Malcolm Paterson, ‘Maori Heritage in Onehunga’ in HNZPT, ‘City @ Risk -Onehunga’, 2010.
4
    The numerous springs originating from the southern edge of the Maungakiekie lava flow around Onehunga were
     collectively known as Waihihi and were known for “their profusion and strong flow” Hayward, Murdoch & Maitland, p. 52.
5
    Janice C. Mogford, The Onehunga Heritage, Onehunga Borough Council, 1989, p. 13; Patterson, ‘City @ Risk – Onehunga’;
      New Zealand Archaeological Association (NZAA), R11/99, URL: http://www.archsite.org.nz/.
6
    NZAA, R11/513.
7
    Patterson, ‘City @ Risk – Onehunga’
8
    Ani Piīhema, Ruby Kerei and Steven Oliver. 'Te Kawau, Apihai', Dictionary of New Zealand Biography, first published in 1990.
     Te Ara - the Encyclopedia of New Zealand, https://teara.govt.nz/en/biographies/1t42/te-kawau-apihai (accessed 6
     December 2018); Martin Jones, ‘Historical Overview’, in HNZPT, ‘City @ Risk – Onehunga’, 2010.
9
    Mogford, p. 16; Onehunga Primary School Committee, Onehunga Primary School Centennial 1873-1973, 1973, p. 6;
     Salmond Reed Architects, ‘Former Onehunga Primary School – Selwyn Street, Onehunga: Heritage Assessment’, DRAFT,
     2002, p. 5.

               Heritage New Zealand Pouhere Taonga – List Entry Review Report for a Historic Place, List No. 7109                  7
Onehunga Primary School (Former), ONEHUNGA (List No. 7109, Category 1) - Heritage New Zealand
Māori traders would bring in canoe loads of produce to Onehunga to sell to settlers in
              Auckland, and was developed as an important west coast port. The population of Onehunga
              grew quickly over the next decades and the settlement became the second largest on the
              isthmus after Auckland City.

              Education in Onehunga

              Education was prioritised in the growing Onehunga community with the first school being
              established by the Anglican Church in 1847, followed quickly by the Catholic Church by
              1848.10 Education remained under church control, excepting a few small private schools, until
              the Auckland Provincial Council passed the Education Act 1872.11 This legislation funded
              public schooling in the province through an education rate levied on households.12 The
              Auckland Education Board opened a number of schools in the next years including Onehunga
              District School in 1873.13 Due to the high population of Onehunga the new school was well-
              funded and initially operated from the stone Anglican Church schoolhouse.14 Education was
              subsequently standardised across the country in the 1877 Education Act which guaranteed
              access to free secular state primary education.15

              The Board built a schoolhouse on Selwyn Street and Onehunga District School moved to the
              new site in 1876.16 The expanding population of the settlement ensured the school was well
              attended and, with the increased focus on wider access to education following the election
              of the first Liberal Government in 1891, the Board acquired additional land adjoining the new
              school from local residents in 1898.17 This included Allotment 6 Section 19, which was
              purchased from Bradley and had been originally granted in 1854 to H.C. Lawlor, a resident
              magistrate.18 A small infant block was erected in the widened grounds the following year and,

10
     David Bade, ‘General history of Education in Onehunga’, in Auckland Council Heritage Unit, ‘Historic Heritage Assessment:
      Onehunga Primary School (former)’, September 2013, p. 43; Mogford, p. 112.
11
     Salmond Reed Architects, p. 5; Bade, p. 43.
12
     Onehunga Primary School Committee, p. 7.
13
     Mogford, p. 113.
14
     Onehunga Primary School Committee, p. 7; Bade, p. 44
15
     Michael King, The Penguin History of New Zealand, 2012, p. 233-4; Malcolm McKinnon, 'Colonial and provincial
     government - After abolition', Te Ara - the Encyclopedia of New Zealand, http://www.TeAra.govt.nz/en/colonial-and-
     provincial-government/page-5 (accessed 22 January 2019); Bade, p. 44; Ian Cumming, Glorious Enterprise – The History of
     The Auckland Education Board 1857-1957, 1959, p. 100; Mogford, p. 80.
16
     The land this building was constructed on was low lying and swampy. Bade, p. 45; Salmond Reed Architects, p. 5;
      Onehunga Primary School Committee, p. 7.
17
     James Belich, Paradise Reforged: A History of the New Zealanders From the 1880s to the Year 2000, 2001, p. 130-1; DI
      18A.762, LINZ.
18
     DI 5A.640, LINZ; Daily Southern Cross, 26 Sep 1867, p. 4.

                Heritage New Zealand Pouhere Taonga – List Entry Review Report for a Historic Place, List No. 7109               8
Onehunga Primary School (Former), ONEHUNGA (List No. 7109, Category 1) - Heritage New Zealand
after the Board decided against relocating the original school building, plans were initiated
              for a new senior block to be built on the highest ground of the site, Allotment 6.19

              Creation of Onehunga Primary School (former) Main Building
              The Onehunga Primary School (former) main building was designed by the architectural
              partnership of John Mitchell (c.1859-1947) and Robert Watt (1860-1907), the architects for
              the Auckland Education Board. They were responsible for designing all new schools and
              additions between 1892 and 1907 and their designs “are held to represent an important
              phase in the architectural development of school buildings in New Zealand”.20 Taking
              advantage of the prominent position of the site, they designed a large Queen Anne style-
              influenced timber building. This created a dramatic landmark from its commanding position
              visible from the township, port and harbour. Queen Anne architecture was closely associated
              with progressive, secular ideas and was used widely in New Zealand state architecture during
              the first decade of the Liberal Government as well as in Britain from the 1870s, particularly in
              Board schools.21 The striking applied timbering and detailed bracket ornamentation on the
              main façade and belfry evoked civic pride in the institution and demonstrated the
              importance given to education by both the government and the local community.22 The
              classrooms were symmetrically arranged with two wings either side of the large central room
              and wide u-shaped corridors. The building had a total of seven classrooms, five large and two
              smaller rooms, as well as a headmaster’s room, a teachers’ room, and two basement
              equipment rooms on the eastern side. One of the classrooms was also the school hall and
              contained a small museum collection, the cadet rifles and the roll of honour of students who
              had received scholarships. Reflecting the importance given to the learning environment for a
              good education, features of the modern design also included dedicated science facilities
              fitted with gas and water that could be used for a laboratory and the rooms were arranged to
              be well positioned for light and air flow.23 Mitchell and Watt continued using an innovative
              ventilation and heating system pioneered in their earlier school designs, with large windows
              in the gable ends to maximise light, ventilation holes in the eves as well as patent stoves and
              roof ventilators in each classroom. The rooms thought to be warmer or cooler were painted

19
     Salmond Reed Architects, p. 6.
20
     Salmond Reed Architects, pp. 17-18; Lucy Mackintosh, ‘Upgrade Report Onehunga Primary School’, HNZPT, 2010, p. 4.
21
     Peter Richardson, An Architecture of Empire – The Government Buildings of John Campbell, MA Thesis, 1988, p. 50;
      Malcolm Seaborne & Roy Lowe, The English School: Its architecture and organisation, Vol. II 1870-1970, 1973, p. 8-9.
22
     Seaborne and Lowe, ibid.
23
     Auckland Star (AS), 20 Nov 1901, p. 4; Warwick Kellaway, Education 150: From schoolhouse to classpace in the Waikato –
      Bay of Plenty, 1981, pp. 105, 132

               Heritage New Zealand Pouhere Taonga – List Entry Review Report for a Historic Place, List No. 7109             9
Onehunga Primary School (Former), ONEHUNGA (List No. 7109, Category 1) - Heritage New Zealand
appropriate colours.24 Other features of the design included separate entrances for every
              classroom and washbasins at the ends of the main corridors.25

              Construction was initially deferred for a short time as the Board was low on funds, however a
              tender of £2,374 plus £60 for the belfry was then accepted from G.M. Handcock and the
              building was completed in 1901.26 The building was officially opened with a public ceremony
              on November 20th 1901. The Education Board had spent a substantial portion of its £10,000
              budget on the improvements at the school totalling £4,000 for the land, new buildings and
              other improvements since 1898. The Board hoped this would reduce future expenditure
              requirements and reflected the growth and importance of Onehunga, particularly as other
              smaller schools in the wider isthmus were experiencing decreasing rolls. The opening was
              described at the time as ‘one of the most important events that ever occurred in
              Onehunga’.27

              Onehunga District High School
              Shortly after the main building was opened, the local community pushed for it to be used as
              a District High School. Onehunga District School provided classes up to standard seven,
              however the community found the expense required for older students to attend secondary
              schools in Auckland City to be too high.28 The Liberal Government reforms to education in
              1900 widened access to secondary education, previously the preserve of the elite, and the
              Onehunga community pushed to take advantage of the new opportunities presented. After
              the Education Board provided their support for the proposal, Onehunga District High School
              opened in July 1903.29 The school ended the year with the highest number of enrolled
              students at a high school in Auckland Province with many students travelling from as far
              away as Pukekohe and Point Chevalier.30 By August 1904 the school had more students

24
     The rooms were painted with Durecso, a recently patented durable coating that could be coloured as required. At
      Onehunga warm colours were used in rooms considered to be colder and cool colours in warm rooms. AS, 21 Nov 1901,
      p.1, 27 May 1913, p. 4; Thames Star (TS), 1 Feb 1916, p.5.
25
     AS, 20 Nov 1901, p. 4
26
     Salmond Reed Architects, p.6.
27
     The original school building was demolished and the timber was reused at Richmond Road and Newton West schools. AS,
      21 Nov 1901, p. 1
28
     Salmond Reed Architects, p. 7; TS, 18 April 1902, p. 1
29
     Archives New Zealand, ‘Buildings and Sites – Primary Schools – Auckland – Onehunga 1905-1925’, BCDQ A739 1050 Box
      264 b 7/11 a; Salmond Reed Architects, p. 7; Onehunga Primary School Committee, p. 8; Mogford, p. 115.
30
     Tramlines were extended to Onehunga in 1903 which led to the continued rise in the population of the settlement as well
      as contributing to the continued overcrowding of the schools at Onehunga. Archives New Zealand, ‘Buildings and Sites –
      Primary Schools – Auckland – Onehunga 1905-1925’, BCDQ A739 1050 Box 264 b 7/11 a; Salmond Reed Architects, p. 8.

                Heritage New Zealand Pouhere Taonga – List Entry Review Report for a Historic Place, List No. 7109             10
applying than there was space available.Requests for more classrooms were refused
                however, as Auckland Grammar School only had half the roll it was able to accommodate.31
                The high school education offered at Onehunga focused on science and technical education
                with a view towards agriculture. In 1912 the Education Board determined that it would be
                more efficient and economical to close the high school department at Onehunga and the
                students could instead attend other secondary schools in Auckland.32

                Changes to Onehunga Primary School Main building
                The next decades saw a number of changes to the organisation and functioning of Onehunga
                District School, later known as Onehunga Primary School, in response to roll growth as well
                as changing teaching methods and ideas.33 The main building was primarily used for teaching
                the senior classes, standards one to seven, but the rooms were also used for other school
                purposes.34 In 1929 one of the classrooms temporarily housed a dental clinic until a
                permanent two-chair clinic was built elsewhere on the school grounds; after a special
                education class was established in 1930, it was reportedly taught in one of the basement
                rooms which had been converted into a classroom, and a school library was created in one of
                the classroom spaces.35

                Onehunga School was the principal school in the area during these years and was one of the
                largest in Auckland.36 The school roll was under constant pressure from the growing
                population and the infant block was rebuilt with more classrooms after it burnt down in
                1922.37 While the main building wasn’t initially expanded, the need for more classes is
                reflected in the changing internal layout of the block. From 1919 the largest classrooms were
                progressively partitioned into separate smaller spaces so by 1952 the building was noted as

31
     Salmond Reed Architects, p. 8.
32
     ibid., p. 9.
33
     Archives New Zealand, ‘Buildings and Sites – Primary Schools – Auckland – Onehunga 1905-1925’, BCDQ A739 1050 Box
      264 b 7/11 a; Nancy Swarbrick, 'Primary and secondary education - Education from the 1920s to 2000s', Te Ara - the
      Encyclopedia of New Zealand, http://www.TeAra.govt.nz/en/primary-and-secondary-education/page-3 (accessed 14
      January 2019); Cumming, p. 640; Belich, p. 154.
34
     Archives New Zealand, ‘Buildings and Sites – Primary Schools – Auckland – Onehunga 1905-1925’, BCDQ A739 1050 Box
      264 b 7/11 a.
35
  The dental clinic was to provide care to students at Onehunga Primary School and surrounding schools in the district.
Salmond Reed Architects, p. 11; Report by Railford Gardiner, 1967, in HNZPT, ‘Application for Nomination’, Appendix 1.3,
12015-062; ; Archives New Zealand, ‘Buildings and Sites – Primary Schools – Auckland – Onehunga 1925-44’, BCDQ A739
1050 Box 264 c 7/11 2, ‘Buildings and Sites – Primary Schools – Auckland – Onehunga 1944-1966’, BCDQ A739 1050 Box 265
a 7/11 3; SN146 9000 68 13, Sourced from http://retrolens.nz and licensed by LINZ CC-BY 3.0.
36
     Salmond Reed Architects, p. 10.
37
     The new infant block was a two story brick building with six classrooms fronting Selwyn Street, south west of Onehunga
      Primary School (former). Salmond Reed Architects, p. 11.

                    Heritage New Zealand Pouhere Taonga – List Entry Review Report for a Historic Place, List No. 7109        11
containing 10 classrooms, the Headmaster’s study, a staffroom, library and cloakrooms in the
              corridors.38

              The alterations to the classroom layout affected the heating and ventilation arrangements of
              the rooms many of which were noted to receive little to no sunlight after the changes.39 In
              1939 the patent stoves had been removed and Airflow gas heating had been installed,
              however the building was still considered cold and the system was replaced again in 1955
              with a boiler located in the infant block.40 The lighting in the classrooms was deemed
              inadequate for health and safety standards and electric lighting was installed in 1960.41 At the
              same time as the lighting changes, the centre front classroom was converted into staff toilets
              and an administration office.42

              The school was periodically subject to vandalism and in 1942 a party on the porch of the
              main building had caused a small amount of fire damage requiring minor repairs.43 The belfry
              was removed from the building in 1947 due to a leak that couldn’t be located and the finials
              were also removed before 1967.44 Routine maintenance at the school continued over these
              years including a roof replacement in 1957.45 The largest change to the external structure
              came in 1968 when it was noted that many of the classrooms were smaller than the
              minimum regulated size. Three of the classrooms on the north and west sides were enlarged

38
   Ministry of Education correspondence and plans from the mid-1920s indicate that the rear west classroom was partitioned
first followed by the rear east classroom and centre front classroom were also partitioned around this time. The remaining
large classrooms were partitioned by 1967. Other methods to address overcrowding at the school included hiring local halls
for additional classes, Te Papapa School was opened in 1913 to take additional students that couldn’t be accommodated,
and all the Standard five and six students were transferred to the newly established Manukau Intermediate School in 1943.
Archives New Zealand, ‘Buildings and Sites – Primary Schools – Auckland – Onehunga 1905-1925’, BCDQ A739 1050 Box 264
b 7/11 a, ‘Buildings and Sites – Primary Schools – Auckland – Onehunga 1944-1966’, BCDQ A739 1050 Box 265 a 7/11 3;
Bridget Graham, pers. comm. 22 Jan 2019; Salmond Reed Architects, pp. 9, 13; Bade, p. 45; Onehunga Primary School
Committee, p. 10.
39
  Sir George Grey Special Collections, Auckland Libraries, 7-A4300; Sir George Grey Special Collections, Auckland Libraries,
NZG-19011130-1039-1
40
  Archives New Zealand, ‘Buildings and Sites – Primary Schools – Auckland – Onehunga 1925-44’, BCDQ A739 1050 Box 264 c
7/11 2; SN146 9000 68 13, Sourced from http://retrolens.nz and licensed by LINZ CC-BY 3.0; Bridget Graham, pers. comm. 22
Jan 2019 and 29 Jan 2019; Salmond Reed Architects, p. 12; Onehunga Primary School Committee, p. 12.
41
     Archives New Zealand, ‘Buildings and Sites – Primary Schools – Auckland – Onehunga 1944-66’, BCDQ A7391050 Box 265 a
      7/11 3
42
     Ibid.
43
     Salmond Reed Architects, p. 13.
44
     Report by Railford Gardiner, 1967, in HNZPT, ‘Application for Nomination’, Appendix
1.3, 12015-062
45
     Archives New Zealand, ‘Buildings and Sites – Primary Schools – Auckland – Onehunga 1944-66’, BCDQ A7391050 Box 265 a
      7/11 3.

               Heritage New Zealand Pouhere Taonga – List Entry Review Report for a Historic Place, List No. 7109              12
with fibrolite extensions and louvre windows and verandahs were also enclosed.46 Other
              changes to the classrooms included the installation of orange and grey carpets and Pinex wall
              boarding.47

              School Grounds and Swimming Pool

              When the building was constructed the surrounding grounds were landscaped with terraces
              and paths, and a flagpole was erected at the front of the building.48 Further terracing with
              rock retaining walls was completed in 1930 as designed by John Park, a former and future
              mayor of Onehunga.49 The improvements were partly paid for through local fundraising and a
              special grant from the Ministry of Education.50 In 1966 the damage to the walls was fixed
              along with fencing of the wider school grounds.51 In the early twentieth century the flat area
              west of the building was used as a general assembly space and playground as well as for fairs
              and bazaars. From the 1950s this space was evidently paved and used for car parking as well
              as remaining a play area.

              Following the creation of the first learner pool at Cornwall Park School in 1938, the
              Onehunga School Committee began planning for a similar pool at Onehunga Primary
              School.52 These long shallow pools were being rapidly introduced into many schools during
              the next decades as swimming and water safety were important skills for New Zealand
              children given the high rate of drowning deaths on the extensive coastline.53 In 1945 a

46
     The school committee spent $16,000 on the upgrades to the classrooms. Salmond Reed, p. 36; Onehunga Primary School
      Committee, p. 16.
47
     Friends of Onehunga Community House, ‘The Restoration Process of the Onehunga Community House 2002-2016’, as
      provided in Review application, BDG 383, HNZPT.
48
     Salmond Reed Architects, p. 7; Sir George Grey Special Collections, Auckland Libraries, NZG-19011130-1039-1; New
      Zealand Herald (NZH), 21 Nov 1901, p. 5 The terracing was completed under the guidance of the Education Board foreman
      Mr Waterman.
49
     Archives New Zealand, ‘Buildings and Sites – Primary Schools – Auckland – Onehunga 1925-44’, BCDQ A739 1050 Box 264 c
      7/11 2; Salmond Reed Architects, p. 11.
50
     After the work was completed the Board/School Committee initially had some trouble paying the full bill as the
      government refused to subsidise the donations. After legal action was threatened by the contractors a special grant was
      approved to pay the balance owed. Archives New Zealand, ‘Buildings and Sites – Primary Schools – Auckland – Onehunga
      1925-44’, BCDQ A739 1050 Box 264 c 7/11 2; Salmond Reed Architects, p. 11; NZH, 16 Dec 1929, p. 18.
51
     Archives New Zealand, ‘Buildings and Sites – Primary Schools – Auckland – Onehunga 1944-1966’, BCDQ A7391050 Box 265
      a 7/11 3.
52
     The pool at Onehunga School was first proposed in 1939 by the school committee who applied for reduced water rates for
      the water supply. Auckland Star, 26 Sep 1939, p. 4; Cornwall Park School Jubilee Committee, Cornwall Park School Golden
      Jubilee 1921-1971, 1971, p. 15.
53
     From the 1920s the government had subsidies available for taking children to local municipal pools. Swimming lessons for
      students at Onehunga before the creation of the learner pool were taught at the beach. By 1967 a third of New Zealand
      primary schools had pools that were mostly learner pools. AS, 7 Mar 1945, p. 4; David Pointon, A Dip in the Clear Blue
      Water: A History of Auckland City Swimming Baths & Pools, 1984, p. 29; D. R. Wills, Physical Education in NZ: A Brief

               Heritage New Zealand Pouhere Taonga – List Entry Review Report for a Historic Place, List No. 7109               13
learner pool was constructed immediately east of the senior block on a lower terrace for a
              total of £265, much of which had been fundraised by the students.54 The pool was large
              enough for multiple classes to use it at the same time.55 The fundraising efforts were noted in
              Parliament as an example of school/community co-operation that could be used by other
              schools to build public facilities.56 In 1958 an experimental filter was installed at the
              Onehunga pool which, after proving to be successful in maintaining clean water, was
              subsided by the government and installed at a number of other learner pools over the next
              decades.57 In 2019 the pool is still in regular use by Onehunga Primary School.

              Onehunga Primary School Community

              From the earliest days of the Onehunga District School the local community were heavily
              involved in its organisation and running.58 The Onehunga School Committee was comprised
              of local residents and had responsibility for school functions and sometimes raised loans as
              part of their role. Community contributions were also monetary through the fundraising
              efforts of the school. From 1922 Mrs R. Buchanan, a local resident, invested in a scholarship
              for Onehunga student success known as the Buchanan prize.59 In 1941 community
              participation opportunities were enhanced with the formation of one of the earliest active
              Parent-Teacher Associations (PTA) in the country.60 As well as connecting parents and
              teachers through adult education opportunities, the PTA supported the school with events
              and fundraising for items such as a new piano, as well as supplying sports uniforms and other
              school equipment.61

     Outline, 1967, pp. 10, 15; Robert A. Stothart, The Development of Physical Education in New Zealand, 1974, p. 33; Norine
     Bouchard, Untold Stories of Onehunga Vol. 2, 2004, p. 81.
54
     Salmond Reed Architects, p. 13.
55
     This space had been used in the early years of the school as a rifle range by the Onehunga cadets. The students were asked
      to raise £40 in a fortnight selling threepenny tickets and managed to raise £45 in the first five days. Some of the learner
      pools built at this time cost as little as £100, however the more expensive pools were of higher quality. Auckland Star, 3
      Mar 1943, p.4, 7 Mar 1945, p. 4.
56
     The learner pool at the school was the first pool in Onehunga. The War Memorial Pool at Jellicoe Park opened in 1956.
      Kevin Moran, The shaping of Aquatics Education in New Zealand Schools: An Historical Study of Curriculum Policy and
      Practice, MA Thesis, 1999, p. 150; Norma Williams, Between Two Lanes: A Life in Swimming, 1996, p. 72.
57
     Archives New Zealand, ‘Buildings and Sites – Primary Schools – Auckland – Onehunga 1944-66’, BCDQ A7391050 Box 265 a
      7/11 3; ‘Physical Education – Swimming – Swimming Pools 1950-1963’, BCDQ A739 1050 Box 4615 a 28/9/3;; Stothart, pp.
      43-4; Bob Stothart with Ian Culpan, For the Record – An Encyclopaedia of Historical Aspects of New Zealand Physical
      Education, 2012, p. 72.
58
     Onehunga Primary School Committee, p. 16; Cumming, pp. 22-3.
59
     Onehunga Primary School Committee, p. 18.
60
     Onehunga Primary School Committee, p. 10; Salmond Reed Architects, p. 12.
61
     Onehunga Primary School Committee, p. 17; Onehunga School PTA, PTA Minutes, 110 Nov 1941, p. 170. Salmond Reed

                Heritage New Zealand Pouhere Taonga – List Entry Review Report for a Historic Place, List No. 7109                  14
The 1950s and 1960s saw a significant demographic shift in the Onehunga community with
               an influx of Polynesians and other immigrants who came to work in the numerous factories
               that were established at Onehunga during the post-war years.62 By 1973 the school
               curriculum had expanded with cultural clubs and teaching “songs, dances and traditions of
               Maori, Samoan, and Niuean cultures as well as those that stem from […] British traditions”.63

               A number of students who attended Onehunga Primary School went on to have national and
               international success in later years. 64 These careers included politics—Alfred E Allen, John
               Rae, George Laking and Aileen Henderson; sports—Peter Wolfenden, Ramesh Patel, Peter
               Gurnick, Kevin Curtin and Jonah Lomu; medicine —Dr Murray Brennan; Music—Ricky May;
               and fine arts—Olive Emily Jones and Kevin Davies.

               From 1973 the future of the buildings at the school was in question as the main building was
               identified as needing replacement and the infant block was condemned due to it being an
               earthquake hazard.65 The Board decided to build a new school on the lower part of the site
               and retain the swimming pool as part of the new complex. The main building continued to be
               used during the period of construction (1979–1982) with a plan to demolish it after the new
               school opened. In 1980 the Principal of Onehunga Primary School, Lee Drummond, called a
               public meeting to discuss turning the building into a community house once it was no longer
               needed for classes as an alternative to demolition.66 The plan received local support and the
               building became known as Onehunga Community House in 1982 under the management of
               the Friends of Onehunga Community House Committee.67

               Onehunga Community House

               The committee expressed interest in restoring the building in the early 1980s however no
               physical changes were made. The Friends of Onehunga Community House Committee

      Architects, p. 14.
62
     Peter Verschaffelt, Onehunga Primary School Legacy and Legend – the school on the hill, 2015, p. 12. Jones, City @ Risk -
      Onehunga; Salmond Reed Architects, p. 14.
63
     Onehunga Primary School Committee, p. 15; Salmond Reed Architects, p.14.
64
     Jonah Lomu attended the school from 1980. The present school was constructed during his schooling and the swimming
      pool was retained as part of the school complex. John Parker. 'Jones, Olive Emily', Dictionary of New Zealand Biography,
      first published in 2000. Te Ara - the Encyclopedia of New Zealand, https://teara.govt.nz/en/biographies/5j7/jones-olive-
      emily (accessed 25 January 2019); Auckland Council Heritage Unit, ‘Appendix 6’, p. 50; Verschaffelt, pp. 43-70, 75-99;
      Onehunga Primary School Committee, pp. 18-19.
65
     Salmond Reed Architects, p. 15.
66
     Salmond Reed Architects, p. 16.
67
     ibid.

                Heritage New Zealand Pouhere Taonga – List Entry Review Report for a Historic Place, List No. 7109               15
formed and took over management of the building from 1992 and in 2002 the committee
              began organising and fundraising for the restoration which was completed in stages under
              the direction of conservation architect Antony Matthews.68 In 2005 a replacement belfry,
              designed to closely replicate the original, was built and added on the earthquake
              strengthened roof in the same position as at construction in 1901.69 The original school bell
              was reinstalled in the new structure. The enclosed south porch was opened and the finials
              were also remade and replaced. A new sprinkler system was installed in 2006. From 2007 to
              2014, the internal rooms were restored to their original design with most partitions, wall
              coverings and carpets removed and a ramp was built to the new main entrance door on the
              west side of the building. The louvre windows were replaced with multi-pane windows
              designed to match the remaining original ones and the removed walls were rebuilt. All lean-
              tos were removed and French doors opening onto a new central deck were added between
              the rear classrooms. The carpark west of the building was resurfaced in 2016. The total
              amount fundraised for the restoration totalled over $950,000 in early 2018.70 The Friends of
              Onehunga Community House created a museum in the small classroom in the west wing. The
              museum contains artefacts associated with New Zealand education such as early flashcards
              and books, items specific to Onehunga Primary school such as old school books and
              committee minute books, and general Onehunga history. The building is used by a wide
              range of community groups daily including yoga classes, craft groups, family gatherings, and
              public meetings.

              Associated List Entries
              N/A

68
     The Friends of Onehunga Community House Committee formed in 1992 and became an incorporated society in 1994.
      Friends of Onehunga Community House, ‘Restoration Process’; Bridget Graham and Tony Broad, pers. comm. 29 January
      2019.
69
     The original structure partly remained internally after the belfry was removed. Antony Matthews, pers. comm. 21 January
      2019; Central Leader, 7 September, 2005, p. 9; Correspondence, Tunnicliffe to Robin Byron, HNZPT Heritage Advisor
      Architecture, 26 March 2007, HNZPT file BDG 383.
70
     Review application, received 21 August 2018, HNZPT file BDG 383.

               Heritage New Zealand Pouhere Taonga – List Entry Review Report for a Historic Place, List No. 7109              16
2.2.   Physical Information

       Current Description

       Context
       Onehunga Primary School (Former) is located at Onehunga. Onehunga is a residential suburb
       on the central Auckland Isthmus on the northern edge of the Manukau Harbour. The School
       forms part of a collection of buildings associated with the development of Onehunga as a
       colonial centre including Onehunga Blockhouse, (1860, List Number 91, Category 1),
       Onehunga Post Office (1901-2, List Number 5473, Category 2), Carnegie Free Library (1911-
       12, List Number 4796, Category 1), Church of our Lady of Assumption (1887-9, List Number
       523, Category 2), St Peters Anglican Church (first constructed c1848, scheduled Auckland
       Unitary Plan, 1621). The place is opposite the Manual Training classrooms that were built to
       service schools in Onehunga District from 1920.

       The site
       The school is prominently located on the lower slopes of Maungakiekie overlooking
       Onehunga and the harbour and adjoins the present primary school on the south and east
       sides. The building is located in the centre of the generally rectangular site with the
       swimming pool in the eastern part of the site and the carpark on the west side fronting the
       road. The concreted driveway extends along the north side of the building with a raised
       garden on the boundary and grassed terraced area is located in the southern side.

       Exterior
       Onehunga Primary School (former) is a large striking building with plain kauri timber
       weatherboards and a corrugated iron roof. The building is broadly symmetrical and arranged
       along an east-west axis with a complex roof with multiple gabled elements. The main
       elevation faces south and encompasses three projecting north-south aligned gabled bays
       separated by two recessed bays with flush gables. There are also two further single story
       gable elements at the rear which are aligned east-west and are parallel to the rest of the
       building and a basement under the eastern side of the building. The prevailing form for the
       roof is gabled with connecting ridged sections.

        Heritage New Zealand Pouhere Taonga – List Entry Review Report for a Historic Place, List No. 7109   17
South Elevation
This is the main elevation and includes the three projecting bays with the recessed bays in
between. The belfry is located on the centre projecting bay which also has an additional
gablet on the east and west sides. This elevation has the highest amount of ornamentation as
it is the most prominently visible side from the main part of Onehunga. The design
incorporates a distinctive window arrangement with one or two central twelve-pane sash
windows flanked by eight-pane windows and surmounting three-pane windows. The
windows are visually emphasised with applied vertical timbering and triangular pediments.
Other elements include boxed eves with decorated brackets and finials, as well as smaller
decorated brackets supporting the window sills. Doors are located on either side of the
projecting bays beside the flush gables. On the eastern side the doors are accessed via
wooden and concrete steps while on the west side the doors are joined a wooden deck with
central steps. The base of the building has flush narrow vertical timber boards which support
the building above the downhill eastern slope. Shuttered twelve-pane sash windows are
located within the base that provide light to the basement.

West Elevation
The west elevation faces Selwyn Street and incorporates a ramp to the present main
entrance doors. The window arrangements are a mixture of the original window
arrangement and restored windows which also use twelve-pane sash windows. This elevation
is less ornamented than the southern elevation but continues the use of elements such as
the boxed eves with decorated brackets and finials, and applied vertical timbering. This
elevation has a grassed space in front of the building with the paved carpark joining the road.

North elevation
The north elevation is primarily comprised of the rear gabled elements with a fenced central
timber deck in between. There is continued use of retrained ornamentation included boxed
eves, brackets and finials. The windows are primarily twelve-pane sash windows and
surmounting three-pane windows and there are also four six-pane windows above French
doors opening onto the deck.

East elevation
This elevation is the only two story element within the building with the basement below the
eastern most part of the building. The windows are a mixture of eight and twelve-pane sash

 Heritage New Zealand Pouhere Taonga – List Entry Review Report for a Historic Place, List No. 7109   18
windows with surmounting three-pane windows and shuttered basement windows. Applied
vertical timbering is minimal and the main ornamentation is through the use of boxed eves,
decorated brackets, and finials. There is a metal staircase to the external door of the main
part of the building and four doors to access the unfloor space and basement areas in the
base of the building.

Interior
The main building of Onehunga Primary School (former) has predominantly the same interior
layout as at 1901. The restored classrooms generally have match-lined vertical kauri timber
walls and polished kauri timber floors. The ceilings of the classrooms are high pitched with
exposed rafters and iron ties. The visible remains of the spaces through which the chimneys
and ventilation were inserted through the roof remain in the rooms. The corridors are also
generally the same with match-lined walls and polished floorboards, however they have
board and batten ceilings and a dado rail along the walls. The internal walls have fan lights
between the rooms and the corridor. Each of the gable ends have sash windows. The
classroom spaces on the main floor are connected by the hallway and the layout is broadly
symmetrical and can be discussed in three parts.

-    Centre section
The centre part of the building formerly comprised of a single room that has been
partitioned. North of the partition is a classroom space with a blackboard and internal
windows, including one in the partition wall. South of the partition are the female and
handicapped toilets separated from the partition by a section of corridor which joins the east
and west corridors. The toilets have a low ceiling above them, and at the roof level is the
base of the belfry and the bell rope can be accessed from this space. On east side of the
centre room is the former teachers’ room which is presently the male toilet and on the west
side the headmaster’s room and part of the west corridor is presently a caretaker’s residence
with a kitchen, a bathroom and bedroom.

-    East Wing
The east wing comprised of the u-shaped corridor around a small classroom space and two
large classroom spaces on the north and east sides. The small and the east classrooms have
fixed blackboards and the small room is presently carpeted. The north classroom has French
doors on the west side opening onto the deck and a small kitchenette in the south east

 Heritage New Zealand Pouhere Taonga – List Entry Review Report for a Historic Place, List No. 7109   19
corner and ceramic tiles are visible on the opposite side of the wall in the corridor. The
corridor also contains two large built in cupboards.

-    West Wing
This wing also has a small classroom and a large north classroom and the west classroom has
been partitioned into two spaces. The partitioned rooms are used as a kitchen, with a sink
and other facilities, and as an office. The office contains a wall that has layers of exposed wall
decoration showing the different stages of décor since construction. There are also marks on
the floor which are associated with the now removed gallery seating present in the school
from 1901. Some marks are present also present in the north classroom which also has
French doors to the deck. The small classroom is in use for the museum collection which
includes a number of artefacts associated with Onehunga school including student exercise
books, a volume of original Onehunga School Committee Minutes (1937-1942), two volumes
of Onehunga School PTA Minutes (1944-1960, 1976-1978) as well as research into the history
of the school and former students, and a variety of records relating the management of the
place by the Onehunga Community House Committee between 1980 and 1990. The museum
also holds artefacts and furniture related to schooling in New Zealand and associated care of
children including books, word cards, chairs and desks, and a dental chair and other artefacts
related to the wider Onehunga district. The corridor contains early cloak-bay hooks beside
the kitchen door and the Buchannan boards and framed images of Onehunga are hung on
the walls.

Basement
The basement has vertical match-lining and plain ceiling and floorboards. The rooms have
timber posts with pillows under the support beams for the main rooms of the building.

Swimming Pool
The swimming pool is located immediately east of the building on a lower terrace. The pool,
which is surrounded by a galvanised steel fence, measures approximately 75ft by 17ft. The
pool has brick walls lined with a painted concrete lining. At the south side of pool is a
changing room and pool filter house constructed from concrete block and timber.

 Heritage New Zealand Pouhere Taonga – List Entry Review Report for a Historic Place, List No. 7109   20
Comparisons
Onehunga Primary School (former) is one of a small number of surviving schools built on a
large scale demonstrating the national commitment to education during the early twentieth
century, a time when the provision of education was expanding due to population growth
and legislative change associated with the Liberal Government. Built in a diverse number of
architectural of styles, other schools include Bayfield School (former), Auckland, constructed
1896-1912 (List No. 112, Category 1 historic place), Hunter Building, Wellington, constructed
1906 (List No. 221, Category 1 historic place), Auckland Girls Grammar School Main Block,
constructed 1909 (List No. 112, Category 2 historic place), St Michaels and All Angels Stone
School Building, Christchurch, constructed 1912 (List No. 1927, Category 1 historic place),
Auckland Grammar School Main Block, constructed 1916 (List No. 4471, Category 1 historic
place), and Wellington East Girls College Main Building, constructed 1923 (List No. 1445,
Category 1 historic place).

The place is one of a small number demonstrating the commitment to the primary school
education along with Bayfield School (former). Both these schools are examples of Queen
Anne style-influenced architecture which is closely connected with progressive secular
education around the world. Bayfield School was built and expanded over many years unlike
the main building at Onehunga Primary School (former) which was designed as a single
concept and built at one time. Other surviving examples of this style of architecture are
additions to schools including Karangahake School (List No. 127, Category 1 historic place),
and Cambridge Primary School (List No. 4157, Category 1 historic place).

The architectural style was also used for other state buildings during the first Liberal
Government including Dunedin Prison (Former), (List No. 4035, Category 1 historic place) and
The Bath House (former), Rotorua, (List No. 141, Category 1 historic place).

Construction Professionals
Mitchell and Watt - Architects
G.M. Handcock – Builder
Antony Matthews – Architect (Restoration)

Construction Materials
Heart Kauri Timber
Brick
Concrete

 Heritage New Zealand Pouhere Taonga – List Entry Review Report for a Historic Place, List No. 7109   21
Key Physical Dates
       1898 – Land purchased for school
       1901 – Original construction
       Pre-1919 – Rear-west classroom partitioned
       1920s – Rear-east and centre classrooms partitioned
       1930 – Grounds extensively landscaped
       1939 – Patent Stoves removed, Airflow gas heating installed
       1942 – Building damaged by fire
       1945 – Learner pool constructed
       1947 – Belfry removed
       1955 – Boiler heating system added.
       1957 – Building re-roofed
       1960 – Electric lights installed; classroom converted to staff toilets and administration office
       1968 – Building extended and verandahs enclosed
       2005-6 – External restoration work, including reconstruction of belfry
       2007-2014 – Internal restoration work, removing partitions, carpets, wall coverings; removed
       extensions and replaced louvre windows with replica sash windows.

       Uses
       Education                           School (Former)
       Civic Facilities and Recreation Community Centre

2.3.   Chattels

       This List entry includes chattels that contribute to the heritage significance of the place.

                                              Sick Bay bed

       These beds were used in New Zealand schools from at least the mid-twentieth century as sick
       bay beds. This bed is presently kept in the kitchen of the Onehunga Primary School (former)
       main building.

        Heritage New Zealand Pouhere Taonga – List Entry Review Report for a Historic Place, List No. 7109   22
2.4.   Sources
       Sources Available and Accessed
       Primary sources available include archives records relating to the place during the period that
       it was part of Onehunga School with plans and correspondence, and newspaper reports on
       PapersPast. Secondary sources include books about the history of schooling and Onehunga
       as well as reports and plans about the building and overviews of the area. Site visits were
       undertaken as well as conversation member of the Friends of Onehunga Community House
       committee.

       Further Reading
       Salmond Reed Architects, ‘Former Onehunga Primary School – Selwyn Street, Onehunga:
       Heritage Assessment’, DRAFT, 2002

       Mogford, Janice C., The Onehunga Heritage, Onehunga Borough Council, 1989.

       Onehunga Primary School Committee, Onehunga Primary School Centennial 1873-1973,
       1973.

3.     SIGNIFICANCE ASSESSMENT71
3.1.   Section 66 (1) Assessment

       This place has been assessed for, and found to possess aesthetic, architectural, historical, and
       social significance or value. It is considered that this place qualifies as part of New Zealand’s
       historic and cultural heritage.

       Aesthetic Significance or Value
       Onehunga Primary School (former) has aesthetic significance as an elaborate building of
       grand proportion which is one of Onehunga’s most prominent landmarks. The Queen Anne
       influenced exterior decoration has been enhanced with the replacement of the removed
       belfry and finials during the restoration emphasising the original design.

       Architectural Significance or Value
       Onehunga Primary School (former) has architectural significance as a visually well-preserved
       example of the use of Queen Anne influenced architecture in state buildings, particularly

               71
                 For the relevant sections of the Heritage New Zealand Pouhere Taonga Act 2014, see Appendix 4:
                Significance Assessment Information.

        Heritage New Zealand Pouhere Taonga – List Entry Review Report for a Historic Place, List No. 7109        23
schools, in New Zealand during the period of the first Liberal Government. Queen Anne style
architecture was associated with progressive ideas and was used in secular state schools
internationally. The place is representative of the wider use of this style in schools across the
country as public schooling expanded in the late nineteenth and early twentieth century. The
focus of the ornamentation on the main façade shows the importance of the visual impact of
the place on the community and demonstrates how architecture was used to convey the
priorities of the state and local communities. The original design and plan of the building has
been generally preserved. The place is also one of the last remaining grand school buildings
designed by Mitchell and Watt during their time as architects for the Auckland Board of
Education and only remaining design that was constructed at a single time. It shows their
innovations in window arrangements placed in the gable ends intended to capture more light
as well as retaining physical details related to the earliest heating and ventilation used in the
building.

Historical Significance or Value
Onehunga Primary School (former) has historical significance as a symbol of the educational
philosophies of the first Liberal Government and the development of education over the
twentieth century. Being built in 1901 and soon converted into a District High School the
place demonstrates the investment in education made by the Liberal Government and the
Auckland Education Board as well as the expansion of secondary education in the early years
of the century. The changes to the place show the changing expectations of education over
the century as classrooms and teaching methods altered. The creation of the learner pool in
1945 is also significant as part of a historic shift in expectation of access to swimming
education in the mid-twentieth century. The place also reflects the development of
Onehunga township having been constructed on a large scale that demonstrates the
importance of the settlement at the turn of the century.

Social Significance or Value
Onehunga Primary School (former) has been an important building in the Onehunga
community for well over a century since its construction. The community-initiated retention
of the place when it was threatened with demolition and subsequent re-use as a community
facility demonstrates the community’s support and commitment to their former school. The
continued fundraising and restoration of the place by the Friends of Onehunga Committee to
the present reflects the communities’ ongoing interest in the place. It remains in use for a

 Heritage New Zealand Pouhere Taonga – List Entry Review Report for a Historic Place, List No. 7109   24
You can also read