OMNICHANNEL The Future of Physical Stores - in an
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
There’s no denying that Australians love to shop in and opportunities, and in this report we look at stores. some key aspects of the future of physical retail in an omnichannel world. Before the pandemic, Australia’s largest shopping centre (Chadstone) typically attracted over 24 million visitors a year. We explore how the in-store experience can be enhanced through use of new technology, how stores can play to their But with online retail growing in both popularity and dollar strengths, and how experiential retailing can deliver a unique spend, in recent years many large Australian retailers have and compelling offer that drives customer engagement. closed their doors. On the other hand, an increasing number of pureplay online retailers are opening innovative physical stores And how can retailers measure the success of their stores in this and seeing both brand benefits and sales increases. newly integrated world? While ABS data tells us that physical retail is still the Solutions like our Retail Analytics platform bridge the data overwhelmingly dominant mode (over 90% of all retail dollars divide between online and offline to enable retailers to truly are still spent in bricks and mortar stores), Australia’s most understand what is going on in store, from dwell times to successful retailers are increasingly embracing an omnichannel demographics, and from foot traffic to conversions and so much approach, integrating their online and offline sales channels. more. Check us out at wingarc.com.au/retail to learn more. This new paradigm for retail integration brings both challenges Steve Hulse is CEO of WingArc Australia
THE GROWTH OF ONLINE SHOPPING It’s impossible to talk about the future of the store without first addressing the growing elephant in the room: the incredible rise of online shopping in recent years. Much has been written about the impact of ongoing shutdowns on shopper behaviour, and in particular on the balance between online and traditional bricks and mortar stores. But the bottom line is that in spite of everything, Australian shoppers remain remarkably committed to physical stores. Australian online shopping has undeniably undergone a stepwise increase in both engagement and frequency. The number of households who had made an online purchase of any kind went up from 75% in 2019 to 82% in 2020 – an increase of 1.36 million households.1 At the other end of the scale, the number of shoppers who purchase at least one item online every week went up from 6% in 2019 to almost 16% in 2020.2 While online shopping will surely evolve as Australia continues to experience intermittent shutdowns, the evidence to date is that growth in online shopping may have slowed. Recent ABS data indicates that the proportion of online retail sales has somewhat stabilised between January and April 2021.3 THE FUTURE OF STORES | 3
Proportion Of Total Sales Made Online 25 % 20 % 15 % 10 % 5% 0% 20 0 0 21 8 19 17 21 18 19 0 18 9 7 8 9 7 2 2 01 1 02 1 01 01 01 20 0 0 20 20 20 0 20 20 20 20 20 -2 -2 -2 -2 l-2 l-2 l-2 l-2 - n- n- n- - - - n- - pr pr pr pr ct ct ct pr ct Ju Ju Ju Ja Ja Ju Ja Ja O O O A A O A A A % of Total Australian Retail Turnover; Online Total % of Total Non-Food Sales; Online Non-Food % of Total Food Sales; Online Food Source: ABS
Looking deeper into the 9.2% of sales that in a physical store (79% down to 64%). More return to stores even while measures such as were made online, only 2.8% of these were importantly for physical stores, the proportion masks and physical distancing remaining in made by pureplay retailers (retailers who who do all or most of their shopping online place. only sell online).4 has only increased from 7% to 15%.5 Some of the positive innovations that were When asked about their perceptions of their This is in spite of the proportion shopping implemented during the pandemic may be own behaviour, Australian shoppers reflected mostly online rising to as much as 31% at the here to stay too. similar trends in terms of their split between height of the Covid-19 restrictions. in-store and online shopping. Moving forward, 44% of Australian shoppers Consumers’ continued commitment to expect new contactless click and collect or The biggest drop has been among those people physical retail is not entirely dependent on delivery features that were initiated during who formerly did most or all of their shopping a “return to normal”. Shoppers are happy to the pandemic to remain long term.6 Retail Sales: April 2021 Primary Shopping Mode 7% 15% 14% 31% 2.8% 6.4% Pureplay Omnichannel 21% Online Online 16% 79% 54% 64% 90.8% In-Store Before During After 8th Covid-19 Covid-19 May 2021 About Half in Person, Half Online All or Mostly All in Person All or Mostly Online THE FUTURE OF STORES | 5
THE VALUE OF PHYSICAL STORES Internationally, major pureplay retailers such as Amazon, Alibaba, JD.com and Wayfair have already opened multiple stores and have plans for more.7 These moves have driven both increased sales and better customer service outcomes. “The importance of stores to drive our brands is clear. In new geographic locations where we open new stores, inevitably brand awareness increases as do our digital sales The harsh reality is from those areas.” Accent Group CEO Daniel Agostinelli.8 when customers come The majority of Australia’s most successful in store we sell them more and they buy retailers are omnichannel, with 36% selling between 50% and 75% of their products in store.9 For Coles, customers who shop via both online and physical channels are 2.1 times more. more profitable than those who only purchase through one.10 A proportion of Australian retailers (21%) also believe that omnichannel is Richard Murray, CEO, JB Hi-Fi14 their customers’ top priority.11 Nearly 9 out of 10 Australian shoppers say that a retailer delivering a consistent omnichannel experience is important.12 The recent move by David Jones’ to have one executive responsible for both online and physical stores probably reflects its desire to meet that customer demand.13 THE FUTURE OF STORES | 6
I believe the biggest long-term beneficiaries of COVID will prove to be category leading brick- and-mortar retailers. Gavin S. Baker Founder, CIO & Managing Partner Atreides Management LP15 THE FUTURE OF STORES | 7
THE ONLINE For a number of years now, it has been 67% searching online before purchasing in a clear that most shoppers have adapted their physical store.16 TO IN-STORE behaviour to optimise omnichannel retailing. Nine out of ten Australians own a This has increasingly blurred the lines smartphone,17 and the majority of shoppers RELATIONSHIP between the channels. (59%) admit to using those smartphones while shopping in store. 43% of Australian shoppers have engaged in “showrooming” or visiting a physical retailer Most commonly, they are using them to to select an item and then searching online compare prices (74%), read product reviews for the best price. The opposite practice of (34%), or seek input on prospective purchases webrooming is even more popular, with from family or friends (30%).18 Main Reasons for Checking Online Before Visiting a Physical Store Having an integrated digital capability and strong store network continues to be key to 54% 51% delivering innovative and 43% high-quality customer experience. 21% Daniel Agostinelli Find Best Product Check Stock Reserve CEO, Accent Group19 Price Research Levels Click & Collect THE FUTURE OF STORES | 8
CASE STUDY: ONLINE TO BRICKS AND MORTAR I think there’s a real After 5 years growing exclusively online, furniture retailer Brosa opened its first physical showroom in 2019.20 opportunity here The showroom experience blends digital and for us to make it a physical elements. “We knew we were onto something good hub for customers to experience the brand. when customers started turning up at the studio before we even opened – the fit out was still being done.” Ivan Lim, Co-founder and CEO, Brosa Ivan Lim CEO and Co-Founder, Brosa Interior designers guide shoppers through the showroom and provide styling advice and 3D visualisations of redecorated rooms in their homes. Customers can also wonder on their own and use the QR tags to look up product details.21 THE FUTURE OF STORES | 9
IN-STORE STRENGTHS: TACTILE Being “Hands on” matters to shoppers. While trying on clothing is an obvious advantage of in-store shopping and is highly valued by 57% of shoppers, handpicking items is actually more important (67%). The associated activity of testing items before purchasing them also rates highly (46%).22 “I believe there are many experiences which are missing from an online experience. Even with all the augmented reality and virtual reality technology, customers still have this inherent need to interact or experience something.” Kevin Jiang, President of International Business for Fashion and Lifestyle, JD.com23 The ability to physically touch items is particularly important for personal care products (70%), furniture (67%), clothing (59%) and beauty products (56%). For complex electronic components like televisions and entertainment devices, where the technical specifications of the product are important, the preference for physical store purchasing falls to 49%.24 Having the ability to touch items in store is also valued by shoppers as 41% believe it reduces the likelihood of the hassle of having to return items.25 THE FUTURE OF STORES | 10
SERVICE “Shoppers want to touch and feel products, to try them on, to speak to customer support people in real life. Bricks and mortar retailers can take comfort in this and continue to provide the best in-store experiences for their customers.” Sej Patel, Country Director, The most powerful Toluna, Australia & New Zealand26 Customer service encompasses a wide range of activities, but for 50% of Australian shoppers, what they most want from store associates is extensive product knowledge. This is followed marketing lever by an awareness and willingness to check for stock availability (27%).27 we have is our Successful retailers like Mecca acknowledge this by spending twice the industry norm on in-store team members, and three times customer service the industry norm on staff education and engagement.28 and services. Store associates also have a potentially important role to play around the time of Jo Horgan CEO and Founder, Mecca31 purchase, with 42% of shoppers wanting help to get the most out of their product.29 Customer service can also have a more fundamental attraction, with 31% of shoppers valuing the human connection, and 24% valuing the connection with store staff and other shoppers that comes from physical stores.30 THE FUTURE OF STORES | 11
DESTINATION SHOPPING There are only two countries in the world that have more shopping centre space per head of population than Australia.32 For many of us, “going to the shops” is still something to look forward to, with 47% of Gen Z (under 25s) counting socialising as a reason for visiting physical stores.33 We need to create Despite the shutdowns, Westfield Living Centres recorded 450m customer visits in 2020, equating to 46m per month. The average time destinations that spent per visit was over 90 minutes.34 Recent moves by shopping centres to really enrich people’s experiences, not only diversify their appeal supports the social and recreational aspects of shopping in physical stores. For example, at the recently opened just to come and shop Westfield Coomera Living Centre, only 60% of the footprint is retail with the rest dedicated to dining, leisure & entertainment, and services.35 Shopping centres are also exploring other ways of attracting shoppers. For example, the for necessities. Springfield Orion centre in Queensland recently installed a reverse vending machine into which shoppers can receive payment for depositing Chris Barnett eligible recycling materials.36 Head of Retail, GPT Group39 AMP Capital has taken a different approach again at its Indooroopilly Shopping Centre where a large multi-brand car dealership has been established.37 Mirvac has gone further in creating “WeShow”, a specially designed space for online retailers to open physical stores.38 THE FUTURE OF STORES | 12
EXPERIENTIAL SHOPPING Experiential retail is a general term used We have fewer stores, to describe any aspect of store design or environment that attempts a deeper engagement with shoppers by activating one or but more beautiful more of the five senses. Some of these can be quite overwhelming like stores, where you can the Samsung “Black Egg” installation, where visitors’ Instagram feeds are showcased in an immersive environment. The theory is that delivering a more memorable in-store experience leads to positive have an experience. If you’re going to outcomes such as increased brand awareness, higher conversion rates and competitive differentiation. By definition, experiential retail must provide the customer with a unique experience and encourage someone to thus is it difficult to measure the direct impact over a more ‘standard’ retail environment. leave the house, then What is clear, however, is that many leading retailers are designing stores that attempt to more creatively utilise light, sound, texture, you need to make that smell, and where appropriate, taste. special. Canada Goose is one example: a clothing retailer that has designed a concept store called “The Journey”. The aim is to immerse Simon Schofield shoppers in the spirit of the outdoors, using MD, Witchery40 augmented reality to create the feeling of walking across cracking panes of ice before entering a minus 12-degree room. THE FUTURE OF STORES | 13
LOCAL SHOPPING Where People Expect to Shop More or Less in 2021 21% The shutdowns associated with the pandemic 18% forced many people to shop within a limited 16% radius of their homes. 13% 10% 10% While international online retailers, CBD and large shopping centres have all have a net negative intention, shopping locally is net positive. -11% Overall, 80% of consumers say it is important -14% -14% or very important to shop locally.41 Some of the reasons cited for this include a desire to support local businesses, as well as -25% convenience, quality and customer service. -26% -29% Metcash, which operates the iconic local IGA Online Online Local Int’l Online CBD Shopping network, directly attributes an 11.4% increase Marketplace Retailer Shops Retailer Shops Centre in sales in the quarter encompassing the shutdown to people shopping locally.42 “These types of family-owned local Reasons to Shop Locally supermarkets do tend to connect well with Reasons Not To Reasons To the community. 18% 61% Convenience Support Local 60% Business That’s because they offer more locally produced products, and the owners are 48% Help Economy usually locals who hire team members from 20% 43% Distance the community. 57% 39% Price They also tend to support more community 38% Quality events, like school fundraisers.” 37% Service Sense of Professor Gary Mortimer, a retail expert 35% Community at Queensland University of Technology’s 28% 25% Delivery Options business school 28% 18% Selection THE FUTURE OF STORES | 14
BARRIERS TO Key Online Strengths IN-STORE Stock Availability 47% SHOPPING Quick and Convenient Navigation to Products 39% Ability to see an Extended Range of Stock 29% While Australian shoppers are committed to Availability of Online Customer Reviews 23% shopping in physical stores, that does not Exclusive Offers, Memberships necessarily mean they are overly satisfied or Loyalty schemes 17% with the experience. Satisfaction with online Personalised shopping may in fact be twice as high as it is Offering 16% for in store.43 Dissatisfaction with physical stores occurs when they fail to meet expectations. There is Key In-Store Annoyances no doubt that the rise of online has both raised expectation levels and created whole new Long Wait Times criteria on which to make a judgement. for Service 54% Unhelpful Staff 58% As stores evolve and install new technology, Having to Repeat Information some of the key factors where online currently to Multiple Staff Members 51% holds an advantage may dissipate. Currently, Items out of however, it is likely that the reason shoppers Stock 53% love online shopping is because physical stores Slow can’t deliver on some aspects to the same level. Checkout 47% Disjointed Online/ In-Store Experience 26% Until some of these issues are substantially addressed, physical store shopping satisfaction is unlikely to reach the levels found online. Apart from potential cost savings, the advantages of using technology to address The retail success stories of 2022 and beyond some of these shortcomings are clear, with will be those that make it more efficient for 45% of shoppers more likely to frequent retailers that use technology to improve their consumers to get what they need using digital retail experience, and 35% expecting retailers channels, and what they want to buy via a unique to use technology in store.44 and valuable in-store experience. Karen Webster, CEO, PYMNTS45
PRODUCT SEARCH Product searching online is generally relatively easy and also helps to emphasize the wider range of products and product options, such as different sizes and colours, that may not be available in a physical store. Major retailers such as Coles, Woolworths, Chemist Warehouse, Bunnings, and Officeworks, have attempted to match this experience in store by providing staff with handheld devices to enable them to identify if an item is in stock at that store or nearby, or even when it might be back in stock. Our Bunnings product Despite this facility also being available on retailers’ smartphone apps, 42% of shoppers finder app has had want store associates to have these devices.46 really good take up, and it’s really loved US research has found that these devices can increase purchase likelihood by 43%, return visits by 12% and basket value by 81%.47 While this may be a partial solution to product search, it still requires shoppers to brief the by customers. associate, which may trigger two of the major turnoffs: unhelpful staff (58%) and having to Rob Scott repeat information to multiple people (51%).48 Managing Director, Wesfarmers49 A range of technology solutions have been developed to provide product search features in store that do not require the shopper to either consult a staff member or their own device. One of these is “smart shelves” or Electronic Shelf Labels (ESL) that replace traditional static paper price tags on shelf edges with digital labels providing pricing and product information. THE FUTURE OF STORES | 16
PERSONALISED SHOPPING Global research found that consumers will spend 48% more when their shopping experience is personalised.50 Most online retailers seek to personalise the shopper journey by making relevant product suggestions. But many larger retailers find it difficult to deliver a similar personalised service via their in-store staff. We are already Different types of technologies have been developed to address this. Some use passive observations of shopper behaviour, e.g., seeing around 80 pausing to view a product on shelf triggering relevant offers on a digital screen. Others involve using WIFI or Bluetooth to track per cent of the shoppers as they move around stores and either activate targeted digital signage (which may even recognise shopper demographics) customers identifying and/or send them offer notifications.51 Various technologies have also been embedded themselves in store. into “smart trolleys”. These can track in- store movement, but also enable customers to Shane Lenton retrieve and store information about products in real time, answer product queries, and CIO, Cue Clothing Co53 enable instant check out without waiting in the queue. Woolworths is already trialling smart trolleys with these and other shopper enablement features.52 Retailers like Cue have gone further with active systems in which shoppers identify themselves in store thus enabling more focussed offers. THE FUTURE OF STORES | 17
POST-PURCHASE ENGAGEMENT Retailers have always understood the importance of their brand. Many online retailers, particularly in fashion-related categories, have been able to create brand- driven relationships with their customers via online forums and extensive personalised eDM and social media marketing. With 72% of consumers wanting a personal relationship with their favourite brands, and 63% interested in post-purchase brand community engagements, the opportunities for physical retailers are obvious.54 One of the most well-known examples of using stores to build brand relationships are Apple stores. Their free in-store live seminars clearly address the 73% of shoppers who are seeking that particular form of engagement.55 Other tactics include Augmented and Virtual Reality-based technology: 98% of Australian retailers believe that AR will increase store foot traffic56, stating that experiential retail tactics can result in two times that number of repeat purchases.57 The huge US chain, Macy’s, for example, user VR/AR to enable shoppers to design a living space while in store with 3D images of furniture, and then virtually move through that space using a VR headset. Macy’s claims that this has increased furniture sales by 60% verses non-VR sales.58 THE FUTURE OF STORES | 18
THE GREAT DATA DIVIDE Whatever happens to the future store, one issue that bricks and mortar retailers will have to grapple with is the great data divide between online retail and offline. Online retailers have access to a wealth of data about every interaction with their site, with the ability to track not just visitor numbers but the entire customer journey from start to finish, whether or not that journey leads to a sale or an abandoned cart. In comparison, if physical retailers have any information at all, it is likely to be a much more rudimentary picture of customer behaviour. Perhaps a basic traffic count, or data from point of sale systems and the store loyalty program, both of which only tell part of the story. Here, again, new technology can play its part in levelling the playing field for in-store retail. Solutions like WingArc Retail Analytics can provide a detailed breakdown of customer activity, revealing valuable data points such as traffic trends, conversion rates, dwell times by category, and a breakdown of customer demographics. Retail Analytics can also integrate with other data sources, such as Point of Sale or loyalty program data to give a complete picture of store performance. Check us out at wingarc.com.au/retail to learn more. THE FUTURE OF STORES | 19
REFERENCES 15 https://company-announcements.afr.com/asx/adh/8ebc6617-a7a7-11eb-a82b- 968172caf8bd.pdf 16 https://mumbrella.com.au/63-of-consumers-prefer-in-store-shopping-blis- 1 https://auspost.com.au/content/dam/auspost_corp/media/documents/ecommerce- research-585127 industry-report-2021.pdf 17 http://www.roymorgan.com/findings/8032-mobile-phone-trends- 2 https://auspost.com.au/content/dam/auspost_corp/media/documents/ecommerce- march-2019-201907010451 industry-report-2021.pdf 18 https://mumbrella.com.au/63-of-consumers-prefer-in-store-shopping-blis- 3 https://www.abs.gov.au/statistics/industry/retail-and-wholesale-trade/retail- research-585127 trade-australia/apr-2021 19 https://assets.kpmg/content/dam/kpmg/au/pdf/2021/australian-retail-outlook- 4 https://www.abs.gov.au/articles/online-sales-april-2021-supplementary-covid-19- 2021-report.pdf analysis 20 https://insideretail.com.au/news/brosa-launches-second-bricks-and-mortar- 5 https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/1246/6441/files/Australia_Retail_Trends_Shopify. showroom-201911 pdf?v=1622032972 21 https://insideretail.com.au/news/brosa-breaks-new-ground-in-furniture- retailing-201909 6 https://www.retailbiz.com.au/offline-retailing/two-thirds-of-consumers-expect- in-store-safety-features-to-stay/ 22 https://www.shopassociation.org.au/news/new-research-australians-prefer- shopping-store-virtual-experiences-help-drive-online-purchases 7 https://blog.retail.org.au/newsandinsights/what-do-shoppers-want-in-a-post- pandemic-world 23 https://insideretail.com.au/e-commerce/why-this-jd-com-exec-still-believes-in- physical-retail-202102 8 https://assets.kpmg/content/dam/kpmg/au/pdf/2021/australian-retail-outlook- 2021-report.pdf 24 https://www.shopassociation.org.au/news/new-research-australians-prefer- shopping-store-virtual-experiences-help-drive-online-purchases 9 https://www.cybersource.com/content/dam/documents/en/global-digital- shopping-index-australia.pdf 25 https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/1246/6441/files/Australia_Retail_Trends_Shopify. pdf?v=1622032972 10 https://www.itnews.com.au/news/coles-charts-the-rise-of-omnichannel- shopping-561165 26 https://www.channelnews.com.au/customers-prefer-online-for-ce-shopping/ 11 https://assets.kpmg/content/dam/kpmg/au/pdf/2021/australian-retail-outlook- 27 https://blog.retail.org.au/newsandinsights/what-do-shoppers-want-in-a-post- 2021-report.pdf pandemic-world 12 https://www.manh.com/sites/default/files/sys/documents/2020/12/manh-retail- 28 https://www.cmo.com.au/article/684772/power-omnichannel-experiences-comes- 2021-vision-key-insights-retail-and-evolution-omnichannel-en-au.pdf fore-mecca/ 13 https://www.channelnews.com.au/david-jones-unites-physical-and-online- 29 https://www.rga.com/news/press-releases/australias-loyalty-crisis-new-report- stores-under-one-exec/ uncovers-a-staggering-60-of-customers-in-australia-unlikely-to-return 14 https://www.news.com.au/finance/business/retail/how-jb-hifi-wasnt-destroyed- 30 https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/1246/6441/files/Australia_Retail_Trends_Shopify. by-amazon-and-survived-lockdowns/news-story/fd4dfe7a92f099ea218b553e65341a30 pdf?v=1622032972
31 https://www.cmo.com.au/article/684772/power-omnichannel-experiences-comes- pandemic-world fore-mecca/ 47 https://insights.samsung.com/2020/01/03/5-retail-technology-trends-to-watch- 32 https://www.swinburne.edu.au/news/2020/07/what-is-the-future-of-shopping- in-2020/ centres/ 48 https://www.bandt.com.au/study-aussies-eye-bricks-mortar-return-this- 33 https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/1246/6441/files/Australia_Retail_Trends_Shopify. christmas/ pdf?v=1622032972 49 https://www.itnews.com.au/news/bunnings-group-to-re-platform-its-e- 34 https://retailbeauty.com.au/westfield-living-centres-clock-up-450-million-visits- commerce-sites-561209 in-2020/ 50 https://www.shoppingcentrenews.com.au/shopping-centre-news/top-ten-retail- 35 https://www.shoppingcentrenews.com.au/latest-news/industry-news/westfield- trends-for-2021/ coomera-opens-to-spectacular-gold-coast-crowds/ 51 https://www.retailbiz.com.au/offline-retailing/emerging-technologies-that-will- 36 https://envirobank.com.au/new-envirobank-super-kiosk-rvm-at-springfield- enhance-the-in-store-experience/ orion-shopping-centre/ 52 https://www.retailbiz.com.au/offline-retailing/emerging-technologies-that-will- 37 https://www.shoppingcentrenews.com.au/shopping-centre-news/feature-stories/ enhance-the-in-store-experience/ amp-capital-introduces-new-automall-concept/ 53 https://insideretail.com.au/business/how-cue-is-bringing-the-best-of-online-to- 38 https://www.news.com.au/finance/business/retail/radical-plan-to-save-australias- its-physical-stores-202010 shopping-centres/news-story/40bc6c6695b9c621e6e6081ce1eca458 54 https://www.rga.com/news/press-releases/australias-loyalty-crisis-new-report- 39 https://www.commercialrealestate.com.au/news/more-than-shopping-the-future- uncovers-a-staggering-60-of-customers-in-australia-unlikely-to-return of-retail-in-a-post-covid-world-8-1051414/ 55 https://www.rga.com/news/press-releases/australias-loyalty-crisis-new-report- 40 https://insideretail.com.au/stores/small-but-beautiful-inside-witcherys-store- uncovers-a-staggering-60-of-customers-in-australia-unlikely-to-return evolution-202104 56 https://www.adnews.com.au/opinion/as-shopping-habits-transform-now-is-the- 41 https://www.commbank.com.au/content/dam/commbank-assets/business/insights/ time-for-retailers-to-embrace-ar docs/consumer-insights-report_may-2021.pdf 57 https://www.pymnts.com/news/retail/2020/how-experiential-retail-is-giving- 42 https://insideretail.com.au/news/metcash-reaps-benefits-as-consumers-shop- physical-stores-an-edge/ more-locally-202008 58 https://www.retaildive.com/news/macys-expanding-vr-furniture-shopping-to- 43 https://www.pymnts.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/Global-Digital-Shopping- 90-stores-by-january/539873/ Index-December-2020.pdf 44 https://go.adyen.com/rs/222-DNK-376/images/Retail-Report-PDF-AU.pdf?utm_ medium=Social&utm_source=LinkedIn&utm_campaign=2020-CD-AU-AgilityReport- AORTG&utm_content=AgilityReport 45 https://www.pymnts.com/news/retail/2020/physical-and-digital-retail-unite-for- the-new-in-store-experience/ 46 https://blog.retail.org.au/newsandinsights/what-do-shoppers-want-in-a-post-
360 Collins Street Melbourne Victoria, 3000 Australia +61 3 9615 5200 wingarc.com.au/retail
You can also read