DRAFT FOR CONSULTATION - MAY 2018 - Heathrow Consultation
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
Page 2 Environmental Noise Directive Noise Action Plan 2019-2023 Draft © Heathrow Airport Limited 2018
CONTENTS 1 Foreword. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 2 Purpose and scope . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 3 Description of Heathrow Airport . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11 4 Background to noise and regulation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15 5 Heathrow’s framework for noise management . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25 6 Results of the 2016 Noise Mapping . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 35 7 Developing the Noise Action Plan . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 39 8 Our approach to managing noise (the Noise Action Plan) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 41 9 Evaluating the implementation and the results of the Noise Action Plan . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 49 Figures Figure 4.1 Heathrow Airport’s aircraft noise regulation and controls . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18 Figure 5.1 Framework for noise management. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25 Figure 5.2 Heathrow Airport’s noise management and control measures currently in place . . . . . . . . . . 26 Tables Table 4.1 Strength of evidence for health and quality of life effects from environmental noise . . . . . . . 16 Table 5.1 Qualification criteria for noise categories . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 27 Table 5.2 Range of current operating procedures. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 28 Table 5.3 Range of schemes that Heathrow currently offers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 29 Table 5.4 Heathrow’s stakeholder engagement forums and industry groups. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 32 Table 6.1 Comparison of 2018 predictions with 2016 outcomes. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 36 Table 6.2 Highlights of noise outcomes after second Noise Action Plan. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 36 & 37 © Heathrow Airport Limited 2018 Environmental Noise Directive Noise Action Plan 2019-2023 Draft Page 3
Page 4 Environmental Noise Directive Noise Action Plan 2019-2023 Draft © Heathrow Airport Limited 2018
1 FOREWORD Heathrow brings huge economic benefits both • Improved air conditioning facilities at our local locally and nationally – as one of the largest schools, building on from our window and single-site employers in the UK, Heathrow is Adobe building programmes. proud to provide the workplace for over 76,000 Heathrow has long been at the forefront of people, over half of whom live in Heathrow’s five international efforts to address aircraft noise and we local boroughs. Nationally, Heathrow is the UK’s know we must continue to build on this. We are global gateway and plays a big role in underpinning proud of the fact that, despite the number of the UK’s economic success, connecting regions aircraft movements at the airport going up, our across the country to over 180 destinations in noise footprint has shrunk considerably over the past 85 countries. few decades and is at the smallest it has ever been. But for all the benefits that Heathrow delivers, we To continue to drive improvements over the next know that aircraft noise remains an issue for those five years, here are some key actions we will be living around the airport. That’s why we strive to working with towards airlines, NATS and work together with our airlines, NATS (our air traffic community stakeholders: controllers), the Government and the communities • Implementation of our Quiet Night Charter themselves to manage and reduce the effects of aircraft noise. These measures are set out in our • A review of our charging structure that provides Noise Action Plan which we publish every five years. incentives to our airlines and takes account of CAA recommendations in this area The plan which follows is now the third Noise Action • A new noise insulation strategy Plan Heathrow has produced. It demonstrates the progress we’ve made striving to remain a global • Supporting and encouraging independent leader in noise management and delivering against research that will enhance our understanding of initiatives which reduce the impact of aircraft noise. how aviation affects and can improve quality of life and health outcomes near our airport Since our last action plan in 2013, we have made • New methods of detecting and communicating solid progress against the actions we have been changes to operations that might impact working towards in the last five years. This includes: residents. • The launch of our Fly Quiet and Green league table in 2013 which has been incentivising This plan goes beyond the requirements of airlines to use their quietest aircraft and best European legislation by considering actions which operational practices will manage ground and air noise for affected communities. It includes new commitments which • The noisiest Chapter 3 aircraft on the verge of are part of our sustainability leadership plan no longer being in operation at Heathrow and ‘Heathrow 2.0’ and will see us continue to deliver Chapter 14, the quietest aircraft category has progress in this key area. already reached 60.8% • A considerable effort that has seen the reduction We look forward to working closely with our local in the number of late running departures communities, airlines, NATS and policy makers to deliver our new Noise Action Plan that continues to • An investment in 52 new noise monitors with a build on our efforts to reduce the impact of noise direct data feed to the WebTrak flight from our operations. information website • The new xPlane web tool, a world first, which allows community members to analyse overhead flights, including aircraft type, movement type and height • The new features in WebTrak including a rainfall map layer and the introduction of Noise Preferential Routes to improve transparency on disruptions and flight performance • Trials of steeper climbs, slightly steeper John Holland-Kaye approaches and the detection of landing Chief Executive, Heathrow Airport Limited gear deployment © Heathrow Airport Limited 2018 Environmental Noise Directive Noise Action Plan 2019-2023 Draft Page 5
Page 6 Environmental Noise Directive Noise Action Plan 2019-2023 Draft © Heathrow Airport Limited 2018
2 PURPOSE AND SCOPE Purpose Scope The purpose of this Noise Action Plan is to comply In accordance with the requirements of the EU with the requirements of the European Union (EU) Noise Directive 2002/49/EC, this action plan makes Environmental Noise Directive 2002/49/EC (END) reference to Lden noise contours calculated on a and associated UK government regulations. decibel (dB) scale for 2016 operations. They were produced by the Environment Research Consultancy The airport operator is deemed the competent Department (ERCD), part of the CAA using the UK authority for drawing up the Noise Action Plan, civil aviation noise model ANCON (version 2.3) and which for Heathrow airport, is Heathrow Airport were published for Heathrow airport in 2017. Limited (HAL). The final adoption and approval of The contours are shown in Annex 11. the Noise Action Plan is undertaken by the Secretary of State for the Department of Food Through the actions set out in this plan, we will and Rural Affairs (DEFRA). Government guidance seek to manage aircraft noise from Heathrow’s states that noise action plans are “designed to operation. It is important to note that this manage noise issues and effects arising from Noise Action Plan only includes actions related aircraft departing from and arriving at the airport”, to developments for which the airport has “including noise reduction if necessary”. (See legal been granted planning permission and intends context page 17.) to take forward at the time of publication. The scope of this Noise Action Plan does not Heathrow has made significant progress in include a mitigation strategy or specific actions to addressing the noise challenge but recognises that deal with any new infrastructure or planned and Heathrow’s operations do result in noise impacts for permanent airspace changes. our local communities. This document sets out how we plan to manage and where possible reduce the Specifically, this means that this Noise Action Plan impact of aircraft noise. However, in some cases applies only to operations within the current responsibilities for noise management fall to the 480,000 annual movement limit on the existing DfT, NATS, CAA or Local Planning Authorities, so in two-runway system. It does not cover any those cases we are committed to recommending expansion at Heathrow. As we consider major and seeking to influence proposed changes. changes or development proposals that will affect the noise environment, we will review our plan with Our first Noise Action Plan covered the period 2010 input from the Heathrow Community Engagement to 2015 and our second, 2013 to 2018. This is our Board (HCEB), Heathrow Strategic Noise Advisory third Noise Action Plan and will cover 2019 to Group (HSNAG), the Heathrow Community Noise 2023. It has been compiled in line with DEFRA’s Forum (HCNF) and other relevant stakeholders. 2017 guidance (see Annex 2) and the main actions (Section 8) have been developed in dialogue with The legal requirement is for Heathrow Airport various groups including the Heathrow Community Limited to consider noise issues within the 55dB Lden Noise Forum (HCNF). and 50dB Lnight noise contours. These contours take into account aircraft noise during take-off, landing and ground roll. We have extended the scope of this plan by giving consideration to actions which seek to address the impacts of aircraft noise in areas beyond the specified contours as well as noise created by taxiing aircraft and engine testing carried out within the airport perimeter. © Heathrow Airport Limited 2018 Environmental Noise Directive Noise Action Plan 2019-2023 Draft Page 7
As part of our Quiet Night Charter, by 2022 we will seek to at least halve the number of flights on non-disrupted days that operate late after 23:30 Airside ultra-low emissions zone by 2025 to improve quality of life through cleaner air 50% airport passenger journeys made by public and sustainable transport by 2030, supporting no more airport-related cars on the road, so local areas can thrive without increased congestion The Noise Action Plan also aligns with Heathrow The Noise Action Plan does not include noise from 2.0, our sustainability leadership plan which was airport construction activities or noise from road launched in 2017 and sets out a clear sustainability and rail traffic associated with the airport. vision and goals for Heathrow. Within the pillar Action plans for noise associated with major road “A Great Place to Live”, Section 4 is called “Respite and rail routes are dealt with separately under for Residents – A place that is getting quieter” and government legislation and do not fall within the contains three headline goals that broadly reflect responsibility of airport operators. the five groups of actions in this plan. For information, please see • Encourage the use of the quietest aircraft www.noisemapping.defra.gov.uk available, operated with the least noise impact practicable, within an agreed noise envelope. New noise from these sources associated with any expansion of the airport would also be addressed • Influence national and international policy and through the planning and consenting process. engage with local planning authorities to ensure more effective land planning processes in noise affected areas, and to improve our noise mitigation. • Continue to improve the relationship with our local community by working more transparently and collaboratively to develop noise action plans, as well as improving our communications, monitoring and research capability. Page 8 Environmental Noise Directive Noise Action Plan 2019-2023 Draft © Heathrow Airport Limited 2018
Brexit In June 2016, the UK voted to leave the European Union and in March 2017, the UK triggered Article 50. PLACEHOLDER: Update on developments up to Dec 2018 Evaluation of Directive 2002/49/EC Relating to the Assessment and Management of Environmental Noise Final Report The Centre for Strategy & Evaluation Services LLP August – 2016 It should be noted that Heathrow when developing its Noise Action Plan strives to exceed the minimum requirements of the Environmental Noise Directive (END). For example, since 2009 we have calculated and published Lden and Lnight noise contours annually, rather than only every five years. In addition, given its importance to local residents, we have included the management of ground-based noise sources in our plan. Regardless of the status of the UK’s position in relation to EU Directives in the coming years, Heathrow is supportive of the Noise Action Plan process and the concept of a single strategic document collating aircraft noise management commitments and initiatives. As a result of this support Heathrow is committed to continuing to coordinate the management of aircraft noise in this way. © Heathrow Airport Limited 2018 Environmental Noise Directive Noise Action Plan 2019-2023 Draft Page 9
Page 10 Environmental Noise Directive Noise Action Plan 2019-2023 Draft © Heathrow Airport Limited 2018
3 DESCRIPTION OF HEATHROW AIRPORT Heathrow has two runways, four passenger Heathrow Expansion terminals and one cargo terminal with two aprons. The airport is located approximately 21 km In July 2015, the Airports Commission issued its (13 miles) west of the city of London and borders report recommending a new north-west runway suburban housing, business premises and mixed at Heathrow to secure the UK’s status as an use open land to the north and south; suburban international aviation hub. In October 2016, the housing and business premises to the east; and Government announced that a north-west runway three large reservoirs, mixed use open land, housing at Heathrow is its preferred scheme and location and business premises to the west. In 2017, there for expanding airport capacity in the South East. were just under 476,000 movements handling In February 2017, the Government published the around 78 million passengers. draft Airports National Policy Statement (ANPS) for consultation. A revised draft ANPS was published in Planned development October 2017 for further consultation and a parliamentary vote is expected in summer 2018. 2019 – 2023 and beyond Outlined below are development and expansion activities planned during the lifetime of this Noise Action Plan. Capital investment plan PLACEHOLDER Revised Draft Airports National Policy Content on infrastructure plans within existing permissions will be provided here Statement: new runway capacity and infrastructure at airports in the South East of England Presented to Parliament pursuant to Section 9(2) of the Planning Act 2008 Moving Britain Ahead October 2017 PLACEHOLDER January 2017 Add 2017 outcomes re vote and designation To get permission for the expansion of Heathrow, we have started the process of obtaining a Development Consent Order (DCO) under the Planning Act 2008. The first consultation, Consultation 1, ran from January to March 2018 and set out the project’s emerging proposals and options. A second consultation on our preferred scheme and airspace design envelopes is planned for early 2019. It is anticipated that the DCO application will be submitted in 2020 and, if it is approved in 2021, construction can start to allow operations on the new runway from 2026. © Heathrow Airport Limited 2018 Environmental Noise Directive Noise Action Plan 2019-2023 Draft Page 11
As an interim measure we are considering an Airspace change and option to raise the 480,000 ATM limit by 25,000 as part of the DCO application. Furthermore, the DCO future airspace strategy application will include plans for modifying the Much of the UK’s airspace has barely changed since taxiways of the existing northern runway to enable the 1960s, yet we have twice as many aircraft in full easterly alternation following the ending of the the skies. The airspace was designed for an age Cranford Agreement1. when aircraft were fewer and less efficient, and As explained on page 7, this plan does not cover navigation was much less sophisticated. For these the proposed expansion of the airport, the reasons, the UK’s entire airspace needs to be proposed raising of the ATM limit or the brought up to date – that is why the Government modification of taxiways on the existing northern has embarked on its “Future Airspace Strategy” runway to enable easterly alternation. (FAS) to modernise the UK’s airspace. The aim of the strategy is to make the airspace more efficient; improve punctuality; cut CO2 emissions; reduce noise from less aircraft-holding at low levels; and to ensure there is capacity to meet future demand. The FAS will require all UK airports to modernise, as well as the network that sits above these airports which is known as en-route airspace. FAS is also part of a Europe-wide modernisation project, called the Single European Sky, to make the skies above Europe more efficient. Even without a new runway, a redesigned airspace at Heathrow is required to accommodate new satellite-based Performance Based Navigation (PBN) as well as changes required for the efficient operation of a two-runway Heathrow. 1 https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/588390/17-02-01_DL_IR_Heathrow_ Hillingdon_2225774.pdf Page 12 Environmental Noise Directive Noise Action Plan 2019-2023 Draft © Heathrow Airport Limited 2018
For any airspace change the appropriate sponsor must follow the process in CAP1616 Airspace Design: Guidance on the regulatory process for changing airspace design including community engagement requirements. In the event of approval of any major development occurring which affects the existing noise situation, this Noise Action Plan would be reviewed and reissued to take any new noise mitigation measures into account. Long-term noise strategy Heathrow’s long-term noise strategy has been fundamentally the same for many years now and is essentially based on ICAO’s Balanced Approach with the addition of a “Working with Communities” pillar. This approach is not expected to change in the long-term. Section 4 of this document sets out the regulatory regime under which Heathrow manages noise and Section 5 sets out in a little more detail Heathrow’s noise management framework. Our sustainability leadership plan, Heathrow 2.0, mentioned in Section 2, sets out Heathrow’s • Clear and transparent engagement with ambition towards a future of sustainable aviation. community groups and industry stakeholders to At the heart of our ambition within Heathrow 2.0 is achieve collaborative and beneficial our commitment to manage and where possible improvements. reduce our noise impacts. We expect a number of • Promotion of a research agenda that enhances key areas of activity to be central to not only this our understanding of the impacts of aviation Noise Action Plan but future iterations. These include and the effectiveness of the interventions used the following: to reduce noise impacts. • On-going modernisation of the fleet and incentives to use aircraft with the newest noise reduction technologies. • Investigation and appropriate implementation of effective noise abatement procedures. • Airspace design and management to minimise adverse noise impacts and, where appropriate, to maximise respite for residents. • Provision of a comprehensive sound insulation scheme for the most affected houses and schools. • Continual improvement of voluntary measures especially for reducing the impacts of night operations. • Enhanced monitoring, reporting and management of all ground- and air-based noise sources. © Heathrow Airport Limited 2018 Environmental Noise Directive Noise Action Plan 2019-2023 Draft Page 13
Page 14 Environmental Noise Directive Noise Action Plan 2019-2023 Draft © Heathrow Airport Limited 2018
4 BACKGROUND TO NOISE AND REGULATION Aircraft noise Leq metric because, based on current research, it has proven to have the best correlation with associated Noise is created by aircraft approaching or taking health outcomes such as annoyance and sleep off from airports and by taxiing aircraft and engine disturbance. See Table 4.1 below. testing within the airport perimeter. In the UK, daytime aircraft noise is typically measured Airframe noise results when air passes over by calculating this average noise level in decibels (dB) the aircraft’s body (the fuselage) and its wings. over 16 hours (07:00-23:00) over the summer period This causes friction and turbulence, which make to give a single daily figure. As these Leq 16hr noise. The amount of noise created varies according contours have been used in the UK for over 30 years, to the way the plane is flown, even for identical they allow historic trends to be monitored. aircraft. Aircraft land with their flaps extended and this creates more friction (and produces more noise) In 2002 the EU Environmental Noise Directive (END) than a plane with its flaps up. provided a standardised means for mapping and assessing road, rail and air transport noise across Engine noise is created by the sound from the Europe. Member states are required to develop moving parts of the engine and by the sound of the strategic noise maps every five years based on the air being expelled at high speed once it has passed metric Lden and submit Noise Action Plans detailing through the engine. Most of the engine noise how the identified noise problems are to be comes from the exhaust or jet behind the engine as managed and mitigated over the five-year period. it mixes with the air around it, although fan and Like Leq, the noise metric Lden is also a time-averaged combustor noise from the front of the engine can noise metric with penalty weightings for noise in also be audible on the ground. the evening (19:00-23:00) and night Aircraft manufactured today are much quieter than (23:00-07:00) periods. they were 30 or even 20 years ago and this trend is Noting that research on health impacts is usually expected to continue as even quieter aircraft are based on Leq metrics, we acknowledge, however, introduced in the future. As a result, even though that most people struggle to understand how the the number of aircraft movements over the past concept of ‘average noise over a day’ relates to decade has been relatively stable, the airport noise their own individual experience. We have been contours have continued to reduce in area. working for a number of years, and most recently through the HCNF, to expand the use of Measuring and reporting noise supplementary and event-based metrics that better For many communities, aircraft noise is a series of reflect individual experiences of noise following discrete noise events of no longer than one to two feedback from community members. minutes duration, varying in noise level and The outcomes of this work can be seen in our frequency of occurrence, and spaced out over a recent annual noise contours reports (2016) which part or all of a day, with daily, weekly and monthly present data with a wide range of historic and new variation. Consequently, measuring noise, metrics, as well as our Community Noise describing its impacts and describing change are Information Reports from the new noise monitors inherently complex. Any attempt to define and located in community areas. measure noise and change has its limitations and These reports include the longstanding average cannot fully capture the spectrum of personal noise level metrics but are supplemented by other experiences of noise. Furthermore, there are many noise metrics that reflect the number of aircraft subjective effects such as perception, attitude, visual noise events above a specific sound level (e.g. impact – collectively these are sometimes labelled 65dBA Lmax), as well as westerly and easterly only “non-acoustic factors”. Nevertheless, seeking to contours, and other information such as overflight quantify noise with objective metrics is essential for maps and flight path usage statistics. The noise any efforts to manage the noise challenge. contours report can be found at https://www. There are a range of metrics which are used to heathrow.com/file_source/HeathrowNoise/Static/ describe aircraft noise and inform policy. The most Heathrow_NAP_Contours_2016_and_Summer_ common international measure of noise is the LAeq Contours_2016.pdf (often shortened to Leq). It means ‘equivalent continuous noise level.’ Most policy is based on the © Heathrow Airport Limited 2018 Environmental Noise Directive Noise Action Plan 2019-2023 Draft Page 15
4 BACKGROUND TO NOISE AND REGULATION Presented in a format developed in conjunction sources including aircraft, road traffic, railways, with the HCNF in 2017, the Community Noise construction and cumulative/combined noise. Information Reports presents data from new noise The key health and quality of life effects considered monitors located in community locations and are summarised in Table 4.1, along with the include time-averaged and event-based noise strength of evidence for that effect associated with metrics. The reports are available at https://www. aircraft noise. It can be noted that whilst noise heathrow.com/noise/reports-and-statistics/reports/ might negatively impact on some health outcomes community-noise-reports. and determinants, Government policy also acknowledges the potential health benefits of Effects of noise aviation, such as the impact of aviation on the Noise can have a significant and disruptive effect on health determinants of employment, income and everyday life. There are many different effects and education in the population. sources of noise and individuals experience each of The Government continues to research on the them to varying degrees. effects of noise on human health and Heathrow Heathrow has conducted a literature review of supports the desire to understand these effects published, peer-reviewed scientific papers that have better. We recognise that human response to noise been written by recognised experts in noise and its is extremely complex and varies between people effects on health and quality of life from across the and places and is influenced by many non-acoustic world. This review evaluated the strength of factors. We will continue to monitor government evidence for noise effects from different noise research in these areas. CURRENT KEY METRICS STRENGTH EFFECT SPECIFIC OUTCOMES USED OF THE EVIDENCE Hypertension Lden, Leq16hr Coronary Heart Disease (CHD) Cardiovascular and Sufficient Acute Myocardial Infarction (AMI) Leq 24hr Stroke Self-reported sleep Interference with falling asleep Lnight and Lmax Sufficient disturbance Awakening/Interference with staying asleep Objective sleep disturbance Awakenings Lnight and Lmax Sufficient Leq, Lden and, Reading Cognitive development for a few Sufficient Standardised test scores studies, Lmax Bothered, disturbed or annoyed by noise at Leq 24hr, Lden Annoyance Sufficient home and Ldn Leq 8hr Hearing impairment Loss in hearing (individual None at
Interdependencies The legal context – regulation of Noise & emissions aircraft noise in the UK There are interdependencies between the noise There are three main tiers of regulation which produced by aircraft, the emission of local air govern aircraft noise in the UK: International, pollutants from aircraft engines and the emission European and National. Local controls could be of carbon dioxide (CO2) from aircraft engines. considered as a fourth tier. Figure 4.1 below Finding the right balance can affect aircraft noise demonstrates the hierarchy. management strategies. Most of the technological advances in aircraft design in the last twenty years International regulation have led to both a reduction in noise and CO2 The International Civil Aviation Organisation (ICAO) emissions but a few cases have resulted in a less is a specialised agency of the United Nations, optimal performance in emissions of local air created to promote the safe and orderly pollutants such as oxides of nitrogen (NOX). development of international civil aviation There are many factors that will influence the throughout the world. It sets standards and design of aircraft and engines and the challenge recommended practices necessary for aviation for the aviation industry is to address these issues safety, security, efficiency and regularity, as well as simultaneously. for aviation environmental protection. After a Operational controls also need to be balanced. standard is adopted it is put into effect by each For example, the adoption of a reduced thrust ICAO member state in its own territories. setting for an aircraft during take-off, can reduce Noise certification standards NOX emissions by 30% or more in some cases compared to a full thrust setting. Many airlines ICAO has set progressively tighter certification already employ ‘reduced thrust’ as their standard standards for noise emissions from civil aircraft. operating procedure. Whilst this is beneficial in the Aircraft operating in member states must conform immediate vicinity of the airport, there can be a small to these standards, which are known as ‘Chapters.’ increase in the noise experienced by those further The Chapters set maximum acceptable noise levels away from the airport under the departure flight for different aircraft at three specific locations path as the aircraft decreases its angle of ascent. during landing and take-off. We have long been aware of the interdependencies The first aircraft noise standard, Chapter 2, was between noise, local air quality and CO2 emissions introduced in 1973 and aircraft in this category and have undertaken a number of studies to help have been banned from operating within the EU quantify the exact balance that needs to be struck since 1 April 2002, unless they are granted specific for specific situations. The level of scientific exemptions. Chapter 3, 4 and 14 categories were understanding of interdependencies is however introduced in the years 1977, 2001 and 2013, constantly evolving and Heathrow continues to respectively. promote further research. Since 2006, all new aircraft types have had to meet Similarly, there can be more subtle noise distribution the requirements of Chapter 4, which were set at interdependencies. With steeper climb rates, aircraft 10 decibels below that of Chapter 3 (cumulative of will be higher along their flight path and this can the margins at the three assessment points). reduce noise for communities further from the The latest noise standard Chapter 14 was agreed in airport, but it can increase noise for communities 2013. This increased stringency by 7 decibels nearer to the airport. Furthermore, some (cumulative margin) relative to Chapter 4 levels and procedures can increase noise directly below a flight became effective (for large aircraft) from 31 track but increase noise received at sideline December 2017. As with the Chapter 4 standard, locations. At Heathrow, we are conducting a study Heathrow supported efforts for an even more on the effects of these steeper climbs and we have stringent level, however we welcome the deployed almost 20 new monitors to measure continuous improvement the new standard secures. centreline and sideline noise. This will inform Heathrow’s future strategy on airspace design. The vast majority of civil aircraft now operating fall within Chapters 4 and 14. As yet, there is no © Heathrow Airport Limited 2018 Environmental Noise Directive Noise Action Plan 2019-2023 Draft Page 17
4 BACKGROUND TO NOISE AND REGULATION INTERNATIONAL United Nations International Civil Aviation Organisation Certification Balanced Approach European Union European Civil Aviation Conference EUROPEAN European Commission Directive Regulation (EU) ‘Operating European Commission Directive “Chapter 2 ban” 2006/93/EC Restrictions” No598/2014 “Environmental Noise” 2002/49 UK GOVERNMENT UK Aviation Planning Policy Acts of Parliament UK Aeronautical Policy Framework Information Publication NATIONAL Noise Policy Civil Aviation Aerodrome Aerodrome Statement for Act 1982, Regulations Regulations England 2006,2012 2003 1999 National Planning Environmental Noise Airports Act 1986 Policy Framework Regulations 2006 Local Plans Planning Conditions LOCAL Terminal 4 & 5 Figure 4.1 Heathrow Airport’s aircraft noise regulation and controls internationally agreed date for the phase-out of With the goal of addressing the noise problem in Chapter 3 aircraft, although Heathrow has set a the most cost-effective manner, ICAO has voluntary target for all movements to be Chapter 4 developed policies on each of these elements, as or 14 compliant by 2020. (See Action 1.1) well as on noise charges. Balanced Approach This approach, together with our focus on improving communication and community engagement In 2001 ICAO published the manual, A Balanced activities, forms the basis of our framework for noise Approach to Aircraft Noise Management. management described in the next section. Known as the Balanced Approach, it recommends identifying the noise problem at an airport and then analysing the various measures available to reduce European regulation noise through the exploration of four principal The EU works to define a common aviation policy elements, namely: in Europe. It has issued various regulations and • reduction at source (quieter aircraft); directives relating to the management and control of environmental issues and is increasingly • land-use planning and management; assuming responsibilityfor the regulation of • noise abatement operational procedures aircraft noise standards. Member States are (optimising how aircraft are flown and the routes obliged to comply with the requirements of the they follow to limit the noise impacts); and regulations and directives and incorporate them • operating restrictions (preventing certain noisier into national legislation. types of aircraft from flying at certain times or at The regulations and directives of most relevance to any time). aircraft noise are: Page 18 Environmental Noise Directive Noise Action Plan 2019-2023 Draft © Heathrow Airport Limited 2018
1 EC Directive 92/14/EEC replaced by EC Directive Heathrow airport’s financial incentives is available 2006/93/EC on the limitation of the operation at http://www.heathrowairport.com/about-us/ of aeroplanes covered by Part II, Chapter 2, partners-and-suppliers/conditions-of-use Volume 1 of Annex 16 to the Convention on The Act also permits airport operators to levy International Civil Aviation, second edition financial penalties on aircraft operators who (1988) – This directive banned Chapter 2 aircraft breach noise abatement requirements imposed from landing in the EU from 1 April 2002. by the Secretary of State. A sum equal to the 2 Regulation (EU) No598/2014 of the European penalties received must then be paid for the Parliament and of the Council of 16 April 2014 benefit of people who live in the vicinity of on the establishment of rules and procedures the airport. regarding the introduction of noise-related At Heathrow, we use this power to fine airlines. operating restrictions at union airports within a This money has been used for projects in the Balanced Approach and repealing Directive local community including environmental and 2002/30/EC. This ensures that the Balanced noise mitigation projects for local schools and Approach is adopted in respect of aircraft noise community groups. In 2009 we launched a management. It also sets out the definition of new large grants scheme for schools, charities marginally compliant aircraft and the process and other local groups to bid for funds of to be followed in the implementation of an up to £50,000 for community and operating restriction. environmental projects. 3 EC Directive 2002/49EC (Environmental Noise The Civil Aviation Act 2012 (the Act) was Directive or ‘END’) – This directive required designed to modernise key elements of the Member States to create strategic noise maps regulatory framework for civil aviation in the UK from all transport sources (road, rail and air) in and offers a package of reforms to make urban areas every five years and to adopt action regulation, and the sanctions which support it, plans to manage noise. The directive also aims flexible, proportionate, targeted and effective. to harmonise methods for measuring noise across the EU. It is under this directive that 2 The Aerodromes (Noise Restrictions) Heathrow has produced this Noise Action Plan. (Rules and Procedures) Regulations 2003 The Civil Aviation Act 2006 also confirms that the Acts of Parliament and regulations Secretary of State and airport operators remain subject to these regulations. These regulations The UK Government also enacts Acts of Parliament transposed the EC Directive 2002/30/EC into and regulations which deal with aircraft noise. UK law (see above). They apply to major airport The relevant legislation is detailed below: operators (i.e. above 50,000 aircraft movements 1 The Civil Aviation Acts 1982, 2006, 2012 of civil sub-sonic jet aeroplanes per year) and These Acts grant the government powers to reflect the adoption of the ICAO Balanced introduce noise control measures to limit or Approach to achieving noise objectives. mitigate the effect of noise and vibration The regulations also set out the procedures which connected with taking off or landing aircraft airports should follow when considering noise at designated airports (the Secretary of State related operating restrictions. These include: has currently designated Heathrow, Gatwick • taking into account costs and benefits of and Stansted). measures; These powers were widened by the Civil Aviation • being non-discriminatory on grounds of Act 2006. This Act also permits an airport nationality or identity of air carrier or aircraft authority to charge aircraft operators for use of manufacturer; and the airport based on noise and emissions. • being no more restrictive than necessary in Airport operators can thereby introduce order to achieve the environmental differential charges to incentivise the use of objectives for a specific airport; quieter and cleaner aircraft. We are the only airport worldwide at present that has • ensuring any performance-based operating differentiated charges for aircraft within the restrictions are based on the noise Chapter category. Information regarding performance of the aircraft as determined by ICAO certification procedures. © Heathrow Airport Limited 2018 Environmental Noise Directive Noise Action Plan 2019-2023 Draft Page 19
4 BACKGROUND TO NOISE AND REGULATION Where possible, these Regulations will now have National regulation, controls to be applied in accordance with Regulation (EU) No598/2014 of the European Parliament and policy and of the Council of 16 April 2014 (see above) Noise Policy Statement for England (NPSE) which repealed EC Directive 2002/30/EC and also relates to noise related operating The Noise Policy Statement for England (NPSE) was restrictions. Where there is a conflict, Regulation published by DEFRA in 2010 and is recognised (EU) No598/2014 will take precedence. through UK aviation noise policy. Its policy vision is to “promote good health and a good quality of life 3 The Environmental Noise (England) through the effective management of noise within Regulations 2006 – These regulations the context of Government policy on sustainable transpose the requirements of EC directive development”. The vision is supported by three 2002/49/EC (Environment Noise Directive – Noise Policy Aims: see above) into UK law. They place a duty on the Secretary of State to produce strategic noise “Through the effective management and control of maps and, under regulation 18, airport environmental, neighbour and neighbourhood operators are obliged to produce Noise Action noise within the context of Government policy on Plans based on the strategic noise maps. sustainable development: Once prepared and adopted, the Noise Action • Aim 1: avoid significant adverse impacts on Plans must be reviewed and if necessary revised health and quality of life at least every five years and whenever a major • Aim 2: mitigate and minimise adverse impacts development occurs affecting the noise on health and quality of life, and situation. The regulations were amended in • Aim 3: where possible to contribute to the both 2008 and 2009. improvement of health and quality of life.” 4 Airports Act 1986 – This Act gives power to The NPSE refers to the established concept of the the Secretary of State to make orders if it Lowest Observed Adverse Effect on health (LOAEL), appears that the existing runway capacity of which is the level above which adverse effects on the airport is not fully utilised for a substantial health and quality of life can be detected. The proportion of the time during which it is Statement then extends this concept to introduce available. It includes powers to limit the number the definition of the Significant Observed Adverse of occasions on which aircraft may land or Effect (SOAEL) as the level above which significant take off at an airport and schemes to allocate adverse effects on heath and quality of life occur. airport capacity. The NPSE does not stipulate the values of the LOAEL 5 Aeroplane Noise Regulations 1999 and SOAEL which can vary depending on noise These regulations set out the noise certificate source, receptor and time of day. This allows requirements for both propeller and jet flexibility for different policy areas such as annoyance aeroplanes registered in the UK. It makes as opposed to impact on health indicators, and the provision to ensure that no aircraft can land or ability to adapt policy in line with recent research. take off in the UK without a noise certificate issued by its competent authority which meets Aviation Policy Framework (APF) at least equal requirements to those for UK The UK government has an important role in registered aircraft. The regulations make setting and developing the policy framework for reference to noise certification standards and aircraft noise control at UK airports. In March 2013 noise limits issued by ICAO and also provides a the Government published its Aviation Policy list of aircraft that are exempt from the ICAO Framework (APF) which sets out that aviation needs noise certification. to grow delivering the benefits essential to our economic wellbeing, whilst respecting the environment and quality of life. It is underpinned by two core principles of collaboration and transparency. It aims for all stakeholders to work together to develop workable solutions based on clear and accessible information. Page 20 Environmental Noise Directive Noise Action Plan 2019-2023 Draft © Heathrow Airport Limited 2018
With respect to noise, the overall objective is to location. At the heart of the NPPF is a presumption limit and, where possible, reduce the number of in favour of sustainable development. people in the UK significantly affected by aircraft On land-use the Aviation Policy Framework (APF) noise. The APF also promotes cooperation with the “recognises that land-use planning and objective to encourage the aviation industry and management is one of the elements of the ICAO local stakeholders to strengthen and streamline the Balanced Approach which should be explored way in which they work together. when addressing noise problems at an airport. We fully support this framework and regard it as a In line with the Government’s noise policy, the foundation on which our actions can be based. Government’s National Planning Policy Framework We often go above and beyond the requirements (NPPF) says that planning policies and decisions set by Government, and are committed to working should aim to avoid situations where noise gives with them and with local communities to address rise to significant adverse impacts on health and the noise issue. quality of life as a result of new development, and to mitigate and reduce to a minimum, other The APF is expected to apply, as amended in part by adverse impacts on health and quality of life arising the Consultation Response on UK Airspace Policy from noise from new development, including (Oct 2017), until Government publishes its Aviation through the use of conditions.” Strategy in early 2019 (see ‘Evolving Government Policy’ below). The term “avoid” can include allowing dwellings in noise impacted areas that achieve suitable internal Planning policy – National Policy Planning design noise levels. Framework (NPPF) The principal mitigation measure for aircraft noise Land-use planning can play an important role in impacts for new developments is the provision of reducing the impact of aircraft noise by restricting acoustic insulation and can be required on a certain types of developments near airports such as statutory basis under section 79 of the Civil Aviation houses and schools. The National Policy Planning Act 1982 at Heathrow. In practice however, all of Framework (NPPF) came into force in March 2012 the airport’s current noise insulation schemes are and a new draft for consultation was published in provided on a voluntary basis and meet the March 2018. expectations of the APF. The NPPF sets out the Government’s planning The 2013 APF and subsequent draft policy policies for England and how these are expected to modifications in the 2017 Consultation Response be applied. It provides a framework within which on UK Airspace Policy indicate that the Government local plans can be developed which reflect expects airport operators to; community needs. • offer households exposed to levels of noise of The NPPF noise aims widely reflect those in the NPSE. 69dB Leq 16hr or more, assistance with the costs In particular, the NPPF asks that planning policies and of moving; decisions should avoid noise which could give rise to • to offer full insulation to be paid by the airport significant adverse impacts of health and quality of for homes within the 69dB Leq 16hr contour, life as a result of a new development and mitigate where the home owners do not want to move and reduce to a minimum, other adverse impacts on (added by 2017 draft policy); health and quality of life. • to offer acoustic insulation to noise-sensitive This does not explicitly prevent the construction of buildings, such as schools and hospitals, new dwellings or conversion of existing buildings. exposed to levels of noise of 63dB Leq 16hr The NPPF also aims to identify and protect areas of or more; tranquillity. Of note, the NPPF sets out that both • where acoustic insulation cannot provide an new and existing development should be protected appropriate or cost-effective solution, to offer from contributing to or being put at unacceptable alternative mitigation measures; and, risk from, or being adversely affected by unacceptable levels of soil, air, water or noise • to offer financial assistance towards acoustic pollution or land instability. It also asks to ensure insulation to residential properties exposed to that new development is appropriate for its levels of noise of 63dB Leq 16hr or more (modified by 2017 draft policy). © Heathrow Airport Limited 2018 Environmental Noise Directive Noise Action Plan 2019-2023 Draft Page 21
4 BACKGROUND TO NOISE AND REGULATION The APF document also confirms that any potential • Option analysis in airspace change proposals for new nationally significant airport • New metrics and appraisal guidance to assess development projects following any Government noise impacts decision on future recommendation(s) from the • Use of a “tier” system for categorising airspace Airports Commission would need to consider changes tailored compensation schemes where appropriate, which would be subject to separate consultation. This Airspace Consultation Response states that the The APF explains that airports may wish to use Government intends to make changes to the noise alternative criteria or have additional schemes compensation policies contained in the 2013 APF based on night noise where night flights are an via the new Aviation Strategy which, as noted issue. Airport consultative committees should be above, is still being developed. involved in reviewing schemes and invited to give While the Airspace Consultation Response makes views on the criteria to be used. clear that the Government will undertake additional Evolving Government Policy consideration of this issue in developing the Aviation Strategy, the 2013 APF and the Airspace Over the course of 2017 the Government has been Consultation Response together indicate that the consulting on aviation strategy, airspace policy and Government will expect airport operators to: expansion in the South-East and this will have implications on the APF. When policies are adopted • offer households exposed to levels of noise of by the Government some sections of this Noise 69dB Leq 16hr or more, assistance with the costs Action Plan may need to be updated. Our Action of moving; 5.17 envisages annual review and update of this • offer full insulation to be paid by the airport for Noise Action Plan actions progress or Government homes within the 69dB Leq 16hr contour, where policy changes. the home owners do not want to move (this is an additional requirement proposed in the 2017 Aviation Strategy draft Airspace Policy); The Government is developing a new Aviation • offer acoustic insulation to noise-sensitive Strategy for the UK, which will set out the long buildings, such as schools and hospitals, exposed term direction for aviation policy making to 2050 to levels of noise of 63dB Leq 16hr or more; and beyond. The latest document “Beyond the • where acoustic insulation cannot provide an Horizon – The Future of UK Aviation – Next steps appropriate or cost-effective solution, to offer towards an Aviation Strategy” (April 2018) states alternative mitigation measures; that Strategy will look at “whether the right regulations, controls and incentives are in place to • offer financial assistance towards acoustic ensure the sector continues to address noise insulation to residential properties exposed to impacts as well as tackling air quality concerns”. levels of noise of 63dB Leq 16hr or more Detailed policy proposals are expected to be regardless of the type (infrastructure or airspace) published in a green paper in the autumn of 2018, or level of change (i.e. remove requirement for a followed by a final Aviation Strategy in early 2019. minimum 3dB change) (as modified by the changes proposed in the 2017 draft Airspace Airspace Policy Policy); and In February 2017, the Government also consulted • consider compensation for significantly on its draft Airspace Policy. In October 2017, it increased overflight as a result of the change, published the document Consultation Response based on appropriate metrics which could be on UK Airspace Policy: A framework for balanced decided upon according to local circumstances decisions on the design and use of airspace and the economics of the change proposal (this (the Airspace Consultation Response) which sets is an additional requirement proposed in the out emerging government policy on related issues, 2017 draft Airspace Policy); including the following: • Changes to the noise compensation policy • The creation of an Independent Commission on Civil Aviation Noise (ICCAN) Page 22 Environmental Noise Directive Noise Action Plan 2019-2023 Draft © Heathrow Airport Limited 2018
Airports National Policy Statement Night flight restrictions Also in February and October 2017, the Following consultation in 2016, DfT published the Government held two consultations on its Draft night flight restrictions for the designated airports Airports National Policy Statement (ANPS): new (Heathrow, Gatwick & Stansted) for the period runway capacity and infrastructure at airports in the 2017-2022. The environmental objective is to South East of England. A parliamentary vote on this “limit or reduce the number of people ANPS is expected in the summer of 2018. This policy significantly affected by aircraft noise at night, (including its proposals in relation to noise and including through encouraging the use of quieter compensation) will apply to a relevant application aircraft, while maintaining the existing benefits of for development consent for expansion at Heathrow night flights”. Airport made under the Planning Act 2008. The Government set out a number of indicators to Heathrow is committed to working with the assess how well the environmental objective will be Government and Local Authorities to take into measured which include: account the principles of the NPSE, NPPF, the ICAO • the area and number of people within the Balanced Approach and other emerging aviation 48dB LAeq 6.5hr night contour; policy when it is finalised. We also aim to work • the WebTAG assessed sleep disturbance closely with local authorities on the development of impacts; their Local Plans. • the average quota count of aircraft each season; Professional Practice Guidance on Planning and, and Noise • the number of movements in the night quota In 2017 the Association of Noise Consultants period. (ANC), the Institute of Acoustics (IOA) and From October 2018, a new QC/0.125 category was Chartered Institute of Environmental Health (CIEH) introduced to reduce the number of aircraft exempt published a jointly-produced document, from the noise quota and all aircraft now count The Professional Practice Guidance on Planning & toward the airport’s movement limits. Noise quota Noise (ProPG). limits at Heathrow were reduced from 5100 to The new guidance is a blueprint for acoustic 2735 (summer) and from 4080 to 2415 (winter). practitioners, council planners and developers and For more detail see Annex 6 and the DfT Night aims to protect home dwellers from noise by flight restrictions at Heathrow, Gatwick and putting good acoustic design at the heart of all new Stansted, Decision Document. residential development. The three organisations say that if their recommendations are followed early UK Aeronautical Information Publication (AIP) in the planning process: The UK AIP is designed to be a manual containing 1 good acoustic design will enable homes to be thorough details of regulations, procedures and built in some areas previously considered other information pertinent to flying aircraft in the unsuitable because of noise; UK. It covers aspects such as Continuous Descent 2 noisy sites where residential development will Approaches (CDAs) and other noise abatement never be suitable can be quickly identified, procedures. The full range of noise abatement saving developers time and unnecessary costs; procedures in the UK AIP can be accessed at the and following link: http://www.nats-uk.ead-it.com/ 3 home building can be started much earlier on public/index.php%3Foption=com_content&task=bl sites where noise is not an issue. ogcategory&id=94&Itemid=143.html We are encouraged by this document and we would support further work with planning authorities to ensure the outcomes described. © Heathrow Airport Limited 2018 Environmental Noise Directive Noise Action Plan 2019-2023 Draft Page 23
Page 24 Environmental Noise Directive Noise Action Plan 2019-2023 Draft © Heathrow Airport Limited 2018
5 HEATHROW’S FRAMEWORK FOR NOISE MANAGEMENT In this section, we set out Heathrow’s strategy for Our first pillar, Quieter Planes, is based on the managing aviation noise, describe the measures Reduction at Source element of the Balanced currently in place and discuss the developments and Approach. Our second pillar, Quieter Procedures, outcomes as the end of Heathrow’s second Noise reflects the element of Noise Abatement Action Plan approaches. Operational Procedures. The third pillar is on Land-use Planning and Mitigation and includes Our noise strategy sound insulation and land-use, similar to ICAO’s At Heathrow we are determined to remain at the second principal element. Our fourth pillar takes forefront of international efforts to address the the Balanced Approach element on Operating challenge of aircraft noise, while continuing to Restrictions and expands it to include Voluntary safeguard the connectivity and economic benefits Measures. Our fifth pillar, Working with Local that the airport provides. Communities, goes beyond the Balanced Approach as we recognise the importance of community Our Framework for Noise Management has five engagement and collaboration in identifying and pillars as shown in Figure 5.1. The first four of these understanding issues and working towards have been developed to reflect the four principal improvements. elements of ICAO’s Balanced Approach to Aircraft Noise Management. FRAMEWORK FOR NOISE MANAGEMENT Land-use Operating Quieter Quieter restrictions and Working with planning and planes procedures voluntary measures local communities mitigation APPROACH GENERAL COMMITMENT As aircraft and technology improves and planes become quieter, we will continue to work to ensure that residents share in the benefits. We are committed to continuing to provide Quieter planes a strong financial incentive for airlines to use the quietest planes currently available, including in the early morning period, through the use of variable landing charges. We are committed to take full advantage of opportunities to manage airspace Quieter procedures differently, working with local communities to identify changes that could benefit them. This will include trialling new airspace management and operating procedures We are committed to continuing to help with noise insulation and mitigation through Land-use planning a range of schemes. We will also continue to press the Government to provide and mitigation more detailed guidance on planning around airports, and to restrict noise sensitive development in high noise areas. We do not see restrictions as a first resort and are committed to developing voluntary Operating restrictions measures through collaborative approaches. These can be quicker to implement and and voluntary measures more effective. Where restrictions are in place we are focussed on ensuring that they are adhered to fully. Underpinning all of our work to address aircraft noise, we are committed to engaging Working with local openly and constructively with local communities to understand their concerns and to communities provide accessible information and an on-going dialogue. Figure 5.1 Framework for noise management © Heathrow Airport Limited 2018 Environmental Noise Directive Noise Action Plan 2019-2023 Draft Page 25
You can also read