NATIONAL EBOLA RECOVERY STRATEGY FOR SIERRA LEONE - GOVERNMENT OF SIERRA LEONE 2015-2017
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
National Ebola Recovery Strategy for Sierra Leone acronyms A4P Agenda for Prosperity CSO civil society organization DISECS District Security Committees ECOWAS Economic Community of West African States EVD Ebola virus disease GDP gross domestic product IMF International Monetary Fund MDG Millennium Development Goal MW megawatt(s) NGO non-governmental organization PROSECS Provincial Security Committees UNDP United Nations Development Programme WASH water, sanitation and hygiene Government of Sierra Leone July 2015
3 contents Foreword 5 Executive Summary 6 1. Introduction 11 1.1. Background 11 1.2 Strategy Preparation Process 13 1.3 Structure of the Strategy Document 14 2. Economic Impact of the Ebola Crisis 14 2.1 Impact on Economic Sectors 14 Agriculture 14 Mining and Construction 15 Manufacturing 15 Transport and Tourism 16 Energy 17 Roads Infrastructure 18 2.2. Impact on Macroeconomic Aggregates 18 Inflation and Exchange Rate 18 Balance of Payments 18 Public Finances 19 Public Debt 20 Financial Sector 20 Medium-term Macroeconomic Outlook and Challenges 22 3. Social Impact of the Disease 24 3.1 Health Services 24 3.2 Education 26 3.3 Water, Sanitation and Hygiene 26 3.4 Gender, Women and Children 27 3.5 The Elderly and Disabled 27 3.6 Labour and Employment 27 3.7 Implication for Social Protection 28 4. Impact on Governance, Security and the Justice System 30 5. Lessons Learned from the Ebola Epidemic 31 6. The Recovery Strategy 32 6.1 General Objectives of the Recovery Strategy 32 6.2 Principles Guiding the Post-Ebola Recovery Strategy 33 6.3 Strategic Assumptions 35 7. Immediate Recovery Strategies 35
National Ebola Recovery Strategy for Sierra Leone 7.1 Getting to and Maintaining Zero Infections 35 7.2 Managing and Mitigating Immediate Ebola Impact in the Social Sector 36 Health Care Services 36 Water and Sanitation 36 Education 37 Gender, Children, Social Protection 37 Labour and Youth Employment 38 7.3 Restoring Economic Growth and Output 38 Strategies to Recover Agriculture 38 Strategies to Recover Fisheries 39 Strategies to Recover Tourism and Air Transport 39 Strategies to Recover Trade and Private Sector Development 39 Strategies to Recover Road Development 39 Strategies to Recover Energy Services 40 Strategies to Restore Mining Operations 40 Strategies to Increase Domestic Revenue Mobilization 40 Strategies to Recover Financial Services 40 7.4 Strategies to Strengthen Governance, Justice and Security 40 8. Building National Systems for Resilience and Sustainable Development 41 8.1 Building a Resilient Health System 41 8.2 Community Development, Trust in Public Institutions and Peacebuilding 42 8.3 Establishment of Integrated National Security and Disaster Risk Management System 42 8.4 Strengthening Implementation of Public Sector Reforms 42 8.5 Strengthening Aid Effectiveness through the New Deal and Mutual Accountability Principles 42 8.6 The Role of the Private Sector and Trust 42 8.7 Dealing with Inequalities, Especially Gender-based 43 8.8 Regional Opportunities 43 8.9 Strengthening Economic and Financial Policy Management 43 9. Preconditions Underpinning Immediate Recovery Efforts 44 10. Risk Management 45 11. Transition Arrangements 45 12. Financing and Implementation 46 Annex 1 50 Annex 2 51 Annex 3 53
5 foreword Message from the President Sierra Leone as we all know was a leading United Nations example of post-conflict recovery. This was evidenced by the closure of the UN peace mission in March 2014. As a show of resilience, we contributed troops towards peace-keeping in Africa; we became one of the fastest growing economies in the world; growth rates in real GDP stood at 15.2 percent in 2012, and 20.1 percent in 2013; and poverty dropped from 70 percent in 2003 to 52 percent before the Ebola Virus Disease struck in May 2014. These gains have been largely reversed by the Ebola outbreak, compounded by two related shocks: coincidental drop of global price of the country’s leading export commodity, iron ore; and two of the major mining companies – the African Minerals and the London Mining – suspended operations due to financial distress. The twin crisis constrained our progress and drive to achieving our collective Vision 2035 of middle income country and drastically reducing poverty. We believe all is not lost. While the disease has caused unspeakable carnage, we are encouraged that it has equally presented us with invaluable opportunities and lessons to learn. We are left to accept that our country was still fragile and that more reform efforts are needed in building public institutions. We have worked on recovery today because we have seen light at the end of the tunnel in the fight against the disease; an outcome of concerted efforts of Government, the public, and the international community. Our recovery strategy is planned for implementation within a period of 24 months, spanning July 2015 to June 2017, with the first six to nine months focusing on 1) restoring basic access to health- care; 2) getting kids back to school; 3) social protection; and 4) restoring growth through the private sector and agriculture. I am very hopeful that, with the lessons learned from this epidemic and sustained commitment from my Government and our Development Partners, this recovery programme shall heal affected communities and institutions, and build a foundation for a more resilient Sierra Leone that is better prepared to face future shocks and epidemics. We hope to quickly recover from the epidemic and reengage the Agenda for Prosperity. Let me take this opportunity to thank our Development Partners, our communities and front-line doctors and nurses, some of whom laid down their lives for God and Country. H.E. Dr. Ernest Bai Koroma President of the Republic of Sierra Leone
National Ebola Recovery Strategy for Sierra Leone executive summary A. Background Context The gross domestic product (GDP) growth rate for 2014 is estimated at 7 percent, and 1 Sierra Leone is one of three countries in the percent excluding iron ore, compared to the Mano River Union to suffer from the worst 11.3 percent projection at the beginning of recorded Ebola outbreak since the disease was the year. For 2015, the economy is projected first diagnosed in 1976 in the Democratic to contract by 23.5 percent, and by 1 percent Republic of Congo. The socio-economic excluding iron ore. Inflation rates increased impact of the disease has been devastating. modestly over the second half of 2014, while To date more than 8,000 infection cases and the monthly average exchange rate depreciated more than 3,000 deaths have been recorded. by around 13.5 percent, and the trade balance Medical personnel are among the victims, with deteriorated from US$362.3 million in 2013 to at least 295 health care workers infected and US$6.8 million. The government’s fiscal deficit 221 dead, including 11 specialized physicians. doubled to 3.8 percent of GDP (compared This is especially worrying, as these personnel with 2013), reflecting higher current spending were already in short supply. The ratio of skilled and decline in revenues (both associated with health personnel to population size has reduced EVD, although revenues were also impacted from an already low level of 17.2 personnel by the decline in iron ore revenues late in the per 10,000 people before the outbreak to the year). Despite the higher deficit, official interest current record low of 3.4 per 10,000. The rates remained low, reflecting increased system required minimum ratio is 25 per 10,000. Of liquidity from unsterilized foreign exchange the cumulative deaths, 446 are children: 222 inflows associated with the Ebola efforts. The girls and 220 boys. Orphans are estimated at fiscal position is expected to deteriorate sharply 8,345: 4,182 girls and 4,163 boys. Widows in 2015, reflecting full year effects from the are estimated at 954 and widowers at 465. same pressures, and there is an increased risk The epidemic has crowded out the effective re- of higher domestic financing costs raising debt sponse to other diseases (including traditional sustainability risks. The country’s fragility has killers such as malaria) in the national health been increased once again; the hopes embodied care system; non-Ebola illnesses certainly will in its Agenda for Prosperity (2013–2018) and have added to the death toll recorded during chances of achieving Vision 2035 have been this period. Following substantial efforts by the badly undermined. government, communities and international agencies, the disease is trending downward, with the number of new infections significantly B. Socio-economic Impact decreasing in the past couple of months, but it cannot be said to be contained until zero cases are recorded. 1. Impact on Social Services Economic growth rates have slumped since Delivery the onset of Ebola virus disease (EVD), which There has been a 23 percent decrease in health followed very strong growth rates in 2012 and service delivery. About 78 teachers are reported 2013, of 15.2 and 20.1 percent respectively. to have died, and the educational institutions The economy suffered a double shock from remain closed, with some school facilities used as the Ebola outbreak and the simultaneous Ebola holding and treatment centres. This poses sharp decline of iron ore prices that resulted a serious risk of pupils not returning to school in both iron ore companies being placed un- after the disease has been controlled, and brings der administration and a sharp curtailment a higher chance of increased teenage pregnancy. of production and revenues to government.
7 The epidemic has seen the disruption of the sequential steps: (i) getting to and maintain- implementation of water and sanitation pro- ing zero cases, (ii) implementing immediate jects. Expert personnel have fled the country recovery priorities, with a special focus on following the outbreak, and public works restoring access to basic healthcare, reopening generally have been put on hold in many parts and running of schools in a healthy environ- of the country. This can also be said for projects ment, providing social protection support, and in other social service sectors. revamping the private sector, including agricul- ture activities; and (iii) transitioning back into 2. Growth, Employment and the Agenda for Prosperity plan. Human Development It is crucial to underscore that the Agenda Revenue lost to the disease is estimated at for Prosperity (A4P) remains the defining about Le350 billion (US$74 million). There document for the overall development of the has been a significant disruption in agricultural country, despite the EVD setback, and is the activities and a decline in agricultural output. main national anchor for dealing with the The private sector has been severely affected, medium- to long-term challenges posed by the with a 50 percent decline in formal employ- disease. Lessons learned from the outbreak re- ment. Manufacturing has lost 60 percent of its inforce the need to recalibrate our development employees, and a number of new investment trajectory and ensure a robust A4P and drive to ventures have been postponed. Cross-border Vision 2035. It is also recognized that, given trade has come to a standstill. Air transport scarce resources and a multitude of spending remains handicapped, with only two carriers priorities, the recovery plans must be brought providing flights, and sea transport has been back into the prescribed public financial man- reduced. agement framework of the budget, forward es- timates, and prescribed procurement processes to ensure the necessary internal accountability, 3. Implications for Social assessment of options, transparency, and value- Protection for-money outcomes. EVD has increased levels of poverty and vul- The recovery strategy will rely on the New nerability. The situation is dire especially for Deal for Engagement in Fragile States as an women, children and the youth. To date, 3,034 implementation guide. The New Deal, to survivors have been registered, of which 750 are which Sierra Leone is a signatory, is a guide for females and 591 males. This has increased so- fragile states to attain and sustain resilience. Its cial spending pressures, while the government’s emphasis on country ownership, strengthening revenue position has been badly undermined. institutions, capacity building, and the effective use of government resources dovetail with the objectives and highlights of the report. C. Recovery Strategy 2. Preparation Process 1. Context and Objective of The Recovery Strategy preparation process the Strategy has been highly participatory, and the process continues to evolve. It draws input from the The 24 month Recovery Strategy – spanning Ebola Recovery Working Group, which com- July 2015 to June 2017 – will focus on three prises representatives from the government and
National Ebola Recovery Strategy for Sierra Leone development partners, including the private of communities; improving surveillance and sector, non-governmental organizations and health management information; ensuring the civil society. It also takes into account sector and thorough disinfection of all facilities used as ministerial consultations; inputs from national holding and treatment centres; and providing experts and international missions; the multi- for post-Ebola complications and challenges, agency Ebola Recovery Assessment; and vari- especially those associated with Ebola survivors. ous national and international socio-economic impact studies. Comments were also received 3. Access to Water and from Development Partners Committee meet- Sanitation ings and Cabinet consultations. These include provision of emergency water, The recovery strategy will rely on the New sanitation and hygiene (WASH) services to Deal for Engagement in Fragile States as an Ebola care centres; disinfection of affected com- implementation guide. The New Deal, to munities and monitoring of WASH services’ which Sierra Leone is a signatory, is a guide for functionality; restoration of water, sanitation fragile states to attain and sustain resilience. Its and hygiene service delivery in health units and emphasis on country ownership, strengthening schools; promotion of the retention of positive institutions, capacity building, and the effective health and hygiene behaviour through com- use of government resources dovetail with the munity engagement and ownership. objectives and highlights of the report. 4. Getting Kids to School D. Immediate Priorities Decontaminate educational institutions used as holding and treatment centres; repair schools to basic operational level; promote better 1. Eradication of the Disease health habits and access to water and sanita- tion; train teachers on Ebola and psychosocial Stepping up efforts to completely eradicate therapies; provide early Ebola detection devices the disease to ensure effective socio-economic and isolation facilities; engage communities recovery, through enhancing disease surveil- on child care; expand the school feeding pro- lance and contact tracing; improving infection gramme; provide incentives for pupils to return prevention and control; maintaining safe and to school; and support the most vulnerable dignified burials; deepening community en- children, including those with disabilities and gagement; increasing cross-border surveillance; girls, as well as Ebola survivors. sustaining support for mental and psychologi- cal services; and improving operational services. 5. Protection of the Most Vulnerable 2. Restoring Health Services Recovery assistance will be targeted at the most These include a review of the national health vulnerable and affected individuals – Ebola system, strengthening of health care facilities, survivors, orphans, widows and widowers – and and ensuring compliance with infection protec- interim care centres and homes will be estab- tion and control standards; leveraging existing lished. The reintegration of Ebola survivors and foreign medical teams to address immediate related health workers, including burial teams, health staff shortages; new recruitment/train- into their communities will be facilitated, and ing of health personnel; restoring the trust livelihood support provided.
9 6. Economic Sectoral Response short-term recovery programmes. The me- dium- to long-term needs shall be integrated and Prudent Macroeconomic into the Agenda for Prosperity. Policies The total cost of implementing the strategy for Provide support to the agricultural sector; full recovery for a period of 24 months – span- rebrand the country and improve its image ning July 2015 to June 2017 – is estimated through destigmatization campaigns to restore at US$1.3 billion, with a financing gap of tourism and attract private investment, as US$896.2 million. well as ensure the resumption of air and sea transport operations; provide support to the Implementation will focus on two broad strate- energy sector; resume public infrastructure gic components. Component One will focus on programmes, including road works; improve delivering four highly prioritized recovery areas the implementation of revenue collection in the first six to nine months: i) sustaining the strategies; strengthen the implementation of fight against the disease and restoring access to financial services policies and maintain appro- basic health services; ii) getting kids back to priate monetary and debt policies to stabilize school; iii) social protection; and iv) support- the financial sector. ing private sector recovery with special focus on accessing finance and supporting agricultural E. Subregional Dimension activities. These six-to-nine month initiatives have a total cost of US$306.3 million, with a This will focus on strengthening the provision current financing gap of US$102.1 million, of service delivery centres at border crossings to taking into consideration existing government stimulate cross-border trade and regional trade and in-country donor resources towards the and investment through the Growth Triangle rapid results project. In Component Two, the Framework; adopting a unified approach to government will focus the 10 to 24 months Ebola eradication and recovery; improving on three areas to sustain the recovery process: cross-border coordination on security, disease i) water and sanitation; ii) private sector de- control, and data sharing; deepening and velopment; and (iii) providing energy services broadening the scope of regional infrastructure to support and sustain the recovery. Activities projects (roads, transport and energy); and not completed in the first 6 to 9 months under ensuring a regional approach for image rebuild- Component One will be carried forward into ing, rebranding and destigmatization. the 10-to-24 month period. And recovery areas for which strategies have been identified in this F. Budgeting and programme but not prioritized for funding here Implementation Issues will be addressed within the normal national budget. and Risks 2. Existing Plan 1. Zero Infections and Full The recovery strategy will be implemented Recovery within the existing budget and medium-term expenditure frameworks, consistent with The current focus of the government is on the Agenda for Prosperity plan, including getting to and maintaining zero infections and these monitoring and evaluation arrange- the delivery of quick wins and immediate and ments; development partners’ support will be
National Ebola Recovery Strategy for Sierra Leone coordinated to ensure that they operate within pressure on suppliers and the domestic finan- the New Deal and the Mutual Accountability cial sector and resulting in higher government Framework principles; and a subregional security yields and domestic debt sustainability approach will be adopted, but with country- challenges. Further capital flight due to percep- specific implementation through sector basket tions of an ailing banking sector could add to funds. depreciation pressures on the currency, adding to macroeconomic instability and thwarting 3. Risks the recovery efforts. To mitigate some of these risks, the government will maintain the agreed The strategy will be subjected to significant International Monetary Fund programme, per- risks which, given the urgency of recovery formance criteria and structural benchmarks. efforts, will be hard to mitigate. Getting to zero and maintaining zero could take longer 4. Principles Guiding the than anticipated, which will either delay the Recovery recovery efforts or erode them. The shortage of skilled administrators and analysts in the public Thus, the key principles guiding the recovery sector could frustrate timely implementation process include building on the existing due to the limited absorptive capacity of the response capacity in the fight against the economy. Raised community expectations of disease; ensuring continued mobilization of equitable aid disbursements, if not met, could communities; strengthening sector coordina- lead to social unrest. There is a significant risk tion; ensuring an implementation recovery that unfunded budget shortfalls could develop that is effective, efficient, and accountable; and through the year, particularly if significant iron strengthening subregional coordination. ore production fails to materialize, leading to
11 1. Introduction mining, with the agricultural, construction and services sectors showing strong performance.1 Macroeconomic stability had considerably 1.1 Background improved: single-digit inflation was recorded, as well as low official interest rates and stable Sierra Leone is among the West African coun- exchange rates. The country was assessed as tries worst affected by the Ebola virus disease. having a low risk of debt distress. The country’s The disease was detected in rural Guinea in performance was encouraging not only on the February 2014 and spread to Sierra Leone growth front, but also in poverty reduction in May 2014. Since then, more than 8,000 and human development. The national poverty Sierra Leoneans have been infected, and more headcount dropped from 70 percent in 2003 to than 3,000 have died of the disease. While 52 percent before the Ebola outbreak, and the the epidemic has killed many people, mostly Human Development Index had shown signs women and children, it is especially worrying of improvement, increasing from 0.329 in 2005 that a good proportion of doctors, nurses and to 0.374 in 2013, and ranking 183rd out of other health personnel are among the fatalities. 187 in 2013.2 The strong growth performance Children have been orphaned by the disease; was accompanied by improved ratings on the schools closed down from the beginning of World Bank’s Ease of Doing Business Index, the academic year in September 2014 until as the country strove to emerge from a fragile April 2015. Over two-thirds of those infected post-conflict state. Notable progress had been are in the economically active age group. made in peace consolidation and strengthening Furthermore, the epidemic has crowded out of democratic governance and human rights. effective response to other diseases in the Considerable investment had been put into national health care system, and, as a result, public sector capacity to deliver effective and non-Ebola-related illnesses have added to the efficient public services with transparency and suffering and the death toll. accountability. These efforts all culminated in the peaceful conclusion of the second and third The disease has caused unprecedented social post-conflict democratic elections of 2007 and and humanitarian damage, accompanied by se- 2012, respectively. vere economic consequences. It has remarkably reduced the impressive gains made in economic The EVD epidemic, along with the sharp growth over the years, badly affecting farmers, decline in commodity prices that has caused traders, investors and a range of other economic the country’s two iron ore mines to be placed agents. Key economic activities – including under administration, has reversed many of agriculture, manufacturing, construction, trade these achievements. The hopes embodied in and commerce, transport, and tourism – have the Agenda for Prosperity (the third generation been disrupted, and this has significantly in- poverty reduction strategy) and the country’s creased the national unemployment rate. Vision 2035 have been badly undermined. It has wreaked untold havoc on the economic Prior to the epidemic shock, the economy of and social fabric of Sierra Leone, weakening the Sierra Leone had recovered remarkably follow- growth prospects of the economy and causing ing the end of the civil war in 2002, and was 1 Ministry of Finance and Economic Development of on a trajectory to sustainable development. Sierra Leone. Economic Bulletin 2013, Volume 19, Issue The country recorded double-digit real GDP 2, p. 3. 2 Government of Sierra Leone, UNDP, World Bank, and growth rates of 15.2 and 20.1 percent in 2012 African Development Bank. The Economic and Social and 2013, respectively, driven largely by iron ore Impact of Ebola Virus Disease in Sierra Leone: Joint Preliminary Assessment Report, p. 17.
National Ebola Recovery Strategy for Sierra Leone a rapid reversal of the gains made in manag- outbreak, pointing towards the need to ing macroeconomic stability and improving recalibrate our development trajectory and human development. This has consequently ensure a robust A4P and drive to Vision held back the government’s efforts at fighting 2035 unemployment, poverty and vulnerability. • Identifying missed opportunities and plan- ning for their exploitation, particularly the The country is confronted with numerous need to accelerate the implementation of post-Ebola challenges that demand planning structural reforms, emphasizing applica- and urgent action if the country is to (i) ensure tion of the rule of law (particularly the the timely implementation of actions to ar- public finance management laws) and rest further erosion of the development gains strengthening of regional cooperation, obtained prior to the disease outbreak, (ii) especially within the Mano River Union expedite socio-economic recovery and reduce States, on issues pertaining to health, the suffering caused by the disease, and (iii) security, management of natural resources, speedily chart a course to reclaim the path to and general subregional socio-economic sustainable development that Sierra Leone had development laid before the outbreak of the disease and the demise of the iron ore sector. It should be emphasized that this strategy was prepared when the disease was still infect- Figure 1 is a graphical representation of the ing and killing people, although it has been Agenda for Prosperity growth path along which encouragingly trending downward decisively. the country was moving, illustrating the socio- Therefore, given the unique crisis we are facing, economic disruption caused by the shock of the which necessitates planning for recovery with Ebola epidemic. The A4P remains the defining the continuity of EVD, and in order not to lose document for the overall development of the sight of the risk of complacency in the fight country despite this shock. The medium- to against the disease, we will integrate getting long-term recovery programmes will be inte- to and maintaining zero infections within the grated within the A4P, while we immediately recovery strategy. implement others to restore lost livelihoods and address heightened levels of poverty and A two-year implementation period is planned vulnerabilities due to the disease. for ending the disease and overcoming the immediate post-Ebola challenges, from June The Ebola Recovery Strategy will therefore 2015 to May 2017, while incorporating the not replicate the A4P, but repair, strengthen medium- to long-term actions within the and build on it with the following specific A4P. The success of this will depend on the objectives: efficiency and effectiveness of programme • Getting to and maintaining zero infections implementation, and calls for enhanced co- • Focusing on implementing quick-wins/ ordination and application of basic principles immediate actions for dealing with the of good governance and management. A joint current epidemic shock government–development partners committee, • Formulating and adopting strategies to with civil society participation, will be set up prevent future health and other emergen- to provide guidance on the implementation, cies of similar magnitude, as well as build- monitoring and evaluation of the immediate ing a robust health care system recovery programme within the framework of • Applying lessons learned from the the A4P.
13 Figure 1: The Ebola Recovery Strategy, Agenda for Prosperity (2013– 2018, and Vision 2035 Vision 2035 Expected Actual Development Development Path Results Post-Ebola Planned Development Path before Ebola Agenda for Prosperity (2013-2018) Ebola Agenda for Begun Response & Change Recovery Curve (2008-2012) Completed Actual Ebola Catastrophe Development Struck, May 2014 Path up to Outbreak of Ebola Time horizon Figure 1: The Ebola Recovery Strategy, the Agenda for Prosperity (2013- 2018), and Vision 2035 1.2 Strategy Preparation (UNDP) studies on the economic and social impact of Ebola on households in Sierra Leone; Process a study on the impact of Ebola on business in Sierra Leone; assessments by the International The preparation of the Sierra Leone Ebola Growth Centre; and the Ebola Recovery Recovery Strategy draws from the various Assessment done in January 2015 by the Multi- analyses carried out on the economic and social Agency Mission, comprising representatives impact of the disease by the Government of from the UN, the World Bank, the European Sierra Leone and other stakeholders. These Union, and the African Development Bank. include assessments by the Ministry of Finance and Economic Development; the ministry’s The government and the development partners various policy documents; strategic plans established the Working Group on Ebola submitted by government ministries, depart- Recovery, co-chaired by the Ministry of Finance ments and agencies for the 2015 financial year and Economic Development, UNDP, and the budget process and Medium Term Expenditure World Bank. The working group comprised Framework 2015–2017 driven by the epidem- a wide range of stakeholders, including key ic; ministerial discussions on the 2015 financial government agencies, donors, UN agencies, year budget and strategic priorities post-Ebola; non-governmental organizations (NGOs), sectoral recovery strategies; joint assessments civil society organizations (CSOs), and the by the government and development partners; private sector. It organized several meetings impact studies by the Work Bank, Statistics and technical workshops to provide inputs to Sierra Leone and International Poverty Action; the preparation of this document, including the United Nations Development Programme the identification of immediate recovery needs.
National Ebola Recovery Strategy for Sierra Leone Various other stakeholders, including interna- tional missions and national experts, have also 2. Economic Impact provided strategic inputs. of the Ebola Crisis 1.3 Structure of the 2.1 Impact on Economic Strategy Document Sectors A review of the socio-economic, governance and justice system impact of the disease is presented Agriculture in Sections 2, 3 and 4, while Section 5 presents lessons learned from the disease. Sections 6 and EVD significantly reduced agricultural and 7 discuss the recovery priorities. Strategies to food production in Sierra Leone in the second restore functionality in the national health care half of 2014 (this sector employs 70 percent system and other social sectors have been out- of the labour force and contributes to 40–45 lined alongside actions to relaunch economic percent of the GDP). The epidemic started activities to stimulate state revenue generation spreading from mid-2014 when crops were and restore viable public investments. Actions being planted and expanded during the crop to restore normal operations in the security and maintenance and critical harvesting period of justice system have also been outlined. staple crops (rice, maize and cassava). Labour shortage is the main factor that affected crop Section 8 discusses opportunities the disease production in 2014, as the traditional work has presented for building national systems for gangs were disbanded. resilience and sustainable development, identi- fying fault lines leading to the outbreak and the The total national crop production of 2.09 difficulty of containing it, and suggesting long million tons in 2014 was a decrease of about strategies to overcome weaknesses identified. five percent from production levels in 2013.1 It stresses those actions that would continue Production of the main staple crop, rice, is into the medium and long term and that will estimated to have declined by eight percent. be incorporated into the Agenda for Prosperity. The relatively low level of impact at the na- Sections 9 and 10 are devoted to discussing tional level reflects the onset of the disease in the preconditions and risks underpinning the the second half of 2014 and masks relatively implementation of the recovery programmes, high subnational production and food security with 10 discussing management of the imple- impacts. For example, the decline in rice pro- mentation risks. Section 11 discusses the tran- duction is estimated at 17 percent in Kailahun sition arrangement, including management District. Cash crop performance was also af- of a possible resurgence of the disease in the fected to the extent that, although production recovery phase, and linking medium- to long- of crops like cocoa was estimated to be normal term recovery to the A4P. Section 12 discusses in 2014, exports fell by 30 percent owing programme cost details/financing issues and largely to a reduction in cross-border trade. the implementation arrangement, including Women’s cooperatives in other rural districts monitoring and evaluation. such as Koinadugu have witnessed a decline of at least Le200 million (about US$42,000) in revenue since the disease struck.2 1 Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry, and Food Security and Food and Agriculture Organization. The Food Security Situation in the Context of Ebola Outbreak in Sierra Leone: A Rapid Assessment Report, September 2014. 2 Ibid. p. 23.
15 Generally, about 47 percent of all agricultural ore resulted in both iron ore companies being activities have been disrupted, resulting in the placed under administration in late 2014/early likelihood of the agricultural sector’s contribu- 2015. While the administrators were able to tion to GDP being negative compared with the structure a deal on the resumption of produc- earlier (March 2014) projection of a positive tion from the smaller of the two mines, the 4.6 percent contribution to real GDP growth.3 larger one remains on hold. Meanwhile, iron This has worsened the livelihoods of a consid- ore prices have continued to decline to multi- erable proportion of farm families, currently year lows (by end March 2015), which does estimated at 420,000 nationwide. Within not bode well for this subsector. the non-farm household sector, 179,000 household heads are reported to have lost jobs If iron ore production levels cannot be re- or employment since Ebola broke out. At an sumed in 2015, this will have a major adverse average of six persons per household, according impact on government revenues, GDP, and to the last national population census of 2004, the workforce and businesses connected to the livelihoods of close to 2.3 million people the sector. Similarly, the decline in world oil have been worsened by the disease. prices is likely to impact government revenues adversely through the reduction of petroleum Livestock trade dropped significantly, due license fees, although there will be some offset mostly to the restriction of movement and from the extinguishment of implicit petroleum limitation of transport services. Furthermore, consumer subsidies. Also, reports suggest that many farmers depend on wild animals as a artisanal mining, especially gold and diamond source of animal protein and income. The activities, almost ceased operations owing to outbreak has affected this source of livelihood restrictions on movement of people. following restrictive public messages on the consumption of bush meat, reinforced by com- The construction industry was buoyant prior munity by-laws. to the outbreak of Ebola, and had been crucial to poverty reduction given its labour-intensive Mining and Construction nature. It utilized unskilled labour intensively during the implementation of public and pri- Mining contributed around 27 percent of GDP vate investment programmes, particularly in 2014 and has been dominated by the iron road and building construction. The disease ore subsector over the last three to four years, has overturned this source of livelihood by which alone contributed around 24 percent.4 creating a lull in construction activities. Several Other mining operations include rutile, ilmen- road works and many other infrastructure ite, bauxite, and diamonds. Ebola has had little construction projects have been suspended. direct effect on mineral production in 2014, The construction industry is estimated to have with the main companies generally achieving declined in real terms by 10 percent in 2014. their planned production levels in that year. However, the sharp decline in the price of iron Manufacturing 3 Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry, and Food Security; Food and Agriculture Organization; World Food The small but expanding manufacturing sector Programme; and International Fund for Agricultural had been instrumental in boosting employ- Development. Agriculture Sector Post-Ebola Virus Disease ment and poverty reduction prior to the EVD Response Programme, December 2014. 4 Government of Sierra Leone, UNDP, World Bank, and outbreak. Besides its direct impact on employ- African Development Bank. The Economic and Social ment, it has had an indirect impact through Impact of Ebola Virus Disease in Sierra Leone: Joint Preliminary Assessment Report, p. 31. backward and forward linkages, bringing
National Ebola Recovery Strategy for Sierra Leone together small-scale business operators and rural Côte d’Ivoire lately), have suspended opera- farmers with large businesses within supply and tions. Travel restrictions imposed by countries value adding chains. Manufacturing enterprises around the world, including African states, had consumed intermediate inputs from other compounded the frustration of the industry. sectors in the production of beer, soft drinks, The disruption of air transport hampered cross- paint, soap, cement, foam mattresses, and so border and regional trade and reduced the sup- on, and the vast majority of street vendors ply of essential commodities, exerting upward traded in products from the manufacturing pressure on prices. It also frustrated govern- sector. The disease has seriously affected these ment efforts at fighting the disease, impeding income avenues. Bars, night clubs, cinemas and needed humanitarian assistance from abroad, related activities ceased trading in response to including essential medical supplies and staff. Ebola measures, which, coupled with the lull in Lulls in sea transport additionally hampered construction activities, resulted in a significant the movement of international traders, as the drop in demand for locally manufactured prod- disease caused a growing general scare. Sea ves- ucts. A leading manufacturing firm, the Sierra sels that maintained operations were run with Leone Brewery, which manufactures alcoholic higher costs and insurance. and non-alcoholic beverages, deferred its in- vestment plan and significantly scaled down About 70 percent of business establishments operations because of falling demand. This led attributed the “limited availability of raw ma- to a loss of about 24,000 jobs related to the terials and resale difficulties” to the limited air entertainment industry. The loss of market travel and quarantine policies, with 65 percent for agro-industry inputs upstream rendered asserting that the disease caused an increase in 22,500 persons in agriculture unemployed; transportation costs. This contributed to busi- they depended on these firms to purchase the ness reports showing significant decreases in raw materials they produced. total sales. Transport and Tourism The tourism and hospitality sector is highly vulnerable to domestic shocks, and Ebola has The recovery of domestic transport following devastated it. According to available data from the end of the civil war had supported an the National Tourist Board, tourist arrivals expanding economy, enhancing the develop- from abroad dropped by 46.1 percent in 2014 ment of supply and value chains through the compared to 2013. Foreign investors declined strengthening of forward and backward link- by 46.9 percent. A total of 50 out of 70 hotels ages, and hence the development of small-scale and 200 out 242 guest houses closed down enterprises and survival of informal economic because of the fall in occupancy, while all night operators. International transport had picked clubs totally ceased operations. This led to a 75 up impressively, supporting the revitalization percent fall in employment in the sector, from of the tourism sector and private sector devel- 4,207 people pre-Ebola to 1,051 at the end of opment. Now, all of these positive trends have 2014. Revenue generated in the sector declined been reversed by the disease. from US$58.8 million in 2013 to US$31.8 million in 2014. Some hotels managed to oper- Air transport has been particularly hit; since ate at a half-month workforce rate to cushion August 2014, all airlines, with the exception the costs of operations. of Air Maroc and Brussels Airlines (and Air
17 Energy resulted in the plant being run beyond its technical limits. Unreliable and limited energy services in urban areas and the near absence of energy A number of energy projects that were in the services in rural areas are major obstacles to an offing in the wake of the outbreak have suffered adequate response to the Ebola crisis. Many severe implementation setbacks: health centres are without light and a cold • Construction of 2.2 MW hydropower chain for medicines. The lack of street lighting plants in Charlotte and Bankasoka contributes to a worsening security situation. • Extension and rehabilitation of the low and Structural deficiencies in service delivery sys- medium voltage distribution network in tems were clearly exposed by EVD. Electricity Western Area (Islamic Development Bank access and consumption in Sierra Leone are project), and extension and rehabilitation of among the lowest in Africa. The country’s the distribution network in Freetown (Japan limited and dilapidated power infrastructure International Cooperation Agency project) (for generation, transmission and distribution) • Emergency grid works/Energy Access is a major constraint to expanding electricity Project and energy sector Utility Reform access in the country, which remains below 10 Project (World Bank) percent. Public electricity services are limited • Moyamba hydropower project (UN to selected areas, and sparse coverage and un- Industrial Development Organization) reliable service exacerbate poverty. Electricity and Betmai hydropower plant project tariffs remain among the highest in Africa, • The 128 MW thermal generation project constraining energy consumption. Because for Western Area (Copperbelt Energy of scarce supply and high costs, electricity Corporation) and electrification of 14 represents only 7 percent of the total energy district headquarter towns consumption. • Solar street light project phases 1 and 2; the Goma Hydropower Dam Extension Improving energy services will not only be Project; and the Côte d’Ivoire, Liberia, required for the containment of the crisis, but Sierra Leone and Guinea West African also for the successful economic and social Power Pool Project to cover seven districts recovery following reasonable ‘containment’. in Sierra Leone The Ebola crisis impacts the energy sector in various ways. Fiscal space for the financing of Furthermore, the installation of a new thermal infrastructure services has further decreased as power plant (Copperbelt Energy Corporation public funds were reallocated to the crisis and heavy fuel oil plant) was planned for 2016 to as financing options evaporated. There were generate additional capacity, but this is unlikely delays in the maintenance of thermal plants to materialize due to the effects of the Ebola and implementation of energy projects as expa- crisis; as such, severe power outages between triates were evacuated and external consultants March and July 2016 are projected. The crisis could not visit Sierra Leone to provide needed has also led to the deferment of studies on technical assistance. In particular, critical peri- long-term power generation options, which odic maintenance was deferred, as contractors are necessary to minimize poor investment did not visit the country during the epidemic, decisions in the future. Overall, an integrated and this resulted in the deterioration of the approach in the energy sector must address existing thermal plants at Kingtom and Black both short-term electricity supply needs in Hall Road in Freetown. In addition, the need health facilities so that these have lighting, cold to provide power throughout the outbreak chain, and other facilities, as well as support to
National Ebola Recovery Strategy for Sierra Leone improve broader electricity services to contrib- food inflation on a national basis over the sec- ute to economic and social recovery following ond half of 2014. The national inflation rate, reasonable ‘containment’. which had fallen from 8.2 percent at the end of 2013 to 6.4 percent at the end of April 2014, Roads Infrastructure rose to 7.9 percent at the end of January 2015. Road projects, including maintenance works, About 65 percent of business establishments have been interrupted since the onset of the attributed the “limited availability of raw mate- epidemic. Almost all activities in this sector rials and resale difficulties” to the rising level of came to a standstill. International contractors general prices. The depreciation in the exchange and consultants supporting operations left the rate contributed to the rise in inflation. The country following the outbreak. Restrictions of exchange rate, which had been stable between movement also affected the projects’ timelines. 2012 and the first half of 2014, depreciated by Projects in the offing, with design works com- 13.5 percent in the second half of 2014 due menced, were all postponed until the end of to foreign currency demand pressures arising the epidemic. In turn, the poor road network from Ebola-related uncertainties and essential that existed in most communities thwarted a imports (food, pharmaceutical and petroleum more robust response to the disease. products), but also from the demise of iron ore production and exports late in the year, a sharp decline in foreign investment inflows, and 2.2. Impact on maintenance of very low government security Macroeconomic yields. Aggregates To meet the increased demand for foreign cur- The combined effect of the disruptions to rency, the Bank of Sierra Leone increased its agriculture, mining, manufacturing, construc- weekly sales of forex from US$0.5 million in tion, transport and tourism, and domestic June to US$3 million in October, and carried and international trade on the GDP has been out five wholesale forex operations between substantial. Economic growth is estimated to September and December 2014 amounting have decelerated to 7 percent in 2014 from to US$30 million. Nevertheless, EVD-related a pre-Ebola projected growth rate of 11.3 donor inflows, including IMF extended credit percent. The non-iron ore economy grew by facility support, supported central bank foreign 1 percent compared to the earlier projected exchange reserves, which steadily increased growth rate of 6 percent. The deceleration was over the second half of 2014 and into 2015. magnified in the second half of 2014 given the With the demise of the iron ore sector and strong growth rates up to mid-year prior to the large financing requirements for the post-EVD EVD outbreak. recovery programme, continued donor inflows will be required to support the currency over Inflation and Exchange Rate 2015–2016. The closure of markets (lumas), internal travel Balance of Payments restrictions, and the resultant difficulty in the distribution of farm produce caused some price The improvement in the balance of payments spikes. Data indicates price spikes for the staple in 2012–2013 continued into the first half of food, rice, of up to 30 percent countrywide, 2014, reflecting both a strong iron ore–driven although there was no discernable increase in increase in export receipts and a decline in
19 imports (particularly of machinery and equip- • Secondly, government current spending ment related to the iron ore construction increased, with public funds the first line of phase). Hence, despite lower-than-projected resources for the Ebola response. In total, capital inflows, at the end of June 2014, gross the government allocated US$27 million official foreign international reserves increased (2.8 percent of expenditure) in 2014 to to US$570 million (4 months of imports) from fund Ebola-related activities. It is notable US$473 million (1.8 months of imports). that public servants have continued to be paid throughout this period at the increased The external trade balance deteriorated in rates announced in the 2015 budget. Areas the second half of 2014 on account of lower where government spending has declined iron ore export receipts and maintenance of a include domestically funded capital projects relatively high level of imports, predominately (down by around 14 percent of the planned due to EVD requirements. However, capital budget) and foreign-financed capital pro- inflows increased significantly during the same jects (down by 40 percent of the budget) period, mainly due to higher-than-anticipated as contractors and international technical budget support and Ebola-driven foreign sup- assistance ceased work and left the country. port, which resulted in some additional reserve accumulation by the central bank. Scaled-up budget support from development partners – including the African Development Public Finances Bank, World Bank, European Union and IMF – through the Extended Credit Facility While there was some moderate fiscal slippage and access augmentation played a critical role over the first half of 2014 due to some spend- in covering the financing gap. All outstand- ing overruns and shortfalls in revenue and ing bills were cleared at the end of 2014, and grants, resulting in an accumulation of unpaid advances from the central bank were reduced bills totalling about 1 percent of non-iron ore substantially below prescribed limits. While GDP, the onset of EVD greatly accelerated fis- these actions ensured that the budget was cal pressures. By the end of 2014, tax revenues adequately financed for 2014, huge challenges were down 1.5 percent of GDP and tax arrears were expected to emerge in 2015 and subse- had mounted significantly. Fiscal expenditure quent years. also declined by just over 1 percent of GDP, but higher current outlays due to higher EVD- Over 2015, revenues are expected to remain related expenditures and a higher wage bill weak, reflecting the economic slowdown (mainly for subvented agencies) were offset (particularly in the iron ore sector, which is by much lower capital expenditure. The total unrelated to the EVD crisis), lower commodity fiscal impact in 2014 was estimated at US$130 prices and associated investment flows, and million, which occurred through two channels: ongoing compliance challenges exacerbated • Firstly, the slowdown in economic activity by EVD. In contrast, fiscal expenditure to and weaker tax compliance adversely affected achieve and maintain zero infections and for domestic revenue collection. Total revenue the post-Ebola recovery efforts and resumption collected in 2014 was US$90 million below of the existing public investment programme is the pre-Ebola projection. The deterioration significant. Accordingly, in line with ongoing in international prices of iron ore also weak- IMF programmes and the commitments made ened revenues at year end. In all, state revenue following the Heavily Indebted Poor Countries loss since the beginning of the outbreak is debt forgiveness process, the government estimated at Le350 billion (US$74 million). remains committed to limiting debt financing
National Ebola Recovery Strategy for Sierra Leone and maintaining fiscal sustainability, despite The situation was also compounded by difficul- the EVD spending requirements and the col- ties experienced by the two state banks in rec- lapse of the iron ore sector. onciling a large percentage of non-performing loans. With additional foreign borrowing and Under the IMF programme formalized in April downward pressure on the currency, a key 2015, the fiscal deficit in 2015 is projected to challenge ahead is the ability of the state to decline to 3.6 percent of GDP from 3.8 percent service external debt due in 2015, 2016 and in 2014. Estimates of external financing and 2017, which is estimated at US$36.4 mil- contributions to the Ebola response amount to lion, US$42.1 million and US$49.8 million US$381 million, while domestic financing is respectively, excluding debt owed to the IMF. set at around US$90 million. Should resump- The IMF has provided debt relief support tion of iron ore exports from the larger iron ore towards the recovery effort through the New mine fail to occur from mid-2015 and if zero Catastrophe Containment and Relief Trust EVD infection rates is not achieved by the sec- Fund. But greater efforts are required to secure ond quarter of 2015, then the fiscal deficit and additional debt relief from other creditors, its financing requirements could widen further. since the IMF’s exposure is only 14.7 percent of current debt stock. A further challenge could Public Debt materialize if the financing gap is unable to be covered by foreign inflows and substantial Total public debt is estimated at US$1.49 bil- recourse to the domestic financial system is lion, of which US$1.1 billion is external. Debt warranted. If domestic liquidity were to tighten management policies and strategies since the and non-bank financial institutions were to end of the civil war have been underpinned by a continue to withdraw from the market in robust macroeconomic framework manifested government securities, any substantial increase in recent years in declining inflation rates, a in domestic financing could result in sharply stable exchange rate, declining government higher treasury bill yields, which will place security yields, and rising foreign exchange even greater strains on the budget, particularly reserve cover. Debt sustainability analyses in 2016. consistently concluded that Sierra Leone’s risk of debt distress remains moderate. Financial Sector However, the current Ebola epidemic, which In recent years, the government embarked has impacted negatively on key macroeco- on the establishment of community banks nomic indicators, poses additional challenges and financial services associations to improve to maintaining debt sustainability. The drop in access to finance for farmers and small-scale domestic revenue and increase in expenditure enterprises, especially in rural areas. Ebola has induced by the Ebola outbreak in the first seriously affected financial intermediation in couple of months resulted in a widening of the rural areas. Some bank branches in epicentres financing gap. Part of this gap was covered by temporarily suspended operations, and this increased borrowing from the domestic bank- affected trade. Some banks reported that cash ing sector. The situation was compounded by withdrawals were high at the onset of the crisis, the sharp decline in securities held by non-bank as depositors sought to convert local currency financial institutions, in part the result of the into dollars, which also contributed to the de- success in achieving lower government security preciation of the exchange rate and consequent yields resulting from high system liquidity. inflationary pressures. Some community banks and financial services associations that provided
You can also read