LOOKING INTO THE FUTURE - Royal ...
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
DECEMBER 2021 AEROSPACE LONG AND THIN ROUTES R38 DISASTER – 100 YEARS ON HAVE ‘COMEDY’ CABIN SAFETY VIDEOS GOT OUT OF HAND? www.aerosociety.com December 2021 Volume 48 Number 12 LOOKING INTO THE FUTURE THE REVOLUTIONARY JAMES WEBB Royal Aeronautical Society SPACE TELESCOPE GETS READY TO FINALLY LAUNCH
Roland Berger is helping the aerospace and aviation industries to thrive in the post-COVID era and to achieve a True Zero climate footprint. We are your trusted partner to help solve the most complex, business- critical problems. We propel companies to realise their potential and deliver realistic solutions focusing on Strategy, Sustainability, M&A and Operations. aerospace@rolandberger.com rolandberger.com
Volume 48 Number 12 December 2021 EDITORIAL Contents Worth the wait Regulars 4 Radome 12 Transmission Come 22 December, there will be many fingers, toes and other body parts The latest aviation and Your letters, emails, tweets crossed tightly around the world as the much-delayed NASA James Webb aeronautical intelligence, and social media feedback. Space Telescope (JWST) gets set to launch from French Guiana atop an Ariane analysis and comment. 54 The Last Word 5 rocket. Originally announced in 1996, the NASA, ESA and Canadian Space 11 Pushing the Envelope Keith Hayward asks whether Agency partnership JWST was meant to cost $1bn and launch in 2007 but Rob Coppinger looks at the rise in space tourism has seen its cost balloon to $9.7bn and its launch date slip to this year. That how GPS jamming can be is the best use of space countered by navigating science to reduce costs and said, its capabilities promise a treasure-trove of science that will revolutionise using visual odometry. environmental impacts. our understanding of the Universe, peering further back in cosmic time and in greater resolution than ever before. Once operational, JWST will be 100 times Features more powerful than the Hubble space telescope and promises to open up yet 22 Bill Read/RAeS Korean Air more frontiers. Yet while JWST has been waiting to launch, space technology has 14 moved on and it may be that the era of super-expensive giant space probes is coming to an end. In the future, in-orbit manufacturing will allow giant antennas and apertures to be built in space, freeing them from the constraints of surviving the G and vibration of a rocket launch, as well as needing to be folded inside a Detracting from life-saving messages? fairing. After launch, the most hazardous part of JWST’s mission will be the two Is the trend for making Testing sustainable weeks of unfolding origami-like into its deployed configuration. Second, is that technology flight safety briefings more SpaceX’s giant Starship rocket is on the horizon which not only promises heavy- Boeing’s ecoDemonstrator entertaining for passengers programme is aiming to undermining their safety lift to LEO with radically reduced kg-to-orbit costs but in-orbit refuelling and a message? improve the environmental cadence of flights that seem like science fiction. With these capabilities, Starship efficiency of aircraft and has the potential to turn the harsh equation of expensive, infrequent science airlines. 26 Safety first Making the case for investing missions on its head, allowing for humans to flood the Solar System with cheap, in airline safety in the 18 Good neighbours disposable probes built and launched en masse. JWST then, represents not only GKN Aerospace opens a new boardroom. a landmark in space science missions but perhaps represents the high water Global Technology Centre in mark of multibillion-dollar space probes, that could well give way to a new era of Filton. 28 Wendy Pritchard lower-cost nanosatellites that could explore every corner of the Solar System. Airbus Tim Robinson FRAeS, Editor-in-Chief 20 tim.robinson@aerosociety.com @RAeSTimR The R38 disaster – 100 years on Correspondence on all aerospace matters is welcome at: publications@aerosociety.com An RAeS historical lecture on Together in electric and the loss of the R38 airship over Editor-in-Chief Editorial Office 2021 AEROSPACE subscription the Humber in August 1921. Tim Robinson FRAeS Royal Aeronautical Society rates: Non-members, £190 hydrogen dreams +44 (0)20 7670 4353 No.4 Hamilton Place To place your order, contact: The UK government’s tim.robinson@aerosociety.com London W1J 7BQ, UK Wayne J Davis transport decarbonisation plan 32 Going the distance Deputy Editor +44 (0)20 7670 4300 +44 (0)20 7670 4354 and its possible impact upon The future prospects of low- publications@aerosociety.com aerosubs@aerosociety.com cost long-haul point-to-point Bill Read FRAeS traditional aerospace supply +44 (0)20 7670 4351 www.aerosociety.com Any member not requiring a print chains. travel. bill.read@aerosociety.com AEROSPACE is published by the Royal version of this magazine should Aeronautical Society (RAeS). contact: membership@aerosociety.com Production Manager Wayne J Davis FRAeS +44 (0)20 7670 4354 Chief Executive David Edwards FRAeS USA: Periodical postage paid at Champlain New York and additional Afterburner wayne.davis@aerosociety.com Advertising offices. 38 Message from our President +44 (0)20 7670 4346 Postmaster: Send address changes 39 Message from our Chief Executive Publications Executive partners@aerosociety.com to IMS of New York, PO Box 1518, Chris Male FRAeS +44 (0)20 7670 4352 Champlain NY 12919-1518, USA. 40 Book Reviews Unless specifically attributed, no chris.male@aerosociety.com material in AEROSPACE shall be taken 43 Library Additions ISSN 2052-451X Production Executive to represent the opinion of the RAeS. 44 Obituaries Annabel Hallam Reproduction of material used in this +44 (0)20 7670 4361 publication is not permitted without the 46 2021 Branches Conference annabel.hallam@aerosociety.com written consent of the Editor-in-Chief. 48 Formula Flight takes off Book Review Editors Printed by Buxton Press Limited, Tony Pilmer and Katrina Sudell Palace Road, Buxton, Derbyshire 50 New Member Spotlight book.reviews@aerosociety.com SK17 6AE, UK 51 RAeS Diary Cover: James Webb Space Telescope .(NASA) Distributed by Royal Mail 52 Elections Additional content is available to view online at: aerosociety.com/aerospaceinsight Including: Four news reports from the 2021 Dubai Air Show, Challenges to Gulf mega-carriers, The Read AEROSPACE and the Insight blog on your R38 airship disaster – 100 years on, ATR celebrates 40th anniversary, Boeing charts a greener flight smartphone or tablet with the AEROSPACE app Online path, The UK’s FlyZero project, Rolls-Royce races to set new electric aircraft speed record. APP available from iTunes and Google Play. @aerosociety i Find us on LinkedIn f Find us on Facebook www.aerosociety.com DECEMBER 2021 13
Blueprint INTELLIGENCE / ANALYSIS / COMMENT Open the pod bay doors... Another partner, Genesis Engineering Solutions, will develop the Single Person Spacecraft, allowing astronauts and space tourists to carry Orbital Reef out EVAs in a shirt-sleeve environment. Growth potential Artist’s rendering of Orbital Reef showing three core modules with large windows, as well as six additional modules, including inflatable ones. In its fully built-up configuration it will contain 90% of the living space of the ISS. Orbital Reef 4 AEROSPACE
Accessing the station Transport to and from Orbital Reef would be provided by Boeing’s CST-100 Starliner crew capsule or potentially by Sierra Space’s Dreamchaser reusable spaceplane. An orbital inclination of 51.6° to the equator at 500km will take it over launch sites in the US, Kazakhstan, India and South America. SPACEFLIGHT Orbital Reef in LEO Blue Origin, Boeing, Redwire Space and Sierra Space have announced plans for a private space station, Orbital Reef. Orbital Reef would act as a commercial business park in low Earth orbit (LEO) and is planned to be operational by the end of the decade. The station would be able to host up to ten astronauts at one time, to conduct microgravity research, filming or as a space hotel. The outpost will be constructed using Blue Origin’s New Glenn rocket launches, with crews flown to the station using Boeing Starliner capsules or potentially Sierra Space’s Dreamchaser spacecraft. DECEMBER 2021 5
Radome COVID-19 AIR TRANSPORT AEROSPACE Transatlantic flights restart Eurocontrol pushes for charges rethink British Airways A new think paper massive revenue shortfall from European ATM for European ANSP provider Eurocontrol (air navigation service has highlighted providers) which will the challenges and reach €8.6bn by the end vulnerability of the of the year, with annual European Route Charges income from airlines System which has faced falling from around €8bn significant pressure to just €3.2bn. This will during the pandemic. have to be passed on Grounded flights and no to airlines in the form of traffic due to Covid-19 higher charges in the meant that the ‘User coming years, says the Pays’ model caused a paper. AIR TRANSPORT ACI sees faster recovery but full return in 2025 Airports group ACI Europe group estimates that a full has released an updated recovery will not occur until outlook on the recovery 2025. The group also said of passenger air traffic in that Europe’s airports lost Europe, with the recovery 1.26billion passengers gathering pace thanks to in 2021, a decrease of On 8 November, the US reopened its borders to fully vaccinated passengers from an easing of pandemic -62% compared to 2019 Europe after a 20-month ban. The reopening saw British Airways flight BA001 and travel restrictions. It but volumes were up Virgin Atlantic flight VS3, both using Airbus A350s, perform a unique synchronised forecasts passenger air 70% compared to 2020. parallel take-off from London Heathrow to New York JFK to mark the end of more than travel improving from Worst affected during 600 days of pandemic travel restrictions. The long-awaited reopening of transatlantic an estimated -60% the summer season were flights between the US and Europe represents a huge boost to the airline industry this year compared to airports in the UK (-71%), with the US accounting for 40% of BA’s business. Pre-pandemic, in 2019, 22million 2019 volumes, to -32% Ireland (-68%) and Finland passengers and 900,000t of freight flew between the UK and US. in 2022. However, the (-78%). NEWS IN BRIEF propulsion but also at after sole shareholder carrier. The cause of launched from Rocket ZeroAvia has announced a retrofitting existing airliners. South African Airways the accident, which Lab’s spaceport at Mãhia partnership with Mitsubishi In addition, ZeroAvia has decided that the airline is happened shortly after Peninsula on North Island Heavy Industries RJ entered a partnership no longer viable. Mango take-off from the carrier aboard an Electron rocket, Aviation Group (MHIRJ) with Alaskan Air Group, ceased operations in mid on 17 November, is the first stage carbon-fibre to collaborate on zero- parent group of Alaska 2021 after being unable to not yet known but the booster of which was later carbon hydrogen-electric Airlines, to incorporate a pay money owed to South MoD has stated that the recovered from the Pacific propulsion for regional 3MW hydrogen-electric Africa’s Air Traffic and pilot ejected safely. The Ocean. jets. MHIRJ is the world’s powertrain into a de Navigation Services. accident is the first loss largest CRJ MRO and Havilland Canada DHC of a UK F-35B. Otto Aviation has support company, having Q400 turboprop to give it A UK Lockheed completed testing of its acquired the CRJ regional a range of 500nm. Martin F-35B fighter New Zealand-based enhanced laminar flow airliner programme has crashed into the Rocket Lab launched two Celera 500L. The aircraft from Bombardier. The Grounded South African Mediterranean Sea small BlackSky optical has now concluded 55 partnership will not only low-cost carrier Mango while flying on a routine Earth-imaging satellites tests flights with a total look at new aircraft Airlines is now not operation from the HMS into orbit on 17 November. flight time of 51hr. Otto with hydrogen-electric expected to return to flight Queen Elizabeth aircraft The satellites were is now seeking further 6 AEROSPACE
DEFENCE AEROSPACE UK seeks new private Embraer aggressors With the retirement of the Training (ORT) aerial support Hawk T1/T1A training service tender, issued on aircraft now brought forward 29 October, includes a from 2030 to 2022, the requirement for air-to-air, UK Ministry of Defence is target, threat simulation, seeking a new contractor- and mission augmentation Embraer reveals based aviation training service from the third quarter training. Meanwhile, Affinity net zero family of 2022, following the Flying Training Services Embraer has revealed a new family of four sustainable concept aircraft to reach its target collapse of the Air Support to has been awarded a £65m of achieving net zero carbon emissions by 2050. Each aircraft is fitted with a different Defence Operational Training 12-year contract from the propulsion system and fuel type, comprising the nine-seat hybrid electric Energia Hybrid (ASDOT) programme. Valued UK MoD for four additional E9-HE to be ready by 2030, the nine-seat battery-powered Energia Electric E9-FE and at around £100m, the MoD’s Textron Texan T-6C basic the 19-seat hydrogen-powered H2 Fuel Cell Energia – both to be ready in 2035 – and new medium to fast speed trainers to boost throughput the 35-50 seat H2 Gas Turbine Energia hydrogen or JetA/SAF turbine aircraft which is Operational Readiness of pilots at MFTS. scheduled to be ready in 2040. SPACEFLIGHT GENERAL AVIATION Russian ASAT tests threatens ISS Organiser of Emiliano Sala crash flight found guilty AGI The organiser of a ‘grey’ which was flying Sala charter flight in which from Nantes, France, to footballer Emiliano Sala Cardiff in a night flight, and pilot David Ibbotson David Henderson, had were killed in a crash previously admitted in January 2019 in the to trying to arrange a English Channel off the passenger flight without coast of Guernsey, has permission. The jury been found guilty of also heard how the pilot, Russia has been the subject of widespread international condemnation after conducting ‘endangering the safety Ibbotson, did not hold an anti-satellite test which created over 1,500 trackable pieces of space debris. The test of an aircraft’ and jailed a commercial pilot’s involved using a ground-based missile to hit a decommissioned Kosmos 1408 military for 18 months by Cardiff licence, IFR, or current satellite on 15 November. Astronauts aboard the ISS, which passes near the debris cloud Crown Court. The rating on the Piper every 90 minutes, closed off parts of the ISS as a precaution for two days following the test. organiser of the flight, Malibu. funding to achieve FAA of its new indigenous on 8 November aboard operates 25 rotary-wing certification. UAE mega-carrier AIDC T-5 Brave Eagle a SpaceX Dragon crew bases and nine fixed- Emirates is to accelerate advanced trainer. capsule. NASA commander wing bases across the The Royal Air Force has a recruitment drive for The twin-seat aircraft, Shane Kimbrough, pilot Pacific Northwest and entered the Guinness pilots and engineers developed from the Megan McArthur, Japanese Intermountain West World Records by as the post-pandemic F-CK-1 Ching-Kuo astronaut Akihiko Hoshide, regions of the US. conducting the first-ever recovery in air travel fighter, took to the and ESA astronaut Thomas flight of an aircraft, an continues. The airline skies on 21 October, Pesquet descended US corporate giant GE Ikarus C42 microlight, is planning to recruit a accompanied by a T-5 to Earth and made a has announced it will split powered by zero-carbon further 6,000 staff over prototype. Taiwan plans successful splashdown in itself up into three public fully sythnetic fuel. The the next six months, with to acquire 66 T-5s by the Gulf of Mexico. companies, focusing fuel, Zero Petroleum’s 2,500 of them being 2026 which will replace on aviation, healthcare UL91, was made using pilots and engineers. the AT-3 and F-5E/F US not-for-profit air and power. GE Aviation hydrogen extracted trainers. medical transport operator will form the core of the from water and carbon On 21 October, Taiwan Life Flight Network has independent aerospace extract from CO2 in the conducted the first Four astronauts returned ordered 12 Bell 407GXi concern with the separation atmosphere. production version flight to Earth from the ISS helicopters. The Network completed by 2024. DECEMBER 2021 7
Radome FIRST NEWS FROM DAS21 AEROSPACE DEFENCE Airbus launches A350F freighter Checkmate sniffs out international interest Airbus Revealed earlier this prototypes are now year at the MAKS under construction at the exhibition in Moscow and Komsomolsk-on-Amur making its international factory in Siberia. The debut at the Dubai Air company also revealed Show was Sukhoi’s that an uncrewed UCAV Su-75 ‘Checkmate’ fifth- version of the Su-75 was The show saw Airbus launch a new member of the A350 family, the A350F cargo variant generation single-engine also under development. with orders for seven A350Fs from Air Lease Corp and four from CMA CGM Group. The stealth fighter mock-up, Aimed at the export airframer ended the week with 408 potential aircraft orders (269 firm orders plus 139 which was displayed market, Russia’s Rostec commitments), the largest of which was for 255 A321neo family aircraft from equity firm along with weapons in said that the company had Indigo Partners which was distributed among its partner airlines Wizz Air (75 A321neos its own pavilion. At the held talks with the UAE and 27 A321XLRs), Frontier (91 A321neos), Volaris (39 A321neos) and JetSMART (21 show, Sukhoi parent about co-production and A321neos and two A321XLRx). Airbus Defence also received orders for two A330MRTTs group UAC revealed that supplying systems for the from the UAE Air Force, plus two A400Ms for the Indonesian MoD. the first few Checkmate stealth fighter. AIR TRANSPORT DEFENCE Boeing shows off 777X, ‘21st Century Skyraider’ unveiled racks up freighter orders This year’s Dubai Air UAE-based Sky One and Show also saw the two 777Fs from Emirates. international air show At the show, Boeing also debut of Boeing’s newest announced that its MRO widebody, the 777X, facility in Gatwick, UK, will which took part in the be the company’s newest flying display. Boeing passenger-to-freighter RAeS ended the show with 101 line, converting 737s to orders, including 72 737 cargo aircraft. The first Making its debut in mock-up form at the Dubai Air Show was the Calidus B-350, a MAXs for Indian airline aircraft through the facility two-seat, single-turboprop light attack/ISR aircraft with 13 hardpoints for weapons. The Akasa Air. Among other will be a 737-800 for aircraft is larger than the previous Calidus B-250 COIN design and contemporaries, Boeing orders were four Icelease, which placed an such as the Super Tucano, with a wingspan of 50ft and a MTOW of 20,000lb. The aircraft from Air Tanzania, order for 11 737BCFs at aircraft will be powered by a 2,600shp P&WC PW127 turboprop. three 777-300s from the show. FULL DAS21 REPORT IN JANUARY AEROSPACE NEWS IN BRIEF fighters to Cairo in a to conduct critical Hybrid Electric Propulsion followed by two in 2024 The Lufthansa Group has €3.8bn contract. This will research, support off- Architecture (MAHEPA) and all four in 2026. announced a return to bring Egypt’s total Rafale planet industrial activity project. profits in Q3 2021, with a fleet up from 24 to 54 and ensure a continued Kenya Airports Authority profit of €17m compared aircraft. US presence in LEO Wright Electric has (KAA) is to auction off 73 to a loss of €1.3bn for the after the retirement of launched the Wright derelict aircraft which have same period last year. The US space company the ISS. Spirit – a 100-seat, been abandoned at four airline group reports that Nanoracks has electric-powered of its airports. In August bookings have returned announced a partnership GA manufacturer Pipistrel regional aircraft. Based 2020, KAA contacted the to 80% of their pre- with Lockheed Martin has completed the first on the BAe 146 regional owners of the abandoned pandemic levels. to develop a private flight testing phase jet, the Wright Spirit will aircraft to settle accounts commercial crewed of the hybrid-electric be equipped with four and request their removal. Dassault has announced space station to orbit the version of its four-seat engines. Flight testing The aircraft types for sale that a defence deal with Earth. To enter service Panthera. The powertrain will begin in 2023 include Ukrainian An-24s, Egypt signed earlier this in 2027, the Starlab and flight performance replacing first one jet a Boeing 737-200, DC- year has come into force, commercial space lab will tests were conducted engine with a high- 3s, a DC-8 and DC-9s with the company to be continuously crewed as part of Europe’s power density inverter and a 707-300 (the supply a further 30 Rafale by up to four astronauts Modular Approach to with a 2,700hp motor, bidding price for the 707 8 AEROSPACE
AIR TRANSPORT DEFENCE easyJet and Ryanair trial Two-seat J-20 breaks cover in low-carbon turnarounds China Chinese Internet A joint trial between Meanwhile, rival Ryanair easyJet and Bristol has invested €7.3m in Airport has demonstrated electric ground handling a 97% reduction in at 11 airports around CO2 emissions during Europe, partnering with aircraft turnarounds.The Menzies Aviation at demonstration, set to Amsterdam Schiphol, run for six months, saw Gothenburg-Landvetter, diesel-powered vehicles and Oslo Airport, along Photographs on social media have confirmed that China has developed a rumoured and ground support with Azul Handling at two-seat variant of its J-20 stealth fighter. The aircraft was spotted during taxi tests at equipment, such as Alicante, Barcelona, Chengdu’s Aerospace Plant, confirming long-running speculation about a new variant of steps, baggage trollies Madrid, Malaga, Mallorca, the fighter. The twin-seat J-20 is the first two-seat stealth fighter in the world, with other and loaders replaced Seville, Santiago and aircraft (F-22, F-35 and Su-57) all being single-seat. This may indicate a training role or by electric equipment. Valencia airports. as a specialised two-seat strike or ‘loyal wingman’ command fighter. AEROSPACE SPACEFLIGHT Rolls-Royce Return to Moon schedule Rolls-Royce smashes electric slips speed records NASA has announced spacesuits for the lunar that its Artemis surface meant that the programme to return earliest date for a human humans to the Moon for landing will be 2025. In the first time in over 50 addition, a legal challenge years will now not meet by Jeff Bezos’ Blue Origin the goal of a landing in over awarding the landing 2024 set by the previous contract to SpaceX also Rolls-Royce has announced that it believes ‘Spirit of Innovation’ has broken the world Trump administration. A delayed progress. While speed record for an electric-powered aircraft – with the racer reaching a top speed of combination of funding the SLS rocket is set to 387.4mph in runs at Boscombe Down, UK, on 16 November. The claims, to be verified shortfalls for the landing make its first flight in early by the Fédération Aéronautique Internationale (FAI), saw the aircraft break three existing system and Orion 2022, the first crewed electric flight records, with a recorded speed of 345.4mph over 3km, 330mph over 15km capsule, as well as the flight of Artemis will be a and a climb to 3,000m in 202seconds. need to develop new circumlunar flyby in 2024. begins at $2,497). Auction Correction winners will have seven UK communications In the September edition of AEROSPACE in the article ON THE MOVE days to collect their aircraft. satellite operator Inmarsat ‘The Air Force of 2040’ we has agreed a $7.3bn used an image of USAF Chief Etihad Airways has Javier Marin, MD, Airports Kratos and General takeover by US-based General Charles Q Brown announced the and Executive Member of Atomics Aeronautical Viasat. The deal may be Jr, with a caption incorrectly appointment of Dr Nadia the Board of Directors at stating that it was former Systems (GA-ASI) are reviewed under the UK’s Bastaki as its Chief Human Aena has been elected NASA administrator, Charles each to design and National Security and Bolden. We apologise for any Resources, Organisational as President of Airports develop a new Off-Board Investment Act 2021, confusion caused. Development and Asset Council International (ACI) Sensing Station (OBSS) brought in to protect key Management Officer, who Europe. demonstrator drone for the British interests from The Junkers A50 Junior will become the first female US Air Force in 12 month foreign takeovers. Replica, developed by executive at Etihad. Salem Butti Salem Al design and development Junkers Flugzeugwerke Qubaisi has been named contracts. OBSS will A 1929 Junkers AG, retains the corrugated Jet Aviation has appointed as the new D-G of the act as an attritable ‘loyal monoplane is to return as metal skin look of the Jeremie Caillet as Senior UAE national space wingman’ and extra a 600kg microlight replica, original but uses a Rotax VP Regional Operations agency to replace Dr weapons bay for crewed with first deliveries to engine and Garmin Europe, Middle East and Mohammed Nasser Al aircraft. begin in April 2022. instruments. Africa. Ahbabi. DECEMBER 2021 9
By the Numbers Understanding the world of Aerospace through data The James Webb Space Telescope – A Comparison NASA 10 AEROSPACE
Pushing the Envelope Exploring advances on the leading edge of aerospace Robert Coppinger Navigating the future F inding your way around using satellite- with a regional 3D surface model database carried based navigation is such an essential by the aircraft’s avionics. In future, the system could feature of daily life that people forget the operate at night with infrared (IR) sensors comparing days of paper maps and map books spread what they see with an IR database. In a way it is a out over the car dashboard or ground. combination of that original pilotage, knowing the For civil aviation the days of pilots’ pilotage, landscape, and motion-related technologies. navigating by landmarks and dead reckoning, using The 3D map is used in combination with INS speed estimates and heading information, were data and visual odometry, which estimates how much replaced first by radio navigation, using radio beacons, the camera, and therefore the aircraft, has moved and then inertial navigation systems (INS). In 1978, between two images. From this, velocity and relative the first four United States government global movement can be calculated. Clouds can disrupt positioning system (GPS) satellites were launched this terrain vision, map comparison system, but and, in 1983, then US President Ronald Reagan Saab found that the navigation accuracy returned authorised the GPS signal for civilian commercial immediately once the clouds were avoided. Terrain airlines. radar could be used to see through clouds but, in In the 38 years since Reagan’s decision to make contested airspace, emitting a detectable radar signal Navstar, the true name of the US GPS service, could be unwise. Lidar, laser radar, is problematic for available for civil aviation, its signals have been added the same reason. With the 3D map, INS data and to by Russia’s GLONASS, European Union’s Galileo visual odometry, the algorithms generate a more and China’s BeiDou system. Public signals for the accurate velocity vector and assist the INS to deliver latter were available in Asia in 2012. Navstar is a the GPS denied navigation capability. military service and the origins of GPS were to serve the needs of the US armed forces. The effectiveness Navigation without GPS of GPS for munition accuracy was witnessed in 1991 during the Gulf War. The idea of navigation without GPS has also been the subject of university research for civil applications. Jamming The universities of Manchester and Bristol’s Project Agile uses a micro aerial vehicle (MAV). What is Technology to jam satellites’ navigation signals or common between the Saab system and Project Agile spoof them, to give an incorrect position, emerged is the use of visual odometry. The MAV has a vision- at arms’ fairs a few years after the first Gulf War. based navigation system where the computer has a In 2003, Russian GPS jamming equipment was processor for each of the camera image’s pixels and employed by Iraqi forces. In 2018, Finnish Prime the processors work in parallel. It can analyse the Minister, Juha Sipilä, said NATO training in Finland’s scene for that change between images to calculate northern airspace had been disrupted by GPS relative movement. This processing allows everything jamming which he suspected was the work of the to be done by the MAV’s avionics, no information is Russian military. sent elsewhere – no signal can be jammed. Solutions to GPS jamming and spoofing have The Project Agile MAV can also remember where been in development for various governments’ it has been and so that scene will not be processed militaries for decades. In October this year, Saab making the visual navigation more computationally THE IDEA OF announced it will offer a ‘navigation in GPS-denied efficient. Project Agile MAV’s visual system can also NAVIGATION environments’ capability as part of its Gripen fast jet track moving vehicles. The Project Agile researchers WITHOUT GPS offer for Finland’s HX requirement. That country is see applications in infrastructure monitoring. HAS ALSO BEEN seeking a replacement fighter aircraft for its Boeing Forty years after the first deployment of a satellite THE SUBJECT F/A-18C/D Hornet fleet. In 2020, Saab completed navigation system, the future of navigation could be Gripen E flight tests using new algorithms for a combination of the new and the old. Perhaps the OF UNIVERSITY real-time and accurate positioning based on image next step for vision-based systems is the addition of RESEARCH mapping, known as 3D-mapping. Data from the celestial navigation and an electronic version of the FOR CIVIL aircraft’s passive electro-optical sensors is compared sextant developed in the 18th Century. APPLICATIONS DECEMBER 2021 11
o Transmission LETTERS AND ONLINE @aerosociety i Find us on LinkedIn f Find us on Facebook www.aerosociety.com f NAL Library Lifetime Achievements Project Altitude On 11-12 November the RAeS Careers Department hosted a Project Altitude events programme for secondary school students at WMG Academy in Coventry. Supported by Boeing, the two-day event included a Geoffrey Wardle [On Brian series of careers talks from Riddle and Mike Stanbury RAeS members and partners Lifetime Achievement awards] including Boeing, Airbus, Flight Congratulations! Crowd and BAE Systems, as Former Chief Librarian of the RAeS National Aerospace well as hosting a hands-on Vidyasagar Kotha Library (NAL), Brian Riddle, and dedicated NAL volunteer glider challenge. Congratulations! Mike Stanberry have been announced as winners of Lifetime Achievement Certificates at the Aviation Heritage UK Awards 2021. Nominated by AHUK members, winners were announced Breaking Boundaries lecture Ian H I can’t believe how good the building looks compared to at the 213th members’ meeting at RAF Museum Cosford and when I worked in it in the mid certificates were presented by Maggie Appleton, CEO of the RAF ‘90s. Almost unrecognisable. Museum. Remembrance Sunday f New Safran Green Room at 4HP Tim Robinson/RAeS The Society’s Publications Dept Production Manager, Wayne J Davis, spoke at the racial inclusion and diversity gala, Breaking Boundaries 2021, last month. The series of four lectures focused on how the inclusion of racial and ethnic diversity within the aerospace/defence industry can be improved. It was hosted at Robert Scott [On the Bristol Aerospace Museum, Bristol, and jointly sponsored by Remembrance Sunday] Airbus, MBDA and Atkins. Proud to be a member of the Society and see it reminding us all of the importance of From the RAeS photo archives remembering the fallen who gave their lives so that we RAeS/NAL could enjoy ours. Never forget. i Safran UK National Executive Nigel Woodford opened the new Safran Green Room at RAeS HQ at No.4 Hamilton Place with RAeS CEO David Edwards and Marie de Saint-Cheron, Director of European and Multilateral Affairs, Safran. Jean Marcel Peyruquet Simon Henley I had the Congratulations Nigel. privilege of using the room yesterday – didn’t realise at Graham Adlam Looking the time just how privileged I good Nigel. was! Thank you Safran. UK defence spending Simon Luxmoore Excellent Gisela Bonnaud Brilliant! Doug Greenwell [On the Nigel. Concorde 101, G-AXDN, makes its maiden flight from Filton Congrats Safran, Dave, effect on the defence budget on 17 December 1971, the first flight of a pre-production Royal Aeronautical Society! of the latest UK Budget and Sylvie Langlois What an Concorde. It was retired to the Imperial War Museum Duxford, Our RAeS Toulouse Branch Spending Review(1)] Worrying achievement! Congratulations. UK, where it landed on 20 August 1977, having made 269 is happy to support Safran – how will this impact the flights (632 hours), of which 168 flights were supersonic. Group in France! Tempest project? 12 AEROSPACE
Picture an aeronautical zero-carbon future Ashley Lovett What will 2050 look like? This is Engineering has reimagined John Constable’s 1816 painting The Wheat Field in a zero-carbon future. Created by artist Ashley Lovett and the Museum of Engineering Innovation and entitled The Wheat Field 2050, the revised painting shows solar-powered farming robots on the ground, together with agricultural drones and hydrogen-powered aircraft in the air. Also featured in the painting are bison reintroduced into the wild, regrown woodland and hedgerows, diverse crops, and tent-shaped buildings designed to regulate internal temperature(2). i RAeS at Aeronautical Engineering finals Black History Month podcast Dave Edwards [On Aeronautical Engineering Mechanical category finals] Really great day seeing the cool, calm and collected way the finalists rose to the challenge! Look forward to hearing the results – good A new RAeS podcast is known stories of achievement luck all and thanks for the available which celebrates and by people of colour within warm welcome! acknowledge the contribution Britain’s military forces and of Black British Aviators to how they may inspire the black UK aerospace. Wayne J Davis and brown people of today’s Simon Henley speaks to film-maker, writer, UK. Congratulations to everyone actor, and social commentator, It is available on the involved – you’re all winners in Andrew Rajan, and together ‘Aerosociety podcast’ feed on my eyes! In November, the RAeS was the Competition Organising Partner they look at some of the little- Soundcloud(3). for the WorldSkills UK Aeronautical Engineering: Mechanical category finals at HMS Sultan, supported by Leonardo. RAeS CEO David Edwards is seen here visiting the finalists. The winners were announced on 26 November. 1. https://www.aerosociety.com/news/was-defence-the-big-loser-in-the-budget/ 2. https://artsandculture.google.com/story/FgWRsEOj0UGA-Q/ 3. https://soundcloud.com/aerosociety-podcast/black-history-month-podcast-to-be-published-final?si=623e81b8ed424a20a721babfc93c28e4 @aerosociety i linkedin.com/raes f facebook.com/raes www.aerosociety.com DECEMBER 2021 13
AEROSPACE Boeing ecoDemonstrator testbed Testing sustainable technology BILL READ FRAeS reports from Glasgow on how Boeing is researching new technologies to improve the environmental efficiency of aircraft and airlines through its ecoDemonstrator programme, which in 2021 is partnered with Alaska Airlines. I n October, Boeing brought its latest ecoDemonstrator aircraft over to Glasgow, the Scottish city where the UK hosted the UN COP26 international climate change conference in November. AEROSPACE was invited to tour the aircraft while it was at Glasgow Airport. Boeing has been running its ecoDemonstrator programme for a number of years. Beginning in 2012, Boeing has used eight aircraft as flying test beds to trial a wide variety of different technologies and test them in the air to see if they have potential to be developed into solutions to improve aircraft and airline efficiency, enhance passenger experience and reduce the impact of aviation on the environment. These have included technologies that reduce fuel use, emissions and noise, as well as incorporating more sustainable materials. Other projects have focused on cabin amenities, such as smart galleys, seats and lavatories that increase airline reliability and the efficiency of fleets and crews. The ecoDemonstrator programme is run by a small team of engineers and specialists working within the Boeing Commercial Airplanes’ Product Development division. The team is augmented by engineers and researchers from Boeing, together with airlines, suppliers and academia. The team has the motto ‘innovate, collaborate, accelerate’ with the aim of supporting one another to use the test platform to advance innovation for aviation and the constant evolution of new ideas. The aircraft and technologies used for the first seven EcoDemonstrator programmes are summarised as follows: 14 AEROSPACE
2012: 737-800NG (delivered to American Airlines) 14 projects, including: ● Aerodynamic performance of the 737 MAX advanced technology winglet ● Variable area fan nozzle to optimise engine efficiency ● Active engine vibration control ● Regenerative hydrogen fuel cell for aircraft electrical power ● Flight path optimisation for operational efficiency ● Carpets made from recycled materials ● Flying on a blend of sustainable aviation fuel 2014: 787-8 Dreamliner (owned by Boeing) 35 projects, including: ● Aerodynamic and flight control improvements ● Advanced wing coatings to reduce ice accumulation ● S oftware applications and connectivity technologies to improve flight planning, fuel- load optimisation, in-flight routing and landing ● Airborne Spacing for Terminal Arrival Routes (ASTAR) system to help achieve precise spacing between aircraft during approaches ● Touch-screen displays on the flight deck ● Wireless sensors to reduce wiring weight ● Outer wing access doors made from recycled 787 carbon fibre ● First flight using renewable diesel 2015: 757 (owned by the aircraft finance division of Stifel) 20 projects, including: ● Robust wing designs to enable natural laminar flow and improve aerodynamic efficiency, including Krueger shield to protect the leading edge of the wing from insects, ‘bug-phobic’ coatings that can reduce drag from insect residue and active flow control to improve airflow over the rudder ● Flight using 5% blend of renewable diesel This aircraft was subsequently dismantled with around 90% being reused or recycled. 2016: E170 (owned by Embraer) Six projects, including: ● Ice-phobic paint to reduce drag ● Wireless measurement of airflow over the surface of the wing DECEMBER 2021 15
AEROSPACE Boeing ecoDemonstrator testbed Boeing ● Wing slat cove fillers to reduce noise Above from left to right: 2019: 777-200 (owned by Boeing) ecoDemonstrator Chief ● Air data measurement system using light 53 projects, including: Engineer, Rae Lutters, distancing and ranging (LiDAR) gives a tour of the ● Small vertical ‘vortex generator’ vanes formed ● Flown used SAF sourced from Brazilian aircraft; Test equipment aboard the 737 MAX from shape memory alloys extended on take-off sugarcane ecoDemonstrator; iPad and landing to improve aerodynamic efficiency 2018: 777 Freighter (owned by FedEx Express) apps developed from but retracted during flight 37 projects, including: previous ecoDemonstrator ● Electronic flight bag application to automatically projects provide weather ● Surface Operations Collision Awareness information to pilots to reroute an aircraft to avoid bad weather System (SOCAS) which uses optical and radar improve fuel efficiency and conditions sensors to detect obstacles on the ground reduce emissions. ● Operational efficiency project to enable pilots, ● FLYHT Aerospace Solutions’ Automated All images unless stated: Bill Read/ air traffic controllers and an airline’s operations RAeS Flight Information Reporting System (AFIRS) centre to share digital information to optimise provides tracking, distress and data-streaming routing capabilities from flightdata recorders ● Self-disinfecting lavatory using ultraviolet light to ● World’s first commercial airliner flight flown on disinfect all surfaces 100% sustainable fuel ● Galleys equipped with sensors to help cabin ● Manufacturing by-products reused as fittings crews locate catering items faster and enable replacing titanium alloy (Ti64) with over 75% airlines to better manage inventories using data recycled content analytics ● A laser system to detect clear air turbulence ● Organic LED displays in the ceiling and on a cabin divider to inform and entertain passengers 2020: 787-10 (owned by Etihad Airways) Nine projects, including: ● Landing gear modified to be quieter by Safran Landing Systems ● Another operational efficiency project ● Portable ultraviolet wand to disinfect high-touch and hard to clean surfaces, including flight deck control panels Boeing Commercial Aircraft now incorporate technologies which were evaluated and proven on the ecoDemonstrator programme, including more aerodynamically efficient winglets on the 737 MAX, iPad apps that provide real-time weather and other information to pilots to help improve fuel efficiency and reduce emissions, customised landing approach path information to lower noise and flight deck touch-screen displays and a camera system on the 777X to help pilots avoid ground obstacles. 16 AEROSPACE
The 2021 programme the experimental additions removed before joining the airline’s fleet in 2022. After announcing its partnership with Alaska Although the ecoDemonstrator looks like Airlines in June 2021, Boeing began testing the a conventional passenger jet from the outside, latest ecoDemonstrator in August. The aircraft the aircraft incorporates design lessons learned flew from Boeing Field in Seattle to Glasgow on from previous projects and features split scimitar 3-4 October. The eight-hour flight across the winglets on the wing tips. The interior of the cabin Atlantic was fuelled by a 50/50 blend of paraffin is fitted with basic seats while the front of the SAF. fuselage is equipped with test and monitoring The choice of Glasgow as the destination equipment. airport was no coincidence. Not only was Glasgow Not all the different technologies are being set to host the UN COP26 summit but Boeing tested at the same time but among the 2021 has strong links with Scotland, having established projects include: the ‘Boeing Scotland Alliance’ in March 2020 ● The cabin interior sidewalls are made from which created 200 supply chain jobs plus major recycled carbon composite fibre created from investment into research and development waste from the 777X production line. The projects. programme’s Chief Engineer, Rae Lutters, The eighth ecoDemonstrator 2021 test explained that such panels could save platform is a Boeing 737-9 which is being used 9-13.6kg across an aircraft to test 21 different technologies and modes ● Low-profile anti-collision light designed to of operation. Although the aircraft is in Alaska fit mostly within the fuselage provides better Airways livery, it is currently being operated by protection for the light, improves maintenance Boeing as an experimental aircraft and will have and reduces drag. While this Hanwha Systems test light is installed into a window plug, anti- collision lights are normally located on the top and bottom of the fuselage ● An acoustic lining inside the engine nacelle is being evaluated for its ability to reduce noise on current jet engines and inform designs for next-generation ultra-high bypass models ● A fire extinguishing agent is being tested in partnership with Meggitt to replace ozone- depleting Halon 1301 ● The aircraft will also be conducting further operational efficiency flights in which pilots, air traffic controllers and an airline’s operations centre share digital information. The flight across the Atlantic to Glasgow was used to trial a new safer communication system featuring text-based communication between ATC and pilots, with the aim of increasing the clarity of transmissions ● Identifying ways in which commercial airliners can be used to measure greenhouse gas emissions to help the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration improve its climate modelling and long-term forecasting Boeing and Alaska Airlines also took the opportunity of the visit to bring along a number of key executives to speak at a series of events, including President of Boeing Europe and Managing Director of Boeing UK and Ireland Sir Martin Donnelly and Alaska Airlines Vice President of Public Affairs & Sustainability, Diana Birkett Rakow. Donnelly spoke about Boeing’s connections with Scotland and Europe while Rakow explained Alaska Airlines’ plans to achieve net zero carbon emissions by 2040. DECEMBER 2021 17
AEROSPACE GKN Aerospace Global Technology Centre Good neighbours DOMINIC PERRY*, reports from the opening of GKN Aerospace’s new Global Technology Centre in Filton, UK on 18 October 2021. G KN Aerospace has reinforced its the very best capability from around the UK to presence in the UK with the opening have its greatest impact.” of its new £32m ($44m) global technology centre (GTC) in Bristol. Welcome to the neighborhood Located in Filton – the heart of the city’s historic aerospace industry – the facility has While near neighbours of the GTC include been part-funded by the UK government-backed aerospace giants Airbus and Rolls-Royce, GKN Aerospace Technology Institute, which provided stresses that it is already working with companies £15m. from outside the industry, such as McLaren, Specialising in research and development Renishaw and Sandvik. Once fully operational, it into the technologies required for tomorrow’s will house 300 people from GKN and its partners. low- or zero-carbon aircraft, such as advanced Paja emphasises that research enabling the manufacturing techniques and hydrogen decarbonisation of aviation will be a core focus propulsion, the site will ensure that GKN retains its of the site. “The deployment of new technologies, position as a key tier one supplier. such as additive manufacturing and composite Celebrating the formal opening of the GTC materials, can deliver significant improvements in on 18 October, David Paja, GKN Aerospace the efficiency of conventional aircraft and engines,” Chief Executive, said the centre is based around he says. two ambitions: “developing industry-changing “‘The Airbus’ ‘Wing of Tomorrow’ programme, technology and creating a world-class ecosystem”. where our rear spar in composite materials is a The GTC was “created to be a partnership critical building block, is a great example.” Below left: The centre’s hub”, he said, creating a space where GKN and GKN handed to Airbus the first fixed trailing opening ceremony. the wider industry and academia can collaborate edge for that programme in September – one of Below right: GKN’s new “o integrate, connect and support our partners, our the initial projects to be delivered from the GTC. Global Technology Centre. customers and our suppliers in a way that enables However, preceding that, GKN earlier this GKN Aerospace 18 AEROSPACE
Right: An artist’s Eviation impression of the Eviation Alice electric aircraft. Below right: Constructing The ‘Wing of Tomorrow’. year shipped the first composite empennage, wings and wiring system for the Eviation Alice electric aircraft – a project that was begun while construction of the GTC was still under way. Airbus In addition, says John Pritchard, President of GKN’s GKN Aerosp ace civil aerospace business, “thanks to the site’s agile working, the structures for the Alice were designed, produced and delivered in programme the company and its partners from GKN Aerospace around 12 months.” industry and academia are developing a hydrogen “Tell me anywhere else in the traditional fuel-cell powertrain for sub-regional aircraft aviation industry where you could go from a clean that could enter service by around 2026. Total sheet of paper to the delivery of parts that are investment in the project is £54m, with the going to fly in a year,” he says. “Take that to one government contributing half. of our more traditional manufacturing locations The H2GEAR project “has only been possible and you are looking at three years minimum if you with the support of the ATI”, says Paja, which is pushed it.” helping to “position the UK at the very leading Next up for the team at the GTC is the design edge of the zero-emission flight”. and development of the carbonfibre wing and He stresses his belief that “no one company wiring system for another zero-emission aircraft: has all the answers and no one company can the electric vertical take-off and landing VA-X4 go it alone”, which underlines the importance of being brought to market by fellow Bristol firm facilities, such as the GTC. Vertical Aerospace. “Tackling climate change will require While the initial prototype will fly with a wing unprecedented collaboration between industry, built by a different manufacturer, GKN will produce academia and government, working through the structure for all serial aircraft. these problems together and creating the right conditions for success.” Novel power GKN already runs two similar sites in Europe, located in Trollhättan, Sweden and Hoogeveen Although well known for its aerostructures in the Netherlands, respectively specialising in work, GKN is also using the GTC to develop propulsion technology, and composite development novel propulsion systems. Under its H2GEAR and high-voltage wiring systems. *Deputy Editor of Flight International DECEMBER 2021 19
AEROSPACE Decarbonising aviation Together in electric and hydrogen dreams PAUL ADAMS, Director and aerospace sector specialist at Vendigital, looks at the UK government’s ambitious goals for decarbonistaion of air transport and the implications for traditional aerospace supply chains. T he publication of the UK government’s Committee (CCC) predicting that the UK aviation transport decarbonisation plan earlier sector will become the second largest contributor this year will only enhance interest in to greenhouse gas emissions by 2050, unless demand for electric and sustainably- significant action is taken. There is an urgent need fuelled aircraft. However, this would to introduce more sustainable methods of air travel, have a knock-on impact across the supply chain and, including electric aviation and the use of sustainable to achieve the industry’s jet zero vision in a cost- fuelling solutions, such as hydrogen. effective way, effective collaboration will be essential. Globally, a large number of companies are Published in June 2021, the government’s competing to develop low-emissions methods of transport decarbonisation plan sets out a pathway air transport. This includes eVTOL manufacturers, for achieving UK transportation’s net zero vision. As such as Bristol-based air taxi company, Vertical well as discussing how the plan complements the Aerospace, which is aiming to launch its first government’s overall decarbonisation strategy, the commercial passenger flight by 2023. However, report adopts a dual-pronged approach to delivering in reality, the small scale of these solutions makes passenger journeys, while reducing greenhouse gas them better suited to a future transport ecosystem emissions. This involves not only bringing sustainable complementing autonomous electric vehicles and technologies to market quickly but also the creation potentially replacing some elements of rail travel, of a fully joined-up, multi-modal transportation system. rather than long-haul passenger flight. Major players within the aerospace industry are Accelerating carbon emission investing in the potential of sustainable aviation fuels reductions (SAFs). For example, in October 2021, Rolls-Royce and Boeing announced a partnership, in collaboration Over the ast 50 years, ongoing technological with World Energy. This will focus on testing a 747 developments within the sector have enabled Flying Testbed, using 100% sustainable aviation significant reductions in carbon emissions. fuel on a Trent 1000 engine. Rolls-Royce has also However, it is clear that improvements are not Airbus’ ZEROe hydrogen- announced a commitment to ensure all its large happening quickly enough, with the Climate Change powered BWB concept. engines are compatible with SAF by 2023. Airbus 20 AEROSPACE
It is important to bear in mind that, throughout its of more sustainable aircraft. While OEMs have entire history, the commercial aviation industry has historically had access to bespoke technologies, relied on a single fuel source. For this reason and they may need to adapt their procurement approach to optimise its future performance, it is important in the future by purchasing more ‘off-the-shelf’ that the sector is united in choosing a sustainable solutions. replacement for kerosene. Currently, hydrogen The entire industry, particularly in the UK, must appears to be the front runner for the long term, with also consider how to build composite capability Airbus pledging to bring a hydrogen-fueled aircraft further down the supply chain. Composite materials to market by 2035. However, in reality, there are are key to light-weighting future aircraft and, due still a number of practical challenges around its use, to the nature of working with composites, careful including the investment needed to replace legacy thought needs to be given to the end-to-end supply infrastructure at airports around the world. chain process, in order to deliver a more cost- effective model. Carbon emission reducers, assemble! Value from the start One of the key challenges facing the industry on its journey to the jet zero future is the need to adapt its Considering the true design cost of emerging procurement style to effectively nurture and develop technologies at an early stage will also make a sustainable technologies. For example, components, difference as to whether they make it to market. such as batteries will need to be procured from Investors have learnt some tough lessons through major specialist organisations supplying multiple their experience in green power generation and industries. This means that aerospace OEMs are electric vehicle technology, both in terms of risk unlikely to have the ability to design bespoke and returns in a competitive space. With investors batteries which meet their individual needs, as they now becoming more clued-up when it comes to have previously enjoyed. This will require a new assessing the commercial viability of developments, collaborative approach to both product and supply it is vital that start-ups are able to demonstrate the chain design. value that their technological solutions will bring Indeed, many still believe the industry is and provide a clear roadmap for achieving cost characterised by adversarial supplier relationships. reductions, as well as technology. However, this will not support a change of approach To support all of this it is clear that addressing required to achieve net zero emissions. In order to the climate change crisis and achieving ‘jet zero’ will rapidly bring sustainable technologies to market require some of the industry’s best scientific and and industrialise them at every level of the supply technological brainpower. As such, the recent influx chain, cross-industry collaboration, combined with of people from more diverse backgrounds into STEM government support, will be essential. As part of this subjects can only be a positive driver for the industry, process, OEMs may need to team up with smaller many of whom state climate change as motivation suppliers and learn lessons from other areas of UK for their choice. industry that have made more progress on their Through effective cross-industry collaboration, journeys to net zero, such as the automotive sector. the sector can become united in the common goal The standardisation and simplification of Vertical Aerospace’s all of achieving its jet zero ambitions and moving UK components will also be key to the development electric VA-X4 concept. transportation towards a more sustainable future. Vertical Aerospace DECEMBER 2021 21
You can also read