Legal Tech - ISSUE 930 JUly 2019 - New Zealand Law Society
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
I S S U E 9 3 0 · J u ly 2 0 1 9 Legal Tech What does the Climate crisis: Using brain Public new union for the cold hard fingerprinting in insurance for legal workers facts court legal aid want? Page 42 Page 52 Page 72 Page 81
POSTGRADUATE LAW Elevate your knowledge “Doing a Master’s allows you to hone in on the area of law that you find really interesting. You can engage with the topics, speak with other people who know a lot about the field, pull it apart, get to know it well, write about it... and just find that part of the law that makes you tick.” KATHLEEN HENNING, LLM STUDENT 1st in New Zealand QS TOP 100 for research quality among the world’s best (2018 PBRF) law schools APPLY NOW victoria.ac.nz/postgraduate-law
Martelli McKegg welcomes Jacqueline Lethbridge to the partnership. The partners of Martelli McKegg are very pleased to announce that Jacque Lethbridge joined the partnership on 1 June 2019. Jacque is an experienced commercial and civil litigator specialising in insolvency and restructuring matters. Jacque has a reputation for taking on complex and challenging disputes and is often called upon by high-profile individuals and commercial entities with complex cases that require robust and innovative representation at the highest levels of the Courts. As well as running cases as Senior Counsel, Jacque regularly works with senior Barristers and Queen’s Counsel. Jacque joins the firm having been a partner or director of leading Auckland litigation firms for nearly a decade. Jacque can be contacted on +64 9 300 7628 or email jacque@martellimckegg.co.nz Phone: +64 9 379 7333 Fax: +64 9 309 4112 Web: martellimckegg.co.nz Address: Level 20, PwC Tower, 188 Quay Street, Auckland
16 9 New Zealand Law Society 29 · Reforms take family justice 6 · From the Law Society backwards, Law Foundation 7 · New Zealand Law Society research finds ▹ BY LYNDA HAGEN People in the Law Alternative Dispute 10 · On the move Resolution 16 · Lagi Tuimavave, 31 · Cognitive biases: challenging 68 46 Wellington Family Law the way we think ▹ BY PAUL SILLS ▹ BY ANGHARAD O'FLYNN 34 · When is arbitration the best 19 · Warrick McLean, CEO, Coleman way of resolving a dispute? Greig Lawyers ▹ BY ANDREW KING ▹ BY ROBERT FISHER QC 20 · NZAL Lawyers successfully 35 · New Zealand lawyer behind launched ▹ BY MAI CHEN new Singapore mediation chambers ▹ BY NICK BUTCHER Update 24 · Imprisonment imposed Practising Well for violent attack on dog 37 · Are you being defined by ▹ BY ANITA KILLEEN your job? ▹ BY RAEWYN NG 26 · Directors’ duties and the 39 · Mental health in the workplace case for vulnerable trading? ▹ BY HUGH NORRISS ▹ BY RICHARD GORDON 50 88 A B O U T L AW TA L K the law, for the purpose of upholding the rule of law and of the hardcopy LawTalk may be cancelled by emailing LawTalk is published monthly by the New Zealand Law facilitating the administration of justice in New Zealand. subscriptions@lawsociety.org.nz and stating “please Society for the legal profession. It has been published cancel LawTalk hardcopy” and advising name, lawyer ID S U B M I S S I O N O F M AT E R I A L since 1974 and is available without charge to every New (lawyer login), workplace and address. Zealand-based lawyer who holds a current practising All contributions, letters and inquiries about submission SUBSCRIPTIONS certificate. LawTalk is also distributed to others involved of articles should be directed to the Managing Editor, in the justice system or legal services industry. These editor@lawsociety.org.nz. Non-lawyers and lawyers based outside New Zealand include members of the judiciary, legal executives, may subscribe to LawTalk by emailing subscriptions@ ADVERTISING librarians, academics, law students, journalists, Members lawsociety.org.nz. Annual subscriptions in New Zealand of Parliament and government agencies. Total LawTalk Advertising inquiries should be directed to advertising@ are NZ$145 for 11 issues (GST and postage included). circulation is around 13,400 copies. lawsociety.org.nz. Information on rates, deadlines and Overseas rates are available on request. conditions is available on the Law Society website under A B O U T T H E L AW S O C I E T Y E N V I R O N M E N TA L S TAT E M E N T News and Communications/LawTalk. The Law Society The New Zealand Law Society was established on has a strict policy of not publishing articles in exchange LawTalk is printed on Sumo Matte. This is an 3 September 1869. It regulates the practice of law in for advertising. environmentally responsible paper. Forestry Stewardship New Zealand and represents lawyers who choose to be Council (FSC) certified, it is produced using Elemental L AW TA L K O N L I N E members. The powers and functions of the Law Society Chlorine Free (ECF) Mixed Source pulp from Responsible are set out in the Lawyers and Conveyancers Act 2006. As An online version of LawTalk is available on the New Sources and manufactured under the strict ISO14001 well as upholding the fundamental obligations imposed Zealand Law Society’s website at www.lawsociety.org. Environmental Management System. The FSC is an on lawyers who provide regulated services, the Law nz. A link to the latest online LawTalk is emailed to all international non-profit, multi-stakeholder organisation Society is required to assist and promote the reform of practising lawyers each month after publication. Receipt which promotes responsible management of the world’s 4
Contents Practice 66 · The hawks helping lawyers Classifieds 42 · The new union for legal automate legal documents 84 · Will notices workers ▹ BY CRAIG STEPHEN ▹ BY TRACEY CORMACK 86 · Legal Jobs 46 · Catherine O’Connell - Setting 68 · Is software eating the 88 · CPD Calendar up sole practice in Japan law? ▹ BY JAMIE DOBSON ▹ BY TRACEY CORMACK 72 · Using brain fingerprinting in Lifestyle 50 · Oh the places you’ll go court ▹ BY EMMA PAIRMAN 90 · A New Zealand Legal ▹ BY MARK WILTON 74 · 5G: Big deal or not really? Crossword ▹ SET BY MĀYĀ 52 · Climate crisis: the cold hard ▹ BY DAMIAN FUNNELL 91 · The Devil’s Own – far facts about all that “hot 76 · How lawyers can successfully more than a fusty male air”▹ BY JENNY COOPER QC embrace social media preserve ▹ BY ALICE NUNN 57 · Sustainable Practice ▹ BY ANDREW KING 94 · Tail end Technology 78 · Lawyers Complaints 60 · Legal tech in New Zealand Service ▹ BY GEOFF ADLAM 64 · LegalTechNZ aims to promote Access To Justice benefits of technology 81 · Access to Justice: An insurance- ▹ BY NICK BUTCHER based proposal ▹ BY JOSS OPIE 65 · Nuix releases a SaaS eDiscovery solution to support the ‘New Law’ frontier ▹ BY CRAIG STEPHEN forests. FSC certification is internationally recognised as the most rigorous environmental and social standard PEOPLE for responsible forest management. The paper used to produce LawTalk meets FSC requirements at all stages P R E S I D E N T Tiana Epati D I G I TA L C O N T E N T E D I T O R SENIOR DESIGNER along the production cycle. The shrink wrap used for Craig Stephen · 04 463 2982 Andrew Jacombs · 04 463 2981 VICE PRESIDENTS delivery of LawTalk is 27 micron biodegradable film craig.stephen@lawsociety.org.nz andrew.jacombs@lawsociety.org.nz Nerissa Barber (Wellington) manufactured in New Zealand. This degrades naturally. Herman Visagie (Central North Island) L E G A L W R I T E R DESIGNER If you wish to discard LawTalk, please recycle it. The Tim Jones (Auckland) Tracey Cormack · 04 463 2936 Sophie Melligan wrapping may be composted. Andrew Logan (South Island) tracey.cormack@lawsociety.org.nz sophie.melligan@lawsociety.org.nz C O N TA C T D E TA I L S EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR C O M M U N I C AT I O N S A D V I S O R JUNIOR DESIGNER 26 Waring Taylor Street, Wellington 04 472 7837 Helen Morgan-Banda (SOCIAL MEDIA) Nina Gillanders PO Box 5041, Wellington 6140, New Zealand Jamie Dobson nina.gillanders@lawsociety.org.nz MANAGING EDITOR AND DX SP 20202 jamie.dobson@lawsociety.org.nz C O M M U N I C AT I O N S M A N A G E R A D V E RT I S I N G Geoff Adlam · 04 463 2980 WEBMASTER Maria Pirela · 04 463 2905 editor@lawsociety.org.nz Miranda Kaye · 04 463 2990 advertising@lawsociety.org.nz ***** FPO ***** miranda.kaye@lawsociety.org.nz Placeholder for SENIOR PRINTING AND DISTRIBUTION C O M M U N I C AT I O N S A D V I S O R D I G I TA L C O N T E N T S P EC I A L I S T Format Print, Petone, Wellington FSC Certificate PLEASE Nick Butcher · 04 463 2910 Angela Ludlow ISSN 0114-989X (Print) ***** FPO ***** RECYCLE nick.butcher@lawsociety.org.nz angela.ludlow@lawsociety.org.nz ISSN 2382-0330 (Digital) 5
N E W Z E A L A N D L AW S O C I E T Y J uly 2 0 1 9 · L AW TA L K 9 3 0 NEW ZEALAND LAW SOCIETY From the Law Society anticipated work arising from that We all agree that justice jurisdictional expansion. delayed is justice denied. The District Court is entering The right of all New Zealanders to a stage of renewal over the next access a timely resolution of matters three years: 46 existing judges will before our courts is fundamental to be retiring by 2022. As the people’s the effective and functional oper- court, this renewal provides a ation of the justice system. Delay unique opportunity for the court to is not conducive to the wellbeing address gender and ethnic diversity of court users. Timely resolution is to reflect all in our society. required for everyone in the court At the beginning of the year system whether they are facing the Chief District Court Judge and criminal charges, are the victims Principal Family Court Judge invited of crime, witnesses, or are seeking practitioners around the country to a civil remedy or resolution of a seminars facilitated by NZLS CLE family matter. Time spent in the Ltd. These seminars provided a system should be reduced to the window into becoming a District minimum as appropriate to properly Court and/or Family Court Judge. determine a matter. These seminars not only gave those Last month saw the country’s first who attended an insight into the ever wellbeing Budget. challenges and rewards for such As part of that Budget the Gov- contribution to the justice system ernment announced a decision to but also encouraged experienced fund an additional 10 District Court members of the profession to con- judges and two further Youth Court sider expressing their interest to judges this year through an increase serve on the bench. to the statutory cap, raising judge And help too is also on the way numbers from 160 to 182. The decision to increase the for coronial cases. In the week cap to 182 provides for a further 10 unfunded positions before the Budget, the Government to enable further judges to be funded in future budgets announced eight relief coroners will without the need for legislative change. be appointed to address the backlog These decisions have been welcomed by the pro- of cases and delays in this jurisdic- fession, the judiciary and members of the public as a tion, with funding to come from significant step to address the well-publicised workload existing Ministry of Justice baselines. pressures and delays in the District Court. The number of deaths reported to the Currently there is a backlog of cases and the long The decision coroners is increasing year on year delay times for cases to be heard is considerable. The to increase and the additional appointments will District Court deals with over 200,000 cases each year. the cap to provide more support and resources There are more complex and serious offences coming 182 provides to reduce the waiting times for fam- before criminal courts which require more time and for a further ilies in the coronial system at such a resources. There is an increasing rise in the number 10 unfunded stressful time. of both defended Care of Children Act applications positions to The Law Society welcomes these and without-notice applications, causing additional enable further judicial resourcing decisions and is pressures in the Family Court. And then there is still a judges to be encouraged these steps have been backload of adjourned cases from the industrial disputes funded in taken to address the delay of justice in the court in 2018. future Budgets in the District Court. ▪ Legislative changes in July this year will see the without the expansion of the Youth Court jurisdiction to include need for Mark Wilton is the Convenor of 17-year-olds, with the aim of reducing re-offending. The legislative the New Zealand Law Society’s additional two Youth Court judges will assist with the change Courthouse Committee. 6
L AW TA L K 9 3 0 · J uly 2 0 1 9 N E W Z E A L A N D L AW S O C I E T Y Racing Reform Bill penalties raise serious concerns is irregular and should be strongly of the penalty should be made by Penalty provisions in the Racing discouraged. The regulator, enforcer, a court, and not the enforcement Reform Bill ignore strong objections and adjudicator should be distinct agency. from the Ministry of Justice and from one another,” Mr McHerron The Law Society recommended appear to lack justification, the New said. that the committee seek an expla- Zealand Law Society says. “The Law Society shares the min- nation from officials on why the The Law Society presented a sub- istry’s concerns. There has been no pecuniary penalty provisions have mission on the bill to the Transport response to the ministry’s objec- been included against the ministry’s and Infrastructure select committee tions and it is highly unsatisfactory concerns. on 5 June. The bill received its third that there has been no attempt at The Law Society also said it was reading on 20 June. The penalty justification. hard to see justification for the fast- provision clauses were unchanged. “The ministry notes that regimes track nature of the bill. Only four Law Society spokesperson Jason where the regulator determines pen- working days had been allowed for McHerron said the bill contains alties can also create a perception interested parties to comment. provisions for collection of off- that the regulator uses penalties to “Unrealistic deadlines imposed on shore betting charges. These allow gather revenue. The bill does make the select committee process seri- the Department of Internal Affairs some provision for court review of ously hinder the public’s input into to impose pecuniary penalties on the decision. However, it is also not legislation and the proper scrutiny offshore betting operators in certain clear how the review process will of bills,” Mr McHerron said. circumstances. operate in practice.” “The Law Society appreciates the “The Ministry of Justice has Mr McHerron said the Legislation need for a swift legislative response recorded strong objections to these Design and Advisory Committee’s in relation to some bills, but in the penalty provisions. It says that Legislation Guidelines state clearly present case it is not clear what the allowing determinations of liability that decisions about liability for justification is for the very truncated to be made by non-judicial bodies pecuniary penalties and the amount consultation period.” ▪ Charities Act review has limitations largely considers the Charities Act the review,” it says. A narrow terms of reference in isolation, rather than as part of “The Law Society has recently means the Department of Internal the wider scheme of New Zealand written to the Law Commission, rec- Affairs’ review of the Charities Act charity law. Ideally, that would be ommending that the Commission’s 2005 does not cover or adequately the subject of a comprehensive and future work programme should take into account a number of mat- cohesive review. include a wider, first principles ters, the Law Society has said. The Law Society says it believes review of the Charities Act and the In a submission on the review the Law Commission would be best Charitable Trusts Act.” discussion document Modernising placed to conduct such a review. In spite of a short extension of the Charities Act 2005, the Law Society “It is not clear that it is appropriate the timeframe for submissions, the says these include the “charitable for the Department of Internal Affairs Law Society says the three to four- purposes” definition, interplay with to lead a review of the Charities Act month period for submissions is tax concessions linked to registration, regime that is principally admin- still relatively short and will most interplay with other aspects of charity istered by Charities Services, and likely have been very challenging law, and interplay with other regimes. given that Charities Services’ role for many sector participants and The submission says the review as regulator is an important part of stakeholders. ▪ 7
N E W Z E A L A N D L AW S O C I E T Y J uly 2 0 1 9 · L AW TA L K 9 3 0 He Waka Roimata Jo Hambleton elected report an important Otago branch step, says Law Society President able to get better outcomes.” Dunedin lawyer Jo Hambleton The report, He Waka Roimata, Ms Epati says the legal profession has been elected President of the from Te Uepū Hāpai i te Ora – the is a key participant in the criminal Otago branch of the New Zealand Safe and Effective Justice Advisory justice system and has a long history Law Society. Mrs Hambleton is an Group is an important first step for- of advocacy for reform. associate with Dunedin firm O’Neill ward in the assessment of how our “There have been many changes Devereux. After graduating LLB at criminal justice system is viewed made to criminal justice legisla- Otago University she was admitted and impacts on communities, the tion over the years. Right back as a barrister and solicitor in May New Zealand Law Society says. to attempts in the early 1990s to 1999. She completed a Graduate “This report contains some very replace the Crimes Act 1961, the Diploma in Child Advocacy in 2007 stark messages and conclusions. Law Society has called for whole- and specialises in family law. Group Chair Chester Borrows says sale reform rather than the piece- the overwhelming impression from meal, knee-jerk reaction approach The following Council was elected people who have experienced the which has occurred. The report has at the branch AGM on 12 June: criminal justice system is one of provided us with a broad-ranging grief. That is a call to action, and set of principles which come from President: Jo Hambleton. the need for involvement by all many parts of our communities. Vice-President: Taryn Gudmanz. stakeholders,” Law Society President A principled approach must be Immediate Past President: John Tiana Epati says. the driving force for change,” Ms Farrow. “There is also a strong message of Epati says. Central Otago Representative: hope for change. Mr Borrows says the “It is also important to ensure Dale Lloyd. group believes solutions already exist that the reforms are accompanied North Otago Representative: and there is a national will to build by recognition of the need to ensure Louise Laming. a criminal justice system to meet New Zealand has a human rights- New Practitioners Representative: the needs of our country in 2019 based criminal trial process. The Derek McLachlan. and beyond. The next report from rights of all defendants to a fair trial OWLS Representative: Karen the group will give its response and must remain a foundation stone of Billinghurst. that will be an important moment. criminal justice. Law Faculty Representative: Ben “This report highlights the need “The New Zealand Law Society France-Hudson. for access to justice to be a funda- fully supports the work Te Uepū Council Members: Will Martin, mental priority. We look forward Hāpai i te Ora – the Safe and Effec- Lisa Brown, Sharon Knowles, Craig to the group’s suggestions on how tive Justice Advisory Group is doing Power, Lucia Vincent. everyone who becomes involved in and we look forward to continuing the criminal justice process will be involvement in the reform process.” ▪ Shirley Smith Address on 29 August The Law Society’s Wellington branch Women in Law Committee is holding the 11th annual Shirley Smith Address in Wellington on 29 August. The 2019 address will be presented by Professor Vanessa Munro, Professor of Law at the University of Warwick, England. The title is "Judging Juries: The 'common sense' comundrums of prosecuting violence against women". ▪ 8
L AW TA L K 9 3 0 · J uly 2 0 1 9 N E W Z E A L A N D L AW S O C I E T Y Overseas Investment David Campbell re-elected Act not operating Auckland effectively branch President The Overseas Investment Act 2005 does not appear to be operating efficiently or effectively, and its perceived complexity may be discouraging overseas investment, the Law Society has said in comments on the discussion A u c k l a n d l aw y e r D av i d paper Reform of the Overseas Investment Act 2005, April 2019. Campbell has been re-elected It says its experience reflects the discussion paper concerns about the President of the New Zealand Law inordinate delay in processing applications and the high cost involved in Society’s Auckland branch. Mr making an application. There are also difficulties with using the conterfactual Campbell is a partner at Kensington test to determine if a proposed investment is likely to benefit New Zealand, Swan, where he specialises in com- following the High Court decision in Tiroa E and Te Hape B Trusts v Chief mercial and civil disputes, with Executive of Land Information New Zealand [2012] NZHC 147. ▪ a special focus on competition law, product liability and liability insurance. He was re-elected unopposed. There were three branch Measured approach best for council vacancies. Sue Styants was re-elected unopposed and she is financial institution legislation joined by Misha Henaghan and Sarah Jerebine who were elected unopposed as new members. ▪ The preferred package of options in the options paper Conduct of Financial Institutions, April 2019 appears sound, but a measured approach needs to be taken to regulating organisations that provide financial services to New Zealand consumers, the Law Society says. In comments on the options paper, the Law Society says lack of focus on New Zealand Law the consumer has long been an anomaly in financial services regulation. Society submissions It supports a principles-based approach to regulation and notes that the Copies of all submissions options set out are being pursued to a tight timetable “with the ambitious made by the Law Society aim of legislation being introduced to Parliament before the end of 2019”. can be found on our website “The Law Society understands that regulators, banks and insurers are at www.lawsociety.org.nz/ currently engaged in an ongoing review of Conduct and Culture. A measured news-and-communications/ approach needs to be taken to developing this regime, to allow sufficient law-reform-submissions. consideration and input from regulators and market participants.” ▪ 9
O N T H E M O V E · P E O P L E I N T H E L AW J uly 2 0 1 9 · L AW TA L K 9 3 0 PEOPLE IN THE LAW ON THE MOVE Gabrielle Wagner domestic and inter- promoted to the partnership in 2017. She appointed to District national corporate specialises exclusively in insurance and Court bench transactions, with par- commercial litigation. ticular expertise in Auckland barrister private equity and ven- Tanya Kennedy joins Gabrielle Wagner ture capital. He also has Lambton Chambers has been appointed extensive international a District Court Judge experience in commer- Tanya Kennedy has with Family Court cial matters, with deep sectoral focus in joined Wellington’s jurisdiction. She will technology, intangible assets and blockchain. Lambton Chambers as a be based in Manukau. Megan Pearce has barrister sole. Admitted Admitted as a barrister joined the firm as a in June 1996, Tanya has and solicitor in June 1988, Ms Wagner senior associate. She has extensive experience in started her career with Cairns Slane before experience in advising employment law. She moving to Morrison Morpeth in 1990. She on corporate and com- advises and represents worked at McCabe McMahon from 1993 mercial matters, and has clients in the full range of employment to 1999, becoming a partner in 1996. Ms specialist expertise in law issues and institutions, including Wagner has been a barrister sole since 1999, commercial contracting mediation, litigation, and conducting or practising in all areas of family law. She has with an ICT focus, fund raising for early stage representing clients in relation to employ- conducted several Family Court Appeals in companies as well as advising on technology ment investigation processes. the HIgh Court and has also held a number and telecommunication transactions. of positions on the New Zealand Law Tanya Wood appointed Society and ADLS Inc. Judge Wagner will Shaun Cousins joins Special Counsel by be sworn in on 12 July 2019 in Auckland. Rainey Collins Duncan Cotterill Swearing-in of David Shaun Cousins has Duncan Cotterill has Goddard QC on 26 July joined the Dispute appointed Tanya Wood Resolution and as special counsel. An error in the June issue of LawTalk meant Litigation team at Tanya specialises in a wrong date was given for the swearing-in Rainey Collins as an construction litigation of David Goddard QC as a Justice of the associate specialising in and insurance law, with High Court and Court of Appeal. He will family law. His particu- particular emphasis be sworn in on 26 July and not 19 July as lar areas of expertise in the resolution of stated. We apologise for any confusion. are contracting out, care of children and complex building disputes. She has over relationship property agreements. Shaun 17 years’ experience assisting a range of Acting District Court graduated from the University of Waikato owners, developers, contractors and con- Judge appointed in 2011 and has practised over the last eight sultants in project and contract disputes. years in the Waikato. Janette Helen Walker, retired District Joe Donald joins Braun Court Judge, has been appointed to be Katie Shanks joins Bond and Lomas an Acting District Court Judge for a term Wotton + Kearney commencing on 3 August 2019 and expiring Auckland office Joe Donald has joined Hamilton litigation on 27 August 2020. and dispute resolution firm Braun Bond Wotton + Kearney part- and Lomas as a senior solicitor. Joe was Anderson Lloyd makes ner Katie Shanks has admitted as a barrister and solicitor in two appointments returned to Auckland July 2013. He has experience in civil liti- after spending six years gation, family and employment law and Anderson Lloyd has announced two in Sydney and will run has also dealt with a range of immigration appointments in its corporate and com- the first trans-Tasman and criminal matters. Joe has appeared mercial team. insurance practice. as an advocate in various levels of New Derek Roth-Biester has been appointed Katie began her career Zealand’s courts and tribunals and is a corporate and commercial partner. Derek in Auckland before joining Wotton + familiar with all forms of alternative has significant experience advising on Kearney in Sydney in 2013 and being dispute resolution. 10
L AW TA L K 9 3 0 · J uly 2 0 1 9 P E O P L E I N T H E L AW · O N T H E M O V E Jennifer Yang joins range of transactions, also represents clients in connection with Buddle Findlay as including private merg- regulatory investigations and proceedings Senior Associate ers and acquisitions, by the Commerce Commission, Securities takeovers, joint ven- Commission, Financial Markets Authority Jennifer Yang has tures, reorganisations and Serious Fraud Office. joined Buddle Findlay’s and capital raisings, on Jacob Kerkin in Auckland office as a Overseas Investment the Auckland litiga- senior associate in the Act matters. tion team has been corporate and com- To m C l e a r y i n promoted to senior mercial team. Jennifer the Auckland litiga- associate. Jacob is an advises on commercial tion team has been experienced com- contracts, with a focus promoted to senior mercial litigator with on strategic procurement and technology associate. Tom is an expertise in a broad based business process outsourcing mat- experienced commer- range of disputes, including those relat- ters. Before joining Buddle Findlay, Jennifer cial litigator who is ing to property and construction, class worked as senior legal advisor to global skilled in advising and actions, banking and finance, contract professional services and management representing clients in complex disputes. and tort. consultancy firms in London. He has particular expertise in intellectual Amelia Markram in property, media, trusts, contract and con- the Auckland property Chapman Tripp sumer protection law. team has been pro- promotes nine lawyers Robert Grignon in moted to senior legal the Auckland tax team advisor. Amelia special- Chapman Tripp has announced the pro- has been promoted to ises in construction and motion of seven new senior associates and senior legal advisor. major projects, advising the recognition of two senior legal advisors, Robert is a tax specialist clients on the front and from 1 June. advising on all aspects back ends. She has extensive experience Joseph Lill in the of New Zealand tax in large scale construction contracts and Christchurch litiga- law, with a particular consultancy arrangements on a wide range tion team has been focus on M&A transactions, cross-border of projects. promoted to senior investment, property transactions and Kylie Mutch in the associate. Joseph spe- post-settlement iwi corporate structuring. Auckland property cialises in health and Sam Holden in the team has been pro- safety as well as gen- Auckland litigation moted to senior asso- eral civil litigation and tream has been pro- ciate. Kylie works with insurance law. He regularly advises clients moted to senior asso- developer and contrac- during investigations and has appeared in ciate. Sam specialises tor clients on domestic District Court and High Court proceedings. in commercial litigation and international con- Philip Ascroft in the with a particular focus struction projects across a wide variety of Auckland corporate on banking and finance, sectors, including residential, commercial, team has been pro- insolvency and construction disputes. He mining, energy and infrastructure. moted to senior associ- ate. Philip specialises in corporate and securities law. He has a particular focus on equity capital markets and mergers and acquisitions, and regularly provides listed company com- pliance and corporate governance advice. Luke Bowers in the Auckland corporate team has been promoted to senior associ- ate. Luke’s expertise lies in corporate and securities law, focusing on mergers and acquisitions. He advises clients on a broad 11
O N T H E M O V E · P E O P L E I N T H E L AW J uly 2 0 1 9 · L AW TA L K 9 3 0 Alden Ho joins Development at Columbia University. Kelly Johnson Norling Law Pele Walker, the Commission’s chief becomes Greenwood mediator, has served as Acting Chief Roche principal Alden Ho has joined Executive since former Chief Executive Auckland firm Norling Cynthia Brophy left in December 2018. G r e e nwo o d R o c h e Law as an associate. has appointed Kelly Alden was admitted as Jordan Curtis Johnson as a principal, a barrister and solicitor promoted to Junior from 1 June. Kelly was of the High Court of Barrister Associate admitted as a barrister New Zealand in 2011 and solicitor in August and of the Supreme Jordan Curtis has been 2007. She specialises in Court of Victoria in 2016. He is an experi- promoted to Junior commercial property enced commercial advocate with a focus on Barrister Associate at with particular experience in commercial insolvency, debt recovery and construction Auckland’s Old South leasing, acquisition and disposals and ligitation. Before joining Norling Law Alden British Chambers. developments. Kelly has acted on a number worked at Martelli McKegg in Auckland H e j o i n s t h e Ta x of high profile and strategic projects for and Mills Oakley in Melbourne. C o n t r o ve r s y t e a m corporate and government clients. wo rk i n g fo r G e o ff Appointments to Pitcairn Clews. Jordan joined the Chambers in Harkness Henry Islands Court of Appeal July 2018. He is a graduate from the announces appointments University of Auckland with BSc and Two Auckland-based barristers have been LLB degrees and he also has completed Waikato law firm Harkness Henry has appointed to the Court of Appeal of Pitcairn a Masters in Taxation Studies with first announced three appointments. Islands. Former High Court Judge Paul class honours. Laura Fischer joins Heath QC and Miriam Dean QC have been the Litigation Team appointed Justices of Appeal. This follows Georgetti Scholarship as a solicitor. Laura the retirement from the Pitcairn Court of for Harriet Farquhar was admitted in March Appeal of Sir Bruce Robertson and Rodney 2014 after graduating Hansen QC. The Assistant Attorney-General Crown Law Office from the University of of Pitcairn Islands, Danielle Kelly, says this lawyer H a r r i e t Waikato. Before joining continues a long tradition of members of Farquhar has been Harkness Henry she the New Zealand bench and bar serving awarded a William practised family law in Rotorua and general in the Pitcairn Islands legal system. She Georgetti Scholarship. litigation in Te Awamutu. Laura has particu- says at the swearing-in ceremony in May, Ms Farquhar is an lar expertise in relationship property matters, the Pitcairn community welcomed the Assistant Crown Counsel both contentious and non-contentious. new judges and expressed its gratitude in the Constitutional Jessica Mathieson has been appointed a for the quality of legal services that has and Human Rights team. She studied law solicitor in the Resource been provided from New Zealand. at Victoria University of Wellington and Management and was admitted as a barrister and solicitor Employment Team. New Chief Executive in December 2016. She is also Associate Jessica was admitted in for Human Rights Editor of the New Zealand Women’s Law March 2019 after com- Commission Journal – Te Aho Kawe Kaupapa Ture a ngā pleting a law degree Wāhine. with first class honours The Human Rights Commission board Ms Farquhar has received funding from the University of has appointed Rebecca Elvy as its new towards a Master of Laws at New York Waikato. Chief Executive. Ms Elvy, who will take up University, focusing on human rights, Katelyn Silvester her role in August 2019, is currently Chief constitutional and international law. There is employed as a law Executive of Ngā Taonga Sound and Vision were three other scholarship recipients, in clerk in the private (New Zealand’s audio-visual archive). other fields than law. The scholarships were client team. Katelyn She has postgraduate qualifications in established by the late William Georgetti, has law and social sci- Business Administration and Strategic a Hawke’s Bay farmer, who wanted to ence degrees from the Studies (Massey University and Victoria create opportunities for the “best brains” University of Waikato University) and has studied Organisational to benefit from his bequest. and is completing her professionals. 12
L AW TA L K 9 3 0 · J uly 2 0 1 9 P E O P L E I N T H E L AW · O N T H E M O V E DMK Law Ltd formed Since her retirement from full-time Connell. Before this she clerked for Justice duties, Judge Henwood as served as an Glazebrook in the Supreme Court. S t a cey D a i l y and Acting District Court Judge. Outside the Harriet Farquhar Amanda Munting- courtroom, she helped implement Te will study for her Kilworth have formed Hurihanga, a youth justice programme, LLM at NYU, focusing DMK Law Ltd, a and served as chair of the Confidential on human rights, specialist family and Listening and Assistance Service, which constitutional and employment law firm supported people who suffered abuse or international law, in based in Nelson. Stacey neglect while in the care of the state before particular on issues commenced her career 1992. She also established, and currently of climate change-re- in Invercargill before chairs, the Henwood Trust, which provides lated displacement and migration in the returning to Nelson independent policy advice on working with Pacific region. Harriet is an Assistant in 2011. Amanda young offenders. The Trust has worked Crown Counsel in the Constitutional and h a s p ra c t i s e d l aw extensively with iwi on a number of key Human Rights Team at Crown Law. She is in Christchurch and initiatives. a graduate of the Law Faculty at Victoria London and has been University of Wellington and clerked for practising law in Nelson Three young lawyers Justice Arnold in the Supreme Court. since 2011. Stacey and receive Ethel Benjamin Rosalind Kós will Amanda have extensive family law and Scholarships undertake study for her employment law experience. LLM at the University Three lawyers have been awarded 2019 New of Chicago exploring Madeleine Cochrane Zealand Law Foundation Ethel Benjamin a comparative and Wright joins Berry Simons Scholarships. The award was established pragmatic approach in 1997 and honours New Zealand’s first to the prosecution of Madeleine Cochrane woman barrister and solicitor, Ethel family violence cases. Wright has joined spe- Benjamin, who was admitted in 1897. Its Rosalind aims to identify possible reforms cialist environmental value is up to $50,000 annually. to New Zealand’s criminal procedure in law firm Berry Simons Nicola Hodge will family violence cases. Rosalind is currently as a senior associate. study for her LLM at a Senior Solicitor at Crown Solicitors Luke She joins the firm from Cambridge University Cunningham Clere, Wellington. She is a the Department of focusing on issues of graduate of the University of Canterbury Conservation where constitutional and Law School and former clerk to Justice she was legal lead in the pre-consulta- human rights law, French at the Court of Appeal. tion stage of developing the National particularly litigation Policy Statement. Before that she spent aspects, in order to Blair Shepherd gains almost four years as senior solicitor at the broaden her understanding of contem- scholarship to Duke Environmental Defence Society. Madeleine porary issues of social justice. Nichola is Law School has been involved in plan change or a graduate of the University of Canterbury resource consent processes throughout Law School and is working as a solicitor Tauranga lawyer Blair Shepherd has New Zealand, from hearings before at the Wellington branch of Meredith accepted a scholarship to study for a Master councils and the Environment Court, to the Court of Appeal. Judge Carolyn Henwood VUW Distinguished Alumni Legal Accounting Bureau · Save time and money Kathy Kell provides comprehensive, · Always know your trust account kathy@accountingbureau.co.nz accurate, efficient and timely is balanced and your month end District Court Judge Carolyn Henwood is certificates are filed on time Ph 09 444 1044 management of solicitors’ trust Fax 09 929 3203 accounts. · Our service is completely secure one of six Victoria University of Wellington and confidential www.accountingbureau.co.nz alumni who have been selected as Outsource the management of · Trusted professionals with over your firm’s trust account. Either 20 years’ experience Distinguished Alumni Award winners for come to us or we can come to · 72 law firms currently use our Powered by juniorPartner. 2019. The awards are to recognise their out- you remotely. services Practice Management software you can trust. standing contributions to different fields. 13
O N T H E M O V E · P E O P L E I N T H E L AW J uly 2 0 1 9 · L AW TA L K 9 3 0 of Laws in International he imbued in me was the client comes first, and helped iwi obtain some control of the Legal Studies at Duke that you have to do the best for the client, Whanganui River. L aw S c h o o l , D u ke and that it doesn’t matter who they are. It “Michael is right up there in terms of his University in the United has stuck with me and I still try and live massive contribution to the community States. Blair was admit- up to that.” and has really set the bar very high for the ted in November 2017 Arthur still works full time and has no younger partners of Cooney Lees Morgan and works at Holland firm plans to retire. He says jokingly, “I am to step up to.” Beckett Law in the in the second half of my career. Owen says a love of the law, strong work litigation and disputes resolution team. “I keep working partly for the intellectual ethic and a commitment to helping others His primary academic focuses at Duke stimulation, partly the sense of wanting seem to be traits that run in the Cooney will be international arbitration, interna- to do the best thing for the clients, but a family. “The old Irish blood is in there, that tional trade and climate change. The LLM major thing is the people I work with. We determination and pioneering spirit. But programme ends in May 2020 and Blair have a wonderful team.” Michael has certainly taken that to the intends to sit the New York Bar Exam in Chief Executive Partner Nick Wells adds, next level.” July 2020. “His intellectual rigour, unfailing enthu- After graduating from Auckland siasm, wide experience and dedication University and being admitted to the Bar Arthur Young celebrates to service has helped shaped Chapman in January 1966, Michael moved home to 60 years as Chapman Tripp into the firm it is today. His private Tauranga to join the family firm in 1970 Tripp partner clients trust and rely on his judgement, alongside his father, uncle and brother. gentlemanly approach and personal touch.” He became a partner two years later. Chapman Tripp lawyer Arthur Young is Property and contract law became his celebrating 60 years Michael Cooney areas of expertise. Current CLM partner as partner of the retires after nearly Sally Powdrell says Michael is known as firm. Chapman Tripp 50 years at CLM an astute and tough negotiator who fights says he is the longest hard to advance his clients’ best interests. serving partner who Michael Cooney retired on 1 June after “He has been a real devotee of the law,” is still working in the a career of nearly 50 Sally says. “He has always been respected New Zealand legal years at Tauranga by the legal community both locally and profession. law firm Cooney Lees nationally as a lawyer of high standing." Mr Young continues to practise as head Morgan. During his of the firm’s Private Client team. Aged 84, time in practice he has Lexvoco joins LOD he was admitted to the Bar on 22 March served as Tauranga’s 1957. On 1 April 1959, he became a junior Co ro n e r, ove r s e e n Australian and New Zealand “new law” partner at Sheffield and Young, one of the the establishment of firm lexvoco has joined LOD (Lawyers founding firms of Chapman Tripp. Aquinas College, and chaired Tauranga on Demand) from 1 May. The firm is now “It is incredible to reflect on the past Energy Consumer Trust (TECT). known as LOD, but says it is business as 60 years and how the legal landscape has “Whatever Michael decides to turn his usual. LOD has 10 offices globally, 650 changed. Early on, it was the days of stamp mind to, he gives it 100%, excelling at lawyers and consultants and over 500 duty and death duty, and trying to trim whatever it is, whether it be work, com- corporate and law firm clients. those down, going to the Land Transfer munity or family matters,” says his cousin Office in person to have the memorials and Cooney Lees Morgan partner Owen written up in the great heavy ledgers, Cooney. Contributing information turning up to have the registrations, and In recognition of Michael’s service to the to On the Move you had to get there at 8am to be ahead community, he was made a Member of the Brief summaries of information about of the queue,” he says. New Zealand Order of Merit in 2013 and promotions, changes in law firms, “Lots of law has changed enormously, was awarded a Paul Harris Fellowship by recruitment and retirement are pub- but actually much is the same. Our work Rotary International. lished without charge in On the Move involves dealing with people, and human “The partners of Cooney Lees Morgan (which is also available online on the nature, if it changes at all, is only gradual have always made strong contributions Law Society website). Please send in its change.” to our community,” Owen says. “Michael’s information as an email or MS Word A former President of the Auckland grandfather, HO Cooney, had a hand in document (no PDFs please) to editor@ University Students Association in 1958-59, establishing the Port of Tauranga, and lawsociety.org.nz. Submissions should he received the University’s Distinguished Lionel Lees was involved in the power be three or four sentences without Alumni Award in 2002. Arthur is a long generation scheme which was the forerun- superlatives and may be edited to standing member of the Society of Trust ner of Trustpower. Our firm’s other name conform to the format used. A jpeg and Estate Practitioners. partner, Ed Morgan, earned an MBE for photo may be included, but please Arthur worked with his first principal, championing Māori interests. He helped set ensure you have permission for us to Joe Sheffield, for 25 years, and he had a up the Tauranga Moana Māori Trust Board, use it. huge influence on Arthur’s career. “What was involved in the return of Mt Taranaki 14
L AW TA L K 9 3 0 · J uly 2 0 1 9 L AW R E F O R M Opportunity to get involved in law reform Calling all practitioners keen to make a contribution to law reform in New Zealand, now is your time to get involved. The New Zealand Law Society plays an active and important role in the reform of law in New Zealand. The Law Society has a reputation for producing high quality, impartial and considered submissions on a wide range of legal issues, on behalf of the legal profession and in the public interest. This is possible thanks to the dedication and hard work of members of the profession who volunteer their time and expertise to serve on the Law Society’s law reform committees. The Law Society is now calling for applications from members and associate members interested in serving on the Law Society’s Law Reform Committee or one of the specialist committees listed below: Accident Compensation Committee Civil Litigation and Tribunals Committee Commercial and Business Law Committee Criminal Law Committee Criminal Law Committee Employment Law Committee Environmental Law Committee Health Law Committee Human Rights and Privacy Committee Immigration and Refugee Law Committee Legal Services Committee Public and Administrative Law Committee Rule of Law Committee Tax Law Committee Youth Justice Committee If you are: • enthusiastic about, and have skills and expertise in a relevant area of law, • keen to share your knowledge and to work collaboratively with other practitioners, • willing to volunteer your time and expertise for the benefit of the profession and the community, and • available to respond to consultation on law reform when required … then we need you. New Zealand Law Society committee membership is a great way to get involved and have your say on law reform issues. It is also an excellent basis for professional development and collegiality. Go to www.lawsociety.org.nz/law-society-services/law-reform/get-involved for information on the committees and role descriptions, and to apply. Application forms and information packs are also available via email from lee.adamson@lawsociety.org.nz. Applications close at 5pm Friday 26 July 2019. Committee convenors will be appointed by the Law Society Board at its meeting on 23 August 2019 and committee members will be appointed by the President in late August. 15
P R O F I L E · P E O P L E I N T H E L AW J uly 2 0 1 9 · L AW TA L K 9 3 0 16
L AW TA L K 9 3 0 · J uly 2 0 1 9 P E O P L E I N T H E L AW · P R O F I L E PEOPLE IN THE LAW PROFILE Lagi Tuimavave, Wellington Family Law New in the Law BY ANGHARAD O’FLYNN Born in Samoa, Lagi Tuimavave is the oldest of What do you enjoy most five children and spent her formative high school years about being a lawyer? growing up in Wellington, attending Wellington Girls’ “I enjoy working in a firm with very College. experienced partners who have Bilingual in English and Samoan, Ms Tuimavave says been so hands-on with my devel- that while she was an English studies buff, her favourite opment. I think it is so important subject was legal studies, as the subject supported the for new lawyers to be surrounded needs of students who spoke English as their second by willing and experienced teachers. language. She is a solicitor with Wellington Family Law. This is an experience I can never take for granted. When did you realise that you “I am so reluctant to say that I wanted to be a lawyer? enjoy being a lawyer for the mere “My father helped me to decide and I eventually learnt fact that I get to file evidence for my the value of having a law degree. clients, attend court and bill them. “Since college, I realised that I had no other options No, for me, joy in being a lawyer but to become a lawyer, hence my perseverance with comes from the mere fact that a English. client thanks me for helping them “Once at law school I knew I had made the right alleviate stress and pain. It’s in the decision, despite the many challenges I had to endure. way I give them legal advice and I feel so honoured to have a practising certificate because practical advice. It’s about being I feel a deep sense of responsibility for the elderly, young upfront and not sugar coating the people, Pacific islanders and any vulnerable member legal system. I guess you can say or members of our community.” As a lawyer, that I enjoy being a lawyer because understanding I care about people.” You have a BA majoring in Samoan differences studies and cultural anthropology. is crucial. I What made you lean Do these help you in your day- can never toward specialising to-day work as a lawyer? assume I know in family law? “I’m lucky I got to major in these papers. someone’s “Family law presents to me an “Cultural anthropology gave me perspective about culture simply opportunity to help people with different cultures and their rituals and the varied ways from listening their issues. Family law has the people live and organise themselves. I love that we are to their stories. human element; it is the core of all so different and that we can all learn a thing or two Being a lawyer the area of law. I like that there from each other. comes with are steps people could be advised “As a lawyer, understanding differences is crucial. I a great deal to take before engaging the legal can never assume I know someone’s culture simply of trust but system unless they are urgent from listening to their stories. Being a lawyer comes also the need matters. with a great deal of trust but also the need to respect to respect “[I think] Family law should my clients’ vulnerabilities in a system that should only my clients’ be less adversarial and more be turned on as an absolute last resort.” vulnerabilities conciliatory.” 17
J uly 2 0 1 9 · L AW TA L K 9 3 0 I’m going to be silent on the issue. “The profession needs to be free from entitled people who think it is ok to bully or sexually violate their staff. Such behaviour needs to be eliminated. Let’s respect each other and appreciate that upholding each other’s unique mana is conducive to better outcomes for all. “There is a great and urgent need for diversity in the legal profession. We need more Māori and Pasifika law- yers in litigation teams in all firms, let’s be a reflection of our country. “I think there is a growing shortage of legal aid lawyers. This saddens me because access to justice is being denied. I’m really hoping this decline is only temporary. “I feel honoured to be at Wellington Family Law where I feel supported and I can only hope the same for my junior colleagues.” Can you tell me about anyone who inspires you? “In general, my mother Piilua inspires me. She is the most hard-working woman that I know. I feel beyond blessed that she is my mother. In the legal profession, Tiana Epati inspires me. I met her early this year and I am so proud of her. I thank her for her bravery and for sharing some of the most painful moments of her career as a Pasifika woman in the legal profession.” Family law can be very stressful, what do you get up to your spare time to decompress? “I am a proud believer of God – so going to church gives me a great sense of peace and relief. After finishing study, did hope that they are all well supported “I spend most of my spare time with my nine-year-old you find the job matched and looked after by members of brother TJ. He is the greatest company ever. A nine- the expectations you their practice. year-old best friend will make you forget all about your had in school? “Sexual harassment and bullying work/life worries. “To be honest, I wasn’t quite pre- is real in the legal fraternity – to me “I have a solid group of close friends and mentors pared for the level of responsibility it is a long term disease that needs who I can always count on for a good time – quality at that comes with being a family serious treatment. Just because I this age and time is important.” ▪ lawyer. Going home and wondering personally haven’t experienced it whether a client will be okay over in my current firm doesn’t mean Angharad O’Flynn is a Wellington-based journalist. the weekend is a demonstration of the extent to which I have brought this obligation upon myself. This is something I am trying to get used to.” Are there any issues currently facing young lawyers and/or the legal system as a whole that you’d like to highlight? Recognised industry experts Serving legal documents for over 30 years “I think, in general, young and new lawyers are expected to work long Fast, professional, nationwide process serving for solicitors & government agencies. arduous hours to earn their place P: (09) 302-2476 E: team@docuserve.co.nz W:www.docuserve.co.nz and meet expectations. I can only 18
L AW TA L K 9 3 0 · J uly 2 0 1 9 P E O P L E I N T H E L AW · P R O F I L E PEOPLE IN THE LAW PROFILE The Innovators Warrick McLean, CEO, Coleman Greig Lawyers LawFest organiser Andrew King continues a series of interviews with key legal professionals with their inno- vation and technology stories. What does legal from traditional law firms. Having easier for firms compared to what it innovation mean to you? automation champions and drivers was five years back. There are plenty It means doing things better. It of change is the key. These staff may of AI platforms but for many firms means being able to step back and not be tech-savvy, but they seek this is an area left to the big boys. watch how you could join the dots opportunities for improvements. Delivering automation to much of differently. Interestingly, this is a The biggest opportunity lies in our daily routine is the key where skill not everyone has, and lawyers automating tasks and workflows. smaller firms can improve service often tend to be challenged by Many firms may use your existing delivery, turnaround and productiv- transformation. software rather than investing in ity. AI will happen and is happening Legal innovation is important for new technology. but only to a niche few at this stage. our clients, firm productivity and also for our current and prospective What pressures are What opportunities staff. Fifty-four percent of my firm’s organisations facing has legal innovation staff is millennial, so we get staff in the delivery of brought to you? to think about and find new ways legal services? The push to change the way we of doing things that are exciting, Firms are very competitive. Changes deliver our services is much less interesting and challenging. Firms are impacting on the profession of a push these days. Lawyers are need to challenge and engage their as it is being driven by pro-active actively highlighting the opportuni- younger staff to think differently firms and legal entrepreneurs. They ties and seek assistance from prac- and add value to the work. Engaging are keen to cash in on an industry tice service teams. It means legal millennial staff the right way can that has been historically slow to innovation is no longer an internal get the best from them and will change. Clients are pushing some sell and is now really gaining a life help to potentially retain them for of the changes but on the basis of of its own. longer. It costs a lot to train quality our experience we need to challenge If process improvement is your talent, so retaining them for as long our clients with different offerings thing then it is an exciting time to as possible is important. and ways of doing things. be in law and for me, I simply enjoy reflecting on how far our firm has What role does What developments do come over the last ten years. We technology play you see in how legal have not been bold but have just in innovation? services are delivered? been very consistent at improving Technology plays a crucial role in Many smaller and mid-tier firms are the way we do things. getting a firm excited about the now able to “get in on the action” as opportunities that innovation can the price of technology drops and What are some of your bring, as innovation is the key and the number of legal technology start- tips to start innovating technology is simply an enabler. ups increases. The challenge lies in or developing an Getting partners to join the execution. Many of the legal start-up innovative mindset? innovation bus. It is all about offerings make the execution of legal A few years back we picked a few bringing people along for the ride tech and innovation a whole lot innovation champions to assist 19
You can also read