Last Call for the Princeton Conservative? - 100 YEARS OF BAKER RINK REMEMBERING GRANT WAHL '96

Page created by Dave Vaughn
 
CONTINUE READING
Last Call for the Princeton Conservative? - 100 YEARS OF BAKER RINK REMEMBERING GRANT WAHL '96
REMEMBERING               100 YEARS       THE FUTURE
                     GRANT WAHL ’96           OF BAKER RINK       OF FISH

                                          Last Call for the
                                      Princeton Conservative?

                                                                      JANUARY 2023
                                                                 PAW.PRINCETON.EDU

SIGNOFF--00pawJan_Cover.indd 1                                                12/19/22 3:37 PM
Last Call for the Princeton Conservative? - 100 YEARS OF BAKER RINK REMEMBERING GRANT WAHL '96
Seeking leaders who
want to change the world.

  Don Fornes
Princeton ‘95
 Harvard ‘20

     The Harvard Advanced Leadership Initiative aims to unleash the potential of
             experienced leaders to help solve society’s most pressing challenges.

                 Learn more at advancedleadership.harvard.edu or 617-496-5479.
Last Call for the Princeton Conservative? - 100 YEARS OF BAKER RINK REMEMBERING GRANT WAHL '96
January 2023 Volume 123, Number 5

                                                                                                                                                                                             An editorially independent
                                                                                                                                                                                          magazine by alumni for alumni
                                                                                                                                                                                                              since 1900

                                                                                  PRESIDENT’S PAGE             2                                                                                  Branzino hatchlings
                                                                                                                                                                                                     swim in the clear
                                                                                  FROM THE EDITOR              3                                                                                  waters at Ideal Fish,
                                                                                                                                                                                                              page 34
                                                                                  INBOX                        4
                                                                                  ON THE CAMPUS                9
                                                                                  New initiatives in University’s
                                                                                  diversity, equity, and
                                                                                  inclusion report HBCU
                                                                                  partnership commences
                                                                                  Students seek action against
                                                                                  professor who used N-word
                                                                                  Debating whether to remove
                                                                                  Witherspoon statue Seven
                                                                                  seniors honored SPORTS:
                                                                                  Celebrating 100 years of
                                                                                  Baker Rink RESEARCH: Life
                                                                                  as a lonely bee Correcting
                                                                                  Native American histories

                                                                                  PRINCETONIANS               41
                                                                                  George Butts ’08 the hand
                                                                                  model Jessica Lander ’10 on
                                                                                  educators helping immigrant
                                                                                  students Taylor Plosser
                                                                                  Davis ’93 transforming homes
                                                                                  for aging clients
                                                                                  CLASS NOTES                46
                                                                                                                    Crashing the Conservative Party 24               Sea Change                                      34
                                                                                  MEMORIALS                  63     Princeton has been an incubator of right-wing    Eric Pedersen ’82 wants to revolutionize the
                                                                                  CLASSIFIEDS                 71    talent over the past 60 years, yet students      seafood industry and forge a new way to
                                                                                                                    and alumni say conservative life on campus is    farm fish out of his one-of-a-kind factory in
   Navid Baraty; courtesy Leila Philip ’86, Nada Elbuluk ’04, Beverly Schaefer

                                                                                  PRINCETON PORTRAIT 72             endangered. By David Walter ’11                  Waterbury, Connecticut. By Wayne Coffey

                                                                                  PAW.PRINCETON.EDU
                                                                                                                                    Beaver Land            Treating Vitiligo
                                                                                                                                    On the latest          In the first edition of
                                                                                                                                    PAWcast, Leila         PAW’s new Newsmakers
                                                                                                                                    Philip ’86 discusses   Q&A series, dermatologist        PAW Goes to the Movies
                                                                                                                                    her new book about     Nada Elbuluk ’04 explains        Dean Jill Dolan discussed
                                                                                                                                    how beavers built      a skin condition where           with PAW the new film She
                                                                                                                                    North America —        antibodies attack the cells      Said, about the newspaper
                                                                                                                                    and how they can           that make pigment.           reporters who investigated
                                                                                     PAWCAST                                        help with climate                Sign up to receive     Harvey Weinstein.
                                                                                         Leila                                      change today.                      PAW’s Alumni
                                                                                       Philip ’86                                                                       in the News         Rally ’Round the Cannon
                                                                                                                                                                        newsletter at       Gregg Lange ’70 investigates
                                                                                                                                                                       paw.princeton.       a nearly-forgotten style of
                                                                                                                                                       Elbuluk ’04 edu/email.               flag football.

                                                                                 On the cover: Photo by Sameer A. Khan h’21

SIGNOFF--01pawJan_TOC.indd 1                                                                                                                                                                                         12/19/22 9:22 AM
Last Call for the Princeton Conservative? - 100 YEARS OF BAKER RINK REMEMBERING GRANT WAHL '96
THE PRESIDENT ’ S PAGE

          Service Through a New LENS

I
     n the first PAW page of my presidency, back in
     September 2013, I emphasized that an ethic of
     service was fundamental to Princeton’s mission. I
     called upon the University community to ask “how
we can live up more fully to Princeton’s informal motto,”
a motto that now reads, “Princeton in the nation’s service
and the service of humanity.”
   This fall we took a giant step in the right direction.
   In late October, we announced the Learning and Education
through Service (LENS) initiative, which offers every
Princeton undergraduate the opportunity to do a paid
summer service internship during their time at the University.
That’s not something we’ve been able to do before, and it
sets a new standard for higher education support of service-
oriented learning.
   LENS seeks to eliminate two obstacles that sometimes
stand in the way of Princeton students seeking service            the value of service and encourage students to give service a
internships. Sometimes they can’t find an internship. And         central place in their lives and careers.
sometimes they can’t find funding for their internship.              Doing that doesn’t require someone to join the Peace Corps
   With the help of generous alumni and friends, Princeton        or Teach for America — though of course it’s great if they
had already established an array of internship programs           do! I often say to students that you can live a life of service in
that aim to solve these problems. The number and variety          nearly any profession: It’s more a matter of how you do your
of programs, however, complicated the task of finding an          job than what job you do.
internship that matched a student’s needs.                           George Shultz ’42, Maria Ressa ’86, Wendy Kopp ’89,
   LENS will integrate and supplement Princeton’s existing        and Mellody Hobson ’91 all exemplify, magnificently
summer internship programs to create “one-stop shopping”          and distinctively, a tradition of service proudly shared by
for rising sophomores, juniors, and seniors who seek to           generations of Princeton alumni.
explore summer service internships. In so doing, it will make        Yet, though service can take many forms, a commitment
it easier for all students to find service opportunities that     to it does not arise automatically or accidentally. It requires
are both personally meaningful and responsive to the needs        thoughtfulness, dedication, and care. And those habits of
of the world.                                                     mind are more likely to flourish among our alumni if they
   In the words of Vice President for Campus Life W.              take firm hold during a student’s time at Princeton.
Rochelle Calhoun, the initiative will “strengthen collaboration      For that reason, I hope that every Princeton student will
among departments and offices that support service and social     find a way to make service a central part of their experience at
impact internships during the summer, as well as provide          this University. With resources from LENS, I am optimistic
greater transparency for students so they better understand       that they will.
the options available to them.”                                      This generation of students has a strong commitment to
   LENS includes financial support to ensure that every           service. Some will use LENS to build on past projects, and
qualifying internship is a paid internship. Not only will         others will explore new ones. Their interests encompass
LENS provide additional funding to enable existing                human rights, community history, medical research, animal
programs to expand their reach, it will also encourage            welfare, education, and many, many other causes and topics.
students to secure their own internships and help them to         The LENS website collects stories at https://lens.princeton.
identify University funding to support them. This means that      edu/student-stories, where you can get a sense of our
more students will be able to spend their summers engaging        students’ passion and impact.
in experiential learning opportunities focused on service and        Thanks to gifts from alumni and friends and the creative
social impact.                                                    work of administrative leaders, LENS will make possible
   The LENS acronym takes some alphabetic liberties (in           many more stories like those. In its infancy, LENS will
particular, it grabs the “n” from the end of “education”) to      depend partly on Annual Giving, though our long-term goal
spotlight an idea from the University’s strategic planning        is to raise a naming gift to provide continuing support for
process. A committee of students, staff, faculty, and alumni      the program.
urged Princeton to regard service as “an embedded and                I’m grateful to the alumni, friends, staff, and faculty who
pervasive lens” on learning. Service experiences, said the        have enabled us to take this new and substantial step toward
committee, should deepen students’ understanding of the           that ideal, and I look forward to seeing how LENS enables
subjects they studied in Princeton’s classrooms.                  and inspires our Tigers to do good in the world.
   Several faculty have incorporated this recommendation
into their teaching, and some LENS opportunities will link
to Princeton academic work. All of the internships, whether
or not they connect directly to coursework, will reinforce

            PAW PROVIDES THESE PAGES TO PRESIDENT CHRISTOPHER L . EISGRUBER ’8 3
Last Call for the Princeton Conservative? - 100 YEARS OF BAKER RINK REMEMBERING GRANT WAHL '96
Editor’s Note

                                                                                                      A Devastating Loss
                                                                                                                               By Peter Barzilai s’97

                                                                      B
                                                                               etween the deadline stress, the
                                                                               disagreements, and the laughs at The Daily
                                                                               Princetonian in the mid-1990s, there were
                                                                      times when staff members couldn’t help but stop
                                                                      and admire the work of one of their colleagues.
                                                                          Before Grant Wahl ’96 was a world-famous
                                                                      soccer journalist, he was a Princeton student with
                                                                      a special talent. His colleagues could see it in how
                                                                      he did the work, and the readers could see it in his
                                                                      elegant writing and smart reporting.
                                                                          “For a very small group of us who were in that
                                                                      room with [Grant] every afternoon and a lot of
                                                                      evenings in ’94, ’95, and ’96, it was a golden era,”
                                                                      said Justin Pope ’97, co-sports editor in 1996-97.
                                                                      “There was this energy and kind of cockiness, and
                                                                      it came from the top, and he was the person who
                                                                      sat on that tower. Grant created an environment
                                                                      that people wanted to be a part of and wanted to do
                                                                      ambitious work.”
                                                                          Grant, 49, died Dec. 10 while covering a World
                                                                      Cup match in Qatar. After saying he felt ill for a few
                                                                      days, Grant collapsed in the press box and could not
                                                                      be saved by paramedics. His wife, Céline Gounder
                                                                      ’97, said an autopsy performed by the New York
                                                                      City Medical Examiner’s Office revealed the cause
                                                                      of death was an aortic aneurysm.
                                                                          “The chest pressure he experienced shortly before
                                                                      his death may have represented the initial symptoms,”                                                              Grant Wahl ’96 and
                                                                      she wrote. “No amount of CPR or shocks would have                                                                  Céline Gounder ’97
                                                                                                                                                                                            with their dogs.
                                                                      saved him. His death was unrelated to COVID. His
                                                                      death was unrelated to vaccination status. There was
                                                                      nothing nefarious about his death.”
                                                                          A reporter for Sports Illustrated from 1996 to 2021, Grant
                                                                      wrote about college basketball and LeBron James before
                                                                      devoting himself to soccer. His impact on the game in the U.S.
     Courtesy Sabine Wallis; courtesy Malena (Salberg) Barzilai ’97

                                                                      has been immense. Many of the tributes from around the world
                                                                      have credited him with being a visionary. Prominent soccer
                                                                      figures, athletes, and politicians expressed their heartache and                                                            From left,
                                                                      sent condolences to Céline and Grant’s family.                                                                         Nate Ewell ’96,
                                                                                                                                                                                           Malena (Salberg)
                                                                          I got to know Grant through my wife, Malena (Salberg)                                                             Barzilai ’97, and
                                                                      Barzilai ’97, who worked with him at the Prince, and in my                                                            Grant Wahl ’96
                                                                      previous life as a sports journalist. I was thrilled when he wrote                                                             in 1995.
                                                                      a profile of Leeds coach Jesse Marsch ’96 for the November
                                                                      issue of PAW. We talked about the World Cup and how he               dorm room because he was that guy,” said Allison Slater Tate
                                                                      was looking forward to covering it and continuing to grow his        ’96, another colleague at the Prince who has remained close to
                                                                      Substack website, “Fútbol with Grant Wahl.”                          Grant and Céline. “His smile was so big and welcoming. He
                                                                          His death has deeply hurt the Princeton community and            was like my brother. And I loved him with my whole heart.”
                                                                      reminded many not only of his immense skills as a journalist            Grant was also fiercely courageous. Whether it was running
                                                                      but also his kindness and warmth.                                    for president of FIFA in part to highlight corruption within
                                                                          “He would walk you home to make sure you got back to your                                                       Continues on page 4

                                                                      paw.princeton.edu                                                                 January 2023 P r i n c e t o n a lu m n i w e e k ly 3

SIGNOFF--03-06pawJan_Inbox.indd 3                                                                                                                                                                          12/19/22 3:11 PM
Last Call for the Princeton Conservative? - 100 YEARS OF BAKER RINK REMEMBERING GRANT WAHL '96
YOUR VIEWS          FOSSIL-FUEL DIVESTMENT           ORGANIC CHEMISTRY
         continued from page 3
         the world governing body of soccer

                                                                                     Inbox
         or wearing a rainbow T-shirt to the
         U.S.-Wales match in Qatar on Nov. 21 to
         support LGBTQ rights, he did not shy
         away from a good fight.
             “He had such a mature sense of
         journalism,” said Nate Ewell ’96, who was
         a co-sports editor in 1995-96 and worked
         with Grant on one of his most memorable,                                                      To pleasantly converse
         and courageous, stories at Princeton.
             Writing in the Prince for the last time,
                                                                                                       with rural Americans,
         Grant authored a thorough rebuke of
                                                                                                       one must avoid politics
         future Hall of Fame men’s basketball                                                          entirely, and frankly,
         coach Pete Carril shortly after his                                                           that goes for plenty of
         retirement. “Privately, in practice or in                                                     urban Americans, too.
         the locker room, what you haven’t seen is                                                     That is not a true solution
         the daily hell promulgated by ‘Princeton’s                                                    to our divide, but it may
         professor of basketball,’ whose vicious                                                       be all we have to prop
         assault on the characters of his ‘students’                                                   open a door to rediscover
         would have gotten any real professor
                                                                                                       our common humanity.
         fired, on the spot,” Grant wrote.
             Ewell said that several months before
         that story ran, “he and I met with the                                                           Outside of politics, one finds warm,
         whole basketball team and heard their          VIEWS OF A DIVIDED COUNTRY                     hardworking, gracious humans, but
         concerns. [Grant] was asking how we            Having ridden Harley-Davidson                  mention politics and they throw up a
         should approach this story? What was the       motorcycles more than 300,000 miles,           wall of defensiveness and conspiracy
         right way? What was the ethical way?”          crisscrossing two-lane rural America           theories. Unable to justify their
             Said Pope: “He delivered the               over the past 19 years, I enjoyed the          opinions, they claim to being treated
         goods. He did the reporting. He                article about Walter Kirn ’83’s road trip to   condescendingly. They go with gut
         talked to people. He wasn’t just [an]          understand the American political divide       feelings, and talk radio and Fox
         undergraduate firing off a story. It was       (“Lost in the Democracy,” November             resonate with those feelings, feeding
         the difference between activism and            issue). Not a journalist, but an excellent     their anger and hate. To pleasantly
         journalism.                                    bar mate and listener, I have spoken           converse with rural Americans, one
             “That piece inspired people to be          with hundreds of rural residents in bars,      must avoid politics entirely, and frankly,
         more courageous and showed what                cafés, and gas stations. Not only can          that goes for plenty of urban Americans,
         student journalists can do. But at the end     many not provide local directions, as          too. That is not a true solution to our
         of the day, he was just a better reporter      Kirn describes, they have rarely, if ever,     divide, but it may be all we have to prop
         than everybody.”                               traveled outside a 50-mile radius of their     open a door to rediscover our common
             Ewell, who is now vice president of        birthplace. Their view of events outside       humanity.
         communications for the NHL’s Vegas             that radius has grown from disinterest to      Geoff Smith ’71
         Golden Knights, said he learned from           distrust, anger, and hate, fueled by talk      Carlsbad, Calif.
         Grant how to be a better journalist — and      radio and Fox political shows. Of interest
         that he shouldn’t be a journalist.             to them are gas, food, crop, cattle, and       Regarding the story on Walter Kirn ’83:
             “I’m not joking at all when I say I        tractor prices … and gun rights. Largely       I agree that the tone of Democratic
         wouldn’t be here if it wasn’t for him,” he     irrelevant are pandemics, Ukraine, and         Party leaders toward middle-class
         said. “I wanted to be a sportswriter, but I    climate change.                                Americans who do not support them
         looked at [Grant] and said, I can’t do this.
         I’m not Grant. None of us were.”
                                                        WE’D LIKE TO HEAR FROM YOU                     Letters should not exceed 250 words and
             But like a great teammate, Grant                                                          may be edited for length, accuracy, clarity,
         made those around him better.                                @pawprinceton                    and civility. Due to space limitations, we are
             “He had this innate goodness,” Slater                                                     unable to publish all letters received in the
         Tate said. “Not that he didn’t have an         Email: paw@princeton.edu                       print magazine. Letters, articles, photos,
         edge, but that edge is why he would wear       Mail: PAW, 194 Nassau Street,                  and comments submitted to PAW may
                                                        Suite 38, Princeton, NJ 08542                  be published in print, electronic, or other
         a freaking rainbow shirt to a game in
                                                        PAW Online: Comment on a story                 forms. The views expressed in Inbox do
         Qatar. He was like, ‘Screw it, I’m going                                                      not represent the views of PAW or
                                                        at paw.princeton.edu
         to do the right thing,’ and we all admired                                                    Princeton University.
                                                        Phone: 609-258-4885
         and loved him for that.”

         4 P r i n c e t o n a l u m n i w e e k ly January 2023

SIGNOFF--03-06pawJan_Inbox.indd 4                                                                                                                 12/19/22 9:23 AM
Last Call for the Princeton Conservative? - 100 YEARS OF BAKER RINK REMEMBERING GRANT WAHL '96
Inbox
         can be condescending. I despise              country as a whole is helped or hurt by        arguments against the growing number
         condescension, but I despise being lied      this brain drain.                              of concerned citizens it considers its
         to even more.                                Steve Beckwith ’64                             enemies. Twenty years ago, for instance,
             Alas, when someone is really             New York, N.Y.                                 when British Petroleum began heavily
         good at telling me lies I want to hear,                                                     promoting the term “carbon footprint,”
         I have trouble spotting them. I believe      DIVEST PRINCETON                               the company did so to shift blame from
         that that is something Republican            Having attended President Christopher          corporate malfeasance to individual
         Party leaders have perfected in the          Eisgruber ’83’s State of the University        lifestyle choices.
         case of many middle-class Americans,         program at Reunions last spring, at                Note that BP is unfortunately and
         especially regarding their economic          which he professed himself opposed to          inexplicably missing from the list of
         best interests.                              fossil-fuel divestment, I was unprepared       companies from which Princeton has
             Many of the lies involve deflecting      for the trustees’ decision to divest, which    committed to dissociate. For alumni truly
         blame onto others: pregnant women,           I vigorously applaud (On the Campus,           committed to the “service of all nations”
         migrants, anyone identifying as LGBTQ,       November issue). Hats off to Divest            — and for anyone worried about famine
         anyone who does not want to own a gun        Princeton and its students, faculty,           and drought, fires and hurricanes, rising
         in order to feel safe, anyone who believes   administration, and alumni supporters          temperatures and rising seas — we need
         that only secular education should be at     who these past years raised awareness          to keep fighting.
         public expense.                              with their advocacy, and to the Faculty        Ben Beckley ’03
             The biggest lie, though, is that         Committee, which championed                    Astoria, N.Y.
         massive tax cuts for the wealthy and         divestment despite the limited charge it
         corporations will ever benefit anyone        was originally given.                          I remember when I was at Princeton,
         except the wealthy and corporations.             It would have been interesting to          walking past Nassau Hall there were
         The last 40 years have made that amply       be a fly on the wall during the trustees’      often students marching and chanting
         clear. Only more progressive taxation, a     discussions leading to their decision. I       “Divest!” to demand that the University
         robustly nonpartisan judicial system, and    have never understood why the board            divest from companies doing business
         a firmly secular education system can        operates with such little transparency,        in South Africa under the apartheid
         benefit the vast majority of middle-class    especially with respect to major               regime. Although I felt some sympathy
         Americans, regardless of their color,        decisions like this one.                       for their cause, I thought they were too
         creed, or gender.                            Robert L. Herbst ’69                           radical and idealistic. Now in retrospect
         Margaret Ruttenberg ’76                      Larchmont, N.Y.                                I recognize they were on the right side
         New York, N.Y.                                                                              of history, just as the students of Divest
                                                      A few reactionary alumni have criticized       Princeton will be on the issue of fossil-
         The article on Walter Kirn mentioned         members of the broad and burgeoning            fuel investments.
         the “brain drain” from small and             divestment movement for failing to free            Entering Princeton at the time of
         medium cities. I think there is evidence     ourselves from gas-guzzling cars and           the 1970s oil crisis (when oil reserves
         for this every month in PAW. The             single-use plastic (Inbox, December            were wrongly forecast to run out in 20
         obituaries from the classes in the           issue and PAW Online). It’s true that          years), I chose to study mechanical
         1950s and earlier contain many grads         the proliferation of fossil fuels touches      engineering because I wanted to work
         who came from small cities and after         nearly every aspect of modern life,            on solar energy. After graduation,
         graduation returned there. Some              just as slavery’s economic impact was          much to my disappointment I was
         were professionals such as doctors           once inescapable — even for white              unable to find a job in that field. (Energy
         or lawyers while others joined a local       abolitionists in their starched white          companies advertising their research
         business, often family owned. They           cotton shirts.                                 and development on photovoltaics and
         became leaders in the local community.           What’s also true, as I write this on a     solar thermal collectors were engaged in
         Gradually this changed and many              70-degree day in late fall in Astoria, New     an early form of greenwashing.) So it’s
         grads from the 1960s and later years         York, is the severity of the worsening         taken around four decades, but climate
         shifted to careers in consulting, finance,   climate crisis and its underlying causes. In   change has finally led us to acknowledge
         technology, etc., that were located in       1965, the American Petroleum Society told      the urgency of ending fossil-fuel
         large cities. Small cities were the losers   its members that carbon dioxide would          extraction and use, and making the
         in this trend.                               produce “marked changes in climate” by         difficult but crucial transition to
             In my day, “Princeton in the Nation’s    the year 2000. The fossil fuel industry has    renewable energy.
         Service” was thought to mean working         known for more than half a century the         Larry Moffett ’82
         for the government, especially in            havoc it would wreak on people’s lives.        Brussels, Belgium
         Washington, D.C. However, I think that           In those 50-odd years, the industry
         those who returned home to small cities      has not only sought to hide its own            I am surprised that the climate activists
         also were working in the nation’s service.   culpability, but waged a relentless public     behind Divest Princeton were pleased
         An interesting question is whether the       relations campaign, full of spurious           with the measures that the University

         paw.princeton.edu                                                               January 2023 P r i n c e t o n a lu m n i w e e k ly 5

SIGNOFF--03-06pawJan_Inbox.indd 5                                                                                                           12/19/22 9:23 AM
Last Call for the Princeton Conservative? - 100 YEARS OF BAKER RINK REMEMBERING GRANT WAHL '96
Inbox
                                                                                        has taken to drop fossil fuels. Your cover    I remember being completely enthralled
                                                                                        stated, “Dropping Fossil Fuels,” but the      by the class. Whether it was how it made
         An editorially independent magazine
                                                                                        dissociation is far from dropping fossil      me think, or the cool visuals and seeming
         by alumni for alumni since 1900
                                                                                        fuels. This seems like a half measure         ease of Professor Jones’ ability to draw
         January 2023 Volume 123, Number 5                                              that doesn’t achieve any of the change        electron orbitals of various shapes and
         Editor                                                                         that the activists are seeking. If the        colors, or just the zeal and energy that
         Peter Barzilai s’97                                                            University were serious about divesting       he brought to the class, I was highly
         Managing Editor                                                                from these companies and ultimately           motivated to learn.
         Brett Tomlinson
         Associate Editor                                                               dropping fossil fuels, it could ensure            Unfortunately, this excitement came
         Carlett Spike                                                                  that no products from Exxon Mobil             crashing down after my first exam result
         Digital Editor
         Elisabeth H. Daugherty                                                         and the other 89 blacklisted companies        was a 33 (yes, out of 100). I remember
         Class Notes/Memorials Editor                                                   make their way onto campus. That              calling home and telling my parents
         Nicholas DeVito                                                                includes natural gas that provides            that I would need to drop the class.
         Senior Writer
         Mark F. Bernstein ’83                                                          electricity, gasoline and diesel used         My parents urged me not to. After my
         Writer/Assistant Editor                                                        in motor vehicles, and the rubber and         second exam grade came back with
         Julie Bonette
                                                                                        plastics used throughout campus.              a 66, I was pissed at my parents and
         Art Director                                                                   Additionally, it could stop accepting         myself for not dropping the class, and
         Matt Cole
                                                                                        Annual Giving money from alumni who           now it was too late. I went to Dr. Jones
         Publishing Director                                                            work for or have investments in these         for extra help, and things started to
         Allison Sullivan
                                                                                        companies. It could cut ties with any         click. The rest of that semester and
         Administrative Coordinator                                                     company with operations in Canada             the next were some of the most
         Brielle McArdle
                                                                                        until it outlaws tar sand development.        memorable and rewarding academic
         Student Interns
         Evelyn Doskoch ’23; Jack Hartman ’24;
                                                                                        The University could also dissociate          times of my life.
         Connor Odom ’25; Kate Stewart ’25                                              from China since it stubbornly                    As a parent, spouse, and spinal
         Proofreaders                                                                   continues to be the world’s worst             surgeon, I am faced with problems
         Joseph Bakes; W. Raymond Ollwerther ’71                                        polluter.                                     that force me to think deeply and
         Webmaster                                                                          If Princeton truly wants to drop fossil   solve for unknowns. I have shared this
         Steven Wolock
                                                                                        fuels it has a lot more work to do. So        story repeatedly with my children to
         PAW Board
         Marc Fisher ’80, Chair
                                                                                        why doesn’t the University do more? It’s      emphasize the importance of learning
         Naomi Nix ’10, Vice Chair                                                      because life without fossil fuels is much     over grades. I am truly grateful for
         Bene Cipolla ’95                                                               worse than life with them. Fossil fuels       “Orgo.” In life, we all get kicked in the
         *Alexandra Day ’02
         *Courtney Coleman Everson ’03                                                  have allowed human flourishing and the        teeth someday. It is how we react that
         Christina H. Lee *99 s*99                                                      high standard of living that Princeton’s      makes the difference. Thank you, Dr.
         Andrew Madden ’92                                                                                                            Jones.
                                                                                        students, activists, professors, and
         *Hilary Parker ’01
         Greg Rosalsky *13                                                              trustees enjoy. Instead of pandering to       Justin Tortolani ’92, M.D.
         Jessica Stahl ’06                                                              the activists, the University should own      Towson, Md.
         Ethan Sterenfeld ’20
         *Monica Moore Thompson ’89                                                     up to the fact that to have a high standard
         *ex officio                                                                    of living the University must use fossil      Editor’s note: A longer version of this letter
                                                                                        fuels.                                        appears online at bit.ly/tortolani.
         Local Advertising/Classifieds
         Phone 609-258-4886, PAWads@princeton.edu                                       Brandon Rogers ’06
         Ivy League Magazine Network                                                    Spring, Texas                                 I had some complex emotions reading
         Heather Wedlake, phone 617-319-0995                                                                                          the article in The New York Times about
         heatherwedlake@ivymags.com                                                                                                   Dr. Maitland Jones as well as the follow-
         Address Changes                                                                                                              up in the Princeton Alumni Weekly.
         Alumni and Donor Records
         100 Overlook Center, Suite 300                                                                                                   In fall 1993, I took organic chemistry
         Princeton, NJ 08540                                                                                                          from Dr. Jones. As others have noted,
         alumrecs@princeton.edu, phone 609-258-3114                                                                                   this was a notorious weed-out course
         Princeton Alumni Weekly (I.S.S.N. 0149-9270) is an editorially                                                               for premedical students. I knew it would
         independent, nonprofit magazine supported by Princeton University
         and paid advertising. Its purpose is to report with impartiality news
                                                                                                                                      be tough and I worked hard. Despite
         of the alumni, the administration, the faculty, and the student body of                                                      my effort, I failed the first midterm. I
         Princeton University. The views expressed in the Princeton Alumni Weekly
         do not necessarily represent official positions of the University. The                                                       dropped the class. So did a lot of other
         magazine is published monthly with a combined July/August issue.
             Princeton Alumni Weekly, 194 Nassau Street, Suite 38, Princeton,                                                         students.
         NJ 08542. Tel 609-258-4885; email paw@princeton.edu; website paw.
         princeton.edu.                                                                 ORGO WITH MAITLAND JONES                          I was 19 and knew I wanted to be
             Printed by Fry Communications Inc., Mechanicsburg, Pa. Annual
         subscription: $22 ($26 outside the U.S.), single issue: $2. Copyright © 2023
                                                                                        I took Professor Maitland Jones’ “Orgo”       a doctor someday. It still felt like a
         the Trus­tees of Princeton University. All rights reserved. Reproduction in    (“A Combustible Mix,” December issue)         fragile dream. The very real chance of
         whole or in part without permission is prohibited. Periodicals postage paid
         at Princeton, N.J., and at additional mailing offices.                         in the academic year 1989-90, and in my       failing organic chemistry was too much
             Postmaster: Send Form 3579 (address changes) to PAW Address
         Changes, 194 Nassau Street, Suite 38, Princeton, NJ 08542.                     view, it was my first true college course.    to risk.

         6 P r i n c e t o n a l u m n i w e e k ly January 2023

SIGNOFF--03-06pawJan_Inbox.indd 6                                                                                                                                                 12/19/22 9:23 AM
Last Call for the Princeton Conservative? - 100 YEARS OF BAKER RINK REMEMBERING GRANT WAHL '96
I took organic chemistry again over          up. We have allowed pernicious lies
         the summer back at home at a local               and hate to become “normal” political
         college. And here I am, 30 years later, a        discourse. Some even say the events
         mid-career physician with an important           of Jan. 6, 2021, were “normal political
         legacy of service to patients, my                discourse.” We have to find a way back
         community, and my students.                      from this precipice, if we are to survive as
             But many of my classmates never took         a nation.
         organic chemistry again. I know they             Edward Groth ’66
         found success in many ways, but what             San Francisco, Calif.
         about medicine? The field is not better
         off because bright young minds were              DISABILITY AWARENESS
         discouraged by a professor like Dr. Jones.       National Disability Employment
             I would challenge those of us serving        Awareness Month (NDEAM) has
         on medical school admission committees           been observed every October since
         to consider applications holistically;           1988. For me, as an alum with hidden
         applicants are so much more than their           disabilities (specifically, autism spectrum
         organic chemistry grades. We should              disorder and ADHD), this raises the
         value not only academic achievement              question: In all the years that I have
         but also communication skills, empathy,          been reading PAW, why have I never
         integrity, leadership, enthusiasm,               seen any reporting related to NDEAM?
         diversity, and distance traveled. We             In fact, why have I not seen any stories
         should not be delegating the future of           on disability save last year’s profile on
         medicine to undergraduate professors of          Naomi Hess ’22 (“Opening Doors,”
         organic chemistry.                               March 2022)?
                                                                                                                             Loden Coats
         Amy Hairston Crockett ’96, M.D.                      Adults with disabilities constitute 20                     & Alpine Blazers
         Greenville, S.C.                                 percent of the United States population.
                                                          This includes Princeton alumni, many
         Editor’s note: A longer version of this letter   of whom have gone on to be successful
         appears online at bit.ly/ahcrockett.             as artists, entrepreneurs, engineers,
                                                          academics, and public servants. Several   137.102202 Robert Stolz Ad Formatmutation_2.125"4.75"_231122_v1.indd
                                                                                                                                                            23.11.22 16:581
         ANTI-IMMIGRATION VITRIOL                         alumni are parents to adult children with
         The article about Leah Boustan ’00’s             disabilities, and they have had to watch
         book, Streets of Gold, was informative           their children navigate the job market
         (Research, November issue). The                  and all the obstacles (and, yes, triumphs)
         facts she and her co-author reiterate            that come with this.
         have been long known and are beyond                  Disability employment is a relevant                        President’s
         dispute. How many immigrants our                 issue in the Princeton community. Your
         country can absorb, whom to admit, and           feature on Hess was inspiring, but what                         Award for
         how to deal with an influx that vastly           is the follow-up? Do you plan on profiling
         exceeds reasonable limits are fraught            any other leaders in Princeton’s disability                   Distinguished
         political issues, and neither party has          community on campus? And what is your
         been willing or able to solve them for           plan when it comes to addressing alumni                          Teaching
         30 years. But the hate, vitriol, and fear        with disabilities and/or alumni who work
                                                                                                                   The Office of the Dean of the Faculty
         mounted against immigrants are not               with this population? Where are the
                                                                                                                  invites all members of the community
         “myths,” they are part of a campaign             podcast episodes or the Reunions panel                                   to submit
         of out-and-out lying for partisan                discussions?                                               letters of nomination for the 2023
         advantage, to drive citizens to vote                 Reach out to us alumni and find out                              President’s Award
         against the incumbent administration.            who we are and what disability issues we                       for Distinguished Teaching.
             Calling lies “myths” suggests that           face in our lives. I am confident you will              All current full, associate, and assistant
                                                                                                                   professors as well as professors of the
         people are merely misinformed when               get an overwhelming response.
                                                                                                                      practice, university lecturers, and
         something much worse is going on. If             Preston Burger ’07                                           senior lecturers on continuing
         you think I’m exaggerating, study the            New York, N.Y.                                                 appointment are eligible for
         commercials aired during the baseball                                                                                      nomination.
         playoffs from a PAC called “Citizens for         Editor’s note: Alumni with disabilities who
                                                                                                                         Please send letters of nomination
         Sanity,” which promote all the “myths”           have stories to share are invited to contact                        by February 3, 2023 to:
         cited in PAW’s review and throw in drug          PAW at paw@princeton.edu, (609) 258-                           Office of the Dean of the Faculty
         dealers and child rapists to spice things        4886, or paw.princeton.edu/contact.                         9 Nassau Hall or PADT@princeton.edu

         paw.princeton.edu                    January 2023 P r i n c e t o n a lu m n i w e e k ly 7

SIGNOFF--03-06pawJan_Inbox.indd 7                                                                                                                              12/19/22 9:23 AM
Last Call for the Princeton Conservative? - 100 YEARS OF BAKER RINK REMEMBERING GRANT WAHL '96
S AT U R DAY, F E B R UA RY 2 5 , 2 0 2 3

                                                                     Courtesy of SHAPE Public Affairs Office

                                                                                                                                                       Photo: Bruce Liffiton
                                     WOODROW WILSON AWARD                                                           JAMES MADISON MEDAL
                                     Gen. Christopher Cavoli ’87                                                        Robert Kahn *64
                                      Supreme Allied Commander Europe;                                               Chairman, CEO and President
                                     Commander, U.S. European Command                                          Corporation for National Research Initiatives

                                                      Register today
                                                to reconnect with friends and fellow alumni;
                                        honor Princetonians during the Service of Remembrance;
                                           and celebrate Princeton’s top alumni award recipients.

                                            Alumni Day is a free event, open to all alumni and their guests.
                                                Learn more about the event and the award recipients at
                                                        alumni.princeton.edu/alumniday.

                                                  STAY CONNECTED TO PRINCETON BY FOLLOWING
                              @PrincetonAlumni          ON SOCIAL MEDIA AND VISITING                                         alumni.princeton.edu.

AlumniDay-JanuaryPAW-120522.indd 1                                                                                                                                             12/5/22 10:51 AM
NEWS, SPORTS, AND RESEARCH   DIVERSITY REPORT     SPORTS ON STAGE        SOCIAL BEES

                                     On the Campus

                                                                                                       Baker Rink has been renovated and
     Beverly Schaefer

                                                                                                   refreshed several times, but its historic
                                                                                                  surroundings remain unmistakable. This
                                                                                                      month, Princeton hockey’s venerable
                                                                                                    home celebrates its 100th anniversary.
                                                                                                                    Read more on page 18.

                        paw.princeton.edu                                            January 2023 P r i n c e t o n a lu m n i w e e k ly 9

SIGNOFF--09-17pawJan_OTC.indd 9                                                                                                         12/19/22 9:23 AM
On the Campus / News
                                                                                                      number of transfer students to 100 over
                                                                                                      the coming years. More than 90 percent
                                                                                                      of Princeton’s transfers come from
                                                                                                      community colleges.
                                                                                                          The combined efforts should put
                                                                                                      nontraditional students “on a path that
                                                                                                      strengthens their outcomes, but also
                                                                                                      the ecosystem of higher education,”
                                                                                                      according to Crittenden.
                                                                                                          The news came in December, just
                                                                                                      after the University published its second
                                                                                                      annual diversity, equity, and inclusion
                                                                                                      (DEI) report. The 48-page document
                                                                                                      (online at inclusive.princeton.edu)
                                                                                                      details the University’s efforts across and
                                                                                                      beyond campus to become more diverse,
                                                                                                      accessible, and accountable in matters
                                                                                                      related to race and ethnicity, gender,
                                                                                                      sexual orientation, religion, citizenship
         DIVERSITY, EQUITY, AND INCLUSION REPORT                                                      status, and more.

         Princeton Reaches Out
                                                                                                          The University’s DEI work is
                                                                                                      “guided by a set of institutional action
                                                                                                      plans,” according to the annual report,

         University to launch pilot programs that                                                     and follows President Christopher
                                                                                                      Eisgruber ’83’s September 2020 call “to
         engage nontraditional students                                                               find additional ways to promote racial
                                                                                                      equity for members of the Princeton

        P                                             The combined efforts
                  rinceton will pilot two new                                                         community and society as a whole, and
                  programs for local community        should put nontraditional                       to redouble the University’s past efforts
                  college students in the 2023-24     students “on a path                             to make Princeton a more diverse,
         academic year, building on a 2020 pledge                                                     inclusive, and equitable community.”
                                                      that strengthens their
         to expand the University’s teaching.                                                             Vice Provost for Institutional Equity
             “If you want to reach adult learners,
                                                      outcomes, but also the                          and Diversity Michele Minter said that
         community colleges are a really good         ecosystem of higher                             this work is not a top-down effort, but
         place to go,” said Vice Provost for          education,” according                           rather stems from and engages the entire
         Academic Affairs Cole Crittenden *05.        to Vice Provost Cole                            community.
             The first pilot will bring up to 36      Crittenden *05.                                     “We’ve tried to share ownership
         students from regional community                                                             and to encourage people to take
         colleges to Princeton this summer to         according to Crittenden. The fellows            responsibility in their own sphere of
         spend six to eight weeks earning credit      will teach an accredited Princeton              influence or in their own operations,”
         for two courses and learning more            course hosted at the community college,         said Minter, who also invited the
         about the transfer process, according to     and the effort will be led by staff in          community to share feedback by visiting
         Crittenden.                                  the McGraw Center for Teaching and              racialequity.princeton.edu/your-ideas-
             Crittenden said the students will        Learning.                                       change. “It’s everybody’s work.”
         be able to take advantage of Princeton           In addition, last year the Community            According to the report’s data
         resources, such as “financial aid officers   College Faculty Program increased               section, Princeton’s faculty and staff
         who can give an excellent overview           benefits for community college                  have become more racially diverse. In
         of the kinds of things students should       instructors who mentor Princeton                fall 2022, 21.4 percent of tenured and
         be paying attention to when they’re          graduate students, such as the ability          tenure-track faculty identified as Asian,
         thinking about transferring.” Staff from     to take one free Princeton course per           Black, Hispanic/Latino/a/x, or Native
         the Emma Bloomberg Center will lead          semester, and Crittenden said the               American, compared to 17.4 percent in
         the effort.                                  Prison Teaching Initiative at the Fort          2018. Senior staff identifying as Asian,
             For the second pilot, Princeton will     Dix federal facility is “getting back on its    Black, Hispanic/Latino/a/x, or Native
                                                                                                                                                     Designer491/Alamy

         recruit and hire two recent Ph.D.s and       feet” after a hiatus; the program is going      American, rose from 19 percent in 2017-
         place them as visiting teaching and          strong at state facilities. He also cited the   18 to 23 percent in 2021-22; nonsenior
         advising fellows at a local community        related expansion of Princeton’s transfer       staff saw a similar 4-percentage-point
         college partner yet to be determined,        program, which aims to increase the             increase in the same period.

         10 P r i n c e t o n a l u m n i w e e k ly January 2023

SIGNOFF--09-17pawJan_OTC.indd 10                                                                                                              12/19/22 2:59 PM
News / On the Campus
              Frederick Wherry *04, who became
         the University’s inaugural vice dean              COLLABORATIVE RESEARCH
         for diversity and inclusion in July, said
         there’s a “sense of momentum” when                10 Projects Kick Off Princeton’s
         it comes to hiring a diverse body of
         faculty. “Over time you really see steady
                                                           Partnerships with HBCUs

                                                           L
         progress, … and so long as we’re moving                   ess than six months after        groundbreaking impacts of the
         in the right direction, it feels really                   Princeton announced new          research itself, “it was a win-win,”
         good,” he said.                                           partnerships with five           said Tessa Lowinske Desmond,
              In January 2022, the University              historically Black colleges and          an associate research scholar and
         announced an increase in graduate                 universities (HBCUs), joint research     lecturer at Princeton’s Effron Center
         student stipends by an average of about           projects spanning from cybersecurity     for the Study of America and a co-
         25 percent — the largest ever one-year            to public health have begun.             principal investigator (PI) of one of
         increase — which took effect in the fall.             In November, Princeton announced the projects.
         The University hopes this will ensure             10 research partnerships chosen for          She’ll be working on “The
         that it can continue to “attract and retain       the first round of funding through the   Heirlooms Garden Project” with co-PIs
         the very best students without regard to          Princeton Alliance for Collaborative     Hanna Garth, an assistant professor
         economic background.”                             Research and                                                  of anthropology
              Graduate students were also invited          Innovation (PACRI),         Each project will be at Princeton;
         to last spring’s inaugural Inclusive              a new initiative that
                                                                                     funded for two years, Kimberly Jackson,
         Academy (IA) Symposium, which was                 “enable[s] research
         organized by the Graduate School                  collaborations
                                                                                       with a maximum of chair                 of chemistry
                                                                                                                         and biochemistry,
         to support all students in preparing              between Princeton         $250,000 per project. professor of
         for life after graduation. In addition,           faculty and their                                             biochemistry, and
         the Graduate School launched the                  peers at HBCUs,” according to the        director of food studies at Spelman;
         accompanying Best of Access, Diversity,           University’s initial announcement in     and Whitney Barr, program and garden
         and Inclusion (BADI) Awards to honor              May.                                     manager at Spelman and a trained
         those “who have made significant                      The selected proposals encompass     landscape designer.
         impacts in the Princeton graduate                 the natural sciences, social sciences,       They are using the funds to train
         student community around diversity                humanities, and engineering and          Princeton and Spelman students
         and inclusion.”                                   “take up some of the most difficult      in oral storytelling techniques and
              Other highlights from the report:            challenges of our day,” according to     then send them, over the next two
         • The Effron Center for the Study of             Princeton’s November announcement.       summers, to select sites to collect 240
            America, established in November                   “We were very pleased with the       oral histories from those working to
            2021, is investing in faculty, visitors, and   strength and number of proposals         preserve Black and Indigenous seed-
            fellows in “emerging areas of American         submitted for the first round of         and foodways, such as farmers and
            studies scholarship” including race and        PACRI funding and look forward to        gardeners, in the Southeastern United
            ethnicity studies.                             the results that will come from these    States and Appalachia.
         • Native and Indigenous members of               collaborative, creative projects,”           “So much about food is hidden
            the community are enjoying a newly             said University spokesman Michael        within stories and people’s memories,”
            dedicated affinity space on campus, and        Hotchkiss.                               said Barr, who noted that the project
            the Princeton University Library started           Each project will be funded for      will provide open-source access to the
            an Indigenous Studies Working Group            two years, with a maximum of             interviews.
            to learn from scholars in the discipline       $250,000 per project. Two projects           Garth said it’s important to collect
            and to curate related library resources.       were chosen in conjunction with          the narratives because the knowledge
         • The Task Force on the Future of Alumni         each of the five HBCU partners:          is often not understood by people
            Affinity Programming is developing             Spelman College, Howard University,      outside of the farming communities;
            recommendations for “a set of guiding          Jackson State University, Prairie        the narratives can also provide insight
            principles to inform work with alumni          View A&M University, and the             on well-adapted seeds.
            affinity groups.”                              University of Maryland Eastern               Spelman is an ideal partner, as the
              Eisgruber acknowledged that there            Shore. The United Negro College          institution already has an eighth-of-
         is more to do in a message included in            Fund, which advocates for and funds      an-acre on campus — centered around
         the report. “This University is — and will        scholarships for Black students, is also African diasporic plants — used to
         remain — a work in progress,” he wrote.           a PACRI partner.                         teach agroecological and regenerative
         “Commitments to diversity, inclusion,                 From funding scholarships for        practices that are part of Black
         and excellence require constant vigilance         HBCU students to the potentially         culture. By J.B.
         and unceasing effort.” By J.B.

         paw.princeton.edu                                                              January 2023 P r i n c e t o n a lu m n i w e e k ly 11

SIGNOFF--09-17pawJan_OTC.indd 11                                                                                                           12/19/22 9:23 AM
On the Campus / News
                                                                                                   he believes “Joe Scanlan intentionally
                                                                                                   and carefully planned his use of the
                                                                                                   word in order to raise another debate on
                                                                                                   free speech (akin to the Katz debacle)
                                                                                                   wherein he would emerge victorious.”
                                                                                                   Smith said he believes that Scanlan knew
                                                                                                   the class “would be greatly distressed by
                                                                                                   his use of the word.”
                                                                                                       Scanlan has since written a letter,
                                                                                                   published Nov. 16 by The Daily
                                                                                                   Princetonian, in which he said he is
                                                                                                   “extremely sorry that I overestimated
                                                                                                   my familiarity with my students and
                                                                                                   assumed that we could enter a discussion
                                                                                                   … without making some ground rules,
                                                            Visual arts professor Joe Scanlan,     first and foremost, about whether we
                                                            pictured at the Kunstmuseum Den        could use or even discuss the word at all.
                                                              Haag in the Netherlands in 2020,     As I have heard loud and clear from my
                                                            apologized after using the N-word
                                                                while teaching a poem in class.    students, that was a grievously hurtful
                                                                                                   overestimation on my part.”
         CLASSROOM CONTROVERSY                                                                         Princeton politics professor Keith
         Students Outraged After University                                                        Whittington, who wrote the 2018 Pre-
                                                                                                   read, Speak Freely: Why Universities Must
         Clears Professor Who Said the N-Word                                                      Defend Free Speech, told PAW that “it’s
                                                                                                   critically important that you maintain a

         S
                  tudents made their disapproval      some students left, including Omar           certain level of comfort and trust with the
                  known after Princeton University    Farah ’23, who also reached out to           students so you can actually engage in the
                  said it is standing behind Joe      administrators to file a complaint.          educational process more effectively, and
         Scanlan, a professor of visual arts who      Farah was told a few days later by Cheri     using that language, I think, just winds up
         said the N-word in one of his classes.       Burgess, director for institutional equity   pushing some students away. And so, I
             The controversy started on Nov. 3        and equal employment opportunity in          think most of the time, you’re much better
         while Scanlan was teaching “Words as         the Office of the Provost, that an initial   off if you don’t do it.”
         Objects.” Students had been assigned to      assessment “determined that, given the           Scanlan has continued to teach, but
         read a series of poems by Jonah Mixon-       academic context in which the word was       Simon Wu ’17, a Ph.D. candidate at Yale,
         Webster including “Black Existentialism      used, it does not implicate the Policy on    was appointed course co-adviser.
         No. 8: Ad Infinitum; or Ad Nauseam”          Discrimination and/or Harassment,”               The repercussions have continued.
         — an example of concrete poetry, which       according to the Prince.                     Twenty-one visual arts students
         is defined by the Poetry Foundation as          In a statement, University spokesman      signed a letter calling for a University
         emphasizing “nonlinguistic elements          Michael Hotchkiss said, “Princeton           investigation and critical engagement
         in its meaning, such as a typeface that      guarantees all faculty and students the      “with the events [that] took place and
         creates a visual image of the topic.”        ‘broadest possible latitude’ to speak        their impact on students. And we call on
             The poem is 24 pages consisting          freely inside and outside the classroom.     the Visual Arts department to reconcile
         solely of the N-word, which in this case     Speech is only restricted under narrow       with the space they have held for racism
         ends with “as.” The word itself appears      exceptions that do not apply to this         and disrespect.”
         in large print across the first two pages,   incident. Our rules recognize that these         The Prince reported that several visual
         and a series of “s’s” trail on for the       free speech protections apply to words       arts students hung posters advocating
         remainder.                                   and ideas that people may find ‘offensive,   for Scanlan’s dismissal at a Nov. 15 open
             In a 2021 blog post, Mixon-Webster,      unwise, immoral, or wrong-headed,’           studio event.
         who is Black, said “it is still a cultural   but these protections are essential for          The Prince’s editorial board also
         priority to continue appraising the word     Princeton’s truth-seeking mission.”          published a column that stated that
         while speculating on its implications for       David Smith ’24, a Black student in       “white people’s use of the N-word has
                                                                                                                                                 Minnie Cho/Fuseloft LLC

         Black futurity.”                             the class, compared Scanlan’s choice         irreversibly harmed Black people and
             Scanlan, who is white, told PAW he       to use the N-word in class to former         communities throughout the course of
         said the word when asking his class how      professor Joshua Katz calling the Black      American history, and continues to have
         it functioned in the poem.                   Justice League “a small local terrorist      that effect today. Although Scanlan says he
             The fallout was immediate.               organization” in a 2020 online opinion       did not intend to hurt anyone, that is the
             According to The Daily Princetonian,     column. Smith told PAW via email that        consequence of his language.” By J.B.

         12 P r i n c e t o n a l u m n i w e e k ly January 2023

SIGNOFF--09-17pawJan_OTC.indd 12                                                                                                          12/19/22 2:59 PM
News / On the Campus
                                                                                                                        CAMPUS ICONOGRAPHY

                                                                                                                        University Considers Removing
                                                                                                                        Witherspoon Statue

                                                                                                                        T
                                                                                                                                 he University’s Committee             president, and preacher.
                                                                                                                                 on Naming is reviewing a                  But Witherspoon also had a “complex
                                                                                                                                 proposal to remove or replace         relationship to slavery,” according to
                                                                                                                        a campus statue of John Witherspoon,           Princeton & Slavery Project research by
                                                                                                                        an influential figure in the American          Lesa Redmond ’17, who wrote her senior
                                                                                                                        Revolution who owned slaves during his         thesis about the Witherspoon family’s
                                                                                                                        time as Princeton’s president.                 ties to slavery in the United States. While
                                                                                                                            Last May, five members of the              Witherspoon tutored three free Black
                                                                                                                        philosophy department — graduate               students during his time at Princeton, he     specific decisions about renaming and
                                                                                                                        students Brendan Kolb, Kathryn Rech,           also purchased two enslaved people to         changing campus iconography.” Those
                                                                                                                        Giulia Weissmann, and Waner Zhang,             farm his country estate and voted against     criteria include determining whether the
                                                                                                                        and Professor Boris Kment *06 —                abolishing slavery in New Jersey.             namesake was “significantly out of step
                                                                                                                        created a petition that said the statue,           The naming committee’s review             with the standards” of the namesake’s
                                                                                                                        which has stood outside East Pyne              “will be informed by rigorous research,       time and if the space in question plays “a
                                                                                                                        Hall since 2001, “pays great honor … to        scholarly expertise within and beyond         substantial role in forming community at
                                                                                                                        someone who participated actively in the       the University community, and input           the University.”
                                                                                                                        enslavement of human beings, and used          from the broad University community,”             Kolb, Rech, and Zhang, who responded
                                                                                                                        his scholarly gifts to defend the practice.”   according to a University release. The        to questions from PAW by email, wrote
                                                                                                                        The petition, signed by 285 members            committee began holding listening             that while Witherspoon, in his time,
                                                                                                                        of the campus community, proposed              sessions with alumni, faculty, staff, and     “didn’t stand out among people in power
                                                                                                                        replacing the statue with a plaque that        students in late November and found           for a commitment to defending racist
                                                                                                                        “details both the positive and negative        “diversity of opinion about the statue        norms or power structures,” the towering
                                                                                                                        aspects of Witherspoon’s legacy.”              among every constituency,” according          statue and its high-traffic location unduly
                                                                                                                            Witherspoon, who emigrated from            to history professor Angela Creager, the      exalt his legacy.
 Danielle Alio/Princeton University; Willem de Kooning (1904–1997; born Rotterdam, Netherlands; died East Hampton,

                                                                                                                        Scotland to serve as the College of New        committee’s interim chair.                        “[O]ur argument has both aesthetic
 N.Y.), Woman II, 1961. Oil on paper mounted on canvas, 73.7 x 57.1 cm. Promised gift of Preston H. Haskell, Class of

                                                                                                                        Jersey’s sixth president, from 1768                Princeton’s Board of Trustees will        and moral dimensions,” they wrote,
 1960. © The Willem de Kooning Foundation / Artists Rights Society (ARS), New York / Photo: Douglas J. Eng

                                                                                                                        to 1794, was the only clergyman and            have the ultimate say in any changes to       “based on the broad principle that
                                                                                                                        college president to sign the Declaration      the statue’s placement or presentation.       depictions of a certain grandeur are
                                                                                                                        of Independence. The 10-foot bronze            In April 2021, the trustees adopted           inappropriate for certain spaces when the
                                                                                                                        sculpture, created with an identical twin      “Principles to Govern Renaming and            subject depicted was actively engaged
                                                                                                                        at the University of the West of Scotland,     Changes to Campus Iconography”                in racialized slavery — a practice that
                                                                                                                        stands on a plinth with three tablets          (available online at bit.ly/re-naming),       separated out the humanity that Princeton
                                                                                                                        that explain his legacies as a patriot,        which established “criteria to help guide     aims to serve.” By B.T.

                                                                                                                                                                       Haskell ’60 Gift Supports Museum,
                                                                                                                                                                       New Art Education Center
                                                                                                                                                                       A
                                                                                                                                                                                 n education center at the new Princeton University Art Museum will
                                                                                                                                                                                 be named for collector and philanthropist Preston H. Haskell III ’60
                                                                                                                                                                                 in recognition of his major gift to the Venture Forward campaign, the
                                                                                                                                                                       University announced Nov. 13. Haskell also will donate eight abstract paintings to the
                                                                                                                                                                       museum, including works by Willem de Kooning and Mark Rothko.
                                                                                                                                                                           Haskell, the founder and chairman of a Florida-based engineering, architectural,
                                                                                                                                                                       and construction company, served two terms on Princeton’s Board of Trustees and
                                                                                                                                                                       24 years on the museum’s advisory council. The University declined to provide the
                                                                                                                                                                       amount of Haskell’s gift.
                                                                                                                                                                           The new museum, designed by architect David Adjaye, is under construction
                                                                                                                                                                       at the site of the previous museum and expected to open in 2024. In a University
                                                                                                                                                                       release, museum director James Steward credited Haskell with financial support
                                                                                                                          Willem de Kooning’s Woman II is one
                                                                                                                          of eight abstract paintings donated          and volunteer leadership that helped make the project a reality. Haskell’s gift of art,
                                                                                                                          by Preston H. Haskell III ’60.               Steward added, “takes our collection of modern art to a new level.” By B.T.

                                                                                                                        paw.princeton.edu                                                               January 2023 P r i n c e t o n a lu m n i w e e k ly 13

SIGNOFF--09-17pawJan_OTC.indd 13                                                                                                                                                                                                                           12/19/22 2:59 PM
On the Campus / News
         CLASS CLOSE-UP
                                                                                                         IN SHORT
         Looking to
         Pandemics Past
         to Plan the Future

         W
                       hen the COVID-19 pandemic
                       began to rattle the globe,
                       Professor Keith Wailoo,
         a historian of medicine, disease, and
         health care, felt as if we were “living                                                         IMANI PERRY, a professor of
         inside our history books,” as one of his                                                        African American studies, won
         colleagues put it.                                                                              the 2022 National Book Award for
             Media outlets and the public suddenly                                                       nonfiction for South to America: A
         became very interested in finding out                                                           Journey Below the Mason-Dixon to
         what pandemics of the past could teach                                                          Understand the Soul of a Nation.
         us. Wailoo said he was peppered with                                                            In their citation for the award, the
                                                                                                         judges wrote that South to America
         questions like, “What are we going
                                                                                                         is “elegantly personal and archival,
         through right now? How does it compare         During the Spanish Flu pandemic of
                                                                                                         predictive and bold, sweet and
         to what’s happened in the past? And are        1918-19, face masks were required on
                                                        public transit in Seattle, Washington.           soulful, and, most of all, true.”
         there lessons from the past that we can                                                             Perry delivered an emotional
         apply to thinking about and navigating                                                          acceptance speech at the Nov. 16
         the uncertainties of COVID?”                      After learning the basics, students           ceremony, saying that artists and
             Wailoo, who served as president of         were asked to think about solutions for          intellectuals are obliged to bear
         the American Association for the History       the present and the future.                      witness and be truthful. “We may
         of Medicine from 2020 to 2022, gave               “How do you figure out wise policy            write in solitude, but we labor in
         talks and interviews, including with           with this historical backdrop, this historical   solidarity,” she said. “Community is
         PAW, but he also decided to “share some        knowledge, in mind?” Wailoo asked.               never easy but absolutely necessary.
                                                                                                         Let us meet the challenges of a
         of that insight and wisdom from the field         For the midterm, students wrote a five-
                                                                                                         broken world together, making
         with students who were interested in the       to-seven-page paper focusing on a local          intercessions with love unbound and
         intersection of history and public policy.”    or national issue in pandemic policy, such       heart without end.”
             In the fall, 23 students took advantage    as masking mandates, and how the issue
         by enrolling in “Making Post-Pandemic          relates to historical antecedents. The final     Princeton announced two changes
         Worlds: Epidemic History and the Future,”      consisted of a longer paper with a more          in major administrative roles:
         a dual history and School of Public and        international scope.                             Computer science professor
         International Affairs (SPIA) class.               Students also were required to write          JENNIFER REXFORD ’91 was
             Through twice-a-week 50-minute             weekly responses to readings such as             appointed as the next provost, and
         lectures in Robertson Hall and precepts,       Charles Rosenberg’s book The Cholera             chemical and biological engineering
                                                                                                         professor PABLO DEBENEDETTI
         the course identified throughlines             Years: The United States in 1832, 1849,
                                                                                                         will step down as dean for research
         from the Black Death to polio to AIDS,         and 1866 and Fang Fang’s 2020 writings           after 10 years in the role.
         such as challenges to globalization and        in Wuhan Diary: Dispatches from a                   Rexford, a former Pyne Prize
         misinformation.                                Quarantined City.                                winner who chairs the computer
             There are “really familiar themes in          “I found the readings incredible.             science department and has been on
         the history of pandemics,” according to        That’s probably my favorite part about           the faculty since 2005, will become
                                                                                                                                                     Ian Dagnall Computing/Alamy; Sameer A. Khan h’21

         Wailoo. “So, one goal of the class is just     the course,” said SPIA major Nannette            provost March 13, taking over for
         to have students be … more informed            Beckley ’23.                                     Deborah Prentice, who is leaving
         about the recurring questions — like              Beckley, who plans to pursue a                Princeton to become vice-chancellor
         around trust and expertise, civil liberties,   master’s in public health in epidemiology        of the University of Cambridge. The
                                                                                                         provost leads Princeton’s budgeting
         social inequality — that inevitably            after she graduates, said she has always
                                                                                                         process, oversees long-term
         emerge after pandemics.”                       been interested in illness and disease,
                                                                                                         planning, and serves as the chief
                                                        but the class has taught her more about          academic officer.
                                                        the behavioral, social, and political               Debenedetti has led Princeton’s
         “Through this class,                           aspects of pandemics.                            research agenda and overseen
         I’ve seen that we’ve                              “Through this class,” she said, “I’ve         growth in sponsored research and
         been repeating history.”                       seen that we’ve been repeating history.”         industry and foundation awards. He
         — Nannette Beckley ’23                         By J.B.                                                              Continues on page 17

         14 P r i n c e t o n a l u m n i w e e k ly January 2023

SIGNOFF--09-17pawJan_OTC.indd 14                                                                                                              12/19/22 9:23 AM
You can also read