PHYSIOLOGYNEWS - The Physiological Society

Page created by Phillip Warren
 
CONTINUE READING
PHYSIOLOGYNEWS - The Physiological Society
PHYSIOLOGYNEWS
                                                              spring 2005 | number 58

IUPS 2005
Images of the Bristol, Nottingham, Oxford and KCL
Meetings

Also featuring:
Living history – the case of the misbehaving circuit
50 years of caveolae
Obesity – why all the noise?
From tadpole to frog: a tale of two networks
The Nobel Prize

                 A publication of the Physiological Society
PHYSIOLOGYNEWS - The Physiological Society
King’s College London

 Images from and around
  King’s College London,
venue for the Physiological
     Society Meeting
  17-20 December, 2004
     (photos by Prem Kumar)

 More images from the KCL Meeting
  appear on the inside back cover
PHYSIOLOGYNEWS - The Physiological Society
PHYSIOLOGYNEWS
                                                             Editorial                                                                     3

                                                             IUPS 2005                                              4
                                                             Images of KCL Prem Kumar, David Eisner          ifc, ibc
   The Society’s dog. ‘Rudolf Magnus gave                    Oxford Focused Meeting Denis Noble                     5
   me to Charles Sherrington, who gave me                    Nottingham Focused Meeting Paul Greenhaff              6
   to Henry Dale, who gave me to the                         Bristol Focused Meeting Sergey Kasparov, Julian Paton 7
   Physiological Society in October 1942’                    ‘The Senses’ Karl Gegenfurtner                         8

                                                             Living History
                                                             The case of the misbehaving circuit Stanley Salmons                           9
Published quarterly by the Physiological Society
                                                             A summer in the life of ... Giovanni Mann                                    11
Contributions and Queries
Executive Editor                                             Features
Linda Rimmer                                                 The Nobel Prize Tim Jacob                                                    12
The Physiological Society                                    50 years of caveolae - a round-up Michael Taggart                            13
Publications Office
                                                             Obesity - why all the noise? Paul Trayhurn                                   15
Building 4A, The Michael Young Centre
                                                             Metamorphosis from tadpole to frog: a tale of two networks Denis
Purbeck Road
Cambridge CB2 2HP
                                                             Combes, Simon Merrywest, John Simmers, Keith Sillar                          17
                                                             Impact of the intrauterine environment on respiratory health throughout
Tel: +44 (0)1223 400180                                      life Richard Harding, Megan Cock, Gert Maritz                                19
Fax: +44 (0)1223 246858                                      The interdependence of cell volume and resting membrane potential
Email: lrimmer@physoc.org                                    James Fraser, Christopher L-H Huang                                          21
The Society web server: http://www.physoc.org                Mechanosensory transduction in the enteric nervous system Terence
                                                             Smith, Nick Spencer, Grant Hennig                                            23
Magazine Editorial Board                                     The fire within: fuel selection in shivering muscles François Haman,
Editor                                                       Stéphane Legault, Jean-Michel Weber                                          26
Austin Elliott (University of Manchester)                    Differential screening of a subtractive cDNA library reveals that maternal
Members                                                      undernutrition affects fetal heart gene expression Hyungchul Han,
Lesley Anson (Nature)                                        Thomas Hansen                                                                28
Laura Blackburn (University of Cambridge)                    NMDA receptor kinetics are tuned for coincidence detection during
Munir Hussain (University of Liverpool)                      spike-timing dependent synaptic plasticity Björn Kampa, Greg Stuart          29
John Lee (Rotherham General Hospital)                        Myocardial connexin 43: gap junction-dependent and gap junction­
Thelma Lovick (University of Birmingham)                     independent effects on ischaemia/reperfusion injury Antonio Rodriguez-
Bill Winlow (Prime Medica, Knutsford)                        Sinovas, David Garcia-Dorado, Alberto Cabestrero, Marisol Ruiz-Meana         31
                                                             Endocrine granules David Perrais, Justin Taraska, Wolfhard Almers            33
© 2005 The Physiological Society                             Exploring connections between the cerebellum and motor cortex in
ISSN 1476-7996                                               humans Jeff Daskalakis, Robert Chen                                          35
                                                             Bilateral interactions between the upper limbs Richard Carson,
The Society permits the single copying of                    Stephan Riek, Winston Byblow                                                 37
individual articles for private study or research. For       Fishing for 02 chemoreceptors in vertebrates Michael Jonz,
copying or reproduction for any other purpose,               Colin Nurse                                                                  39
written permission must be sought from the
Physiological Society (lrimmer@physoc.org).                  International News
                                                             Transport mechanisms across cell membranes David Brown,
Opinions expressed in articles and letters submitted
                                                             Myrtani Pieri                                                                41
by, or commissioned from, Members, Affiliates or
outside bodies are not necessarily those of the
Physiological Society.
                                                             Affiliate News
                                                             When is a young physiologists’ symposium NOT a young physiologists’
The Physiological Society is registered in England           symposium? Charlotte Waters                                         43
as a company limited by guarantee: No 323575.
Registered office: PO Box 11319, London WC1X
8WQ                                                          The Dead Ringer team clean up at
Registered Charity: No 211585.                               Lastingham Dead Ringer Society                                               44

Printed by The Lavenham Press Ltd                            Letters to the Editor                                                        45

                                                             Society News
Cover photo                                                  New Council members Austin Elliott                                           34
Cover illustration from Combes et al. p. 17
                                                             Profiting from Postgraduate Talent 2004 Sarah Blackford                      46
                       Ventral view of metamorphosing
                       stage 61 Xenopus tadpole.             G L Brown Lecture Judy Harris, Michael Rennie                                47
                       Background activity is rhythmic       Benevolent Fund Joanna Rattray                                               48
                       spinal ventral root discharge         Deceased Members                                                             48
                       simultaneously driving tail           Where does my future lie? Sai Pathmanathan                                   48
                       oscillations during swimming (top     Biology in the real world Sai Pathmanathan                                   48
                       trace) and limb extension-flexion
                       thrusts (lower traces).               What have Council been talking about? Austin Elliott                         49
                       Photography courtesy of Sean
                       Earnshaw, University of St Andrews,   Funding boost for graduate training in
                       using a Nikon FM SLR camera with      animal research Clare Stanford                                               40
                       110 mm macro lens.                    Unbelievable!                                                                50
                                                             Book Reviews                                                                 50
                                                             Noticeboard                                                                  18
PHYSIOLOGYNEWS - The Physiological Society
PHYSIOLOGYNEWS
 Action points                            Guidelines for contributors
 Grants                                   These guidelines are intended to assist
                                                                                                   In this issue
                                                                                                   This issue of Physiology News contains
 For full information on Members’         authors in writing their contributions and to
                                                                                                   several examples of the serendipity on which
 and Affiliates’ Grants, Pfizer in vivo   reduce the subsequent editing process. The
                                                                                                   science often depends. A trained mind asking
 Physiology Grants, Network               Editorial Group of Physiology News tries to              the right questions is essential in research,
 Interaction Grants, Non-Society          ensure that all articles are written in a                but serendipity and chance play a role too. A
                                          journalistic style so that they will have an             thought in the right place; a totally
 Symposia Grants, Postgraduate
                                          immediate interest value for a wide                      unexpected observation; a chance finding
 Support Fund information and the         readership and will be readable and                      that leads somewhere unforeseen.
 Vacation Studentship Scheme visit:       comprehensible to non-experts. In
 http://www.physoc.org/grants             particular, scientific articles should give a            For me personally this is a big part of the
                                          good overview of a field rather than focus               attraction of doing research, and also part of
 Membership applications                  entirely on the authors’ own research.                   what makes research and its history
                                                                                                   interesting to read about. In Living History,
 Applications for Full and Affiliate                                                               Stanley Salmons gives an example of
 Membership are received throughout       Format of articles
                                          The main message or question posed should be             serendipity when he describes how a simple
 the year and have no deadlines. A        introduced in the first paragraph. The background        malfunctioning circuit took him down many
 decision is normally made within 8­      for the topic should then be established, leading        new scientific avenues, and even into cardiac
 10 weeks of the Administration           up to the final conclusion.                              surgery.
 Office receiving the application. For
                                          Length of articles                                       Sometimes, of course, it can take a long time
 full details please visit:               This will be determined by the subject matter and        for a serendipitous finding to be fully
 http://www.physoc.org/join               agreed with the Editorial Administrator.                 appreciated. As Mike Taggart describes on
                                                                                                   p. 13, it has taken caveolae 50 years, but
                                          Submission of articles                                   they definitely seem to have made it from
 Change of address                        Authors should submit articles as a Word                 morphological curiosity to centre stage in
 Members should inform the                document attached to an email. Illustrations             cell biology.
 Administration Office of any changes     should be sent as separate attachments (see below)
 of address, telephone, fax or email      and not embedded in the text.
                                                                                                   Another of the charms of research is that
 address.                                 Illustrations and authors’ photographs
                                                                                                   nothing is ever set in stone. Paradigms
                                                                                                   change, and even in the best-explored areas
 Changes can be emailed to:               Authors are encouraged to submit diagrams,
                                                                                                   there are new ideas to be found, and new
 jgould@physoc.org or updated online      drawings, photographs or other artwork with their
                                          articles or to suggest appropriate illustrations. A      ways of looking at things, as Fraser and
 at http://www.physoc.org                 photograph of the author(s) should also                  Huang explore for the GHK equation (p. 21).
                                          accompany submissions, if possible. Illustrations
                                          and photographs may be colour or black and               Aside from those brief highlights, we have a
                                          white, prints, transparencies or tif/jpeg files with a   full issue's worth of science News and
                                          minimum resolution of 300 dpi. Electronic                Views, Features, and Society news. We
 Physiology News                          colour figures should be saved in CMYK mode.             preview some IUPS and San Diego
                                                                                                   attractions, introduce you to your new
 Deadlines                                References                                               Council members on p. 34 and highlight
                                          Authors are requested to keep the number of              what the Council has been talking about on
 Letters and articles and all other       references to a minimum – preferably no more             p. 49. Plus the joys (?) of research
 contributions for inclusion in the       than two or three. Please cite all references in the     committees and themes in Unbelievable!
 Summer 2005 issue, No. 59, should        style of The Journal of Physiology (see                  Happy Easter.
 reach the Publications Office            Instructions to Authors 2005 at
                                          http://www.physoc.org)                                   Austin Elliott
 (lrimmer@physoc.org) by 20 April,
 2005. Short news items are
 encouraged and can usually be
 included as late copy if space
 permits.

 Suggestions for articles
 Suggestions for future articles are
 welcome. Please contact either the
 Editorial Administrator or a member
 of the Editorial Group of Physiology
 News (see contents page for details).

 Physiology News Online
 Physiology News is now available on
 our website: http://www.physoc.org.
PHYSIOLOGYNEWS - The Physiological Society
EDITORIAL        PN       3

Democracy? Ho hum                                         NB to Council: could be time to
                                                          triple the membership charges.
                                                                                                  Society’s parliament, it was felt,
                                                                                                  directly elected by the membership
At its 2004 Annual General Meeting                                                                and therefore accountable to them.
in Cork, the Members of the                               Note, though, that there was more       In addition, really significant
Physiological Society voted to                            on the relevant voting paper than       changes in how the Society’s rules
abolish voting on oral                                    just the changes in voting on           were drawn would require a vote of
communications and posters.                               communications. There were also         the Members. A referendum, in
                                                          some changes in the make-up of the      effect.
Well, I say ‘the Members’. I could                        group of Trustees who are legally
(more accurately) have said ‘well                         responsible for running the Society     Unfortunately, aspects of this don’t
under 5% of the Members’.                                 (Physiology News, 57, 41). So on        seem to be working.
                                                          the above reasoning we would have
No precise numbers – the                                  to conclude that the Members            Perhaps an incentive is needed.
scrutineers winced at the prospect                        wanted those to go through too.         Maybe the Society should offer a £5
of them being repeated here, and                                                                  discount off the annual membership
had a lapse of memory.                                    Or that we don’t care. Take your        fee to people who actually send
                                                          pick.                                   back their ballot papers.
Given the 100-plus years that the
Society’s tradition of voting on                          One thing this is not, though, is       NB to Council: how about this: put
communications had existed, it                            fully-functional Society democracy.     the annual membership fee up £10,
might seem pretty surprising that so                      Misfunctioning, or even                 and then offer £5 off if they vote.
few of the Society’s Members could                        dysfunctional, maybe.
rouse themselves to vote.                                                                         Whatever the Society decides to do
                                                          To repeat: it is only functioning if    (or doesn’t decide, or decides not to
One rather expects that few people                        we – the Members – all are 100%         do) about this, there is one point
will trudge along to AGMs, whether                        happy that our not voting means we      that cannot be reiterated enough.
for Trades Unions, learned Societies                      don’t care what the result is.
or residents associations. Unless                                                                 In a democracy, people get to think
they are, respectively, trying to stop                    As I have written before, I find this   for themselves. But if what they
your university being closed, trying                      hard to believe, given what an          think is that they’re not bothered,
to triple your membership charges,                        argumentative bunch physiologists       then they can have no complaints if
or opposing the construction of a                         are. In my experience most              they don’t like what gets done in
railway line at the end of your                           scientists prefer to spend their free   their name.
garden.                                                   time, like their lunch hours,
                                                          debating, arguing, grumbling and,       ‘Well I didn’t vote for any of them,
But less than 5% of the Society’s                         occasionally, eating. Put half a        so you can’t blame me.’
Members could even be bothered to                         dozen of them in a bar during a
vote via a postal ballot that had                         Society Meeting, start an argument      Wrong.
been mailed out to them.                                  about whether voting on
                                                                                                  There is an apt quote for this sort of
                                                          communications is a waste of time,
Reading something, ticking a few                                                                  ailing democratic-but-participation­
                                                          and watch them go.
boxes, and stuffing the piece of                                                                  light process, usually attributed to
paper in an envelope. How difficult                       So what makes us so vote-shy?           the American politician Adlai
or time-consuming is that?                                                                        Stevenson:
                                                          The major changes in Governance
If one is being charitable, one can                       at the Society a few years ago, in      ‘In a democracy, people get the
read the (lack of) response of the                        particular the change to a fully­       government they deserve.’
membership as being a tacit                               elected Council, were a laudable
approval of the change. People                                                                    Remember that when you get this
                                                          attempt to make the Society more
probably see that the motion is                                                                   year’s voting papers.
                                                          democratic and give the Members
being proposed by the Society’s                           more of a direct say in how the         Austin Elliott
Council, assume it will go through,                       Society was run. The Society’s
and approve by doing nothing.                             Council should be a bit like the

Physiology News | No. 58 | Spring 2005 | www.physoc.org
PHYSIOLOGYNEWS - The Physiological Society
4        PN            IUPS

IUPS 2005
As a decent number of Physiological Society Members troop off to the IUPS meeting in San
Diego, we preview some of the attractions…

First - the meeting!                                                                                              Grant. Don’t blame us if you get
… of course, the biggest attraction is                                                                            arrested, though.
the IUPS conference itself. After all,
what could be more enticing than the                                                                              • Visit Sea World; entrance is a slightly
prospect of meeting up with 2000+                                                                                 painful $50, but the Killer Whale show
other bioscientists from all around the                                                                           is quite something (word of warning;
world? Well, the prospect of meeting                                                                              wear something waterproof if you are
up with 2000+ scientists somewhere                                                                                going to sit in one of the first 10 rows).
sunny. IUPS conferences have a long                                                                               For a preview visit the webcam at:
and distinguished history – this one is                                                                           http://www.shamu.com/ca/shamu­
the 35th, with the first having taken                                                                             cam/index.htm
place in Basel in 1889 - and have
visited many locations around the                                                                                 • For the young (or at least young-at­
world, but sunshine and an exotic                                                                                 heart), wander down to Pacific Beach
location is always a plus. The last three                                                                         (‘PB’) to take in the nightlife. Don’t
meetings, for those that weren’t there,                                                                           forget to rehydrate afterwards.
were a slightly damp and chilly                                                                                   Alternatively, go there in the day to
Glasgow in 1993 (the last time the                                                                                stroll along the beach. For a ‘Surfcam’
IUPS came to Britain), St Petersburg in                                                                           preview and other local surf info have a
1997 (described by participants as                                                                                look at: http://scilib.ucsd.edu/sio/ocean/
‘unforgettable’, for a whole range of
reasons) and most recently                                                                                        • Visit Balboa Park for a day to do the
Christchurch in 2001. For anyone                                                                                  museums (multi-museum day tickets
interested, a report on this last meeting                                                                         available for around $30), go to the
can still be found on our website in                                                                              zoo, or just stroll around. NB: Some bus
issue 45 (Winter 2001).                                                                                           routes from the hotel district to Balboa
                                                                                                                  Park do go through ‘interesting’ parts
Second, the city                                                                                                  of town; watch out for bus-stop benches
San Diego has many visitor attractions,                                                                           with signs like: ‘In jail? Make bail! –
and as a small service we have                                                                                    call 1-800-BOND-OUT’
provided a brief list of must­
visits/must-dos (purely for those who                 From the top:                                               • Take the coast light railway - the
have spare days, of course).                          Physiology News Editor Austin Elliott visits the Hotel      ‘San Diego trolley’ - down to Tijuana
                                                      del Coronado; life’s a beach in San Diego; beware of        and stroll over into Mexico for duty­
                                                      killer whales at Sea World.
                                                                                                                  free shopping, Mexican food, and
                   IUPS 2005                                                                                      ‘other attractions’.
    th                                                You should…
 35 Congress of the International Union
      of Physiological Sciences                       • Have dinner on a restaurant terrace                         Want to try your hand as a
         San Diego, CA, USA                           overlooking the ocean (or at least                                      writer?
                                                      within earshot of the sea) in La Jolla                       Due to scheduling conflicts none of the
          31 March – 5 April, 2005
                                                                                                                   regular Physiology News team will be
          (http://www.IUPS2005.org)                   • Have lunch at the famous Hotel del                         reporting from the IUPS. We would
                                                      Coronado (The ‘Del’) on Coronado                             therefore welcome brief reports (300
 Two Journal of Physiology symposia will take place
                                                      Island. The ‘Del’ is where the future                        words) on the meeting from anyone who
                   at the IUPS:
                                                      Edward VIII of England first met Mrs                         would like a shot at being a stand-in
    PDZ domain scaffolding proteins and their         Simpson, and will also be immediately                        Conference/Foreign Correspondent, and
       functions in polarized cells (4 April)         recognisable to anyone who has seen                          thinks they could be both entertaining
    TRP channels: physiological genomics and          the movie Some Like It Hot. True                             and informative. We will pay £50 for
               proteomics (5 April)                   movie buffs can buy a blue blazer and                        any pieces published and are keen to get
                                                      yachting cap at one of San Diego’s                           views from physiologists of all ages - so
                                                      first-rate thrift stores and try pretending                  come on, get your reporter’s notebook
            (http://www.jphysiol.org)
                                                      to be Tony Curtis pretending to be Cary                      out.

                                                                                                               Physiology News | No. 58 | Spring 2005 | www.physoc.org
PHYSIOLOGYNEWS - The Physiological Society
OXFORD FOCUSED MEETING                                         PN              5

Oxford Focused Meeting                                    calcium transients and calcium
                                                          handling was published instead by The
                                                                                                      that. The irony is obvious. The
                                                                                                      significance lies much deeper and is
The Society’s first meeting                               Royal Society (DiFrancesco & Noble,         more important. As Hodgkin and
on modelling in physiology                                1985). I believe that was also the point    Huxley’s work showed: the best
                                                          at which the traditional ‘British’          simulation work in physiology is
I built my first cardiac cell model in                    approach to the life science started to     strongly based experimentally, and it
1960 (Noble, 1960) following the                          lose ground to the more pragmatic style     succeeds to the extent that it interacts
discovery of the potassium channels, iK1                  championed in the United States, where      further with experimental work, both by
and iK, in cardiac Purkinje fibres                        Bioengineering groups at various            suggesting new experiments and by
(Hutter & Noble, 1960). In October                        universities took up the challenge,         itself developing in iterative interaction
2004, the Society held its first ever                     including notably the work of Luo and       with them.
meeting devoted to modelling in                           Rudy (1994) and of Raimond Winslow
physiology. There can’t be many other                     (Rice et al. 1999). The preferred key       This strategy can also be linked to the
areas of our science that have waited 44                  journals now include the American           growing popularity of what has come to
years for a dedicated meeting! One                        Journal of Physiology (where my latest      be called ‘systems biology’. No-one is
could argue that it is 52 years, since the                modelling work has been published),         quite sure what the term means, but
paradigm model was that of Hodgkin                        the Journal of General Physiology,          physiologists can be clear that, at the
and Huxley (Hodgkin & Huxley, 1952).                      Circulation Research and the                least, it includes quantitative analysis of
It was therefore a great pleasure to be                   Biophysical Journal. These are all          the areas that are traditionally called
able to welcome Sir Andrew Huxley to                      published in the USA. It is worth           systems physiology. It also includes
introduce the Hodgkin-Huxley-Katz                         noting, though, that Philosophical          what molecular and genomic biologists
lecture on the first day of the meeting.                  Transactions of the Royal Society and       now refer to as the theory of
                                                          Progress in Biophysics and Molecular        interactions. The distinguished
Why such a long delay? One reason is                      Biology continue to be active in this       geneticist Gabriel Dover (2000) goes
that, until fairly recently, the Society                  area.                                       as far as to say: ‘We don’t have a
has not held focused meetings on any                                                                  theory of interactions and until we do
subject. When I started work as                           In fact, we now find ourselves having       we cannot have a theory of
Meetings Secretary in 1974 all the                        to catch up. The Oxford meeting was         development or a theory of evolution’.
Society’s meetings were general.                          an excellent contribution to achieving      This is therefore also the route by
Moreover, the Secretary was required                      that, since it showed how strong the        which physiology can reconnect with
to mix all the topics up in each meeting                  field still is here in the UK, but it was   the mainstream of biological thought,
by arranging the abstracts in the order                   also a strongly international one, with     including developmental biology and
in which they were received. I was the                    presentations from countries as far         evolutionary biology (Diamond, 1993).
first to break this tradition by                          flung as the USA, Japan, Russia,
                                                          Canada and New Zealand. There were          Finally, I hope we don’t have to wait a
organising abstracts into sessions with
                                                          roughly equal numbers of talks              further 44 years before the next Society
oral presentations on similar topics
                                                          presented from the UK and from              meeting on modelling work (I might
forming each session. So, it is only
                                                          abroad. The meeting attracted 127           not be around to witness that!).
during the last 30 years that focused
sessions, and then complete focused                       participants, and was sponsored by the      Denis Noble
meetings, have been held.                                 British Heart Foundation, Pfizer and        University of Oxford, UK
                                                          Novartis, as well as by the
                                                          Physiological Society. Philosophical        References
But I think there is also a deeper,
                                                                                                      Diamond JM. (1993). Evolutionary physiology. In The Logic of Life,
philosophical reason. British                             Transactions of the Royal Society will      ed. Boyd CAR & Noble D, pp 89-111. OUP, Oxford.
physiology has been so keen on its                        be publishing around 30 papers in a
                                                                                                      DiFrancesco D & Noble D (1985). A model of cardiac electrical
empirical tradition, reflected also in the                volume arising from the meeting, while      activity incorporating ionic pumps and concentration changes.
strength of empiricism in British                         the Hodgkin-Huxley-Katz lecture will        Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B 307, 353-398.
philosophy, that it has been fairly                       be published in The Journal of              Dover G (2000). Dear Mr Darwin. Letters on the evolution of life and
                                                          Physiology.                                 human nature. Weidenfeld and Nicolson, London.
antipathetic to theoretical work. Notice,
in the title of Hodgkin and Huxley’s                                                                  Hodgkin AL & Huxley AF (1952). A quantitative description of
                                                                                                      membrane current and its application to conduction and excitation in
paper, that they refer to ‘a quantitative                 A second significant sign lies in the       nerve. J Physiol 117, 500-544.
description’ rather than to ‘a                            strategy of the Journal of Experimental
                                                                                                      Hutter OF & Noble D (1960). Rectifying properties of heart muscle.
quantitative theory’.                                     Physiology, whose Editorial Board has       Nature 188, 495.
                                                          announced that it wishes to foster
                                                                                                      Luo C & Rudy Y (1994). A Dynamic model of the cardiac ventricular
Nevertheless, the early papers on nerve                   quantitative integrative physiology,        action potential - simulations of ionic currents and concentration
and heart cell models were nearly all                     including modelling. A future focused       changes. Circulation Research 74, 1071-1097.
published in The Journal of Physiology.                   volume will be devoted to this field. A     Noble D (1960). Cardiac action and pacemaker potentials based on
                                                          journal of experimental physiology          the Hodgkin-Huxley equations. Nature 188, 495-497.
That tradition was broken in 1985 when
the work that Dario DiFrancesco and I                     sponsoring theoretical work?! I like        Rice JJ, Jafri MS & Winslow RL (1999). Modeling gain and
                                                          both the irony and the significance of      gradedness of Ca2+ release in the functional unit of the cardiac
published on the first simulations of                                                                 diadic space. Biophys J 77, 1871-1884.

Physiology News | No. 58 | Spring 2005 | www.physoc.org
PHYSIOLOGYNEWS - The Physiological Society
6      PN            NOTTINGHAM FOCUSED MEETING

Nottingham Focused
Meeting
Responsiveness of muscle,
bone and connective tissue
to physical activity: genetic
and molecular integration

The first Focused Meeting of the
Physiological Society took place at
the University of Nottingham
Graduate Entry Medical School in
Derby from 12-13 July, 2004

It’s clear that the application of modern
techniques in physiology is providing                  Over 60 delegates attending found the new Meeting format highly enjoyable and productive
us with unforeseen knowledge
concerning the way in which our             linking of changes in muscle myo­                          hosted by the Centre for Integrated
musculo-skeletal mass maintains itself      filament turnover with the turnover of                     Systems Biology and Medicine
and adapts under both catabolic             extra-cellular matrix, the marked                          (http://www.nottingham.ac.uk/cisbm/)
(immobilisation, space flight,              response of tendon to exercise, the                        at the University of Nottingham. It
hospitalisation) and anabolic (growth in    existence of genetic traits which make                     highlighted recent research addressing
childhood, strength training/body           human beings good or poor responders                       the responsiveness of muscle, bone and
building, rehabilitation) conditions.       to exercise, etc.                                          connective tissue to physical activity,
Some remarkable physiological                                                                          and in particular recent genetic and
phenomena have been discovered              This, the first Focused Meeting of the                     molecular advances to our
recently, e.g. the marked anabolic          Physiological Society, organised by                        understanding of what controls tissue
response of bone to vibration, the          Paul Greenhaff and Mike Rennie, was                        mass under these conditions.

                                                                                                       The 2 day event allowed contemporary
                                                                                                       physiological findings to be set in a
                                                                                                       context of transcriptional and
                                                                                                       translational control of the tissues of
                                                                                                       the musculo-skeletal system, some of
                                                                                                       which like bone and tendon had
                                                                                                       hitherto been thought only to respond
                                                                                                       weakly and slowly. The meeting was
                                                                                                       attended by over 60 delegates, and
                                                                                                       lecture presentations by an international
                                                                                                       panel of symposium speakers were
                                                                                                       accompanied by original
                                                                                                       communications by attendees.

                                                                                                       The overwhelming opinion from
                                                                                                       Members was that this new format of
                                                                                                       Meeting was highly enjoyable and
                                                                                                       productive, facilitating detailed
                                                                                                       discussion in an informal and friendly
                                                                                                       environment (particularly in the bar
                                                                                                       following the symposium dinner).
                                            Top left: .Marco Narici, Martin Thompson and Mike
                                                                                                       Clearly this new initiative of the
                                            White enjoying lunch (left to right)                       Society should go from strength to
                                            Top right and centre: Delegates engrossed in informal      strength… (please pardon the pun).
                                            discussions
                                            Left: Arnold de Haan, David Jones and Michael              Paul Greenhaff
                                            Rennie (left to right) debate the merits of the new        School of Biomedical Sciences, University of
                                            focused meeting format of the Society.                     Nottingham, UK

                                                                                                    Physiology News | No. 58 | Spring 2005 | www.physoc.org
PHYSIOLOGYNEWS - The Physiological Society
BRISTOL FOCUSED MEETING                       PN       7

The University of Bristol hosted this 2                                                                          (Institute of Bioengineering and
day meeting sponsored by the                                                                                     Nanotechnology, Singapore) who works
Physiological Society, with additional                                                                           on new transcriptional and
contributions from Pfizer UK and the                                                                             transductional strategies for targeting
Department of Physiology. The aims                                                                               neurones. In his presentation, Dr Shu
were to raise awareness in the                                                                                   described advantages of the
physiological community of the recent                                                                            recombinant baculoviruses for neuronal
achievements of this rapidly developing                                                                          gene transfer. Presently, this type of
technology, to give researchers an                                                                               vector is seldom used in neuroscience
opportunity to interact with some of the                                                                         but this might change given the relative
world’s leaders working in the area and,                                                                         ease of its production, efficient gene
finally, to facilitate collaborations                                                                            delivery into central neurones and
between laboratories around the world.                                                                           relatively large packaging capacity.
                                                           Central neurones transduced with cell-type specific
Gratifyingly, this turned out to be a                                         viral vectors
                                                                                                                 Sebastian Kügler (Department of
truly international meeting with                                                                                 Neurology, University of Göttingen,
contributions from Germany,                                                                                      Germany) then gave an overview of his
Singapore, Switzerland, the UK and the
                                                             Viral gene transfer in                              work on adeno-associated viral vectors.
USA. Bristol seemed to be the right
place for this event given that several
                                                          neuroscience: new tricks of                            This vector is currently one of the
                                                                                                                 favourites in the field of gene therapy.
large research groups in this University                            the trade                                    Dr Kügler illustrated its use in his
are using viral vectors in a variety of                     A Physiological Society Focused                      studies on neuroprotection. After the
research programmes ranging from                            Meeting held at the University of                    lunch break and poster session,
central control of blood pressure to                         Bristol (4-5 September, 2004)                       Beverley Davidson (University of Iowa,
gene transfer into transplanted blood                                                                            USA) spoke of virally mediated
vessels.                                                  gene/protein in gain-of function or loss­              expression of RNAi in vivo, which she
                                                          of function experiments. Moreover,                     is developing as a gene therapy tool for
Viral vectors provide an excellent                        targeted viral vectors open a whole new                neurodegenerative diseases. Gene
opportunity to address the major                          method for specific genomic                            suppression using RNA interference has
challenge presented by the topic of                       experiments on phenotypically                          been one of the hottest scientific topics
physiological genomics. As Boron and                      identified neuronal sub-populations.                   of the last few years and Dr Davidson’s
Boulpaep recently put it: ‘Physiological                                                                         work on siRNA has been published in
genomics (or functional genomics) is a                    The meeting ran over 2 days. On 4                      the most prestigious biomedical
new branch of physiology devoted to                       September the invited speakers gave                    journals. James Uney (University of
understanding the roles genes play in                     their presentations. First, Markus                     Bristol) then spoke about regulatable
physiology… In order to grasp the                         Ehrengruber (University of Zürich,                     gene expression and presented his
function of a gene product, the                           Switzerland) addressed some new                        studies on tetracycline-regulatable viral
physiologist must retrace his steps back                  developments in the alfavirus family of                gene expression systems. His talk was
up the reductionistic road and achieve                    vectors and described recent Semliki                   followed by Andy Baker (University of
an integrated inderstanding of that                       Forest virus vectors that have decreased               Glasgow) who is developing an
gene’s function at the level of the cells,                cytotoxicity. This development is                      interesting strategy to alter the tropism
organs and whole body’ (Boron WF,                         important because the original versions                of viral vectors. This is achieved by
Boulpaep EL (2002). Medical                               of these vectors, used in previous                     modifications to the capsid proteins of
Physiology. Saunders). Indeed, being                      studies, are highly toxic for the                      adenoviral and adeno-associated viral
exceptionally efficient gene delivery                     transduced cells, which clearly                        vectors using peptide sequences derived
vehicles, viral vectors allow both                        compromises the credibility of the                     from a phage display approach.
expression of a transgenic protein or                     results that may be obtained. This                     Nicholas Mazarakis (Oxford
suppression of an endogenous                              lecture was followed by Wang Shu                       Biomedica, Cambridge) presented
                                                                                                                 recent developments in his company for
                                                                                                                 using lentiviral vectors for gene therapy
                                                                                                                 treatment of neurodegeneration in man.
                                                                                                                 He focused on feline immunodeficiency
                                                                                                                 virus derived vectors with
                                                                                                                 transductional properties altered using
                                                                                                                 alternative coat proteins. Lentivirus­
                                                                                                                 derived vectors were also the topic of
                                                                                                                 Mohan Raizada’s talk (University of
                                                                                                                 Florida, USA). The University of
                                                                                                                 Florida is one of the leading world
  From the left: Nicholas Mazarakis, Stephen White, Markus Ehrengruber and Sebastian Kügler relaxing at the
                                              symposium dinner                                                   centres for viral vector development

Physiology News | No. 58 | Spring 2005 | www.physoc.org
PHYSIOLOGYNEWS - The Physiological Society
8        PN              BRISTOL FOCUSED MEETING/THE SENSES

and Dr Raizada spoke on his work
using lentiviral vectors to study
                                                      The Journal of Physiology
mechanisms underlying the generation
of essential hypertension. The final
                                                      symposium ‘The Senses’
speaker, A G Teschemacher (University
                                                      A Journal of Physiology
of Bristol), presented a wide variety of
applications of both adeno- and                       symposium on sensory physiology
lentivirus derived vectors based on her               was held in San Diego on 22
own studies and those performed in                    October, 2004. The satellite
collaboration with Sergey Kasparov                    symposium to the annual meeting
and Julian Paton in the Department of                 of the Society for Neuroscience
Physiology, University of Bristol.                    brought together leading experts
Specifically, she described studies                   to highlight the similarities and
where phenotypically identified                       differences in processing
neuronal populations were genetically                 strategies for a variety of sensory
targeted using adeno- and lentiviral
                                                      systems such as vision, audition,
vectors for dynamic confocal imaging
and functional studies at the cellular                somatosensation and olfaction.
and systems level.
                                                      A lot of progress has been made on the
In addition to these presentations, about             very early stages of sensory processing,
two dozen posters were presented                      as indicated by a number of Nobel
during the lunch and tea breaks by                    Prizes over the past few decades. As a
various researchers attending the                     consequence, the process of converting        empirical evidence. Along the same
symposium, as well as by the speakers.                physical energy into the excitations of       lines of space perception, Frank
This provided a further opportunity to                sensory nerves is quite well understood.      Bremmer (Marburg, Germany) showed
meet the speakers and discuss issues                  The biggest current questions are what        how information from visual, auditory
relating to viral gene delivery from the              kinds of features are extracted from the      and somatosensory systems is
experts. The meeting was followed by                  information stream and how these are          integrated in the parietal cortex of
dinner at one of Bristol’s finest                     used to recognize objects and guide           monkeys and humans.
harbour-side restaurants.                             actions.
                                                                                                    One of the current core questions in
On Sunday morning Bristol-based                       Several of the talks dealt with the           sensory physiology is how
groups (Kasparov-Paton viral                          question of how elementary features are       computations are performed in neural
laboratory in the School of Medical                   conveyed to the central nervous system.       ensembles. Miguel Nicolelis (Durham,
Sciences and James Uney’s laboratory                  Ed Callaway (La Jolla, USA) pointed           USA) showed state dependent
in the Dorothy Hodgkin Building)                      out how luminance and chromatic               responses in the barrel cortex of awake
opened their doors to the speakers and                information are conveyed to the visual        behaving rats. Michael Shadlen is
any delegates. This provided a further                cortex in separate pathways. Paul Fuchs       investigating similar questions in awake
chance to see first hand experiments                  (Baltimore, USA) presented a detailed         behaving monkeys, tracing the
with viral vectors and to discuss the                 model of time and intensity coding at         complete sequence of steps from
different technologies being applied.                 the hair cell’s ribbon synapse in the         sensory processing to decision making.
                                                      inner ear.
We believe that this meeting provided a                                                             The symposium was a big success in
great opportunity to gain novel insights              Linda Buck (Seattle, USA), who was            pointing out similar coding strategies
into the rapidly developing world of                  just recently awarded this year’s Nobel       for converting elementary sensory
viral gene transfer and to discuss the                Prize for physiology or medicine,*            information into features for quite
newest developments in the field with                 discussed how the excitations of              different sensory modalities. However,
some of the world’s leaders and to                    olfactory receptors are converted into        it also made clear that we have quite a
establish closer contacts and new                     smells. Peter Mombaerts (New York,            long way to go towards understanding
collaborations.                                       USA) presented work on the genetic            the crucial next steps from features to
                                                      basis of olfactory maps.                      objects and actions.
Sergey Kasparov
Julian F.R. Paton                                     Probably even more important than             Karl R Gegenfurtner
Department of Physiology, University of Bristol, UK   recognizing things, sensory information       Justus-Liebig-University, Giessen, Germany
                                                      is used to enable orientation in space        and member of the Editorial Board, The Journal of
                                                                                                    Physiology
                                                      and to form decisions about future
Papers from the Bristol symposium                     actions. David McAlpine (London, UK)           *See Tim Jacob’s article on the Nobel
were published in the January issue of                presented a new model of auditory              Prize winners Linda Buck and Richard
Experimental Physiology (2005, 90.1)                  space perception and supporting                Axel on p. 12 of this issue

                                                                                                 Physiology News | No. 58 | Spring 2005 | www.physoc.org
LIVING HISTORY             PN        9

The case of the misbehaving circuit
Stanley Salmons recalls the accident that replaced a paradigm

                                                             In 1965 I was pursuing a PhD in Eric                         The fast muscle nerve would still carry
                                                             Ashton’s anthropometry group in the                          intermittent high-frequency bursts, but I
                                                             Department of Anatomy at the                                 believed that the much greater activity
                                                             University of Birmingham, developing                         imposed by the stimulator would have
                                                             micropower radiotelemetric techniques                        the dominant effect. I developed the
                                                             for recording muscle activity from                           stimulator and we did the experiment.
                                                             freely moving primates. On 15                                The stimulated fast muscle became
                                                             September that year I tried a new type                       slower (Fig. 1). Later Frank Sréter and
                                                             of single-pulse generator. It proved hard                    I were to show that the physiological
                                                             to keep it stable, so it was unsuitable                      and biochemical effects of cross­
                                                             for this application. It struck me,                          reinnervating a slow muscle could be
                                                             however, that it could form the basis of                     nullified if stimulation was used to
                                                             an implantable stimulator, with which                        restore its normal activity pattern
                                                             one could resolve the controversy about                      (Salmons & Sréter, 1976). I put forward
                                                             the nature of the neural influence on                        the notion of functional adaptation, and
                                                             muscle.                                                      this became the more favoured
                                                                                                                          paradigm (Salmons & Henriksson,
                                                             At that time there was a good deal of                        1981).
        Above: Brenda Russell (around 1976)                  interest in the cross-reinnervation
           Below: Jan Henriksson (1998)                      experiments of Buller, Eccles and
                                                             Eccles. These, it was widely believed,                            Where are they now?
                                                             showed that the contractile
                                                                                                                          Gerta Vrbová is Emeritus Professor
                                                             characteristics of fast and slow muscles
                                                                                                                          of Developmental Neuroscience in the
                                                             were determined by chemotrophic
                                                                                                                          Department of Anatomy &
                                                             factors delivered via the motor nerves.
                                                                                                                          Developmental Biology, University
                                                             A competing view, championed by
                                                                                                                          College London.
                                                             Gerta Vrbová, held that this neural
                                                             influence was mediated by the different
                                                                                                                          John Gergely is Senior Scientist at
                                                             frequencies of impulse activity in these
                                                                                                                          the Boston Biomedical Research
                                                             nerves. Dr Vrbová had just joined the
                                                                                                                          Institute.
                                                             Department, so I suggested to her that
                                                             we use the (as yet unbuilt) stimulator to
                                                                                                                          Jan Henriksson is Professor and
                                                             activate a fast muscle with the
                                                                                                                          Joint Head of the Section for Exercise
                                                             continuous, low-frequency pattern
                                                                                                                          Physiology, Department of Physiology
                                                             normally found in slow muscle nerves.
                                                                                                                          and Pharmacology, Karolinska
                                                                                                                          Institute, Stockholm.

                                                                                                                          Brenda Russell is Professor of
                                                                                                                          Physiology, Biophysics,
                                                                                                                          Bioengineering and Medicine, and
                                                                                                                          Associate Vice Chancellor for
                                                                                                                          Research at the University of Illinois
                                                                                                                          at Chicago.

                                                                                                                          Larry Stephenson is Ford-Webber
                                                                                                                          Professor of Surgery and Chief of
                                                                                                                          Cardiothoracic Surgery for Wayne
                                                                                                                          State University, the Detroit Medical
                                                                                                                          Center and Harper Hospital.

                                                                                                                          Jonathan Jarvis is Reader in the
                                                                                                                          Department of Human Anatomy and
Figure 1. Single twitch contractions of rabbit tibialis anterior muscles. Upper trace: control. Lower trace: stimulated
                                  at 10 Hz for 6 weeks (Salmons & Vrbová, 1969).                                          Cell Biology, University of Liverpool.

Physiology News | No. 58 | Spring 2005 | www.physoc.org
10         PN           LIVING HISTORY

                                                         In 1977 I met Jan Henriksson, an
                                                         exercise biochemist, at an IUPS
                                                         meeting in Szeged. In discussion we
                                                         realized that exercise-induced and
                                                         stimulation-induced changes differed
                                                         only in degree (Salmons & Henriksson,
                                                         1981). Brenda Russell (at that time
                                                         Eisenberg), who had been a colleague
                                                         at University College London, was at
                                                         the same meeting; we decided to
                                                         establish the time course of
                                                         ultrastructural changes during fast-to­
                                                         slow transformation (Eisenberg &
                                                         Salmons, 1981). Subsequently Jan,
                                                         working in Oliver Lowry’s lab,
                                                         confirmed that oxidative enzyme
                                                         activity rose and fell in the same way                 Larry Stephenson, a contemporary portrait
                                                         as Brenda had shown for mitochondrial
Figure 2. SDS-PAGE (tube gels) demonstrating the         density (Henriksson et al. 1986).              skeletal muscle, a technique that still
expression of slow myosin light chains (MLCs) after 10   During transformation to a stable 2A           has immense potential for patients with
weeks of stimulation; co-electrophoresis was used to
confirm the identity of the bands. From left to right:
                                                         phenotype this biphasic response was           heart failure, and in which my
control rabbit tibialis anterior muscle (TA), control    absent, evidence of interaction between        colleague, Jonathan Jarvis, has played a
soleus (SOL), stimulated TA, mixed TA + SOL, mixed       the pathways underlying adaptive               major role. Other clinical applications
stimulated TA + SOL (Sréter et al. 1973).                change (Mayne et al. 1996). At first it        have been: stimulation of paralysed
                                                         was hard to reconcile the adaptive             (including denervated) muscles to
In Boston I worked with Frank Sréter                     capacity of muscle with the existence          restore posture, movement, or
and John Gergely on the newly                            of discrete fibre types, but I used a          ventilation lost through stroke or
discovered myosin light chains                           threshold model to explain both this           spinal-cord injury; pacing of the
(MLCs). We found that slow MLCs                          and the sequence of changes that               diaphragm in apnoeic babies; and
were induced by stimulation (Fig. 2).                    followed the onset and cessation of            configuration of conditioned muscle
This was an exciting observation                         stimulation (Salmons, 1990).                   grafts as artificial sphincters. But it all
because it showed that muscle                                                                           started with a badly behaved circuit.
stimulation elicited qualitative, as well                A feature of the adaptive response of
as quantitative, changes in protein                      muscle to increased use was a dramatic         Stanley Salmons
expression. My group and others,                         increase in fatigue resistance (Salmons        Emeritus Professor of Applied Myology, Department of
particularly Dirk Pette’s in Konstanz,                   & Sréter, 1976). In 1979 Larry                 Human Anatomy and Cell Biology, University of
                                                         Stephenson, a cardiothoracic surgeon           Liverpool, UK
subsequently added many other
proteins to this list. The underlying                    then in Philadelphia, asked me if such a
                                                                                                        References
changes at gene level have yet to be                     muscle could do cardiac work. That             Eisenberg BR & Salmons S (1981). The reorganisation of subcellular
unravelled, so the story is far from                     was the beginning of a 25-year                 structure in muscle undergoing fast-to-slow type transformation: a
                                                                                                        stereological study. Cell Tiss Res 220, 449-471.
over.                                                    collaboration on cardiac assist from
                                                                                                        Henriksson J, Chi MM-Y, Hintz CS, Young DA, Kaiser KK, Salmons
                                                                                                        S, et al. (1986). Chronic stimulation of mammalian muscle: changes
                                                                                                        in enzymes of six metabolic pathways. Am J Physiol 251, C614-
                                                                                                        C632.

                                                                                                        Mayne CN, Sutherland H, Jarvis JC, Gilroy SJ, Craven AJ &
                                                                                                        Salmons S (1996). Induction of a fast-oxidative phenotype by chronic
                                                                                                        muscle stimulation: histochemical and metabolic studies. Am J
                                                                                                        Physiol 270, C313-320.

                                                                                                        Salmons S (1990). On the reversibility of stimulation-induced muscle
                                                                                                        transformation. In The Dynamic State of Muscle Fibres, ed. Pette D,
                                                                                                        pp 401-414. Walter de Gruyter, Berlin.

                                                                                                        Salmons S & Henriksson J (1981). The adaptive response of skeletal
                                                                                                        muscle to increased use. Muscle Nerve 4, 94-105.

                                                                                                        Salmons S & Sréter FA (1976). Significance of impulse activity in the
                                                                                                        transformation of skeletal muscle type. Nature 263, 30–34.

                                                                                                        Salmons S & Vrbová G (1969). The influence of activity on some
                                                                                                        contractile characteristics of mammalian fast and slow muscles. J
                                                                                                        Physiol 201, 535-549.

                                                                                                        Sréter FA, Gergely J, Salmons S & Romanul F (1973). Synthesis by
                                                                                                        fast muscle of myosin light chains characteristic of slow muscle in
           Jonathan Jarvis and Stanley Salmons at the World Cardiac Bioassist Meeting, Paris, 2003      response to long-term stimulation. Nature 241, 17-19.

                                                                                                     Physiology News | No. 58 | Spring 2005 | www.physoc.org
A SUMMER IN THE LIFE OF ...                          PN           11

A summer in the life of…
The Society’s Executive Committee Chairman shares
some of his scientific journeys
                                                          memorable sites. On arrival in Buenos
                                                          Aires, I had 45 min to find my way from
                                                          the international to the national airport to fly
                                                          on to Iguazu falls. A relatively stressful
                                                          journey by bus through what seemed like a
                                                          never ending line of traffic, but in the end I       Above: Iguazu Falls, a natural boundary between
                                                          never expected to be so overwhelmed by the           Argentina and Brazil (with Pepe, M-Carmen and
                                                          thundering noise of the numerous                     Chelo).
                                                          waterfalls. Other attractions of Buenos Aires
                                                                                                               Below: Giovanni, Jose Viña (member of our
                                                          included sight-seeing at night, excellent            International Sub-Committee, University of Valencia,
                                                          steak, and impressive displays of tango!             Spain) and Guiseppe Poli (University of Torino, Italy)
  David Yudilevich and Giovanni in the company of                                                              visiting the sights in Buenos Aires, Argentina.
                   Albert Einstein                        In June Tetsuro Ishii and I travelled to
                                                          Berlin as invited guests of the
I am currently Chairman of the Executive                  Hydroxynonenal Society. There we were
Committee of the Physiological Society and                accommodated in the Hilton just opposite
Head of Graduate Research Studies in the                  the German and French Cathedrals and
Guy's, King's & St Thomas' School of                      Katharina Mahn provided an eye-opening
Biomedical Sciences at King's College                     tour of what was East Berlin, including the
London. The majority of my time is spent                  Berliner Dom and other sites.
on research, though I do thoroughly enjoy
interacting with the staff in the London and              I flew to Valencia in July to meet up with
Cambridge offices of our Society. I am                    Jose Viña's research group in the
fortunate to have excellent research links                Departamento de Fisologia. On this
with friends in Spain (Jose ‘Pepe’ Viña),                 occasion, my wife Lynn travelled with me.
Italy (Guiseppe Poli), Japan (Tetsuro Ishii               Pepe took us on an inspired tour of
and colleagues), Brazil (Claudio Mendes                   Valencia, and we particularly appreciated
Ribeiro), Oxford (Clive Ellory), Edinburgh                the visit to the market in the old part of
(Richard Sharpe) and numerous colleagues                  town. There Pepe was greeted at several
at King's and my closest collaborator                     market stalls and was given some of the
Richard Siow.                                             finest fresh squid I have ever seen. It
                                                          transpired that these individuals were Pepe's
Rather than a 'week in the life of ...’, I                patients, who he was treating for dietary
thought I would share some of my scientific               conditions. Although we had a splendid
journeys during May to August 2004.                       dinner with Pepe and his family, we never
Before I start reminiscing about scientific               did get to taste the freshly prepared squid!
travels, the photograph of colleagues in
front of the poster of Albert Einstein is quite           My summer was rounded off in August with
dear to me. David Yudilevich cherished this               an annual pilgrimage to Portugal, where my
poster brought from Chile to Queen                        family and I have spent our summer                   Above: Katharina Mahn (Giovanni's PhD student and
Elizabeth College, where he was Head of                                                                        a now a postdoc with Rachel Tribe and Lucilla
                                                          holidays for the past 6 years. Later in
Department of Physiology until 1985. We                                                                        Poston), originally from the Humboldt Universität in
                                                          November, with 'wanderlust' still in my              Berlin, enjoys a beer or two with Tetsuro Ishii (Univ.
spent many hours in his office at                         blood, I set off for mainland China on               Tsukuba, Japan) in the beautifully restored
Kensington discussing and arguing about                   behalf of the School of Biomedical Sciences          'Gendarmenmarkt' in Berlin.
science! On his retirement he presented the               and the Society. One of my objectives was
poster to me and it now hangs in my office                to discuss joint degrees and exchange of             Below: Between travels abroad, I seem to find time to
at Guy's Campus. The recent joint meeting                 postgraduates with senior colleagues at              field calls from the Society’s office and/or my
of the Physiological Society and Chilean                  Tsinghua University and Peking University.           daughters.
Physiological Society at King's bears                     On behalf of the International Sub-
testimony to David's unique ability to foster             Committee of our Society, I met with the
links between Chile and the UK.                           President and Meetings Secretary of the
                                                          Chinese Association of Physiological
Thanks to sponsorship from the Society,                   Sciences to explore the possibility of a joint
Pepe and I co-organized a symposium                       meeting in China in 2008. David Eisner, our
entitled Phytoestrogens and isoflavones:                  International Secretary, is now liaising
cell signalling and physiological action at               further with colleagues in China.
the International Society for Free Radical
Research (SFRR-I) meeting in Buenos                       Giovanni E. Mann
Aires, Argentina in May. As with most of                  Academic Department of Physiology and
my trips abroad, I find moments to explore                Cardiovascular Division, King's College London, UK

Physiology News | No. 58 | Spring 2005 | www.physoc.org
12      PN          THE NOBEL PRIZE

The Nobel Prize
Tim Jacob traces the route that Linda Buck and Richard Axel took to claim one of the
major uncollected prizes in sensory science – the secrets of the olfactory system

This year’s Nobel Prize for Medicine                                                         efforts came to nothing. Looking back
and Physiology was shared by Linda                                                           Axel has commented that this was
Buck (57) and Richard Axel (58) for                                                          because of the large number of odorant
their discovery of the olfactory receptor                                                    receptors, each of which was only
gene family.                                                                                 expressed at a very low level. Finally,
                                                                                             Buck made the breakthrough by
In 1991, after about 8 years of research                                                     making three assumptions. The first
effort, they published their landmark                                                        was that the odorant receptors were
paper in Cell in which they reported                                                         likely to be members of the 7­
that they had succeeded in cloning 18                                                        transmembrane G-protein coupled
different members of an extremely                                                            receptor family. The second was that
large multigene family that, they said,                                                      the odorant receptors themselves should
‘may encode odorant receptors’. This                                                         exhibit significant diversity and belong
family we now know is the largest so                                                         to a multigene family and the third that
far discovered and occupies about 3%                                                         their expression be limited to the
of the human genome. In order to                                                             olfactory epithelium. Homologues of
achieve this breakthrough they made                                                          the 7-TM domain superfamily were
some educated guesses that narrowed                                                          amplified from olfactory epithelial
the odds – in other words luck played a                                                      RNA. Using restriction enzymes to
part.                                                                                        digest the PCR product they looked for
                                                    Linda Buck (top) and Richard Axel        fragments that consisted of a mixture of
Following publication they went their                                                        DNA sequences arguing that a
separate ways. Axel remained at             polymerase chain reaction (PCR) that             multigene family would generate a set
Columbia where he has been since his        finally unlocked the secrets of the              of DNA fragments whose molecular
undergraduate studies. Buck moved to        olfactory system.                                weight would be far greater than the
Harvard for 10 years and then                                                                original PCR product. The restriction
westward in 2002 to the Fred                From 1982-1991 Linda Buck was a                  digestion of a single species of DNA,
Hutchinson Cancer Research Center in        postdoctoral fellow in Richard Axel’s            on the other hand, would generate a set
her home town, Seattle. Although            lab. The Howard Hughes Medical                   of fragments whose molecular weights
working separately, they both               Institute (HHMI) was supporting both             would sum to that of the original PCR
demonstrated, in different publications,    of them during this period. To                   product.
that each olfactory receptor neuron         understand the olfactory system it was
(ORN) expressed only one type of            necessary to discover how the system             Stuart Firestein, a colleague at
olfactory receptor and that each ORN        responded to thousands of different              Columbia and another major player in
expressing the same receptor sent its       molecules of different shapes and sizes.         olfactory research has pointed out that
axon to the same place in the olfactory     Did it achieve this with a restricted set        this work would probably not have
bulb. Buck went on to publish the idea      of promiscuous receptors or a large              been possible without HHMI support:
of a ‘combinatorial code’ that is the       number of relatively specific receptors?         ‘It would have been hard to do this if
currently accepted view of how              And second, how did the brain utilise            you were required to produce regular
different odours are discriminated.         these responses to discriminate between          publications to support your next
                                            odours? In 1983, Kary Mullis at Cetus            grant,’ he said. Buck was a 44-year old
The secrets of the olfactory system had     Corporation conceived of a way to start          postdoc at the time of the publication of
long been one of the major uncollected      and stop a polymerase's action at                their Cell paper with 10 papers to her
prizes in sensory science. Over the         specific points along a single strand of         credit – only three as first author. The
years there had been many theories          DNA. The result was PCR for which he             HHMI has nurtured 13 Nobel Prize
attempting to explain how/why               was awarded the Nobel Prize for                  winners since it was established in
molecules smell including molecular         Chemistry in 1993. So, instead of                1984 and Columbia University itself
vibration, piezo electric currents,         hunting for the receptor proteins                has produced a steady stream of Nobel
membrane diffusion pores and                directly, Axel and Buck used PCR to              Laureates, 72 in all. Twenty-one of
molecular shape. Most of them were          look for genes that contained                    these are in Physiology and Medicine,
empirical and did not lend themselves       instructions for proteins found only in          including Eric Kandel (2000).
to scientific test. It was the advent of    the olfactory epithelium. It was a               Tim Jacob
molecular biology and, in particular,       technique in its infancy and at first their      University of Cardiff, UK

                                                                                          Physiology News | No. 58 | Spring 2005 | www.physoc.org
FEATURES          PN        13

50 years of caveolae – a round-up
It is 50 years since the first microscopic observation of the tiny flask-shaped
plasmalemmal invaginations termed caveolae. Only in the last decade, however, with the
discovery of the family of caveolin proteins that are integral to these organelles, have we
begun to unravel the possible physiological roles of these enigmatic structures

The decade following the second world                                                                        The missing link identified
war proved to be a prolific period for                                                                       The discovery at the turn of the 1990s
the application of electron microscopic                                                                      of a protein component of caveolae,
techniques to the analyses of the                                                                            termed caveolin, was to revolutionise
ultrastructure of tissues and cells.                                                                         the study of these organelles. Caveolin
Through such endeavours Pallade                                                                              is actually a family of protein
(1953) and Yamade (1955) became the                                                                          molecules of mass 21-24kDa with three
first workers to describe an unusual                                                                         main mammalian isoforms
feature of the plasma membrane of                                                                            (imaginatively termed caveolin-1, -2
endothelial and epithelial cells: they                                  Michael Taggart                      and –3). There are two and three
found that the plasmalemma, far from                                                                         isoforms, respectively, of caveolin-1 (α
being uniform, often gave the                             muscle as early as the 1970’s. The                 and β) and caveolin-2 (α, β, γ).
appearance of regular, Ω-shaped                           observations of a close appositioning of           Whereas these show a wide tissue
invaginations; Yamade termed these                        caveolae to elements of the                        distribution, caveolin-3 has a much
structures ‘caveolae intracellulares’                     sarcoplasmic reticulum (the major                  more restricted appearance, being
(see Inset). Ever since, the                              source of releasable organellar Ca2+),             predominant in striated muscle cells.
physiological roles of these organelles                   and immunogold localisation of a Ca2+-             Crucially, transfection of non-caveolin­
has perplexed and fascinated in equal                     ATPase to caveolae, were instrumental              containing cells, which had no
measure. What follows is a very brief                     in developing this idea. By and large,             morphological appearance of caveolae,
round-up of this topic but for more                       however, experimental evidence in                  with caveolin-1 (or -3) induced the
extensive background the reader is                        support of these different roles of                formation of Ω-shaped invaginations.
directed to the reference list at the end                 caveolae was observational and                     Subsequently, an interaction of high
of this article.                                          progress was hindered by the lack of a             molecular weight caveolin oligomeric
                                                          definitive molecular marker of caveolar            complexes with cholesterol appeared to
The early sightings                                       structures.                                        be key to the formation of caveolae.
As caveolae were initially discovered in
cells lining the lumenal surface of                                                                          Caveolins, however, quickly established
hollow organs, a role in                                                                                     themselves as something more than just
macromolecular transport phenomena                        ‘Endothelial cells ... possess … a                 plasma membranous structural
was postulated, including capillary                       large number of vesicles                           components. Biochemical
                                                          concentrated immediately under
permeability and transcytocis and the                                                                        characterisation studies, including
                                                          the cell membranes facing both
regulation of cellular free cholesterol                   the capillary lumen and the                        immunoprecipitation, began to
flux. With regard to the latter,                          precapillary spaces. The vesicles,                 highlight a multitude of signalling
cholesterol sequestering agents have                      sometimes tightly packed in                        molecules co-localising with caveolin­
                                                          layers, are speherical in shape and
been known for many years to disrupt                                                                         1. Furthermore, a small 20 amino acid
                                                          measure ~650A in diameter. Many
the appearance of caveolae.                               of these appear to open at the                     peptide derived from caveolin-1 was, in
Subsequently, caveolae were found to                      surface of the cell membrane.’                     in vitro assays, found to bind to a
be prominent, occupying approximately                                                       Palade (1953)    whole host of signalling molecules that
                                                                                  J Appl Physics 24, 1424
25% of plasmalemmal surface area, in                                                                         act downstream of receptor-coupled
many other cell types including                           ‘Some of these vesicles seem to                    membrane effectors. In cardiovascular
adipocytes, smooth muscle (Fig. 1) and                    communicate with the lumen                         cells, for example, these included
                                                          through openings in the cell
cardiac cells (with a few notable                                                                            PKCα, rhoA, ERK, and nitric oxide
                                                          membrane covering the
exceptions being lymphocytes and                          microvillus. These small cave-like                 synthase (NOS). Binding to this
some cell lines such as HepG2 cells).                     indentations of the cell wall…...                  peptide, termed the caveolin scaffolding
This wide distribution necessitated                       resemble similar structures                        domain, even altered the enzymatic
                                                          described along the inner and
consideration of this idea that caveolae                                                                     activity of these signalling molecules
                                                          outer cell membrane of capillary
might be important for a number of                        endothelial cells by Palade. It is                 and, once introduced into live cells,
functions. Regulation of                                  here proposed to speak of such a                   altered functions as diverse as cytosol­
transmembrane ion fluxes important for                    recess or pocket as a ‘caveolae                    membrane protein translocations,
                                                          intracellulares’
cellular excitability was one possible                                                     Yamade (1955)
                                                                                                             cardiac myocyte beating, flow-induced
function ascribed to caveolae in smooth                                 J Biophys Biochem Cytol 1, 445-458   arterial dilation and eNOS activation.

Physiology News | No. 58 | Spring 2005 | www.physoc.org
You can also read