ELIZABETH II - Canadian Monarchist News Les Nouvelles Monarchiques du Canada - HRH The Prince Philip, Duke of Edinburgh

Page created by Darryl Keller
 
CONTINUE READING
ELIZABETH II - Canadian Monarchist News Les Nouvelles Monarchiques du Canada - HRH The Prince Philip, Duke of Edinburgh
Canadian Monarchist News
             Les Nouvelles Monarchiques du Canada
                                 Spring/Printemps 2021 — No. 50
             An occasional Newsletter for members and friends of The Monarchist League of Canada
                       The Monarchist League of Canada / La Ligue Monarchiste du Canada,
                      PO Box 1057, Lakeshore West PO, Oakville, Ontario, Canada L6K 0B2
                           905-855-7262 (800) 465-6925 www.monarchist.ca

            THE MONARCHIST LEAGUE OF CANADA – 51th ANNIVERSARY 1970-2021

              ELIZABETH II
at 95 our Queen, Friend & Head of the Nation
ELIZABETH II - Canadian Monarchist News Les Nouvelles Monarchiques du Canada - HRH The Prince Philip, Duke of Edinburgh
PAYETTE DEPARTURE DAMAGING
            L.A. CELEB CULTURE FOR HARRY, IN THRALL TO OPRAH
     QUEEN, CHARLES, CAMILLA, WILLIAM,
     CATHERINE, LIEUTENANT GOVERNORS
              DO THEIR DUTY
                                     Report and commentary by The Monarchist League of Canada

T
     here are two distinct kinds of celebrity these days. One is          occasionally distorted by sensation-seeking media pandering to
     self-seeking, often financially rewarding, embraced and en-           an under-informed audience. Happily, the long arc of history
     abled by even “serious” media. Frequently it is also selfish,         and sober second thought dub it valuable for humans and civi-
short-lived and shallow.                                                  lizations alike as the stuff of lasting happiness, the bulwark of
  The other is selfless, not focused on monetary gain, more than           greatness. So, let’s ask a few questions.

THE PAYETTE FIASCO: DAMAGING TO OUR CROWN
  Who on earth briefed Julie         pols and bureaucrats over the        and so on ad nauseam. In the          birthplace nor its roots, maybe
Payette as to the expectations       years to permit the “Household”      restrictive climate of isolated       it’s time for a new one.
that apply to any Governor Gen-      at Rideau Hall to become a re-       households, COVID-restrictions,          Not that much considered
eral, yet still allow plenty of      volving door, with employment        fatigue and worry, rumour and         republican opinion exists that
room for particular enthusiasms      eventually the locus of abusive,     sensation abound and gain a cur-      The Queen’s 95th and a Platinum
and causes? If indeed “someone”      unhappy behaviour recently doc-      rency beyond proportion.              Jubilee might not remedy: true,
did so, how could the message        umented in excruciating detail?         Then, too, a fallback argument     yet shallow in implication. And
have been so misunderstood?          How could a clearly brave, tal-      of some monarchists has been          the mere notion of an Aus-
Who did due diligence prior to       ented and intelligent woman for      “Well, if you don’t care for the      tralian-style debate/referendum
her selection, no great talent in    whom the country initially wish-     ‘British’ roots of our Monarchy,      down the road is appalling – as
HR being needed to suggest it        ed only success, and which ad-       in fact day-to-day it is our fellow   Canada would then be reduced to
might begin with recent employ-      mired her journeying through         Canadians, the GG and LGs, who        enduring a permanently-dimin-
ers. And who imagined that al-       the vast depths of space, have       “are” the Crown.” Clearly, if the     ished and partisanally-debated
lowing her to import her Private     been allowed to steer her Ottawa     Royal soap opera is unappealing       Monarchy in a state of endless
Secretary into the particular cul-   course so off-chart? And what is      for some, to find its supposedly-      controversy, a so called “Crown-
ture once a source of pride at       the plan to rebuild the deraci-      worst feature transplanted by         ed Republic” a term used by
Rideau Hall could end happily?       nated and depopulated talent         scandal at home is anything but       some Down Under “monar-
What indifference caused many         pool at Rideau Hall? The lack of     helpful. Logic then follows: if the   chists” who should know better!
                                     a seasoned, loyal team to run The    system is not ideal in either its
                                     Queen’s Canadian Home was a
                                     recipe for any GG to run into
                                     problems. Remediating that ab-       McCOWAN NAMED GG SECRETARY
                                     sence is as important as choosing       Jan 28 saw the Prime Minister      tence to enable the next Gover-
                                     “the right” person to represent      bring new leadership “to restore      nor General to share particular
                                     our Sovereign. There is good rea-    a healthy work environment” at        interests while conforming to
                                     son to believe that newly-ap-        Rideau Hall by plucking Ian Mc-       the dignity, norms and historic
                                     pointed Secretary to the Gover-      Cowan from a senior position at       expectations of anyone who rep-
                                     nor General Ian McCowan is           the Privy Council Office to be-         resents The Queen.
                                     well equipped for the enormous       come Secretary to the Governor
                                     challenge facing him.                General. Ottawa insiders praised
                                        The Payette fiasco is damaging     the appointment, calling him “a
                                     to the Canadian Crown for sev-       good fit” – “intimately acquainted
Julie Payette: let down              eral reasons, beginning with folk    with the ways of Ottawa, he can
Queen and country                    wondering how the appointment        call anyone and get action imme-
                                     could go do wrong, and asking        diately,” Considered probably the
                                     whether even the government          best qualified to serve since the
                                     thinks it is of little importance?   revered Esmond Butler, his early
                                     As well, knowledge of Civics,        recruitment to Rideau Hall of
                                     while improved since the sixties     former staffers from the halcyon
                                     and seventies, remains lament-       days of David Johnston augured
                                     ably shallow, and allows for a       well, as does his good under-
                                     worried citizenry, egged on by       standing of the personal role he
                                     no-nothing media and their           has to play as Secretary. It is
                                     “polls”, to declare the Monarchy     hoped that McCowan restores a
                                     irrelevant, the sky about to fall    high level of loyalty and compe-

                                     2   – Canadian Monarchist News – Spring/Printemps 2021
ELIZABETH II - Canadian Monarchist News Les Nouvelles Monarchiques du Canada - HRH The Prince Philip, Duke of Edinburgh
left, Oprah: allowed
                                                                                                                             allegations without names
WHY DO WE FEEL SO CONFLICTED ABOUT HARRY?                                                                                         above, Harry – once
                                                                                                                                           our Harry!
   The Royals mirror our own fami-        brother and their wives.                 grandmother yet implying she pre-
lies, wherein we have favourite sib-         So, with his Grandfather gravely      sides over but unaware of some
lings and loved elders, along with        ill, the world rocked by COVID, the      racist conventicle. She who has been
unique rituals and hallowed tradi-        sacrifices to “normal” life being em-     the soul of the multi-racial Com-
tions, all jockeying for place with       braced by his family and the Realms,     monwealth, with countless Black
naughty uncles and unemployed             how could he have allowed himself        Prime Ministers, many having em-
cousins. And not infrequently a dot-      on Commonwealth Sunday, no less,         erged from colonial rule, esteeming
ing parent will “excuse” a child’s        to become part of Oprah’s travelling     her as confidante and friend. And
fault, a loving granny slip him a few     circus of celebrity, with Canada ret-    Oprah – hitherto a much-admired
bucks and his kin agree that the          rospectively nothing more than a         interviewer of substance – abandon-
(5th) job or the (3rd) wife will surely   way-station on the road to Holly-        ing journalistic standards in favour
be his salvation. Love is wonderful,      wood?                                    of mutual tear-shedding; giving vir-
foregiveness admirable and patience          At once both hurtful to our Royal     tually nary a tough challenge to the
the gift of the saints.                   Family and injurious to the Crown        endless references to “they said”,
   However, most of us are not            in a way that made the peregrina-        “them”, “the firm” and other un-
saints – secular or sacred.               tions of a sad Duke of Windsor seem      identified objects of criticism; not to
   Harry, O Harry. We will never          as nothing by comparison, the man-       mention adding supposed cuteness
forget that brave boy – our brave boy     ifesting of grievance culture on US      by doting on the now best-known
– walking the long and lonely miles       television by two children of privi-     chickens in California. Pace Win-
behind his Mother’s coffin, so alone        lege, at least one of whom should        ston: Some chickens! But whose
even as billions watched. The             have known better, is lamentable.        necks were actually being wrung?
Hooray Henry years succeeded                 Let’s be clear about one thing:          We’ll opine one likely result of
quickly by heroism, the maturity to       anyone who says she feels depressed      this woeful misadventure: greatly-
give up the in-theatre military ser-      or suicidal should be listened to, be-   increased odds on Barbados deter-
vice he loved so that his mates           lieved and found professional help.      mining that its future lies in becom-
would not be threatened. The deep         However, the narrative of how these      ing a republic. Of course that is for
concern of all he had learned encap-      feelings were apparently not dealt       Barbadians to decide. Many of the
sulated in his founding the Invictus      with is beyond belief – Harry says       island monarchies across the Carib-
Games. Our pride at his Canadian          he was “ashamed” to confide in his        bean have at different times con-
courtship, where he could move            family. In other words, his amour pro-   templated what Barbados is calling
through Toronto streets freely, buy       pre trumped his duty to his wife?        the end of the colonial era, but none
a panini at the local Italian bakery      Any other resource failing, he could     has acted on it. One might imagine
and spend a weekend without the           have gone to his father, his brother,    various scenarios leading such a
intrusion of media. The happiness at      his grandmother – and in short           country to ditch the Crown: an au-
his marriage, bi-racial and bi-conti-     order the best medical assistance        thoritarian leader bent on accruing
nental, set to stand for a new normal     would have been procured.                untrammelled power; a scandal at
of diversity and devotion, perfect           The rest was deplorable: a farrago    the vice-regal level; perception of
for his role as Commonwealth Am-          of venting, of slamming family in        Royal indifference to a natural dis-
bassador. His anticipated partner-        public including two of our future       aster. Or indeed, some rational dis-
ship in a life of service with his        Kings, of simpering over love of         cussion engaging debate on the
                                                                                   topic and then persuading the pub-
                      IN THIS EDITION OF CMN                                       lic of the advantages of a republic.
                                                                                   But if The Queen’s Sovereignty is
                                                                                   terminated in Barbados now, the
  Shout-out to the                        Essay on Princess                        world will know who sent the storm
  Lieutenant Governors            4-5     Elizabeth Gift Book 1935 11-13           that brought the end of the reign of
                                                                                   the only monarch Barbados ever en-
  New bilingual flyer:                    Au Secours                               joyed.
  The Case for the Crown         7-10     la Monarchie                    16
                                                                                                       continued on page 4

                                                                                     Canadian Monarchist News – Spring/Printemps 2021 –              3
ELIZABETH II - Canadian Monarchist News Les Nouvelles Monarchiques du Canada - HRH The Prince Philip, Duke of Edinburgh
time of infection.
                                                                                                                        Who could not admire Her Hon-
                                                                                                                     our, the Lieutenant Governor of
                                                                                                                     New Brunswick’s solution to the
                                                                                                                     impossibility of a New Year’s Day
                                                                                                                     Levee inside Government House.
                                                                                                                     The public was as always bade wel-
                                                                                                                     come as Ms Murphy and her partner
                                                                                                                     exchanged masked greetings and
                                                                                                                     distributed treats through the win-
                                                                                                                     dows of attendees’ cars.
                                                                                                                        Bien que son programme soit res
                                                                                                                     treint par le virus, Son Honneur le
                                                                                                                     lieutenant-gouverneur du Québec, J
                                                                                                                     Michel Doyon, a continué de faire
                                                                                                                     sentir la présence de la Couronne,
                                                                                                                     que ce soit en entreprenant la re-
                                                                                                                     mise de la Médaille du lieutenant
Our Queen: admired Head of                                                                                           gouverneur pour mérite exception-
multi-racial Commonwealth
                               QUEEN, CHARLES,                          catholic taste in books with a public        nel au Centre de la Famille Valcartie,
                                                                        for whom tv and internet have di-            l’Inauguration de l’ancienne pou-
                               CAMILLA, WILLIAM,                        minished literary pursuits. Hardly           drière française de la Citadelle de
                               CATHERINE                                glamorous work this – but her en-
                                                                        thusiasm and persistency is the ad-
                                                                                                                     Québec ou accueillant jeunes du
                                                                                                                     camp de jour citoyen de l’Assemblée
                                 How The Queen keeps calm and           mired stuff of the working royals.            nationale du Québec.
                               carries on is beyond imagination.           No less has this constancy been              Across the Rockies, despite the
                               What a Monarch! Within days of the       true of William and Catherine. How           added burden of renovations to
                               cannonade from California HM was         we loved Will’s utterly spontaneous          Government house, BC’s Lieutenant
                               showing her newly-acquired ease in       rejoinder to the media jackals: “The         Governor launched the Victory
                               Zoom calls. Smiling and seemingly        Royal Family is very much not a              Over Covid-19 Garden. Inspired by
                               imperturbable in her 95th year, she      racist family.” Called out by the            the victory gardens of WWII, the
                               can joke with an Australian Premier      brother who, one might have                  first year of its operation eased food
                               about a new statue honouring her as      thought, was joined to him by the            insecurity of the vulnerable by pro-
                               easily as she celebrated British Sci-    most indissoluble ties of bereave-           ducing, harvesting and distributing
Queen’s Zoom call with South   ence Week. Care, concern for others,     ment and hurt, in the past, and by           an incredible TON of vegetables,
Australia Governor & Premier                                            the supportive bonds and excite-             ranging from kale to garlic. Ms
                                                                        ment of shared service into the fu-          Austin’s Household collaborated
                                                                        ture. He is evidently possessed of           with Premier Horgan’s team and
                                                                        the emotional maturity to encour-            government partners to develop a
                                                                        age his children on the UK equiva-           safe approach to install the new
                                                                        lent of Mothers’ Day to write cards          Cabinet following the 2020 provin-
                                                                        to the grandmother they had never            cial election. The unique solution
                                                                        known. And Catherine of her own              adhered to all public health regula-
                                                                        volition attended the “banned” vigil         tions while complying to all legal
                                                                        for Sarah Everard, the young woman           and protocol requirements of our
                                                                        murdered as she walked alone at              democracy in an engaging event.
                                                                        night in London, the Duchess’ un-               Space doesn’t allow for the entire
                                                                        precedented presence speaking                record of vice-regal service by all,
                                                                        louder than any TV show, and testi-          including Their Honours Janice
                                                                        fying to her spot-on judgement –             Fillmon’s ongoing Tree Project in
                                                                        what a Queen she shall be!                   Manitoba to Liz Dowdeswell’s Zoom
                                                                                                                     calls and partnering with Tourism
                                                                        A BIG SHOUT-OUT                              Ontario to produce a number of
                                                                                                                     agri-tourism adverts for various
                                                                        TO OUR                                       parts of the sector. www.dropbox.
                                                                        LIEUTENANT                                   com/sh/1xi2tp9ovwhmgf8/AABK
                                                                                                                     gAXcI-Ui6zS7R1mfWGbXa?dl=0
                               a pitch-perfect statement on the
                                                                        GOVERNORS                                       The point is: how well The Queen
                               controversy – what an example for           ...how well The Queen is represented by   is represented by all her Canadian
                               the rest of us who grumble about         all her Canadian vice-regals. And how well   vice-regals. And how well they serve,
                               isolation or standing in lines for       served by them are we as citizens...         doing their duty at trifling expense.
                               shots and shopping!                         Less covered by the media, and
                                  Charles, however stricken at his      provided with far fewer resources
                               fatherhood being panned even as          than the Royals, The Queen’s
                                                                                                                     AND FINALLY:
                               his own father was ill and hospital-     Canadian representatives in the              OF POLS, POLLS
                               ized, showed some of his Mother’s
                               phlegm by managing a laugh when
                                                                        provinces have continued to do
                                                                        their duty in the face of varying re-
                                                                                                                     & PUNDITS…
                               reporters shouted questions about        strictions on socializing and move-             Prime Minister Trudeau replied to re-
                               the interview as he left an engage-      ment, and to invent imaginative              porters’ questions with calm neu-
                               ment. Camilla, who well under-           ways to undertake outreach and               trality rather than affirmative sup-
                               stands the nature of the British tabs,   tweak tradition to meet the exigen-          port for the Monarchy in Canada. “If
                               went on to continue her useful cam-      cies of social distancing and all that       people want to later talk about con-
                               paign for reading, sharing her           goes with being a good subject in                                 continued on page 6

                               4   – Canadian Monarchist News – Spring/Printemps 2021
ELIZABETH II - Canadian Monarchist News Les Nouvelles Monarchiques du Canada - HRH The Prince Philip, Duke of Edinburgh
Our Lieutenant Governors at Work

                                                                                 Outside Government House,
                                                                                 NS Lieutenant Governor            How many dogs have their own page on
                                                                                 Arthur J LeBlanc makes                a Vice-regal website? Meet MacDuff
                                                                                 official draw for Family SOS,           Austin-Chester, Vice-Regal Canine
                                                                                 a charity providing support      Consort to Their Honours at Government
                                                                                 to families in the Halifax         House, Victoria - and a delight to all he
                                                                                 area.                               greets there (except for his “righteous
                                                                                                                        indignation” when squirrels, rabbits,
                                                                                                                    crows or deer appear). The tradition of
                                                                                                                      the Vice-regal’s best friend continues
                                                                                                                           with a very distinguished canine!

Newfoundland & Labrador’s Lieutenant Governor Judy Foote and His Honour          British Columbia’s Lieutenant Governor, Janet Austin, with Shxwtitostel, a red cedar canoe carved by the
Howard Foote adapt to COVID realities, including a series of virtual visits to   Honourable Steven Point, 28th Lieutenant Governor of British Columbia, which served as inspiration for the
raise spirits at long-term care homes throughout December, assisted by their     BC Reconciliation Award, for furthering reconciliation with the Province’s Indigenous peoples, or inspiring
dog Sailor Girl, a big hit with the residents!                                   others to continue reconciliation efforts. The first recipients will be honoured in April 2021.
Le lieutenant-gouverneur du Québec, J Michel Doyon, dépose une fleur
pour marquer le 11 mars, la Journée de commémoration nationale
en mémoire des victimes de la COVID-19.

                                                                                 The Queen’s York Rangers visit with their Colonel, the Lieutenant Governor of Ontario

                                                                                                         Canadian Monarchist News – Spring/Printemps 2021 –                           5
ELIZABETH II - Canadian Monarchist News Les Nouvelles Monarchiques du Canada - HRH The Prince Philip, Duke of Edinburgh
POLS, POLLS             stitutional change and shifting our      media have had a field day with the         school system, were perpetrated by
& PUNDITS...            system of government, that’s fine.        Payette-Interview dislocation of the       the Canadian state, not the British.
continued from page 4   They can have those conversations.       Canadian Crown, with as usual, sane        Reconciliation has always been
                        But right now, I’m not having those      and extreme positions jockeying for        Canada’s responsibility, and it has
                        conversations.” However, we are in-      attention, the former usually be-          always been within our power to
                        formed reliably that he has no in-       coming more prevalent as time              achieve… It is, of course, true that
                        tention whatsoever of touching the       passes while the vitriol appears           Canada could become a republic,
                        issue.                                   rather more quickly. We thought the        while retaining the system of gov-
                           Opposition Leader Erin O’Toole has    editorial in the National Post of          ernment we inherited from Great
                        been a supporter of the Monarchist       March 13 struck the right balance;         Britain. But getting rid of the mon-
                        League of Canada, and remains a          positive, reasoned – but not adula-        archy would entail sweeping consti-
                        convinced monarchist.                    tory, either.                              tutional reforms that would require
                           NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh took ad-        …The credit for this country’s          tremendous effort and huge ex-
                        vantage of the post-interview cli-       legacy of stable government, free-         pense, with very little benefit. It
                        mate to re-assert his republican po-     dom, democracy, justice and the            would also necessitate a historic
                        sition, contrary to the long tradition   rule of law rests chiefly with the          agreement between Canada’s in-
                        of democratic socialist support for      Crown, but we rarely hear this ac-         creasingly disparate regions and na-
                        the Crown exemplified by figures           knowledged by our politicians or           tionalities that could very easily tear
                        such as Jack Layton and Allan Blak-      the chattering classes… While              the country apart. Far better to stick
                        eney. He told CTV’s Question Period      racism is always inexcusable, this         with a system that has proven re-
                        that “I don’t see the relevance of it,   controversy is no more an admon-           markably stable and successful for
                        and I don’t think that most Canadi-      ishment of the Crown than the              over 150 years, and a Queen who has
                        ans do.” The party is holding a Vir-     actions of our prime minister are a        served us extremely well for nearly
                        tual Convention in April 9-11. At        repudiation        of    Parliamentary     70. Long may she reign.
                        press time it was unclear if a ru-       democracy… the monarchy itself is             What more can we say? This has
                        moured republican resolution had         more than just a group of individu-        not been a tempest in a teapot. Nor
                        been proposed and, if so, whether it     als. It is an ideal. An ideal that holds   will it prove the undoing of the
                        would be selected for consideration      that a country is more than just the       Crown’s representing “all that is best
                        by delegates.                            sum of its parts; more than just the       and most admired in the Canadian
                           Without any recent statement of       people who run it or its institutions.     ideal.”
                        Annamie Paul’s position, the Green       … a monarchy can rise above the               There is sadness, and much to be
                        Party Leader previously indicated        rough-and-tumble world of politics,        reflected on, not least that when we
                        she had “no position” on the             offering stability and serving as a         speak from choler and disappoint-
                        Monarchy, in sharp contrast to the       beacon of the ideals we strive to up-      ment, we perhaps deepen the divi-
                        support enthusiastically given by        hold. The royals themselves will not       sions of all who hear us: family,
                        her monarchist predecessor Eliza-        always live up to those ideals, be-        country, Commonwealth – albeit we
                        beth May.                                cause they too are human. But the          may imagine our venting to be sat-
                           The pollsters have been hard at       Crown transcends even those who            isfying.
                        work questioning Canadians about         wear it… getting rid of the monar-            But there is also joy: the example
                        their views on the Crown. Unfortu-       chy would not fix any of the prob-          of our Queen and her succeeding
                        nately, some persist in inviting neg-    lems faced by Aboriginals, or settle       generations; the gifts of unsung
                        ative opinion by asking leading          any of the disputes between First          heroes ranging from first respon-
                        questions about whether the coun-        Nations and the federal govern-            ders to Lieutenant Governors; the
                        try should continue to have ties to      ment. It would only add legal com-         calmness of our national life despite
                        “the British Monarchy” which of          plications since many First Nations        pandemic. The long view is surely
                        course suggests ours is a foreign        have treaties that were signed di-         promising, as Clough reminds us,
                        monarchy, alien to these shores.         rectly with the Crown. And a lot of        for although the sun seems to
                        They might as well ask if we should      the injustices inflicted on Aborigi-        emerge so slowly, “But Westward,
                        continue with “the Papua New             nal people, such as the residential        look: the land is bright.”
                        Guinean Monarchy” or “the New
                        Zealand Monarchy.” That said, all
                        polls showed a significant shift in          THE CASE FOR THE CROWN
                        greater negative attitudes towards
                                                                    The next four pages of CMN in English and in French –
                        the Crown. Of course we’d rather
                        see refreshed or greater support in         is the League’s newest flyer, designed to summarize
                        these surveys, as the contrary makes        major arguments for Canada’s constitutional monarchy.
                        news and implicitly suggests change         You can find it online in the publications section of our
                        is inevitably in the air. But we know       website – monarchist.ca – or request colour copies from
                        that all polling is naturally condi-        domsec@symparico.ca – surely all readers can think of three
                        tioned by the news of the day – and         people to whom they could give a copy!
                        we can expect they will begin to re-
                        bound as the country considers
                        more fully the truth of what it has
                                                                    BIEN FONDÉS DE LA MONARCHIE
                        heard of late, and celebrates The           CONSTITUTIONELLE
                        Queen’s 95th birthday, Prince               Les quatre pages suivantes du NMC en anglais et en français –
                        Philip’s 100th, and the unique cele-        est le plus récent dépliant de la Ligue, avec les principaux
                        bration of a Platinum Jubilee in            arguments pour notre monarchie. Vous pouvez le trouver en
                        2022. Indeed the same sort of happy
                        events turned around the polls after        ligne – “publications” de notre site Web – monarchist.ca –
                        the long nightmare of the disinte-          ou demander des copies de domsec@sympatico.ca. Sans doute
                        gration of Charles and Diana’s mar-         tous nos lecteurs peuvent penser à trois personnes à qui
                        riage.                                      ils pourraient donner un exemplaire!
                           Pundits in traditional and social

                        6   – Canadian Monarchist News – Spring/Printemps 2021
ELIZABETH II - Canadian Monarchist News Les Nouvelles Monarchiques du Canada - HRH The Prince Philip, Duke of Edinburgh
LA LIGUE MONARCHISTE DU CANADA
                                           THE MONARCHIST LEAGUE OF CANADA
                                                               monarchist.ca
                                               CP 1057, RPO Lakeshore West, Oakville, ON L6K 0B2
                                                            domsec@monarchist.ca

             BIEN-FONDÉ DE LA
         MONARCHIE CONSTITUTIONELLE
                                         9 avantages-clés

1                                                             3
     CHEF DE NATION VERSUS CHEF D’ÉTAT Jour après                    ARBITRES DU FÉDÉRALISME : ONZE
     jour nos représentants élus démocratiquement sont               COURONNES Le Canada est un État fédéral :
     au cœur de débats profitables à propos desquels il y             notre Constitution donne le pouvoir de légiférer
a parfois de la controverse. C’est bien. Cela encourage la    dans certains domaines à Ottawa et dans d’autres
recherche de la réussite et la réalisation d’accomplisse-     domaines aux provinces. Les gouvernements exercent
ments pour des objectifs à la fois partisans et personnels.   ce pouvoir au nom de la Reine. Ainsi, il existe 11
Le Premier ministre est tour à tour le Chef du gouverne-      couronnes au Canada - légalement appelées « La
ment et « leader » d’un parti politique suscitant parfois     Reine du chef du Canada » ou « La Reine du chef »
certaines divergences. Le Souverain représente, quant         d’une province. La Reine est représentée par un
à lui, l’unité au sein de la nation et ses représentants      Lieutenant-gouverneur. Les premiers ministres, dont
ont la confiance de tous les Canadiens. La monarchie           le séparatiste René Lévesque, ont souligné l’importance
protège et rassemble à la fois tous ce que les Canadiens      de la Couronne dans leur Déclaration constitutionnelle
recherchent et demeure constante malgré les élections         clé de 1978. Puisque la monarchie donne l’autorité à
et les changements au pouvoir : c’est-à-dire une société      chaque entité législative, elle garantit également que
tolérante et responsable. En présidant plusieurs événe-       l’État de droit sera respecté dans le traitement des
ments dont les Jeux Olympiques, la célébration de la          différends entre Ottawa et les provinces. Ces faits
Confédération canadienne sur la colline parlementaire,        expliquent le fort soutien des provinces à l’institution
la Reine et sa famille soulignent l’importance d’une par-     de la monarchie, qui réconcilie l’identité régionale
ticipation non-partisane mettant ainsi l’emphase sur le       avec l’unité nationale.

                                                              4
pouvoir unificateur de ces grands rassemblements, lui -
                                                                    IDENTITÉ NATIONALE, STABILITÉ & FIERTÉ
conférantainsi une autre dimension.
                                                                    La proximité géographique, les échanges commer-

2
      GARDIEN DE LA LIBERTÉ Le Parlement, la Reine,                 ciaux, les accords militaires ainsi que la facilité
      le Sénat et la Chambre des Communes. Aucune loi,        avec laquelle nous pouvons être envahis par les médias
      aucun règlement ou dépense n’est autorisé sans          américains peuvent affecter notre identité nationale.
l’assentiment royal. Le Parlement est élu et dissous          Notre gouvernance favorise la loyauté et l’appartenance
avec son accord et en son nom. C’est également en             à un monarque plutôt qu’à une personnalité politique ou
son nom que sont élus les représentants officiels et            une idéologie. Cette différence nous apporte une culture
les diplomates; que les accords sont rectifiés et les          distincte, à la fois dynamique et paisible. La monarchie
commissions d’enquêtes formées. En temps normal               constitutionnelle – version canadienne – procure la
ce n’est qu’une formalité. Toutefois la prérogative           stabilité. Cet état de fait est confirmé chaque année dans
« royale » s’assure que l’accord des lois prévaut en          le « Rapport sur le développent humain » produit par
apportant une garantie de neutralité non-violente             les « Nations Unies » et dans lequel le Canada figure
et non-partisane – pouvant éteindre les débuts                régulièrement au sein des premiers pays. Les change-
d’incendies constitutionnels tel qu’expliqué par              ments sont cependant inévitables et la plupart sont pour
Frank McKinnon un politicien scientifique de                   le mieux au gré des politiciens et des événements qui se
l’Alberta – si le débat politique devait dégénérer.           succèdent. Les Canadiens ont voté dans non moins de
Ainsi même un gouvernement populaire ne pourrait              vingt-deux élections depuis l’avènement d’Élizabeth II!
déclencher des élections simplement pour justifier             La monarchie amène une stabilité malgré tous les
un point de vue ou une démarche quelconque.                   changements. La souveraine possède plusieurs années
                                                              d’expérience et constitue une figure de référence
                                                              importante vu son parcours presque sans faille.

                                                                  Canadian Monarchist News – Spring/Printemps 2021 –     7
ELIZABETH II - Canadian Monarchist News Les Nouvelles Monarchiques du Canada - HRH The Prince Philip, Duke of Edinburgh
5
      SERMENTS : UTILES ET PERSONNELS La loyauté             connaissance du système monarchique comme forme
      la plus profonde des humains est envers les autres     de gouvernement. En 1867, les Pères de la Confédération
      êtres humains. Les serments sont prêtés à la Reine     ont dès lors unanimement opté pour la forme d’une
par nos nouveaux compatriotes, les législateurs, les         monarchie constitutionnelle pour le Canada. En 1982,
juges, les membres des FC et de nombreux autres              la nouvelle Constitution du Canada a entériné la
fonctionnaires. Faire leur promesse à la Souveraine          Couronne de sorte que seul un accord unanime entre
plutôt qu’à un politicien montre que leur loyauté ultime     les paliers provinciaux et le fédéral pourrait changer
n’est pas envers des figures élues, mais envers les lois      la donne. Enfin, le Parlement a adopté unanimement
qui constituent le tissu de la société civilisée. Ces        en 2013 la « Loi sur la succession au Trône » qui
Serments soulignent que le respect de l’État de droit        supprime les barrières indépendamment du sexe
applicable à tous doit prévaloir sur la partisanerie –       pour statuer du futur monarque.

                                                             8
agir pour promouvoir le bien-être d’un segment étroit
                                                                   COMMUNAUTÉ, BÉNÉVOLAT,
de la société. Les Serments à la Reine reflètent
                                                                   RECONNAISSANCE Dans leurs déplacements
également l’accent mis par le Canada sur l’importance
                                                                   constants, la Reine, les membres de la famille
de la personne, de la dignité et de l’égalité de chaque
                                                             royale et ses représentants au Canada apportent leur
individu : dès que les nouveaux citoyens prêtent le
                                                             soutien aux communautés et aux secteurs bénévoles :
serment de citoyenneté, ils deviennent des membres à
                                                             une partie vitale de notre existence nationale. Ils
part entière de la famille canadienne. Chaque Canadien
                                                             inspirent de nombreuses personnes à rendre des
prête allégeance à la Reine, rendant ainsi hommage à
ses décennies de service à l’ensemble du Canada.             services similaires. Ils créent et décernent des
                                                             distinctions honorifiques non politiques à des

6
       UNE MONARCHIE PARTAGÉE Les Canadiens                  concitoyens exceptionnels. Ces activités royales et
       possèdent une grande chance d’avoir à leur tête       vice-royales ne figurent pas souvent dans les
       une Souveraine dont la figure emblématique est         programmes d’information nationaux. L’ouverture
immédiatement et mondialement reconnue. La Reine             d’une nouvelle bibliothèque, la visite d’une salle de
ainsi que tous les membres de la famille Royale tissent      la Légion, un discours à un cours d’éducation civique
un lien unique sans caractère militaire affiché entre tous     dans une école ou un déjeuner avec un club de service
les membres de notre population dans toute sa diversité      local ne sont pas dans le collimateur des médias.
avec le reste du Commonwealth. Les nations issues de la      Mais ils constituent la base de notre société civile
Nouvelle-Guinée jusqu’au Bélize, de la Nouvelle-Zélande      et apportent une grande fierté et une aide importante
jusqu’à l’Inde, reflètent également la richesse du Canada     aux communautés du Canada.

                                                             9
d’aujourd’hui. En 2010, notre Reine s’envola de Toronto
vers New York pour s’adresser aux Nations-Unies.                    UNE RÉPUBLIQUE : DISTRAYANT & INDÉSIRABLE
La veille au soir, la Reine annonça fièrement lors d’un              Personne n’a encore proposé un autre système
diner officiel à Toronto : « Je voyagerai de ce Royaume               de gouvernement pour le Canada qui refléterait
nordique en tant que Reine du Canada ». Le Gouverneur        de la même manière l’histoire de notre nation et serait
Général et les Lieutenants-gouverneurs représentent          supérieur à la monarchie constitutionnelle en termes
la Reine et assument les responsabilités qui leur            de fonctionnement quotidien de l’État canadien. Les
incombent au nom de la Souveraine. Cette disposition         Canadiens se souviennent des débats constitutionnels
                                                             déchirants du siècle dernier. De tels arguments n’ont
permet à notre pays de faire partager des traditions
                                                             rien fait pour aider les objectifs essentiels de la
d’une ancienne monarchie dont hérite l’histoire du
                                                             population : l’environnement, les salles de classe
Canada, alors que, dans le même temps, nous nous
                                                             surpeuplées, l’accès aux soins de santé et le soutien aux
remémorons des services offerts par des concitoyens
                                                             familles monoparentales et à faible revenu. Un système
illustres. Ne pensons qu’au Major-Général Georges
                                                             présidentiel ferait en sorte que le Canada ressemblerait
Vanier, Lincoln Alexander, David Lam et Lynda
                                                             davantage aux États-Unis, combinant le rôle de chef
Haverstock pour n’en nommer que quelques-uns qui ont
                                                             d’État avec celui de chef de gouvernement. Comme nos
servi la Couronne et notre pays avec grande distinction.
                                                             amis américains l’ont redécouvert lors des processus de

7
      UNE RÉFLEXION SUR NOTRE PROPRE HISTOIRE                destitution dans l’administration Trump, cela s’avère
      ET NOTRE DÉVELOPPEMENT La Monarchie                    parfois une combinaison malheureuse. Alternativement,
      d’aujourd’hui puise sa source dans les racines         l’élection d’un président ou d’un Gouverneur général
du passé. Beaucoup des premiers peuples de Canada            créerait simplement un autre homme politique, offrirait
choisirent des chefs de tribu dont les rôles s’inspirèrent   un autre niveau d’ambition personnelle, nécessiterait
davantage des guides du temps passé. L’établissement de      une autre série d’élections et rendrait le titulaire de
colonies françaises et anglaises au Canada a aussi nourri    ce poste redevable aux intérêts des différentes factions
sa propre expérience de la monarchie. Les différentes         et groupes auxquels le résultat devrait être rendu.
vagues d’immigration ont connu leur lot en matière de

8   – Canadian Monarchist News – Spring/ Printemps 2021
ELIZABETH II - Canadian Monarchist News Les Nouvelles Monarchiques du Canada - HRH The Prince Philip, Duke of Edinburgh
THE MONARCHIST LEAGUE OF CANADA
                                        LA LIGUE MONARCHISTE DU CANADA
                                                          monarchist.ca
                                         PO Box 1057, RPO Lakeshore West, Oakville, ON L6K 0B2
                                                        domsec@monarchist.ca

             THE CASE FOR THE CROWN
                                    9 Key advantages

1                                                        3
     NATIONAL IDENTITY, STABILITY & PRIDE:                      GUARANTOR OF FREEDOM: Parliament –
     Easy travel to and from the USA, trade and                 The Queen, the Senate, the elected Commons.
     military alliances and American media can                  No bill, regulation or spending is authorized
muddle Canada’s distinct identity. Our governance        without the Royal Assent. Parliament is summoned
focuses loyalty via allegiance to a monarch rather       and dissolved in The Queen’s name. Also in her name,
than to a politician or ideology. This difference         public officials and diplomats are appointed, treaties
underlies our distinct culture, energetic and yet        approved, cabinets commissioned. Normally, this is a
tranquil. Constitutional monarchy – the Canadian         formality. However, “the Royal Prerogative” ensures
way – provides stability. This is confirmed each year     that the rules of law prevails, and provides a non-
in the United Nations’ Human Development Index,          partisan, non-violent safeguard – a constitutional
which regularly ranks Canada high up in the              fire extinguisher as Alberta political scientist Frank
countries the world. Change is inevitable, and           MacKinnon has put it – should usual democratic
much of it good; political leaders also come and go.     processes ever be threatened. For example, even a
Canadians have voted in 22 federal elections during      popular government could not simply dispense
The Queen’s reign! The Crown provides constancy          with holding an election!

                                                         4
amidst so much change. The Sovereign has the
                                                                REFEREE OF FEDERALISM: ELEVEN
experience of decades, without the taint of a
                                                                CROWNS – Canada is a federal state: our
personal agenda. Such continuity constitutes
                                                                Constitution gives law-making power in
an important anchor in our society.
                                                         certain areas to Ottawa, others to the provinces.

2
       HEAD OF THE NATION VS HEAD                        Governments exercise this authority in the name of
       OF GOVERNMENT: Day to day our                     The Queen. Thus 11 Crowns exist in Canada – legally
       democratically elected representatives            referred to as “The Queen in right of Canada” or
engage in healthy partisan debate on issues about        “The Queen in right of” a province. The premiers,
which Canadians disagree. That is good. It encourages    including the separatist René Levesque, underlined
striving for partisan goals and personal success.        the importance of the Crown in their key 1978
The Prime Minister is our head of government and         Constitutional statement. Since the monarchy
leader of a political party. As such, his actions are    gives authority to each law-making entity, it also
often controversial. The Sovereign, however, is a        guarantees that the rule of law will be followed in
force of unity as head of the nation, and with her       dealing with disputes between Ottawa and the
team of representatives is trusted by all Canadians.     provinces. These facts explain the strong support by
The monarchy protects and exemplifies the things          the provinces for the institution of monarchy, which
Canadians agree about, and remain constant,              reconciles regional identity with national unity.

                                                         5
regardless of an election: a notably tolerant, mature
                                                               OATHS: USEFUL & PERSONAL: The deepest
society, By presiding at events such as the Montréal
                                                               loyalties of humans are to other human beings.
Olympics and Canada Day celebrations on Parliament
                                                               Oaths are taken to The Queen by our new
Hill, The Queen and her family emphasize the non-
                                                         fellow Canadians, legislators, judges, CF members and
partisan, unifying nature of great national occasions.

                                                             Canadian Monarchist News – Spring/Printemps 2021 –   9
ELIZABETH II - Canadian Monarchist News Les Nouvelles Monarchiques du Canada - HRH The Prince Philip, Duke of Edinburgh
many other public officials. Making their promise to         Canada’s form of government. In 1982, Canada’s
the Sovereign rather than to a politician shows their      new Constitution entrenched the Crown so that
ultimate loyalty is not to elected figures, but to the      only unanimous federal-provincial agreement could
laws that make up the fabric of civilized society.         ever alter it. Parliament unanimously passing the
Such Oaths underline that following the rule of law        Succession to the Throne Act in 2013 removed barriers
applicable to all must prevail over partisanship –         of gender in determining our future monarchs.

                                                           8
acting to promote the well-being of a narrow
                                                                  COMMUNITY, VOLUNTEERISM,
segment of society. Oaths to The Queen also reflect
                                                                  RECOGNITION – In their constant round
Canada’s emphasis on the importance of the person,
                                                                  of travels, The Queen, members of the Royal
and of the dignity and equality of each individual:
                                                           Family and her Canadian representatives bring
the moment new citizens take the Citizenship Oath
                                                           encouragement to the communities and volunteer
they become full members of the Canadian family.
                                                           sectors: a vital part of our national existence. They
Each Canadian gives allegiance to The Queen, so
                                                           inspire many to similar service. They create and
reciprocating her decades of service to all Canada.
                                                           award non-political honours to outstanding fellow

6
       A SHARED MONARCHY: Canadians are                    citizens. These Royal and vice-regal activities do not
       fortunate to have as our monarch an instantly       often feature on national news programs. Opening a
       recognizable world figure. The Queen and             new library, visiting a Legion Hall, speaking to a
members of the Royal Family link our diverse               school civics class or lunching with a local service
population to a far-flung Commonwealth, unique in           club are not on the media’s radar. But they constitute
that it seeks no military advantage. These nations –       the basis of our civil society, and bring significant
from New Guinea to Belize, from New Zealand to             pride and assistance to Canada’s communities.

                                                           9
India – mirror the rich diversity of today’s Canada.
                                                                 A REPUBLIC = DISTRACTING &
In 2010, our Queen flew from Toronto to New York,
                                                                 UNDESIRABLE – No one has yet proposed an
where she addressed the United Nations. The night
                                                                 alternative system of government for Canada
before, The Queen proudly told an Official Dinner in
                                                           which would in the same way reflect our nation’s
Toronto that “I shall be travelling from this Northern
                                                           history and be superior to constitutional monarchy
Realm as Queen of Canada”. The Governor General
                                                           in terms of the day-to-day functioning of the
and the Lieutenant Governors represent The Queen
                                                           Canadian state. Canadians remember the wrenching
and perform most of the constitutional functions of
                                                           constitutional debates of the last century . Such
the Sovereign in her name. This arrangement allows
                                                           arguments did nothing to help practical concerns:
our country to share in the traditions of an ancient
                                                           the environment, crowded classrooms, access to
monarchy stemming out of Canada’s history, while at
                                                           health care and support for single-parent and low-
the same time we enjoy the services of distinguished
                                                           income families. A presidential system would make
fellow citizens – think of Major-General Georges
                                                           Canada more closely resemble the United States,
Vanier, Lincoln Alexander, David Lam and Lynda
                                                           combining the role of head of state with head of
Haverstock, to name but a few – who served Crown
                                                           government. As our American friends re-discovered
and country with great distinction.
                                                           during impeachment processes in the Trump

7
      A REFLECTION OF OUR HISTORY                          administration, this proves an unhappy combination.
      & DEVELOPMENT: Today’s monarchy stems                Alternatively, the election of a president or governor
      from our history. Many of Canada’s first              general would simply create another politician,
peoples chose chieftains whose role was much like          offer another level of personal ambition, necessitate
that of other leaders in ancient times. Settlement by      another set of elections and make the holder of
French and British people brought to Canada their          that office beholden to the interests of the different
own experience of monarchy. Many subsequent                factions and groups to which the result was owed.
immigrants have also known the monarchical system
of government. In 1867, the Fathers of Confederation                        monarchist.ca
unanimously chose constitutional monarchy as

10   – Canadian Monarchist News – Spring/ Printemps 2021
The Princess Elizabeth Gift Book, 1935
an Essay in celebration of the 85th anniversary of its publication
and the 95th birthday of Elizabeth our Queen, BY ALASTAIR GLEGG

                                      I
                                         n 1914 Princess Mary’s Gift
Princess, at nine                        Book was published to
you’ve taken a                           raise funds for the
                                      wartime ‘Queen’s Work for
people for your                       Women Fund’. Authors
                                      and artists were invited to
friend, Let love be                   contribute stories, poems,
so unshaken until                     or pictures, and some of
                                      the best-known did so.
your journey’s end…                   Twenty years later a simi-
                                      lar project was undertaken,
                                      this time to support the
                                      moving of the Princess
                                      Elizabeth of York Hospital
  This essay is quite unlike          for Children from Hack-
  anything CMN has printed            ney to a more appropriate
  before. It traces with wit and      location in the country.
  erudition the fruits of an era      That was 85 years ago, and
  when reading was a common           as the then Princess Eliza-
  pastime, and children’s books       beth celebrates her 95th
  were at once popular and            birthday this year I
  demanding, whimsical and            thought it an appropriate
  serious, not beneath the            occasion to recall the con-
  talents of some of the finest        tributions made by many
  pens in the land, nor reliant       famous authors of the day,
  on much illustration save the       several of whom had writ-
  imagination of the brain. In        ten pieces for the earlier
  such a world our Queen grew         volume as well.
  up. And how lovely to think of         James Barrie’s piece
  these authors’ inventing new        comes first, appropriately
  stories for her 10th birthday,      enough, as it concerns a
  and to the benefit of the            children’s hospital in a
  Hospital that bore her name.        chateau previously occu-
  We thought that the 95th            pied by the Germans dur-
  birthday of The Queen was the       ing the First Battle of the
  ideal occasion for our reader       Marne in 1915. He de-
  so settle back and feel the         scribes it as “an odd little
  masterstroke of the essayist        hospital that was mine”
  open “the realms of gold”. – Ed     (he donated the funds to
                                      establish it) where a vol-
                                      unteer staff cared for local
                                      children who had been se-
                                      riously wounded by shell-
Alastair Glegg was born in            fire or bombs. One night a
                                      Zeppelin was brought
London in 1940 and grew up in         down by gunfire in the
Southern Rhodesia. After teaching     grounds: it had been on
languages in Rhodesia, Barbados,      several bombing runs, but
and Canada he joined the University   Barrie felt sure that “the
                                      airmen had no idea there
of Victoria Faculty of Education      were these small people
where for 25 years he lectured and    below.” He says that in retrospect     but the porcupine refused to be
published numerous articles on        the hospital seemed gay, but it was    combed and slashed Ham with his
Educational History and               not always so: however, as his most    spiny tail instead of saying Thank-
                                      famous creation Peter Pan might        You. Ham asked Noah for the lid of
Administration.                       have said, “If we cannot always be     a big biscuit tin – (‘Ararat Biscuits’ –
                                      gay we can always make pretend”.       I missed the pun the first time I
                                         Rudyard Kipling wrote a new Just-   read it, but parents of small children
                                      So Story about the Porcupine and the   in the 1930s would probably have
                                      Hedgehog: Noah’s son Ham was           got it) – and next time the porcu-
                                      grooming the animals on the Ark,                 continued on page 12

                                                                              Canadian Monarchist News – Spring/Printemps 2021 –   11
THE PRINCESS             pine tried to slash him he used it as    papers, in which their comic strips
ELIZABETH                a shield and told him that for being     played an important part, but they
GIFT BOOK...             so fretful he would have to go and       united for a good cause. Teddy Tail of
continued from page 11   live in a hole in the ground in Africa   the Daily Mail first appeared in 1915
                         when the Ark came ashore. Because        and the author, Una Lascot, con-
                         his little cousin the hedgehog had       tributed a story about Teddy and his
                         been so good and polite he would be      friends putting on a circus.1919 had
                         allowed to go and live in England        seen the arrival of Uncle Oojah the
                         “all among gardens and box-borders       elephant in the Daily Sketch, and 16
                         and slugs where people will be glad      years later Flo Lancaster told how
                         to see you”. Kipling died in 1936, as    his friends watched the Silver Ju-
                         did Barrie, and perhaps these were       bilee. The long-running comic strip        Rudyard Kipling
                         the last pieces they wrote.              of Pip, Squeak and Wilfred also first ap-
                            Animal stories have always been       peared in 1919 in the Daily Mirror and
                         favourites with children, and Fran-      “Uncle Dick” (B. J. Lamb) submitted                   in sunset fires
                         cis Brett Young, author of over 30       a piece on how they got their names.           The children told me that,
                         novels, described how three hungry       That strip ran until 1956, outlasted                   aloof, alone,
                         cuckoos, finding no more food in          only by Rupert the Little Bear who first      Dwelt the Good Grocer, whom
                         the desert conditions of a South         appeared in the Daily Express in 1920,             I had not known…
                         African winter, followed their friends   and whose author Mary Tourtel               To you dear children of old days,
                         the swallows and storks and flew all      contributed an account of his ad-                         I send
                         the way to England to a village in       venture with robbers and giants.            This apologia to your early friend.
                         Worcestershire where they settled        Walt Disney sent two colour car-
                         happily. Algernon Blackwood turned       toons of Mickey Mouse and his ‘ret-           However, I think it unlikely that
                         from his tales of mystery and horror     inue’ arriving for the party, com-         any of the children had ever read
                         to relate the story of Alexander III,    plete with top hat and an ermine           the original book, perhaps best
                         a black chow dog, who did not in-        cape for Minnie.                           known as it contains his poem The
                         tend to be left at home when his            Enid Bagnold, who had served as         Rolling English Road.
                         family went to watch the Jubilee         a nurse and driver in France during           As might be expected of that pe-
                         Procession but set off on his own to      the War and is best known as the au-       riod there are some cautionary and
                         see the King and Queen where he          thor of National Velvet and The Chalk      moral tales: the prolific Compton
                         ‘exchanged pleasant and friendly         Garden, wrote a piece about story-         Mackenzie put aside the sense of
                         glances with his fellow monarchs’. L.    telling at bedtime, and there are also     humour evident in Whisky Galore to
                         A. G. Strong, perhaps best known for     tales whose popular heroes are now         tell of a Fairy Washerwoman who
                         his Inspector McKay detective sto-       probably long forgotten: one about         occasionally appeared on a He-
                         ries, told how two country gentle-       Woolly Bear, contributed by Shirley        bridean isle and could be heard by
                         men were concerned about the             Cooke, and another about Hepzibah          the stream beating out the dirt from
                         plight of small animals trapped in       Hen, by Olwen Bowen who pub-               tweeds and blankets with a heavy
                         the middle of the corn field when it      lished numerous children’s books in        mallet as the crofters did. Big Hec-
                         is cut, and arranged with a seagull to   the 1920s. W. H. Davies the Welsh          tor ignored the warnings of the old
                         see that they could escape in time.      poet who in 1908 wrote Autobiogra-         women, and captured the fairy who
                         Herbert Asquith, son of the wartime      phy of a Supertramp based on his own       agreed to look after his farm for a
                         Prime Minister and brother of Vio-       world-wide wanderings, which even          year if he promised to release her
                         let Bonham Carter, wrote a poem          included losing a leg while jumping        then. The farm prospered, and Hec-
                         called Come and Change in which a        a railroad car in Canada, sent a verse     tor became very rich, but he would
                         wizard invites children to choose        about Street Criers.                       not let her go after a year and cursed
                         their favourite animal into which he        I was initially puzzled by G. K.        her, whereupon she vanished along
                         will magically transform them:           Chesterton’s contribution,The Good         with his good fortune. He died
                                                                  Grocer (An Apology). Then I discov-        alone and in poverty, and “there is
                           Everything you choose is here,         ered that twenty years earlier             not even so much as a nettle grow-
                               Zebra, armadillo, deer,            Chesterton had written The Flying          ing green nor a loose stone to mark
                             Every kind of dog and cat,           Inn, a satire based on the premise         where once upon a time that un-
                          Pard and panther, mouse and bat,        that Prohibition had come to Eng-          grateful man lived”.
                           Wild horse that knows not bit          land and that all the friendly pubs           Denis Mackail, James Barrie’s offi-
                                      or shoe,                    were effectively closed. Grocers            cial biographer and Rudyard Kip-
                            Toad and tapir and kangaroo.          were allowed to sell alcohol, but          ling’s cousin, wrote about Rather
                                                                                                             Greedy Little Hugh who dreamed each
                           The echoes of Shakespeare’s rhy-          The wicked Grocer groces in             night of having everything he want-
                         thms and themes reoccur in Walter                spirits and in wine,               ed, but on his birthday could not
                         De La Mare’s poem Stars:                    Not frankly or in fellowship            wake up from a dream in which he
                                                                        as men in inns do dine;              had to go on and on playing with
                               If to the heavens thou lift        But packed with soap and sardines          the train he had said he wanted so
                                        thine eyes                    and carried off by grooms,              badly, even though he desperately
                                 When winter rules our             For to be snatched by Duchesses           wanted to stop. “Terrible, wasn’t it.
                                     northern skies,                and drunk in dressing rooms.             Are you feeling sorry for him? Well,
                               And snow-cloud none the                                                       but he was rather greedy, you know,
                                       zenith mars                  He offered the subsequent Apology         and he had said “I shan’t” and “I
                              At Yule-tide midnight these         for The Song against the Grocers because   won’t,” and “Go away!” One oughtn’t
                                         thy stars.                                                          to say that kind of thing, ought one?
                                                                      …where far off in the warm              Not even in a dream.”
                           In the 1930s there was fierce com-                 western shires                     James Hilton contributed another
                         petition among the popular daily           Steep sloping woods are dipped           chapter of Goodbye Mr. Chips to re-

                         12   – Canadian Monarchist News – Spring/Printemps 2021
should never fly when one could
                                          walk”, but to their horror the Prin-
                                          cess was once late for lunch because
                                          she had been talking to a boy who
                                          had written a poem for her. They
                                          took back their original gifts and re-
                                          placed them with Good Looks and a
                                          Sense of the Ridiculous, which they
                                          claimed had brought many prin-
                                          cesses to a bad end. She married the
                                          poet, and their children did not
Walter de la Mare                         have Fairy Godmothers.
                                             Poetry and prophesy have often
                                          gone together. In 1934, when contri-
mind the reader of the importance         butions to this fund-raising book
of honour and kindness, because           were invited, King George V, Prin-
“even when you are fighting systems        cess Elizabeth’s grandfather, was just
…there are human beings behind            69 years old, although not in good
those systems”. Hugh Walpole, the         health, and her uncle Edward was
author of Rogue Herries and other his-    heir to the throne. Her father, the
torical novels, recalled his child-       Duke of York, was next in line (as-
hood when “it was considered good         suming Edward produced no heirs)
for children to do what they dis-         but few could have foreseen that he                 J M Barrie
liked”. He was forbidden to enter his     would be crowned king just two
grandmother’s drawing room, or to         years later, following his father’s
touch her little gold chair: of course    death and Edward’s abdication, and
he did so, and accidentally damaged       that the next monarch would be a
it. He was sent to bed without sup-       Queen.
per, and “for weeks moved in a               Lord David Cecil, professor of
dreadful thick never-shifting cloud”.     English Literature at Oxford, con-
   There are, naturally, several pieces   tributed a poem about another Prin-
about princesses. Margaret Irwin          cess Elizabeth who would have to
wrote historical novels, specializing     face a similar challenge:
in the Elizabethan period, and she
contributed a one-act play about the           But sometimes through
little Princess Jeanne d’Albert who                  a leaded pane
in 1541 was forced to marry a much               Or stepping down the
older man for reasons of state. Per-                 spacious stair
haps not the most suitable topic, but       I seemed to see another child
happily in her fictional version the         Who lived there once in days
wedding was cancelled at the last                     that were…
minute.                                         She paused, she sighed,
   Joyce Anstruther, who wrote                 she clenched her hands,
under the name of Jan Struther and            The knuckles through her
created the delightful character of               rings showed white,
Mrs. Miniver, contributed a poem           Then turning as in stately dance
called Princess Jane of London Town            Moved sad and splendid
about a young girl who sees no rea-                   out of sight.                           G K Chesterton
son to be jealous of a real princess:
   I own no marble palace, but the           The last poem in the collection is
Marble Arch is there:                     by the author and playwright John
                                          Drinkwater who also looked into
  While as for crystal fountains –        the future, accurately foreseeing the         The Princess
  well, I’ve got Trafalgar Square…        respect and affection with which               Elizabeth Gift
    I keep no golden coaches:             the young Princess Elizabeth con-             Book.(1935)
         I always use instead             tinues to be regarded:                        In aid of the Princess
    My stately motor buses, of                                                          Elizabeth of York
         a rich majestic red;                Princess, at nine you’ve taken             Hospital for Children.
   And miles of secret passages                 a people for your friend,               Hodder & Stoughton:
     go winding underground                  Let love be so unshaken until              London.
  With steely steeds to carry me                  your journey’s end…
       wherever I am bound.                  Still may the bells be ringing             © Alastair Glegg
                                              when we are dust and dead,                Victoria, BC, Canada
  The Unromantic Princess is the title         To tell a princess singing               March, 2021
of a charming story by Elizabeth                because her heart is wed
Bowen. As was the custom, fairy               To ages all between the tale
godmothers were invited to her                   of ninety or nineteen,
christening, but they were “full of           Or nine as any nightingale
modern ideas” and gave the princess            at noon among the green.
the gifts of Punctuality and Com-
monsense. Their surprisingly green
and contemporary motto was “One

                                                                                   Canadian Monarchist News – Spring/Printemps 2021 –   13
You can also read