Colorado Driver Licenses and the Non- Ci4zen Client
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
Today’s Topics 1. Traffic Issues Legal Framework (ALS) | Suspensions SR-‐22 Insurance | ProbaBonary Licenses | RevocaBons 2. Out-‐of-‐State & InternaBonal Drivers IDLC | NRVC | NDR | Non-‐Resident Drivers | Int’l Reciprocity | 1949 Geneva ConvenBon | SSN Issues 3. ExcepBons Processing U.S. CiBzens | Lawful Permanent Residents Temporary Presence / Status | Unlawful Presence 4. Fraud InvesBgaBons Risk Factors | Pot. Consequences | Agg./Mit. Factors | Hearing Procedure 5. SB-‐251, CO-‐RCSA Overview | Current Issues | TLPs | ULPs | Appointment Scheduling 6. SAVE Issues Required informaBon | Standard Process | Manual VerificaBon | CorrecBng Info 7. Habitual Traffic Offender HTO | Driving while Rev. Prohibit. | Agg. Driving 8. Aggravated DUI AZ’s Aggravated DUI Offense & ImplicaBons for Colo. 9. DMV Hearings Overview | ConsideraBons Note: I will not be spending much Bme on alcohol-‐driving DMV issues, which merit their own, in-‐depth treatment. For reasons of Bme and complexity, I will for the most part not address issues involving minors.
Legal Framework • Post-‐ConvicBon v. Admin. License Suspension (ALS) • As of 2014, 41 States had ALS schemes, inc. Colorado. • Features of ALS schemes: – Pre-‐convicBon suspension in some instances; – 2-‐track system: AdministraBve & Criminal/Traffic; and, – PotenBal for mulBple suspension periods as a result of same charge: pre-‐ & post-‐ convicBon.
Forms of Restraint in Colorado Suspension Revoca4on ! Generally, a maximum of 1 year ! Generally, a minimum of 1 year and a ! Base period of 6 months maximum of 5 years for a single offense ! ProbaBonary license available ! ProbaBonary license unavailable ! Early reinstatement with Interlock restricted license available for alcohol offenses only (fin. assistance may be available, 42-‐2-‐132.5(4)) Denial Cancella4on (42-‐2-‐122) ! Self-‐explanatory ! Physical or mental incompetence ! Fraud / MisrepresentaBon / Omission on applicaBon ! RetroacBve determinaBon of ineligibility ! DeterminaBon of unlawful presence in U.S. ! Etc. NOTE: Falsely applying for a license while a suspension or revocaBon is in effect is a criminal offense. 42-‐2-‐132(3) – Class 2 Traffic Misdemeanor.
Timing of Ac4on • Wait-‐and-‐See Offenses include: – Point assessments – No Vehicle Operator License (NVOL) – Driving under RevocaBon (DUR) • Immediate Administra4ve Ac4on when: – DUI – No Possession of Insurance (NPOI) – Out-‐of-‐state license restraint – Certain other offenses: vehicular homicide, etc. – Further penalty may be imposed as a result of points assessment following convicBon
TYPICAL SUSPENSIONS Offense DMV Restraint Point Assess. Early Notes (convic4on) Eligibility Points Suspension 0-‐/6/-‐12 months✔ N/A PDL Eligible✔ CRS § 42-‐2-‐127 (limited purposes) No Insurance (#1) Indefinite 4 PTS Varies# financial responsibility act (FRA) suspension | CRS 42-‐2-‐127.7; 42-‐4-‐1409 No Vehicle Op. License No AutomaBc 3-‐6 PTS N/A 3 PTS (1st off.); 6 PTS (2+ off.) Suspension 42-‐2-‐101(1),(11); 42-‐2-‐127(r) UnsaBsfied Judgment Indefinite N/A N/A Lots of opBons for parBal saBsfacBon & restoraBon of DL Out-‐of-‐State Restraint Indefinite N/A N/A Interstate Driving Compact – must resolve with restraining state Failure to Pay Child N/A Special hearing procedures and Support only a limited probaBonary license available | 42-‐2-‐127.5 ✔ DiscreBonary
Common Points Assessments (Assessments follow Convic4on) Driver Consecu4ve 12-‐Months Consecu4ve 24-‐Months Other Adult – 21+ years 12 points 18 points N/A Adult – 18-‐(less than) 21 9 points 12 points 14+ points bet. 18-‐21 Minor (under 18) 6 points N/A 7 points (prior to age 18) Offense Points NVOL #1 3 points 42-‐2-‐101(1),(11); 42-‐2-‐127(r) NVOL 2+ 6 points 42-‐2-‐101(1),(11); 42-‐2-‐127(r) DWAI 8 points DUI, DUI Per Se 12 points Reckless Driving 8 points “Simple” Careless Driving (no death) 4 points ReducBons for Bmely payment of fine for traffic offense or infracBon: 3+ points reduced to 2; 2 points reduced to one. 42-‐2-‐127(5.5)
Proba4onary Driver’s Licenses
Proba4onary Driver’s Licenses (a.k.a. PDLs / “RED Licenses”) Availability ! Available when license has been suspended, depending on circumstances ! Unavailable when license revoked, but “Early Reinstatement” on restricted license with Interlock available in alcohol cases Procedure ! Request hearing ! Hearing officer considers miBgaBng and aggravaBng factors ! Hearing officer determines scope of limited driving privilege Validity ! Maximum period of validity is the length of underlying restraint(s) Considera4ons ! Issuance of probaBonary license is discreBonary ! Hearing Officer’s decision is guided by regulaBons at 1 CCR 211-‐3, and overarching consideraBons are public safety and modificaBon of future driving behavior ! Hearing Officer will balance regulatory aggravaBng and miBgaBng factors ! Hearing Officer may require maintenance of SR-‐22 insurance coverage Restric4ons ! OperaBon of commercial vehicle prohibited on PDL ! Driving while at work prohibited if under age 17 ! PDL can’t be issued to a person who has never held a license in any State. ! PDL can’t be issued where pending case could lead to restraint w/no PDL opBon ! If driver has ever had prior PDL, then second PDL will generally not be issued ! PDL may be limited to driving for employment, educaBon, childcare, etc.
AggravaBng/MiBgaBng Factors Aggrava4ng Mi4ga4ng ! Collision involving death or injury where driver at fault ! Demonstrated efforts to correct behavior leading to restraint ! Any collision where driver at fault ! Errors by DMV that negaBvely affected driving privilege ! ConvicBon for traffic violaBons carrying 6+ points ! Time w/o driving already served under current restraint(s) ! ConvicBon defined in Fed. Motor Carrier Safety RegulaBons ! Lack of subsequent violaBons (where citaBon late reported) ! ViolaBon of “out of service” order w/ serious pub. safety risk ! Evidence that any substance abuse is under control ! Any offense listed under the HTO statute ! Other ! Carelessness as shown in driver record or other info ! Recklessness as shown in driver record or other info ! Repeated disregard for law / public safety ! Prior restraint(s) ! Prior issuance of PDL ! Repeated commission of same offense ! Driver’s “reluctance to be truthful or candid at hearing” ! AccumulaBon of 3+ points beyond minimum for PTS restraint ! Evidence of violaBon of terms of prior PDL ! Evidence of non-‐compliance with probaBon ! Evidence of substance-‐abuse problem that is not, or is unlikely to remain, under control NOTE: The above factors are also relevant to the Hearing Officer’s consideraBon of the length of restraint, where length is discreBonary. Hearing officer begins with base period of 6 months and adds or subtracts Bme based on above factors.
License Revoca4ons
Revoca4on Non-‐Alcohol Mixed Alcohol ! Driving under Restraint (DUR) ! DUR-‐Alcohol ! DUI ! MulBple DURs in five years ! HTO – driving while revocaBon ! DUI per se prohibited ! Driving with BAC 0.15+ ! Aggravated HTO ! MulBple alcohol offenses ! Express consent refusal ! Other How NVOLs Turn into DURs and worse: • A first convicBon for NVOL results in the assessment of 3 points; • Subsequent convicBons for NVOL result in 6-‐point assessments; will quickly results in excessive-‐ points suspension when combined with other assessments. • Driving aoer suspension can result in a DUR. • 2+ DURs in five years cause a 3-‐year period of revocaBon. • 3+ DURs in seven years trigger an HTO designaBon and a 5-‐year revocaBon. • Driving during HTO revocaBon is a first-‐degree misdemeanor. • Obtaining a license and proof of insurance can ooen allow a plea deal to a non-‐moving violaBon, enabling the person to avoid this downward spiral. Cita6ons: 42-‐2-‐101(1), (10), (11) [NVOL]; 42-‐2-‐138(1)(b); 42-‐2-‐206
TYPICAL REVOCATIONS Offense DMV Restraint Point Assess. Early Notes (convic4on) Eligibility Drive under Restraint 1 year" N/A None 42-‐2-‐138(3) DUR – Alcohol 1 year" N/A 1 month★ 42-‐2-‐138(1)(d) 2nd DUR in 5 years 3 years N/A None 42-‐2-‐138(1)(b) HTO (no-‐alcohol) 5 years N/A None 42-‐2-‐206 HTO (alcohol) 5 years N/A 1 month★ 42-‐2-‐206; 42-‐2-‐132.5 DUI 1 9 months 12 PTS 1 month★ 42-‐4-‐1301; 42-‐2-‐132.5 DWAI 1 None 8 PTS N/A 42-‐4-‐1301(1)(g), (6) DUI Per Se 1 9 months 12 PTS 1 month★ BAC 0.08+ 42-‐4-‐1301(2); 42-‐2-‐126(3) Persistent Drunk Driver 1 year, then N/A Refusal: 2 months★ 2+ alc. ViolaBons (admin. or court); DUR-‐ mandatory 2 years Other: 1 month★ Alc.; BAC 0.15+; Exp. Consent Refusal; (PDD) / Refusal 42-‐1-‐102(68.5); 42-‐2-‐126(c); 42-‐2-‐132; with Interlock 42-‐2-‐132.5 ✔ DiscreBonary | ♯ Demonstrate current insurance | " ConsecuBve to prior restraint | ★ With Interlock
Length of Restraint Adult Driver -‐ Non-‐Commercial License Points Suspension 2nd DUR in 5 Years Restraint Simple DUI #1 Eligibility Interlock 1st Refusal + DUI ConvicBon Habitual Traffic Offender 0 20 40 60 80 Months
INTERLOCK RESTRICTED LICENSES Designa4on Eligible Length Notes Early Reinstatement with Restricted License 1st DUI with 9-‐month revocaBon 1 Month At Least 8 Months* 42-‐2-‐132.5(4)(a)(II)(A) *4 months if no Interlock interrupt DUI/DUI per se/DWAI/Excess BAC 1 Month At Least 1 Year Longer of Bme remaining on restraint or 12 months, with at least 1-‐year revocaBon 42-‐2-‐132.5(4)(a)(I) DUR-‐Alcohol prior to alcohol offense 1 Month At Least 1 Year 42-‐2-‐132.5(b) – means that a DUR-‐alcohol restraint will not affect Interlock eligibility Habitual Traffic Offender – Alcohol 1 Month 5 Years Eligible only if (42-‐2-‐132.5(4)(c)): LIMITED 42-‐2-‐205 (a) 1 convicBon for DUI/DUI per se/DWAI AND (b) No add. violaBons except DUR or Reckless Driving Mandatory Interlock-‐Restricted License Following Reinstatement Persistent Drunk Driver (PDD) N/A At Least 2 Years 42-‐2-‐132.5(3); 42-‐1-‐102(68.5) MulBple DUI/DUI per se/DWAI N/A At Least 1 Year 42-‐2-‐132.5(1) Excess BAC (0.15+) or prior PDD N/A At Least 1 Year 42-‐2-‐132.5(1); 42-‐2-‐126 (where prior PDD in effect) HTO – Alcohol N/A At Least 1 Year 42-‐2-‐132.5(1); 42-‐2-‐203 RevocaBon for Interlock Circumvent N/A At Least 1 Year 42-‐2-‐132.5(1), (7) Notes: • A separately imposed non-‐alcohol restraint must be saBsfied prior to eligibility for early reinstatement with Interlock. 42-‐2-‐132.5(4)(b). • DMV may not impose points suspension if the incident that would otherwise trigger suspension arose from the same transacBon giving rise to another type of restraint (i.e., DUI revocaBon). 42-‐2-‐127(8)(b)(I). • However, express consent refusals can result in points revocaBon from same incident, which might run concurrently. 42-‐2-‐127(8)(b)(I). • MulBple revocaBons from same incident should run concurrently; but will not do so if from separate incidents. 42-‐2-‐125(5). • Early reinstatement requires SR-‐22 for longer of 3 years or Bme remaining on restricted license. 42-‐2-‐132.5(4)(b).
Financial Responsibility Liability Insurance & SR-‐22
Liability Insurance & SR-‐22 • Colorado law generally requires insurance liability coverage for bodily injury or death of at least $25,000 to any one person in any one accident, $50,000 to all persons in any one accident, and $15,000 for property damage. C.R.S. § 10-‐4-‐620. • Failure to maintain insurance is a crime (42-‐4-‐1409) and also grounds for suspension (42-‐2-‐127.7). • “Proof of Financial Responsibility” and “Proof of Future Financial Responsibility” refer to SR-‐22 insurance and may be required following certain suspensions, revocaBons, and cancellaBons, and in certain other instances. 42-‐7-‐103(14). • SR-‐22 insurance is a scheme by which the insurer cerBfies to the DMV that the required insurance will remain in effect for a specified period of Bme into the future. The insurance company is required to noBfy the DMV if the coverage ever lapses, which will result in a license restraint. • Default period for maintaining SR-‐22 insurance is three years; however, there are plenty of excepBons. See, e.g., 42-‐2-‐172.7(2), (4)(c). • SR22 is waived in certain circumstances, including where the driver can show that an insurance policy was in effect at the Bme of the alleged offense. See C.R.S. § 42-‐2-‐302.
SR-‐22 Insurance Card Am. Assoc. of Motor Veh. Administrators
FINANCIAL RESPONSIBILITY LAW – A FEW SCENARIOS Designa4on CRS Result SR22 Notes Failure to SaBsfy Judgment 42-‐7-‐401 SR22 3 Years Indefinite suspension -‐ Discharge in bankruptcy negates suspension. or ResBtuBon Order 42-‐7-‐402. ParBal saBsfacBon of judgment or seulement, and passage of Bme can also negate suspension. 42-‐7-‐403-‐404 No Proof of Insurance 42-‐2-‐127.7 SR22 3 Years Indefinite suspension, then progressively longer suspensions 42-‐4-‐1409 result from subsequent violaBons. DUI / DUI per se / DWAI 42-‐4-‐408(c) SR22 Length of SR-‐22 required for lesser of the length of the revocaBon or 3 1st Offense & No Accident revocaBon years, starBng at reinstatement. Ex.: 9-‐month revoke for 1st DUI triggers 9-‐month SR-‐22 requirement. DUI / DUI per se / DWAI 42-‐4-‐408(b) SR22 3 Years MulBple or Accident Mandatory RevocaBon 42-‐2-‐125 SR22 3 Years ExcepBon for mandatory revocaBons for failure to complete 42-‐4-‐406 required alcohol classes. 42-‐2-‐125(m); 42-‐4-‐406(1). ExcepBons also for some revocaBons for minor drivers. 42-‐4-‐406(1). ProbaBonary License 42-‐2-‐127 SR22 3 Years Cancelled 42-‐4-‐406 CancellaBon – Physical or 42-‐2-‐122 SR22 ? ExcepBon for persons receiving approved therapy. Mental incompetence 42-‐4-‐406 42-‐2-‐122(2.5); 42-‐4-‐406. Points Suspension 42-‐4-‐406(2) Insurance N/A Prior to issuance of PDL or reinstatement, renewal, or issuance, must provide proof of insurance. (SR-‐22 not required.) 42-‐4-‐1409 – Compulsory insurance; 42-‐4-‐1409(6) – mandatory dismissal if driver proves insurance was in effect • Motor Vehicle Financial Responsibility Law: 42-‐7-‐101 et seq. • Term of SR-‐22 insurance is a minimum of 3 months. 42-‐7-‐408(2) • If the three-‐year SR-‐22 period applies, then any Bme during which the insured has not been licensed will be credited toward the period. 42-‐7-‐408(b). • Compliance is monitored through the Motorist Insurance IdenBficaBon Database (MIIDB). See 1 CCR 204-‐21.
Out-‐of-‐State and Interna4onal Drivers
Interstate Driver’s License Compact • The Interstate Driver’s License Compact, inc. at C.R.S. § 24-‐60-‐1101 et seq., which Colorado joined in 1965, governs interstate driving issues in Colorado, including: – Interstate, reciprocal driving restraints – See ArBcle V (new licenses); ArBcle III (exisBng); – Requirement that out-‐of-‐state convicBons (inc. criminal and administraBve violaBons) be reported to driver’s home (licensing) state – See ArBcles II(c), III; – The effect of out-‐of-‐state convicBons on the driver’s license – See ArBcle IV; including: • Offenses, including DUIs, where the home state is required to give effect to the foreign state’s law; • Other offenses in which the home state is required to determine if there is a corresponding, “substanBally similar,” offense under home-‐state law, and, if so, to treat the foreign offense as if it had occurred in the home state; and, – ProhibiBon on holding licenses in mulBple states – See ArBcle V; see also 24-‐60-‐1106. • Colorado’s implementaBon of the Compact: – For non-‐enumerated foreign offenses that require Colorado to find a corresponding offense, the DMV is prohibited from assessing points against the driver’s license – CRS 24-‐60-‐1105(2). • It is possible to request a hearing in order to argue that Colorado does not have a corresponding offense. License holds for foreign judgments are a common source of issues that a hearing can resolve. – For the more serious offenses where Colorado is required to give effect to the foreign state’s law, the implemenBng statute limits these to 42-‐2-‐128 (vehicular homicide), 42-‐2-‐1301 (DUI, DUI per se, DWAI), and 42-‐4-‐1603 (duty to give noBce/informaBon/aid in accident involving injury or death). – Colorado honors driver licenses issued by other compact members, unless the driver becomes a resident in Colorado, in which case the person must obtain a Colorado license. 24-‐60-‐1106. An excepBon is available if the person needs to retain an out-‐of-‐state license under the laws of another state in order to pracBce a regular trade or profession. Id. • Member States: All states except Georgia, Massachuseus, Michigan, Tennessee, and Wisconsin (source: AAMVA) • Procedures manual (1994) is available here: – hup://www.aamva.org/uploadedFiles/MainSite/Content/DriverLicensingIdenBficaBon/DL_ID_Compacts/DLC %20AdministraBve%20Procedures%20Manual.pdf
IDLC DMV Hearings • DMV regulaBons implemenBng the Compact are at 1 CCR 204-‐16 and govern procedures for issuing Colorado licenses to individuals under restraint in another member state. • Hearing Procedures: – File request for hearing to DMV Hearing SecBon. – DMV requests driver’s out-‐of-‐state record and analyzes the record, applying Colorado law. • Hearing Principles: – At hearing, applicant must show that: • At least one year has passed since out-‐of-‐state license was revoked or suspended; • Applicant has not driven since the restraint was imposed; and, • Applicant is now a Colorado resident. – Any evidence of driving following restraint will result in the applicant having to wait the longer of one year from the violaBon date or unBl one year aoer Colorado reinstatement eligibility, whichever is longer. – Otherwise, DMV bears burden of showing that the applicant is NOT eligible, based on its analysis of the out-‐of-‐state driving record. DMV will calculate the applicant’s reinstatement eligibility date based on Colorado law. – DMV is prohibited from issuing a PDL or other temporary license while the out-‐of-‐state triggered restraint remains in effect. – If the applicant obtains a reinstatement or clearance leuer from the foreign state, then he or she may apply for a Colorado license.
Non-‐Resident Violator Compact • Grew out of developments in the 1960s; current agreement originated in 1977; Colorado joined in January of 1982. Source: AAMVA. • The Compact facilitates the processing of traffic citaBons by enabling the 45 member states to process citaBons across borders. • Non payment of a citaBon in one member state will trigger an indefinite suspension in the driver’s home state pending resoluBon. • In the five non-‐member states – Alaska, California, Michigan, Montana, Oregon, and Wisconsin, a driver receiving a citaBon might have to either resolve the citaBon or post a bond before being allowed to “proceed.” Likewise, a driver licensed in a non-‐member state might be required to do the same in a member state. The bond may have to be paid roadside. • The Procedures Manual (1994) is available here: – www.aamva.org/uploadedFiles/MainSite/Content/DriverLicensingIdenBficaBon/DL_ID_Compacts/NRVC %20Procedures%20Manual.pdf
Na4onal Driver Register (NDR) • Administered by Nat. Highway TransportaBon Admin. and used by all 50 states to implement reciprocal obligaBons. • Contains informaBon on revocaBons, suspensions, and serious traffic violaBons, including DUI. • Each driver receives a status [www.nhtsa.gov/Data/NaBonal+Driver+Register+(NDR)]: – No Match: no record in NDR; – Licensed (LIC): holds valid, unrestrained license in state; – Eligible (ELG): eligible to apply (no restraint / no need to reinstate); – Not: not eligible to drive; or, – NEN: not eligible to drive on account of non-‐moving violaBon.” • “Problem Driver Pointer System” (PDPS) holds the following informaBon for ID purposes: – Full name and aliases; – DOB, License #, and SSN (if permiued by state law); – Sex, height, weight, eye color; and, – State of Record (the state that populated the database). – State of Record is required to update the NDR within 31 days of receiving a convicBon, revocaBon, suspension, or license denial. – Disputes about NDR data must be resolved with the State of Record.
Non-‐Resident Drivers Persons Exempted from Holding a Colorado License • Non-‐residents over 16 possessing a valid DL from another State. 42-‐1-‐102(62); 42-‐2-‐102. • AcBve-‐duty military personnel on assignment in Colorado and spouses. Id. • Non-‐resident students, so long as considered non-‐residents for tuiBon purposes. Id. • Once a person establishes Colorado residency, the person has 30 days to convert his or her DL to a Colorado license. Id. (And 90 days to register a vehicle.) And… • “The statutory bases for this rule are §§ 42-‐1-‐204 , 42-‐2-‐102(1)(c) , 42-‐1-‐102(62) , and 42-‐1-‐102(81) , CRS. The purpose of this rule is to include in the definiBon of "non-‐resident" under § 42-‐1-‐102(62) , those persons who are working on a temporary or seasonal basis with appropriate documenta4on from the United States Ci4zenship and Immigra4on Services, who do not have permanent resident status, and therefore shall not be considered to have "gainful employment" for the purposes of establishing residency. These non-‐residents shall be exempt from the requirement to obtain a Colorado driver's license under § 42-‐2-‐102(1)(c) , and shall not be considered to have "gainful employment" unless he or she otherwise meets the definiBon of resident by either conBnuously residing within the state for 90 days or more or by owning or operaBng a business in this state.” – 1 CCR 204-‐29 But… • Colorado law defines a “resident” as “any person who owns or operates any business in this state or any person who has resided within this state conBnuously for a period of ninety days or has obtained gainful employment within this state, whichever shall occur first.” 42-‐1-‐102(81).
Interna4onal License Reciprocity • Colorado has license reciprocity agreements with Canada, France, Germany, and South Korea, and applicants for a Colo. license who hold a license from these countries do not have to take the driving tests. Source: www.colorado.gov/pacific/dmv/new-‐colorado-‐another-‐ country – However, all such persons must apply under SB-‐251. • Persons from other countries, including those holding InternaBonal Driver’s Licenses (IDLs), must pass the wriuen and driving tests prior to applying for a Colorado license. – Test may be taken through a third-‐party vendor (i.e., an accredited driving school). – Rental cars may be used, unless the contract expressly forbids use in driving tests.
Driving under the Geneva Conven4on • USA is signatory to 1949 ConvenBon on Road Traffic, establishing reciprocity between member countries with recogniBon of member driver licenses for a period of at least one year. • The ConvicBon also creates the InternaBonal Driver’s License (IDL) valid for a period of up to one year: – Can only be applied for in the applicant’s home country. – Administered in U.S. by AAA. • In the U.S., state laws governing residency may separately require a foreign visitor to obtain a state driver’s license. • Foreign visitor can drive on foreign license for 90 days – however, keep in mind that employment in Colorado or operaBon of business could create residence much sooner than the 90 days.
You can also read