Caring Architecture - The Design of a New Building for Children and Adolescent Psychiatry in Gothenburg - Chalmers Publication Library
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
Caring Architecture - The Design of a New Building for Children and Adolescent Psychiatry in Gothenburg Master Thesis Chalmers Shool of Architecture Anita Mustonen Examiner: Peter Fröst Tutor: Christine Hammarling
Caring Architecture - The Design of a New Building for Children and Adolescent Psychiatry in Gothenburg Anita Mustonen Examiner: Peter Fröst Tutor: Christine Hammarling Master Thesis Chalmers School of Architecture Department of Architecture and Civil Engineering Architecture and Urban Design, MPARC June 2017
Caring Architecture - The Design of a New Building for Children and Adolescent Psychiatry in Östra Sjukhuset in Gothenburg Anita Mustonen © Anita Mustonen 2017 Chalmers School of Architecture Department of Architecture and Civil Engineering 412 96 Göteborg Sweden Cover: Illustration of a patient room Göteborg 2017
Abstract The number of children and adolescents in Sweden that forming the program and have given input to the sketch are admi ed to a hospital for psychiatric care have been proposal in the process. increasing for the past 20 years. Meanwhile, the children The concept for the building is to work with places for and youth psychiatry in Östra Sjukhuset in Gothenburg has different levels of engagement with your surroundings. too small and dysfunc onal locali es. This Master Thesis is The building should allow for pa ents to sit alone, sit on about the design of a new building for them. the side of an ac vity and look at what’s happening or to Väs as gheter has ini ated the process for a new building take part in the ac vity. This have been achieved through for children and adolescent psychiatry, and this project has designing the building so that you can sit in a private place run parallel of the pre-study in that process. The building and watch things that happen elsewhere in the building, will contain both inpa ent and outpa ent care, as well as divide the pa ents into small groups, and have different administra on and staff areas. sizes of dayrooms to choose between. A theore cal framework for the design has been made by Through this project I want to give an example of how searching literature and analyzing case studies. During the to design a healthcare facility for children that supports process, there has been mee ngs with people working with their healing process. Hopefully some of the ideas from children and adolescent psychiatry in Östra Sjukhuset where my design will s ck with the staff group I’ve met with and they have told about their wishes and I have presented inspire them in the process for a new building. and discussed my sketches. Those mee ngs have helped in
My thanks During this semester there are many people that have helped and supported me in different ways, and I would like to send a big thank you to the following: My tutor Chris ne Hammarling for helping me in my process, coming with valuable input and poin ng at things I’ve either forgo en, or chosen not to see. My examinor Peter Fröst, for valid comments in the seminars and for always answering quickly if I had ques ons. Erik Tari and Henrik Hagejärd for all the comments, smalltalk and input during the project, and for always pu ng up with me when I took a break from my project by disturbing you. The group for the pre-study at BUP Östra Sjukhuset; Reino Moberg, Kenneth Bergersson, Marie Carlsson, Camilla Ersdal and Suzanne Ågård, for all the input from the mee ngs and for being engaged and posi ve about my work. Saga Karlsson and Stefan Lundin for good comments on the final seminar. The comments where truly inspiring for me and they (almost) made me want to work another semester on the project. Erik Hedborg for good comments on the mid-term seminar, and interes ng discussions during the process. Håkan Sigurdsson for a very interes ng discussion at Universeum that I have though about throughout the project. Philip Rasko for being there when I came home from school and wanted to think about something else, and for understanding how demanding a master thesis process is. My family for always asking me how it is going, believing in me and congratula ng me on progress. And finally, all the students in my corridor for good input and for bearing with me when I asked about your projects. Anita Mustonen June 2017
Content Introduction Design proposal Background 6 The program 42 Purpose and aim 6 The site 44 Research ques on 7 Building form - step by step 46 Method 8 Site plan 48 Reading instruc on 9 Departments in BUP 50 Terms 9 Arrangement of departments 51 Groundfloor (floor 0) 52 Theory Floor 1 54 A healing environment? 10 Floor 2 56 Evidence-based design 11 Emergency department 58 Design for psychiatry 12 Wai ng areas 59 Design for children and adolescents 14 Ward unit 62 Stages of development 15 Pa ent room 64 Summary: theory 18 Ac vity square 66 Case studies Sec ons 68 Psychiatry Östra sjukhuset 20 Facade 70 Psykiatrins hus 24 Conclusion Slagelse psykiatri 28 Conclusion 72 Sofieskolen 32 Reflec on 72 Summary: case studies 34 References Östra Sjukhuset References 74 Östra sjukhuset 36 List of figures 76 The buildings 38 Traffic and flows 39 visions for the future 40 BUP in Östra sjukhuset 41 5
Introduction Background Purpose and aim In Sweden today mental illness is considered one of the The aim with this project is to design a new building for biggest health issues (Socialstyrelsen 2016). The number Children and Youth Psychiatry where all of its departments of children that are submi ed to psychiatric care for can exist in the same building at Östra Sjukhuset in depression has increased during the last 30 years and the Gothenburg. Focus is on designing an environment where number of pa ents in children and adolescence outpa ent children and their rela ves can feel safe and get recover care has increased since 2005 (Cederblad 2013). While from illness. mental illness is increasing, the s gma around it is s ll very The purpose with this is to show an example of how to present. Even though three quarters of the popula on create a healing environment for children and adolescents are es mated to be in close contact with mental illness in in the need of psychiatric care. Another purpose with some way, people are s ll scared to talk about it and the this project is to give the staff at BUP Östra Sjukhuset an care is worse than for many other diseases (Riksförbundet alterna ve project to the one that is being developed in a Hjärnkoll). pre-study for a new building for them. To give psychiatric care a natural and worthy place in our hospitals might contribute to encourage people to seek care, and make them feel like they are accepted in the society. BUP Östra Sjukhuset Children and Youth Psychiatry (Barn och Ungdomspsykiatri [BUP]) at Sahlgrenska University Hospital in Gothenburg have two departments in Östra Sjukhuset and three departments on other loca ons in the city. The facili es in Östra Sjukhuset are too small and not designed to suit today’s ideas for psychiatric care, and collabora on between the departments in the hospital site and the other departments is difficult since there is such a distance between them. 6
Introduction Research question Main question How can we design healing environments for children and adolescents in psychiatric care? Sub-questions How can a new building look like that will be added to the exis ng structure of a modernist hospital? Delimitations Focus in the design proposal will be on the areas for the pa ents. Areas for staff will be designed in an overview scale, but will not be studied more thoroughly. The design project focuses on the built part of the facility and will not go deep into furniture or equipment. The construc on will be studied just briefly to see how it affects the building, but for some details that are of interest for the design. Regarding the outdoor areas some ideas will be shown, but not drawn in detail. 7
Introduction Method Dialogue Case studies This project runs parallel to a To find examples of how to achieve certain quali es pre-study for a new building for BUP and learn more about how to design for psychiatry I have in Östra Sjukhuset. This has made looked at some case studies. Four of them are presented in it possible for me to par cipate in the report, chosen because they have interes ng elements mee ngs with representa ves from BUP, a representa ve that I’ve implemented in some way in the design. from Väs as gheter, and an architect making the pre- I have used case studies as a way to get more knowledge study. The first of these mee ngs where mainly about about the program for a building for psychiatric care as well forming the program for the building and learning what as a reference for room sizes and placement of func ons. the departments wanted. Later on I had the opportunity to present and discuss my sketches with the staff group, and Sketching to adapt my design a er their comments. Throughout the project I have used sketching as a tool, both by hand Literature study and digital sketches using Revit. The My literature study will include sketching has been a way to take reading about evidence based the process forward and to create a base for discussing design, healthcare architecture, my project with others. The sketching have influenced psychiatry in general and children and adolescents my search for literature in the way that I’ve tried to find psychiatry, as well as some about children’s development. literature about things I wasn’t sure how to design. The sources have been found using mainly Chalmers Library’s tool Summon, with some use of Google Scholar to find sources that are referenced in reports I’ve read that couldn’t be found in Summon. The references include books, printed reports, digital reports, scien fic ar cles, newspaper ar cles and websites. 8
Introduction Reading instruction Terms Children and adolescents psychiatry Psychiatric care for everyone below the age of 18. The abbrevia on BUP (Barn och Ungdomspsykiatri) will be used in the report. Theory Oupatient care Healthcare that does not require the pa ent to stay Design proposal overnight. Case studies Inpatient care Analysis Healthcare where the pa ent is admi ed to the hospital Östra Sjukhuset and stay overnight. The report is divided in two main parts. One which explains the theore cal framework on which the design proposal is based and one that present the design proposal. The theore cal part is divided in three parts; a summary of the literature study, a presenta on of four case studies and a presenta on of Östra Sjukhuset. Each part of the report can be read separately, but preferably it’s read from cover to cover. In the end of each of the first three part is a summary that sums up important elements that will be used in the design. 9
Theory A healing environment? “ A very brief search of the websites of some Swedish and Danish architecture firms that do healthcare Experiences and new research Experienc buildings, show that it is obvious that the term “healing environment” is a bit of a buzz word in Scandinavia today. show how a stro strong connec on between “ In many of the project descrip ons for new healthcare the physical healthcare environment buildings, and most of the new buildings for psychiatry, and the wellbeing and recovery of the term healing environment or some equivalent to that was used, o en in combina on with health promo on and the pa ents. - Quote from White Architects’ descrip on of the new pa ent centered care. psychiatry building in Södra Älvsborgs Sjukhus. ukhus. khus. Translated Healing environment can mean many things. In evidence from Swedish based design it is about the things we can measure and put numbers on, in a salutogenic approach it is about crea ng an environment that is easy to read and orientate in, as well as being aesthe cally pleasant. In the anthology Architecture as Medicine (From, L. Lundin, S. “ “ 2009) Lena Walther states in the chapter Six li le houses (pp 21-32) that a healing environment should, among other things, contain s mula on of all senses, have a connec on to nature, minimize stress factors, have sufficient work spaces, include spaces for spiritual issues, (...) the building b should provide the show a variated architecture and display art in some form. materiali l condi ons for a dignifi gnified Most of these factors have evidence that they actually do affect healthcare outcomes, these will be treated in the and healing environment(...) ...) - Quote from Liljewalls Architects’ descrip p on of Rågården, Rågården paragraph about evidence-based design. Stefan Lundin a new building for forensic psychaitric care in Gothenburg. discuss the term healing architecture in his licen ate thesis Translated from Swedish Evidence, Intui on, Dialogue (Lundin, S. 2015) and argues that it cannot be based solely on evidence, since there i not enough to be fount, but that the architect must use his/ hers intui on, meaning more or less concious knowledge “ “ that has been developed over me. The dialogue with the client is also important in achieving a healing environment, since it is the client that knows the func onality of the care the best. The suppo suppor ng ideas in thehee project are ((...)) Healing H architecture re (..) ( - Quote from Karlsson Arkitekter’s descrip p on of the new psychiatric hospital in Slagelse. Translated from f Danish ih 10
Theory Evidence-based design Evidence-based design [EBD] in healthcare is about making informed decisions in the design process. The evidence in the design comes from research and studies that have found rela ons between certain design elements and healthcare outcomes. In the paper A Review of the Research Literature on Evidence-Based Healthcare Design (Ulrich, 2008) Ulrich et al. iden fy eleven elements of which there are evidence that they affect the outcomes of healthcare. Some of Single pa ent rooms compared to having shared rooms these, like ceiling li s and noise-reducing finishes might be can increase pa ent sa sfac on, increase pa ent privacy, too specific to apply to this project, but many of the others improve pa ents’ sleep and reduce pa ents’ stress. are of hight relevance. Single bed rooms and access to daylight improve pa ent sleep, reduce pa ent stress and increase the pa ent sa sfac on, and a view of nature can reduce stress and depression as well as the me the pa ent spend in the hospital (Ulrich 2008). The Center for Healthcare Architecture [CVA] at Chalmers published a paper called Evidensbas för vårdens arkitektur 1.0 (Evidence-base for healthcare architecture 1.0) wri en by Roger Ulrich. In this report eight areas on which there are evidence for how architecture affect outcomes are iden fied. Those are single-pa ent rooms, pa ent safety, Access to daylight and views to nature both have the daylight, working environment, way-finding, posi ve effect that they can reduce the length of stay for pa ents, distrac ons, sound-environment and a rac veness. reduce pa ent stress, improve pa ents’ sleep and reduce depression. Posi ve distrac ons such as nature and art, as well as an a rac ve environment in general have been shown to increase pa ent sa sfac on with the care given, and reduce anxiety. 11
Theory Design for psychiatry When designing for psychiatry there are many things to think about. The pa ents can have a distorted view on reality, need a lot of personal space, want to withdraw and be alone or need social training to adapt to the world outside the hospital. Golembiewski (2010) states that a sence of coherence [SOC] is essen al when designing for psychiatric care. SOC can be achieved from working with comprehensibility, meaning that the building should be easy to read and understand; manageability, giving the pa ents chans to influence his/hers surroundings; and meaningfulness, which might be reached through an aesthe cally pleasing environment and sufficient space for visitors to enhance the social support for the pa ent. Golembiewsky (2010) also recommends using natural materials and trying to create homelike environments so the pa ents feel that they are in a familiar place. A study conducted in a psychiatric ward by Beauchemin and Hays (1996) show that pa ents that stayed in a room that got direct sunlight during part of the day had in average a 13% shorter stay than pa ents in rooms that lay in shadow all day. 12
Theory Gradients of engagement The suppor ng triangle describes the different levels of ac vi es that a person can take part in depending on his or hers state of well-being (Bengtsson & Grahn 2014). In a healthcare project this can be used as guidelines for High well-being what kind of places to create in the building. Outward-directed Activating and stimulating In the pa ent room the inward-directed engagement could engagement surroundings take place in the bed, but also on a bench by the window with a view to the nature outside, or by a desk where Active Activating surroundings handicra s or other alone ac vi es can take place. There engagement can also be emo onal engagement to the surroundings by looking up at what happens outside or open the door to Emotional Active but not demanding the corridor and listen to the life in the department. Ac ve engagement surroundings engagement can be to work at the desk or talk to someone in the sofa. Inward-directed Calm and private In the common areas of the ward there will also be engagement surroundings places for different levels of engagement. Places to sit Low well-being alone in the garden, a winter garden, ac vity rooms and areas for hanging out with each other. Figure 1. The suppor ng triangle. (Bengtsson & Grahn 2014) Patient room Corridor Day room Activity room Inwards directed engagement Outwards directed engagement Figure 2. Sec on illustra ng how the gradient can look like in a building. Made by the author 13
Theory Design for children and adolescents As childhood is a period of great developments for a person children of different ages have very different needs. Younger children are more dependent on their parents while teenagers might want to be more independent and regarded as adults. During a visit to Universeum, a science center for children and adults in Gothenburg, I had a discussion with Håkan Sigurdsson, scien fic leader and project manager at Universeum. We discussed the differences between different ages. Small children can some mes be very focused for a quite long me, but then suddenly they get bored and need something else to do, otherwise they might start running around making noise or playing with trashcans. When discussing how to work with teenagers Håkan said that teenagers want to be met as adults so if you design for adults, teenagers most o en like it be er than if you try to direct the design specifically to them. Universeum has recently changed their target group according to this, earlier it was Children and Youth, now it’s Children and Adults, since teenagers are best met by being met as adults. Håkan said that it is not easy to try to figure out before hand what children might like. Universeum had an exhibi on when I was there about health where the most popular part was to see how long you could hang from a bar, a very simple and cheap thing to build, but much more liked than more complicated stands. Håkan talked about the teenage years as being difficult since a teenager is s ll in many aspects a child but wants to be an adult, but it’s good to try to encourage the childish sides some mes. He had an example of an area where you could build large structures using different forms of building blocks that was very popular among teenagers, as long as they where first to the site. If the area was occupied by seven-year-olds the teenagers wouldn’t play there in fear of appearing childish, the same would happen if there would be older children in the room. To build things and manipulate their surroundings in a no ceable way seems to be fascina ng to children of all ages, including those well past the age of 18. 14
Theory Stages of development Children of different ages have very different needs and since children of all ages come to BUP the facility must fit all their needs. Following development stages are based on Piaget’s theory of cogni ve development as it is presented in Maria Nordström’s research report ”Barns boendeföreställningar i e utvecklingspsykologiskt perspek v” (Nordström, 1990) and a slideshow from a lecture held by Helena Fagerberg Moss in the Centre for Healthcare Architecture’s theme day “Liten blir stor - om barnets utveckling och behov” (Fagerberg Moss, 2014). Age 0 - 1,5 Experience the world with all senses Object constancy Dependent on parents Forming bonds with people Trust Architectural challenges: Engage all senses Create interes ng views on crawling level Age 1,5 - 4 Rapid development Develop a language Own will Vivid imagina on Pretend play Rooms are defined by what happens there Architectural challenges: Something to do while wai ng S mulate imagina on 15
Theory Age 4-7 Concrete thinking Ques oning Rooms are defined by what you can do there Understanding of inside/outside Finding an iden ty Architectural challenges: S mulate crea vity Allow for play Age 7 - 12 Internalized ac ons Logic thinking Analyzing Understand how spaces relate to each other Social Awareness of other’s perspec ves Architectural challenges: Easily readable structure Places for play, places for thinking Age 12+ Abstract thinking Awareness of own thinking Rela onship to parents change Architectural challenges: Create a feeling of dignity Avoid childish environments, wants to iden fy more with adults 16
Theory Creating a daily life In daily life children move between different places. They wake up at home, go to school, then maybe some leisure ac vi es or a friends house and then home again School (Rasmussen 2004). When a child is in a hospital though, this part of everyday life easily gets lost since everything is in the same building. To get to school you go through a corridor, iden cal to the one where your room is, and same thing when you get to some kind of ac vity. This could be avoided if each part gets its own expression and if the Home Friend’s home borders between different parts are clear. In the building there will be an ac vity square which should have access to the outdoors, and be easily available both for people visi ng the outpa ent departments as well as the pa ents staying in the wards. The wards should feel more like a home than a hospital, without long corridors, and with several spaces to move Leisure activities freely between. To make it feel safe there should be a good overview over the ward, but without elimina ng places to withdraw and sit alone. The school should be placed so that it is possible to Places for children have a small schoolyard for it, and that the pa ents can Rasmussen (2004) argues that there is a difference go out of the main door, and enter somewhere else to get between places for children, e g places that adults have into the school. This is important as it gives the pa ent a designed for children, and children’s places, meaning small break from being in the hospital, and it makes the places that children make their own. An example of a place school feel like something different than the rest of the for children could be a playground, while a child’s place departments. might be a tree that is good for climbing (Rasmussen 2004). Rasmussen argues that “a place, including ‘places for children’, becomes a ‘childrens place’ a er a child connects with it physically”(p 165). To enhance the possibility that children will make a place theirs the text takes up two criteria that can be used; to invite to movement and to allow for changing the environment in some way, like building structures or pu ng up pictures. In a hospital se ng the child’s choice of place is limited and all places around him/her are designed by adults. Therefore it is very important to try to design places that children can connect to in a hospital se ng. 17
Theory Summary: Theory Following illustra ons show elements and ideas picked up in the literature study that will be incorporated in the design. Single pa ent rooms Pa ent rooms should face south or east N W E S Pa ent rooms should have windows towards nature with greenery Make good use of daylight in the building 18
Theory Dayroom Dayroom Groups of 3-5 pa ents around a small dayroom 1 pat. 1 pat. 1 pat. 1 pat. 1 pat. 1 pat. 1 pat. 1 pat. TV/ Groups of 6-10 pa ents make a ward that share a Team Dining Kitchen Dayroom bigger dayroom, dining and kitchen Work with posi ve distrac ons such as nature views and art Create places where pa ents can sit and watch ac vi es without taking part Create places that the pa ent can make their own in some way, like building structures, changing colors or pu ng up photos and drawings. 19
Case studies Psychiatry Östra sjukhuset Figure 3. The psychiatric clinic at Östra Sjukhuset Photo taken by the author Facts Loca on: Göteborg, Sweden Year: opened in 2009 Architect: White Area: 18800 m2 Pa ent rooms: 120 The building for psychiatry in Östra Sjukhuset in Gothenburg has been awarded with the Healthcare Building Prize 2007. It is designed with the pa ent in focus with small pa ent groups, good daylight in all pa ent rooms, atriums in the common areas and easy access to an enclosed yard. There are lots of wooden materials in the building and the yards are full of green plants. It is a low building, 2-4 floors to keep the connec on to nature for all wards. Figure 4. Atrium in the ward unit (White Architects) 20
Case studies 3 2 4 5 5 4 1 6 7 3 3 3 1 Café 2 Kitchen 3 Care unit 4 Teaching facilities Figure 5. Floor plan over the wards 5 Occupational therapy, training (From, Lundin 2009) 6 Drug evaluation 7 Contemplation room Building layout The entrance for the building is in the north-west corner. Along the east side in the first two floors are the emergency department, floor 3-5 are wards, administra on and different kinds of therapy rooms. The wards are placed along the south and eastern facade, and together with a slim volume towards north they enclose three big yards that the pa ents have access to. Figure 6. Yard in the psychiatric clinic (White Architects) 21
Case studies Patient unit Patientroom Dayroom Activity room Dining Kitchen Atrium/yard/balcony Conversation room Nurse station Conference room Staff room Serving functions Figure 7. Illustra on of the ward layout Ward layout The wards are arranged in departments of 14 pa ents, which are then divided into smaller groups of three to five pa ents that share a small dayroom. The pa ent rooms are arranged around a “heart” to minimize the corridors and give a central point to the department. In this “heart” is a nurse sta on, dining area with kitchen, a bigger dayroom and an ac vity room. From the common areas the pa ents can reach an enclosed yard. 22
Case studies Figure 8. Small day room in the ward unit (White Architects) My inspiration from this The main idea from this project that I will take into mine is to work with different steps of social engagement in the building. The pa ent can sit alone in his/her room, but with an open door look at what happens in the common areas, or look at the yard through the window. The next step is the day room shared by four pa ents, and from that you can advance into the big common area, or even into the yard that is shared by several units. I also like how they have worked with light and that many pa ent rooms have light from two direc ons. The small atrium in the common areas is a good way to bring light into a quite thick building. 23
Case studies Psykiatrins hus Figure 9. Main entrance to Psykiatrins hus. (Åke E:son Lindman) Facts Loca on: Uppsala, Sweden Year: opened in 2013 Architect: Tengbom Area: 33 000 m2 Pa ent rooms: 104 Psykiatrins hus, the new building for psychiatry in the hospital in Uppsala has been praised by architects and cri cized by pa ents. The posi ve comments mean that the glazed building will break the s gma around psychiatric illness (Tengbom), while cri c pa ents say that the glazing makes you too visible in the building and that the buidling is cold and impersonal( Uppsala Nya Tidning, 2013). The main idea is pa ent centered care and to break the s gma around psychiatric care through making an open building. The entrance hall is a high open atrium with water mirrors, a library open for the public and some sea ng. From the atrium you can reach the rest of the floor where the care facili es are. Figure 10. Main entrance to Psykiatrins hus. (Åke E:son Lindman) 24
Case studies Figure 11. Floor plan from the compe on proposal by Tengbom Architects (Tengbom Architects) Building layout Each floor contains both outpa ent and inpa ent areas, as well as staff administra on an pause areas. The administra on is gathered in the middle of the building towards the atria, while pa ent rooms and exam rooms are along the outer facades. In the outpa ent care the pa ent waits in a wai ng area with big windows, and the counseling rooms are placed between two corridors to give them doors from two ways to eliminate the risk of staff being cut off from the exit. Wai ng areas are placed along the facade in a long space which gives the pa ents possibility to choose to sit away from others, but s ll by a window. Figure 12. A view of the buidling showing the balconies in the pa ent rooms (Åke E:son Lindman) 25
Case studies Patient unit Patientroom Dayroom Activity room Dining Kitchen Atrium/yard/balcony Conversation room Nurse station Conference room Staff room Serving functions Figure 13. Illustra on of the ward layout Ward layout In the wards the pa ent rooms are arranged along the facade over a corner, with a nurse sta on placed in the corner for good overview. The common areas and conversa on rooms are mainly placed with windows to the atria. Since this building is high there is no possibility to get access to a courtyard form the ward, but each pa ent room has a small private balcony to give them some form of outdoor area. 26
Case studies Figure 14. The main atrium in psykiatrins hus (Åke E:son Lindman) My inspiration from this From this project I take inspira on from the idea of having both inpa ent and outpa ent care on each floor, but in different parts of the building. The team sta on is centrally placed with good overview and the pa ent rooms are directed out from the building. To give some counseling rooms two doors provide be er security for staff since they can’t be blocked from the exit by aggressive pa ents. 27
Case studies Slagelse psykiatri Figure 15. Slagelse Psykiatrisygehus (Architectural Review) Facts Loca on: Slagelse, Denmark Year: Opened in 2015 Architect: Karlsson Architects and Vilhelm Lauritzen Architects Area: 44 000 m2 Pa ent rooms: 194 The psychiatric hospital in Slagelse is a result of a compe on which Karlsson Architects won with the proposal “The park in the house, the house in the park” (Parken i huset - huset i parken). The building is one of the first new psychiatric hospitals in an extensive work on improving buildings for psychiatric care in Denmark (Godt Sygehusbyggeri, 2017). Focus in the project where to design healing environments for psychiatric care by working with a low scale, a well-worked concept for natural and ar ficial light and a care for materials and details (Karlsson Arkitekter). Figure 16. Atrium by the main entrance Source: h p://www.karlssonark.com/nyt-psykiatrisygehus-i-slagelse/ 28
Case studies Figure 17. Structural plan for the psychiatric hospital in Slagelse (Karlsson Arkitekter) Building layout The outpa ent care and administra on are gathered in a high building in the north, and south of them the wards stretch out into the park in a one floor building. There are many courtyards of different forms, either open or closed, for watching, for being in and to let light into the building. Figure 18. Floor plan for pa ent rooms (Karlsson Arkitekter) 29
Case studies Patientroom Dayroom Activity room Dining Kitchen Atrium/yard/balcony Conversation room Nurse station Conference room Staff room Serving functions Figure 19. Illustra on of the ward layout Ward layout Each ward consists of 17 pa ent rooms arranged around a small courtyard. The pa ent rooms all face a courtyard on one side, and a glazed corridor along the small courtyard on the other. This give all pa ent rooms very good daylight condi ons, as well as an interes ng view through the door to the pa ent room. The staff areas are gathered by the entrance to the ward, by the dining area for pa ents. Because of the yard the staff have a very good overview over the whole department. 30
Case studies Figure 20. Yard between the ward units (Architectural Review) My inspiration from this Slagelse psychiatric hospital had great condi ons with the big site and surrounding nature and the architects managed to take care of this and make a small scale building with good contact to nature. When looking from the pa ent room out through the door the pa ent look through a glazed corridor into a common yard. To give the pa ent a view through the pa ent door allow for him/her to stay in a safe and private place but s ll see things happening outside. This project show an example of how to give the staff good overview by placing a glazed yard in the middle of the department. 31
Case studies Sofieskolen Figure 21. Render of Sofieskolen (Archdaily) Facts Loca on: Ballerup, Denmark Year: planned opening 2018 Architect: Creo Arkitekter & JAJA architects Sofieskolen is a home for children with au sm. It’s built to be a building that feels like a home and not an ins tu on, with small groups of dwellings gathered around a living room. It is low scale with only two floors. The upper floor is Figure 23. Render of corridor withdrawn towards the neighboring forest to make the Source: archdaily.com h p://www.archdaily.com/784811/creo-and-jaja- scale even lower towards nature. to-design-home-for-children-with-au sm-near-copenhagen Figure 22. Sec on of the common areas (Archdaily) 32
Case studies Figure 24. Exploded sketch of the building (Archdaily) My inspiration from this What I like with this building is the low scale and the broken up volume that brings the nature into the building. Place built furniture made of wood that works both for storage and sea ng make corridors and common areas feel though ul and welcoming. The smaller groups of dwellings around an open living room is an element that has been used in other psychiatry buildings as well and might be a way to make the building feel less like an ins tu on. 33
Case studies Summary: Case studies Following illustra ons show quali es picked up from the case studies which are incorporated in the design proposal. A small atrium in the ward brings daylight and greenery into the building Get daylight from two direc ons in the pa ent room Create a good overview for the staff 34
Case studies Make conversa on rooms with double exits to eliminate the risk for staff of being cut off from the exit Give the corridors access to daylight; place them either towards or along windows Give the pa ent a view through the open door. The door should not face straight into a wall. Weave nature into the building 35
Östra Sjukhuset - The hospital area and the situation today Östra sjukhuset 5 km Östra Sjukhuset is part of Sahlgrenska University Hospital 3 km [SUH] in Gothenburg. SUH also consists of the Sahlgrenska hospital area, Mölndals Sjukhus and Högsbo Sjukhus. Östra Sjukhuset is situated east of the city centre in Östra Sjukhuset Gothenburg and can be reached with tram, bus, car and by Central foot/bike. Station Typology Östra Sjukhuset has a very orthogonal layout of the building. With a few excep ons, all lines run straight along south-north or east-west. This layout very much follows the urban planning ideas of the me when the hospital was built. Figure 25. Östra Sjukhuset in Gothenburg Illustra on by the author Figure 26. Le : Main entrance to the hospital with the central clinic towering above Figure 27. Top right: The central clinic Figure 28. Bo om right: The children’s clinic. Photos taken by the author 36
Östra Sjukhuset MC SH IK 1970 KK CK 1968 PK 1978 2007 BK 1973 NBS 2020 2004 BUP 1988 R McD Hus 1999 37
Östra Sjukhuset The buildings The first part of Östra sjukhuset, the womens clinic (KK), was finished in 1968, then infec on (IK), the children’s clinic (BK) and the central clinic (CK) followed in the next 10 years. The two buildings in the north, marked SH and MC are service buildings for the hospital. In 1988 the first addi on to the hospital since CK was done, a building for Children and youth psychiatry (BUP). In 2004 the children clinic got an addi on and in 2007 the Figure 29. The high, modernis c buildings new building for adult psychiatric care (PK) was finished. (Göteborgsposten 2016) The next big building project in the area is the new building for Dro ning Silvia’s Children´s Hospital (NBS) that will welcome it’s first pa ents in 2020 (Västra Götalandsregionen 2011). All the buildings built between 1968 and 1978 have a cohesive look; the higher buildings have facades of concrete elements with exposed aggregate and window ribbons, and the lower are clad with green glass, also with window ribbons. The building for BUP is similar to the rest, with window ribbons, but clad with a board material, and overall with a less permanent look to it, with less aten on taken to detailing like day water management and how the wall ends in the top. Figure 30. The psychiatric clinic at Östra Sjukhuset Photo taken by the author PK s cks out with it’s white plaster facade and varied window placements. MC SH IK BK KK CK PK CK PK KK BK IK SH MC Figure 31. Views over Östra Sjukhuset (Västra Götalandsregionen 2011) 38
Östra Sjukhuset Traffic and flows P Cars are allowed into the hospital area to reach the entrances to the departments. There are parking areas at the edges of the hospital area, mainly in north-west and P south-east. There is a big stop for trams and buses at the north-west corner of the hospital area, and a bus stop east of the hospital. Goods come to the hospital via the building SH in the north, and are distributed to the hospital through a culvert system. The entrances to the buildings are marked with a white P concrete column with a sign saying which building it is. Most of them have a canopy to protect from the weather. P P Cars Cars with permission Figure 32. Main entrance to Östra Sjukhuset. Photo taken by the author Tram stop Bus stop Goods access Parking P Figure 35. Traffic flows in Östra Sjukhuset Figure 33. Entrance to the children’s hospital. Illustra on by the author Photo taken by the author Figure 34. Entrance to the psychiatric clinic. Photo taken by the author 39
Östra Sjukhuset Visions for the future The buildings in Östra Sjukhuset are star ng to get outdated andthey need to be refurbished and 2 complemented by new buildings. The first step in the development is the new children’s 3 hospital that are being built now, next is an addi on to the 1 women’s clinic and the new building for BUP. Buildings that are further into the future are an addi on to the central clinic and the exis ng children’s clinic, and a new service building north of the hospital. If we move even further into the future the hospital have Figure 37. Östra sjukhuset ca 2025 expanded with even more buildings, mostly towards west (Västra Götalandsregionen) and north. 3 1 2 Figure 38. Östra Sjukhuset 2030, with an addi on the central clinic (1), an addi on to the children’s clinic (2) and a new service building (3) in the north. (Västra Götalandsregionen) Figure 39. A vision for how the hospital area might develop in the future Figure 36. Vision for future expansion of Östra Sjukhuset with many new buildings and a high tech area in the middle of the hospital (Västra Götalandsregionen) (Västra Götalandsregionen) 40
Östra Sjukhuset BUP in Östra sjukhuset Children and youth psychiatry [BUP] in Östra Sjukhuset includes an emergency department, a clinic for ea ng disorders with both inpa ent and outpa ent care, a psychiatry ward and outpa ent care. In another site there ismore inpa ent care, and collabora on with them is very hard. BUP has its own hospital school for the children that get admi ed to the wards or children that for different reasons can not go to a regular school for a while. The patient The pa ent group for BUP range from 0-18 years (0-25 in the department for ea ng disorders). Most of the pa ents in the inpa ent care are of the age of 12 and up, mainly in the age of 16-17, while the younger pa ents are found only in the outpa ent care. BUP The building The building was built in 1988 and is referred to as a temporary structure made of wood in Byggnadsplan 2011, BUP in Östra Sjukhuset a document with plans for the hospital, this can be seen as the building doesn’t have the a en on to detailing that the other buildings in the area have. It is placed in connec on to the children’s hospital in the south end of the hospital area. The departments that are in the building have outgrown it, and in the future they want to bring in the departments that are now located elsewhere, thus there is a big need for larger locali es. Figure 40. The low building to the le is the building for BUP in Östra Figure 41. Main entrance to BUP Sjukhuset today. Photo taken by the author Photo taken by the author 41
Design proposal Design proposal The program BUP today has a great need for expansion as it is today, Building gross area*: 8000 m2 and with the popula on increasing the need will only grow bigger. The new building will contain three different outpa ent Effective care area**: 4000 m2 departments, a day ward department and five ward units. The program I received from the group of representa ves Patient rooms: 38 from BUP included many rooms with office and counseling combined in the same room. With new visions for how the administra ve workplaces in a hospital should look like and Patient rooms/ward: 8 (1 ward with 6) the idea to meet the pa ent on equal terms in a neutral counseling room, I have decided to work more with open Utility area***/ward: 535 m2 administra on areas and dedicated counseling rooms. This allows for the staff to choose between different kinds of rooms depending on the situa on. Utility area ward/patient: 67 m2 I have chosen to take away ac vity spaces from each department and gather them in an “ac vity square” *Building gross area is the buildings total area, exterior in the center of the building so they can be used by all walls included. departments. **Effec ve care area is the area for all rooms, without communica on and technical rooms. *** U lity area is the total area without exterior walls 42
Design proposal Entrance and conference Specialist outpatient care Eating disorders Staff pause 15 m2 Coat room 20 m2 Outpatient care WC 3 m2 WC 3 m2 Staff pause 15 m2 RWC 5 m2 RWC 5 m2 Print/storage 5 m2 WC 3 m2 Office 10 m2 RWC 5 m2 Office 10 m2 Reception 20 m2 Print/storage 5 m2 Silent room 5 m2 Conference mingle 30 m2 Office 10 m2 Admin desk 5 m2 Silent room 5 m2 Conference 25 p 45 m2 Waiting 30 m2 Admin desk 5 m2 Conference 12 p 25m2 Team 10 m2 Waiting 30 m2 Conference 8 p 15 m2 Storage 10 m2 Team 10 m2 Disinfection 5 m2 Administration/staff Relatives 15 m2 Storage 10 m2 Staff room 60 m2 Exam room 10 m2 Disinfection 5 m2 Print/storage 5 m2 Relatives 15 m2 Counseling 10 m2 Office 10 m2 Weighing 7 m2 Changing rooms 45 m2 Emergency department Exam room 10 m2 Staff pause 15 m2 Counseling 10 m2 Reception 20 m2 On-call room 15 m2 School Office 10 m2 WC 3 m2 Eating disorders RWC 5 m2 Print/storage 5 m2 Day ward RWC 5 m2 Office 10 m2 Office 10 m2 Classrom 8 p 25m2 Silent room 5 m2 WC 3 m2 Conference 6 p 15 m2 Admin desk 5 m2 Kitchen chef 20 m2 Wait/play 15 m2 Training kitchen 15 m2 Storage 6 p 15 m2 Waiting 30 m2 Dining 15 m2 Team 10 m2 Activity square Dayroom 25 m2 Office 15 m2 Storage 10 m2 Disinfection 5 m2 WC 3 m2 RWC 5 m2 Relatives 15 m2 Creativity 25 m2 Exam room 10 m2 Lounge 10 m2 Counseling 10 m2 Music 10 m2 Senses 10 m2 Big room 45 m2 Winter garden 60/30 m2 Ward 8 patients Team 15 m2 Meeting 20 m2 Kitchen 10 m2 Storage 10 m2 Small dayroom 10 m2 Dayroom 35 m2 Dining 15 m2 Patient room 17 m2 Patient WC/S 5 m2 Ward 6 patients Team 15 m2 Meeting 20 m2 Kitchen 10 m2 Storage 10 m2 Small dayroom 10 m2 Dayroom 35 m2 Dining 15 m2 Patient room 17 m2 Patient WC/S 5 m2 Dayroom 1 p 20 m2 43
Design proposal The site The site is situated in the eastern side of the hospital area, south of the adult psychiatric clinic. On the site today is a parking deck that is old and will be demolished and the parking spaces replaced on another site. The topography of the site is sloped towards west, with the highest point towards Smörslo sgatan, a quite calm street with a bus stop right by the site. The slope is so steep that the entrance in the west will be one floor below the groundfloor in the east. Adult psychiatry Remissvägen Site for Children’s new BUP hospital tan Smörslottsga Psychiatric y clinic Adults Children’s emergency Walkway Smörslottsgatan Schema c site sec on showing the slope Outpatient Ward Outpatient Ward Outpatient Parking Schema c site sec on with a new building 44
Design proposal Surrounding buildings, Building that will be and almost the en re demolished. The parking hospital area, follow a strict will in part be replaced in a orthogonal system parking deck under the new BUP building, the rest will Parking be located elsewhere. deck Roads and pedestrian paths Greenery and trees around around the site. For privacy Cars vis the site. The hospital area it ing the hospit the building will keep a al has a lot of greenery and distance from the streets. the site is not an excep on. s buse Pedestrian walkway d rs an h ca t wit Stree Heights on the site. The slope rise about 4,5 meters +46,0 +48,0 between the east and +50,5 the west side of the new +47,5 +52,0 building. +50,0 +53,0 +47,5 +51,5 45
Design proposal Building form - step by step The new BUP follows the strict orthogonal plan of Östra Sjukhuset. The shape have long, straight lines to the west where it meets the hospital and a more broken up form to the green are in the east towards smörslo gatan, and the housing area. The steps to reach the final form are schema cally described below. The patient ward Patient rooms The first step in the design of the building was to design a pa ent ward. All pa ent rooms face either south or east for good daylight and to face the green area in the east part of the plot. N Patient rooms Arrange them on the site When the ward was decided they had to be arranged on the plot. There are five units, three on the first floor and two on the second. The wards follow the terrain and are placed to give sun to all pa ent rooms. 46
Design proposal Add the outpatient care The outpa ent care are placed towards the hospital and have a more strict form to meet the orthogonality of the hospital area. Connect the two parts and split the yard To create two yards and to connect the wards with the outpa ent care a building is placed in the middle. This part will be the ac vity square which can be used both by pa ents visi ng the outpa ent departments, and the pa ents submi ed to the inpa ent care. Create an entrance point Since pa ents will come to the building both from the north and the south the entrance will be placed on the middle of the western facade. The outpa ent building is distorted in the middle to create an entry point, placed so that it meets the emergency entrance to the children’s hospital. 47
Design proposal Site plan The building rests in a green se ng, surrounded by trees and different kinds of green areas. The protruding volume with the entrance is highly visible both from north and south and the school in the south gets a small schoolyard that is sunlit all a ernoon. The two yards enclosed by the building have different func ons. The south yard is an ac ve space with cropboxes, a sunlit wooden decking and a place for outdoor group therapy. The north is more passive, for being outdoors, si ng in the grass or strolling on the paths. View towards the entrance from the north Bird view over the building from the north-west View towards the entrance from the south Bird view over the building from the south-east 48
Design proposal Ambulance entrance Main entrance Entrance school N Meter Site plan 1:800 49
Design proposal Departments in BUP Emergency department Eating disorders outpatient care BUP’s emergency department is open for pa ents under The department for ea ng disorders treat pa ents the age of 18. It treats acute psychiatric illness or problems of the ages of 16 through 25 and involves outpa ent and since the pa ents are minors they o en come care, dayward and inpa ent care. The ea ng disorders accompanied by parents or rela ves. Some pa ents arrive department in Östra Sjukhuset have pa ents from the with ambulance, those are o en ac ng out and needs to en re region. be in a calm room without other pa ents. The treatment is adapted to each pa ents needs, for Func ons needed in the emergency department are pa ents under the age of 18 family is always involved, and different kinds of conversa on rooms, administra ve areas if the pa ents are older it is strongly recommended, but and exam rooms. Connected to the emergency department not mandatory to involve family or close rela ves. are twelve in-pa ent rooms. In the first evalua on of the pa ent a medical exam Children that come to this department can be of all ages. is carried out. Some methods used in the treatment are family therapy, group therapy, cogni ve behavioral therapy Specialist department and physical therapy. The specialist department is an outpa ent care department that treats many psychiatric disorders. Some Eating disorders inpatient care are depression, bipolar disorder, Toure e syndrome, The inpa ent treatment program usually lasts for three obsessive-compulsive disorder and different kinds of months, where the pa ents go through different care phobias. zones called red, yellow and green. In the red zone the Children of all ages come to this department. pa ent have a big need for support, in the yellow the need for support is s ll high, but the pa ent is given more own Inpatient care responsibility and in the green zone the focus is on own responsibility, but with some support. The inpa ent care department is for children suffering The treatment in the inpa ent wards involves group from different forms of mental illness that is so severe that therapy, family therapy, meal therapy, mee ngs with a they no longer func on at home. In the inpa ent care the physiotherapist and different kinds of ac vi es such as a pa ents get treatment and counseling, as well as a form wri ng circle and handicra s. of daily life in the hospital school and the play therapy. There are two departments for inpa ent care today, one connected to the emergency department and one called Eating disorders day ward short-stay inpa ent care where the pa ents most o en Treatment in the day ward looks like the treatment in the stay at home over weekends. inpa ent care, but the pa ents stay at home. They come to In the inpa ent care the pa ents are mostly twelwe or the hospital during day me to par cipate in meal therapy, older, it is not common prac ce to admit younger children counceling, family therapy and group mee ngs. to inpa ent care. 50
Design proposal Arrangement of departments Floor 2 Eating disorders outpatient care Eating disorders day ward Activity square Ward Staff Floor 1 Emergency department Admin Activity square Ward Staff Entrance floor Specialist outpatient care Admin Reception School Public stairs Staff Elevator Technical/parking Staff/emergency stairs The groundfloor contain a recep on, the pa ent school, conference rooms and the specialist department. Since the site is sloped the back side of the ground floor is below ground level and houses parking and technical spaces as well as changing rooms for staff. On the first floor we find the emergency department, 22 pa ent rooms divided on three wards, an ac vity square, the main administra on for BUP and the two yards. The second floor has gathered all func ons for ea ng disorders, the oupa ent care, the dayward and 16 pa ent rooms divided on two wards. In the south is a roof terrace connected to the staff room. There are three elevators in the building, two by the main entrance and one in the ac vity square. The main stair for pa ent comunica on is by the main entrance, and there is also one for pa ents in the wards in the ac vity square. Staff/emergency stairs are placed in the south-west and north-east corners of the building. Public stairs Elevator Staff/emergency stairs 51
Design proposal Groundfloor (floor 0) The entrance to the building is placed in the middle of the west facade, protected in a corner that is created through the offset of the yards. The entrance hall will contain a recep on and a small wai ng area. North of the entrance is the specialist department and to the south is the conference area. The school has its own entrance and is placed in the southern end of the building. Along the east side of the building is a parking garage. This part is under ground because of the sloped site. Patients Staff Public stairs Elevator Staff/emergency stairs 52
Design proposal 5 11 11 10 Specialist outpatient care 5 5 9 12 8 10 4 5 6 5 5 5 6 5 5 2 3 Parking 1 Technical 11 13 Conference 14 15 14 14 14 14 9 1 Main reception 2 Team station/reception 3 Waiting 10 4 Family/relatives room 17 5 Counseling room School 6 Exam room 17 16 Technical 7 Reception 8 Disinfection 16 9 Storage 10 Administration 17 11 Private office 16 9 12 Silent room 13 Coat room 14 Conference room 15 Conference mingle 1:500 16 Class room 17 Changing room staff 53
Design proposal Floor 1 The pa ents reach the floor via the main staircase in the entrance hall. From the entrance lobby the emergency department, the ac vity square and the administra on are reached directly. The wards are reached through the ac vity square, that by this is given a very visible place in the building. There is an office in the ac vity square to that staff can have control over who moves through the area. The flow of pa ents are mainly in the western and the central part of the building, while staff move around mainly in the east part of the building, separated from the public pa ent flow. The ward by the ambulance contains only six pa ent rooms, and has two pa ent rooms with private dayrooms for pa ents that need to be alone. This ward can easily be locked off from the rest of the building but keep access to the north yard to be used by pa ents with an escape risk. Flow from ambulance Patients Staff Public stairs Elevator Staff/emergency stairs Access to the yard 54
Design proposal Emergency department 5 10 11 11 13 15 23 5 5 5 16 5 6 10 10 12 14 9 6 5 2 17 8 20 3 22 18 19 5 4 9 5 16 21 5 5 19 5 16 2 9 3 16 20 16 16 Activity square Ward 6 patients 24 25 26 27 10 28 14 11 16 1 Main reception 17 Administration 2 Team station/reception 11 2 3 Waiting 16 11 4 Family/relatives room 11 22 18 19 13 5 Counseling room 11 9 6 Exam room 16 11 21 7 Reception 14 19 8 Disinfection 11 16 9 Storage 11 9 10 Administration 11 Private office 16 16 16 16 12 Silent room 13 Staff pause 14 22 9 19 16 Ward 8 patients 14 Conference room 2 15 On-call room 16 16 Patient room 17 18 21 17 Day room 16 18 Dining 19 Day room small 16 20 Day room 1 patient 19 21 Atrium 16 16 16 16 22 Kitchen 23 Ambulance entrance 24 Creativity room Ward 8 patients 25 Music room 1:500 26 Room for the senses 27 Activity room 28 Winter garden 55
Design proposal Floor 2 The second floor houses the departments for ea ng disorders, including an outpa ent department, a day ward and 16 pa ent rooms, that will mainly be used for pa ents with ea ng disorders, but also for some other pa ents. The organiza on is very much like the first floor, but with some differences. The outpa ent care for ea ng disorders does not have the need for double access to conversa on rooms, so the double corridor is removed in favor of some extra area for rooms. In the south, above the third ward on the first floor, there is a roof terrace connected to the staff room. This space can be used for future expansion if the departments outgrow the building. Patients Staff Public stairs Elevator Staff/emergency stairs 56
You can also read