AQA English Literature - Unseen Poetry and Romeo and Juliet
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
ARNOLD HILL ACADEMY AQA English Literature Unseen Poetry and Romeo and Juliet
AQA iGCSE ENGLISH LITERATURE Paper 1 Higher Section A – Unseen Poetry AO1 Respond to texts critically and imaginatively; select and evaluate relevant textual detail to illustrate and support interpretations AO2 Explain how language, structure and form contribute to writers’ presentation of ideas, themes and settings Band Mark Specific Descriptors Insightful, critical, imaginative & evaluative response to texts and task 30-35 marks Insightful /impressive engagement with writers’ ideas and attitudes 6 ‘Insightful’ ‘impressive’ Insightful/interpretations using imaginatively selected supporting textual detail impressive analysis of aspects of language and structure; perceptive and imaginative assured critical and/or imaginative and/or evaluative response to texts and task 24-29 marks sustained and developed appreciation of writers’ ideas and attitudes 5 ‘confident’ ‘assured’ confident convincing interpretations using precisely selected supporting textual detail analysis of aspects of language and structure in convincing detail considered/thoughtful response to text and/or task 18-23 marks thoughtful consideration of writers’ ideas and attitudes 4 ‘considered’ considered interpretations using thoughtfully selected supporting textual detail ‘thoughtful’ thoughtful consideration of aspects of language and structure with thoughtfully selected textual support clear/consistent response to text and/or task 12-17 marks clear/consistent understanding of writers’ ideas and attitudes 3 ‘clear’ ‘consistent’ clear interpretations using relevant supporting textual detail clear/consistent understanding of features of language and structure supported by relevant and appropriate quotation explained response to text and/or task 6-11 marks explained response to writers’ ideas/ attitudes 2 ‘explained’ explained interpretations using relevant textual detail explained understanding of features of language and structure supported by relevant quotation some response to texts and/or task 1-5 marks some familiarity with writers’ ideas supported by a range of textual detail 1 ‘some’ some familiarity with obvious features of language and structure supported by some relevant textual detail 0 0 marks Nothing worthy of credit Grade Boundaries out of 35 A* A B C D 25 20 15 11 7 1
AQA iGCSE English Literature paper 1 Section A – Unseen poetry Question Types Year Questions What impressions of childhood does Duffy create in this Specimen poem? How does she convey these ideas to the reader? (35 marks) What impression of the main character does Stallworthy create in the poem and how does he convey these ideas to June 2012 the reader? (35 marks) What does the narrator of the poem feel about the birth of Jan 2013 her child and how does the poet present these feelings? (35 marks) What feelings does the narrator of the poem have about his students and his job as a teacher and how does Lawrence June 2013 convey these feelings to the reader? (35 marks) 2
Past Paper - Specimen Section A: Unseen Poetry You must answer the one question in this section You are advised to spend about 45 minutes on this section Read the poem below and then answer the question that follows. In Mrs Tilscher’s Class You could travel up the Blue Nile with your finger, tracing the route while Mrs Tilscher chanted the scenery. Tana. Ethiopia. Khartoum. Aswan. That for an hour, then a skittle of milk and the chalky Pyramids rubbed into dust. A window opened with a long pole. The laugh of a bell swung by a running child. This was better than home. Enthralling books. The classroom glowed like a sweetshop. Sugar paper. Coloured shapes. Brady and Hindley* Faded, like the faint, uneasy smudge of a mistake. Mrs Tilscher loved you. Some mornings, you found She’d left a good gold star by your name. The scent of a pencil slowly, carefully, shaved. A xylophone’s nonsense heard from another form. Over the Easter term, the inky tadpoles changed from commas into exclamation marks. Three frogs hopped in the playground, freed by a dunce, followed by a line of kids, jumping and croaking away from the lunch queue. A rough boy told you how you were born. You kicked him, but stared at your parents, appalled, when you got back home. That feverish July, the air tasted of electricity. A tangible alarm made you always untidy, hot, fractious under the heavy, sexy sky. You asked her how you were born and Mrs Tilscher smiled, then turned away. Reports were handed out. You ran through the gates, impatient to be grown, as the sky split open into a thunderstorm. Carol Ann Duffy * Ian Brady and Myra Hindley murdered five children in the 1960s. 3
Past Paper Poems June 2012 Section A: Unseen Poetry Spend about 45 minutes on this section. The poem below is about an experienced sailor who drowns. Read the poem carefully and then answer the question that follows. The Last Mystery He knew that coastline – no man better – Knew all its rocks and currents, like the veins And knuckles on the brown back of his hand; The leap-frog rollers and tall tons that batter Boat-rib and man-rib into grains Of indistinguishable sand: He had known them all since he could stand. A shanty* was his earliest lullaby, The beach his back-yard, flotsam all his toys. He was admitted to the mystery Of tides; the wind’s writing on the sky; Could out-sail, out-dive, out-swim boys Older by half; was known to save Many from the sabre-toothed, man-eating wave. Knowing so well the temper of the coast, And all subaqueous hazards of the sea, What voice, thought, impulse lugged him from his ale (When every flag was fighting with a mast And waves kicked bollards off the quay), To match his Lilliputian* sail Against the wrestling muscles of the gale? Only the lemming* knows: his friends knew only Boat-rib and man-rib littered the long shore Many tides after. I declare he fell Like a pearl-dazzled diver through the sea To that last mystery on its floor; Whose is the heart-beat under the swell, The hand that turns the whirlpool and the shell? Jon Stallworthy * Shanty is a traditional song sung by sailors. * Lilliputian refers to Lilliput which is a land of very small people in Gulliver’s Travels. * Lemmings are rodents which are reputed to rush each year into the sea and drown. 4
Past Paper Poems Jan 2013 Section A: Unseen Poetry Spend about 45 minutes on this section. The poem below is about an experienced sailor who drowns. Read the poem carefully and then answer the question that follows. Morning Song Love set you going like a fat gold watch. The midwife slapped your footsoles, and your bald cry Took its place among the elements. Our voices echo, magnifying your arrival. New statue. In a drafty museum, your nakedness Shadows our safety. We stand round blankly as walls. I’m no more your mother Than a cloud that distils a mirror to reflect its own slow Effacement at the wind’s hand. All night your moth-breath Flickers among the flat pink roses. I wake to listen: A far sea moves in my ear. One cry, and I stumble from bed, cow-heavy and floral In my Victorian nightgown. Your mouth opens clean as a cat’s. The window square Whitens and swallows its dull stars. And now you try Your handful of notes; The clear vowels rise like balloons. Sylvia Plath (1932 – 1963) 5
Past Poems June 2013 Section A: Unseen Poetry Spend about 45 minutes on this section. The poem below is about an experienced sailor who drowns. Read the poem carefully and then answer the question that follows. Last Lesson of the Afternoon When will the bell ring and end this weariness? How long have they tugged the leash, and strained apart, My pack of unruly hounds! I cannot start Them again on a quarry of knowledge they hate to hunt, I can haul them and urge them no more. No longer now can I endure the brunt Of the books that lie out on the desks; a full three-score Of several insults of blotted pages, and scrawl Of slovenly work that they have offered me. I am sick, and what on earth is the good of it all? What good to them or me, I cannot see! So, shall I take My last dear fuel of life to heap on my soul And kindle my will to a flame that shall consume Their dross of indifference; and take the toll Of their insults in punishment? – I will not! – I will not waste my soul and my strength for this. What do I care for all they do amiss! What is the point of this teaching of mine, and of this Learning of theirs? It all goes down the same abyss. What does it matter to me, if they can write A description of a dog, or if they can’t? What is the point? To us both, it is all my aunt!* And yet I’m supposed to care, with all my might. I do not, and will not; they won’t and they don’t; and that’s all! I shall keep my strength for myself; they can keep theirs as well. Why should we beat our heads against the wall Of each other? I shall sit and wait for the bell. D. H. Lawrence (1885 – 1930) *‘It is all my aunt!’ – an expression which means ‘it is all nonsense’. 6
How to analyse poems 1 Analysing a poem you have never seen before under exam conditions needn’t be a frightening prospect. You can improve through practice and by following these steps: First of all, read the poem. It seems obvious, but you’d be surprised how many students dive straight in and begin writing having only read the title or first few lines. Take the time to read the poem through two or even three times. Really try and hear it in your head, getting a feel for the sounds and rhythms and noticing any strange rhymes or interesting words. Your analysis should then work through the following: Speaker Who is the speaker in the poem? The voice in the poem isn’t necessarily the poet himself – poets often speaker through personas, real or imagined, personal or impersonal – though of course it can be. Is it in the first or third (or second) person? Is there anything that reveals or implies anything about the speaker? Who are they speaking to? Setting What is the poem’s setting? Where does the poem take place? A poem can be set anywhere, in the past, present or future. How does this setting/location influence the atmosphere of the poem? Form What is the form of the poem? Poems can be written in various forms (see below for summary of the most common) which dictate their length, their layout on the page, the line length, whether they rhyme or not and how they rhyme (the rhyme scheme), their meter (the rhythmic structure of the line.) Some forms are associated with certain themes or genres – sonnet form, for example, is commonly used for love poetry; ballad form for narrative (story) poems. Poets make deliberate decisions about which form to choose, and form always interacts with content, whether to reinforce it or to work against it – a sonnet about the end of a relationship might have a particular poignancy, for example. The best way to work out and begin talking about the form (and also a good way to calm exam nerves) is to start counting. Count the number of stanzas, the number of lines, the number of syllables in the lines if they are regular or there is a pattern. Mark the rhymes and the stresses (see below for summary of common stress patterns). This should help show up any patterns, and crucially, where the poem deviates from or tries to break away from the pattern. Thinking about rhyme for example – are all the rhymes full/perfect rhymes? (i.e. night/light, sky/high) or are there some variations? Subject matter – what is the poem about? If you aren’t sure, try to describe exactly what is happening in the poem. It’s absolutely fine to express a difficulty in understanding as the poet has probably made it intentionally complex, reflecting something about what they’re trying to say. Look at the imagery used in the poem. Poets often use figurative and metaphorical language that take words beyond their literal meanings, and attempt to do so in novel ways. Perhaps choose a couple of the most interesting images in the poem and comment on them. Why are they interesting? What is the poet doing? What does the choice of a particular word do to our understanding, or how does an image create an atmosphere in the poem? Finally, what does the poem mean? You can write an excellent essay covering all of the previous points and ignoring this one, but if you can it’s a good idea to end with a summary of what the poem means; what the poet was trying to say, and, perhaps, whether you think they were successful in saying it. 7
How to analyse poems 2 Common poetic forms and literary terms Alexandrine: A 12 syllable poetic line Alliteration: the repetition of consonants at the beginning of words e.g. ‘the lazy languid line’. When consonant sounds are repeated within words it is called consonance e.g. ‘some mammals are clammy’ Assonance: the internal rhyming of vowel sounds e.g. ‘on a proud round cloud in white high night’ (ee cummings) Ballad: A poetic form mostly written in four line stanzas (quatrains) of alternating lines of iambic tetrameter (four pairs of unstressed-stressed syllables) and iambic trimeter (three pairs). Usually, only the second and fourth lines are rhymed (abcb), although there is considerable variation in the form. Examples of ballads: The Ballad of Moll Magee, WB Yeats, Ballad of the Breadman, by Charles Causley Blank verse: A type of poetry with a regular meter (generally iambic pentameter) but no rhyme. Cliché: a saying, expression or idea that has been overused to the point of losing its original meaning; a stereotype. Dramatic irony: a rhetorical device where the author causes a character to behave in a way that is contrary to the truth, or that the audience is aware is wrong. Free verse or vers libre: A form of poetry without any regular patterns, rhymes or meters. Its form is its irregularity. Heroic couplet:Commonly used for narrative poetry, heroic couplets are rhymed iambic pentameter pairs of lines. Hyperbole: exaggeration Metaphor: an analogy between two words or ideas where one stands for the other e.g. ‘his smile was the sun’ – not to be confused with the simile. Personification – ascribing human characteristics to inanimate objects or forms Simile – a kind of metaphor which uses the words as or like – e.g. ‘he fights like a lion’ Sonnet: A poetic form. Fourteen lines long. Can be rhymed in a number of ways, but the most common are Shakespearean and Petrarchan. Shakespearean sonnets are rhymed in three groups of four lines rhymed alternately, followed by a couplet – i.e. abab cdcd efef gg. The closing rhyming couplet often sums up the sonnet. Petrarchan sonnets are divided into a group of eight lines, called the octave and a group of six lines called the sestet. The octave is usually rhymed abba abba, and the sestet cde cde. Usually there is a ‘turn’ or ‘volta’ - a change of direction or mood between the octave and the sestet. Traditionally, the octave put forward a proposition and the sestet offered a solution. Examples of sonnets: Sonnet 18 by Shakespeare, Shall I compare thee to a summer's day?, Leda and the Swan, by WB Yeats,On His Blindness, by Milton Terza rima: A rhyming verse stanza form consisting of an interlocking three line rhyme scheme – aba bcb cdc ded etc -Acquainted With The Night by Robert Frost Villanelle: A nineteen line poem with a complex scheme consisting of alternating refrains. The best way of describing the form is to look at a villanelle itself. The most famous example in English is Do Not Go Gentle Into That Good Night by Dylan Thomas 8
How to analyse poems 3 Describing meter We often talk about meter as the sequence of feet in a line, with each foot a group of syllable types. The most common syllable groupings are: Iamb – unstressed/stressed or short/long e.g. Shall I compare thee to a summer’s day? (Shakespeare) Trochee – stressed/unstressed or long/short e.g. Tyger Tyger burning bright (The Tyger, William Blake) Dactyl – stressed/unstressed/unstressed or long/short/short e.g. Just for a handful of silver he left us/ Just for a riband tostick in his coat (The Lost Leader, Robert Browning) Anapaest – unstressed/unstressed/stressed or short/short/long e.g. Twas the night before Christmas and all through thehouse/ Not a creature was stirring not even a mouse Spondee (stressed/stressed) and Amphibrach (unstressed/stress ed/unstressed) are also quite common. Lines are named for the kind of feet (whether they are iambic or dactylic etc) and then for the number of feet. If there are three it is trimeter, four is tetrameter, five is pentameter, six is hexameter etc. 9
Paper 1 Section B Higher - Prose / Drama – Romeo and Juliet Band Mark Specific Descriptors Insightful, critical, imaginative & evaluative response to texts and task Insightful /impressive engagement with writers’ ideas and attitudes 34-40 marks Insightful interpretations using imaginatively selected supporting textual 6 ‘Insightful’ ‘impressive’ detail impressive analysis of aspects of language and structure; perceptive and imaginative. assured critical and/or imaginative and/or evaluative response to texts and task 27-33 marks sustained and developed appreciation of writers’ ideas & attitudes 5 ‘confident’ ‘assured’ confident convincing interpretations using precisely selected supporting textual detail analysis of aspects of language and structure in convincing detail. considered/thoughtful response to text and/or task thoughtful consideration of writers’ ideas and attitudes 20-26 marks considered interpretations using thoughtfully selected supporting textual 4 ‘considered’ ‘thoughtful’ detail thoughtful consideration of aspects of language and structure with thoughtfully selected textual support. clear/consistent response to text and/or task 13-19 marks clear/consistent understanding of writers’ ideas and attitudes 3 ‘clear’ ‘consistent’ clear interpretations using relevant supporting textual detail clear/consistent understanding of features of language and structure supported by relevant and appropriate quotation explained response to text and/or task explained response to writers’ ideas/ attitudes 7-12 marks 2 ‘explained’ explained interpretations using relevant textual detail explained understanding of features of language and structure supported by relevant quotation some response to texts and/or task 1-6 marks some familiarity with writers’ ideas supported by a range of textual detail 1 ‘some’ some familiarity with obvious features of language and structure supported by some relevant textual detail 0 0 marks Nothing worthy of credit Grade Boundaries out of 40 A* A B C D 28 23 18 13 8 10
Paper 1 Section B Foundation - Prose / Drama Romeo and Juliet Question Types Year Questions 08 How does Shakespeare present the relationship between Juliet and her parents? (40 marks) Specimen OR 09 ‘The most interesting part of the play is the fight which results in the deaths of Tybalt and Mercutio. After that the audience tends to lose interest.’ What do you find of interest after this point in the play? Question 8 ‘Shakespeare presents Romeo as impulsive and Juliet as cautious.’ How do you respond to this view of their relationship? (40 marks) OR June 2012 Question 9 In Act 1 Scene 1 Romeo says: “Here’s much to do with hate, but more with love.” How far do you think that Shakespeare presents love as being more powerful than hate in the play? (40 marks) Question 8 08 How are adults presented in Romeo and Juliet? Refer to two or more of the following characters in your response: The Nurse The Friar The Prince Capulet Lady Jan 2013 Capulet Montague Lady Montague.(40 marks) OR Question 9 09 How is conflict presented in Romeo and Juliet?(40 marks) Question 8 What do you find interesting about the ways Shakespeare presents female characters in Romeo and Juliet? (40 marks) OR June 2013 Question 9 In the prologue Shakespeare describes Romeo and Juliet as “star-crossed lovers”. What is the role of fate in the play?(40 marks) 11
Paper 1 Section B Romeo and Juliet Romeo and Juliet: Analysis by Act and Scene INTRODUCTION Tragedy as well as comedy deals with a conflict between an individual force (which may be centered either in one character or in a group of characters acting as one) and environing circumstances. In tragedy the individual (one person or a group) is overwhelmed; in comedy the individual triumphs. In tragedy, as in comedy, five stages may be noted in the plot development: (i) the exposition, or introduction; (2) the complication, rising action, or growth; (3) the climax, crisis, or turning point ; (4) the resolution, falling action, or consequence; and (5) the denouement, catastrophe, or conclusion. Let it not be thought for a moment that each of these stages is clearly differentiated. As a rule they pass insensibly into each other, as they do in life. Especially is this true in a play like Romeo and Juliet, where the weaving of the plot is so close and compact. ANALYSIS BY ACT ACT SCENE I. THE EXPOSITION, OR INTRODUCTION (TYING OF THE KNOT) Prologue. The Prologue briefly gives the setting and theme of the play and prepares us for a drama of pathos in which the destiny of two lovers is determined by fate and external circumstances, rather than by character. Act I, Scene i. The thread of the feud action is here introduced with the peace-making Benvolio on the side of the Montagues and the fiery Tybalt on the Capulet side. The quarrel is suppressed when the Prince enters and, in the presence of the heads of the two houses which have thrice disturbed Verona's streets with broils, declares that death will be the penalty if civil peace is again threatened by their hatred. This warning is a preparation for the tragic climax. The love action is suggested. The strangeness of Romeo's new mood is discussed by his parents and Benvolio. When Romeo enters, it is soon discovered that the cause is unrequited love. Benvolio's determination to teach Romeo to forget this lady prepares the way for the change in the hero's feelings in the masquerade scene. Act I, Scene ii. The entrance of Juliet is prepared for; County Paris is a claimant for her hand. Romeo consents to attend the Capulet masquerade. In the chance meeting of Romeo and Benvolio by the servant as he sets out to invite guests to the feast may be read the significance of the part played by accident in determining the outcome of the play. Act I, Scene iii. Juliet is introduced. Lady Capulet announces to her daughter in the presence of the garrulous nurse that Paris is seeking her in marriage and that she is to meet him that night at the feast. Act I, Scene iv. Mercutio joins with Benvolio in urging the reluctant Romeo to forget his sad love affair and to enter into the spirit of the feast. The scene ends with a vague foreboding of the consequences hanging on the night's events. The complete mastery of fate over the destiny of these star-crossed lovers is emphasized in Romeo's helpless cry: "But He, that hath the steerage of my course, direct my sail" (lines 112-113). 12
Paper 1 Section B Romeo and Juliet II. THE COMPLICATION, RISING ACTION, OR GROWTH (TYING OF THE KNOT) Act I, Scene v. The feast is on. Romeo catches sight of Juliet and immediately is in love with her. Already the counteracting forces are at work. Tybalt, the chief antagonist, hearing his voice, recognizes him and is enraged that a Montague should dare attend a Capulet feast. He leaves the hall with a determination to punish this intrusion. This is the motive to the complication of the feud action. Romeo and Juliet meet, love at sight, and part; and the dramatic entanglement has begun. Act II, Scene i. This scene explains Romeo's presence in the next. Mercutio's observations about Rosaline and love in general show that his companions know nothing of the change in Romeo. Act II, Scene ii. By a masterly device the usual delays attending lovemaking are removed and the dramatic interest and entanglement intensified. By chance, again, Juliet in her confession of love to the heavens and the night is overheard by her lover himself, and he comes to her call. In this, the famous balcony scene, the lovers plan marriage. Through the scene are scattered presentiments of evil. Act II, Scene iii. The soliloquy of the Friar reflects the doom that awaits the love of Romeo and Juliet, while his knowledge of herbs prepares us for his later intrigue. He promises reluctantly to officiate at a secret wedding and sees in this union a possible reconciliation between the hostile houses. The scene ends with the significant words : "Wisely and slow; they stumble that run fast." Act II, Scene iv. The first part of this scene, where it is revealed that Tybalt has sent a challenge to Romeo, prepares us for the crossing of the feud action and love action. It also furnishes an opportunity for Mercutio to express his disdain of Tybalt. The second part completes the arrangement for the marriage. Act II, Scene v. After suspense to which the Nurse's garrulity gives humorous relief, Juliet wrings from her the message sent by Romeo. Act II, Scene vi. The marriage rite is performed, but even this joyous scene is not without its warning (lines 9-10): These violent delights have violent ends And in their triumph die. < img src="http://www.burstnet.com/cgi- bin/ads/ad6493a.cgi/ns/v=2.3S/sz=300x250A/" border="0" alt="Click Here" /> 13
Paper 1 Section B Romeo and Juliet III. THE CLIMAX, CRISIS, OR TURNING POINT (THE KNOT TIED) Act III, Scene i. The threads of the feud action and the love action cross each other. Tybalt in seeking out Romeo comes upon Mercutio, who exchanges daring words with him. By chance, Romeo comes that way. Tybalt calls him "villain," but he controls his anger at this insult out of respect to his secret new alliance with a Capulet. The hot- blooded Mercutio is angered at what seems to be a vile submission and takes up the fight. Romeo and Benvolio come between them, but Tybalt strikes Mercutio a last revengeful blow and then runs off. The blow is fatal and the death of his friend rouses Romeo to revenge. Tybalt comes back in triumph but £oon is the victim of death at the hands of Romeo. Citizens and members of the two houses gather. The Prince hears an account of what has taken place and Romeo is sentenced to banishment. IV. THE RESOLUTION, FALLING ACTION, OR CONSEQUENCE (THE UNTYING OF THE KNOT) Act III, Scene ii. Juliet is told of her cousin's death and her husband's banishment. After she has become almost distracted with confusion and despair, the Nurse finally says that she knows where Romeo is hid, and goes to take him a ring from Juliet and ask him to come that night to take his last farewell. Act III, Scene iii. When Romeo hears his sentence of banishment he gives way to despair. What the philosophy of Friar Laurence fails to do in the way of comfort is effected by the message from Juliet. The Friar warns him to depart by break of day for Mantua and promises to keep him informed of happenings in Verona. Act III, Scene iv. The action of the Paris love suit begins to take definite shape. Capulet sets the following Thursday as the wedding day of his daughter and the county. Act III, Scene v. The lovers bid farewell and the shadow of the tragic catastrophe falls on their parting words. Hardly has Romeo escaped, when Lady Capulet comes in to tell Juliet of the wedding to take place on Thursday. The enmity of the family now concentrated on Romeo as the slayer of Tybalt makes it impossible for Juliet to confess her marriage. She pleads for time, but her angered father bursts forth in abuses, her mother turns a deaf ear, and even the Nurse fails her in her time of greatest need. Her only hope is in the Friar and to him she resolves to go. Act IV, Scene i. Juliet shows wonderful self-control in her meeting with Paris at the Friar's cell, but after he has gone her anguish finds full expression. The Friar suggests a daring intrigue by which Juliet shall take a drug that will make her appear dead for forty-eight hours. This will relieve her from her marriage to Paris and will afford an opportunity for Romeo to take her shortly away to Mantua. Act IV, Scene ii. Capulet, regardless of his daughter's feelings, is insistently making preparations for the marriage, but she is just as determined and far more skillful in thwarting his purpose. She feigns willing submission and seems eager for the day. Act IV, Scene iii. After cheerfully attending to the preparations for her wedding, Juliet asks to be left alone for the night that she may pray. In spite of terrifying misgivings and fears, she drinks the potion. The intrigue of the Friar is begun. 14
Paper 1 Section B Romeo and Juliet Act IV, Scene iv. A scene of irony and suspense. The household is astir preparing the trappings of the feast, the bridegroom is at hand, but the bride cannot be found. Act IV, Scene v. The Friar's intrigue seems to be succeeding. The drug has produced the semblance of death and the wedding feast is turned into a funeral. The merry talk of Peter and the musicians gives relief and is a reflection of the insincerity and lack of true feeling in the Capulets' attitude toward their daughter. Act V, Scene i. The scene shifts to Mantua. Irony and ominous foreboding are found in Romeo's cheerful thoughts, caused by a strange dream. When Balthasar brings him news of Juliet's burial, but no word from the Friar, the audience realizes that there has been some dangerous mistake in the carrying out of the intrigue. After Romeo has determined to be with Juliet that night in the monument, and has, by bribing a poverty- stricken apothecary, procured the means in the shape of an instant-working deadly drug, all seems lost — yet a slight hope remains that chance will intervene and avert the tragic end. Act V, Scene ii. The flaw in the carrying out of the Friar's plan is explained. Again accident has proved the enemy of the lovers, for just as the messenger was about to depart for Mantua, the doors of the house at which he stayed were sealed because of the pestilence. As Friar Laurence hastens to the tomb to be present when Juliet awakes, there is a hope that he may arrive in time to meet Romeo and stay his death. V. DENOUMENT, CATASTROPHE, OR CONCLUSION (THE KNOT UNTIED) Act V, Scene iii. Chance is hostile to the end and drags down not only the two lovers but Paris as well. After this tragic ending of the love action and the feud action, the Friar explains the marriage and intrigue. His words are supplemented by the letter that Romeo leaves with Balthasar. At last the family feud is ended by the death of the star-crossed lovers. 15
Paper 1 Section B Romeo and Juliet Themes Themes are the fundamental and often universal ideas explored in a literary work. The Forcefulness of Love Romeo and Juliet is the most famous love story in the English literary tradition. Love is naturally the play’s dominant and most important theme. The play focuses on romantic love, specifically the intense passion that springs up at first sight between Romeo and Juliet. In Romeo and Juliet, love is a violent, ecstatic, overpowering force that supersedes all other values, loyalties, and emotions. In the course of the play, the young lovers are driven to defy their entire social world: families (“Deny thy father and refuse thy name,” Juliet asks, “Or if thou wilt not, be but sworn my love, / And I’ll no longer be a Capulet”); friends (Romeo abandons Mercutio and Benvolio after the feast in order to go to Juliet’s garden); and ruler (Romeo returns to Verona for Juliet’s sake after being exiled by the Prince on pain of death in 2.1.76–78). Love is the overriding theme of the play, but a reader should always remember that Shakespeare is uninterested in portraying a prettied-up, dainty version of the emotion, the kind that bad poets write about, and whose bad poetry Romeo reads while pining for Rosaline. Love in Romeo and Juliet is a brutal, powerful emotion that captures individuals and catapults them against their world, and, at times, against themselves. The powerful nature of love can be seen in the way it is described, or, more accurately, the way descriptions of it so consistently fail to capture its entirety. At times love is described in the terms of religion, as in the fourteen lines when Romeo and Juliet first meet. At others it is described as a sort of magic: “Alike bewitchèd by the charm of looks” (2.Prologue.6). Juliet, perhaps, most perfectly describes her love for Romeo by refusing to describe it: “But my true love is grown to such excess / I cannot sum up some of half my wealth” (3.1.33–34). Love, in other words, resists any single metaphor because it is too powerful to be so easily contained or understood. Romeo and Juliet does not make a specific moral statement about the relationships between love and society, religion, and family; rather, it portrays the chaos and passion of being in love, combining images of love, violence, death, religion, and family in an impressionistic rush leading to the play’s tragic conclusion. 16
Love as a Cause of Violence The themes of death and violence permeate Romeo and Juliet, and they are always connected to passion, whether that passion is love or hate. The connection between hate, violence, and death seems obvious. But the connection between love and violence requires further investigation. Love, in Romeo and Juliet, is a grand passion, and as such it is blinding; it can overwhelm a person as powerfully and completely as hate can. The passionate love between Romeo and Juliet is linked from the moment of its inception with death: Tybalt notices that Romeo has crashed the feast and determines to kill him just as Romeo catches sight of Juliet and falls instantly in love with her. From that point on, love seems to push the lovers closer to love and violence, not farther from it. Romeo and Juliet are plagued with thoughts of suicide, and a willingness to experience it: in Act 3, scene 3, Romeo brandishes a knife in Friar Lawrence’s cell and threatens to kill himself after he has been banished from Verona and his love. Juliet also pulls a knife in order to take her own life in Friar Lawrence’s presence just three scenes later. After Capulet decides that Juliet will marry Paris, Juliet says, “If all else fail, myself have power to die” (3.5.242). Finally, each imagines that the other looks dead the morning after their first, and only, sexual experience (“Methinks I see thee,” Juliet says, “. . . as one dead in the bottom of a tomb” (3.5.55–56). This theme continues until its inevitable conclusion: double suicide. This tragic choice is the highest, most potent expression of love that Romeo and Juliet can make. It is only through death that they can preserve their love, and their love is so profound that they are willing to end their lives in its defense. In the play, love emerges as an amoral thing, leading as much to destruction as to happiness. But in its extreme passion, the love that Romeo and Juliet experience also appears so exquisitely beautiful that few would want, or be able, to resist its power. The Individual Versus Society Much of Romeo and Juliet involves the lovers’ struggles against public and social institutions that either explicitly or implicitly oppose the existence of their love. Such structures range from the concrete to the abstract: families and the placement of familial power in the father; law and the desire for public order; religion; and the social importance placed on masculine honor. These institutions often come into conflict with each other. The importance of honor, for example, time and again results in brawls that disturb the public peace. Though they do not always work in concert, each of these societal institutions in some way present obstacles for Romeo and Juliet. The enmity between their families, coupled with the emphasis placed on loyalty and honor to kin, combine to create a profound conflict for Romeo and Juliet, who must rebel against their heritages. Further, the patriarchal power structure inherent in Renaissance families, wherein the father controls 17
the action of all other family members, particularly women, places Juliet in an extremely vulnerable position. Her heart, in her family’s mind, is not hers to give. The law and the emphasis on social civility demands terms of conduct with which the blind passion of love cannot comply. Religion similarly demands priorities that Romeo and Juliet cannot abide by because of the intensity of their love. Though in most situations the lovers uphold the traditions of Christianity (they wait to marry before consummating their love), their love is so powerful that they begin to think of each other in blasphemous terms. For example, Juliet calls Romeo “the god of my idolatry,” elevating Romeo to level of God (2.1.156). The couple’s final act of suicide is likewise un-Christian. The maintenance of masculine honor forces Romeo to commit actions he would prefer to avoid. But the social emphasis placed on masculine honor is so profound that Romeo cannot simply ignore them. It is possible to see Romeo and Juliet as a battle between the responsibilities and actions demanded by social institutions and those demanded by the private desires of the individual. Romeo and Juliet’s appreciation of night, with its darkness and privacy, and their renunciation of their names, with its attendant loss of obligation, make sense in the context of individuals who wish to escape the public world. But the lovers cannot stop the night from becoming day. And Romeo cannot cease being a Montague simply because he wants to; the rest of the world will not let him. The lovers’ suicides can be understood as the ultimate night, the ultimate privacy. The Inevitability of Fate In its first address to the audience, the Chorus states that Romeo and Juliet are “star- crossed”—that is to say that fate (a power often vested in the movements of the stars) controls them (Prologue.6). This sense of fate permeates the play, and not just for the audience. The characters also are quite aware of it: Romeo and Juliet constantly see omens. When Romeo believes that Juliet is dead, he cries out, “Then I defy you, stars,” completing the idea that the love between Romeo and Juliet is in opposition to the decrees of destiny (5.1.24). Of course, Romeo’s defiance itself plays into the hands of fate, and his determination to spend eternity with Juliet results in their deaths. The mechanism of fate works in all of the events surrounding the lovers: the feud between their families (it is worth noting that this hatred is never explained; rather, the reader must accept it as an undeniable aspect of the world of the play); the horrible series of accidents that ruin Friar Lawrence’s seemingly well-intentioned plans at the end of the play; and the tragic timing of Romeo’s suicide and Juliet’s awakening. These events are not mere coincidences, but rather manifestations of fate that help bring about the unavoidable outcome of the young lovers’ deaths. The concept of fate described above is the most commonly accepted interpretation. There are other possible readings of fate in the play: as a force determined by the 18
powerful social institutions that influence Romeo and Juliet’s choices, as well as fate as a force that emerges from Romeo and Juliet’s very personalities. Motifs Motifs are recurring structures, contrasts, and literary devices that can help to develop and inform the text’s major themes. Light/Dark Imagery One of the play’s most consistent visual motifs is the contrast between light and dark, often in terms of night/day imagery. This contrast is not given a particular metaphoric meaning—light is not always good, and dark is not always evil. On the contrary, light and dark are generally used to provide a sensory contrast and to hint at opposed alternatives. One of the more important instances of this motif is Romeo’s lengthy meditation on the sun and the moon during the balcony scene, in which Juliet, metaphorically described as the sun, is seen as banishing the “envious moon” and transforming the night into day (2.1.46). A similar blurring of night and day occurs in the early morning hours after the lovers’ only night together. Romeo, forced to leave for exile in the morning, and Juliet, not wanting him to leave her room, both try to pretend that it is still night, and that the light is actually darkness: “More light and light, more dark and dark our woes” (3.5.36). Opposite Points of View Shakespeare includes numerous speeches and scenes in Romeo and Juliet that hint at alternative ways to evaluate the play. Shakespeare uses two main devices in this regard: Mercutio and servants. Mercutio consistently skewers the viewpoints of all the other characters in play: he sees Romeo’s devotion to love as a sort of blindness that robs Romeo from himself; similarly, he sees Tybalt’s devotion to honor as blind and stupid. His punning and the Queen Mab speech can be interpreted as undercutting virtually every passion evident in the play. Mercutio serves as a critic of the delusions of righteousness and grandeur held by the characters around him. Where Mercutio is a nobleman who openly criticizes other nobles, the views offered by servants in the play are less explicit. There is the Nurse who lost her baby and husband, the servant Peter who cannot read, the musicians who care about their lost wages and their lunches, and the Apothecary who cannot afford to make the moral choice, the lower classes present a second tragic world to counter that of the nobility. The nobles’ world is full of grand tragic gestures. The servants’ world, in contrast, is characterized by simple needs, and early deaths brought about by disease and poverty rather than dueling and grand passions. Where the nobility almost seem to revel in their capacity for drama, the servants’ lives are such that they cannot afford tragedy of the epic kind. 19
Symbols Symbols are objects, characters, figures, and colors used to represent abstract ideas or concepts. Poison In his first appearance, in Act 2, scene 2, Friar Lawrence remarks that every plant, herb, and stone has its own special properties, and that nothing exists in nature that cannot be put to both good and bad uses. Thus, poison is not intrinsically evil, but is instead a natural substance made lethal by human hands. Friar Lawrence’s words prove true over the course of the play. The sleeping potion he gives Juliet is concocted to cause the appearance of death, not death itself, but through circumstances beyond the Friar’s control, the potion does bring about a fatal result: Romeo’s suicide. As this example shows, human beings tend to cause death even without intending to. Similarly, Romeo suggests that society is to blame for the apothecary’s criminal selling of poison, because while there are laws prohiting the Apothecary from selling poison, there are no laws that would help the apothecary make money. Poison symbolizes human society’s tendency to poison good things and make them fatal, just as the pointless Capulet-Montague feud turns Romeo and Juliet’s love to poison. After all, unlike many of the other tragedies, this play does not have an evil villain, but rather people whose good qualities are turned to poison by the world in which they live. Thumb-biting In Act 1, scene 1, the buffoonish Samson begins a brawl between the Montagues and Capulets by flicking his thumbnail from behind his upper teeth, an insulting gesture known as biting the thumb. He engages in this juvenile and vulgar display because he wants to get into a fight with the Montagues but doesn’t want to be accused of starting the fight by making an explicit insult. Because of his timidity, he settles for being annoying rather than challenging. The thumb-biting, as an essentially meaningless gesture, represents the foolishness of the entire Capulet/Montague feud and the stupidity of violence in general. Queen Mab In Act 1, scene 4, Mercutio delivers a dazzling speech about the fairy Queen Mab, who rides through the night on her tiny wagon bringing dreams to sleepers. One of the most noteworthy aspects of Queen Mab’s ride is that the dreams she brings generally do not bring out the best sides of the dreamers, but instead serve to confirm them in whatever vices they are addicted to—for example, greed, violence, or lust. Another important aspect of Mercutio’s description of Queen Mab is that it is complete nonsense, albeit vivid and highly colorful. Nobody believes in a fairy pulled about by “a small grey-coated gnat” whipped with a cricket’s bone (1.4.65). Finally, it is worth noting that the description of 20
Mab and her carriage goes to extravagant lengths to emphasize how tiny and insubstantial she and her accoutrements are. Queen Mab and her carriage do not merely symbolize the dreams of sleepers, they also symbolize the power of waking fantasies, daydreams, and desires. Through the Queen Mab imagery, Mercutio suggests that all desires and fantasies are as nonsensical and fragile as Mab, and that they are basically corrupting. This point of view contrasts starkly with that of Romeo and Juliet, who see their love as real and ennobling. 21
Paper 1 Section B Romeo and Juliet Character cards Name: Name: Family Loyalty: Family Loyalty: Personality Traits: Personality Traits: Top 5 quotes: Top 5 quotes: Themes they link to: Themes they link to: Name: Name: Family Loyalty: Family Loyalty: Personality Traits: Personality Traits: Top 5 quotes: Top 5 quotes: Themes they link to: Themes they link to: 22
Paper 1 Section B Romeo and Juliet Character cards Name: Name: Family Loyalty: Family Loyalty: Personality Traits: Personality Traits: Top 5 quotes: Top 5 quotes: Themes they link to: Themes they link to: Name: Name: Family Loyalty: Family Loyalty: Personality Traits: Personality Traits: Top 5 quotes: Top 5 quotes: Themes they link to: Themes they link to: 23
Paper 1 Section B Romeo and Juliet Character cards Name: Name: Family Loyalty: Family Loyalty: Personality Traits: Personality Traits: Top 5 quotes: Top 5 quotes: Themes they link to: Themes they link to: Name: Name: Family Loyalty: Family Loyalty: Personality Traits: Personality Traits: Top 5 quotes: Top 5 quotes: Themes they link to: Themes they link to: 24
Paper 1 Section B Romeo and Juliet Character cards Name: Name: Family Loyalty: Family Loyalty: Personality Traits: Personality Traits: Top 5 quotes: Top 5 quotes: Themes they link to: Themes they link to: Name: Name: Family Loyalty: Family Loyalty: Personality Traits: Personality Traits: Top 5 quotes: Top 5 quotes: Themes they link to: Themes they link to: 25
Romeo and Juliet Key Quotes 1. But soft, what light through yonder window breaks? It is the east, and Juliet is the sun. Arise, fair sun, and kill the envious moon, Who is already sick and pale with grief That thou, her maid, art far more fair than she. . . . The brightness of her cheek would shame those stars As daylight doth a lamp; her eye in heaven Would through the airy region stream so bright That birds would sing and think it were not night. Romeo speaks these lines in the so-called balcony scene, when, hiding in the Capulet orchard after the feast, he sees Juliet leaning out of a high window (2.1.44–64). Though it is late at night, Juliet’s surpassing beauty makes Romeo imagine that she is the sun, transforming the darkness into daylight. Romeo likewise personifies the moon, calling it “sick and pale with grief” at the fact that Juliet, the sun, is far brighter and more beautiful. Romeo then compares Juliet to the stars, claiming that she eclipses the stars as daylight overpowers a lamp—her eyes alone shine so bright that they will convince the birds to sing at night as if it were day. This quote is important because in addition to initiating one of the play’s most beautiful and famous sequences of poetry, it is a prime example of the light/dark motif that runs throughout the play. Many scenes in Romeo and Juliet are set either late at night or early in the morning, and Shakespeare often uses the contrast between night and day to explore opposing alternatives in a given situation. Here, Romeo imagines Juliet transforming darkness into light; later, after their wedding night, Juliet convinces Romeo momentarily that the daylight is actually night (so that he doesn’t yet have to leave her room). 2. O Romeo, Romeo, wherefore art thou Romeo? Deny thy father and refuse thy name, Or if thou wilt not, be but sworn my love, And I’ll no longer be a Capulet. Juliet speaks these lines, perhaps the most famous in the play, in the balcony scene (2.1.74–78). Leaning out of her upstairs window, unaware that Romeo is below in the orchard, she asks why Romeo must be Romeo—why he must be a Montague, the son of her family’s greatest enemy (“wherefore” means “why,” not “where”; Juliet is not, as is often assumed, asking where Romeo is). Still unaware of Romeo’s presence, she asks him to deny his family for her love. She adds, however, 26
that if he will not, she will deny her family in order to be with him if he merely tells her that he loves her. A major theme in Romeo and Juliet is the tension between social and family identity (represented by one’s name) and one’s inner identity. Juliet believes that love stems from one’s inner identity, and that the feud between the Montagues and the Capulets is a product of the outer identity, based only on names. She thinks of Romeo in individual terms, and thus her love for him overrides her family’s hatred for the Montague name. She says that if Romeo were not called “Romeo” or “Montague,” he would still be the person she loves. “What’s in a name?” she asks. “That which we call a rose / By any other word would smell as sweet” (2.1.85–86). 3. O, then I see Queen Mab hath been with you. . . . She is the fairies’ midwife, and she comes In shape no bigger than an agate stone On the forefinger of an alderman, Drawn with a team of little atomi Athwart men’s noses as they lie asleep. Mercutio’s famous Queen Mab speech is important for the stunning quality of its poetry and for what it reveals about Mercutio’s character, but it also has some interesting thematic implications (1.4.53–59). Mercutio is trying to convince Romeo to set aside his lovesick melancholy over Rosaline and come along to the Capulet feast. When Romeo says that he is depressed because of a dream, Mercutio launches on a lengthy, playful description of Queen Mab, the fairy who supposedly brings dreams to sleeping humans. The main point of the passage is that the dreams Queen Mab brings are directly related to the person who dreams them—lovers dream of love, soldiers of war, etc. But in the process of making this rather prosaic point Mercutio falls into a sort of wild bitterness in which he seems to see dreams as destructive and delusional. 4. From forth the fatal loins of these two foes A pair of star-crossed lovers take their life, Whose misadventured piteous overthrows Doth with their death bury their parents’ strife. . . . O, I am fortune’s fool! . . . Then I defy you, stars. This trio of quotes advances the theme of fate as it plays out through the story: the first is spoken by the Chorus (Prologue.5–8), the second by Romeo after he kills Tybalt (3.1.131), and the third by Romeo upon learning of Juliet’s death (5.1.24). The Chorus’s remark that Romeo and Juliet are “star- crossed” and fated to “take their li[ves]” informs the audience that the lovers are destined to die 27
tragically. Romeo’s remark “O, I am fortune’s fool!” illustrates the fact that Romeo sees himself as subject to the whims of fate. When he cries out “Then I defy you, stars,” after learning of Juliet’s death, he declares himself openly opposed to the destiny that so grieves him. Sadly, in “defying” fate he actually brings it about. Romeo’s suicide prompts Juliet to kill herself, thereby ironically fulfilling the lovers’ tragic destiny. 28
Romeo and Juliet More Key Quotes 1. What's in a name? That which we call a rose By any other word would smell as sweet. (2.2.45-6), Juliet 2. O Romeo, Romeo, wherefore art thou Romeo? (2.2.35), Juliet 3. A plague o' both your houses! They have made worms' meat of me! (3.1.95-6), Mercutio 4. But, soft! what light through yonder window breaks? It is the east, and Juliet is the sun. (2.2.2-3), Romeo 5. A pair of star-cross'd lovers take their life. (Prologue, 7) 6. Good night, good night. Parting is such sweet sorrow, That I shall say good night till it be morrow. (2.2.197-8), Juliet 7. See how she leans her cheek upon her hand! O that I were a glove upon that hand, That I might touch that cheek! (2.2.23-5), Romeo 29
Romeo and Juliet More Key Quotes 8. Thus with a kiss I die. (5.3.121), Romeo 9. O, she doth teach the torches to burn bright. It seems she hangs upon the cheek of night Like a rich jewel in an Ethiop's ear. (1.5.43-45), Romeo 10. O happy dagger! (5.3.175), Juliet Honorable Mention Give me my Romeo, and, when he shall die, Take him and cut him out in little stars, And he will make the face of heaven so fine That all the world will be in love with night, And pay no worship to the garish sun. (3.2.21-5), Juliet A fool's paradise. (2.4.159), Nurse How fares my Juliet? that I ask again; For nothing can be ill, if she be well. (5.1.15-16), Romeo to Balthasar This bud of love, by summer's ripening breath, May prove a beauteous flower when next we meet. (2.2.127-8), Juliet 30
Romeo and Juliet More Key Quotes "A plague o' both your houses!" (3.1.104) What does it mean? Tension between the Montague and Capulet families has been mounting until a fight erupts in the streets. Romeo's best friend, Mercutio, goads Tybalt Capulet into a duel. Mercutio is stabbed by Tybalt, who runs away. Mercutio curses both families in his final words, wishing a plague on both families. Mercutio's words foreshadows the loss that both families will soon feel. "O! I am Fortune's fool!" (3.1.133) What does it mean? After Tybalt and Mercutio die, Benvolio tells Romeo that Prince Paris will probably doom him to death if he's caught. Romeo calls himself Fortune's fool. Romeo is discreetly referencing the prologue, where the audience learns that Romeo and Juliet are fated for misfortune. But Romeo also feels Fortune is being especially cruel; he just got married, and he might be put to death. His words bring the idea of fate and destiny back into the audience's mind. "For never was a story of more woe [t]han this of Juliet and her Romeo." (5.3.317-318) What does it mean? In the last two lines of the play, Prince Escalus remarks on the lives of Juliet and Romeo. He's saying that no other tale has been this sad. While Escalus is right, his words also allow for the enduring quality of Romeo and Juliet's love. Their classic love story has been told and retold to every generation since first hitting the stage in 1594. The following quotes are part of the famous balcony scene — Act II, Scene II — when Romeo and Juliet agree to elope. Some of the most quoted lines from Shakespeare are from this scene "But, soft! what light through yonder window breaks? It is the east, and Juliet is the sun!" (2.2.2-3) What does it mean? Romeo, our young hero, already loves Juliet. In his words of adoration, he compares Juliet to a sunrise. Juliet hasn't seen Romeo below her window; she has no idea Romeo is even on her family's grounds. The important thing to take away is Romeo's use of language. Throughout the play, Romeo associates Juliet with 'light' imagery. He finds her love to be bright, sunny, and warm. "O Romeo, Romeo! wherefore art thou Romeo?" (2.2.33) What does it mean? Juliet is thinking about Romeo and his family ties. In Shakespearean times, "wherefore" meant "why". Juliet is asking why Romeo is a Montague. Although Juliet is unaware that Romeo is in the orchard below, she accurately points out a primary conflict in their relationship; their families probably won't accept or approve of their marriage. 31
You can also read