2019 Holiday Gift & Event Guide - Nov. 27 - Dec. 3, 2019 www.lansingcitypulse.com - City Pulse

Page created by Eddie Harrison
 
CONTINUE READING
2019 Holiday Gift & Event Guide - Nov. 27 - Dec. 3, 2019 www.lansingcitypulse.com - City Pulse
Nov. 27 - Dec. 3, 2019

www.lansingcitypulse.com   Locally owned • A newspaper for the rest of us

                                        2019 Holiday
                                         Gift & Event
                                               Guide
                                                              See page 12
2019 Holiday Gift & Event Guide - Nov. 27 - Dec. 3, 2019 www.lansingcitypulse.com - City Pulse
2   www.lansingcitypulse.com                         City Pulse • November 27, 2019

                                            Make sure your last
                                            holiday season with
                                           Mackerel Sky includes
                                           gifts with the fabulous
                                                 purple bow!

                            Enjoy the shopping
                          experience in Mackerel
                             Sky’s welcoming
                               atmosphere.

                          As you would expect,
                           we are chock full of
                         wonderful treats for all.

                         We always look forward
                             to seeing you.
2019 Holiday Gift & Event Guide - Nov. 27 - Dec. 3, 2019 www.lansingcitypulse.com - City Pulse
City Pulse • November 27, 2019                                       www.lansingcitypulse.com                                        3

   
   
   
   

                                                                                                Feel the joy of the Holiday Season
                                                                                                 with your favorite holiday tunes
                                                                                                  and traditional carols with the
                                                                                                Lansing Symphony Orchestra
                                                                                                   Holiday Pops Concert!
                                                                                                   Enter to win 2 tickets to the
                                                                                                     Holiday Pops Concert
                                                                                                     on December 22nd at
                                                                                                      lansingcitypulse.com

       517.999.999
       517.999.9999       sales@acd.net   1800 N Grand River Ave Lansing, MI
2019 Holiday Gift & Event Guide - Nov. 27 - Dec. 3, 2019 www.lansingcitypulse.com - City Pulse
4                   www.lansingcitypulse.com                                                               City Pulse • November 27, 2019

                                                                                                                               VOL. 19
                                                                                                                             ISSUE 16
                                 (517) 371-5600 • Fax: (517) 999-6061 • 1905 E. Michigan Ave. • Lansing, MI 48912 • www.lansingcitypulse.com
                                                                                          ADVERTISING INQUIRIES:    (517) 999-5061
                                                                                          or email citypulse@lansingcitypulse.com
                                                                            PAGE          CLASSIFIEDS: (517) 999-6704

                                                                              25              EDITOR AND PUBLISHER • Berl Schwartz
                                                                                               publisher@lansingcitypulse.com • (517) 999-5061
                                                                                              ARTS & CULTURE EDITOR • Audrey Matusz
                                                 Williamston Theatre brings six plays to life audrey@lansingcitypulse.com • (517) 999-5068
                                                                                              EVENTS EDITOR/OFFICE MANAGER • Suzi Smith
                                                                                                suzi@lansingcitypulse.com • (517) 999-6704
                                                                                              PRODUCTION MANAGER • Skyler Ashley
                                                                            PAGE               production@lansingcitypulse.com
                                                                                               (517) 999-5066
                                                                              27               Composition • Abby Sumbler
                                                                                              STAFF WRITERS • Lawrence Cosentino
                                                 Wellness abounds at new East Lansing shop lawrence@lansingcitypulse.com • (517) 999-5065
                                                                                               Dennis Burck • dennis@lansingcitypulse.com
                                                                                               (517) 999-6705
                                                                                               Kyle Kaminski • kyle@lansingcitypulse.com
                                                                            PAGE               (517) 999-6710

                                                                              33              SALES EXECUTIVE
                                                                                               Lee Purdy • lee@lansingcitypulse.com • (517) 999-5064
                                           Queers Who Brunch will celebrate local ingredients Contributors: Andy Balaskovitz, Justin Bilicki, Capital
                                                                                        News Service, Bill Castanier, Ryan Claytor, Mary C.
                                                                                        Cusack, Tom Helma, Gabrielle Lawrence Johnson, Terry
                                                                                        Link, Kyle Melinn, Mark Nixon, Dennis Preston, Carrie
                                                                           Cover        Sampson, Nevin Speerbrecker, Rich Tupica, Ute Von Der
                                                                                        Heyden, David Winkelstern, Paul Wozniak

                                                                             Art         Distribution manager:
                                                                                           Garrett Clinard • (517) 999-6704
                                                                                         Delivery drivers: Garrett Clinard, Dave Fisher, Dale
                                                                        By Skyler Ashley Gartner, Jack Sova, Gavin Smith
                                                                                         Interns: Matthew Stine • stinem47@gmail.com

NOW AT 10:00 A.M.
SUNDAYS on
2019 Holiday Gift & Event Guide - Nov. 27 - Dec. 3, 2019 www.lansingcitypulse.com - City Pulse
OF THE WEEK
City Pulse • November 27, 2019                                               www.lansingcitypulse.com                                                                                                      5

 PULSE                                                                                                                                       NEWS & OPINION
       Pondering public pool preservation
$1.24 million needed                                                                                                                                                              OF THE WEEK
to keep pool afloat
in Moores Park
   The future of one of the longest con-
tinuously operating public pools in the
nation remains uncertain as city offi-
cials grapple with a $1.2 million repair
bill and the possibility of summertime
heartbreak across Lansing.                                                                                                                           805 N. Seymour Ave., Lansing
   Lansing Mayor Andy Schor                                                                                                                              Owner: Kevin Schoen
announced last week he would consid-                                                                                                                  The massive brick house that has
er “just about everything” to keep the                                                                                                             commanded the northwest corner
97-year-old Moores Park Pool open for                                                                                                              of Seymour Avenue and Madison
another season. But with thousands                                                                                                                 Street for 110 years is finally getting
of gallons leaking out every summer,                                                                                                               a makeover, according to its owner,
pipes rusting and concrete cracking                                                                                                                Kevin Schoen.
— and the possibility that the pool's                                                                                                                 Schoen, the CEO of internet pro-
chlorinated water is seeping into the                                                                                                              vider ACD.net, bought the house at
Grand River — its continued operation                                                                                                              805 N. Seymour in 2014 at a bank
remains in jeopardy without some cash                                                                                                              auction for $20,500. He plans to
to fix it, he said.                                                                                                     Skyler Ashley/City Pulse   convert the house into apartments.
   “It’s time for us to address the prob-     Dale Schrader (left) and Bill Castanier (right) are considering a joint fundraising                     Since Schoen bought the house
lems with this pool rather than putting       effort to help fund the fixes.                                                                       five years ago, frustrated neighbors
$100,000 every year into Band-Aids,                                                                                                                have watched the 1909 edifice slide
which aren’t working because it’s still       idents.                                       expensive) to maintain.                                downhill fast. The stately porches,
leaking,” Schor said.                            “There’s a track record in Lansing of         The city pays about $100,000 annu-                  held up by Ionic columns, appear
   Schor said the whole job does not          public and private partnerships, and I        ally to keep the pool open, but a recent               on the verge of collapse, with yel-
need to be done in one year, “but I need      could certainly see this happening for        Park Department report shows the cost                  low tape around the east porch. The
to fund some of the fixes.”                   the pool,” Castanier added. “This is          of decades of neglected maintenance.                   main floor windows are boarded.
   Schor and a few City Council mem-          important and could be part of our leg-       Rusted piping needs to be replaced.                    Several upstairs windows are gone
bers — with only so much cash to              acy for the next generation. We don’t         Discharge valves spill directly into the               but not boarded up, leaving the
spread across more than 100 different         often get the chance to look at some-         Grand River and need to be rerouted.                   interior vulnerable to the elements.
parks — are hesitant to float the repair      thing this significant and have an abil-      The concrete interior is forming several                  Dale Schrader, who lives near
costs in their entirety. The city has since   ity to do something about it.”                cracks.                                                the house, is angry that Schoen has
turned to the local philanthropic com-           “This could find some broad support           The cost for the “needed” repairs                   waited so long to restore it while it
munity to churn up suggestions. And           in the city,” added Preservation Lansing      rests at $1.24 million — with room to                  continues to deteriorate. Schrader
it doesn’t look like the pool will sink       President Dale Schrader. “It’s unique,        grow.                                                  is president of Preservation Lansing
without a fight.                              but it’s more than just a mere relic of          Also, Schor said the pool — for                     and has rehabbed several houses in
   “There’s always a big price tag with       our past. The community still uses this       unknown reasons — loses 8-10 inches                    the area.
anything of architectural and histor-         space. It makes our city more livable.        of water daily. And given its proximity                   His preservation instincts
ical significance, said Bill Castanier,       It attracts tourists. It’s really something   to the riverfront, the chlorinated pol-                inflame every time he looks at the
president of the Historical Society of        for Lansing to be proud of. We can’t          lution may be finding its way into the                 house.
Greater Lansing. (Castanier is an edi-        afford to lose it.”                           Grand River. That’ll need to be fix No.                   “I drive by it every day and I
torial contributor to City Pulse.)               The egg-shaped public pool along           1, Schor said.                                         can’t believe there are windows
   “The question this city really needs to    Moores River Drive was built. Designed           “I don’t know how much it costs to                  open, with rain and birds flying in,”
answer is whether this is worth saving        by former city engineer Wesley Bintz,         continually refill, but between that and               he said. “Five years and very little
and whether we’d all be willing to put        the pool is believed to be one of only        the damage that is done to the river and               progress is way too long. He should
in some blood, sweat and tears in order       five of its design that have survived         environment through leakage, it’s a big                at least seal those windows off and
to save the pool.”                            beyond the first half of the 20th centu-      problem,” Schor added. “I didn’t know
   Castanier said the Historical Society      ry. Only a few still operate today.           about the unknown drainage until the                                              See Eyesore, Page 6
and Preservation Lansing are eyeing              But while the iconic pools, with their     season was underway. Either way, it’s
                                              concrete archways and unique, above-          in really bad shape and this needs to be               “Eyesore of the Week” is our look at some
early plans to launch a joint fundrais-                                                                                                            of the seedier properties in Lansing. It rotates with
ing campaign. Donations could flow            ground design, serve a certain histori-       addressed.”                                            Eye Candy of the Week and Eye for Design. Have
                                                                                                                                                   a suggestion? Email eye@lansingcitypulse.com or
from local businesses, developers and         cal significance to the community, they                                                              call it in at 517-999-6715.
the more passionate neighborhood res-         can also be notoriously difficult (and                                   See Pool, Page 6
2019 Holiday Gift & Event Guide - Nov. 27 - Dec. 3, 2019 www.lansingcitypulse.com - City Pulse
6                                                                           www.lansingcitypulse.com                                              City Pulse • November 27, 2019

Pool                                         tenance and other pet projects (like
                                             wireless Internet installation) usually
                                             only leave room for a few additional
                                                                                           now would be to knock it down.”
                                                                                              The city of Tampa, Florida, offered
                                                                                           one of only a few — albeit expensive
                                                                                                                                       to split the cost of repairing the pool
                                                                                                                                       between the city, the county and oth-
                                                                                                                                       er sources like state grants and private
                                             improvements each year.                       — success stories after it reopened its     donations. Plans are far from solidified,
from page 5
                                                And the City Council has to be mind-       Bintz pool in 2016 at a cost of more        but he’d also like to tap into the coun-
   Castanier recognizes the funding          ful of the entire city — not just the nos-    than $3.2 million. Leaks forced city        ty’s parks and trails millage to supplant
challenge but plans to resist the possi-     talgic end of Moores River Drive.             officials to close the pool in 2009, and    some of the repair costs.
bility of closure by any means necessary.       “$1.2 million is a lot of money,”          neighborhood residents rallied for five        “This pool means a lot to the commu-
   “I’ve informally polled my board,         said City Council Vice President Peter        years to raise cash before the city allo-   nity and to Lansing’s history,” Morgan
and it sounds like we’re interested in       Spadafore. “It’s over half of our parks       cated its own resources to the effort.      said. “At the same time, it’s not fair to
getting behind an effort to help save        millage. Spending that on one project            “I recognize the nostalgia,” added       residents paying the city’s parks mill-
it, whether that means private or pub-       means numerous projects across the            Councilwoman Patricia Spitzley. “But        age to have more than half going to any
lic fundraising or something else alto-      rest of the city will be neglected. I’m all   as an at-large member, I don’t know         one single project. There are 100 parks
gether,” Castanier added. “This goes         ears for ways to try and save the pool,       if I’m comfortable saying we’re going       across the city, and lots of projects wait-
well beyond the city’s resources, but 50     and I think the city should have some         to spend $1 million-plus to repair this     ing to get done.
years from now, if we allow it to disap-     skin in the game, but I’m hoping the          thing. I’m still supportive of keeping         While the pool continues to deterio-
pear, we’ll regret that decision.”           philanthropic and business communi-           the space natural or trying to find some    rate, records show its popularity among
   The conversation surrounding the          ties are willing to come to the table and     other beneficial, recreational use like a   Lansing residents has only grown. City
future of the Moores Park Pool — one         keep this local asset afloat.”                splashpad. I’m still open to ideas.”        data shows the number of annual vis-
of three city pools — is a familiar one:        Schor is weighing alternative uses for        Councilman Brian Jackson, whose          its more than doubled from 2,969 in
$1.2 million could spruce up a lot of        the pool in the event of its closure, but     ward encompasses the Moores Park            2014 to 6,078 this year. It leaves offi-
playgrounds in a lot of different parks.     noted demolition is not an option.            neighborhood, suggested the pool            cials with a million-dollar question: Is
How much cash can the city justify              Bintz pools have been closing across       could be reopened next summer for           it worth keeping the investment alive?
pouring into one facility that only oper-    the country for decades. The city of          less than $1.2 million as officials track      “I look at this $1.2 million and our
ates 10 weeks out of the year?               Weirton, West Virginia — faced with           down a more sustainable way to pay for      robust park system — 16 miles of
   “We have other parks and equipment        more than $1 million in repair costs          the long-term renovations. He’d like        trails and 114 parks — and we’re still
that need our attention and I just don’t     of its own — was forced to shutter its        the city to put up some stopgap cash as     trying to make sure we can keep that
see how we can justify spending all of       pool in 2007. Today, it’s nothing but         the pool preservation efforts continue.     whole system going,” said Third Ward
this money on one pool,” explained           a makeshift storage facility awaiting            “It’s not so much about the preserva-    Councilman Adam Hussain. “We need
Councilwoman Jody Washington. “I             demolition. Officials there blamed            tion aspect for me, but it’s more about     to look for different revenue sources to
just don’t think it’s feasible. It saddens   unsurmountable costs for its demise.          the service this pool provides to kids      keep the pool open in perpetuity, but I
me. It really does, but I just don’t see        “We’re thinking about maintaining          during the summer when they have            do believe that money is out there.”
what else can be done without some           the front part or an archway to pre-          nothing else to do,” Jackson added.            City officials encourage those with
other revenue coming in.”                    serve some of the original structure,”        “There are voices in that neighborhood      suggestions on the future operation of
   Lansing’s parks millage brings in         said Weirton Parks and Recreation             that want to see these younger kids         Moores Park Pool to contact the city’s
about $2.1 million annually, but last        Director Coty Shingle. “We’ve talked          have something positive to do rather        Park Board at parkboard@listserv.lan-
year about $600,000 was used to              about opening up some type of skating         than sit around with idle hands.”           singmi.gov. Visit lansingcitypulse.com
subsidize the city’s cemeteries and          rink. I think people realized this was a         Ingham County Commissioner               for previous and continued coverage.
Groesbeck Golf Course. Annual main-          bit of a pipe dream. The easiest thing        Thomas Morgan is also exploring plans       —KYLE KAMINSKI

Eyesore                                                                                    upper-end housing is already saturat-
                                                                                           ed” in the area.
                                                                                              The house was originally a “four-
                                                                                                                                       ished.
                                                                                                                                         A funky, twisted set of steps to the
                                                                                                                                       second floor will probably have to go,
from page 5                                                                                plex,” an unusual layout of four sepa-      though.
                                                                                           rate units, so the conversion will not be     “We’ll have to reconstruct the stair-
be a better steward of that house for the                                                  a stretch, design-wise. Schoen expects      ways so they’re up to modern code,”
neighborhood.”                                                                             the high ceilings to add to the units’      Schoen said.
  Schoen said he has been gradually                                                        appeal.                                       When rehab work is complete, the
laying the groundwork. Last year, he                                                          But it will take a lot of work and       house will have two two-bedroom units
put a new roof on the house at a cost        None of the fancy Victorian architec-         material cost to make those four units      and two three-bedroom units, Schoen
of $35,000. The interior plaster and         tural styles seem to apply. There isn’t       inhabitable.                                said.
truckloads of miscellaneous debris have      much decoration, except for a deli-              “The only way to get these things up       The third floor attic, with its low,
been removed.                                cate latticework pattern on top of the        to spec is to go full guts on them, bring   angled ceiling and spectacular window
  “Structurally, it’s in very good shape,”   upstairs windows. If it’s a Queen Anne        all the plumbing and electrical to code,”   views, will make a cozy set of bedrooms.
Schoen said. “That’s why it’s best to        house, she’s not wearing any makeup.          Schoen said.                                  Schoen said he has no set timetable
retain these older brick properties. It’s    “Neoclassical” might be more apt, but            Inside, the plaster walls are gone       to finish the job.
difficult to rebuild them or build some-     the columned porches are only one sto-        and the house is stripped to its studs.       “Realistically, if I do it correctly, it’s
thing similar these days.”                   ry high instead of two, perhaps out of        The copper pipes were stolen from the       going to be two years,” he said.
  The house’s red brick shell is as          Midwestern modesty.                           house long ago. Even in the pitch-black       Schoen said he never seriously con-
impressive as ever. When viewed from           Schoen estimates it will cost him           gloom of the first floor, where the win-    sidered pulling a permit for demolition.
the corner, its sheer size and striking      “easily a half million or more” to bring      dows are boarded up, two spacious liv-        “That’s a bad thing to do,” Schoen
symmetry make it look like as if it’s        the 4,000-square-foot house up to             ing rooms with bay windows and a fire-      said. “It would just be an empty lot.
multiplying into two or more houses.         snuff. He intends to turn the house into      place make for an inviting space.           Urban infill isn’t really occurring these
  Many homes of the period flaunt            four market rate housing units. He said          The stairway banister and upstairs       days. It’s definitely best to keep these
their filigrees or announce their owner’s    he’ll need to charge $1,300 to $1,400         railing, made of polished hardwood, is      brick structures, even if it takes a while
wealth, but the Seymour house speaks         monthly rent to make the project via-         in excellent shape and will likely be a     to rehab them.”
in low tones of solidity and function.       ble, but he fears that “the market for        star attraction when the project is fin-    — LAWRENCE COSENTINO
2019 Holiday Gift & Event Guide - Nov. 27 - Dec. 3, 2019 www.lansingcitypulse.com - City Pulse
City Pulse • November 27, 2019                                                www.lansingcitypulse.com                                                                                       7

      LETTERS
                                            Have something to say about a local issue                                   CHARTER TOWNSHIP OF LANSING
                                            or an item that appeared in our pages?                                      SYNOPSIS OF PROPOSED MINUTES
                                            Now you have two ways to sound off:

    to the editor                           1.) Write a letter to the editor.
                                            • E-mail: letters@ lansingcitypulse.com
                                            • Snail mail: City Pulse,
                                                                                              A REGULAR MEETING OF THE BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF THE CHARTER TOWNSHIP
                                                                                              OF LANSING WAS HELD AT THE TOWNSHIP OFFICES LOCATED AT 3209 WEST
                                                                                              MICHIGAN AVENUE, LANSING, MICHIGAN ON TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 12, 2019, AT
                                                                                              7:00 P.M.
                                               1905 E. Michigan Ave.,
Try again, Andy                                Lansing, MI 48912                              MEMBERS PRESENT:        Supervisor Hayes, Clerk Aten
   The train wreck that was the             • Fax: (517) 371-5800                             		                      Trustees: Broughton, Harris, McKenzie, Bankson
appointment of the latest BWL com-          • At lansingcitypulse.com                         MEMBERS ABSENT:         Treasurer Rodgers
missioner demonstrates a distinct           2.) Write a guest column:                         ALSO PRESENT:           Michael Gresens, Attorney
lack of thought and consideration.          Contact Berl Schwartz for more                    ACTION TAKEN BY THE BOARD:
The train started going off the rails       information:                                      Meeting called to order by Supervisor Hayes.
when the mayor failed to consider a         publisher@lansingcitypulse.com                    Minutes of the meeting held on October 29, 2019 approved.
highly qualified candidate, choosing to     or (517) 999-5061                                 Agenda approved.
                                            (Please include your name, address and            Authorized Supervisor to provide a letter in Support of Acquisition of Adjacent Property for
“beat the bushes to find an applicant”                                                        the UAW Local 602.
instead. Apologizing for the “over-         telephone number so we can reach you.
                                            Keep letters to 250 words or fewer. City          Rental fund budget approved.
sight” is not enough. Why was Payne                                                           West Side Water budget approved.
ignored when she had already been           Pulse reserves the right to edit letters and      Designated Clerk as Chair Pro Tem in absence of Supervisor.
                                            columns.                                          Approved 2020 meeting dates.
contacted by the mayor’s office? Are
                                                                                              Claims approved.
these appointments taken so lightly                                                           Meeting adjourned.
that no one noticed that they had a        ‘Forgotten’ BWL
qualified applicant? Or were there                                                            Diontrae Hayes, Supervisor
other considerations that led the may-     candidate speaks out                               Susan L. Aten, Clerk			                   			                                    CP#19-341
or’s office to look elsewhere? In the         Regarding last week’s story that the
absence of an explanation, it is easy      mayor told the city council he had to dig
to imagine palace intrigue accompa-        deep to find a 3rd ward candidate for                                        CITY OF EAST LANSING, MICHIGAN
nying this appointment.                    the BWL board because there were no
   The reaction from city council was      applicants, while my application was                                                 NOTICE OF ADOPTION
equally distressing. With the excep-       there all along, my response is… real-                                               ORDINANCE NO. 1468
tion of Brian Jackson, council down-       ly? Either his staff is incompetent and                AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND THE ZONING USE DISTRICT MAP OF
played the fact that the BWL Board         “forgot” to tell him there was an appli-               CHAPTER 50 -- ZONING -- OF THE CODE OF THE CITY OF EAST LANSING
of Commissioners oversees a highly         cant (though they had just emailed me
technical, $355 million a year com-        asking I was still interested) or Mayor            Please take notice that Ordinance No. 1468 was adopted by the City of East Lansing City
                                           Schor didn’t want me on the board.                 Council at their meeting held on November 12, 2019 and will become effective upon the
pany that is responsible for a large                                                          expiration of seven (7) days after the publication of the following summary of ordinance.
percentage of greenhouse gas emis-            I can only conclude that, since I
sions in the Lansing region. Instead       have spoken out at BWL meetings and                                          SUMMARY OF ORDINANCE NO. 1468
they treat is as just another seat on      met with their leadership urging them
one of Lansing’s many boards and           to lower fossil-fuel use in the face of            THE CITY OF EAST LANSING ORDAINS:
commissions. Effective governance          climate change, the mayor and BWL                  Ordinance 1468 amends the Zoning Use District Map by rezoning the properties at 710,
at BWL requires commissioners who          do not want a person with an environ-              722, and 722 ½ Grove Street from R-2, Medium Density Single-Family Residential District,
have the background and under-             mental bent on their board.                        to RM-32, City Center Multiple-Family Residential District.
standing to evaluate information and          Would having one person on the
data presented by management. It           BWL’s board who recognizes the long-               A true copy of Ordinance No. 1468 can be inspected or obtained at the Office of the City
                                                                                              Clerk at City Hall, 410 Abbot Road, East Lansing, Michigan during normal business hours.
is not enough for an individual to be      term costs of continuing with fossil-fu-
“willing to learn and engage” and “get     els mean that the lights would go out              					Jennifer Shuster
up to speed.” Other city boards have       in Lansing? Hardly. So why am I so                 					City Clerk
subject expertise: the Mechanical          scary?                                             					                                                                            CP#19-342
Board has seats for contractors, and          The Lansing Area Environmental
four of the six seats on the Board of      Action Team, of which I am a mem-
Plumbing are allocated to plumbers.        ber, gave the BWL a 10-point plan                                            CITY OF EAST LANSING, MICHIGAN
Given the scale of its operations          for lowering fossil fuel use with some
                                           practical and doable ideas, including                                                NOTICE OF ADOPTION
and importance of its work, the BWL                                                                                             ORDINANCE NO. 1459
Board must have expert knowledge           building smaller decentralized power
among its commissioners. It is right       facilities, more reliance on solar and                 AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND AND RENAME ARTICLE VI - DISTRIBUTED
that some seats be open to any resi-       wind, using all-source bidding to open                 ANTENNA SYSTEMS AND SMALL CELL NETWORKS - AND AMEND SECTIONS
dent, but good governance requires a       the power generating bidding to a wid-                 42-271, 42-272 AND 42-273 AND ADD SECTIONS 42-274 THROUGH 42-288
                                                                                                  TO CHAPTER 42 - TELECOMMUNICATIONS - OF THE CODE OF THE CITY
higher level of expertise on the BWL       er range of options, and adding on-bill                OF EAST LANSING TO REGULATE SMALL WIRELESS COMMUNICATIONS
board.                                     financing to help consumers pay for                    FACILITIES DEPLOYMENT IN ACCORDANCE WITH STATE LAW
   The mayor will have the opportunity     efficiency and green energy projects.
to appoint two new commissioners           I could go on. Some of these could                 Please take notice that Ordinance No. 1459 was adopted by the City of East Lansing City
                                           actually save money and all would – of             Council at their meeting held on November 19, 2019 and will become effective upon the
in 2020. The climate emergency                                                                expiration of seven (7) days after the publication of the following summary of ordinance.
demands commissioners who will             course – lower pollution, and the con-
bring innovative thinking to BWL. The      comitant health issues. Nothing on that                                      SUMMARY OF ORDINANCE NO. 1459
Lansing Environmental Action Team          list screamed “radical” or “dangerous.”
will continue to insist that we can wait      This action by the mayor should be              THE CITY OF EAST LANSING ORDAINS:
no longer for action, both at BWL and      a wake-up call for those concerned                 Ordinance 1459 amends and renames Article VI – Distributed Antenna Systems and Small
the city. For more about LEAT, visit       with climate change. By bypassing                  Cell Networks and amends Sections 42-271, 42-272, and 42-273, and adds Sections 42-274
our Facebook page or send email            someone who speaks out to lower fos-               through 42-288 of the Code of the City of East Lansing by amending the requirements for
to info@lansingenvironmentalaction-        sil-fuel use, the mayor and BWL are                small cell wireless communications facilities deployment to be consistent with Public Act
                                           letting us know they are not interested            365 of 2018 and to require zoning review and approval in limited circumstances.
team.org.
    Randy Dykhuis                          in moving out of their comfort zone to             A true copy of Ordinance No. 1459 can be inspected or obtained at the Office of the City
   Lansing                                 address the climate change emergen-                Clerk at City Hall, 410 Abbot Road, East Lansing, Michigan during normal business hours.
                                           cy.
                                              And that, my friends, is very scary.            					Jennifer Shuster
                                                                                              					City Clerk
                                              Rebecca Payne                                   					                                                                            CP#19-343
                                              Lansing
2019 Holiday Gift & Event Guide - Nov. 27 - Dec. 3, 2019 www.lansingcitypulse.com - City Pulse
8                                                                                                     www.lansingcitypulse.com                                                     City Pulse • November 27, 2019

                   Alternate universe
                                                                                                                    the essential facts, and those facts               paign but of sinister forces conspir-
                                                                                                                    show a president who solicited for-                ing against him.
                                                                                                                    eign interference in American elec-                   Rep. Devin Nunes and other
                                                                                                                    tions and attempted to extort that                 Republicans on the Intelligence
    Donald Trump isn’t on trial. The Republican Party is.                                                           foreign interference by withholding                Committee used the hearings to put
                                                                                                                    military aid to an ally.                           this alternate universe on full display
   The most inci-                                                        their president’s crimes; this time,          If those aren’t impeachable offens-             and then became indignant when

                                                      INFORMED DISSENT
sive moment of the                                                       they’ve closed ranks and chosen will-      es, nothing is.                                    witnesses said they had no idea what
impeachment inqui-                                                       ful ignorance and and conspiratorial          And yet, when all is said and done,             the hell they were talking about.
ry’s public hearings                                                     fantasies.                                 every single Republican represen-                  As Frum puts it: “To those not
came at the very                                                            Schiff is correct: The impeachment      tative and senator is likely to vote               immersed in the fantasy franchise,
end, on Thursday                                                         of Donald Trump is no longer about         against impeaching or removing                     people like Devin Nunes sound
                                       JEFFERY C. BILLMAN
afternoon, courte-                                                       Donald Trump. This is instead a            Donald Trump, in the process both                  like crazy people. Which in turn, of
sy of Intelligence                                                       trial of the Republican Party — and        sanctioning his actions and delegit-               course, only drives them crazier.”
Committee Chairman Adam Schiff,                                          of the ability of our democratic insti-    imizing the inquiry as — to borrow                    This would be amusing if the
the former federal prosecutor who                                        tutions to serve as a check on a thor-     Trump’s favorite phrase — a witch-                 consequences weren’t so dire, if
had spent two weeks methodical-                                          oughly corrupt would-be strongman.         hunt.                                              this were just some Bircher fringe,
ly constructing a case that Donald                                          And both are going to fail the test.       To be sure, this impeachment                    not the driving force of the modern
Trump had wantonly abused his                                               At the risk of beating a dead horse,    is a partisan affair, but viewing                  GOP, from the president to Congress
office only to watch his Republican                                      there’s no ambiguity about what            it through a red-versus-blue lens                  to the propaganda machines from
colleagues bury their heads in the                                       happened. As Gordon Sondland,              obscures a more dangerous reality:                 which tens of millions of Americans
sand.                                                                    Trump’s ambassador to the                  America’s dominant political party                 get their information. Being an
   “What we’ve seen here is far more                                     European Union — a hotel owner             is fundamentally broken, an author-                elected Republican in 2019 means
serious than a third-rate burglary of                                    who literally purchased his post with      itarian cult of personality locked in              chugging the Kool-Aid — or at least
the Democratic headquarters,” Schiff                                     a $1 million donation to Trump’s           its own propaganda feedback loop.                  pretending you have.
said, referencing Watergate. This “is                                    inaugural committee — had admit-              As George W. Bush speechwrit-                      That’s why Republicans are going
beyond anything Nixon did. The dif-                                      ted a day earlier, there was a quid        er David Frum explains in The                      to give Trump the pass their prede-
ference between then and now is not                                      pro quo that came directly from the        Atlantic: “Rupert Murdoch, Roger                   cessors didn’t give Nixon.
the difference between Nixon and                                         White House. Trump conditioned an          Ailes, and the others have fenced                     The Republican Party is broken.
Trump. It’s the difference between                                       Oval Office meeting with Ukraine’s         off conservative Americans from the                And the longer it stays in power, the
that Congress and this one.”                                             new president — who, while fighting        rest of American society. Within that              more likely it is to break our entire
   Richard Nixon, of course, resigned                                    a war with Russia, needed to demon-        safe space, insiders hear only what is             democracy, too.
                                        in 1974                          strate his deep ties to Washington         familiar and comforting.”                             (Jeffrey Billman is the editor
                                        after top                        — on the announcement of sham                 Within this safe space — which                  of INDY Week, in Durham, North
       NOTICE TO CREDITORS
           Decedent's Trust             Republicans                      investigations into political rival Joe    has its own language, a hallucino-                 Carolina.)
  TO ALL CREDITORS, the
  Settlor, Kenneth S. Parr, DOB:
                                        told him that                    Biden and a debunked conspiracy            genic hodgepodge of names and
  12/09/1935 of 2700 Burcham
  Drive, East Lansing MI 48823,
                                        the evidence                     theory that Ukraine had conspired          catch-phrases — the hearings didn’t
  died 10/27/2019. There is no
  personal representative of the
                                        of his crimes                    with the Democrats to frame Russia         produce a straightforward narra-                                               STATE OF MICHIGAN
                                                                                                                                                                                                     PROBATE COURT
                                                                                                                                                                                                   COUNTY OF INGHAM
  Settlor's estate to whom Letters of
  Administration have been issued.
                                        was too great                    for election interference in 2016.         tive of corruption but evidence of a                                             PUBLICATION OF
                                                                                                                                                                                                   NOTICE OF HEARING
  Creditors of the decedent are
  notified that all claims against the  to ignore.                          To up the ante, Trump then over-        Deep State cover-up. There is a “fake                                           FILE NO 19-1367-GM
  Kenneth S. Parr and Carol M. Parr                                                                                                                                                          In the matter of Ke'Aylah Elese
  Living Trust, dated 02/27/2009,       Forty-five                       ruled his advisers and blocked near-       whistleblower” and a “Russia hoax”                                       Ariel Smith.
  will be forever banned unless                                                                                                                                                              TO ALL INTERESTED PERSONS
  presented to co-trustees Philip       years lat-                       ly $400 million in military aid to         and a “Black Ledger” and collusion                                       including: Ashanna Smith, whose
  S. Parr and Robert S. Sloan,                                                                                                                                                               address(es) are unknown and
  within 4 months after the date of     er, con-                         assist Ukraine’s war against Russia.       between a DNC operative and the                                          whose interest in the matter
  publication or attorney Bradley A.                                                                                                                                                         may be barred or affected by the
  Vauter J.D. (P35762) of Bradley       gressional                       Sondland and everyone else could           Ukrainian embassy and — courtesy                                         following:
  Vauter & Associates, P.C., 1193                                                                                                                                                            TAKE NOTICE: A hearing will be
  Andre Dr. Ste. D, Grand Ledge MI      Republicans                      read between the lines, but there          of Glenn Beck — a rehash of the                                          held on 12-5-2019 at 2:30 p.m.
  48837, (517) 853-8015.                                                                                                                                                                     at 313 W. Kalamazoo, Lansing,
                                        are again                        was no need to: In a July 25 phone         (((George Soros)))-as-puppet-master                                      before Judge Dunnings, for the
                                                                                                                                                                                             following purpose: for guardianship
  Trustee Philip S. Parr
  313 W. Barnes Ave.                    faced with                       call, Trump directly linked a request      trope.                                                                   of Ke'Aylah Elese Ariel Smith.
  Lansing MI 48910

  Trustee Robert S. Sloan
                                        equally                          for military assistance to the “favor”        In this alternate universe, the real                                  Date: 11-21-19
                                                                                                                                                                                             Kimberlyn Trice
  PO Box 173
  Goldenrod, FL 32733.
                                        unassailable                     of opening the investigations.             story isn’t the president abusing his                                    1119 Leslie St.
                                                                                                                                                                                             Lansing, MI 48912
                           CP#19-346    evidence of                         Again, there’s no real dispute over     office to further his reelection cam-                                                          CP#19-345

                 NOTICE OF ANNUAL MEETING AND ELECTION OF DIRECTORS                                                                                      CITY OF LANSING
                            INGHAM CONSERVATION DISTRICT                                                                                            NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING

              To all residents of the Ingham Conservation District, notice is hereby given that                       NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that a Public Hearing will be held on Monday, Monday,
    on the 15th day of January 2020, between the hours of 5:30 pm and 8:30 pm, at Piazzano’s,                         December 2, 2019 at 7:00 p.m. in the City Council Chambers, 10th Floor Lansing City Hall,
    1825 N. Grand River Ave., in the City of Lansing, an annual meeting and director’s election will                  124 W. Michigan Ave., Lansing, MI for the purpose of considering:
    be held. Charlie Martin is on the ballot for a 4-year term as an Ingham Conservation District
    Board Director.                                                                                                    An Ordinance of the City of Lansing, Michigan, to amend Chapter 404 of the Lansing
                                                                                                                       Codified Ordinances by adding Section 404.13 to provide for the issuance of annual and
              The event will include dinner, silent auction, natural resource conservation updates                     temporary 2:00 a.m. to 5:00 a.m. street parking permits to City of Lansing residents; and to
    and a presentation entitled “Ingham County Rural – A Township Tour through the Seasons”                            provide for permit applications, limitations and fees.
    by local conservationist Jim Hewitt. Dinner tickets are $10.00 and are available at www.
    inghamconservation.com.                                                                                           For more information, please call 517-483-4177. If you are interested in this matter, please
                                                                                                                      attend the public hearing or send a representative. Written comments will be accepted
               On the 2nd day of December, 2019, being the business day nearest to 45 days prior                      between 8 a.m. and 5 p.m. on City business days if received before 5 p.m., on the day of
    to the date of the annual meeting, absentee ballots are available for voting in this election at                  the Public Hearing at the City Clerk’s Office, Ninth Floor, City Hall, 124 West Michigan Ave.,
    the Conservation District office located at 1031 W. Dexter Trail, in the City of Mason, during                    Lansing, MI 48933 or email city.clerk@lansingmi.gov.
    the regular business hours of the Conservation District which are 9:00 am and 3:00 pm
    Monday – Thursday. Residents are individuals of legal age who can demonstrate residency                           Chris Swope, Lansing City Clerk, MMC/CMMC
    in the Conservation District (Ingham County) via one piece of identification.                                     www.lansingmi.gov/Clerk
     		 		                                                                             CP#19-344                      www.facebook.com/LansingClerkSwope			                                               CP#19-340
2019 Holiday Gift & Event Guide - Nov. 27 - Dec. 3, 2019 www.lansingcitypulse.com - City Pulse
City Pulse • November 27, 2019                                         www.lansingcitypulse.com                                                                        9

 Former tennis coach sues Lansing Catholic High
 Lawsuit: School                                                                     wasn’t fired. He retired.”                 and has undoubtedly worsened any
                                                                                        A copy of the high school’s 2017        possible prospects for future employ-
 officials misled                                                                    message to parents wasn’t includ-          ment.
 parents on retirement                                                               ed in court records, but a retraction        Court records further state Landfair
                                                                                     demand sent by Lopez before the law-       waited until this year to demand a
    A former tennis coach at Lansing                                                 suit claimed it included the language      retraction for the now 2-year-old mes-
 Catholic High School is suing the                                                   “let go” rather than “retired” and had     sage only because he was previously
 Catholic Diocese of Lansing, claim-                                                 wrongly implied that Landfair was in       unaware that it had been sent.
 ing school officials misled parents                                                 some way involved with messages to           Officials at the diocese didn’t return
 into thinking he was fired from the                                                 students that were deemed “inappro-        phone calls for this story, but court
 job when he had actually been able to                                               priate.”                                   records show their attorneys dispute
 retire.                                                                                Landfair worked for the Diocese for     the bulk of Landfair’s contentions.
    Ron Landfair, longtime boys’ varsi-                                              more than 20 years, most recently as         Tom Meagher, attorney for the
 ty tennis coach and ministry director,                                              its director of multicultural ministries   diocese and Lansing Catholic High
 filed a lawsuit in April alleging that                                              — an outreach position left unfilled       School, said the suit lacks merit. “He
 school officials — in an intention-                                                 since his departure in October 2017.       said he was intentionally defamed. We
 ally misleading message to parents       damages for defamation and inten-
                                                                                     He also served several years as varsity    don’t think that’s the case.”
 — implied they had fired Landfair in     tional infliction of emotional distress.
                                                                                     boys’ tennis coach at Lansing Catholic       Meagher declined to elaborate on
 2017 following “inappropriate” text      The complaint also contends school
                                                                                     High School and repeatedly led the         his defense as the case proceeds in
 messages with a student, when instead    officials painted Landfair in a “false
                                                                                     team to state championship games.          30th Circuit Court. Records show the
 Landfair had been left to peacefully     light.”
                                                                                        Landfair declined to comment for        lawsuit has been referred to third-par-
 retire.                                     “Mr. Landfair retired with a supe-
                                                                                     this story, but his lawsuit also claims    ty mediation in an attempt to reach a
    The lawsuit specifically names        rior record,” said Landfair’s attorney,
                                                                                     the subsequent damage to his rep-          resolution ahead of a trial.
 the Diocese of Lansing, Bishop Earl      Karen Lopez. “He had an excellent
                                                                                     utation caused by the implication of         Visit lansingcitypulse.com for con-
 Boyea, Lansing Catholic High School      record, yet they put out this defamato-
                                                                                     termination and misconduct has only        tinued coverage as the litigation con-
 and Principal Doug Moore and seeks       ry message that somehow he had been
                                                                                     caused emotional distress, embarrass-      tinues.
 to recover more than $25,000 in          ‘let go.’ That implies he was fired. He
                                                                                     ment, humiliation, anxiety, depression      — KYLE KAMINSKI
2019 Holiday Gift & Event Guide - Nov. 27 - Dec. 3, 2019 www.lansingcitypulse.com - City Pulse
10                                                                                   www.lansingcitypulse.com                                              City Pulse • November 27, 2019

‘Unconscious bias’ plagues Ingham Co. health insurance
Life-saving drugs                                 of the cul-                                                                                                                “We’re in a
excluded for HIV,                                 tural stigmas                                                                                                            fortunate sit-
                                                  attached        to                                                                                                       uation where
gender transition                                 HIV.                                                                                                                     we might be
   Ingham County could soon revamp                   “I fell victim                                                                                                        able to make
its health insurance offerings after              to discrimina-                                                                                                           some of these
officials found that multiple employ-             tory prescrip-                                                                                                           determi-
ees have had difficulty accessing                 tion coverage                                                                                                            nations for
name-brand HIV treatment and other                and procedures                                                                                                           o u r s e l v e s ,”
medications to facilitate gender tran-            that direc tly                                                                                                           Dolehanty
sitions.                                          contradict the Sebolt                            Crenshaw             Heywood                 Naeyaert                   added.           “I
   And some county commission-                    core values that                                                                                                         don’ t know
ers contended an “unconscious bias”               Ingham County                                       “The policy as it exists literally                                   why this is
against those with HIV and the                    has laid out for me,” he told commis-            excludes every transgender employee.         happening, but we’ll be sure to find
LGBTQ community could be blamed                   sioners. “I would have to switch to a            That is unacceptable. That is discrim-       out so we can address the problem.
for the access issues as they look to             generic drug. Without that prescrip-             ination,” said Todd Heywood, board           The focus is all about getting employ-
level the playing field on prescription           tion coverage, I’m forced to use tem-            chairman at Ingham Community                 ees access to their medication as effi-
drugs.                                            porary assistance programs. … I’m                Health Center. “The only two chronic         ciently as possible.”
   “These medications can be a matter             here today to ask for help.”                     diseases or issues that require medi-           County employees, in theory, can
of life and death,” said Commissioner                Ingham County this year funneled              cation on the list of exclusions are         still access excluded medications,
Ryan Sebolt. “These are medications               its employee health insurance offer-             for HIV and for gender identity. This        but not without seeking an exception
that are literally keeping some people            ings into a self-funded pool that                whole system is deliberately designed        and repeatedly revealing their per-
alive. If you can’t access them, it shows         includes employees in the city of                to exclude people based on their oth-        sonal medical histories to the coun-
our coverage is lacking. Employees                Lansing and the Community Mental                 erness within the community.”                ty’s human resources department,
should not be jumping through hoops               Health Authority amid efforts to save               Commissioners are largely unclear         an insurance benefits facilitator and
to access their medication. This really           cash. Officials said the switchover is           how those specific medications man-          numerous other third-party assistance
is a top priority for the county.”                saving about $2 million annually, but            aged to find their way onto the list of      programs to piece the prescriptions
   An unnamed county employee liv-                it also includes a new list of exclusions.       exclusions for county employees, but         together.
ing with HIV confronted the commis-                  Among those excluded medica-                  they’ve launched an investigation to            And while that process might work
sion’s County Services Committee last             tions are standard fare for the health           eventually lift the restrictions. A forth-   for some, some officials said it can pose
week with complaints over difficulty              insurance industry: Botox; drugs to              coming report from county Controller         undue obstacles to proper coverage.
accessing a name-brand treatment                  induce abortions; anabolic steroids;             Tim Dolehanty is designed to provide            “It makes my skin crawl that some-
plan prescribed by his doctor. Those              anti-wrinkle agents; sexual dysfunc-             some answers next month.                     one would have to repeatedly dis-
medications, for reasons still under              tion medication; hair removal prod-                 “It’s just not acceptable that our        close their medical history like this,”
investigation, were found to be specif-           ucts; hair growth products. But it               employees have to go through this            said Commissioner Robin Naeyaert.
ically excluded from coverage.                    also specifically prohibits name-brand           type of stress or hassle in order to get     “Patients shouldn’t have to disclose
   City Pulse is withholding the iden-            HIV drugs and treatment for gender               life-saving drugs,” said Commission          that to anyone but their physicians.
tity of the employee in consideration             dysphoria.                                       Chairman Bryan Crenshaw. “We need            The idea that any employee would
                                                                                                   to get this right and very quickly. The      have to divulge such personal infor-
                                                                                                   biggest issue is making sure employ-         mation like this makes me physically
                               NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARINGS                                           ees have access to the medication they       ill.”
                               EAST LANSING CITY COUNCIL                                                                                           As an added consequence for
                                                                                                   need and deserve.”
  Notice is hereby given of the following public hearings to be held by the East Lansing City         Generic rather than name-brand            Ingham County’s prescription access
  Council on December 17, 2019 at 7:00 p.m., in the 54-B District Court, Courtroom 2, 101          HIV treatment medication, Heywood            issue, the Ingham Community Health
  Linden Street, East Lansing:
                                                                                                   explained, is often behind the curve         Center this year was demoted to a “top
     1. A public hearing will be held to consider a modified site plan and special use             of constantly evolving research on the       performer” rather than a “leader” in
       permit application from 341 Evergreen, LLC for the properties at 100 W. Grand               virus. Drugs that aren’t on the cut-         the Human Rights Campaign’s annual
       River Avenue, 120-140 W. Grand River Avenue and 341-345 Evergreen Avenue for a
       5-story residential building with one level of parking, including a mix of apartment        ting edge of medical technology often        Healthcare Equality Index. Officials
       types ranging from studios to three-bed units. The subject property zoned                   include a host of negative side effects      attributed the diminished status to the
       Conditional B-3, City Center Commercial District.
                                                                                                   and can lend to a substandard method         newfound coverage gaps.
     2. A public hearing will be held to consider a site plan and special use permit               of treatment for county employees.              “This creates a real question of
       application from The Peabody Group for the property at 115 Albert Avenue to allow              And because the FDA has yet to            hypocrisy in terms of county values
       the establishment of a restaurant, including alcohol sales. The subject property is
       zoned B-3, City Center Commercial District.                                                 formally approve any method of hor-          and county procedures,” Heywood
                                                                                                   monal transition treatment for trans-        added. “We have a non-discrimination
     3. A public hearing will be held to consider Ordinance 1431: An ordinance to amend
       the Zoning Use District Map of Chapter 50 – Zoning – of the Code of the City of             gender patients, all medication for          ordinance, but this system deliberate-
       East Lansing to rezone the northeast corner of Haslett and Park Lake Roads from             gender dysphoria is currently prohib-        ly discriminates against some of our
       RA, Residential Agricultural to B-2, Retail Sales Business.                                 ited on the county’s insurance plan as       own employees. There’s absolutely an
  The City of East Lansing will provide reasonable accommodations, such as interpreters for        well. Ingham County, however, is not         unconscious bias that plays into this.
  the hearing impaired and audio tapes of printed materials being considered at this meeting,      alone. Transgender-inclusive health-         It’s our job to see this thing gets fixed.”
  upon notice to the City of East Lansing, prior to the meeting. Individuals with disabilities
  requiring reasonable accommodations or services should write or call the City Manager’s
                                                                                                   care benefits are a nationwide scar-            Visit lansingcitypulse.com for con-
  Office, 410 Abbot Road, East Lansing, MI 48823 (517) 319-6920, TDD 1-800-649-377.                city. The Human Rights Campaign              tinued coverage as county officials
                                                                                                   tracked fewer than 20 percent of its         continue to investigate the insurance
  					Jennifer Shuster
  					City Clerk                                                                                  rated municipalities as offering those       shortfall.
     					                                                                         CP#19-347       benefits.                                    —KYLE KAMINSKI
City Pulse • November 27, 2019                                                    www.lansingcitypulse.com                                                                                        11

         Schor lights fire under                                                                                            CHARTER TOWNSHIP OF MERIDIAN
                                                                                                                             NOTICE OF TOWNHALL MEETING

                                                                                                  A SPECIAL MEETING of the Meridian Township Board has been called for Thursday,

          menorah movement
   It was touch and                              a Nativity scene in a county courthouse
                                                                                                  December 12, 2019 at 6:00 pm in the Town Hall Room, 5151 Marsh Okemos, Michigan
                                                                                                  48864. This is the Annual Goal Setting Meeting of the Township Board at which they will
                                                                                                  discuss:

                                                                                                      1) The Township Board 2020 Goals

                                      POLITICS
go last Friday after-                            was “indisputably religious” because                 2) The Township Manager’s Compensation and Contract Review
noon, but Lansing                                the display came with the banner                     3) Closed Session to discuss the Township Manager’s Annual Performance Review
Mayor Andy Schor                                 “Gloria in Excelsis Deo.” And in 1995,           					                                                          BRETT DREYFUS, CMMC
succeeded in lighting                            the Court ruled the KKK could stick              					                                                               TOWNSHIP CLERK
a 9-foot menorah next                            a cross in the Ohio statehouse plaza                                                                                           CP#19-348
to the state’s 61-foot                           during the holiday season. In that case,
state Christmas tree                             though, Ohio allowed other religious                         2020 TOWNSHIP BOARD MEETING SCHEDULE RESOLUTION
in front of the state                            symbols in the plaza. They just didn’t                     At a regular meeting of the Township Board of the Charter Township of Meridian,
Capitol during the                               want the KKK’s cross.                                Ingham County, Michigan, held at the Meridian Municipal Building, in said Township on
Silver Bells in the City festivities.               Back in 2006 when the Michigan                    the 19th day of November, 2019 at 6:00 p.m., local time.
   Now the mayor is looking to feature           House passed a resolution in support                 PRESENT: Supervisor Styka, Clerk Dreyfus, Treasurer Deschaine,
                                                                                                               Trustees Jackson, Opsommer, Sundland, Wisinski
a larger candelabra — contributed                of a state Christmas tree and meno-                  ABSENT:
by a private citizen — next to the               rah display, then-Michigan Jewish                          The following resolution was offered by Clerk Dreyfus and supported by
Christmas tree during the eight days of          Conference Director Susan Herman                     Trustee Opsommer.
Hanukkah, starting Dec. 22. Whether              said such a setup would be an inappro-                      WHEREAS, the Township Board desires to announce the time, date, and place of
that’s going to fly will likely be dis-          priate mix of church and state.                      all regular meetings of the Board, pursuant to MCL 42.7; and
cussed Dec. 18 at a meeting of the state            Today, Rahbi Asher Lopatin, execu-                        WHEREAS, the Township Board deems the 2020 regular meeting schedule
Capitol Commission, which by law                 tive director of the Jewish Community                sufficient to uphold the Board's Policies and Procedures, and advance its Global Ends.
oversees the Capitol grounds.                    Relations Council of Metropolitan                          NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Township Board of the Charter
   The issues here are many.                     Detroit and the American Jewish                      Township of Meridian, Ingham County, Michigan that the Township Board adopts its
                                                                                                      regular 2020 meeting schedule as follows:
   The Capitol Commission has rules              Committee, is convinced there is an
on Capitol lawn displays. They can’t             equity argument.                                     Tuesday, January 7, 2020       6:00 P.M. Regular Meeting
be taller than 4 feet. They must be                 “If there’s going to be a Christmas               Tuesday, January 21, 2020      6:00 P.M. Regular Meeting
                                                                                                      Tuesday, January 28, 2020      6:00 P.M. Joint Meeting (Township Boards and Commissions)
taken down at night. Basically, the              tree — and it’s a wonderful, beautiful               Tuesday, February 4, 2020      6:00 P.M. Regular Meeting
state doesn’t want a lot of large gaudy          Christian symbol — we should be able                 Tuesday, February 18, 2020     6:00 P.M. Regular Meeting
clutter. It also doesn’t want to be held         to put up a dignified Jewish symbol, as              Tuesday, March 3, 2020         6:00 P.M. Regular Meeting
                                                                                                      Tuesday, March 17, 2020        6:00 P.M. Regular Meeting
responsible if a vandal tags something           well,” he said.
                                                                                                      Tuesday, March 31, 2020        6:00 P.M. Regular Meeting
while on state property.                            Schor, who is Jewish, agrees. That’s              Tuesday, April 14, 2020        6:00 P.M. Joint Meeting (School Districts & Local Governments)
   But if that’s the case, why the excep-        why he is pushing the issue, even                    Tuesday, April 21, 2020        6:00 P.M. Regular Meeting
tion for the 61-foot conifer that clearly        though Capitol Facilities initially told             Tuesday, May 5, 2020           6:00 P.M. Regular Meeting
                                                                                                      Tuesday, May 19, 2020          6:00 P.M. Regular Meeting
is a symbol for the Christian holiday of         him no.                                              Tuesday, June 2, 2020          6:00 P.M. Regular Meeting
Christmas?                                          Schor said state Facilities Manager               Tuesday, June 16, 2020         6:00 P.M. Regular Meeting
   Next, is the property on which the            Robert Blackwell told city workers                   Tuesday, July 7, 2020          6:00 P.M. Regular Meeting
massive evergreen sit on city right of           last Friday, allegedly, with a couple of             Tuesday, July 21, 2020         6:00 P.M. Regular Meeting
                                                                                                      Thursday,August 6,2020         6:00 P.M. Regular Meeting
way or state property? Because if it’s           Capitol security personnel nearby, that              Tuesday, August 18, 2020       6:00 P.M. Regular Meeting
state property, why are city workers             if the menorah was kept near the tree,               Tuesday, September 1, 2020     6:00 P.M. Regular Meeting (Budget Hearing & Deliberations)
erecting the tree, trimming the tree             the state would confiscate it.                       Tuesday, September 15, 2020    6:00 P.M. Regular Meeting
and decorating the tree, Schor asks.                Once news of this got out, the                    Tuesday, October 8, 2020       6:00 P.M. Regular Meeting
                                                                                                      Tuesday, October 22, 2020      6:00 P.M. Regular Meeting
   If it’s on city property, Schor argues        Capitol Commission chairman, Gary                    Thursday, November 5, 2020     6:00 P.M. Regular Meeting
he can put a menorah next to the tree            Randall -- fearing a national story with             Tuesday, November 17, 2020     6:00 P.M. Regular Meeting
if he wants.                                     Gov. Gretchen Whitmer being in Israel                Tuesday, December 1, 2020      6:00 P.M. Town Hall Meeting
                                                                                                      Tuesday, December 8, 2020      6:00 P.M. Regular Meeting
   The state says it has paperwork               of all places -- quickly told Blackwell to
showing this small piece of concrete on          leave the menorah alone.                               2. Each of the above meetings shall be held at the specified time in the Town Hall
the other side of the sideway is state              The city’s 9-foot menorah didn’t stay                  Room of the Meridian Municipal Building, 5151 Marsh Road, Okemos, Michigan
                                                                                                           (517) 853-4000, unless changed and noticed in accordance with MCL 15.265.
property. It’s all part of the Capitol           near the tree for long. Once Silver Bells
grounds.                                         was over, city workers moved it back                   3. A summary of this resolution stating date, place, and time shall be posted in the
   Both sides are digging through their          to City Hall. That specific menorah                       Meridian Municipal Building within ten (10) days after the first regularly scheduled
                                                                                                           meeting of the year in accordance with MCL 15.265.
records for proof of their arguments.            isn’t designed for prolonged outdoor
                                                                                                      ADOPTED:        YEAS: Supervisor Styka, Clerk Dreyfus, Treasurer Deschaine,
   In the meanwhile, there’s the whole           exposure.                                            		                    Trustees Jackson, Opsommer, Sundland, Wisinski
freedom from religion argument. Is                  Since the lighting, Schor said he’s
                                                                                                      		              NAYS:
it appropriate to put a Jewish symbol            received overwhelming support from
for a religious holiday on government            the community. Whether he’ll be                      Resolution declared adopted.
property?                                        open to more congratulations later in                STATE OF MICHIGAN)
   Not surprisingly, the U.S. Supreme            December is yet to be seen.                          		               ) ss.
                                                                                                      COUNTY OF INGHAM)
Court has looked into this very issue,              (Kyle Melinn, of the Capitol newslet-
but the results aren’t clear cut. In 1984,       ter IRS, can be reached at melinnky@                 I, the undersigned, the duly qualified and acting Clerk of the Township of Meridian,
                                                                                                      Ingham County, Michigan, DO HEREBY CERTIFY that the foregoing is a true and a
the court ruled a city-sponsored crèche          gmail.com.)                                          complete copy of a resolution adopted at a regular meeting of the Township Board on
in a public park did not violate the                            Correction                            the 19th day of November, 2019.
establishment clause because the dis-               Because of a reporting error, the last        						BRETT DREYFUS, CMMC
play included other “secular” symbols.             name of Lansing City Councilman Adam           						     TOWNSHIP CLERK
                                                   Hussain was misspelled in a story in the                         CP#19-349
   Five years later, the court found that               Nov. 20 issue of City Pulse.
12                                                                          www.lansingcitypulse.com                                          City Pulse • November 27, 2019

                                                                                      2019
                                                                              Holiday                                           Gift
                                                                               Guide

                                                                                                                                                       Skyler Ashley/City Pulse

Humble gift suggestions from humble City Pulsers
Retro Mini Video                                                                                                                     Sega or Nintendo is “most awesome”
                                                                                                                                     will carry on within our hearts forever.
Game Consoles                                                                                                                        Thankfully, just about every major
                                                                                                                                     game company has jumped on the
By SKYLER ASHLEY                                                                                                                     mini console bandwagon. Was your
Honestly, I love the gift-giving poten-                                                                                              loved one a PlayStation kid? Boom.
tial of these things. As a gift, retro mini                                                                                          Get them a PlayStation One Classic.
video game consoles strike a perfect                                                                                                 Are they a Nintendo fan boy? Sega
generational balance in their capacity                                                                                               fanatic? Purchase accordingly. But if
as an entertaining novelty. These bad                                                                                                you were purchasing for somebody too
boys have big stocking-stuffer energy.                                                                                               young to have this deeply ingrained
Give one to anybody between the ages                                                                                                 sense of electronic tribalism, I’d ulti-
10 to 18, and you’ve given them an in-        noticed that I’ve gone with the broad       cess. Chances are, your family couldn’t    mately recommend the Super Ninten-
teractive toolbox to peruse the classic       suggestion of any retro mini console,       afford a Sega Genesis AND a Super          do Classic. As of now, it’s probably the
video games of yore. Give one to any-         rather than a particular unit. There’s an   Nintendo. You had one shot to make         most difficult to obtain but it arguably
body above the age of 25, and you’ve          important, childhood-memory-specific        the right choice. Therefore, most of us    has the best lineup of games among
supplied them with a fully loaded hy-         reason for that. For most of us, asking     have a soul bond to the line of consoles   the competition. Most big stores such
podermic needle of nostalgia.                 our parents for a video game console        we grew up with, and the daily middle
If you’re reading this, you’ve obviously      was a meticulously researched pro-          school lunchroom debate over whether                                        See Gifts, Page 13
You can also read