WATER A GLOBAL CHALLENGE - ID4D

Page created by Howard Robinson
 
CONTINUE READING
WATER A GLOBAL CHALLENGE - ID4D
WATER
A GLOBAL CHALLENGE
WATER A GLOBAL CHALLENGE - ID4D
TABLE OF CONTENTS
                                   Access to drinking water and sanitation
         04                        is a fundamental human right
                                   INTERVIEW WITH CATARINA DE ALBUQUERQUE – EXECUTIVE CHAIR, SANITATION AND FOR ALL

         09                        “Day Zero” is scheduled for July 9th in Cape Town
                                   INTERVIEW WITH XANTHEA LIMBERG – COUNCILLOR, CAPE TOWN CITY

         13
                                   Make water and sanitation a central
                                   humanitarian issue                                                                                                                                              WATER
                                                                                                                                                                                                   A GLOBAL CHALLENGE
                                   INTERVIEW WITH JEAN LAPÈGUE – SENIOR ADVISOR WASH, NGO ACTION CONTRE LA FAIM

                                   Hydro-diplomacy to prevent the militarization of water-
         17                        related conflicts                                                                                                                                  Everywhere in the world, water is still a key issue. Source of inequalities
                                   INTERVIEW WITH FADI GEORGES COMAIR – HONORARY PRESIDENT, MEDITERRANEAN NETWORK OF                                                                  when scarce or difficult to access, of geopolitical conflicts when shared, of
                                   BASIN ORGANISATIONS                                                                                                                                public health problems when polluted or even of humanitarian disasters
                                                                                                                                                                                      when provoking natural catastrophes: whatever challenges the water
                                                                                                                                                                                      issue raises, the most affected are always the most vulnerable people.
                                   “In most cases, wars are not fought over water”
         21                        INTERVIEW WITH STEPHEN MCCAFFREY – DISTINGUISHED PROFESSOR OF LAW, MCGEORGE SCHOOL                                                                 2.1 billion human beings do not have access to safely managed domestic
                                   OF LAW, UNI. OF THE PACIFIC
                                                                                                                                                                                      drinking water. Population growth increases the pressure on the resource
                                                                                                                                                                                      and extreme climate events are more and more frequent. Today, water
                                   “Women and men have differential roles, rights                                                                                                     is more than ever a global challenge: a common good to share, a vital
         24                                                                                                                                                                           resource to sustainably manage, a human right to uphold.
                                   and responsibilities”
                                   INTERVIEW WITH SARA AHMED – RESEARCHER, BOARD MEMBER OF WATERAID INDIA
                                                                                                                                                                                      With this document, Ideas for Development gives a voice to ten experts
                                                                                                                                                                                      who are mobilized, on a national or a global level, on water issues and
                                                                                                                                                                                      challenges. Fight for a universal access to drinking water and sanitation,
                                   Latin America: Adaptation to climate change
         28                                                                                                                                                                           anticipation of extreme shortages, reduction in inequalities, adaptation to
                                   and wastewater treatment                                                                                                                           climate change, technologic innovation, hydro-diplomacy…
                                   TRIBUNE BY MAURICE BERNARD – AFD DIRECTOR FOR THE ANDEAN AREA
                                                                                                                                                                                      Even though the challenges are enormous, works and actions of women
                                                                                                                                                                                      and men featuring in the following pages demonstrate every day that
                                   Why do toilets need to be reinvented?
         30                        INTERVIEW WITH DOULAYE KONÉ – SENIOR PROGRAM OFFICER, WASH PROGRAM,
                                                                                                                                                                                      solutions do exist. They all unanimously agree on one point: only a strong
                                                                                                                                                                                      commitment of the international community and proactive public policies
                                   GATES FOUNDATION
                                                                                                                                                                                      will improve resource management and conservation, mitigate the
                                                                                                                                                                                      impacts of climate change and make the right to water a reality.
                                   When innovation and private enterprise facilitate
         34                        access to drinking water
                                   INTERVIEW WITH ASKWAR HILONGA – TANZANIAN ENGINEER, INVENTOR OF THE NANOFILTER

                                   Provide a quality, sustainable and affordable                                                                                                      Sharpen you vision of development with the ID4D blog,
         38                        service to all                                                                                                                                    coordinated by the Agence française de développement:
                                   TRIBUNE BY CÉLINE GILQUIN – HEAD OF AFD’S WATER AND SANITATION DIVISION
                                                                                                                                                                                                            ideas4development.org

                                                                                                                                                                                                                          @iD4D
    Publishing director: iD4D. Interviews: Sabine Cessou & Aurélie Darbouret. Editorial and graphic conception: A nimal pensant .
    Photo credits: p. 5 © Joseph Moura, p. 9–11-15 © Cyril Le Tourneur d’Ison, p. 17 © Andrea&Mada Photographers, p. 25 © Didier Gentilhomme, p. 26 © Ania Gruca, p. 29
    © Jorge Cardoso, p. 30 © Patricia Esteve, p. 33 © James Keogh, p. 35–36 © Georgina Goodwin, portrait of Stephen McCaffrey © McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific.

2                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     3
WATER A GLOBAL CHALLENGE - ID4D
WATE R, A GLOBA L CHA LLE NGE

                                                           HUMAN RIGHT

        “Access to drinking
       water and sanitation is
    a fundamental human right”

                                    C
              TERVIEW W                           atarina de Albuquerque         developed countries, where the lack
         IN             I                         was the first UN Special       of access to water was not really
    AN

                            TH

                                                  Rapporteur on the              apparent. At the time, the water crisis
                                                  Human Right to Water           was especially blatant in the poorest
                                    and Sanitation from 2008 to 2014. She        countries, which were colonies and
                                    is now Executive Chair of the global         therefore did not have a seat around
                                    partnership Sanitation and Water for         the table. Furthermore, civil society
        CATARINA                    All. After having contributed to the         organizations, which today influence
    DE ALBUQ UERQUE                 recognition of access to water and           the debates at the United Nations,
                                    sanitation as a fundamental human            were virtually absent from the UDHR
    F irs t UN Spe c ia l R a p -
    po rte ur o n th e H u ma n     right, she is today concerned about          negotiations.
      Right to Wa t e r a n d       seeing that the most disadvantaged           It was only in 2005 that Germany
    Sanitatio n f r o m 2 0 0 8     populations are still left behind and that   and Spain pushed for the opening
             to 20 1 4              public policies take up this right far       of discussions on a right to water,
                                    too little. For Catarina de Albuquerque      even before the creation of the United
                                    there is no doubt: it is impossible          Nations Human Rights Council. The
                                    to regulate access to water without          two countries subsequently proposed
                                    binding public policies.                     the creation of a mandate of Special
                                                                                 Rapporteur to analyze the possibility
                                    Why did access to drinking water only        of recognizing this right. So, I was
                                    become a human right in 2010?                appointed and I worked to have this
                                    If the Universal Declaration of Human        right recognized. Bolivia, which was
                                    Rights (UDHR) of 10 December 1948            very interested in the recognition of a
                                    mentions all rights except the right         right to water at the time, took up the
                                    to water, it is because access to            issue. I persuaded the Ambassador
                                    water was taken for granted by the           of Bolivia to the United Nations in
                                    negotiators of the text, who were            New York to include not only the
                                    diplomats from wealthy families in           right to water, but also the right to
                                                                                 sanitation. On 28 July 2010, the United
                                                                                 Nations General Assembly adopted the
    “Making access to water                                                      resolution making access to drinking
                                                                                 water and sanitation a fundamental
    a right means it must be                                                     human right. This was an essential              Kinshasa, DRC.
                                                                                                                             Pipe operators are
    affordable, accessible,                                                      step and one of the happiest days of my
                                                                                 experience as a Rapporteur!
                                                                                                                               recruited among
                                                                                                                           inhabitants by water
    of good quality”                                                                                                        users associations,
                                                                                                                             responsible for the
                                                                                 Is this recognition mainly symbolic or       good managing of
                                                                                 can it bring about a real change?              water fountains.

4                                                                                                                                                                              5
WATER A GLOBAL CHALLENGE - ID4D
WATE R, A GL OBAL CHAL L EN G E                                                                                                                                                                                                                             WATE R, A GLOBA L CHA LLE NGE

                                                                                    D I ST R I B U T I O N O F WAT ER C O N SU M P T I O N
                                                                                                   AR O U N D T H E W O R L D

                                                                     70%
             It is first and foremost symbolic, but
                                                               A g ri c u l tu re                                                                                “We need laws, public                                         flushing. In Singapore and Australia,
             I do, of course, hope that it will have                                                                                                                                                                           water recycling is also being developed:
             more far-reaching effects. It has                                                                                                                   policies and regulations                                      recycled water goes back into the
             already influenced the Sustainable                                                                                                                  to encourage agriculture,                                     drinking water system and is safely
             Development Goals (SDGs) and                                                                                                                                                                                      drunk by people.
             has even led to the adoption of an                                                                                                                  tourism and industry                                          We need laws, public policies and
             independent goal on water and                                                                                                                       to make efforts to save,                                      regulations to encourage agriculture,
             sanitation set out in the 2030 Agenda.                                                                                                                                                                            tourism and industry to make efforts to
             I fought to make sure that it was                                                                                                                   recycle and reuse water”                                      save, recycle and reuse water. People
             not limited to a simple declaration                                                                                                                                                                               have a responsibility, but it is especially
             of good intentions. It was absolutely                                                                                                                                                                             governments which have the duty to
                                                                                                                                                   19%
             essential that the normative content                                                                                                                                                                              adopt appropriate legislation.
                                                             11%                                                                              I n d u s tr ies
             was included in the SDGs. Making
                                                       Mu n i c i p a l i ti e s
             access to water a right means that it                                                                                                               Why do you talk about poor water                              How do you account for the
             must be affordable, accessible, of good                                                                                                             management?                                                   deficiencies in public policies?
             quality, etc. Furthermore, did you know                                                                                                             Firstly, there is a huge lack of                              The lack of good public policies is
             that the only human right explicitly                                                                                                                investments in the maintenance                                sometimes due to a lack of knowledge
             recognized and mentioned in the 2030                                                                                                                of water systems. For example, in                             or competence by governments.
             Agenda is precisely the right to water                                                                                                              the USA, the situation is tragic. The                         However, the main reason is that it is
             and sanitation? This is the result of the                                                                                                           equipment is dilapidated, never                               difficult to win elections by promising
             battle I waged with hundreds of civil                                                                                                               repaired, and there are huge losses                           to adopt this type of measure for water
             society actors. These rights have now                                                                                                               recorded.                                                     management. It is a subject which
             been taken into account in constitutions                                                                                                            Secondly, certain tariff or subsidy                           can be difficult to sell electorally. This
             and national plans. People make claims                                                                                                              systems have adverse effects. The
                                                                                  Source: United Nations World Water Development Report 2017,
             about them in national courts. The                                                            UN Water                                              example of Jordan clearly illustrates
             world is changing. Some headway is                                                                                                                  this: the Government maintains
             being made. The situation is, however,                                                                                                              substantial subsidies for water for
             far from being perfect.                      falling. I also do not deny the impact of                                                              agriculture, as it is a major source of
                                                          climate change. But we know that there                                                                 foreign currency for the country. But
             How can we account for the current           is enough water on the planet to ensure                                                                the adverse effect of these subsidies
             water crisis?                                access to it for all. The problem lies in                                                              is that they have encouraged farmers
             The quantity of available water today        poor public policies and the significant                                                               to consume a lot of water in one of the
             is the same as the quantity available        lack of regulations, which are, however,                                                               countries in the world where there is
             at the time of the dinosaurs. The first      essential in order to prioritize the                                                                   the least water. The Government is now        2. 1 bi l l i on peopl e, i . e. 30% o f t h e w o rl d ’s
             difference is that there were fewer          various water uses. For example, in the                                                                making efforts to promote water-saving      popul at i on, still do not have access to safely managed
                                                                                                                                                                                                                     domestic drinking water supply services
             dinosaurs than there are humans. The         event of a crisis, will priority be given to                                                           crops, but priorities are changing very,
             second is that in their time, there was      human consumption or to watering golf                                                                  or even too, slowly.
             no tourism, agriculture or industry.         courses? Or to the irrigation of huge                                                                  In the tourism sector, we see that it is
             Yet agriculture consumes 70% of the          agricultural crops intended for export?                                                                only when the price of water increases
             fresh water available and industry                                                                                                                  that hotels invest in water-saving
             19%. It is essential to educate the                                                                                                                 taps or water recycling systems. For
             population by explaining that water is        “There is enough water on                                                                             example, in Las Vegas, which is located
             a scarce and valuable resource, but                                                                                                                 in one of the most arid regions in the
             it does get on my nerves when some
                                                             the planet to ensure access                                                                         USA, very binding tax policies have
             try to lay all the blame for the water        to it for all. The problem lies                                                                       forced hotels to drastically reduce their
             crisis on individuals! Households                                                                                                                   consumption, while ensuring that the
             have more swimming pools, showers,
                                                           in poor public policies and the                                                                       city’s tourism revenues are maintained.
                                                                                                                                                                                                               4. 4 bi l l i on peopl e, i . e. 60% o f t h e w o rl d ’s
                                                                                                                                                                                                              popul at i on, do not have saf ely manage d s anit at io n
             washing machines, dishwashers, etc.,          significant lack of regulations”                                                                      In Japan, certain buildings have been                                 ser vices
             but the major problem is not related                                                                                                                equipped with dual pipe systems: the
             to domestic use. The quantity of water                                                                                                              water used for the shower does not go
             available per capita is admittedly                                                                                                                  down the drain, but is reused for toilet                              Source : Unicef

6                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       7
WATER A GLOBAL CHALLENGE - ID4D
WATE R, A GL OBAL CHAL L EN G E

                                                     F R E S H WAT E R AVAILABILITY IN THE WORLD                                                                                                                 CLIM ATE
                                                                c u b ic me t er s per per son and per year, i n 2007

                                                                                                                                                                                    “Day Zero”
                                                                                                                                                                                 is scheduled for
                                                                                                                                                                              July 9 th in Cape Town

                                                                                                                                                                                      C
                        0
     S ho rtage
                                                                                                                                                                TERVIEW W                           ape Town, the second largest    Mayoral Committee overseeing Informal
                        1 ,0 0 0                                                                                                                           IN             I
                                                                                                                                                                                                    city of South Africa and very   Settlements, Water & Waste Services,

                                                                                                                                                      AN

                                                                                                                                                                              TH
Hydric s tre s s
                                                                                                                                                                                                    popular with tourists, is       and Energy in February 2017.
                        1 ,7 0 0
Vulner ability                                                                                                                                                                                      struck by a severe drought
                        2 ,5 0 0                                                                                                                                                      since 2016. Led by Mayor Patricia de          Why was the decision taken to set limits
                                                                                                                                                                                      Lille from the Democratic Alliance,           for water consumption per household in
                        6 ,0 0 0                                                                                                                                                      municipality took strong measures to          Cape Town?
                                                                                                                                                             XANTHEA                  restrict water consumption. The city is       For more than a decade, the City
                        1 5 ,0 0 0                   is especially because in the water                    more in periods of scarcity. There will           LIMBERG                  also preparing for a “Day Zero” scenario,     demands water restrictions as part of
                                                     sector, most of the infrastructure is                 be an extremely marked increase in          Cape To w n Co unc i l -
                                                                                                                                                                                      the day when the taps run dry and some        water conservation policies because
                        7 0 ,0 0 0                   underground. Yet what cannot be seen                  inequalities.                                                              200 water collection sites provide water      of the drought affecting the region and
                                                                                                                                                       l o r i n c harge o f the
                                                     does not gain votes.                                                                              May o ral Co mmi tte e         for 4 million inhabitants. Yet, the City      of the increasing urbanization due to
                        6 8 4 ,0 00                  Water is too cheap in many countries.                 Are you pessimistic?                        o v e rs e e i ng I nfo rmal   is not waiting for the catastrophe to         a constant influx of new dwellers from
                                                     The price of water should be increased                I am very concerned about inequalities.           Se ttl e me nts ,        happen: several projects will produce
                                                                                                                                                            Wate r & Was te
                       Data n o t                    for those who can pay, slums should                   I have fought relentlessly in this         Se rv i c e s , and Ene rgy.
                                                                                                                                                                                      200 million more litres of water in the
                       av aila b le o r n o t
                       s ignif ic a n t
                                                     be connected to the official networks                 field. When I was a Rapporteur at the                                      current year, explains Xanthea Limberg,       The City is not
                                                     and social tariffs should be introduced               United Nations, my objective was to                                        Cape Town Councillor and Chair of the
                                                     for the most vulnerable. This would                   include this theme in the SDGs. We                                                                                       waiting for the catastrophe
                   Sources: FAO, United Nations,
                   World Resources Institute (WRI)
                                                     establish a fair system accessible to                 succeeded. For this recognition to                                                                                       to happen
                                                     all, while avoiding wastage. But the                  serve a purpose, it has to be taken into
                                                     increase in water tariffs can bring                   account and we have to change the
                                                     about revolutions and few politicians                 way we work. Unfortunately, I do not
                                                     are willing to take this risk. However, if            see any changes. We cannot simply
                                                     the Minister of Water is smart, he can                say: “Almost everyone has access
                                                     have a lot of success and maybe even                  to water.” This “almost” is not good
                                                     become Prime Minister!                                enough for me. This “almost” means
                                                                                                           that we are continuing to ignore the
                                                     What are the future challenges?                       poorest, people who belong to an
                                                     Today, over two billion people lack                   ethnic, linguistic minority, etc. If we
                                                     drinking water. Every year, millions                  do not identify the most marginalized
                                                     of people die from diseases related                   (the homeless, migrants, refugees)
                                                     to unsafe water. With the ongoing                     and if we do not implement special
                                                     climate change, there will be less and                public policies to reach them, we will
                                                     less fresh water available. The real                  never achieve a rate of access to water
                                                     tragedy is that the aggravation of the                of 100%. Yet 100% of human beings
                                                     water crisis will first and foremost                  with access to water and sanitation          Cape Town, South
                                                     affect those who are already the most                 is what all the Heads of State and         Africa. The 4 million
                                                                                                                                                       Capetonians could
                                                     disadvantaged. Those who suffer in                    Government pledged to the world in            soon be deprived
                                                     times of abundance will suffer even                   September 2015. •                                      of water.

8                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              9
WATER A GLOBAL CHALLENGE - ID4D
WATE R, A GL OBAL CHAL L EN G E                                                                                                                                                                                                                     WATE R, A GLOBA L CHA LLE NGE

                                                                       P O P U L AT I O N                                                                         Cape Town, South Africa.
                                                                                                                                                            Inhabitants of the rehabilitated
                                                                   I N T H E C AP E T O W N                                                                         informal settlement of
                                                                                                                                                              Flamingo Crescent now have
                                                                             AR EA                                                                             access to water and toilets.
                                                                                                   4
                                                                                                millions
             rural areas of the neighbouring                                                                   instance, you can tell the city.       and the majority less than 47 rands (€3,2)
             poorer province of Eastern                                                                        Our inspectors will come and           per month.
             Cape. Many white households                                                                       issue a fine going from 5,000
             also leave Johannesburg and                                                                       up to 10,000 rands (340 to 680         If the current drought persists and the
             the richest and industrialized                                                                    euros). The fines are set by the       current restrictions are not respected,
             Gauteng Province because of the                                                                   Municipal Court, depending on          how seriously are you preparing the
             perception of levels of crime.             2.4                                                    the severity of the offence or if it   “Day Zero” as a catastrophe scenario?
             Cape Town is internationally             mi ll i o n s                                            has happened more than once.           If our consumption of water remains at
             recognized for its efforts in water                                                               On the last quarter of 2017,           the current level of 6 million litres per
             management. The “Mother City”,                                                                    400 fines were issued. As the          day, “Day Zero” is scheduled for July 9th!
             as people call the second largest                                                                 numbers escalate, we will have         All the municipalities around Cape Town
             city after Johannesburg, has                                                                      to increase the capacity of our        and the agricultural sector draw water
             the lowest water use per capita                                                                   water inspectors’ team.                from the same set of dams. Hence, we,
             amongst big cities in South                                                                       The situation demands                  as an entire province, need to reduce
             Africa. This policy is ensuring we                                                                further restrictions. As               our consumption. That is why the city is
             can still reduce our demand in                                                                    Mayor Patricia de Lille said           focused on massively doing so.
             order to save the water resource                                                                  in December, 200,000 out of            “Day Zero” is not when Cape Town
             still within our six dams.                                                                        707,800 households are not             runs out of water, but when our dams
             We have implemented level 5                                                                       respecting the city restrictions.      reach a level of 13,5% – meaning nearly
             water restrictions in September,                                                                  Devices controlling water              empty – with no possibility to normally
             restricting the water use to                                                                      management are being                   provide water to the city. The level as
             87 litres per person per day.             19 9 5                              2017                installed on some properties.          of January was 29,7% with only about                “If “Day Zero” happens […],
             Level 6 was implemented                                                                           In January, our municipal              19,7% of useable water left. If “Day Zero”
             in January and level 6B on
                                                                 Source: Western Cape Province.
                                                                                                               council has decided on a new           happens because of the non-respect of
                                                                                                                                                                                                          we will then have to manage
             February 1st. Currently, the water                                                                set of measures hoping these           the current restrictions, we will then have         carefully and efficiently some
             use is set to no more than 50 litres per                                                will change behaviours. The principle            to manage carefully and efficiently some
             person per day.                                                                         is simple: if you use more water, you            time with a strict use of 25 litres of water
                                                                                                                                                                                                          time with a strict use of 25 litres
                                                                                                     will pay more for it. We are also looking        per day and per capita, until the rains             of water per day and per capita”
             How difficult is it to implement the                                                    at reducing the pressure level of water          refill some of our aquifers (rain season
             restriction measures?                                                                   coming out of the taps; less pressure            starts with the austral winter in June,
             The municipality has a Water                                                            means water savings. Finally, a water            editor’s note).
             Department with an inspectors’                                                              levy is being discussed to enable the        As a responsible local government, we
             team that goes out and respond                                                                 City to finance water augmentation        are attempting to avoid “Day Zero” but we                            settlements – where communities
             to the water complaints they                                                                      projects, implying to produce          have to prepare for any eventuality. If Day                          already use communal taps as a water
             receive. We have launched                                        T O P 10                           water and to increase the            Zero happens, the alternative plan is to                             collection site -, clinics and hospitals,
             a campaign to encourage                             C I T I ES FAC I N G WAT ER                       capacity of our aquifers.          set 200 water collections sites, in order                            and the Centre Business District (CBD) to
             people to report abuse: if                              D EFI C I T B Y 2050                           Our plan is that the              to deliver 25 litres per person per day on                           make sure that key businesses and the
             you see your neighbours                                                                                464,000 richest households        a 24h/24h basis. A large portion of Cape                             economy still work.
                                                                 B ecause of aqui f er s af f ect ed
             watering their gardens                                  by cl i m at e change and,
                                                                                                                     pay for it, with the 52,000      Town will depend on water collection                                 We are also looking at expanding water
             with a hosepipe connected                             ur ban and soci oeconom i c                       wealthiest at a rate above       sites, but some sectors will be excluded                             collection points through partnership
             to a municipal line, for                                      devel opm ent                            150 rands (€10) per month         from that policy, such as informal                                   with the private sector in order to use

                                                                     Source: Nature Sustainability, vol. 1,
                                                                              pp. 51–58 (2018)

                         1                          2                                3                           4                  5                            6                               7              8                   9                    10

                LOS ANGELES                     JAIPUR                DAR ES-SALAAM                           DALI AN         SAN DI EGO                    KARACHI                            HARBIN       P H O EN I X    P O R TO A LEG R E     M O NT E R R E Y
                       (US A )                   ( In d ia )                  ( Tanz ani a)                   ( C hi na)          ( U SA)                   (Pak i s tan)                      (Chi na)        (USA)             (Braz i l )          (M exico)

10                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            11
WATER A GLOBAL CHALLENGE - ID4D
WATE R, A GL OBAL CHAL L EN G E

                                                                                                                                                                                                         EM ERGENCY

                                                                                              under construction in Strandfontein will
                                                                                              deliver 7 million litres of water per day.
                                                                                                                                                                   Make water
                                                                                              In a first stage, it will give 2 million litres
                                                                                                       per day and as of May 5th more
                                                                                                          million litres per day.
                                                                                                                                                              and sanitation a central
                                                                                                             We are also trying to
                                                                                                                     maximize our
                                                                                                                          aquifers, a
                                                                                                                                                                humanitarian issue
                                                                                                                          source of water
                                                                                                                          that will produce
                                                                                                                         100 million litres

                                                                                                                                                                           T
                                                                                                                      from 2020 onwards,
                                                                                                                    if well managed.                      TERVIEW W                 he humanitarian action                             development, especially the World
                                                                                                                                                     IN             I
                                                                                                                  According to a ground                                             and development agendas                            Water Forum. It is also essential for

                                                                                                                                                AN

                                                                                                                                                                    TH
                   WAT E R S T R E S S                                                                          water survey conducted in                                           are complementary and                              the situation of the most vulnerable to
                                                                                                               2016, at least 150 million                                           interdependent. Their issues                       be a strategic and financial priority for
                    IN AFRICA                                                                                          litres of water per                                 consequently need to be addressed in                        governments. Indeed, humanitarian
                                in 2 0 2 5                                                                             day can be delivered                                a coherent manner. According to Jean                        needs around the world have reached
                                                                                                                      by the Cape Flats,                                   Lapègue, in addition to woefully lacking                    an unprecedented level: according to the
                      Wate r s h o r t a g e in 2 0 2 5                                                                                                    JEAN
                                                                                                                      Table Mountain Group                                 financing, the water and sanitation sector                  United Nations, in 2017, over 140 million
                      (le s s t h a n 1 ,0 0 0 m 3 / h a b ./ y e a r )                                                                               LAPÈGUE
                                                                                                                     and Atlantis aquifers.                                is not sufficiently taken into account                             people in 37 countries required
                      Wate r s t r e s s in 2 0 2 5 ( 1 ,0 0 0 t o                                                  The city has moved             Se ni o r Wate r-       in humanitarian    operations  and                                       immediate assistance.
                      1,700 m 3 / h a b ./ y e a r )                                                              drill rigs onto the sites      Sani tati o n- Hy gi e ne development projects. His                                                   From the development
                                                                                                                to get more water, and           Adv i s o r o f the NGO   objective at the World Water                                                   perspective, according to the

                                                                                                                                                                                                                    3
                                                                                                                                                  Ac ti o n c o ntre l a
            Source: UNDP                                                                                      allocated more resources                                     Forum: make sure these                                                           World Health Organization
                                                                                                                                                      fai m (ACF )
                                                                                                           to drill underground in a                                       issues are central                                                                  (WHO), in 2015,
                                                                                              sustainable and environmental-friendly                                       to the discussions                                                                    663 million people still
                                                                                              approach.                                                                    of governments,
                                                                                                                                                                           development                                          times                             did not have access
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   to an improved
                                                                                              Are the tourists prepared for water                                          agencies and                            more people                                     water source.
                                                   their infrastructures. Water collection    restrictions?                                                                civil society                      will be af f ect ed by f loods                       319 million of them,
                                                   could also be done through grocery         Everybody needs to comply, even if the                                       organizations.                                    by 2100                              i.e. 48%, live in Sub-
                                                   stores, where you can collect your         key operations in the CBD will still be                                                                              Source: French Water Partnership
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 Saharan   Africa. In
                                                   25 litres per day and pay for them         connected to water from taps. This                                           What are you expecting                                                               addition, almost a third
                                                   at the normal public rate. Finally, a      includes foreign visitors, 1.5 million                                       from the 8th World Water                                                          of people worldwide do
                                                   disaster management plan has also          people in 2016, and South African                                            Forum, which is being held                                                    not benefit from real access
                                                   been coordinated with the province of      tourists, 2.1 million people the same                                        in Brasilia in March 2018?                                               to sanitation. The World Water
                                                   Western Cape, the police and the army      year according to South African Tourism                                      Action contre la faim (ACF) advocates                       Forum should serve as a reminder that
                                                   to minimize any abuse and maintain law     statistics.                                                                  for the humanitarian approach to have                       dealing with people in crisis situations
                                                   and order around the water collection      We have launched in October 2017 a                                           its place in symposiums concerning                          is a priority, because they are the first
                                                   sites.                                     “Tourist Saving Water” campaign. Our                                                                                                     to be affected by the lack of access to
                                                                                              message is that you can still come to                                                                                                    water, sanitation and hygiene. Last
                                                   Beyond 2018, how will you manage the       Cape Town and explore its wonders                                                                                                        year, ACF provided its services to some
                                                   situation in the middle and long term?     and beauty, but remind you need to
                                                                                                                                                “It is essential for the situation                                                     6 million people. 40% of them were in an
                                                   In the long term, many projects are        save like a local to what was then                of the most vulnerable to be a                                                         acute emergency situation. That is a lot,
                                                   on the way to maintain and increase        our Level 5 restriction plan, 87 litres                                                                                                  but, without wishing to play on words, it
                                                   our water supply. Such as desalination     per day. We have had advertisements
                                                                                                                                                strategic and financial priority                                                       remains a drop in the ocean of needs!
                                                   plants, possible on our site since Cape    at the International Airport and we               for governments”
                                                   Town stands along two oceans, the          communicated with the hotel industry                                                                                                   What issues will you be addressing at
                                                   Atlantic and the Indian Ocean. The first   and tourist agencies so that the message                                                                                               the World Water Forum?
                                                   of the three temporary plants currently    can be shared. •                                                                                                                       ACF will be focusing on the link between

12                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          13
WATER A GLOBAL CHALLENGE - ID4D
WATE R, A GL OBAL CHAL L EN G E                                                                                                                                                                                                                                WATE R, A GLOBA L CHA LLE NGE

                                                                                                                                                                                                        “Water channels less
                                                                                                                                                                                                        than 4% of global Official
                                                                                                                                                                                                        Development Assistance
                                                                                                                                                                                                         (ODA), i.e. some
                                                 water, sanitation, nutrition and public                      Sustainable Development Goal (SDG)            also operational constraints: sanitation,
                                                 health. Indeed, public health issues                         in September 2015, etc.: the sector           unlike water, which can be distributed      US 8 billion dollars a year”
                                                 remain highly dependent on the health                        is moving fast. But this substantial          collectively, must in most cases be
                                                 environment of populations. Every health                     progress requires a greater capacity for      individualized at the household level,
                                                 centre needs to be equipped with water                       implementation, in particular for the         which makes its installation complex and
                                                 and sanitation and to be able to treat                       SDGs. At the global level, over twenty        costly.
                                                 waste (particularly medical waste). This                     UN agencies are involved in the water         There is also a significant financial       opportunities, despite a few promising
                                                 is essential.                                                sector. But three factors are essential       constraint. The sanitation budget is        examples, such as the recovery of
                                                 We also promote young professionals                          to ensure more effective coordination:        often chronically lower than the budget     excrement for compost or waste sorting
                                                 who are active in the water sector. The                      a single recognized and strong agency         devoted to water (58%), which gives         to create income-generating activities.
                                                 young generation is the generation                           in charge of coordinating the sector,         an indication of how sanitation comes       The water sector generates an economic
                                                 which has grown up with the SDGs. In                         an interministerial platform to allow         second in priorities. In 2016, 42% of the   interest and attracts financing, while
                                                 practical terms, we are going to ensure                      concerted sectoral discussions,               total budget devoted by governments to      sanitation remains a financial drain. All
                                                 that a sufficient number of young people                     a multi-stakeholder consultation              the water-sanitation-hygiene triptych       this contributes to this subsector lagging
                                                 can attend the Forum, contribute to                          platform to assist governments in the         was earmarked for sanitation.               behind, a lag which is exacerbated in
                                                 the various processes (including the                         implementation of the SDGs.                   Finally, sanitation does not yet create     rural areas, where only 24% of sectoral
                                                 ministerial declaration) and express                         These three recommendations were              sufficient strong and replicable economic   financing is allocated to sanitation.
                                                 their point of view, which is often                          made by the United Nations Secretary-
                                                 innovative and revolutionary.                                General’s Advisory Board on Water &                                                       Can you give examples of countries
                                                                                                              Sanitation in November 2015 and are                                                       where water and sanitation
                                                 What is the main barrier to action for                       still relevant and supported by ACF.                                                      management are great emergencies?
                                                 access to water?                                                                                                                                       The indicators for access to the service
                                                 The recognition of the right to water in                     Does the World Water Forum not                                                            are critical in Burkina Faso: in 2015,
                                                 July 2010, the definition of a dedicated                     indeed provide a good opportunity for                                                     only 54% of the population had access
                                                                                                              interministerial discussions?                                                             to water and 2% to sanitation at national
                                                                                                              It does, indeed, play this role by default,                                               level and these rates stand at 43% and
                                                   S ANITATION                                                but everything depends on the good                                                        12% in rural areas. But the country is
                                                  IN THE W ORLD                                               will of the ministers who are present,
                                                                                                              because the framework of the Forum
                                                                    S a fe l y m an a g e d
                                                                                                              and its political process leading to
                                                                             39%
                                                                                                              a ministerial declaration of intent
                                                                                                              are not binding and are not placed
                                                                                                              under the auspices of the United
                                                                                                              Nations. The World Water Forum does,
                                                                                                              however, provide a major opportunity
                                                           I n 20 1 5 ,                                       for advocacy for the coordination

                                                  39%
                                                                                                              of the water sector and also a real
               Lim it ed                                                                                      opportunity for discussions between
                 8%                                                                                           countries and stakeholders, with a view
                                        o f th e w o rl d po p u l ati o n us e d
                                                                                                              to a harmonious implementation of the
                                          s a fe l y m an a g e d s an i tati o n
                                                                                                              SDGs.
                                                       s e rv i c e s .
                                                                                                   Ba s i c
                                                                                                   29%        Why is there less interest in sanitation
                U n im p r o v e d
                                                                                                              than in water?
                     12%
                                                                                                              Besides the issues of image concerning
                                                                                                              waste and excrement, the sanitation
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     Shohila, Bangladesh.
                                                                      O p e n de fe c a ti o n                sector is affected by various constraints.                                                                                             Six months per
                                                                              12%                             Firstly, access to water, which is more                                                                                                year, during floods,
                                                                                                              easily perceived as a vital and immediate                                                                                              inhabitants live
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     almost in autarky
                                                                                                              need, is systematically given priority                                                                                                 in the inundated
                                     Source: Progress on drinking water, sanitation and hygiene:
                                          2017 update and SDG baselines, JMP Washdata.                        over access to sanitation. There are                                                                                                   village.

14                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       15
WATER A GLOBAL CHALLENGE - ID4D
WATE R, A GL OBAL CHAL L EN G E

                                                                                                                                                                                GEOPOLITICS

                                  showing a real political and strategic        access to water than the other way
                                  will to achieve the SDGs, in particular via   round.
                                  the implementation of a decentralized         Climate change is a major concern.
                                  sectoral policy.                              In Sahelian zones, it is a pervasive
                                  Senegal is also a good example in terms       and real problem. Similarly, in
                                  of policy decisions in the sector. The next   the Middle East (Jordan, Iraq) and
                                  World Water Forum will, moreover, be          Southern Africa (Madagascar), the
                                  held in this country in 2021. We can also     decline of groundwater is tangible
                                  mention India, a country with the record      and documented. The inevitable
                                  rate for open defecation (597 million         consequences are known: displacement
                                  people in 2014, according to Unicef).         of populations and increase in the
                                  However, the problems of sanitation are       cost of infrastructure, which must be
                                  so critical in this country that there has    adapted to a resource that is increasingly
                                  been growing political awareness and          scarce and more complicated to locate.
                                  major commitments have been made at           Geophysical surveys are systematically
                                  federal level.                                conducted and telescopic wells are
                                  Finally, countries affected by chronic        becoming more and more common.
                                  crisis situations (Somalia, Afghanistan,
                                  Southern Sudan, etc.) are logically           What do you expect from donors?
                                  those which have the most difficulties        First and foremost, more financing                                                                                                                   Palestinian
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     Territories.
                                  in making progress in access to water         is needed. It is easy to observe the                                                                                                                 Without water or
                                  and sanitation. These issues become           low level of financing in the sector in                                                                                                              sanitation,
                                  secondary priorities and come after           humanitarian situations. We just have to                                                                                                             health conditions
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     are precarious.
                                  security. They also suffer from the typical   look at the fact that in 2017, the United
                                  corollaries in conflict situations: lack of   Nations Office for the Coordination of
                                  access to territories, corruption, poor
                                  governance, absence or non-application
                                  of the legal framework, drain on human
                                                                                Humanitarian Affairs launched a global
                                                                                appeal for funds in order to reach the
                                                                                101.2 million most vulnerable people.
                                                                                                                                       Hydro-diplomacy
                                  resources and technical capacities,
                                  gradual disappearance of the private
                                  sector, etc.
                                                                                Out of a total need of US 23.5 billion
                                                                                dollars in all sectors taken together,
                                                                                26% was covered, i.e. only 6.2 billion
                                                                                                                                  to prevent the militarization
                                  As of access to water, should we worry
                                  more about climate change or about
                                                                                were raised. The water sector is
                                                                                still underfunded, both in terms of
                                                                                development and emergency situations.
                                                                                                                                   of water-related conflicts
                                  conflict situations?                          Water channels a total of less than 4% of
                                  Even if certain conflicts are directly        global Official Development Assistance
                                  related to competition over water             (ODA), i.e. some US 8 billion dollars a

                                                                                                                                                         A
                                  resources (Sri Lanka or the Gaza              year, and this has been plummeting
                                  Strip), in reality, there are more conflict   for 5 years. Financing in the water                    TERVIEW W                       ccess to water still causes    need to establish specific negotiation
                                                                                                                                  IN             I
                                  situations which lead to problems of          sector in humanitarian situations also                                                 conflicts between those        processes on water issues and

                                                                                                                             AN

                                                                                                                                                  TH
                                                                                accounts for less than 5% of total aid.                                                who share or fight over        anticipate the increase in water stress
                                                                                This is critical, especially considering                                               access to the same source.     and its consequences.
             “In reality, there are more                                        the fact that the first disaster response                                These tensions are even more serious,
                                                                                interventions are generally actions in the                               or even explosive in regions where water     Are water-related conflicts on the rise
             conflict situations which lead to                                  water and sanitation sector.                                             resources are scarce. This is the case on    in the Middle East?
                                                                                                                              FADI GEORGES
             problems of access to water                                        Finally, what we expect from the main
                                                                                                                                 COMAIR
                                                                                                                                                         the shores of the Mediterranean and all      All the causes of vulnerability are to
                                                                                multilateral institutional donors is more                                countries in the Middle East. There is a     be found in the Middle East! First of
             than the other way round”                                          flexibility to allow integrated and multi-   Wate r di pl o mat and
                                                                                                                                                         risk that they will be further exacerbated   all, 60% of water in countries in the
                                                                                sectoral projects to be supported, for       i nte rnati o nal ne go -   in the future by the consequences of         region comes from external countries.
                                                                                example, projects which link water and        ti ato r, Mi ddl e Eas t   climate change. For Georges Comair, a        Secondly, the region is experiencing
                                                                                nutrition. •                                        s pe c i al i s t    water diplomat, countries in the region      strong population growth, at a rate

16                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       17
WATER A GLOBAL CHALLENGE - ID4D
WATE R, A GL OBAL CHAL L EN G E                                                                                                                                                                                                                  WATE R, A GLOBA L CHA LLE NGE

                                                                                                                                                                                               TURKEY

                                                                                                                                                              GREECE
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     IRAN
                                      of about 3.8% per year. Finally, the                   equitable sharing and reasonable use                                                                            SYRIA
                                      quantity of water available per capita                 of water – a text which was ratified by                                                            LEBANON
                                      is low: 700m3 per capita per year in                   all countries in the region, with the                             Mediterranean
                                                                                                                                                                                                                            IRAQ
                                      the Middle East, against an average of                 exception of Israel and Turkey.                                           Sea                      ISRAEL
                                                                                                                                                                                       West Bank
                                      7,000m3 per capita per year worldwide.                 The texts of the United Nations
                                                                                                                                                                                     Gaza Strip
                                      Consequently, all the ingredients are                  Economic Commission for Europe
                                      there for conflicts. At the same time,                 (UNECE) can also be taken as an                                                                             JORDAN
                                      we have established major dynamics to                  example. The management of the
                                      promote dialogue between States.                       Danube is, for instance, exemplary:
                                                                                             all the countries which share the river                  LIBYA
                                                                                                                                                                             EGYPT
                                   What are these tools which promote                        negotiate and work together. This
                                   cooperation and sustainable water                         management model can be applied in                                                                  Red                    SAUDI ARABIA
                                   resources management?                                     the Middle East. The management of the                                                              Sea
                                   The UN texts, which I call “anti-crisis”                  Orontes River was the first success of
                                   texts, are there to build cooperation                     hydro-diplomacy in the Middle East.
                                   and peace and secure water for future
                                   generations.                                                     What is hydro-diplomacy?
                                   Countries with transboundary                                           I created this concept in the          between Palestine, Jordan, Syria, Israel      European Framework Directive, which         WAT E R
                                   basins will need to transfer                                              early 1990s. Hydro-diplomacy        and Lebanon. Israel decided to occupy         came into force in 2015. The principle

                                                                              14
                                   information, exchange                                                        refers to the fact of getting    the Palestinian Territories to secure         involves getting riparian countries of    S C A R C IT Y
                                   their databases, model                                                         all stakeholders in water      its access to water. This hegemonic           a watercourse together to agree on a        IN T H E
                                   the impact of climate                                                            management around            domination causes water and military          regulatory text (UN, European, Middle
                                   change affecting                                                                   the table in the context   conflicts. The Red Sea-Dead Sea               Eastern…) and organize an equitable
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        MID D L E E A S T
                                   these basins                           of the 33 likely                             of a new governance.      project might break the deadlock in this      sharing of water and its reasonable      m 3 p e r c a p ita p e r ye a r
                                   by conducting                      most water stressed                               The aim is to promote    situation. This canal between the Red         use. The creation of a basin agency
                                   technological                        countries in 2040                               the economic and         Sea and Dead Sea will supply additional       comes with three major questions: What                 + 2 ,5 0 0 m 3
                                   audits, and                      are in the Middle East                              social benefits for      desalinated drinking water, which will        governance should be adopted? What
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      + 1 ,7 0 0 m 3
                                   propose                                                                             transboundary basins      be equitably distributed between Jordan,      Water Code should be used? And what
                                                                    Source: Aqueduct Projected Water Stress
                                   adaptation plans.                   Country Rankings, Technical Note,              and work on preventing     Palestine and Israel.                         legislative text should be used in the                 + 1 ,0 0 0 m 3
                                   This is without                                WRI 2015
                                                                                                                    the militarization of        The Nile, for its part, concerns the two      event of dispute?
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      - 1 ,0 0 0 m 3
                                   forgetting that the                                                            water-related conflicts.       Sudans, Eritrea, Ethiopia and Egypt.          Governance is a central issue.
                                   countries upstream from                                                    I have applied this concept        Once it has been completed, the Grand         Riparian countries can opt for a Basin
                                   watercourses will need to                                           in the basin of the Orontes River,        Ethiopian Renaissance Dam will be             Commission, which is only composed        Source: Le Dessous des Cartes

                                   ensure that they do not cause harm to                      which originates in Lebanon, crosses               the largest hydropower dam in Africa          of technicians, or for a Basin Agency,
                                   countries located downstream.                              Syria and flows into the Mediterranean.            and will store approximately 80% of           which is more broadly composed of
                                   In the transboundary basins in the                         According to Unesco, the win-win                   the water from the Nile. There will be        politicians, researchers, industry
                                   Middle East, international legislative and                 agreement signed between Lebanon,                  serious consequences for food security        leaders, farmers… In the latter case,
                                   regulatory texts are increasingly being                    Turkey and Syria is a model for water              in Egypt, whereas the country is already      water demand management takes
                                   used. For example, the 1997 United                         management in the Middle East.                     faced with increased droughts and major       into account comprehensive plans for
                                   Nations Convention advocates for the                       I have also applied it in the context of           demographic pressure. Conversely, the         adaptation to changes, with measures
                                                                                              the Jordan River crisis, which affects             dam will secure Sudan’s energy needs.         concerning floods, droughts, the
                                                                                              Palestine, Lebanon, Israel and Jordan.             Consequently, it is not only water            transfer of populations, etc.
                                                                                              For the Nile, we will need to establish            sharing that is at issue, but also the food
             700m3 of             water per year are                                          an extremely dynamic hydro-diplomacy!              and energy security of countries. The         Apart from water sharing, what
             available to a Middle East                                                                                                          sectoral approach alone is no longer          problems can Basin Agencies provide a
                                                                                             Indeed, what are the current areas of               sufficient to work on water issues.           response to?
             inhabitant. It is almost 10 times                                               tension in the Middle East?                                                                       Basin Agencies can address problems
             less than the world average.                                                    There are many inter-State issues over              What is the role of Basin Agencies?           related to agriculture, the efficiency
                                                                                             water. For example, the Tigris and the              The concept of basin agencies came            of networks and financing structures.
                                                                                             Euphrates cross Turkey, Syria and Iraq.             about in France in the 1970s. It was          For example, in the Middle East, the
                                                                                             Water from the Jordan River is shared               extended to Europe in the context of a        agricultural sector is a huge water

18                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         19
WATE R, A GL OBAL CHAL L EN G E

                                                                                                                                                                                 GEOPOLITICS

                                  consumer and its irrigation methods
                                  need to be changed. But how to finance
                                                                               water stress, as is currently the case
                                                                               in Lebanon, with the 2 million Syrian
                                                                                                                                                      “In most cases,
                                  the necessary technological change?          refugees.
                                  The lack of efficiency of drinking water
                                  networks is also a central issue. In the
                                                                               The water shortage will also increase
                                                                               the security threat: the strongest
                                                                                                                                                     wars are not fought
                                  Middle East, there is a 40% loss rate on     countries will impose their hegemonic
                                  drinking water supply networks due to
                                  leaks, against 10% in Europe. How can
                                                                               management on the weakest countries
                                                                               and conflicts will intensify.
                                                                                                                                                        over water”
                                  they be stopped and service quality be       Finally, this increased scarcity will
                                  improved for citizens?                       cause an economic and environmental
                                  Consequently, the question of financing      shock. The economies of countries will

                                                                                                                                                          M
                                  is central to the water issue. Financing     be affected and river ecosystems will
                                  can be provided by systems of donors,        change: there will be fewer green areas,                TERVIEW W                        anagement and sharing          What is the extent of the water crisis?
                                                                                                                                  IN             I
                                  creditors (World Bank, European              less flora, less fauna. This will also have                                              of waters often provoke        It is estimated that 700 to 800 million

                                                                                                                             AN

                                                                                                                                                   TH
                                  Investment Bank, etc.), or by private        a number of consequences.                                                                conflicts in the world.        people lack sufficient clean drinking
                                  financing in the context of public-private   The Paris Pact on Water and Adaptation,                                                  Or more accurately,            water. The water crisis concerns water
                                  partnerships with regulatory agencies.       signed in 2015, provides for water data                                    awake underlying tensions between            pollution, over-use of rivers and lakes,
                                  This can finance the construction of         to be shared so that we can understand                                     States sharing the vital resource. For       depletion of underground waters.
                                  infrastructure, such as wastewater           how aquifer resources will be affected                                     Stephen McCaffrey, lawyer specialized        Internationally, problems often arise when
                                  treatment plants, which are essential        by global changes and develop common                STEPHEN                in watercourses management, zones of         one State sharing a river with another
                                  in preventing water in countries             responses. This type of framework does
                                                                                                                                  MCCAFFREY               hydroconflicts exist but conflicts there     State changes the way it uses the water.
                                  downstream from being polluted by            not exist in the Middle East. For the time         Di s ti ngui s he d     are not only related to water. A look on     It can be by building a dam, diverting
                                  countries upstream.                          being, the creation of a Mediterranean          Pro fe s s o r o f L aw,   international management of water and        some of the water for irrigation purposes
                                                                               Water Agency has not been able to             fo rme r I nte rnati o nal   water conflicts.                             or allowing new industrial activities to
                                  How is global warming threatening            materialize for diplomatic reasons. But        L aw Co mmi s s i o n’s                                                  discharge their waste into the river.
                                                                                                                              Spe c i al Rappo rte ur
                                  Middle East?                                 the negotiation is going to resume in the                                  When did water become a scarce
                                                                                                                                o n i nte rnati o nal
                                  The Middle East is one of the first          context of the “5+5” Dialogue, which I             w ate rc o urs e s      resource?                                    What is the peculiarity of water
                                  regions affected by global warming.          have the honor of chairing.                                                The amount of water on Earth has been        compared to other resources?
                                  According to the modelling of                                                                                           the same for billions of years and is not    Water is characterised by more
                                  climatologists, a temperature rise of two    What are the emergencies?                                                  likely to change. What has changed is        complicated problematics than other
                                  degrees will have an impact of 30% on        Without hesitation, political will! Without                                the planet’s human population. It has        natural resource issues: it is vital to
                                  rainfall over the next ten years.            dialogue between riparian countries,                                       multiplied many times even only since        human life and is also used for a wide
                                  Faced with the coming shortage,              without active hydro-diplomacy, conflicts                                  even the mid-20th century.                   range of purposes, from drinking and
                                  farmers will leave increasingly arid         will increase.                                                             In the second half of the 20th century,      generating electricity to powering mills
                                  areas and settle on the Mediterranean        The second need is education, as it is                                     water specialists and international          and irrigating agricultural lands. And it
                                  coasts. Rural areas will consequently        the basis of sustainable development.                                      organizations, such as the United            is also essential to the maintenance of
                                  lose their populations to large cities.      We need to train senior officials and                                      Nations, began to realize that the amount    a healthy environment as demonstrated
                                  In addition, the presence of these           educate young generations to ensure                                        of water per capita was decreasing           by the conclusions of the Kishenganga
                                  climate refugees will further increase       everyone understands that water is                                         sharply. And the link between water-         case which opposed Pakistan to India. The
                                                                               the condition for their survival in this                                   borne diseases and poor (or no)              Permanent Court of Arbitration found that
                                                                               region and that wastage has dramatic                                       sanitation also were better understood       India had the right to use the waters of
                                                                               consequences on supply. The population                                     during this period.                          the Kishenganga River for the production
             “We need to train senior                                          has a role to play!                                                        Perhaps oddly, severe famines during this    of hydroelectric energy, but it must do so
             officials, educate young                                          Finally, the third emergency is to work                                    period, such as that in Ethiopia, received   while ensuring a minimum environmental
                                                                               on the water-energy-food triptych, in                                      much coverage in the media, but were         flow to protect water resources, even
             generations to ensure they                                        the context of a regional body, in order                                   actually, for the most part, brought on by   though the 1960 Indus Waters Treaty
             understand that water is                                          to reduce the energy cost of water                                         droughts that prevented growing crops.       made no mention of such an obligation.
                                                                               and promote sustainable resources                                          So, water scarcity was manifested in food
             the condition for their survival”                                 management.                                                                scarcity. Finally, it must be said that we   How are problems of water
                                                                               And only good governance will make all                                     have much better information now than        management dealt with
                                                                               this possible. •                                                           we did fifty years ago on these matters.     internationally?

20                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  21
WATE R, A GL OBAL CHAL L EN G E                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               WATE R, A GLOBA L CHA LLE NGE

                                                                                                                                                                                  WATER, SOURCE OF CONFLICTS

                                                                                                                                           The Col umbi a                                                        The Danube                                              T h e S yr D a rya
                                                                                                                                               Ri ver                                                           Sl o v ak i a, Hungary                                        K yrg yzsta n ,
                                                                                                                                          Canada, United States                                                                                                               Uzb ekista n ,
                                              The legal framework for management          Silala (Chile v. Bolivia, 2016) were filed to                                                                                                                                       Ta jikista n ,
                   T RAN S-                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   K a za kh sta n
                                              of transboundary aquifers and               The Hague. Not counting the important
                  BOUND ARY
                                              watercourses is reflected in the 1997 UN    Kishenganga Arbitration (2013).
                   WAT E RS                   Convention on the Law of the Non-
                                                                                                                                                                                    The Dour o,
                                                                                                                                                                                 t he Tagus and
                                              Navigational Uses of International          Can water diplomacy contribute to                                                       t he Guadi ana
                                              Watercourses. This treaty is generally      build peace?                                                                                 Spai n,                                                                                    T h e I n d u s R i ve r
                                              accepted as a codification of the rules     Of course, it can. Because, it is                                                           Po rtugal                                                                                          and its
                                              of customary international law on the       fundamentally in the interest of States to                                                                                                                                                  t ri b u t a ri e s
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      In d ia , P a kista n
                                              subject. There are over 300 treaties        cooperate with States they share natural                                          The Senegal
                                              between countries sharing freshwater        resources with. Conflict is always more                                              Ri ver                                                                                                  The Mekong
                                                                                                                                          The Col or ado
                                              resources, and those treaties often         expensive than cooperation and its                                                    Se ne gal ,                                                                                              Ch in a , La os,
                                                                                                                                              Ri ver                           Mauri tani a
                                              establish their own implementation          outcome more uncertain. Cooperation                                                                                                                                                        V ietn a m, Th a ila n d ,
                                                                                                                                           Uni te d State s ,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           Ca mb od ia
                                              mechanisms, generally in the form of        can increase the basket of benefits                   Me x i c o
                         263                  joint commissions.                          available to all riparian States, getting
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                The Ganges
                  in t er n a ti o n a l      The implementation of treaties such         away from what is otherwise likely to                                                                                                               I ndi a, Bangl ade s h
                        r ivers                                                                                                                   The Cenepa                                   Sahar an
                                              as the UN Watercourses Convention           be a zero-sum game where one’s gain                                                                  aqui f er s
                                                                                                                                                     Ri ver
                                              and other bilateral and regional water      is always the other loss. In most cases,                 Ec uado r, Pe ru                           L i by a, Chad,
                                                                                                                                                                                                   Sudan
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         The Ni l e
                                              agreements will help and bring a            wars are not fought over water. Water-                                                                                                            Egy pt,
                                              sustainable and peaceful management         based conflict almost always reveals                                                                                                       Ethi o pi a, Sudan,
                                              of transboundary waters.                    an underlying problem, or problems,                      The Par aná                                         The Zambezi                         Uganda
                                                                                                                                                      Ri ver                                         Zambi a, Zi mbabw e
                                                                                          between the States concerned, giving
                                                                                                                                                 Braz i l , Paraguay,
                                              Are water-based conflicts increasing?       rise to tense relations between them,                     Arge nti na
                                              Based on the number of disputes             that water or any other trigger can set
                                              submitted to the International Court        off.                                                    unprecedented, torrential rainfall and               the early 1990s, with the realization                           Forecasts
                          145                 of Justice, one could conclude that                                                                 accompanying floods; and this has been               that governments were often not doing                           for 2025
              S t a t es’ t er ri to ri e s   water-based conflicts are increasing.       Are there some international examples                   borne out recently. The IPCC has also                enough to ensure that their populations
                a r e r u n thro u g h                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       Wat e r
                    or b or d e re d          But most water-related disputes are         of successful water management?                         predict that for each degree of global               had access to safe, clean water. In
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             s c ar c it y
                       b y su c h             not submitted to the Court, hence this      Examples of successful water                            warming, approximately 7% of the                     2003, the UN Committee on Economic,
             in t er n a t ion al ri v e rs   number is only the tip of the iceberg.      management include cooperative efforts                  global population is to be exposed to a              Social and Cultural Rights adopted                                    L ac k o f
                                              Only two cases (River Oder, 1929, and       of European countries concerning the                    decrease of renewable water resources                General Comment 15, The Right to                                      inf r as t r uc t ur e s
                                              Meuse, 1937) concerning the use of          Rhine and the Danube, both of which                     of at least 20%.                                     Water, recognizing that such a right
                                              shared freshwater resources had been        are governed by treaties that establish                 The uncertainties and changes in water               was included in articles 11 and 12 of                                 L it t le o r no
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             s ho r t age
                                              submitted to the World Court until the      joint commissions. We can also think of                 distribution and timing of availability              the ESC Covenant on the rights to an
                                              1990s. After 1997, year of the Gabcíkovo-   treaty arrangements between the United                  brought about by climate change make                 adequate standard of living and health.
                                              Nagymaros Project case opposing             States and its neighbours, Canada                       it urgent to build regimes for sustainable           According to the Comment, the right to                          Water conflict
                                              Hungary and Slovakia, there had been a      and Mexico, which also establish joint                  water management. It will be difficult               water entitles everyone to “sufficient,                         zones
                                              succession of cases, concerning various     management commissions. However;                        for even the most advanced countries                 safe, acceptable, physically accessible
                        300
                                              aspects of the use of rivers through        power asymmetries can skew equality                     to cope with these developments alone,               and affordable water for personal and
              t r ea t ies be tw e e n                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      H igh t e ns io n,
              cou n t r ies s h a ri ng       which, or along a bank of which, borders    of participation in the management                      and to the extent that shared freshwater             domestic uses.”
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            r is k o f w at e r
                   f r esh w ate r            run between countries (Navigational and     of shared freshwater resources as                       resources (including groundwater) are                The major challenge is in                                            w ar
                    r esou r c e s            Related Rights, 2009, Pulp Mills, 2010,     illustrated by the relationship between                 involved, it will be virtually impossible.           implementation of the right, especially
                                              Certain Activities, 2015, Construction      Israel and its neighbours, Lebanon,                     Thus, cooperation will become even                   - but not only - in developing countries.                             D is put e s o v e r
                                              of a Road, 2015) and dispute over the       Jordan, and especially, Palestine.                      more important as the effects of climate             International donors, both multilateral                               r e s o ur c e s har ing
                                              status and use of the waters of the                                                                 change, already observable, intensify.               and bilateral are supporting the                                      e t hydr aulic
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             ins t allat io ns
                                                                                          How climate change is aggravating                                                                            implementation of this right, but it
                                                                                          water crisis?                                           In a context of decreasing freshwater                will take time. The difficulties are
            “Conflict is always more                                                      Severely. The Intergovernmental Panel                   availability, how to make a human right              underscored by the fact that the US                             Sources: UN, UNDP

            expensive than cooperation”                                                   on Climate Change (IPCC) has long                       to water effective?                                  State of California, 6th largest economy
                                                                                          predicted that arid areas of the world                  A human right to water is not contained              in the world, recently had as many
                                                                                          will become even more dry, while humid                  in any of the basic human rights                     as 250,000 inhabitants for whom the
                                                                                          or well-watered areas will experience                   instruments. It has emerged, only in                 human right to water was not realized. •

22                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                23
WATE R, A GLOBA L CHA LLE NGE

                                                                                                                                                       Jamalpur District,
                                                                     GENDER                                                                            Bangladesh. A
                                                                                                                                                       woman uses a
                                                                                                                                                       manual pump to
                                                                                                                                                       collect drinking
                                                                                                                                                       freshwater.

            “Women and men have                                                                                                                                             For instance, tanks and ponds have been
                                                                                                                                                                            filled with concrete for the development
                                                                                                                                                                            of housing, malls, etc. affecting drainage

          differential roles, rights and                                                                                                                                    channels and leading to waterlogging
                                                                                                                                                                            during flash floods. Marginalised women
                                                                                                                                                                            in marginalised or fragile environments

                responsibilities”                                                                                                                                           prone to climate uncertainty are more
                                                                                                                                                                            vulnerable, as are women in conflict
                                                                                                                                                                            prone areas and refugee camps.

                                                                                                                                                                            How does water and sanitation scarcity

                                  W
                                                                                                                                                                            affect women and young girls’ life?
               TERVIEW W                           ater and sanitation sector                  Women have diverse water needs                                               Typically, girls in South Asia and in
          IN             I
                                                   is no exception and makes                   including water for both domestic                                            many regions of Africa spend more
     AN

                          TH

                                                   way for deep inequality                     (bathing, washing, drinking, cooking)                                        time fetching water and doing other
                                                   between men and women.                      and productive (agriculture, small                                           domestic chores compared to their
                                  There is a rising consciousness of the                       enterprises, aquaculture) purposes.                                          brothers. As girls reach puberty and
                                  gender inequalities in many fields of                        Access to water cannot be seen in                                            start menstruation, they are often pulled
                                  development, but gender questions                            isolation from access to sanitation and                                      out of school, particularly if there are
               SARA
                                  find little resonance in the water                           good hygiene, including menstrual                                            no sanitation facilities. No doubt these
             AHMED
                                  and sanitation sectors. Sara Ahmed,                           health management. And of course,                                           norms are being challenged and many
          Inde pe nd e n t        researcher    and  specialist of water,                               water quality and safe wastewater                                   organizations such as WaterAid and its
         re s e arc he r o n      rural  development    and  gender                                            disposal are as important as                                 partners have done a lot of awareness
     the po litic al e c o n o my equity, explains how women                                                      availability.                                             raising on Menstrual Hygiene matters in
        o f w ate r, r u r a l    are at a disadvantage when                                                         Competition and conflicts                              India. Taboos are being broken and low-
                                                                                      Women
          de v e lo p me n t
                                  it comes to water and                          and girls are                          over water, particularly                            cost sanitary napkins are being made
      and ge nde r e q u it y
             in Ind ia            sanitation.                                  responsible for                            in the context of water                           available to young women.

                                                                         8 10
                                                                            water collection in                             scarcity or multiple
                                  How is the global                                                                           uses from the same                            How to remedy water scarcity and
                                  water crisis a                                                                                water source can                            quality issues including social equity
                                  women’s issue?                                out of                                          impact women                                and gender justice?
                                  Gender equality                                                                               differentially, e.g.                        Keeping social equity and gender justice
                                  is at the heart of                         h o u se h o l d s                                 walking  further to                         as guiding principles in the development
                                  the Sustainable                       with water off premises                                collect water   for                          of policies and plans whether at the
                                  Development Goals                                                                           domestic purposes                             local, national or global level is critical.
                                                                           Source: Progress on drinking water,
                                  (Goal 5). Likewise,                     sanitation and hygiene: 2017 update               or using water of                               Good planning needs to be supported
                                                                           and SDG baselines, JMP Washdata.
                                  gender intersects with                                                                 poor quality. Long lines                           by strong analysis based on gender and
                                  other social relations                                                              at community stand posts                              socio-economically disaggregated data,
                                  of power, particularly in the                                                   and fights over water brought                             the use of practical participatory tools,
                                  developing world to determine who has                             by tankers are not uncommon in many                                     the development of gender-sensitive
                                  access to how much water, when and                           semi-arid areas prone to water scarcity.                                     indicators for monitoring and evaluation,
                                  where.                                                       In many parts of the world, gender                                           and not least, the equal participation
                                                                                               intersects with social caste to determine                                    of women. Sadly, both the water and
                                                                                               who has access to which water. Typically                                     climate sectors are largely gender blind,
     “Gender intersects with                                                                   in India, Dalit (lower caste) women often                                    though they pay adequate lip service to
                                                                                               are not allowed to access the village well                                   the need to address women and gender
     social caste to determine who                                                             or if they do, the area has to be purified                                   concerns.
     has access to which water”                                                                after they have withdrawn water.                                             Policies have been created to
                                                                                               Urbanisation and concomitantly, the                                          have women participating in water
                                                                                               growth of peri-urban areas has also put                                      management, but it needs also capacity
                                                                                               pressure on common water resources.                                          buildings and bottom up approaches.

24                                                                                                                                                                                                                                25
WATE R, A GL OBAL CHAL L EN G E                                                                                                                                                              WATE R, A GLOBA L CHA LLE NGE

                                                                                             Bukoba, Tanzania.
                                                                                             Every day, Mariam
                                                                                             Abkaraki fetches
                                                                                             water one kilometre
                                                                                             away from home.

                                        A lot can also be done locally – small               is often determined by land ownership,          supported by Unesco, was launched in
                                        actions that build social capital or support         which restricts women’s participation in        Venice in May 2017. I have been working
                                        autonomous adaptation efforts are great,             community water user associations where         in the water field for 30 years and I
                                        and likely to be more sustainable in the             decisions about crops and water rotations       am very interested in the relationship
                                        long term.                                           are taken. Male out-migration, seasonal         between art, culture and water. My
                                        I don’t really think that the situation              or otherwise, puts a larger burden on           dream was to have a water museum in
                                        has fundamentally changed in the last                women to manage homes and fields in             India.
                                        decades. Terms like “gender”, “equity”,              the absence of state recognition of their       We have started this virtual museum1
                                        “inclusion” are still very much on the               role as farmers – bypassed by agricultural      first with the idea to engage young
                                        margins of our discourse on water.                   extension workers as they are not recorded      people to learn about their water history
                                                                                             as heads of households. But migration           and water heritage. Water is so much a
                                            What could change the gender roles over          can also be seen as an adaptive strategy        part of our life that we take it for granted.
                                            water?                                           since remittances can be used to enhance        Young people must understand that
                                            Gender is dynamic and we are already             household water security – build water          water just doesn’t come out of a tap.
                                            seeing that a lot of roles are changing          storage and harvest rainwater in drought        People used to revere water. Poems,
                                            as men assume more responsibility                prone areas, or build a toilet or a flat-roof   stories, values, ethics: there is so much
                                            for household work and as women are              (for food storage) in flood prone areas.        about water in all cultures.
                                            engaged in collective action and decision-       In India, there have been reforms in
                                            making both at the household and                 public policy to accord greater land rights
                                            community level. Empowering women                to women, whether as sole holders or            “As girls reach puberty
                                            requires that they can first, freely access      joint, and several networks have been
                                            education (at a minimum, complete                negotiating with the State to ensure            and start menstruation, they
                                            school and if possible a graduate                that policy is implemented. But if there
                                                                                                                                             are often pulled out of school,
                                            degree or professional or skill-based            is no water, land cannot be cultivated,
                                            qualification). Secondly, women require          beyond the one or two rain-fed crops.           particularly if there are no
                                            assets in their names, whether it is land        Unfortunately, work on land rights has
                                                                                                                                             sanitation facilities”
                                            or a house or a well. Land reforms in            not always extended to water rights.
                                            India have played a role in facilitating joint
                                            ownership and encouraging women to               How giving better access to water can
                                                own a field of their own, or lease land      help empowering women?
                                                    collectively. And access to land         Access to water for domestic purposes
                                                       typically determines access           closer to her home can save women               The aim is not to fossilize history. Water
                                                          to water for agriculture.          the time and energy spent in collecting         is a connector across different faiths

                       200
                                                             Thirdly, capacity building      water, even though it does not                  and communities. Much of our so-
                                                              on the technical and           necessarily question gender roles:              called “old” water infrastructures have
                                                                financial aspects of         women continue to fetch water, and              withstood time and are still used (step
                        million hours                            managing local water        make even more frequent trips as                wells, tanks, karez, etc.). Through digital
                        are lost every day                        infrastructure is          household water demand increases.               narratives, we want to show how people
                       by women and girls                         equally important.         Time saved can be used for income-              have used and managed water in the
                      spend collecting water                      There are examples of      generating opportunities. For                   past and how these water systems have
                                                                women being trained as       example, the Self-Employed Women’s              been adapted through times.
                                                               handpump mechanics,           Association’s (Indian NGO) Water                Through this virtual museum, we want
                             Source: Unicef
                                                             masons or water pump            and Work campaign was built on this             to demonstrate the importance of
                                                         operators, but these are few        connection with members organizing              interdisciplinarity and, collaboration
                                                     and far between.                        around the development of local water           between artists, scientists, engineers,
                                                                                             resources that they could manage.               water professionals… Water is a flow
                                        Why are women’s land rights important                                                                resource, and more importantly, a shared
                                        to build water security?                             Last year, you launched the online              resource. We need to think about water
                                        Women and men have differential roles,               Living Waters Museum. Why is it                 in a systemic and integrated manner. •
                                        rights and responsibilities in relation to           important to promote water heritage?
                                        water – their access to water for irrigation         A global network of water museums,              1
                                                                                                                                                 www.livingwatersmuseum.org

26                                                                                                                                                                                                                     27
You can also read