TREE CONNECTIONS 11.05 11.07.2021 - An Art and Exhibition Project by Klaus Littmann - Kulturstiftung ...

Page created by Enrique Carrillo
 
CONTINUE READING
An Art and Exhibition Project by
                                                               Klaus Littmann

TREE CONNECTIONS
   from Christian Friedrich Gille to Christo

 11.05.– 11.07.2021
LIST OF DISPLAYED WORKS                  VITO ACCONCI                                  ANONYMOUS                                      ANONYMOUS
                                         (1940–2017)                                                                                  China, 17 th century (Ming & Qing dynasty)
In the following all descriptions are
listed chronologically in alphabetical   Model for War Memorial in the Middle          Komposition mit morschem                       Tree root sculpture for meditation
order following the surnames of the      of the Trees, 1984                            Baumstamm, around 1820                         made from different parts, H: 60 cm
exhibiting artists.                      Mixed media, Plexiglas, wooden box,           Oil on paper, 34.5 × 27.2 cm
                                         43 × 116 × 119 cm                                                                            The material astonishes with its multiple
Texts on the exhibits:                                                                  The small format is the key here. Views       levels of reality. There is root wood at
Regine Bungartz and Isabel Zürcher       “It’ll grow over in time,” or “Let’s just wait from above and below converge so              the base, looking as though churned by
                                         for the dust to settle.” These sayings,        closely that our own point of view begins     stormy seas, riddled with unpredictable
© 2021 KBH.G                             often reeled off in passing, imply that a      to waver. Here is a tree revealing its        whorls and shadowy hollows. A bough
                                         catastrophe has gone before. Getting           innermost secrets while—like a morbidly       marked by notches rises from it like
                                         over it will take some time and depend         evocative eruption—it shoots up into          antlers, obstinately pushing upward in its
                                         on the reliability of natural cycles. In the the sky. Its consistency seems mossy,           urge to grow. In the dynamic interaction
                                         face of war and annihilation, plants are       with thin shoots disappearing into the        of the two elements we see a windswept
                                         bearers of hope. Eucalyptus trees grow         blue ground, hopelessly trying to tether      tree standing on an exposed crag: Who
                                         quickly and their leaves form a canopy         the overpowering creature. The soft           is holding whom, what has this wood
                                         that is at once dense and airy, while          greens and browns, mottled and porous,        witnessed in its long life and how old
                                         their slender, branchless trunks enable        are reminiscent of a painter’s palette,       will it still become?
                                         them to be planted in closely packed           inter­mixing flatly with streaks of impasto
                                         rows. Vito Acconci’s War Memorial              paint. Such primeval power from an
                                         nonetheless leaves room for architec-          anonymous hand heralded the art of
                                         tural elements to be placed around the         Surrealism in the nineteenth century.
                                         roots. Seating conforming to the order         Max Ernst would later call his pictorial
                                         of the forest provides a shady oasis for       fantasies intermingling massed roots,
                                         commemorating the countless unknown masks, and monsters “swamp angels.”
                                         departed.
ANONYMOUS                                   HANS ARP                                       PI-RO AUTENHEIMER                            STEPHAN BALKENHOL                          JOSEPH BEUYS
(Mali, 10 th –15 th century)                (1886–1966)                                    (1933–1997)                                  (* 1957)                                   (1921–1986)

Small door, ironwood, 35 × 23 cm            Figure-Fleur-Chute, 1951                       Untitled, 1962                               Katzenfrau (Cat Woman) 4, 2004             von hier aus 7000 Eichen                    monumental sculpture at the Academy
                                            Relief, 27 × 21 × 4 cm                         Wood, metal (chainmail),                     Wawa wood, colored, 172 × 39.5 × 30 cm (Mitwirken durch eine Baumspende)               in Düsseldorf. Beuys responded to the
It is difficult to discern how human and                                                   22 × 38.5 × 25 cm                                                                       1982                                        “forest of sculptures” he re-called from
animal relate to one another here, but      Constellation ‘Amphore’, 1955                                                               Complete with pedestal, the nude statue Poster, offset, signed                         the days of the Nazi regime with the
they both emerge from the same wood.        Relief, 31 × 21 × 4 cm                         We are asked to accept the boards as         is life-sized—a stylite that looks almost                                              aspiration to set social processes in
Whoever it was that released them so                                                       they are: too short, too long, sometimes     dainty, in a tranquil pose. Splinters and  On March 16, 1982, Joseph Beuys             motion through art. This idea was new at
straightforwardly from the grain, it is     Working in relief—not quite sculpture          riddled with nails. Pi-Ro Autenheimer        furrows in her surface keep her at a       planted on the edge of Friedrichsplatz in   the time, as were Beuys’s art “actions,”
clear that carrier and sign, ground and     and not quite picture—Hans Arp tried for       offers found objects as a sculptural col-    distance, bearing witness to the artist’s  front of the Museum Fridericianum           and proved highly attractive to students
figures are one. The old door from Mali     decades to strike different balances:          lage, undramatic and rapidly assembled.      manual labor. Balkenhol carves and         the first tree for his action 7000 Oaks.    in particular. Resistance is not futile
reveals once more the fascination felt      between presence and absence, here             Horse and rider exhibit a crude whimsy       hews each of his figures from a stake                                                  and no institutional rule is sacrosanct.
by many modernist European artists          and there, shadow and light. In his            that would be hard to top. Harking           of African Wawa wood. They display the Joseph Beuys and Bernhard J. Blume,             7000 Oaks was what Beuys called his
for artifacts from far-off continents and   hands, even solid wood gives the impres-       back to the portentous tradition of the      characteristic traces of his work openly, Kontakt mit Bäumen, 1982 Print on            contribution to the 1982 documenta in
cultures. Paul Klee comes to mind with      sion that the forms could shift again at       equestrian statue, they are the diamet-      even flagrantly. A human body with         paper, signed by Beuys and Blume            Kassel, with the subtitle “City Forestation
his reduced figures—coming together         any moment. It’s all very simple. And          rical opposite of bricolage: Astride his     a cat’s head would normally strain the                                                 Instead of City Administration.” Seeing
and diverging again in their loose          everything is in motion, dream figures         magnificent steed, the proud command-        imagination, but the soft wood fuses       7000 Eichen, documenta VII, 1982            more and more high-priced status sym-
distribution across the picture plane.      and metamorphoses on a wooden game             er was for centuries the embodiment of       them in peaceful coexistence. A long       Black-and-white offset, graphite            bols circulating in the art market, Beuys
Witnesses to bygone days seem to have       board. A vegetable form or the outline         state and military power. All that remains   cultural history demonstrates how con-     signature, 14.7 × 10.5 cm                   planted tree after tree in Kassel—not
been excavated out of this wooden           of a human body? Top and bottom seem           here of such omnipotence is a frail          ducive this organic material is to convey-                                             for sale and with the participation of a
panel, the tool marks intermingling with    interchangeable; for Arp, amphorae are         skeleton, like a rickety chair that would    ing a vision, releasing never-before-seen Rettet den Wald, 1972                        public that is likewise far removed
the fibers of the material. Depending       related to female forms. Every element is      not even support the weight of a child.      beings from its core. flowing, other times Offset on paper, signed and numbered,       from art.
on the fall of light, the figures look as   animated and personified; positive and         As a throw-away relic of the comman­         geometric edges, or was it chance and      41 × 29.3 cm
though engraved while begging us to be      negative are interdependent, either tec-       der’s armor, the chainmail likewise          the magic of their inventors?
remembered: We engrave in our memo-         tonically like a blueprint for architecture,   undermines any gesture of menace, its                                                   “Save the forest!”: This 1972 appeal
ries things that should be preserved and    or perhaps like the contour of a sand-         rattling long since silenced by rust.                                                   has lost none of its relevance. Armed
not lost.                                   bank spared by the waves. Has the wood                                                                                                 with brushwood brooms, the group sets
                                            grain inspired the sometimes flowing,                                                                                                  off, Joseph Beuys (with hat) in the lead,
                                            other times geometric edges, or was it                                                                                                 a vi­­sual artist, founding member
                                            chance and the magic of their inventors?                                                                                               of the Greens Party, and professor of
FRANZ BURKHARDT                                                                        MIRIAM CAHN                                    ALEXANDRE CALAME                             CHRISTO
(* 1966)                                                                               (* 1949)                                       (1810–1864)                                  (1935–2020)

Rue Chateau de Graaf, 2020                  quickly by a masterful hand, overlooks a   Untitled, 1989                                 Fallen Tree – Struck by Lightning,           Wrapped Trees                                appearance, had the effect of revealing
Pencil and ink on paper,                    section of the wayside. The artist zooms   Charcoal on paper, 58.5 × 58.5 cm              ca. 1840                                     Project for the Fondation Beyeler,           for the first time the sculptural power of
26 × 20.7 cm                                back here to the nineteenth century,                                                      Oil on paper on canvas, 29.4 × 51 cm         Riehen, Switzerland, 1997                    their crowns. Transforming the Champs-
                                            evoking images of longing. Or does this    Drawing is touch, the hand coming                                                           Pencil, charcoal, pastel, wax crayon, and    Elysées into an avenue of surreal-looking
Böschwey, 2021                              leafless growth instead capture a scene    into contact with charcoal and paper.          Tronc d’hètre, c. 1849                       fabric sample, 106.6 × 244 cm                fabric creatures has so far remained a
Pencil and ink on paper,                    of the impenetrably dense present?         Traces of the working process are part         Oil on cardboard, 45.5 × 33 cm                                                            utopian dream—a symbolic act of protec-
40.5 × 28.3 cm                                                                         of the motif. Unadorned and for that                                                        Wrapped Trees                                tion for the city’s trees.
                                                                                       all the more striking, a lone small tree       The almost tender precision in the           Project for the Avenue des Champs-
Container 2 Kubik, 2020 –2021                                                          juts willfully into the field of paper. The    rendering of foliage, trunk, and moss        Elysées, 1987
Mixed media, plywood, Styrodur,                                                        branching packs emotional power. Firmly        fails to distract from the drama. The        Color lithograph with collage of
Styrofoam, paint,                                                                      anchored in soft charcoal black, short         trunk lies rent open, its insides erupt-     transparent polyethylene, thread, staples,
12 × 200 × 210 cm                                                                      lines fan out straight to form the figure.     ing in all directions like flames. Badly     felt marker, 71 × 56.5 cm
                                                                                       Vehemence and tenderness could hardly          wounded, the sturdy tree has been
There’s not much left of the barn, the                                                 be more closely aligned. Basel-based           forced to surrender to the lightning         The plans never fail to impress. Christo
wooden wall, or the roof truss. A motley                                               artist Miriam Cahn has attracted interna-      strike. Alexandre Calame’s trees are         and Jeanne-Claude knew just what they
assortment of boards, painted and                                                      tional acclaim for her relentless, polit-      more than mere nature studies. Their         wanted to do and brought many an
gone gray over the years, the rubble of                                                ically motivated visual language. Like         knotted boughs, mottled bark, and            ambitious idea to fruition through draw-
a wooden structure, is now heaped in                                                   a seedling of her art, drawing strength        subtle torsion bear witness to long lives,   ings, sketches, or collages. And they
a container. Used, spent, unusable, and                                                from refusing to ingratiate itself, the tree   testify to their defiance and majesty,       not infrequently did so in the face of
ready for removal. Is art now trying                                                   defies the dusty winds.                        demand our respect and inspire               official resistance. Each visualization,
to pillory our material consumption?                                                                                                  wonder. We can sense the crown of            designated as a “project,” speaks for
Is it suggesting that the patina of aging                                                                                             the beech tree towering far above us         feasibility and anticipates what has since
roof battens makes for a modern-day                                                                                                   by the way it filters the fall of light.     become, and will remain, an indelible
painting? In the drawing, the chaotic                                                                                                                                              memory. For example the 178 trees on
jumble, several times removed from its                                                                                                                                             the Berower estate in Riehen that were
natural origins, returns to its roots. A                                                                                                                                           each wrapped in a polyester cocoon in
tangle of intractable branches, sketched                                                                                                                                           1998. Their isolation, indeed their dis-
TONY CRAGG                                     HANS EMMENEGGER                             SONJA FELDMEIER                                 AKSELI GALLEN-KALLELA                     CHRISTIAN FRIEDRICH GILLE
(* 1949)                                       (1866 –1940)                                (*1965)                                         (1865–1931)                               (1805–1899)

Level Head, 2005                               Waldbild, before 1934                       The Peepul Tree, 2020                           A lake view (Lake Keitele), 1905          Gestürzter Baum, um 1830               in his studio, probably in order to paint
Wood, 91 × 65 × 60 cm                          Oil on canvas, 46 × 31 cm                   Video, 25 min 13 sec                            Oil on canvas, 47 × 36.5 cm               Oil on primed paper, 29,3 × 40 cm      it later in oil in a different format. There,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                            his senses zeroed in on new details. His
No living body is ever completely at rest,     What is surface here and what is trans-     The felling of the tree is violent; it is       Akseli Gallen-Kallela sets two trees       Baumstudie freier Äste, um 1840       brushstrokes are sometimes impetuous,
but not many rotate as exuberantly and         parent? Are we looking at a forest, or      physical and unintentionally sculp­tural.       against a luminous backdrop at the pre- Oil on paper, 26,4 × 26,8 cm             quickly sketching treetops almost im-
yet strictly horizontally as Tony Cragg’s      does the image spirit us away into          For days on end, a team of several men          cise moment when darkness is about to                                            pressionistically. The forest seems utterly
Level Head. Neither column nor torso,          a world of visions and dreams? Warm         sawed, hacked at, and dismantled the            swallow up all the colors. A pine bough    Waldstudie, um 1840                   windless—as if it had grown there pri-
the figure tries to capture at once both       sunlight casts the silhouettes of trees     sturdy tree shrine in the northern Indian       hangs down, protruding into our field of Oil on paper on cardboard, 53 × 38,5 cm marily for the benefit of our observation.
inner turbulence and outward velocity:         on the tall trunks of their companions,     city of Haridwar. The old giant had             vision. It is answered by a filigree birch                                       Looking more laid out than torn out of
Does it perhaps evoke a drastic state          raising almost symmetrical branches         to make way for the main road to be             stem pushing its way up from the lower Baumkrone gegen blauen Himmel,            the ground, two trunks nestle together
of personal agitation? Or perhaps the          out of the darkness like a slender cross.   widened in advance of the pilgrimage            edge as a delicate counterpart, signaling um 1850                                like legs, the protagonist having left the
frozen trail of a frenetic dance or a vortex   Hans Emmenegger camouflages this            festival. Sonja Feldmeier captured the          spring and renewal. Like the rosy sunset Oil on handmade paper on cardboard,     picture field, caught up in the cheerful
in swirling water? “I am interested in         artful lighting with the pretext of a       event with her camera, condensing it            with lake and forest in the background,    37,7 × 27,5 cm                        green of the spring leaves.
formal construction that runs through          simple forest scene. There is movement      down to twenty-five minutes. The Peepul         both elements are characteristic of Nordic
the work,” says the artist. The laminat­-      here, as trunk for trunk the trees send     Tree renders us speechless as we stop           Expressionist painting.                    Zweigstudie, um 1860
ed wood is conducive to conveying              us wordless signs via the shadows of        in the midst of all the hustle and bus-                                                    Graphite on paper, 14,5 × 19 cm
dy­namism, able to be sawn, layered,           their neighbors.                            tle, market activities, noise, and traffic
sand­ed. The elongation, inclination,                                                      to bear witness to a baffling sacrilege.                                                  Christian Friedrich Gille gives us in his
multiplication, and rotation of stacked                                                    There are still visitors in the shrine at the                                             sketch a course in both art and nature.
ellipses play variations on an irresistible                                                foot of the sacred peepul tree even as                                                    Fascinated by the crooked growth of the
pull that draws the gaze into ever new                                                     it is being felled. Why must a Hindu                                                      tree, its contorted surfaces and the al-
circumambulations. The layered tempo,                                                      shrine be destroyed to make room for                                                      ternation between gnarled old wood and
the liquefied wood are dizzying, putting                                                   a Hindu pilgrimage festival? In order                                                     young shoots, the painter has recorded
our visual habits to the test as we con-                                                   to distract from this contradiction, the                                                  the details in color with scientific pre-
tinually discern a new head or bust from                                                   authorities engaged only men of Muslim                                                    cision. Plein air painting was foreign to
every angle.                                                                               faith as tree-cutters.                                                                    him. He instead set down on paper his
                                                                                                                                                                                     rendering of the lichen-covered bough
MICHAEL GITLIN                              NIKLAUS HASENBÖHLER                          EDGAR HONETSCHLÄGER                           KIM JUNG-MAN                               TADASHI KAWAMATA                            WILLIAM KENTRIDGE
(* 1943)                                    (1937–1994)                                  (* 1967)                                      (* 1954)                                   (* 1953)                                    (* 1955)

Improvised Shelter 2, 1987                  Autumn Leaf, 1993                            Ki, Vienna, 2020                              Drawing Shadows (from the series           Tree Hut in Madison Square Park, NY,        Lekkerbreek, 2013
Wood, 139,5 × 117 × 79 cm                   Charcoal on Ingres paper, 65 × 50 cm         Japanese ink on Washi (Japanese hand-         Street of Broken Heart), 2012              2008                                        Linocut on Universal Technological
                                                                                         made paper), 63 × 93 cm                       Hanji (Korean traditional paper),                                                      Dictionary (or Familiar Explanation
Sculptural concerns l, 1987                  The oscillations ripple outward and the                                                   black wood frame, 150 × 110 cm            It is the most rudimentary of dwellings      of the Terms) used in all Arts and
Wood, 56 × 51 × 38 cm                        lines circle around their model as if       Alba, Vienna, 2020                                                                      and yet it signals a lawless realm. Cob-     Sciences by George Crabb, 1826
                                             poised to take off and transform the        Japanese ink on Washi (Japanese hand-         Perhaps the tree trunk speaks of affec-   bled together from simple boards, the        Paper, 170 × 108 cm
At some point, something’s got to give,      autumn leaf into something altogether       made paper), 63 × 93 cm                       tion without using words. Doesn’t the     hut bespeaks poverty and the will to sur-
right? We know, sense, feel when our         new. In autumn especially, growth rebels                                                  sight of the slender shadow cast upon it vive but, even more, civil disobedience.      “Lekkerbreek,” which means “breaking
own body is out of kilter before we          against wilting and withering away.         He has been described as a utopian re-        presuppose tender attention? A silhou-    In Madison Square, where the property        easily,” is the vernacular name for a
can put it into words. We perceive and       Niklaus Hasenböhler has inflated his        alist. But the artist, filmmaker, and envi-   ette runs through the body of the tree    prices are the highest anywhere in the       small tree that grows on sandy ground
control our balance unconsciously in a       autumn leaf like a sail that wants to       ronmental activist Edgar Honetschläger        and cuts it in half below the V-shaped    world and the airspace is now also           in South Africa. So the title already tells
highly complex, internalized process. But capture one last time everything that has      is also a mobilizer. Something needs          fork. The line is soft and playful, un-   being sold on the stock exchange, the        the whole story. Because the constantly
what if we were to observe a perpetual       motivated, indeed driven, his art up to     to be done, and he is a doer. For his         dramatic like a strand of hair that falls tree house defies capitalist profiteering.   rewritten, blurred, invented, and fab-
state of falling, sliding, drifting apart?   this point. The artist was drastic in his   international renaturalization project Go     across a face it distracts us for a few   Without taking up expensive ground,          ricated political reality of that country
Michael Gitlin’s objects unleash stored      treatment of the themes he came upon        Bugs, Go, land is being acquired collec-      moments from the robust growth. We        it nests in a habitat usually reserved for   remains the challenge and frame of
sensations of weight, volume, and            in the social margins, dashing loneli-      tively to be barred from human use for        feel the urge to reach out and touch      birds. Tree Hut is the symbol of an up-      reference for William Kentridge’s entire
balance in space. The Israeli-American       ness and doubt onto his canvases with       the sole purpose of giving insects back       the smooth bark, like an arm, a torso, a  ward flight and a memorial that is           oeuvre, which has grown out of drawing.
artist, who was born in South Africa,        expressive vehemence. His drawings          their habitat. Giving, not taking, is the     leg: a presence more comforting than      perhaps also meant to remind us that         Ground and figure are related here in
explodes the rules of Minimal Art, frag-     only came to public attention late in his   order of the day if we are to construc-       cunning. Drawing Shadows is part of the the urban park was once a place for            such a way that the horizontal lines of
menting the cube into individual parts to career. In retrospect, an “autumn leaf”        tively combat the destruction of the envi-    photographic series Street of Broken      ephemeral games. David is challenging        text disrupt the image. Conversely, the
undermine any impression of monumen- seems like a harbinger of his untimely              ronment. Honetschlaeger’s ink drawings        Heart, which Kim Jung-man published       Goliath here. Because no matter how          motif—the tree—lambently rebels against
tality. Finally, he hints via the title that death—and like a stark departure from       bring to light the endangerment of            both as individual prints and in book     provisional and model-like this hunter’s     a canonized, neatly ordered realm of
sculpture is something that concerns         nature studies of earlier                   nature reserves. How much longer will         format. The perforations along the top    aerie may look, it leaves a lasting im-      knowledge. Fractures are inscribed in
us: “Improvised Shelter” and “Sculptural                                                 the trees in the foreground last? Is there    edge allude to a before and after, like a pression as a cunning attack on civiliza-    the sharp contrast of black and white,
Concerns” are plastic physical evidence                                                  a sky without power cables, and where         tear-off calendar. Moments follow one     tional megalomania.                          and cracks are everywhere. There can
of the need to acknowledge uncertainty                                                   do they all lead anyway?                      upon the other, sensitive observations                                                 be no unified story on a ground that has
in life.                                                                                                                               made in passing on a solitary walk.                                                    been subject to such massive interfer-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                              ence.
PER KIRKEBY                                  JANNIS KOUNELLIS                            KRIŠTOF KINTERA                              SOL LEWITT                                   KLAUS LITTMANN                                 DAVID NASH
(1938–2018)                                  (1936–2017)                                 (* 1973)                                     (1928 –2007)                                 (* 1951)                                       (* 1945)

Crystal Tree, 1985                           Untitled, 2004                              Nervous Trees, 2013                          Square #4, 2004                              Arena for a Tree, 2021                         Crack and Wrap Column, 2010
Oil on canvas, 200 × 150 cm                  Tree trunks, barbed wire, steel,            Electro-mechanical object, fiber glass,      Wood, paint 97.2 × 36.8 × 36.8 cm            Site specific installation, 8 × 12 m           Oak, 197 × 53 × 51 cm
                                             200 × 360 × 45 cm                           globe, DC motor, electronic control unit,
Gemstones are created in absolute                                                        battery                                      It has already been quite some time          The layout of the space here harks back        Wood is a consuming passion for the
darkness, under enormous pressure.           Steel, tree, barbed wire—it doesn’t take                                                 since design, handwork, and manufac-         to the dawn of occidental culture. At first    British artist David Nash. He continually
Luminous and precious, they are re-          much to evoke associations of imprison-     Humor can provide fertile soil when it       ture were disassociated once and for all.    a battleground, then a theater, and finally    puts its malleability to the test, watch-
trieved from the earth after gradual         ment, torture, and extermination. What      comes to dealing with tense or hopeless      While originality, along with the artist’s   an arena has since antiquity offered a         es its natural growth, and also lets the
geological processes have lent them a        non-place did this fence once screen        situations. Krištof Kintera’s Nervous        personal handwriting and skill, long         setting where everyone has a view of           material speak for itself in sculptures
variety of intense hues. Crushed gem-        off, what wasteland yawns behind it?        Trees seem to have been nourished by         gave art its special aura, in the 1960s      the events taking place in the center.         made for interior spaces. In his Crack
stone is used as a pigment, one of the       Jannis Kounellis runs the wire through      just such humus. They hold the globe,        industrially produced products, including    The rows of seats build a horizontally         and Wrap Column, the artist has for-
original ingredients in the production of    each tree trunk as if through a body. And   trembling, in their uprooted clutches.       laths, grids, and sheet metal, made their    structured shell. Their stacked arrange-       mulated both a design principle and its
paints and dyes. This was surely doubly      yet these posts still have growth poten-    A troupe of electromagnetically motored      way into art studios and workshops.          ment protects without enclosing and            opposite, presenting a concept and its
significant to the geologist and artist      tial; their weight could put the wire’s     skeletal trees displays to us the fate-      Artists became contractors, delegating       screens without shutting out the air. In       paradoxical counterpart: Fracture and
Per Kirkeby, because the dynamics of         tensile strength to the test. Dented        ful reversal of the usual conditions: In     the actual execution of their work. In the   such an arena, the protagonist can find        envelopment, a continuous chain and in-
paint layered onto canvas and the layers     and bent, it too attests to tremendous      the unrestrained exploitation of natu-       case of Sol LeWitt, this freed him up to     a place for itself in the city. As a growing   termittent cracks determine the rhythm
of rock are related. Body-high brush-        willpower. Tree trunks, barbed wire, and    ral resources, the globe becomes the         focus all the more intensely on his own      sculpture, a source of shade, or a host        in which the individual parts rest atop
strokes—in agate black, amethyst, emer-      steel set the pace here, a mute appeal      nerve center of a system spiraling out of    alphabet of space. Here, cubic spatial       for birds and insects, the tree proposes       one another. Joining and separating are
ald green—have spent several seasons         to flee this fateful situation.             control. Can growth also be a bad thing?     elements framed by square timbers            itself as a one-off event. The arena will      the two opposing operations that make
in the studio, storing a previous stage                                                  Head over heels, the little trees start to   are placed on top of and next to each        remain standing on Basel’s Münsterplatz       the column grow. In the upward-tapering
in each overpainting. “To paint,” Kirkeby                                                dance—and we may find our laughter           other. Their stacking is in the process of   until May 24—and then seek new audi-           silhouette a tree is still present—and at
once said, “means to surpass intellectual                                                sticking in our throat.                      growth, pushing up a permeable volume        ences in other cities, in each case for a      the same time flirts with the simulation
clarity.” To accomplish this, he opens up                                                                                             and building a prototypical framework.       different tree.                                of a tower or skyscraper. The reproduc-
color spaces that are almost physically                                                                                               Square is free of any architectural func-                                                   tion of natural growth creates its own
accessible and invites us into the earth’s                                                                                            tion, merely enveloping empty space                                                         architecture.
interior.                                                                                                                             according to the principle of repetition.
                                                                                                                                      The seemingly rigid, modular order hones
                                                                                                                                      our sense of rhythms and proportions,
                                                                                                                                      of planning and ordering, and of the stu-
                                                                                                                                      pendous mobility of shadow and light.
LOUISE NEVELSON                                HANS OP DE BEECK                             MERET OPPENHEIM                                                                             GIUSEPPE PENONE                               MARKUS RAETZ
(1899–1988)                                    (* 1969)                                     (1913 –1985)                                                                                (* 1947)                                      (1941–2020) / Daniel Spoerri (*1930)

Untitled, 1976–1978                            Blossom Tree, 2018                           Herbst, 1930                                 root wood fluff itself up like a bird all by   Ripetere il Bosco, Frammento 14,              Palette, 1989
Wooden relief, paint,                          Steel, concrete, polyurethane, exposy        Watercolor on paper,                         itself? There he turns to and fro on the       2007/ 2008                                    Mixed media, 97 × 96 × 26 cm
213.4 × 87.6 × 12.7 cm                         resin, coating, plywood,                     25 × 31 cm                                   branch like a flag in the wind, a dancer       Wood, 261 × 30 × 14 cm
                                               1656 × 1706 × 275 cm                                                                      with head held proud but a bit unsteady,                                                     It is possible to draw using little sticks—
A door can be locked and bolted, but                                                        Er sieht sich um, 1971                       a piece of plastic for his beak. “He’s         Sculpture is what it is, what it is made      no one knew that better than Markus
Louise Nevelson’s relief is more than          Few building materials are considered        Cadavre exquis, wood, metal, bicycle         looking around,” is the succinct name          of. With no need for a pedestal, the core     Raetz. Or one can declare a tabletop to
that. Along its central axis, three open-      less natural than gray concrete. And         reflector,                                   Oppenheim gave her piece. And we               detaches itself from its sheathing. The       be a picture and marvel at the way the
ings are suggested, and yet there is no        steel or polyurethane can also be cast       H: 29 cm                                     suddenly remember what it is to be             beam—a building component, ready to           remains of a working session or a meal
sign of a handle or knob to open these         smoothly in virtually any form. When                                                      creative.                                      become part of a floor or roof—seems to       look when hung on the wall—in his
supposed hatches. The heads of the             melded together, they swallow the am-        Waldtempelchen, 1974                                                                        reclaim its origins. A beam is a piece of     “Tableaux-pièges,” or “snare pictures,”
screws sunk deep into the wood are             bient light. These material qualities give   Mixed media,                                                                                wood is a beam is a work of art is a tree.    Daniel Spoerri pays homage to the
likewise camouflaged. Black as coal,           Op de Beeck’s Blossom Trees a soulless       31.5 × 37.5 × 29.5 cm                                                                       The levels of meaning flow into each          moment. Both artists realized that what
the wood takes on a metallic character.        air, making them seem like mere models                                                                                                   other, or more precisely: grow into each      we see is a matter of perspective. In
Precisely aligned elements evoke a wide        that quote and echo a memory of Asian        Nothing is impossible and certainly not                                                     other. Few artists of his generation have     this work, the friends came together
range of images: mischief black as night       prints. Rigorously cultivated and tamed,     in dreams, which sort things according                                                      dealt with trees as long and intimately       and each contributed in his own way
or the strict principles of composition;       the tree seems to have become here           to their own laws. As if in her sleep,                                                      as Giuseppe Penone. Trees are for him         to a playful moment of illusion. One of
suffocating rejection or a curiosity that is   nothing more than an easycare prop.          Meret Oppenheim was able to dissolve                                                        much more than just a motif or “theme”:       them seems to have scribbled on and
ignited especially by a blocked passage.       Summer and winter alike, it delights us      the boundaries of established object art.                                                   Their growth and bracing, their stability     then collaged slips of paper and pho­
Louise Nevelson, the daughter of Jewish        with a touch of pink—delicate like the       The artist simply called the beings she                                                     and vulnerability, are at the very heart of   tographs, while the other froze his studio
immigrants to the USA, worked with             spring? Op De Beeck is putting us to the     created, often from found items, choses                                                     his entire artistic production.               table and threaded it in as a tribute to
material that literally lay at her family’s    test: How far can he push his artificial     (things). Taking a playful delight in                                                                                                     his friend and part of his own oeuvre.
feet: Her father owned a sawmill, and          naturalness before it fails to seduce us?    alienation, she coaxed out the poetry in                                                                                                  Immune to any artistic handwriting, the
wood waste and furniture fragments             How little does it take for a synthetic      inanimate objects. Craft and mystery are                                                                                                  wood bows to this appropriation and, as
would become Nevelson’s raw material,          blossom to awaken in us the magic and        not contradictory, and shells and peb-                                                                                                    always, adapts the shade it casts to the
which she invested with the vocabulary         fragrance of an entire cherry blossom        bles are there to inspire witty flights of                                                                                                given situation.
of modern art.                                 festival?                                    fancy that display to the world charm-
                                                                                            ing new designs for nature: Didn’t the
JOHANN MARTIN VON ROHDEN TIM ROLLINS                                                       DANIEL ROTH                                                                              MICHAEL SAILSTORFER
(1778–1868)                                 (1955–2017) and K.O.S.                         (* 1969)                                                                                 (* 1979)

Baumstudie (Rom), c. 1810                   Pinocchio, 1991/ 92                            Encounters at a Possible End of the         inner spaces, open to projections.           Waldputz, 2000                                evoked in the work Forst. Here, in a
Oil on primed paper on cardboard,           Wood, acrylic, wax, tung oil,                  Inner Chambers, 2010                        The void is embraced, the vague takes        C-print, 250 × 480 × 480 cm                   machine-generated manege, a tree
35.2 × 44.2 cm                              H: 106 cm, ø 15 cm                             2 part-installation, fabric, epoxy resin,   on contours; one step beyond all that                                                      is unnaturally upended and forced
                                                                                           glue, tree bark, metal,                     is familiar, the work captures an air        Forst, 2010                                   headlong into the ground, the crown
The tree has been dashed down on            The tree trunk was already breathing           220 × 60 × 60 cm and                        space, offering the mantle of tree bark      Steel, electric motor, oak tree,              dragging round and round until all
paper rapidly, free from the pressure       with life when the woodcarver in the           180 × 50 × 40 cm                            as a prop for a journey into the interior.   dimensions variable                           sense of life is vanquished.
of creating a successful large compo-       children’s story Pinocchio freed the
sition. It simply grows out of a vaguely    rogue inside. The name of the legendary        Encounters at a Possible End of the                                                      Whether wooded or arable land, recre­
implied rootless trunk into the sky, as a   wooden marionette is a neologism made          Inner Chambers, 2010                                                                     ational area, fallow land or building site:
form of possibility and a set piece for     up of pino for pine, pinco for fool, and       C-print, 35 × 5 cm                                                                       Hardly any terrain in our latitudes is left
a landscape in the making. The focus        occhio for eye. But who is it exactly that                                                                                              entirely untouched, and the parcelling
on precisely rendered painterly details     is peering out at us here so defiantly,         Daniel Roth has been called an “asso-                                                    of land into usable plots has long since
alongside diffusely fraying areas offers    fully veiled by the bark? Should we take       ciative cartographer.” He tells stories                                                  reached the forest as well. But what
the eye disparate depths of field; as if    tools in hand and free this imprisoned         without words, using materials instead                                                   purpose does this square serve that
the painter was anticipating photogra-      being? For Tim Rollins, that would prob-       to reconstruct, as it were, the gaps in                                                  Michael Sailstorfer uncovered not far
phy, we experience in his study an expo-    ably not be taboo. The art teacher set         our memories. Extremely selective in his                                                 from his father’s farm in Lower Bavaria?
sure time that reveals branches swaying     out decades ago to use artistic methods        choice of media, he reinvents cultural                                                   The word ‘Waldputz’ means primarily
in the wind. Due to his obsession with      to help fight poverty, drugs, AIDS, and         history in precisely dosed arrange-                                                      clearing the ground of all vegetation.
detail, Johann Martin von Rohden left       gang warfare in the South Bronx. His           ments, assigning us a place in the                                                       Tree trunks assume the role of building
behind a comparatively small oeuvre,        amalgam of hands-on assistance and             events beyond any concrete indications                                                   outlines here, demarcating this unusual
making every meticulous production          explanation, Arte Povera, performances,        of place or time. His picture here turns                                                 stage. Is the dark coloring the result
from his workshop all the more valuable.    and gallery visits is a decided departure      us into explorers on an expedition into                                                  of a pesticide, or does it anticipate
The illusion and reproduction of expe-      from traditional academic art education.       the earth’s interior and accomplices in                                                  the height of a planned construction
rienced reality emerges bit by bit here     Perhaps Pinocchio is meant to be the           the search for the unknown. But isn’t                                                    volume? Nothing is clear here—and
from layered dabs of paint that gradually   godfather for self-empowerment? The            everything we see in fact verifiable                                                      thus the image summons the idea of
condense into an image.                     possibilities offered by the tree trunk as     and concretely formed? Two characters                                                    a forest replete with thousands of
                                            relatable model and initiation into artistic   made of felt and wood face each other                                                    unpredictable unknowns. A painful
                                            practice have not yet been exhausted.          in the White Cube, silent witnesses to                                                   caesura in natural cycles is likewise
HERMANN SCHERER                               ROMAN SIGNER                               KLAUS STAECK                                                                             NIKLAUS STOECKLIN                           SU-MEI TSE
(1893–1927)                                   (* 1938)                                   (* 1938)                                                                                 (1896 –1982)                                (* 1973)

Striding Child with Two Women, 1925           In the Styrian Forest, 2002                Deutscher Mischwald (regenfest),            started going organic and individual         Kapelle mit Erhängtem, 1929                 (in collaboration with Jean-Lou Majerus)
Fir wood, 146 × 54 × 52 cm                    Video transferred to DVD, color, sound,    1984                                        responsibility advanced to the status of     Oil on wood, 54 × 61 cm
                                              9 min 8 sec                                Poster, offset print, 84 × 59 cm            a moral imperative. Nearly forty years                                                   Trees & Roots #2, #3, #4, 2011
Looking back today, it is hard to under-                                                                                             after they were made, Klaus Staeck’s         The stumps of trees stand in isolation      Bronze, 350 × 200 × 200 cm
stand why Hermann Scherer’s figures            If a new forest is to grow, something      Lasst uns nicht im Regen stehen,            posters still strike a chord today. If the   around a pink chapel in a grotesquely
caused such a sensation in their day.         must make way for it. Acts of liberation   1983                                        detoxification will succeed and we can        forlorn landscape. The world has been       Trees & Roots II, 2010
They were deemed morally offensive            are radical and follow a precise plan.     Poster, offset print, 84 × 59 cm            once again offer the forest healthy soil     smothered under sand. The painter           C-Print, 100 × 150 cm
and even banned from an exhibition at         A double spiral of boreholes testifies                                                  is an open question.                         applies the brush like a fine scalpel to
the Kunsthalle Basel in 1925. We feel         to the subtle humor with which Roman       The message could not be any clearer:                                                    make the bough bend under the weight        The little trees and bushes look highly
that we recognize in the minimal differ-      Signer deals with explosives. Although     Profit destroys habitats. Graphically, the                                                of the hanged man. A human life is          artificial and yet obstinately original. Cul-
ences of posture and facial expression        the detonations bring to mind a mil­       superimposition of a dead forest and a                                                   extinguished with ruthless subtlety. The    tivated in small planters, they have long
here “three ages of man.” And yet the         itary operation on enemy soil, leaving     bar code, the symbol for internationally                                                 black interior of the house of worship      been part of the inventory of sophisti-
boy is striding forth like a little man. If   thick clouds of smoke wafting over the     identifiable commercial articles, breaks                                                  provides no consolation. New Objectivity    cated interiors. In Su-Mei Tse’s work,
we are tempted to identify the sculp-         lumberyard, in the long run, each bang     down to a fatal common denominator.                                                      was the name of the 1925 exhibition in      the dwarf plants manifest a special
ture as a nuclear family from the back,       made room for a young beech. There         The “German mixed forest,” shooting up                                                   Mannheim, Germany, in which Niklaus         relationship between roots and crown.
the two female bodies we discern from         they grow in synchrony, looking almost     straight as an arrow above barren moor-                                                  Stoecklin exhibited this work, the only     Arranged eqidistant from one another
the front then subvert the expectation        tame in their carefully planned rows.      land, acts as a border fence cutting off                                                 Swiss artist represented. The title said    on raked sand, they are merely set in
of this social norm. Scherer’s sculpture      And with them there quietly germinates     our view of any far horizon. “Acid rain”                                                 it all: Those who had witnessed war         place. The white of the terrain, broken
has assimilated the archaic calm, even        the hope that new life can take root in    was a pressing issue on everyone’s lips                                                  were seeking relentless objectivity—a       only by ten-der grass, appears even
tenderness of medieval depictions of the      soil that has been blasted apart.          in the 1980s, not least in West Germany.                                                 hyper-clarity suppressing the expres-       more synthetic under the dark root balls.
Virgin Mary and at the same time points                                                  More than just alluding to the threat of                                                 sionistic exuberance of painterly gesture   Cultural refinement and natural erosion
a hundred years beyond itself. What                                                      forest die-back, the term became syn-                                                    and allowing for not even a quantum         are indis­tinguishable here, and the tree
image could today more compellingly                                                      onymous with widespread man-made                                                         of charm. Nothing overlaps or merges        becomes a transport commodity be-
express our human affiliation than this                                                   environmental pollution. Demands were                                                    here. As if in glaring neon light, the      tween climates and mentalities. Growing
small group hewn from a single fir tree?                                                  made for an about-face in environmen-                                                    wasteland and the bitter truth slap us in   up in Luxembourg as the daughter of a
                                                                                         tal policy, including the shutdown of                                                    the face. The world we once knew has        Chinese-British couple, Su-Mei Tse
                                                                                         lignite-fired power plants, while farms                                                   slipped through our fingers.                 found her way to an art that intertwines
JEAN TINGUELY                                                                              MARK TOBEY                                    SHIGEO TOYA                                 GÜNTHER UECKER
                                              (1925 –1991)                                                                               (1890–1976)                                   (* 1947)                                    (* 1930)

Western lore and aspects of Asian phi-        L’Ours de Bursinel, 1990                      strength, is being attacked from all sides   Forest Cathedral, 1955                        Untitled, 1989                              Baumskulptur, 2001
losophy. Mobility is secondary here: Cast     Tree stump, iron, concrete,                   by industrially manufactured set pieces.     Tempera on paper on cardboard,                Fire treated wood,                          Mixed media, 120 × Ø 70 cm
in bronze and with packed roots, the          electric motor,                               The battle here seems futile, and the        53 × 39 cm                                    L: 40 × 48 × 0 cm, R: 30 × 40 × 35 cm
tree gives us all the time in the world for   220 × 230 × 230 cm                            “explosiveness” that Tinguely incorpo-                                                                                                 A tremor ran through the new gener-
contemplation.                                                                              rated as a formal quality into his figures    Oil paintings, glazes, stucco façades,        Most of the time, we understand “natu-      ation of artists. In its “zero hour,” the
                                              Eléonore, 1990                                also quite painful.                          even rock: The finest cracks may appear        ral” as being diametrically opposed to      young Federal Republic of Germany
                                              Floor sculpture, iron, stump,                                                              in their surfaces. Temperature, humidity,     “artificial.” We recognize either some-      wanted to, indeed had to, reinvent itself.
                                              raising car tyre, animal sculls with                                                       and the ravages of time inscribe dynam-       thing grown or made. This habit of          There were plenty of sparks to light
                                              antlers, electric motor,                                                                   ic structures into their intact skin. Other   sorting is being scientifically questioned   the flame. Art vehemently screamed
                                              250 × 400 × 360 cm                                                                         things are doomed to breakdown from           today, but it has already been faltering    and lashed out at everything that was
                                                                                                                                         the outset: The growth of tree bark or        for decades for Shigeo Toya. The Japa-      considered to be established and all
                                              Junkyards were his studios and the                                                         of crystals is accompanied by edges           nese sculptor saws his pieces of wood,      that had allowed the horror of history to
                                              source of the raw material for his art.                                                    and fractures, the whole resembling its       burns and scrapes their surfaces, in the    take place. Some artists joined forces,
                                              Jean Tinguely welded together iron and                                                     components. Mark Tobey often bases            process knocking holes in our supposed      among them Günther Uecker, a found-
                                              sheet metal parts, rubber belts, bones                                                     his pictorial abstractions on microscopic     knowledge of growth, stability, and de-     ing member of the “Zero” group. They
                                              and bolts, coils and wheels, eyelets                                                       views of natural phenomena, details           cay. His sculptures have the appearance     tried out new things, staked their claims,
                                              and hooks to create expansive sculp-                                                       of the finest close-ups. Was Forest            of never-before-seen oversized fruits       provoked, destroyed. Uecker began to
                                              tures. Machines are extensions of, and                                                     Cathedral inspired by weathered bark,         or seeds. Ruffled and notched, they lie      hammer nails into volumes and sur-
                                              replacements for, human physi­cal                                                          or are we looking at a mineral structure      there on the ground—evidence of harsh       faces. The nails spread out in billows
                                              labor, skeletons of pure efficiency.                                                        or perhaps eroded soil? The “Informel”        weather, a volcanic eruption, a relent-     across furniture, boards, and walls,
                                              “The passion, tenderness, and drive he                                                     qualities of this painting call to mind       lessly harsh existence. The craftsman’s     forming swarms of shadows and unruly
                                              invested in his best works seem to elicit                                                  myriad associations. The cathedral in         treatment of the material becomes in        patterns, scraping open surfaces and
                                              in viewers their own associations with                                                     the title evokes a place of inwardness, a     Toya’s work an elemental force that gifts   enlarging volumes with their spiky fur.
                                              life.” (A. Monteil, 2005). In the colossal                                                 space permeated by light: Here we feel        us with new totems in the form of swirls,   The canvas was transformed into ban­
                                              tree trunk from Bursinel in the canton of                                                  a resonance, painting as silence and          folds, and notches.                         daging material. Here, the trunk wears
                                              Vaud, the artist saw the torso of a sitting                                                as an echo of the cracked webs of our                                                     its wounding crown of thorns with pride.
                                              bear. This trunk, a vestige of animal                                                      selves.
CHRISTIAN VOGT                               Kulturstiftung Basel H. Geiger | KBH.G
(* 1946)                                     Spitalstrasse 18, 4056 Basel, Switzerland

Skulptur Alfonso Hüppi, 2000                 +41 61 262 01 66, kbhg.ch
Carbon print on hand-made paper,
150 ×111 cm

It’s all there, exuding a sober presence.
Under homogeneously over-cast skies,
Basel’s Barfüsserplatz, otherwise busy
day and night, is deserted here. How
small the phone booths were back then,
next to the tall tree. The tram stop and a
row of houses appear to crouch under
the trunk, which is tectonically encased
in brick. Here a bench, there a bicycle,
no trace of bustling activity across the
urban square. Christian Vogt has docu­
mented here a sculpture by Alfonso
Hüppi that was temporarily set up on the
square for the cultural project Skultur in
2000. But the artist foregoes any situa-
tional punchline. The sculptural protag­
onist is shot with a wide-angle lens,
adding even more distance to the image.
An eerie silence pervades the scene—
only along the edge of the large print
does the second, momentary authorship
of the photograph make itself known.
You can also read