TORONTO'S FUTURE WEATHER & CLIMATE DRIVER STUDY: OUTCOMES REPORT

Page created by Todd Holmes
 
CONTINUE READING
TORONTO'S FUTURE WEATHER & CLIMATE DRIVER STUDY: OUTCOMES REPORT
TORONTO'S  
FUTURE  
WEATHER  &  
CLIMATE  
DRIVER    
STUDY:    
  
OUTCOMES  
REPORT    
  
Summary  of  the  SENES  
Consultants  Ltd  Study  by  
                                                                                                                   
Toronto  Environment  Office            Less  Snowfall  Expected  in  2040-­‐2049  (in  centimetres)  
October  30,  2012                      x 140  centimetres  less  in  parts  of  Toronto  
                                        x 160  centimetres  less  on  parts  of  the  Oak  Ridges  Moraine  
                                     
                                                                                                               1  
  
TORONTO'S FUTURE WEATHER & CLIMATE DRIVER STUDY: OUTCOMES REPORT
Why  We  Did  What  We  Did                            INTRODUCTION    
                                                              
     Clear   Direction   from   City   Council   re:        In  order  to  more  effectively  plan  municipal  infrastructure  investment  and  provision  of  
     policies  and  actions  including                      services,   the   City   of   Toronto   needs   to   know   what   currently   influences   Toronto's  
       
     Climate  Change  Action  Plan  (2007)    
                                                            present  weather  and  climate.  The  City  needs  to  determine  how  these  influences  are  
     Ahead  of  the  Storm  (2008)                          likely  to  change,  and  how  severe  the  consequences  are  likely  to  be  in  the  future.    In  
                                                            simple  terms,  the  City  of  Toronto  needs  a  better  understanding  of  why  Toronto  gets  
     To  Prepare  the  City  for  the  Future               the  weather  and  climate  it  gets  now  and  what  weather  and  climate  it  can  expect  to  
                                                            get  in  the  future.  
     The   City   needed   Toronto   &   GTA   specific  
     Weather         &      Climate       Information  
                                                              
     unavailable  from  Environment  Canada.                For  large  cities  with  high  density  populations  and  concentrated  critical  infrastructure,  
                                                            climate  and  weather  can  have  a  significant  impact  on  economic  activity  and  municipal  
                                                            services.  Existing  global  and  regional  climate  models  have  not  provided  cities,  such  as  
     Toronto   Environment   Office   uses                  Toronto,   with   sufficiently   tailored   information   to   understand   and   address   specific  
     an   innovative   approach   to                        local  future  impacts.  
     modelling  climate  and  weather.                        
                                                            The  Toronto's  Future  Weather  &  Climate  Driver  Study  aims  to  help  understand  what  
     We  combine  modelling  technologies                   projections  on  future  climate  mean  for  the  City  of  Toronto.  By  improving  the  level  of  
     Global  Climate  Models  (GCM)                         certainty   about   climate   related   weather   changes,   the   City   will   be   better   guided   in  
     Regional  Climate  Models  (RCM)  
     Local  Weather  Models  (WRF)  
                                                            making   investment   and   budgetary   decisions   regarding   infrastructure   and   service  
                                                            provision  responsibilities.  
                                                              
                                                            The   study   was   undertaken   by   SENES   Consultants,   based   in   Richmond   Hill.   SENES  
                                                            works  on  projects  around  the  globe  and  specializes  in  climate  modelling.  The  Toronto  
       
                                                            Environment   Office   commissioned   the   study   to   support   the   City's   climate   change  
                                                            policies.      
     Advisors:  Environment  Canada,  Ministry  of            
     Environment,  Toronto  Region                          WHY  DID  THE  CITY  UNDERTAKE  THE  CLIMATE  DRIVERS  STUDY?    
     Conservation  Authority      
       
     Consultants:  SENES  +  Hadley  UK                     There   are   three   reasons   why   the   City   cannot   solely   rely   on   the   existing   climate  
                                                            projections   derived   from   Global   and   Regional   Climate   Models   to   fully   understand  
                                                            current   and   future   climate   and   weather   patterns   for   Toronto:  
                                                                                                                                                                     2  
  
TORONTO'S FUTURE WEATHER & CLIMATE DRIVER STUDY: OUTCOMES REPORT
1)   The   Great   Lakes   –   The   Great   Lakes   have   an   important   influence   on   Toronto's        New  Approach    
climate   and   weather.   Without   the   Great   Lakes,   Toronto   would   have   an   extreme                
continental   climate   instead   of   its   more   moderate   continental   climate.   Global   and           The   approach   was   new   and   innovative   when  
                                                                                                               this  project  was  conceived.      
regional   climate   models   do   not   adequately   represent   the   moderating   effect   of   the           
Great  Lakes  on  the  City's  climate  and  weather.  The  implication  is  that  the  City  cannot           The   approach   taken   has   been   very   successful  
adequately   predict   future   climate   change   impacts   for   Toronto   from   these   models             (proved  value  of  approach).    
alone.                                                                                                           
                                                                                                               Approach   subsequently   adopted   by   the  
                                                                                                               National  Center  for  Atmospheric  Research,  and  
2)  Lack  of  focus  on  urban  climate  and  weather  impacts  –  Large  urban  centres,  such                by   the   Ministry   of   the   Environment   with   the  
as   Toronto,   comprise   a   small   percentage   of   Canada's   land   mass.   However,   they   are       University  of  Toronto.    
home  to  a  substantial  percentage  of  Canada's  economic  activity  and  population  (80%                    
of   the   Canadian   population   live   in   urban   areas).   Local   impacts   of   future   climate       To  Answer  New  Questions    
changes  on  city  and  urban  populations  are  not  sufficiently  detailed  in  the  global  and               
regional   climate   models   to   inform   cost   effective   infrastructure   planning   and                 Included  Influence  of  the  Great  Lakes,  Niagara  
adaptation.                                                                                                    Escarpment  and  the  Oak  Ridges  Moraine.  
                                                                                                                 
                                                                                                               Examined  a  10  Year  Period  (not  30  Years)  
3)   The   need   for   weather   and   climate   'extremes'   rather   than   'averages'   –   The                        
operation  of  critical  infrastructure  such  as  the  electrical  grid,  water  treatment  plants,           Wanted   data   and   information   concerning   the  
sewers   and   culverts,   public   transport   and   roads   are   sensitive   to   particular                future  "extremes"-­‐of-­‐weather  rather  than  the  
temperature   and   weather   thresholds.   Beyond   these   thresholds   infrastructure   may                 future  "means"-­‐of-­‐climate.    
have   reduced   capacity   or   may   not   function   at   all.   While   we   cannot   ignore   gradual       
climate   change,   variation   in   the   patterns   of   extreme   weather   pose   a   particular           Recent  Empirical  Data  
challenge   to   the   operation   of   municipal   and   provincial   infrastructure.   The   focus   of  
                                                                                                               Globally,  2010  ranked  as  the  warmest  year  on  
global  and  regional  climate  models  on  climate  averages  are  unlikely  to  provide  cities,             record,  as  was  2005  and  1998  before  it.  
such   as   Toronto,   with   adequate   insight   into   extreme   weather   projection   changes             The   10   warmest   years   on   record   have   all  
necessary  for  prudent  infrastructure  management.                                                           occurred  since  1998.    
                                                                                                                 
                                                                                                               Over   the   ten   years   from   2001   to   2010,   global  
Monitored  weather  events  identified  in  Table  1  below  (Environment  Canada)  show  an  
                                                                                                               temperatures  have  averaged  0.46°C  above  the  
increasing   occurrence   of   record   years   between   2000   and   2009.   This   data   suggests          1961-­‐1990   average,   and   are   the   highest  
that  extreme  weather  events  are  changing  more  rapidly  than  predicted  by  the  models                 temperature  increase  ever   recorded  for  a   10-­‐
built  around  the  standard  30-­‐year  climate  averages.                                                    year   period   since   the   beginning   of  
                                                                                                               instrumental  climate  records.  

                                                                                                                                                                          3  
  
TORONTO'S FUTURE WEATHER & CLIMATE DRIVER STUDY: OUTCOMES REPORT
 
Table  1:    Record  Weather  Events  in  Toronto  by  Year  in  the  Period  2000-­‐2009  Provide  Rationale  For  Study      
  
     Year     Record  Events                                                                                                                                    
     2000     Wettest  summer  in  53  years  with  13%  more  precipitation  than  normal.                                                                     
     2001     Driest  growing  season  in  34  years;  first  ever  heat  alert;  14  nights  with  temperatures  above  20°C  (normal  is  5  nights).         
                                                                                                                                                                
     2002     Driest  August  at  Pearson  Airport  since  1937;  warmest  summer  in  63  years;  5th  coldest  Spring.  
                                                                                                                                                                
     2003     Rare  mid-­‐Spring  ice  storm  –  Pearson  Airport  used  a  month’s  supply  of  glycol  de-­‐icer  in  24-­‐hours.                             
     2004     Year  without  a  summer;  May  rainfall  in  Hamilton  set  an  all-­‐time  record;  and  another  all-­‐time  record  409  mm  rainfall         
              was  set  at  Trent  University  in  July  which  was  equivalent  to  14  billion  litres  of  water  in  5  hours  (a  200  year  event).       
                                                                                                                                                                
     2005     Warmest  January  17  since  1840;  January  22nd  blizzard  with  whiteouts;  warmest  June  ever;  number  of  Toronto  days                    
              greater  than  30°C  was  41  (normal  is  14);  August  19  storm  washed  out  part  of  Finch  Avenue.                                         
     2006     23  tornadoes  across  Ontario  (14  normal);  record  year  of  major  storms;  record  one-­‐day  power  demand  of  27,005  MW                 
              due  to  summer  heat.                                                                                                                            
                                                                                                                                                                
     2007     Protracted  January  thaw;  2nd  least  snow  cover  ever  in  Toronto  (half  the  normal  amount);  snowiest  Valentine’s  Day  
                                                                                                                                                                
              ever;    chunks  of  ice  fell  from  CN  Tower;  2-­‐3  times  the  normal  number  of  hot  days  in  the  summer;  record  latest-­‐in-­‐
                                                                                                                                                                
              season  string  of  +30°C  days  around  Thanksgiving.  
                                                                                                                                                                
     2008     Toronto’s  3rd  snowiest  winter  ever;  record  for  highest  summer  rainfall.                                                                  
     2009     3rd  rainiest  February  in  70  years;  Hamilton  had  a  100-­‐year  storm;  one  of  the  wettest  summers  on  record;  tornados  hit         
              Vaughan-­‐Woodbridge  area  in  late  August;  an  unusually  mild  and  storm-­‐free  November  in  Toronto  –  Downtown  had  a                 
              record  "no  snow"  for  the  first  time  ever  –  first  snow-­‐free  November  at  Pearson  Airport  since  1937.                              
              Toronto's  earliest  ever  official  heat  wave  (June  19-­‐21)  
                                                                                                                                                                
     2012  
                                                                                                                                                                
     Also     Three  1  in  100  year  storms  in  Toronto  in  less  than  12  years:  July  2000,  August  2005,  July  2012.                                 
                                                                                                                                                                
                                                                                                                                                                   4  
  
TORONTO'S FUTURE WEATHER & CLIMATE DRIVER STUDY: OUTCOMES REPORT
International  Panel  on  Climate  Change  (IPCC)                                                                        Exponentially   Increasing   Rates   of   Temperature  
Scenarios  of  Future  Climate  Driven  by  Population,                                                                  Change  in  the  recent  past  and  into  the  Future 2  
Economics,  and  Technology  Adoption1                                                                                     
  
                                                                                                                         Showing different rates (slopes) of change from the same
IPCC Emission Scenarios                                                                                                  monitored temperature data set (1860-2010)
B1    Low Growth (Integrated World)
A1B   Moderate Growth (Balanced Energy Use)                                                                              This shows that the changes are occurring more rapidly now
A2    High Growth (Divided World)                                                                                        than before and that they should also be examined on smaller
                                                                                                                         and more recent time intervals in respect to City
The  City's  approach  adopted  Scenario  A1B  regarded  as  an  upper-­‐middle  of                                      responsibilities.   
the  road  scenario  (i.e.,  not  an  extreme   scenario)  into  the  future.  Also  note  
that  A1B  &  A2  are  essentially  similar  until  2060.  
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               
                                                                                                                         2
                                                                                                                               From   Climate   Change   2007:   The   Physical   Science   Basis.  Contribution   of   Working  
                                                                                                                         Group   I   to   the   Fourth   Assessment   Report   of   the   IPCC  [Solomon,   S.,   D.   Qin,   M.  
                                                                                                                         Manning,   Z.   Chen,   M.   Marquis,   K.B.   Averyt,   M.   Tignor   and   H.L.   Miller   (eds.)].  
1
 From  Pachauri,  R.K.  and  Reisinger,  A.  (Eds.)"Climate  Change  2007:  Synthesis  Report                            Cambridge  University  Press,  Cambridge,  United  Kingdom  and  New  York,  NY,  US  at  
Contribution  of  Working  Groups  I,  II  and  III  to  the  Fourth  Assessment  Report  of  the                        Technical                Summary                   3.1                  -­‐              Accessed  
Intergovernmental   Panel   on   Climate   Change,   (2007)   at   p   46.   Accessed   at                               athttp://www.ipcc.ch/publications_and_data/ar4/wg1/en/tssts-­‐3-­‐1-­‐1.html  
http://www.ipcc.ch/pdf/assessment-­‐report/ar4/syr/ar4_syr.pdf                                                             
                                                                                                                           

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            5  
  
TORONTO'S FUTURE WEATHER & CLIMATE DRIVER STUDY: OUTCOMES REPORT
Global  and  Regional  Climate  Model  Improvements                                                                      Model  Improvements  of  Geographic  Scale  and  Three  
(from  1970  to  2010)  in  Physical  and  Chemical                                                                      Dimensional  Computational  Grid  Resolution  (1990-­‐
Complexity3                                                                                                              2007) 4  

More  processes  and  better  chemistry  were  included  sequentially  and                                               Scale  &  Resolution  of  IPCC  Assessment  Reports  (AR)      
                                                                                                                                  st                                           nd
created  increasing  certainty  in  the  results  obtained.                                                              FAR  =  1   –  1990                        SAR  =    2   -­‐  1996  
                                                                                                                                      rd                                       th
                                                                                                                         TAR  =   3   -­‐  2001                      AR4  =   4   -­‐  2007  
  
                                                                                                                           
3
      From  Le  Treut,  H.,  R.  Somerville,  U.  Cubasch,  Y.  Ding,  C.  Mauritzen,  A.  Mokssit,  T.                                                                                                                                        
                                                                                                                         4
Peterson  and  M.  Prather,  2007:  Historical  Overview  of  Climate  Change.  In:  Climate                                From  Climate  Change  2007:  The  Physical  Science  Basis.  Contribution  of  Working  
Change   2007:   The   Physical   Science   Basis.  Contribution   of   Working   Group   I   to   the                   Group  I  to  the  Fourth  Assessment  Report  of  the  IPCC  [Solomon,  S.,  D.  Qin,  M.  
Fourth  Assessment  Report  of  the  IPCC  [Solomon,  S.,  D.  Qin,  M.  Manning,  Z.  Chen,  M.                         Manning,  Z.  Chen,  M.  Marquis,  K.B.  Averyt,  M.  Tignor  and  H.L.  Miller  (eds.)].  
Marquis,  K.B.  Averyt,  M.  Tignor  and  H.L.  Miller  (eds.)].  Cambridge  University  Press,                          Cambridge  University  Press,  Cambridge,  United  Kingdom  and  New  York,  NY,  US  at  
Cambridge,  United  Kingdom  and  New  York,  NY,  USA.  Chapter  1.2                                                    Chapter  1.5  Accessed  at  
                                                                                                                         http://www.ipcc.ch/publications_and_data/ar4/wg1/en/ch1s1-­‐5.html  
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  6  
  
TORONTO'S FUTURE WEATHER & CLIMATE DRIVER STUDY: OUTCOMES REPORT
HOW  DID  WE  APPROACH  THIS  STUDY?      
  
Overcoming   the   limitations   of   global   and   regional   climate   models   in   understanding  
localized   climate   and   weather   requires   a   unique   approach.   In   consultation   with  
climatologists,   meteorologists,   hydrologists   and   climate   adaptation   specialists   from  
Environment   Canada,   the   Ontario   Ministry   of   the   Environment   and   Toronto   Region  
Conservation   Authority,   SENES   and   the   City   of   Toronto   used   existing   Environment  
Canada  and  United  Kingdom  Meteorological  Office  -­‐  Hadley  Centre  results  from  global  
and  regional  climate  models  as  input  into  a  local-­‐scale,  weather  forecasting  research  
model.                                                                                                                                                                          
                                                                                                                    An  example  of  a  single  grid  cell  within  a  
  
                                                                                                                    Global  Climate  Model  of  300  km  x  300  km  
To  appreciate  the  distinctiveness  of  the  Toronto  Climate  Drivers  Study  approach  it  is                   resolution.      
necessary  to  understand  the  basics  of  global  and  regional  climate  models:                                   
  
Global  Climate  Model  (GCMs)  -­‐  The  standard  approach  to  climate  modeling  has  been  
to   use   global   climate   models   linked   to   data   of   climate   averages   for   30   year   time  
periods.      These  models  operate   at   a   course   spatial   resolution:   a  300   km2   grid   scale.  
While   remaining   relevant   to   understanding   climate   impacts   on   national   scale,   this  
modelling  makes  no  differentiation  in  projected  future  climate  averages  for  Toronto,  
London,   North   Bay,   or   Muskoka   due   to   its   coarse   grid   scale,   nor   does   it   distinguish  
between   lakes   versus   lands,   or   high-­‐lands   versus   low-­‐lands,   or   urban   versus   rural  
lands   –   all   areas   and   conditions   within   a   grid   cell   are   described   by   their   mean  
condition.      
                                                                                                                                                                                
                                                                                                                    An  example  of  a  single  grid  cell  within  a  
Regional  Climate  Model  –  Allows  refinement  of  global  model  results  by  introducing                        Regional  Climate  Model  of  40  km  x  40  km  
Regional  Climate  Models  (RCMs)  of  medium  resolution  (typically  in  the  range  of  40  -­‐                  resolution.      
100   km2   or   larger).   While   providing   greater   geographic   differentiation   than   global                
models,  they  still  do  not  adequately  represent  features  such  as  the  Great  Lakes  which                  These  two  maps  show  the  equivalent  area  of  
are  critical  to  explaining  Toronto's  weather  and  climate.                                                    one   grid   cell   in   which   all   weather   data   is  
                                                                                                                    considered   uniform.   The   maps   do   not  
                                                                                                                    necessarily   represent   actual   modelling   grid  
  
                                                                                                                    cells  

                                                                                                                                                                             7  
  
TORONTO'S FUTURE WEATHER & CLIMATE DRIVER STUDY: OUTCOMES REPORT
                                                       Weather  Research  Forecasting  (WRF)  Model  -­‐  Developed  jointly  by  the  US  National  
                                                        Centre   of   Atmospheric   Research,   the   US   National   Oceanic   and   the   Atmospheric  
                                                        Agency  this  model  allows  the  output  of  spatially  variable  mean  and  extreme  weather  
                                                        predictions  that  account  for  the  influence  of  local  geography  and  topography.    
                                                          
                                                        The  Toronto's  Future  Weather  &  Climate  Drivers  Study  uses  a  sequential  combination  
                                                        of  these  models.  Results  from  global  and  regional  models  were  fed  into  the  Weather  
                                                        Research   Forecasting   (WRF)   model   of   much   finer   spatial   resolution   to   provide  
                                                        detailed  estimates  of  Toronto's  future  local  weather  between  2040  and  2050  –  a  time  
                                                        horizon   relevant   to   a   large   range   of   infrastructure   replacement   activities   that   City  
                                                        staff  can  reasonably  envisage.    
An  example  of  grid  cells  in  a  Weather              
Research  Forecast  (WRF)  model  of  1  km  x          The  result  is  a  climate-­‐weather  model  capable  of  operating  at  a  very  fine  resolution  (1  
1  km  resolution  used  in  evaluation  of             km2).  This  allows  different  climate  and  weather  projections  to  be  established  for  even  
Toronto's  future  climate  and  weather.               small   areas   within   Toronto   (e.g.   equivalent   in   area   to   small   individual   postal   code  
                                                        areas  or  smaller  areas  within  Scarborough,  North  York  or  Downtown)  rather  than  only  
                                                        large  regional  areas  such  as  southern  Ontario  or  even  larger  provinces  and  nations.    
                                                          
                                                        Having  climate  and  weather  projections  physically  down-­‐scaled  to  this  level  is  critical  
                                                        to   addressing   infrastructure   impacts   caused   by   extreme   weather   events   similar   to  
                                                        those  that  caused  the  Finch  Avenue  culvert  collapse  and  road  wash  out  of  August  19  
                                                        2005.                          
                                                          
                                                        The  results  of  the  City's  climate-­‐weather  model  were  compared  against  output  from  
                                                        more  traditional  global  and  regional  model  combinations  to  verify  performance.  The  
                                                        City's   results   for   were   judged   to   be   very   good   and   within   the   range   of   theoretically  
                                                        expected  results  and  in  keeping  with  global  and  regional  model  output.      
                                                          
                                                          
                                                          
  
                                                                                                                                                                       8  
  
TORONTO'S FUTURE WEATHER & CLIMATE DRIVER STUDY: OUTCOMES REPORT
WHAT  ARE  "CLIMATE  DRIVERS"?                                                                                 Common Winter Low Depressions -
                                                                                                               Sources and Storm Tracks
The  SENES  Study  references  "Climate  Drivers"  in  its  title  (Toronto's  Future  Weather  &  
Climate  Driver  Study)  to  reflect  the  significance  of  large  scale  meteorological  features  
and   processes   that   determine   or   "drive"   Toronto's   day-­‐to-­‐day   weather   such   as   the  
location  of  the  Jet  Stream  and  movement  of  major  air  masses.    Climate  models  such  
as  global  and  regional  climate  models  can  predict  potential  climatic  changes  into  the  
future.   These   potential   changes   need   to   make   sense   and   be   consistent   with   our  
understanding  the  laws  of  physics  and  known  behaviours  of  weather  systems.
  
Models   that   run   equations   and   provide   climate   data   output   need   to   make   sense   in  
light  of  our  understanding  of  physical  meteorological  processes  that  we  know  operate  
in  the  atmosphere  now.  For  example:  
    
                                                                                                                                                                       
     x Does   the   average   position   of   the   polar   front   jet   stream   move   northward   in       Source: Klok et al., 2002
          keeping  with  the  predicted  average  temperature  changes?                                          
     x Are   predictions   of   more   intensive   but   fewer   summer   storms   logically                    Summer and Winter Jet Streams  
          consistent  with  increased  occurrence  of  updrafts  of  warm  air?    
     x Does  the  influence  of  Lake  Ontario  and  other  Great  Lakes  continue  to  modify  
          summer  temperatures?    
     x Is  a  reduction  in  winter  snowfall  accompanied  by  a  corresponding  increase  in  
          winter  rainfall?    
  
Identifying  the  climate  drivers  that  control  Toronto's  present  weather  is  a  major  part  
of  the  study  and  an  important  way  to  corroborate  the  overall  integrity  of  model  data  
and  computer  program  assumption.    
  
                                                                                                                                                                       
                                                                                                               Source: University of Maryland, Department of
                                                                                                               Atmospheric and Oceanic Science (2003)  

                                                                                                                                                               9  
  
TORONTO'S FUTURE WEATHER & CLIMATE DRIVER STUDY: OUTCOMES REPORT
Confidence  in  Results  using  Mean                                                                SUPPORT  FOR  TORONTO'S  APPROACH    
Temperature  as  an  example                                                                          
                                                                                                    Toronto's   approach   of   adding   output   from   climate   models   into   a   weather   model   in  
Compared  with  Monitored  Means  (2000-­‐09)                                                       order  to  obtain  more  locally  relevant  future  weather  predictions  was  cutting  edge  and  
1)   Toronto’s   Climate-­‐Weather   Model   v.1=  
      o
8.70 C  
                                                                                                    innovative  when  conceived.  It  has  been  subsequently  adopted  by  the  National  Center  
2)   Environment   Canada’s   Canadian   Regional                                                   for  Atmospheric  Research  (NCAR)  for  the  whole  of  the  USA  as  well  as  by  the  Ontario  
                                o
Climate  Model  v.4.2.3  =  6.69 C                                                                  Ministry  of  the  Environment  in  partnership  with  the  University  of  Toronto.  
                                           o
3)  Monitored  Data  from  Pearson  =  8.73 C                                                         
                                                                                                    THE  RESULTS  FOR  TORONTO  
Compared  with  Other  Models  (2040-­‐49)  GTA    
                                       o
Our   forecast   change   of   4.4 C   compares  
                                                                                                      
favourably   with   Low   Resolution   Models                                                       The   study   predicts   that   climate   change   will   continue   to   create   different   weather  
                              o          o
showing  changes  from  -­‐2.7 C  to  6.3 C                                                         patterns   across   Toronto   in   the   future.   Some   changes   can   be   regarded   as   being  
                                                                                                    positive   -­‐   longer   growing   season,   generally   more   pleasant   weather   and   fewer   City  
                                                                                                    resources   required   for   winter   snow   clearance.   However,   other   changes   can   be  
Snowfall  and  Rainfall                                                                             regarded   as   being   negative.      Though   a   similar   number   of   storms   per   year   are  
                             x        Less  Snow  &  More  Rain  -­‐-­‐  in  Winter                 projected  a  fewer  number  of  "heavy"  storms  (>25mm/day)  are  expected.  However,  a  
                             x        More  Rain  in  July  (80%)  &  August                        small   number   of   those         "heavy"   storms"   will   produce   "very   intense"   storms   and  
                                      (50%)  
                                                                                                    produce  much  greater  amounts  of  rainfall  in  short  periods  than  previously  seen  with  
                                        
                                                                                                    clear   impacts   on   city   infrastructure   (culverts   and   drainage   management)   and   an  
                                        Pearson Airport: Change 2000-2009 to 2040-2049
                            80                                                                      increased  potential  for  flooding.  
                            60
                                                                                                      
                                                                                                    The  changes  (comparing  2000-­‐2009  monitored  data  with  modelled  results  for  2040-­‐
     Difference in Amount

                            40
                                                                                         Rainfall
                                                                                         (mm)
                                                                                                    2049)  are  predicted  to  be  as  follows:    
                            20
                                                                                         Snowfall
                                                                                         (cm)
                                                                                                      
                             0
                                                                                                    Precipitation  -­‐  Snow  and  Rain  
                            -20
                                                                                                         • Less  snow  and  more  rain  in  the  winter    
                            -40
                                  Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec                        • 26  fewer  snow  days  per  year,  9  less  in  December    
                                                     Month
                                                                                                         • Slightly  more  precipitation  (snow  plus  rainfall)  overall  
                                                                                                         • Marked  rainfall  increases  in  July  (80%)  and  August  (50%)  
                                                                                                         • Extreme  rainstorm  events,  fewer  in  number  but  more  extreme  

                                                                                                                                                                                                          10  
  
                                                                                                            
Temperature                                                                                                4.4oC  Average  Annual  Temperatures  
   • Average  annual  temperatures  increase  by  4.4oC                                                    Increase  in  Toronto  
   • The  projected  average  winter  temperature  increase  by  5.7oC.                                      
   • The  projected  average  summer  temperature  increase  by  3.8oC.    
   • The   extreme   daily   minimum   temperature   rises   by   13oC   (i.e.,   becomes   less  
       cold).      
  
Wind  
   • Unchanged  average  wind  speeds    
   • Reduced  maximum  wind  speeds  
   • No  changes  in  wind  direction    
  
Comfort  Measures  
   • Reduced  occurrences  of  Wind  Chill    
   • Virtual  disappearance  of  Wind  Chill  events  with  temperatures  below  -­‐20°C;  
   • Humidex  events    greater  than  20°C  increase  more  than  60%    
   • The  maximum  Humidex  increases  from  48°C    to  57°C                                                                                                 
                                                                                                                •   The  extreme  daily  maximum  
                                                                                                                    temperature  "becomes  
Temperature  Degree  Days                                                                                           warmer"  by  7.6oC  (i.e.,  
   • Values   below   18°C   can   be   used   to   estimate   the   heating   requirements   of                    becomes  warmer).    
       buildings.   The   occurrence   of   such   degree   days   are   expected   to   reduce   by         
       almost  a  third  -­‐  31%    
   • Values   above   24°C   can   be   used   to   estimate   the   cooling   requirements   of  
       buildings.   The   occurrence   of   such   degree   days   are   expected   to   increase   by  
       more  than  five  times  -­‐  560%  (i.e.,  from  32  degree-­‐days  to  180  degree  days  per  
       year)  
  
                                                                                                                                                     11  
  
Extreme  DAILY  Rainfall                                                                       CHANGES  IN  "EXTREMES"    
                      x      Fewer    Precipitation  Storms  >25  mm                             
                             in  Winter    
                                                                                               Most  global  climate  models  assess  changes  in  the  averages  that  typify  a  climate.  The  
                      x      Same  Number  of  Storms  in  Summer      
                      x      BUT  the  Summer  Storms  will  be                                Toronto  Future  Weather  &  Climate  Drivers  Study  assessed  these  climate  averages  but  
                             Much  More  Intense                                               also   extended   the   study   to   assess   potential   changes   in   the   "extremes"   of   weather  
                                                                                               (maximums  and  minimums).  This  included  examining  the  changing  likelihood,  severity  
                                 Pearson Airport: Extreme DAILY Rainfall                       and  durations  of  "extremes"  such  as  heat  waves  and  intense  rainstorms.      
                    180

                    160
                                                                                                 
                    140                                                                        Table   2   summarizes   the   changes   expected   to   occur   between   the   period   2000-­‐2009  
                    120
                                                                                               and  the  period  2040-­‐2049.  Key  projections  include:    
     Amount in mm

                    100                                                       2000-2009
                    80                                                        2040-2049          
                    60

                    40
                                                                                                   x Though   the   number   of   storms   that   occur   in   winter   decrease,   the   number   of  
                    20                                                                                  storms  that  occur  in  summer  remains  the  same  –  but  the  maximum  amount  of  
                     0
                          Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul   Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec                             rainfall  expected  in  any  single  day  and  in  any  single  hour  more  than  doubles.      
                                                Month

                                                                                                 
                                                                                                   x The  number  of  days  when  the  humidex  exceeds  40oC  is  expected  to  increase  
                                                                                                        fourfold.  
                                                                                                                             
                                                                                                             x The   number   of   degree   days   >24oC   (a   degree-­‐day 5   occurs   when   the  
                                                                                                               temperature  is  higher  than  24oC  for  24  hours)  -­‐  which  is  typically  used  as  the  
                                                                                                               measure  of  air  conditioning  being  required  -­‐  increases  six-­‐fold.    
                                                                                                                 
                                                                                                             x The  number  of  "heat  waves"  (i.e.,  events  with  more  than  3  consecutive  days  of  
                                                                                                               temperatures   greater   than   32OC)   is   expected   to   increase   from   an   average   of  
                                                                                                               0.57   occurrences   per   year,   as   in   the   period   1971-­‐2000,   to   5   occurrences   per  
                                                                                                               year  in  the  period  2040-­‐2050.  
                                                                                                 
                                                                                                 
                                                                                                                                                                                                                     
                                                                                               5
                                                                                                For  an  explanation  of  what  is  meant  by  "degree  days"  please  see:        
                                                                                               http://www.oahpp.ca/resources/documents/Accumulated%20Degree%20Days.pdf  

                                                                                                                                                                                                                        12  
  
Table  2:  Projected  Future  Weather  Changes  Compared  to  Recent  Weather  
                                                                                                                     Annual  Weather             Annual  Weather    
Weather  Type             Parameter                                                               Units                2000-­‐2009                 2040-­‐2049  
Extreme                   Maximum  Amount  in  One  Day                                             mm                       66                       166  
Precipitation             Number  of  Days  with  More  Than  25mm                                 days                      19                          9  
                          Mean  Annual  Daily  Maximum                                              mm                       48                        86  
                          100  year  Return  Period  Maximum  Daily                                 mm                       81                       204  
                          10  year  Return  Period  Maximum  Daily                                  mm                       62                       135  
                          10  year  Return  Period  Maximum  Hourly                                 mm                       20                         39  
Extreme  Rainfall         Maximum  Amount  in  One  Day                                             mm                       66                       166  
                          Number  of  Days  with  More  Than  25mm                                 days                      16                          9  
Extreme  Snowfall         Maximum  Amount  in  One  Day                                             cm                       24                        18  
                          Number  of  Days  with  More  Than  25cm                                 days                      16                          3  
                                                                                                     o
Extreme  Heat             Maximum  Daily  Temperature                                                  C                     33                         44  
                          Number  of  Days  with  Temperature  >  30  oC                           days                      20                         66  
                          Number  of  heat  waves"  (>3  consecutive  days  >  32OC*             events                  0.57**                       2.53  
                                                                                                     o
Extreme  Cold             Minimum  Daily  Temperature                                                  C                  -­‐  17                     -­‐11  
                          Number  of  Days  with  Temperature  <  -­‐10  oC                        days                      25                          0  
                          Number  of  Days  with  Temperature  <  -­‐0  oC                         days                   128                           70  
                                                                                                  o
Wind  Chill               Extreme  Daily  Wind  Chill                                               C  eq.                 -­‐24                      -­‐17  
                          Number  of  Days  with  Temperatures  >  20  oC                          days                      12                          0  
Degree  Days              Number  of  Degree  Days  >  24  oC    (A/C  required)               degree-­‐days                 31                       180  
                          Number  of  Degree  Days  >  0  oC                                   degree-­‐days              3452                       4587  
                          Number  of  Degree  Days  <  0  oC    (Heat  required)               degree-­‐days              440                           66  
Extreme  Wind             Maximum  Hourly  Wind  Speed                                           km/hr                       92                        48  
                          Maximum  Wind  Gust  Speed                                             km/hr                    130                           75  
                          Number  of  Days  with    Winds  >  52  km/hr                            days                        1                         0  
                                                                                                  o
Humidex                   Maximum  Humidex                                                          C  eq.                   48                         57  
                          Number  of  Days  with  Humidex  >  40  oC                               days                        9                        39  
Storms                    Average  Number  of  Storms  per  Year                                                             30                        23  
                          Average  Number  of  Summer  Storms  per  Year                                                     16                        17  
                          Average  Number  of  Winter  Storms  per  Year                                                     14                          6  
      * Note: This data is not included in SENES Report Volume I. It is included in subsequent data extraction and analysis by SENES for the City.
      **Derived from Meteorological Services Canada data recorded at Toronto Pearson International Airport.

                                                                                                                                                                       13  
        
Modelling  Future  Extreme  Storms  is                         THE  BENEFITS  OF  THE  FUTURE  WEATHER  PREDICTIONS    
Much  Harder….  but  ….                                          
                                                               The  study  provides  projections  that  can  inform  present  and  future  infrastructure  and  
                                                               service   decisions   (e.g.,   water   pipe   sizing,   heat   resistance   of   road   surface   materials)  
                                                               and  policy  development  planning  (e.g.,  heat  wave  responses,  pest  infestations).      
                                                                 
                                                               By   improving   the   level   of   certainty   regarding   the   magnitude   and   frequency   of  
                                                               expected  climate  change,  and  particularly  extreme  weather  events,  the  City  is  better  
                                                               guided   in   making   decisions   regarding   capital   works   investments   and   adjustments   to  
                                                               operational   procedures.   This   may   reduce   the   risk   of   unsustainable   investment   and  
                                                               loss  associated  with  infrastructure  construction,  maintenance  and  operations  that  do  
                                                               not  take  into  account  extreme  weather  events  and  climate  change  projections.          
                                                                 
                                                               THE  CERTAINTY  OF  THE  FUTURE  WEATHER  PREDICTIONS    
                                                                   
                                                                 The   study   predicts   potential   future   outcomes   based   on   the   data   and   the   modelling  
                                                                 capabilities   of   the   recent   past.      The   weather   of   the   future   will   continue   to   change  
                                                                 rapidly   and   at   an   accelerating   rate   into   the   future.      With   the   passing   of   years   the  
Storm of August 19th, 2005                                       certainty  surrounding  the  outcomes  in  the  study  will  need  to  be  reassessed  and  the  
                                                                 study   will   need   to   be   re-­‐examined.   The   City   can   address   this   by   maintaining   a  
a)    Highest  Rainfall  is  shown  over  Finch  Avenue  
                                                                 watching  brief  of:    
b)   Captured   by   Modelling,   but   NOT   by                   
Standard   Environment   Canada   Monitoring   at                    1. The  changing  state  of  climate  change  science  and  predictions;  and  
Pearson   International   Airport   (the   best                      2. The  ongoing  changes  in  weather  extremes  and  means  for  Toronto;  and    
weather   monitoring   station   for   Toronto)  
                                                                     3. The  significance,  value  and  needs  of  timely  adaptation  and  financing  its  costs.  
because   the   centre   of   the   storm   was   distant  
from  the  airport  monitoring  station.    
  
c)   Monitoring   stations   can   only   identify   what  
happens  at  a  particular  station.  Modelling  can  
identify   what   happens   between   stations.   This  
example   typifies   the   benefits   of   not   relying  
purely  on  monitored  data.    

                                                                                                                                                                                14  
  
SUMMARY  AND  CONCLUSIONS                                                                                            Future  Warmer  Temperatures  
                                                                                                                     x     Average  annual  temperatures  increase  by  
                                                                                                                                  o
Using   a   weather-­‐climate   model   approach,   this   study   projects   the   future   weather                       4.4 C  
                                                                                                                     x     Projected  average  winter  temperature  
changes  that  Toronto  may  expect  in  2040-­‐2049.  The  model  combined  an  ensemble  of                                                  o
                                                                                                                           increases  by  5.7 C.  
large-­‐scale  global  and  medium-­‐scale  regional  climate  model  data  as  inputs  to  a  local                 x     Projected  average  summer  temperature    
scale  Weather  Research  Forecast  (WRF)  model  to  predict  successive  hourly  weather                                                     o
                                                                                                                           increases  by  3.8 C.    
conditions  into  the  future,  in  and  around  Toronto.                                                                    
                                                                                                                     x     The  extreme  daily  minimum  temperature                                                                  
                                                                                                                                                             o
The   study   is  unique   as   it   goes   beyond   the   standard   modelling   means  of  rainfall   and                -­‐  “becomes  less  cold"  by  13 C.      
                                                                                                                     x     The  extreme  daily  maximum  temperature                                                            
temperature  and  assesses  extremes  of  temperature  and  precipitation.  On  average  in                                                                  o
                                                                                                                           -­‐  "becomes  warmer"  by  7.6 C  
2040-­‐2049,  warmer  annual  average  temperatures  of  4.4oC  are  expected.  For  seasonal                          
averages   winter   temperatures   are   projected   to   increase   by   5.7oC   and   summer                       Future  Extreme  Heat  
temperatures   by   3.8oC.   Extreme   daily   maximum   temperatures   are   projected   to                           
increase  by  7.6oC,  but  extreme  daily  minimum  temperatures  are  projected  to  also  rise                     x     Mean  Maximum  Daily  Temperature    
by   13oC   (i.e.,   becomes   less   cold).   Less   snow   and   more  rain   in   the   winters   (26   fewer           between  (2000-­‐2009)  and  (2040-­‐49)  
                                                                                                                           changes  from  .  .  .    33°C  to  44°C    
snow  days  per  year)  and  fewer  rainstorm  events  per  year  are  anticipated.  However,  
                                                                                                                             
the   model   predicts   more   extreme   rainstorms   and   marked   rainfall   increases   in   July               Maximum  daily  air  temperature  is  recorded  at  
(80%+)  and  in  August  (50%+).                                                                                     a   weather   station   by   selecting   the   highest   1-­‐
                                                                                                                     hourly   air   temperature   within   each   24-­‐hour  
Considering  these  results  as  part  of  City  Council's  decision  making  processes  may  aid                    period.  (Averaged  here  over  10  years).    
                                                                                                                       
the  City  and  the  community  better  prepare  and  adapt  to  future  climate  change.  
                                                                                                                     x     Number  of  days  per  year  with  
                                                                                                                           temperatures  greater  than  30°C    
                                                                                                                           between  (2000-­‐2009)  and  (2040-­‐49)  
                                                                                                                           changes  from  .  .  .      20  days    to    66  days  
                                                                                                                       
                                                                                                                     Future  Rain,  Storms  and  Snowfall  
                                                                                                                     Less  snow,  more  rain  in  winter.  
                                                                                                                     Fewer  snow  days  per  year  
                                                                                                                       
                                                                                                                     Fewer  rainstorms  per  year    
                                                                                                                     But  more  extreme  rainstorms  
                                                                                                                     More  rainfall  in  July  (80%+)  and  August  (50%+)  
                                                                                                                       
                                                                                                                                                                                                 15  
  
You can also read