The pathophysiology of motor symptoms in Parkinson's disease
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
Acta neurol. belg., 2003, 103, 129-134 The pathophysiology of motor symptoms in Parkinson’s disease P. SANTENS, P. BOON, D. VAN ROOST and J. CAEMAERT Departments of Neurology and Neurosurgery, Ghent University Hospital, De Pintelaan 185, B-9000 Gent ———— Abstract a direct and an indirect pathway, connecting the This review focuses on some of the known and hypo- input nuclei of the basal ganglia, i.e. the striatum thetical pathophysiological mechanisms underlying the (caudate nucleus and putamen) with the output motor symptoms in Parkinson’s disease (PD). Current nuclei, the internal pallidum (GPi) and substantia views on these mechanisms have largely been influenced nigra pars reticulata (SNr). These two pathways by models of basal ganglia functioning and dysfunction- have opposite effects on the output of the basal ing. These models have allowed to explain some clinical ganglia : the direct pathway has a net positive effect findings and to predict a number of results of basal gan- on the basal ganglia output, while the indirect path- glia surgery in movement disorders. However, neuro- way has a negative effect. Dopamine released from physiological studies as well as neurochemical data striatal terminals of substantia nigra pars compacta have broadened our vision on basal ganglia functioning (SNc) neurons has opposite effects on both path- and dysfunctioning in PD. Moreover, these more funda- mental insights in basal ganglia functioning allow new ways, resulting in a net release of thalamic output concepts on the development of treatment strategies, and to cortical motor areas. In this way a release of on the prevention of motor fluctuations in PD. motor programs and inhibition of unwanted move- ments can be balanced to result in finely tuned motor behaviour. Introduction : the basal ganglia Both direct and indirect pathways originate in the matrix compartment of the striatum. Recently it In contemporary neuro-anatomy the striatum was suggested that a third pathway, originating in (putamen and caudate nucleus), the pallidum the striosomal compartment of the striatum also (internal and external), the subthalamic nucleus exerts control over movement by means of its con- and the substantia nigra (pars compacta and reticu- nections to the substantia nigra. This pathway lata) are considered the nuclei of the basal ganglia. might therefore control dopamine release accord- Over the last few years it has been demonstrated ing to variables such as experience and evaluation that these nuclei play a key role in mediating motor (Graybiel A. M. et al., 2000). It is a well-known and non-motor behaviour, cognition and emotion. that dopamine release is dependent on the predic- The functions of the basal ganglia have been tion of reward of an action (Walters J. R. et al., explained in terms of anatomy and connectivity, 2000). biochemistry and electrophysiology. Apart from dopamine, several other neurotrans- Several models of the functional anatomy of the mitters have been implicated in basal ganglia func- basal ganglia have been proposed. The most tion (Fig. 1), the most important being glutamate familiar model was introduced in the 1980’s and GABA. Finally, the electrophysiological (Alexander G. E. et al., 1990 ; DeLong M., 1990). properties of basal ganglia nuclei are complicated This model is based on the existence of separate and differ substantially from one nucleus to another parallel loops, mediating motor, cognitive and one. Tonic discharges can be interrupted by phasic emotional functions, and running through the basal alterations which are related to initiation or perfor- ganglia in a more or less uniform fashion (Fig. 1). mance of movements. In this review we will focus on motor function, Two important characteristics of basal ganglia unless otherwise specified. function included in this classical model are con- In spite of the many criticisms raised and the vergence and segregation. Convergence refers to obvious oversimplification of basal ganglia con- the fact that along the circuits the number of neu- nectivity, this model has provided a framework that rons decreases by each step, thus converging infor- allowed to predict outcomes of lesions and of sur- mation following each relay. Segregation not only gical procedures in extrapyramidal disorders implies separation of the individual circuits along (Obeso J. A. et al., 2000b). Central in the descrip- their path through the basal ganglia, but also the tion of the model is the existence of two pathways, separation of information flow for motor functions
130 P. SANTENS ET AL. FIG. 1. — The model of basal ganglia functional anatomy as proposed by Alexander and DeLong. White arrows indicate an excita- tory connection, dark arrows indicate an inhibitory connection. Neurotransmitters involved in these connections are indicated in ital- ics. The existence of two pathways, a direct and indirect one, is indicated. of individual parts of the body. The “focussing” chemical and electrophysiologic changes can be hypothesis of basal ganglia function in movement predicted from the model. Many of these predic- is based on this segregation. According to this tions have been confirmed by in vitro and in vivo hypothesis the release of motor programs is findings in animal models and humans. A charac- focussed to a specific body part, while movements teristic increase in firing rate of the GPi and STN of surrounding body parts are inhibited by means has been found in MPTP-treated animals of the indirect pathway. (Obeso J. A. et al., 2000b). The consequence of this An important consideration is the fact that basal increased firing rate is an excessive activation of ganglia output ultimately results in changes of cor- basal ganglia output nuclei, leading to inhibition of tical output. Electrophysiological studies have the thalamo-cortical and brainstem motor systems. demonstrated that basal ganglia modulate spatio- This increase is reversed by administration of temporal organisation of cortical activity implicat- dopaminergic agents. Moreover pallidotomy and ed in the selection and propagation of adequate deep brain stimulation of the STN or GPi can movement (Brown P. et al., 1998). It appears that induce clinical improvement in patients with PD basal ganglia are implicated in coherence of mus- (Obeso J. A. et al., 2000b). cle and cortical activity at higher frequency ranges Electrophysiological studies in animal models (Salenius S. et al., 2002). This leads to fusion of have suggested that oscillatory activity may appear motor unit activities sufficient to sustain adequate within the basal ganglia nuclei following dopami- force and speed of movement onset (Pfann K. D. et nergic depletion in the striatum. Studies of the elec- al., 2001) (“scaling” – see below). trical activity of neighbouring neurons have shown that coherence increases, which suggests a loss of The consequences of dopaminergic deficit segregation within the basal ganglia (Bergman H. in Parkinson’s disease et al., 2002 ; Brown P., 2003). From a biochemical point of view dopaminergic Following degeneration of the SNc dopaminer- denervation of the striatum increases expression of gic neurons projecting to the striatum, several bio- preproenkephalin and D2 receptor mRNA in
THE PATHOPHYSIOLOGY OF MOTOR SYMPTOMS IN PARKINSON’S DISEASE 131 the occurrence of an isometric tremor in PD patients, characteristically evoked by squeezing the fingers of the examiner. Indeed, if fusion of motor units does not occur appropriately when stronger forces are to be generated, this might lead to inter- ruptions of motor activity, and hence isometric tremor. The frequency of this tremor is not corre- lated to the frequency of the resting tremor which may be present in the same patient (De Letter M. et al., 2003 ; Salenius S. et al., 2002). Finally, alterations in sensory processing have FIG. 2. — Schematic representation of EMG bursts in ago- been suggested to contribute to bradykinesia and nist and antagonist muscles during a reaching movement in hypokinesia. This suggestion is supported by the normal controls and in PD. In normal controls the goal is reduced amplitude of the frontal component of the reached by single agonist-antagonist mechanisms. In PD, ago- somatosensory evoked potentials in PD nist bursts are hypometric, requiring multiple bursts to reach the target (scaling). (Abbruzzese G. et al., 2003). Tremor neurons of the indirect pathway. Conversely in neu- rons of the direct pathway the expression of mRNA Although text books teach us that the classical for the D1 receptor, substance P and dynorphin is tremor of PD is a resting tremor, a variety of decreased (Obeso J. A. et al., 2000b). tremors can be found in PD (Deuschl G. et al., 1998). Most frequently, a rest tremor and postural Bradykinesia and hypokinesia or kinetic tremor with equal frequency ranging from 4-7 Hz is found (classical parkinsonian These cardinal features of parkinsonism point to tremor) although in the early stages and in severe a number of different alterations of movement. akinetic-rigid symptoms higher frequencies may They refer to slowness of movement, reduced occur (Deuschl G. et al., 2000). movement amplitude, disturbances of movement Only two human conditions with resting tremor initiation, and decrease of spontaneous or associat- are known : PD and Holmes’ tremor. Both condi- ed movements (Berardelli A. et al., 2001). tions share the common factor of dopaminergic Bradykinesia and hypokinesia are commonly deficiency in the striatum (Brooks D. et al., 1992). explained by the changes occurring in the basal This would suggest that lesions of the SNc are ganglia as explained above. It is frequently quoted indispensible for the occurrence of resting tremor. in this sense that PD patients are “driving while Many observations support this hypothesis, but the stepping on the brakes”. Of course this is an over- question is if dopamine deficiency is enough. simplification, which becomes more clear when Indeed, in primate models resting tremor can only these features of parkinsonism are analyzed in be evoked by combined lesions in the SNc, the red greater detail. It has been demonstrated manifold nucleus and the cerebello-thalamic fibers that PD patients have longer latency times before (Deuschl G. et al., 2000). PET studies have sug- movement occurs, that they take longer before gested the influence of serotonergic denervation in reaching appropriate forces to perform voluntary the origin of rest tremor (Doder M. et al., 2003). movements, and that movements are more fre- Other PET studies of cerebral metabolism have quently broken down in small steps, requiring mul- pointed to cerebellar hypermetabolism in tremor, tiple EMG bursts to reach a target (Berardelli A. et which was reverted by thalamic stimulation leading al., 2001) (Fig. 2). to tremor arrest (Deiber M. P. et al., 1993). This These changes can be explained in part by the suggests a mechanism originating in the cerebel- results of studies of alterations in cortical activity lum or its connecting systems, such as the oliva in PD patients performing isometric contractions. It inferior. has been shown that coherence between cortical In a clinical context, it is well known that dopa- activity and muscular activity is decreasing in the minergic suppletion is not always able to control higher frequency ranges (Salenius S. et al., 2002). parkinsonian tremor (Elble R. J., 2002). Moreover This leads to a defective fusion of motor units it has been argued that patients displaying tremor resulting in a slower recruitment of force, and an have a better prognosis as far as motor progression inappropriate generation of muscular force to reach and development of mental deterioration is con- a target. This might be implicated in the under- cerned (Deuschl G. et al., 2000). Recent findings scaling of movement (hypometria), which is to be however have shed doubt on these dogmatically corrected by multiple bursts of muscular activity accepted statements (Vingerhoets G. et al., 2003). (Pfann K. D. et al., 2001) (Fig. 2). Furthermore this The pathophysiology of parkinsonian tremor might explain a well-known phenomenon, which is remains a matter of debate. Peripheral influences, if
132 P. SANTENS ET AL. ever present, are minor and all available evidence long-loop reflexes originating in muscle spindles points towards a central mechanism involved in the and running through cortical relays are at the basis generation of the tremor in PD. of increased muscle tone. This view is based on an So-called tremor cells, displaying rhythmic increase of M2-responses after arrest of a voluntary activity linked to the tremor frequency have been movement. However, this finding has not been found in several basal ganglia nuclei. Tremor cells accepted universally and several aspects of rigidity are more frequently found in ventrolateral thalamic in PD do not fit the hypothesis of long-loop reflex- nuclei than in the internal pallidum and subthala- es (Delwaide P. et al., 1990). Most compelling is mic nucleus. Rare tremor cells have been described the equal distribution of rigidity in distal and proxi- in the external pallidum and none were detected in mal as well as axial musculature. Another clinical the striatum (Deuschl G. et al., 2000). This sug- finding which is hard to reconcile with this theory gests that convergence may be implicated in the is the increase of rigidity by contralateral move- generation and enhancement of tremor activity ment (Froment’s sign). Therefore other mecha- along the basal ganglia-thalamic pathways. nisms must be involved. Another observation linking clinical and electro- A very interesting and attractive hypothesis is physiological data is that although frequency of the involvement of reticulospinal tracts. In fact, parkinsonian tremor may be very similar in differ- electrophysiological studies have demonstrated ent body parts, tremor activity is almost never that the activity of inhibitory interneurons at spinal coherent between limbs, which suggests that the levels are differentially altered in PD. The activity basic rhythm might be an inherent characteristic of of IA spinal inhibitory interneurons is increased, a patient’s disturbed basal ganglia system, but the while the activity of IB interneurons seems to be generators of the tremor might be different from decreased. This may lead to tonic facilitation of one body part to another one (Deuschl G. et al., alpha motor neurons. These processes can be 2000). reversed by administration of L-DOPA. The only It has been suggested manifold that the thalamic descending tract able to differentially influence motor nuclei are at the origin of parkinsonian tremor. these interneurons is the reticulospinal tract A putative mechanism involves specific voltage- (Delwaide P. et al., 1993). Reticular nuclei in the dependent calcium channels that are able to gener- brainstem, such as the nucleus reticularis giganto- ate a spontoneous rhytmicity of neurons in condi- cellularis and the nucleus pontis caudalis receive tions of hyperpolarization. Indeed, in PD, thalamic afferents from the pedunculopontine nucleus, nuclei are inhibited and hence hyperpolarized by en- which is connected to the basal ganglia as shown in hanced GABA-ergic neurotransmission (Jahnsen H. the original model (Pahapill P. A. et al., 2000). The et al., 1984 ; Magnin M. et al., 2000). However the activity of these reticular nuclei can be tested elec- electrophysiological characteristics of the spikes trophysiologically by means of the startle reflex generated by these calcium currents do not fit the and the audiospinal augmentation of the H-reflex tremor-linked activity of thalamic neurons. (Delwaide P. et al., 1993). Another very interesting putative mechanism is the STN-GPe pacemaker. When neurons from The pathophysiology of motor fluctuations these two nuclei are isolated in vitro, they develop rhytmic activity (Plenz D. et al., 1999). The fre- Motor fluctuations are a serious burden in quencies of these rhythms are lower than tremor advancing PD. It has been suggested that 50% of frequencies in PD. However it cannot be excluded patients treated with L-DOPA for 5 years suffer that filtering through downstream nuclei somehow from motor fluctuations (Marsden C. D. et al., modifies tremor frequencies, perhaps under the 1977). Several types of fluctuations have been influence of dopaminergic deficiency. described, the most notable ones being end-of-dose Finally loss of segregation, as mentioned above, and on-off fluctuations and dyskinesia. Advanced might be at the origin of the coherence of neigh- disease, therapy duration and half-life of the bouring neurons, leading to the development of dopaminergic agent used to initiate therapy have functional units propagating tremor activity along consistently been correlated with the development the cortico-subcortico-cortical pathways. These of motor fluctuations (Fahn S., 2000). Progressive functional units may display coherence between degeneration of nigral neurons leads to loss of their neurons, but not with neurons belonging to buffer capacity for L-DOPA and hence a deteriora- other neighbouring functional units. In this way tion of the long-duration response. The remaining different tremor generators may develop for differ- short-duration response may not be sufficient to ent parts of the body (Deuschl G. et al., 2000). sustain motor function continuously and subse- quently off-episodes develop before a new dose of Rigidity L-DOPA is taken. Current knowledge considers the development The pathophysiology of rigidity in PD remains a of on-off fluctuations and dyskinesias a conse- matter of debate. The traditional view holds that quence of plasticity in the basal ganglia induced by
THE PATHOPHYSIOLOGY OF MOTOR SYMPTOMS IN PARKINSON’S DISEASE 133 chronic intermittent stimulation with short-acting loss of segregation, causing increased coherence of dopaminergic agents (Obeso J. A. et al., 2000a). neurons that are normally acting independently. Indeed, compared to long-acting dopaminergic Further pathophysiological studies on coherence agents, an increase in Immediate Early genes (IEG) within basal ganglia and coherence with cortical in the Fos family and in mRNA for prepro- and muscular activity might enhance our knowl- enkephalin is found in MPTP animals treated with edge of bradykinesia and tremor. short-acting dopaminergic treatments. This means Finally, brainstem reticular nuclei seem to be that the mechanisms involved in the development involved in the generation of rigidity and axial of motor fluctuations and dyskinesias are essential- symptomatology. These nuclei are awaiting further ly controlled by altered transcription of genes exploration to define their exact pathophysiological (Bedard P. J. et al., 1999). However, it is unknown role in PD. how these changes develop in the context of dopaminergic treatment with short-acting agents. REFERENCES Some have suggested that this may depend on changes in the state of phosphorylation of NMDA- ABBRUZZESE G., BERARDELLI A. Sensorimotor integration receptors, located in the vicinity of dopamine in movement disorders. Mov. Disord., 2003, 18 : receptors, and responsible for the control of long- 231-240. term potentiation and depression (LTP and LTD, ALEXANDER G. E., CRUTCHER M. D. Functional architec- respectively). This could lead to a form of abnor- ture of basal ganglia circuits : neural substrates of mal learning and memory with subsequent dyski- parallel processing. Tr. Neurosci., 1990, 13 : 266- nesia and shortened motor responses (Obeso J. A. 271. BARA-JIMENEZ W., SHERZAI A., DIMITROVA T., FAVIT A., et al., 2000a). In the three pathway-model suggest- BIBBIANI F., GILLESPIE M, MORRIS M. J., ed above, dyskinesias would follow striosome- MOURADIAN M. M., CHASE T. N. Adenosine A2A predominant activation of IEG medially due to receptor antagonist treatment of Parkinson’s LTD in the input from associative cortex, combined disease. Neurology, 2003, 61 : 293-296. with matrix-predominant activation in the sensori- BEDARD P. J., BLANCHET P. J., LEVESQUE D., SOGHO- motor striatum, located more laterally, as a conse- MONIAN J. J., GRONDIN R., MORISSETTE M., GOULET quence of sensorimotor cortico-striatal LTP M., CALON F., FALARDEAU P., GOMEZ-MANCILLA B., (Graybiel A. M. et al., 2000). An interesting obser- DOUCET J. P., ROBERTSON G. S., DIPAOLO T. vation is the potential role of adenosine 2A (A2A) Pathophysiology of L-dopa-induced dyskinesias. receptor antagonists in the treatment of PD. A2A Mov. Disord., 1999, 14 Suppl. 1 : 4-8. receptors are involved in phosphorylation of gluta- BERARDELLI A., ROTHWELL J. C., THOMPSON P. D., HALLETT M. Pathophysiology of bradykinesia in mate receptors and antagonists seem to confer Parkinson’s disease. Brain, 2001, 124 : 2131-2146. benefit in animal models of PD, as well as in BERGMAN H., DEUSCHL G. Pathophysiology of human PD. This underscores the role of glutama- Parkinson’s disease : from clinical neurology to tate-mediated mechanisms following dopaminergic basic neuroscience and back. Mov. Disord., 2002, denervation and intermittent receptor stimulation 17 Suppl 3 : S28-S40. (Bara-Jimenez W. et al., 2003). BROOKS D., PLAYFORD E. D., IBANEZ V., SAWLE G., THOMPSON P. D., FINDLEY L. J., MARSDEN C. D. Isolated tremor and disruption of the nigrostriatal Conclusion dopaminergic system : an 18F-DOPA PET study. Neurology, 1992, 42 : 1554-1560. Many aspects of the pathophysiology of symp- BROWN P. Oscillatory nature of human basal ganglia activity : relationship to the pathophysiology of toms in PD remain to be unraveled. It is at present Parkinson’s disease. Mov. Disord., 2003, 18 : 357- unclear why some patients develop symptoms that 363. do not occur in others. This suggests the presence BROWN P., MARSDEN C. D. What do the basal ganglia do ? of subgroups of PD, perhaps related to difference in Lancet, 1998, 351 : 1801-1804. progression rate and prognosis. The view on the DE LETTER M., SANTENS P., VAN BORSEL J. The effects of pathophysiology of PD symptoms is evolving into levodopa on tongue strength and endurance in a modified one, in which different aspects of patients with Parkinson’s disease. Acta Neurol. connectivity, plasticity, neurophysiology and mole- Belg., 2003, 103 : 35-38. cular biology are to be integrated. Present evidence DEIBER M. P., POLLAK P., PASSINGHAM R., LANDAIS P., suggests that basal ganglia are important in the GERVASON C., CINOTTI L., FRISTON K., spatiotemporal organisation of motor cortex out- FRACKOWIAK R., MAUGUIERE F., BENABID A. L. Thalamic stimulation and suppression of parkin- put. Dopamine deficiency causes electrophysiolo- sonian tremor. Evidence of a cerebellar deactiva- gical changes in the basal ganglia and leads to bio- tion using positron emission tomography. Brain, chemical alterations that ultimately result in altered 1993, 116 (Pt 1) : 267-279. gene transcription, further modified by pharma- DELONG M. Primate models of movement disorders of cological therapy. An important characteristic basal ganglia origin. Tr. Neurosci., 1990, 13 : 281- of dopamine deficiency in the basal ganglia is the 285.
134 P. SANTENS ET AL. DELWAIDE P., PEPIN J. L., MAERTENS DE NOORDHOUT A. La OBESO J. A., OLANOW C. W., NUTT J. G. Levodopa motor rigidité parkinsonienne : aspects cliniques et complications in Parkinson’s disease. Tr. Neuro- physiopathologiques. Rev. Neurol., 1990, 146 : sci., 2000a, 23 (suppl.) : S2-S7. 548-554. OBESO J. A., RODRIGUEZ-OROZ M. C., RODRIGUEZ M., DELWAIDE P., PEPIN J. L., MAERTENS DE NOORDHOUT A. LANCIEGO J. I., ARTIEDA J., GONZALO N., The audiospinal reaction in parkinsonian patients OLANOW C. W. Pathophysiology of the basal gan- reflects functional changes in reticular nuclei. glia in Parkinson’s disease. Tr. Neurosci., 2000b, Ann. Neurol., 1993, 33 : 63-69. 23 (suppl.) : S8-S19. DEUSCHL G., BAIN P., BRIN M., SCIENTIFIC COMMITTEE PAHAPILL P. A., LOZANO A. M The pedunculopontine Consensus statement of the movement disorder nucleus and Parkinson’s disease. Brain, 2000, society on tremor. Mov. Disord., 1998, 13 (suppl 123 : 1767-1783. 3) : 2-23. PFANN K. D., BUCHMAN A. S., COMELLA C., CORCOS D. M. DEUSCHL G., RAETHJEN J., BARON R., LINDEMANN M., Control of movement distance in Parkinson’s WILMS H., KRACK P. The pathophysiology of disease. Mov. Disord., 2001, 16 : 1048-1065. parkinsonian tremor : a review. J. Neurol., 2000, PLENZ D., KITAL S. T. A basal ganglia pacemaker formed 247 (suppl V) : 33-48. by the subthalamic nucleus and external globus DODER M., RABINER E. A., TURJANSKI N., LEES A. J., pallidus. Nature, 1999, 400 : 677-682. BROOKS D. J. Tremor in Parkinson’s disease and SALENIUS S., AVIKAINEN S., KAAKKOLA S., HARI R., serotonergic dysfunction. An 11C-WAY 100635 BROWN P. Defective cortical drive to muscle in PET study. Neurology, 2003, 60 : 601-605. Parkinson’s disease and its improvement with ELBLE R. J. Tremor and dopamine agonists. Neurology, levodopa. Brain, 2002, 125 : 491-500. 2002, 58 : S57-S62. VINGERHOETS G., VERLEDEN S., SANTENS P., MIATTON M., FAHN S. The spectrum of levodopa-induced dyskinesias. DE REUCK J. Predictors of cognitive impairment in Ann. Neurol., 2000, 47 (suppl. 1) : 3-11. advanced Parkinson’s disease. J. Neurol. Neuro- GRAYBIEL A. M., CANALES J. J., CAPPER-LOUP C. surg. Psychiatry, 2003, 74 : 793-796. Levodopa-induced dyskinesias and dopamine- WALTERS J. R., RUSKIN D. N., ALLERS K. A., BERG- dependent stereotypies : a new hypothesis. Tr. STROM D. A. Pre-and postsynaptic aspects of Neurosci., 2000, 23 (suppl.) : S71-S77. dopamine-mediated transmission. Tr. Neurosci., JAHNSEN H., LLINAS R. Ionic basis for the electro-respon- 2000, 23 (suppl.) : S41-S47. siveness and oscillatory properties of of guinea pig thalamic neurones in vitro. J. Physiol., 1984, P. SANTENS, M.D., Ph.D., 349 : 227-247. Department of Neurology, MAGNIN M., MOREL A., JEANMONOD D. Single-unit analy- Ghent University Hospital, sis of the pallidum,thalamus and subthalamic De Pintelaan 185, nucleus in parkinsonian patients. Neuroscience, 2000, 96 : 549-564. B-9000 Gent, MARSDEN C. D., PARKES J. D. Succes and problems of E-mail : Patrick.Santens@UGent.be. long-term levodopa therapy in parkinson’s dis- ease. Lancet, 1977, 345-349.
You can also read