THE FUTURE OF WINTER SPORTS - A DELPHI STUDY - CSM RESE ARCH REP ORT COMMISSIONED BY MASTERCARD - WHU
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
CSM RESEARCH REPORT THE FUTURE OF WINTER SPORTS – A DELPHI STUDY C O M M I S S I O N E D BY M A S T E R CA R D
INTRODUCTION Dear readers, Skiing is more popular than ever before tive endorsement deals for men. In 2025, DELPHI STUDY WITH and has steadily expanded its base over gender parity in ski sports organizations 13 PROJECTIONS AND the past five years (Schmidt et al., 2019). has not yet been reached. The same holds 46 EXPERTS The latest developments sound very true for the digitization in these organiza- promising, but it is undeniable that the in- tions, which have made a lot of progress dustry is also facing challenges. There- but still lack behind, despite a strong de- The desire to predict the future is part of fore, we conducted a scientifically-based sire to catch up to digital frontrunners in human nature. In ancient Greece, the Or- Delphi study on the future of skiing with other sports. The desire for the use of dig- acle of Delphi foretold the future and be- the support of renowned winter sports ital ski sports simulations is limited and came one of the most famous cult sites experts. The study takes us on a journey might need more time to grow. Five years in history (Häder, 2009). However, for our through time and outlines skiing in the from now, there are far more skiers on the scientific “view into the crystal ball,” we year 2025. real slopes than in the digital world and did not consult the Oracle of Delphi, but video gaming has not yet proven to be a rather collected the opinions of leading According to our experts, five years from critical factor in getting young people ex- minds in the skiing industry. These in- now, despite huge environmental chal- cited about skiing. cluded FIS officials, former elite athletes, lenges, the skiing industry has managed managing directors of ski resorts, tech- to find technological solutions to sus- Based on our experts’ opinions, this is nology experts, eSports developers, and tain best skiing conditions for long pe- how skiing might look like in the year media representatives. riods of the year – both for professional 2025. However, critics may object: Why and recreational skiers. Technology has should we care about future projections? With the help of a “real-time” version not only helped to make resorts more cli- Why should we be concerned today with of the Delphi method (Dalkey & Helmer, mate-friendly, but digital innovations have the development of the skiing industry in 1963), originally developed by the US mil- also enabled an entirely new skiing expe- five years’ time? By then, the world will no itary in the 1960s for forecasting purpos- rience. Cashless payments and seamless longer be comparable to that of today, any- es, a total of 46 proven experts evaluated consumer interactions have become the way. Does it, therefore, make any sense to and commented on 13 projections on the new normal, making recreational skiing think about long-term strategies? Our an- future of ski sports. Each projection was more fun and more secure. Security has swer is yes! In the new realities of the dig- assessed in terms of probability, impact, similarly increased for professional skiers itized society and economy, future readi- and desirability of its occurrence. For the in 2025. With the enhancement of availa- ness is a core capability. It is important year 2025, five different scenarios were ble technologies and an extended usage to think through future scenarios and to analyzed and are presented on the follow- of advanced data analytics methods, ath- carefully deal with the consequences ing pages in more detail. letes face less risk of severe injuries and, they might have. Projections help play- thus, can deliver record-breaking per- ers in the skiing industry to identify trends This study was conducted in close coop- formances on the slopes. Moreover, dig- early, reduce uncertainty, and increase eration with Mastercard. We would like to ital technologies including virtual real- their competitiveness. Decision makers take this opportunity to thank Nicole Krieg ity simulations have helped athletes to are required to anticipate future changes and Hannah Bruckner for their excellent continuously improve their skills. At the and must learn to think counterfactually collaboration. We would also like to thank same time, augmented reality applica- in order to shape the future of their be- the experts who participated in the study, tions guide both professional and recre- loved sports. as well as Marcus Höfl and Andreas Berg- ational skiers through the fastest and/or mann from MHM Majors GmbH for their safest route, based on weather and slope Our Delphi study is designed to help ath- support in identifying and contacting rel- conditions. letes, managers and decision makers to evant stakeholders for this study. adapt their business model in a timely While this all has happened in five years manner in order to build their own orga- from now, some areas still require more nization in a sustainable and future- focus. According to our experts, wage oriented way. Our goal is not to make an Authors gaps between male and female athletes exact prediction, but to initiate a produc- Prof. Sascha L. Schmidt, Daniel Beider- still exist, mainly because of more lucra- tive debate about the future of skiing. beck, Nicolas Frevel, and Harry Krüger 2
CONTENT THE MOST IMPORTANT STUDY RESULTS 4 FOCUS ON SUSTAINABILITY? 5 How climate change will impact the ski sports ecosystem FASTER, HIGHER, STRONGER? 7 How technologies will shape ski sports LAST ANALOG EXPERIENCE? 9 How digitization will impact the ski sports ecosystem GENDER PARITY ACHIEVED? 11 How gender parity will evolve GAMING TO ATTRACT NEW TARGET GROUPS? 13 How simulation games will impact the next generation of skiers STUDY DESIGN AND METHODOLOGY 15 REFERENCES 17 ABOUT THE AUTHORS 19 3
THE MOST IMPORTANT STUDY RESULTS 1 Climate focus is inevitable and the winter sports 2 Modern technologies can contribute significantly industry will master this to the advancement of existential challenge ski sports, but institutional support is needed P. 5 P. 7 3 Recreational skiers will have a seamless experience 4 Despite great desire, it will be a rocky road to in ski resorts by 2025 – achieve gender parity however, ski sports orga- in ski sports by 2025 – nizations have a long way both on and off the slope to go to become digital frontrunners P. 9 P. 11 5 Gaming in ski sports will not play a vital role by 2025 – neither in attracting the majority of people to play, nor in motivating young generations to ski P. 13 4
CLIMATE FOCUS IS INEVITABLE AND THE WINTER SPORTS INDUSTRY WILL MASTER THIS EXISTENTIAL CHALLENGE 1 CLIMATE CHANGE IS AMONG THE FIG. 1.1 MOST CURRENT TOPICS OF OUR TIME 2025: SUSTAINABILITY HAS BECOME A CRITICAL AND IT INCREASINGLY AFFECTS THE PREREQUISITE FOR STAKEHOLDERS IN THE WORLD OF SKIING. FOR SKI RESORTS, WINTER SPORTS ECOSYSTEMS TO BE SUCCESSFUL CLIMATE CHANGE MIGHT NOT JUST BE A PROBLEM, BUT AN EXISTENTIAL Rank THREAT. 77% PROBABILITY 1/13 Glaciers are shrinking at an unprece- 4.26 dented rate and are more and more often IMPACT 1/13 closed to skiers. Ski resorts might see 4.46 a significant drop in the number of days DESIRABILITY 1/13 they can operate every season. They try to fight back with an armada of snowmak- MORE SUSTAINABILITY IN ter sports tourists will demand it. Offer- “ARTIFICIAL SNOW WINTER SPORTS IS HIGHLY ing zero-emission-winter-sports might DESIRED, BUT THE BUSINESS be a competitive advantage in the future. PRODUCTION IMPACT UNTIL 2025 REMAINS There is consensus among the experts HAS IMPROVED AND DEBATABLE that more sustainable ski resorts will be WILL FURTHER able to attract larger numbers of guests. However, if zero emissions are to be IMPROVE THROUGH The debate about climate change and its reached on a larger scale, it would need TECHNOLOGY AND role in the world of skiing is not new, but to be a common goal of all stakeholders THEREFORE HELP TO it is gaining a whole new type of momen- involved. It is conceivable that subsidies, tum now with increasing societal aware- licenses, and public permits will be more MAINTAIN GOOD ness. Therefore, we projected for 2025 and more dependent on sustainability ef- SKIING CONDITIONS that “Sustainability has become a critical forts. Winter sports officials among our IN A MORE CLIMATE- prerequisite for stakeholders in the win- group of experts see the need to take the ter sports ecosystems to be successful.” topic seriously and to develop a viable ac- FRIENDLY WAY” On the one hand, climate change has be- tion plan (see Fig. 1.1). come tangible, and one group of experts argued that all stakeholders will need On the other hand, despite the reality ing machines that paint the hills white. to act sustainably if they want to stay in of climate change, another group of ex- This reliance on snowmakers leads to two business. Basically, it will no longer be a perts argued that sustainability won’t questions: When will ski resorts get too choice of whether be more sustainable, be a prerequisite for success in winter warm for snowmaking machines? And will but a prerequisite for success as win- sports. They believe that climate change this reliance be sustainable in the future? Sustainability is certainly a hot topic for the foreseeable future and a major point of criticism that ski resorts face. However, does this mean that ski resorts have no “WE NEED TO TAKE SUSTAINABILITY SERIOUSLY choice but to become more sustainable in the future? Might they withstand the AND ALSO PUT REQUIREMENTS growing pressure from consumers and tourists for climate-friendly solutions? INTO PLACE” Or might sustainability become a pre- requisite for all stakeholders in the winter sports ecosystem to be successful? 5
“IF WINTER SPORT RESORTS ARE NOT GOING TO DO WORK MORE SUSTAINABLY, THEY WILL BE LEFT WITHOUT VISITORS” might play a role for ski resorts, but not TECHNOLOGIES WILL PLAY skiing conditions in a climate-friend- by 2025. For now, sustainability is no A DECISIVE ROLE IN THE ly way seems to be technically unrealis- more than a buzzword in their view; while FUTURE OF WINTER SPORTS tic. There is a lot of skepticism whether it is widely debated, it does not lead to INCLUDING MAINTENANCE there will be innovations (e.g., in artificial any significant action being taken. Visi- OF GOOD SKIING CONDITIONS snow) that can make a difference at a rea- tors are still driving hundreds of kilome- IN A CLIMATE-FRIENDLY WAY ters into the mountains with their SUVs for a few days of skiing. Experts of our study rated the projec- “I WOULD LIKE Whether or not winter sport stakehold- tion that “technologies have helped to SUSTAINABILITY ers will act significantly more sustaina- maintain good skiing conditions in a cli- TO BECOME A bly by 2025 is, of course, very difficult to mate-friendly way” with the third highest predict. It is clear, though, that the issues score on all three dimensions – probabil- PREREQUISITE TO of climate change and sustainability will ity, impact, and desirability (see Fig. 1.2). BE SUCCESSFUL, not disappear. Ultimately, it will be con- While there is overall consensus about BUT I AM NOT sumers and tourists who decide whether the importance of climate-friendliness, sustainability will become a prerequi- our experts show different levels of opti- OVERLY OPTIMISTIC” site for success in winter sports. Our mism in achievement of climate-friendly experts agree that more sustainable winter sports with the help of technology. winter sports would be highly desirable sonable cost. However, other experts are (highest desirability amongst all projec- Some of our experts see an inherent con- much more optimistic. They argue that tions, see Fig. 1.1), but leave open whether tradiction between winter sports and technology has already helped the ski- the affected stakeholders are willing to climate-friendliness. For example, over- ing industry to become significantly more bear the costs and live with the conse- tourism and artificial snow are inherent- energy efficient, for example, in terms of quences. ly bad for our climate. Maintaining good snow-grooming equipment or snowmak- ing machines. In their view, advanced technologies as well as entirely new tech- nical solutions will help preserve good skiing conditions. Thus, there seems to be consensus that FIG. 1.2 good skiing conditions will be main- 2025: TECHNOLOGIES HAVE HELPED tained in a more and more climate-friend- TO MAINTAIN GOOD SKIING CONDITIONS ly way in the future. It is questionable IN A CLIMATE-FRIENDLY WAY though whether we will ever see true cli- mate-friendliness – i.e., zero emissions – in the world of skiing. This would clearly Rank 65% require significant investment, radical re- PROBABILITY 3/13 thinking, and more climate-friendly ways 3.82 of snow-making. But, many stakeholders IMPACT 3/13 in the winter sports industry truly care 4.35 about nature and they will leverage tech- DESIRABILITY 3/13 nology for viable solutions. 6
MODERN TECHNOLOGIES CAN CONTRIBUTE SIGNIFICANTLY TO THE ADVANCEMENT OF SKI SPORTS, BUT INSTITUTIONAL SUPPORT IS NEEDED 2 THE IMPACT THAT TECHNOLOGIES FIG. 2.1 HAVE HAD ON THE WORLD OF SPORTS 2025: TECHNOLOGIES HAVE INCREASED ATHLETES’ SAFETY IS VAST AND MIGHT BECOME MORE AND SPORTIVE PERFORMANCE PRONOUNCED IN THE FUTURE. EXAM- PLES OF IMPACTFUL APPLICATION OF Rank TECHNOLOGY IN SPORTS ARE NU- 76% PROBABILITY 2/13 MEROUS RANGING FROM SPRINTING, JAVELIN AND THE POLE VAULT (HAAKE, 4.02 2009), CYCLING, AND SWIMMING, IMPACT 2/13 TO TEAM SPORTS SUCH AS FOOTBALL 4.46 AND BASKETBALL (FOSTER ET AL., DESIRABILITY 1/13 2012; SCHMIDT & EBERHARD, 2016). In most sports, the rate of improvement sportive performance has plateaued given the natural limits of human ability. Most Delphi experts strongly believe in the ef- provements, particularly in terms of better performance improvements in the future fect and benefit that technology will have material. Our experts agree that the level will be the consequence of technological on both safety and performance. For ath- of physical ability has reached its relative innovation and application (Balmer et al., letes’ safety, we have already seen signifi- maximum so the next level of performance 2011; Dyer, 2015). For example, researchers cant improvements over the past few dec- improvement will come from technolo- found that only half of the progress in terms gy. For example, digital solutions will allow of world records in speed skating stems athletes to train better and (mentally) pre- from actual athletic improvement, while “AS THE SPORT IS UNIQUE pare for training and competitions. Artifi- the other half results from technological cial intelligence could be used to improve IN TERMS OF OUTDOOR advancements (de Koning, 2010). Technol- the interplay of human ability and technol- ogy has also massively increased athletes’ FACTORS (E.G., SNOW, ogy. As in any industry, the pace of change safety over the past few decades and we ICE), THE DIGITAL SIMULA- and development will largely depend on expect to see continued improvements in TIONS’ BENEFITS MIGHT willingness to invest in technologies. the future. The sports industry might take BE MARGINAL” a leading role in the introduction of “yet un- foreseen digital technologies” (Merkel et al., TECHNOLOGIES ALONE WILL 2016). Winter sports are no different and we ades with the FIS Injury Surveillance and NOT BE ENOUGH TO FURTHER have seen and will continue to see similar Prevention System, protective wear, and INCREASE INCLUSIVENESS developments in the future. inflatable airbags, to name a few. At the IN SKI SPORTS same time, there is still significant room for improvement, particularly in areas like TECHNOLOGIES WILL FURTHER material, analytic tools, and physical train- Will we see ski world cups where all ath- INCREASE SAFETY AND ing (e.g., with neurological feedback). One letes, independent of gender, age or dis- PERFORMANCE IN WINTER of the most promising areas, according to ability, compete against each other in the SPORTS – BOTH FOR PROFES- our experts, is the prevention of injuries same competition? This was the under- SIONAL ATHLETES AND using technology and analytics. The ever- lying question of our future projection RECREATIONAL SKIERS improving quality of data allows athletes that, “Ski world cups have become inclu- and their coaches to take preventive ac- sive for athletes across the board through tions and adapt behaviors where needed. modern technologies.” The answer, ac- The projection that “technologies have Similarly, advanced analytics help to sim- cording to our experts, is: unlikely. They increased athletes’ safety and sportive ulate slopes and potential crashes to im- believe that the probability and impact performance,” yielded the second high- prove slopes and reduce risk. of this scenario to be relatively low (see est estimated probability, and impact and Fig. 2.2). Interestingly, they also consider highest desirability of all projections in our When it comes to performance, we have it not to be particularly desirable, which study (see Fig. 2.1). This suggests that our also seen remarkable technological im- might be counterintuitive. 7
High-tech hardware such as protheses HIGH-END DIGITAL SIMULATIONS of virtual reality, for example, to prepare could allow disabled and non-disabled ath- WILL COMPLEMENT, BUT NOT athletes for (difficult) slopes. The notion letes to compete at eye level. Modern tech- REVOLUTIONIZE, TALENT DE- of training anywhere and anytime seems nologies could also allow for competition VELOPMENT IN SKIING BY 2025 to be a desirable goal. Skiing simulations among non-disabled athletes across age could significantly increase athletes’ groups and gender. Similarly, they could maximal training hours by making train- allow amateur sportsmen to compete with The question whether “high-end digital ing independent from snow and weather elite athletes, which could have many be- simulations of ski races for profession- conditions. It would simplify training and nefits including fan engagement and wider al athletes have revolutionized talent de- reduce costs (e.g., travel) at the same access to sports. Imagine amateurs with velopment and training for elite skiing” led time. But benefits do not only arise for exoskeletons racing against elite downhill to a lot of debate among our experts (see elite athletes. Ski schools could use sim- skiers without supportive aids. Technolo- Fig. 2.3) and they did not reach consen- ulations to educate and train both first- gies could not only help to include more in- sus. Many of the experts see strong ad- time and more advanced skiers. Similarly, dividual athletes, they could also give na- vantages of ski race simulations. They ar- it could help older skiers, in particular, to tional teams access to sports that would gue that simulations might significantly maintain the physical condition they need usually be out of reach due to weather improve the quantity and quality of feed- for skiing into old age. conditions, for example. Access could be back athletes can receive about their facilitated by training in virtual environ- technical and physical skills that, in turn, It is, however, also worth mentioning that ments or by production of artificial snow. can lead to better performance and im- an opposing group of experts considers Participation of more nations in ski world proved safety (e.g., injury prevention). these simulations significantly less prob- cups would make them more inclusive and This could become particularly impor- able and desirable. They see digital ap- increase interest around the world. tant given advancements in sensor tech- plications as a potential support in some nology. For performance analysis (as well areas of training at best, arguing that as tracking over time) in general, simu- the impact for elite athletes will be mar- “FEEDBACK ON METABOLISM lations could become a key component. ginal compared to real-life training and AND TECHNIQUE WILL BE Simulations could also aid the identifica- feedback coaching. In any case, a great INCREASINGLY IMPORTANT tion and development of talent. The ex- user experience will be indispensable for perts also see great potential in the use adaption of simulations. TO MAKE SURE ATHLETES WILL BE FIT FOR THE DESIRED ACTIVITY. THIS IS TO AVOID INJURIES AND TO MAKE SURE FIG. 2.2 2025: SKI WORLD CUPS HAVE BECOME INCLUSIVE FOR ATHLETES THE BEST POSSIBLE ACROSS THE BOARD THROUGH MODERN TECHNOLOGIES PREPARATION WILL TAKE PLACE ON EVERY LEVEL Rank (ELITE TO TOURIST)” 43% PROBABILITY 9/13 2.78 However, our study results suggest that IMPACT 10/13 there could be several reasons why tech- 3.12 nology is unlikely to make ski world cups DESIRABILITY 9/13 more inclusive. Arguments include, for example, the different preconditions of disabled and non-disabled athletes, which would never allow for a fair com- petition given the lack of comparability. FIG. 2.3 Experts supporting this line of argumen- 2025: HIGH-END DIGITAL SIMULATIONS OF SKI RACES FOR tation claim that competition between PROFESSIONAL ATHLETES HAVE REVOLUTIONIZED TALENT athletes with equal preconditions is one DEVELOPMENT AND TRAINING FOR ELITE SKIING of the most important aspects of sports; the preconditions keep sports fair and in- Rank teresting for spectators. A key problem 48% PROBABILITY 8/13 for full inclusiveness in ski world cups will remain; skiing is only performed in a few 3.09 countries and is, even with the help of vir- IMPACT 7/13 tual reality technology, unlikely to achieve 3.00 a global presence. DESIRABILITY 10/13 8
RECREATIONAL SKIERS WILL HAVE A SEAMLESS EXPERIENCE IN SKI RESORTS BY 2025 – HOWEVER, SKI SPORTS ORGANIZATIONS HAVE A LONG WAY TO GO TO BECOME DIGITAL FRONTRUNNERS 3 TECHNOLOGY IS NOT ONLY KEY FIG. 3.1 FOR PROFESSIONAL ATHLETES TO 2025: MOST SKIING RESORTS HAVE BECOME CASHLESS IMPROVE THEIR PERFORMANCE, MAKING THEM MORE SECURE BUT IT IS ALSO IMPORTANT TO Rank IMPROVE THE EXPERIENCE FOR 65% PROBABILITY 4/13 RECREATIONAL SKIERS. 3.32 Today, nearly three out of four recrea- IMPACT 5/13 tional skiers are equipped with weara- 3.77 bles (ISPO, 2017). And while skiers with DESIRABILITY 5/13 action cameras are a common picture on the slopes, ski masks that integrate Wi-Fi, GPS, and Bluetooth features dis- playing skiers’ performance on the snow, using Augmented Reality, are rather new tions). While there are already ski resorts customer centricity and increase con- (Fedosov et al., 2016). The experience off where most skiers do not need cash in venience to retain existing and attract the slope is similarly subject to change their pockets, there is some skepticism new winter sports enthusiasts. Our ex- from modern technologies. Since digi- by our experts about the speed of distri- perts imagine winter vacations without tization allows for a more seamless ex- bution. Adoption rates in smaller ski re- queues as skiers are directed to empty perience in every part of our life, winter sorts might be lower and the accessibil- lifts via apps or digital signals and a con- sports fans also expect the highest de- ity of cashless technologies for elderly venient process of booking travel, rent- gree of convenience when visiting a ski resort visitors could be a hurdle. ing skis, and buying lift passes with just event or when hitting the slopes. But how a few clicks based on customer prefer- will the ski sports ecosystem evolve? Next to a cashless and more secure ski- ences. This would offer tremendous up- ing environment, experts also assessed side potential for ski resorts since such the projection that the “ski sports eco- a seamless experience would allow cus- MOST SKI RESORTS WILL system offers a seamless experience tomers to spend their time on the key ac- BECOME COMPLETELY for recreational visitors through digital tivity: skiing. CASHLESS BY 2025, technologies” by 2025. This projection OFFERING A SEAMLESS was also given high probability (62%) and While the impact of such a projection EXPERIENCE FOR VISITORS solid impact (rank 4 out of 13 projections) seems obvious, there are two main ob- ratings (see Fig. 3.2). According to our stacles to this development: First, the ski experts, ski resorts will further improve sports ecosystem is relatively fragment- The projection that “most ski resorts have become cashless making them more secure” was assessed by our ex- perts to have a stable probability of 65% (see Fig. 3.1). Isolating the responses of “I WOULD PREFER THE MOUNTAINS the technology experts within our panel, however, reveals that this group agreed TO REMAIN DIGITAL AND with 77% probability, making it the high- TECH FREE AS MUCH AS POSSIBLE est ranked projection within this sam- ple of study participants. This fact bol- TO REMAIN ITS FLAIR. BUT FROM sters confidence in the likelihood of ski A BUSINESS-PERSPECTIVE resorts to become cashless and more secure by 2025. Experts also assess the THIS IS OF HIGH DESIRABILITY” impact and desirability of this projec- tion relatively high (rank 5 of all projec- 9
“ESPECIALLY THE FOREFRONT OF RESORTS, BEING MORE COURAGEOUS AND INNOVATIVE, WILL MAKE FULL USE OF DIGITAL TICKETING AND GEO-LOCATION TRACKING FOR INCREASED EXPERIENCE. THE SAME HOLDS TRUE FOR SECURITY, PURCHASE PROCESS OF FOOD AND BEVERAGES, AS WELL AS MERCHANDISING AND TICKETING” ed, which makes a conversion towards a to close the gap to digital frontrunners is tended their lead in terms of digital capa- seamless process along the entire cus- high (see Fig. 3.3). In fact, this is the most bilities. It is not too late, but experts agree tomer journey more difficult. Second, desired projection of those unlikely to oc- that ski sports organizations must fo- many experts agree that the resorts at cur by 2025. cus on digital development and applica- the forefront will achieve the seamless tion of new technology to catch up. This experience by 2025, but many resorts will Consequently, the urgency for ski sports is not only important to ensure the rele- lag behind—taking much longer than until organizations to digitize is salient, as re- vance of skiing in the future, but also to 2025 to become digitized. flected in our experts’ discussion. Other attract young talent to work in the winter sports organizations appear to have ex- sports sector. DIGITIZATION OF SKI SPORTS ORGANIZATIONS WILL LAG BEHIND DIGITAL FRONTRUNNERS, DESPITE FIG. 3.2 A STRONG DESIRABILITY 2025: THE SKI SPORT ECOSYSTEM OFFERS A SEAMLESS EXPERIENCE TO CATCH UP FOR RECREATIONAL VISITORS THROUGH DIGITAL TECHNOLOGIES Rank Regarding the projection that “ski sports 62% PROBABILITY 5/13 organizations have become digital front- runners compared to other sports or- 3.42 ganizations” by 2025, there is skepti- IMPACT 4/13 cism that this projection will become 3.52 reality. At the same time, the desirability DESIRABILITY 8/13 “FOR ME THERE FIG. 3.3 2025: SKI SPORTS ORGANIZATIONS HAVE BECOME DIGITAL IS NO DOUBT FRONTRUNNERS COMPARED TO OTHER SPORTS ORGANIZATIONS THAT THE SKIING RESORTS WILL 39% Rank PROBABILITY 10/13 HAVE BECOME 3.00 CASHLESS IN 2025” IMPACT 8/13 3.75 DESIRABILITY 6/13 10
DESPITE GREAT DESIRE, IT WILL BE A ROCKY ROAD TO ACHIEVE GENDER PARITY IN SKI SPORTS BY 2025 – BOTH ON AND OFF THE SLOPE 4 GENDER INEQUALITY HAS BEEN sponsoring income; and this will contin- “50% OF SKIER AMONG THE IMPORTANT SOCIAL ue to hold true in the future. They argue ISSUES FOR DECADES. IN 2017, MORE that “the interest on male skiing races” CONSUMERS ARE THAN 70% OF THE GLOBAL POPU- and “the money you can earn on the male FEMALE AND WE LATION BELIEVED THAT THERE WAS sport” will remain higher than for female SEE IN THE INDUSTRY STILL INEQUALITY BETWEEN WOMEN races. On the other hand, there will al- AND MEN IN TERMS OF SOCIAL, ways be top female athletes who earn ALREADY TODAY POLITICAL OR ECONOMIC RIGHTS more money than most male competitors. A SIGNIFICANT (STATISTA, 2017). Some experts argue that “public pres- INCREASE OF FEMALE sure” and rejuvenation in ski sports organ- This inequality is also reflected in winter izations could help to reduce this gap. MANAGEMENT sports, though there has been progress. POSITIONS” At 43%, the 2018 Winter Olympics in Next to endorsement deals, there are also Pyeongchang had the highest female special events exclusive to men such as share in history, but there were still disci- the Hahnenkamm race that account for probability, impact, and desirability, sug- plines that remained men’s only, such as a difference in payment. Experts of our gesting that experts neither see a need, Nordic combined (The Guardian, 2018). A Delphi study do not believe that “women nor a wish for women to compete in this similar picture emerges in professional racing will have been brought back to skiing event (see Figure 4.2). Interesting- alpine ski sports. For races where men the Hahnenkamm” by 2025. This projec- ly, female participants have even less ap- and women participate, prize money is tion yielded the second lowest estimated petite for this projection, rating it lowest equal. However, over the course of a sea- son the amount of prize money for men is still higher, largely because women do not participate in some of the most pres- tigious and rewarded races. For example, FIG. 4.1 women do not participate in the Hahnen- 2025: THE WAGE GAP BETWEEN PROFESSIONAL MALE kamm race in Kitzbühel, where in 2019 the AND FEMALE SKIING ATHLETES HAS BEEN CLOSED “prize money was almost twice as high […] as at comparable events in the alpine ski- Rank ing World Cup” (FIS, 2019). The question 55% PROBABILITY 6/13 is: How will gender parity evolve? 3.00 IMPACT 8/13 ON THE SLOPE, WAGE GAPS 3.66 BETWEEN MALE AND FEMALE DESIRABILITY 7/13 ATHLETES COULD BECOME SMALLER, BUT SPONSORSHIPS AND SPECIAL EVENTS WILL STILL MAKE A DIFFERENCE FIG. 4.2 2025: WOMEN RACING HAS BEEN BROUGHT With a probability of 55%, experts in our BACK TO THE HAHNENKAMM study do not reveal confidence in the as- sumption that “the wage gap between Rank professional male and female skiing ath- 31% PROBABILITY 12/13 letes has been closed” by 2025 (see Fig- ure 4.1). Most experts stated that, already 2.33 today, prize money is the same for events IMPACT 12/13 where male and female athletes partici- 2.51 pate. The difference comes instead from DESIRABILITY 12/13 11
in terms of probability, impact, and desir- FIG. 4.3 ability. However, this topic still appears to 2025: SKI SPORTS ORGANIZATIONS HAVE ENTERED A PROMISING WAY polarize, since the experts surveyed did TO ACHIEVE GENDER PARITY IN MANAGEMENT POSITIONS not reach consensus on this projection. Rank Key arguments by experts include both 53% PROBABILITY 7/13 sportive and economic reasoning. While the danger for athletes could be minimized 3.18 by future technology, some experts simply IMPACT 6/13 believe that “the Streif as a stand-alone 3.89 event for men is a value” and that any DESIRABILITY 4/13 changes would take away some of its DNA. Nevertheless, there are some experts who see a trend towards less segmentation in male and female competition and the po- tential to have a female slalom race in Kitz- Regarding the probability of occurrence, not evident that ski sports organizations bühel. However, it seems clear from the there are two main obstacles according will have reached gender parity by 2025, expert perspective, that there will be no to our Delphi experts. First, there is “not the high desirability might help to over- women downhill race at the “male bastion” enough interest by women” and there “are come obstacles and make positive steps Hahnenkamm by 2025. not many women, who want to engage towards gender parity off the slope. themselves in the organizations.” Second, some experts argue, that there is a cultur- GENDER PARITY IN MANAGE- al shift required to achieve gender parity in Leana Dobler during the MENT POSITIONS IN SKI management positions as some “ski sport Giant slalom of Longines Future SPORTS ORGANIZATIONS IS organizations, especially small and lo- Hahnenkamm Champions STRONGLY DESIRED cal ones, are still very traditional” and the at the Streif. “governance [is] old-fashioned.” While it is ▼ The projection that “ski sports organi- zations have entered a promising way to achieve gender parity in management positions” by 2025, revealed a large dis- crepancy between reality and wishful thinking. While experts rated the desir- “SKI SPORT ORGANIZATIONS, ESPECIALLY SMALL AND LOCAL ONES, ARE STILL VERY TRADITIONAL AND NEED FURTHER CULTURAL DEVELOPMENT” ability as high (rank 4 of all projections), the probability of occurrence was only as- sessed at 53%, rank 7 (see Figure 4.3). This picture holds true for all group of ex- perts, and is even more distinct amongst female study participants, who rank the desirability of this projection second, but their confidence in its probability is low at only 56%, rank 9 within this group. 12
GAMING IN SKI SPORTS WILL NOT PLAY A VITAL ROLE BY 2025 – NEITHER IN ATTRACTING THE MAJORITY OF PEOPLE TO PLAY, NOR IN MOTIVATING YOUNG GENERATIONS TO SKI 5 IN TODAY’S OMNIPRESENT DISCUS- SION OF DIGITIZATION THERE IS ONE PHENOMENON NOT TO BE MISSED: “I DON’T BELIEVE THAT ESPORTS. EVERYONE TALKS ABOUT IT NOWADAYS, AND EVEN IF WE GAMING WILL BE A RELEVANT ARE NOT INTERESTED IN ESPORTS, WE ARE SOMEHOW ATTACHED TO ACCESS THAT BRINGS DIGITAL GAMING. PEOPLE INTO THE SNOW” According to latest estimates, there are 2.5 billion video gamers on the globe (Statista, 2019a); this number takes into account regular and casual gamers – gaming. While there are only a few hun- gaming have become an integral part of even those who just play on their smart- dred professionals who can make a living our society and social life. But how does phones every now and then. However, from playing videogames, the global au- this relate to ski sports? it is important to differentiate between dience for eSports has already exceeded gaming and eSports. In contrast to gam- 450 million people (Newzoo, 2019). These First of all, digital sports simulations are ing, eSports only comprises competitive numbers show that both eSports and typically not amongst the most popular eSports titles globally. Playing compet- itively in digital tournaments is some- thing that is established in football with the simulation game FIFA or Pro Evolu- FIG. 5.1 tion Soccer. However, there are far more 2025: MORE PEOPLE PLAY DIGITAL SKI RACING SIMULATIONS popular games like League of Legends, THAN ACTIVELY PARTICIPATE IN SKIING Dota 2, or Counterstrike (Nielsen, 2019). As of now, digital ski sports simulations Rank are focusing rather on casual gaming 23% than eSports. PROBABILITY 13/13 2.16 IMPACT 13/13 THE OUTDOOR SKIING 2.00 ADVENTURE WILL NOT DESIRABILITY 13/13 BE SUBSTITUTED BY VIDEO GAMING BY 2025 Although gaming is a popular leisure ac- FIG. 5.2 tivity, experts do not expect the num- 2025: DIGITAL SKI RACING SIMULATIONS HAVE INCREASED THE ber of ski sports gamers to exceed the ATTRACTIVENESS OF WINTER SPORTS IN YOUNG TARGET GROUPS number of actual skiers worldwide (see Fig. 5.1). This perception is consistently shared across experts of all age groups. Rank 35% Given that there are already more than PROBABILITY 11/13 110 million skiers in the 15 largest skiing 2.46 nations and more than 150 million winter IMPACT 11/13 sports enthusiasts around the globe, this 2.58 assessment sounds reasonable (Sta- DESIRABILITY 11/13 tista, 2019b). There is not only consen- 13
▲ Children during the starting numbers draw for the Men’s super-G “THE ACTIVE PART IN THE of FIS Ski Alpine World Cup at the Streif in Kitzbühel. NATURE IS THE MOST IMPORTANT EXPERIENCE sus in terms of probability of occurrence, FOR SKIING” but also in terms of desirability. Experts largely agreed that they would not like to see “more people play digital ski racing simulations than actively participating in skiing.” Hence, experts expect skiing to the assumption that “digital ski racing perts. Digital ski racing simulations might remain an outdoor activity in the future simulations have increased the attrac- not have a stunning effect on the future and will not be substituted by a digital ex- tiveness of winter sports in young tar- of skiing, but there are still advocates for perience. get groups” by 2025 was also assessed more ski gaming offerings amongst the with a probability of only 35% by the ex- experts surveyed. perts of this study (see Fig. 5.2). Even ACCORDING TO EXPERTS, though it is a slightly more desirable to GAMING WILL NOT reach the next generation of skiers with BRING YOUNG PEOPLE digital simulations, the overall impact of INTO THE SNOW gaming was rated low (see Fig. 5.2). Ex- perts still see parents as the main factor to motivate young people to ski. However, While skiing might not be substituted dig- the opportunity of reaching a broader au- itally, our experts can imagine real skiing dience, e.g., Chinese skiers, with mobile to be complimented by video gaming. But games was also appreciated by some ex- 14
STUDY DESIGN AND METHODOLOGY THE PRESENT STUDY WAS CONDUC- FIG. 6.1 TED ON BEHALF OF MASTERCARD DELPHI-STUDY SHOULD TACKLE THREE MAJOR TOPIC AREAS AND IS BASED ON THE DELPHI FOR PROJECTIONS IN 2025 METHOD THAT WAS INVENTED BY THE U.S. RAND CORPORATION. THE DELPHI TECHNIQUE IS A SCIENTIF- A TECHNOLOGY & DIGITALIZATION B SPORTS & CLIMATE C INCLUSIVENESS IN SKI SPORTS ICALLY ESTABLISHED RESEARCH METHOD THAT SOLICITS OPINIONS 1 The ski sport ecosystem offers 7 Technologies have 10 Ski world cups have a seamless experience for increased athletes’ become inclusive FROM A PANEL OF EXPERTS IN AN recreational visitors through safety and sportive for athletes across digital technologies Fig. 3.2 performance Fig. 2.1 the board through ITERATIVE SURVEY PROCESS. modern technologies 2 Ski sports organizations have 8 Sustainability has Fig. 2.2 become digital frontrunners become a critical As part of the method, selected experts compared to other sports prerequisite for 11 Women racing has evaluate preformulated future theses, organizations Fig. 3.3 stakeholders in the been brought back winter sports eco- to the Hahnenkamm so-called projections, according to their systems to be Fig. 4.2 3 Most skiing resorts have be- probability of “occurrence” (in percent), come cashless making them successful Fig. 1.1 as well as their “impact” and their “de- more secure Fig. 3.1 12 The wage gap bet- 9 Technologies have ween professional sirability” on a Likert scale from 1 (very 4 More people play digital ski helped to maintain male and female low) to 5 (very high). The experts support racing simulations than good skiing condi- skiing athletes has actively participate in skiing tions in a climate- been closed Fig. 4.1 their quantitative evaluations with option- Fig. 5.1 friendly way Fig. 1.2 al comments and arguments. Upon com- 13 Ski sports organiz- 5 Digital ski racing simulations ations have entered pletion of their own evaluation, experts have increased the attractive- a promising way to get access to the evaluations of the entire ness of winter sports in young achieve gender parity target groups Fig. 5.2 in management panel. Moreover, they are provided with positions Fig. 4.3 summary statistics such as the median 6 High-end digital simulations of ski races for professional or the level of consensus/agreement by athletes have revolutionized projection. Experts may choose to main- talent development and trai- ning for elite skiing Fig. 2.3 tain or modify their evaluations in subse- quent iterations (von der Gracht, 2012). This study used a so-called “Real-time Delphi,” which is an advanced form of the Delphi technique where experts can im- mediately compare their responses to step 1, the future projections were formu- FORMULATION OF those of other participants and change lated. In step 2, the actual Delphi survey FUTURE PROJECTIONS their opinion as often as they like. This was conducted. In step 3, the survey re- scientifically valid procedure reduces sults were aggregated and analyzed by the dropout rate (Gnatzy et al., 2011). The means of descriptive statistics and cod- The relevant literature (e.g., Gausemeier present Delphi study was conducted in ing of the qualitative arguments to derive et al., 1996) recommends the derivation of three steps as depicted by Figure 6.2. In scenarios. Delphi projections from several sources. FIG. 6.2 PROCESS OF THE DELPHI STUDY (BASED ON VON DER GRACHT & DARKOW, 2010) FORMULATION OF REAL-TIME EXECUTION OF DEVELOPMENT OF DELPHI PROJECTIONS DELPHI SURVEY FUTURE SCENARIOS DESK EXPERT DELOPMENT OF REVIEW AND ANALYSIS SCENARIO PLAUSIBILITY RESEARCH INPUT PROJECTIONS PRETESTING OF RESULTS FORMULATION CHECKS 15
Our process for this study was as follows: ing of Delphi panels is recommended be- mulation process. Only six projections dis- Future drivers of ski sports were identi- cause different views from different ex- play a coefficient of variance of more than fied through input from experts and via pert groups enhance the validity of Delphi 0.5, which denotes consensus according desk research of largely internet-based studies (Yaniv, 2011). Next, we identified to the relevant literature (von der Gracht & sources. To structure the insights, all driv- potential experts for each category. The Darkow, 2010). As intended, the balance of ers were assigned to one of the three resultant list of 248 candidates was short- our expert panel apparently triggered con- overarching themes: (i) technology and ened to 162 experts based on several cri- troversial discussion. digitization, (ii) sports and climate, and teria (e.g. years of experience, age, mix (iii) inclusiveness in ski sports. For every of backgrounds). The 162 candidates re- theme, 3-6 projections were formulated ceived a written invitation including a per- that best condensed the respective driv- sonalized link to our online Delphi portal. ers. This process ensured a broad spec- Finally, 46 experts from 41 organizations FIG. 6.4 trum of projections and concentration on (see Fig. 6.4) participated in our Delphi DEMOGRAPHICS OVERVIEW N=46 key developments to minimize participant survey. This equals a remarkable partici- dropout rates (Nowack et al., 2011; Hung et pation rate of 28.4%. Thus, the panel size COUNTRY OF ORIGIN al., 2008). The time horizon of the study, was in line with comparable Delphi studies OF EXPERTS by 2025, was based on relevant compa- (Merkel et al., 2016). rable Delphi studies that allow a foresee- able time period (von der Gracht & Darkow, ANDORRA AUSTRIA DENMARK 2010). A five-year projection is not seen as EXECUTION OF THE SURVEY ‘looking too far into the future’, which fos- AND ANALYSIS OF RESULTS ters expert discussion on changes that FRANCE GERMANY GREECE seem realistic in the near to mid-term. The Delphi survey was conducted over a three-week period and was administered ITALY SWEDEN SWITZERLAND SELECTION via the internet using “Surveylet” by Cal- OF EXPERTS ibrum (http://calibrum.com/), an online UNITED USA survey tool specifically designed to facili- KINGDOM tate the Delphi research method. We ana- By definition, Delphi panels are not sta- lyzed the 1,794 quantitative evaluations tistically representative; therefore, an im- provided by our 46 experts for 13 projec- AGE proper expert selection is one of the most tions on three dimensions. The projections 7 serious validity threats to Delphi studies were then clustered into five scenarios 25-34 (Creswell, 2003). In our study, the expert based on their content-related proximity. 11 selection was conducted in a multi-stage Additionally, 429 written arguments were 35-44 process similar to Okoli and Pawlowski analyzed. While the future projections have 15 45-54 (2004). First, categories were defined to a mean probability of occurrence between ensure a balance between the expert 23% and 77%, the impact of 10 of the 13 12 55-64 groups: (i) sports (tech) executives, (ii) ath- projections is rated as medium or high (i.e., letes and ski sports officials, (iii) media at least a score of 2.5 on a 5-point Likert 1 >64 representatives and academics, and (iv) scale). This underscores their relevance resort managers (see Fig. 6.3). Balanc- and confirms the accuracy of the prefor- GENDER 40 MALE FIG. 6.3 6 WITH 46 EXPERTS THE DELPHI-STUDY HAS A SOLID OPINION BASE – FEMALE ORIGIN, AGE AND BACKGROUND ARE WELL DISTRIBUTED – GENDER WITH HIGH PROPORTION OF MEN, REPRESENTING INDUSTRY AVERAGE BACKGROUND SPORTS (TECH) 16 EXECUTIVES ATHLETES AND SKI SPORTS 13 OFFICIALS MEDIA REPRE- SENTATIVES 10 AND ACADEMICS RESORT 7 MANAGERS 16
REFERENCES Balmer, N. / Pleasence, P. Foster, L. / James, D. Merkel, S. / Schmidt, S. L., & Nevill, A. (2011) & Haake, S. (2012) & Schreyer, D. (2016) Evolution and revolution: gauging the Influence of full body swimsuits on The future of professional football: impact of technological and technical competitive performance. A Delphi-based perspective of German innovation on Olympic performance. Procedia Engineering, 34, 712–717 experts on probable versus surprising Journal of Sports Sciences, 30, scenarios. 1075–1083 Gausemeier, J. / Fink, A. Sport, Business and Management: & Schlake, O. (1996) An International Journal, 6(3), 295-319 Creswell, J. W. (2003) Szenario-Management – Planen und Research Design: Qualitative, Führen mit Szenarien (2. Ed.). Newzoo (2019) quantitative, and mixed method München: Carl Hauser Verlag 2018-2020 Global eSports audience, approaches (2. Ed.). accessed via URL Thousand Oaks: Sage Publications Gnatzy, T. / Warth, J. / von der Gracht, https://newzoo.com/key-numbers/ H. A. & Darkow, I. L. (2011) on 03.01.2020, 10.23am Dalkey, N. & Helmer, O. (1963) Validating an innovative real-time An experimental application of the Delphi approach – A methodological Nielsen (2019) Delphi method to the use of experts. comparison between real-time and eSports playbook for brands 2019, Management Science, 9, 458-467 conventional Delphi studies. accessed via URL Technological Forecasting and https://nielsensports.com/de/ de Koning, J. J. (2010) Social Change, 78, 1681-1694 esports-playbook-for-brands-2019/ World records: how much athlete? on 03.01.2020, 09.52am how much technology. Haake, S. (2009) International Journal of Sports The impact of technology on sporting Nowack, M. / Endrikat, J. Physiology and Performance, 5, performance in Olympic sports. & Guenther, E. (2011) 262–267 Journal of Sports Sciences, 27, 1 Review of Delphi-based 421–1431 scenario studies: quality and Dyer, B. (2015) design considerations. The progression of male Häder, M. (2009) Technological Forecasting and 100 m sprinting with a lower-Limb 2800 Jahre Delphi: Social Change, 78, 1603-1615 amputation 1976–2012. Ein historischer Überblick. Sports, 3, 30–39 Wiesbaden: VS Verlag Okoli, C. & Pawlowski, S. D. (2004) für Sozialwissenschaften The Delphi method as a research tool: Fedosov, A. / Elhart, I. / Niforatos, E. / an example, design considerations and North, A. & Langheinrich, L. (2016) Hung, H. L. / Altschuld, J. W. applications. SkiAR: Wearable Augmented Reality & Lee, Y. F. (2008) Information & Management, 42, 15-29 system for sharing personalized content Methodological and conceptual on ski resort maps. issues confronting a cross-country Schmidt, S. L. / Beiderbeck, D. Proceedings of the 7th Augmented Delphi study of educational program & Frevel, N. (2019) Human International Conference 2016, evaluation. SPOAC Sportbusiness-Studie 2019. 46, 1-2 Evaluation and Program Planning, 31, SPONSORs Verlag, Hamburg 191-198 Fédération International Schmidt, S. L. & Eberhard, K. (2016) de Ski (2019) ISPO (2017) SPOAC Sportbusiness-Studie 2016. Kitzbühel awards a record prize money, These are the digital trends SPONSORs Verlag, Hamburg accessed via URL in winter sports, https://www.fis-ski.com/en/alpine- accessed via URL Statista (2017) skiing/alpine-news-multimedia/ https://www.ispo.com/en/trends/ Global gender disparity in social, news-multimedia/news/test2/ digital-trends-winter-sports-data-maps- political and economic rights 2017, kitzbuhel-awards-a-record-prize- goggles on 08.01.2020, 10.04am quoted based on statista.com, money on 29.12.2019, 05.44pm https://www.statista.com.login.bibproxy. 17
whu.edu/statistics/312310/believe- wintersportlern-nach-laendern-in- Scenarios for the logistics services currently-inequality-between-men- absoluten-zahlen/, industry: A Delphi-based analysis women-in-social-politcal-and-or- accessed on 02.01.2020, 10.14am for 2025. economic-rights/, International Journal of Production accessed on 08.01.2020, 10.05 pm The Guardian (2018) Economics, 127, 46-59 Winter Olympics: women’s Statista (2019a) long race to parity, Yaniv, I. (2011) Newzoo, Number of active video accessed via URL Group diversity and decision quality: gamers worldwide from 2014 to 2021, https://www.theguardian.com/sport/ amplification and attenuation of the quoted based on statista.com, URL ng-interactive/2018/feb/08/winter- framing effect. https://www.statista.com.login. olympics-womens-long-race-to-parity International Journal of bibproxy.whu.edu/statistics/748044/ on 29.12.2019, 05.29pm Forecasting, 27, 41-49 number-video-gamers-world/, accessed on 02.01.2020, 09.31am Von der Gracht, H. A. (2012) Images Consensus measurement in Delphi Cover @ Mastercard Statista (2019b) studies: Review and implications for Page 4 @ Mastercard Vanat, L., 2019 International report future quality assurance: Pages 12, 14, 18 @ Imago on snow & mountain tourism, Technological Forecasting and quoted based on statista.com, URL Social Change, 79, 1525-1536 Design & Layout https://de.statista.com.login.bibproxy. Sebastian Struch whu.edu/statistik/daten/studie/ Von der Gracht, H. A. www.sebastianstruch.de 247654/umfrage/die-herkunft-von- & Darkow, I. L. (2010) mail@sebastianstruch.de 18
ABOUT THE AUTHORS PROF. DR. SASCHA L. SCHMIDT Sascha L. Schmidt is a professor, chair versity in Boston/USA. The “Future of holder and director of the Center for Sports” is one of Sascha’s key research Sports and Management (CSM) at WHU - areas. Prior to his academic career, he Otto Beisheim School of Management in worked as a strategy consultant for Mc- Dusseldorf/Germany. At the same time Kinsey & Company and he has been an he is the academic director of “SPOAC - entrepreneur. Sports Business Academy by WHU” and affiliate professor at the Laboratory for @ProfSLS Innovation Science (LISH) at Harvard Uni- sascha.schmidt@whu.edu DANIEL BEIDERBECK Daniel Beiderbeck is a PhD student at doctorate, he worked for two years as a the Center for Sports and Management strategy consultant at McKinsey & Com- (CSM)at WHU - Otto Beisheim School of pany, where he supported numerous dig- Management and Program Manager at ital transformation projects in various in- the SPOAC. Daniel‘s research focuses on dustries. Delphi studies to investigate future sce- narios for football and eSport. Prior to his daniel.beiderbeck@whu.edu NICOLAS FREVEL Nicolas Frevel is a PhD student at the analyses. His focus is on technologies in Center for Sports and Management (CSM) sport. Before his doctorate, he worked as at WHU - Otto Beisheim School of Man- a consultant at McKinsey & Company in agement. He conducts research on top- various industries and functions. ics in the field of „The Future of Sports“ with the help of Delphi-based scenario nicolas.frevel@whu.edu HARRY KRÜGER Harry Krüger is a doctoral student at the ant for McKinsey & Company in various Center for Sports and Management (CSM) industries though his projects largely fo- at WHU - Otto Beisheim School of Man- cused on digitization, automation, and agement. As part of his research, Harry machine learning. does research on the sports consump- tions behavior of young generations. Be- fore his doctorate, he worked as a consult- harry.krueger@whu.edu 19
WHU – Otto Beisheim School of Management Center for Sports and Management (CSM) Erkrather Straße 224a D - 40233 Düsseldorf T: + 49 211 4470974-1 csm@whu.edu www.csm.whu.edu
You can also read