The Evolving World of Bitcoin - Julia C. Wirts, CFA Managing Director, Portfolio Manager - Fiduciary Trust International

Page created by Cheryl Powers
 
CONTINUE READING
The Evolving World of Bitcoin - Julia C. Wirts, CFA Managing Director, Portfolio Manager - Fiduciary Trust International
February 2021

                The Evolving World of Bitcoin
                                          Julia C. Wirts, CFA
                            Managing Director, Portfolio Manager
Bitcoin has staged an extraordinary resurgence in recent months, crossing $40,000 for the first
       time ever in early January 2021. Today’s buyers, which includes prominent US corporations and
       high-net-worth investors, have turned to Bitcoin as a hedge to inflation and return enhancer in
       response to unprecedented central bank stimulus during the pandemic and historically low interest
       rates. Also driving the rally over the past year has been a stronger appetite for risk assets following
       progress on COVID-19 vaccines and the removal of election uncertainty. Expectations that Bitcoin
       might gain broader acceptance as a digital currency due to its adoption on widely used payment
       apps has intensified demand as well. Finally, government agencies and the private sector have
       taken steps to establish firmer guidelines around the treatment of cryptocurrencies, leading to
       greater interest from hedge funds, endowments and other institutional investors.

       Nonetheless, it appears that Bitcoin is still in the early stages of development and public oversight
       remains spotty, making comprehensive data on the sector difficult to come by to help determine
       Bitcoin’s potential value to investors. Further, Bitcoin’s price volatility and regulatory uncertainty
       could lessen its future appeal to more mainstream businesses and investors.

         FIGURE 1            BITCOIN’S PRICE SINCE 2016

                               $40,000

                                $35,000

                               $30,000

                               $25,000

                               $20,000

                                $15,000

                                $10,000

                                 $5,000

                                     $0
                                           2016             2017    2018   2019      2020

                               Source: Bloomberg, as of 1/7/2021.

         1
             Source: Bloomberg, as of 1/2/2021.

1   THE EVOLVING WORLD OF BITCOIN            fiduciarytrust.com
The Mechanics of Bitcoin
    It is believed that Bitcoin was first conceived in the aftermath of the 2008 Great Financial Crisis (GFC) as an
    alternative medium of exchange and store of value. Cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin can be transferred directly from
    one owner to another through a financial ledger called “blockchain.” This ledger is maintained by a global network
    of individuals and entities that expend incredible amounts of computer energy to verify transactions and are
    “rewarded” with virtual currency, an activity otherwise known as “mining.” Bitcoin is referred to as a cryptocurrency
    because sophisticated encryption techniques are used to regulate the creation of new units and make online
    transactions safe and secure. Further, the blockchain does not rely on traditional intermediaries such as banks
    or brokerage firms. The goal is to provide a peer-to-peer medium of exchange that allows buyers and sellers to
    remain anonymous. It is decentralized, “incorruptible” and transparent. Every transaction is shared with the entire
    network of Bitcoin users, allowing participants to maintain a running total of each transaction so that the same unit
    of currency is never used more than once.

    Proponents of Bitcoin think this ability to easily transfer value from person to person globally will ultimately lead to
    an increase in its usage. Alternatively, ambiguity around regulation could discourage businesses from accepting
    digital currencies. No law requires companies or individuals to accept Bitcoin as a form of payment. Instead, its
    use is limited to businesses and individuals that are willing to accept Bitcoins.

    Unlike traditional currencies, Bitcoin is not issued or regulated by a governmental agency. Rather, it is created by
    a computer program and traded on the web through online exchanges such as Coinbase, which typically hold it
    for buyers in a “virtual wallet.”2 Users are not required to provide a social security number, but instead are identified
    by a web address linking them to transactions.

    The open and deregulated nature of the system initially raised concerns that Bitcoin might be used to fund illicit
    activities like terrorism or drug trafficking. One of the best-known examples was the so-called Silk Road market,
    a section of the “dark web” where drugs were sold until it was shut down by the FBI in October 2013. In fact,
    according to a recent report, in 2020, the criminal share of all cryptocurrency activity was only 0.34%, a drop
    from 2019’s 2.1%.3 Most US sanctioned Bitcoin platforms now require photo identification and other personal
    information to authenticate users, making it harder for illegal activity to occur.4

    A Store of Value
    The founders of Bitcoin set a limit on the number of coins (21 million) that could be mined, and there are
    currently 18.5 million in circulation worldwide. This capped supply is one of Bitcoin’s most well-known features
    and was intended to act as a hedge against inflation caused by central banks printing excessive amounts of
    money. Bitcoin was also devised to be harder to mine as the blockchain neared its maximum circulation level.
    For example, in May 2020, the total coins awarded to miners was cut in half, and it’s expected to take 120 years
    to obtain the remaining 2.5 million coins. While the perceived scarcity of an asset doesn’t automatically award
    value to it, the idea that there will be fewer opportunities to mine or earn it has been cited as a reason demand
    has returned this year.5

    Bolstering its reputation as a store of value have been recent endorsements from US companies, high-profile
    investors and hedge funds. Some market pundits have suggested that the cryptocurrency could take the place

    2
         ypically take the form of a thumb drive, computer software or cellphone, hold the private keys necessary to access the blockchain and buy, sell and
        T
        trade bitcoin with others.
    3
         ource: Chainalysis, “ 2021 Crypto Crime Report”, 1/19/2021. (https://blog.chainalysis.com/reports/2021-crypto-crime-report-intro-ransomware-
        S
        scams-darknet-markets)
    4
        Source: Bloomberg, “FBI Snags Silk Road Boss With Own Methods” Greg Farrell, 10/04/2013.
    5
        Source: CoinDesk, “Bitcoin Halving, Explained” Alyssa Hertig, 12/17/2020.

2   THE EVOLVING WORLD OF BITCOIN               fiduciarytrust.com
of gold due to its greater functionality, such as limited supply, and that it may become a global market asset.6 As
    one example of its potential growing transactional use, the widely used mobile payment company Square, Inc.
    bought $50 million in Bitcoin during the third quarter of 2020.7 Also, as of December 31, 2020, publicly traded
    firms held a combined $30 billion in Bitcoin as part of their reserve assets.8

    While Bitcoin has rallied alongside gold, silver and other assets understood to be hedges to inflation, its unpredictable
    nature and history of sharp drawdowns have raised doubts about its suitability as a digital currency or store of
    value. To start, Bitcoin has only been around for about 12 years and has no record as a wide-scale asset class.
    Unlike traditional fiat currencies, the price of a Bitcoin is determined by the supply and demand on the exchanges
    where it trades rather than such factors as central bank monetary policy, inflation or foreign currency exchange
    rates. In the US for example, the dollar is backed by the full faith and credit of the government, offering additional
    support for the investment.

    Due to its fixed supply, the Bitcoin market remains relatively small, which has contributed to its dramatic swings in
    price. Bitcoin has acted more like a speculative risk asset the past year, moving higher on positive investor sentiment
    and its perceived scarcity value rather than on conventional financial metrics like earnings strength or attractive
    price multiples. While not available today, an ETF has the potential to provide a new, almost unlimited stream
    of capital to fuel demand for Bitcoin. Given its inelastic supply, this raises the risk of another market bubble and
    elevated price volatility.

    Lastly, inflation may simply fail to take off irrespective of central bank actions, diminishing Bitcoin’s proposed merit
    as a store of value. Important to note, Bitcoin has shown little correlation with gold (a traditional bulwark against
    inflation) in recent months and has outperformed other hedges.9

    FIGURE 2             BITCOIN PERFORMANCE VERSUS INFLATION HEDGE ASSETS

                             600
                                                      Bitcoin to US dollar
                                                      Gold
                             500                      Silver
                                                      Bloomberg Bardays US Enhanced nflation Index
                                                      Commodity Channel Index
                             400

                             300

                             200

                              100

                                0
                                    1/20   2/20    3/20    4/20     5/20    6/20     7/20      8/20   9/20   10/20   11/20   12/20   1/21

                         Source: Bloomberg. Price performance as of 1/7/2021. Indexed to 100 as of 1/1/2020.

    6
        Source: CNN, “Bitcoin soars again after BlackRock says it could replace gold” Paul R. La Monica, 11/20/2020.
    7
        Source: Square press release, "Square, Inc, Invests $50 Million in Bitcoin”, 10/8/2020.
    8
        Source: TokenPost, “$30B in Bitcoin (BTC) being held as a reserve asset by 29 companies” 12/30/2020.
    9
        Source: JP. Morgan, “Flows & Liquidity. Bitcoin’s Competition with Gold.” N. Panigirtzoglou, M. Inkinen, N. Poddar, CFA, 10/23/2020.

3   THE EVOLVING WORLD OF BITCOIN                 fiduciarytrust.com
FIGURE 3             BITCOIN CORRELATION WITH OTHER ASSETS

                         Bitcoin 90-day Correlation Ending 1/15/2021

                            $45000                                                                                                           0.6%
                                              Bitcoin Price (LHS)    Gold (RHS)
                                              S&P 500 (RHS)          Dollar (RHS)
                            $40000
                                                                                                                                             0.4%
                            $35000

                            $30000                                                                                                           0.2%

                            $25000
                                                                                                                                             0%
                            $20000

                             $15000                                                                                                          -0.2%

                            $10000
                                                                                                                                             -0.4%
                             $5000

                                 $0                                                                                                          -0.6%

                                      7/19 8/19 9/19 10/19 11/19 12/19 1/20 2/20 3/20 4/20 5/20 6/20 7/20 8/20 9/20 10/20 11/20 12/20 1/21

                        Source: Bloomberg, as of 1/15/2021.

    Validation by Institutional Investors
    Companies active in the crypto industry argue that Bitcoin has matured since its last run, pointing to a tighter
    regulatory environment and new interest from mainstream investors. The Bitcoin market in 2017 was driven by
    trading on exchanges in east Asia,10 as well as initial coin offerings, startups that created and sold their own digital
    currencies as a funding source for their business ventures. This activity raised over $4 billion before the Security
    Exchange Commission (SEC) cracked down in 2018, finding that most of the proceeds were used to buy more
    Bitcoin instead of invested in growing the business.11

    Today, Bitcoin has been boosted in part by large institutional investors, attracted by the predictability and safety
    that a more regulated venue offers. For example, those holding at least 1,000 Bitcoins in their wallets collectively
    bought half a million coins worth roughly $11.5 billion from September through the end of December 2020.12
    According to Bloomberg, Yale University, which controls one of the biggest college endowments in the US,
    has started to buy cryptocurrency,13 while a major life insurance company bought $100 million in Bitcoins last
    December.14 It is clear from developments like this that adoption is spreading from family offices and corporate
    accounts to institutions. This distinction is important as organizations like foundations, endowments and
    pension funds are typically run by boards and teams of lawyers that carefully review each new investment.
    Such a vetting process may bolster the case for Bitcoin.15

    10
         Source: Reuters, “How American investors are gobbling up booming bitcoin”, Tom Wilson, Alun John 12/3/2020.
    11
         Source: The Security and Exchange, “SEC Halts Fraudulent Scheme Involving Unregistered ICO” 04/02/2018.
    12
         Source: The Wall Street Journal, “Bitcoin’s Rally Has Already Outlasted 2017’s Epic Run” Paul Vigna, 12/24/2020.
    13
         Source: Bloomberg, “Harvard and Yale Endowments Among Those Reportedly Buying Crypto”, Joanna Ossinger, 1/25/2021
    14
         Source: MassMutual Press Release, “Institutional Bitcoin provider NYDIG announces minority stake purchase by MassMutual” 12/10/2020.
    15
         Source: Bloomberg, “JPMorgan Says MassMutual’s Bitcoin Foray Signals Widening Demand” Joanna Ossinger, 12/14/2020.

4   THE EVOLVING WORLD OF BITCOIN              fiduciarytrust.com
Enhanced Regulatory Oversight
    US policy makers and regulators have sought to make the industry safer and more accessible for investors by
    holding it to the same standards associated with traditional asset classes. For instance, the Internal Revenue Service
    officially declared cryptocurrency a “property” in 2017, with any realized gains taxed like a stock.16 Popular crypto
    exchanges like Gemini and Coinbase have agreed to be governed by the New York State Department of Financial
    Services, which requires users to provide identifying information. In 2020, the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency
    (OCC) granted approval for all OCC-regulated banks to hold cryptocurrencies on behalf of their customers. Financial
    advisors now have access to a growing roster of regulated exchanges and custodians when buying, selling and
    holding Bitcoin for clients. Most recently, the US Department of the Treasury unveiled a plan to curb the anonymous
    transfer of assets by criminals via unregulated wallets. The proposal would require banks and exchanges to keep
    records of customer transactions exceeding $3,000 and the identities of all parties involved. Finally, Coinbase
    announced that it had filed for an IPO with the SEC in December, moving the crypto exchange further into the
    mainstream, with all the rules and regulations that come with it.17

    Enduring Price Volatility
    Despite Bitcoin’s increasingly regulated status, its price performance has remained volatile in the time since 2017.
    For example, Bitcoin traded at $10,542 to start December 2017, climbing to $19,783 just eighteen days later before
    losing 80% of its value in 2018.18 More recently, Bitcoin hit a record high of $42,000 on January 11, 2021, only to
    tumble over 30% later in the month, in part due to fears of increased regulation and that its price had risen too
    far too fast. At a US Senate hearing in January, Secretary of the Treasury (then nominee) Janet Yellen expressed
    concerns that cryptos could be used to finance illegal activities, while European Central Bank President Christine
    Lagarde called for more global oversight. As the industry evolves to include more sophisticated investors and products,
    Bitcoin’s performance may be determined to a greater extent by traditional fundamentals and metrics, reducing its
    overall volatility. But for now, its price is primarily a function of supply and demand and the sentiments of its traders.

    FIGURE 4            BITCOIN’S HISTORICAL VOLATILITY

                         10-day Trailing Volatility (%) for Period Ending 1/7/2021

                             300

                             250

                             200

                              150

                              100

                               50

                                0
                                    1/16 5/16   9/16   1/17   5/17   9/17   1/18   5/18   9/18   1/19   5/19   9/19   1/20 5/20   9/20 12/20

                         Source: Bloomberg, as of 01/07/2021.

    16
         Source: Internal Revenue Service, “Virtual Currencies” https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employed/virtual-currencies
    17
          ource: Wall Street Journal, “Coinbase’s Crypto Conundrum” Andrew Ross Sorkin, Jason Karaian, Michael J. de la Merced, Lauren Hirsch and
         S
         Ephrat Livni, 12/18/2020.
    18
         Source: Bloomberg, as of 12/17/2017. 80% loss represents the period from December 17, 2017 to November 26, 2018.

5   THE EVOLVING WORLD OF BITCOIN                fiduciarytrust.com
The Investable Universe of Bitcoin
    Demand for alternative assets jumped following the GFC in response to a steep drawdown in the equity markets
    and historically low yields on fixed income securities. Institutional and high-net-worth investors found themselves
    searching for new ways to mitigate systematic risk and meet annual return targets. In a world where benchmark
    interest rates are near, at, or below 0%, the opportunity cost of not allocating to Bitcoin may be higher. The industry
    appears to have reached a point where it can accommodate a reasonable amount of capital and offer the
    infrastructure necessary for qualified investors, with companies creating everything from index funds to options
    markets and custody services.

    Derivatives, such as futures and options contracts remain the preferred option for large investors, many of whom
    are hesitant to buy Bitcoin directly for fear of overly influencing the market or mismanaging the wallets that store
    the coins. Daily volumes for Bitcoin options on US exchanges hit $1 billion last December, with much of the
    activity occurring on the derivatives platform Deribit.19 On the Chicago Mercantile Exchange, Bitcoin futures and
    options grew 117% year over year as of the end of December 2020.20

    Although the SEC has yet to approve an exchange traded fund (ETF), other fund options are now available.
    Bitfury, a Bitcoin mining company, started an institutional investor program for family offices in May 2020, providing
    an entry point outside of the derivatives market.21 The Grayscale Bitcoin Trust, the largest publicly traded crypto
    fund, has $17 billion in assets under management (AUM) as of January 1, 2021, while total AUM at the firm is
    $20 billion.22 In December, Bitwise Asset Management debuted its Bitwise 10 Crypto Index Fund, the first publicly
    traded index fund, which tracks the l0 biggest cryptocurrencies by market cap including Bitcoin (75%).23 In total,
    cryptocurrency funds attracted over $15 billion in 2020 versus $2.57 billion in 2019.24 In addition, institutional
    and ultra-high-net-worth investors can access Bitcoin through a limited partnership structure, such as the Wise
    Origin Bitcoin Index Fund I LP. The fund tracks the performance of the Fidelity Bitcoin Index through passive,
    direct ownership of Bitcoin.

    Finally, recognizing the need for reliable and user-friendly benchmarks and pricing data, the S&P Dow Jones
    Indices plans to launch two products in early 2021 that will cover more than 550 cryptocurrencies.25

    The Rise of the Retail Trade
    While the price of Bitcoin has been sustained in part by the support of institutional investors, demand has also
    come from the retail sector, aided by the global shift to ecommerce and the use of mobile devices to transfer
    money and purchase goods and services online. For instance, during 2020 we saw over 38 million transfers of
    Bitcoin worth less than $1000 into personal wallets, almost double the number in 2017.26 In the banking system,
    a customer’s financial information moves from the retailer to the merchant processor27, to a payment network and
    then finally to the bank that settles the transaction. Given the risk of identity fraud, theft and hack, cryptocurrency
    has enabled users to move funds relatively quickly and safely without the need for multiple intermediaries.

     19
          Source: Bitcoin.com, “Bitcoin Options Daily Volume Crosses $1 Billion, $100K Strike Introduced for 2021” Jamie Redman, 12/18/2020.
     20
          Source PRNewswire, “CME Group Reports 2020 Annual, Q4 and Monthly Market Statistics” CME Group, 01/05/2021.
     21
          Source: Yahoo!Finance, “Bitfury announces institutional investor program for mining farms” Aislinn Keely, 05/26/2020.
     22
          Source: Grayscale, Company Website.
     23
          Source: Bitwise, Asset Management Company Website.
     24
          Source: CoinDesk, “Blockchain Bites: Square’s Green Bitcoin Pledge, $15B AUM in Crypto Funds” Daniel Kuhn, 12/08/2020.
     25
          Source: CoinDesk, “S&P, State Street Back $15M Investment in Crypto Data Startup Lukka” Danny Nelson, 12/10/2020.
     26
          Source: The Wall Street Journal, “Bitcoin’s Rally Has Already Outlasted 2017’s Epic Run” Paul Vigna, 12/24/2020.
     27
           erchant processing refers to the ability of a merchant to accept a transaction payment through a secure channel. For those merchants who operate
          M
          online, a virtual payment terminal is an ideal solution to allow the acceptance of new payment channels such as credit and debit cards.

6   THE EVOLVING WORLD OF BITCOIN              fiduciarytrust.com
At the same time, we have seen a rise in retail trading during the pandemic, aided by the arrival of low-cost and
    easy-to-use brokerage platforms. Payment apps have also made buying, selling and holding assets, including
    cryptocurrency, much simpler. This market demographic tends to be younger, with a significant amount of their
    financial information gleaned from social media channels. We expect some attention will ultimately flow to Bitcoin
    due to recent celebrity endorsements.28

    As an early backer of cryptocurrencies, Square’s Cash App has permitted its members to trade and store Bitcoin
    since 2018, essentially acting as both an exchange and custodial wallet. As of November 2020, account holders
    held approximately $1.8 billion in Bitcoin, an increase of 180% from the previous year.29 PayPal recently announced
    that it will accept Bitcoin as a payment at 26 million merchant sites starting in 2021. The company also secured
    the first conditional cryptocurrency license from the New York State Department of Financial Services, enabling
    Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies to be traded on its site. Users will be able to convert their currencies to US dollars
    with no incremental fees.

    With close to 350 million active accounts on PayPal, Bitcoin has the opportunity to further expand its reach.30
    Additionally, given healthy demand from hedge funds and other institutional investors, supply is likely to become
    even more constrained, potentially leading to higher price upside. In another development, cryptocurrency is now
    accepted by Visa Inc., which launched a credit card in 2020 that offers rewards in Bitcoin rather than airline miles
    or cash.31

    The Next Chapter for Bitcoin
    Bitcoin soared over 300% in 202032 as investors sought both risk assets and inflation hedges in response to
    aggressive monetary and fiscal policies worldwide. In many ways, Bitcoin’s performance has been fundamentally
    different than its rise and fall three years ago, as buyers now range from retail traders and US corporations to
    endowments and the ultra-wealthy. Supporters of Bitcoin cite a more stable backdrop for investors as a result
    of enhanced oversight, the establishment of regulated products and custody services and a surge in institutional
    interest. However, we would be hesitant to call it a structural shift in the industry, especially during a year of acute
    financial disruption.

    At the moment, cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin appear to lack the stability, transparency and safeguards of more
    traditional asset classes. Trading remains highly opaque and regulation uneven, making it difficult to reach a
    conclusion on the potential risks and rewards of Bitcoin. Further, banks and other financial institutions continue to
    grapple with a number of regulatory and legal hurdles that may hinder Bitcoin’s path to legitimacy. These obstacles
    include the custodial prerequisites if assets are held on a blockchain network, fulfilling anti-money laundering
    obligations, protecting against cyber threats and appropriately evaluating counterparty risk. As the industry
    evolves, clients may have more resources at hand to determine if Bitcoin makes sense for their portfolios. For
    now, the investment landscape is apt to transform considerably, yielding far too many risks for an investor today.

    28
         Source: CNBC, “Big investors new to cryptocurrencies appear to be behind bitcoin’s rally to a record” Kate Rooney, 12/18/2020.
    29
         Source: New York Times, "Bitcoin Hits New Record, This Time With Less Talk of a Bubble” Nathaniel Popper, 11/30/2020.
    30
         Source: PayPal, Company Website.
    31
         Source: CNBC, “With bitcoin near all-time high, this is where Visa’s CEO sees crypto going” Eric Rosenbaum, 11/20/2020.
    32
         Source: Bloomberg 2020 XBT-USD Price Data.

7   THE EVOLVING WORLD OF BITCOIN              fiduciarytrust.com
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
    The author would like to acknowledge the contributions of Jon Heckscher, Managing Director, Director
    of Fixed Income and Chief Investment Officer Pennsylvania Region, to this white paper.

8   THE EVOLVING WORLD OF BITCOIN   fiduciarytrust.com
Biographies

                                         Julia C. Wirts, CFA,
                                         Managing Director and Portfolio Manager
                                         Julia is responsible for providing investment research, thought leadership and
                                         portfolio management for clients. Before joining Fiduciary Trust, Julia worked with
                                         ultra-high net worth individuals and families as an Investment Advisor at Hawthorn,
                                         PNC Family Wealth. She has spent her career creating customized portfolios for
                                         sophisticated relationships, performing fundamental equity research and developing
                                         thought leadership papers on topical investment themes. She has an extensive
                                         background in Responsible Investing (RI) and played a large role in building out
                                         Hawthorn’s RI platform. In addition, she worked for Philadelphia International
                                         Advisors and The Pew Charitable Trusts. Julia earned the Chartered Financial
                                         Analyst® (CFA) designation and is a member of the CFA Society of Philadelphia.
                                         She is involved in various local organizations including the National Society of the
                                         Colonial Dames of America, the 1874 Society for the Morris Animal Refuge and the
                                         Acorn Club of Philadelphia where she serves on the Investment Committee that
                                         oversees the club’s endowment. Julia received her undergraduate degree from
                                         Trinity College and her Masters in Public Affairs from the University of Pennsylvania.

9   THE EVOLVING WORLD OF BITCOIN   fiduciarytrust.com
GROWING AND PROTECTING WEALTH FOR GENERATIONS
Fiduciary Trust International is a wealth management firm founded in 1931 by families for families, with a singular focus on growing and
protecting your wealth through generations. We work closely with individuals, families and foundations to build and manage personalized
investment portfolios, and to develop estate plans that extend wealth to future generations.

Investment Management         I   Wealth Planning      I    Trust, Estate and Family Office Services

                                               Fiduciary Trust             Arlington, VA             Radnor, PA            FTCI (Cayman) Ltd.
                                               International Offices       (703) 647-4132            (610) 975-4300        Grand Cayman
                                               New York, NY                Boca Raton, FL            San Francisco, CA     (877) 384-1111
                                               (877) 384-1111              (561) 226-3400            (877) 284-2697        (212) 632-3000
        fiduciarytrust.com                                                                                                 (calling from
                                                                           Coral Gables, FL          San Mateo, CA         outside the US)
                                                                           (800) 618-1260            (877) 284-2697

                                                                           Fort Lauderdale, FL       St. Petersburg, FL
                                                                           (561) 226-3400            (877) 384-1111

                                                                           Lincoln, MA               Washington, DC
                                                                           (781) 274-9300            (888) 621-3464

                                                                           Los Angeles, CA           Wilmington, DE
                                                                           (800) 421-9683            (866) 398-7414

Securities, mutual funds and other non-deposit investments:

                       I                   I
 NOT FDIC INSURED MAY LOSE VALUE NO BANK GUARANTEE

Fiduciary Trust Company International, headquartered in New York, (and subsidiaries doing business as Fiduciary Trust International) and FTCI (Cayman)
Ltd. are part of the Franklin Templeton family of companies.

This communication is intended solely to provide general information. The information and opinions stated are as of June 30, 2020, unless otherwise noted,
and may change without notice. The information and opinions do not represent a complete analysis of every material fact. Statements of fact have been
obtained from sources deemed reliable, but no representation is made as to their completeness or accuracy. The opinions expressed are not intended as
individual investment, tax or estate planning advice or as a recommendation of any particular security, strategy or investment product. Please consult your
personal advisor to determine whether this information may be appropriate for you. This information is provided solely for insight into our general manage-
ment philosophy and process. Historical performance does not guarantee future results and results may differ over future time periods.

IRS Circular 230 Notice: Pursuant to relevant US Treasury regulations, we inform you that any tax advice contained in this communication is not intended or
written to be used, and cannot be used, for the purpose of (i) avoiding penalties under the Internal Revenue Code or (ii) promoting, marketing or recom-
mending to another party any transaction or matter addressed herein. You should seek advice based on your particular circumstances from your tax advisor.

CFA® and Chartered Financial Analyst® are trademarks owned by the CFA Institute

© 2021 Fiduciary Trust International. Allrights reserved.
You can also read