The digital age Navigating - What senior leaders worldwide have learned from pushing the boundaries of change.
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
Cognizanti Part III Navigating the digital age Navigating the Digital Age What senior leaders worldwide have learned from pushing the boundaries of change. Vol 12 • 2019 Vol 12 • 2019
About Cognizant Cognizant (Nasdaq-100: CTSH) is one of the world’s leading professional services companies, transforming clients’ business, operating and technology models for Cognizanti is an annual journal published by Cognizant. the digital era. Our unique industry-based, consultative approach helps clients Our mission is to provide unique insights, emerging envision, build and run more innovative and efficient businesses. Headquartered strategies and proven best practices that globally-minded in the U.S., Cognizant is ranked 193 on the Fortune 500 and is consistently listed companies can use in their quest for business and IT among the most admired companies in the world. performance excellence. All articles published in Cognizanti represent the ideas Learn how Cognizant helps clients lead with digital at www.cognizant.com or and perspectives of individual Cognizant associates and follow us @Cognizant. contributors who have documented expertise in business- technology strategy and implementation. The content of U.S. Headquarters: World Headquarters: the articles published in Cognizanti represents the views 211 Quality Circle 500 Frank W. Burr Blvd. of the individual contributors and not necessarily those College Station, TX 77845 Teaneck, NJ 07666 USA of Cognizant. They are put forward to illuminate new Tel: +1 979 691 7700 Phone: +1 201 801 0233 Fax: +1 979 691 7750 Fax: +1 201 801 0243 ways of conceptualizing and delivering global services Toll Free: +1 855 789 4268 Toll free: +1 888 937 3277 for competitive gain. They are not intended to be, and are Email: inquiry@cognizant.com Email: inquiry@cognizant.com not a substitute for, professional advice and should not be relied upon as such. India Operations Headquarters: European Headquarters: For more insights, and to continue the conversation #5/535, Old Mahabalipuram Road 1 Kingdom Street online, please visit our e-community at http://connections. Okkiyam Pettai, Thoraipakkam Paddington Central cognizant.com or download our Perspectives app from the Chennai 600 096 India London W2 6BD Apple App Store or Google Play at http://cogniz.at/ Phone: +91 (0) 44 4209 6000 Phone: +44 (0) 20 7297 7600 itunescognizantperspectives or http://cogniz.at/ Fax: +91 (0) 44 4209 6060 Fax: +44 (0) 20 7121 0102 googleplaycognizantperspectives, respectively. Email: inquiryindia@cognizant.com Email: infouk@cognizant.com China Operations Headquarters: APAC Headquarters: Cognizant Technology Solutiions 1 Changi Business Park Crescent, (Shanghai) Co. Plaza 8@CBP # 07-04/05/06, CN Shanghai You Do Space Tower A, Singapore 486025 ChuanQiao Road Phone: + 65 6812 4051 Looking for the future of Pu Dong New District Phone: +86 21 6100 6466 Fax: + 65 6324 4051 Email: inquiry@cognizant.com magazine publishing? Fax: +86 21 6100 6457 Email: inquirychina@cognizant.com 1. Download our Cognizant AR app @ the Apple App Store or Google Play to view videos contained in this issue. Primary Global Delivery Centers: Budapest (Hungary), Buenos Aires (Argentina), Guadalajara (Mexico), London (UK), 2. Once the app is installed, train Manila (Philippines), Shanghai (China), Toronto (Canada); Chennai, Coimbatore, Kolkata, your mobile phone’s lens on Bangalore, Hyderabad, Pune, Mumbai, New Delhi, Cochin (India); Bentonville, AR; the thumbnail image of our Bridgewater, NJ; Des Moines, IA; Phoenix, AZ; Tampa, FL (U.S.). app on pages 5, 17 and 38. Primary Regional Offices: We welcome your input on this Atlanta, Chicago, Dallas, Los Angeles, Norwalk, Phoenix, San Ramon, Teaneck (U.S.); feature and would love to hear London (Canada); London (UK); Frankfurt (Germany); Paris (France); Madrid (Spain); Helsinki (Finland); Copenhagen (Denmark); Zurich, Geneva (Switzerland); Amsterdam what you think! (The Netherlands); Hong Kong, Shanghai (China); Tokyo (Japan); Melbourne, Sydney (Australia); Bangkok (Thailand); Kuala Lumpur (Malaysia); Buenos Aires (Argentina); Dubai (UAE); Manila (Philippines). © Copyright 2019, Cognizant Technology Solutions No part of this publication may be used or reproduced in any manner whatsoever without written permission of Cognizant.
An annual journal produced by Cognizant VOLUME 12 • 2019 The Cognizanti Team Publisher: Malcolm Frank, President, Cognizant Digital Business Editor-in-Chief: Alan Alper, Vice President, Corporate Marketing/ Thought Leadership Programs Editor: Rajeshwer Chigullapalli, Associate Director, Corporate Marketing Thought Leadership Program Management: April Vadnais, Associate Director, Corporate Marketing Art Director: Jason Feuilly, Director, Corporate Brand/Design Design/Print Production: Diana Fitter, Contributing Art Director Editing: Mary Brandel, Contributing Editor Columnist: Bruce J. Rogow, Independent Advisor Digital Distribution: Nikhil Narayanan, Associate Director, Social Media Marketing Editorial Advisory Board Irene Sandler, Vice President, Marketing, Cognizant Mats Johard, Cognizant Consulting Head, Nordics Ramkumar Ramamoorthy, Chairman & Managing Director, India Ben Pring, Vice President, Cognizant Center for the Future of Work Gary Beach, Publisher Emeritus, CIO magazine
Table of contents 4 Editor’s Note With Digital, the More We Live … the More We Learn Alan Alper, Cognizant 6 The First Word Get Ready: AI Is Grown Up and Ready for Business Rajeshwer Chigullapalli, Cognizant 16 Health Insurance From Vision to Reality: How MetLife Applied Blockchain to Solve a Difficult Health Insurance Challenge Zia Zaman, MetLife 26 Healthcare Digital Helps Geisinger Redesign Primary Care Services Jaewon Ryu, M.D., Karena Weikel, Juliann Molecavage, Rebecca A. Stametz & David Riviello 38 Commentary A Radical Rethink to Replenishing the Talent Pool Gary Beach, CIO magazine
46 Property & Casualty Insurance Attrition Expedition: Using AI to Chart a Course to Retain Call Center Employees Michelle Deitchman, The Hartford 52 Banking & Financial Services Tapping Blockchain to Slash Costs, Enhance Trust and Speed B2B Transactions Micah Kerr, Discover Financial Services & George Throckmorton, Nacha 62 The Last Word On the Road to Digital: Practical Encounters Bruce J. Rogow, IT Odyssey
With Digital, the More We Live … the More We Learn When it comes to digital technology, business or thinking, established organizations have a different set of challenges from those of digitally native pioneers. They have hardwired business conventions, and are often constrained by regulatory mandates, customer/industry requirements and inflexible legacy systems and processes that just can’t turn on a dime – despite all the talk about human-centered design, Agile development methodologies and DevOps automation. Compared with those that grew up in the “all things digital” era, it isn’t as simple for these organizations to be digital across key business functions and tasks or in most interactions and transactions with employees, partners and customers. So, what’s a 20th century or older company in need of a modern digital overhaul to do? Pilot, perfect and, over time, provide business results that demonstrate the art of the possible. This issue of Cognizanti is dedicated to heritage companies experimenting with artificial intelligence (AI), blockchain and tailored platforms to more effectively serve their employees, customers and partners. Their efforts illustrate how companies must master the fundamentals that surround new technology adoption and business process change before dramatically over-reaching. Take insurance giant MetLife, which is piloting blockchain and smart contract technology to enable women in Singapore with gestational diabetes to be compensated for the cost of treatment over their cellphones – without having to file a claim. Or The Hartford, which is employing innovative AI-powered tools to reveal surprising truths about employee turnover to enhance its workplace culture. Then there’s Discover and Nacha, which are exploring how distributed ledger technology can make online business purchases safer. Or Geisinger, which is improving patient and population health and wellness while streamlining physician workflows via a platform-centric approach.
Editor’s Note We open with a fact-based look at AI and how to ensure its effective and ethical deployment. Veteran IT industry commentator Gary Beach then explores novel ways organizations can restock the digital talent pool. Bruce Rogow concludes the issue with practical advice, gleaned from interactions with top senior business and IT leaders, on proven ways to cut through digital headwinds. We hope you enjoy and benefit from the views shared by your colleagues and our commentators. If you’d like your own digital journey featured in an upcoming issue of Cognizanti, or in our Digital Perspectives app (available both at the Apple App Store and Google Play on smartphones and tablets), contact me at Alan.Alper@cognizant.com. You can also share your point of view on our Cognizant Connections e-community (ask your client partner for an invite). Scan the below image for a welcome from Editor-In-Chief Alan Alper. See inside cover for instructions to download the Cognizant AR app. Cognizanti • 5
The First Word Get Ready: AI Is Grown Up and Ready for Business By Rajeshwer Chigullapalli Despite great enthusiasm for AI, full-blown deployments remain the exception rather than the rule across businesses in the U.S. and Europe, according to our recent research. Businesses can turn the tide by honing their AI strategies, maintaining a human- centric approach, developing governance structures and ensuring AI applications are built on an ethical foundation. Germinating in R&D labs since the offering an intelligent foundation 1940s, artificial intelligence (AI) is for creating products and services slowly but surely moving into the that drive topline growth. mainstream across the consumer Given the hype, it’s no wonder that world. But in the enterprise space, the AI market is expected to grow AI remains bound by concerns at a strong 36% CAGR to reach $191 about balancing its responsible billion by 2025.1 And according development, deployment and to Gartner, global business value usage with its ability to deliver created from AI is projected to total business value. And while there’s $3.9 trillion in 2022.2 widespread recognition of AI’s immense potential, many To gauge executive perceptions organizations are still working to of and achievement with AI, we determine how AI can move the recently surveyed 975 business needle where it makes the most leaders from organizations in sense: controlling costs, unleashing the U.S. and Europe. While our new customer experiences and study uncovered widespread Cognizanti 7
enthusiasm and optimism about Moreover, most respondents AI, it also revealed AI’s nascent expect major or significant stage of adoption. For instance, the benefits in terms of revenue vast majority of AI projects (78%) growth from their use of AI. In remain in experimental stages (i.e., fact, almost all expect value proofs of concept and prototypes). to increase significantly within three years, with financial The state of the state services and technology industry of AI in business companies leading the pack (see Figures 1 and 2). The following are the key takeaways gleaned from our study: ❙❙ AI is infiltrating multiple business functions. Among ❙❙ Most respondents consider all business functions, AI to be vital to business customer service appears success. The vast majority of to be a prime target for AI respondents across industries use across industries. This is view AI as extremely or very understandable, since customer important to their business. Not satisfaction, engagement and surprisingly, respondents were buy-in is critical to ensuring also optimistic about AI’s ability business success and justification to generate benefits, including of an AI-led transformation cost efficiency, revenues and agenda (see Figure 3, next page). new products and services. Importance of AI to company success TECHNOLOGY 40% 53% FINANCIAL SERVICES 32% 53% MANUFACTURING 38% 47% HEALTHCARE 42% 41% INSURANCE 46% 36% RETAIL 28% 50% MEDIA 31% 24% 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% Very important Extremely important Base: 975 senior leaders in the U.S. & Europe Source: Cognizant Figure 1 8
Expected revenue boost from AI TECHNOLOGY 42% 39% FINANCIAL SERVICES 38% 39% RETAIL 37% 39% HEALTHCARE 39% 32% MANUFACTURING 38% 32% INSURANCE 43% 27% MEDIA 41% 10% 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% Significant benefit Major benefit Base: 975 senior leaders in the U.S. & Europe Source: Cognizant Figure 2 Top business functions for AI use CUSTOMER SERVICE 30% MANUFACTURING PROCESS 26% OPERATIONS 20% RESEARCH & DEVELOPMENT 18% FINANCE 13% SALES & MARKETING 13% SUPPLY CHAIN/PROCUREMENT 9% HUMAN RESOURCES 7% RISK & COMPLIANCE 6% 0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% (Percent of respondents naming each function) Base: 975 senior leaders in the U.S. & Europe Source: Cognizant Figure 3 Cognizanti • 9
Organizations are also focusing ❙❙ Choice of AI technology is their AI efforts on areas that influenced by functional area are core to the business, such and associated processes. as operations in the healthcare Respondents reported using industry, production in manufac- all five of the AI technologies turing and R&D in technology. included in our study at a fairly similar rate (see Figure 4). Many AI technologies currently in use 58% 49% SMART ROBOTICS/ 47% AUTONOMOUS VEHICLES 60% 46% 35 % 40% 33% 45% ANALYSIS OF 54% NATURAL LANGUAGE 42% 40% 44% 56% 42% 58% ADVICE ENGINES/ 53% MACHINE LEARNING 53% 44% 35% 41% 50% 55% 52% COMPUTER VISION 56% 35% 44% 51% 42% 49% 58% VIRTUAL AGENTS 44% 52% 41% 72% 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% Media Retail Technology Manufacturing Healthcare Insurance Financial Services Base: 975 senior leaders in the U.S. & Europe Note: Multiple responses allowed Source: Cognizant Figure 4 10
Organizations seem to attach ❙❙ Faster-growing organizations equal importance to the various appear to be more optimistic technologies that can power about AI and more aggressive an AI strategy. However, virtual in their AI adoption. Roughly agents (conversational AI) 85% of respondents at faster- and computer vision (machine growing organizations expect intelligence algorithms that AI to provide a major or recognize patterns, among significant impact on revenues, other things) led other AI compared with 71% of slower- technologies by a small growing businesses (see Figure margin. Respondents said 5). A higher percentage of their companies are selectively faster-growth organization deploying technologies tailored respondents (89%) also to specific functional areas, such expect AI to provide a major or as virtual agents for customer significant benefit in terms of service and bots in production. efficiencies that translate into Expected revenue increase SLOWER-GROWTH BUSINESSES 29% 42% FASTER-GROWTH BUSINESSES 55% 30% 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% Significant impact Major impact Base: 975 senior leaders in the U.S. & Europe Source: Cognizant Figure 5 Expected cost reduction SLOWER-GROWTH BUSINESSES 32% 45% FASTER-GROWTH BUSINESSES 56% 33% 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% Significant impact Major impact Base: 975 senior leaders in the U.S. & Europe Source: Cognizant Figure 6 Cognizanti • 11
cost reduction vs. slower growth organization, it becomes clear businesses (77%) (see Figure that most organizations have yet 6). While a significant majority to hone a clear-cut AI strategy. of faster-growth companies Further, given that top (66%) said AI will increase jobs, challenges related to senior only 38% of respondents at management commitment, businesses with slower growth business buy-in, adequate rates said they believed this to budget and lack of be true. preparedness, it’s apparent ❙❙ AI adoption challenges span that many companies are still talent acquisition, business struggling to define AI’s central cases and ethics. Respondents role in advancing business expressed a similar level of objectives. concern regarding challenges Interestingly, technology industry on the path to AI, with 40% of respondents were more apt than executives considering each of respondents in other industries to the 13 challenges listed to be be aware of ethical considerations extremely or very challenging. playing a role in AI deployments When that data is combined (see Figure 7). This could be the with the finding that only 15% of result of increased scrutiny of respondents were aware of a fully the FAANG (Facebook, Apple, implemented AI project at their Amazon, Netflix and Google) Concerns over ethical AI vary across industries TECHNOLOGY 55% FINANCIAL SERVICES 45% HEALTHCARE 43% RETAIL 41% MANUFACTURING 41% INSURANCE 41% MEDIA 29% 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% (Percent of respondents rating high or significantly high concern) Base: 975 senior leaders in the U.S. & Europe Source: Cognizant Figure 7 12
companies relative to their use of be geared around solving a data- and algorithmic-enabled human problem and factor in the analytical decision making, as right combination of machines well as the issues they’ve had and human talent – from devel- to contend with regarding user opment and deployment, privacy. Sustainable and successful through usage. AI deployments will need to be ❙❙ Enact an effective governance built on a foundation that ensures structure: Businesses need ethical and responsible outcomes. to engage teams in defining standards, best practices and The road ahead: investment strategies to get strategy, governance the most value from AI. The and ethics imperatives governance model should ensure that AI-led decisions are To successfully move from the reached in a transparent and nascent stages of AI into full auditable way while obviating the business value realization, we influence of biases (unintended believe organizations should or otherwise) that may creep into focus on three key areas: AI the fabric of AI designs. strategy, governance and ethics. Addressing gaps in these areas ❙❙ Build an ethical foundation can place AI on a sustainable path – and continually maintain it: to delivering desired results. We For AI to take hold, businesses recommend businesses take the need to embed processes following actions when planning that ensure integration of their path to AI: ethical considerations into the development, deployment and ❙❙ Embrace a human-centric ongoing usage of AI, both inside strategy: In addition to focusing the organization’s four walls and on measurable business value, with customers and partners. an effective AI strategy should This article was adapted from our primary research-based report “Making AI Responsible – and Effective.” To learn more, visit https://www.cognizant. com/artificial-intelligence-adoption-for-business. Cognizanti • 13
Endnotes 1 “Artificial Intelligence Market,” Markets and Markets, February 2018, https://www.marketsandmar- kets.com/Market-Reports/artificial-intelligence-market-74851580.html. 2 Alex Knapp, “Gartner Estimates AI Business Value to Reach Nearly $4 Trillion by 2022,” Forbes, April 25, 2018, https://www.forbes.com/sites/alexknapp/2018/04/25/gartner-estimates-ai-business- value-to-reach-nearly-4-trillion-by-2022/#47bf0f433f9b. Author Rajeshwer Chigullapalli is an Associate Director within Cognizant’s thought leadership program. He has over 25 years of experience in the areas of business research and publishing. Previously, he was the Head of ICFAI University Press and Chief Editor, SPG Media, India. He can be reached at Rajeshwer.Chigullapalli@cognizant.com. Acknowledgments The author would like to thank Cognizant Digital Business’s AI and Analytics Practice for their contributions to this article, including Poornima Ramaswamy, Vice President, James Jeude, Vice President and Practice Leader, Jerry A. Smith, Vice President, Data Sciences, and Bret Greenstein, Global Vice President and Head of the AI Practice. 14
Scan the above image to hear about MetLife’s use of blockchain as told by Zia Zaman. See inside cover for instructions to download the Cognizant AR app.
Health Insurance From Vision to Reality How MetLife Applied Blockchain to Solve a Difficult Health Insurance Challenge By Zia Zaman Working with well-placed partners, the global insurer launched the world’s first automated insurance solution for gestational diabetes in Singapore, taking enterprise blockchain technology from the highly aspirational to the incredibly practical and meaningful. Along the way, it uncovered the potential, and limitations, of distributed ledger technology’s uplifting impact on both underserved communities and society as a whole. In September 2016, a colleague in new insurance idea based on a our innovation center LumenLab smart contract (contracts that walked into my office with a verify and carry out credible bold idea. At LumenLab, we’re transactions without third parties), accustomed to this; based in to which I responded, “Wouldn’t Singapore, we were established it be great if we could make an to build disruptive businesses for insurance payout as effortless as MetLife. “Lumen,” a measure of getting a soft drink from a vending light, symbolizes our commitment machine?” to illuminating new paths for This ambitious idea took solving problems faced by people advantage of the technology in Asia today. underlying Bitcoin: blockchain, or Still, I underestimated just how more precisely, distributed ledger pivotal this moment would be. technology (DLT). He enthusiastically pitched a Cognizanti 17
Validating learn is an exceptionally fast and inexpensive way to challenge opportunities assumptions, eliminate risk and Back then, Bitcoin had yet to reach transform uncertainty into valuable its peak valuation, and while there insights – be it consumer pain was a lot of talk about use cases points (what we call “jobs-to- in the enterprise, nobody, in any be-done”), product-market fit or industry, had gone and done it. technology readiness. LumenLab thrives on challenges The process runs in two stages: like this. exploration and experimentation. Over the course of our four-year During the exploration stage, we existence, we’ve developed and frame the problem and define refined our own “test & learn” what success looks like. We then process for building new ventures refine the true job-to-be-done for (see Figure 1). We measure the customer and generate ideas success in terms of knowledge for how to build solutions. At the gained through small experiments, end of this stage, we have “fallen which can subsequently turn in love with the problem” and may into commercial impact. Test & have found new ways of solving it. The test & learn framework PHASES TOOLS BEHAVIORS 1 Define and align on ❙ Goals and bounds scope and success INNOVATION EXPLORATION FRAME ❙ Context capturer ❙ Into-the-wild interviews 2 Understand our consumers ❙ Persona builder and unlock great insights CURIOSITY EXPLORE ❙ Jobs-to-be-done finder Generate a range of ❙ Solution developer 3 EXPANSIVITY ideas, and align ❙ Ideation sprint CREATE on the best ❙ Rule breaker Develop and ❙ Value proposition 4 refine our solution EXPERIMENTATION BLUEPRINT ❙ Competitor mapper to setup for success EXPERIMENTALITY ❙ What-if financials Set-up and run ❙ Assumption mapper “pretotypes” to ❙ Adaptive planning 5 test and learn VELOCITY EXPERIMENT efficiently ❙ Experiment designer Launch our pilot to ❙ Minimum viable product 6 build and move BRAVERY PILOT ❙ Elevator pitch toward scale Figure 1 18
During the experimentation stage, low in cost but still represented a we formulate a value proposition, latent coverage gap for customers. run small-scale experiments to It needed to be a niche market test our assumptions, and iterate so we could keep it small enough until we’re confident with building to experiment. And we needed a pilot. The result is real-world a short claim period, with a high validation that can be used to build enough incidence rate to ensure commercial products – without the we could learn enough about the risk and uncertainty that typically end-to-end customer experience accompanies new ventures. in a short time span. After much deliberation, a team member’s Using blockchain to pregnant wife suggested a serve the underserved solution: gestational diabetes mellitus, or simply GDM. When we set out to build the world’s first blockchain-powered GDM is a form of diabetes that health insurance application, we develops during pregnancy, needed to make sure it offered occurring either when an real benefits. Do the benefits expectant mother can’t produce of blockchain line up with real enough insulin, or the insulin customer needs? Is the technology is not working well enough to ready for actual insurance act on the sugars in her body. customers? Can we align the This leads to excess glucose in right group of partners to build a the bloodstream, which can be system on blockchain? These are passed on to the baby. Associated just some of the questions we had complications during pregnancy when we started, and we would and labor include excess birth methodically answer every one of weight, premature birth and, in them as we moved forward. some serious cases, stillbirth. GDM affects one in five pregnant Our first challenge was to find a women in Singapore1 and, crucially, proper product scope. We needed is typically not fully covered by to cover a risk that was relatively general health insurance. In other GDM affects one in five pregnant women in Singapore and is typically not fully covered by general health insurance. In other words, we’d found a real, addressable need that cut across the population. Cognizanti • 19
words, we’d found a real, address- different systems. We needed able need that cut across the clinics to help us distribute Vitana, population. electronic medical records (EMR) providers to record customer data, Hence, Vitana was born. But we and a technology provider with couldn’t do it alone. deep expertise with DLT to help us implement our ambitious plans. Assembling the right partners Because MetLife doesn’t have a traditional insurance business A key benefit of blockchain is that in Singapore, we also partnered it eliminates many of the processes with Swiss Re to reinsure the that add to the cost of insurance risk and offer valuable insight on for customers – including under- product design and delivery in the writing, onboarding and claims Singapore market. Additionally, the processing. Our vision for Vitana Monetary Authority of Singapore was to shortcut the process to (MAS) provided the regulatory provide a frictionless experience for sandbox that made the whole customers. We wanted customers experiment possible. to sign up in just a few minutes and our policies to be issued completely Our team of collaborators also hassle-free. To top it off, we wanted consisted of Singapore’s largest to completely eliminate the claims clinic group, Singapore Medical process for customers afflicted with Group (SMG), EMR start-up Vault GDM. This meant payouts would Dragon, and business services automatically appear in patients’ provider Cognizant. Together – bank accounts upon diagnosis – over the course of six months – we zero paperwork. developed a customer journey, reengineered clinical processes To realize this vision, we had to and built the technology that connect disparate data from many turned Vitana into reality. Our vision for Vitana was to shortcut the process to provide a frictionless experience for customers. We wanted customers to sign up in just a few minutes and our policies to be issued completely hassle-free. To top it off, we wanted to completely eliminate the claims process for customers afflicted with GDM. 20
The truly transformational moment happens at the “claim” stage. From a customer’s perspective, it’s all invisible and completely frictionless. Vitana in practice virtually simultaneously. All parties – clinics, insurers, reinsurers and Vitana has two elements: a regulators – now have visibility of mobile app for customers and a new policies in real time. It doesn’t blockchain back-end to act as just strengthen communications; it the source of truth for all involved eliminates much of the transaction parties. But for all the technology costs for the parties interacting involved in Vitana, our focus was with one another. on the customer journey. The truly transformational moment Early in her pregnancy, after happens at the “claim” stage. being informed about the risks From a customer’s perspective, of GDM and being told about it’s all invisible and completely the innovative new coverage, the frictionless. Around Week 25, the expectant mother is encouraged expectant mother is tested for to sign up by simply downloading GDM by her clinic, which updates the app and entering her her EMR with the results. Should government-issued ID number. the customer test positive for The app automatically connects to GDM, the EMR automatically the customer’s electronic medical writes the result onto the records and populates personal blockchain. The smart contract information. All that remains is then executes, and a payout is for the customer to answer three automatically triggered to the simple underwriting questions and customer’s bank account. enter payment information. This takes about two minutes – and she Again, all parties are instantly is instantly covered. notified, and the insurers – in this case, us – can process the “claim” A smart contract is automatically and make the payment, without created, encrypted and deployed the customer ever contacting to an Ethereum blockchain. MetLife. This creates a policy document, which is emailed to the customer Cognizanti • 21
Triggering the smart contract When downloaded, the Vitana app automatically connects to the patient’s electronic medical record and deploys a smart contract to the blockchain. All parties now have visibility into new policies in real time. If the patient tests positive for GDM, the EMR automatically writes the result onto the blockchain, which executes the smart contract and triggers the payout to her bank account. MOBILE APP BLOCKCHAIN INSURER ELECTRONIC REGULATOR HEALTH RECORD REINSURER Figure 2 Takeaways to date partnership and was pivotal in the cocreation of this initiative. At the Vitana was designed as a time of writing, many conclusions time-bound experiment in the are still to be drawn; however, some sandbox of MAS. As a progressive lessons stand out already: regulator, MAS delivered on the spirit of a public-private 22
and at a fraction of the cost of traditional systems, meaning we We found a real customer need will be better equipped to serve in GDM, and blockchain helped customers’ micro-protection us put together a seamless, needs. frictionless experience for customers afflicted by the condition. Getting data prepared to go Offering real value to expectant onto blockchain might be more mothers in a time of need has difficult than setting up and been a rewarding and gratifying executing the distributed ledger experience. We are serving the technology. underserved; the potential for us to insure future risk pools will increase When we designed the process access to and inclusion with flow in partnership with the clinic, insurance. This is arguably Vitana’s we needed to rewire existing greatest potential legacy. processes, which was an incredible change management effort, and even then we weren’t able to eliminate all manual steps. Real-time shared data across all parties using blockchain is A word of caution: Operating on invaluable. blockchain increases the required trust in the integrity of the data It is our firm belief that as the and the reliability of the processes technology matures and new that other parties use to feed platforms emerge, the future of to the ledger. You can’t just go data will be decentralized. One back and change a record when added benefit is increased data it is immutable. This is not what protection for customers, whose you typically hear at Consensus data can be shared in encrypted conferences,2 but it is a lesson fashion only. we will remember for our future Using blockchain, we can imagine solutions. a world where we can offer new services and products more simply When we designed the process flow in partnership with the clinic, we needed to rewire existing processes, which was an incredible change management effort. Cognizanti • 23
The beauty of blockchain is that it makes it clear to first-time insurance buyers that if “this” happens, then “this” is what you get, automatically. Effectively, it increases trust between insurer and customer, which is the basis for fulfilling relationships going forward. The future of ❙❙ Fully automated back-end: Our back-end processes will blockchain in eliminate all manual steps to insurance ensure the smooth servicing As we continue to gather insights of future products. This will from the early success of Vitana, enable faster, cheaper and more many insights and lessons emerge efficient processing. for potential future blockchain- At a meta level, this is a peek into based experiments. These key the future of our industry and insights stand out: possibly a way to include the next ❙❙ Parametric insurance: This is a two billion people in the world of type of insurance that does not insurance, driving greater financial indemnify the pure loss, but inclusion of our four identified ex ante agrees to make a underrepresented segments: payment upon the occurrence women, middle-class farmers, of a triggered event.3 Its key octogenarians and people of faith.4 benefit is around simplicity and It works because of two factors: targeted accessibility to create simplicity and trust. The beauty of low-cost, niche products. blockchain is that it makes it clear ❙❙ Frictionless experience: to first-time insurance buyers that We expect sign-up for the if “this” happens, then “this” is what product to be simple (minimal you get, automatically. Effectively, underwriting) and claim it increases trust between insurer payments to be automatically and customer, which is the basis triggered based on an objective, for fulfilling relationships going quantitative result for the forward. customer. This reduces risk of fraud and eliminates the need for the traditional claims process. 24
Endnotes 1 Salma Khalik, “Diabetes Fight Focuses on Pregnant Women,” The Straits Times, March 29, 2016, https://www.str aitstimes.com/singapore/health/diabetes-fight-focuses-on-pregnant-women. 2 Consensus is the annual gathering of the cryptocurrency and blockchain technology world. For more information, see https://www.coindesk.com/events/consensus-2019. 3 This means the agreement takes place before the event occurs. 4 LumenLab Annual Report 2018: http://lumenlab.sg/2018/12/20/annual-report-2018/. Author Zia Zaman joined MetLife in July 2014 as the Chief Innovation Officer for the company’s Asia region and Chief Executive Officer of LumenLab, an industry- first innovation center. As a member of MetLife’s Asia Leadership Group, he is responsible for steering the company’s innovation agenda across the region and around the world, with a passion for finding new ways to help the underserved. Much of Zia’s inspiration for new thinking sprouted on the two campuses where he studied. Zia holds an MBA from Stanford’s GSB. His most formative early years were spent at MIT, where he wrote about probability, traveling salesmen and hockey goalies while pursuing his undergraduate and master’s degrees in electrical engineering and operations research. Zia can be reached at Zzaman@metlife.com | linkedin.com/in/zia-zaman-4ba46. Cognizanti • 25
Healthcare Digital Helps Geisinger Redesign Primary Care Services By Jaewon Ryu, M.D., Karena Weikel, Juliann Molecavage, Rebecca A. Stametz & David Riviello How can healthcare be made easier for both patients and physicians? This regional U.S. healthcare organization is answering that question by closing care gaps and streamlining workflows with a data-informed, platform- centric approach. At Geisinger, we work to keep comprises nearly 1,800 physicians, people healthy, and a key 13 hospital campuses, two research component is developing centers, an innovation institute, innovative ways to identify and a medical school and a health manage clinical conditions, ideally plan with more than 550,000 outside of the hospital setting. members. In addition to fulfilling While this may seem unusual for its mission to bring better health a health organization with more to its patients and members, than a dozen hospital and trauma Geisinger has a long-standing campuses, this notion of making commitment to quality, medical health easier is front and center in education, research, innovation our approach to patient care. and community service. Geisinger is a non-profit, For many years, the practices of integrated health system that the U.S. healthcare industry have dates to the 1915 founding of made hospital admissions and its flagship hospital, Geisinger emergency departments central Medical Center in Danville, PA. to care delivery. Not only are The physician-led system now these sites more expensive for Cognizanti • 27
providing care, but they haven’t conditions and even proactively always delivered the best health determining whether they’re at outcomes or experiences either. risk for developing a disease that could be prevented. That’s where Our focus instead spans the our Anticipatory Management care continuum, where we’re Program (AMP) app comes in. increasingly building programs to manage populations outside the hospital walls, with a particular Assessing risk to emphasis on expanding primary improve care care access. This orientation makes At Geisinger, we’re no strangers to healthcare easier by meeting innovation. We’re well recognized people where they are. It’s easier to as one of the earliest adopters get to a clinic than a hospital, and of electronic health records the home is even more convenient (EHR) and for our development still. We are uniquely positioned to of transformative approaches to do this because of the breadth of care delivery (see Quick Take, our organization, which is designed page 30), such as ProvenCare® to improve care for more than 1.5 or, more recently, the Fresh Food million patients in Pennsylvania Farmacy or Geisinger at Home. and New Jersey. Continuing this tradition of innovation, the Steele Institute To meet patients in these locations for Health Innovation was formed instead of in hospital facilities, in 2018. This institute forges a patients need to stay as healthy new generation of leading-edge as possible. We can help them do solutions that aim to drive greater this by getting a complete picture affordability, improve quality and of each patient’s health status, increase access. enabling them to manage existing To meet patients in these locations instead of in hospital facilities, patients need to stay as healthy as possible. We can help them do this by getting a complete picture of each patient’s health status, enabling them to manage existing conditions and even proactively determining whether they’re at risk for developing a disease that could be prevented. 28
With AMP, we recognize that Closing gaps improving care quality, identifying gaps in care and the patient’s risk with digital for developing an illness are all Previously, identifying and closing tightly intertwined. The industry gaps had been a largely manual often defines care gaps as missed process. The ambulatory and health screenings based on patient primary care practices used paper gender, health status, socio- forms to list patients’ care gaps, economic factors and age. These making it difficult to capture screenings include mammograms, discrete data such as errors or colonoscopies, prostate and omissions caught by physicians. nephropathy screenings, regular Our teams needed a more hemoglobin A1c (HgbA1c) tests effective way to create a complete and dozens more. and accurate view of patients and care gaps, ideally embedded in By filling these gaps, Geisinger the physicians’ workflows. We can take better care of individuals, also needed to be more proactive understand our communities’ about identifying potential disease burden more deeply conditions, not just current and coordinate interventions documented health. appropriately. Each of these capabilities is important to Geisinger as we, and the industry, move steadily away from fee- for-service business models and toward value-based models in which reimbursements are based on the quality of health outcomes. Without complete health information, it becomes that much more difficult to optimize health outcomes. Cognizanti • 29
Quick Take The Doctor Ordered Food Geisinger prescribes healthy food combined with clinical intervention and education to take on Type 2 diabetes By Allison Hess At Geisinger, our Fresh Food week using fresh fruits, vegetables, Farmacy™ program is showing us whole grains, lean meats and that grocery carts filled with lean other staple items. Patients work meats, whole grains and fresh fruits with care teams to set and meet and veggies are as effective as some goals to control their diabetes medications. and may receive food prep and meal planning advice, nutritional Type 2 diabetes is a major issue in guidance, health education classes the central Pennsylvania communi- and healthy recipes. ties we serve. To meet our patients with uncontrolled Type 2 diabetes We rely on data analytics to show where they are, we had to address a our Food Farmacies are improving key obstacle: food insecurity. Type population health, closing care 2 diabetes responds to a better gaps and reducing the cost of diet, but many of our patients with care. Data from our initial patients the condition regularly experience enrolled in our first Fresh Food hunger and/or don’t have money Farmacy in Shamokin, PA, shows for or access to healthy foods. those patients experienced an average two-point drop in HbA1c Our Fresh Food Farmacy program levels, along with lower weight, addresses those problems. We blood pressure, triglycerides opened our first Food Farmacy in and cholesterol. In comparison, 2016 and launched two more this common diabetes medications, on summer. The Farmacy average, help to lower a patient’s provides food HbA1c by a half point. for patients and their Published data shows there is an households $8,000 to $12,000 cost savings for to make 10 every one point in HbA1c reduction. meals per Applied to our results, we could 30
potentially see medical savings of services, including $16,000 to $24,000 per patient foot exams, per year. mammograms and colonoscopies. These patients also had 27% lower emergency room usage and 70% While frequent check-ups, as well lower hospital readmission rates, as devotion to prescribed therapies as well as higher participation in and physical-fitness regimens, can primary care and specialty care contribute to better outcomes, our services, compared with a similar Fresh Food Farmacy demonstrates unenrolled population. Patients that a proper diet can go a long way receiving eye exams increased toward enabling those with chronic more than 16%, and more patients illnesses to live healthier lives. participate in other preventive care Author Allison Hess is the Vice President of Health Innovations at Geisinger. A 12-year Geisinger veteran, she focuses on building transformative, scalable, measurable and sustainable solutions that improve health, care delivery and the patient experience while lowering cost. Allison earned her bachelor of science in health education with a concentration in psychology from Bloomsburg University. In addition to several certifications, she is currently pursuing her MBA and has been recognized for her leadership and employee engagement efforts within the organization. Allison can be reached at mediateam@geisinger.edu. Cognizanti • 31
Being both a provider and payer reading or high body mass enabled us to combine data index – that enable us to say captured in Geisinger Health Plan with confidence that he or she medical claims with clinical data in may be suffering from an as-yet the EPIC™ EHR and, in doing so, undiagnosed disease. Armed migrate from an analog process with this data during an exam, to a digital one. This enables us a physician can decide which to capture diagnosis information screenings or interventions are from the health claims. All the appropriate, and our care teams claims data funnels into a data and health coaches can help warehouse, which stores data from ensure these happen. a legacy health plan system, as well When we introduced the EHR- as claims data from the recently embedded application in 2017, implemented Cognizant TriZetto® we targeted our patients 65 years Facets® core administrative of age and older, many of whom platform. have multiple chronic and complex Using custom algorithms, we were conditions and visit their primary able to generate insights from care physicians several times a these combined data sets and year. We recently extended the deliver them to our physicians feature to cover patients with using AMP, which was developed disabilities, as well. and deployed in partnership with our innovation and care teams. When a physician pulls up a patient record, she accesses this application and information as part of her workflow right at the point of care. This makes it easier to keep an accurate and relevant record of a patient’s clinical conditions, thereby triggering the right interventions and care plan. With these data sets and algorithms, we can find clinical markers in a patient’s EHR – such as an elevated blood glucose 32
While the app and its underlying analytics, algorithms and data warehouse help streamline patient management for teams, a key ingredient in the primary care redesign was to make it easier for care teams to communicate regularly about the patient’s care. Keeping it simple complications is coded E11.9. But in a clinical record, physicians might To address physicians’ time write “Type 2” or “Type II” or “Type pressure, we introduced several Two.” Given this, we had to map program components that have the data carefully so that claims added to AMP’s success. For data could interact meaningfully example, the app’s user experience with the EHR. is optimized into the current workflow to decrease duplicate Daily, weekly and monthly effort; physicians tell us the application use reports, analytics interface is intuitive. We partnered and dashboards suggest that with our end-users to ensure the physicians have widely accepted product’s ease of use, including the app. The reports also help target the use of color cues, like red to individual teams or physicians who mark an item as incorrect. Ongoing exhibit sub-optimal app use. one-to-one and group training sessions emphasize the correlation Redesigning primary between closing care gaps and care with data more effective care teams. This The app is one aspect of our helps keep the focus on the clinical broader primary care redesign, problem, not the technology where we’ve implemented a solution. team-based care model for a We’ve had to overcome several defined patient panel. Instead challenges along the way. For of being a single practitioner, example, the health plan’s claims each physician is teamed with processing system captures data additional staff such as nurses, coded according to the ICD-9 case managers, health managers, or ICD-10 healthcare industry community health assistants coding standards. However, the and pharmacists, all supporting EHR system allows physicians comprehensive care for patients. more freedom in their note- While the app and its underlying taking verbiage. In the ICD-10 analytics, algorithms and data code set, Type 2 diabetes without Cognizanti • 33
warehouse help streamline patient Patients have benefited from the management for teams, a key app in many ways. For example, ingredient in the primary care physicians say their typical 15- to redesign was to make it easier 20-minute appointment blocks for care teams to communicate don’t provide ample time to regularly about the patient’s care. cover all their patients’ health For example, teams conduct daily issues, especially those with 10- to 15-minute huddle meetings, multiple chronic conditions. run by trained moderators, to Appointments would run long, plan their days as efficiently as making physicians late for other possible by being more proactive patients, or subsequent follow-up rather than being reactive. Items appointments would be needed covered may include appointment to cover missed topics, which cancellations and schedule increased inconvenience and cost. openings, newly discharged Physicians were bearing the brunt patients who need follow-up visits, of the stress of trying to manage patient calls for advice that indicate this situation. a need for a visit, or patients with Now, whenever a patient 65 multiple care gaps to address. years or older schedules a visit, Data drives the care teams. the system automatically blocks Whiteboards, aka “huddle boards,” double the appointment length, display aggregate data, results or 40 minutes instead of 15 or 20. and targets. Physicians use their While not every patient may need personal dashboards to identify that additional time, simply adding individual patients. Care gaps that a time cushion has taken some of aren’t addressed during a visit are the pressure off providers, who investigated promptly as “missed generally report a greater sense of opportunities.” fulfillment. We have rolled out that capability to all of our ambulatory care sites. Whenever a patient 65 years or older schedules a visit, the system automatically blocks double the appointment length, or 40 minutes instead of 15 or 20. While not every patient may need that additional time, simply adding a time cushion has taken some of the pressure off providers, who generally report a greater sense of fulfillment. 34
Anchoring new sometimes by shifting patients to other providers or recruiting new attitudes providers. The AMP app is an anchor for an This effort and others implemented extended program in which we at Geisinger are all part of the track every variable possible related value-based care model and to primary care. The goal has been outcomes-driven business model. to fully inform the primary care These models require much teams with all of the information more than simply getting away inputs available. To that end, the from using current procedural EHR needs to be as comprehensive technology coding widgets for as possible so the care teams can billing. They require changing the adapt the care plans accordingly. In physician culture and mindset, as turn, great care management helps well as addressing all the factors patients avoid chronic conditions, that affect a patient’s health. worsened symptoms, hospital admission or emergency room visits, Whether we are providing fresh all of which add to healthcare costs. produce to diabetic patients or developing a precision medicine Understanding the disease burden therapy, it’s our physicians and is also important for deploying primary care teams that connect care programs and resources our patients with these services. appropriately. The data helps us The app helps these teams, and better understand the patient load, our associates, successfully care or panel, each physician is carrying. for communities and individuals. Two physicians may each have a 2,000-patient panel, but if one group largely comprises younger, healthy patients vs. older patients with multiple chronic conditions, the workload will not be balanced. Previous procedures to monitor panel size and track patients didn’t ensure accurate, up-to-date primary care physician data in EHRs. Now, provider groups review records, and the physician who sees a patient the most frequently will have that patient attributed to him. The system also tracks provider productivity. Whether a provider’s panel seems overly light or heavy, it can be balanced, Cognizanti • 35
Authors Jaewon Ryu, M.D., J.D., is the President and CEO at Geisinger. Before coming to Geisinger, he served as president of integrated care delivery at Humana and previously held leadership roles at the University of Illinois Hospital & Health Sciences Systems and at Kaiser Permanente. Dr. Ryu received his undergraduate education at Yale University and his medical and law degrees from the University of Chicago, after which he completed his residency training in emergency medicine at Harbor-UCLA Medical Center. Karena Weikel, A.S.A., M.A.A.A., F.A.H.M., C.S.F.S., is Vice President, Risk and Revenue Management at Geisinger. She is a risk professional with 17 years of healthcare experience and is responsible for managing Geisinger’s overall cost of care, trend mitigation, data management, vendor relations, under- writing, provider economics, risk adjustment, operational and regulatory reporting, rate filing support, and organization-wide financial analytics for all lines of business. Juliann Molecavage, D.H.A., M.S.H.A., B.S.H.M., is Associate Vice President, Quality and Primary Care Services at Geisinger Health. Her focus is on quality, primary care practice redesign and information technology solutions and operations, and she has led many organization-wide strategic initiatives. Juliann graduated from Walden University with a doctorate in healthcare administration. She is responsible for overseeing quality initiatives for the Geisinger Medicine Institute as well as the implementation of new models of care for Geisinger. Rebecca A. Stametz, D.Ed., M.P.H., is the Associate Vice President, Product Innovation in the Steele Institute for Health Innovation at Geisinger. She directs a cross-functional, design-led department that deploys software engineering and advanced analytics to create and deliver enhanced value through health information technology throughout the care continuum. As a principal, her research focuses on program implementation, medical transparency, family-patient engagement and learning healthcare system models. Rebecca holds a master’s of public health from East Stroudsburg University and a doctorate of education in adult education from Pennsylva- nia State University. David Riviello is Senior Clinical Informatics Analyst in the Steele Institute for Health Innovation at Geisinger. His primary role in this initiative has been to advance the analytics and algorithms feeding AMP and measuring key performance indicators. David earned a B.S. in mathematics at Bloomsburg University. The authors may be reached at mediateam@geisinger.edu. 36
Scan the above image to hear Gary Beach’s thoughts on the future of learning. See inside cover for instructions to download the Cognizant AR app.
Commentary A Radical Rethink to Replenishing the Talent Pool By Gary Beach Four-year degrees are so old-school. To flood the workforce with the emerging skills needed today, businesses and employees alike need to relearn how to learn, with faster and less costly approaches to upskilling. All is not well in the global talent which finished last, was already arena. The digital “skills gap” that experiencing a skills imbalance. emerged earlier this decade is The first signs emerged in 1942, widening into a chasm. According when the U.S. War Department’s to International Data Corp’s Army General Classification Test Futurescape 2019 report, two indicated that 40% of Americans million jobs in artificial intelligence aged 17 to 24 had the cognitive (AI), the Internet of Things, cyber- ability of an 8-year-old.3 security and blockchain will remain By 1983, officials in the Reagan unfilled by 2023 due to a lack of Administration were so concerned human talent.1 Some experts claim that they commissioned a report the only solution is a structural entitled “A Nation at Risk,” whose reset focused on how individu- ominous conclusion warned: “Our als learn. Most agree that the once unchallenged preeminence transition won’t be easy. in commerce, industry, science That’s because the skills gap has and technological innovation is deepened over time. It started being overtaken by competitors in 1964, when the International throughout the world. … If an Association for the Evaluation of unfriendly foreign power had Educational Achievement fielded attempted to impose on America the First International Math Study the mediocre educational (FIMS), which ranked student performance that exists today, we math proficiency of students in 13 might well have viewed it as an developed countries.2 The U.S., act of war.”4 Cognizanti • 39
You can also read