SYMBIOSIS OF SMART OBJECTS ACROSS IOT ENVIRONMENTS - SYMBIOTE
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
nd
688156 - symbIoTe - H2020-ICT-2015 2 Open Call – Evaluation Criteria
Public
Symbiosis of smart objects across IoT
environments
688156 - symbIoTe - H2020-ICT-2015
2nd Open Call – Evaluation Criteria
The symbIoTe Consortium
Intracom SA Telecom Solutions, ICOM, Greece
Sveučiliste u Zagrebu Fakultet elektrotehnike i računarstva, UNIZG-FER, Croatia
AIT Austrian Institute of Technology GmbH, AIT, Austria
Nextworks Srl, NXW, Italy
Consorzio Nazionale Interuniversitario per le Telecomunicazioni, CNIT, Italy
ATOS Spain SA, ATOS, Spain
University of Vienna, Faculty of Computer Science, UNIVIE, Austria
Unidata S.p.A., UNIDATA, Italy
Sensing & Control System S.L., S&C, Spain
Fraunhofer IOSB, IOSB, Germany
Ubiwhere, Lda, UW, Portugal
VIPnet, d.o.o, VIP, Croatia
Instytut Chemii Bioorganicznej Polskiej Akademii Nauk, PSNC, Poland
NA.VI.GO. SCARL, NAVIGO, Italy
Universität Zürich, UZH, Switzerland
© Copyright 2017, the Members of the symbIoTe Consortium
For more information on this document or the symbIoTe project, please contact:
Sergios Soursos, INTRACOM TELECOM, souse@intracom-telecom.com
Version 1.0 Page 1 of 7
© Copyright 2017, the Members of the symbIoTend
688156 - symbIoTe - H2020-ICT-2015 2 Open Call – Evaluation Criteria
Public
1 Evaluation Criteria for symbIoTe-OC2-L1, symbIoTe-
OC2-L2 and symbIoTe-OC2-L3/4
Evaluation Categories:
(Number of rating stars = 5; threshold for each question = 3/5)
Request to Evaluators:
Please provide detailed comments justifying the provided scores
Section A: Basic Info Score:
(Threshold 3/5)
Team expertise
Please rate the expertise and profile of the team in relation to the
proposed solution.
Section B: IoT Solution Score:
(Threshold 9/15)
Impact of IoT solution
Please rate how innovative is the described IoT solution with respect to
the targeted business domains (markets), established clients and
achieved partnerships.
Clarity of business vision and ambition
Please rate how clear and ambitious the business vision of the applicant
is.
Maturity of the IoT solution involved and appropriateness of the
approach
Please rate how mature the described IoT solution is from a technical
perspective.
Section C: Innovation and impact Score:
(Threshold 6/10)
Clarity of the offered resources/services and alignment with
symbIoTe vision
Please rate how clearly the resources/services to be offered are
described and how aligned these offerings are with the symbIoTe vision.
Version 1.0 Page 2 of 7
© Copyright 2017, the Members of the symbIoTend
688156 - symbIoTe - H2020-ICT-2015 2 Open Call – Evaluation Criteria
Public
Extent of potential benefits from the involved IoT solution
Please rate how realistic and extensive are the envisioned benefits from
joining the symbIoTe ecosystem.
Section D: Implementation Score:
(Threshold 3/5)
Feasibility of work plan
Please rate how feasible is the work plan based on the requested
duration, budget and timing of deliverables.
Section E: Data Management Score:
Not applicable,
not addressed,
Soundness of approach with respect to management of poorly
sensitive/private data, if applicable addressed, well
Please rate how sound is the (planned) approach of the described IoT addressed
solution to manage the involved sensitive/private data, in relation to the
respective EU legislation.
Version 1.0 Page 3 of 7
© Copyright 2017, the Members of the symbIoTend
688156 - symbIoTe - H2020-ICT-2015 2 Open Call – Evaluation Criteria
Public
2 Evaluation Criteria for symbIoTe-OC2-Apps
Evaluation Categories:
(Number of rating stars = 5; threshold for each question = 3/5)
Request to Evaluators:
Please provide detailed comments justifying the provided scores
Section A: Basic Info Score:
(Threshold 3/5)
Team expertise
Please rate the expertise and profile of the team in relation to the
proposed solution.
Section B: IoT Application Score:
(Threshold 9/15)
Impact of IoT application
Please rate how innovative is the described IoT application with respect
to the targeted business domains (markets), established clients and
achieved partnerships.
Clarity of business vision and ambition
Please rate how clear and ambitious the business vision of the applicant
is.
Potential of the IoT application involved and appropriateness of the
approach
Please rate the potential and appropriateness of the described IoT
application is from a technical perspective.
Section C: Innovation and impact Score:
(Threshold 9/15)
Feasibility and alignment with symbIoTe ecosystem
Please rate how feasible the resources/services to be accessed are
within the symbIoTe ecosystem
Extent of potential benefits from the involved IoT application
Version 1.0 Page 4 of 7
© Copyright 2017, the Members of the symbIoTend
688156 - symbIoTe - H2020-ICT-2015 2 Open Call – Evaluation Criteria
Public
Please rate how realistic and extensive are the envisioned benefits from
joining the symbIoTe ecosystem.
Sustainability
Please rate the user engagement potential of the application and its
sustainability and potential of deployment in real life.
Section D: Implementation Score:
(Threshold 3/5)
Feasibility of work plan
Please rate how feasible is the work plan based on the requested
duration, budget and timing of deliverables.
Section E: Data Management Score:
Not applicable,
not addressed,
Soundness of approach with respect to management of poorly
sensitive/private data, if applicable addressed, well
Please rate how sound is the (planned) approach of the described IoT addressed
appliaction to manage the involved sensitive/private data, in relation to
the respective EU legislation.
Version 1.0 Page 5 of 7
© Copyright 2017, the Members of the symbIoTend
688156 - symbIoTe - H2020-ICT-2015 2 Open Call – Evaluation Criteria
Public
3 Evaluation Criteria for symbIoTe-OC2-Trials
Evaluation Categories:
(Number of rating stars = 5; threshold for each question = 3/5)
Request to Evaluators:
Please provide detailed comments justifying the provided scores
Section A: Basic Info Score:
(Threshold 3/5)
Team expertise
Please rate the expertise and profile of the team in relation to the
proposed solution.
Section B: Trial Info Score:
(Threshold 6/10)
Appropriateness of the end-user community
Please rate how appropriate is the community described and the
feasibility of the involvement plans
Quality and engagement level of the end-user community
Please rate the level of vitality of the community and the
representativeness of the end-user needs, as well as the applicant’s
experience with engaging such communities.
Section C: Innovation and impact Score:
(Threshold 6/10)
Extent of potential benefits for the involved community
Please rate how realistic and extensive are the envisioned benefits from
joining the symbIoTe ecosystem.
Community engagement and feedback
Please rate the potential of end-user engagement and the sustainability
of the community after the end of the extension, as well as the quality of
the feedback expected.
Section D: Implementation Score:
Version 1.0 Page 6 of 7
© Copyright 2017, the Members of the symbIoTend
688156 - symbIoTe - H2020-ICT-2015 2 Open Call – Evaluation Criteria
Public
(Threshold 3/5)
Feasibility of work plan
Please rate how feasible is the work plan based on the requested
duration, budget and timing of deliverables.
Version 1.0 Page 7 of 7
© Copyright 2017, the Members of the symbIoTeYou can also read
