Residential. A market on the rise - June 2018 - JLL
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
Contents 1. Macroeconomic and socio-demographic landscape 2. Financing 3. House purchase market 4. Developer market 5. Rental market 6. Solutions and disposal of non-performing assets 7. Case Studies 8. Residential clock 9. Zoom cities Appendix
Economic context The Spanish economy grew at a healthy Thanks to the creation of almost half Statistics Institute, the average salary pace in 2017. GDP was up 3.1% YoY, a million jobs in 2017, Spain proved to has grown 0,2% to reach €23,156.34 which is 60 basis points higher than the be one of the most dynamic Eurozone EU average of 2.5% YoY. countries in terms of job creation. Disposable income has already grown to reach €651,023 million, a rise of 10% This pace of economic expansion Salaries have been on a path of versus the low reached in 2013. According drove net job creation last year. The incipient recovery since 2013 following to Oxford Economics, this upward trend unemployment rate at the end of the a year-on-year decline of 0.8% in 2012 is set to continue over the next three last quarter of 2017 stood at 16.55%, during the economic crisis. According years. Disposable income is set to grow the lowest figure for eight years. to the latest data issued by the National at an average pace of 1.3% YoY. Residential Report Spain | 2018 5
GDP growth in Spain 5% 4% 3% 2% 1% 0% -1% -2% -3% -4% 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 Source: Oxford Economics Average annual salary 3.5% 3.0% 2.5% 2.0% 1.5% 1.0% 0.5% 0.0% -0.5% -1.0% 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 Source: INE (National Statistics Institute) Household disposable income in Spain 700,000 Millions of euros: 2010 prices 650,000 600,000 550,000 500,000 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 Source: Oxford Economics 6 Residential Report Spain | 2018
The uptick in employment, Spanish net improvement in lending terms and higher household disposable income, household wealth as well as an expansive monetary policy and low oil prices, have all bolstered economic activity in Spain. In 2017, domestic demand was up 2.8% year-on-year, thanks to the rise in household spending, the primary driver of economic activity. Households have also deleveraged €1,373,412M 2017 4Q since mid-2008, reducing debt levels from some €900 billion to €704 billion 3.8% YoY in February 2018. This reduction of around €200 billion since December 2008 (20%) is further explained by interest rate cuts and the consequently cheaper financing €1,322,863M 2016 4Q Household wealth has therefore returned to pre-crisis levels. According 3.3% YoY to the Bank of Spain, net household wealth in the fourth quarter of 2017 stood at €1,373,412 million, a rise of 3.8% on the same period in 2016. Source: Bank of Spain Residential Report Spain | 2018 7
The reduction in household debt and In addition to the uptick in domestic The economic fundamentals are resulting rise in net wealth has come demand, Spain also benefited from an positive and are driving the recovery against a backdrop of moderate extremely buoyant tourism sector, which of the residential property sector. average inflation of 2% per annum, is still booming after marking its fifth thanks primarily to low energy prices. record year in 2017 with 80 million foreign Investment in construction (in In the first quarter of 2018, inflation visitors. Tourist visitor numbers are up 6% terms of gross capital formation) ran out of steam and rose by just to March, versus the same period last year. continued to grow in 2017, rising 2.8%. 1%, according to preliminary data All these factors are leading to higher- The construction sector currently released by the INE. than-expected economic growth. represents 5% of GDP, in line with the Unemployment rate in Spain 30% 25% 20% 15% 10% 5% 0% 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 Source: INE and Oxford Economics 8 Residential Report Spain | 2018
European average (versus 12% in 2006- pace of growth will be slower at an monetary policy factors and the gradual 2007). Its contribution to GDP growth average of 2.9% per annum, according monetary normalisation process. was positive, adding 0.34 percentage to Oxford Economics, due to a number points to the growth of 3.1% posted of factors, such as weaker household The European Central Bank has last year. spending as unfulfilled demand that decided to scale back its bond had accumulated during the crisis purchase programme from 60 billion The positive macroeconomic begins to tail off. per month to 30 billion as of January indicators and the healthy outlook 2018. This measure will remain in for 2018 make Spain an ideal location The pace of job creation is expected to place until September 2018 or until to attract both international and remain constant at around 2.4% in 2018 the Governing Counsel observes a domestic capital. and 2019, which will translate into almost sustained shift in the path of inflation 850,000 new jobs and an unemployment that is compatible with the 2.0% The outlook for Spain in 2018 is positive rate of close to 10% by 2022. target. The interest rates applicable to and the country is set to remain one major financing transactions remain of the fastest-growing economies, The performance of the economy over unchanged at 0%, a situation that will not only in Europe, but globally. The the medium term will be determined by likely be extended until 2020. GDP growth in Europe 1.0% - 2.0% 2.0% - 3.0% 2.8% >3.0% 2.8% 1.8% 2.2% Eurozone 3.3% 5.2% 4.7% 1.9% 3.4% 1.7% 2.5% 4.2% 1.6% 2.7% 2.3% 3.6% 3.7% 3.3% 2.5% 4.1% 2.1% 2.4% 4.9% 4.4% 2.8% 3.4% 4.2% 2.2% 2.9% 1.5% 1.6% Source: in-house preparation based on Oxford Economics data Residential Report Spain | 2018 9
Socio-demographic backdrop After several years in negative territory, INE figures also show that the number those with five people or over – will the Spanish population is growing of homes in Spain will actually increase continue to recede, as they have done once more. According to the latest data by 902,663 (4.9%) from 2016 to 2031. in recent years. available (July 2017), the population This means an average of 60,000 homes now stands at 46,549,045, an increase will be built per annum to reach a total Meanwhile, the ageing population will of 0.2% on last year. figure of 19,281,354 by 2031. continue to be the norm in Spain. The percentage of the population aged 65 The Spanish Autonomous Communities The average household size will fall or over will rise from the current level to see the biggest population rises in 2017 from 2.50 people currently to 2.35 by of 18.7% to 25.6% in 2031 and 34.6% are the Balearic Islands (1.5%), Canary 2031. The smallest households (those in 2066. These socio-demographic Islands (1.0%) and Madrid (0.9%), while the made up of 1 or 2 people) will continue changes will impact the types of population fell in Extremadura, Castilla & to grow in the period 2016-2031, while homes that will be needed to meet Leon (-0.8% in both) and Asturias (-0.7%). the largest households – especially future requirements. 10 Residential Report Spain | 2018
Resident population in Spain 48,000,000 2.5% 47,000,000 Resident population of Spain 46,000,000 2.0% 45.000.000 44,000,000 1.5% % change 43,000,000 42,000,000 0.5% 41,000,000 40,000,000 0.0% 39,000,000 38,000,000 -0.5% 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 Change YoY Resident population of Spain Source: INE (National Statistics Institute). Resident population as at 1 January 2017 Change in the breakdown of homes by size (2016-2031) 35% 32.10 30.60 30% 28.60 25.10 25% 21 19.80 20% 5.70 4.10 15% 10% 5.70 4.10 5% 0% 1 occupant 2 occupants 3 occupants 4 occupants 5 occupants or more 2016 2031 Source: INE (National Statistics Institute) Residential Report Spain | 2018 11
02. Financing 12 Residential Report Spain | 2018 report Spain
Financing The number of new mortgages The amount of the average home granted continues to grow mortgage loan grew 5.9% in 2017 to reach €116.679. Although total debt continues to The number of mortgages taken out to buy a home in 2017 grew by 9.7% versus Mortgage lending continued to shrink, households and companies the year before to 310,096, according to INE grow in the first quarter of 2018 at are taking advantage of increased data. This is the fourth consecutive year-on- a rate of 5.6% YoY to total 84,073 liquidity levels and are once again year rise and the highest figure since 2011. new loans. The average loan taking out loans. In monetary terms, these loans totalled amount also increased by 5.3% 36,199,371 million, up 16.6% versus 2016. to €120,527. Informe Logística Residential Spain || 2018 ReportEspaña 2017 13
Number of mortgages and average amount in Spain Number of mortgages granted 1,400,000 175,000 1,200,000 150,000 Average amount (€) 1,000,000 125,000 800,000 100,000 600,000 75,000 400,000 50,000 200,000 25,000 0 0 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 Number of mortgages granted Average amount Source: INE (National Statistics Institute) The pick-up in financing is now a reality, although we are still considerably below the 1.2 million mortgages signed in 2007. Mortgages taken out in 2017 are barely a third of those signed at the height of the property boom, when more mortgages were granted than houses sold. The increase in new mortgage transactions is compatible with the gradual settlement of outstanding mortgage balances, thanks to an improvement in financing conditions: the average term of new mortgages is up in 2017, as is the loan-to-value ratio. However, both indicators are still some distance behind the all-time highs reached a number of years ago 14 Residential Report Spain | 2018
Average mortgage term (years): 2007 28.3 max 2003 21.2 min 2015 22.8 anual 2016 23.1 anual 2017 23.3 anual LTV ratio: 2004 65% max 2009 55.4% min 2015 62% anual 2016 63.9% anual 2017 65.1% anual Source: Bank of Spain Residential Report Spain | 2018 15
16 Residential Report Spain | 2018
The effort made by households to average mortgage rate to buy a home forecasted to remain at current levels repay their mortgages has registered a in 2017 was 2.2%, according to lender for the rest of the year, albeit with small substantial downward shift since 2012. data submitted to the Bank of Spain. rises as 31 December approaches, The mortgage affordability rate (the ratio all of which will depend on how the between the mortgage instalment before The 12-month Euribor rate – to which European Central Bank handles its deductions and gross household income) most Spanish mortgages are indexed expansive monetary policies. standed at 34.1% in 2017, versus the – has been in negative territory for two figure of over 50% during 2006 and 2007. years, specifically from 15 February Fixed-rate mortgages gain weight 2016 when it fell below 0% on a ahead of possible interest rate hikes. Lending rates climbed to over 6% in monthly basis for the first time. The 2008, over 3 percentage points higher benchmark index closed the month of According to the latest INE data (March than now. Lending rates have gradually April 2018 at -0.190%, an all-time low. 2018), fixed-rate mortgages represent come down since 2010 in line with All indicators suggest it will remain at 37.8% of all mortgages granted, cuts to the ECB benchmark rate. The under 0% for the rest of the year. It is compared to just 1% in 2007. Average mortgage affordability rate 80% 70% 60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0% 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 Source: Bank of Spain Interest rates for new mortgage loans: 7% 6% 5% 4% 3% 2% 1% 0% Sep-17 Jan-18 May-18 Jan-15 Sep-15 Jan-16 May-16 Sep-16 Jan-17 May-17 May-13 May-14 Sep-14 May-15 Jan-09 May-09 Sep-09 Jan-10 Mayn-10 Sep-10 Jan-11 May-11 Sep-11 Jan-12 May-12 Sep-12 Jan-13 Sep-13 Jan-14 Jan-08 May-08 Sep-08 Source: Bank of Spain Residential Report Spain | 2018 17
Percentage of mortgages taken out by interest rate 100% Fixed 90% Variable 80% 70% 60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0% 2015M01 2015M03 2015M05 2015 M07 2015M09 2015M11 2016M01 2016M03 2016M07 2916M09 2016M11 2017M01 2017M03 2017M05 2017M07 2017M09 2017M11 2018M01 2016 2017 Fixed 25.1% 38.1% Variable 74.9% 61.9% Source: INE (National Statistics Institute) Although the financing scenario A salient factor in the Spanish is set to impact the sales activity of has changed radically since the regulatory horizon is the entry into financial institutions (cross-selling will property crash, the number of force of the new Mortgage Law, which be restricted, as will other incentives house purchases going through is currently going through parliament to attract clientele). Revenue streams without any sort of financing has and is expected to be approved in will also be hit (fees and commissions) risen by 30% since 2007, when the second half of 2018. Once again, and banks will be forced to make their the mortgages granted actually this legislative initiative is aimed at mortgage clauses uniform. The new exceeded the number of real estate protecting consumers – in fact it only law also contains two provisions which transactions. The ratio of mortgages affects retail mortgage loans – and will have a major impact on the risk to real estate transactions has enhancing financial institutions' shouldered by the lender: the ease with stabilised somewhat. transparency. The new legislation which borrowers can switch to fixed- WIN-WIN FOR DEVELOPERS AND the return of some of those small and that we have witnessed it over recent FUNDS medium-sized developers with vast months with major developers debuting knowledge of their local market. However, on the stock market. The new element lies One of the direct consequences of the a shortage of the raw material – land within making the most of this win-win real estate and financial crisis in Spain with planning permission –, the reduced relationship – knowledge of the real estate between 2008 and 2014 was the almost financial muscle of these developers in and construction sectors on the one entire disappearance of the residential terms of making acquisitions and the hand, and the provision of finance on the development sector as it was known difficulties in securing bank financing to other – with smaller developers, whose at that time. This led to the decline leverage the acquisition of land to push sphere of influence and business is based and extinction of – whether through through residential projects is driving on a more local scale, by establishing bankruptcy or subsequent liquidation – of partnerships between “industrial” specific corporate investment vehicles the major listed developers, as well as the (residential developers) and “financial” created for a specific term. This enables lion’s share of residential developers with (investment funds) partners to jointly them to execute ongoing real estate a more local core. carry out real estate projects. projects with greater guarantees through the acquisition of land and subsequent The improvement in the residential This relationship is nothing new, given development of the project (leaning market across certain areas has sparked on bank loans during the construction 18 Residential Report Spain | 2018
rate or foreign currency mortgages and more stringent conditions for banks on foreclosure in the event of a default (see Appendix). Bank financing to developers is also recovering, although loans are only granted to the most solvent borrowers. With the exception of prime products, developer loans may not be used to finance the acquisition of land, but rather only to fund construction costs. Residential projects therefore require a level of shareholder equity that covers the purchase of the land, at the very least. Although there is no common framework and it largely depends on the characteristics of each project, it is still necessary to secure a certain level of off-plan sales before the banks will consider lending – somewhere in the region of 30% – to ensure the viability and success of the development. As regards loan-to-value ratios, developer loans are somewhere in the region of 70%, safely below pre-crisis levels. phase). This is a natural association that benefits both parties, thanks to the sharing of risk and which, little by little, is driving the recovery of the local development industry. Alberto Segurado Head of Debt Advisory JLL Spain Residential Report Spain | 2018 19
03. House purchase market 20 ResidentialReport Residential Spain | 2018 ReportSpain
Transactions The uptick in employment, increased on 2016. In line with the three previous total of 22,415 units sold across Spain. consumer confidence – which years, pre-owned sales have grown at surpassed 100 points in 2017 – and the figures in excess of 10%. The recovery of house sales is not improvement in financing conditions confined to large cities and coastal with all-time low mortgage rates However, 2017 also marked a turning areas popular with tourists. The continue to underpin house purchases. point for the sales of new-build recovery of the real estate market that properties, which were up 7.0% on the got underway in 2016 has continued House sales continue to grow. previous year. We are seeing positive into 2017 and spread to every corner of new-build sales figures for the the Iberian Peninsula. House sales soared 16.3% in 2017 first time in 10 years. New off-plan versus the previous year, registering sales are on the rise, which is driving With the exception of Ceuta and the largest year-on-year rise since 2014. new residential developments. The Melilla, all of Spain’s Autonomous Total house sales – both pre-owned take-up of existing stock has been Communities have registered year- and new-build – reached 532,367 uneven across the country. There is on-year rises in excess of 10%. The transactions, with the last quarter of now a lack of new, available stock in highest rises are to be found in Castilla the year the busiest. In fact, 2017 was Madrid and Barcelona, for instance, La Mancha (27.0%), Cantabria (26.5%) the best year since the property crash meaning both cities are now the focus and Navarra 22.2%). The smallest rises of 2007. for new developments. Sales of new were recorded in the Basque Country properties are therefore expected to (11.5%), Castilla & Leon (11.6%) and The house sales indicator has posted register an uptick in 2018. Extremadura (12.4%). As regards four years of consecutive growth. provincial capitals and municipalities Although accounting for a small slice with over 100,000 inhabitants, the Pre-owned homes were once again of the market (just over 4%), the highest growth could be found in the driving force behind this growth, purchase of subsidised housing also Albacete (43.7%), Parla (40%) and coming in at 481,969, a rise of 17.4% grew 5.9% last year versus 2016, with a Barakaldo (38.3%). Residential Report Spain | 2018 21
Forecasts point to the number of Household real-estate wealth rose GDP in the third quarter, according transactions continuing to rise to 12% in Q4 2017 to reach 425.56% to the last available data released reach an average of 600,000 homes of GDP, versus net financial wealth by the Bank of Spain. The numbers per annum over the next three years. which represented just 115.5% of reflect Spanish households' strong Evolution of the number of housing transactions 1,200,000 1,000,000 800,000 600,000 400,000 200,000 0 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 New-build Pre-owned Source: Ministry of Public Works and Transport 22 Residential Report Spain | 2018
preference for putting their money according to a living conditions survey is still higher than the European into property rather than financial conducted by the INE. Despite the average of 69.2%, according to the products. The home ownership ratio increase in the rental market, the latest Eurostat data (2016). is Spain currently stands at 77.1%, percentage of homeowners in Spain Percentage of housing transactions over the country total House purchases (% of total) < 1.0% 1.0 - 2.0% 2.0 - 4.0% 4.0 - 6.0% > 6.0% Source: Ministry of Public Works and Transport Residential Report Spain | 2018 23
Foreign demand Foreigners accounted for 13.11% of total house buyers in Spain in 2017, according to data from the Association of Property Registrars. This percentage held steady Ranking in 2017, which translates into a significant of foreign increase in absolute terms. buyers 2016 Foreign demand for housing in recent years reflects a recurring trend in terms of nationalities. 1. United Kingdom: 19.00% 6. Italy: 5.41% The British lead the ranking of foreign 2. France: 8.05% 7. Romania: 4.53% buyers, representing 15.01% of all 3. Germany: 7.69% 8. China: 4.53% purchases by non-Spanish nationals. However, the numbers have fallen 4. Sweden: 6.72% 9. Morocco: 3.00% slightly, most likely as a consequence 5. Belgium: 6.03% 10. Russia: 2.71% of Brexit and, more importantly, the Other: 32.3% performance of the pound sterling. If it were not for Brexit, foreign demand would likely have been higher still. The British are followed by French nationals, who registered an increase from the 8.05% in 2016 to 8.64% last year. In fact, this is the fastest growing nationality in absolute terms. They are followed by Germans (7.77%) and Belgians (6.39%). Prices are still extremely attractive for many foreign buyers, especially in certain coastal areas. We are therefore likely to see a constant arrival of foreign residents from a whole host of countries, especially other Europeans, looking to buy property in Spain, taking advantage of the favourable economic circumstances in a country that is a tourist hotspot. 24 Residential Report Spain | 2018
Foreign buyers as a % of market total 14% 12% 10% 8% 6% 4% 2% 0% 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 Source: Association of Spanish Registrars 1. United Kingdom: 15.01% 6. Italy: 5.77% 2. France: 8.64% 7. Romania: 5.34% 3. Germany: 7.77% 8. China: 4.38% 9. Morocco: 3.86% 4. Belgium: 6.39% 5. Sweden: 6.38% 10. Russia: 2.85% Ranking Other: 33.61% of foreign buyers 2017 Residential Report Spain | 2018 25
Prices Thanks to an improvement in the macroeconomic landscape and easier access to credit, the increased demand has not only triggered an increase in transactions, but also a boost to house prices in Spain, especially in large urban centres. According to the INE’s House Price Index, homes were 7.2% more expensive in 2017 versus the previous year. New- build prices were up 7.4%, while pre- owned house prices rose 7.2%, marking the fourth consecutive year of rising prices. This increase in house prices is much higher than the average increase in inflation, which is 2%. House prices were up across all of Spain’s Autonomous Communities. In just one year, house prices rose by over 10% in the regions of Madrid We expect house prices to rise and Catalonia. Castilla la Mancha and at an average rate of 3.80% Extremadura saw the lowest price YoY over the next three years. rises, registering an increase in prices of These rises will be higher under 0.5% YoY. in cities such as Madrid and Barcelona. House Price Index in Spain (% YoY) 10% 8% 6% 4% 2% 0% -2% -4% -6% -8% -10% 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 General New-build Pre-owned Source: INE (National Statistics Institute) 26 Residential Report Spain | 2018
Increase in house price index by Autonomous Community in 2017 (%) Madrid 11.9% Catalonia 10.2% Balearic Islands 9.8% Ceuta 8.0% Melilla 7.7% Spain 7.2% Basque Country 7.1% Canary Islands 6.0% Andalusia 4.5% Cantabria 4.4% Community of Valencia 4.1% La Rioja 3.6% Aragón 3.1% Galicia 2.9% Asturias 2,4% Castilla y León 2.3% Navarra 2.1% Murcia 1.9% Castilla - La Mancha 0.4% Extremadura 0.2% 0.0% 2.0% 4.0% 6.0% 8.0% 10.0% 12.0% Source: INE (National Statistics Institute) The price per square metre average of €1,804.2/sqm, whereas they At the other end of the spectrum, for non-regulated housing stood at an average of €1,550.7/sqm for the lowest prices were in the stood at €1,558.7/sqm in properties over five years old. province of Alicante, specifically the fourth quarter of 2017, the towns of Elda, Alcoy, Ontinyent according to data from the In municipalities of more than 25,000 and Crevillent, where prices failed Ministry of Public Works. inhabitants, the highest prices to exceed €600/sqm in the last were to be found in San Sebastian quarter of the year. However, the appraised value is still (€3,437.3/sqm), Sant Cugat del Vallés in €542.7/sqm lower than the all-time Barcelona (€3,060.5/sqm), Barcelona The average price for subsidised highs reached in the first quarter of (€3,053.6/sqm), Santa Eulalia del Río housing in Spain in the last quarter 2008. As regards properties under five on Ibiza (€3,004.9/sqm), Ibiza (€2,939/ of 2017 stood at €1,128.3 per years old, appraised values reached an sqm) and Madrid (€2,861.5/sqm). square metre. Residential Report Spain | 2018 27
Unit price (€/sqm) Unit price < 1,000 €/m2 1,000 - 1,250 €/m2 1,250 - 1,500 €/m2 1,500- 1,750 €/m2 > 1,750 €/m2 Source: own information based on Ministry of Public Works data. Includes both new and pre-owned homes. The affordability index, expressed as the number of years of the buyer’s full annual income to pay the median house price, stood at an average of 7 years in 2017, down from 9 between 2006 and 2008. Housing affordability index in Spain 9.5 9.0 8.5 Year´s salary 8.0 7.5 7.0 6.5 6.0 5.5 5.0 Nov-15 Apr-16 Sep-17 Feb-17 Jul-17 Dec-17 Sep-06 Feb-07 Jul-07 Dec-07 May-08 Oct-08 Mar-09 Aug-09 Jan-10 Jun-10 Nov-10 Apr-11 Sep-11 Feb-12 Jul-12 Dec-12 May-13 Oct-13 Mar-14 Aug-14 Jan-15 Jun-15 House price/gross rental level of dwelling Source: Bank of Spain 28 Residential Report Spain | 2018
Residential Report Spain | 2018 29
04. Developer market 30 Residential Report Spain | 2018 InfResidential
Developer activity Following the market downturn in recent Of the total permits issued in incipient recovery in 2014 (an years, the pick-up in demand is leading to a 2017, 61,337 were for flats (up increase of 42.5%) selective reactivation in the house building 30.8% year-on-year) and 19,411 sector. In certain locations, the demand were for single-family homes, a With respect to this year (January is having trouble finding new product or year-on-year rise of 13.2%. and February 2018), construction properties that meet their requirements. permits have grown 17.4% to Permits authorised for 15,000 on the same period last New residential construction permits the construction of new year, taking house building figures issued in 2017 amounted to 80,786, up homes have been rising for 4 back to 2011 levels. 26.2% in YoY terms. consecutive years following an New-build construction permits in Spain in 2017 Total Single-family residences Flats or apartments No. of permits 80,786 19,411 61,337 YoY change 26.2% 13.2% 30.8% Residential Report Spain | 2018 31
Number of new-build permits (housing) 700,000 600,000 500,000 400,000 300,000 200,000 100,000 0 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 Source: Ministry of Public Works However, the level of construction activity remains very low if compared to other countries, such as France and the Netherlands . Housing units under construction per 1,000 inhabitants 20 18 16 14 12 10 8 6 4 2 0 UK France Italy Netherlands Spain 2006 2008 2010 2012 2014 2016 2017 Source: Oxford Economics Housing units under construction per 1,000 inhabitants in Spain and France 20 15 10 5 0 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 1990 2015 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2016 2017 France Spain Source: Oxford Economics 32 Residential Report Spain | 2018
New-build construction permits in 2017 and YoY change 56.1% 28.4% 29.4% 1.9% 4.4% New-build permits -15.6% 53.8% 96.3% -5.0% < 500 9.5% 97.7% -59.8% -24.2% -17.6% 500 - 1,000 68.5% -17.4% 41.4% 1,000 - 2,500 7.0% 48.6% 15.6% -24.3% 22.8% 2,500- 5,000 > 5,000 27.6% -7.6% 23.3% -16.6% -4.9% 66.8% 15.7% Annual growth (2016-2017)]) -13.3% 15.7% Annual growth 3.4% -14.6% -26.6% 41.4% 61.9% -10.5% 67.5% -7.6% 22.7% 41.9% 22.5% 11.2% 115.6% 69.2% 87.0% -1.1% 50.5% 58.7% 81.2% 27.5% Source: JLL based on Ministry of Public Works data Developer activity is still insufficient factor into account, located in low is now forming, akin to what can be to meet structural demand, which is populated towns where there are found in France. estimated at around 150,000 new homes houses that are hard to be sell. under, according to Bank of Spain data. The need for new supply is leading to These homes will have to be built in Although the estimated market is fresh developer activity outside the areas where there is actually demand, smaller than during the boom years, mainstays of Madrid and Barcelona, unlike the pre-crisis years when homes when 800,000 homes were built per such as in Valencia, the Basque Country were built without taking that crucial year, a more mature and stable market and Andalusia. Residential Report Spain | 2018 33
Land market This upturn in developer activity well-established areas is driving land and another, and even between is being felt in the land market. prices upwards. two municipalities within the same In 2017, 20,789 urban land Autonomous Community. transactions were carried out, up The average land price per square metre 19.5% on 2016, and with a value in 2017 grew 0.8% on 2016 to stand The highest average land prices over of €3.503 billion, up 17.7% on the at an average of €162.2. The average the course of the year – in municipalities previous year. The land transacted transaction volume has also grown for with over 50,000 inhabitants – were represented a surface area of 27.41 the past four years (since 2013). registered in the province of Madrid million square metres, a year-on- (€290.3/sqm), the Balearic Islands year increase of 18%. Construction is picking up, but growth (€265.7/sqm) and Barcelona (€242.4/ is not uniform across the country. sqm). The lowest average prices were The greater activity and lack of There is a great deal of disparity registered in León (€46.5/sqm), Zamora land in large urban centres and in land prices between one region (€46.8/sqm) and Ávila (€53.7/sqm). Number and value of urban land transactions in Spain Number of transactions 50,000 25,000 45,000 40,000 20,000 Transaction value (M.€.) 35,000 30,000 15,000 25,000 20,000 10,000 15,000 10,000 5,000 5,000 0 0 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 Transaction value (right axis) Numer of transactions (left axis) Source: Ministry of Public Works 34 Residential Report Spain | 2018
The areas with most acute scarcity of land are Madrid, Barcelona, Valencia and Alicante, the Costa del Sol, Basque Country and Balearics. The residential land market is anything However, it is a different story in other These real estate developers require but uniform, which requires a micro-level parts of the country like in Castilla & a portfolio that is sufficiently scaled analysis that encompasses demand, León and Castilla La Mancha where to meet their 5-10 year business house prices and town planning issues. land prices are only seeing marginal plans. They therefore need to make Demand at the moment stems mainly increases or even shrinking. significant purchases of land, which is from those moving house or those beginning to run out in large cities, a buying homes as an investment. It We are therefore faced with a two- factor that leads them to take on land is concentrated in well-established speed market in which competition without planning permission. or tourist areas, which is translating is ever greater, leading many to focus into demand for land with planning much more closely on land under In the current year, developers are permission and a hike in prices in the management. expected to acquire land held by large aforementioned areas where available investment funds, which snapped land is in short supply. Due to this lack Leading property developers made up the banking sector’s toxic asset of land with planning permission in the various land purchases in 2017 for a portfolios. However, those funds and main urban and coastal areas, prices are total amount in excess of €600 million, the Sareb have already put their best expected to jump even higher in prime mainly in Madrid, Barcelona and assets on the market. and sought-after areas. coastal areas. Residential Report Spain | 2018 35
Leading players Funds International investment funds, which “Large listed companies have have led the acquisition of banks’ expressed considerable interest in asset portfolios since the onset of assets held by investment funds, so the crisis, have become the leading it is likely that they’ll put together owners of land, a scarce resource large portfolios valued somewhere now in Spain. They are estimated to in the region of between 200 and hold land valued at over €15 billion 500 million euros. However, we’ll and are expected to gradually begin also see one-off deals taking place. putting products on the market We could also see the emergence of during the second half of 2018. wholesale buyers of land, who would sell to smaller or local companies The large funds that acquired assets any assets deemed non-strategic, from the banking sector in 2017 those located in unfamiliar areas or are therefore expected to become products in less mature phases of leading players in the land market, development”. through sales of either individual assets or portfolios to developers. Enrique Losantos The plots set to come on the market CEO JLL España are in prime locations such as Madrid, Catalonia and the coast, but also in other parts of the country, like Galicia, Seville and Zaragoza, that are also beginning to see activity and which are of interest of property companies. 36 Funds Residential Report Spain | 2018
Developers The recovery of the residential Metrovacesa market has spurred on the creation The company is owned by Santander and BBVA and was relisted on the stock of new players, thanks to strategic market in February 2018. It is the developer with the largest land portfolio. agreements, joint ventures or The company has six million square metres of land and the ability to develop corporate deals between international 37,500 homes, expecting to hand over between 4,500 and 5,000 units by funds and local developers. 2021. The developer plans to hand over 520 units this year compared to 110 last year. The latest examples in 2017 include the acquisition of 75% of Inmoglaciar by Cerberus, the purchase of Habitat Neinor by Bain Capital and Värde’s acquisition of Vía Célere. This was the first developer to list on the stock market in March 2017. It holds 1.3 million sqm to build 12,000 homes and plans to hand over 2,500 However, following this early phase of during the course of 2018. intense investor activity, we are now seeing IPOs and a consolidation of the developer market. Following its Aedas acquisition of Vía Célere, Värde carried An investee of US fund Castlelake, Aedas has 1.5 million square metres of out the first major consolidation deal, land to build 13,270 homes. The company plans to hit its cruising speed of approving the merger of its acquired 3,000 homes per annum in 2022. asset with DosPuntos, which was spun off from the now defunct Parquesol. The new holding company is now Vía Célere lining up its stock market debut. The company controlled by Värde has 1.43 million square metres for some 12,200 homes. The 20 most important companies in the sector, which include the recently listed Neinor, Aedas and Metrovacesa, Aelca together with Aelca, Vía Célere, ASG The other company controlled by Värde has 1.28 million square metres for and Amenabar, have sufficient land to some 13,000 homes. It plans to launch 49 new developments in 2018 with develop 80,000 homes over the next around 3,700 homes. few years. Amenabar A survivor of the financial crisis, the company registered the highest amount of new homes in 2017: 700 units. It is also the company that plans to begin construction on the largest number of new homes this year: 3,000 units. The market remains highly fragmented and M&A activity is expected in the coming years in a bid to consolidate. Developers Residential Report Spain | 2018 37
Leading developers and work in the pipeline 2018-2020 38 Residential Report Spain | 2018
Ranking Developer Units 1 Metrovacesa 12,600 2 Neinor Homes 10,250 3 Aedas Homes 9,850 4 Via Célere 6,200 5 Aelca 5,750 6 Activum SG Iberia 5,000 7 Acciona Inmobiliaria 4,500 8 Amenábar 3,750 9 KRONOS 3,750 10 CORP 3,000 11 Pryconsa 2,850 12 Q21 Real Estate 2,550 13 Quabit 2,250 14 Ibosa 2,200 15 Inbisa 2,100 16 ACR 1,800 17 Realia 1,650 18 Momentum RE 1,500 19 Inmobiliaria del Sur 1,175 20 Grupo Lar 780 Total 83,505 Source: Coordinated Institute of Governance and Applied Economics – July 2017 The present and future of residential land Investment in land during 2017 reached Pamplona, Zaragoza, Bilbao, San be able to meet their own demand 3.5 billion euros, up 18% versus the Sebastian and Alicante, will benefit and that of others. Both options previous year, across almost 21,000 from the shortage of land in major are appealing as the risk is more transactions. This is a clear reflection of cities and current investor appetite. manageable than in the traditional the growing interest. acquisition of land without planning The direct acquisition of land with permission, where the local authorities Given the lack of supply in other planning permission is complicated. called the shots. markets, which have become drained, Price increases, competition among investors have turned their attention to investors, the emergence of new types The “living” sector is expected to be residential land. This asset represented of players and other factors such as the main attraction over the coming 42% of total investment in 2017, up from rising construction costs are some of years. We will continue to see deals the 32% witnessed in 2016. the main reasons for this. As a result, for residential land and student the market is seeking alternative accommodation, both of which are The demand for residential land goes avenues when it comes to investing: established markets. From this point hand-in-hand with an improvement in acquisitions of companies, stock on, Spain will follow in the footsteps the Spanish economy, as well as buyers’ market debuts, the acquisition of land of other countries in terms of deals capacity to purchase a home. In 2017, without planning permission and last which provide “alternative living the number of approved projects in year’s favourite, the acquisition of large, solutions” such as co-living and Spain reached the 80,000 home mark. debt-laden asset portfolios. build-to-rent. This leads us to expect that key interest In order to unearth new products in will continue to be concentrated in the short term, the major funds which cities such as Madrid, Barcelona, Seville, acquire these portfolios will first seek Maria de la Puerta Valencia and Malaga. Nevertheless, to clear up the assets' legal status and Head of Residential other cities with less activity in this then divest. In addition, the companies Land, JLL Spain regard, such as Santander, Burgos, investing in land-use management will Residential Report Spain | 2018 39
05. Rental market 40 Residential Report Spain | 2018 InfResidential
A market snapshot Although property ownership In fact, 13.8% of Spanish homes are years), while in 2007 only 28.4% of reigns supreme in Spain, the rental rented at market price (16.3% if all young people lived in rented homes, market has been gaining ground types of renting are taken into account a hike of 19.4% over the last decade. in recent years, driven primarily by and 22.8% if the free transfers are In terms of the 30-44 year-old group, younger people. included too). This figure increases to 15.8% lived in rented homes in 2007, 50% among the youngest group (16-29 versus 24.2% in 2017, a rise of 8.4%. Rented homes at market price by age group 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0% 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 16-19 years 30-44 years 45-64 years Total Source: Living conditions survey, Spanish National Statistics Institute Residential Report Spain | 2018 41
Many Spanish nationals do not have In fact, the weighting of rented homes rental or co-op amount for a sufficient savings to pay a deposit or is lower than the European average minimum 25-year period. face difficulties in accessing financing, (19.2%, and a far cry from countries which coupled with a shift in mentality such as Switzerland (50.2%), Germany ıı Pave the way for the young and socio-demographic changes, (39.9%) and Denmark (37.9%)) population to access adequate means that the rental market will and respectable rented housing. continue to thrive. The 2018-2021 State Housing Plan comprises nine programmes, of ıı Ensure that the elderly The State Housing Plan (see table) sets which four are geared towards population are able to enjoy out a series of subsidies for young, low promoting the idea of renting with the adequate and respectable income tenants and developers looking following objectives: rented or co-operative to grow the rental market in Spain, housing at capped prices via which remains less mature than in ıı Contribute to an increase in the the promotion of residential neighbouring countries. amount of public and private complexes with specially- rented or co-operative homes adapted facilities and available, setting out a maximum communal services. Rented homes at market price by European countries 60 50 % of rented homes 40 30 20 10 0 Switzerland Germany Spain Denmark Sweden Luxembourg Greece EU 28 UK Italy Czech Republic Cyprus Netherlands Austria Belgium France Ireland Finland Portugal Norway Slovakia Latvia Slovenia Poland Hungary Estonia Malta Croatia Romania Lithuania Source: Eurostat 42 Residential Report Spain | 2018
Residential Report Spain | 2018 43
State Housing Plan In order to meet its objectives, the specifically programmes 2, 4, 8 and and grants for developers, young State Housing Plan 2018-2021 – 91 – envisage a series of subsidies tenants and those on low incomes. Programme 2: Subsidies to rent a home Facilitate access to and long-term occupancy of rental accommodation for low-income segments of the population Scope of the subsidies ıı In general cases: up to 40% of the monthly rent Eligible persons ıı Those over 65: up to 50% of monthly rent Tenants ıı Subsidy of up to 30% in the tranche spanning €601 to €900 in certain circumstances determined by Spain’s Autonomous Communities Requirements Primary and permanent residence Income threshold: ıı 3x IPREM (Benchmark index for the calculation of subsidies) ıı 4x IPREM: general large family category and people with disabilities ıı 5x IPREM: special large family category and people with a certain degree of disability. Rental ceiling: ıı Generally €600 per month ıı €900 per month in certain circumstances that are determined by Spain’s Autonomous Communities. 1 See https://www.fomento.gob.es/MFOM/LANG_CASTELLANO/DIRECCIONES_GENERALES/ARQ_VIVIENDA/APOYO_EMANCIPACION/ POLITICAVIV/ for further details 44 Residential Report Spain | 2018
Programme 4: Foster creation of rental stock Foster the creation of publicly or privately-owned homes (new or following refurbishment) to be allocated to the rental or co-operative markets for a minimum term of 25 years. Eligible persons Natural persons of legal age. Scope of the subsidies Public authorities, public and private bodies and entities, ıı Option 1: up to public, private or semi-private companies and other €36,750 per residence companies in which the Public Authorities hold a stake. capped at 50% of the investment Foundations, social enterprises and their associations, housing ıı Option 2: up to cooperatives, NGOs and public interest associations and €31,550 per residence those referred to in the fifth additional provision of the Local capped at 40% of the Authorities Act 7/1985 of 2 April. investment Rental contract requirements Primary and permanent residence Income threshold of the tenants: ıı Option 1: up to 3x IPREM ıı Option 2: up to 4.5x IPREM Rental price: ıı Option 1: up to €5.5 per square metre ıı Option 2: up to €7 per square metre Residential Report Spain | 2018 45
Programme 8: Subsidy programme for the young Afford access to decent and suitable housing for those aged under 35, be it for rental properties or through direct subsidies to buy a home in municipalities of less than 5,000 inhabitants. Scope of the subsidies • Rental subsidies Eligible persons ıı Up to 50% of monthly rent ıı Up to 30% on the tranche between €601 and €900 Those aged under 35 • Help-to buy-scheme ıı Up to €10,800 capped at 20% of the purchase price (less than €100,000).. Requirements Rental subsidies: Primary and permanent residence Total household income must be less than: ıı 3x IPREM in the general category ıı 4x IPREM general large family category and people with disabilities ıı 5x IPREM special large family category and people with a certain degree of disability ıı Maximum monthly rent of €600 ıı Maximum monthly rent of €900 in certain circumstances determined by Spain’s Autonomous Communities Help-to-buy scheme: ıı Primary and permanent residence ıı Total household income must be less than: •3x IPREM in the general category •4x IPREM general large family category and people with disabilities • 5x IPREM special large family category and people with a certain degree of disability ıı Purchase price of under €100,000 46 Residential Report Spain | 2018
Programme 9: Programme to foster the creation of homes for the elderly and those with disabilities Foster the creation or refurbishment of homes to be allocated for a minimum term of 40 years to the rental or co-operative markets for elderly or disabled tenants, providing them with adapted facilities and communal services. Eligible persons Scope of the subsidies Public authorities, public and private bodies and entities, public, private or semi-private companies and other ıı Up to €400 per square companies in which the Public Authorities hold a stake. metre of usable living space capped at 40% Foundations, social enterprises and their associations, of the investment housing cooperatives, NGOs and public interest associations. Requirements Primary and permanent residence ıı Those aged over 65 or with a disability ıı Income of less than 5x IPREM (total household income)) ıı Not property owners ıı Net worth or assets of under €200,000 ıı Rental price/assignment per month: up to €9.5 / sqm of usable living space Residential Report Spain | 2018 47
Rental levels Demand for rented housing continues recommended by the Bank to rise in a market where supply has of Spain. traditionally been held by private individuals and where the existence Increases in rental levels of large rented housing portfolios and the price per square managed by companies is still at a metre are somewhat varied premium. There is not enough supply according to location, as (or quality is low) to satisfy the demand, double-digit growth figures which is driving rental prices upwards. in cities contrast with those in medium-sized centres, which As with purchase prices, rental prices are considerably lower or where have been rising sharply over the prices are still actually falling. last two to three years. According to data published by Idealista, prices Prices will continue to rise in Spain rose by 8.8% in Q1 2018 to throughout 2018 in the country’s €10.60 per square metre per month. major urban hubs, thanks to This represents an 18.3% hike YoY. high demand and a scarce According to our forecasts, the supply of quality products. In average price is set to increase by Madrid for example, rental levels 6.1% over the next three years. have grown by 11% versus 2016, while Barcelona prices are up by Despite the increases of prices, the 8%. The price per square in these housing affordability rate stands at cities is significantly higher than the 18%, still well below the 30% maximum nationwide average. Price per square metre, rented housing 20.0 € 19.0 € 18.0 € 17.0 € 16.0 € 15.0 € 14.0 € 13.0 € 12.0 € 11.0 € 10.0 € 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 Madrid Barcelona Source: Idealista 48 Residential Report Spain | 2018
Price per square metre, rented housing Unit price, rented housing (€/sqm) < 6.0 €/sqm 6.0 - 8.0 €/sqm 8.0 - 10.0 €/sqm 10.0- 12.0 €/sqm > 12.0 €/sqm Source: JLL based on Idealista data Residential Report Spain | 2018 49
Yields on buy-to-let homes In a landscape of low interest rates, Occupancy in the assets of major professionalism within the sector. the yields offered on buy-to-let portfolios is in the region of 85-90%, homes are high in comparison to with tenant turnover equalling 35% Investment in rented housing is those generated by other financial and OPEX amounting to approximately witnessing a radical transformation products. 15 to 20% of rental levels. The average with the creation of Socimis [Reits] period of a property lying empty and entry of institutional investors According to Bank of Spain figures, before a new rental contract is signed into what until now has been an investment in residential property fluctuates between six weeks and three underdeveloped sector in Spain. offered a gross rental yield of 4.2% in months, depending on location. Q4 2017. This figure jumps to 11.4% Several residential Socimis specialising if the rise in property prices over the The growth of the rental market, in rentals have entered into the market. last 12 months is taken into account. increase in rental levels and yields These yields are in stark contrast to on offer are sparking investor One of the major players is Testa the 1.5% earned on 10-year bonds. interest and triggering greater Residencial, the biggest residential Listed (REIT - LISTED MAB) Mkt Cap (€M) 2017 Housing units FIDERE 255.5 2,001 Albirana 168 5,000 ELAIA 119 41 Entrecampos cuatro 98.4 215 Grupo Ortiz 75.3 352 VITRUVIO 68.2 n.d. OPTIMUM 59.9 n.d Hadley 56 355 OPTIMUM III 54.5 121 QUONIA 44.2 n.d. VBARE 28.9 131 AL BRECK SOCIMI (RREF II) 27 639 Colon Viviendas 19.6 298 Domo Activos 7.7 80 PROMORENT 3.7 11 Total 1,085,9 9,244 Unlisted (REIT - NOT LISTED MAB) Housing units Testa Residencial 9,041 Tempore Properties 1,500 Rembrandt Activos Residenciales 491 Quid Pro Quo 158 Elix n.d. Total 11,190 50 Residential Report Spain | 2018
Socimi in Spain with 9,000 rented Testa Residencial, Albirana in the management of these homes and a portfolio valued at 2.2 Properties, Fidere (the latter two assets. billion euros, which is planning to are both owned by Blackstone) and debut on the stock market in mid-2018. Témpore are the leading Socimis in Major institutional investors require terms of rented homes owned. sizeable batches of assets in order to The Socimi, conceived in 2016 as a joint optimise operating costs. venture between Merlin and the banks Nevertheless, the market remains with shares in Metrovacesa, reached an fragmented and the banks continue Socimis such as Testa or servicer agreement in 2017 with Acciona to add to hoard large portfolios of homes. Azora are seeking to swell their 1,058 new homes to its portfolio, on asset portfolios by creating rented top of the 1,500 homes to be included One of the main obstacles faced homes through joint projects with on the back of a recent agreement by the sector is a lack of entire developers and construction firms. signed by BuildingCenter, the real buildings of rented homes which estate arm of CaixaBank. would facilitate increased efficiency Residential Report Spain | 2018 51
06. Solutions and divestment of non performing assets 52 Residential Report Spain | 2018
Backdrop to the solutions - financial systems. Some of the association with international funds major milestones in this process have to create professional servicers to developed to reduce the included: maximise retail disposals. non-performing assets in the financial system ıı The need for bailouts or resolution ıı The start of an institutional market of many entities, creating new for divestment of assets through entities to achieve this (FROB, portfolios of non-performing loans In the earlier sections of this report, JUR) under various memoranda of (NPLs) and real estate assets (REOs) we have detailed the weaknesses in understanding in the sector. risk management in financial entities These milestones have been and the collapse in the real-estate ıı The creation of a Spanish Bad Bank developing since 2011-2012, with 2017 market since its 2007 peak, and how (SAREB) to manage non-performing seeing the largest volume or non- these have resulted in a massive stock assets in the real estate sector performing assets traded in the market of non-performing assets - mostly originated by entities reporting to from the balance sheets of financial secured against real estate - in Spain's the FROB. entities and SAREB. financial entities. ıı Segregation of duties in banks The pro forma situation of non- Managing these non-performing assets that were not bailed out, for the performing assets in the Spanish has been an enormous challenge for management and divestment of non- system at year-end 2017 is shown the Spanish - and indeed European performing assets, including cases of below. Distressed assets (%) - December 2017 2,8 2,2 1,5 4,0 4,1 30,1 4,7 Santander ES (+Popular) Liberbank 4,9 Caixabank Unicaja Bankia (+BMN) Kutxabank 11,4 Sabadell Ibercaja BBVA ES Abanca 28,5 Cajamar Bankinter 16,3 19,7 35 REOs 30 NPLs 25 20 15 10 5 0 Caixabank Bankia (+BMN) Sabadell BBVA ES Cajamar Liberbank Unicaja Kutxabank Ibercaja Abanca Bankinter Santander ES (+ Popular) *Figures in billion € Source: own elaboration based on the data of each financial institution Residential Report Spain | 2018 53
Disposal of non-performing assets in 2017 The disposal of assets in 2017 included a number of flagship international transactions, resulting in a new focus for both sellers and investors: Project Horizon BBVA, Santander and Banco Popular Promoción), and seeking liquidity for relationship and the advice when the contributed land to Metrovacesa Suelo these through the capital markets. new company was floated. y Promoción to maximise the value of its assets, through development of The total value of land in this deal In line with this deal, both SAREB and thousands of homes over the coming was around €1.25 billion. JLL was Solvia/Sabadell have announced years, thus transforming a real estate the main advisor for both the sellers similar strategies, based on land asset into a holding in a property (financial entities) and the buyer banks and how they can be turned developer (Metrovacesa Suelo y (Metrovacesa), continuing the into vehicles. Project Quásar Following the resolution and sale of retain 49% of the capital, and which after completion of the Santander Banco Popular, the purchaser (the includes both foreclosed assets and deal. JLL was also part of the pool of Santander Group) disposed of all of NPLs in its scope. advisors for the buyer (Cerberus). the bank's non-performing real estate exposure, in a process organised by With an approach similar to Quasar, Similarly, although on a smaller scale, Morgan Stanley. This deal - which was although in a bilateral format with Liberbank disposed of a large chunk of worth over €10 billion at market value (with a gross value of more than €30 no need for an organised process, its non-performing real estate assets in billion) - was agreed with Blackstone, BBVA disposed of €5 billion (at market a vehicle acquired by Bain Capital, with with JLL as the lead advisor, in the form value, €17.8 billion gross value) of non- the participation of the bank and one of a vehicle in which Santander will performing real estate assets, shortly of its benchmark shares (OceanWood). 54 Residential Report Spain | 2018
You can also read