PREVENTION OF HIV INFECTION THROUGH VACCINATION: RESEARCH DIRECTIONS AND LIMITS
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
PREVENTION OF HIV INFECTION THROUGH VACCINATION: RESEARCH DIRECTIONS AND LIMITS Viorela-Ioana Nicolae1,2, Edgar-Costin Chelaru1,2, Ștefan-Decebal Guță1,2* Costin-Ștefan Caracoti1,2, Alexandru-Andrei Muntean1,2 1 Carol Davila University of Medicine and Pharmacy, Bucharest, Romania 2 Cantacuzino National Medico-Military Institute for Research and Development, Bucharest, Romania ABSTRACT Human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) is a circular retrovirus that belongs to the Lentivirus genus. Through multiple mechanisms, the virus penetrates and replicates inside host cells, causing a chronic infection in humans, with a long latency period and multiple pathological implications, an example being AIDS (acquired human immunodeficiency syndrome), a serious condition that progressively destroys the body’s immune system. There is currently no curative treatment for this infection, antiretroviral therapy (ART) being the only control of virus replication and transmission. Although new therapies provide a longer life expectancy than in the past, many people living with HIV remain undiagnosed or are diagnosed late. For this reason, HIV infection is an important medical problem worldwide; the latest research in this field aiming at developing a vaccine intended to prevent HIV infection. This review follows some of the current studies aimed to prevent HIV infection through vaccination and the limits encountered in their development. At the end of the paper some promising directions for the future of this field are presented. Keywords: HIV, prevention, vaccine, viral vector, human monoclonal antibody, DNA REZUMAT Virusul imunodeficienței umane (HIV) este un retrovirus circular ce face parte din genul lentivirusurilor. Prin multiple mecanisme virusul pătrunde și se replică în interiorul celulelor gazdă, provocând la om o infecție cronică cu o perioadă lungă de latență și multiple implicații patologice, un exemplu fiind SIDA (sindromul imunodeficienței umane dobândite), o afecțiune gravă ce distruge progresiv sistemul imun al organismului. În prezent nu există un tratament curativ pentru această infecție, terapia antiretrovirală (ART) fiind singura formă de controlare a replicării și transmiterii virusului. Deși noile terapii asigură o speranță de viață mai lungă decât în trecut, multe persoane care trăiesc cu HIV rămân nediagnosticate sau sunt diagnosticate târziu. Din acest motiv, infecția HIV este o problemă medicală importantă la nivel mondial, ultimele cercetări în acest domeniu îndreptându-se către realizarea unui vaccin ce are ca scop prevenirea infecției HIV. În acest review sunt studiate o parte din studiile de actualitate ce au ca scop cercetarea în vederea prevenției infectării cu virusul HIV prin vaccinare și limitele întâmpinate în urma desfășurării acestora. În finalul articolului sunt prezentate și câteva direcții promițătoare pentru viitorul acestui domeniu. Cuvinte-cheie: HIV, prevenire, vaccin, vector viral, anticorpi monoclonali umani, ADN INTRODUCTION The human immunodeficiency virus analysis it was concluded that LAV and HTLV (HIV) is part of the Retroviridae family, III were identical and were named HIV. In 1986 genus Lentivirinae. As a clinical entity, the followed the discovery of LAV-2 or HTLV IV, HIV infection was reported in 1981, and the which was later called HIV-2 [1-2]. etiological agent was isolated in 1983 and named Over time, various hypotheses have Lymphadenopathy Associated Virus (LAV). emerged about the origin of the virus. The Shortly afterwards, in 1984, a T-cytopathic human immunodeficiency virus is divided retrovirus was isolated and grouped as HTLV into two types, called HIV-1 and HIV-2 [1]. III. Further, through cloning and sequence It has recently been shown that they emerged * Corresponding author: Guță Ștefan-Decebal, e-mail: guta.stefan.decebal@gmail.com ROMANIAN ARCHIVES OF MICROBIOLOGY AND IMMUNOLOGY, Volume 79, Issue 3, pp 195-208 July-September 2020 195
NICOLAE et al. naturally, being transmitted from primates to response) [1, 6]. humans. Molecular tests were able to compare From an epidemiological point of view, human immunodeficiency viruses and similar HIV-1 is responsible for 95% of infections in simian viruses, as well as their phylogeny. the world and includes 4 groups: M, the major Initially, the results showed that HIV-2 came group, and N, O, P which are less common. from West Africa, from the Sooty Mangabey M group (main) comprises the viruses most monkey species, and it has subsequently been frequently involved in infections and is further proved that the most probable source for HIV-1 divided into subtypes: A1, A2, A3, A4, A6, B, C, is a subspecies of chimpanzee, Pantroglodytes D, F1, F2, G, H, J, K. In addition, viruses from troglodytes from Central Africa [2-3]. different subtypes can combine their genetic The earliest evidence of human infection is material to form a hybrid virus, classified as a from a blood sample collected in 1959 in D.R. ‘circulating recombinant form’ (CRF). N group of the Congo, containing an HIV-1 strain [4]. (non-M, non-O) includes distinct viral strains, Considering that the virus looks like a precursor isolated from only a few people in Cameroon. to current strains of HIV in the world and the These appear to be recombinant forms between high rate of errors produced at the time of viral an HIV-like virus and an SIV-like virus, which replication, it can be estimated that the time of suggests that recombination between the two transmission from monkey to man occurred viral species and / or overcoming the species before 1940 [5]. barrier is possible, with the emergence of new HIV has a genome consisting of two identical viral types with unpredictable pathogenic single-stranded, linear, positive-sense RNA capacity. O group (outlier) is responsible for molecules. The major antigens of the viral some of the infections in Central and West envelope are gp 160 and the cleavage products, African countries or countries that had colonies gp 120 and gp 41, these being the first to come in this area. The differences from M group are into contact with the defence factors. The many, especially in the envelope and the pol mechanism through which it enters the body is gene, which encodes the reverse transcriptase, mediated by CD4+ receptors, which are present led to difficulties in diagnosis and treatment. on the surface of leukocytes, endothelial cells P group (‘pending the identification of further and gastrointestinal epithelial cells. In the human cases’) is the newest, formed in 2004. In cell, the virus envelope is formed using the 2009, its resemblance to a recently discovered host’s intracellular resources, thus integrating SIV in gorillas was pointed [3, 7-10]. some of the membrane proteins of the host cell HIV-2 is less prevalent and pathogenic such as molecules encoded by the HLA I and and comprises 8 groups marked from A to H, II genes. Also, through a peptide that binds the main ones being A and B. In this type, simultaneously to MHC II molecules and to the recombinant strains are rare; the first case of CD4 lymphocyte receptor, HIV behaves as a HIV-2 CRF was described in 2010 [9-10]. superantigen [1, 6]. Starting with the last part of the 20th century, CD4+ T-helper lymphocytes are the only HIV infection became a problem of maximum cells in which the virus replicates in high titers, importance, spreading very fast within 10 years. macrophages being also susceptible, but in In 1992, WHO data showed that 10-12 million much lower infectious titers. A major feature people were infected. According to UNAIDS of this retrovirus is the genetic variability that (United Nations Program on HIV / AIDS), in predominates especially in the env gene due 2019 the number of people with this infection to hypervariable regions and this represents was approximately 38 million, of which about a problem both to the existing treatment and 1.7 million were new cases, and 690.000 people to the implementation of a vaccine to prevent died of AIDS [11]. infection. CD4+ T helper lymphocytes have a The overall incidence peaked at 3.3 million central role in the host’s immune response to infected per year in 1997. It continued to HIV infection, by activating antibody-secreting decline to 2.6 million per year in 2005, and B lymphocytes (humoral-mediated response) then remained constant until 2015. At the last and cytotoxic lymphocytes (cell-mediated measurement in 2019, a decrease was observed, 196
Prevention of HIV infection through vaccination reaching an incidence of 1.7 million [11]. The most affected area remains Africa, where The most affected are the sexually active according to estimates in 2019 the following people aged between 20 and 40, followed by data were recorded and are listed in the table perinatal infections; in 20% of these cases, below (Table 1) [11]. children develop AIDS in the first year of life. Table 1. Areas affected by HIV/AIDS Number* of people infected Affected geographical area Number* of AIDS deaths with HIV South and East Africa 20.7 million 470.000 Central and West Africa 6.5 million 330.000 Middle East and North Africa 240.000 8.000 Asia-Pacific 5.1 million 180.000 Central Asia and Eastern Europe 1.5 million 47.000 Central and Western Europe, 2.2 million 12.000 North America Latin America 2.1 million 37.000 * = numbers represent an estimation Approximately 90% of HIV-1 infections are • Subtype C: Sub-Saharan Africa, India, M group viruses and are globally distributed as Brazil; follows: • Subtype D: North Africa and the Middle • Subtype A: Central and East Africa and East; countries that were part of the Soviet Union; • Subtype F: Countries in South and • Subtype B: Central and Western Europe, Southeast Asia; North America, South America, Australia, • Subtype G: Central and West Africa; North Africa, the Middle East and several • Subtypes H, J, and K: Africa and the Asian countries, including Japan and Middle East [12]. Thailand; Given that subtype B is dominant in Spain, and Belgium). From the P group only economically developed countries (USA and one infection was discovered in a person from Western Europe), most clinical trials have been France, originally from Cameroon [10]. conducted on it, although it is responsible for HIV-2 is found mainly in West African only 12% of HIV infections globally. Subtype countries (Cape Verde, Ivory Coast, Gambia, C is found in 50% of infections, but the fact that Guinea-Bissau, Mauritania, Mali, Niger, it is dominant in poor countries, such as India Sierra Leone, Senegal, Liberia, Ghana, etc.). and Africa, makes it less included in clinical There has been an increase in prevalence in trials [10]. India and several cases have been reported in N group viruses have been identified in Europe and the Americas, most often in people several people from Cameroon. O group HIV- of West African descent. The greatest diversity 1 infections are found mainly in Central and of subtypes is found in Cameroon and D.R. West Africa, and in small numbers in countries of the Congo. In the future, due to population that used to have colonies in this area (France, migration, the distribution areas of various 197
NICOLAE et al. types of HIV will change [10, 13]. and Bictegravir; 1. Antiretroviral therapy • or Tenofovir alafenamide + Emtricitabine and Raltegravir The virus can be transmitted in several ways: • or Tenofovir disoproxil-fumarate + sexually (heterosexually or homosexually) - Emtricitabine and Raltegravir. 70% according to the WHO, maternal-fetal 2 nucleoside reverse transcriptase (prenatal, perinatal or postnatal), parenteral inhibitors and 1 non-nucleoside reverse (in drug addicts), by blood transfusions or transcriptase inhibitor: organ transplants or in occupational accidents. • Tenofovir alafenamide + Emtricitabine + General prophylaxis measures refer primarily Ritonavir; to protected sexual contact and the avoidance • or Tenofovir disoproxil-fumarate + of sexual intercourse with people suspected of Emtricitabine + Ritonavir. having the infection. But also to the prevention 2 nucleoside reverse transcriptase of infection in young women, counselling and inhibitors and 1 protease inhibitor antiretroviral treatment during pregnancy, potentiated by Ritonavir or Cobicistat: choice of caesarean section and prohibition of • Tenofovir alafenamide + Emtricitabine breastfeeding (these measures reduce the risk or Tenofovir disoproxil-fumarate + of infection of the fetus to 0.3% according to Emtricitabine, in combination with Darunavir the Romanian Anti-AIDS Association), careful + Cobicistat or Darunavir + Ritonavir [15- selection of donors and wearing gloves and 16]. protective equipment [6, 14]. Despite the fact that there is antiretroviral Antiretroviral therapy is established treatment that, properly instituted and depending on the stage of HIV infection, monitored, has positive effects by increasing physiological conditions (pregnancy), presence survival and delaying the onset of opportunistic of immunodeficiency signs and the occurrence infections, it also has a number of limitations. of opportunistic infections, patient’s age, and The most important is the lack of elimination also on the tolerance to treatment. of the infection completely; the treatment only Treatment aims to both reduce viral load reduces viral replication. Patients may also and restore CD4+ and CD8+ T cell numbers, develop resistance to treatment over time [3]. along with decreasing viral replication in the lymphatic and nervous systems and avoiding 2. Post-exposure prophylaxis of HIV the development of resistance to treatment. In the absence of a protective immune Currently, associated therapy is the standard, response or the existence of a vaccine that and is called ART (“Anti-Retroviral Therapy”). can be administered after HIV infection, post- The treatment regimen may have various HIV exposure prophylaxis is considered in combinations of the following drug classes: emergencies and depending on the degree of reverse transcriptase inhibitors, non-nucleoside risk. When it comes to low risk of infection, it is reverse transcriptase inhibitors, protease not recommended to start antiretroviral therapy, inhibitors or fusion inhibitors [15-16]. but it is considered in case of an intermediate Antiviral therapy is started at the time of risk and is mandatory at high risk. The first diagnosis, regardless of the number of CD4+ steps are risk assessment and rapid HIV and cells, and the first intention is to use one of HCV testing. Prophylaxis in these situations is these combinations: best to start in the first 4 hours after exposure 2 nucleoside reverse transcriptase and never exceed 48/72 hours after contact, and inhibitors and 1 integrase inhibitor: antiretroviral therapy will be administered for 4 • Abacavir + Lamivudine and Dolutegravir; weeks, according to the following scheme: • or Tenofovir alafenamide + Emtricitabine • Tenofovir disoproxil-fumarate + and Dolutegravir Emtricitabine; • or Tenofovir disoproxil-fumarate + • or Zidovudine + Lamivudine, to which Emtricitabine and Dolutegravir; Raltegravir is added twice a day or Darunavir • or Tenofovir alafenamide + Emtricitabine + Ritonavir once daily, or Lopinavir + 198
Prevention of HIV infection through vaccination Ritonavir twice daily; or HIV seroconversions are sought among • or Tenofovir disoproxil-fumarate + participants [16]. Emtricitabine + Dolutegravir once daily The researchers explored a number of [15-16]. strategies by which they hope to produce VACCINE TYPES protective immune responses. These include: • Vaccines consisting of recombinant So far, more than 40 HIV vaccines have been subunits; tested on several thousand volunteers. Most of • Vaccines with modified envelope; this research consists of studies on the safety and • Vaccines with antigenic peptides; efficacy of recombinant proteins, produced in a • Vaccines with HIV DNA; variety of different ways. Despite encouraging • Vaccines with recombinant vectors; evidence of human immune responses, it is • Vaccines against viral toxins [15]. unclear whether many of these vaccines could Most of the time, studies use a combination prevent HIV infection [15]. of these vaccine types, in vaccines that contain Vaccines are usually given to a large number a main (“prime”) structure and an adjuvant, of people at high risk of infection. After a stimulant (“boost”) structure. Thus, two or more certain period of time, the results of those who vaccines are combined to broaden or enhance received the vaccine are compared with those immune responses [16]. of volunteers who received placebo and involve The table below (Table 2) presents the studies the evaluation of antibodies in the blood or the currently underway or recently completed (last response of CD8 T cells to HIV in the test tube, 5 years). Table 2. Ongoing or recently completed studies No. of Starting Vaccine Trial name Phase Concept Country Status year type volunteers DNA (the active component of the vaccine that contains virus-derived genes) enters CRO2049/ the cells that will use HIV genes to make I 2014 DNA copies of viral proteins. These proteins 30 Great Britain Ongoing CUT*HIVA-C000 should stimulate the immune system and thus protect against infection. The vaccine was administered SC, IM and ID [17] To evaluate the safety and tolerability of PENNVAX®-GP HIV-1 DNA vaccine and DNA adjuvant IL-12, administered by ID or IM injection with electroporation (EP) in uninfected HIV adults. The injections HVTN 098 I 2015 DNA 94 USA Completed are performed with an EP device, which uses an electrical impulse to open small pores in the cells. Assesses whether EP increases immune response to vaccine [18] Identification of optimal DNA delivery DNA, conditions for amplifying the antibody CUTHIVAC002 I 2015 24 Great Britain Ended protein response to protein-modified intradermal stimulation [19] This study will evaluate the safety, tolerability and immunogenicity of DNA- South Africa, DNA, HVTN 111 I 2016 HIV-PT123 (an HIV type C DNA vaccine) 132 Tanzania, Ongoing protein and Subtype B gp120 / MF59 in healthy, Zambia HIV-uninfected adults [20] To evaluate safety, tolerability and immune response of the DNA-HIV-PT123 vaccine used in combination with one of DNA, South Africa, HVTN 108 I/II 2016 the 2 protein vaccines: bivalent subtype C 334 Completed protein USA gp120/MF59 (protein/MF59) or bivalent subtype C gp120/AS01B (Protein/AS01B) in HIV-uninfected adults [21] 199
NICOLAE et al. To evaluate safety, tolerability and immunogenicity of two HIV-1 vaccines: p24CE1/2 pDNA and p55^gag pDNA, HVTN 119 I 2017 pDNA 56 USA Ongoing with IL-12 pDNA adjuvant, in i.m. administration with electroporation in healthy, HIV-uninfected adults [15] This study tests the mucosal-specific immune response (HIV-specific IgA and IgG in saliva, cervical secretions, semen, DNA, which may include neutralizing activity) adeno- HVTN 076 I 2011 obtained from the administration of a 45 USA Completed virus DNA-type HIV vaccine, followed by the vector administration of an HIV vaccine that uses an adenoviral vector in seronegative patients [22] To evaluate the safety, tolerability, and immunogenicity of four HIV vaccines in HIV-uninfected adults. It includes DNA, three vaccines: Nat-B env DNA, CON-S HVTN 106 I 2014 poxviral 105 USA Ongoing enzyme DNA and env mosaic DNA, and vector a vaccine called MVA-CMDR that can stimulate the immune response to DNA vaccines [23] To evaluate the safety and compare the DNA, immunogenicity of the first DNA vaccine USA, HVTN 092 I 2013 poxviral plans, followed by a stimulation of the 209 Completed Switzerland vector NYVAC vaccine in healthy HIV-1- uninfected adult participants [24] DNA, To evaluate the safety and tolerability of viral the HIV-1 nef/ tat/ vif vaccine, env pDNA vector released by electroporation (EP), followed HVTN 112 I 2016 15 USA Ongoing by stimulation with the envC vaccine with recombinant vesicular stomatitis virus (rVSV), in HIV-uninfected adults [25] To evaluate the safety, pharmacokinetics Passive and the antiretroviral effects of anti-HIV-1 Germany, 10-1074 I 2015 immuni- strong neutralizing monoclonal antibody 33 Completed USA zation 10-1074 in HIV infected and non-infected people [15] Botswana, To evaluate the safety and efficacy Kenya, Passive of human monoclonal antibody mAb Malawi, HVTN 703/HPTN IIb 2016 immuni- VRC-HIVMAB060-00-AB (VRC01) in 1900 Mozambique, Ongoing 081 zation preventing HIV-1 infection in higher risk South Africa exposed women [15] Tanzania Zimbabwe A randomized, placebo-controlled clinical Passive study on the safety, pharmacokinetics IAVI T001 I 2016 immuni- and antiviral activity of the monoclonal 63 USA Ongoing zation antibody PGT121 (mAb) in HIV- uninfected and HIV-infected adults [15] To evaluate the safety and Puerto Rico, Passive pharmacokinetics of three monoclonal South Africa, IMPAACT P1112 I 2015 immuni- antibodies, VRC01, VRC01LS and 158 Completed USA, Zim- zation VRC07-523LS, in infants exposed to HIV babwe [15] The first study of the monoclonal antibody VRC-HIVMAB075-00-AB (VRC07-523LS) in healthy adults. Dose Passive increase study to examine the safety, VRC 605 I 2017 immuni- 26 USA Completed tolerability, dose and pharmacokinetics zation of VRC07-523LS; verifies the safety of administration to healthy adults by IV and SC routes [15] 200
Prevention of HIV infection through vaccination To evaluate the efficacy of VRC01LS and VRC07-523LS antibodies, as well as the organism tolerance range. Part A Passive of the research will study the VRCO1LS VRC 607 I 2016 immuni- antibody, and part B VRC07-523LS. 20 USA Completed zation Their blood concentration and dynamic over time will be monitored, and also if the patients develop an immune response against these antibodies [15] To evaluate the safety and efficacy of Passive (VRC01) human monoclonal antibody in USA, Peru, HVTN 704 AMP IIb 2016 immuni- preventing HIV-1 infection in men and 2700 Brazil, Ongoing zation transgender persons who engage in sexual Switzerland acts with men [15] The first study of VRC-HIVMAB080- 00-AB (VRC01LS) (MAb) monoclonal antibody in healthy adults. It is a dose escalation study to evaluate the safety, Passive tolerability, dose and pharmacokinetics of VRC01LS I 2015 immuni- VRC01LS. 49 USA Completed zation The hypothesis is that VRC01LS is safe to be administered IV and SC to healthy adults [15] To evaluate the safety, pharmacokinetics and activity of 2 experimental Passive human monoclonal antibodies: VRC- South Africa, HVTN 116 I 2017 immuni- 74 Ongoing HIVMAB060-00-AB (VRC01) and USA zation VRC01LS in serum and mucosa in HIV uninfected adults [15] adeno- To evaluate the safety, tolerability and associa- immunogenicity of the recombined vector ted virus coding AAV(rAAV1-PG9DP) for the IAVI A003 I 2014 vector 21 Great Britain Completed PG9 antibody when it is administered contain- intramuscularly, at different doses, to ing gene healthy male adults [15] sequences The main objective is to document the safety of the gp120-CD4 full length IHV01 I 2015 Protein single-chain (FLSC) complex vaccine, 65 USA Completed with a secondary objective of assessing induced immune responses [15] To analyse in HIV-uninfected volunteers the innate, cell-mediated and humoral mediated responses induced by AIDSVAX RV 328 II 2014 Protein B / E in the systemic and mucosal 40 Thailand Ongoing compartments and to characterize the functional specificities of B cells in peripheral blood and bone marrow [15] Randomized, double-blind clinical trial, to evaluate the safety, immunogenicity of Ad26.ENVA.01 Adeno- mucous membranes and innate immune Mucosal/ I 2010 virus 24 USA Completed responses of the recombinant adenovirus IPCAVD003 vector HIV-1 vaccine serotype 26 (Ad26. ENVA.01) in HIV-1 uninfected adults [15] Randomized, double-blind, dose- escalation study to evaluate the safety Adeno- Ad5HVR48. and immunogenicity of the recombinant I 2009 virus 48 USA Completed ENVA.01 serotype 5 HIV-1 HVR48 vaccine vector (Ad5HVR48.ENVA.01) in uninfected HIV-1 adults [15] To evaluate the safety and tolerability of different vaccination regimes, Ad26.Mos Adeno- HIV and C Clade (gp) 140. The response virus IPCAVD010 I 2016 of envelope antibodies from different 36 USA Ongoing vector, vaccination schemes is also monitored. protein Monocentric, randomized, double-blind [15] Adeno- Randomized, double-blind, multicenter HVTN 118 virus Kenya, II 2017 study. Participants are healthy adults, 155 Ongoing IPCAVD-012 vector, Rwanda, USA undiagnosed with HIV [15] protein 201
NICOLAE et al. Follows the safety and tolerability of different vaccine regimens containing Rwanda, Viral HIV (Ad26.Mos.HIV), modified Ankara South Africa, IPCAVD009 I/II 2014 vector, 393 Completed vaccine (MVA) and type 1 HIV-1 Clade C Thailand, protein serotype 26-mosaic vaccine (gp140 DP). Uganda, USA Multicenter, double-blind [15] Randomized, double-blind study to examine the influence of antigenic competition on the immunogenicity of Adeno- Brazil, Peru, HIV-1 Gag / Pol. Tests whether a vaccine HVTN 084 I 2011 virus 100 Switzerland Completed that includes only Gag and Pol peptides vector USA elicits a stronger immune response than a vaccine that includes Env A, B, and C peptides [15] The strategy involves two vaccines, given successively at different times in HIV-1 Adeno- uninfected adults. The goal is to stimulate HVTN 083 I 2010 virus 180 USA Completed different parts of the immune system vector and enhance the body's overall immune response to HIV [15] The HIV VRC rAd5 vaccine contains 4 different components, gag-pol / env Adeno- A / envB / envC. The researchers will HVTN 085 Ib 2011 virus examine how the immune system 90 USA Ongoing vector responds to the vaccine when the 4 components are administered in 3 different ways to HIV-uninfected adults [15] The purpose is to evaluate the safety, Adeno- tolerability of the 2 different vaccination HVTN 117 II 2016 virus regimens Ad26.Mos. HIV trivalent and 201 Rwanda, USA Ongoing VAC89220HPX2004 vector Clade C gp140 or Ad26.Mos4 tetravalent [15] Adeno- virus A study to assess the safety of candidates PEACHI-04 I 2014 vector, with HIV and hepatitis C vaccines when 32 Great Britain Completed Poxvirus given separately or in combination [15] vector The HIV Vaccine Testing Network Poxviral (HVTN) conducted a study to test HVTN 097 I 2013 vector, 2 experimental HIV vaccines in 100 South Africa Completed protein combination with 2 licensed tetanus and hepatitis B vaccines [15] Double-blind clinical trial in HIV- Poxvirus uninfected adults. Uses ALVAC-HIV HVTN 100 I/II 2015 vector, (vCP2438) and bivalent gp120 / MF59. 252 South Africa Completed protein These are experimental vaccines, used only in research [15] Randomized, double-blind clinical trial Poxviral to evaluate the safety and efficacy of HVTN 702 III 2016 vector, ALVAC-HIV (vCP2438) and the bivalent 5400 South Africa Completed protein subtype Cgp120 / MF59 in the prevention of HIV-1 infection in adults [15] To evaluate the safety and tolerability of delayed stimulation regimens of SIDAX Poxviral B / E monotherapy, ALVAC-HIV alone RV 305 II 2012 vector, 162 Thailand Ongoing or the ALVAC-HIV / AIDSVAX B / E protein combination in HIV-negative participants [15] The main purpose of the study is to better define the relative contribution of AIDSVAX® B / E alone, ALVAC-HIV alone or ALVAC-HIV plus AIDSVAX® B / E association to the immune profile observed in the weeks and months after Poxviral initial reception and the stimulation RV 306 II 2013 vector, regimen of the vaccine from the study 360 Thailand Ongoing protein protocol RV144 and their booster effects in both systemic and mucosal compartments. This study will provide a more intense and comprehensive characterization of innate, cell and humoral-mediated immune responses than in the RV144 study [15] 202
Prevention of HIV infection through vaccination To test experimental HIV vaccines that use an adenovirus as a carrier. The vector Replica- can help vaccines stimulate an immune tive viral HVTN 110 I 2015 response. Researchers want to see the 60 USA Ongoing vector, post-vaccination immune response protein. and whether the vaccine adenovirus is contagious [15] To test experimental HIV vaccines that use an adenovirus as a carrier. Replica- Researchers want to see if different ways PXVX-HIV-100-001 I 2013 tive viral 61 USA Ongoing of administering vaccines cause different vector immune responses. They also want to see if adenovirus vaccines are contagious [15] The study evaluates three subtype C HIV vaccines. SAAVI DNA-C2 is a vaccine composed of two DNA plasmids in equal amounts, expressing a subtype Poxviral C HIV-1 polyprotein, comprising Gag- HVTN 086, SAAVI vector, Tat-Nef transcriptase and Env peptides. I 2011 185 South Africa Completed 103 DNA, SAAVI MVA-C is a live, modified protein Vaccinia Ankara virus vaccine that contains the same antigens as SAAVI DNA-C2. Novartis Subtype C gp140 is a glycoprotein vaccine 140 administered with MF59 adjuvant [15] Particles Bivalent DNA-protein anti-HIV1 vaccine CombiHIVvac II 2019 resem- containing multiple HIV1 protein epitopes 30 Russia Ongoing (KombiVI Chvak) bling virus of T and B cells [15] To evaluate the response to 2 different vaccination schemes with an HIV DNA vaccine (HIV-DNA-PT123) or HIV with NYVAC (PT1 and PT4) vaccine followed by a combined stimulation with HIV DNA, USA, South HVTN 101 I 2019 NYVAC (PT1 and PT4) and AIDSVAX 264 Ongoing protein Africa B / E. It will also assess whether BMI and / or gender influence immunogenicity and analyse regional differences in immunological responses between participants in the 2 countries [15] To follow the response to AIDSVAX B / E and MVA / HIV62B in HIV-uninfected Protein, HVTN 114; individuals who have previously received I 2019 poxviral 100 USA Ongoing GOVX-B11 MVA / HIV62B in DNA / MVA or MVA vector / MVA vaccine regimens as part of the HVTN study 205 [15] The volunteers with low-risk HIV infection from RISVAC02 study were Poxviral RisVac02boost I 2019 randomly assigned to get 3 MVA-B 24 Spain Ongoing vector IM shots. They will receive another stimulating dose [15] It can be hypothesized that HIVIS DNA and MVA-CMDR vaccination will lead DNA, to a reduction in HIV reservoir markers RV534 I 2020 viral as a result of vaccine-induced immune 45 Brasil, Peru Ongoing vector responses. The effects may be superior with the addition of TLR4 agonist as immune adjuvant [15] To Evaluate the Safety and Immunogenicity of Recombinant HIV-1 USA, IAVI C101 I 2020 Proteic Envelope Protein BG505 SOSIP.GT1.1 48 Ongoing Netherlands gp140 Vaccine, Adjuvanted in Healthy, HIV-uninfected Adults [15] Vaccines with recombinant viral vectors AIDSVAX B/E vaccine performed on 16,000 participants in Thailand The RV144 trial, also called the “Thailand over a period of 6 years. Two experimental Study”, had a significant impact on the field vaccines were used; the first one was a of HIV vaccination, with the study being recombinant type vaccine, using a virus from the Avipoxvirus family, with inserted genes 203
NICOLAE et al. encoding HIV antigenic proteins, intended of the HIV vaccine used in this study and the to stimulate cell-mediated immunity through existence of a common immune response to T cells, and the second one an experimental authorized vaccines for tetanus and hepatitis B. stimulant vaccine, containing an antigenic HVTN is an interventional, randomized surface protein produced by HIV, aiming to study involving 100 volunteers aged between stimulate the production of antibodies. The two 18 and 40 years, starting in 2013 in South types of vaccines, used together, had a moderate Africa. The participants included in the study effect on the prevention of HIV infection, had no previous pathologies, being clinically with an immunization rate of 31%. This result and imagistically healthy, willing to receive contributes to the hope of researchers to make vaccines against tetanus and hepatitis B, possible an effective anti-HIV vaccine [15, 26]. evaluated with low risk for HIV infection. Starting from this trial, attempts are being The following were used for treatment: made to obtain additional vaccines that could - ALVAC HIV (lyophilized vaccine, enhance protective immune correlations. intramuscular injection, reconstituted from 1.05 The reduction in the risk of HIV infection ml of sterile 0.4% NaCl solution for a single is largely correlated with the total binding of dose of 1 ml > 1.0x 106 CCID50 / ml); plasma IgG to the gp70 of the leukemic virus - AIDSVAX B / E (HIV glycoprotein gp120 in mice, containing HIV-1 gp120 with variable subtype B 300 mcg and glycoprotein gp120 regions 1 and 2 (gp70 V1-V2). A similar subtype E 300 mcg absorbed on 600 mcg of correlation was observed with total plasma aluminium hydroxide adjuvant gel); IgG binding to V2 linear peptides and IgG 3 - hepatitis vaccine (each 1 ml dose contains binding to V1-V2 gp70 schemes. These V1-V2 20 mcg of hepatitis B surface antigen (HBsAg) antibodies appear to bind the middle region of adsorbed on 500 mcg of aluminium as V2 by a strong dependence on lysine at position aluminium hydroxide, for IM administration); 169 and valine at position 172. Consistent - tetanus vaccine (tetanus toxin absorbed with these findings, two genetic analyses of on aluminium hydroxide dihydrate, IM viruses discovered in the RV144 trial identified administration) [28]. increased efficacy against lysine (K)-containing RV 305/306 studies - bivalent vaccine viruses at position 169. Because CD8+ virus testing neutralizing antibodies and level 2 virus The purpose of this study is to evaluate the neutralizing antibodies were almost absent in safety and tolerability of regimens with delayed this test, a hypothesis was raised that protection stimulation of AIDSVAX B / E alone, ALVAC- was mediated by non-neutralizing antibodies. HIV alone or the ALVAC-HIV / AIDSVAX B In this regard, the results of several RV144 / E combination in uninfected HIV participants follow-up studies implicate a role of the effector in RV144. functions of Fc receptor-mediated (FcR) non- The study is interventional, randomized, neutralizing antibodies, including Antibody- double-blind, in which 162 adult volunteers Dependent Cellular Cytotoxicity (ADCC) and participated, starting in April 2012, Thailand. phagocytosis [27]. Subjects included in the study participated in ALVAC HIV vaccine the RV144 trial, received the active product and performed the 4 protocol vaccination visits. The HIV Vaccine Trial (HVTN 097) is a The volunteers were organized in 3 groups: study that aims to test two experimental HIV • The first group was tested with ALVAC vaccines, used in conjunction with two licensed HIV 1 ml per injection containing 10X6 vaccines for tetanus and hepatitis B. CCID50 administered dose, AIDSVAX B / This study seeks answers regarding effective E 1 ml per injection, ALVAC-HIV placebo and safe vaccination in the uninfected 1 ml, AIDSVAX B / E APLACEBO 1 ml, population, how the immune system responds weeks 0-24; to the action of HIV vaccine, if the immune • The second group was tested with response to tetanus and hepatitis B vaccination AIDSVAX B / E 1 ml and placebo 1 ml, can help understand the mechanism of action weeks 0-24; 204
Prevention of HIV infection through vaccination • The third group was tested with ALVAC- Despite many failed attempts to induce HIV 1 ml and placebo 1 ml, weeks 0-24 protective immunity, researchers are (29). increasingly optimistic that scientific progress Neutralizing antibody vaccines will eventually lead to success. While the path to the development of effective vaccines and The International AIDS Vaccine Initiative antibodies against HIV may still be a long one, (IAVI) is a non-profit scientific organization it is at least clearer [22, 30–32]. established in 1996 that aims to develop vaccines and other biomedical innovations DNA-based vaccines that prevent HIV infection. IAVI is committed The study on DNA-based HIV vaccination to supporting the broad field of HIV vaccine took shape 20 years ago. Significant experience research. has been gained in vector design, antigen In 2009, the first antibody capable of optimization, use of DNA immunization, neutralizing the HIV virus was isolated, being as part of the vaccination strategy. With a isolated from HIV-infected volunteers. It has better understanding of the potential for DNA been found that antibodies bind to proteins, immunization and recent advances in HIV making it difficult for them to get past the vaccine research, it is anticipated that DNA carbohydrate “shield.” Some patients develop immunization will play a more important role the so-called neutralizing antibodies (bNAbs). in HIV vaccine development. It has been shown that some broadly An ongoing study, started in 2015 in Neutralizing Antibodies (bNAbs) can provide the USA, aims to evaluate the safety and protection against HIV or a hybrid virus known immunogenicity of the PENNVAX®-GP as SHIV. This protection is largely due to their DNA vaccine and the DNA adjuvant, IL-12, ability to effectively neutralize the virus. administered intradermally or intramuscularly An antibody that appears to neutralize almost by electroporation in HIV-uninfected adults. all viruses is 10E8. This antibody targets Researchers will also look at whether the proximal outer region gp41 of the virus electroporation promotes an improved immune membrane. Unfortunately, its usefulness in response to the vaccine. prophylaxis is questioned. Adverse reactions The study involves 94 volunteers, who such as erythema or redness at injection were divided into four groups. In each group, sites have been reported in seven of the eight participants were given either the PENNVAX®- individuals who received this antibody, but no GP DNA / IL-12 vaccine or a placebo serum. severe side effects. Each group received different doses of the A tri-specific antibody designed by scientists vaccine. Enrolment began with group 1, which from Sanofi and VRC that combines the antigen received a low dose of vaccine and adjuvant. binding fragment (Fragment antigen binding - Researchers examined group 1 safety data Fab) of three bNAbs molecules, including 10E8, before administering higher doses to groups 2, into a single molecule is currently being studied. 3 and 4 [18, 33] The researchers say that the safety issues of the Another ongoing study was launched in May 10E8 antibody are diminished by using only a 2016 in southern Africa. This study evaluates part of it, not the whole antibody. the safety, tolerability and immunogenicity of Work is also underway to obtain stronger the HIV class C DNA vaccine and of the gp120 neutralizing antibodies with a longer half-life, / MF59 subtype B vaccine in healthy, HIV- as well as to obtain antibody combinations that negative adults, aged 18 to 40 years. would be more likely to protect against HIV. Participants were divided into six groups. Longer-acting antibodies 3BNC117-LS and 10- Each group received the experimental vaccine 1074-LS, developed by Rockefeller University (DNA-HIV-PT123) and proteins (Protein / scientists, are already being tested alone and MF59 vaccine) or placebo [21]. in combination in a phase I study involving New research directions both HIV-infected volunteers and uninfected volunteers. There are multiple challenges regarding the development of an effective HIV vaccine: 205
NICOLAE et al. the virus quasi-species biology, the complex shots. All things considered, this subject interactions between the virus and the immune remains vastly unexplored, filled with research system, the incomplete understanding of all the opportunities. immune mechanisms of the human body. Conflict of interests: The authors declare no When it comes to the development of an conflict of interest. effective HIV vaccine, the medical research has been slow, with only one study showing REFERENCES promising results (RV144), and others still 1. Carter JB, Saunders VA. Virology: principles being researched. Nevertheless, new promising and applications. 2nd ed. Chichester, West studies are being developed constantly, as Sussex: John Wiley & Sons. 2013;394. shown previously. 2. Sharp PM, Hahn BH. The evolution of HIV-1 Furthermore, new technologies might change and the origin of AIDS. Philos Trans R Soc B the way research for an effective HIV vaccine Biol Sci. 2010;365(1552):2487-94. is being conducted, just as it has begun to 3. Bush S, Tebit DM. HIV-1 Group O Origin, change vaccinology in recent years. However, Evolution, Pathogenesis, and Treatment: it is important to note that new technologies are Unraveling the Complexity of an Outlier 25 in the early stages of development, and some Years Later. AIDS Rev. 2015;17(3):147-58. might prove to be more effective in the fight 4. CNN - Researchers trace first HIV case to 1959 against HIV [34-35]. in the Belgian Congo [Internet]. 1998; http:// CONCLUSION edition.cnn.com/HEALTH/9802/03/earliest. aids/ Although more than three decades have 5. Faria NR, Rambaut A, Suchard MA, Baele G, passed since the discovery of HIV, we still have Bedford T, Ward MJ, et al. HIV epidemiology. not developed an efficient vaccine that could The early spread and epidemic ignition help prevent or treat this infection. Scientists of HIV-1 in human populations. Science. are still trying out different approaches towards 2014;346(6205):56-61. this goal. The first and also one of the more 6. Ciufecu ES. Virusologie medicala. Bucureşti: successful studies was an American military Editura Medicală Naţională; 2003. 942 p. In study that took place in Thailand, in 2009. This Romanian. was a key study which introduced the concept of 7. Buonaguro L, Tornesello ML, Buonaguro formulating a vaccine based on a recombinant FM. Human Immunodeficiency Virus Type viral vector that would be administered in 1 Subtype Distribution in the Worldwide multiple doses, the second dose being based on Epidemic: Pathogenetic and Therapeutic proteic HIV antigens. Implications. J Virol. 2007;81(19):10209-19. Currently multiple combinations of viral 8. Taylor BS, Sobieszczyk ME, McCutchan FE, vectors that are administered together with Hammer SM. The challenge of HIV-1 subtype secondary protein vaccines, are being tested diversity. N Engl J Med. 2008;358(15):1590- worldwide. From this initiative, various 602. antibodies with specific HIV neutralising 9. HIV Sequence Database: Nomenclature actions have been isolated, that can either Overview [Internet]. 2019; https://www.hiv. prevent or keep the viral load under detectable lanl.gov/content/sequence/HelpDocs/subtypes- values. Thus, one of the main objectives is to more.html try and obtain a passive immunity through 10. HIV strains and types [Internet]. Avert; 2015; these antibodies. htt ps://w w w.aver t.org/professionals/ hiv- Another vaccine concept is of a composition science/types-strains of HIV-like particles that contain viral DNA 11. UNAIDS Factsheet – World’s AIDS Day and multiple HIV protein epitopes from T and 2019 [Internet]. 2019; http://www.unaids.org/ B lymphocytes. Considering the complexity of sites/default/files/media_asset/U NAIDS_ this study subject, close and long term volunteer FactSheet_en.pdf observation is being performed, in an attempt 12. HIV-1 subtypes [Internet]. Aidsmap.com; 2019; to obtain immune status by using multiple https://www.aidsmap.com/about-hiv/hiv-1- 206
Prevention of HIV infection through vaccination subtypes Diseases (NIAID). A Pivotal Phase 2b/3 13. Campbell-Yesufu OT, Gandhi RT. Update on Multisite, Randomized, Double-blind, Placebo- Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV)-2 controlled Clinical Trial to Evaluate the Safety Infection. Clin Infect Dis Off Publ Infect Dis and Efficacy of ALVAC-HIV (vCP2438) and Soc Am. 2011;52(6):780-7. Bivalent Subtype C gp120/MF59 in Preventing 14. Transmiterea virusului HIV | ARAS – HIV-1 Infection in Adults in South Africa Asociatia Romana Anti-SIDA [Internet]. 2019; [Internet]. clinicaltrials.gov; 2020; https:// https://www.arasnet.ro/informeaza-te/hivsida/ clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT02968849 transmiterea-virusului-hiv/ In Romanian. 22. National Institute of Allergy and Infectious 15. IAVI Trials Database - IAVI - International Diseases (NIAID). A Phase 1 Clinical Trial AIDS Vaccine Initiative [Internet]. IAVI; to Evaluate the Safety, Pharmacokinetics, and https://www.iavi.org/ Anti-Viral Activity of VRC-HIVMAB060- 16. The Development of HIV Vaccines | History 00-AB (VRC01) and VRC-HIVMAB080-00- of Vaccines [Internet]. 2019; /content/articles/ AB (VRC01LS) in the Serum and Mucosa of development-hiv-vaccines Healthy, HIV-Uninfected Adult Participants 17. Imperial College London. A Phase I [Internet]. clinicaltrials.gov; 2020; https:// Clinical Trial to Assess the Safety and clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT02797171 Immunogenicity of Three HIV GTU® 23. National Institute of Allergy and Infectious MultiHIV DNA Immunisations Administered Diseases (NIAID). A Phase 1 Randomized, Via the Intramuscular, Intradermal and Double-Blind, Placebo Controlled Clinical Trial Transcutaneous Routes in Healthy Male and to Evaluate the Safety and Immunogenicity Female Volunteers[Internet].clinicaltrials. of 3 Different HIV-1 DNA Priming Regimens gov;2014;https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/ (Nat-B Env, CON-S Env, and Mosaic Env) NCT02075983 With MVA-CMDR Boosts in Healthy, HIV- 18. National Institute of Allergy and Infectious 1-Uninfected Adults [Internet]. clinicaltrials. Diseases (NIAID). A Phase 1 Clinical Trial gov; 2020; https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/ to Evaluate the Safety and Immunogenicity of NCT02296541 PENNVAX®-GP (Gag, Pol, Env) DNA Vaccine 24. National Institute of Allergy and Infectious and IL-12 Plasmid, Delivered Via Intradermal Diseases (NIAID). A Phase 1 Clinical Trial or Intramuscular Electroporation in Healthy, to Evaluate Safety and to Compare the HIV-Uninfected Adult Participants [Internet]. Immunogenicity of 3 DNA Vaccine Prime clinicaltrials.gov; 2018; https://clinicaltrials. Schedules Followed by a NYVAC Vaccine gov/ct2/show/NCT02431767 Boost in Healthy, HIV-1 Uninfected Adult 19. Imperial College London. A Phase I Clinical Participants [Internet]. clinicaltrials.gov; Trial to Assess the Safety and Immunogenicity 2018; https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/ of HIV DNA-C CN54ENV Immunisations NCT01783977 Administered Via the Intramuscular and 25. National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Intradermal Methods With and Without Diseases (NIAID). A Phase 1 Trial to Evaluate Electroporation Followed by Boosting With the Safety, Tolerability, and Immunogenicity of Recombinant HIV CN54gp140 in Healthy Male a Prime-Boost Regimen of HIV-1 Nef/Tat/Vif, and Female Volunteers [Internet]. clinicaltrials. Env pDNA Vaccine Delivered Intramuscularly gov; 2018; https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/ With Electroporation and HIV-1 rVSV NCT02589795 envC Vaccine in Healthy HIV-Uninfected 20. Evaluating the Safety and Immunogenicity Adult Participants [Internet]. clinicaltrials. of HIV Clade C DNA Vaccine and MF59- gov; 2019; https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/ or AS01B-Adjuvanted Clade C Env Protein NCT02654080 Vaccines in Various Combinations in Healthy, 26. Efficacy trials - The RV144 trial [Internet]. HIV-Uninfected Adults - ClinicalTrials.gov 2019; https://www.aidsmap.com/The-RV144- [Internet]. 2019; https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/ trial/page/2028003 show/NCT02915016 27. Perez LG, Martinez DR, deCamp AC, Pinter 21. National Institute of Allergy and Infectious A, Berman PW, Francis D, et al. V1V2-specific 207
NICOLAE et al. complement activating serum IgG as a correlate or Subcutaneously to Healthy Adults [Internet]. of reduced HIV-1 infection risk in RV144. PloS clinicaltrials.gov; 2020; https://clinicaltrials. One. 2017;12(7):e0180720. gov/ct2/show/NCT03015181 28. National Institute of Allergy and Infectious 32. Database of broadly neutralizing antibodies to Diseases (NIAID). A Phase 1 Clinical Trial HIV-1 | bNAber [Internet]. 2019; http://www. to Evaluate the Safety and Immunogenicity of bnaber.org/ Homologous and Heterologous Prime-Boost 33. Ake JA, Schuetz A, Pegu P, Wieczorek L, Regimens Comprising DNA-HIV-PT123, Eller MA, Kibuuka H, et al. Safety and NYVAC-HIV-PT1 and NYVAC-HIV-PT4, and Immunogenicity of PENNVAX-G DNA AIDSVAX B/E in Healthy, HIV-Uninfected Prime Administered by Biojector 2000 or US and South African Adults [Internet]. CELLECTRA Electroporation Device With clinicaltrials.gov; 2016; https://clinicaltrials. Modified Vaccinia Ankara-CMDR Boost. J gov/ct2/show/NCT01927835 Infect Dis. 2017;216(9):1080-90. 29. U.S. Army Medical Research and Development 34. Rios A. Fundamental challenges to the Command. Randomized, Double Blind development of a preventive HIV vaccine. Curr Evaluation of Different One-Year Boosts After Opin Virol. 2018;29:26-32. Sanofi Pasteur Live Recombinant ALVAC-HIV 35. Van Regenmortel MHV. HIV/AIDS: (vCP1521) and Global Solutions for Infectious Immunochemistry, Reductionism and Vaccine Diseases (GSID) gp120 B/E (AIDSVAX® Design: A Review of 20 Years of Research B/E) Prime-Boost Regimen in HIV-uninfected [Internet]. Cham: Springer International Thai Adults [Internet]. clinicaltrials.gov; Publishing; 2019; http://link.springer. 2020; https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/ com/10.1007/978-3-030-32459-9 NCT01931358 30. ‘Beautiful, Long-Lived’ HIV Suppression With Combo bNAbs [Internet]. Medscape; 2019; http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/902572 31. National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (NIAID). VRC 605: A Phase 1 Dose-Escalation Study of the Safety and Pharmacokinetics of a Human Monoclonal Antibody, VRC-HIVMAB075-00-AB (VRC07-523LS), Administered Intravenously 208
You can also read