MINUTES FOR THE - Shire of Coorow

Page created by Eddie Franklin
 
CONTINUE READING
MINUTES FOR THE - Shire of Coorow
Shire of Coorow
Minutes - Ordinary Meeting                                                                   9 December 2020

                                       MINUTES
                                                                ED
                                                         M
                                            FOR THE
                                               R
                                             FI

                             ORDINARY MEETING
                                  N

                                OF COUNCIL
                                 O
                       C
                      N

                                            HELD ON
                U

           WEDNESDAY 9 DECEMBER 2020

          PLEASE READ THE FOLLOWING DISCLAIMER BEFORE PROCEEDING

       Members of the public are cautioned against taking any action on Council decisions, on items in
       these Minutes in which they may have an interest, until such times as they have been advised in
                                           writing by Shire staff

                                                   Page 1
MINUTES FOR THE - Shire of Coorow
Shire of Coorow
Minutes - Ordinary Meeting                                                                                                                         9 December 2020

                                                                     Minutes
      1.      DECLARATION OF OPENING / ANNOUNCEMENT OF VISITORS: .............................................. 3
      2.      RECORD OF ATTENDANCE / APOLOGIES / LEAVE OF ABSENCE PREVIOUSLY
              APPROVED ............................................................................................................................................... 3
      3.      REPONSE TO PREVIOUS PUBLIC QUESTIONS TAKEN ON NOTICE: ...................................... 3
      4.      PUBLIC QUESTION TIME: ..................................................................................................................... 4
      5.      APPICATION FOR LEAVE OF ABSENCE: ......................................................................................... 4
      6.      DECLARATION OF INTEREST: ............................................................................................................ 4
      7.      PETITIONS/DEPUTATIONS/PRESENTATIONS: ............................................................................... 4
      8.      CONFIRMATION OF MINUTES ............................................................................................................. 5

                                                                                                   ED
      8.1     ORDINARY MEETING HELD WEDNESDAY 18 NOVEMBER 2020 HELD AT THE LEEMAN
              RECREATION CENTRE ............................................................................................................... 5
      9.      ANNOUNCEMENTS BY THE PERSON PRESIDING WITHOUT DISCUSSION: .......................... 5
      10.
      11.
                                                                                        M
              MATTER FOR WHICH MEETING MAY BE CLOSED; ...................................................................... 5
              REPORTS: ................................................................................................................................................. 6
                                                                      R
      11.1 ACTING CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER: .............................................................................................. 6
      11.1.1APPLICATION TO PERFORM COMMERCIAL ACTIVITIES IN RESERVE 22521 –
                                                                    FI

            GREENHEAD LEEMAN COASTLINE ........................................................................................... 6
      11.1.2 SEQUICENETARY OF LOCAL GOVERNMENT ........................................................................ 11
                                                  N

      11.1.3 AGED HOME RENTAL RELIEF – MRS JANET JACK ................................................................ 13
      11.1.4 CWA INTEREST IN THE OLD CO-OP BUILDING ...................................................................... 15
      11.1.5 MORPHETT PARK GAZEBO ..................................................................................................... 17
                                                 O

      11.1.6 REVIEW OF POLICY 3.1.1 – SERVICE PROVISIONS ACROSS THE SHIRE .......................... 19
      11.2 MANAGER OF WORKS AND SERVICES: ........................................................................................ 24
                               C

      11.2.1 TENDER FOR RUBBER ROLLER 4/20 ...................................................................................... 24
      11.2.2 TENDER FOR CAT 140 GRADER 6/20 ...................................................................................... 26
                              N

      11.3 DEPUTY CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER: .......................................................................................... 28
                     U

      11.3.1 LIST OF ACCOUNTS PAID FOR THE MONTH OF NOVEMBER 2020...................................... 28
      11.3.2 MONTHLY STATEMENT OF FINANCIAL ACTIVITY – NOVEMBER 2020 ................................ 30
      12.     QUESTIONS BY MEMBERS OF WHICH DUE NOTICE HAS BEEN GIVEN: ............................. 44
      13. URGENT BUSINESS APPROVED BY THE PERSON PRESIDING OR BY DECISION: .......... 44
      13.1 LATE ITEM - TENDER FOR 8X4 TRUCK 5/20 ............................................................................... 44
      14. MATTERS BEHIND CLOSED DOORS:.............................................................................................. 46
      14.1 APPOINTMENT OF PERMANENT CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER .............................................. 47
      15. DATE OF NEXT MEETING: .................................................................................................................. 48
      15.1 ORDINARY MEETING OF COUNCIL.......................................................................................... 48
      16.     CLOSURE: ............................................................................................................................................... 48

                                                                             Page 2
Shire of Coorow
Minutes - Ordinary Meeting                                                         9 December 2020

  1.      DECLARATION OF OPENING / ANNOUNCEMENT OF VISITORS:
          The President, Cr Moira Girando, welcomed those present and opened the
          Meeting at 5pm.

           The Shire of Coorow acknowledges the Aboriginal peoples of Western Australia
           as the traditional custodians of this land, and we pay our respects to their Elders
           past and present.

  2.      RECORD OF ATTENDANCE / APOLOGIES                                /    LEAVE      OF
          ABSENCE PREVIOUSLY APPROVED

          Councillor M J Girando                                                     President
          Councillor B A Jack                                                 Deputy President
          Councillor M R Bothe (from 5.28pm)
          Councillor G V Heales

                                                         ED
          Councillor R R Kau
          Councillor V J Muller
          Councillor V R Oakes
          Councillor S D Peck                      M
          Mr J Merrick                           Acting Chief Executive Officer Deputy Chief
                                          R
          Mrs M Henry                                                       Executive Officer
          Mr K Bean                                            Manager of Works & Services
                                        FI

          Ms E Budrikis                                 Community Economic Development
                                                                                 Coordinator
                               N

          Leave of Absence
                              O

          Apologies
                       C

          Visitors
          Jan Muller (until 5.50pm)
                      N

          Guy Sims (until 5.50pm)
                U

          Rowan Kleindienst (until 5.50pm)
          David Yaksich (until 5.50pm)
          Roslyn Miles (until 5.50pm)

  3.       REPONSE TO PREVIOUS PUBLIC QUESTIONS TAKEN ON
           NOTICE:

           Helen Cazzolli – How to stay in Green Head and have a business. Queried
           regarding what help can be provided about purchasing property to be able to set
           up a business and still remain at home – Businesses include carpentry for her son
           and home catering for herself. It seems not a lot available and have looked at
           blocks at Jurien Bay– Letter has been written to CEO – President Girando
           responded to Ms Cazzolli that research was to occur and a response to be
           provided back to Ms Cazzolli.

                                             Page 3
Shire of Coorow
Minutes - Ordinary Meeting                                                         9 December 2020

           On-going consultation is occurring with Helen Cazzolli to assist the location of
           suitable premises.

           Carol Wall – Green Head Golf Club – Queried a previous Tee Box Grant and an
           invoice that has been sent to the Green Head Golf Club for their portion of the
           grant. The Club would like the Shire to reduce the invoice by $3000 as it believes
           that the volunteer portion was not accounted for in the original application.
           President Girando informed Ms Wall that the Shire would like to request their
           financials and informed Ms Wall that the issue will need to come back to council at
           the December meeting as an Agenda item for a formal decision.

           Staff are researching the original details to determine the extent of Councils
           possible contribution

           Carol Forrest - Gazebo Morphett Park – In the 2015/16 Financial year the Shire
           had budgeted to give the Green Head Community Association $3000, the GHCA
           would like to request that this be refunded to the association from the Shire.

                                                         ED
           President Girando responded that this will be researched and response to be
           given to the association.

                                                   M
           Morphett Park Gazebo is an item for discussion.

  4.       PUBLIC QUESTION TIME:
                                          R
                                        FI

           Nil
                                  N

  5.       APPICATION FOR LEAVE OF ABSENCE:
                                 O

          Nil
                       C

  6.       DECLARATION OF INTEREST:
                      N

          CR Jack 11.1.3 Financial Interest
                 U

          CR Muller 11.1.4 Impartiality Interest

  7.       PETITIONS/DEPUTATIONS/PRESENTATIONS:
       Roslyn Miles and Rowan Kleindienst – Oceanic Group
       Guy Sims & Jan Muller – Coorow Heritage Group

       Visitors Left at 5.50pm

                                             Page 4
Shire of Coorow
Minutes - Ordinary Meeting                                                      9 December 2020

  8.       CONFIRMATION OF MINUTES

  8.1         ORDINARY MEETING HELD WEDNESDAY 18 NOVEMBER 2020 HELD AT
              THE LEEMAN RECREATION CENTRE

        RESOLUTION:                                   2020/104

        Moved: Cr Oakes                               Seconded: Cr Jack

        That the Minutes of the Ordinary Meeting held on Wednesday 18 November 2020
        be confirmed as true and correct.
                                                                       CARRIED 8/0
                                                                     Simple Majority

                                                       ED
  9.       ANNOUNCEMENTS BY THE PERSON PRESIDING WITHOUT
           DISCUSSION:
                                                 M
           The Shire President thanked Mr John Merrick our Acting Chief Executive Officer
           for his dedicated commitment to the Shire of Coorow and Council during his
                                         R
           extended tenure in the position.
                                       FI

  10.      MATTER FOR WHICH MEETING MAY BE CLOSED;
                              N

            For the convenience of members of the public Council may identify, by decision,
            early in the meeting any matter on the agenda to be discussed behind closed
                             O

            doors and that matter is to be deferred for consideration as the last item of the
            meeting.
                       C

            Item 14.1 – Appointment of Permanent Chief Executive Officer
                      N
                U

                                            Page 5
Shire of Coorow
Minutes - Ordinary Meeting                                                            9 December 2020

  11.      REPORTS:

  11.1      ACTING CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER:

        11.1.1APPLICATION TO PERFORM COMMERCIAL ACTIVITIES IN RESERVE
              22521 – GREENHEAD LEEMAN COASTLINE
        Reporting Officer:      Acting Chief Executive Officer
        Responsible Executive: Acting Chief Executive Officer
        File Reference:         A1660
        Disclosure of Interest: Nil
        Attachments:            Confidential (under separate cover)
        Voting Requirements:    Simple Majority
        ____________________________________________________________________

        Council Role:

                                                           ED
           Quasi-judicial    When Council determines an application/matter that directly affects a
                             person’s rights and interests. The judicial character arises from the
                             obligation to abide by the principles of natural justice eg local
                                                     M
                             planning applications, building licences, other permits/licences (eg
                             under Health Act, Dog Act or local laws and other decisions that may
                                           R
                             be appealable to the State Administrative Tribunal (SAT)
                                         FI

        COMMENT:
        To review and consider the application submitted by Oceanic Gro for the
                               N

        commercial collection of seven species of seaweed and collection of wrack
        along the coastline located within reserve 22521 and the installation of a
                              O

        seaweed farm in reserve 22521.
                         C

        For council to review and consider the approval of a planning assessment
        made to the all applicable state agencies for the purpose of either establishing
                        N

        a lease or a license to perform seaweed farming in reserve 22521.
                U

        BACKGROUND:
        The applicant has requested permission from council to perform the following:
           - Collection of wrack,
           - Limited Collection of seaweed samples from the ocean and,
           - Install offshore seaweed farm(s) along coastline of R 22521

        The requested application does not make mention of specific bays located in
        Reserve 22521. Staff made contact and the applicant referred to appropriate bays
        as directed by council and state agencies.

        Reserve 22521 is vested for the purpose of parklands, recreation and camping, with
        a management order in favour of the Shire.

        Licenses are required from both the Department of Primary Industries and Regional
        Development and the Department of Biodiversity, Conservation and Attractions.

                                              Page 6
Shire of Coorow
Minutes - Ordinary Meeting                                                        9 December 2020

      Enquiries made to the Department of Water and Environmental Regulation identified
      that a clearing permit is not required for the removal of dead seaweed. Please refer to
      the comments for further clarification.

      Permission from the relevant land manager/s (e.g. local government authority) is
      required for the applicant to progress.

      If approval is granted conditions in accordance with adopted local laws, policies and
      adopted governing documentation are required to be include.

      There are no marine reserves located in reserve 22521.

      As the reserve is crown land, any proposal will require native title clearance, an
      aboriginal heritage assessment and a declared rare flora assessment.

      COMMENT:

                                                        ED
      If Council wished to exercise a commercial lease, Ministerial permission would need to
      be sort from the Department of Planning, Lands and Heritage.

                                                   M
      Commercial leases over two years also require council to follow provisions of Section
      3.58 Disposing of Property, of the Local Government Act 1995.
                                          R
      Council also may need to refer to Sections 189 and 190 of the Land Administration Act
                                        FI

      1997. Depending upon the value of the disposition, the Council may need to comply
      with Section 3.59 Commercial Enterprises by Local Government which includes land
      transactions.
                               N
                              O

      The other option to investigate, is to seek Ministerial permissions to establish a license
      to allow the installation of the seaweed farms at approved bays in reserve 22512.
                       C

      Staff contacted the Department of Planning, Lands and Heritage. The advice sort
                      N

      indicated that a planning assessment be submitted to the relevant State agencies for
      the purpose of establishing a lease or license.
                U

      Other requirements of the applicant are listed below.

      Department of Primary Industries and Regional Development

      Non-freehold, Crownland or Coastal Water Applications
      If the proposed site for the seaweed operation is in Coastal waters, applicants are
      required to provide the following:
           • a Management and Environmental Monitoring Plan (MEMP)
           • an additional information sheet (including a business plan, financial
              information, etc.) and
           • a completed marking and lighting form that will be assessed by the DPIRD and
              the Department of Transport.

                                             Page 7
Shire of Coorow
Minutes - Ordinary Meeting                                                         9 December 2020

      The applicant is also required to have tenure over the proposed land or waters where
      the aquaculture activity will be conducted. If the site is in Coastal Waters, the applicant
      will need to apply for a lease from the Minister for Fisheries.

      The licensing process involves an internal and external consultation process of 28
      days during which time stakeholders, relevant government agencies, industry and
      community groups can provide their comments on the application.

      If the decision-maker is satisfied and decides to grant the licence, the decision to grant
      will be advertised for a statutory 28 days, during which time affected persons have the
      opportunity to make an application for review to the State Administrative Tribunal.

      If no appeals have been made during this period, the licence can be issued. Overall
      processing time of aquaculture applications is around 3-5 months.

      The applicant will also need to apply for an exemption to collect broodstock, this will
      allow the collection of small quantities of seaweed for aquaculture purposes. The

                                                         ED
      commercial harvest of seaweed is not generally supported by the Department due to
      its importance to marine ecosystems.

                                                   M
      Department of Water and Environmental Regulation
                                          R
      Dead seaweed washed up on the beach is dead aquatic vegetation, and therefore is
      native vegetation as defined in ss3(1) & 51A the Environmental Protection Act 1986.
                                        FI

      However, the taking of this dead seaweed does not constitute "clearing" as defined in
      s51A of the EP Act.
      The taking of seaweed:
                               N

      is not the killing or destruction of, the severing/ringbarking of, or the doing of
                              O

      substantial damage to, native vegetation; and is not the removal from an area of
      native vegetation, because the dead seaweed has already been displaced from its
                       C

      original location.
      Accordingly, the taking of dead seaweed from the beach does not require a clearing
                      N

      permit under the EP Act.
                U

      Department of Biodiversity, Conservation and Attractions

      A Reg 60 application form is to be submitted in order to be assessed for approval of a
      commercial license. As the Shire is the land manager the applicant must seek your
      written permission and any conditions you give them. The licence, when issued states
      that they must abide by the local government conditions.

      Council does not have any adopted policies in relation to this application. Staff
      recommend this is rectified.

      Staff recommend that the applicant is to provide copies of all required
      documentation as set out by the applicable departments prior to operations
      commencing

                                             Page 8
Shire of Coorow
Minutes - Ordinary Meeting                                                    9 December 2020

      The application details the following species to be collected

          -   Betaphycus speciosum, Jelly Weed
          -   Ecklonia radiata, Common Kelp
          -   Sargassum, Gulf Weed
          -   Asparagopsis taxiformi, Red Algae
          -   Ulva, Sea Lettuce
          -   Caulerpa, Sea Grapes
          -   Endarachne binghamiae – Petalonia, Habonari

      The requested rate of collection in 100 specimens per species on an annual basis.

      STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT:
      Department of Planning, Lands and Cultural Heritage
      Department of Biodiversity, Conservation and Attractions
      Department of Primary Industries and Regional Development

                                                        ED
      Department of Water and Environmental Regulation
      Acting Chief Executive Officer
      Environmental Health Officer

      FINANCIAL / RESOURCE IMPLICATIONS:
                                                  M
                                         R
      Nil
                                       FI

      STATUTORY ENVIRONMENT:
      Local Government Act 1995
                              N

      Environmental Protection Act 1986.
      Land Administration Act 1997.
                             O

      POLICY IMPLICATIONS:
                       C

      Nil
                      N

      STRATEGIC IMPLICATIONS:
      Nil
                U

      RISK IMPLICATION:
      There are no known risks with this recommendation.

                                            Page 9
Shire of Coorow
Minutes - Ordinary Meeting                                                9 December 2020

      OFFICER RECOMMENDATION:

      RESOLUTION:                                   2020/105

      Moved: Cr Peck                                Seconded: Cr Bothe

      Council provides conditional approval of collection of wrack along the
      coastline located in reserve 22521 for commercial purposes on the basis the
      applicant seeks and is awarded all required departmental licenses and copies
      are provided to Council for record prior to operations commencing.

      and

      Council provides conditional approval of collection of the following species
          •   Betaphycus speciosum, Jelly Weed
          •   Ecklonia radiata, common Kelp

                                                     ED
          •   Sargassum, Gulf Weed
          •   Asparagopsis taxiformi, Red Algae
          •   Ulva, Sea Lettuce
          •
          •
              Caulerpa, Sea Grapes              M
              Endarachne binghamiae – petalonia, Habonari
                                        R
      at a rate of 100 specimen per species on an annual basis in reserve 22512
                                      FI

      on the basis the applicant seeks and is awarded all required
      departmental licenses and copies are provided to Council for record prior
      to operations
      commencing
                              N
                             O

      and
                       C

      Council approves the submission of a planning assessment to the;
      Department of Planning, Lands and Cultural Heritage,
                      N

      Department of Biodiversity, Conservation and Attractions,
      Department of Primary Industries and Regional Development, and the
                U

      Department of Water and Environmental Regulation,
      for their assessment and review of the application for the purpose of
      establishing a lease or license.

                                                                     CARRIED 8/0
                                                                     Simple Majority

                                          Page 10
Shire of Coorow
Minutes - Ordinary Meeting                                                             9 December 2020

      11.1.2 SEQUICENETARY OF LOCAL GOVERNMENT
      Reporting Officer:      Acting Chief Executive Officer
      Responsible Executive: Acting Chief Executive Officer
      File Reference:         ADM0425
      Disclosure of Interest: Nil
      Attachments:            Nil
      Voting Requirements:    Simple Majority
      ____________________________________________________________________

      Council Role:

           Executive         The substantial direction setting and oversight role of the Council eg
                             adopting plans and reports, accepting tenders, setting and amending
                             budgets.

      REPORT PURPOSE:

                                                           ED
      That Council consider attendance of a Gala Dinner to celebrate 150 years of
      Local Government.

      BACKGROUND:                                    M
      WALGA advises that a “Gala Dinner” is to be held to celebrate 150 years of Local
                                           R
      Government in WA at the Crown Perth on Saturday 20 February 2021.
                                         FI

      The cost of the tickets will be determined “in coming weeks”.
                               N

      COMMENT:
      The current budget provides $10,000 for Members training and development which
                              O

      is largely unspent due to cancellation of the LG Week.
                        C

      STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT:
      Shire of Coorow Councillors & Staff
                       N

      FINANCIAL / RESOURCE IMPLICATIONS:
                U

      2020/2021 Budget

      STATUTORY ENVIRONMENT:
      Nil

      POLICY IMPLICATIONS:
      Policy 1.1.4 – Members Attendance at Conferences, Seminars, Training and induction
      Courses

      STRATEGIC IMPLICATIONS:
      Nil

      PUBLIC CONSULTATION:
      Nil

                                              Page 11
Shire of Coorow
Minutes - Ordinary Meeting                                               9 December 2020

      RISK IMPLICATION:
      Nil

      OFFICER RECOMMENDATION:

      RESOLUTION:                                 2020/106

      Moved: Cr Jack                              Seconded: Cr Peck

      That up to two Councillors will attend the Sesquicentenary Gala Dinner

                                                                       CARRIED 8 /0
                                                                      Simple Majority

                                                  ED
                                              M
                                      R
                                    FI
                              N
                             O
                       C
                      N
                U

                                        Page 12
Shire of Coorow
Minutes - Ordinary Meeting                                                             9 December 2020

      Cr Jack left at 6.05pm

      11.1.3 AGED HOME RENTAL RELIEF – MRS JANET JACK
      Reporting Officer:      Acting Chief Executive Officer
      Responsible Executive: Acting Chief Executive Officer
      File Reference:         A1566
      Disclosure of Interest: Nil
      Attachments:            Nil
      Voting Requirements:    Absolute Majority
      ____________________________________________________________________

      Council Role:

           Executive         The substantial direction setting and oversight role of the Council eg
                             adopting plans and reports, accepting tenders, setting and amending
                             budgets.

                                                           ED
      REPORT PURPOSE:
      That Council consider rental relief for Mrs J Jack’s aged unit.

      BACKGROUND:
                                                     M
                                           R
      Mrs Jack occupies the front unit at the Commercial St complex and has experienced
      prolonged health issues in recent times.
                                         FI

      She has spent significant time away from her home in hospital and has requested
                               N

      Councils support for a refund of rent paid.
                              O

      Alternatively, Council may consider a suspension of rental obligations until Mrs Jack
      is well enough to return home.
                        C

      COMMENT:
                       N

      It has been reported that Mrs Jack has spent only a month or two at home over the
      past 12 months.
                U

      STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT:
      Shire of Coorow
      Mrs J Jack

      FINANCIAL / RESOURCE IMPLICATIONS:
      Nil

      STATUTORY ENVIRONMENT:
      Nil

      POLICY IMPLICATIONS:
      Nil

      STRATEGIC IMPLICATIONS:
      Nil

                                              Page 13
Shire of Coorow
Minutes - Ordinary Meeting                                                 9 December 2020

      PUBLIC CONSULTATION:
      Nil

      RISK IMPLICATION:
      Nil

      OFFICER RECOMMENDATION:

      RESOLUTION:                                  2020/107

      Moved: Cr Girando                            Seconded: Cr Muller

      That Council suspend rental obligations until such time she returns to her unit.

                                                                        CARRIED 7/0
                                                                     Absolute Majority

                                                    ED
                                               M
                                      R
                                    FI
                              N
                             O
                       C
                      N
                U

                                         Page 14
Shire of Coorow
Minutes - Ordinary Meeting                                                             9 December 2020

      Cr Jack return 6.07pm
      Cr V Muller declared an Impartiality Interest as his wife is involved with the
      Coorow Heritage Group
      11.1.4 CWA INTEREST IN THE OLD CO-OP BUILDING
      Reporting Officer:       Acting Chief Executive Officer
      Responsible Executive: Acting Chief Executive Officer
      File Reference:          A97
      Disclosure of Interest: Nil
      Attachments:             Nil
      Voting Requirements:     Simple Majority
      ____________________________________________________________________

      Council Role:

           Executive         The substantial direction setting and oversight role of the Council eg
                             adopting plans and reports, accepting tenders, setting and amending
                             budgets.

                                                           ED
      REPORT PURPOSE:
      To consider approval of an Op Shop in the Co-op building.

      BACKGROUND:
                                                     M
                                           R
      A letter requesting approval for the establishment of an “Op Shop” in the Co-op
      building has been received from the Coorow Waddy CWA.
                                         FI

      It is proposed to operate one or two days a week on a roster basis with members
                               N

      being covered for public liability through CWA headquarters.
                              O

      COMMENT:
      The proposal includes a request for the installation of ceiling fans and water, with an
                        C

      undertaking that all funds raised would go back to the community.
                       N

      Staff continue to seek grant funding opportunities to enable a refurbishment of the
      building to proceed.
                U

      Council does not have an adopted plan for the future use of the building but it is widely
      known that the Coorow Heritage Group have a significant interest in the building.

      STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT:
      Shire of Coorow Councillors & Staff
      Coorow Heritage Group
      Coorow Waddy CWA

      FINANCIAL / RESOURCE IMPLICATIONS:
      Nil

      STATUTORY ENVIRONMENT:
      Nil

                                              Page 15
Shire of Coorow
Minutes - Ordinary Meeting                                                    9 December 2020

      POLICY IMPLICATIONS:
      Nil

      STRATEGIC IMPLICATIONS:
      Nil

      RISK IMPLICATION:
      Nil

      OFFICER RECOMMENDATION:

      That Council approve the request for the establishment of an Op-Shop in the old
      Co-op building.

      RESOLUTION:                                    2020/108

                                                      ED
      Moved: Cr Bothe                                Seconded: Cr Jack

      That Council
                                                 M
          1. Rejects the Staff recommendation to approve the request for the
             establishment of an Op-Shop in the old Co-op building
          2. Allow the Coorow Heritage Group to establish a museum in said building as
                                        R
             Council believes this to be a more beneficial community facility than an Op-
             Shop.
                                      FI

          3. Direct the CWA to approach the Coorow Heritage Group for the possible use
             of the RSL Building for the purpose of an Op-Shop
                              N

                                                                        CARRIED 8/0
                             O

                                                                        Simple Majority
                       C
                      N
                U

                                           Page 16
Shire of Coorow
Minutes - Ordinary Meeting                                                             9 December 2020

      11.1.5 MORPHETT PARK GAZEBO
      Reporting Officer:      Acting Chief Executive Officer
      Responsible Executive: Acting Chief Executive Officer
      File Reference:         A1660
      Disclosure of Interest: Nil
      Attachments:            Nil
      Voting Requirements:    Absolute Majority
      ____________________________________________________________________

      Council Role:

           Executive         The substantial direction setting and oversight role of the Council eg
                             adopting plans and reports, accepting tenders, setting and amending
                             budgets.

      COMMENT:

                                                           ED
      That Council contribute towards the construction of a gazebo at Morphett
      Park.

      BACKGROUND:                                    M
      The Green Head Community Association is requesting a Council contribution of $3000
                                           R
      towards the construction of a Gazebo in Morphett Park.
                                         FI

      Council made a budgetary allocation of this amount in 2016/2017 to recognise the 50th
      anniversary celebrations.
                               N

      Our records do not show that this amount was ever paid from the budgeted allocation.
                              O

      COMMENT:
                        C

      A Gazebo was constructed in 2016 but was so poorly built that it had to be demolished
      and another constructed in its place.
                       N

      The Green Head Community Association paid for the construction of the second
                U

      structure.

      Council did contribute $3000 towards the Leeman celebrations and the Green Head
      group are seeking the same.

      STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT:
      Shire of Coorow Councillors & Staff
      Green Head Community Association

      FINANCIAL / RESOURCE IMPLICATIONS:
      Out of budget expenditure of $3000

      STATUTORY ENVIRONMENT:
      Nil

                                              Page 17
Shire of Coorow
Minutes - Ordinary Meeting                                               9 December 2020

      POLICY IMPLICATIONS:
      Nil

      STRATEGIC IMPLICATIONS:
      Nil

      RISK IMPLICATION:
      There are no known risks with this recommendation.

      OFFICER RECOMMENDATION:

      RESOLUTION:                                  2020/109

      Moved: Cr Peck                               Seconded: Cr Heales

      That Council consider an out of Budget Expenditure of $3000 to the Green
      Head Community Association for the Morphett Park gazebo.

                                                    ED
                                                                   CARRIED 8/0
                                                                 Absolute Majority
                                               M
                                       R
                                     FI
                              N
                             O
                       C
                      N
                U

                                         Page 18
Shire of Coorow
Minutes - Ordinary Meeting                                                            9 December 2020

      11.1.6 REVIEW OF POLICY 3.1.1 – SERVICE PROVISIONS ACROSS THE SHIRE
      Reporting Officer:      Deputy Chief Executive Officer
      Responsible Executive: Acting Chief Executive Officer
      File Reference:         ADM0437 Corporate Management, Policy Manual
      Disclosure of Interest: Nil
      Attachments:            Policy 3.1.1
      Voting Requirements:    Absolute Majority
      ____________________________________________________________________

      Council Role:

           Legislative       Includes adopting local laws, local planning schemes and policies.

      BACKGROUND:
      The Shire President has requested Councils consideration to a change to Policy 3.1.1

                                                          ED
      – Administration Operations.

      Clauses (a) and (b) requires the CEO to reside in Leeman and the Deputy CEO to
      reside in Coorow respectively.                M
      COMMENT:
                                           R
      A rescission motion is required to change this policy, and therefore, an absolute
                                         FI

      majority is required.

      STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT:
                               N

      Shire of Coorow Councillors & Staff
                              O

      FINANCIAL / RESOURCE IMPLICATIONS:
                       C

      Nil
                      N

      STATUTORY ENVIRONMENT:
      Nil
                U

      POLICY IMPLICATIONS:
      3.1.1 Service Provision across the Shire

      STRATEGIC IMPLICATIONS:
      Nil

      PUBLIC CONSULTATION:
      Nil

      RISK IMPLICATION:
      Nil

                                              Page 19
Shire of Coorow
Minutes - Ordinary Meeting                                                        9 December 2020

      OFFICER RECOMMENDATION:

      RESOLUTION:                                       2020/

      Moved: Cr Jack                                    Seconded: Cr Bothe

      That Council, by absolute majority, resolve to change Policy 3.1.1(a) to reflect that the
      CEO resides and works from Coorow and that (b) be altered to reflect that the Deputy
      CEO resides and works from Leeman.

                                                                               CARRIED 0/8
                                                                            Absolute Majority
                                                                                     Against
                                                                                        Lost

                                                        ED
      RESOLUTION:                                       2020/110

      Moved: Cr Jack                               M    Seconded: Cr Oakes
                                          R
      That Council, rescind Policy 3.1.1 ”Service provisions across the Shire” in its entirety
      and remove it from the Policy Manual.
                                        FI

                                                                              CARRIED 8 / 0
                               N

                                                                            Absolute Majority
                              O
                       C
                      N
                U

                                            Page 20
Shire of Coorow
Minutes - Ordinary Meeting                                                            9 December 2020

                     DRAFT POLICY – SERVICE PROVISION ACROSS THE SHIRE

      Sub Section:           Administration - Operations

      Policy Number:         3.1.1

      Policy Subject:        Service Provision across the Shire

      Policy Statement:         To ensure that the community and staff are aware of the level of
                                service provision that Council deems suitable to ensure the
                                continued support and development of all townsites/locations in the
                                Shire. It is to also provide guidance for the ongoing locations of
                                different directorates within the Shire.

      Objectives:               Council strongly supports the concept that there are defined levels
                                of service provision that will alleviate community concerns about

                                                           ED
                                reduction or removal of existing services. Council is committed to
                                ensuring that levels of service provision are maintained and located
                                across the Shire to provide the best outcomes for the community.
                                                     M
                                Council considers that there should be a fair and equitable division
                                of services across the entire Shire.
                                            R
      Definitions:              Service provision is defined as the services provided to
                                          FI

                                ratepayers/residents by the Shire and other operating functions
                                includes (but is not limited to):
                                N

                                   • Library
                                   • Department of Transport (Licencing)
                               O

                                   • Lodgement of Applications
                                   • Receipting
                        C

                                   • General Queries
                                   • Caravan Park
                       N

                                   • Swimming Pool
                                   • Payroll
                U

                                   • Rates
                                   • Creditors
                                   • Debtors
                                   • General Finance (Budget, Reporting, etc)
                                   • Record Keeping and Storage
                                   • Computing Requirements (Server)
                                   • Council Support
                                   • Executive Support
                                   • Environmental Health Services
                                   • Building Services
                                   • Property Management
                                   • Ranger Services
                                   • Cleaning Services
                                   • Roads, Footpaths,
                                   • Parks, Gardens and Ovals
                                   • Mechanical Services

                                               Page 21
Shire of Coorow
Minutes - Ordinary Meeting                                                         9 December 2020

      Guidelines:            Council recognises that the operational functions of the Shire are
                             the responsibility of the Chief Executive Officer and have provided
                             these guidelines to document the preferences of Council and the
                             community.

                             It is recognised that there are geographical challenges in the Shire,
                             mainly due to the distance between the eastern and western
                             boundaries. To ensure that services are provided in the best
                             locations to provide the fairest levels of service the following is
                             proposed.

                             a)   The Chief Executive Officer (CEO) will be domiciled (if
                                  required) and work from the Leeman Coorow Administration
                                  Centre.

                             b)   The Deputy Chief Executive Officer (DCEO) will be domiciled (if
                                  required) and work from the Coorow Leeman Administration

                                                        ED
                                  Centre.

                             c)   The Manager Works & Services (MWS) will be domiciled (if
                                  required) and work from the Coorow Administration Centre.

                             d
                                                  M
                                  The following services should be provided from the Leeman
                                         R
                                  Administration Centre:
                                   • Library
                                       FI

                                   • Department of Transport (Licencing)
                                   • Lodgement of Applications
                                   • Receipting
                              N

                                   • General Queries
                             O

                                   • Council Support
                                   • Executive Support
                       C

                                   • Environmental Health Services
                                   • Building Services
                      N

                                   • Property Management
                                   • Property Record Storage
                U

                                   • Ranger Services
                                   • Cleaning Services
                                   • Parks, Gardens and Ovals

                             e)   The following services should be provided from the Coorow
                                  Administration Centre:
                                   •    Library
                                   •    Department of Transport (Licencing)
                                   •    Lodgement of Applications
                                   •    Receipting
                                   •    General Queries
                                   •    Caravan Park
                                   •    Swimming Pool
                                   •    Payroll
                                   •    Rates
                                   •    Creditors
                                   •    Debtors

                                           Page 22
Shire of Coorow
Minutes - Ordinary Meeting                                                         9 December 2020

                                   •    General Finance (Budget, Reporting, etc)
                                   •    Record Keeping and Storage
                                   •    Computing Requirements (Server)
                                   •    Roads, Footpaths
                                   •    Parks, Gardens and Ovals
                                   •    Mechanical Services

                             g)   To ensure that all communities have access to management
                                  staff, the CEO and MWS should work from the Coorow Leeman
                                  Administration Centre at least one day per week and the DCEO
                                  should work from the Leeman Coorow Administration Centre at
                                  least one day per week. These days should be advertised for
                                  the benefit of the community.

      First Adopted:         10 February 2016, 2016-002

      Last Review:           16 August 2017, 2017-108, 18 July 2018, 2018-081, 9 December
                             2020, 2020-

                                                       ED
                                                  M
                                         R
                                       FI
                              N
                             O
                        C
                       N
                U

                                           Page 23
Shire of Coorow
Minutes - Ordinary Meeting                                                               9 December 2020

   11.2 MANAGER OF WORKS AND SERVICES:

      11.2.1 TENDER FOR RUBBER ROLLER 4/20

      Reporting Officer:      Manager Works & Services
      Responsible Executive: Acting Chief Executive Officer
      File Reference:         ADM0566 – Tenders
      Disclosure of Interest: Nil
      Attachments:            Nil
      Voting Requirements:    Absolute Majority
      ____________________________________________________________________

      Council Role:

           Executive           The substantial direction setting and oversight role of the Council eg
                               adopting plans and reports, accepting tenders, setting and amending

                                                             ED
                               budgets.

      REPORT PURPOSE:
                                                       M
      For Council to consider the tender applications received for the supply of
                                             R
      Rubber Roller and Trade in of Bomag BW25RH.
                                           FI

      BACKGROUND:
      The tender for supply of one Rubber Roller and trade was called for, in accordance
                                  N

      with the 2020/21 Budget. The Rubber Roller was purchased in 2010 and is on the
      shire plant replacement program to be replaced after 10 years.
                                 O

      COMMENT:
                        C

      We received three tenders for the supply of one Rubber Roller and trade in, and
      seven for outright purchase of the rubber roller only. The Shire has a Bomag rubber
                       N

      roller and the parts from the old roller fit the new one. The new Bomag roller has
      high levels of visibility. The frame is design to give the operator access to see the
                U

      tyres of the roller from inside the cab.

      Company                Model            New       Roller    Trade in          Total Ex GST
      Details                                 Price
      Smith                                                       $27,272.72        $27,272.72
      Broughton  &
      Sons
      WA Machinery                                                $20,000.00        $20,000.00
      Brokers
      Allused PL                                                  $41,500.00        $41,500.00
      Pickles                                                     $31,818.18        $31,818.18
      Auctions
      MayDay                                                      $40,000.00        $40,000.00
      Services
      Connectra                                                   $500.00           $500.00
      Building   &

                                                Page 24
Shire of Coorow
Minutes - Ordinary Meeting                                                    9 December 2020

      Developments
      Manheins                                              $35,909.09    $35,909.09
      Australia
      Westrac Cat            Cat CW34     $164,870.00       $35,000.00    $129,870.00
      Tutt      Bryant       Bomag BW28   $173,500.00       $40,000.00    $133,500.00
      Equipment PTY          RH
      LTD
      McIntosh & Son         Liugong      $113,040.00       $50,000.00    $63,040.00

      STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT:
      WALGA Procurement Staff

      FINANCIAL / RESOURCE IMPLICATIONS:
      The 2020/21 Budget contains $205,500 for New roller and $40,000 for trade in ex
      GST

      STATUTORY ENVIRONMENT:

                                                        ED
      Local Government Act 1995

      POLICY IMPLICATIONS:
      3.6.2 Purchase of Goods & Services         M
      STRATEGIC IMPLICATIONS:
                                            R
      Nil
                                          FI

      PUBLIC CONSULTATION:
      Nil
                                  N

      RISK IMPLICATION:
                                 O

      Nil
                       C

      OFFICER RECOMMENDATION:
                      N
                U

      RESOLUTION:                                       2020/111

      Moved: Cr Jack                             Seconded: Cr Oakes
      That:
            1. The tender from Tutt Bryant Equipment PTY LTD for the supply of one
               Bomag BW28RH Roller ($173,500 ex GST) be accepted;
            2. Trading price of Bomag BW25RH (40,000 ex GST) be accepted;

                                                                            CARRIED 8/0
                                                                         Absolute Majority

                                           Page 25
Shire of Coorow
Minutes - Ordinary Meeting                                                               9 December 2020

      11.2.2 TENDER FOR CAT 140 GRADER 6/20

      Reporting Officer:      Manager Works & Services
      Responsible Executive: Acting Chief Executive Officer
      File Reference:         ADM0566 – Tender
      Disclosure of Interest: Nil
      Attachments:            Nil
      Voting Requirements:    Absolute Majority
      ____________________________________________________________________

      Council Role:

           Executive           The substantial direction setting and oversight role of the Council eg
                               adopting plans and reports, accepting tenders, setting and amending
                               budgets.

                                                             ED
      REPORT PURPOSE:
      For Council to consider the tender applications received for the supply of
      Grader and Trade in of Cat 120M Grader CW007.

      BACKGROUND:
                                                       M
                                             R
      The tender for supply of one Grader and trade was called for, in accordance with the
      2020/21 Budget. The Grader was purchased in 2009 and is on the shire plant
                                           FI

      replacement program to be replaced.
                                 N

      COMMENT:
      We received three tenders for the supply of one grader and trade in, and seven for
                                O

      outright purchase of the grader only. As MayDay Services have outright purchase
      price of $115,000 Excl Gst and Westrac have Trade price of $105,000 Excl Gst.
                        C

      Company                Model             New Roller         Trade in          Total       Ex
                       N

      Details                                  Price  Ex                            GST
                                               GST
                U

      Smith                                                       $68,181.81        $68,181.81
      Broughton &
      Sons
      WA                                                          $70,000.00        $70,000.00
      Machinery
      Brokers
      Allused PL                                                  $54,000.00        $54,000.00
      Pickles                                                     $86,363.64        $86,363.64
      Auctions
      MayDay                                                      $115,000.00       $115,000.00
      Services
      Connectra                                                   $500.00           $500.00
      Building   &
      Developments
      Manheins                                                    $72,727.27        $72,727.27

                                                Page 26
Shire of Coorow
Minutes - Ordinary Meeting                                                 9 December 2020

      Australia
      WESTRAC                140          $347,400.00   $105,000.00    $242,400.00
      AFGRI                  JOHN DEERE   $360,000.00   $95,000.00     $265,000.00
                             620GP
      KOMAT’SU               GD 555-5     $331,000.00   $0.00          $331000.00,

      STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT:
      WALGA Procurement Staff

      FINANCIAL / RESOURCE IMPLICATIONS:
      The 2020/21 Budget contains $340,000 for New grader and $80,000 for trade in ex
      GST

      STATUTORY ENVIRONMENT:
      Local Government Act 1995

      POLICY IMPLICATIONS:

                                                    ED
      Policy 3.6.2 Purchases of Goods & Services

      STRATEGIC IMPLICATIONS:
      Nil                                       M
                                        R
      PUBLIC CONSULTATION:
      Nil
                                      FI

      RISK IMPLICATION:
                                 N

      Nil
                                O

      OFFICER RECOMMENDATION:
                       C
                      N

      RESOLUTION:                                   2020/112
                U

      Moved: Cr Jack                              Seconded: Cr Bothe
      That:
            1. The tender from Westrac for the supply of one Cat 140 Grader ($347,400
               ex GST) be accepted;
            2. Tender price of MayDay Services for Cat 120M Grader ($115,000.00 ex
               GST) be accepted

                                                                         CARRIED 8/0
                                                                      Absolute Majority

                                          Page 27
Shire of Coorow
Minutes - Ordinary Meeting                                                         9 December 2020

      RESOLUTION:                                       2020/113

      Moved: Cr Girando                                 Seconded: Cr Bothe

      That Council introduce the late item 13.1 as the next order of business.

                                                                                  CARRIED 8/0
                                                                                Simple Majority

      Item 13.1 has been left in numerical order for ease of recording.

   11.3      DEPUTY CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER:

                                                         ED
  11.3.1 LIST OF ACCOUNTS PAID FOR THE MONTH OF NOVEMBER 2020
     Subject                 List of Accounts Paid
     Reporting Officer:      Finance Officer       M
     Responsible Executive: Deputy Chief Executive Officer
     File Reference:         ADM0652 – Financial Management
                                           R
     Disclosure of Interest: Nil
     Attachments:            List of Accounts for Payment
                                         FI

     Voting Requirements:    Simple Majority
     ____________________________________________________________________
                               N

      Council Role
                              O

           Review            When Council reviews decisions made by officers.
                       C

      REPORT PURPOSE:
                      N

      For Council to accept the list of accounts paid since the last list was prepared.
                U

      BACKGROUND:
      The Chief Executive Officer has been delegated authority to make payments from
      the Municipal account. The Local Government (Financial Management) Regulations
      1996 require a list of payments made under delegated authority to be prepared each
      month and presented to the next ordinary meeting of Council following the
      preparation of the list.

      COMMENT:
      The list has been prepared showing payments made under delegation since the last
      list was prepared for the 18 November 2020 ordinary meeting of council.

      STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT:
      Nil

                                             Page 28
Shire of Coorow
Minutes - Ordinary Meeting                                                 9 December 2020

      FINANCIAL / RESOURCE IMPLICATIONS:
      Nil

      STATUTORY ENVIRONMENT:
      Local Government (Financial Management) Regulations 1996
                         - s13 List of accounts

      POLICY IMPLICATIONS:
      Nil

      STRATEGIC IMPLICATIONS:
      Nil

      RISK IMPLICATIONS:
      This review process should help to ensure that payments are always made under
      the correct authority.

                                                    ED
      OFFICER RECOMMENDATION:

      RESOLUTION:                              M   2020/115

      Moved: Cr Bothe                              Seconded: Cr Peck
                                       R
                                     FI

      That the list of accounts paid under delegated authority for the month of
      November 2020 as presented be accepted, including
                              N

      MUNICIPAL FUND
                             O

      Cheques                 20417 - 20426                            $ 4,963.96
      Payroll DD’s            01/11/2020 – 30/11/2020                  $ 130,849.80
                       C

      EFTS                    15733 - 15866                            $ 781,447.40
      Direct Debits           01/11/2020 – 30/11/2020                  $ 27,547.70
                      N

      TOTALLING                                                        $ 944,808.86
                U

      TRUST FUND
      EFTS                   N/A                                       $        0.00
      Cheques                N/A                                       $        0.00
      TOTALLING                                                        $        0.00

                                                                      CARRIED 8/0
                                                                    Simple Majority

                                         Page 29
Shire of Coorow
Minutes - Ordinary Meeting                                                             9 December 2020

      11.3.2 MONTHLY STATEMENT OF FINANCIAL ACTIVITY – NOVEMBER 2020

      Reporting Officer:      Deputy Chief Executive Officer
      Responsible Executive: Deputy Chief Executive Officer
      File Reference:         ADM0652 – Financial Management-EOM Processing
      Disclosure of Interest: Nil
      Attachments:            11.3.2 – Monthly Statement of Financial Activity
      Voting Requirements: Simple Majority
      ____________________________________________________________________
      Council Role:

           Executive         The substantial direction setting and oversight role of the Council eg
                             adopting plans and reports, accepting tenders, setting and amending
                             budgets.

                                                           ED
      REPORT PURPOSE:
      For Council to accept the Monthly Statement of Financial Activity.

      BACKGROUND:
                                                     M
      In accordance with the Local Government (Financial Management) Regulations
                                              R
      1996, regulation 34 stipulates that a Local Government is to prepare each month a
      statement of financial activity reporting on the sources and applications of funds, as
                                            FI

      set out in the annual budget under regulation 22(1) (d), for that month.
                               N

      The form of the Monthly Financial Statements usually presented to Council is a
      Statement of Financial Activity, which also includes supplementary information
                              O

      including an Operating Statement Function and Activity, Balance Sheet and Cash
      Flow Graph.
                        C

      COMMENT:
                       N

      The Shire is required to prepare the Statement of Financial Activity as per Local
      Government (Financial Management) Regulation 36, but can resolve to have
                U

      supplementary information included as required.

      All mandatory information is provided and the closing surplus balances to the net
      current assets at 30 November 2020.

      STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT:
      Nil

      FINANCIAL / RESOURCE IMPLICATIONS:
      Nil

      STATUTORY ENVIRONMENT:
      Local Government (Financial Management) Regulations 1996
                                        -   s34 Financial activity statement required each month
                                            (Act s. 6.4)

                                              Page 30
Shire of Coorow
Minutes - Ordinary Meeting                                             9 December 2020

      POLICY IMPLICATIONS:
      Nil

      STRATEGIC IMPLICATIONS:
      Nil

      RISK IMPLICATIONS:
      Nil

      OFFICER RECOMMENDATION:

      RESOLUTION:                                2020/116

      Moved: Cr Heales                           Seconded: Cr Kau

      That the Monthly Statement of Financial Activity as included at Attachment

                                                 ED
      11.3.2 for the period ended 30 November 2020 be accepted.

                                                                   CARRIED 8/0
                                             M                   Simple Majority
                                     R
      .
                                   FI
                              N
                             O
                       C
                      N
                U

                                       Page 31
Shire of Coorow
                        Minutes - Ordinary Meeting                                                                                                                                                              9 December 2020

                                                                                      SHIRE OF COOROW

                                                                              MONTHLY FINANCIAL REPORT
                                                                  (Containing the Statement of Financial Activity)
                                                                  For the Period Ended 30 November 2020

                                                                                    LOCAL GOVERNMENT ACT 1995
                                                    LOCAL GOVERNMENT (FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT) REGULATIONS 1996

                                                                                                                                                                  ED
                                  Budget Operating Revenues ‐v‐ Actual (Refer Note 1)                                                                     Budget Operating Expenses ‐v‐ YTD Actual (Refer Note 1)
                                                                                                                                                     14000
                       9,000

                       8,000

                       7,000
                                                                                                                                                         M
                                                                                                                                                     12000
                                                                                                             Amount $ ( '000s)

                                                                                                                                                     10000
                                                                                                                        R
Amount $ ( '000s)

                       6,000
                                                                                                                                                      8000
                       5,000
                                                                                                   FI

                       4,000                                                                                                                          6000

                       3,000
                                                                                                                                                      4000
                                                                                           N

                                                                                Actual 2020‐21                                                                                                       Budget 2020‐21
                       2,000                                                    Budget 2020‐21                                                                                                       Actual 2020‐21
                                                                                                                                                      2000
                                                                                    O

                       1,000

                            0                                                                                                                            0
                                  Jul   Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun                                                                           Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun
                                                                         C

                                                              Month ending                                                                                                        Month ending
                                                        N
                                                       U

                                                                                                                                                                     Budget Capital Expenses ‐v‐ Actual (Refer Note 1)
                                         Budget Capital Revenue ‐v‐ Actual (Refer Note 1)
                                                                                                                                                      5,000
                    2,500
                                                                                                                                                      4,500

                                                                                                                                                      4,000
                    2,000
                                                                                                                                                      3,500
                                                                                                                                 Amount $ ( '000s)
Amount $ ( '000s)

                                                       Budget 2020‐21                                                                                 3,000
                    1,500
                                                       Actual 2020‐21                                                                                 2,500

                                                                                                                                                      2,000
                    1,000
                                                                                                                                                      1,500

                                                                                                                                                                                                        Budget 2020‐21
                                                                                                                                                      1,000

                     500                                                                                                                               500                                              Actual 2020‐21

                                                                                                                                                         0
                                                                                                                                                              Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun
                       0
                            Jul    Aug    Sep    Oct    Nov    Dec      Jan   Feb    Mar   Apr   May   Jun                                                                          Month ending
                                                         Month ending

                                                                                                             Page 32
Shire of Coorow
Minutes - Ordinary Meeting                                                                                                                    9 December 2020
                                                                   SHIRE OF COOROW
                                                          STATEMENT OF FINANCIAL ACTIVITY
                                                                   (By Nature or Type)
                                                        For the Period Ended 30 November 2020

                                                                      Amended        Amended YTD           YTD             Var. $            Var. %
                                                                                                                                                          Var.
                                                                       Annual          Budget             Actual           (b)‐(a)         (b)‐(a)/(a)
                                                                       Budget            (a)               (b)

                                                                          $               $                 $                 $                %
Opening Funding Surplus (Deficit)                                       2,205,197       2,205,197         2,346,136           140,939              6%

Revenue from operating activities
Rates                                                                   3,348,686       3,348,986         3,353,719               4,733            0%
Operating Grants, Subsidies and
 Contributions                                                          1,529,346        673,686            690,112            16,426              2%
Fees and Charges                                                          513,158        389,630            410,371            20,741              5%
Interest Earnings                                                          63,551          16,075            10,997            (5,078)          (32%)
Other Revenue                                                              26,050          10,850             7,459            (3,391)          (31%)
Profit on Disposal of Assets                                               26,559          11,065                 0           (11,065)         (100%)
                                                                        5,507,350       4,450,292         4,472,659            22,367              1%
Expenditure from operating activities

                                                                                                    ED
Employee Costs                                                         (2,081,661)       (860,226)         (872,519)          (12,293)             (1%)
Materials and Contracts                                                (2,476,504)     (1,034,902)         (710,978)          323,924              31%    
Utility Charges                                                          (358,143)       (148,970)          (76,841)           72,129              48%    
Depreciation on Non‐Current Assets                                     (6,334,425)     (2,639,305)                 0        2,639,305           100%      
Interest Expenses
Insurance Expenses
                                                                          (15,051)
                                                                         (187,414)
                                                                                        M  (6,270)
                                                                                         (180,167)
                                                                                                                 255
                                                                                                           (177,400)
                                                                                                                                  6,525
                                                                                                                                  2,767
                                                                                                                                                104%
                                                                                                                                                   2%
                                                                                 R
Other Expenditure                                                         (77,435)        (22,362)          (15,896)              6,466            29%
Loss on Disposal of Assets                                               (189,882)        (79,776)                 0
                                                                         FI

                                                                      (11,720,515)     (4,971,978)       (1,853,379)        3,118,600              63%    

Operating activities excluded from budget
                                                              N

Add back Depreciation                                                   6,334,425       2,639,305                 0        (2,639,305)         (100%)     
Adjust (Profit)/Loss on Asset Disposal                                    163,324          68,711                 0           (68,711)         (100%)     
                                                     O

Adjust Provisions and Accruals                                              2,568               7                 0                  (7)       (100%)
       Amount attributable to operating activities                        287,152       2,186,337         2,619,280         432,943
                                            C

Investing activities
                           N

Grants, Subsidies and Contributions                                     2,692,144        1,016,622          760,940         (255,682)           (25%)     
Proceeds from Disposal of Assets                                          297,159          127,514           23,972         (103,542)           (81%)     
                          U

Land and Buildings                                                       (612,526)       (255,175)         (281,992)          (26,817)          (11%)     
Infrastructure Assets ‐ Roads                                          (1,836,358)     (1,427,385)         (501,657)          925,728              65%    
Infrastructure Assets ‐ Other                                          (2,644,848)     (1,101,990)         (287,207)          814,783              74%    
Infrastructure Assets ‐ Footpaths                                         (55,900)         (55,900)         (67,703)          (11,803)          (21%)     
Plant and Equipment                                                    (1,231,861)       (513,255)         (150,802)          362,453              71%    
        Amount attributable to investing activities                    (3,392,191)     (2,209,569)         (504,449)        1,705,120              77%

Financing Activities
Proceeds from Advances                                                     22,729                0                     0              0
Transfer from Reserves                                                    583,325          63,780                      0      (63,780)         (100%)     
Repayment of Debentures                                                  (78,878)          (9,470)                     0          9,470         100%
Transfer to Reserves                                                    (227,334)                0                     0              0
       Amount attributable to financing activities                        899,842          54,310                      0      (54,310)          100%

Closing Funding Surplus (Deficit)                                              (0)      2,236,275         4,460,967         2,224,692              99%    

Indicates a variance between Year to Date (YTD) Budget and YTD Actual data as per the adopted materiality threshold.
Refer to Note 2 for an explanation of the reasons for the variance.

This statement is to be read in conjunction with the accompanying Financial Statements and notes.

                                                                               Page
                                                                                  2 33
Shire of Coorow
Minutes - Ordinary Meeting                                                                                                               9 December 2020
                                                            SHIRE OF COOROW
                                             NOTES TO THE STATEMENT OF FINANCIAL ACTIVITY
                                                 For the Period Ended 30 November 2020

Note 1: Explanation of Material Variances

The material variance thresholds are adopted annually by Council as an indicator of whether the actual expenditure or
revenue varies from the year to date budget materially.
The material variance adopted by Council for the 2019/20 year is $10,000 or 10% whichever is the greater.

                                                                                Timing/
Reporting Program                      Var. $        Var. %        Var.
                                                                               Permanent
                                                                                             Explanation of Variance

Operating Revenues                       $             %
Rates                                        4,733            0%
Operating Grants, Subsidies and                 0
Contributions                             16,426              2%
Fees and Charges                          20,741              5%
Service Charges                                 0
Interest Earnings                        (5,078)           ‐32%
Other Revenue                            (3,391)           ‐31%
Operating Expense
Employee Costs                          (12,293)            ‐1%

                                                                                             ED
Materials and Contracts                 323,924             31%           U        Timing   This variance is due to small underspends in various areas.
Utility Charges                           72,129            48%           U        Timing   This variance is due to fewer invoices being received to date.
Depreciation on Non‐Current Assets     2,639,305           100%                     Timing   Due to the 2019/20 Audit still be completed, depreciation will
                                                                          U                 not be raised until
Interest Expenses
Insurance Expenses
Other Expenditure
                                             6,525
                                             2,767
                                             6,466
                                                           104%
                                                              2%
                                                            29%
                                                                                M
                                                                           R
                                                               FI

Capital Revenues
                                                     N

Grants, Subsidies and Contributions    (255,682)           (25%)          O        Timing   Budget profiling hasn't been done on a number of grants
Proceeds from Disposal of Assets       (127,514)       (100%)                      Timing   Budget profiling hasn't been done on changeover of vehicles yet
                                              O

                                                                           U

Capital Expenses
                                      C

Land and Buildings                      (26,817)           (11%)          U        Timing   Budget profiling hasn't been done on this asset class yet
Infrastructure ‐ Roads                  925,728             65%           U        Timing   Budget profiling hasn't been done on this asset class yet
                              N

Infrastructure ‐ Other                  814,783             74%           U        Timing   Budget profiling hasn't been done on this asset class yet
Infrastructure ‐ Footpaths              (11,803)           (21%)          U        Timing   Budget profiling hasn't been done on this asset class yet
                             U

Infrastructure ‐ Drainage                       0
Plant and Equipment                     362,453             71%                    Timing   Budget profiling hasn't been done on changeover of vehicles yet
                                                                           U

Financing
Transfer from Reserves                  (63,780)       (100%)                               Transfer to Reserves to occur at the Budget Review.
Loan Principal Repayments                    9,470         100%
Transfer to Reserves                            0

                                                                          Page
                                                                             3 34
Shire of Coorow
            Minutes - Ordinary Meeting                                                                                   9 December 2020
                                              SHIRE OF COOROW
                               NOTES TO THE STATEMENT OF FINANCIAL ACTIVITY
                                   For the Period Ended 30 November 2020

Note 2: Net Current Funding Position
                                                                         Positive=Surplus (Negative=Deficit)

                                                                   Last Years       This Time Last
                                                                    Closing              Year             Current

                                                                  30 June 2020       01 Dec 2019        30 Nov 2020
                                                                         $                $                   $
Current Assets
Cash Unrestricted                                                    2,377,046            3,182,501        3,664,391
Cash Restricted ‐ Conditions over Grants                                     0                     0               0
Cash Restricted                                                      1,881,589            1,593,194        1,881,589
Receivables ‐ Rates                                                    175,672              457,485        1,062,359
Receivables ‐ Other                                                    172,451               73,981           77,004
Inventories                                                             25,982               (4,941)          13,241
                                                                     4,632,740            5,302,219        6,698,584

                                                                                              ED
Less: Current Liabilities
Payables                                                              (278,081)           (101,521)        (229,093)
Provisions Loans                                                       (22,729)            (11,108)         (22,729)
Provisions Leave                                                      (291,752)
                                                                      (592,562)
                                                                                     M    (390,744)
                                                                                          (503,372)
                                                                                                           (291,752)
                                                                                                           (543,574)
                                                                               R
Less: Cash Reserves                                                 (1,881,589)          (1,593,194)      (1,881,589)
Less: Unspent Grants                                                           0                    0                0
                                                                     FI

Add: Loan Current                                                         22,729               11,108           22,729
Less: SSL Sundry Debtors                                                (22,729)             (11,108)         (22,729)
                                                             N

Add: Leave Reserve                                                      183,465              180,148          183,465
Add: Lease Liability Current                                               4,082                4,082            4,082
                                                       O

Net Current Funding Position                                          2,346,136            3,385,801        4,460,967
                                                C

                                      Note 2 ‐ Liquidity Over the Year
                                       N

                        7000
                                      U
    Amount $ ( '000s)

                        6000

                        5000

                        4000

                        3000                2020‐21

                        2000                2019‐20

                                            2018‐19
                        1000

                          0
                                Jul   Aug     Sep     Oct   Nov    Dec       Jan   Feb   Mar    Apr     May       Jun

Comments ‐ Net Current Funding Position

                                                                             Page
                                                                                4 35
Shire of Coorow
Minutes - Ordinary Meeting                                                                                                        9 December 2020
                                                            SHIRE OF COOROW
                                              NOTES TO THE STATEMENT OF FINANCIAL ACTIVITY
                                                  For the Period Ended 30 November 2020

  Note 3: Cash and Investments
                                                                                        Total
                                      Unrestricted     Restricted        Trust         Amount                       Institution
                                           $               $               $              $
   (a) Cash Deposits
       Muni Cash At Bank                      54,475                                        54,475                  BankWest

                                                                                  ED
       Muni Telenet Saver                  2,109,116                                     2,109,116                  BankWest
       Municipal Fund Term Deposits        1,500,000                                     1,500,000                   ME Bank
       Cash at Reserve ‐ Bank                                     4                              4                  BankWest
       Reserve Fund Term Deposits                         1,881,585                      1,881,585                   ME Bank

                                                                                 M
       Trust Fund Bank                                                            0              0                  BankWest
                                                                                               800

                                                                       R
       Petty Cash Float                         800

                                                                    FI
       Total                              3,664,391      1,881,589                0      5,545,980

                                                             N
  Comments/Notes ‐
       Term Deposit For                 Amount
                                                        O
                                                       Held With      Interest Rate    Matures       Interest Expected
       Municipal Funds
                                               C
                                           250,000     ME Bank            1.40%       2/01/2021             1,750
       Municipal Funds                     250,000     ME Bank            1.40%       2/02/2021             2,042
                                              N
       Municipal Funds                     250,000     ME Bank            1.40%       2/03/2021             2,333
       Municipal Funds                     250,000     ME Bank            1.45%       2/04/2021             2,719
                                         U

       Municipal Funds                     250,000     ME Bank            1.45%       2/05/2021             3,021
       Municipal Funds                     250,000     ME Bank            1.50%       2/06/2021             3,438
                                         1,500,000

       Reserve Funds                        406,055    ME Bank           1.45%        2/04/2021             4,416

                                                                        Page
                                                                           5 36
Shire of Coorow
Minutes - Ordinary Meeting                                                                                                                      9 December 2020
                                                                          SHIRE OF COOROW
                                                            NOTES TO THE STATEMENT OF FINANCIAL ACTIVITY
                                                                For the Period Ended 30 November 2020

Note 4: Budget Amendments
    Amendments to original budget since budget adoption. Surplus/(Deficit)                                         Current Budget

               Sub                                                                 Non Cash                                                          Amended Budget
      Prog     Prog                           Description                         Adjustment     Original Budget     Variation        Current Budget Running Balance
                                                                                      $                 $                $                  $              $
                      Budget Adoption                                                                                                                            ‐0
                      Permanent Changes
                      Opening surplus adjustment                                                                             0.00                                ‐0
    03       0301     Rates                                                                      ‐3,116,904.00               0.00     ‐3,116,904.00              ‐0
    03       0302     Other General Purpose Funding                                              ‐1,955,078.18               0.00     ‐1,955,078.18              ‐0
    04       0401     Members of Council                                                            200,737.12               0.00        200,737.12              ‐0
    04       0402     Other Governance                                                              457,697.00               0.00        457,697.00              ‐0
    05       0501     Fire Prevention                                                               197,855.50               0.00        197,855.50              ‐0
    05       0502     Animal Control                                                                 19,050.18               0.00         19,050.18              ‐0
    05       0503     Other Law, Order & Public Safety                                              263,784.03               0.00        263,784.03              ‐0
    07       0704     Preventative Services ‐ Inspection/Admin                                       60,920.64               0.00         60,920.64              ‐0
    07       0705     Preventative Services ‐ Pest Control                                           20,119.00               0.00         20,119.00              ‐0
    07       0707     Other Health                                                                  146,578.04               0.00        146,578.04              ‐0
    08       0803     Care of Families and Other Children                                            13,999.11               0.00         13,999.11              ‐0
    08       0806     Aged & Disabled ‐ Other                                                        24,915.82               0.00         24,915.82              ‐0
    08       0807     Other Welfare                                                                 101,851.21               0.00        101,851.21              ‐0
    09       0901     Staff Housing                                                                 120,346.12               0.00        120,346.12              ‐0
    09       0902     Other Housing                                                                  ‐3,241.79               0.00         ‐3,241.79              ‐0

                                                                                                 ED
    10       1001     Sanitation ‐ General                                                          212,795.51               0.00        212,795.51              ‐0
    10       1002     Sanitation ‐ Other                                                             38,053.44               0.00         38,053.44              ‐0
    10       1003     Sewerage                                                                        4,064.00               0.00          4,064.00              ‐0
    10       1004     Urban Stormwater Drainage                                                      64,709.06               0.00         64,709.06              ‐0
    10       1005     Protection of the Environment                                                  19,791.58               0.00         19,791.58              ‐0
    10
    10
    11
             1006
             1007
             1101
                      Town Planning & Regional Development
                      Other Community Amenities
                      Public Halls and Civic Centre
                                                                                      M              68,251.75
                                                                                                    399,582.50
                                                                                                    669,058.51
                                                                                                                             0.00
                                                                                                                             0.00
                                                                                                                             0.00
                                                                                                                                          68,251.75
                                                                                                                                         399,582.50
                                                                                                                                         669,058.51
                                                                                                                                                                 ‐0
                                                                                                                                                                 ‐0
                                                                                                                                                                 ‐0
                                                                               R
    11       1102     Swimming Areas and Beaches                                                    632,643.34               0.00        632,643.34              ‐0
    11       1103     Other Recreation and Sport                                                  1,458,223.34               0.00      1,458,223.34              ‐0
    11       1104     TV & Radio Re‐Broadcasting                                                     ‐6,300.00               0.00         ‐6,300.00              ‐0
                                                                     FI

    11       1105     Libraries                                                                      37,893.95               0.00         37,893.95              ‐0
    11       1107     Other Culture                                                                 149,470.64               0.00        149,470.64              ‐0
    12       1201     Construction ‐ Streets, Roads, Bridges & Depots                               811,068.39               0.00        811,068.39              ‐0
                                                              N

    12       1202     Maintenance ‐ Streets, Roads, Bridges & Depots                              6,158,839.82               0.00      6,158,839.82              ‐0
    12       1203     Road Plant Purchases                                                        1,131,628.24               0.00      1,131,628.24              ‐0
    12       1205     Traffic Control (Vehicle Licensing)                                           ‐15,600.00               0.00        ‐15,600.00
                                                   O

                                                                                                                                                                 ‐0
    12       1206     Aerodromes                                                                     20,093.72               0.00         20,093.72              ‐0
    13       1301     Rural Services                                                                 13,868.00               0.00         13,868.00              ‐0
                                           C

    13       1302     Tourism and Area Promotion                                                    472,352.76               0.00        472,352.76              ‐0
    13       1303     Building Control                                                               93,696.35               0.00         93,696.35              ‐0
    13       1306     Other Economic Services                                                        16,836.00               0.00         16,836.00              ‐0
                           N

    13       1308     Other Economic Services                                                        31,885.50               0.00         31,885.50              ‐0
    14       1401     Private Works                                                                 ‐16,665.00               0.00        ‐16,665.00              ‐0
    14       1402     General Administration Overheads                                               34,000.04               0.00         34,000.04              ‐0
                          U

    14       1403     Public Works Overheads                                                           ‐200.23               0.00           ‐200.23              ‐0
    14       1404     Plant Operating Costs                                                         ‐49,999.69               0.00        ‐49,999.69              ‐0
    14       1405     Salaries and Wages                                                                  0.00               0.00              0.00              ‐0

                                                                                          0.00        9,002,671                  ‐0        9,002,671

                                                                             Page
                                                                                6 37
Shire of Coorow
Minutes - Ordinary Meeting                                                                                                                                                  9 December 2020
                                                                                SHIRE OF COOROW
                                                                  NOTES TO THE STATEMENT OF FINANCIAL ACTIVITY
                                                                      For the Period Ended 30 November 2020

Note 5: Cash Backed Reserve

                                                                                                 Amended                        Amended                       Amended
                                                                  Amended                                         Actual                         Actual
                                                                                Actual Interest   Budget                         Budget                        Budget       Actual YTD Closing
Name                                            Opening Balance Budget Interest                                Transfers In                   Transfers Out
                                                                                   Earned       Transfers In                  Transfers Out                    Closing           Balance
                                                                   Earned                                          (+)                             (‐)
                                                                                                    (+)                            (‐)                         Balance
                                                       $              $                $             $              $               $              $              $                 $

                                                                                                   ED
Leave Reserve                                          183,465            2,569               0           0               0               0               0      186,034                183,465
Building Reserve                                       404,512            5,939               0      50,000               0               0               0      460,451                404,512
Resource Sharing Reserve                                25,847              362               0           0               0               0               0       26,209                 25,847

                                                                                                  M
Plant Reserve                                          697,832            9,770               0           0               0       (145,768)               0      561,834                697,832
Rebroadcasting Reserve                                  24,472              343               0           0               0         (7,313)               0       17,502                 24,472
Joint Venture Housing Reserve                           67,953              918               0           0               0        (19,771)               0       49,099                 67,953

                                                                                     R
Bowling Club Reserve                                     8,757              123               0       2,100               0               0               0       10,980                  8,757
Road Infrastructure Reserve                                  0                0               0           0               0               0               0             0                     0

                                                                                  FI
Pool Revitalisation Reserve                            406,056            4,416               0           0               0       (410,472)               0           (0)               406,056
Tourist Infrastructure Reserve ‐ Accumulation           62,695              794               0     150,000               0               0               0      213,489                 62,695

                                                                          N
                                                      1,881,589          25,234               0     202,100               0       (583,325)               0   1,525,599            1,881,589

                                                                    O
                                                       C
                                                      N
                                                U

                                                                                       Page
                                                                                          7 38
You can also read