Hotel Market Update - Savills

Page created by Kyle Frank
 
CONTINUE READING
Hotel Market Update - Savills
Australia & New Zealand | Q4 2019

   S P OT L I G H T
    Savills Research
                       Hotel Market Update

Australia Int’l visitors up 2.5% • Australia Domestic visitors up 12.3% • NZL Int’l visitors up 2.5%
Hotel Market Update - Savills
Australia & New Zealand Hotels - Q4 2019

  Hotel investment continues
  Awareness, perspective, relative calm is called for in times of turmoil

 Hotel investors typically take a long-term view       • Bush fires - “All of Australia is burning”          to acquire. Investors holding hotels who may
 beyond the immediate short-term issues which are      • COVID-19 - “Inaccurate digital communication        otherwise consider a sale are reluctant to sell an
 inevitably resolved.                                  surrounding the transmission and morbidity rates      asset, for fear that they will not be able to replace
                                                       of the Coronavirus (COVID-19)”.                       it in the market with an alternative property.
 What the past has taught us
 Over the past two decades, the tourism industry       Fortunately beyond the constant barrage                Australian Hotel Sales - Median Passing Yields
 has proven to be both resilient and swift in          of news, property investors are sanguine              10.0%
 rebounding to “business as usual”. Previous           and their capital appetite remains high                9.5%
 anomalous events have consistently displayed a        for investment grade hotel stock.                      9.0%
 “V” curve rebound:                                                                                           8.5%
                                                                                                              8.0%
                                                       A dearth of Australian hotel real estate               7.5%
 • 9/11 Terrorist Attacks & Ansett Airline Collapse    opportunities and an abundance of                      7.0%
   (2001)                                              unsatisfied capital                                    6.5%
                                                                                                              6.0%
 • Technology Bubble (2001)                            The Australian hotel market experienced relatively
                                                                                                              5.5%
 • SARS (2003)                                         higher levels of transaction volume and value          5.0%
 • Gulf War II (commencing 2003)                       during the 2014 and 2015 calendar years, peaking           09       10   11   12    13        14    15   16    17    18       19
 • Indian Ocean Boxing Day Tsunami (2004)              at a total transaction value of approximately
                                                                                                             Key        Median Passing Yield         Long Term Average
 • Swine Influenza Virus (2009)                        A$3.5bn and 73 recorded transactions in 2015.
                                                                                                                                  Australian Hotels
 News travels in a nanosecond                          Since then, transaction volume and value has                     Sales Volume ($m) & Total Sales (no.)
 The profound impact of digital news which             decreased considerably, despite an increasing
 delivers an immediate and compelling 24/7 news        domestic and global appetite for Australian hotels.   $4000                                                              90
 service, provides many advantages and rapid           In 2019 total hotel transaction value approximated    $3500                                                              80
 global connections. However, there is a frequent      A$2.1bn arising from 48 transactions (compared                                                                           70
                                                                                                             $3000
 tendency to over-sensationalise news before the       to A$1.6bn and 41 transactions in CY2018), albeit                                                                        60
                                                                                                             $2500
 facts are available or confirmed.                     that some transactions counted in the 2019 total                                                                         50
                                                       are yet to be completed.                              $2000
                                                                                                                                                                                40
 This is also compounded where internet based                                                                 $1500
                                                                                                                                                                                30
 “quasi citizen journalists” can post an article       The waning transaction volumes and values              $1000
                                                                                                                                                                                20
 without having to confirm the veracity of the         have occurred due to a number of significant
                                                                                                              $500                                                              10
 information. These practices have introduced the      properties being sold to and held by long term,
 frequently quoted “Fake News” into the common         intergenerational Asian investors who typically             $-                                                           0
                                                                                                                        09 10   11   12   13    14    15   16   17   18    19
 vernacular. The sensationalism of news has been       do not trade their assets. In addition, slowing
                                                                                                             Key   Sales Volumes ($m)                Sales Volumes Long Term
 highlighted in recent events with the following       volumes exacerbate the problem further creating       Average   No of sales
 global messaging examples:                            adverse perceptions of availability of hotel stock
                                                                                                             Source Savills & RCA

savills.com/research                                                           2
Hotel Market Update - Savills
Australia & New Zealand Hotels - Q4 2019

             TOURISM                                               ECONOMIC                                          GDP                              EMPLOYMENT
          CONTRIBUTIONS                                           CONTRIBUTION

                                                                              $61                                 3.1%                                       5%
                                                                              Billion                              of GDP                              of Australian
                                                                                                                                                        Workforce

        TOURISM THREATS
           & IMPACTS

                                                                      BUSHFIRES                             CORONAVIRUS*                                  GLOBAL
                                                                                                              (COVID-19)                                 ECONOMY
                                                                $4.5bn Potential Tourism
                                                                     economic loss                                                                     US-China Trade War
                                                                                                           71,429+ reported cases
                                                                      6m Hectares lost                                                                  Brexit Uncertainty
                                                                                                                1775+ fatalities
                                                                      1 bn Animals lost                                                                Hong Kong Protests
                                                                                                            26 Countries affected
                                                                40% forward bookings

             RESPONSES

                                                                   GOVERNMENT                              CORONA VIRUS                         IMPROVED TOURISM &
                                                                                                             (COVID-19)                          GLOBAL ECONOMIC
                                                                $76m Campaigns spend
                                                                                                                                                    CONDITIONS
                                                                      $20m Domestic                      Vaccine expected in Phase 1
                                                                    $20m International                       trial within months                     Bushfires under control
                                                             $10m Hosting Foreign Media                                                            De-escalation of US-China
                                                            $10m Regional Tourism Event                                                          trade wars - Phase One accord
                                                                    Initiatives                                                                  UK elections = Brexit certainty

Note – *these figures are accurate at 18 February 2020. They are rapidly evolving.

Transaction volumes and values have not declined                          Domestic and international funds are mandated            More recently the Blackrock 2020 Global
due to a lack of investor interest. Rather, the                           to chase yield, which in a low interest rate             Investment Outlook reasserted that “Real estate
reduced volumes have resulted in a substantial                            environment necessitates increased capital               looks compelling given the neutral outlook on
amount of pent up capital seeking a smaller pool                          allocations to yield-generating assets, which            interest rates and has historically offered resilience
of available assets in a number of extremely tightly                      includes real estate.                                    against inflation”.
held markets around Australia, causing yield
compression and “fear of missing out” among                               In terms of global asset allocations, the Blackrock      In time the bush fires will be extinguished and
active investors.                                                         2019 Global Institutional Survey (which covered          an antivirus will be developed to combat the
                                                                          230 institutional clients, representing over $7          COVID-19 virus. Things will return to normal;
Domestically, high net worth investors are actively                       trillion in investible assets) noted the following       investor appetite for investment grade hotel assets
investing in hotels due to the strength of the                            international trends which will continue the trend       will continue unabated, and we anticipate a strong
market and the favourable yields being achieved                           of investors seeking exposure to Australian hotels:      “V-shaped” recovery from any downturn caused
compared to other asset classes.                                                                                                   by the adverse fire and virus impacts of 2019 and
                                                                          •      Concern about the economic cycle is reflected     2020.
In addition domestic fund managers have raised                                   in the fact that 51% of clients intend to
both domestic and international capital to invest                                decrease their allocation to equities.
in Australian hotels. Similarly, international                            •      A significant portion of institutions intend to
investors, including pension funds, fund managers                                increase their exposure to private markets:
and private equity, attracted to the stability and                               real assets (+54%), private equity (+47%) and
transparency of the Australian investment market,                                real estate (+40%).
are seeking high yielding hotel assets.                                   •      This continues a multi-year structural
                                                                                 trend of clients reallocating risk in search of
There remain significant amounts of unsatisfied                                  uncorrelated sources of return.
capital which are uninvested (other than being                            •      Insurers continue to seek alternative sources
held in cash), which are not generating returns                                  of income by increasing allocations to illiquid
in a low-yield interest rate environment.                                        assets and credit strategies; 66% intend to
                                                                                 increase allocations to real assets.

                                                                                                     3
Australia & New Zealand Hotels - Q4 2019

 Welcome to the latest Savills
 Australia & New Zealand YTD              Economic Update -
                                          Australia
 December 2019 update.

 This report covers economic
 indicators likely to affect
 performance across the hotels
                                          The RBA eased Monetary Policy three times during 2019 to                                                                                                                leveraged buyers as well, where debt can be
 sector, key performance
                                          all-time lows of 0.75%. The reasoning behind the move was to                                                                                                            raised at circa 3% (including all line fees and
 indicators across Australia and          stimulate the economy whilst keeping inflation within a 2-3%                                                                                                            margin over swap), while investing into assets
 New Zealand’s major hotel                band. Whilst the Government has been slow to implement                                                                                                                  around 5% (national Office yields are 5%, and
 destinations, trends in                  expansionary Fiscal Policy, the recent bushfire events will                                                                                                             Retail and Industrial are circa 6%).
 domestic and international               result in housing, infrastructure and natural habitat
 visitors, plus recent sales              rehabilitation expenditure as the rebuilding begins.                                                                                                                    Overall it is expected that interest rates will
 transactions.                                                                                                                                                                                                    remain low for longer over the next 2-3 years
                                          There have been unintended consequences from the RBA’s                                                                                                                  as the national and global economy continues
 For the 12 months ended                  aggressive easing’s, in that low rates have triggered a                                                                                                                 to produce low economic growth and
 September 2019, International            meaningful rebound in housing prices over the last four                                                                                                                 governments implement economic and
 and particularly Domestic                months. CoreLogic are predicting that if the price rises                                                                                                                taxation policy stimulus. The Australian Real
 Visitors and Visitor Nights              continue at the same rate, they will be back to their all-time                                                                                                          Estate outlook remains positive for 2020 and
 continued to grow.                       highs by early to mid-2020.                                                                                                                                             beyond, supported by low for longer interest
                                                                                                                                                                                                                  rates; under-leveraged property owners; a
 Of the 10 Australian key                 The RBA stated in the February 2020 easing statement, that;                                                                                                             densifying population underpinned by a
 markets reviewed, 5 markets              “the forecasts imply progress towards the inflation target and                                                                                                          positive immigration policy and positive
 achieved occupancy in excess             full employment, but that progress is expected to be only                                                                                                               employment growth; and disciplined
 of 77%, reflecting the                   gradual. To maintain this progress, monetary policy is very                                                                                                             developers retaining a market of scarcity.
                                          likely to remain accommodative for some time”; and it is
 continuing growth in
                                          prepared to ease further if needed to support sustainable                                                                                                               The World
 international and domestic
                                          growth in the economy, full employment and the achievement                                                                                                              2019 experienced global economic geo-
 visitors. Growth in demand for
                                          of the inflation target over time.                                                                                                                                      political events with the US/China Trade and
 rooms was achieved in 7
                                                                                                                                                                                                                  technology dispute, potential impeachment of
 markets; however, 3 of those                                                                                                                                                                                     President Trump, Brexit, Hong Kong
 markets were impacted by                                                                             Interest Rates                                                                                              democracy protests and the potential for a
 increased new room supply,                  %
                                                                                                                                                                                                                  European recession.
 resulting in an overall decline           12.0
 in RevPAR for those markets,                                                                                                                                                                                     There has been some tempering of economic
 as compared to the previous              10.0                                                                                                                                                                    impacts with the de-escalation of the trade
 corresponding period.                                                                                                                                                                                            and technology disputes between China and
                                           8.0                                                                                                                                                                    the US with the Phase One accord which saw a
 New Zealand’s RevPAR                                                                                                                                                                                             rebound on the US stock exchange. The
 exceeds Australia’s by $7                 6.0                                                                                                                                                                    recent UK election results has enabled the
 (exchange rate adjusted)                                                                                                                                                                                         current government to confirm a Brexit date
 which is reflected in the                 4.0
                                                                                                                                                                                                                  of 31 January 2020 offsetting some of last
 strength of both occupancy                                                                                                                                                                                       year’s uncertainty and business confidence,
 (all key markets above 76%)                                                                                                                                                                                      although there are still issues to be resolved
                                           2.0
 and ADR. For the 12 months                                                                                                                                                                                       during the transition year.
 ended September 2019,                     0.0
 International and particularly                                                                                                                                                                                   The US economy continues its longest
                                                                      DEC -06

                                                                                                    DEC -09
                                                                                          DEC -08
                                                            DEC -05

                                                                                DEC -07
                                                  DEC -04

                                                                                                                                                                                                        DEC -19
                                                                                                              DEC -10

                                                                                                                                                      DEC -14

                                                                                                                                                                          DEC -16

                                                                                                                                                                                              DEC -18
                                                                                                                                                                DEC -15
                                                                                                                                            DEC -13
                                                                                                                                  DEC -12

                                                                                                                                                                                    DEC -17
                                                                                                                        DEC -11

                                                                                                                                                                                                                  economic expansion ever recorded. The US
 Domestic visitation grew, with
                                                                                                                                                                                                                  Federal Reserve maintained interest rates in
 a fall in international Visitor
                                                                                                                                                                                                                  the Q4 19 at a range between 1.5% and 1.75%
 Nights being more than
                                                                                                                                                                                                                  and it is not expected to increase rates until
 compensated by a strong                   Key Small Business Housing Large business Govt.
                                           Bond Yeild - 2yr Govt. Bond Yeild - 3yr Govt. Bond Yeild
                                                                                                                                                                                                                  2021. Holiday retail sales were up 3% as at
 increase in domestic Visitor                                                                                                                                                                                     November 2019 and unemployment is at a 50
                                           - 5yr Govt. Bond Yeild - 10yr Cash Rate
 Nights.                                                                                                                                                                                                          year low at 3.5% and is expected to maintain a
                                                                                                                                                                                                                  neutral rate in 2020.
 During 2019, both Australia               Source ABS, RBA
 and New Zealand cut their                                                                                                                                                                                        Whilst there has been signs of improving
 official cash rates as respective        The demand for Australian property remains strongly driven                                                                                                              global economies, the recent COVID-19 will
 authorities continued to                 by domestic investors, A-REIT’s and Syndicators, as well as                                                                                                             impact global growth in the short term.
 implement accommodative                  foreign investors chasing secure and superior returns; and in
 monetary policy.                         the case of foreigners, supported by a cheap Australian
                                          currency conversion. The cost of debt remains accretive to
               Michael Simpson
               Managing Director Hotels
               +61 431 649 724
               msimpson@savills.com.au

savills.com/research                                                                                                       4
Australia & New Zealand Hotels - Q4 2019

                                Australia and City Hotel Market Operating Performance
                                Year to Date December 2019
                                                                                                                                                           RevPAR
                                                                            OCC YTD                                ADR YTD
                                City                         Occupancy                             ADR                                 RevPAR               YTD
                                                                            Growth %                               Growth %
                                                                                                                                                          Growth %

  -1.9%
                                Australia                      73.9%          -0.9%             $185.58               -1.0%             $137.18              -1.9%
                                Sydney                         82.5%           -1.9%            $220.50              -3.0%              $181.81             -4.8%
                                Hobart Area                    83.1%           4.7%             $184.10               3.0%             $152.90               7.9%
                                Melbourne                      80.3%           -2.0%             $186.11              0.1%             $149.44               -1.9%
                                Gold Coast                     69.5%           -3.3%            $196.84               -2.6%             $136.71              -5.8%

 Australia wide                 ACT & Canberra Area            76.4%           -2.9%            $170.54               -2.8%            $130.26               -5.6%

RevPAR decreased                Adelaide                       80.4%           1.9%             $155.55               -0.1%            $125.06                1.8%
                                Perth                          73.2%           0.1%             $164.40               -1.0%            $120.42              -0.8%
                                Cairns Area                    77.4%           -3.8%            $148.32               -2.8%             $114.84              -6.5%
      Best RevPAR               Brisbane                       72.0%           1.4%              $157.18              1.4%              $113.17              2.8%
      growth market:
                                Darwin Area                    55.9%          -14.7%            $146.20              -0.2%               $81.74             -14.9%
      Hobart Area
                                                                                                                                                            Source STR

          7.9%
                                MARKET WRAP                             combat new rooms supply with its                  overall 0.8% decline in RevPAR,
      +                         Sydney was the top performer            robust calendar of events.                        resulted from a 0.1% increase in
                                nationally (in terms of dollar value                                                      Occupancy and a 1.0% decline
                                of RevPAR $182), outperforming          Gold Coast recorded declines                      in ADR. Perth will introduce
                                the next best performing market         across all KPI’s due to a 1.3%                    additional new supply in the next
      Worst RevPAR              (Hobart) by $29. Sydney however         increase in rooms available (to                   six to twelve months.
      performing markets:       recorded declines across all KPI’s      sell) which was compounded by
      Darwin Area (down         due to a 2.0% increase in rooms         a 2.0% decrease in demand for                     Cairns area reported a 4.5%
      14.9%) Cairns Area        available (to sell) against flat        room nights. An overall 5.8%                      increase in rooms available (to
      (down 6.5%)               growth in demand for room nights.       decline in RevPAR, resulted from                  sell) which exceeded a 0.5%
                                An overall 4.8% decline in RevPAR       a 3.3% decline in Occupancy                       increase in demand for room
                                resulted from a 1.9% decline in         and a 2.6% decline in ADR. The                    nights. An overall 6.5% decline
                                Occupancy and a 3.0% decline in         reduction in year to date demand                  in RevPAR, resulted from a 3.8%
      International Visitor     ADR. The increase in supply in the      for room nights was anticipated                   decline in Occupancy together
      Highlights (Y/E
                                Mascot airport precinct continued       following the staging of the                      with a 2.8% decline in ADR.
      September 2019)
                                to influence the ability for Sydney     Commonwealth games in Gold
      International Visitors
      were up 2.5% to 8.66m     CBD hotels to yield rates which         Coast in Q2 2018. For 2019, YTD                   Brisbane RevPAR grew by 2.8%
      & International Visitor   was further compounded by the           Q4 reported strong RevPAR                         indicating that the market is
      Nights were up 2.1% to    impacts from the NSW bush fires         growth of 5.3% on YTD Q3.                         absorbing the recent new supply.
      275.79m                   which commenced in Q4. Sydney                                                             Significantly, a 4.0% increase
                                is ranked Australia’s number            ACT/Canberra reported a 5.7%                      in rooms available (to sell) was
                                one tourism region in terms             increase in rooms available (to sell)             surpassed by a 5.4% increase in
                                of Visitors, Visitor Nights and         which exceeded a 2.7% increase                    demand for room nights whilst
      Domestic Visitor
                                Expenditure for both International      in demand for rooms. An overall                   ADR increased by 1.4%.
      Highlights (Y/E
      September 2019)
                                and Domestic visitation.                5.6% decline in RevPAR, resulted
      Domestic Visitors were                                            from a 2.9% decline in Occupancy                  Darwin saw a significant decline
      up 12.3% to 115.7m &      Hobart area performed strongly          and a 2.8% decline in ADR.                        of 15.8% in demand for room
      Domestic Visitor Nights   due to a combination of a 2.1%          The May 2019 Federal Election                     nights, representing the lowest
      were up 12.0% to          reduction in rooms available            and subsequent deferment of                       RevPAR performing market for the
      410.1m                    (to sell) and increase of 2.5% in       parliamentary sitting days to                     period. Despite a 14.7% decline in
                                demand for room nights, which           Q3, have negatively impacted                      Occupancy, the market managed
                                enabled this market to achieve the      the results for ACT/ Canberra.                    to hold ADR relatively stable
      NSW, VIC, SA and WA
                                highest growth across all KPI’s                                                           decreasing only 0.2%.
      recorded double digit
      growth in domestic        nationally. Compared to other           Adelaide recorded a growth in
      expenditure               Australian capital cities, Hobart       occupancy of 1.9% due to a 3.7%                   International Visitor Highlights
                                achieves the highest average            increase in demand for room                       (Y/E September 2019) China
                                regional spend per visitor night by     nights which exceeded a 1.8%                      which represents Australia’s
                                International Visitors.                 increase in rooms available (to                   number 1 international visitor
      Visitor Nights varied                                             sell). ADR declined marginally by                 accounting for 15% of the total
      with NT and ACT           Melbourne reported a 4.5%               0.1% resulting in an overall 1.8%                 share of visitors, achieved only
      recording declines of
                                increase in rooms available (to sell)   increase in RevPAR.                               marginal growth YOY. The key
      5.7% and 0.3%
                                which exceeded a 2.5% increase                                                            growth market was India which
      respectively, TAS and
      VIC rose 3.7% and         in demand for rooms, resulting          Perth showed signs of equilibrium                 rose by 12.2% in terms of visitors
      9.7% respectively with    in a 2.0% decline in occupancy.         recording a 7.0% increase in                      and recorded a substantial growth
      the remaining States      ADR recorded marginal growth of         rooms available (to sell) which                   of 18.7% in Visitor Nights (3.5
      recording double digit    0.1% resulting in a RevPAR decline      was surpassed by a 7.2% increase                  million more Visitor Nights YOY).
      growth                    of 1.9%. Melbourne continues to         in demand for room nights. An                                                   i) Amounts are AUD
                                                                                       ii) Unless otherwise stated percentages are expressed as percentage movements
                                                                                                  iii) Unless otherwise stated all comparisons are to the same prior period

                                                                 5
Australia & New Zealand Hotels - Q4 2019

      RECENT SALES
      TRANSACTIONS                             Top International Visitor Markets Year Ending September 2019

                       Hotel Cairns - QLD
                       Number of Rooms
                       92
                       Price Per Room

       SOLD | Dec-19
                       $119,565                          01 - CHINA                             02 - NEW ZEALAND                                                 03 -USA
                                                 TV '000                     1 331                 TV '000                    1 276                  TV '000                       771
                                                 STV                        15.4%                  STV                       14.7%                   STV                         8.9%
                       Ovolo Nishi Canberra      VAG                         1.2%                  VAG                         1.5%                  VAG                         4.7%
                       - ACT                     TVN '000                  58,395                  TVN '000                 12,977                   TVN '000                   13,168
                                                 STVN                       21.2%                  STVN                       4.7%                   STVN                        4.8%
                       Number of Rooms           VNAG                         1.7%                 VNAG                       0.6%                   VNAG                        0.9%
                       85
                       Price Per Room
       SOLD | Dec-19   $528,106

                       Paradise Resort GC -
                       QLD
                       Number of Rooms                      04 - UK                                     05 - JAPAN                                   06 - SINGAPORE
                       357                        TV '000                      670                TV '000                     455                    TV '000                       417
                       Price Per Room             STV                         7.7%                STV                        5.3%                    STV                         4.8%
       SOLD | Nov-19                              VAG                       -4.3%                 VAG                        8.8%                    VAG                         9.4%
                       $120,448
                                                  TVN '000                 20,788                 TVN '000                 10,892                    TVN '000                   5,663
                                                  STVN                        7.5%                STVN                       3.9%                    STVN                         2.1%
                       Vibe North Sydney          VNAG                       -7.4%                VNAG                       4.0%                    VNAG                       -0.8%
                       - NSW
                       Number of Rooms
                                                International & Domestic Visitors – Who Goes Where?
                       185
                       Price Per Room
                                                Year Ending September 2019
       SOLD | Sep-19   $510,753
                                                  NSW                              Int'l        Domestic
                                                                                                                         VIC                             Int'l         Domestic
                       Best Western Lake           TV '000                        4,387              38,333              TV '000                       3,131                  29,428
                       Kawana - QLD                STV                           50.7%                33.1%              STV                          36.1%                    25.4%
                       Number of Rooms             VAG                              1.1%              12.4%              VAG                           4.4%                    12.8%
                                                   TVN '000                      97,784              119,177             TVN '000                    74,329                    82,131
                       81                          STVN                           35.5%               29.1%              STVN                         27.0%                   20.0%
                       Price Per Room              VNAG                            2.4%               12.4%              VNAG                          5.9%                     9.7%
       SOLD | Sep-19   $185,185

                                                  QLD                              Int'l        Domestic                 WA                              Int'l         Domestic
                       Future Citadines
                                                   TV '000                        2,763             25,704               TV '000                        988                   10,833
                       Walker - NSW                STV                            31.9%              22.2%               STV                           11.4%                    9.4%
                       Number of Rooms             VAG                           -0.5%                13.7%              VAG                           4.5%                     11.4%
                                                   TVN '000                      55,216             101,682              TVN '000                    24,493                   49,642
                       252
                                                   STVN                          20.0%               24.8%               STVN                          8.9%                     12.1%
                       Price Per Room              VNAG                            1.3%                11.5%             VNAG                         -4.2%                    19.6%
       SOLD | Sep-19   $802,381

                       Box Hill Motel -VIC        SA                               Int'l        Domestic                 TAS                             Int'l         Domestic
                  N
            C LS
                O

                                                   TV '000                                                               TV '000
             TI

                                                                                   470                7,883                                               293                  3,142
         SA L

                       Number of Rooms
        N VI
       A SA

                                                   STV                            5.4%                 6.8%              STV                            3.4%                    2.7%
      TR

                       23                          VAG                            2.2%                19.3%              VAG                           -4.5%                    3.5%
                       Price Per Room              TVN '000                      9,780               28,293              TVN '000                       4,241                 12,622
                       $259,783                    STVN                           3.5%                 6.9%              STVN                            1.5%                   3.1%
       SOLD | Sep-19                               VNAG                          -3.2%                21.2%              VNAG                         -16.0%                    3.7%

                       Base Backpackers,
                                                  NT                               Int'l        Domestic                 ACT                             Int'l         Domestic
                  N
            C LS
                O

                       Magnetic Is - QLD
             TI
         SA L
        N VI
       A SA

                                                   TV '000                          310                1,643             TV '000                          271                  3,067
                       Number of Rooms
      TR

                                                   STV                            3.6%                  1.4%             STV                             3.1%                   2.7%
                       32                          VAG                            7.3%                  6.6%             VAG                            8.8%                     8.1%
                                                   TVN '000                       3,331                9,017             TVN '000                       6,117                  7,503
                       Price Per Room N/A          STVN                            1.2%                 2.2%             STVN                           2.2%                    1.8%
       SOLD | Sep-19
                                                   VNAG                          -6.8%                 -5.7%             VNAG                          18.4%                   -0.3%

      Source: RCA                               KEY : Total Visitors ('TV '000') | Share of Total Visitors (‘STV’) | Visitors Annual Growth YOY (‘VAG’) | Total Visitor
                                                Nights (‘TVN ‘000) Share of Total Visitor Nights (‘STVN’) | Visitor Nights Annual Growth YOY (‘VNAG’)

                                                Source TRA (Share of total visitors for both International and Domestic Visitors exceeds 100% due to multiple state visits)

savills.com/research                                                         6
Australia & New Zealand Hotels - Q4 2019

                                     Australia Year Ending September 2019

            Total Visitors up                       Visitation Nights up                   Expenditure up
            11.6%                                   7.8%                                   10.0%

Total Visitors (National + International) Visitor annual growth
12 Months Ending September 2019

                                                +    6.7%
                                                    TV yoy
                                                                             +     12.2%
                                                                                   TV yoy
          +   10.8%
              TV yoy
                                                    +   18.2%
                                                        TV yoy
                                                                                     +   11.1%
                                                                                         TV yoy

                                    +   12%
                                    TV yoy
                                                         +       8.1%
                                                                 TV yoy
                                +   2.7%
                                    TV yoy

                                                             7
Australia & New Zealand Hotels - Q4 2019

Economic
Update -                                                                                                                           -2.6%
New
Zealand                                                                                                                          New Zealand wide
The New Zealand economy is softening as other                          declined by 2.1, resulting from a 1.7% decline in
                                                                                                                                 RevPAR decreased
developed economies are, despite the low interest                      Occupancy and a 0.4% fall in ADR. Queenstown
rate regime. As with Australia, the Official Cash                      was the top performer nationally (in terms of dollar
Rate (OCR) is at historical lows of 1% (following                      value of RevPAR $198), outperforming the next best
easing’s from 1.75% in 2019) and is designed to lower                  performing market (Auckland) by $37.
                                                                                                                                       Best RevPAR
mortgage rates and stimulate the household balance
                                                                                                                                       growth market:
sheet by generating greater disposable incomes                         Auckland recorded declines across all KPI’s                     Wellington

                                                                                                                                             1.8%
thereby promoting consumer spending.                                   due to a 2.7% increase in rooms available (to
                                                                       sell) which exceeded a 1.6% increase in demand                   +
The NZ Treasury recorded GDP growth of                                 for room nights. An overall 4.0% decline
+2.4% YOY to June 2019 and are forecasting a                           in RevPAR, resulted from a 1.0% decline in
marginal deterioration to 2.2% YOY to June 2020                        Occupancy and a 3.0% decline in ADR.
before modest upticks from 2021 of circa 2.7%.
Unemployment is forecast to be stable at a positive                    Wellington Despite a 2.3% increase in rooms                     Worst RevPAR
4.3%, while inflation will remain low at 1.9% - 2%                     available (to sell) which exceeded a 0.2%                       performing market:
                                                                                                                                       Auckland
from 2020 up from 1.7% YOY to June 2019.                               increase in demand for room nights, RevPAR

                                                                                                                                             4.0%
                                                                                                                                         -
                                                                       increased by 1.8%. This was achieved from a
In comparison to other developed nations, New                          healthy 4.0% increase in ADR which was partially
Zealand is performing reasonably well considering                      offset by a 2.1% decline in Occupancy.
the global impacts of the US/China trade dispute in
particular. The NZ consumer is beginning to spend,                     Christchurch recorded a 2.8% increase in rooms
with Q4 credit card retail sales highlighting an                       available (to sell) which exceeded a 0.7% increase in            International
increase in spending (+1% sa) driven by discretionary                  demand for room nights. An overall 2.4% decline in               Visitor Highlights
durables (furniture, hardware, appliances),                            RevPAR, resulted from a 2.0% decline in Occupancy                (12 months Ending
hospitality and consumables (non-discretionary).                       and 0.4% decline in ADR.                                         September 2019)
Year to date however, the combination of strong                                                                                         USA and Canada
                                                                                                                                        continue to
income growth and weaker consumption                                   International & Domestic Visitor Highlights (12
                                                                                                                                        demonstrate strong
spending suggests that households have decreased                       Months Ending September 2019)
                                                                                                                                        growth in Visitors with
discretionary spending in response to uncertainty                      International Visitors were up 2.5% to 3.9 million for           South Africa and
about future growth in incomes.                                        the year ending September 2019.                                  Taiwan recording
                                                                       Of the top 10 international visitor markets, Australia           double digit Visitors
MARKET WRAP                                                            made up 39.2% of the total share of Visitors, with               growth
Queenstown reported a 0.8% increase in rooms                           China following at 10.6%.
available (to sell) which was compounded by a
0.9% decrease in demand for room nights. RevPAR
                                                                                                                                        Domestic
                                                                                                                                        Visitor Highlights
New Zealand & City Hotel Market Operating Performance                                                                                   (12 months ending
Year to Date December 2019                                                                                                              September 2019)
                                             OCC YTD                             ADR YTD                        RevPAR YTD              Domestic Visitor Nights
 City                   Occupancy                                   ADR                           RevPAR                                were up 4% to 23.4m
                                             Growth %                            Growth %                        Growth %

 New Zealand               77.9%                -1.6%             $191.81          -1.0%          $149.33           -2.6%                +    4%
 Queenstown                81.7%                -1.7%             $242.76          -0.4%          $198.45           -2.1%

                                                                                                                                       Domestic Visitor Nights
 Auckland                   81.1%              -1.0%              $199.25          -3.0%          $161.53          -4.0%
                                                                                                                                       to the North Island were
                                                                                                                                       up 5%, and Domestic
 Wellington                76.6%                -2.1%             $187.83           4.0%          $143.82           1.8%
                                                                                                                                       Visitor Nights to the
 Christchurch+             76.6%               -2.0%              $157.09          -0.4%          $120.34           -2.4%              South Island were up
                                                                                                                                       2.1%
i) Amounts are NZD                                                                                                  Source STR
ii) Unless otherwise stated percentages are expressed as percentage movements
iii) Unless otherwise stated all comparisons are to the same prior period

savills.com/research                                                                          8
Australia & New Zealand Hotels - Q4 2019

Top International Visitor Markets 12 months ending September 2019

  01 - AUSTRALIA                           02 - CHINA                            03 -USA                             04 - UK                  05 - GERMANY
TV '000                    1 530     TV '000                  413        TV '000                   369        TV '000                  234   TV '000              101
STV                       39.2%      STV                    10.6%        STV                      9.5%        STV                     6.0%   STV                2.6%
VAG                        3.8%      VAG                    -8.8%        VAG                      8.4%        VAG                     0.1%   VAG               -0.6%

RECENT SALES                                                 International & Domestic Visitors – Who Goes Where?
TRANSACTIONS                                                 12 Months Ending September 2019

                     Novotel New Plymouth                     NORTH ISLAND
                     Hobson Hotel - NPL
                                                                                  Int'l       Domestic
                     Number of Rooms
                                                              TVN '000          8,277            15,662
                     85                                       STVN              48.3%            66.9%
                     Price Per Room                           VNAG               -3.1%             5.0%
 SOLD | Nov-18       $249,579

                     Comfort Hotel,
                     Wellington - WEL
                     Number of Rooms
                     115
                     Price Per Room
 SOLD | Nov-18       $211,831

                                                                             SOUTH ISLAND
                                                                                    Int'l     Domestic
                     Huka Lodge - AKL
                                                              TVN '000             8,842          7,766
                     Number of Suites
                                                              STVN                 51.7%          33.1%
                     60                                       VNAG                  -1.7%          2.1%
                     Price Per Room
 SOLD | May-19       $87,563

                     Haka Hotel
                     Backpacker - AKL
                     Number of Rooms
                     63
                     Price Per Room
 SOLD | May-19       $185,714

Source: RCA                                                                New Zealand 12 Months ending September 2019
Note: Recent hotel transactions
over 50 rooms
                                                                            International                                           Domestic Total Visitor
                                                                            Total Visitors up                                       Nights up

                                                                            2.5%                                                    4.0%

KEY : Total Visitors (‘TV ‘000’) | Share of Total Visitors (‘STV’) | Visitors Annual Growth YOY (‘VAG’) | Total Visitor Nights (‘TVN ‘000)             Source STATS NZ
Share of Total Visitor Nights (‘STVN’) | Visitor Nights Annual Growth YOY (‘VNAG’)

                                                                                          9
Savills Hotels Research
                              Savills offers independent advice across hotel development & construction, hotel property investments and
                              management of hotel real estate. With local and international clients including financial, investment and
                              management entities, Savills has the experience to deliver on any project, no matter the size or scope.

Key Contacts
Michael Simpson                             Vasso Zographou                               Max Cooper                                   Rob Williamson                                Adrian Archer
Managing Director                           Director                                      Director                                     Director                                      Director
+61 (0) 431 649 724                         +61 (0) 449 979 039                           +61 (0) 431 776 167                          +61 (0) 412 803 482                           +61 (0) 481 037 429
msimpson@savills.com.au                     vzographou@savills.com.au                     mcooper@savills.com.au                       rwilliamson@savills.com.au                    aarcher@savills.com.au

James Cassidy                                Joanne Morris                                Lauren O’Neill                               Timmy Truong                                  Matthew Schutze
Director                                     Associate Director                           Manager                                      Assistant Valuer                              Graduate
+61 (0) 478 333 858                          +61 (0) 438 887 088                          +61 (0) 481 879 876                          +61 (0) 435 138 818                           +61 (0) 451 407 906
jcassidy@savills.com.au                      jomorris@savills.com.au                      laoneill@savills.com.au                      ttruong@savills.com.au                        mschutze@savills.com.au

Savills plc: Savills plc is a global real estate services provider listed on the London Stock Exchange. We have an international network of more than 600 offices and associates throughout the Americas, the UK,
continental Europe, Asia Pacific, Africa and the Middle East, offering a broad range of specialist advisory, management and transactional services to clients all over the world. This report is for general informative
purposes only. It may not be published, reproduced or quoted in part or in whole, nor may it be used as a basis for any contract, prospectus, agreement or other document without prior consent. While every effort has
been made to ensure its accuracy, Savills accepts no liability whatsoever for any direct or consequential loss arising from its use. The content is strictly copyright and reproduction of the whole or part of it in any form
is prohibited without written permission from Savills Research.
You can also read