Harbor porpoises (Phocoena phocoena vomerina) catching and handling large fish in the U.S. West Coast

Page created by Daniel Rose
 
CONTINUE READING
Harbor porpoises (Phocoena phocoena vomerina) catching and handling large fish in the U.S. West Coast
Harbor porpoises (Phocoena phocoena
        vomerina) catching and handling large
             fish in the U.S. West Coast

                Cindy R. Elliser1, Sanne Hessing2, Katrina H. MacIver1, Marc A. Webber3, and William Keener3
                                              1   Pacific Mammal Research, 2 CetaScience, 3 The Marine Mammal Center
Elliser, C.R., Hessing, S., MacIver, K.H., Webber, M.A., and Keener, W. (2020). Harbor porpoises (Phocoena phocoena vomerina) catching and handling large fish on the U.S. West Coast. Aquatic Mammals 46(2): 191-199.
Harbor porpoises (Phocoena phocoena vomerina) catching and handling large fish in the U.S. West Coast
What’s for dinner?
  • Globally harbor porpoises generally
    feed on small prey (< 30 cm)
  • In the Salish Sea common prey are
        •   Pacific Herring
        •   Walleye Pollock
        •   Pacific Hake
        •   Pacific Sandlance

(species common to Walker et al. 1998 & Nichol et al. 2013)
Harbor porpoises (Phocoena phocoena vomerina) catching and handling large fish in the U.S. West Coast
What’s for dinner?
   • However large prey consumption
     has been documented
          • (in mass and/or length up to 63 cm)

   • No previous knowledge of this behavior
     along the U.S. West Coast

   • Information is limited on harbor
     porpoise foraging ecology/behavior

(Fontaine et al. 1994; Aarefjord et al. 1996; Víkingsson et al. 2003; Sveegaard et al. 2012; Andreasen et al. 2017)
Harbor porpoises (Phocoena phocoena vomerina) catching and handling large fish in the U.S. West Coast
Observations
• Land based behavioral studies:

   • Salish Sea, Washington; Pacific Mammal
     Research

   • San Francisco Bay, California; The Marine
     Mammal Center

• Stranding:

   • Cook Inlet, Alaska; Alaska Stranding
     Network/NOAA/NMFS
Harbor porpoises (Phocoena phocoena vomerina) catching and handling large fish in the U.S. West Coast
Observations

• Burrows Bay
• 7 August 2017
• Salmon sp. (Oncorhynchus sp.)*
• Fish capture
• Fish carried sideways

*W. Walker, pers. comm., 21 February 2019
Harbor porpoises (Phocoena phocoena vomerina) catching and handling large fish in the U.S. West Coast
Observations

• Burrows Bay
• 12 August 2017
• Salmon sp. (Oncorhynchus sp.)*
• Fish capture
• Fish thrown in air

*W. Walker, pers. comm., 21 February 2019
Harbor porpoises (Phocoena phocoena vomerina) catching and handling large fish in the U.S. West Coast
Observations
• Burrows Bay
• 25 July 2019
• Coho salmon (Oncorhynchus
  kisutch)*
• Fish capture
• Fish carried sideways

*W. Walker, pers. comm., 21 February 2019
Harbor porpoises (Phocoena phocoena vomerina) catching and handling large fish in the U.S. West Coast
Observations

• San Francisco Bay
• 17 November 2017
• American Shad (Alosa
  sapidissima)*
• Fish capture
• Fish carried sideways

 *J. Ervin, pers. comm., 13 July 2019
Harbor porpoises (Phocoena phocoena vomerina) catching and handling large fish in the U.S. West Coast
Observations

• San Francisco Bay
• 17 November 2017
• American Shad (Alosa
  sapidissima)*
• Fish capture
• Fish carried sideways

 *J. Ervin, pers. comm., 13 July 2019
Harbor porpoises (Phocoena phocoena vomerina) catching and handling large fish in the U.S. West Coast
Observations

• San Francisco Bay
• 19 October 2016
• American Shad (Alosa
  sapidissima)*
• Female harbor porpoise with
  calf
• Fish carried sideways

    *J. Ervin, pers. comm., 13 July 2019
Observations

• Cook Inlet, Alaska
• 8 August 2014
• Pink salmon (Oncorhynchus
  gorbuscha)
• Consumption/regurgitation
• Lactating female harbor
  porpoise (dead/by caught)
Big dinner! – even if consuming juvenile/sub adult
• American shad            • Salmon species
   • Females: 61.6 cm        • Average for 5 species
   • Males: 50 cm              commonly found in Salish Sea
   • Weight up to 5,500g        • 53.8 cm to 80.0 cm
                                • Wet weight 1,858 to 7, 807 g
   • Dorsal spines

US Fish and Wildlife
                                                            O’Neill et al. 2014
New prey species for U.S. West Coast harbor
porpoises
 • American shad: not a previously known harbor porpoise prey species
    • U.S. West Coast (where it is non-native) or
    • U.S. East Coast (where it is native)
New prey species for U.S. West Coast harbor
porpoises
• Salmon species:
   • Known prey species in the Atlantic
      •   Gulf of St. Lawrence
      •   Scandinavia
      •   West Greenland
      •   Baltic Sea
   • This is the first documentation for the U.S.
     West Coast

                        Fontaine et al., 1994; Aarefjord et al., 1996; Heide-Jørgensen et al., 2011; Andreasen et al., 2017
What are the benefits?
• Harbor porpoises have a high metabolic rate, but limited in the amount
  of energy they can carry
• Big fish, big caloric intake:
   • Fish mass is cubic function of fish length, and the caloric value of the fish is a
     product of their mass
   • More important for pregnant/lactating females due to increased energetic needs?

    Kanwisher & Ridgway, 1983; Brodie, 1996; MacLeod et al., 2007; Gallagher et al., 2018; Rojano-Doñate et al., 2018; Booth, 2019
Risky Business: Eyes bigger than their stomach?
• Asphyxiation of harbor porpoises has been documented
   • German and Irish waters: Scad (Trachurus churus) , sole (Solea solea) and cod
     (Gadus morhua)
   • Outer coast of Washington: American shad
   • San Francisco Bay: Smooth Greyhound shark (Mustelus californicus)
• Risk can increase due to large size and/or species with dorsal spines

                Orr, 1937; Scheffer & Slipp, 1948; Scheffer, 1953; Stolen et al., 2013; Ryan & Bolin, 2014
Conclusions
• Harbor porpoises are likely consuming large prey items
• American shad and salmon species should be listed as prey items
   • Understanding type and size of prey is critical to better understand foraging
     ecology
• Behavior may be seen more often in pregnant and/or lactating females
Supporting evidence
• Current work: PacMam and colleagues
  • Documenting asphyxiation cases along CA, OR, and WA
     • Almost all fish were American shad
     • Almost all of the harbor porpoises were females – most were reproductively
       active
More research is needed!
• Wild harbor porpoise behavior remains poorly understood – reports
  such as these are needed to fully understand their behavioral
  repertoire and ecological relationships
Thank you!
Acknowledgements
We thank Steve Elliser, Linda Rogers, Kathy Burek, James Ervin, James A. Hobbs, Levi
Lewis, NOAA NMFS Alaska Stranding Network, William Walker, Annemarie van den Berg,
and Eligius Everaarts for their support, help, data, and personal communications.

Funding was provided by the Orange County Community Foundation and the Andeavor
Community Foundation

Paper is open access: Elliser, C.R., Hessing, S., MacIver, K.H., Webber, M.A., and Keener, W. (2020). Harbor porpoises
(Phocoena phocoena vomerina) catching and handling large fish on the U.S. West Coast. Aquatic Mammals 46(2): 191-199.
You can also read