GROUP OF EIGHT GO8 SUMMIT: AI COLLABORATION AND COMMERCIALISATION PROGRAM - Thursday 31 October 2019 07.45-17.00
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
OUP OF EIG GHT GROUP OF EIGHT G GO8 SUMMIT: GROUP OF E AI COLLABORATION AND COMMERCIALISATION EIGHT GRO PROGRAM OUP OF EIGH Thursday 31 October 2019 07.45–17.00 Monash University Room G31, Learning and Teaching Building, 19 Ancora Imparo Way HT GROUP OF EIGHT GRO
OUP OF EIGH GHT GROUP O OF EIGHT G GROUP OF E EIGHT GROU UP OF EIGHT T GROUP OF EIGHT GROU
HT CONTENTS PROGRAM OF RO 02 EIG BIOGRAPHIES UP 08 T SUMMIT PAPER F UP go8.edu.au 22
PR GO8 AI COLLABORATION AND COMMER- CIALISATION SUMMIT OG R A M31 OCT 2 GO8 AI COLLABORATION AND COMMERCIALISATION SUMMIT
THU 31 OCTOBER 2019 07.45 Light breakfast on arrival 08.00 Registration 08.30 WELCOME 08.30 – 08.40 Welcome to the Go8 AI Collaboration and Commercialisation Summit Summit Host: Professor Margaret Gardner President and Vice-Chancellor Monash University 08.40 – 08.45 Welcome to Country Elder from the Wurundjeri Land & Compensation Cultural Heritage Council Aboriginal Corporation 08.45 – 08.55 Launch of the Go8 AI Capability Statement Professor Dawn Freshwater Vice Chancellor University of Western Australia and Go8 Chair 08.55 – 09.05 The day’s three key questions Summit Facilitator: Professor Marc Parlange Provost and Senior Vice-President Monash University 09.05 – 09.25 Opening Keynote and Context Dr Alan Finkel Australia’s Chief Scientist 09.25 – 09.40 Keynote Address: Artificial Intelligence and the implications for Australia (by recorded video) Professor Toby Walsh Scientia Professor of Artificial Intelligence UNSW Sydney 1 GO8 AI COLLABORATION AND COMMERCIALISATION SUMMIT 3
THU 31 OCTOBER 2019 SESSION 1 IMPROVING AUSTRALIA’S AI COMMITMENT There are extensive opportunities for Australia from the existing strengths in AI and related fields that are within the Go8 and other organisations. As global advances accelerate, Australia will need to keep pace, and preferably be ahead, in niche areas if it is to have a competitive edge in trade, R&D, and across most sectors; including Defence and Space. Considerations range from required investment, much greater industry adoption, and the building of required workforce skills. 09.40 – 10.40 Improving Australia’s AI commitment Panel Chair: Dr Dean Moss Chief Executive Officer UniQuest University of Queensland and Chair of the Go8 Innovation and Commercialisation Group Dr Tony Lindsay Director STeLaRLab Lockheed Martin Mr Jonathan Chang Silverpond Chief Executive Officer and Founder Professor Sally Cripps Director of Centre for Translational Data Science Professor of Statistics School of Mathematics and Statistics University of Sydney Mr Nicholas Therkelsen-Terry Max Kelsen Chief Executive Officer and Co-founder Dr Mike Molinari Managing Director IP Group Australia For open discussion and with panel Q&A 10.40 – 11.00 Morning Tea 4 GO8 AI COLLABORATION AND COMMERCIALISATION SUMMIT
THU 31 OCTOBER 2019 11.00 – 12.00 Case Studies Panel Chair: Vicki Thomson Chief Executive Group of Eight An industry partner and university partner describe how they worked together to deliver a product for the industry partner. They will highlight the challenges, what the industry partner needed, what the university partner delivered, and lessons learned Case Study 1 – Monash University and Australian Federal Police (AFP) Case study on AFP collaboration with the university on the dark web and using AI to track down cyber criminals. Dr Campbell Wilson Associate Dean (International) Co-Director AiLECS (AI for Law Enforcement and Community Safety) research laboratory Monash University Dr Janis Dalins AFP Co-Director AiLECS Lab and Data Science Lead for Digital Forensics Ms Annelize Venter AFP Manager of Information Data Management and Analytics With Q&A Case Study 2 – AI Startup Hivery Case study on HIVERY, an AI startup, established by three academics and two associates from Coca-Cola. It will explore how the company started with an experimental mindset and convinced established retailers and CPG companies to think differently about embracing and starting out with AI and operations research. The case study will cover how HIVERY secured customer data and used a unique product development methodology to co-develop software applications that assist them look at retail space management in ways never possible; scaling to the USA, Japan and Latin America (LATAM) in the progress. The session may also discuss skills transfer, attracting people to AI careers and access to data. Dr Menkes van den Briel Hivery Data Scientist and Co-founder Mr Franki Chamaki Hivery Chief Operations Officer and Co-founder With Q&A 12.00 – 12.15 Keynote Address: Artificial Intelligence – the European and French context Professor Jean Chambaz President Sorbonne University France and Chair of the League of European Research Universities (LERU) GO8 AI COLLABORATION AND COMMERCIALISATION SUMMIT 5
THU 31 OCTOBER 2019 SESSION 2 IMPROVING AI DEPLOYMENT INTO THE ECONOMY AND SOCIETY How people respond to AI, either by embracing, being concerned, or rejecting it, depends on the degree to which AI is discussed in Australia. The Go8 has a role, with key AI industry innovators, in assisting and informing ways to navigate this societal and industry change. 12.15 – 13.15 Panel Chair: Dr Alastair Hick Senior Director Monash Innovation Professor Sarah Pink Professor and Director Emerging Technologies Research Lab Monash University Ms Narelle Luchetti Acting Head Digital Economy and Technology Division Department of Industry Innovation and Science Professor Anton van den Hengel Director Australian Institute for Machine Learning Chief Investigator Australian Centre for Robotic Vision and Professor of Computer Science University of Adelaide Dr Stefan Hajkowicz Senior Principal Scientist Strategy and Foresight and Director Data61 Insight Team CSIRO Dr Jürg von Känel Associate Director IBM Research Australia Professor Nicole Gillespie KPMG Chair in Organisational Trust Professor of Management School of Business University of Queensland For open discussion and with panel Q&A 13.15 – 14.00 Lunch UNSW soccer robots on show Professor Claude Sammut Professor of Computer Science and Engineering and Head of the Artificial Intelligence Research Group UNSW Sydney with: Tripta Kaur Fourth year undergraduate student School of Computer Science and Engineering and School of Mechanical and Manufacturing Engineering Faculty of Engineering UNSW Sydney Ethan Jones PhD Student School of Computer Science and Engineering Faculty of Engineering, UNSW Sydney 14.00 – 14.30 Keynote Address: Australia AI ethics framework Dr Stefan Hajkowicz CSIRO Senior Principal Scientist Strategy and Foresight and Director Data61 Insight Team 6 GO8 AI COLLABORATION AND COMMERCIALISATION SUMMIT
THU 31 OCTOBER 2019 SESSION 3 AUSTRALIA’S AI POLICY, GOVERNANCE AND REGULATION The expanding role of AI demands Australia be ready to navigate, respond to and incorporate the myriad possibilities from this. There are legal, ethical and regulatory challenges. Trust is essential. A fundamental consideration underpinning policy development, governance and regulation around AI is how trust is established and maintained. Regulatory measures, transparency, and AI clarity, plus visibility regarding ‘safe’ implementation are key to achieving trust. Trust extends to data collection, access and usage that enables AI. Associated with trust and safety, are the areas of ethics, productivity, employment, health and inequality1. 14.30 – 15.45 Panel Chair: Vicki Thomson Chief Executive Go8 Mr Edward Santow Human Rights Commissioner Australian Human Rights Commission Dr Jed Horner Strategic Advocacy Manager Standards Australia Professor Jeannie Paterson Professor of Law University of Melbourne Associate Professor Paul Henman Associate Professor Digital Sociology and Social Policy, School of Social Science University of Queensland Ms Veronica Scott Director KPMG Law KPMG 15.45 – 16.00 Bringing it together: Opportunities for action with future collaboration and discussions Summit Facilitator: Professor Marc Parlange Provost and Senior Vice-President Monash University 16.00 – 17.00 Wrap up drinks 1 ACOLA 2019, The effective and ethical development of artificial intelligence p. 18 GO8 AI COLLABORATION AND COMMERCIALISATION SUMMIT 7
LAUNCH OF THE GO8 WELCOME AI CAPABILITY STATEMENT 08.30–08.40 08.45–08.55 WELCOME BIOGRAPHIES Professor Margaret Professor Dawn Freshwater Gardner AO Go8 Chair and Vice-Chancellor President and Vice-Chancellor The University of Western Australia Monash University Margaret Gardner has been Dawn Freshwater became Vice- President and Vice-Chancellor Chancellor of The University of Monash University since of Western Australia (UWA) in September 2014. Prior to joining January 2017 and is leading the Monash, she was Vice-Chancellor implementation of UWA’s 2030 and President of RMIT from April Vision and Strategic Plan. Her 2005 until August 2014. Professor contribution to the fields of Public Gardner was Chair of Universities Health (specifically Mental Health Australia from 2017 to 2019, and Forensic Mental Health) and is a Go8 Director. She is and her research in Leadership also a Director of Infrastructure practices won her the highest Victoria, the Australia and New honour in her field. Professor Zealand School of Government Freshwater is a Director of the (ANZSOG) and a member of Perth US Asia Centre, Vice-Chair the Prime Minister and Cabinet of the Worldwide Universities Inclusion and Diversity Committee. Network and member of the Professor Gardner was made an NHMRC Women in Health Science Officer of the Order of Australia in Committee. recognition of service to tertiary education. 8 GO8 AI COLLABORATION AND COMMERCIALISATION SUMMIT
SUMMIT FACILITATOR OPENING KEYNOTE 08.55–09.05 09.05–09.25 OPENING KEYNOTE AND KEYNOTE ADDRESS Professor Marc Parlange Dr Alan Finkel AO Provost and Senior Vice-President Australia’s Chief Scientist Monash University Marc is the Provost and Senior Alan became Australia’s Chief Vice-President of Monash Scientist in January 2016. He is University and is Professor in the Australia’s eighth Chief Scientist. Department of Civil Engineering. Prior to this he served as President Prior to his position at Monash, he of the Australian Academy of Technology and Engineering (ATSE), served as Dean of the Faculty of and for eight years as Chancellor of Applied Science at the University Monash University. of British Columbia (Canada) and Dean in Switzerland at the As Chief Scientist, Alan is leading École Polytechnique Fédérale the development of the national de Lausanne (Switzerland) in the hydrogen strategy at the request of the Council of Australian School of Architecture, Civil and Governments. He also led the 2016 Environmental Engineering. He was National Research Infrastructure professor and department chair Roadmap, the 2017 Review into the at Johns Hopkins University and National Electricity Market (“Finkel Assistant and Associate Professor Review”) and the 2018 STEM at the University of California at Industry Partnership Forum report. Davis. He has an MS and PhD from He serves as the Deputy Chair of Cornell University, and a BS from Innovation and Science Australia. Griffith University. He has an extensive science background as an entrepreneur, engineer, neuroscientist and educator. He was awarded his PhD in electrical engineering from Monash University and worked as a postdoctoral research fellow in neuroscience at ANU. He was 2016 Victorian of the Year, and received the 2015 IET Mountbatten Medal (UK) and the 2019 IEEE Joseph F. Keithley Award in recognition of his work in advancing the field of scientific instrumentation. GO8 AI COLLABORATION AND COMMERCIALISATION SUMMIT 9
KEYNOTE ADDRESS PANEL CHAIR 09.25–09.40 09.40–10.40 SESSION 1: IMPROVING AUSTRALIA’S AI COMMITMENT Professor Toby Walsh Dr Dean Moss Scientia Professor of Chief Executive Officer Uniquest Artificial Intelligence University of Queensland UNSW Sydney Toby is Scientia Professor of Dean is CEO of UniQuest, Australia’s Artificial Intelligence at UNSW, leading university commercialisation a researcher at Data61, and entity, managing the University of guest professor at the Technical Queensland’s intellectual property. He University of Berlin. He was named has more than 30 years’ experience in science, academia, business, by “The Australian” as a “rock star” management and commercialisation of Australia’s digital revolution, in Australia, the US and the UK. and he is a Fellow of the Australian He has been managing director Academy of Science. He appears or senior business development regularly on TV and radio talking executive of several health and about AI, and has authored biotech companies worldwide, two books on AI for a general including Agen Biomedical, Launch audience, the most recent entitled Diagnostics, AMRAD ICT, AMRAD “2062: The World that AI Made”. Biotech, and United Drug. Dean established the highly successful York Medical Technologies as a start-up in the UK in 2004. He is a board member of several Australian biotechnology companies and was a member of the investment committee of pre-seed venture funds Uniseed, the Medical Research Commercialisation Fund and the New Zealand Government’s KiwiNet. Throughout his career, Dean has managed the raising of more than $100M in venture capital investment. He sits on the NHMRC Health Innovation Advisory Committee and is Chair of the Go8 Innovation and Commercialisation Group. In 2018, Dean was awarded the title of Adjunct Professor in the office of the UQ’s Deputy Vice-Chancellor (Research). 10 GO8 AI COLLABORATION AND COMMERCIALISATION SUMMIT
PANEL PANEL PANEL 09.40–10.40 09.40–10.40 09.40–10.40 Dr Tony Lindsay (Panellist) Mr Jonathan Chang Professor Sally Cripps Director of Science, Technology, Chief Executive Officer Director of the Centre for Engineering Leadership and and Founder Translational Data Science Research Laboratory (STELaRLab) Silverpond Professor of Statistics, School Lockheed Martin of Mathematics and Statistics University of Sydney STELaRLab is Lockheed Martin’s Jonathan is the founder and CEO Sally is Director of the Centre first international multidisciplinary of Silverpond, a machine learning for Translational Data Science, Research and Development and artificial intelligence company University of Sydney and a (R&D) Laboratory. Prior to his role based in Melbourne. His vision Professor of Statistics, School at Lockheed, Tony was with the inspires the Silverpond team to of Mathematics and Statistics. Defence Science and Technology create ground-breaking solutions She was awarded an Australian Group for 28 years. His last position for clients transforming their Research Council Future Fellow was Chief of the National Security industries; from asset management 2014-2018 and is currently and Intelligence, Surveillance and and utilities to retail, healthcare, Director of the ARC Industrial Reconnaissance Division. In that and research. Transformation Training Centre role he was responsible for R&D Data Analytics for Resources and Jonathan is passionate about programs supporting Australian Environments (DARE). She is also harnessing AI to positively Defence Organisation (ADO) Chair of the International Society transform society. He advocates for ISR Projects including major for Bayesian Analysis’s section responsible AI at speaking events surveillance acquisitions and Bayesian Education and Research and conferences, and with industry intelligence programs. in Practice. Her research focus is groups and government. the development of new and novel probabilistic models which are motivated by the need to solve an applied problem with potential for impact. She has particular expertise in the use of mixture models for complex phenomenon, modelling longitudinal data, nonparametric regression, the spectral analysis of time series and in the construction of transitions kernels in MCMC schemes which efficiently explore posterior distributions of interest. GO8 AI COLLABORATION AND COMMERCIALISATION SUMMIT 11
PANEL PANEL 09.40–10.40 09.40–10.40 CASE STUDIES Mr Nicholas Dr Mike Molinari Therkelsen-Terry Managing Director Chief Executive Officer IP Group Australia and Co-founder Max Kelsen Nicholas co-founded Max Kelsen in Mike is the Managing Director 2015 to provide big data and machine of IP Group Australia, a global learning services and AI to large leader in commercialisation which and small clients. Max Kelsen now has partnered with the Go8 and employs over 30 machine learning Auckland university and committed and AI experts and has delivered to invest a minimum of A$200M AI services and solutions to some over 10 years in technologies of Australia’s biggest brands. In arising from these universities. addition to working with corporate Mike has deep experience in and government clients, the Max commercialisation of technology in Kelsen team has recently attracted millions in funding to further its both Australia and the UK, having research into applying state-of-the- both managed university spinouts art AI to treatment selection and and been an investor in them. outcome prediction for lung cancer Mike holds a DPhil and MSc in and melanoma patients. In 2017, Nick Biomedical Engineering from the co-founded otso.ai, a platform for University of Oxford. enterprises to analyse and process unstructured data from any source. It is now used by thousands across hundreds of teams. Alongside these two roles he heads up Queensland AI, Australia’s biggest AI meetup with almost 3,000 members. Nick has a broad range of expertise spanning business, economics, sales, management and law. He has a deep theoretical and applied understanding of cutting-edge machine learning techniques, and has been widely recognised as a domain expert in this field. Nick has a Bachelor of Laws and Bachelor of Economics from the University of Queensland. 12 GO8 AI COLLABORATION AND COMMERCIALISATION SUMMIT
PANEL & CASE STUDY CHAIR CASE STUDY CASE STUDY 11.00–12.00 11.00–12.00 11.00–12.00 Ms Vicki Thomson Dr Campbell Wilson Dr Janis Dalins Chief Executive Co-director of the AiLECS (AI for AFP Co-Director AiLECS Lab The Group of Eight Law Enforcement and Community and Data Science Lead for Safety) Research Laboratory Digital Forensics Monash University Vicki is Chief Executive of the Campbell is co-director of the Janis Dalins, PhD, leads the AFP’s Group of Eight (Go8) – Australia’s AiLECS (AI for Law Enforcement data science capability and is eight leading research-intensive and Community Safety) research co-director of the AiLECS lab. universities. She took up her role laboratory, a joint initiative of He has over seventeen years’ law in January 2015. Prior to this, she Monash University and the enforcement experience across the was Executive Director of the Australian Federal Police. His AFP, including counter terrorism, Australian Technology Network of expertise encompasses machine uniform policing and digital Universities (ATN). Ms Thomson’s learning, information retrieval forensics. In 2018 he received diverse background covers print and digital forensics. His current the Commissioner’s Medal for and electronic journalism, politics, research focuses on the application Excellence in recognition of his issues management and the of AI in addressing serious efforts in developing and applying higher education sector. She has societal issues such as online child machine learning methodologies an extensive media, political and exploitation. He also explores to law enforcement. policy background and was Chief the ethical implications of AI of Staff to a South Australian technologies in law enforcement Premier. She is a Board member of applications and their explainability the European Australian Business in policing and judicial contexts. Council and is a member of the Australian Government’s New Colombo Plan Reference Group. GO8 AI COLLABORATION AND COMMERCIALISATION SUMMIT 13
CASE STUDY CASE STUDY 11.00–12.00 11.00–12.00 CASE STUDY continued BIOGRAPHIES Ms Annelize Venter Dr Menkes van den Briel Chief Data and Analytics Officer Data Scientist and Co-founder Australian Federal Police Hivery Annelize is a versatile IT senior Menkes is a co-founder at HIVERY, manager with highly developed a startup that develops simple web leadership skills and 20 plus years’ applications around complex experience across a diverse range business challenges for retail of industries, including insurance, businesses. HIVERY uses AI financial services, engineering, techniques to generate measurable mining, manufacturing and and repeatable impact. Menkes pharmaceuticals. Most recently has a PhD in Industrial Engineering she held leadership roles at from Arizona State University. His Anglo American and Suncorp PhD research was in Group, leading distributed agile the area of AI planning and his teams and managing large scale prior work in Operations Research projects and implementations of was cited on the front page of operational analytics. Currently she The Wall Street Journal and in leads teams across three divisions numerous other media. in the Technology and Innovation Portfolio of the AFP. This includes the Data Analytics and Data Science teams. 14 GO8 AI COLLABORATION AND COMMERCIALISATION SUMMIT
CASE STUDY KEYNOTE ADDRESS 11.00–12.00 12.00–12.15 KEYNOTE ADDRESS: ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE – THE EUROPEAN AND FRENCH CONTEXT Mr Franki Chamaki Professor Jean Chambaz Co-founder and President Chief Operations Officer Sorbonne University Hivery Franki Is a founding member of Jean is a professor of Cellular Coca-Cola’s first accelerator; a Biology and former Director of the network of entrepreneurs with the Cordeliers Research Center. His aim of building the next generation institutional leadership positions of billion-dollar businesses with include President of Pierre & Marie the support of Coca-Cola. Franki Curie University and following the later set up Red Garage Ventures, merger with Paris-Sorbonne, he a venture studio which builds was elected President of Sorbonne startups by connecting them to University in 2017. His activities in Coca-Cola’s global assets. He is University Associations include: currently the Co-founder and Chief Chair of the League of European Operations Officer of HIVERY. A Research Universities (LERU) Data61/CSIRO backed AI company in 2018; board member of the helping retailers and FMCGs European University Association leverage AI in ways never before. (EUA) from 2015 to 2018; and Franki specialises in the areas of President of the Coordination Marketing, Design Thinking and of French Research-Intensive Lean Startup; and goes by the Universities (CURIF) from 2014 to belief that anyone who tries to 2018. improve a situation is a designer. GO8 AI COLLABORATION AND COMMERCIALISATION SUMMIT 15
KEYNOTE & PANEL CHAIR PANEL 12.15–13.15 12.15–13.15 SESSION 2: IMPROVING AI DEPLOYMENT INTO THE ECONOMY AND SOCIETY BIOGRAPHIES Dr Alastair Hick Professor Sarah Pink Senior Director Professor and Director of Monash Innovation the Emerging Technologies Monash University Research Lab Monash University Alastair is the Senior Director Monash Sarah is an internationally leading Innovation at Monash University. Design Anthropologist, and is Since 2006 he has been responsible Professor and Director of the for developing a successful licensing Emerging Technologies Research and spin out program at Monash, Lab at Monash University. Her with multiple different interventions research brings new knowledge including proof of concept funds about human futures to the design and strategic partnerships with of emerging technologies, in multiple investors. He was the Chair international, interdisciplinary of Knowledge Commercialisation and industry engaged projects, Australasia from 2015–2018. He and through the design and has developed and run multiple tailoring of innovative new research training programs for technology approaches and techniques. transfer professionals. Following 10 Sarah has numerous scholarly years as a research scientist he has publications and frequently gives been involved in commercialisation keynote and public lectures to of technologies from universities academic, industry and other and research institutes since 1999, stakeholder audiences around the including four years at Cambridge world. Enterprise at the University of Cambridge. Alastair has a BSc (Hons) in Chemistry with Biochemistry, a PhD in Chemical Ecology, an MBA from the Judge Business School. He is a Director of Monash spinout Amaero Engineering and was a founding Director of the $30M Trans-Tasman Commercialisation Fund. He has recently been appointed Chair of the Research Committee for the $100M Monash Technology Transformation Institute in Shenzhen, China. 16 GO8 AI COLLABORATION AND COMMERCIALISATION SUMMIT
PANEL PANEL PANEL 12.15–13.15 12.15–13.15 12.15–13.15 Ms Narelle Luchetti Professor Anton Dr Stefan Hajkowicz Acting Head, Digital Economy van den Hengel Senior Principal Scientist and Technology Division Founding Director, Australian Strategy and Foresight Department of Industry, Institute for Machine Learning Director, Data61 Insight Team Innovation and Science Chief Investigator, Australian Centre CSIRO for Robotic Vision and Professor of Computer ScienceAustralian Institute Narelle is acting head of the Digital for Machine Learning (AIML) Stefan is a senior principal scientist University of Adelaide Economy and Technology Division. in strategic foresight at CSIRO. She leads teams responsible for He leads the Data61 Insight Anton is the founding Director of the digital economy, regulation Team, a group of researchers and The Australian Institute for Machine of emerging technologies, digital consultants helping organisations Learning, Australia’s largest adoption and international digital navigate digital disruption. Stefan’s machine learning research group. policy. The division supports research and consulting work helps He is also a Chief Investigator of companies, governments and the growth and productivity of the Australian Centre of Excellence globally competitive businesses communities explore plausible in Robotic Vision, and a Professor futures and make wise strategic by developing and promoting of Computer Science at the choices. He is a world leading cohesive national digital economy University of Adelaide. He has scholar in decision theory and has policies and programs. Over been a CI on over $60m in research published seminal works on the use the last 10 years Narelle has funding from sources including multi-objective decision support. His worked in digital policy and IT Google, Facebook, Canon, BHP research has contrasted structured implementation across various Billiton and the ARC. He has versus intuitive approaches to agencies, including the Digital authored over 300 publications, decision making. His decision Transformation Agency, Treasury and has recently had a medical models have guided investments and in the private sector. technology achieve first-in-class worth hundreds of millions of dollars FDA approval. Current research and have been used by Australia’s interests include deep learning, State and Federal Governments to vison and language problems, make critical policy choices. Stefan interactive image-based modelling, is widely published in international large-scale video surveillance, research literature and his most and medical machine learning. recent book is “Global Megatrends”. He has a doctorate in geography He and his team have developed from the University of Queensland world leading methods in a range and postgraduate qualifications in of areas within Computer Vision economics from the University of and Machine learning, including New England. He is a current and methods. which have been placed recent member of the OECD and first on a variety of international World Economic Forum global leaderboards. strategic foresight communities. GO8 AI COLLABORATION AND COMMERCIALISATION SUMMIT 17
PANEL PANEL 12.15–13.15 12.15–13.15 UNSW SOCCER ROBOTS ON SHOW Dr Jürg von Känel Professor Nicole Gillespie Associate Director KPMG Chair in Organisational Trust IBM Research Australia Professor of Management University of Queensland Business School Jürg is the associate director of the Nicole is the KPMG Chair in “IBM Research Australia” lab in Organisational Trust and Professor Melbourne. He studied math and of Management at the University computer science at ETH Zürich of Queensland Business School, and holds a Ph.D. in Computer and an International Research Science (1991). He joined IBM in Fellow at the Centre for Corporate 1985 in Zürich Switzerland. In 1991 Reputation, Oxford University. he moved to the IBM TJ Watson Her research focuses on the Research center in the US. In June development and repair of trust, 2011 , he came to Melbourne particularly in challenging contexts to lead the establishment and such as after during technological operation of the IBM Research lab disruption and organisational in Australia. change and after trust failures. Nicole’s research and consulting spans the Health, Banking and Finance, Resources, Higher Education, R&D, Defence and Non-Profit industries. 18 GO8 AI COLLABORATION AND COMMERCIALISATION SUMMIT
ROBOT PRESENTATION KEYNOTE ADDRESS 13.15–14.00 14.00–14.30 KEYNOTE ADDRESS: AUSTRALIA AI ETHICS FRAMEWORK Professor Claude Sammut Dr Stefan Hajkowicz Professor of Computer Senior Principal Scientist Science and Engineering Strategy and Foresight Head of the Artificial Intelligence Director, Data61 Insight Team Research Group UNSW CSIRO Claude is a Professor of Computer Stefan is a senior principal scientist Science and Engineering at in strategic foresight at CSIRO. the UNSW, and head of the AI He leads the Data61 Insight Research Group. He is on the Team, a group of researchers and board of trustees of the RoboCup consultants helping organisations Federation and was general chair navigate digital disruption. Stefan’s of RoboCup 2019, in Sydney. His research and consulting work helps main research area is machine companies, governments and learning for robotics. He is also co- communities explore plausible editor of Springer’s Encyclopedia futures and make wise strategic choices. He is a world leading of Machine Learning and Data scholar in decision theory and has Mining. published seminal works on the use multi-objective decision support. His research has contrasted structured versus intuitive approaches to decision making. His decision models have guided investments worth hundreds of millions of dollars and have been used by Australia’s State and Federal Governments to make critical policy choices. Stefan is widely published in international research literature and his most recent book is “Global Megatrends”. He has a doctorate in geography from the University of Queensland and postgraduate qualifications in economics from the University of New England. He is a current and recent member of the OECD and World Economic Forum global strategic foresight communities. GO8 AI COLLABORATION AND COMMERCIALISATION SUMMIT 19
PANEL PANEL 14.30–15.45 14.30–15.45 SESSION 3: AUSTRALIA’S AI POLICY, GOVERNANCE AND REGULATION BIOGRAPHIES Mr Ed Santow Dr Jed Horner Human Rights Commissioner Strategic Advocacy Manager Australian Human Rights Standards Australia Commission Ed has been Human Rights Jed is the Strategic Advocacy Commissioner at the Australian Manager for Standards Australia. Human Rights Commission He works to enhance Australia’s since August 2016. Ed leads the international participation in digital Commission’s work on detention standards and drives engagement and implementing the Optional with domestic industry. He has Protocol to the Convention been engaged in large scale Against Torture (OPCAT); refugees strategy development for the NSW and migration; human rights Government, including on digital issues affecting LGBTI people; transformation and innovation. counter-terrorism and national Prior to working in Government, security; technology and human Jed was instrumental in major rights; freedom of expression; commonwealth anti-discrimination and freedom of religion. He is a law reform and was a project Senior Visiting Fellow at UNSW. director for the Australian Human In 2009 Ed received an Australian Rights Centre at UNSW, Sydney. Leadership Award, and in 2017 he He continues to serve in a number was recognised as a Young Global of advisory capacities in relation to Leader by the World Economic social impact, including as a Board Forum. From 2010-2016, Ed was Member in the NGO sector. CE of the Public Interest Advocacy Centre, a leading non-profit organisation that promotes human rights through strategic litigation, policy development and education. He was previously a Senior Lecturer at UNSW Law School, a research director at the Gilbert + Tobin Centre of Public Law and a solicitor in private practice. 20 GO8 AI COLLABORATION AND COMMERCIALISATION SUMMIT
PANEL PANEL PANEL 14.30–15.45 14.30–15.45 14.30–15.45 Professor Jeannie Paterson Associate Professor Ms Veronica Scott Professor of Law Paul Henman Director of KPMG Law University of Melbourne Digital Sociology and Social Policy Data, Privacy and Digital School of Social Science KPMG University of Queensland Jeannie is a Professor of Law Paul is Associate Professor Digital Veronica has recently joined KPMG at the University of Melbourne Sociology and Social Policy at Law’s Data, Privacy and Digital team. specialising in contract, consumer the University of Queensland. She was previously special counsel in protection and consumer credit Holding degrees in computer a major law firm’s insurance, media & corporate risk team and lead of its law, as well as new technologies in science and social science, Paul national privacy team. She advises these fields. Jeannie’s research and has examined the role of digital clients on complex and sensitive legal teaching covers three inter-related technologies in public policy and issues, risks and disputes relating to themes: equitable support for public administration for over 20 data, digital content and media & consumers experiencing hardship, years. His publications include communications laws, with a focus marginalisation or vulnerability; Governing Electronically (2010– on data protection (including GDPR), the ethics of AI and automation in 2019, Palgrave) and Performing privacy and confidentiality, health records, freedom of information and influencing consumer choice, and the State (Routledge 2018). His freedom of speech laws, defamation, legislative design in regulating research funding includes ARC social media risks and cyber security. consumer and credit markets and CoE for Automated Decision Her work includes advising the new technologies in those markets. Making & Society (2020–27) and education sector on strategic and ARC Discovery Project Government sensitive projects including clinical trial Web Portals as new Government and research, data breach and crisis Actors (2017–2020). management and cross border data flows. Her recent work includes leading the execution of a large and complex Privacy Impact Assessment on the Victorian Parkville Precinct Electronic Medical Record, advising on HREC applications, advising on the response to major cyber security breaches, the monitoring of drones in airport space, data governance for mega-digital studies, international student exchange agreements, establishing alumni programs and the representing media publishers in relation to contempt charges. Veronica was on the Advisory Committee to the Australian Law Reform Council’s inquiry into ‘Serious invasions of privacy in the digital age’. GO8 AI COLLABORATION AND COMMERCIALISATION SUMMIT 21
SUMMIT PAPER CONTEXT AND RATIONALE Artificial intelligence (AI) is a topic of immense interest. It has been described as the biggest commercial opportunity today, with global GDP predicted to be 14 per cent higher in 2030 due to accelerating AI development and take-up, equating to an additional US$15.7 trillion1. It has also been estimated that digital Twenty-nine Australian universities achieved a innovation, including AI and related rating of world standard or more for Artificial technologies, presents a $315 billion Intelligence and Image Processing in the economic opportunity for Australia over latest Australian Government review of the next decade; if Australia can close the university research performance4. Seven of current gap, so it can be at AI par with the those achieved the highest rating of ‘well average of advanced economies, in 20282. above world standard’ – six of which were Go8 universities, with the University of It is therefore an obvious economic ‘game- Queensland and the University of Western changer’. It is also regarded as a tool for Australia achieving the next highest rating political and/or military supremacy, and it is of ‘above world standard’. the subject of ethical consideration3. In Go8 universities it is of significant strategic focus. The Go8 commitment and contribution to, and interest in, AI does extend beyond The Group of Eight (Go8) does recognise R&D; to economics, societal impacts, and that Australia as a nation has a way to go how universities can assist shape Australia’s in AI global status – and in Government responsible, and effective response. funding – when compared with competitor nations. But Australian universities have Meanwhile, the global AI focus has delivered focussed assiduously regardless; contributing a global index of Governments’ AI readiness5 for many years with determination, and and a 100-year AI study6. This year the with international success, especially in OECD7 and the G20 have developed and niche areas. endorsed AI principles8 and an independent 1 PwC 2017, Sizing the Prize: What’s the real value of AI for your business and how can you capitalise? (https://www.pwc.com/gx/en/issues/analytics/assets/pwc-ai-analysis-sizing-the-prize-report.pdf) 2 AlphaBeta Advisors 2018, Digital Innovation: Australia’s $315 billion opportunity, commissioned by CSIRO Data61 3 ACOLA 2019, The effective and ethical development of artificial intelligence, p.22 4 Australian Research Council 2019, State of Australian University Research 2018 5 Created 2017 by Oxford Insights, the Government AI readiness index asks how well placed are national governments to take advantage of the benefits of AI in their operations and delivery of public services 6 Stanford University launched the One hundred year study on AI in 2014 to ‘study and anticipate how the effects of artificial intelligence will ripple through every aspect of how people work, live and play’ 7 OECD 2019, OECD Council Recommendation on Artificial Intelligence 8 On 9 June 2019, the G20 adopted human-centred AI principles that draw from the OECD principles 22 GO8 AI COLLABORATION AND COMMERCIALISATION SUMMIT
OBJECTIVES high-level AI group was set up by the This Summit provides industry, European Commission to make policy and investment recommendations for government, investors, trustworthy AI9. researchers and innovators In Australia, an AI report, part of ACOLA’s with a forum to discuss and Horizon Scanning series, The Effective and consider key AI challenges Ethical Development of Artificial Intelligence: An opportunity to Improve our Wellbeing, this and opportunities. year provided a comprehensive Australian- contextualised view. The Go8’s pre-eminence in AI deliberations, research and innovation, and what that can The Government is establishing an AI ethics deliver for industry and government partners, framework, while Standards Australia is will be examined through three specific areas expected to recommend to Government outlined below. standards required to support AI. The Summit also provides the opportunity Regardless of the nature of AI and its various for existing and future partners to gain a technological forms10, preparedness depends consolidated appreciation of where there is in part on the knowledge generation, and future joint activity, because AI is not an area the adaptation and translation that resides in for delay or for wasting existing commitment. universities and other research organisations. It is an area where standing still means being A core question for Australia is whether left behind. it should lead – at least in niche areas, or whether it can afford to lag in AI. A core question for the Go8 is what can it better provide, via collaboration and commercialisation, to assist build and secure the nation’s AI advantage. That is the focus of the Go8 AI Collaboration and Commercialisation Summit. 9 https://ec.europa.eu/digital-single-market/en/high-level-expert-group-artificial-intelligence 10 The 2019 ACOLA report for example notes there is lack of consensus on a universal definition however defines it as a collection of interrelated technologies used to solve problems and perform tasks that, when humans do them, requires thinking. It expands further to note four types of AI: Narrow AI; Emerging and Disruptive AI; Generalised AI and Superhuman AI GO8 AI COLLABORATION AND COMMERCIALISATION SUMMIT 23
SUMMIT PAPER PRIORITY AREAS FOR DISCUSSION Summit discussion will focus on what is needed immediately, and in the short-term, from Go8 universities, building on their capacity and knowledge. TOPIC 1 IMPROVING AUSTRALIA’S AI COMMITMENT / LIFTING AUSTRALIA’S GAME IN AI There are extensive opportunities for Australia Many countries, though not yet Australia, have from existing AI strengths and related fields announced major investments in AI research. in the Go8 and other organisations. As global Currently Australia is estimated to spend advances accelerate, if Australia is to have around 0.001 per cent of its GDP on AI11. a competitive edge in trade R&D and most “probably the one big country that is not sectors, it must commit and keep pace, and investing lots of money in AI is actually preferably remain ahead in niche areas. Australia” Considerations range from investment Professor Hugh-Durrant Whyte, Chief Scientist and needed, to greater AI industry adoption, Engineer, NSW Government12 and building necessary workforce skills. “China has committed to becoming a Go8 R&D already makes a wide contribution world-leader in AI by 2030, expecting $210 to AI. This ranges, as examples, from machine billion domestic industry. In 2016 alone, learning and robotics, data science and North America attracted $15-23 billion in autonomous systems, computer vision and private sector AI investments. The European natural language processing, to augmented Union has set a 2020 target for a $20 billion reality and pattern recognition. investment program in AI. In addition, countries like France and Germany have It occurs across many different spheres separately announced significant national of activity – such as agriculture, banking, investments in AI. The UK has launched a cybersecurity and cybercrime, energy, home $1.8 billion program which adds to significant and health care, military, mining, quantum, private sector investment. In Asia, economies space, suicide prevention and underwater such as Japan, Korea and Singapore are also environments. making large investments into AI technology.” Work includes industry partnerships and AlphaBeta Advisors13 examining the implementation aspects of AI, be they economic, social, ethical, or cultural, In addition to ranking 11th on the Government as well as collaborating on regulation, public AI Readiness Index (Oxford Insights), Australia policy and governance. ranks 10th on the Automation Readiness Index which measures the extent to which the policy How opportunities are taken up depends on environment in 25 countries meets an ideal what the supportive environment is. policy response to intelligent automation14. 11 https://www.adelaide.edu.au/aiml/system/files/media/documents/2019-05/AIML%20final%20release.pdf 12 Durrant-Whyte, H. 2019. Can AI make the world a better place? Speech to Ashurst series of AI Forums, 30 July 2019 (https://www.ashurst.com/en/news-and-insights/insights/the-state-of-ai-in-australia/ can-ai-make-the-world-a-better-place-transcript/) 13 AlphaBeta Advisors 2018, Digital Innovation: Australia’s $315 billion opportunity, commissioned by CSIRO Data61 14 https://www.automationreadiness.eiu.com/ 24 GO8 AI COLLABORATION AND COMMERCIALISATION SUMMIT
For Australia to thrive, the ACOLA report The Australian Government has also calls for the establishment of a robust, introduced a consumer data right, to apply harmonised regulatory environment that firstly to the banking sector, followed by is designed to support local innovation, the energy sector and potentially the help start-up companies to commercialise telecommunications sector. This would give AI technologies and to foster economic Australians greatly improved access to their development. own data, with accredited trusted service providers to be allowed access20. Healthcare, agriculture, mining and advanced manufacturing are areas the report proposes Meanwhile, the Australian Information Industry could present key opportunities15. It is also Association (AIIA), the peak member body suggested that human services, financial for the information and communications services, transport and logistics are other technology (ICT) industry, has called for skills existing sectors that may be transformed development and an effective R&D Tax Incentive by AI16. to encourage a more favourable business environment for innovation, commercialisation A September 2019 report commissioned by and export of Australian AI products21. the Federal Minister for Industry, Innovation and Science assesses that new technologies In its 2018–19 Budget, the Australian such as data analytics, automation and Government committed $25 million in robotics in the mining, oil and gas industries additional funding for the Cooperative could add over $70 billion to the economy Research Centres (CRC) program to support in 2030 and create thousands of new jobs additional CRC projects with a focus on AI. domestically17. The intent of the CRC investment is to Access to data, and the effective digital strengthen the link between research infrastructure to make this possible, as well organisations engaged in AI and machine as appropriate data collection policies and learning, and industry seeking solutions or procedures are considered necessary18. exploring opportunities22. It formed part of a The National Data Commission was in broader Government $29.9 million measure, September 2019 consulting on Data Sharing which included AI and machine learning (ML) and Release legislative reforms to improve funding-focused PhD scholarships, and school data sharing and use across the public sector related learning to address skill gaps23. and to enable government agencies to However, such investment may need to be safely share public sector data with trusted significantly boosted if Australia is to “close users, including academics, scientists and the gap” with comparable economies, let innovators19. alone achieve AI leadership. 15 ACOLA 2019, The effective and ethical development of artificial intelligence p.13 16 Standards Australia 2019, Developing standards for AI – Hearing Australia’s Voice 17 AlphaBeta Advisors 2019, Staying Ahead of the Game, and The Hon Karen Andrews MP 2019, ‘New Technologies to accelerate resources industry’, 16 September (media release) 18 ACOLA 2019, The effective and ethical development of artificial intelligence p.13 19 https://www.datacommissioner.gov.au/resources/discussion-paper 20 https://treasury.gov.au/consumer-data-right 21 https://www.aiia.com.au/documents/aiia-news/2019/digital-skills-shortages-and-r-and-d-tax-incentives-remain- obstacles-to-artificial-intelligence-ai-development-in-australia,-says-aiia 22 Department of Industry, Innovation and Science, Factsheet: Additional Funding for CRC projects in Artificial Intelligence 23 The Treasury 2018, Budget Measures 2018–19 – Part 2: Expense measures GO8 AI COLLABORATION AND COMMERCIALISATION SUMMIT 25
SUMMIT PAPER PRIORITY AREAS FOR DISCUSSION QUESTIONS Threshold AI Question: Is there a frank discussion to be had on the consequences of AI inaction for Australia? If we support action (as the Go8 does), how do we differentiate (if at all) from competitor nations, to deliver Australia a competitive advantage? Or, doesn’t Australia need to be at the forefront of AI, and if not why not? Even if we don’t lead, can we adopt AI effectively unless we participate to some extent in its development? How could Australia make an AI difference, and how could the Go8 contribute? How could conditions that help to translate and commercialise AI be improved? What foundational science, alongside significant technology, is required to support and ensure Australian AI performance? What talent is required? How can the Go8 assist address this and recruitment challenges? TOPIC 2 IMPROVING AI DEPLOYMENT INTO THE ECONOMY AND SOCIETY How people respond to AI, either by of AI in financial markets. The potential for embracing, being concerned, or rejecting robots and AI to replace jobs was also viewed it, depends on the degree to which AI is negatively by the majority of respondents.’ discussed in Australia. The Go8 has a role, ACOLA 2019 report, p.190 with key AI industry innovators, in assisting and informing ways to navigate this societal ‘while the impact of AI is often described and industry change. as ‘revolutionary’ and ‘impending’, there is no guarantee that AI technologies such as “AI systems should be designed in a way autonomous vehicles will have their intended that respects the rule of law, human rights, effects, or even that their uptake in society democratic values and diversity, and they will be inevitable or seamless.’ should include appropriate safeguards to ACOLA 2019, The effective and ethical development ensure a fair and just society.“ of artificial intelligence, p.22 OECD Principle on AI, No. 224 “AI is a very important thing and it’s seriously ‘attitudes towards AI are mostly positive impacting everything at the moment (…) it is or neutral. However, there were concerns nevertheless on a cycle.” about the risks of driverless vehicles, the use Professor Hugh-Durrant Whyte, Chief Scientist and of robots in the armed forces and the use Engineer, NSW Government25 24 https://www.oecd.org/science/forty-two-countries-adopt-new-oecd-principles-on-artificial-intelligence.htm 25 Durrant-Whyte, H. 2019. Can AI make the world a better place? Speech to Ashurst series of AI Forums, 30 July 2019 (https://www.ashurst.com/en/news-and-insights/insights/the-state-of-ai-in-australia/ can-ai-make-the-world-a-better-place-transcript/) 26 GO8 AI COLLABORATION AND COMMERCIALISATION SUMMIT
Expertise that can help governments, potential AI risks, they are the least prepared organisations and people understand to deal with them, with the top two concerns how to navigate AI appears essential. (reflecting global views) being AI cybersecurity vulnerabilities and incorrect AI-based decision For example, Monash University has making31,32. examined how the hype of self-driving vehicles can be separated from the reality In January 2019, an open letter from key of how they can become part of society26. business leaders raised the need for a governing body to set standards and The National Facility for Human-Robot guidelines for the ethical use of AI33. And Interaction Research examines how ACOLA recommended an independently led people interact with technological devices AI body with membership from government, including robots. This builds on previous academia and the private sector to provide work by UNSW’s Creative Robotics Lab to leadership and skills in a holistic manner34. test robots including in the workplace27 in collaboration with Fuji Xerox Technology Sectoral analyses also contribute to an Group28. understanding of any potential AI impact for industry35. How Australian industry will In 2018, the University of Adelaide’s navigate its uptake of AI depends on how Institute of Machine Learning submitted well informed and resourced it is, including a discussion paper on the Impact of AI by accessing academic expertise or research- to the Senate Select Committee on the based AI approaches. Future of Work and Workers29. “Unless you think it through, artificial A University of Queensland researcher intelligence will have very serious received Facebook funding to examine consequences. [There will be] wholesale loss how human involvement to support AI can of jobs UNLESS you retrain your workforce, help adjust AI use, and identify fake news30. and challenge them to train up, give them External to the Go8 a recent report by Deloitte the time and give them the ability and the Australia, indicates that while Australian remuneration while they train so they can businesses are the most concerned of seven get into higher skills and better paid, more surveyed countries (Australia, Canada, China, interesting jobs.” Germany, France, the UK and the US) about Andrew Forrest, Chairman Fortescue Metals36 26 https://lens.monash.edu/@design-architecture/2019/07/05/1375635/emerging-technology-and-artificial- intelligence-separating-the-hype-from-reality 27 PwC 2017, Sizing the Prize: What’s the real value of AI for your business and how can you capitalise? 28 Go8 AI Capability Statement and https://newsroom.unsw.edu.au/news/science-tech/being-human 29 https://www.aph.gov.au/DocumentStore.ashx?id=2f5995c3-6fc3-4d45-9d52-df58c7cce7c8&subId=611580 30 https://theconversation.com/users-and-their-bias-are-key-to-fighting-fake-news-on-facebook-ai-isnt-smart- enough-yet-123767 31 Deloitte Insights 2019, Future in the Balance: How Countries are pursuing an AI advantage. 32 https://www2.deloitte.com/au/en/pages/media-releases/articles/australia-unprepared-for-ai-risks-070519.html 33 Nott, G. (2019) ‘AI ethics debate urgent say Aussie business chiefs and academics’, Computerworld, 25 January, retrieved from https://www.computerworld.com.au/article/656724/ai-ethics-debate-urgent-say- aussie-business-chiefs-academics/ 34 ACOLA 2019, The effective and ethical development of artificial intelligence p. 13 35 PwC 2017, Sizing the Prize: What’s the real value of AI for your business and how can you capitalise? 36 Kerr, P (2019) ‘Forrest sees long life at FMG’s Eliwana’, The Australian Financial Review, 25 July 2019 GO8 AI COLLABORATION AND COMMERCIALISATION SUMMIT 27
SUMMIT PAPER PRIORITY AREAS FOR DISCUSSION “these frontier technologies are all about Appropriate skills are also a prime augmenting human intelligence, not taking consideration, with 72 per cent of Australian jobs.” businesses surveyed indicating there were Shaun Gregory, Senior Vice-president and moderate to extreme AI skills gaps in Chief Technology Officer, Woodside Energy37 Australia. Achieving trust has been shown to be The ACOLA report notes demand for AI Skills important. For example, workers’ trust in and expertise has resulted in an international AI technologies depends on algorithm race to attract AI talent. Australia is potentially transparency, having positive AI experiences, able to take advantage of this if it positions and technology responsiveness to people, as itself as a world leader, plus on where it can well as the control level workers can have38. excel, and through strategic investment40. The European Commission recently The Go8, as a core contributor of AI research recommended that, to understand AI’s and skills, can potentially play a large role societal impact, research on potential in achieving this goal. Beyond research, impact should be encouraged, R&D of tools cognitive, and technical skills, the ACOLA should be supported to enable independent report also emphasises the necessity for testing of AI systems, and to inform people human skills such as emotional literacy, of the most trustworthy AI solutions, and communication, creativity and negotiation skills that monitoring mechanisms are needed to assist in adapting to AI, as well as context- to continually analyse, measure and score based skills such as ability to detect poor or impact39. malicious AI or health specific skills in AI41. QUESTIONS Should the Go8’s approach to AI be different to any other ethically and value-affected endeavour of this scale such as space or genomics advancement? How should the Go8 plan to help Australian society and industry adjust to AI? What major gaps need to be addressed to achieve optimal industry adoption of AI? How can societal and industry AI trust be effectively achieved and maintained, and how can the Go8 support this? How should people be educated about AI, and what how can the Go8 assist to ensure appropriate AI-oriented skills in adopters? 37 Gregory, S. (2017) ‘Woodside says robots and AI will make, not take, jobs’, The Australian Financial Review, 14 August 38 ACOLA 2019, The effective and ethical development of artificial intelligence p.77 39 High-Level Expert Group on AI (AI HLEG) 2019, Policy and Investment Recommendations for Trustworthy AI 40 ACOLA 2019, The effective and ethical development of artificial intelligence p. 5 41 ACOLA 2019, The effective and ethical development of artificial intelligence Chapter 3 28 GO8 AI COLLABORATION AND COMMERCIALISATION SUMMIT
You can also read