Global Warming's Increasingly Visible Impacts
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
Acknowledgments We would like to thank Dr. Michael Oppenheimer (Princeton Univ.), Dr. Tim Male, Annie Petsonk, Peter Goldmark and Melissa Carey for reviewing this report. Erica Rowell, Allan Margolin and Elizabeth Thompson provided helpful comments and suggestions. Lauren Sacks, Deepali Dhar, Valentin Bellassen and Alena Herklotz provided valuable assistance with researching and drafting parts of the report. Thanks go to Miriam Horn for the editing work, Bonnie Greenfield for the design and pro- duction, and Sarah Stevens, Jennifer Coleman and Tim Connor for assistance in obtaining images. Cover images: Ray Berkelsman, CRC Reef, Townsville (bleached corals), Bryan Dahlberg/FEMA News Photo (wildfire), U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (Arctic fox) Our mission Environmental Defense is dedicated to protecting the environmental rights of all people, including the right to clean air, clean water, healthy food and flourishing ecosystems. Guided by science, we work to create practical solutions that win lasting political, economic and social support because they are nonpartisan, cost-effective and fair. ©2005 Environmental Defense The complete report is available online at www.environmentaldefense.org.
Contents Signs of global warming in the United States, region by region iv Executive summary v Introduction 1 Part I: Extreme events 3 Killer heat waves 3 Torrential rains and flooding 4 Drought 5 Forests and wildfires 7 Part II: Sea level rise and coastal flooding 10 Part III: Snow, land ice and sea ice 13 Shrinking snowpack 13 Vanishing glaciers 13 Polar ice disintegration 16 Melting permafrost and damage to infrastructure 17 Part IV: Ecological impacts 19 Damage to coral reefs 19 Shifting species ranges and yearly cycles 20 Declining Arctic animal populations 20 Declining amphibian populations 22 Part V: Outbreaks of vector-borne diseases 24 Conclusion 26 References 27 iii
Signs of global warming in the United States, region by region Southeast/South-Central/ Sierra Nevada peaks 3 weeks earlier. Caribbean Islands Part III, “Shrinking snowpack,” page 13. • Smoke from record wildfires in Mexico • South Cascade Glacier in Washington triggers health alert in Texas, 1998. at smallest size ever in the last 6,000 Part I, “Forests and wildfires,” page 7. years. Part III, “Vanishing glaciers,” • Loss of nearly 1 million acres of page 13. wetlands in Louisiana due in part to • Decline in populations of mountain sea-level rise. Part II, page 10. amphibians in Pacific Northwest. • Coral bleaching in consecutive years Part IV, “Declining amphibian popu- observed for the first time in Florida lations,” page 22. Keys 1997–1998. Part IV, “Damage to • First large-scale coral bleaching event coral reefs,” page 19. ever documented in Hawaii in 1996. Part IV, “Damage to coral reefs,” page 19. Northeast/Mid-Atlantic • Loss of large areas of wetlands in Alaska Chesapeake Bay. Part II, page 10. • World's largest recorded outbreak of spruce bark beetles, 1990s. Part I, Midwest/Plains “Forests and wildfires,” page 7. • Deadly Chicago heat wave, 1995. • Worst fire season in 2004; record levels Part I, “Killer Heat Waves,” page 3. of unhealthful smoke particles. Part I “Forests and wildfires,” page 7. Rocky Mountains/Southwest • Shrinkage and thinning of sea ice • One of the worst droughts in 500 years affecting traditional hunting. Part III, in the West, 1999-2004. Part I, “Polar ice disintegration,” page 16. “Drought,” page 5. • Damage to houses, roads, and villages • Worst wildfire season in 50 years in and disruption of mining activities by the West, 2000. Part I, “Forests and melting permafrost. Part III, “Melting wildfires,” page 7. permafrost and damage to infrastructure,” • 16% decline in snowpack in the page 17. Rockies; Spring snow melt begins • Decline in caribou populations due to nine days earlier. Part III, “Shrinking earlier spring. Part IV, “Declining Arctic snowpack,” page 13. animal populations,” page 20. • Dramatic shrinkage of glaciers in Glacier National Park. Part III, Nationwide “Vanishing glaciers,” page 13. • Increase in frequency of intense • Outbreaks of hantavirus in the past precipitation events. Part I, “Torrential decade linked to heavy rains. Part V, rains and flooding,” page 4. page 24. • Sea level rise averaging 4 to 8 inches over 20th century. Part II, page 10. Pacific Coast/Hawaii/ • Migrations and shifts in yearly cycles Pacific Islands of plants and animals, including many • 29% decline in snowpack in the butterfly species. Part IV, “Shifting Cascades; streamflow throughout species ranges and yearly cycles,” page 20. iv
Executive summary Global warming will not only be felt many Europe in July and August of 2003. That decades from now—it is already happen- summer was very likely the continent’s ing and its impacts are clearly visible. This hottest in 500 years. The relentless heat paper gathers examples from the peer- killed at least 27,000 people, breaking reviewed scientific literature of recent all records worldwide for heat-induced impacts around the world. These include human fatalities. The heat and associated increases in extreme weather events, rising drought and wildfires cost European sea level, disappearing glaciers and polar economies more than $14.7 billion ice, damaged coral, changes in wildlife (13 billion euros) in losses in the agricul- distributions and health, and increased ture, forestry, and electric power sectors. activity and abundance of disease vectors. Records have been shattered in other Although a direct link to global warming parts of the world as well in recent years. is difficult to establish for some of these In April-June 1998, 3,028 people died phenomena in isolation, the multitude of in the most disastrous heat wave to ever changes collectively provide clear evidence hit India. In 1995, a five-day heat wave of the immediate and growing danger that caused 525 deaths in Chicago, with the global warming poses to the economy, 106°F (41°C) reading on July 13 the human health, and the ecosystems upon warmest July temperature ever measured. which humans and other species depend. Since greenhouse gas pollution stays in • Torrential rains and flooding the atmosphere for decades or centuries, According to the available data, global humanity may have no more than a dec- warming has increased the intensity of ade left to begin stabilizing the climate to precipitation events over recent decades. avert devastating and irreversible impacts. In December 1999, for instance, Vene- Such an achievement will require a con- zuela saw its highest monthly rainfall in certed effort among all nations. 100 years, with massive landslides and The following are highlights of the flooding that killed approximately 30,000 global warming impacts described in people. On two days in the city of Mai- this report. For readers particularly quetia, rains fell with an intensity nor- interested in the United States, we mally experienced just once in 1,000 years. include, preceding this Executive Sum- mary, a listing of domestic impacts by • Drought, forest pests, and wildfires region. (For a comprehensive rebuttal of From 1998 to 2002, below-normal skeptics’ claims regarding the science of precipitation and high temperatures global warming, see our earlier report, resulted in droughts covering wide The Latest Myths and Facts on Global swaths of North America, southern Warming, available at http://www.undoit Europe, and southern and central Asia. .org/what_is_gb_myth.cfm.) Drought continued in some regions In brief, this is what the scientific through 2004, including the western studies show: U.S., which endured the most severe drought in 80 years and one of the most • Killer heat waves severe in 500 years. The worldwide Human-caused global warming may drought has been linked to unusually have already doubled the chance of warm waters in the Indian Ocean and “killer” heat waves like the one that hit western Pacific, which many scientists v
believe to be caused in part by global basis for the four-and-a-half billion warming. dollar U.S. ski industry. Over the past Insect pests are spreading to forests 50 years, spring snowpack has dimin- previously too cold for their survival; ished by 16% in the Rocky Mountains Alaska, for instance, had in the 1990s and 29% in the Cascade Range, due the world’s largest recorded outbreak of mainly to rising temperatures. Further- spruce bark beetles. more, springtime snowmelt in the Drought, heat, and insect attacks western U.S. now begins 9 days earlier promote severe forest fires. In 2004, on average, lowering stream levels Alaska had its warmest and third driest during the dry summer months. It will summer, resulting in its worst fire year be extremely difficult to solve the prob- on record, with fires consuming an area lem of crippling, long-term water short- of forest the size of Maryland. All told, ages in the West without addressing over the past 30 years, the area burned global warming. annually by wildfires in the Arctic region In almost every mountainous region of western North America has doubled. across the world, glaciers are retreating In Russia, the area of forest burned annu- in response to the warming climate. The ally more than doubled in the 1990s shrinkage of glaciers is already creating compared to the previous two decades. water shortages, and threatening tour- ism in scenic parks. In one basin in • Rising sea level Glacier National Park in Montana, for Sea-level rise is one of the most certain instance, two-thirds of the ice has dis- impacts of global warming. During the appeared since 1850; with uncontrolled 20th century, sea levels around the world warming, the remaining glaciers could rose by an average of 4 to 8 inches (10 to disappear by 2030. In the European 20 cm), ten times the average rate over the Alps, ice that had hidden and preserved last 3,000 years. That rise is projected to the remains of a Stone Age man melted continue or accelerate further, with pos- for the first time in 5,000 years. Vene- sible catastrophic increases of many meters zuela had six glaciers in 1972, but now if the ice sheets on Greenland and/or has only two; these too will melt away Antarctica collapse. Already, one-third of in the next ten years. In the Peruvian the marsh at Blackwater National Wild- Andes, glacial retreat has accelerated life Refuge in the Chesapeake Bay has sevenfold over the past four decades. been submerged under the sea, and the In Africa, 82 percent of the ice on edges of mangrove forests in Bermuda are Mt. Kilimanjaro has disappeared since lined with recently drowned trees. If sea 1912, with about one-third melting level continues to rise, thousands of square in just the last dozen years. In Asia, miles of land in densely populated areas glaciers are retreating at a record pace in such as the eastern U.S. and Bangladesh the Indian Himalaya, and two glaciers may be lost, and flooding during storm in New Guinea will be gone in a decade. surges will worsen. Construction of physical barriers such as seawalls would be • Disintegrating polar ice and expensive and in some cases unfeasible. melting permafrost Since 1950, the Antarctic Peninsula • Shrinking snowpack and has warmed by 4°F (2°C), four times vanishing glaciers the global average increase. In 2002, Mountain snowpack constitutes a criti- a Rhode Island-sized section of the cal reservoir of fresh water, as well as the Larsen B ice shelf, which sits offshore vi
of the Peninsula, disintegrated in only record seriously damaged 16% of the 35 days. The ice shelf acts as a dam for reefs in the world and killed 1,000-year- glaciers on land; its break-up is causing old corals. Mass bleachings are usually a worrisome speed-up of glacier flow caused by excessively high temperatures. into the ocean, which could raise global Scientists therefore attribute the increase sea level. in bleaching events to the rise in average In 2003 the Ward Hunt Ice Shelf, surface ocean temperatures in many the largest in the Arctic, broke in two, tropical regions by almost 2°F (1°C) draining a unique freshwater lake that over the past century. Within the next was home to a rare microbial ecosystem. few decades, continued warming could Since the 1950s, the surface area of the cause mass bleachings to become an Arctic’s sea ice has shrunk by 10 to 15% annual event, wiping out some reef in spring and summer, and the ice has species and ecosystems along with the thinned by about 40% in late summer food, tourism income, and coastline and early autumn. In a turn for the protection they provide. Corals are also worse, the years 2002–2005 have all directly threatened by increasing atmo- seen record or near-record low ice spheric concentrations of carbon dioxide, coverage. The Hudson Bay has been which is acidifying seawater and making particularly hard hit, with the sea-ice it more difficult for corals to build their season shortened by three weeks. The calcium carbonate skeletons. reduced time for hunting ice-dwelling seals is seriously damaging the health of • Shifting species ranges and yearly the bay’s polar bears and causing them cycles to have 15% fewer cubs. At present rates Of over 1,400 species analyzed, ranging of shrinkage, Arctic sea ice could soon from fish and mammals to grasses and pass a point of no return, disappearing trees, over 80% are migrating to higher completely each summer by the end latitudes or higher elevations and of this century and pushing polar bears altering their annual routines in to the brink of extinction everywhere. response to global warming. Over time, Shrinking and thinning ice has also this could cause disruptive ecological made hunting of seals and other food and economic changes, such as the sources more challenging and accident- disappearance of entire fisheries. filled for humans. Continued warming Amphibians have shown particular could destroy traditional societies. vulnerability: In mountains around Because the permafrost on which the globe, many species, including the they are built is melting, buildings and golden toad and most of the 70-odd roads in Alaska have been sinking and species of harlequin frogs, have vanished breaking up. The 4,000 year-old Eskimo or declined because of diseases spurred village of Shishmaref has been so severely by climatic changes. eroded by ocean waves that the entire community was forced to relocate. • Disease outbreaks Higher temperatures accelerate the • Damage to coral reefs maturation of disease-causing agents The past 25 years have witnessed a and the organisms that transmit them, higher incidence around the world of especially mosquitoes and rodents. large-scale coral “bleaching” events, which Higher temperatures can also lengthen can lead to coral death. In 1997–98 the season during which mosquitoes are alone, the largest bleaching event on active, as has already been observed in vii
Canada. Warming has also been linked tions—has also contributed to new to the recent spread of tropical diseases, outbreaks of disease. In the past decade, including malaria, dengue fever and heavy rains associated with El Niño yellow fever, into high-altitude areas in events have caused explosive population Colombia, Mexico, and Rwanda that growth in the rodents that transmit had never seen the diseases before. hantavirus, which can lead to severe and The increase in El Niño events since often fatal illness in humans. As a con- the mid-1970s—a change consistent sequence, record outbreaks of hantavirus with global warming model predic- have been occurring in the U.S. viii
Introduction Global warming is no longer just a pre- is a distant threat, with consequences diction—it is actually happening. It is that will only be felt many decades from undisputed that the average temperature now. The fact is, many widely accepted, at the surface of the Earth has increased peer-reviewed scientific studies have over the past century by about 1°F found evidence that global warming has (0.6°C), with both the air and the already had major impacts on eco- oceans warming.1 Since 1880, when systems and societies across the world. people in many locations first began to Glaciers all around the world and keep temperature records, the 25 warm- Arctic sea ice have been shrinking and est years have all occurred within the disappearing; sea level has been rising last 28 years.2 Scientists know with and flooding low-lying areas; life- absolute certainty that the observed threatening heat waves, flooding rain- dramatic increase in the atmospheric storms, droughts, and forest fires have concentrations of greenhouse gases since become more intense and frequent over pre-industrial times (to levels higher recent decades; corals are “bleaching” than at any other time in at least the and dying in response to higher ocean last 420,000 years) has been caused by temperatures; and numerous animal and human activities, mostly the burning plant species are migrating away from of fossil fuels (coal, oil, and natural gas), the higher temperatures, toward the and to a lesser extent, deforestation.3 poles and higher elevations. While a The ability of greenhouse gases, such direct causal link to global warming has as carbon dioxide, methane, and nitrous been established for some observed oxide, to trap heat at the Earth’s surface changes, such as sea-level rise and is also scientifically well understood. worldwide glacial retreat, such a link While it has not yet been precisely is difficult to definitively establish for determined how much of the recent other changes, such as the increased warming was caused by human activi- incidence of droughts or the migration ties, the consensus among climate of a particular species. However, the scientists is that most of the warming multitude of changes collectively pro- over the past 50 years was probably vides a consistent and clear body of caused by human-produced greenhouse evidence of the immediate and growing gases. (See statements issued by the danger that global warming brings. National Academy of Sciences, the Using the terminology of those tasked American Meteorological Society, the with protecting public health, “the weight American Geophysical Union, the of the evidence,” or information com- Intergovernmental Panel on Climate piled from all available studies, points Change, and the national academies strongly to global warming as a force of eleven countries.)4 Recent precise behind the observed changes. At risk measurements of the heat content of are the health of the global economy, the world’s oceans, which show an of human individuals and communities, increase close to the amount expected and of the ecosystems upon which we from warming by greenhouse gases, depend for food, clean water, other strengthen the consensus view.5,6 resources, and spiritual sustenance. Many among the public may have Carbon dioxide and other greenhouse the misconception that global warming gases stay in the atmosphere for a 1
century or longer after being emitted.7 or where other causative factors may The greenhouse gases we have already be involved. We have relied almost added to the atmosphere since the exclusively on information from peer- Industrial Revolution have therefore reviewed scientific publications and committed the globe to a certain government websites; the few exceptions amount of continued warming over the include a Munich Re company report, a Humanity may coming decades no matter what we do National Geographic article, and a BBC have only a narrow with future emissions.8,9,10 Humanity News article. may have only a narrow window of time There are many more examples of window of time left, left, perhaps a decade or so, to begin the global warming impacts than can fit perhaps a decade long process of stabilizing greenhouse into an easily digestible report like this. or so, to begin the gas concentrations at a level that can For more comprehensive information, long process of avert devastating and irreversible im- the reader may want to refer to other stabilizing green- pacts from climate change.11,12 recent reports, such as the 2004 Arctic This report summarizes some of Climate Impact Assessment; Status of house gas concen- the major impacts that global warming Coral Reefs of the World: 2004; the 2000 trations at a level has already had across the world, National Assessment of Climate Change that can avert including some that have been observed Impacts on the United States; and the devastating and since the publication of major assess- IPCC Third Assessment Report.14 For irreversible impacts ments by the Intergovernmental Panel a comprehensive rebuttal of skeptics’ from climate on Climate Change (IPCC) and the claims regarding the science of global National Academy of Sciences in warming, see an earlier report of ours, change. 2001.13 Our goal is to provide policy- The Latest Myths and Facts on Global makers, journalists, and the public with Warming, available at http://www.undoit facts so that they can make informed .org/what_is_gb_myth.cfm. Occasional decisions on the measures needed to updates to the present report are stem the global-warming tide. We have planned. Suggestions for improvements made every effort to ensure that the and additions are welcome. Please document is scientifically rigorous, send suggestions to: Dr. James Wang, noting where the link between a Environmental Defense, 257 Park particular phenomenon and global Avenue South, New York, NY 10010; warming may not be fully established jwang@environmentaldefense.org 2
PART I Extreme events It is difficult to blame a particular the number of deaths in excess of the extreme weather event (such as a typical number during the summer heat wave, flood-producing storm, period.) In France alone, over 14,000 or drought) on global warming, since people died. In addition to the emo- weather fluctuates naturally. However, tional trauma and medical costs, the climate theory and models predict heat and associated drought and wild- that global warming will increase the fires cost European economies over frequency and/or intensity of some $14.7 billion (13 billion euros)* in losses types of extreme events. A warmed in the agriculture, forestry, and electric world, in other words, is like a loaded power sectors.21 Specific damages die that comes up “Heat Wave” or included a 60% reduction in fodder “Intense Rainstorm” more often than production in France, an 18% decrease an unperturbed world.15 Thus, scientists for wine in Italy, an 11% fall in grain can estimate the fraction of the risk production for Europe as a whole, of a particular kind of event for which livestock deaths (for example, millions humans are responsible. This section of of chickens died in France and Spain, the report presents examples of extreme reducing the flock by 15–20% in A warmed world, events observed during recent decades Spain),22 and cuts in power generation in other words, is that are consistent with the effects of due to shortages of river water for cool- global warming and may be harbingers ing the plants. France, Europe’s main like a loaded die of greater changes to come if we allow electricity exporter, cut its power exports that comes up global warming to continue unabated. by more than half to preserve an ade- “Heat Wave” or quate domestic supply. By the 2040s, the “Intense Rainstorm” risk of a similar heat wave could increase more often than Killer heat waves 100-fold if civilization doesn’t restrain Human-caused global warming may the growth of greenhouse gases, with an unperturbed have already doubled the chance of one out of every two years being hotter world. “killer” heat waves like the one that than 2003 (as compared to the current scorched Europe in July–August one out of every 200).23 2003.16 Strong evidence indicates that India was also hit in 2003 by a severe the summer was the hottest in Europe heat wave. Temperatures reached as in at least the past 500 years.17 All-time high as 122°F (50°C) in May across the high temperature records were broken worst hit areas and over 1,200 people in many countries. In the United King- died.24 Just five years earlier, the most dom, the mercury hit 100.6°F (38.1°C) disastrous heat wave to ever hit India at Gravesend-Broadness, Kent on took place during April–June of 1998, August 10, exceeding 100°F for the with an estimated 3,028 fatalities.25 The first time in that country since records temperature rose as high as 113–121.6°F began.18 In Germany, an all-time (45–49.8°C) in several Indian states. record of 104.4°F (40.2°C) was set Disruptions to the electricity supply due on August 8.19 to excessive demand wreaked havoc on At least 27,000 people died as a result of the relentless heat, breaking all * We obtained the U.S. dollar value from the records worldwide for heat-induced value in euros by applying the 2003 con- human fatalities.20 (The figure refers to version rate. 3
A ship on the river Rhine in Duesseldorf, Germany, July 25, 2003, during the extreme heat wave that scorched Europe for much of the summer. Low water levels meant bigger ships could transport only 30 to 50 percent of their normal cargo. (AP Photo/Martin Meissner) hospital services and on refrigerated precipitation events occurred over the supplies of vaccines and medicines.26 second half of the 20th century.30 This In the United States, Chicago experi- increase is consistent with the predicted enced one of the worst weather-related effects of global warming, since higher disasters in Illinois history when a heat temperatures speed up evaporation and wave resulted in 525 deaths during a increase the amount of water vapor in 5-day period in July of 1995.27 The 106°F the air, leading to heavier downpours. (41°C) reading on July 13 set a record Heavier rainfall in turn increases the for the warmest July temperature since risk of flooding. measurements began. The combination Another factor contributing to more of high humidity and high nighttime intense precipitation in some regions is temperatures meant little respite from the increase in frequency and intensity the heat could be found, especially for of El Niño events since the mid-1970s. such vulnerable populations as the An El Niño is a phase of warmer-than- elderly and people with low incomes. average waters in the eastern Pacific Studies indicate that the increase in and weaker-than-average tropical trade death rate from more frequent heat winds, usually lasting around a year and waves in the future will probably out- occurring once every two to seven years. weigh any decrease in death rate due El Niños typically bring unusually heavy to less severe winter cold in the U.S., rains to the southern tier of the U.S. and because cold-related mortality is more Peru, while causing below-normal pre- complex and not so strongly tied to the cipitation in the northwestern U.S., severity of the cold.28,29 northeastern Brazil, Southeast Asia, Australia, and southern Africa. Several recent El Niños may have been more Torrential rains and flooding intense or long-lasting than any in the According to the available data, a last three centuries.31 Some climate significant increase in the intensity of simulations have indicated that further 4
Devastation in coastal Venezuela caused by the December 1999 flows of mud and rocks. (Lawson Smith, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers) warming of the planet will produce more to October) and was not produced by a frequent and longer-lasting El Niños in hurricane or other tropical cyclone. The the future, thus causing extreme floods ensuing flows of mud and boulders are and droughts to occur more often. thought to have been among the largest One of many extreme flooding events worldwide in at least a century. It is that may have been exacerbated by worth noting that the high death toll global warming occurred in December was partly due to the building of large 1999, when Venezuela experienced its numbers of homes on steep slopes prone highest monthly rainfall in 100 years, to landslides and low-lying areas suscept- with massive landslides and flooding ible to floods. Discouraging development that killed approximately 30,000 in these kinds of vulnerable locations, in people.32 Total December rainfall in the addition to reducing worldwide green- coastal city of Maiquetia, near Caracas, house gas pollution, would help mitigate was almost 4 feet (1.2 m), more than future damages from global warming. 5 times the previous December record. During one particularly intense period, 2.8 inches (72 mm) of rain fell in one Drought hour. Rainfall on two of those December Paradoxically, although flooding events days were “1,000-year events”—in other are very likely to increase with global words, that daily amount of rainfall is warming, droughts are also expected to expected to occur in that location on be more frequent and severe. Higher average only once in 1,000 years. Rain- temperatures tend to increase the rate fall amounts in the neighboring moun- of evaporation; if precipitation doesn’t tains are estimated to have been twice as soon replenish the lost moisture, soils high, or around 8 feet over the month. grow drier. In drier soils, less solar The rainfall was unusual not only for energy is used up in evaporating water, its intensity, but also because it occurred meaning more energy is available to outside of the normal rainy season (May raise the temperature of the soil and the 5
overlying air, leading to even more decreasing the proportion of precipi- desiccating conditions; this kind of self- tation that falls as snow rather than rain amplifying cycle can lead to a lengthy in the mountains, and by accelerating and severe drought.33 Dry soils can drive the rate of snow melt in the spring. another kind of self-amplifying cycle as A reduced snowpack and earlier and well: when there is less evaporation to quicker melts make for lower stream the air because soil moisture is depleted, flows in the summer, when water can there can be less moisture in the atmo- be in short supply. (See “Disappearing sphere locally to form precipitation, Snowpack” in Part III.) potentially resulting in yet drier soils.34 Warmer ocean temperatures due The drought that accompanied the to global warming may also increase devastating heat waves of 2003 in Europe, the severity of droughts. The Indian for instance, is thought to have been Ocean and the western Pacific were intensified by global warming.35 (See the exceptionally warm between 1998 and section “Killer Heat Waves” in Part I.) 2002,* in part because of the overall Models predict that the vulnerability to warming trend in the world’s oceans.37 summer droughts will be especially high In the same period, unusually persistent in many mid-continental areas, which atmospheric flow patterns resulted are often important grain-producing in below normal precipitation, high and/or grazing regions. The reasons for temperatures, and drought conditions their vulnerability are that their climate across wide swaths of North America, isn’t cooled by the ocean and that a large southern Europe, and southern and portion of their precipitation is derived central Asia. Drought continued from continental moisture.36 through 2004 in some areas, including In addition to increasing evaporation the western U.S., where according to and prolonging periods with deficient stream flow records and tree ring studies rainfall, a warmer climate can reduce the drought was the most severe in water supplies in arid and semi-arid 80 years and one of the most severe regions (such as the western U.S.) by in 500 years.38,39,40 During the peak, more than 50% of the area of the co- terminous U.S. suffered from moderate to severe drought, with much of the area experiencing record or near-record low precipitation.41 The average annual flow of the Colorado River at Lees Ferry, Arizona during the 2001–2003 period was 5.4 million acre feet (6.7 cubic kilometers), just half of the 10.2 million * While the geographic pattern of the warmth can be explained by a La Niña event (the opposite of an El Niño, or in other words, a phase of warmer-than-average waters in the western Pacific and cooler-than-average waters in the eastern Pacific), scientists study- Lowering water level during severe drought at ing the 1998–2002 event believe that an Lake Powell on the Colorado River, at the con- fluence with the Dirty Devil River (entering from overall warming trend in the world's oceans left). Top: June 29, 2002. Bottom: December 23, over the past few decades contributed to the 2003. (John C. Dohrenwend, USGS files) unusual extremeness of the warmth. 6
Example of a recent severe wildfire in the West: In Glenwood Springs, Colorado, on June 8, 2002, the evening sun barely penetrates the smoke and ash as evacuees flee West Glenwood because of the spreading wildfires in Garfield County. (Bryan Dahlberg/FEMA News Photo) acre feet (12.6 cubic kilometers)* that Forests and wildfires flowed during the Dust Bowl years Scientists expect global warming to (1930–1937).42 contribute to an increase in wildfire in A number of researchers have used several ways. As discussed in the pre- climate models to examine the under- vious section, droughts are expected to lying causes of the recent drought.43,44 become more common and severe in Their model simulations produced a some regions. Desiccating heat and lack climate pattern very similar to that ob- of precipitation create ideal conditions served, and suggested that the warmth for major wildfires. In addition, longer in the Indian Ocean and western Pacific warm seasons often translate into longer caused the persistent atmospheric flow fire seasons. Warmer temperatures also patterns, which in turn produced the promote outbreaks of insects that feed drought conditions across the wide ex- on trees, killing many of the hosts and panse of mid-latitude regions. In short, creating large amounts of dry fuel for there is mounting evidence that global forest fires. Insects are even spreading warming contributed to the vast extent to areas that until recently were too cold and severity of the recent drought. for their survival. In south-central Alaska in the 1990s, the world’s largest * This comparison of streamflow is adjusted recorded outbreak of spruce bark beetles for changes caused by the Glen Canyon Dam, damaged more than 4 million acres which was constructed in the early 1960s. (1.6 million hectares) of forest, an area The streamflow figures are not corrected for nearly the size of the state of New Jersey.45 increases in water consumption upstream of Since 1994, Canada has been afflicted Lees Ferry over time; but even after applying with its largest and most northerly an extremely large correction, the estimated flow during the recent period would still be spruce bark beetle outbreak ever, affect- 1.3 million acre feet (1.6 cubic kilometers) ing 750,000 acres (300,000 hectares) in lower than during the Dust Bowl. the Yukon.46 7
Aerial view of a white spruce forest severely damaged by spruce bark beetles, Canada. (Courtesy of Natural Resources Canada, Canadian Forest Service, Laurentian Forestry Centre/Luc Jobin) With this combination of heat, around the world, and that global drought and pests, wildfires have become warming has played an important role.49 increasingly destructive in recent dec- The summer of 2004 was particularly ades. Among the regions hit hard are fierce: Alaska’s warmest and third driest the huge tracts of Arctic spruce and summer on record made for its worst pine forest spanning Alaska, northern fire year ever.50,51 A total of 703 fires Canada, Scandinavia, and Siberia consumed 6,517,200 acres (2.6 million (which despite their northerly latitude hectares) of forest, an area the size of are susceptible to fires in the summer- Maryland. Evacuations of threatened time, especially during warm, dry years). communities reached record levels, In the Arctic region of western North and for the first time ever, fire engines America, the area burned annually has were shipped from the lower 48 states doubled over the past thirty years.47 In to deal with the conflagration. Because the Russian Arctic, fire damage increased of the fires, air quality in the interior sharply in the 1990s, with the area of and the northeast of the state was forest burned annually being more than reported as unhealthy or hazardous twice as large as during the previous on 52 days. On June 28 in Fairbanks, two decades.48 The risk of catastrophic health-threatening airborne particulates fires has been exacerbated in the Arctic registered 1,000 micrograms per cubic as well as other parts of the world by meter, the highest ever recorded in decades of fire suppression by humans, Alaska; normal is 65. which has allowed dead, flammable Regions outside of the Arctic have plant material to accumulate. But even seen many severe fires in recent decades remote parts of the Arctic, which have as well. For example, severe drought and seen little fire suppression, have experi- high temperatures in the western U.S. enced an increase in wildfire, suggesting in 2000 resulted in over 122,000 fires, that suppression by itself cannot com- which burned approximately 8.5 million pletely explain the increase in wildfire acres (3.44 million hectares), the worst 8
wildfire season in the last 50 years.52 The As with drought, wildfire can set off a first seven months of that year were the self-amplifying cycle. If, as climate models warmest in 106 years of records in New predict, wildfires continue to increase in Mexico, Utah, and Texas, while Arizona, frequency and intensity,54 the amount Colorado, Nevada, Wyoming, and Idaho of carbon dioxide released into the atmo- had their 2nd or 3rd warmest January– sphere from burning vegetation and July. In 1998, Mexico experienced its soil organic matter could outstrip the worst fire season ever, when 1.25 million amount absorbed by regrowing forests, acres (506,000 hectares) burned during strengthening the greenhouse effect and a severe drought.53 Smoke reaching global warming and possibly leading to Texas triggered a statewide health alert. even more fires in a worsening cycle. 9
PART II Sea level rise and coastal flooding Sea-level rise is one of the most certain erosion, making them susceptible to impacts of global warming. Sea level rose being blown over by the wind. Mangrove around the world by an average of 4 to forests provide habitat for many birds 8 inches (10 to 20 cm) over the course and economically important marine of the 20th century, ten times the average species including shrimp, oysters, and rate over the previous three thousand fish; these forests also filter the water, years.55 The rise in sea level is due to the keeping it clean and clear, and protect expansion of ocean water as it warms, the coast from storm surges and waves. and to the addition of water from melt- (A storm surge is a sharp, localized rise ing glaciers and ice sheets, both of which in sea level lasting hours or days, caused are consequences of global warming. by a storm.) These forests, like other The effects of global sea-level rise coastal ecosystems, are not able to build are amplified in some places due to local up sediment fast enough to keep up geologic and man-made factors. For with the current rate of sea-level rise, example, about one-third of the marsh and could completely disappear in places at Blackwater National Wildlife Refuge where natural or man-made barriers in the Chesapeake Bay in the eastern prevent landward migration. U.S. has become submerged since 1938. On the other side of the Atlantic, Half of the marsh loss is attributed to the Thames Flood Barrier, which the sinking of land due to groundwater protects the city of London from storm extraction, and the rest is attributed surges coming up from the mouth of to global warming.56 Elsewhere in the the river, was used less than once a year Chesapeake Bay, Bloodsworth Island is in the 1980s; in the 1990s it was used 590 acres (235 hectares) smaller than it on average more than six times a year.60 was in 1942, a loss of more than 10% of Although this increase is attributable its original land area.57 mainly to a combination of natural In Louisiana, nearly a million acres variations in storm surge intensity and (400,000 hectares) of biologically-rich increased occurrence of high runoff marsh, 28% of the original marsh area in from rainstorms, it illustrates a potential the state, has been lost to the encroach- impact of rising global sea level. If ing sea since 1932. Many factors have the barrier were to break during a flood, contributed, including the sinking of the resulting damage to London could land along geologic fault-lines, com- cost about $54 billion in 2004 dollars paction of loose soil, and a decrease in (30 billion pounds), roughly 2% of the supply of soil-replenishing sedi- the current U.K. GDP. In addition to ments due to the construction of dams the Thames, more frequent and extreme and levees. However, global sea-level flooding due to sea-level rise threatens rise has contributed at least one-eighth low-lying areas near the mouths of of the flooding, even at the sites that are the Nile in Egypt, the Mekong in sinking most rapidly.58 In Bermuda, Vietnam and Cambodia, the Ganges rising sea level is leading to saltwater and Brahmaputra in Bangladesh, and inundation of coastal mangrove forests.59 other rivers around the world.61 The edges of the forests are now lined Scientists project that sea level will with trees that have recently drowned or continue to rise as a result of human- whose roots have been exposed due to produced greenhouse gas pollution and 10
I below 1.5 meters I 1.5–3.5 meters I above 3.5 meters 200 miles This map highlights the areas along the U.S. Atlantic and Gulf coasts that are vulnerable to inundation resulting from sea-level rise. This is a simple elevation map and does not include additional future impacts from erosion and local sinking of land. Altogether, 22,400 square miles (58,000 square kilometers) of land, an area more than twice the size of Maryland, lie within 5 feet (1.5 m) of sea level; sea level could rise by this amount within the next few centuries. More than 80% of this low land is found in just four states: Louisiana, Florida, Texas, and North Carolina. (Source: Titus, J.G. and C. Richman. 2001. Maps of lands vulnerable to sea level rise: modeled elevations along the U.S. Atlantic and Gulf coasts, Climate Research. Available at http://yosemite.epa.gov/oar/globalwarming.nsf/ content/ResourceCenterPublicationsSLRMapsIndex.html) could reach an additional 3.5 inches to precipitation.) Some studies have even 3 feet (9–88 cm) by the end of the cen- suggested the possibility that warming tury, with even further rises in subse- over the next several centuries would quent centuries as sea level gradually lead to the complete, irreversible dis- adjusts to the warmer climate.62 (The appearance of the Greenland ice sheet, large range for projected sea level rise which would raise sea level by an extra reflects differences among models and 23 feet (7 m); there is also a slight chance emission projections, with the lower end that the West Antarctic Ice Sheet could reflecting possible growth in ice sheets collapse, further raising sea level by in parts of Antarctica due to increased 13–20 ft (4–6 m).63,64 11
Potential impact of sea-level rise on Bangladesh 1989 Total population: 112 million Total land area: 134,000 km2 Sea-level rise of 1.5 m impact Total population affected: 17 million (15%) Total land area affected: 22,000 km2 (16%) This graphic, based on an analysis conducted in 1989, illustrates the potential impact of sea-level rise on Bangladesh, a low-income nation with a very large population living within a few feet of sea level. With a 5 feet (1.5 m) sea-level rise, approximately 8,500 square miles (22,000 square km), or 16% of the country’s land area, would be submerged, displacing 17 million people. That figure is based on the estimated population in 1989. Given that the nation’s population has grown rapidly since 1989 and is projected to continue growing, a much higher number of people could actually be affected. (Source: UNEP/GRID Geneva; University of Dacca; JRO Munich; The World Bank; World Resources Institute. Washington, D.C. http://www.grida.no/climate/vital/33.htm.) In the absence of expensive man- erty due to shoreline retreat and flood- made physical barriers such as seawalls, ing could be costly to taxpayers as well even a moderate sea-level rise would as property owners in the U.S., since the submerge large portions of island federal government subsidizes flood nations and densely populated coastal insurance for much coastal property.68 areas, displacing millions of people. Another impact of rising sea level is (See the accompanying figures for contamination of fresh surface water examples of vulnerable areas in the and groundwater supplies by salty water. eastern U.S. and Bangladesh.) Adapta- Communities that obtain water from tion to sea-level rise could cost several sections of rivers that are currently just percent of GDP for certain developing upstream from the point where the countries, and for many small island water becomes salty include Phila- nations would simply be infeasible.65 delphia, New York City (as an emer- Sea-level rise not only inundates land, gency supply during droughts) and but also causes additional land loss due much of California’s Central Valley.69 to erosion by ocean waves. A foot of sea It takes even more time to stabilize level rise would result in approximately rising sea levels than it does to stabilize 50-1000 feet of horizontal shoreline rising atmospheric temperatures, due to retreat in many parts of the U.S., vary- the slow rate at which water is circulated ing according to location.66 In addition, and heat distributed throughout the depth higher sea levels would exacerbate the of the ocean.70 We need to put the brakes flooding risk associated with storm on rising greenhouse gas concentrations surges during hurricanes and other now to avoid an increasingly disastrous storms.67 Increased loss of coastal prop- rise in sea-level down the road. 12
PART III Snow, land ice and sea ice Shrinking snowpack of the operating costs of the Attitash Over the past 30 years, scientists around Mountain resort in New Hampshire.76 the world have recorded a steady decline Warming thus threatens the ability of in mountain snowpack, an important ski resorts to stay in business and remain reservoir of fresh water, as well as the a vital contributor to regional econo- basis for the ski industry and other mies. U.S. ski resorts bring in approxi- winter tourism. In the western United mately $4.5 billion in revenues annually States, where water is scarce, 75% of the (including tickets, rentals, retail, and water in streams and rivers comes from food and beverages).77 snowmelt, providing a crucial supply Records also show that the spring- for farms, hydroelectric power plants, time pulse, when a large amount of aquatic life, and 60 million people— snow suddenly begins to melt and fill one-fifth of the U.S. population.71 Spring streams, has shifted over the last two snowpack has been decreasing in the decades across the western U.S., begin- region: measurements recorded declines ning 9 days earlier on average than it in three-quarters of the mountainous did 40 years ago.78 Earlier snowmelt areas between 1950 and 1997.72 In the means that streamflow reaches its max- Rockies, snowpack decreased an average imum earlier in the season; throughout of 16%; the Cascades lost an average of California’s Sierra Nevada it now peaks 29%, with many sites in Washington, 3 weeks earlier than it did in 1948.79 Oregon, and Northern California losing Capturing higher streamflows earlier more than 50%. Model simulations in- in the year is difficult in places such as dicate that temperature increases are the California and the Columbia River main culprit in the snowpack decline. Basin. Existing man-made reservoirs are Even precipitation increases in some nearly filled to capacity at that time; areas have generally not been sufficient to avoid flooding, extra runoff must to overcome the impact of strong regional be allowed to drain into the ocean.80 By warming. In the Swiss Alps, rising the time summer arrives, streamflow has nighttime temperatures and an increase greatly diminished, reducing the water in the percentage of precipitation falling supply all through the hottest, driest as rain rather than as snow were to months. The West already faces water blame for a reduction in snowpack of shortages in times of drought: it will be 12–45% between the 1960s and the extremely difficult to prevent still more 1990s at low- to mid-elevation sites.73 crippling water shortages without Assessments of global warming im- addressing global warming. pacts on ski resorts in North America, Europe, and Australia all project nega- tive consequences.74 Assuming current Vanishing glaciers snowmaking technology, the ski season Glaciers are slow-moving “rivers” of in the province of Ontario in Canada ice formed over many years from com- is projected to shorten by 0–16% in the pacted snow on sloping land. In almost 2020s (11–50% in the 2080s), even with every mountainous region across the an increase in snowmaking of 36–144% world, long-term monitoring has re- in the 2020s.75 Snowmaking is expensive; vealed that the vast majority of glaciers for example, it currently makes up 20% are retreating upslope in response to a 13
warming climate;81 the glaciers’ lower increase in regional temperatures and a reaches are melting faster than ice decrease in precipitation. Using climate flowing down from above can replenish models, scientists project that all the them. Since glaciers, like snowpack, glaciers in Glacier National Park could serve to store water and release it disappear completely by 2030, steadily over the year, their continued eliminating one of the park’s main In the European disappearance will have a severe impact tourist attractions.84 Alps, glacial on water supplies in some regions. The Pacific Northwest is witnessing retreat has In Montana’s Glacier National Park, similarly rapid retreats. The South exposed well- the retreat of the glaciers has been Cascade Glacier in Washington State preserved remains, dramatic. Between 1850 and 1979, may currently be at its smallest size ever glaciers in the Blackfoot-Jackson in the last 6,000 years. Between 4000 BC including the Glacier Basin decreased in area by about and A.D. 1958, its length had always 5,000-year-old 65%, from 8.3 square miles (21.6 square stayed within the range of 2.24 to 2.88 Stone Age Oetzal kilometers) to 2.8 square miles (7.4 miles (3.60 to 4.63 km). By 1995, it had “ice man.” square kilometers).82 More recent dropped to 1.81 miles (2.92 km).85 observations show that the retreat and Across the Atlantic, in the European thinning of glaciers in the park Alps, glacial retreat has exposed well- continues: For example, between 1979 preserved remains, including the 5,000- and 1993, Grinnell Glacier shrank by year-old Stone Age Oetzal “ice man.” 22% and Sperry Glacier by 11%.83 The Having survived in the ice for so long shrinkage has been driven by both an due to the absence of ice flow in the flat Grinnell Glacier in Glacier National Park, Montana, viewed from the top of Mount Gould during late summer 1938 (left) and 1981 (right). In just 43 years, a dramatic response to warming is evident, including loss of volume and formation of a lake at the foot of the glacier. Between 1850 and 1993, the glacier shrank 63% in area and the foot receded about 0.7 miles (1.1 km). Debris marks the 1850 glacier boundary, right. (Courtesy of Carl H. Key (originally published in Key et al., 1998. Glacier retreat in Glacier National Park, Montana. In R.S. Williams and J.G. Ferrigno, eds. Satellite image atlas of glaciers of the world, Chapter J, Glaciers of North America. U.S. Geological Survey Professional Paper 1386-J.) 14
Left: In 1978, the Qori Kalis Glacier looked like this, flowing out from the Quelccaya Ice Cap in the Peruvian Andes Mountains. Right: In 2002, the view of Qori Kalis has changed dramatically with a massive 10-acre lake forming at the ice margin. (Courtesy of Professor Lonnie G. Thompson, Byrd Polar Research Center, The Ohio State University) areas where they were found, these has created water shortages for down- remains only now have been exposed stream communities.93 for the first time in thousands of years— Tropical regions in Africa and South- evidence that the recent glacial retreat east Asia are showing similar patterns. is highly unusual.86 82% of the ice on Mt. Kilimanjaro has At the opposite end of the Earth, disappeared since 1912, with about glaciers in the Patagonia region of one third melting in just the last dozen southern South America have been years.94,95 Kilimanjaro’s remaining ice retreating over the past several dec- is projected to disappear by 2020. A ades.87 Chile’s San Rafael Glacier—a glacier on Mount Kenya has shrunk by World Heritage Site and a popular tour- 40% since 1963. Two glaciers in Irian ist attraction where boats can pull right Jaya (the Indonesian portion of the up to the towering edge of the ice on the island of New Guinea) are disappearing water—has retreated 0.6 miles (1 km) and should be gone in a decade. in just the last decade.88 If this continues, In the subtropics, glaciers are also re- the glacier will terminate over land in- treating at a record pace. The Dokriani stead of water in the near future. Bamak Glacier in India retreated 66 ft Even in tropical mountain areas, (20.1 m) in 1998, and an annual average where the climate is generally more of 54 ft (16.5 m) over the preceding stable than in high-latitude regions, 5 years; the Gangotri Glacier is retreating glaciers are receding at an accelerating 98 ft (30 m) per year.96 Both are in the rate.89,90 Venezuela had six glaciers in Himalayan range, which has the world’s 1972. Now it has only two and, if present largest concentration of glaciers outside trends continue, those too will be com- of the polar regions and has been called pletely melted in the next 10 years.91 the “Water Tower of Asia.”97 Seven of the Glacial retreat has accelerated seven- continent’s great rivers originate here and fold in the Peruvian Andes:92 The edge supply water to hundreds of millions of of the Qori Kalis glacier retreated 13 feet people: the Ganges, Indus, Brahmaputra, (4.0 m) annually between 1963 and 1978; Salween, Mekong, Yangtze, and Huang by 1995, the rate had stepped up to 99 Ho. Initially, continued warming is pro- feet (30.1 m) per year. Shrinkage of the jected to swell those rivers with more ex- Zongo Glacier in the Bolivian Andes tensive melting of glaciers and snowpack 15
and increased precipitation.98 This will enough to freeze. Unlike land-based worsen the already high flood risk. In a glaciers and ice sheets, floating ice does few decades, after the most vulnerable not raise sea level when it melts. It does, portions of the glaciers are gone, river flow however, have serious consequences. will get dangerously low in summer.99 One of the most dramatic melting The loss of glacial meltwater would events so far has occurred on the Antarctic reduce summer flows on the Ganges by Peninsula, the part of that continent that two thirds, creating water shortages for juts out towards South America. While several hundred million people and up a slight cooling occurred in the interior to 37% of India’s irrigated farmland.100 of Antarctica over the past century, the Global warming skeptics have actually Peninsula has warmed by around 4°F claimed that the majority of glaciers across (2°C) since 1950, four times the global the world are advancing rather than re- average of 0.9°F (0.5°C).108 The retreat treating. In fact, in only a very few areas, of ice shelves on both the eastern and specifically western Norway, Iceland, western sides of the Peninsula since 1995 and New Zealand, have a significant has been attributed to this regional warm- fraction of the glaciers been expanding ing.109 That retreat took a surprising turn during the past few decades.101,102 That in 2002, when the northern section of the expansion is a result of regional increases Larsen B ice shelf, a large floating ice in storm frequency and snowfall amounts mass on the eastern side of the Penin- rather than colder temperatures, and is sula, shattered and separated from the therefore compatible with a global warm- continent. In just 35 days, beginning on ing trend. But in all other regions of the January 31, 2002, a total of about 1,250 world, the retreat of glaciers has been square miles (3,250 square kilometers) pronounced;103 the total net loss in vol- of shelf, an area bigger than the state of ume across all of the world’s glaciers be- Rhode Island, completely disintegrated. tween 1961 and 1997 is about 3 billion An ice shelf acts as a dam for glaciers acre feet (890 cubic miles, or 3,700 on land. So although its break-up did cubic km).104 Skeptics have also argued not directly contribute to sea-level rise, that the glacial retreat is unconnected to observations show that the removal of global warming by focusing on the iso- the Larsen B ice dam has caused a worri- lated case of Kilimanjaro, for which scien- some acceleration of glacier flow into tists have offered alternative explanations, the ocean (as much as eight-fold), which including a drop in precipitation begin- could in time raise global sea level.110,111 ning in the late 1800s, a decrease in cloud A similar event occurred in the Arctic cover, and the drying effect of regional in the spring and summer of 2003, when deforestation.105 The consensus among the Ward Hunt Ice Shelf, the Arctic’s scientists remains, however, that rising largest ice shelf, broke in two.112 The ice air temperatures are the most important shelf had been acting as a dam for a factor behind the retreat of glaciers on a unique freshwater lake, the largest of its global scale over long time periods.106,107 kind in the northern hemisphere and home to a rare microbial ecosystem that was only discovered in 1999. Researchers Polar ice disintegration believe that rising temperatures caused Polar regions have two kinds of floating the weakening of the ice shelf. When it ice. Ice shelves are thick plates of ice that broke, the lake drained and disappeared. form where glaciers flow into the sea. Sea ice has been faring no better. In Sea ice forms when seawater gets cold 2000 and again in 2001, people were 16
You can also read