Fighting the headwinds - Domestic demand steady despite trade war uncertainty. Q3 2018
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
Asia Pacific Property Digest Q3 2018 Fighting the headwinds Domestic demand steady despite trade war uncertainty.
13 Office 4 35 14 Hong Kong 15 Beijing 16 Shanghai 17 Shenzhen 18 Taipei 19 Tokyo 20 Osaka Feature 21 22 Seoul Singapore Retail 23 Bangkok 36 Hong Kong Articles 24 Jakarta 37 Beijing 25 Kuala Lumpur 38 Shanghai 26 Manila 39 Shenzhen 04 Economic resilience as clouds gather 27 Ho Chi Minh City 40 Tokyo 05 Buoyant property markets 28 Delhi 41 Seoul 08 Co-living: can it work in Australia? 29 Mumbai 42 Singapore 09 Consumer analytics - Indian malls’ 30 Bengaluru 43 Bangkok trump card 31 Sydney 44 Jakarta 10 Finance sector opening-up to bring new opportunities to Shanghai 32 Melbourne 45 Delhi 11 Non-conventional use of space in 33 Brisbane 46 Sydney Singapore malls 34 Auckland 47 Melbourne
Editor's Note Despite the trade war uncertainty, the Asia Pacific economy is sailing on course at the back of resilient domestic demand. Healthy leasing momentum persists in the office market, up by 15% y-o-y in the third quarter as occupier demand in the technology, finance and flexible space sectors remain steady. Retail operators continue to prioritise their efforts in building experiences and services that cater to diversified consumer tastes. The logistics and warehousing sector saw rents edging up further amid sustained strong demand. For more detail by asset class, view this report online at http://www.jllapsites.com/research/appd-online/. The Asia Pacific research team hopes that you find this publication valuable, and we welcome your feedback. Thanks, Dr Megan Walters Head of Research – Asia Pacific 49 59 67 Residential Hotel 50 51 Hong Kong Beijing Industrial 68 Hong Kong 52 Shanghai 60 Hong Kong 69 Beijing 53 Singapore 61 Beijing 70 Shanghai 54 Bangkok 62 Shanghai 71 Tokyo 55 Jakarta 63 Tokyo 72 Singapore 56 Manila 64 Singapore 73 Bangkok 57 Sydney 65 Sydney 74 Jakarta 58 Melbourne 66 Melbourne 75 Sydney
4 – Features ASIA PACIFIC ECONOMY Economic resilience as clouds gather It’s been a rocky year. A mounting trade war between China and the U.S. is challenging global trade. Tighter U.S. monetary policy and dollar strength are weighing on currency markets and investor sentiment. China’s rebalancing maintains course and the gentle slowdown endures. All of this has added up to an environment of heightened uncertainty. Fortunately, growth momentum has shown strength and held up remarkably well. Trade war risks rise Murky inflation and interest rate Domestic drivers moving to the outlook forefront Exports have so far shown a more resilient performance than would Elevated oil prices and strong U.S. There have been no major changes be expected given the challenging dollar have presented problems to economic forecasts with growth situation facing global trade. for emerging markets—weakening expected hold up well, albeit Nonetheless, the spectre of a currencies, weighing on equity markets momentum is anticipated to ease protectionist environment looms and and putting pressure on interest rates— slightly as global prevailing headwinds there are signs that export orders and even those with strong fundamentals. continue. Buoyant domestic demand factory activity are softening. Tensions Central banks in India, Indonesia and supportive policies should between the world’s two largest and Philippines have been quick to underline economic resilience and economies have continued to ramp up respond to this situation by raising help offset a moderation in export with tariffs measures announced worth key rates and more hikes could be on momentum as governments place hundreds of billions of U.S. dollars, the horizon if the situation persists. greater emphasis on facilitating and the conflict seems unlikely to be However, the heightened uncertainty domestic drivers. As more countries settled in the near term. While a deal is supporting a continuation of low- climb the income ladder, this will help could still be struck between China interest policies in countries such as lift more people into the middle class and the U.S., a protracted battle will Japan, Korea and Australia. While and further support an upgrade in challenge growth momentum as the interest rate uncertainty is likely to consumption. effects ripple through supply chains remain present in the near term, rates and impact market sentiment. are expected to gradual rise in the long term as risks slowly dissipate.
5 – Features Table 1: Outlook for Major Economies Real GDP Growth (%) Country 2019 Outlook 2018F 2019F Solid consumption and strength from the services sector to provide support. However, a gradual China 6.5 6.0 slowdown to persist as slower credit growth and trade tensions weigh on activity. A tight labour market and wage growth to bolster consumption and incentivise investment in Japan 1.0 1.2 automation. Trade growth to slow amid global headwinds while a proposed 2019 GST hike poses a downside risk. Robust growth albeit momentum to ease with consumption and infrastructure investment key India 7.6 7.2 drivers. Central bank to closely watch currency and oil price movements as inflation risks remain. Increased government spending and accommodative monetary policy to provide support. Export South Korea 2.6 2.5 growth to slow dented by trade tensions while consumption likely to be soft. Positive momentum for export volumes and business investment, but ongoing headwinds to weigh Australia 3.3 2.6 on consumer spending and residential market. Public infrastructure investment and household spending to underlie stable growth. Central bank to Indonesia 5.1 5.1 keep the focus on stabilising the currency. Solid labour market supportive of consumption but housing market uncertainty and weak equity Hong Kong 3.6 2.3 market may be a drag. Expansionary fiscal policy to help buoy the economy. Trade protectionism to dampen export and manufacturing activity. Government policies to Singapore 3.3 2.4 encourage business investment and healthy infrastructure spending to be sustained. Source: Oxford Economics, November 2018 ASIA PACIFIC PROPERTY MARKET Buoyant property markets Commercial property markets stayed on track despite elevated uncertainty. Office occupiers have carried on leasing space at a brisk pace with structural shifts in occupation underlying strength in demand for flexible space. While solid occupier fundamentals and the positive outlook continued to support the case for real estate investment—albeit with transaction volumes growth easing from its earlier blistering pace. Although global headwinds continue to blow, real estate market conditions should remain buoyant supported by solid growth prospects. Office leasing maintains robust pace Healthy volume of office completions Quarterly rent growth led by Overall leasing activity was up 15% y-o-y Tokyo, Delhi, Hong Kong and Shanghai Guangzhou and Osaka in Asia Pacific in 3Q18, contributing to together accounted for half of the total Asia Pacific rent growth accelerated the year-to-date improvement of 24% completions figure of nearly 1.2 million slightly to 1.2% q-o-q in 3Q18 with several y-o-y. Bengaluru was the regional leasing sqm in 3Q18. Although a healthy level, new markets surprising on the upside. Relatively volumes leader in 3Q18 while high volumes supply declined 36% q-o-q or 22% y-o-y as moderate rental growth was recorded in were also observed in Manila, Delhi and a number of markets recorded no or much Shanghai and Beijing; however, healthy Melbourne. Gross leasing volumes were fewer completions. Despite the new supply, demand and declining vacancy saw down in markets such as Sydney and Tokyo vacancy decreased in the majority of the rents rise at a robust pace in Guangzhou. but in large part due to limited availability Asia Pacific markets tracked during 3Q18. Landlord favourable conditions supported of space. Shanghai, Hanoi and Taipei all saw vacancy a continued uptrend in Hong Kong decline by more than 1 percentage point rents, while tight vacancy and strong Net absorption was up 12% y-o-y as q-o-q, while Kuala Lumpur recorded an pre-commitments gave Tokyo landlords occupational demand remains healthy increase of more than 1 percentage point sufficient confidence to raise rents. Rents across the region with many markets amid softer demand and new completions. maintained on a growth trajectory in reporting broad-based leasing activity. Singapore, albeit with the pace easing up The strongest net absorption was recorded slightly from 2Q18. Fairly balanced supply in markets such as Tokyo, Shanghai and and demand dynamics saw Mumbai SBD Melbourne. BKC and Bengaluru SBD rents hold flat. Tightening vacancy supported moderate rent growth in Melbourne and Sydney CBDs.
Focus on building experiences and a breather with Australia and Hong Kong investment activity came in relatively 6 – Features services in the retail sector both softening during the quarter. However, balanced in terms of acquisition and China rebounded from a quiet second disposals from a net purchasing bias in the Mall operators in China are actively quarter to deliver growth of 14% y-o-y. first half of the year. adjusting tenant mixes to keep up with South Korea continued to show increasing changing consumer tastes; F&B, lifestyle Further capital appreciation levels of activity, with 320% growth on brands, furniture stores and online retailers the corresponding quarter last year. In Prime office capital values continue to be all continued to expand their presence. part, a strong U.S. dollar is also impacting supported by healthy rental growth and Leasing momentum improved for high growth rates as most Asian currencies have investor demand. In Hong Kong, capital streets in Hong Kong’s core areas except depreciated against the U.S. dollar over the values continued to grow on the back of for Central, where landlords of shops with past year. strong prices attained in both the en-bloc large rental payments struggled to secure tenancy without major rental reductions. and strata-titled office sales market. Solid The office sector made up half of all growth in Tokyo capital values was driven F&B operators remained a key source of transaction volumes, while the industrial/ leasing activity in Singapore, while demand by cap rate compression, while a moderate logistics sector recorded slightly higher rise in Seoul capital values was underlined grew from activity-based retailers. Retailers transaction volumes than the retail sector. in Australia continued to focus on existing by an improvement in rental income. Cross-border investment activity accounted Several transactions closed in Singapore store performance and customer service— for one-quarter of total transaction utilising new technologies and concepts. with high pricing, leading to capital value volumes, up slightly on the previous growth in excess of rent growth. quarter but down marginally on long-term Demand for prime logistics space still averages due to the higher concentration strong of deals in South Korea. Cross-border Demand continued to be driven by e-commerce, 3PLs and manufacturing firms in China. Beijing was characterised Figure 2: Office Rental & Capital Value Changes, Yearly % Changes, 3Q18 by renewals during the quarter, while Shanghai saw strong take-up in one of the 20 new completions. Amid the lagged effect of the trade war as well as tight vacancy, 15 a number of 3PLs expanded their space requirements in Hong Kong. The shortage 10 in labour, especially truck drivers, drove the demand for efficient modern logistics 5 space in Tokyo. In Singapore, logistics demand was driven mainly by renewals and relocations. Demand was steady in 0 Sydney and Melbourne with retail trade and transport, postal and warehousing sectors -5 the main demand drivers. -10 Residential market sentiment e ne ey k ng ila ng yo i ai l rta ba ou or ko gh dn an k ur Ko iji impacted by policy measures ka um Se ap To ng Be an bo M Sy Ja ng ng Ba M Sh el Ho Si M The proposed vacancy tax in Hong Kong has led developers to take a less aggressive Rental Values Capital Values pricing stance for new projects. Although Figures relate to the major submarket in each city buyer sentiment started the quarter on a Source: JLL (Real Estate Intelligence Service), 3Q18 strong note with some new projects rapidly achieving high sales rates, sentiment faded considerably towards quarter-end Figure 3: Direct Commercial Real Estate Investment 2008-3Q18 as uncertainties related to the economic outlook and new vacancy tax set in. 160 YTD 2018 Transactions volumes for villas and luxury $116.9 bill apartments in Beijing decreased from a 140 20% y-o-y year earlier with the tighter lending policy restraining demand and leading some 120 prospective buyers to the leasing market. In Shanghai, sales momentum held strong 100 in the high-end market due to pent-up upgrading demand and new supply. 80 Investors stay the course despite 60 uncertainty 40 Investment activity across the Asia Pacific region steadied in 3Q18 after a strong first 20 half of the year, with total year-to-date activity reaching USD 116.9 billion (+20% 0 y-o-y). Total transaction volumes were 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 YTD 2018 relatively flat (+3%) y-o-y at USD 35.6 billion Japan China Australia Hong Kong South Korea Singapore Other in 3Q18. Some of the strongest growth markets over the first half of the year took Figures refer to transactions over USD 5 million in office, retail, hotels and industrial. Source: JLL (Real Estate Intelligence Service), 3Q18
7 – Features Figure 4: Rental Property Clocks, 3Q18 Grade A Office Prime Retail Tokyo, Wellington Kuala Lumpur Wellington Hong Kong Beijing, Tokyo* Auckland Auckland Shanghai Beijing Taipei, Singapore Sydney Growth Rents Growth Rents Manila, Slowing Falling Jakarta, Slowing Falling Melbourne Kuala Lumpur Seoul*, Manila Osaka Rents Decline Rents Decline Canberra Rising Slowing Rising Slowing Ho Chi Minh City, Mumbai, Bangkok Bengaluru Jakarta Guangzhou, Shanghai Delhi Bangkok, Delhi Bengaluru Perth, Chennai Melbourne (Regional), Chennai Seoul Singapore Adelaide, Mumbai Hong Kong * Guangzhou, Sydney (Regional), Hanoi, Brisbane SE Queensland (Regional) Note: Clock positions for the office sector relate to the main submarket in each city. *High Street Shops/Multi-level High Street Prime Residential Prime Industrial Manila Shanghai Bangkok Tokyo Wellington Auckland Guangzhou Jakarta Growth Rents Growth Rents Slowing Falling Slowing Falling Hong Kong Manila, Sydney Rents Decline Rents Decline Shanghai Rising Slowing Rising Slowing Beijing Melbourne Singapore* Singapore (Business Park), Beijing Kuala Lumpur Hong Kong Brisbane Singapore (Logistics) *Luxurious *Logistics space (Hong Kong, Shanghai, Beijing, Greater Tokyo) Source: JLL (Real Estate Intelligence Services), 3Q18 Property markets to maintain good Despite rising interest rates in many momentum markets, underlying fundamentals remain firm and forecasts for further rental growth The outlook for leasing activity remains should see real estate investment remain bright and we hold the view that full- attractive to investors. However, investors year 2018 volumes will higher than the are likely to remain selective and may 2017 level, with risk tilted to the upside continue to face difficulty sourcing product following the region’s strong performance in some markets. in the first three quarters. Occupational demand is expected to remain diverse with leasing activity led by tech, finance and About the author flexible space operators. Given the strong Dr Megan Walters joined JLL in 2010 and in October 2016 was performance this year and expectation appointed as Head of Research – Asia Pacific. In this role, Megan of sustained occupier demand, we are leads a team of 170 professional researchers in the region, which optimistic that leasing activity in 2019 forms part of a network of over 400 researchers in 65 countries should be in line with 2018’s healthy level. around the globe.
8 – Features Co-living: can it work in Australia? Co-living is touted as the next step in Figure 1: Home Ownership vs. Renting in Sydney housing evolution, due to its potential to 45.0% resolve a number of modern housing and social challenges. From a planning point of view, sharing more of our living space 40.0% would relieve pressure on urban sprawl as city populations continue to rise. From a 35.0% social point of view, co-living can prevent isolation and create a greater sense of community. Co-living is also in line with the 30.0% broader ‘sharing economy’ trend that has taken hold over recent years in areas such as vehicles and office space. 25.0% Similar to student housing, co-living 20.0% spaces offer a number of quality amenities 1996 2001 2006 2011 2016 and services including gyms, concierge, cleaning services, laundry and so on, while Own outright Own With a Mortgage Rent still affording tenants city living. The cost of these services is usually included in the Source: Australian Bureau of Statistics rent, which may be somewhat higher than standard house share rents. However, the additional cost incurred to pay for these to continue as millennials increasingly to other global cities such as New York services separately would even out the enter the workforce over the coming (32.0%) and London (48.2%), is also likely additional cost. years, capitalising on global mobility and playing a role. Home ownership is falling expecting it at some point in their careers. (see chart) and attitudes are slowly shifting The current demographic attracted to from suburban to urban lifestyles, but it still co-living consists largely of millennials In Australia, the concept has lagged behind seems that the forces driving co-living in (broadly, those born between 1980 – other markets, with the first property only other parts of the world are far less pressing 2005), many of whom are already used to opening in Sydney in October 2018. This in Australian cities, particularly outside house sharing, facing housing stress, and is largely due to the persistent mindset of of Sydney. Until these dynamics change, increasingly becoming disillusioned with many domestic households who still aspire the opportunity for co-living will likely the idea of home ownership in the process. to own their own house on a quarter acre concentrate on a niche market consisting Co-living is also popular in cites that attract block of land. Higher home ownership of students, temporary and newly arrived a high volume of temporary and longer rates in major Australian cities (62.3% in workers. term expatriate skilled labour force such Sydney and 66.4% in Melbourne) compared as London, Singapore, New York and Hong Kong, which also tend to be cities with higher densities. The attraction to co-living includes About the author move in readiness, lease flexibility, price Ahmed Almihdar is a Senior Analyst for JLL, based in Sydney. transparency and brand recognition, while Focusing on the residential sector, Ahmed’s key role involves avoiding the higher costs of hotels and the analysis and preparation of quarterly market research setting up individually. This trend is likely commentaries on the NSW and ACT residential markets.
9 – Features Consumer analytics - Indian malls’ trump card The Indian retail sector is going through In the age of big data, some of the popular • Analysis of loyalty programmes by a metamorphosis of sorts. Even as the technological tools that quality malls are retailers is also helping them to provide sector is poised for a fresh burst of growth, either using or are planning to make use of a better-quality, store-level experience. organised retail in India is thriving like are beacons, visitor tracking programmes Beacons make use of Bluetooth technology never before. Smart mall owners have and analytics through mobile apps, and in smartphones with relevant apps and now moved on to the use of technology loyalty programmes. Technology and are quite useful for targeted marketing and consumer algorithms and analytics consumer feedback through such tools are in malls. There is also a greater emphasis to ensure that physical retail continues to also finding greater traction with retailers being placed on tracking the usage of social remain relevant. as they use these to improve in-store media by visitors in malls to understand merchandise as well as the overall buyer their preferences. Quality malls are consistently clocking browsing movement. Already, some of the occupancies of over 90%, steady rental prominent retailers, such as Aditya Birla Similarly, video analytics can help to growth and a steady increase in trading Fashion and Retail Limited, Shoppers Stop better merchandise placement by offering densities. To sustain this momentum, they and Big Bazaar, are focusing on optimising greater visibility for high foot-traffic brands are now moving past the ordinary methods the experience of the consumer through by putting them in mall areas that are of just improving the tenant mix or ad hoc data and analytics. considered the most active based on a heat brand refresh. There is now a strong school map analysis of the mall itself. of thought that is looking at consumer Some typical examples of technology being analytics as an important tool that allows used at mall and store level are: We, at JLL, have launched a new tech tool, them to customise their mall strategies to PinPoint, which makes use of geofencing enhance customer experience. • U se of mall Wi-Fi by consumers software to create an accurate shopper to understand the trajectory and profile. Predictive analysis is holding sway, as circulation patterns of mall visitors at analysing consumer buying behaviour and different times of the day and week. Going forward, the emphasis on technology- mall circulation patterns are determining Mall mobile apps along with beacon driven analytics is bound to increase in brand refresh and also being used to technology and sensors to create a malls. With advances in AI and the internet enhance the customer experience, which more customised approach for each of things, malls could offer an enhanced plays on the mall visitors’ interests. This shopper based on previous visits and experience for consumers, predicting their aids in the placement of retailer brands preferences. needs before they realise it themselves! that take into account consumer patterns • Store receipts, brand and merchandise Rigorous analytics will act as a moat against without any lengthy and aimless consumer purchases and spends being future threats to the concept of shopping surveys. analysed using AI to enhance in-store centres. merchandise as well as a mall’s brand mix. About the author Sumedh Gadgil is an Analyst for JLL, based in Mumbai. In his role, he focuses on the Mumbai Retail sector and contributes to bespoke assignments and white papers. Sumedh holds a Bachelor’s degree with a specialisation in Economics.
10 – Features Finance sector opening-up to bring new opportunities to Shanghai Following the national government’s Chart 1: Average Grade A Office Take-Up of Top Multinational Finance Companies pledge to speed up financial reform and 350 the announcement of 12 specific opening- 300 up measures in the 2018 Boao Forum for Thousand sqm GFA Asia, Shanghai has launched its action plan 250 of a 100 measures to further open-up the 200 economy and boost the city’s position as an 150 international finance centre. 100 35 out of the 100 measures announced 50 are related to the financial sector and are 0 aimed at firstly easing market access in e go co n is ai ng en ng or do r gh the banking industry for foreign capital; cis Pa ica zh iji Ko ap n Be an en an Lo Ch ng ng Sh Sh secondly relaxing the restrictions on the Fr Ho Si n Sa proportion of shares and business scope in Sample includes J.P. Morgan, Morgan Stanley, Goldman Sachs, Bank of America, Citi Bank, HSBC, BNP, Credit Agricole, the securities industry for foreign investors; Credit Suisse, and Deutsche Bank and thirdly encouraging the opening-up of Source: JLL Research, 2Q18 the insurance industry. When we studied the average office set up their first offices in Shanghai; and are also flowing into Zhuyuan and Yanggao take-up of ten global finance companies existing foreign finance companies that Road areas. In Puxi, besides core CBD across key cities we saw that Shanghai have obtained licenses in new business Nanjing W. Road submarket, the emerging has the potential to grow office demand areas and are looking for expansion. CBD North Bund submarket is also from foreign finance companies. In terms capturing significant demand from finance of scale, Shanghai still has a long way to The question is—which locations are likely companies. go compared to the world’s finance hubs to benefit from an increase in demand such as New York and London. However, in from foreign finance companies? Based As the financial markets continue to open China, Shanghai is the runner up after Hong on transactions that have happened in up we expect increasing demand for office Kong in terms of foreign finance company Shanghai in the first half of 2018 (with both space. Lujiazui will continue to strengthen presence (Chart 1). domestic and foreign companies), Lujiazui its status as the financial centre of is still the top destination for finance Shanghai; however, rising rents and supply- Last year, Shanghai’s Grade A office market companies, especially from banking sector. shortage post 2019 will encourage spill-over net absorption reached over 1.3 million But Lujiazui is not the only destination. For demand, particularly to the nearby high- sqm GFA, and finance companies were the example, in Pudong, finance companies profile business areas. biggest contributors accounting for 38%. Our view is that the new initiatives will lead to further increased office demand from the About the author finance sector, even in the short term. Cathy Huang is a Senior Manager focusing on Shanghai office market research. She authors market analysis for JLL publications such as We have already witnessed increased the Property Digest and media release, as well as the subscriber- demand in terms of leasing enquiries from based Real Estate Intelligence Service. Cathy also authors consulting two areas, both newly registered foreign projects on behalf of investor and developer clients. finance companies that are looking to
11 – Features Non-conventional use of space in Singapore malls It has been observed that non-conventional suburban malls that house public libraries ft city campus of private education institute use of space is helping to prop up mall include White Sands, home to Pasir Ris PSB Academy, also on its third floor. occupancy and boost foot traffic of late. Public Library and Northpoint City and NEX, which accommodate Yishun Public By early 2019, One Raffles Place shopping The integration of technology in retailing Library and Serangoon Public Library mall will launch a co-working space tenant has gradually shaped consumers’ shopping respectively. In the CBD, Orchard Gateway called Spaces that will occupy 35,000 sq ft behaviour. Specifically, the growing and Chinatown Point have library@Orchard across a few levels in the mall. Apart from popularity and convenience of online and library@Chinatown, respectively, as hosting start-up companies, Spaces also shopping is altering traditional shopping tenants. plans to host fashion and retail-related patterns and contributing to the migration events within the mall. from physical stores to the online platform. The proliferation of co-working in This has resulted in a rise in retail vacancy Singapore in recent years has also led to a Creative deployment of retail space for rates from 2014 through 2017 (as reflected growing number of co-working operators non-conventional use, combined with other in the URA rental retail index) and raised — which typically occupy office spaces — leasing strategies and an improvement oversupply concerns in Singapore. joining the retail tenant mix. In the CBD, in retailer and consumer sentiment, has OUE Downtown Gallery houses a 24,000-sq- contributed to a noticeable stabilisation Recognising the threat from technological ft flexible work space operation, run by The of vacancy rates in malls in 2018. This is disruption, landlords have explored the use Work Project, amidst mostly conventional because non-conventional users generally of retail space for non-conventional uses, retail shops, while China Square Central absorb sizeable volumes of vacant retail particularly those offering a platform for has co-working tenant ClubCo in its tenant space. Besides offering a good networking community gathering and networking such mix. and community-gathering platform, with as public libraries, flexible work spaces and their relatively younger end-users, they educational institutions. Recently, co-working operator JustCo also generate higher foot traffic and inject started a 60,000 sq ft operation on the third vibrancy into the malls, which in turn In recent years, an increasing number of floor of Marina Square to house more than benefits other retail tenants in the malls malls, particularly suburban ones, have 1,000 members. The operation combines and overall performance of the malls. added public libraries as tenants. While retail and co-working elements within the the move is part of a government initiative premises and features a marketplace where Going forward, embracing non- to make libraries more accessible to the members can showcase their products conventional uses in retail could be one of public, landlords also benefit from bonus in complimentary booths. Additionally, the key strategies to help landlords adapt to gross floor area at the mall. Notable Marina Square houses the new 100,000 sq changing shopping behaviour. About the author Angelia Phua is a Consulting Director for JLL, based in Singapore. She guides a team of analysts in undertaking consultancy projects, including real estate market studies, highest and best use studies and planning studies. She oversees research in the retail sector in Singapore and is involved in strategic research work.
Proptech. It’s changing our homes, work and cities. Start-up funding for proptech in Asia Pacific will reach US$4.5 billion in 2020. How will it change your life? We’ve done the research. Download Clicks and Mortar: The Rising Influence of Proptech at – access.jll.com/proptech-report-2017
Office
Hong Kong “Tight-vacancy environment to continue supporting rental growth 14 – Office in the next 12 months.” Stage in Cycle Rental Growth Y-O-Y sq ft per month, Denis Ma, Head of Research, 8.1% net effective on NLA Growth Hong Kong HKD 126.8 Slowing Financial Indices PRC demand slows down as tenant decentralisation gathers pace • Net absorption amounted to just over 1 million sq ft in 3Q18, supported by 170 the realisation of pre-commitments in newly-completed buildings. Tenant 160 decentralisation remained a major trend with 54% of all new lettings in 3Q18 150 located outside of the city’s traditional core office markets. 140 • Despite PRC demand showing visible signs of slowing and the volume of new 130 lettings declining by 23% q-o-q, the Central office market continued to attract Index 120 a bevy of new set-ups and expansion requirements from the banking and 110 professional services sectors. 100 Hutchison House redevelopment to be completed in 2023 90 • CK Asset has set the redevelopment of Hutchison House in motion, issuing 80 4Q14 4Q15 4Q16 4Q17 4Q18 4Q19 eviction notices to tenants requesting offices to be vacated by the end of Rental Value Index Capital Value Index January 2019. Under the current plans, Hutchison House will be redeveloped into a 41-storey building providing up to 493,500 sq ft of commercial space with Arrows indicate 12-month outlook completion anticipated in 2023. Index base: 4Q14= 100 Financial Indicators are for Central. • Swire Properties’ South Island Place in Wong Chuk Hang and One Taikoo Place Source: JLL in Quarry Bay were issued with occupation permits in 3Q18, adding 1.1 million sq ft of Grade A office stock to the leasing market. Physical Indicators Investment market loses momentum 350 6 • Rents in the overall market grew by 2.5% q-o-q in 3Q18. Growth moderated 300 across the market except in Wanchai/Causeway Bay where rental growth 5 gathered pace due to a tight-vacancy environment. 250 4 • The investment market continued to be highlighted by record-breaking Thousand sqm 200 Percent 150 3 transactions, although the investment volume of properties priced over USD 5 million plummeted by 77% q-o-q amid increasing economic uncertainties and 100 2 rising interest rates. 50 0 1 Outlook: Investment yields to stabilise over the near term -50 0 • Strong levels of pre-leasing in upcoming new office developments are likely to 14 15 16 17 18F 19F keep vacancy rates tethered to their current low levels over the next 12 months. Take-up (net) Completions This should help offset any slowdown in leasing demand and provide support Future Supply Vacancy Rate for rents to drift higher by 5-10% in 2018, and at a slower pace of 0-5% in 2019. For 2014 to 2017, take-up, completions and vacancy rates are year-end • With further interest rate hikes looming, investment yields in Hong Kong should annual. For 2018, take-up, completions and vacancy rate are YTD, while future supply is for 4Q18. stabilise over the next 12 months. Still, capital values are forecast to grow in the Physical Indicators are for the overall market. range of 10-15% in 2018 before easing to 0-5% in 2019. Source: JLL Note: Hong Kong Office refers to Hong Kong’s overall Grade A office market.
Beijing “CBD Core Area project delays are keeping vacancy low and pushing up 15 – Office Stage in Cycle rents citywide.” Rental Growth Y-O-Y sqm per month, 4.2% net effective on GFA Growth Mi Yang, Acting Head of Research, RMB 401 Slowing Beijing IT demand strong; landlords more selective with tenants Financial Indices • IT tenants continued to be active; a major IT player quickly absorbed space 150 which was returned by a start-up, forced to reconsider its business plan. Finance remained a key source of demand, and some landlords leveraged this 140 to sign funds with very high rental affordability. 130 • In the tight-vacancy environment, landlords benefitted from waiting lists of 120 Index tenants and mostly preferred to accept SOE-backed companies and industry giants, considering them to be less risky. 110 100 Small project comes online near centre of Beijing • New supply was limited, with just COFCO Landmark (45,756 sqm) in Ditan 90 opening in the quarter. Leasing progress was off to a strong start, with an 80 environmental firm taking up significant space in the building. 4Q14 4Q15 4Q16 4Q17 4Q18 4Q19 Rental Value Index Capital Value Index • Stable demand kept the overall vacancy rate low at 3.2%. Olympic Area and Third Embassy recorded the largest declines in vacancy in the quarter. While Arrows indicate 12-month outlook Index base: 4Q14 = 100 the low-vacancy environment will continue to limit net absorption, large Financial Indicators are for the CBD. requirements will be satisfied as space becomes available. Source: JLL Rents climb in tight market • Benefitting from the lack of available space in the market, all submarkets Physical Indicators recorded positive rental growth for a second consecutive quarter, with Third 800 8 Embassy, Zhongguancun, and Wangjing leading the rise. 700 7 • No major en-bloc deals were recorded in the quarter, but as monetary 600 6 policies tighten nationwide, we expect to see more opportunities come to Thousand sqm 500 5 the market. Sellers under greater financial pressure are likely to market more Percent reasonable prices. 400 4 300 3 Outlook: First CBD Core Area buildings set to open by 2019 200 2 • Following delays to CBD Core Area projects, new buildings are expected to 100 1 come online in 2019 and offer some relief to tenants in the tight-vacancy market. Nearby landlords should be better-positioned to increase rents 0 0 14 15 16 17 18F 19F through end-2018, before CBD Core Area landlords implement more Take-up (net) Completions aggressive pre-leasing strategies closer to their opening dates. Future Supply Vacancy Rate • The remaining majority of new supply is located in emerging Lize; the area will For 2014 to 2017, take-up, completions and vacancy rates are year-end have the capacity to fulfil large requirements for space. annual. For 2018, take-up, completions and vacancy rate are YTD, while future supply is for 4Q18. Physical Indicators are for the overall market. Source: JLL Note: Beijing Office refers to Beijing’s overall Grade A office market.
Shanghai “Strong demand from financial services and TMT companies fuels steady rental growth.” 16 – Office sqm per day, Stage in Cycle Daniel Yao, Head of Research, Rental Growth Y-O-Y China 0.7% net effective on GFA Rents RMB 10.4 Rising Financial Indices Financial services, TMT, and co-working firms lead demand 140 • In the Pudong CBD, a few SOEs committed to large spaces for consolidation and upgrade purposes in 3Q18. In the Puxi CBD, tech and media companies 130 continued to look for upgrade and expansion opportunities. Co-working operators also sought space for expansion, while developers were investing in 120 their own co-working brands as well. Index 110 • The decentralised market continued to see strong leasing momentum. Submarkets like Hongqiao Transportation Hub, Xuhui Bund, and Qiantan 100 outperformed thanks to their strong positioning and industry targeting. 90 Three projects add 173,000 sqm to the Grade A market • Taikang Insurance Tower in the Pudong CBD, ITC Phase 2 T1 in the Puxi CBD, and 80 4Q14 4Q15 4Q16 4Q17 4Q18 4Q19 World Trade Centre Phase 3 in Pudong’s decentralised market reached completion. Rental Value Index Capital Value Index • Pudong CBD vacancy increased 0.6 percentage points q-o-q to 11.1%. Puxi CBD Arrows indicate 12-month outlook vacancy improved 2.2 percentage points q-o-q to 8.7%. Grade A buildings that Index base: 4Q14 = 100 lost tenants due to decentralisation have gradually attracted new occupants. Financial Indicators are for the CBD. Decentralised vacancy improved 2.2 percentage points to 23.9% as new Source: JLL buildings continued to attract upgraders. Rents strengthen in the Puxi CBD as vacancy improves Physical Indicators • Falling vacancy has boosted sentiment for Puxi CBD landlords, allowing 700 12 rents there to increase 1.2% q-o-q to RMB 9.7 per sqm per day. In the Pudong CBD, rents increased by a moderate 0.5% q-o-q. In the decentralised market, 600 10 continued large supply held rental growth to moderate levels. 500 8 • The tight financing environment continued to impact domestic investor activity, Thousand sqm 400 though some SOEs continued to seek headquarter locations. Foreign investors Percent 6 300 such as developers, real estate funds, and pension funds continued to explore 4 opportunities. Notable deals this quarter included the transactions of Bay Valley 200 and Longyu International Plaza. 100 2 Outlook: New demand to support growth in emerging areas 0 0 14 15 16 17 18F 19F • Shanghai’s government is expected to continue pushing the opening-up Take-up (net) Completions initiatives that were announced in July, covering financial services, trade, Future Supply Vacancy Rate technology, and other sectors. Such initiatives are expected to translate to office demand; for example, the recent World AI Conference helped boost For 2014 to 2017, take-up, completions and vacancy rates are year-end demand for offices in the Xuhui Bund area, where the event was held. annual. For 2018, take-up, completions and vacancy rate are YTD, while future supply is for 4Q18. Physical Indicators are for the CBD. • Rents are likely to strengthen in core areas as supply becomes more limited, Source: JLL especially in the Pudong CBD. In the decentralised market, several submarkets are expected to mature quickly, although overall decentralised rent growth is likely to remain constrained by continued large supply. Note: Shanghai Office refers to Shanghai’s overall Grade A office market, consisting of Pudong, Puxi and decentralised areas.
Shenzhen “Tech firms require more space and better facilities as business volume and 17 – Office Stage in Cycle headcount increase.” Rental Growth Y-O-Y sqm per month, 2.5% net effective on GFA Rents Silvia Zeng, Head of Research, RMB 286 Stable South China Significant expansion demand by high-tech firms Financial Indices • Demand for Grade A office space has been mainly for recently completed and 120 high-quality office buildings in Futian and Nanshan District. Large-scale high- 115 tech firms and co-working operators have been actively looking for space for expansion, such as a Shenzhen-based tech company which leased 15,000 sqm in 110 Nanshan. 105 Index • Nonetheless, vacancy in Futian District edged up due to the eviction of peer-to- 100 peer lending (P2P) firms by the government, especially in strata-title buildings. 95 Liquidity issues have seen regulators closely monitor and impose strict controls 90 on P2P firms. 85 Improving occupancy in Nanshan 80 • There was only one Grade A project completed in 3Q18, adding about 40,000 4Q14 4Q15 4Q16 4Q17 4Q18 4Q19 sqm to the market. Located in Nanshan District, the whole property was Rental Value Index Capital Value Index purchased by Bank of Beijing in 2017, for its regional headquarters. Arrows indicate 12-month outlook Index base: 4Q14 = 100 • The overall vacancy rate declined by 30 basis points q-o-q in 3Q18. This was Financial Indicators are for Futian. owing to outstanding absorption in Nanshan District, as high-tech firms were Source: JLL active in their search for office space. Rents edge up; investment market remains active Physical Indicators • Influenced by higher vacancy due to P2P withdrawals in Futian, rental growth 2,500 25 was limited. Rents in Nanshan performed well, though overall rents edged up only by 0.7% q-o-q. High-quality properties in core areas were still favoured by 2,000 20 companies. Thousand sqm • The investment market remained active, due to sustained optimism about 1,500 15 Percent Shenzhen from institutional investors. There were also enquiries from occupiers for self-use space. One en-bloc transaction was recorded in the quarter. 1,000 10 Landlords with a residential focus were more willing to sell due to tight liquidity. 500 5 Outlook: Supply-demand mismatch to impact rental growth 0 0 • The local economy should maintain a positive performance but risks have risen 14 15 16 17 18F 19F due to external political and economic pressures. Many landlords are being Take-up (net) Completions more cautious about tenant selection, putting greater emphasis on tenant Future Supply Vacancy Rate quality over higher rents. For 2014 to 2017, take-up, completions and vacancy rates are year-end • Office leasing is expected to remain firm with high-tech and traditional financial annual. For 2018, take-up, completions and vacancy rates are YTD, while future supply is for 4Q18. firms still the main demand drivers. However, an abundance of supply is Physical Indicators are for the overall market. anticipated to come online over the next 12 months, which is likely to put Source: JLL upward pressure on vacancy and impact rental growth. Note: Shenzhen Office refers to Shenzhen’s overall Grade A office market.
Taipei “Robust leasing demand while investment activity 18 – Office remains moderate.” ping per month, Stage in Cycle Jamie Chang, Head of Research, Rental Growth Y-O-Y Taiwan net on GFA Growth 3.0% NTD 3,206 Slowing Financial Indices Relocations and upgrades continue to support demand 130 • Quarterly net take-up reached 18,200 ping, a record high when owner occupation is excluded. Most new leases were signed by corporate tenants looking to consolidate their operations, requiring large units, or upgrade to 120 space in new buildings. Space released by relocations also started receiving leasing enquiries or lease commitments. Index 110 • Net take-up for the first three quarters this year was recorded at 41,600 ping approaching the highest annual volume on record, largely due to the newly- completed buildings drawing tenants. 100 One new addition to stock in 3Q18 90 • There was one new project completion, providing 10,700 ping of leasable space 4Q14 4Q15 4Q16 4Q17 4Q18 4Q19 in Dunhua North. Rental Value Index Capital Value Index • Although a new building has been released this quarter, robust demand Arrows indicate 12-month outlook continued, pushing the overall vacancy rate downwards by 1.2 percentage Index base: 4Q14 = 100 Financial Indicators are for Xinyi. points q-o-q to 6.9%. Source: JLL Decreasing vacancy supports rent growth • New completions with decreasing vacant space further supported rents, and Physical Indicators leases signed in the newly-completed buildings pushed the overall rent to increase by nearly 2% y-o-y to NTD 2,695 per ping per month, the highest value 200 12 since 2001. 180 10 160 • Quarterly investment activity continued to be dominated by corporate investors 140 8 acquiring industrial facilities for self-occupation. However, a large en-bloc office Thousand sqm 120 tower transaction pushed the overall direct investment volume to NTD 12.1 Percent 100 6 billion, a decrease of 40% y-o-y. 80 60 4 Outlook: Market prospects remain positive for 2018 40 2 • The new supply volume is expected to peak in 2018, with no large-scale 20 completions in the short term. In this scenario, when expansion of space is 0 0 14 15 16 17 18F 19F not possible in current buildings, tenants tend to seek availability in new and Take-up (net) Completions upcoming projects. For this reason, several projects that are currently under Future Supply Vacancy Rate construction have reached commitment rates of 50% or above. For 2014 to 2017, take-up, completions and vacancy rates are year-end • Institutional investors are likely to remain observant but actively seek direct annual. For 2018, take-up, completions and vacancy rate are YTD, while investment opportunities in commercial real estate, while evaluating the future supply is for 4Q18. Physical Indicators are for the overall market. feasibility of public projects and other alternative property sectors. All levels of the Source: JLL Taiwanese government have launched, and are expected to continue to launch, various public-and-private projects totalling NTD 200 billion. Domestic funds remain abundant while investors are active in seeking channels to funnel funds. Note: Taipei Office refers to Taipei’s overall Grade A office market.
Tokyo “Occupational demand maintains strength; investor 19 – Office interest remains strong.” tsubo per month, Stage in Cycle Rental Growth Y-O-Y Takeshi Akagi, Head of Research, gross on NLA Growth Japan 2.9% JPY 37,660 Slowing Net absorption soars Financial Indices • According to the Tankan Survey in September, the business sentiment index 150 of large manufacturers was 19 points, 2 points lower q-o-q. This was the third consecutive quarter of decline. The business sentiment index of large non- 140 manufacturers also declined by 2, to 22 points, marking the first decrease in eight quarters, largely due to trade friction and natural disasters. 130 Index • Net absorption in 3Q18 totalled 295,000 sqm, the second straight quarter above 120 200,000 sqm. Net take-up during the first three quarters totalled 599,000 sqm, the second highest level on record. This has been a reflection of the absorption 110 of new supply and continued expansion demand, coming from sectors including information and communication, manufacturing and financial services. 100 Vacancy rate further decreases 90 4Q14 4Q15 4Q16 4Q17 4Q18 4Q19 • New supply totalled 259,000 sqm in 3Q18, increasing total stock by 3% q-o-q Rental Value Index Capital Value Index and 7% y-o-y. With limited available space for lease in existing buildings, Arrows indicate 12-month outlook occupiers have been committing to upcoming supply. Much of the space Index base: 4Q14 = 100 expected to enter the market through end-2019 has already been leased. Source: JLL • The vacancy rate stood at 1.5% at end-3Q18, decreasing 50 bps q-o-q and 140 bps y-o-y. The vacancy rate tightened throughout the CBD in spite of the relatively major supply, in particular in Akasaka/Roppongi and Otemachi/ Physical Indicators Marunouchi. 700 5 Rent and capital value growth accelerates 600 • Rents averaged JPY 37,660 per tsubo per month at end-3Q18, increasing 1.5% q-o-q 4 and 2.9% y-o-y. This marked the 26th straight quarter of growth and it was 500 Thousand sqm particularly strong this quarter in Shinjuku. 400 3 Percent • Capital values increased 4.8% q-o-q and 5.7% y-o-y at end-3Q18. Growth was 300 2 driven by accelerating rent growth and cap rate compression. A notable sales 200 transaction was Hulic’s acquisition of a stake in Shinagawa Season Terrace for 1 JPY 61 billion or at an estimated NOI cap rate of 3.6%. 100 0 0 Outlook: Capital values to grow moderately 14 15 16 17 18F 19F • According to Oxford Economics, Japan’s real GDP is forecast to grow by 1.1% in Take-up (net) Completions 2018 while CPI is likely to rise 1.1% in 2019. Rising trade tensions remain a major Future Supply Vacancy Rate downside risk. For 2014 to 2017, take-up, completions and vacancy rates are year-end annual. For 2018, take-up, completions and vacancy rate are YTD, • With robust demand expected to persist and strong pre-commitments to while future supply is for 4Q18. upcoming supply, we now expect the vacancy rate rise to be more moderate. Source: JLL As a result, rents are likely to hold relatively stable. Capital values should see moderate growth. Note: Tokyo Office refers to Tokyo’s overall Grade A office market.
Osaka “Limited supply supports rent growth; stronger activity in the 20 – Office investment market.” Stage in Cycle Rental Growth Y-O-Y tsubo per month, Yuto Ohigashi, Director - Research, 11.0% gross on NLA Rents Japan JPY 20,267 Rising Financial Indices Robust demand continues 240 • According to the September Tankan Survey for Greater Osaka, the business sentiment index for large manufacturers was 14 points, decreasing by 4 points 220 q-o-q. That for non-manufacturers was 27 points, decreasing 2 points q-o-q. 200 This reflected the impacts of the natural disasters on exports, production and 180 inbound tourism, as well as that of the macroeconomic policy in the U.S. on Index corporate sentiment. A tight labour market continued, with unemployment at 160 3.0% in 3Q18. 140 • Net absorption totalled 30,000 sqm in 3Q18, posting a healthy figure due largely 120 to new supply, after remaining sluggish for three quarters on the back of limited 100 supply. Robust demand persisted from real estate, professional services and 80 manufacturing sectors. 4Q14 4Q15 4Q16 4Q17 4Q18 4Q19 Rental Value Index Capital Value Index Vacancy hovers around 1% Arrows indicate 12-month outlook • Total stock increased by 2% q-o-q and 2% y-o-y, as Namba Skyo (NLA 35,000 sqm) Index base: 4Q14 = 100 entered the market. Occupiers include WeWork, Asahi Intelligence Service and Source: JLL Mory Industries Maruichi Steel Tube. • The vacancy rate stood at 1.1% at end-3Q18, increasing 30 bps q-o-q and decreasing 60 bps y-o-y. The quarterly increase followed seven straight quarters Physical Indicators of decline. 160 9 Capital value growth accelerates 140 8 • Rents averaged JPY 20,267 per tsubo per month at end-3Q18, increasing 2.0% q-o-q 7 120 and 11.0% y-o-y. Rental growth was recorded for the 17th straight quarter, 6 albeit at a slower pace. Rents moved above JPY 20,000 per tsubo per month Thousand sqm 100 Percent 5 for the first time since 1Q09. Double-digit growth was recorded for the second 80 4 consecutive quarter. 60 3 40 • Capital values grew 7.5% q-o-q and 27.5% y-o-y at end-3Q18. This was the 20th 2 20 straight quarter of growth, reflecting a rental increase and cap rate compression. 1 0 0 Outlook: Rent and capital value growth momentum to continue 14 15 16 17 18F 19F Take-up (net) Completions • According to Oxford Economics, the growth forecast for Osaka in 2018 is 0.2% and Future Supply Vacancy Rate 2019 is 0.4%. Heightened economic and financial market uncertainty along with lingering disruptions caused by the typhoon present risks to the growth outlook. For 2014 to 2017, take-up, completions and vacancy rates are year-end annual. For 2018, take-up, completions and vacancy rate are YTD, while • Occupational demand is expected to remain robust while new supply is future supply is for 4Q18. Source: JLL expected to remain extremely limited, with no completions in the pipeline for 2019. As such, the vacancy rate is forecast to decrease further and drive further rent growth momentum. Capital values should also rise, on the back of rent growth and with further compression of cap rates probable. Note: Osaka Office refers to Osaka’s 2-Ku’s Grade A office market.
Seoul “Positive leasing activity across submarkets leads to 21 – Office strong net absorption.” pyung per month, Stage in Cycle Rental Growth Y-O-Y Sungmin Park, Head of Research, 0.0% net effective on GFA Rents Korea KRW 92,481 Stable Demand levels remain robust for all three business districts Financial Indices • Overall net absorption stood at 32,300 pyung—the highest level since 4Q16— 120 on the back of large tenants moving in as well as sustained positive leasing demand for all major business districts. The largest lease in the quarter was at Gran Seoul in the CBD, where SK including its affiliates SK E&S and SK Innovation took up 4,300 pyung. 110 Index • Demand for prime office space in Yeouido continued. Take up occurred at a brisk pace, aided by attractive incentives at IFC and FKI Tower. Major leases during the quarter included MMC (1,585 pyung), P&G (1,000 pyung), 100 and ANZ (553 pyung) into Three IFC. Gangnam’s demand was also positive on the back of decent take up at ASEM Tower, Gangnam N Tower, and Arc Place. 90 Despite strong demand, influx of stock pushes up vacancy 4Q14 4Q15 4Q16 4Q17 4Q18 4Q19 • Seoul’s overall vacancy increased about 70 bps q-o-q to 13.1% with new stock Rental Value Index Capital Value Index arrivals. Yeouido saw the largest take-up aided by large scale move ins at IFC Arrows indicate 12-month outlook and FKI Tower—KB Asset Management (2,000 pyung), Aramco Korea Index base: 4Q14 = 100 (554 pyung) into Three IFC and KB Bank (5,000 pyung) into FKI Tower. Financial Indicators are for the CBD. Source: JLL • Centropolis (GFA 37,122 pyung) in the CBD and Gangnam N Tower (GFA 12,562 pyung) in Gangnam completed in 3Q18. No space was taken in Centroplis, although Korbit and Lotte’s new co-working company have leased Physical Indicators space in Gangnam N Tower. 300 14 Sale of Samsung C&T Tower sets record high price per pyung 250 12 • Rents increased 1.4% q-o-q as incentives finally showed some contraction at 10 200 major buildings across business districts. On a like-for-like basis, Yeouido rents Thousand sqm 8 Percent outgrew Gangnam and the CBD, posting a 0.9% increase q-o-q. 150 6 • Samsung C&T Tower (GFA 18,360 pyung) in Gangnam was concluded as the 100 largest deal during the quarter, which traded from Samsung C&T to Koramco 4 for KRW 748.4 billion, a record high price per pyung of KRW 30.5 million. 50 2 Outlook: Net absorption and rental growth to improve further 0 0 14 15 16 17 18F 19F • Seoul’s net absorption is expected to remain on track driven by new Grade A Take-up (net) Completions stock additions in the CBD and Gangnam. This is expected to result in relocation Future Supply Vacancy Rate and upgrade activity, aided by high incentive packages offered to prospective For 2014 to 2017, take-up, completions and vacancy rates are year-end tenants. The recent pick up in Yeouido’s leasing demand and expansion of annual. For 2018, take-up, completions and vacancy rate are YTD, while co-working companies are also likely to continue to bolster the leasing market. future supply is for 4Q18. Physical Indicators are for the overall market. • Rental growth is likely to show modest improvement but be limited by the Source: JLL existing vacancy as well as new stock arrivals throughout 2018. Gangnam should continue to outperform the other two markets with limited stock, along with decent demand, underpinned by a strong business landscape of its key tenants. Note: Seoul Office refers to Seoul’s overall Grade A office market.
You can also read