Europe's best co-ops Many hands make light work, and in the case of wine co-operatives it also makes practical and financial sense, enabling ...
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
XXXXXXXXXX Europe’s best co-ops Many hands make light work, and in the case of wine co-operatives it also makes practical and financial sense, enabling members to produce good-quality and good-value wines. Christelle Guibert looks at the concept of the co-op before our regional experts pick their top wines from France, Italy and Spain Imagine that you’ve inherited half a collective investment, which in many areas hectare of village-level vines in a classic region often attracts government subsidy, resulting in renowned for its affordable wines. Let’s say better equipment and facilities as well as the you’re in Mâcon, or Trentino, or Valencia. expertise of a professional winemaking team While you may be keen to continue the family supported by specialist viticulturists. The legacy, you already have a full-time job and co-operative is also often the ideal forum in lack the time and inclination to produce, which to share the opinions and expertise of bottle and market your own wine. Joining the its members, a continual improvement in local winemaking co-operative is an attractive quality being the collective goal. and practical solution, and many vineyard When we think of co-ops, though, we owners have gone down that route. shouldn’t always imagine big and unbranded. Today, co-ops are responsible for a large True, many supermarkets’ own labels are proportion of the total wine production in supplied by co-operatives, but some hugely most of the classic European wine regions. It’s popular brands are co-ops in disguise – hard to put an exact figure on their Champagne Nicolas Feuillatte and Vignobles importance but, according to the Oxford Foncalieu in the Languedoc are examples Companion to Wine, since 1975 more than half – while Iuli, the Cantina Viticoltori del of the wine produced in France has come from Monferrato in Piedmont, has just three Photograph: Morsa Images/Getty Images co-ops. The figure is even higher for Italy. members working 18 hectares of vines. While some originated in the 19th century, Preconceptions of quality are equally to be most were established in the 1930s, with avoided, as wines produced by co-operatives France’s first cooperative, Vignerons Libres in can offer superb value for money at different Maraussa in the Hérault department, founded Christelle Guibert is price points – the Mâcon-Villages from Cave in 1901. Today, by joining forces with Decanter’s tastings de Lugny, for example, or Château Grenouille neighbouring vineyard holders, growers and director who has from La Chablisienne. On the following pages regions alike have more chance to make an worked in wine for our experts highlight some of France, Italy and impact with their wines. It also allows for more than 20 years Spain’s most consistently reliable co-ops. ➢ D E C A N T E R • F e b r u a r y 2 016 | 57
France James Lawther MW is a Decanter contributing editor, the DWWA Regional co-Chair for Bordeaux and an author, lecturer and wine guide based in Bordeaux Co-ops play a huge role in France’s wine scene. The figures speak for themselves: 619 co-ops with 85,000 affiliated growers account for half of the country’s total production Above: the Corbières- the growers guaranteed providing they follow (excluding the Charente’s Cognac-based based co-op of Cave specifications. The cellars have been extended industry). Generating an annual turnover of d’Embres-et- and the co-op’s image modernised through about €6 billion, their social and economic Castelmaure is one of innovative packaging and labelling. The wines clout is enormous. But the big question is: do the role models in have a kiss of the garrigue, generous fruit and they produce decent wine? Languedoc-Roussillon refined tannins. Thirty years ago the answer would have been In the northern Rhône, the Cave de Tain a resounding ‘no’, but now there are co-ops at Top: half of all Crozes- has been one of the leading producers in the the cutting edge of French wine production Hermitage production region for some time. Half of all Crozes- making wines that are clean, compelling and is made by the Cave Hermitage production comes from here, and representative of origin. They are often good de Tain with 31ha of the 136ha of Hermitage under its value, too. Investment in modern facilities and control (including the 23ha Gambert de Loche equipment is part of the answer, but the real estate), this co-op is second only to Chapoutier go-getters are those coaxing quality fruit from in the production of this prestigious wine. their growers on a regular basis. A Syrah specialist (although white versions The Languedoc-Roussillon has always been of Crozes-Hermitage, St-Joseph, St-Péray and dominated by co-ops (69% of the region’s Hermitage are also produced), Cave de Tain production), one of the role models being the produces 5.5 million bottles annually. In 2014 Cave d’Embres-et-Castelmaure. In the 1980s it invested €10 million in new vats and grape a large part of this co-op’s Corbières-based reception equipment. ‘When the grapes are vineyard was replanted with Syrah and ripe, time is of the essence and we can now Grenache and the decision taken to soften the harvest in eight days if necessary,’ explains often muscular tannins of Carignan using general manager Xavier Gomart. The carbonic maceration. ‘We’ve advanced step by individual selections have greater depth and step, with quality the overriding objective,’ character, but throughout the range the fruit, says Bernard Pueyo, manager and winemaker freshness and spice of Syrah is prevalent. at Castelmaure since 1983. Further west in Bordeaux, the Union de These days the 400 hectares that annually Producteurs de St-Emilion, founded in 1931, produce two million bottles are managed on a is the oldest co-op in the Gironde but took a plot-by-plot basis. A series of special selections serious plunge into the modern era in the new has been introduced with remuneration for millennium. A gravity-fed winery complete 58 | F e b r u a r y 2 016 • D E C A N T E R
co-ops Lawther’s eight to try: French co-ops Mailly Grand Cru, Blanc de Astrum Wine, Cambridge Wine Merchants, £21.90 (2011) Bottle Bank, D Byrne & Co Noirs, Champagne NV Hercules Wine Warehouse, The Vintner Firm, dark and fresh with spicy fruit and 90/100 Floral, acacia bouquet with citrus notes. a hint of vanilla oak. Finishes young and £40 Marks & Spencer Pure, ripe and fruity with a refreshing zip tannic, so needs food. 2016-2021 Alc 13% 100% Pinot Noir. Rich and of acidity. Drink 2016-2018 Alc 12.5% biscuity on the nose, then the Cave d’Embres-et- palate is full, round and Cave de Tain, Gambert de Loche, Castelmaure, La Pompadour, structured with a note of Hermitage, Rhône 2013 91 Corbières Languedoc- brioche. This is a full- £54.99 (2009) All About Wine, Jolly Vintner Roussillon 2013 86 flavoured, harmonious and Powerful and brooding. Restrained nose £9.50-£14.20 Bottle Bank, effervescent Champagne. with hidden depth and complexity. Invinity, Vinatis, Vinoa Drink 2016 Alc 12% Chocolate, spice and dark fruit nuance Hearty and generous with on the full and dense palate. Solid tannic plum and dark cherry notes La Chablisienne, Côte de frame. A wine to age. Drink 2019-2030 and the laurel and thyme Léchet 1er Cru, Chablis Alc 13.5% nuance of the south. Grippy Burgundy 2012 89 finish. Drink 2016-2017 Alc 14% £20.27 Astrum Wine, Christopher Cave d’Embres-et-Castelmaure, No3 Keiller, Vinatis de Castelmaure, Corbières, Union de Producteurs de St-Emilion, Subtle bouquet with mineral Languedoc-Roussillon 2013 90 Waitrose, St-Emilion, Bordeaux 2014 and citrus notes. Clean, long £19 (2012) The Wine Society 86 and structured. Elegant Classy Syrah-Carignan-Grenache blend. £13.49 Waitrose weight and style. Drink Melds intensity of flavour with quality Fresh and fruity with blueberry and 2016-2022 Alcohol 13% texture and tannins. Lovely balance for a cherry notes. Medium-bodied. Light, big wine. Drink 2016-2020 Alc 14.5% fine tannins. Dry finish. Very drinkable. La Chablisienne, La Pierrelée, Chablis, Drink 2016 Alc 12.5% Burgundy 2013 87 Cave de Tain, Esprit de Granit, £13.50-£14.99 (2012) Addison Wines, St-Joseph, Rhône 2013 88 For full details of UK stockists, see p89 with 141 stainless steel vats co-op, the success of La Left: the busy bottling was constructed, along with Chablisienne resides in the line at the Union de a cellar that holds 5,300 quality of fruit. ‘There’s Producteurs de barrels. In the vineyard, the nothing particularly special St-Emilion 150 members are now about the winemaking – assessed with respect to most of the ageing is done in yields and other criteria and tank – but we work closely remunerated accordingly. with our 225 members to Twenty years ago the produce the best grapes Union sold half its production possible,’ says general in bulk, but now everything manager Damien Leclerc. is sold in bottle. St-Emilion The wines have attractive grand cru and St-Emilion fruit and finesse as well as wines provide the lion’s the tension and minerality share, but generic Bordeaux, associated with Chablis. Castillon Côtes de Bordeaux Champagne has 138 and St-Emilion satellites are also produced. co-ops and one of the smallest is Mailly Grand Photograph: Jean-Bernard Nadeau/Cephas As well as the Union’s flagship brands, Royal Cru with 80 growers, 73ha and a yearly St-Emilion and Aurelius, and own-label production of 450,000-500,000 bottles. The supermarket brands, there are 50 château wines are produced exclusively from grapes labels that are vinified separately. The style of grown in the grand cru village of Mailly with the wines is classic St-Emilion, apart from the Pinot Noir (which represents 75% of more obviously modern Aurelius. production) the speciality. Ten different Moving into Burgundy, La Chablisienne Champagnes are made, the non-vintage Brut produces nine million bottles annually from Réserve representing two-thirds of production. 1,280ha. This represents 25% of the total All are rich and full in style but exude production of Chablis. Another benchmark harmony and balance. ➢ D E C A N T E R • F e b r u a r y 2 016 | 59
Italy Ian D’Agata is a DWWA Regional co-Chair for Italy, scientific advisor to Vinitaly International and award- winning author of The Native Wine Grapes of Italy Italy is the world’s largest wine producer (it vies for first or second position with France on a yearly basis) and so inevitably co-ops play a huge role in the country’s wine economy. Of Italy’s 122 largest wine producers with annual revenues in excess of €25 million, 41 all the cheap plonk are co-ops. Four of these are in the top 10, and and tried a slightly Cantine Riunite in Campegine (near Reggio more expensive Emilia) is numero uno, with an annual income Pinot Grigio such as in 2014 of €536m. Tramin’s. The majority of Italy’s many co-ops produce Cantina Terlan large volumes of decently made if not especially (143 members, exciting wines, but are remarkably successful, 165ha, 1.4 million reporting a 7% increase in annual income in bottles a year) 2014 (as opposed to only 6% for wine estates) makes Italy’s – a noteworthy improvement on their 3.8% longest-lived white annual average for the previous decade. In wines (many from addition, co-ops posted a lofty 11% increase in the 1960s are export sales. splendid), and easily So which are Italy’s best or most exciting Above: Alto Adige’s Italy’s best Pinot Bianco. Additionally, its co-ops? The good news is that there are almost Cantina Terlan and the Porphyr Lagrein Riserva and Quarz Sauvignon too many to count (that said, it’s only fair to 380ha of vineyards Blanc are also among Italy’s top two or three admit there are remarkably bad ones, and farmed by St Michael- wines made with those varieties. Cantina St rather well-known ones among them). Eppan’s 350 members Michael-Eppan (350 members, 380ha, 2.2 If Piedmont’s Produttori del Barbaresco (top) make some of million bottles a year) is famous for its top (52 members, 110ha and 480,000 bottles a Italy’s best white Sanct Valentin bottlings, the Sauvignon of year) isn’t Italy’s best co-op, then it’s certainly varietal wines which has long been viewed by Italian wine the best at making red wines. Indeed, lovers as Italy’s best wine from that variety. Barbarescos this good are hard to come by Cellarmaster Hans Terzer deserves credit not even at family-run estates. General director just for producing exceptionally high-quality Aldo Vacca is a walking encyclopedia on wines in relatively large volumes, but also for Nebbiolo and Barbaresco, and he produces not being the spiritual leader of a new generation just a delicious and very fairly priced entry- of young and talented winemakers for whom level Barbaresco, but a bevy of Barbaresco crus he sets an example. Last but not least in Alto that rank with the best wines in Italy. Adige, Kellerei Nals Margreid and Cantina It is generally accepted that Italy’s best Valle Isarco also produce a host of unbeatable co-operatives are Alto Adige’s, just south of the wines when it comes to price for quality. border with Austria. Is anyone making better Still in Italy’s north, in the Valle d’Aosta on white wines in Italy than Alto Adige’s Cantina the border with France, is another of Italy’s Tramin? Perhaps only another Alto Adige truly great wine producers, Cave Mont Blanc co-op, Terlan; and many would argue that de Morgex et de La Salle (80 members, 14ha, St Michael-Eppan is at the same quality level. 140,000 bottles a year). It is responsible for The Nussbaumer from Cantina Tramin (290 most of the winemaking in the northern third members, 235ha, 1.5 million bottles a year) is of the region (the Alta Valle), producing a Italy’s best Gewurztraminer, and its Unterebner series of magnificent still and sparkling white is one of the country’s three best oaked Pinot wines – both by the tank and the traditional Grigios – a clear-cut example of just how noble method – from the local white Prié grape. The a wine Pinot Grigio can be. If only importers co-op also deserves credit for its innovation and wine lovers outside Italy stopped buying and research: thanks to president Mauro 6 0 | F e b r u a r y 2 016 • D E C A N T E R
co-ops D’Agata’s eight to try: Italian co-ops Cantina Terlan, Quarz Cantina Gallura, Canayli Sauvignon Blanc, Alto Vermentino di Gallura Superiore, Adige 2013 93/100 Sardinia 2014 90 £39-£46 AG Wines, £22 Exel Astrum Wine, Farr Fresh and citrussy, with a delicate Vintners, Highbury herbal twist and noteworthy saline Vintners, Woodwinters and balsamic strokes on the long, Deep, pure and zippy finish. Drink 2016-2018 concentrated – a rare Alc 13.5% example of oaked Sauvignon that is more Cantina Santadi, Terre than the sum of its parts. Superb. Brune, Carignano del Drink 2016-2025 Alcohol 14% Sulcis Superiore, Sardinia 2010 93 Cantina Tramin, Nussbaumer £38-£42 AG Wines, Eclectic Gewurztraminer, Alto Adige 2013 Tastes, Exel, Great Western 93 Wine, Hedonism, Slurp £24.50-£32 Corking Wines, Dense, rich and suave, Drinkmonger, The Drink Shop with polished, chocolatey Rich, deep and complex. A Gewurz plum and smoky dark that can stand up to the best from berry aromas and Alsace, but in a much drier style. flavours. A real beauty. Drink 2016-2023 Alc 14% Drink 2016-2026 Alc 14% Cantina St Michael- Produttori del Barbaresco, Above: the riddling racks for the traditional- Eppan, Sanct Valentin Montestefano Riserva, method sparklling wines made at Cave Mont Blanc Sauvignon, Alto Adige Barbaresco, Piedmont 2008 93 de Morgex et de La Salle in Valle d’Aosta 2013 92 £39 Astrum Wine £25-£31 Christopher Keiller, Notes of rose petals with sour red Jacod, technical director Nicola Del Negro, and Eurowines, Ministry of Drinks cherry and sweet spices on this in association with Dr Provino Lale Demoz of Sage, yellow melon and high-acid, classically styled and the Institut Agricole Régional, a wine is now green fig notes – rich and ageworthy Barbaresco. Very fine. also made from a rare and mostly forgotten suave. A serious Drink 2016-2035 Alc 14% local red variety called Roussin de Morgex. It’s Sauvignon, between the a delicious red bubbly that spends about 18 oakiness of Pouilly-Fumé ArPePe, Valtellina, months on its lees. and the grassiness of New Zealand. Lombardy 2013 91 Clearly, not all of Italy’s great wine co-ops Drink 2016-2020 Alc 14% £40 Noble Fine Liquor are located in the north. Sardinia’s Cantina 100% Nebbiolo. Dense Santadi produces about 1.7 million bottles a Cave Mont Blanc de Morgex et de and precise aromas and year, and among those are two of Italy’s top La Salle, Rayon, Valle d’Aosta flavours of red cherry, 100 red wines: the magnificent Terre Brune, a 2013 91 mountain herbs and Carignano del Sulcis Superiore; and Rocca £22 Exel liquorice. Mouthwatering Rubia, a Carignano del Sulcis Riserva. Now Made from the local Prié grape. acidity keeps your palate that Carignan is suddenly becoming Bright, juicy and floral, with yellow interested. Drink fashionable, it is only fair to point out that for apple and lime flavours that last and 2016-2021 Alc 14% decades it was this co-operative that showed last. Hard to put the glass down! the world (certainly France and Spain) just Drink 2016-2018 Alc 13.5% For full UK stockist details, see p89 how noble this variety can be. Founded in 1960, Santadi boasts more than 200 members who farm more than 600ha of prime vineyard land on the island. Emilia Romagna’s standout Lambrusco wine In fact, there are many other Italian co-ops producers Cavicchioli and Chiarli 1860, and worthy of an honourable mention: Lombardy’s Sardinia’s Cantina di Mogoro, Cantina ArPePe, Abruzzo’s Cantina Tollo (which has Gallura and Cantina del Vermentino-Monti almost single-handedly has kept the families immediately spring to mind. Seek them out – of the Chieti province afloat over the years), their wines will surprise you. ➢ D E C A N T E R • F e b r u a r y 2 016 | 61
Spain Sarah Jane Evans MW is a DWWA Regional co-Chair for Spain. In 2010 she was made a member of the Gran Orden de Caballeros de Vino for services to Spanish wine Spain is still overrun with small co-ops. Often named after the Virgin Mary or Jesus Christ, they had – and many retain – a powerful social function in supporting the Underlying the bulk community. For some, the integration with the production is a vision. outside world remains slow. Others have Bodegas Patrocinio, specialised, and focused on wine. formed in Rioja Alta in These can be hard to spot, as they often 1985, notes: ‘We have a hide behind brands. Few would recognise huge responsibility to Cevipe in Penedès, although it’s a very our families, our town, significant supplier of base wine to producers Rioja, and Spanish of cava. Furthermore, if you have ever enjoyed wine in general. a very low-priced Garnacha, then it’s more Co-operativism has than likely to have come from a co-op. Great- been crucial for the value Garnacha and Monastrell is something survival of many that the co-ops have done very well. What they small-scale grape have been less good at is offering ‘aspirational’ growers – the incentive wines – ones that can be sold at a higher price of individual interest is and create more value for their members. Above: harvesting replaced by collective effort and compensation.’ This is not entirely surprising, for in Godello grapes at Its UK importer gave its wine the name Dos contrast to France and Italy, Spain’s co-ops are Martín Códax in Galicia Cientos (200) to symbolise the co-op’s 200 still in transition; the country only joined the growers with their 525ha of vineyards. European Union in 1986. Nevertheless, progress Top: in Rioja, Bodegas Certainly it is in marketing that many of has been made. Take Bodegas del Rosario. Patrocinio has 525ha of the co-ops fall down, not yet able to build Accounting for some 85% of the Bullas DO vineyards farmed by profiles for themselves and invest in export. production, it had little incentive to change. 200 growers Bodegas Borsao in Campo de Borja is a good Yet it is choosing to focus on building identity example of early success in brand building. in what has been an overlooked region. Representing almost a third of the DO, the 650 Co-ops are supposed to be all about (large) members with 2,500ha of vineyards have a size, and few can be larger than Anecoop. This strong emphasis on Garnacha – it’s almost multi-faceted Valencian business is said to be two-thirds of production. the largest seller of oranges in the world. While Catalonia retains many smaller co-ops that wine is a mere 6% of its business, it adds up to were an essential support to villages during a substantial number. Winemaker Norrel the hard aftermath of the Spanish Civil War. Robertson MW, who works with co-ops across Today they represent Catalan dynamism. Spain, notes two of Anecoop’s specific quality Celler de Capçanes in Montsant was one of projects: its work with the co-op in San Martín the early co-ops to show entrepreneurial skill. de Unx in Navarra, and its ‘exciting’ winery La Its diversification began when it was Viña, in Font de la Figuera, Valencia, working approached by the Jewish community in with old-vine Monastrell and Alicante Bouschet. Barcelona to make a kosher wine. Primavera, Covinca in the Cariñena DO, founded in the wine created, is a classic brand today, and 1987 with a production today of seven million there are now six wines in the kosher portfolio. bottles, is another co-op that is better known Around this is an extensive collection of among consumers by its brands than its own wines, produced by the 150 members. Today name. Its Extra Special Old Vine Garnacha (£5) they reflect their origins, offering fascinating made for Asda is a typical example of keenly terroir choices such as a range of contrasting priced private label. Garnachas grown on different soils. Another co-op led by a team with vision is Right: Asda’s Extra Special Old Vine Garnacha, one with surely the best site in Spain: Martín made by the Covinca co-op in Cariñena Códax in Galicia. On a hill above the Salnés 62 | F e b r u a r y 2 016 • D E C A N T E R
co-ops Old, dry-farmed Garnacha vines farmed by Celler de Capçanes in Montsant Evans’ eight to try: Spanish co-ops Agrícola Castellana, Cuatro its honeyed, citrus complexity, with leesy, Society is £5.50, but this Selección Rayas Viñedos Centenarios creamy overtones. Drink 2016 Alc 13% Especial, using a little new oak, shows Verdejo, Rueda 2014 91/100 just how well they can step up. Typical £8.29-£8.50 All About Wine, Celler de Capçanes, Cabrida Garnatxa good value from a Spanish co-op. Drink Drinkmonger, ThirtyFifty Vinyes Velles, Montsant 2010 91 2016-2017 Alc 15% A co-op showcasing its finest in £23-£35 Berry Bros & Rudd, Connolly’s, 100% old-vine Verdejo. All the HarperWells Bodegas Borsao, Tres Picos concentration of lime acidity A Montsant co-op doing what Montsant Garnacha, Campo de Borja with the keynote edge of does best: centenary Garnacha. Named 2013 86 Verdejo bitterness and a slight after the mountain goat (cabrida), this is £12.59-£15 Bentley’s, Cheers, spice of crystallised ginger. an exceptional Garnacha reflecting all of D Byrne & Co, Fareham, Highbury Drink 2016-2017 Alcohol 13% Montsant’s wildness. A blend of sour Vintners, Noel Young, Rannoch cherry and plum with a firm grip of Scott, St Andrews Wine Co Bodegas del Rosario, Niño de las Uvas tannin. Drink 2016-2020 Alc 15% Garnacha, the traditional Macabeo-Malvasia, Bullas 2014 88 engine of the co-ops, is now £12 Laithwaites Bodegas San Martín, Señorio de Unx the height of fashion. Borsao Macabeo (Viura) with aromatic Malvasia. Garnacha, Navarra 2011 88 was a pioneering exporter and Rich, creamy palate with delicate smoky £8.99 Virgin Wines Tres Picos its leading wine. Others may notes from fermentation in French oak, Navarra still has some lovely old-vine have surpassed it, but it’s still a modern balancing an overlay of white flowers. Garnacha in addition to the usual range classic. Drink 2016-2019 Alc 14.5% Delightfully fresh from fruit grown at of international varieties. This has dense higher altitudes. Drink 2016-2017 Alc 14% blueberry and bramble fruit. Bodegas Patrocinio, Finca Dos Drink 2016-2018 Alc 14% Cientos, Rioja 2012 86 Bodegas Martín Códax, Mara Martín £11.99 10International, The Market Square Godello, Monterrei 2013 88 Bodegas Virgen de la Sierra, Tempranillo from Rioja Alta, rounded out £9-£11 Bay Tree Wine, Carruthers & Kent, North Cruz de Piedra Selección with Garnacha and given a liquorice and & South, Reserve Wine, The Good Wine Shop, Especial Garnacha, citrus lift by Graciano. The blend of The Secret Cellar, Vino Wines, Woodwinters Calatayud 2013 88 American and French oak gives a classic Albariño is Codax’s business, and visitors £8.25 The Wine Society smoke and vanilla note and grip of chalky to the co-op can taste through every The oldest vineyards in the arid tannins. Drink 2016-2019 Alc 13.5% style. Mara Martín is a fine contrast: from soils of Calatayud. The co-op’s warmer inland Monterrei, Godello shows basic Garnacha at The Wine For full details of UK stockists, see p89 Valley, the winery overlooks the mussel beds million-bottle business that accounts for 20% in the bay. Like a number of successful co-ops, of Rueda’s total production. It manages it was founded in the mid-1980s. Today it has 2,150ha of vineyard belonging to 400 growers 270 members, and takes in grapes from and has been a leader in technology, and in another 300 families, altogether an impressive international wine-quality certification. management exercise. The next decade poses many questions for Another significant white wine co-op is the Spain. Is the super-efficient winery the only Rueda’s largest producer: Agrícola Castellana. model? Can smaller co-ops keep afloat? And From a small base in 1935 it has grown to a 15 who defends their members’ interests best? D D E C A N T E R • F e b r u a r y 2 016 | 6 3
You can also read