DEPRESSION IN DENVER: THROUGH THE LIFESPAN - Denver Public Health
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
CONTENTS 02 Executive Summary SECTION ONE 05 Introduction SECTION TWO 08 Depression Through the Lifespan SECTION THREE 14 Downstream Effects of Untreated Depression SECTION FOUR 16 Key Contributors SECTION FIVE 17 Specific Populations SECTION SIX 20 Barriers to Mental Health Care SECTION SEVEN 22 Diagnosis and Treatment of Depression in Denver SECTION EIGHT 25 Moving Forward to Support Positive Mental Health 29 APPENDIX: DATA SOURCES 32 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS 33 ENDNOTES 01 DENVERPUBLICHEALTH.ORG
DEPRESSION IN DENVER: THROUGH THE LIFESPAN EXECUTIVE SUMMARY A comprehensive and collaborative approach to addressing depression is essential to the well-being of Denver residents and the success of our city. Depression is one of the most common mental illnesses, as well as one of the leading causes of illness, disability, and premature death in the United States. In addition to its impact on individual health, depression has significant implications for the well-being of families and communities. The causes of depression are complex. Its development and trajectory are related to biological, medical, and genetic factors, as well as a person’s social, economic, and environmental circumstances. As a result, depression is deeply associated with social inequities, and although depression can affect any person at any time in their lives, its impact is disproportionately felt by specific groups of people. As such, Denver must develop strategies to address depression within all of our communities to promote the health of all people in Denver. This report brings together findings from both well-established and novel data sources to support a localized understanding of the scope and impact of depression. Such understanding is needed to drive actions among various stakeholder groups that can effectively mitigate the burden of depression in Denver. DEPRESSION CAN APPEAR AT ANY POINT ACROSS ONE’S LIFESPAN 02
Key Themes and Findings DEPRESSION IS A COMMON AND CRITICAL HEALTH ISSUE ACROSS THE LIFESPAN • Mental health issues are of great negatively impact their quality can intensify the medical concern to Denver youth, and of life, as well as the health and complications of these conditions. there is interest among them in development of their children. Depression is associated with an making resources and support increased risk of mortality from all more available to young people • Depression is significantly causes. facing mental health challenges. associated with illness, disability, and premature death. It is • Suicide rates in Denver are • Depression impacts Denver adults more common among people consistently higher than national of all ages, races/ethnicities, and with a number of chronic rates, and depression is a key geographic locations. medical conditions (diabetes, underlying factor in suicide. cardiovascular disease, stroke, • During and after pregnancy, Alzheimer’s disease, and drug many women in Denver struggle and alcohol dependency), and with depression. Depression can the presence of depression DEPRESSION IS A HEALTH EQUITY ISSUE • A person’s mental health status is depression and/or underserved • Concerns about the cost of greatly impacted by their social, by existing treatment services. treatment, lack of insurance, economic, and environmental These include men, LGBTQ and lack of adequate insurance circumstances. Psychological communities, communities of coverage for mental health trauma, chronic stress, and color, people involved with services are common reasons social determinants of health the justice system, pregnant that Denver residents do not are significant contributors to women, people experiencing receive mental health care depression. homelessness, people who or counseling services when are uninsured or underinsured, needed. • A number of groups are immigrants and refugees, and disproportionately impacted by first responders. EFFECTIVE TREATMENTS EXIST, BUT BARRIERS PERSIST • Stigma, personal beliefs, patients) is a critical strategy the metro region: challenges attitudes, and experiences are for ensuring that people who in institutionalizing screening strong drivers of whether or not are experiencing depression are and referral protocols, difficulty a person seeks professional help promptly diagnosed and able sharing information across for depression. to access timely and effective providers, and challenges with treatment services. reimbursement for integrated care services. • Integrated care (where mental health and primary • Integrated care is increasingly care providers collaborate to available in Denver, but barriers address both the physical and inhibit the broad adoption of fully mental health needs of their integrated practices throughout 03 DENVERPUBLICHEALTH.ORG
DEPRESSION IN DENVER: THROUGH THE LIFESPAN Moving Forward to Support Positive Mental Health The findings of this report have implications for the work of health systems, policy makers, researchers, community-based organizations, employers, and community members. Next steps include actions to: Undertake communication strategies to decrease stigma and increase knowledge and awareness of depression and its impacts. Conduct research to increase understanding of mechanisms and community solutions for addressing depression. Initiate policies and programs that address key contributors to depression. Identify and support individuals who are experiencing depression. Increase the availability of integrated care. Reduce stigma and other barriers to accessing mental health services. 04 04
SECTION ONE INTRODUCTION SCREENING AND INTERVENTION IN PRIMARY CARE ADDRESSES MENTAL HEALTH CONCERNS A 32 year old Latino came for a follow-up HIV care visit. Before being seen by his primary care provider, screening questions by the clinic behavioral health specialist showed that he had developed feelings of hopelessness over the past three months and had begun drinking six to eight beers a day. Upon further questioning by the primary care provider, he noted financial difficulties and stresses within his family. He was offered counseling with the behavioral health specialist, but he did not have time to do so. (He was currently working 80 hours a week to support his family.) However, the patient visibly relaxed during an open, collaborative discussion about depression and alcohol use. At the end of the visit, he committed to markedly decreasing his alcohol intake and trying to fit some form of exercise into his very busy schedule. 05 DENVERPUBLICHEALTH.ORG
DEPRESSION IN DENVER: THROUGH THE LIFESPAN Mental health is an essential component of overall health for every person at every stage of life. It is “a state of well-being in which every individual realizes [their] own potential, can cope with the normal stresses of life, can work productively and fruitfully, and is able to make a contribution to [their] community.”1 By actively promoting mental health for all Denver residents, we can support the success of everyone living in Denver and ensure a promising future for our city. depression (NOUN) / DE•PRES•SION / In 2017, approximately 76,100 (one depression may experience feelings out of every eight) Denver residents of persistent sadness, hopelessness, age five and older indicated that irritability, guilt, or worthlessness. they had experienced eight or more Depression can lead to difficulty Within the context of this days of poor mental health over engaging in work and activities, report, the term “depression” the past month. 2 That is more than problems with concentration and the total number of people living in decision-making, changes in sleeping refers to “clinical depression.” Denver’s four largest neighborhoods and eating patterns, and physical Clinical depression is typically – Montbello, Hampden, Westwood, symptoms such as aches or pains, diagnosed when symptoms and Capitol Hill – combined. Previous headaches, cramps, or digestive studies have shown that people who problems. are present for at least two respond affirmatively to this question weeks and are sufficiently often warrant a clinical diagnosis of In recognition of the significant social, depression. economic, and health burden of severe to interfere with daily depression and other mental illnesses, activities. Clinical depression Mental illnesses are health conditions national stakeholders have issued that are associated with poor mental numerous foundational documents is understood to be caused health, or changes in mood, thinking, that call attention to the need for a by a confluence of biological, psychological, and social factors, with emotional trauma, chronic 1 OUT OF 8 stress, and social inequities playing a critical role in its DENVER COUNTY RESIDENTS AGE FIVE AND OLDER INDICATED progression. Clinical depression THAT THEY HAD EXPERIENCED EIGHT OR MORE DAYS OF POOR is different from situational MENTAL HEALTH OVER THE PAST MONTH. depression, which refers to the THIS IS MORE THAN THE TOTAL NUMBER OF PEOPLE LIVING time-limited mood changes that IN DENVER’S FOUR LARGEST NEIGHBORHOODS—MONTBELLO, one may experience in response HAMPDEN, WESTWOOD, AND CAPITOL HILL—COMBINED. to identifiable life events, such as illness, relationship problems, and behavior. Mental illnesses public health approach to mental problems at work or school, or represent the leading cause of health issues and provide evidence loss of a loved one. Clinical disease burden in the United States, for population-based mental health depression is often chronic and as measured by life years lost to strategies. 5,6,7 Despite these calls to illness, disability, and premature action, there is a relative shortage may rise and fall spontaneously death. 3 of information regarding the scope or with treatment. The and impact of depression and other Affecting people of all ages and mental health issues at a local level. impacts of untreated clinical social groups, depression is one of This local understanding is essential depression are wide-ranging, the most common mental illnesses to the establishment of adequate within the U.S., and it carries the with implications for the health and accessible treatment services, highest disease burden of all mental initiation of prevention strategies, and and well-being of individuals, health conditions.4 People living with appropriate allocation of resources. families, and communities. 06 DENVERPUBLICHEALTH.ORG 06
Overview of Data Sources on Depression This report features three kinds of data to evaluate the frequency of depression and its complications: TELEPHONE & ELECTRONIC QUALITATIVE DATA WRITTEN SURVEYS HEALTH RECORDS from more detailed, in-person discussions with youth and key stakeholders. No data source is superior and each has strengths and limitations. Together they provide a more complete picture of depression in Denver. See Appendix 1 for more detail about data sources and their strengths and limitations. NOTE: At times, this report references information regarding outcomes and disparities associated with mental illness or mental health conditions. This occurs when depression-specific information is unavailable. Given our understanding of depression as one of the most common mental illnesses experienced within the United States, mental illness can be considered a proxy for depression in these circumstances. How Can This Report Be Used? Denver Public Health developed this report to provide a clearer picture of depression’s impact in Denver, so as to: ENHANCE UNDERSTANDING OF DEPRESSION AS A KEY LOCAL HEALTH ISSUE. CREATE RECOGNITION OF GAPS IN OUR CURRENT TREATMENT SYSTEMS. SUPPORT ACTIONS THAT CAN EFFECTIVELY MITIGATE THE BURDEN OF DEPRESSION IN OUR LOCAL COMMUNITIES. 07 DENVERPUBLICHEALTH.ORG
DEPRESSION IN DENVER: THROUGH THE LIFESPAN SECTION TWO DEPRESSION THROUGH THE LIFESPAN Depression can affect any individual at any time in their lives and can be caused by many factors, including genetics, brain biology, and chemistry, as well as life events such as trauma, loss of a loved one, a difficult relationship, an early childhood experience, or any stressful situation.8 Since most of these factors are not specific to one age group, depression and depressive symptoms can appear at any point across one’s lifespan. Childhood and Adolescence (0-17 YEARS OLD) Less than three decades ago depression was seen as an adult disorder: children were considered too developmentally immature to experience depression disorders, and adolescent mood disorders were seen as part of ‘normal’ teenage mood swings.9 More recently it has been recognized that children and adolescents also experience depression, making this stage of life an important time both for recognition and prevention of depression. RELEVANT DATA DENVER YOUTH HEALTH ASSESSMENT | QUALITATIVE INTERVIEW AND WRITTEN SURVEY DATA 15 % Youth expressed concern about inadequate OF DENVER YOUTH SURVEYED awareness of and access to mental health cited mental health issues as services. They also talked about stigma interfering the most important issue affecting with help-seeking behavior. Young people their health surveyed noted a lack of safe places for mental health conversations and stigma faced by peers, family, and the broader community. This caused 4 % MENTIONED DEPRESSION SPECIFICALLY them to worry that peers who were coping with mental health challenges may not reach their potential and might harm themselves. 08
HEALTHY KIDS COLORADO SURVEY | WRITTEN SURVEY DATA According to the 2015 Health Kids Colorado Survey, nearly three in 10 middle and high school students in Denver NEARLY 3 IN 10 indicated that during the past 12 months they felt so sad MIDDLE & HIGH SCHOOL or hopeless almost every day for two weeks or more in a row that they stopped doing some usual activities, which STUDENTS IN DENVER are symptoms consistent with depression. Depression among youth is statistically significantly higher in females than males (39% vs. 20%). While the rate does vary among race/ethnicity, age groups, and grade levels, there is no statistically significant difference among these groups. However, the data shows that gay, lesbian, and bisexual INDICATED THAT DURING THE PAST 12 MONTHS THEY FELT SO SAD OR HOPELESS ALMOST EVERY DAY FOR TWO students were more than twice as likely to feel this way WEEKS OR MORE IN A ROW THAT THEY STOPPED DOING (58%) compared to their heterosexual classmates (26%). SOME USUAL ACTIVITIES. PERCENTAGE OF STUDENTS WHO FELT SO SAD OR HOPELESS ALMOST EVERY DAY FOR TWO WEEKS OR MORE IN A ROW THAT THEY STOPPED DOING SOME USUAL ACTIVITIES DURING THE PAST 26% 58% 12 MONTHS (BY SEXUAL ORIENTATION) Source: Healthy Kids Colorado Survey, 2015 (Question: During the past 12 months, did you ever feel so sad or hopeless almost every day for two weeks or more in a row that you stopped HETEROSEXUAL GAY, LESBIAN OR BISEXUAL doing some usual activities?) COLORADO HEALTH OBSERVATION REGIONAL DATA SERVICE (CHORDS) ELECTRONIC HEALTH RECORD DATA In Denver in 2016, 4% of children and adolescents ages 0-17 were diagnosed with depression at a CHORDS participating healthcare provider. This included 4% of non-Hispanic whites, 3% of non-Hispanic blacks and 4% of Hispanics. WHAT PERCENT OF CHILDREN HAVE BEEN DIAGNOSED WITH DEPRESSION BY A MEDICAL PROVIDER? (BY AGE GROUP) 12% WE SEE A PROGRESSIVE AND 10% 11 % SIGNIFICANT INCREASE FROM ONE AGE GROUP TO THE NEXT. 8% 6% 7% 4% 1% 2% .1% 0% 0-5 YEARS 6-11 YEARS 12-14 YEARS 15-17 YEARS Source: Colorado Health Observation Regional Data Service (CHORDS), 2016 09 DENVERPUBLICHEALTH.ORG
DEPRESSION IN DENVER: THROUGH THE LIFESPAN CHORDS data also provide the ability to map the frequency of diagnosed depression by census tracts. This allows for resources to be allocated to areas most in need. PREVALENCE OF DIAGNOSED DEPRESSION AMONG CHILDREN =5% 3 -
Adulthood (18+ YEARS OLD) Adulthood is a period of life that can encompass multiple different stages and experiences, such as post high school education as a young adult, starting a family, working many different jobs and careers through middle adulthood, and retirement in older adulthood. Each stage has risks for developing depression, whether related to financial worries, relationship breakdowns, or stressful events such as the death of a loved one.10 Pregnancy and After Delivery BETWEEN Depression can be associated with pregnancy and the period following (postpartum period). According to The American Congress of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, between 14-23% of women will struggle with symptoms of depression during pregnancy, making depression the 14-23% OF WOMEN most common complication of pregnancy.11,12 In contrast, the prevalence of WILL STRUGGLE WITH SYMPTOMS OF depression in all women of reproductive age is only one in 20.13 Depression DEPRESSION DURING PREGNANCY not only impacts the mother’s quality of life, but may also interfere with a mother’s ability to maintain health during pregnancy or after birth and to bond with or respond to her infant. This can impair the parent-child Source: American Pregnancy Association, 2015 interactions that are necessary for healthy brain development.14 RELEVANT DATA PREGNANCY RISK ASSESSMENT MONITORING SYSTEM (PRAMS) TELEPHONE AND WRITTEN SURVEY DATA NEARLY NEARLY COMPARED TO MOTHERS WHO DID NOT REPORT 2X AS LIKELY 2XAS LIKELY 2X AS LIKELY 3X MORE LIKELY 2XAS LIKELY DEPRESSION, MOTHERS TO REPORT TO REPORT TO REPORT TO REPORT TO HAVE WHO DID WERE DIFFICULTY HAVING A ARGUING EXPERIENCING SOMEONE APPROXIMATELY: PAYING THE HUSBAND, MORE THAN HOMELESSNESS. CLOSE TO HER BILLS. PARTNER, OR NORMAL WITH EXPERIENCE A ONE’S SELF A HUSBAND OR PROBLEM WITH INCARCERATED. PARTNER. DRINKING OR DRUGS. Source: Pregnancy Risk Assessment Monitoring System (PRAMS), 2014-2016 In 2016, approximately 9% of Denver mothers (and a similar percentage of Colorado mothers) experienced postpartum depression. Among women told by a healthcare worker that they had postpartum depression: 55% 8% 2% TOOK PRESCRIPTION ENGAGED IN ENGAGED IN A MEDICATION FOR DEPRESSION. COUNSELING. SUPPORT GROUP. Source: Pregnancy Risk Assessment Monitoring System (PRAMS), 2014-2016 11 DENVERPUBLICHEALTH.ORG
DEPRESSION IN DENVER: THROUGH THE LIFESPAN DENVER HEALTH PREGNANCY-RELATED DEPRESSION SCREENING DATA ELECTRONIC HEALTH RECORD DATA In 2015, Denver Public Health began supporting the implementation of universal JAN 2017 DEC 2017 pregnancy-related depression screening in obstetric, family medicine, and pediatric settings within Denver Health. By September 2017, all Denver Health clinics had adopted screening protocols and nearly 80% of women were being screened at least once during pregnancy and during the first six months postpartum. 24 % OF WOMEN HAD A POSITIVE SCREEN DURING PREGNANCY Based on data extracted from Denver Health electronic health records dating from January 2017 through December 2017, 24% of women had a positive screen during pregnancy, and 19% had a positive screen during their postpartum period. All women seen for prenatal care and delivery, as well as all children turning seven 19% OF WOMEN HAD A POSITIVE SCREEN DURING THEIR POSTPARTUM PERIOD months old with at least one well-child visit, were included in this records review. Source: Denver Health Electronic Health The number of positive screens is much higher than the prevalence identified in Record Data, 2017 the PRAMS survey. While not all women with a positive screen will end up with a depression diagnosis, these data indicate that more than one in five pregnant or postpartum women presenting at Denver’s largest safety net health care system are experiencing some depressive symptoms. Many women with a positive screen are accessing services from the integrated behavioral health specialist. Non-Pregnant Adults WHAT PERCENT OF ADULTS REPORTED THEIR MENTAL HEALTH AS NOT GOOD EIGHT OR MORE DAYS DURING THE PAST 30 DAYS? RELEVANT DATA 20% BEHAVIORAL RISK FACTOR 15% SURVEILLANCE SYSTEM (BRFSS) 10% TELEPHONE SURVEY DATA 5% From 2012-2016, 15% of Denver adults surveyed indicated that they had eight 0% or more days of poor mental health 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 (which includes stress, depression, and problems with emotions) during Source: Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System (BRFSS), 2016 (Question: the past 30 days (previous studies Thinking about your mental health, which includes stress, depression, and problems with emotions, for how many days during the past 30 days was your mental health have shown that people who respond not good?) affirmatively to this question often warrant a clinical diagnosis of depression). It’s unclear if there have been any significant increases or decreases over this time period. More women than men reported eight or more days of poor mental health during the past 30 days. More non-Hispanic black adults reported eight or more days of poor mental health during the past 30 days compared to non-Hispanic white adults or Hispanic adults. WHAT PERCENT BY GENDER BY RACE/ETHNICITY OF ADULTS REPORTED THEIR MENTAL HEALTH AS NOT GOOD EIGHT OR 14% 17% 14% 26% 15% MORE DAYS DURING THE PAST 30 DAYS? MALE FEMALE NON-HISPANIC NON-HISPANIC HISPANIC BY GENDER WHITE BLACK & RACE/ Source: Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System (BRFSS), 2016 (Question: Thinking about your mental health, ETHNICITY which includes stress, depression, and problems with emotions, for how many days during the past 30 days was your mental health not good?) 12
The frequency of symptoms of depression was similar across adult age groups. 14% 18% 15% 17% 16% 11% 18-24 YEARS 25-34 YEARS 35-44 YEARS 45-54 YEARS 55-64 YEARS 65+ YEARS Source: Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System (BRFSS), 2016 (Question: Thinking about your mental health, which includes stress, depression, and problems with emotions, for how many days during the past 30 days was your mental health not good?) COLORADO HEALTH OBSERVATION REGIONAL DATA SERVICE (CHORDS) ELECTRONIC HEALTH RECORD DATA The frequency of a clinical diagnosis of depression from electronic health records (11%) was somewhat lower than the frequency of symptoms of depression from telephone survey data (14%). A discrepancy between these two estimates would be expected due to the stigma associated with seeking treatment, among other factors. Subgroup analyses suggest that the discrepancy between self-reported and diagnosed depression is similar for different demographic groups. Regardless of the data source, depression is common at all stages of adulthood, among men and women, and among persons in all racial and ethnic groups. CHORDS data also provide the ability to map by census tracts. This allows for resources to be allocated to areas most in need. PREVALENCE OF DIAGNOSED DEPRESSION AMONG ADULTS 18 YEARS AND OLDER IN DENVER COUNTY BY CENSUS TRACT, 2016 PREVALENCE >= 15% 10 -
DEPRESSION IN DENVER: THROUGH THE LIFESPAN SECTION THREE Downstream Effects of Untreated Depression Depression is a leading cause of disease burden, or life years lost to illness, disability, and premature death within the U.S.15 In addition to its negative impact on individual health, untreated depression also has significant implications for the well-being of families and communities. Health Outcomes Associated with Untreated Depression Chronic Health Suicide Conditions Depression and chronic medical conditions are Depression is a prominent risk factor for suicide. In 2013, often inter-connected, with effects working in both suicide was the eighth leading cause of death in Denver, directions. People with chronic health conditions (such causing more deaths than homicide or motor vehicle as Parkinson’s disease, cancer, diabetes, cardiovascular crashes. 21 Between 2004-2016, 68% of Denver suicides disease, cerebrovascular disease, and Alzheimer’s were associated with a current depressed mood, and 25% disease) are more likely than others to experience were associated with a diagnosis of depression. 22 depression.16 Conversely, depression may increase one’s risk for developing certain medical conditions, such as cardiovascular disease, diabetes, stroke, and Alzheimer’s disease. Untreated depression may worsen the course and management of chronic illnesses, regardless of the causal relationship.17 DEATHS DUE TO SUICIDE, 2004-2016 DENVER U.S. Substance Use 20 AGE-ADJUSTED MORTALITY RATE A significant number of Americans who experience PER 100,000 PEOPLE mental illness also struggle with co-occurring drug or 15 alcohol dependency. In 2016, 18.5% of American adults with mental illness met the criteria for a substance use disorder, as compared to 5.4% of adults without mental 10 illness.18 5 Premature Death 0 4 6 9 5 07 8 10 14 16 15 12 11 0 0 0 0 0 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 Depression is associated with a 50% increased risk of mortality from all causes.19 People with persistent and severe mental illness die an average of 10 years earlier Source: Colorado Violent Death Reporting System than people without mental illness. 20 14
The Impact of Untreated Depression on Families and Communities Children’s Health Colorado data reveal that children who have a parent with depression are more than twice as likely as other children to experience overall poor mental health, need mental health care, and receive a mental health diagnosis. At the same time, children who have a parent with depression are also less likely to access needed mental health care. 23 In addition, untreated depression during pregnancy can impact the developing fetus, resulting in physiological, behavioral, hormonal, and cognitive effects. 24 Depression also interferes with parenting practices after birth. Mothers experiencing depression are less likely to start or maintain breastfeeding, use age appropriate well child visits, or engage in interactive play with their infants, all of which have the potential to impact child health and development. 25 Maternal depression is also associated with detrimental outcomes for children, including lower performance on cognitive, emotional, and behavioral assessments and increased risk for mental health problems later in life. 26 Educational Attainment “If we can enhance the well-being of patients that we are working with in our community, Depression is significantly related to educational attainment. Children and youth who have depression and we are not only going to see an improvement in other mental health conditions have an increased risk of family relationships and interactions with people in not completing high school. 27,28 the work place but also in physical health outcomes, because people might be more invested and Workplace engaged in taking care of themselves.” CAITLIN HERNANDEZ, PH.D. Approximately 88% of people with severe depression BEHAVIORAL HEALTH CONSULTANT indicate that they have experienced some level of functional impairment as a result of their symptoms, and 43% report having experienced serious difficulties with work, home, or social activities. 29 Companies that put resources into supporting the mental health of employees with depression can expect a significant return on their investment related to reduced absences and increased productivity. 30 15 DENVERPUBLICHEALTH.ORG
DEPRESSION IN DENVER: THROUGH THE LIFESPAN SECTION FOUR Key Contributors A variety of factors are involved in the development of depression, including brain chemistry, hormonal changes, genetics, and the presence of other chronic health conditions. Across the lifespan, a person’s mental health status is also greatly impacted by their social, economic, and environmental circumstances. Social inequities are associated with an increased risk of depression and other mental illnesses.31 Experiences of psychological trauma and chronic stress also increase vulnerability for the development of depression, particularly in the absence of healthy relationships and other factors that contribute to one’s ability to cope with adversity.32,33 SOCIAL DETERMINANTS OF HEALTH refer to social, economic, and environmental conditions that impact “A lot of [our patients] require case management because they health outcomes. These conditions are shaped by the distribution of need access to food, they need cheaper housing – that’s a big wealth, power, and resources and as one that’s been coming up – they don’t have a place to live or such, social determinants of health they live in an unsafe place because they don’t have means to go find anywhere often contribute to social inequities. Examples of social determinants else to live…they have all of these other things that really do require immediate of health include income, housing, assistance, so mental health is kind of way at the end.” food security, living conditions, social support, social inclusion, and CLAUDIA MURO | MENTAL HEALTH CLINICAL SUPERVISOR immigration status. PSYCHOLOGICAL TRAUMA is an emotional response to an “event, series of events, or set of circumstances that is experienced KEY CONTRIBUTORS TO DEPRESSION by an individual as physically or emotionally harmful or life threatening and that has lasting PARENTAL adverse effects on the individual’s HEALTH MENTAL functioning and mental, physical, STATUS HEALTH STATUS social, emotional, or spiritual well- being.”34 Witnessing community violence (such as mass shootings, bullying, or gang activity), being the SOCIAL, ECONOMIC, BRAIN AND ENVIRONMENTAL victim of sexual or physical abuse, CHEMISTRY natural disasters, and war or political CONDITIONS violence are examples of events or circumstances that can lead to psychological trauma. ABSENCE OF HEALTHY PSYCHOLOGICAL CHRONIC STRESS is associated RELATIONSHIPS TRAUMA with ongoing, stressful conditions & OTHER FACTORS that lack discrete beginnings and THAT CONTRIBUTE TO endings, such as those associated RESILIENCE with psychological trauma or social determinants of health. GENETICS CHRONIC STRESS 16
SECTION FIVE Specific Populations A number of groups are disproportionately impacted by depression and/or underserved by existing treatment services in Denver.35 An understanding of trauma, chronic stress, and social determinants of health as significant contributors to depression can provide critical context for understanding identified differences in depression rates and treatment access among each of these groups. Men Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Compared to women, men experience higher rates of substance use and overdose. 36 They are also Transgender, and Queer disproportionately impacted by suicide, with men representing 76% of Denver suicide-related deaths (LGBTQ) between 2004-2016. 37 These differences suggest high Youth and adults who identify as LGBT are more likely rates of undiagnosed and untreated depression among than other people to experience depression, poor mental men. The under-diagnosis of depression among men may health, and substance abuse.41,42 “Homosexuality” was be perpetuated by lower rates of healthcare utilization and labeled as a disease within the Diagnostic and Statistical the use of screening tools that do not accurately identify Manual (DSM) until 1973 and within the International the depressive symptoms most frequently experienced Classification of Diseases (ICD) until 1990. This resulted by men, such as anger and aggression. 38 Men are also in stigmatization and a focus on “treating homosexuality,” overrepresented within other groups of people that are rather than working to address the mental health needs disproportionately impacted by depression, accounting for of LGBTQ patient populations. Many treatment providers 75% of those who experience chronic homelessness and lack training in caring for LGBTQ patients, and care 80% of those arrested for all violent crimes. 39,40 settings may not meet their needs. 76% MEN REPRESENT 76% OF DENVER SUICIDE-RELATED DEATHS BETWEEN 2004-2016 Source: Colorado Violent Death Reporting System 17 DENVERPUBLICHEALTH.ORG
DEPRESSION IN DENVER: THROUGH THE LIFESPAN Communities of Color People Involved with the Most communities of color experience rates of depression that are similar to those seen within majority populations. Justice System However, these communities bear a disproportionately Among people who are or have been involved with the high disability burden associated with mental illness. This criminal justice system in Colorado, 25% have a serious is likely indicative of differences in disease trajectory and mental illness, and 80% have an addiction disorder.45 severity, as well as disparities in treatment access and Former prison inmates are at a particularly high risk for barriers related to biases and cultural differences between death in the weeks following their release from prison, patients and clinicians.43 These comparably poor mental with drug overdose and suicide among the leading causes health outcomes may also be driven by the historical of demise during this time period. This reveals a need to adversity experienced by many communities of color provide sustained physical and mental health care upon “If we are going to help the community, we have to help everybody. If we do so, then I think that [individuals who are justice-involved] will be less likely to return to jail. They will be more likely to comply with parole, probation, substance abuse treatment, and mental health counseling.” CINZIA AYITE | CASE COORDINATOR in the United States; race-based exclusion from health, release from prison.46 In addition, parental imprisonment educational, social, and economic resources has led to increases the risk of depression among children, and socioeconomic disparities that are, in turn, linked to paternal imprisonment increases the risk of depression mental health.44 among female partners. 47,48 AMONG PEOPLE WHO ARE HAVE AN 25 80 OR HAVE BEEN INVOLVED WITH THE CRIMINAL JUSTICE % HAVE A SERIOUS MENTAL ILLNESS % ADDICTION DISORDER SYSTEM IN COLORADO: Source: Colorado Criminal Justice Reform Coalition Pregnant Women As noted and expanded upon previously within this report, between 14-23% of women will struggle with symptoms of depression during pregnancy, in contrast to just 5% of all women of reproductive age.49, 50, 51 18
People Experiencing Uninsured/ Homelessness Underinsured Mental illness increases a person’s likelihood of Mental health providers in the Denver area have noted a experiencing homelessness. Approximately 19% of persistent coverage gap for people who are not eligible Coloradans who experience chronic homelessness have a for Medicaid but who cannot afford the costs associated severe mental illness.52 Mental illness may be exacerbated with purchasing or utilizing private insurance. 57 by chronic stressors related to homelessness, such as exposure to the elements and heightened risk of violence.53 Immigrants & First Responders Refugees As people who are trained and designated to respond in an emergency, first responders are typically among Rates of depression and other mental health conditions the first present at trauma sites and often the first to are elevated among some immigrant and refugee attend to the victims. A 2017 survey of 2,000 U.S. adults populations, particularly those who have been exposed who are employed as firefighters, police officers, EMT/ to war, violence, or torture, as well as those who have paramedics, and nurses revealed that as many as 85% experienced forced migration, exile, or uncertainty of first responders have experienced symptoms related regarding their legal status. Recognizing and treating to mental health issues, and approximately 34% have mental health conditions among immigrants and refugees received a formal diagnosis of a mental health disorder, can pose a challenge for healthcare providers, due to such as depression. 58 These prevalence rates are differences in language and culture that may impact understood to be notably higher than those reported communication and presentation of symptoms. 54 In within the general population. 59 In Colorado, suicide is the addition, Denver-area health clinics have recently leading occupational cause of death among emergency experienced an average 17% decrease in appointments responders, and leadership within emergency responder made by members of immigrant and refugee communities, departments report significant challenges to maintaining 19% increase in “no-show” rates, and 20% increase mental health of first responders. These challenges in mental health resource inquiries stemming from include persistent stigma about admitting “weakness,” persecution-related stress. 55 This may be related to the inadequate funding and training to provide ongoing “chilling effect” that has been observed nationally, wherein support within departments, and a lack of treatment immigrants and refugees are becoming increasingly providers trained to address the trauma experienced by reluctant to seek healthcare due to fear of persecution. 56 first responders.60 19 DENVERPUBLICHEALTH.ORG
DEPRESSION IN DENVER: THROUGH THE LIFESPAN SECTION SIX Barriers to Mental Health Care People experiencing depression often fail to seek professional help, despite the existence of effective treatment. These treatment gaps are associated with barriers to accessing professional services, as well as low levels of professional help-seeking behavior among people with depression. This illustrates a need for both improved access and enhanced awareness of available resources. RELEVANT DATA COLORADO HEALTH ACCESS SURVEY | TELEPHONE SURVEY DATA What Barriers do Denver County Residents Face in Accessing Professional Services for Depression? In 2017, it is estimated that 12% of Denver County residents five years and older indicated that they had poor mental health (eight or more days of poor mental health) during the past 30 days. While some Denver County residents did talk about mental health with their general doctor or primary care provider (14%), or a mental health provider (18%), many Denver County residents did not receive the mental health care or counseling services they needed. Roughly 10% of Denver County residents five years and older indicated that they needed mental health care or counseling services but did not get it during the past 12 months. The reasons for why they did not get the needed mental health care or counseling services varies among this population, and can be seen in the table on the next page. 20
REASONS WHY THOSE INDICATING THEY NEEDED MENTAL HEALTH CARE OR COUNSELING SERVICES DIDN’T GET IT AT THE TIME DURING THE PAST 12 MONTHS CONCERNED ABOUT THE COST OF TREATMENT 65% DID NOT FEEL COMFORTABLE TALKING WITH A HEALTH PROFESSIONAL ABOUT THEIR PERSONAL PROBLEMS 38% CONCERNED ABOUT WHAT WOULD HAPPEN IF SOMEONE FOUND OUT THEY HAD A PROBLEM 33% HAD A HARD TIME GETTING AN APPOINTMENT 34% DID NOT THINK THEIR HEALTH INSURANCE WOULD COVER IT 50% DID NOT SEEK AN APPOINTMENT BECAUSE THEY WERE UNINSURED 85% Young people (19-29 years) were most concerned about cost of treatment (99%). Individuals who identified as non-Hispanic Black or Hispanic were twice as likely as non-Hispanic Whites to report that they were not comfortable talking with a health professional about their personal problems (51% and 62% vs. 26%, respectively). Women were more likely to not seek care as a result of concern about the cost of treatment or because they did not think their insurance would cover it. Men were more likely to feel uncomfortable talking with a health care provider about their problems and worried that someone might find out they have a problem. Source: Colorado Health Access Survey, 2017 What Other Factors May Prevent People from Seeking Care for Depression? Personal beliefs, attitudes, and experiences – as well as the beliefs, attitudes, and experiences of family members and other close relations – may impact whether or not a person seeks professional help for depression. These may be shaped by:61 BELIEFS THAT DEPRESSION AND HELP-SEEKING ARE DISCORDANT WITH ONE’S SELF- IDENTITY OR PERSONAL GOALS. STIGMATIZING ATTITUDES AND MESSAGES BY FAMILY AND FRIENDS ABOUT DEPRESSION AND HELP-SEEKING BEHAVIORS. RELIANCE ON ALTERNATIVE COPING STRATEGIES, INCLUDING NORMALIZATION OF SYMPTOMS AS EVERYDAY LIFE PROBLEMS. USE OF MALADAPTIVE COPING STRATEGIES, SUCH AS ALCOHOL OR OTHER DRUG USE. ATTITUDES AND BELIEFS ABOUT HEALTH CARE PROVIDERS AND EFFECTIVENESS OF TREATMENT OPTIONS. CULTURAL AND/OR LINGUISTIC APPROPRIATENESS OF AVAILABLE INTERVENTIONS. 21 21 DENVERPUBLICHEALTH.ORG
DEPRESSION IN DENVER: THROUGH THE LIFESPAN SECTION SEVEN Diagnosis and Treatment of Depression in Denver Effective treatments exist for depression, including numerous evidence-based options for counseling and several types of antidepressant medications. The earlier treatment begins, the more effective it is. Integrated care is a critical strategy for ensuring that people who are experiencing depression are promptly diagnosed and able to access timely and effective treatment services. What is Integrated Care? In an integrated care system, different types of health care providers work closely together to produce the best outcomes for people with multiple healthcare needs. Within the context of treating depression, integrated care occurs when mental health specialty and primary care providers collaborate to address both the physical and mental health needs of their patients. This can include bringing mental health care into a primary care setting, as well as bringing primary care to settings in which people receive mental health treatment. CHARACTERISTICS Function in the Communicate Collaborate, Have formal Have OF FULLY same space consistently at driven by a and informal professional INTEGRATED PRACTICES62 within the the system, team, shared concept meetings to roles and same facility as and individual of team care. support an cultures that Source: Substance one integrated levels. integrated blur and blend. Abuse and Mental system. model of care. Health Services Administration, 2013 Additionally, using patient navigation services to help patients identify and overcome barriers to care can enhance the degree of integrated care for people with depression and other mental health concerns.63 Patient navigators link patients with essential health and community services by facilitating communication between the patient and their care team and by providing health education, health coaching, advocacy, health assessment, and triage. Patient navigators may also provide and/or mobilize social support for patients. 22
Why Integrated Care? Physical and mental health problems often occur at the same time. Primary care providers manage care for a large percentage of people who are in treatment for depression and other mental health conditions, and an integrated care approach can enable them to collaborate with mental health specialists in the provision of this care. Additionally, the utilization of integrated care models can facilitate access to mental health treatment for people who would not otherwise seek or have access to mental health services, as well as primary care treatment for those who are currently in treatment for a chronic mental health condition. Almost 70% of people with poor mental health do not seek professional help or do so only from their primary care clinician, who may not be trained to assist them with mental health concerns.64 Moreover, 70% of Coloradans who were unable to access needed mental health services in the past year indicated that they had access to a primary care doctor during this time.65 The practice of integrated care may also have implications for suicide prevention; more than one-third of people who attempted suicide had seen a healthcare provider in the week prior to their attempt.66 Integrated care also holds promise as a cost-efficient model of care delivery. People with chronic medical and comorbid mental health or substance use disorder conditions can incur healthcare costs that are two to three times as high as those of individuals without these comorbidities. It is thought that a portion of this additional spending may be saved through effective care integration.67 ALMOST 70 % OF PEOPLE WITH POOR MENTAL HEALTH OF COLORADANS WHO WERE UNABLE TO ACCESS NEEDED MENTAL DO NOT SEEK PROFESSIONAL HELP OR DO SO ONLY FROM THEIR PRIMARY CARE CLINICIAN, WHO MAY NOT 70% HEALTH SERVICES IN THE PAST YEAR INDICATED THAT THEY HAD ACCESS TO A PRIMARY CARE DOCTOR DURING BE TRAINED TO ASSIST THEM WITH THIS TIME. MENTAL HEALTH CONCERNS Integrated Care in Denver INTEGRATED CARE PRACTICES integrated practice, as defined by WITHIN DENVER METRO AREA the Substance Abuse and Mental COMMUNITY HEALTH CENTERS Health Services Administration- Health Resources and Services Interviews conducted with 32 Administration Center for community health centers in Integrated Health Solution’s the Denver Metro Area revealed “[As navigators], we try to see Standard Framework for Levels of significant progress towards the Integrated Healthcare. if there is anything that we adoption of integrated care models in Denver.68 INTEGRATED CARE PRACTICES can help [patients] with like WITHIN COLORADO SIM PRACTICE giving them medication, • Approximately 80% of clinics SITES have a protocol for screening working along with their all patients for mental health Colorado’s State Innovation Model family doctor, or with the concerns on a regular basis. (SIM) provides support for mental health integration within hundreds psychologist. More and more, • Nearly two-thirds of clinics have a of primary care practices across the visit by visit, they come back workflow or processes to support state. Among Colorado SIM practices, a warm handoff in the event of a larger practices are more likely to to us. And they open up to us positive screen, wherein a primary be integrated. Rates of screening for and we find more ways to care provider can introduce a depression are higher among large patient to a mental health provider clinics, adult practices, and practices help them.” during the appointment. with greater percentages of patients on Medicaid or with no insurance.69 TOM CASSIO • Almost half of clinics reported PATIENT NAVIGATOR close or full collaboration, INTEGRATED CARE PRACTICES FOR indicating that they were PERINATAL POPULATIONS approaching or functioning as an 23 DENVERPUBLICHEALTH.ORG
DEPRESSION IN DENVER: THROUGH THE LIFESPAN Approximately 73% of Denver mothers depression appear to be higher within period.71 Regardless of whether a said they were asked if they felt Denver’s largest safety net health care mother was identified as depressed, down or depressed by a healthcare system, where 83% of mothers are 75% discussed what to do if depressed provider, either during the prenatal being screened for depression during during or after pregnancy with a or postpartum periods.70 Rates of pregnancy, and 92% of mothers are healthcare provider.72 screening for pregnancy-related screened during their postpartum Challenges to Integrated Care in Denver WITHIN COMMUNITY HEALTH CENTERS IN THE DENVER METRO AREA, HEALTH CARE PROVIDERS HAVE IDENTIFIED CHALLENGES TO INSTITUTIONALIZING SCREENING AND REFERRAL PROTOCOLS THAT INCLUDE:73 • Competing priorities for time. • Length of time from intake to treatment at community mental health centers. • Language and cultural barriers. • Barriers to sharing protected health information. • Staff capacity and training. • Lack of standardized screening and referral protocols • Lack of streamlined intake processes at community to support broad adoption of best practices. mental health centers. “A lot of people build relationships over time with their primary care doctor, and when they present [behavioral health providers] as [part of the] team and someone who can assist and support them, it plays down the stigma that something is wrong with you, that you’re diseased or bad, that it can’t be a part of your health care, that it’s something separate. I think having that integrated model really helps reduce stigma. It makes it just a normal part of your care.” KC LOMONACO, PSY.D. | LICENSED CLINICAL PSYCHOLOGIST COLORADO SIM PRACTICES HAVE ALSO NOTED SEVERAL CHALLENGES TO INTEGRATED CARE, INCLUDING:74 • Available funding does not fully meet the gaps left by non-billable services. • Challenges with attaining alternative payment models. • Barriers to information sharing. EFFORTS TO INSTITUTIONALIZE PREGNANCY-RELATED DEPRESSION SCREENING AND REFERRAL PRACTICES WITHIN DENVER’S LARGEST SAFETY NET HEALTH CARE SYSTEM HAVE EXPOSED NEEDS RELATED TO: • Culturally and linguistically appropriate screening instruments for populations speaking languages other than English and Spanish. • Destigmatizing depressive symptoms across racial and ethnic groups. • Education for providers regarding differences in screening outcomes, and the need to use clinical judgment in addition to screening results. 24
SECTION EIGHT Moving Forward to Support Positive Mental Health The information presented within this report has served to: establish the frequency of depression in Denver, as it presents throughout the lifespan; draw attention to key factors, critical disparities, and barriers to care; and provide an understanding of current integrated care practices in Denver. These findings can be used by health systems, policy makers, community-based organizations, researchers, employers, and community members to support positive mental health. Next Steps for Health Systems Incorporate processes for screening and referral. Identify and use screening instruments and referral processes that are appropriate for men, people of color, LGBTQ populations, and women who are pregnant or postpartum. Incorporate integrated care models. Incorporate patient navigation services. Incorporate innovative strategies to support patients during waiting periods for first therapy appointments. This may include offering psychoeducation, peer support, and/or tools to help clients gather data that will be useful for developing their treatment plan (e.g. mood trackers, etc.). Promote the use of counseling and support groups as a complementary or alternative strategy to prescription medication for treating depression. Raise awareness of mental health by sharing public awareness campaign materials. Examples of local public awareness campaigns include Let’s Talk (letstalkco.org) and Colorado’s Pregnancy-Related Depression Campaign (postpartum.net/colorado). 25 DENVERPUBLICHEALTH.ORG
DEPRESSION ININ DEPRESSION DENVER: DENVER:THROUGH THROUGHTHE THE LIFESPAN LIFESPAN Next Steps for Policy Makers SPOTLIGHT Address social determinants of health that contribute to and/or Denver’s School-Based exacerbate mental health issues, including economic instability and Health Centers’ Adolescent food and housing insecurity. Recognize the importance of infant Depression Care Model and early childhood mental health and social and emotional learning Denver’s School Based Health Centers (SBHCs) have utilized their for preventing future mental health Adolescent Depression Care Model since 2003. During the 2017-2018 concerns. school year, 521 children and adolescents received support under this Support policy approaches – such integrated care model. Program features include: as paid parental leave – that • Medical and mental health providers work in partnership to address support both parental mental depression in children and adolescents, with the medical provider health and children’s social and typically serving as the first point of contact. emotional learning. • Standardized screening tools are utilized to identify symptoms Incentivize the use of integrated of depression and support formulation of a working depression care models and include diagnosis. Following initial diagnosis, screenings are repeated opportunities for mental health monthly. promotion and prevention work. • Identified patients are typically seen by mental health providers on a Ensure adequate insurance weekly basis. coverage (across all payors) for evidence-based mental health • Medical providers provide ongoing, monthly follow-up treatment and services, without unnecessary support for those patients who choose not to participate in therapy. barriers. • SBHC medical providers are able to prescribe anti-depressant Ensure adequate, evidence-based medications when indicated. Psychiatrists are utilized for more mental health services within complex cases. correctional facilities, with support for careful transitions of care for • Patient progress is reviewed regularly at interdisciplinary clinic team people with identified mental health meetings. or substance abuse disorders. 26
Next Steps for Community- Based Organizations Raise awareness of mental health by sharing public awareness campaign materials. Examples of local public awareness campaigns include Let’s Talk (letstalkco. org) and Colorado’s Pregnancy Related Depression Campaign (postpartum.net/colorado). Support approaches that address parental mental health concerns while supporting children’s social and emotional learning. Address social determinants of health that contribute to and/or exacerbate mental health issues, including economic instability and food and housing insecurity. SPOTLIGHT Alma Program and Mindful Mood Balance for Moms (MMB) These programs employ new models for assisting women who are experiencing post-partum or prenatal depression, using peers (Alma) and online modules (MMB). For more information, visit: mentalhealthinnovation.org/portfolio-item/ alma/ and mentalhealthinnovation.org/portfolio-item/mmb- online-tool-for-moms. Next Steps for Researchers Evaluate associations between aspects of the built environment (parks, traffic, density, ambient noise) and depression. Evaluate the role of community connectedness and social support in depression outcomes. Evaluate patient outcomes and medical costs of integrated care models. Investigate reasons for the noted gap between the number of people who take prescription medications for depression and the number of people who engage in counseling or support groups. Evaluate the effect of early childhood support programs and subsequent risk of depression. Evaluate the interactions between drug and alcohol mis- use and depression. 27 DENVERPUBLICHEALTH.ORG
DEPRESSION IN DENVER: THROUGH THE LIFESPAN Next Steps for Employers Place mental health professionals at job sites to talk to workers about challenges they are experiencing and provide assistance in addressing stressors. SPOTLIGHT Create policies that support employees with mental illness, including systems to help employees in transitioning back to work after a medical leave. Executives Institute policies - such as paid parental leave - that support both parental mental health and children’s social and emotional learning. Partnering Ensure that all employee insurance plans offer adequate mental health coverage and that employees are aware of their ability to access mental to Invest health services through their insurance. in Children Offer opportunities for employees to participate in mental health awareness training – such as Mental Health First Aid (visit mhfaco.org for a schedule of (EPIC) available classes). Raise awareness of mental health by sharing public awareness campaign EPIC undertakes efforts to materials. Examples of local public awareness campaigns include Let’s Talk understand and promote (letstalkco.org) and Colorado’s Pregnancy Related Depression Campaign family-friendly workplace (postpartum.net/colorado). policies and practices that can support both children’s social and emotional learning and parental mental health. EPIC’s employer toolkits can be found here: coloradoepic. org/initiatives/fftoolkit. Next Steps for Community Members Complete a mental health awareness training – such as Mental Health First Aid (visit mhfaco.org for a schedule of available classes). Advocate on behalf of mental health issues, including increasing access to services. Contribute to community efforts that address social determinants of health. 28
You can also read