DAILY NEWS ARTICLES/EDITORIALS 06TH FEBRUARY 2021
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
Best IAS Coaching in Bangalore Daily News Articles/Editorials 06th February 2021
Shiksha IAS https://iasshiksha.com/daily-news-article/daily-news-articles-editorials-06th-february-2021/
DAILY NEWS ARTICLES/EDITORIALS 06TH FEBRUARY 2021
Posted on February 11, 2021 by admin
Page: 1
Best IAS Coaching in Bangalore Daily News Articles/Editorials 06th February 2021
Shiksha IAS https://iasshiksha.com/daily-news-article/daily-news-articles-editorials-06th-february-2021/
Beating down critical journalism, creative freedom.
The curious deference of the judiciary is part of the precariousness of the rights to freedom in
India today.
Context:
1. A young freelance journalist was arrested and charged with lacking appropriate media
credentials on the days of the Republic that trauma, points of entry into Delhi.
2. The curious deference of the judiciary is part of the precariousness of the rights to freedom
and creative freedom in India today.
3. The Some locations had lethal iron nails embedded into the road and trenches dug deep to
prevent the Journalist and ingress of farmers long encamped around the capital city.
About Media clampdown:
1. A few days after the riots, nine senior journalists were charged under the law of sedition, for
reporting the ambiguous circumstances of the sole fatality in the riots.
2. The Home Ministry decreed that only journalists with press credentials granted by the central
government could legitimately report on the farmers’ agitation.
3. A number of social media pages run by newspapers and websites were blocked by executive
order.
4. The legal process of securing injunctions began, along with an unsubtle threat that employees
of the social media company, Twitter, could face arrest for failure to comply.
5. The tragedy of a government that remains deaf to the anxieties of a significant section of Indian
citizens was transformed into farce.
Meaning of Sedition Law in India:
1. Section 124A of the Indian Penal Code deals with the offence of sedition. It lays down that,
2. Whoever by words, either spoken or written, or by signs, or by visible representation, or
otherwise, brings or attempts to bring into hatred or contempt, or excites or attempts to excite
disaffection towards, the Government established by law in India,
3. Parson shall be punished with imprisonment for life, to which fine may be added, or with
imprisonment which may extend to three years, to which fine may be added, or with fine”.
4. The Case in Devi Saran v/s State AIR 1954 Pat 254, the SC Court has held that Section 124A
imposes reasonable restriction on the interest of public order & therefore it is protected under
Article 19 (2) of the Constitution.
Freedom of the press in India:
Page: 2Best IAS Coaching in Bangalore Daily News Articles/Editorials 06th February 2021
Shiksha IAS https://iasshiksha.com/daily-news-article/daily-news-articles-editorials-06th-february-2021/
1. The rights of the press in India arise out of the freedom of speech and expression under Article
19(1)(a) of the Constitution.
2. The press has a variety of rights including the right to publish, right to circulate, right to receive
information, right to advertise, right to dissent, etc.
3. Some of the major laws related to mass media in India include the following: First Press
Regulations, Gagging Act, Indian Press Act, Vernacular Press Act, Official Secrets Act, Press
and Registration of Books Act, Sea Customs Act, Contempt of Court.
4. Media law covers an area of law which involves media of all types (TV, film, music, publishing,
advertising, internet & new media, etc.), and stretches over various legal fields, including but
not limited to corporate, finance, intellectual property, publicity and privacy.
5. Social media law India is regulated by the Information Technology Act which was enacted in
the year 2000 to regulate, control and deal with the issues arising out of the IT. Social
networking media is an within the meaning of Indian information technology act 2000
(IT Act 2000)
Restrictions on Freedom of Press in India:
1. The freedom of press comes within the ambit of freedom of speech & expression. In a
democracy, freedom of press is highly essential as it acts as a watchdog on the three organs of
a democracy viz. the legislature, the executive & the judiciary.
2. But, the freedom of press is not absolute in nature. It is subject to certain restrictions which are
mentioned in Article 19(2) of the Constitution. The following are the grounds of restrictions laid
down in Article 19(2) :
Sovereignty & Integrity of India
Security of the State
Friendly relations with Foreign States
Public Order
Decency or Morality
Contempt of Court
3. The grounds of ‘Public Order’ & ‘Friendly relations with Foreign States’ was added by the
Constitution (First Amendment) Act,1951.
4. While the ground of ‘Sovereignty & Integrity of India’ was added by the Constitution (Sixteenth
Amendment) Act, 1963.
Imperfections made worse:
1. The “rights to freedom” granted under Article 19of the Constitution: free speech, free
Page: 3Best IAS Coaching in Bangalore Daily News Articles/Editorials 06th February 2021
Shiksha IAS https://iasshiksha.com/daily-news-article/daily-news-articles-editorials-06th-february-2021/
movement, and peaceful assembly.
2. The Articles in the Fundamental Rights chapter, Article 19 includes a non obstante clause:
notwithstanding all its promises, each of the rights comes with certain conditions attached.
3. The First Amendment to the Constitution, when the government of a fledgling nation sought
to negotiate the fine line between freedom and necessity.
4. The matters of sedition, the first impulse of the judiciary in the afterglow of the Republic’s
emergence, were to strike the law down.
5. The Article13 of the Constitution annulled every law that was inconsistent with the
fundamental rights chapter and the Patna High Court was on solid ground when it held the
sedition clause in criminal law unconstitutional.
6. To possibilities of disorder, the Supreme Court reinstated the law, but held it applicable only
to “activities as would be intended to create disorder or disturbance of public peace by resort
to violence”.
7. The Gujarat High Court in 2012upheld this precedent in a matter involving the country’s
largest English language newspaper, The Times of India, after sedition charges brought by the
Commissioner of Police in Ahmadabad city.
8. The Court added that the Constitution protected strong commentary on “measures or acts of
the Government, or its agencies, so as to ameliorate the condition of the people or to secure
the cancellation or alteration of those acts by lawful means”.
Page: 4Best IAS Coaching in Bangalore Daily News Articles/Editorials 06th February 2021
Shiksha IAS https://iasshiksha.com/daily-news-article/daily-news-articles-editorials-06th-february-2021/
State’s new weapon:
1. He was charged with sedition and other offences, and the statutes invoked.
2. The Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act could potentially result in indefinite detention.
3. New weapon like IT Social networking media is a within the meaning of Indian information
technology act 2000 (IT Act 2000), also use.
Angle of religion:
1. The Politics of religious offence constitute another clear threat to freedom of speech and
expression.
2. The arrest of a stand-up comic, Munawar Faruqui, in Indore, for jokes that he did not crack,
represents a particular depth of absurdity. hearings in the Madhya Pradesh High Court.
3. The Rangarajan versus Jagjivan Ram case in 1989,the Supreme Court declined to embrace
a doctrine of censorship.
4. The benchmark for judging the potential for offence had to be a “reasonable” person and not
someone of “weak and vacillating” mind.
5. In the case of the TV serial, Tandav¸ whose producers and cast face charges despite multiple
apologies, The Court has now chosen to underline the conditional nature of the free speech
right.
Another blow:
1. The regulating the right to freedom of movement, the Supreme Court has encountered
unanticipated turbulence.
2. While hearing a petition seeking the dispersal of protests against the Citizenship (Amendment)
Act, the Court ruled that expressions of dissent should take place in “designated places only”.
3. In The ongoing farmers’ protests, the Court baulked,a ruling that the protests were
unconstitutional would have been the legal basis for a coercive dispersal of the farmers.
4. While The hearing a recent matter involving hate speech,the Chief Justice of India observed
that the Court is trying to discourage litigation under Article 32, which enables any citizen to
invoke the writ jurisdiction of the higher judiciary when fundamental rights are threatened.
Conclusion:
1. The Father of the Nation Mahatma Gandhi, "The role of journalism should be service. The
Press is a great power, but just as an unchained torrent of water submerges the whole
countryside and devastates crops, even so an uncontrolled pen serves but to destroy."
2. There are three pillars of a democracy the legislative, the executive & the judiciary. The press
acts as the fourth pillar of a democracy.The press has played many significant roles in
delivering justice, public welfare etc
Page: 5Best IAS Coaching in Bangalore Daily News Articles/Editorials 06th February 2021
Shiksha IAS https://iasshiksha.com/daily-news-article/daily-news-articles-editorials-06th-february-2021/
3. This ambivalence articles 32“that B.R. Ambedkar called the heart and soul of the
Constitution”, and the curious judicial deference to the political executive, is central parts of the
story of how precarious the rights to freedom are today.
A prisoner’s tragedy, a nation’s shame.
The Perarivalan case is an example of state agencies sacrificing the lives of those with a
‘peripheral role’ in a conspiracy.
Context:
1. It has been in prison for almost 30 years without proved for his role in the assassination of Rajiv
Gandhi during the 1991 election campaign.
2. The heart of the injustice being inflicted on Perarivalan is that government agencies have
continued to insist on his incarceration despite being unsure of his role.
Prolonged injustice
1. The charges of the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) against Perarivalan for TADA, were
upheld by the trial court along with the conspiracy to commit murder under IPC.
2. The course of many rounds of litigation, his conviction only for the conspiracy to commit
murder under the IPC has been sustained and he has served 30 years as part of his life
imprisonment sentence and his death sentence was commuted in February 2014.
3. While the confessions to a police officer are inadmissible as evidence under the Indian
Evidence Act to protect people from coerced police confessions,
4. The terrorism legislations such as TADA and POTA made confessions to the police admissible
as long as it was made to an officer not lower than the rank of Superintendent of Police.
Prisoner’s conditions in India:
1. NCRB 2019 data says there are 1350 functional jails in India, with a total capacity of approx. 4
Lakh prisoners but actual strength exceeds 4.78lakh. In that 4.3% are women and 69.05%
(approx. 3.3 lakh) were under trials and only 30.11% are convicted for crime.
2. Indian prisons face three long-standing structural constraints: overcrowding, thanks to a high
percentage of under trials in the prison population, understaffing and underfunding.
3. The inevitable outcome is sub-human living conditions, poor hygiene, and violent clashes
between the inmates and jail authorities.
4. Overcrowding, prolonged detention of under-trial prisoners, unsatisfactory living conditions,
lack of treatment programmes .
Page: 6Best IAS Coaching in Bangalore Daily News Articles/Editorials 06th February 2021
Shiksha IAS https://iasshiksha.com/daily-news-article/daily-news-articles-editorials-06th-february-2021/
5. Also allegations of indifferent and even inhuman approach of prison staff have repeatedly
attracted the attention of the critics over the years.
A suspect
‘confession’(justice delayed is justice denied):
1. The trail of this Case was damning until Mr. Thiagarajan came out in November 2013 and made
the startling revelation that he had not recorded Perarivalan’s ‘confession’ accurately.
2. It was a glaring omission that completely changed the nature of Perarivalan’s involvement. In
effect, Perarivalan was convicted based on a manipulated confession to a police officer.
3. We have a situation where there is an acknowledgment at the highest levels that the origins
and the making of the bomb remain unknown, and yet Perarivalan continues to be in prison for
purchasing batteries whose use remains a mystery.
4. Having served 30 years of life imprisonment for the conspiracy to murder, his effort to get a
remission under the Code Of Criminal Procedure was rejected by the Central Government in
April 2018.
5. On February 4, the Centre informed the Court that the Governor had finally considered
Perarivalan’s pardon and had decided that the President alone had the power to consider such
an application.
6. It is a shocking abdication of a constitutional duty and a blatantly unconstitutional manoeuvre
to ignore the advice of the State government, which the Governor is constitutionally bound to
Page: 7Best IAS Coaching in Bangalore Daily News Articles/Editorials 06th February 2021
Shiksha IAS https://iasshiksha.com/daily-news-article/daily-news-articles-editorials-06th-february-2021/
follow.
Life in jail
1. Perarivalan was 19 years old when he was imprisoned, and 30 years later is still fighting for his
freedom. In those 30 years,
2. In his book, He then asks us, who can ever give him back his life. We must ask ourselves why
Perarivalan continues to be incarcerated when we know that his confession was manipulated,
3. The government agencies themselves admit not knowing the origins of the bomb, and that
Perarivalan is not part of the investigations on the bomb.
4. It is our fear that releasing Perarivalan would be a collective admission of our failure.
Rights of Prisoner’s:
1. Cruel and Unusual Punishments.
2. Drawing and Quartering.
3. Sexual Harassment or Sex Crimes right.
4. Right to Complain About Prison Conditions and Access to the Courts.
5. Disabled Prisoners.
6. Medical and Mental Health Care.
7. Human Rights.
8. Discrimination
Amaitava Roy panel on prison reforms:
1. In 2018, the Supreme Court appointed this panel. The committee submitted its report on
February 2020 with major recommendations includes.
2. For overcrowding
1. Special fast-track courts should be set up to deal with petty offences.
2. Lawyers – prisoner’s ratio: there should be at least one lawyer for every 30 prisoners.
3. For Understaffing
1. The Supreme Court should pass directions to start the recruitment process against
vacancies
2. There should be use of video-conferencing for trial.
4. For Prisoners
1. Every new prisoner should be allowed a free phone call a day to his family members to
see him through his first week in jail.
2. Alternative punishments should be explored.
CONCLUSION:
1. Mahatma Gandhi advocates “Hate the Crime and Not the Criminal“ men are born equal and
Page: 8Best IAS Coaching in Bangalore Daily News Articles/Editorials 06th February 2021
Shiksha IAS https://iasshiksha.com/daily-news-article/daily-news-articles-editorials-06th-february-2021/
are endowed by their creator with some basic rights.
2. These rights are mainly right to life and liberty,but if any person doesn't comply with ethics of
the society then that person is deprived of these rights with proper punishment.
3. Many experts believe that the main objective of prisons is to bring the offenders back to the
mainstream of the society.
4. The Various workshops had been organized by the State Government in collaboration with
NGO's to bring reforms in the current prison systems.
Page: 9Best IAS Coaching in Bangalore Daily News Articles/Editorials 06th February 2021
Shiksha IAS https://iasshiksha.com/daily-news-article/daily-news-articles-editorials-06th-february-2021/
There are no comments yet.
Page: 10You can also read
