Captain Phillips and the Drivers of Piracy in East Africa and Somalia
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
Captain Phillips and the Drivers of Piracy in East Africa and... http://www.brookings.edu/blogs/africa-in-focus/posts/2013/1...
« Previous | Next »
Jessica Smith and Amadou Sy | October 18, 2013 2:18pm
Captain Phillips and the Drivers of Piracy in East
Africa and Somalia
For those headed to the theaters this weekend, you should check out “Captain Phillips” (which
was rated highly by Rotten Tomatoes in case you need more than our opinions and take on the
film). “Captain Phillips” is a Hollywood portrayal of the 2009 hijacking of the MV Maersk Alabama
by Somali pirates off of the coast of Somalia. While some media outlets have reported that the
movie unfairly left out the background of the Somalis who are drawn into piracy, there are several
allusions to a widely discussed Somali piracy narrative within the film.
The gist of the Somali pirate narrative alluded to in the movie is that the pirates are fisherman
who got their start combating overfishing and polluting in their waters. These fishermen originally
demanded fines, working as the unofficial “Somali Coast Guard” (also referenced in the movie),
from exploitative foreign commercial fishing vessels. However, this narrative of fishermen turning
to piracy because their waters are overexploited is often overstated and oversimplified. In fact,
according to the 2013 U.N. Transnational Organized Crime East Africa Threat Assessment, the
focus on commercial fishing vessels in the Gulf of Aden and the Somali Basin is actually on the
decline, rather the focus is on commercial vessels from countries willing to pay out ransom. In a
United Nations survey of 56 pirates, only 14 of them listed their former occupation as fisherman.
A bulk of respondents listed themselves as unemployed or employed in informal business
activities, such as khat sales and transportation. In the movie, Muse also bemoans his lack of
opportunities, and the pirates come across as young and desperate to succeed in getting a large
1 of 5 11/13/13 8:22 AMCaptain Phillips and the Drivers of Piracy in East Africa and... http://www.brookings.edu/blogs/africa-in-focus/posts/2013/1...
ransom payment.
Idealistic as the Somali pirates may have been initially, it becomes clear in the movie that by 2009
the original piracy motivations no longer applied. At the beginning of the film, the pirates are
roused from their village by men with guns who work for a kingpin. A sleepy eyed Muse, the
captain of the pirates who board the Maersk Alabama (played by Somalia born actor Barkhad
Abdi), is forced at gun point to assemble his pirate crew. In another instance, when asked by the
titular Captain Phillips, played by Tom Hanks, the pirates respond rather sarcastically that of
course they are all just fishermen. Thus, the movie presents a rather subtle and nuanced view of
the current scenario for piracy in East Africa.
Indeed, ransom payments are the main venture of real-life Somali pirates, unlike the small-scale
robberies of the initial Somali piracy narrative. Ransoms have increased in value from under a
million dollars on average per year in 2005 to an average payment of $5 million in 2011 (although
the average dropped in 2012 to $4 million). As mentioned repeatedly in the film, the hijackers are
rarely the sole profiteers from a hostage taking scenario. A band of pirates is usually headed by a
kingpin who organizes the mother ship and negotiators, who have higher education and can
command up to 5 percent of the payout. Pirate crews need to be nearly proportionate to crew
members on the commercial vessels being hijacked so the split generally has to be divided
between a lot of people. According to the United Nations, financiers of planned hijackings can
buy shares of attempts, and the typical cost of an attempt is about $50,000 dollars. Thus, the
payout needs to cover pirate crew, the kingpin’s costs, and the original outlay, as well a high
return to investors (investors typically claim at minimum 30 percent of the payout). The U.N.
argues that piracy in Somalia in the past garnered public support because of the perception of its
redistributive nature. However, this support has recently waned, hinting at the fact that
communities are not really seeing the benefits of piracy. As Somalia reconstructs and attracts
more legitimate business investors, there may be less support for an activity that increases risk
and negative perceptions of the business environment.
What Can Be Done about Piracy in Somalia and East Africa?
The number of successful pirate hijackings has dropped since November 2011 when over 40
successful attacks were recorded for that month alone. In comparison, in 2012 there were only
15 successful attacks off the East African coast, according to UN figures. The drop has been
attributed to increased private armed security on the part of commercial vessels and anti-piracy
taskforces from foreign governments, which have been supported by enforced prosecution of
hijackers. Maritime law before 2011 did not allow armed security on commercial vessels, but the
International Maritime Organization has since added it to its guidance on best management
practices for piracy for high risk areas. Although the situation has seen improvement, some pirate
2 of 5 11/13/13 8:22 AMCaptain Phillips and the Drivers of Piracy in East Africa and... http://www.brookings.edu/blogs/africa-in-focus/posts/2013/1...
groups have turned to inland hostage taking and hijacking attempts still continue.
There are three main potential methods to prevent piracy:
• Increase the costs of hijacking for pirate networks.
• Provide the people involved with alternative employment.
• Remove the kingpin and increase security to raise the costs of attempted hijackings for
the pirates, i.e. loss of life and imprisonment.
In terms of finding alternative employment, it may be tough to replace hijacking with a lucrative
option. As far as fishing goes, it is difficult to determine if it is still a viable option for the Somalis.
According to a UN FAO report from 2005, their fish stocks may be overexploited even though
there may be some opportunities for increased fishing of large, high-value fish, such as tuna and
mackerel. The UN Security Council reported in 2011 that fishery programs in Somalia are
generally neglected by NGOs and assistance programs. Thus, this is a largely untested
prevention mechanism.
Our Brookings colleague, Vanda Felbab-Brown, an expert on conflict, has pointed out that piracy
will continue unless the financiers and kingpin networks on land are dismantled. She has studied
piracy in the Strait of Malacca, which stretches between Malaysia and the Indonesian island of
Sumatra (and carries about 40 percent of global trade). The Malacca Strait area reduced piracy
by nearly 75 percent from the beginning of the 2000 to the end of the decade. Unfortunately, the
lessons learned from the experience in the Strait of Malacca might not be helpful for the East
African context. Felbab-Brown attributes this reduction to a concerted effort between Singapore,
Indonesia and Malaysia to increase security in their waters.
Somalia on the other hand has a very weak government compared to the countries that border
the Malacca Strait. The interdiction effort by the commercial vessels and their foreign
governments currently underway in the waters of East Africa seems to be working. However, this
may actually increase the threat of greater violence for hostages and patrol units because of the
use of armed guards on ships and the intensified counter response from pirates. Thus, East
Africa is faced with the long-term and difficult obstacles of strengthening governance in Somalia
as well as finding alternative livelihoods for pirates.
Perhaps the onus will be on the foreign governments and transport industry for the foreseeable
future. Fortunately, Belgian authorities have had some success in tearing apart the Somali kingpin
network this week with the capture of Mohamed Abdi Hassan; a kingpin similar to the boss of the
pirate captain Muse in “Captain Phillips.” The notorious kingpin was lured to Belgium with a fake
3 of 5 11/13/13 8:22 AMCaptain Phillips and the Drivers of Piracy in East Africa and... http://www.brookings.edu/blogs/africa-in-focus/posts/2013/1...
offer to serve as adviser to an upcoming documentary on Somali piracy, and was then arrested by
authorities when he showed up to the meeting. With such drama and continued obstacles in
preventing piracy in Somalia and East Africa, we may see another Hollywood movie about piracy
in the near future.
Jessica Smith
Research Analyst, Global Economy and Development, Africa Growth Initiative
Amadou Sy
Senior Fellow, Global Economy and Development, Africa Growth Initiative
@ASYBrookings
Amadou Sy is a senior fellow in the Africa Growth Initiative and currently serves as a member of the Editorial Board of
the Global Credit Review. His research focuses on banking, capital markets, and macroeconomics in Africa and
emerging markets.
More Posts from Amadou > | View Expert Page >
4 of 5 11/13/13 8:22 AMCaptain Phillips and the Drivers of Piracy in East Africa and... http://www.brookings.edu/blogs/africa-in-focus/posts/2013/1...
Comments for this thread are now closed.
2 comments ★ 0
Best Community Share ⤤ ⚙
Christopher Smith • 25 days ago
As a ship's captain frequently trading in the Gulf of Aden Area, I can vouch for the
authenticity of the marine and piracy scenes. In many respects they are terrifyingly
lifelike. Of course, being filmed on a ship and not in a studio makes a massive
difference to reality.
With the tragic events in Nairobi and East Africa over the last few weeks, the movie has
become especially topical and relevant. For more intuitive background to this sad part
of the world and the life of pirates and those sailing in the area, check out Amazon
Books/Kobo/B&N/iTunes Books - 'The Megiddo Revenge
5 • Share ›
Squarely Rooted • 13 days ago
As someone who is most definitely not a ship's captain trading in the Gulf of Aden Area,
but someone who does have an academic background in cinema, I ask, no, beg of you
- don't cite Rotten Tomatoes. It demeans us all. Use Metacritic if you must. Thank you.
• Share ›
ALSO ON AFRICA IN FOCUS WHAT'S THIS?
Will the Al-Bashir Regime in Sudan Creating Jobs for Kenya’s Youth: Is a
Survive Recent Pressures? Preferential Public Procurement …
1 comment • 12 days ago 3 comments • 9 days ago
Mboriundo Charles — We really sympathize peter njiraini — Thank you Rob for your
with the people of Sudan in this unfair and comment. Apart from the 30 per cent
inhuman economic … preferential procurement the …
✉ Subscribe d Add Disqus to your site
5 of 5 11/13/13 8:22 AMYou can also read
