AWARDS 2018 Shining the spotlight on excellence in insurance investment - Insurance Investment Exchange

Page created by Joshua Stewart
 
CONTINUE READING
AWARDS 2018 Shining the spotlight on excellence in insurance investment - Insurance Investment Exchange
AWARDS 2018

               Shining the
              spotlight on
                excellence
              in insurance
               investment
AWARDS 2018 Shining the spotlight on excellence in insurance investment - Insurance Investment Exchange
CONTENTS

                                                                             EDITOR’S LETTER
                                                                             Insurance investment skill has
                                                                             never been as critically important
                                                                             as in today’s challenging
03 Judges                               12	
                                           Best Overall Asset                environment for insurers.
04 Overview                                Manager: Aviva Investors            The Insurance Investment
06	Outstanding Contribution:           	
                                         Most Innovative                     Exchange Awards 2018 are
     David Astor                             Investment Solution             an important reminder of just
07	Rising Star: Daniel Blamont,             of the Year:                    how important investment
     Phoenix Group                           Natixis Investment Managers     performance is to the modern
08	Best General Insurer:               14	 Best Fixed Income               insurance industry. This year, we
     AIG                                     Asset Manager: Conning          also introduced personal awards
	
 Best Small Insurer:                    	   Best Multi-Asset Manager:       for those individuals and teams
     Canopius                                                                who have raised the bar and
                                             Insight Investment
                                                                             deserve recognition.
09	Best Annuity Provider               15	Best Client Service:
                                                                                We thank all the firms who
   Insurer:                                  Columbia Threadneedle
                                                                             entered the awards and the judges
   Rothesay Life                             Investments
                                                                             who diligently sifted through so
	 Best Life/Health Insurer:            	   Best Alternatives
                                                                             many entries. We had a strong field
   Vitality                                  Asset Manager:                  of candidates and to be shortlisted
10	
   Best Insurer Investment                   Aviva Investors                 was a notable achievement.
   Team:                                16	 Diversity Initiative               A special congratulations
   The Phoenix Group                         of the Year: Columbia           to all the winners and highly
11	
   Capital Efficiency Initiative             Threadneedle                    commended firms – you can
   of the Year:                         	   Adviser of the Year:            wear your badges with pride. The
   LV=                                       Ernst & Young                   excellence on display this year
	 Best Reinsurer:                      18 Technology Firm                  shows the community is stepping
   Swiss Re                                  of the Year: MSCI               up to the plate to meet the many
                                                                             challenges insurers face.
Contact us                                                                      We wish you all the best for
                                                                             the investment battlefield in the
John Townley                           Dr Bob Swarup                         coming months, and look forward
Tel: 07770 392365                      Tel: 07801 552755                     to honouring new victors in 2019.
Email: john.townley@insurance          Email: bob.swarup@insurance
investmentexchange.com                 investmentexchange.com                Bob Swarup, co-founder, Insurance
                                                                             Investment Exchange

2   Insurance Investment Exchange Awards 2017                              www.insuranceinvestmentexchange.com
AWARDS 2018 Shining the spotlight on excellence in insurance investment - Insurance Investment Exchange
JUDGES

                       We would like to thank all our judges for giving
                       their valuable time and sharing their experience
                               to pick some truly worthy winners

                  T
                       he judges for the 2018      Norman Peard
                       Insurance Investment        Senior insurance and investment
                       Exchange Awards were:       banking professional and actuary.

                  Bob Swarup                       Stephen Riley
                  Co-founder, Insurance            Experienced insurance
                  Investment Exchange              and reinsurance company
                                                   executive and director
                  Mary Boyle
                  Independent investment           Barry Smith
                  consultant                       Former CEO, Ageas

                  Bridget Gardiner                 Eric Vynckier
                  Executive director,              Board member, Forrester
                  The Brokerage Citylink           Friendly Society, and former
                                                   CIO at Alliance Bernstein
                  Rob Groves
                  CIO, Pension Insurance           David Worsfold
                  Corporation, and former CIO at   Contributing editor, Insurance
                  Friends Life Group               Investment Exchange

www.insuranceinvestmentexchange.com                         Insurance Investment Exchange Awards 2018   3
AWARDS 2018 Shining the spotlight on excellence in insurance investment - Insurance Investment Exchange
OVERVIEW

    Solving the investment
           equation
    As the investment landscape grows more complex and the base business model
    comes under strain, insurers and their investment teams face balancing myriad
                  pressures to deliver the returns demanded of them
                                                   Bob Swarup

I
  n quantum cosmology, the
  Lagrangian equation is a popular
  technique that combines the
function at the heart of some
deep-rooted existential problem
with all of its myriad constraints
into one single complex equation.
By doing so, the hope is that one
can begin to reflect the irritating
contours of reality and if not solve,
then at least optimise to make
progress towards an answer.
   This is not a treatise on arcane
mathematica, but the feeling
must feel familiar to insurance
investors everywhere.                   are few and far in between, and         have to tackle a three-
   The problem is simple enough:        the textbooks forgot to include         dimensional problem of
how to generate returns today.          the chapter on organisational           risk, return and regulatory
   The solution is something            politics and bureaucracy.               capital. That has become
different entirely. In an ideal            In more normal circumstances,        increasingly complex in
world, risk is a mathematical           not all of these constraints apply      recent years.
number, there is a bond for             and investing is a less fraught             On the one hand, there is new
every cashflow, and yield is not        activity. But we live in a far from     regulation in the form of Solvency
a problem.                              normal world today, and the             II, which increased the demands
   In the real world, however,          question of how to invest in the        on insurers’ resources and the
uncertainty swamps risk,                here and now is a tough one.            scrutiny of their decisions. Some
cashflows don’t line up neatly             Line up the constraints and the      elements of it are prescriptive,
and yield is the problem that           investment Lagrangian today is          others less so. But it has forced
bedevils us all. Then, there are        formidable for insurers.                the community to look deeper
the strictures and demands of                                                   into its investment decisions
regulation, of actuaries and of         A complex landscape                     and map out the risks in more
stakeholders. Economic risk and         While the rest of the investment        detail than ever, whilst also
regulatory capital diverge, cash        community ponders the trade-off         holding more capital back for
is a problem, the assets that work      between risk and return, insurers       possible losses.

4   Insurance Investment Exchange Awards 2018                                 www.insuranceinvestmentexchange.com
AWARDS 2018 Shining the spotlight on excellence in insurance investment - Insurance Investment Exchange
OVERVIEW

    To blame Solvency II alone        stakeholders are demanding            markets as they align to new
for the woes of insurers today,       more – more yield, more capital       investor preferences.
however, would be unfair. What        efficiency and more returns to           This is a journey of opportunity
has really undone insurers has        shareholders.                         and peril. Necessity is the mother
been the confluence with the             In the absence of suitable         of innovation, and the past few
sustained low yield environment       assets, they have cast the net        years have seen plenty of that
of the last decade. The fact that     wider. We have moved into             across strategies, structures and
new regulation has exposed            different geographies, gone           modelling. That is encouraging
balance sheet volatility speaks       down the credit curve, sought out     and shows that as an industry, we
more to the uncertainty that          alternative investment strategies     are innovating to find answers to
exists more than ever today.          and private assets, and devised       once intractable problems.
    The insurance business model      new structures to optimise that          But there is also risk. These
is simple – collect premiums,         risk-return-capital tradeoff.         new assets and structures bring
invest said premiums in assets        Even equity – once anathaema          new risks and exposures. As the
with secure returns (preferably       – is making an appearance in          palette expands and the portfolio
contractual), pay out claims and      insurance portfolios.                 grows broader, there is also a
live off the margin. It’s a mantra       This is an explosion of            greater need to curate, to distil,
that has served the industry well     complexity that is also self-         to analyse and to understand.
for the best part of two centuries.   fuelling. Globally, public fixed      Above all, there is a need to be
    The problem is that today, the    income assets are approximately       vigilant and ensure that the hunt
premiums are still piling in and      some $100trn, with insurers           for yield and capital efficiency
the claims are still going out, but   making up a significant chunk         do not overcome a prudent
somewhere in the middle, the          of that. The areas they are           assessment of economic risk
factory line has broken down.         moving into are far smaller – for     and substance.
The assets just no longer exist       example, private debt is perhaps
in enough quantum. A strong           some $2trn today, of which only       Uncertainty vs volatility
underwriting environment might        a fraction ticks the boxes for        As talk moves from quantitative
mask this in better times, but that   insurers in terms of risk profile.    easing to tapering and tightening,
is not the case today.                That has also grown four-fold in      a clear divergence has appeared
    The assets that served insurers   the past three years, reflecting      between growing economic
well in better times – sovereigns     both an escalation in supply to       uncertainty and muted financial
and investment grade fixed            meet insatiable demand but            volatility. Financial markets
income – have seen yields fall,       also structural shifts in the wider   are ultimately yoked to the real
fall and then some to the point                                             economy and over the long run,
where they largely no longer                                                their behaviour must reflect
meet the return targets for           ‘The premiums                        underlying economic reality.
management or for shareholders.                                                 Either uncertainty must fall to
Cash is never an option, as the         are still piling                    match expectations or volatility
whole business model is about           in and the                          must rise to reflect the dilemmas
outperforming cash.                     claims are still                    facing policymakers today.
                                                                                Managing the insurance
Retooling the business model            going out but                       portfolio in this environment
The insurance investor’s problem        somewhere in                        is the challenge for the year
today is that they are being given      the middle the                      ahead. Meeting it and solving
increasing amounts of money                                                 this Lagrangian will require both
to invest precisely when they           factory line has                    independent thought and more
would like less, and whilst their       broken down’                        dialogue than ever. n

www.insuranceinvestmentexchange.com                                Insurance Investment Exchange Awards 2018   5
AWARDS 2018 Shining the spotlight on excellence in insurance investment - Insurance Investment Exchange
AWARD WINNER

David Astor
Outstanding Contribution               JUDGES’ COMMENTS

D
       avid Astor has had a            ‘David’s calm authority, deep knowledge and shrewd judgement have
       distinguished career in         been qualities he has brought to every position he has held. During the
       the insurance industry,         past 15 years in particular these have helped Hiscox negotiate a safe
in particular managing the             passage through turbulent times.’
investment portfolio of Hiscox
Insurance through a period
of growth and development.             our fund managers and other              “I congratulate them on the
This was also a period of              third-party providers.                foresight and enterprise they
unprecedented regulatory                  “I would like to thank John        had to establish the Insurance
change with the advent of              and Bob for creating a forum to       Investment Exchange, which
Solvency II.                           promote and stimulate debate and      is now an integral part of
   David recently retired as           interaction between us all.           the industry.” n
chief investment officer at
the insurer after more than
15 years in the role and his
contribution to the Hiscox
success story was acknowledged
by Hiscox Group chief executive
officer Bronek Masojada:
“I would like to thank David Astor
for his contribution to Hiscox
over the last 15 years, during
which he has overseen asset
growth from £0.6bn to £4.4bn
and delivered consistently
strong investment returns.
   “David has been a safe pair of
hands during periods of economic
uncertainty and a valued member
of our senior management team.”
   On receiving the award, the
ever-modest David Astor chose
to switch the spotlight away from
himself and on to the founders
of the Insurance Investment
Exchange, Bob Swarup and
John Townley.
   “In our business, managing
the assets well relies on a
successful collaboration with

6   Insurance Investment Exchange Awards 2018                             www.insuranceinvestmentexchange.com
AWARDS 2018 Shining the spotlight on excellence in insurance investment - Insurance Investment Exchange
AWARD WINNER

Daniel Blamont, Phoenix
Rising Star

D
      aniel Blamont has been
      head of investment strategy
      at Phoenix Group since 2012
and has established a reputation
for making bold decisions.
   He has been a key leader in the
restructuring of the investment
team and has helped refocus its
priorities, in particular through a
significant shift away from fixed
income assets to a developing a
diverse range of illiquid assets.
He has been instrumental in
Phoenix’s foray into alternative
credit, including infrastructure
debt, equity release mortgages
and commercial real estate debt.
   This boldness has made him an
in-demand presenter at specialist
conferences and market events
as well as a leading contributor to
industry and professional journals.
   Daniel has been at Phoenix since
2012. Prior to that he worked for
more than nine years in investment
banking, starting in fixed income
research at Deutsche Bank in
2002, moving to insurance and
pension structuring at Deutsche
Bank in 2006. Between 2010 and
2012 he was ALM structurer with
special focus on Scandinavia, UK
and The Netherlands in the context
                                      JUDGE’S COMMENT
of Solvency II at Credit Suisse.      ‘Daniel has had a major impact on Phoenix since he arrived in 2012.
   He graduated from King’s           He has made a series of significant changes to its investment strategy,
College London with a BSc             ensuring that its asset allocation is well-matched to its unique
in Mathematics and Management         book of business. He has become a major contributor to industry
and also holds an MSc in              events, prompting many senior investment managers to challenge
Financial Mathematics from            conventional wisdom.’
Warwick University. n

www.insuranceinvestmentexchange.com                                Insurance Investment Exchange Awards 2018    7
AWARDS 2018 Shining the spotlight on excellence in insurance investment - Insurance Investment Exchange
AWARD WINNERS

AIG
Best General Insurer                                                            JUDGE’S
                                                                                COMMENT

T
     he quiet consistency of AIG’s                                              ‘AIG has not had an easy time
     investment performance                                                     recently so to turn around
     through a turbulent year                                                   investment performance so
for the general insurance                                                       significantly against that back-
market made it the standout                                                     ground is a major achievement.
performer of the past 12 months.                                                In addition to being rocked by
This came off the back of some                                                  very heavy catastrophe losses
poor figures at the turn of                                                     that hit all major global insurers,
2015-16. A significant re-alloca-                                               in the UK there have been other
tion of assets ensured investment                                               major challenges for general
performance was a strong                                                        insurers, such as the slashing of
contributor to the overall recov-                                               the discount rate. It has been a
ery in underlying group perfor-                                                 question of holding one’s nerve
mance in the face of some major                                                 in investment departments and
corporate restructuring. n                                                      no-one has done that better
Highly Commended: Allianz                                                       than AIG.’

Canopius
Best Small Insurer                      performance tripled its contri-
                                        bution to the balance sheet of its

T
                                        main Lloyd’s syndicate 4444.
     urbulent market conditions,           Maintaining sufficient liquidity
     new ownership and a com-           to pay large claims while pro-
     plete overhaul of corporate        ducing an investment income
identity as Sompo Canopius              that caught the eye of market
became just Canopius did not            commentators is a significant
stop the specialty London Market        achievement and one that
insurer turning in a stellar invest-    made Canopius stand out among
ment performance in 2017. In            the London Market’s many
round numbers, investment               smaller insurers. n

JUDGE’S COMMENT
‘Investment performance went from steady to spectacular in 2017,
just as underwriting results turned nasty. It takes real skill, knowledge
and judgement to achieve such results against that background.’

8   Insurance Investment Exchange Awards 2018                                 www.insuranceinvestmentexchange.com
AWARDS 2018 Shining the spotlight on excellence in insurance investment - Insurance Investment Exchange
AWARD WINNERS

Rothesay Life
Best Annuity Provider                 JUDGE’S COMMENT

T
                                      ‘This is the standout performance among annuity providers. Focused,
      he annuity market has been      appropriate strategies have played their full part in enabling the com-
      tough in recent years with      pany to establish itself as a serious player in the annuity market.’
      returns and rates that are
unattractive to potential inves-
tors combining with government                                               a key ingredient in that success. It
reforms to fundamentally alter the                                           has a focus on mitigating financial
market’s dymanics.                                                           and longevity risk.
   Specialist provider Rothesay                                                 The company said: “This
Life has maintained a clear focus                                            award was hugely gratifying.
since its 2007 launch enabling it                                            For the second year in a row
to become a leading life insurer                                             we have been recognised
specialising in bulk annuities and                                           externally for our achievements in
other de-risking solutions for                                               providing innovative and secure
defined benefit pension schemes                                              insurance solutions for pension
and insurance companies, and its                                             schemes, insurance companies
investment performance has been                                              and policyholders.” n

Vitality
Best Life/Health Insurer              JUDGE’S COMMENT

O
      ne of the big success           ‘Vitality has not only grown in size and scope but has established a
      stories in the UK insurance     reputation for paying claims slightly ahead of market averages in
      sector during the past few      terms of speed and percentage of claims met in full. This requires great
years has been the way in which       confidence in the consistency of investment returns, which is precisely
Vitality has established itself       what it has enjoyed.’
as a major player in the health
insurance, income protection and
related markets.                      a consistent investment                Vitality’s risk profile. This has
   This successful growth             performance from a dynamic             also given the company a
has been underpinned by               portfolio that is well matched to      platform from which to launch
                                                                             a suite of investment products
‘Vitality has not only grown in size                                         into the UK.
 and scope but it has established                                               This growth has been
                                                                             supported by consistent,
 a reputation for paying claims                                              above-average returns from
 slightly ahead of market averages’                                          Vitality’s investment portfolio. n

www.insuranceinvestmentexchange.com                                Insurance Investment Exchange Awards 2018     9
AWARDS 2018 Shining the spotlight on excellence in insurance investment - Insurance Investment Exchange
AWARD WINNER

The Phoenix Group
Best Insurer
 Investment Team

I
   nsurance company investment
   departments are proud of
   their teamwork ethos and in
one of the tightest categories in
this year’s Insurance Investment
Exchange Awards it was the
Phoenix Group that led the
way as the Investment Team
of the Year.
   Phoenix’s Financial
Management Group
(FMG), has led the Phoenix
Group’s development and
implementation of the
shareholder investment strategy,
expanded the investment
capabilities of the group, been
instrumental in the group’s
successful M&A acquisitions of
Axa and Abbey Life and provided
ALM expertise, particularly in
terms of the Tier 2 USD bond
issuance in 2017.
   These achievements were
made possible through
collaboration with both internal
and external stakeholders,             risk-adjusted yield by investing       steps have been made in
including asset managers,              in illiquid private assets classes     the implementation of this
investment banks, consultants,         and creating bespoke mandates          strategy. This has seen Phoenix
industry peers and active              for public assets tailored to          Group’s holding of illiquid
dialogue with the regulators.          Phoenix requirements. Over the         assets quadruple. n
   The team is headed by               past 12-18 months, significant         Highly Commended: LV=
Scott Robertson with Daniel
Blamont, the winner of the new
Rising Star Award, as head of
                                       JUDGE’S COMMENT
investment strategy.                   ‘Big challenges faced and met by a great all round team approach. Have
   Scott and Daniel introduced an      slightly different pressures from other insurers but need to deliver and
investment strategy focused on         this entry shows that they do just that.’
improving the diversification and

10   Insurance Investment Exchange Awards 2018                              www.insuranceinvestmentexchange.com
AWARD WINNERS

LV=
Capital Efficiency                                                             without introducing excessive
                                                                               levels of counterparty risk.
Initiative of the Year
                                                                                   LV= developed a truly inno-

L
                                                                               vative reinsurance solution that
    V= has a £900m block of                                                    allowed it to achieve its objec-
    legacy with-profits deferred                                               tives of a 5% increase in Solvency
    annuity business with par-                                                 II capital cover ratio, reduced
ticular product features that,                                                 balance sheet volatilty and
combined with the low-yield envi-                                              reduced long-tailed risk exposure.
ronment and Solvency II regime,                                                    James Pratt, capital efficien-
led to a number of issues including                                            cy manager, said “It’s great to
large capital requirements,                                                    have external recognition of the
material balance sheet volatility                                              structure we designed.” n
from interest rates and an inability
to use the Matching Adjustment.
   The objective of its winning
                                        JUDGE’S COMMENT
capital initiative was to improve,      ‘Highly specialised but well thought through response to a very
at an acceptable cost, the quality,     technical problem. The speed of the project’s delivery from
quantity and stability of its capital   design to implementation is impressive.’

Swiss Re
Best Reinsurer                                                                 allocator. Its investment team
                                                                               adds value through activities that

A
                                                                               go well beyond the core mandate
       sset management sustain-                                                of managing Swiss Re’s assets.
       ability creates value for                                                  It acts as a ‘centre of excellence’
       Swiss Re and its sharehold-                                             for financial market expertise
ers by following a disciplined,                                                across the group. It is also a rec-
long-term-oriented investment                                                  ognised thought leader on sus-
approach and focusing on a                                                     tainable investment themes and
high-quality investment portfolio.                                             is highly engaged in the global
It enters markets strategically                                                policy and industry dialogue
through its flexible investment                                                around responsible investing and
platform and is well-positioned to                                             infrastructure financing. n
be a strong contributor to Swiss
Re’s financial performance, helping
minimise earnings volatility.
                                        JUDGE’S COMMENT
    Differentiation is pivotal to       ‘Swiss Re is consistent, rigorous and has a solid track record. It has
extending its role as a knowledge       always provided leadership to the whole industry on key topics.’
company and strategic asset

www.insuranceinvestmentexchange.com                                  Insurance Investment Exchange Awards 2018     11
AWARD WINNERS

Aviva Investors
Best Overall Asset                                                                 Portfolios are wholly struc-
                                                                                tured to meet specific goals. The
Manager
                                                                                duration objective, rating, sector

A
                                                                                allocation limits and discretion to
       viva Investors’ insurance                                                invest in private placements can
       heritage affords it a unique                                             be altered to meet client needs.
       understanding of the chal-                                                  In 2017, it heavily invested in
lenges and regulatory constraints                                               people with extensive insurance
faced by today’s insurers.                                                      asset management experience
   It works closely in partnership                                              and boosted its fixed income and
with clients to kill complexity and                                             alternatives strategies. n
bring transparency to core areas,                                               Highly Commended:
including fees, its investment                                                  Insight Investment
process and detailed reporting on
asset allocation.
   In the process, it aims to build
                                        JUDGE’S COMMENT
and maintain long-term relation-        ‘Comprehensive coverage of alternative asset classes as well as
ships and conducts its business         the long-term stable assets central to insurer portfolios. Aviva now
simply and with integrity.              appears to have a solid platform backed by first-class client service.’

Natixis
Most Innovative                                                                 solutions addressing major
                                                                                global environmental challenges
Investment Solution
                                                                                such as climate change, protec-
of the Year
                                                                                tion of landscapes, biodiversity,

T
                                                                                soil and marine resources.
      hrough its Mirova affiliate,                                                 It designs innovative ap-
      Natixis Investment Managers                                               proaches to financing sustain-
      has a dedicated focus on                                                  able projects, organisations
responsible investing with €9bn                                                 and businesses that conserve
in AUM.                                                                         the environment and improve
   With the ambition to allocate                                                people’s livelihoods, while being
more than €1bn to natural capital                                               commercially successful over
over the next five years, Mirova                                                the long term. n
brings together the requisite
strategic vision and expertise to
scale up this promising market.
                                        JUDGE’S COMMENT
   It serves institutional clients      ‘This is a bold innovation and deserves a lot of credit. It places
seeking market-level returns            Natixis right at the forefront of environmental investment.’
with high-impact investment

12   Insurance Investment Exchange Awards 2018                               www.insuranceinvestmentexchange.com
SPONSORED CONTENT
 Conning

 Dare to be different
                                               regulatory requirements. This is         as opposed to investing through
 Woody Bradford,                               particularly true for multinational      standalone investment depart-
 chairman and CEO at                           companies. While changing reg-           ments that seek incremental in-
 Conning, on keeping up                        ulatory and rating agency models         come. They must look at investment
 with the pace of change                       will likely have a profound impact       risk in the context of the overall en-

 I
                                               on investment strategies, regulato-      terprise risk of their companies.

‘‘        t is not the strongest or the most
          intelligent who will survive but
          those who can best manage
                                               ry changes generally lag more in-
                                               novative opportunities to address
                                               risk and return optimisation.
                                                                                        Survival instinct
                                                                                        How will investment departments
     change,” said Charles Darwin.                 The impact of these regulatory       be measured in terms of their per-
        The pace and magnitude of              changes may distort risk and return      formance? At the enterprise level,
     change in the investment envi-            metrics, and artificially increase de-   will a new purpose for investments
     ronment is remarkable, if not un-         mand for favoured asset categories.      be to diversify risk, in addition to
     precedented. This is of particular        Companies will need to be respon-        producing incremental income?
     concern for insurance executives          sive to regulatory requirements,            This could require more granu-
     responsible for managing capital          but differentiation will come from       lar integration into business goals,
     and investments and responding            being ahead of this curve.               perhaps at product or unit level, and
     to regulatory changes. Companies              Companies must be innovative         a more granular approach to both
     that can keep up with this pace of        in seeking new investment prod-          investing and measuring invest-
     change through innovative invest-         ucts and strategies that will im-        ment performance, supported by
     ment approaches will find a com-          prove the risk and return profile of     sophisticated modelling tools, big
     petitive advantage – others may           the firm. But they also need to con-     data, AI, and behavioral economics.
     fall by the wayside.                      sider the chance that investment         In addition, management incen-
                                               yields overall may remain de mini-       tives must support this approach.
     Break with convention                     mis for an extended period of time.         Darwin would agree that com-
     In order to innovate, insurance              Will barely beating a benchmark       panies that can innovate and adapt
     industry leaders need to question         that is close to zero support a          will develop an advantage over
     conventional wisdom and create a          sustainable business model and,          those who rely on conventional
     culture of innovation —past beliefs       if not, what innovative strategies       approaches to investing. Invest-
     may no longer be true in this new         make sense?                              ment risk is increasingly important
     investment environment. Will reg-             Insurance industry leaders will      in measuring overall enterprise
     ulatory and rating agency models          need to integrate investments more       performance, but will need to be
     continue to serve as an effective         fully into business performance,         applied at a more granular level to
     guide for appropriate capital levels                                               optimise product performance.
     and structure? Will investment            ‘COMPANIES WILL NEED                       Risk management may
     income continue to serve as a pri-        TO BE RESPONSIVE                         become increasingly critical, as the
     mary source of income in the insur-                                                importance of investment perfor-
                                               TO REGULATORY
     ance industry?                                                                     mance shifts to that of overall
        Executives need to understand
                                                 REQUIREMENTS, BUT                      risk management as an integral
     and articulate risk characteristics         DIFFERENTIATION WILL                   part of measuring business perfor-
     that recognise both internal busi-         COME FROM BEING                         mance in a complex and volatile
     ness requirements and expanding            AHEAD OF THIS CURVE’                    economic environment. n

     www.insuranceinvestmentexchange.com                                      Insurance Investment Exchange Awards 2018    13
AWARD WINNERS

Conning
Best Fixed Income                        JUDGE’S COMMENT
Asset Manager
                                         ‘Conning knows what its clients are looking for in this field and

C
                                         maintains a steady focus on delivery. A very good, all-round entry.’
      onning’s commitment
      to insurance expertise,
      investment performance                                                   fixed income and equity products
and research, and an unrivalled                                                as well as non-US dollar solutions
client service has allowed it to                                               for clients that operate in other or
develop customised solutions for                                               multiple currencies.
insurance investors. This formula                                                 As an insurance-focused
has evolved with the needs of the                                              manager, Conning has designed
industry, adding geographies,                                                  solutions around the unique needs
products and capabilities to                                                   of insurance companies – for
address the challenges of the                                                  sustainable, tax-efficient income,
insurance space.                                                               muted volatility and efficient use
   Conning has spent years de-                                                 of capital. n
veloping ‘non-core’ solutions for                                              Highly Commended:
clients, including various specialty                                           Insight Investment

Insight Investment
Best Multi-Asset Manager                                                          The strategy’s success led
                                                                               its multi-asset team’s total

M
                                                                               assets under management to
        ulti-asset investment has                                              grow from £5.3bn to £7.3bn,
        been a core part of Insight’s                                          over the 12 months to
        business for many years.                                               31 December 2017.
Its central philosophy is to provide                                              Insight believes its strategy has
solutions that help clients achieve                                            two key distinguishing features –
their goals with more controlled                                               combining market-based returns
volatility/higher levels of certainty.                                         with strategies that are less reliant
   Insight’s flagship multi-asset                                              on rising markets and dynamic
Broad Opportunities strategy has                                               asset allocation framework with
been running since 2004 and aims                                               wide ranges. n
to deliver a return of cash plus
4% pa (net of fees) over rolling
five-year periods with materially
                                         JUDGE’S COMMENT
lower volatility than equities.          ‘Good results and growth show that Insight is delivering a solution
Over the long term, it has               that clients value. Professional, transparent and comprehensive.’
exceeded this target.

14   Insurance Investment Exchange Awards 2018                              www.insuranceinvestmentexchange.com
AWARD WINNERS

Columbia Threadneedle
Best Client Service                       JUDGE’S COMMENT

C
                                          ‘Great client-focused service backed by solid technical expertise.
      olumbia Threadneedle                A flexible deployment of service solutions tailored to clients’ needs.’
      Investments strongly
      believes that at a time of
increasing complexity for the                                                    invested directly in its fund range,
insurance industry one size does                                                 across 15 asset classes.
not fit all. It offers a highly bespoke                                             Investment operations are
client relationship and service                                                  supported by a seamless servicing
management proposition, closely                                                  proposition whether clients
tailored to the evolving require-                                                operate their own internal asset
ments of individual institutional                                                manager or have outsourced their
and corporate clients.                                                           investment function. This service
   Its investment team manages                                                   offering provides comprehensive
£34bn of assets on behalf of eight                                               support to meet clients’ risk-man-
insurance entities, overseeing                                                   agement responsibilities and
over 160 segregated portfoli-                                                    regulatory obligations, however
os. A further 200 mandates are                                                   complex they are. n

Aviva Investors
Best Alternatives                         JUDGE’S COMMENT
Asset Manager

S
                                          ‘Excellent. Some real innovation backed by in-depth analytics, client
       ome of Aviva Investor’s            support. Ahead of the curve.’
       most innovative work has
       been in alternative income.
It now offers an integrated                                                      opportunities. The objective is
multi-asset platform that                                                        to seek assets able to generate
includes real estate finance,                                                    low-risk, long-dated, fixed or
infrastructure, private corporate                                                inflation-linked income, making
debt, structured finance and                                                     them particularly suitable for
unlevered infrastructure in                                                      cashflow-driven investing.
low-risk social infrastructure                                                      Material environmental, social
such as schools, hospitals and                                                   and governance (ESG) issues
low-carbon infrastructure.                                                       are integrated into its analysis
   It is one of the few asset                                                    and decision-making. n
managers with a broad platform                                                   Highly Commended:
monitoring the premia available,                                                 Alliance Bernstein and
looking for relative value                                                       Pemberton Capital Advisors

www.insuranceinvestmentexchange.com                                   Insurance Investment Exchange Awards 2018     15
AWARD WINNERS

Columbia Threadneedle
Diversity Initiative                                                              and personal development, and
                                                                                  linked to incentive rewards.
of the Year
                                                                                     It has already made materi-

C
                                                                                  al progress in achieving visible
     olumbia Threadneedle has                                                     change in gender balance. As
     embarked on the challenge                                                    at Dec ’17, 40% of the company
     of embedding genuine di-                                                     board, 40% of its regional execu-
versity deep into its culture. Its                                                tive committee and 27% of invest-
approach spans public advocacy,                                                   ment professionals are women,
education, training, recruitment                                                  compared with 33%, 29% and
practices, improved policies, flexi-                                              29%, respectively, in Dec ’16. n
ble working and transparency.                                                     Highly Commended:
   Employee performance is                                                        Dive in for Diversity Festival
measured against values of ‘client
focus’, ‘excellence’, ‘integrity’ and    JUDGE’S COMMENT
‘respect’. Diversity and inclusion
are part of the ‘respect’ dimension.     ‘A very impressive range of diversity initiatives. In particular, the level of
Performance in respect of these          female participation is way above the sector average. It was good to learn
values is reflected in appraisals        about their flexible working practices and youth-focused initiatives.’

Ernst & Young
Adviser of the Year                                                                  With in-depth advice on a range
                                                                                  of emerging issues, EY is at the

E
                                                                                  forefront of top-quality technical
     Y’s global network of insur-                                                 advice to insurance CIOs and
     ance and investment profes-                                                  their teams.
     sionals has provided guidance                                                   Ryan Allison,manager,
on pivotal areas in the industry.                                                 EMEIA insurance – risk and
   The team has consistently pro-                                                 actuarial services, says: “This
duced high quality thought lead-                                                  award has motivated the whole
ership materials and has contrib-                                                 team to continue working to a high
uted to the industry’s collective                                                 level in the hopes of continuing to
knowledge in areas such as avia-                                                  assist our clients to achieve their
tion finance, ground rents and the                                                vision and goals.” n
investor story in light of Brexit.
   In collaboration with the EY
Solvency II Pillar 1 team, it has also
                                         JUDGE’S COMMENT
shared insights on the latest PRA        ‘Tackling illiquid assets head on and resolving critical challenges for the
and EIOPA consultation papers            industry. Market-leading achievement across the most complex issues.’
that are shaping current thinking.

16   Insurance Investment Exchange Awards 2018                                 www.insuranceinvestmentexchange.com
SPONSORED CONTENT
Columbia Threadneedle

Gender agenda
                                        l Championing a diverse and inclu-      actively promoting shared parental
Columbia Threadneedle’s                 sive culture and demonstrating a        leave and encouraging male em-
drive to increase gender                commitment to diversity.                ployees to take advantage of it.
diversity in the industry is            l Increasing focus on pipeline          l Regularly hosting employee
reaping impressive results              development and engagement pro-         events with internal and external

W
                                        grammes.                                speakers showcasing successful,
              omen comprise just 9%     l Attracting female talent through      diverse role models to keep our
              of investment manag-      improved recruitment policies.          employees engaged on the diver-
              ers in the UK. Women      l Acting as an advocate and indus-      sity topic.
are just as capable as men when it      try ambassador for improved gen-
comes to fund management or ful-        der balance in asset management.        Measure of success
filling senior roles in business. Yet      Our senior management team           In our industry ‘what gets mea-
they continue to be significantly       together with our employee-led          sured gets done’, and we have made
outnumbered. This matters deeply.       Diversity & Inclusion Group have        good progress as a result of the
    At a time when individual in-       implemented initiatives that have       action plan. In the Counting Every
vestors face increasing challenges,     led to better representation of         Woman 2017 report by think tank
the investment industry needs a         women in senior positions and on        New Financial, Columbia Thread-
broad mix of experience, ideas and      the investment floor. We achieved       needle Investments came top of
opinions to help us understand          this through a combination of ad-       the asset management sector for
and deliver the financial outcomes      vocacy, training and improved pol-      women on executive commit-
our clients expect. Our industry is     icies around parental leave, flexible   tees (at 40% representation), and
missing out on a huge pool of talent    working and recruitment.                among the top five for board level
and resources.                                                                  representation (with 33%).
                                        Progress report                            We are committed to public
Diversity deliverables                  Concrete steps included:                advocacy and are proud to be a
We are pleased to have been select-     l Revising our recruitment poli-        leading voice in our industry. Back
ed for ‘Diversity Initiative of the     cies to ensure we have both male        in 2015, we were the first European
Year 2018’ at this year’s Insurance     and female representation on            asset manager to publicly disclose
Investment Exchange Awards, rec-        candidate lists in order to advance     our gender diversity data and have
ognising our efforts to proactively     more qualified women to the in-         published our progress data on our
cultivate a diverse workforce and       terview phase. For senior hires we      website ever since.
aiming to achieve equal gender          now have at least one woman on            “Asset managers have a real
representation at all levels.           the interview panel and we report       opportunity to drive diversity in
   We were equally proud to be one      on our recruitment progress quar-       financial services. We are proud
of seven founding signatories of the    terly across roles and departments      of our achievements in promoting
Women in Finance Charter in 2016        to the regional executive commit-       better gender diversity. But this is
and the first asset manager to sign.    tee. We also invest in unconscious      only a start. It is our responsibility
   To ensure that we achieve the        bias training for hiring managers.      to ensure the momentum contin-
targets we set, Columbia Thread-        l Taking a closer look at our flexi-    ues from here,” says Ishvinder Sian,
needle Investments adopted a gen-       ble working and reviewing our ma-       senior insurance relationship man-
der action plan built around four       ternity and paternity policies, and     ager and founding member of the
areas of focus:                         improving them as a result. We are      Diversity & Inclusion Group. n

www.insuranceinvestmentexchange.com                                   Insurance Investment Exchange Awards 2018     17
AWARD WINNER

MSCI
Technology Firm                          JUDGE’S COMMENT
 of the Year:
                                          ‘Analytical tools that drive efficiency are essential in today’s challenging

M
                                          market and MSCI has an impressive suite to meet client needs.’
         SCI’s multi-asset class
         analytics have been
         assisting insurers and                                                                                integrated into client workflows
their asset managers for over 40                                                                               and this has proved attractive. The
years. Through a combination                                                                                   powerful engine runs billions of
of advanced analytics, data and                                                                                calculations per day.
services, MSCI supports insurance                                                                                 MSCI’s best-in-class solutions
companies in calculating regulato-                                                                             have helped insurers turn chal-
ry capital and gaining insights into                                                                           lenges into opportunities as they
their portfolios.                                                                                              can source look-through to funds,
   Its ready-to-use, highly config-                                                                            model holdings using integrated
urable and scalable SaaS analytics                                                                             terms and conditions, and market
engine with built-in security                                                                                  data and access models for illiquid
master, market data and ASP                                                                                    assets like private real estate and
deployment, can be seamlessly                                                                                  syndicated (leveraged) loans. n

                                                                        ACTIVELY CONNECTING
                                                                           SUSTAINABILITY
                                                                          TO OPPORTUNITY

                                                                            A changing world creates opportunity.
                                                                            Mirova has embraced sustainable
                                                                            investments for over 30 years* — with
                                                                            the goal of creating value. See how you
                                                                            may benefit from their deep expertise
                                                                            in sustainable equity, green bonds, and
                                                                            alternative investments.
                                                                            Learn more at im.natixis.com

                                                  FOR PROFESSIONAL CLIENTS ONLY. * The 1st SRI fund was created in 1984 within Ostrum AM, the management firm of
                                           Mirova. Mirova is an affiliate of Natixis Investment Managers, the holding company of a diverse lineup of specialized investment
                                        management and distribution entities worldwide. In the UK: Provided by Natixis Investment Managers UK Limited (One Carter Lane,
                                        London, EC4V 5ER), which is authorised and regulated by the UK Financial Conduct Authority (register No. 190258). Mirova French
                                       Public Limited liability company with board of Directors. Regulated by AMF under n°GP 02-014 RCS Paris n°394 648 216. Registered
                                           Office: 59, Avenue Pierre Mendes France – 75013 - Paris. Mirova is a subsidiary of Ostrum Asset Management. ESGINT10-0518
UPCOMING IIE EVENTS

                                                       popularity as the mix of thought-
                                                       provoking presentations, panel
                                                       debates and specialist breakout
                                                       sessions strike the right chords
                    INSURANCE                          for the industry’s top investment
                                                       professionals.
                    INVESTMENT                            This year the Insurance
                                                       Investment Exchange has
                    EXCHANGE                           expanded its programme
                                                       of events with a series of

                  T
                                                       intimate breakfast roundtables
                        he Insurance Investment        complementing the quarterly
                        Exchange has expanded its      seminars that dive into specific
                        popular events programme       topics of interest in far more detail
                  for 2018.                            and allow for a fuller debate.
                     Over the last four years its         Our overarching theme is
                  quarterly half-day seminars          Waiting for Godot, a homage
                  have examined a wide range           to the seminal play by Samuel
                  of issues, focusing clearly on       Beckett, as we ponder where we
                  the key challenges facing chief      are in the current cycle and as we
                  investment officers, asset           wait – seemingly interminably
                  managers and their advisers.         – for what happens next, be it
                  These have grown steadily in         growth or crisis.

                    Register your interest now for forthcoming events with
                       events@insuranceinvestmentexchange.com

                                 Key upcoming highlights include:

                       Tues 12 June         Tues 18 September         Tues 27 November
                     New approaches            Enhancing                    A look
                    to asset allocation         returns                     ahead
                         and ALM               on capital                  to 2019
                      Half-day seminar       Half-day seminar          Half day seminar
                      8.45am - 1.30pm        8.45am - 1.30pm           8.45am - 1.30pm
                       Skinners’ Hall         Skinners’ Hall            Skinners’ Hall

                  You can find reports of recent seminars and roundtables at
                         www.insuranceinvestmentexchange.com

www.insuranceinvestmentexchange.com                             Insurance Investment Exchange Awards 2018   19
www.insuranceinvestmentexchange.com
You can also read