AN ENIGMATIC GIANT GEOSCIENCE DIPLOMACY IN NORTH KOREA - GEOSCIENTIST
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
T H E M A G A Z I N E O F T H E G E O L O G I C A L S O C I E T Y O F L O N D O N SPRING 2021 AN ENIGMATIC GIANT GEOSCIENCE DIPLOMACY IN NORTH KOREA TAKING THE BLACK IN DECOLONISING ALL THAT NEXT STEP GEOSCIENCE COLLECTIONS GLITTERS The pros and cons of Initiatives to Historical links Tales of fortunes post-doctoral research confront invisibility assessed made and lost
Editor’s welcome SPRING 2021 W elcome to the linked to our science first edition features. The magazine of the Geological Society of London of the We appreciate that new-look, quarterly some readers are The Geological Society Trustees of the Geological Geoscientist magazine. disappointed to lose the Burlington House Society of London We’ve had great fun monthly print issues and Piccadilly 2020-2021 putting the issue question whether they’ll London W1J 0BG Dr Michael Daly (President) together, working engage as much digitally T +44 (0)20 7434 9944 Mrs Joanna Alexander with our new publishers, James (p. 19). This was a difficult decision enquiries@geolsoc.org.uk Mr Thomas Backhouse Pembroke Media, and we hope you for us to make and was, of course, (Not for Editorial – Please Mr Andrew Bloodworth find it stimulating and entertaining. partly motivated by the need to contact the Editor) Mr John Booth (Vice This issue takes us from volcanic make financial savings. Likewise, President) peaks in enigmatic North Korea tough choices have had to be Publishing House Dr Jennie Gilbert (p. 22), to the Californian and made across the Society as we The Geological Society Dr Joel Gill (Secretary, Australian gold rushes of the 19th face a period of considerable Publishing House Foreign & External Affairs) Century (p. 40). It also touches uncertainty (p. 6). Unit 7 Mr Graham Goffey (Treasurer) on the critical issues of diversity, But there are also positive motives Brassmill Enterprise Centre Dr Kathryn Goodenough equality and inclusion, with reports behind the change. Many of you Brassmill Lane Prof James Griffiths and opinion pieces that highlight have written to us with questions Bath BA1 3JN (Secretary, Professional the immense and persistent about the sustainability of print, and T +44 (0)1225 445046 Matters) barriers faced by many, including some have chosen to opt out of print E sales@geolsoc.org.uk Dr Michael Kehinde Black (p. 30) and LBGTQ+ (p. 16) entirely, in favour of a digital offering. Prof Chris King geoscientists, as well as outlining We want to communicate afresh Library Mr Andrew Moore the actions we can all take to help in print and digitally and, in doing T +44 (0)20 7432 0999 Prof Bryne Ngwenya remove these barriers and make so, retire our outdated and poorly E library@geolsoc.org.uk Dr John Perry our community more inclusive. functioning website, which was Mr Nicholas Reynolds (Vice unloved and rarely used. EDITOR-IN-CHIEF: President) At a time when both Fellowship Prof. Andy Fleet Mrs Sarah Scott and geoscience student numbers DEPUTY EDITOR-IN-CHIEF: Ms Gemma Sherwood Geoscientist are in decline, it is essential to widen Mr David Shilston Miss Jessica Smith magazine will our reach, and we truly believe EDITORS: (Vice President) continue to serve that by focusing our efforts on Dr Amy Whitchurch Dr Helen Smyth both print and digital, we can place Ms Sarah Day Prof Robin Strachan as a welcoming and Geoscientist magazine – a showcase E geoscientist@geolsoc.org.uk (Secretary, Publications) inclusive forum for the activities of the Society and Dr Alexander Whittaker of geoscientists – into more hands. EDITORIAL ADVISORY (Secretary, Science) Those readers may be people who PANEL Mrs Lucy Williams It is no secret that diversity is an have not found us before, those Mrs Natalyn Ala Dr Keith Myers (co-opted issue both within the geoscience who perceive the Society as elitist Mr Steve Branch – Treasurer designate) community and in our Society. and outdated, or those who view the Dr Robin Cocks Change is slow, but the Society field of geoscience as simply dirty Dr Howard Falcon-Lang The Geological Society is taking steps to rectify this. For and polluting, rather than a key part Dr Hazel Gibson of London is a Registered example, Council recently asked of the journey towards net zero. Prof. Tony Harris Charity, number 210161. for an evaluation of the Society’s We hope that by providing a range Mr Edmund Nickless ISSN (print) 0961-5628 historical links to slavery and of options for accessing content, we Dr Alan Roberts ISSN (online) 2045-1784 colonialism, and our Archivist, will reach a more diverse audience, Prof. Peter Styles Caroline Lam, reports the findings and that Geoscientist magazine will Dr Colin Summerhayes Subscriptions: for non- on page 36. The research will be continue to serve as a welcoming Prof. Frances Wall member subscriptions, please used to determine Society policies and inclusive forum for both long- Dr Jan Zalasiewicz contact the Publishing House. and we will ensure that updates are term and new readers. provided in the future. Our new print and online offerings Cover image: Chonji (Heaven Lake) on the summit of Mount Paektu All of the articles in this issue are works in progress, and we would are available online, via our newly love to hear your thoughts and Geoscientist is published four times per year on behalf of launched and mobile-device suggestions – you can get in touch The Geological Society of London by friendly website www.Geoscientist. with us at geoscientist@geolsoc.org. www.jamespembrokemedia.co.uk Online. The site features additional uk or via Twitter @geoscientistmag. content, including more in-depth © 2021 The Geological Society of London reports and letters, as well as videos AMY WHITCHURCH, EDITOR GEOSCIENTIST.ONLINE | SPRING 2021 3
CONTENTS VOL . 31 | NO. 01 | SPRING 2021 12 30 3 UNEARTHED EDITOR’S WELCOME 42 LIFE AFTER PHD 6 The pros and cons of post-doctoral research NEWS Updates from the Society and the community 40 16 VIEWPOINT Safe and inclusive fieldwork, Reverse the decline, Black 36 underrepresentation in the minerals industry, Quarterly dismay and more… F E AT U R E S 22 WHERE SCIENCE AND DIPLOMACY MEET A unique collaboration provides 45 BOOKS & ARTS insights into Mount Paektu Latest recommendations from Fellows 30 WHERE ARE THE BL ACK GEOSCIENTISTS? 48 Grassroots initiatives to O B I T UA R I E S confront invisibility Norman John Snelling Peter George Fookes 36 50 DECOLONISING THE GEOLOGICAL SOCIET Y’S COUNCIL ELECTIONS COLLECTIONS All the information you need Assessing the Geological for the upcoming elections Society’s historical links to slavery and colonialism 54 FIVE MINUTES WITH…. 40 Kathryn Goodenough, Principal Geologist with the A L L T H AT G L I T T E R S Tales of fortunes made and lost BGS and Chief Editor of ES3 The Geological Society of London accepts no responsibility for the Every effort has been made to trace copyright holders of material All advertising material is expected to conform to ethical views expressed in any article in this publication. All views expressed, in this publication. If any rights have been omitted, the publisher and trading standards, and reasonable care is taken to ensure except where explicitly stated otherwise, represent those of the offers their apologies. that advertisers are reputable and reliable. However, inclusion author, and not the Geological Society of London. All rights reserved. in this publication or as an insert does not constitute a guarantee No responsibility is assumed by the Publisher for any injury or endorsement of the quality or value of such products or No paragraph of this publication may be reproduced, copied or and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products services, or of the claims made by its manufacturer. Geoscientist transmitted save with written permission. Users registered with liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation and the Geological Society of London can give no assurance Copyright Clearance Center: the Journal is registered with CCC, of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained that an advertiser will fulfil its obligation under 27 Congress Street, Salem, MA 01970, USA. in the material herein. all circumstances. GEOSCIENTIST.ONLINE | SPRING 2021 5
NEWS S O C I E T Y A N D CO M M U N I T Y U P D AT E S Society’s Burlington House tenure remains uncertain Steeply rising rent threatens our tenure at Burlington House. Two initiatives are underway to ensure a long, sustainable and relevant future for our Society, writes Richard Hughes, Executive Secretary IN LATE JANUARY 2021 the President, concessionary rent (as granted to Mike Daly, updated the Fellowship the Royal Academy of Arts > 150 years on behalf of Council on the situation ago); and regarding the Society’s future occupancy • The acquisition by the Society of of Burlington House. Fellows will be a long lease or virtual freehold aware that since then a public awareness arrangement either through purchase and political engagement campaign has or on the basis of a government grant The root cause been underway in an effort to persuade reflecting the considerable societal of the uncertainty Government to reconsider its position. In value of the LS. surrounding the Society’s parallel, a project has also begun to look at Communications with the landlord (the potential alternative options for the Society, Ministry of Housing, Communities and future occupancy of should it have to relocate. Local Government, MHCLG) continue. Burlington House A summary of the background to the However, an affordable solution that would is unaffordability situation is provided below. Further details allow the Society to remain at Burlington due to steeply are available at www.geolsoc.org.uk/ House for the long-term remains out of rising rents burlingtonhouse. reach. Discussions have led only to the The root cause of the uncertainty offer of a lease on the same terms as the surrounding the Society’s future occupancy current one, with a rate of rent increase of Burlington House is unaffordability due fixed at 8% per annum for the first five years rights to sub-let would be in the region to steeply rising rents. The Burlington of the term. To illustrate the effects of an of £17.6m. The landlord also ruled out House Learned Societies (the LS: the 8% annual rent increase, Burlington House- payment ‘in kind’, that is through transfer Geological Society, Royal Society of related costs in 2020 (excluding Covid title of collections. Chemistry, Royal Astronomical Society, impacts) total £570k, of which £217k is The Geological Society is self-financing Linnean Society, and the Society of rent. Total costs are forecast to increase to and a financially neutral outcome is Antiquaries) entered an arbitration process £710k in 2025 and £900k in 2030, the rent forecast for 2021. An 8% or greater with the landlord in 2014-15, and since components of which are £320k in 2025 escalation of our already significant annual then several avenues have been pursued to and £470k in 2030. rent will turn neutrality into an escalating secure our future at Burlington House on The enquiry into the purchase of a annual loss over the coming years. Despite an affordable long-term basis. The avenues long lease was rebuffed by the landlord, the current rent being approximately 1/3 of pursued by the LS include: who saw ‘no scope’ for entering the landlord’s targeted market rent levels, • Renegotiation of the current such discussions. It should the large footprint (almost 14,000 sq. unsatisfactory lease and rent escalation be noted that on the basis If you have a ft.) and substantial other facilities- formula; of recent valuations the query relating related costs mean that our to the lease, • The pursuit of a political solution that cost of a long lease for the please email occupation accounts for almost might provide for a long lease with Society’s premises with no burlingtonhouse@ 10% of the Society’s annual geolsoc.org.uk 6 GEOSCIENTIST | SPRING 2021
NEWS RENEWALS REMINDER RICHARD HUGHES, Executive Secretary, writes: I would like to remind Fellows who have not yet done so to renew their Fellowship for the current year. Non-renewal may result in the discontinuation of your Fellowship with the subsequent inconvenience of having to then re-apply. Moreover, late payments result in additional costs and administration for the Society. To continue your support, please renew your Fellowship today, preferably online via the website. Note that you now have the option of a monthly or quarterly Costly rent and falling revenues direct debit to spread your have put the Geological Society’s payments. If you wish to discuss future at Burlington House in doubt any aspect of your renewal, please call the Fellowship Department. income. In addition, the Society forecasts campaign to gain Government support falling revenues in the medium term due to to remain at Burlington House. Should MORE ONLINE a substantial Open Access-driven reduction Government be unwilling to re-consider Keep up-to-date with in publishing income. Falling Fellowship their stance we would seek their the latest news and discussion, and view numbers of between 1-3% per annum since assistance in supporting a move. additional geoscience-related 2017 are expected to continue, given the Council has directed the commencement reports, videos and more at reduction in the national oil industry and of two initiatives. Firstly, a public awareness www.Geoscientist.Online falling numbers of students choosing to and political engagement campaign, study Earth sciences. These challenges managed by www.april6.com. The primary have forced the Society, for the first time, objective of this campaign is to influence to reduce its staffing levels, in part through Her Majesty’s Government to achieve President’s a redundancy programme, to achieve a an equitable outcome that extends the Day Awards neutral out-turn in 2021. Society’s future at Burlington House on The Awards will be With no further realistic options available affordable rent terms and under a new presented on President’s for negotiation with the landlord, Council lease that gives the Society freedom to Day on 25 June 2021. discussed the situation in August 2020. pursue its strategic and business objectives. It is likely that some Three conclusions were forthcoming from Secondly, a project to examine the restrictions will be in the discussion: Society’s options for relocation from place in June, so we are 1. The escalating rents are an Burlington House began in January, chaired planning a virtual event. unsustainable burden on the Society’s by past-President David Shilston. Further updates on finances, and continued residence While many Fellows have a strong President’s Day will follow at Burlington House threatens its attachment to the building where the Society in newsletters and on the future existence. has enjoyed continuous occupation since website, so please keep 2. The time has come to face up to the 1874, a large number of Fellows feel little or an eye out. On the day, long-standing lease issue, with us no attachment to it. Whatever the outcome, talks will be given by some since 2005, and consider seriously the the Fellowship can be assured that Council of the senior medallists, options for alternative premises and is committed to seeking the best possible which Fellows will be able to attend virtually. our relocation. solution to guarantee a long, sustainable and 3. The Society should launch a final relevant future for our Society. GEOSCIENTIST.ONLINE | SPRING 2021 7
NEWS Fellowship categories TURN TO PAGE 50 Read the and benefits review project supporting statements from the nominees to be new Geological An in-depth review of the current fellowship categories, fee structure, and Society Council members membership benefits is underway, writes Richard Hughes, Executive Secretary not to adversely impact the Society’s overall The Society aims to attract and retain more members financial position, and its important policy, outreach, education, communications and advocacy work on behalf of the profession. Any new proposed fellowship categories, fees, and membership benefits will need the approval of the Society’s Professional & Chartership and Finance & Planning Committees before being considered by our governing Council in April 2021. Under the Society’s bye-laws, any proposals to change COUNCIL OUR CURRENT, largely age-based structure fees must also be approved at our Annual MEETINGS, is complex compared to other learned General Meeting, scheduled for late June OGMS AND societies/professional bodies, and seen 2021. Any changes will therefore not come by some as divisive and discriminatory. into effect until the 2022 renewal cycle, which AGM 2021 The Society needs a simpler, more will start in the autumn of 2021. The dates for appealing structure that enables it to more Fellows’ views were sought in an online meetings of Council successfully attract and retain members survey published in December 2020, and I and Ordinary General from all parts of our community, especially am very grateful to those who took the time Meetings are: underrepresented groups. Any new structure to respond. Further information will be made 7 April, 23 June, 22 September and will need to be broadly cost-neutral so as available before the Annual General Meeting. 24 November. The Annual General Meeting will be held Society Awards virtually on Friday The Society is delighted to announce the names of the winners of its medals 25 June, 11am – and funds and offers all its wholehearted congratulations. 12.30pm. The agenda NAME AFFILIATION AWARD and further details Prof David Pollard Stanford University Wollaston Medal of the arrangements Prof Nicholas White University of Cambridge Lyell Medal will be communicated Prof Graham Pearson University of Alberta Murchison Medal via our newsletters, Dr Phil Christie Schlumberger Cambridge Research William Smith Medal website and in the Prof Sanjeev Gupta Imperial College London Prestwich Medal summer issue of Prof Kenneth McCaffrey University of Durham Dewey Medal Geoscientist. Prof Chris Jackson Imperial College London Coke Medal For details on the Dr Helen Reeves Jacobs Coke Medal elections to Council, Dr Sheila Peacock Blacknest (AWE) Distinguished Service Award the list of continuing Dr Anjana Khatwa Wessex Museums, UK R H Worth Medal and retiring Council Prof Marie Edmonds University of Cambridge Bigsby Medal members, as well Dr Caroline Gill Shell U.K. Limited Aberconway Medal as the supporting Dr Emma Liu University College London Wollaston Fund statements for the Dr Luke Parry University of Oxford Lyell Fund President Designate Dr Andrew Thomson University College London Murchison Fund and Council nominees, Dr Fabian Wadworth University of Durham William Smith Fund please see story, facing Dr Finnigan Illsley-Kemp Victoria University of Wellington President’s Award page, and page 50. Dr Scarlett Jazmin President’s Award 8 GEOSCIENTIST | SPRING 2021
NEWS PLEASE NOTE ONLY FELLOWS ELECTIONS OF THE SOCIETY ARE ELIGIBLE TO VOTE TO COUNCIL 2021-2022 GEOSCIENTIST’S OCTOBER issue and subsequent email newsletters invited Fellows to nominate new members of Council to succeed those who will be retiring at the Annual General Meeting on 25 June 2021. One nomination was received for the post of President Designate and a further 14 nominations for the seven remaining vacancies. The process for the election of members of Council is set out at section 6 of the Bye-laws and the process for the election of President is set out at section 7. The preliminary ballot is in progress, the results of which will ballot pack. If you have not heard from It is important that Council is determine the list for the formal CES via email or post, or would prefer representative of the views and vote at this year’s Annual General to receive a postal ballot pack, or have diversity of all the Fellowship, so Meeting on Friday 25 June 2021. any other difficulties casting your Fellows are urged to participate As in past years, Civica Election vote, please contact Christina Marron in the preliminary ballot, which Services (CES) is administering this (christina.marron@geolsoc.org.uk) at will determine the list for the year’s Council ballot on behalf of the Society. formal vote at the Annual General the Society. CES is the UK’s leading The Council elections are your Meeting. The closing date for independent ballot services provider opportunity to choose who should voting, online or postal, is 23.59 on and has an extensive experience of serve on Council to best represent the Wednesday 31 March 2021. Postal overseeing ballots for a wide range interests of all Fellows and to shape the ballot forms must be sent to CES (not of organisations. future of the Society. Fellows may wish to the Society) and must arrive by In February, Fellows should have to make their choices having regard to Wednesday 31 March. received an email from CES with the area of expertise of the continuing Graham Goffey, Treasurer, is retiring instructions for how to vote online. and retiring members of Council that are from Council and Keith Myers was If you have not heard to date, please shown on the tables on page 53. Their co-opted by Council in April 2020 as check your spam emails before biographies are at www.geolsoc.org. Treasurer-designate. His nomination contacting the Society. Fellows uk/biographies. Council is particularly for election is endorsed by Council. for whom we do not have an email keen to strengthen representation from See page 50 for supporting statements address will have received a postal experienced academics. of the Council nominees. Queen’s New Year Honours List 2021 Dr Malcolm Butler, Chair of the UK Onshore Geophysical Library, was awarded an OBE for services to education, research and development, and Dr Alison Monaghan, Principal Geologist at the British Geological Survey was awarded an MBE for services to geology. The Society offers both our sincere congratulations. GEOSCIENTIST.ONLINE | SPRING 2021 9
A Special NEWS Publication celebrates female geologists The journal will engage early career researchers Special Publications launched The Geological Society’s Publishing House is happy to announce the publication of two new books in early 2021 Launch of Earth Science, Celebrating 100 Years of Female Systems and Society journal Fellowship of the Geological Society: Discovering Forgotten Histories Due to be published in March 2021, In January, the Geological Society officially launched its first fully this Special Publication celebrates the gold open access journal, Earth Science, Systems and Society centenary of the first female Fellows (ES3), writes David Boyt, Head of Editorial Development elected to the Society – 112 years after its formation. It presents the often- ES 3 COVERS the spectrum of Earth will be used to support a programme untold stories of pioneering women science, with a particular focus of discounts and waivers aimed at geoscientists from across the world who on interfacing, cross-disciplinary increasing access for those without navigated male-dominated academia research related to sustainability in funding. Standard APC discounts and learned societies, and it uncovers society. In addition to publishing are available for Fellows of the important female role models in the high-calibre research, the journal Geological Society and authors from history of science. aims to encourage inclusivity and developing countries. Available online at https:// diversity in publishing, engage As the Society’s first fully OA journal, sp.lyellcollection.org/online-first/506 directly with early career researchers, ES3 builds on the hybrid open-access and via the Special Publications series and embody principles of openness options available via the Society’s at www.geolsoc.org.uk/sp506. and transparency in science. existing journals and Special Publications The journal’s Chief Editor, Dr to provide authors with a dedicated Geoethics: Status and Future Kathryn Goodenough (British route to open-access publication, Perspectives Geological Survey; see ‘Five which aims to be compliant with This book is a significant step forward in minutes with…’, page 54), heads mandates from the key funders and the development of geoethical thinking, an international Editorial Board institutions, both now and in the future. its theoretical foundations and practical of researchers and professionals ES3 is owned and published by the applications. Geoethics is now ready to representing a broad range of subject Geological Society, using the systems be introduced outside the geoscience knowledge and experience. and services of Frontiers Media. community as a platform for global Under the journal’s open access • ES3 is live online and welcomes ethics, addressing anthropogenic (OA) publishing model, all accepted submissions at www.EScubed.org changes and the responsible interaction articles will be subject to an article • Authors can also choose to submit between humans and the Earth system. processing charge (APC), which work to one of the journal’s three live Available online at https:// supports the costs associated Special Issues, which include ‘Earth sp.lyellcollection.org/online-first/508 with publication. The Society has Sciences and the Race to Net Zero’. and via the Special Publications series established ES3 as a not-for-profit • For any queries, please contact: from April. publishing endeavour. Any surplus david.boyt@geolsoc.org.uk 10 GEOSCIENTIST | SPRING 2021
NEWS 2020 statement on climate change in the geological record The Geological Society has published an updated scientific statement, writes Alicia Newton, Director of Science & Communications jointly convened a panel of climate assessments. They also The paper reviews the evidence of climate change experts to review the Geological received questions raised by in the geological record Society’s existing statements Fellows following the Society’s and to create a revised version Annual General Meeting in that reflects the current state of 2019. This information was scientific research. The resulting distilled into a comprehensive paper is published in the Journal publication that documents four of the Geological Society (Lear billion years of Earth history, and et al. (2020) J. Geol. Soc. 178(1): explores how previous episodes jgs2020-239; https://doi. of greenhouse gas-induced org/10.1144/jgs2020-239). warming can inform our As part of their process, understanding of Earth’s future. THE GEOLOGICAL SOCIETY addendum in 2013. Because the expert panel reviewed A related conference will be published its first statement on this is a fast-moving field of nearly 200 peer-reviewed held 26-27 May. Visit www. the geological record of climate science, in 2018 the Society and publications, as well as white geolsoc.org.uk/05-GSL-Climate- change in 2010, followed by an the UK Paleoclimate Society papers and international Change for more information Image credit: Natashia Mattocks Mary Anning Fossil enthusiast Evie Swire sparked the campaign when she asked her Rocks campaign mother, ‘Why isn’t there a statue to Mary, Mummy?’ The Geological Society honours Mary Anning by supporting statue campaign THE GEOLOGICAL Society renowned throughout the has become an official scientific world in the early supporter of the campaign 19th century. Mary’s work to acknowledge the life and was groundbreaking within work of Mary Anning (1799 palaeontology, however - 1847) through a statue to because Mary was a woman be erected in her honour on and from a working-class The Mary Anning Rocks with-author-tom-sharpe- the Jurassic Coast. Aiming background, she didn’t receive campaign coordinator says, “We tickets-139642324953 to commemorate Mary’s the recognition she deserved see the statue as an inspirational Visit our online exhibition: contribution and inspire during her life. Regrettably, presence in the landscape www.geolsoc.org.uk/Library- future fossil-hunters with her Mary was never able to where she worked.” and-Information-Services/ unique story, this support is join the Society because To find out more about Exhibitions/Women-and- in line with the Society’s goal women were not considered the campaign, visit www. Geology/Mary-Anning to promote Earth science for Fellowship until 1919. maryanningrocks.co.uk/ Download our KS3 factsheet: education and awareness. However, the foundations Join the Library on 9 March www.geolsoc.org.uk/~/ Mary Anning was a fossil to our science were laid by for an online talk by Tom media/shared/documents/ hunter and collector, who countless dedicated and Sharpe ‘Mary Anning and education%20and%20careers/ made many incredible passionate geologists, just the men of learning’. www. Resources/FactSheets/ discoveries in her home town like Mary, who deserve to be eventbrite.co.uk/e/gsl-library- Mary%20Anning%20factsheet. of Lyme Regis, becoming remembered and celebrated. event-mary-anning-talk- pdf?la=en GEOSCIENTIST.ONLINE | SPRING 2021 11
NEWS The Discussion Group aspires to attract a diverse audience and attendance is open to all – Fellows and guests PARTNERSHIP WITH THE JP MORGAN FORCE FOR GOOD PROGRAMME Building a community platform to connect geoscience educators and practitioners We recently announced that the Geological Society is launching the Geoscience Education and Outreach Network (GEON), Geological Society an online platform for sharing education initiatives and discussion Discussion Group 2021 across the geoscience community. We are thrilled to have been chosen as a recipient of the THE DISCUSSION GROUP fosters Meetings are open to all – Fellows, prestigious JP Morgan Force wide-ranging scientific discussion in a their guests and non-Fellows. To make for Good programme. Through social setting on a variety of geoscience a reservation, contact Becky.Goddard@ the programme, JP Morgan will topics. It has roots in the Geological geolsoc.org.uk provide pro bono technical support Society Dining Club, which dates back The programme for 2021, including to develop the online platform. to 1824, becoming a formal part of the talks related to the Society’s ‘Year of GEON will represent a Society as one of the Specialist Groups Space’ theme, includes: significant opportunity to increase in 2016. Since 2018, a summary of the • 14 Apr. Stac Fada impact deposit. collaboration and best practice meetings has been available on the Dr Ken Amor, University of Oxford across the geoscience community. Society’s website, with topics ranging • 9 Jun. The Mars 2020 Mission. The ultimate aim will be to inspire from masonry repairs, the critically Prof Caroline Smith, Natural a skilled and diverse community of stressed Earth, deep continental History Museum future geoscientists. subduction, and how life began on • 14 Jul. Summer outing. Gilbert White To find out more and register Earth, to the future of the Society itself. Museum, Selborne your interest, please get in touch: Traditionally, meetings take place Fellows are invited to join the GEON@geolsoc.org.uk in the evening at a range of venues in Discussion Group as part of the annual London, when a topical subject is raised membership renewal process. by an invited speaker and debated over For more information, please contact dinner. However, events in 2020 have John Bennett (Honorary Secretary) J O I N T H E D E B AT E Has a news item got you thinking? been held with equal success by Zoom, via the website: www.geolsoc. We welcome readers’ letters and without travelling and with a convivial org.uk/Groups-and-Networks/ feedback. Share your views by glass of wine to hand from the comfort Specialist-Groups/Geological-Society- emailing geoscientist@geolsoc.org.uk of your own home! Discussion-Group/ 12 GEOSCIENTIST | SPRING 2021
NEWS Energy Transition Theme Geological knowledge informs We are excited to announce the energy projects such as Krafla launch of the Geological Society’s Geothermal Power Plant, Iceland Energy Transition Theme, write Image credit: Ásgeir Eggertsson, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons Dr Nick Gardiner (University of between academia, business, government in caverns meeting’. For more information St Andrews and Lead, Energy and public communities, and aim to inspire visit: www.geolsoc.org.uk/Hydrogen- Transition Theme) and Dr Alex a new generation of geoscientists. Storage-in-Caverns Whittaker (Imperial College London Energy Transition Theme events Energy Transition Discussion Meeting and Chair, Science Committee) and activities (April 2022) A number of events and activities are A multi-day conference in Burlington THE SHIFT to a low/neutral carbon economy, planned for 2021-22, to support and align House, London, in April 2022 will bring which is essential to tackle climate change, is with the Energy Transition Theme. together geoscientists, the energy transition now a pressing international effort. November communities, and policymakers, with an aim 2021 marks the UK-co-hosted United 2021 Webinar Series: of assessing the on-going directions and Nations Climate Change summit (COP26), • 13 April (13.00-16.30) Geosciences priority roles for the geosciences in the energy which is expected to drive new international and the Energy Transition: How can transition, following the COP26 meeting. agreements for decarbonisation. the Geosciences contribute to the Geosciences will play a pivotal role in Energy Transition? Decarbonisation Working Group enabling the increasingly urgent energy • 7-8 June (13.00-16.30) Geosciences and The Decarbonisation Working Group, chaired transition. Earth resource stewardship the Energy Transition: Energy Transfer, by Prof. Mike Stephenson, continues to work will also be critical to the development of Injection and Storage on key issues at the interface of geoscience circular economies, reducing waste and • 6-7 September (provisional) Geosciences and public policy, developing resources and environmental impact, driving innovation, and and the Energy Transition: Mineral initiatives to highlight and communicate key supporting business. Geological solutions Supplies on a Finite Planet enabling decarbonisation technologies to will underpin responsible resource and waste These seminars are being coordinated policymakers and the wider public. More management, new innovative technologies by Prof. Jon Gluyas (Durham University), information about their work can be found for both storage (H and He) and capture (CO2, Prof. Stuart Haszeldine OBE (University at www.geolsoc.org.uk/Policy-and-Media/ radioactive waste), and geothermal energy of Edinburgh), Prof. Rob Knipe (University issues/decarbonisation/working-group production. Geological knowledge will allow of Leeds), Dr David Reiner (University of the sourcing of essential raw materials, in Cambridge), Prof. Frances Wall (University Special issue of ES3: Earth Sciences particular critical metal resources, to support of Exeter), Jo Coleman OBE (Shell), Dr and the Race to Net Zero new technologies in energy storage and Nick Gardiner (University of St Andrews and The Geological Society’s new OA journal, transmission, transportation, construction, Theme Leader), Dr Jen Roberts (University Earth Science, Systems and Society (ES3, and engineering. of Strathclyde) and Prof. Mike Stephenson see page 10) will publish a special issue on Geoscientists are therefore uniquely (British Geological Survey). the theme of Earth Sciences and the Race placed to support policy makers, to Net Zero. Submissions are welcomed on stakeholders and industry in the Hydrogen Storage in Caverns Meeting all aspects of this topic: www.escubed.org/ management of Earth resources that are (12 April 2021, virtual event) research-topics/2/earth-sciences-and- fundamental to the energy transition. The This meeting is being organised in the-race-to-net-zero Society’s Energy Transition Theme will collaboration with Energy Research champion this goal, support communication Accelerator. If you would like to contribute, In addition, a number of outreach events participate or help shape how the event will be planned throughout 2021 and 2022 might proceed, please email Seamus. aligned with the theme. Further information Garvey@nottingham.ac.uk or mhste@bgs. can be found at www.geolsoc.org.uk/ET ac.uk with the title ‘About Hydrogen storage and www.geolsoc.org.uk/events GEOSCIENTIST.ONLINE | SPRING 2021 15
VIEWPOINT S EN D YO U R L E T T ER S TO G EO S C I E N T I S T@ G EO L S O C .O RG .U K A N D T W EE T U S AT @ G EO S C I E N T I S TM AG . F O R G U I DA N CE O N S U B M I T T I N G A CO LU M N , S EE G EO S C I E N T I S T.O N L I N E COLUMN Field courses are vital, “Some but they must be safe barriers are invisible” Fieldwork is important, but we must recognise the manifest risk it poses to LGBTQ+ people, argues Prof. Chris Jackson Want to join the debate? Email A s the old saying goes, “the best geologist has seen the most rocks!” This Why might sexual orientation be a barrier to fieldwork? Queer people are as able to deal with stress felt by LGBTQ+ people in these locations geoscientist @geolsoc.org.uk students who run into trouble overseas. Such restrictions highlight the statement superficially makes cold weather and boulder-strewn is not conducive to fact that many institutions sense; if you’ve seen many slopes as non-queer people, teaching and learning, do not have field-course risk rocks, you can draw on those aren’t they? I’m not questioning presenting further barriers. assessments explicitly covering experiences to... erm... identify this, but rather highlighting that Holding field courses in LGBTQ+-specific risks; even and interpret more rocks. But there are still about 70 countries such countries presents an where such assessments and geoscientists rely on numerous where being gay, lesbian, unnecessary risk. In most cases, related evacuation policies are skills to determine the structure, bisexual, and/or transgender other suitable field locations in place, they remain untested. composition, and evolution of is illegal, and many more with exist that support attainment Like many geoscientists, Earth and other planets – skills minimal protections against of the learning objectives. We I do not see a future where that span a bewildering range discrimination towards LGBTQ+ must select such alternatives to fieldwork is not a core element of disciplines and scales. people. This is nothing to do with promote an inclusive learning of the geoscience toolkit. Fieldwork is undoubtedly having sex; this discrimination environment, to the benefit of an However, we must be aware important and is a core element exists simply for being (or individual course and the wider of and work to remove the of many Earth science courses. perceived as being) a member community that our graduates barriers to fieldwork placed There are, however, numerous of the LGBTQ+ community. will join. Deciding not to hold a in front of all members of the barriers to fieldwork. Some are For example, in 2014 a British field course in a location that is geoscience community. obvious, such as those related to tourist was arrested in Morocco unsafe for LGBTQ+ geoscientists coping with the sheer physicality after authorities searched his is not a political or value of fieldwork. Many more are less phone and found images used statement on a country or its obvious, such as the requirement to prosecute him, while the citizens. We have a duty of care for safe conditions under which arrest, torture, exile to Canada, to our colleagues and students. to change sanitary protection. and eventual suicide in 2020 Additionally, universities And some barriers are perhaps of activist Sarah Hegazi was or staff in the field may not P R O F. C H R I S J A C K S O N invisible, such as sexual triggered by her waving a be able to immediately assist Chair in Sustainable Geoscience, orientation and gender identity. rainbow flag in Egypt. The or repatriate employees or University of Manchester 16 GEOSCIENTIST | SPRING 2021
VIEWPOINT old-fashioned perceptions of what geology is and what geologists do, as you rightly point out, especially around geology’s association with the extractive industries. This complex problem is not one the Society can fix alone. We are therefore partnering with a number Geologists are forensic detectives, of other organisations and gathering data on location stakeholders to widen the appeal of geology. Two LET TER in the media, and little or notable organisations are: Reverse the decline no specific mention of the term geology in schools, is it any wonder that many are ∞ University Geoscience UK, the subject association of geoscience departments based DEAR EDITORS, concerned that these will unaware of the tremendous within British universities. We Geology’s popularity is in largely become point-and-see opportunity geology offers co-organised the June 2020 decline for many reasons. exercises that do not instil for employment, intellectual student enrolment summit, A big one is that, as a sound recording techniques challenge and personal which led to the development community, we have allowed or stimulate the kind of mind fulfilment, as well as its key of a strategy and a plan of it to become widely regarded that seeks out answers. role in locating essential action is currently being as just the study of some Safety and inclusivity in the resources and helping pursued to increase interest. dusty old rocks. Geologists field are vital, but difficult Earth’s environment? ∞ Diversity in Geoscience UK, know it is far more than that issues. Thankfully many A hard task lies ahead, a recently established charity – it is Earth Science. Another classic localities already have but we must hurry to fully looking at ways to improve reason is the name change to suitable access and it wouldn’t convince the public that diversity and inclusion for Earth sciences or geoscience take much work to improve first-class geologists are, and all within the community. – this only creates confusion many more field locations. always will be, absolutely vital. They are currently assessing and dilutes our message. Some sites even offer for hire potential projects and The Geological Society off-road mobility scooters. RICHARD ARTHUR fundraising opportunities, urgently needs to be more Would the Geological Society and we can work together proactive in encouraging be interested in helping to set George Jameson, with them to improve access extra mural courses and up a database of such places Diversity and Inclusion Project to field locations throughout spreading the word. and help raise funding to Lead, Geological Society of the country. Clearly, we must embrace improve matters? London, writes in response: Our goals may not be diversity and inclusivity, True geologists are The Society is acutely aware of realised overnight, but they while eliminating racism, like forensic detectives. the decline in the popularity of will go some way to dusting but we cannot give in They must think across geology over recent years. This off the perception of geology to those clamouring to disciplines to understand is most noticeable in the drop as just the study of old rocks. remove traditional fieldwork the complexities of Earth’s in student numbers applying Given the gravity of the requirements. It should natural processes and its for and studying geology situation, it is essential for the be crystal clear why it is many human-made problems. at undergraduate level, community to address this ridiculous to think the The combination of a less something we are genuinely task together and we welcome personal experience gained outdoorsy generation and concerned by. additional support. through fieldwork is not geology’s toxic association Ideally, we want every absolutely essential, and it with destructive and polluting person to be familiar with worries me that anyone could extractive industries are major geology as an area of think they can become a real barriers to be overcome if study and aware of the To anyone who wishes to ‘geologist’ without it. geology’s popularity is to applications of geology to our continue this conversation, Virtual field trips are great be improved. With so little everyday lives. However, this please get in touch by emailing for inclusivity, but I am coverage of accurate geology ideal is nuanced. There are diversity@geolsoc.org.uk GEOSCIENTIST.ONLINE | SPRING 2021 17
VIEWPOINT COLUMN still ingrained, and where Black “We have accepted lack underrepresentation is not seen as an issue. of diversity as normal” It is time for us to do more than speak up. We must go beyond wearing t-shirts, using Why are Black geoscientists underrepresentated in the hashtags and glossy Corporate minerals industry, asks Dr Andrew P.G. Abraham Social Responsibility reports. We need to take action to create truly diverse and welcoming G eology (and all its incredible subfields) is an amazing science to learn. Even though most of us, who are white, have rarely met Black geoscience students, Silence is a form of complicity, workplaces in academia and the minerals industry. This will not happen overnight, but we and the minerals The integral importance of professors, geoscientists and can make a start through open geoscience and the minerals corporate leaders, we have industry gives the dialogue on inclusivity, equity, industry to global economies rarely voiced concern, and impression that it and breaking down barriers. should make it a strong choice mostly accepted the lack of does not care We need to create intern for developing future careers. diversity as something normal. programmes, more scholarships So, why does it not attract more It should not have taken the and bursaries, and mentorship Black students and why are horrific murder of George Floyd boardrooms are an echo and outreach programmes there so few Black geoscientists to create the unprecedented chamber insulating them from to attract Black high-school and corporate leaders? global change in corporate reality. This should shame us all. students into geoscience. We The scarcity of Black attitudes. But the minerals The industry’s Black need to encourage them to geoscientists is not a function industry, to a large extent, underrepresentation starts continue in academic research of Black students finding has stood silent. Silence is a with the education system and work in the minerals geoscience and careers form of complicity, and the that has not yet stepped up industry. How can we do this? in the minerals industry minerals industry gives the to changing its predominantly By creating a paradigm shift in uninteresting, it is a function impression that it does not white complexion. This is a culture and attitude, celebrating of over 40 years of white care. Why? Because it does not major global issue, especially in Black role models, recognising geoscientists and corporate understand nor feel connected primarily white countries where Black student’s abilities and leaders happily content with to the Black community colonial attitudes and systemic achievements, encouraging them the status quo. and its predominantly white racism are to become leaders, accepting them for who they are, and nurturing their desires to succeed. Visit Geoscientist. • This opinion piece links to Online to read the latest the feature ‘Waiting for a discussions paradigm shift: in full Black underrepresentation in geoscience and the minerals Industry’, available at www.Geoscientist.Online • See also feature, page 30. D R A N D R E W P. G . A B R A H A M An independent consultant who serves as volunteer Director External Engagement for the Canadian Federation of Earth Sciences 18 GEOSCIENTIST | SPRING 2021
VIEWPOINT the danger in that? The power Society activities, Geoscientist of print is that ‘it comes to you’, has to be affordable, so you read it. Online letters, particularly in these difficult as now, hide in plain sight, free times, and staff were tasked for all the world to read if they with finding ways to become can be bothered – and cynically more sustainable. The editorial put there in the full knowledge team drew up a variety of that nobody will. They will go options for the production of as unread in future as they do Geoscientist. These detailed now, and for the same reason options were assessed by – one that no amount of web the Finance and Planning design can ever overcome. Committee and agreed by Council, which decided on P R O F. E M E R . P E T E R enhanced online presence STYLES, DR TED NIELD and quarterly publication. This decision reflected both DEAR EDITORS, costs and the best use of the I am saddened to hear the time of the editors and others society is reducing the number producing Geoscientist. LET TER of magazine issues per year. Peter and Ted forcefully Quarterly dismay From my perspective, all this will mean is that I engage less with the magazine and argue that having letters initially and immediately online will “hide [objections DEAR EDITORS, loathing that characterised the Society, as I already and dissent] in plain sight”. We write, as a former President, ‘reunification’, members of receive a torrent of digital This may be true for some Professional Secretary, the Institution (practising communications and cohorts of Fellows, but others Editor-in-Chief and Editor of geoscientists) were not willing offerings – getting the print will doubtless be far more at Geoscientist, to express our for academics, who then magazine cuts through this home finding or expressing sadness and dismay that this dominated, with steely resolve, and means I actually read it. views online. We hope that fine magazine is to become a the Old Lady of Piccadilly, A move towards digital putting more resources into quarterly, with promises of an to hold any editorial sway. It provision will result in less of timely online news and debate enhanced online presence. seems hardly coincidental that my attention, I’m afraid. will serve a broad range of the You attempt to put a brave this present measure is being Fellowship and help attract a face on it, but beyond that taken just as the worst fears of CHRIS JACK new Fellows. – and some questionable our own times are coming true. Geoscientist continues to greenwash – we detect two We are sure that the new Prof. Andy Fleet, be ‘by and for the Fellows’ real motives: saving money, quarterly will be a thing Editor-in-Chief; David and, as ever, we encourage and stifling dissent. In the of beauty; but quarterlies Shilston, Deputy Editor-in- our community to voice any right circumstances in these cannot be topical. High Chief; Dr Amy Whitchurch, concerns and share their straitened times, we approve of production values and long Editor; Sarah Day, Editor, opinions – email your letters the former, but never the latter! intervals lead to blandness Geoscientist magazine, to geoscientist@geolsoc.org. Geoscientist is unique among and inconsequentiality. One write in response: In making uk. Indeed, our problems learned body magazines in that knows there will never be changes to Geoscientist, we are usually that we do not it belongs to the Fellowship anything piquant in these are trying to provide the best hear from all sides of a and not ‘the Society’ (whatever organs – even in Letters, service to the full spectrum of debate, especially those who THAT is). It owes this ‘Fourth assuming there are any. Fellows that we can, given the agree rather than dissent, Estate’ status to its history – So where will Fellows, in resources available to us, and and in hearing a variety of being formed from the merger the last resort, go to voice improve how we provide news views rather than the same of the Society’s anaemic any objections to the way and debate in exciting, varied argument repeated. newsletter and the Institution Trustees and staff or others are and timely ways. Dare we end by saying of Geologists’ far superior misconducting the Society’s As Peter and Ted highlight, that we have published British Geologist. In the business? They will go online, money was a key factor in a fuller response on climate of suspicion, fear and we are told. Result! For where is making the changes. Like all Geoscientist Online? GEOSCIENTIST.ONLINE | SPRING 2021 19
VIEWPOINT We should be doing more LET TER to ensure that geology is taught in schools Inspirational geoparks need investment DEAR EDITORS, Would education help I read Melvyn Giles’ article increase public awareness and about The Scottish Geology thereby funding of geoparks? Trust (Geoscientist 30(10), 28- In pre-university science, 29, 2020) with great sympathy geology is incorporated as a for the cause – that public minor component, though interest in dramatic Scottish perhaps too fleetingly to landscapes is not matched by impress young minds. We investment in our geoparks. should instead exploit the There is a perception that the geography curriculum, but public is unwilling to engage here the window might be with lengthy explanations. TV closing – even geomorphology LET TER documentaries often open may be fighting a rear-guard with sequences on plate tectonics, floods or icecaps, action to preserve its long- standing space as relative Capturing young before rapidly giving way to the urge to feed public interest newcomers such as climate change and environmental imaginations in animal behaviour. Many despoliation crowd out the film directors seem to believe time available. DEAR EDITORS, issues like climate change the physical world is merely a I am most concerned by and geohazards. The setting for the organisms that P R O F. E M E R I T U S , recent articles citing the profession has always inhabit it. IAN REID decline in the teaching changed as it moved of geology, its adverse forward, not only for the The dramatic landscapes of Scotland impact on the profession few, but for the many. can inspire interest in geology which, in my view, is to the Indeed, the comment detriment of society. from the Editor’s desk in A geological degree the October issue that gives one a wonderful “Geology has a way of start to a career. In my capturing the imagination, school, geology was not whatever level of detailed taught, but it seemed an understanding you reach” obvious degree choice, should be exploited to its given it combined the full potential. subjects I studied at A The profession must Level: physics, chemistry, reach out beyond the botany and zoology. I known world of geology went on to enjoy a career and be more proactive. in civil engineering, not Perhaps the slogan for in geotechnics, but as a universities should be maritime civil engineer. ‘Kick Start your Career Geology as a subject has with a Geology Degree’, developed and continues reinforcing the view that to do so. It has much to geology is a broad church. contribute to our future, including tackling major DR ROG E R MADDR E L L 20 GEOSCIENTIST | SPRING 2021
VIEWPOINT David wearing one of the face Follow us @geoscientistmag coverings YOUR TWEETS @Volcanologist: It’s ‘crewed’ not ‘manned’. (E.g. see here ourplnt.com/please-use-crewed -not-manned/#axzz6gtiTOMfr) @geoscientistmag: Thank you for flagging this. We’re disappointed we didn’t pick this up during our editing process and will endeavour to be more thorough in the future. LET TER @Volcanologist: Excited to see the latest @geoscientistmag on Mars with a great interview with Geo Divya Persaud. Mini-volcanologist is a bit obsessed with the Mars Rovers, she’s going to love flicking FEATURE Decolonising geosicence face through the pics in this mag: geolsoc.org.uk/ Geoscientist/December-2020 The harrowing deaths of George Floyd and Breonna Taylor in the coverings United States, and the subsequent rise @NEURISA: Who doesn’t want to read about of the Black Lives Matter movement #Megalodon and #DataEthics? Looks like a great issue profoundly affected much of society @geoscientistmag! last summer. One of the most notable outcomes has been organisations, DEAR EDITORS, such as our own, investigating the To my delight the Société @Leannes_space: Great article in @geoscientistmag about geological data gathering for the Normandy Géologique de France sent me landings, I wonder if ‘auger-gate’ would have meant their geologically themed face requisitioning any of these @BritGeoSurvey augers to coverings (€5 each or €15 for cover their tracks? all four, and around €3 postage to the UK). Designed for non- @alpeacegeo: why are you cancelling ‘Sticks & Stones’ NEW ONLINE HOME medical use they can be worn from Geoscientist? This is literally the only thing I read If you enjoy reading Geoscientist consistently in the whole magazine! magazine, why not visit for four hours and are machine www.Geoscientist.Online to washable at 60° C. @geoscientistmag: We miss it too! After nearly 20 years our cartoonist decided to access even more debate, Designs include a pair of lay down his pen. You can follow the news and science? Our newly cream on black illustrations launched website features an adventures of Dalston and friends at of the ammonite laevigatus array of additional content, www.stonechatproductions.co.uk (James Sowerby) from including geoscience-related southern England. @fktodd: Starting young in this reports, videos and more. The household #GeoKid #GeologyRocks site is mobile-device-friendly, DAVID NOWELL so you can read on the go. LET TER What makes a geologist? DEAR EDITORS, was 1/4 of the first year, The chemistry, physics Being able to With respect to your 2/3 of the second year, and maths that took up communicate is a rare editorial piece in October’s and full time only in the the rest of the teaching skill too, something that issue (Geoscientist 30(9), last year (this adds up to a time have been very useful my English master at October 2020), what is a little less than two years). in a commercial career school stressed. geologist anyway? You’ve But my last year contained as a hydrogeologist, So I’d recommend a met the requirements to be no palaeontology before broadening out broad first degree – you a Fellow of our Society, so I whatsoever (my choice) and into the contaminated don’t know at that stage think you are. I did my first I concluded correctly that land aspects of nuclear where your career might degree at Cambridge, in I could avoid answering decommissioning, and even take you. Natural Sciences, which is any exam questions some of the finer points of also modular. Earth science about sandstone. reactor dismantling. J O H N H E AT H C O T E GEOSCIENTIST.ONLINE | SPRING 2021 21
You can also read