Alligator (Alligator mississippiensis) Aquaculture in the United States - Regulations.gov
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
REVIEWS IN FISHERIES SCIENCE & AQUACULTURE 2018, VOL. 26, NO. 1, 86–98 https://doi.org/10.1080/23308249.2017.1355350 Alligator (Alligator mississippiensis) Aquaculture in the United States Mary J. Nickuma, Michael Masserb, Robert Reighc, and John G. Nickumd a All Things Editorial, Fountain Hills, Arizona, USA; bTX A&M University, College Station, Texas, USA; cAquaculture Research Station, Louisiana State University Agricultural Center, Baton Rouge, Louisiana, USA; dNickum & Nickum, Inc., Fountain Hills, Arizona, USA ABSTRACT KEYWORDS Commercial production of American alligator (Alligator mississippiensis) under intensive aquaculture American alligator; alligator conditions began in the 1980s. During the last 30 years, alligator farming has become an mississippiensis; aquaculture aquacultural industry worth millions of dollars in the southern United States. In 2014, farmers in Louisiana, the nation’s largest producer of captive-reared alligators, sold more than 383,000 skins valued at more than $77 million. Most alligator farming operations utilize wild-sourced eggs, which are collected from wetland habitats under the authority of permits issued by State agencies. Typically, these permits include a requirement to return a portion of farm-reared animals to the same area where eggs were collected to maintain wild populations. Intensive rearing of alligators requires an abundance of warm water and good quality food. Extruded feeds formulated specifically for alligator are the industry standard in modern production systems. Disease can be an occasional problem in alligator production operations but risks can be minimized with provision of clean water, high-quality feed, and good hygienic conditions in grow-out facilities. Belly skins are the primary product of alligator aquaculture, but alligator meat is also sold in niche markets. Although products made from alligator skins have strong consumer appeal, the relatively high cost of products made with alligator leather limits sales to more affluent consumers. Growth of alligator farming, using current production methods, will be limited by the natural productivity of the wild resource upon which the industry depends and demand for products utilizing alligator leather. From 2004 to 2013, global demand for skins of all species of crocodilians averaged 1.4 million skins annually, of which 24.3% were American alligator. Introduction role as ecosystem engineers in wetland ecosystems The American alligator (Alligator mississippiensis) some- through the creation of alligator holes, which provide times referred to colloquially as a gator or common alli- wet and dry habitats for other organisms. gator, is a large crocodilian reptile endemic to the The American alligator is listed as ‘Least Concern’ by southeastern United States. It is one of two living species the International Union for Conservation of Nature in the genus Alligator within the family Alligatoridae (IUCN). Historically, hunting had decimated their popu- and it is larger than the other extant alligator species, the lation. Subsequent conservation efforts have allowed Chinese alligator. Adult male American alligators mea- their numbers to increase and the species was removed sure up to 3.4 to 4.6 m in length and can weigh up to 453 from the list in 1987. Alligators are now harvested for kg. Females are smaller, measuring around 3 m. The their skins and meat. American alligator inhabits freshwater wetlands, such as Though not truly domesticated, alligators and croco- marshes and cypress swamps from Texas to North Caro- diles have been bred in farms since at least the early 20th lina. It is distinguished from the sympatric American century; however, the vast majority of these early busi- crocodile (Crocodylus acutus) by its broader snout, with nesses were farms in name only, primarily keeping alliga- overlapping jaws and darker coloration. It is less tolerant tors and crocodiles as a tourist attraction (Anonymous, of saltwater, but more tolerant of cooler climates than 2014). The St. Augustine Alligator Farm Zoological Park, the American crocodile, which is found only in tropical established in 1893, was a prime example of this early climates. type of alligator farm. Only in the 1960s did commercial Alligators are apex predators and consume fish, operations that either harvested eggs from the wild or amphibians, reptiles, birds, and mammals. Hatchlings bred alligators on-site begin to appear (Medley, 1970). feed mostly on invertebrates. They play an important This was largely driven by diminishing stocks of wild CONTACT Mary J. Nickum mjnickum@hotmail.com All Things Editorial, Fountain Hills, AZ 85268, USA. © 2018 Taylor & Francis
REVIEWS IN FISHERIES SCIENCE & AQUACULTURE 87 alligators, which had been hunted nearly to extinction by The results of this partnership have provided significant this time. benefits to both aquaculture entrepreneurs and natural As the American alligator was placed under official resource managers, demonstrating one case in which protection in 1967 (under a law preceding the 1973 commercial use of a public resource has become an inte- Endangered Species Act) farming alligators for skins gral part of an effective wildlife management plan. became the most viable option for producing leather (aside from illegal poaching; Medley, 1970). Mostly con- Alligator biology centrated in the southern U.S. states of Louisiana, Flor- ida, and Georgia, the practice quickly spread to other The reptilian order Crocodilia includes 23 species of nations. Both the American and Chinese alligator are alligators, caimans, crocodiles, and gharials. There are farmed intensively today, mostly within each species’ only two species of alligators; American alligator respective native region. (Alligator mississippiensis) and Chinese alligator (A. Although farming alligators and crocodiles first grew sinensis). The American alligator, once nearly elimi- out of the demand for skins (Lyman, 1998), alligator and nated from its native range, has recovered after years crocodile meat, which was long a part of southern cook- of state and federal protection; the Chinese alligator ing (especially Cajun cuisine; Marcus, 1993 ) and some remains critically endangered (Thorbjanarson, 1992; Asian and African cuisines, began to be sold later and Crocodile Specialist Group, 1996). The American alli- shipped around the world to markets unfamiliar with gator first received federal protection as an endan- crocodilian meat. Chinese cuisine, based on traditional gered species in 1967. The alligator was removed Chinese medicine, considers alligator meat to be a cura- from endangered classification in 1987 because of its tive food for colds and cancer prevention, although there rapid recovery under the protection of state and fed- is no scientific evidence to support this (Chang and eral laws. It is now classified as “threatened because Olson, 2008). of the similarity of appearance,” which is a classifica- A common misconception is that alligators are an tion intended to protect similar-looking crocodilian easy source of revenue and not difficult to care for in species that are still threatened by international trade captivity; however, few alligators businesses are success- of their hides and other products (USFWS, 2008). All ful in the developing world. To offset overhead costs and products derived from crocodilian species are strictly have a regular source of income, crocodilian facilities can regulated under the International CITES Treaty add tourism. By utilizing different types of farming, such (https://cites.org/eng/disc/text.php). as ranching and breeding, combined with tourism, alliga- The American alligator’s native range extends along tor farming can provide income for people in that area the Atlantic and Gulf coast states from North Carolina (Brien et al. 2007). to Texas and into northern Mexico, and includes small Alligator farming has minimal adverse effects on the populations in Arkansas and Oklahoma (Joanen and environment, though it has at least two positive direct McNease, 1987). The alligator populates mostly freshwa- effects on alligator conservation. It provides the luxury ter habitats but will occupy slightly saline environments. goods industry with a reliable stream of product, which Male alligators are known to grow to 5 m in length, reduces illegal poaching to obtain skins and alligator weigh over a 450 kg, and live a century. Males grow farmers will release juvenile alligators into the wild to larger than females (3 m maximum) and sexual maturity support steady population growth. Wild alligator conser- is reached by both sexes at 2 m in length. Along the Gulf vation has also benefited indirectly from farming. Busi- coast, maturity is reached in 9–10 years but in North nesses engaging in ranching protect alligator habitats, Carolina, it is not until 18–19 years of age (Fuller et al., caring for nesting sites to ensure a healthy population. 1983). Because there is a fiscal incentive to keep a healthy envi- Alligators are apex predators that have survived since ronment for breeding alligators, the animals are seen as the Age of Reptiles (The Mesozoic Era), 200 million an economic resource. years ago. They are distinguished from most other croco- Today alligator aquaculture is a multi-million dollar dilians based on head morphology and body color. The industry in parts of the American South, producing snout of the alligator is broader and has no exposed thousands of farm-raised alligator skins and tons of alli- lower teeth when the mouth is closed compared to other gator meat annually. The development of alligator aqua- crocodilians. Adult alligators tend to be black while croc- culture in the United States is a success story of public- odiles are brownish in coloration. Alligators consume private partnership that has returned an iconic wildlife many types of prey. Young alligators mostly consume species to its native habitat while creating a profitable insects, snails, crustaceans, and small fish. Larger indi- use for the private land on which that species depends. viduals consume fish, turtles, birds, and mammals.
88 M. NICKUM ET AL. Alligators, as all reptilians, are tetrapod vertebrates alligator, this paper will focus on that state’s experience having skin covered with scales or scutes. They repro- with commercial alligator farming since the 1970s. duce through amniotic eggs and are cold-blooded, or ectothermic. Alligators cannot regulate their body tem- Genesis of the management program peratures physiologically. Like other ectotherms, they function most efficiently within a narrow temperature The development of alligator farming, from a low-input range. Their preferred core body temperature is 32–35 C activity relying on the natural production of wild popula- but they are vigorous at core temperatures of 26–37 C tions to today’s high-intensity farming operations, has (Brattstrom, 1965). Upper lethal temperature is 38–39 C been many years in the making. Although American alli- (Colbert et al., 1946) and lower lethal temperature is gator has been used as a natural resource in the south- 2–4 C (Coulson and Hernandez, 1964). In the wild, alli- eastern United States since before European settlement, gators modify wetlands by creating “gator holes” or small heavy exploitation of the species did not begin until the ponds. These deeper holes within the wetlands produce early 1800s (Joanen et al., 1997). During most of the vital habitat for other wetland creatures, especially dur- 19th century, demand for alligator skins fluctuated with ing droughts. Alligators will also tunnel into banks and the availability of more durable and desirable leather create dens above water level with access to air. These products in the marketplace. The advent of commercial deep-water “gator holes” and dens help alligators tanning in the U.S. in the late 1800s, which improved the find thermal refuges during hot and cold weather durability and aesthetic appeal of animal skins, created a (USFWS, 2008). growing demand for alligator leather and increased Alligators can alter their core body temperature, hunting pressure. Strong demand led to widespread within limits, through physiological and behavioral exploitation of wild alligator populations from the late adaptations, such as endogenous heat production, which 19th to the mid-20th centuries, resulting in near elimina- increases with the size of the animal, by contact with tion of the animal from its natural range by the 1960s. In warmer substrates, basking, and changing activity cycles response, Louisiana banned alligator hunting in 1962 seasonally (Brattstrom, 1965). It appears alligators have (Joanen et al., 1997) and the U.S. government placed the some vasomotor control of their circulatory system, as American alligator on the federal list of endangered core, dorsal, and ventral temperatures can differ simulta- species in 1967, where it remained for 20 years (USFWS, neously (Morgareidge and White, 1969). To maintain 2008). core temperatures, alligators are mostly nocturnal in By 1987, alligator populations had recovered suffi- summer and diurnal in winter. These adaptations have ciently throughout the southern U.S. to allow removal of allowed the alligator to inhabit cooler climates than other Alligator mississippiensis from the endangered species crocodilians (Lance, 2003). list. However, under the Convention on International The favorable biological traits of the American alliga- Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora, tor and a consistent demand for alligator skin for luxury the U.S. government continues to classify the American leather products made A. mississippiensis a good candi- alligator as “threatened due to similarity of appearance,” date for aquaculture production. Scientific research to which allows the federal government to regulate legal develop alligator farming methods began in the 1970s in trade in alligators and alligator products to inhibit illegal Louisiana and Florida, and continues to the present day. trade in products from similar-looking reptiles (e.g., some crocodiles and caimans) harvested elsewhere in the world (USFWS, 2008). A primary requirement of the History of alligator farming Federal regulations regarding trade in alligator products Alligator farming is an aquacultural industry worth tens is annual verification by states with exploited alligator of millions of dollars in the southern United States. It is populations that their harvesting programs are not detri- practiced primarily in Louisiana, Florida, Georgia and mental to the species’ survival. To comply with this Texas, where large numbers of wild alligators live in the requirement, the Louisiana Department of Wildlife and states’ coastal marshes and inland swamps. In 2014, Fisheries (LDWF) employs an extensive research and farmers in Louisiana, the nation’s largest producer of management program to ensure the well-being and sus- captive-reared alligators, sold more than 383,000 m of tainable use of the state’s wild alligator populations skins valued at more than $77 million (LSUAC, 2015). (LDWF, 2016a). This effort, which includes both com- Florida, the second largest alligator-farming state, pro- mercial alligator farming and wild harvest, has become a duced only one-tenth of Louisiana’s output that same model of effective crocodilian conservation that is emu- year (FFWCC, 2015). Given dominance of Louisiana in lated around the world (Joanen et al., 1997; Heykoop farmed production and wild harvest of American and Frechette, 2001; Moyle, 2013).
REVIEWS IN FISHERIES SCIENCE & AQUACULTURE 89 In Louisiana, interest in farming alligators for conser- It is estimated that Louisiana now has a wild alligator vation and commercial purposes began in 1959 when the population of about two million animals, with an addi- LDWF initiated an intensive management program tional 300,000 captive-reared alligators present on farms. aimed at restoring the state’s alligator population to a Despite the harvest of more than 28,000 wild alligators level that could support sustained annual harvests annually by licensed hunters and collection by alligator (Joanen and McNease, 1979). Research conducted in the farmers of more than one-half million eggs from the 1960s and 1970s produced information on alligator biol- wild resource each year, the state’s sustainable-use pro- ogy and husbandry that led to Louisiana’s successful alli- gram has succeeded in maintaining a stable-to-slightly gator ranching program, which now supports the state’s increasing alligator population since 1972. Additional commercial alligator industry. Since the initiation of its information on the LDWF alligator management pro- sustainable-use program in the early 1970s, LDWF esti- gram is available on the agency’s website (http://www. mates that nearly a million wild alligators have been har- wlf.louisiana.gov/wildlife/alligator-program). vested, more than eight million eggs have been collected from the wild for farming operations and the skins of Alligator farming as a livestock production five million captive-reared alligators have been sold enterprise (LDWF, 2016b). Although alligator producers are typically identified as Production of farmed alligators at the industrial scale “farmers,” most are actually ranchers who obtain their that characterizes today’s intensive grow-out operations stock from wild-sourced eggs rather than from brood- is a relatively recent development. However, alligator stock housed on their properties, as farmers would do. farming has been of interest to residents of the southeast- A small number of producers do obtain some eggs from ern United States since the late 19th century, with early on-site reproduction, but all growers obtain the majority, attempts at captive production recorded as far back as if not the entirety, of their stock from eggs collected from 1891 in Florida (Lane and King, 1996). Early “farms” the wild under permits issued by the LDWF. In 2014, were little more than fenced enclosures where alligators more than 528,000 eggs were collected from 434,000 hec- caught in the wild were held for captive breeding or dis- tares of Louisiana wetlands to be used in alligator farm- play. The unnatural conditions on these farms often did ing operations (LDWF, 2016b). Nearly 80% of these not meet environmental requirements of the alligators wetlands are privately owned. Farmers establish lease for courtship and mating, and few offspring were pro- agreements with private landowners to collect eggs on duced (Joanen and McNease, 1971, 1980). their property during the alligator nesting season in For years during the first half of the 20th century, alli- May–June. These arrangements produce income for the gator farming was perceived by many as an exotic curios- landowner and provide incentive to maintain agricultur- ity endemic to some southern states. It was not until the ally unproductive land as income-generating wetland early 1960s, when wild alligator population of Louisiana habitat for alligator. reached the lowest level in history and alligator hunting Collected eggs are transported to the farm and incu- was banned, that interest in alligator farming as a sci- bated at 30–32 C for approximately 65 days. Hatchlings, ence-based, livestock production enterprise developed. 20–30 cm in length when they emerge from the egg, are Alligator farming, it was argued, if practiced as efficiently stocked in temperature-controlled production houses as other forms of livestock production, could facilitate and grown to a length of 1–1.5 m prior to slaughter. the restoration of wild populations and support the A critical component of the LDWF alligator manage- state’s economically important skin trade, which no lon- ment program is the requirement that producers return ger had access to the wild resource. 12% of farm-raised animals to the wild in the same areas In 1964, the LDWF initiated a research program to where eggs were collected. This mandate is based on a determine the feasibility of raising alligators in captivity. determination from population studies that 12% of wild During a nine-year period, a series of studies were con- hatchlings can be expected to survive to a length of ducted at Rockefeller Wildlife Refuge (Grand Chenier, 1–1.5 m. Returning this percentage of farm-raised ani- Louisiana) to identify management practices for the care mals to the wild every year ensures that population num- and husbandry of captive-reared American alligator bers are not reduced by egg harvesting or destructive (Joanen and McNease, 1971, 1975, 1977). Experiments natural occurrences, such as floods and nest predation, focused on factors such as pen design (optimum size, and a consistent level of annual recruitment is main- suitable vegetation types, pond configurations, and ratios tained. LDWF closely monitors the farm-release pro- of dry land to open water areas); male-female stocking gram to ensure producer compliance and to track effects rates; food sources and feeding methods; reproductive of the program on the wild resource. biology (including courtship, mating behavior, and nest
90 M. NICKUM ET AL. construction); egg incubation; and alligator growth rates. usually home-made devices designed in a variety of Results of these studies demonstrated that “closed sys- shapes and sizes—where they are placed in tagged bas- tem” alligator farming was possible, if not always eco- kets with damp vermiculite, sphagnum, or other bedding nomical. Farms dependent on captive broodstock were material and held at 30–32 C for approximately 65 days. unlikely to generate the numbers of offspring needed for The use of hatching containers allows groups of eggs to commercial viability. Alligator ranching, which relies on be identified by the date and place of collection, so infor- the collection of wild-sourced eggs, was deemed to be a mation on the characteristics (e.g., date of hatch, percent more reliable approach (Elsey et al., 1994). Although in hatching success) of clutches obtained from nests in dif- the early years of the research, when wild alligator popu- ferent areas can be recorded. Hatchlings remain in the lations were still low, collection of eggs or hatchlings for incubator for 24 hr after hatching to allow the umbilical commercial purposes was prohibited. cord to separate naturally from the eggshell. They are Wild populations had recovered sufficiently by 1972 then moved to production houses and stocked at initial to allow the resumption of alligator hunting in one densities of about two to four animals per square meter. coastal Louisiana parish in September of that year Stocking densities may vary considerably among farms (LDWF, 2016b). During the nine years that followed, since the recent removal of minimum-space require- alligator hunting expanded to other coastal parishes and ments from LDWF alligator farming regulations was restored statewide in 1981. Populations continued to (LDWF, 2015). Despite differences in production meth- grow and in 1986, a limited number of egg collections ods, all farmers are careful to maintain conditions that were permitted for private producers. Use of wild- minimize disease and optimize growth rates. sourced eggs provided benefits to both producers and Disease is usually not a major problem in most alliga- wildlife managers. Private growers obtained farm stock tor aquaculture operations, but diseases can appear at lower cost and many eggs that would have been lost to unexpectedly and develop quickly when they do occur. natural mortality in the wild were put to productive use. Little information is available concerning diseases that Also, the requirement that producers return to the wild afflict alligators in the wild; however, among captive- each year a percentage of their one to two year old reared alligators, dermatitis is a relatively common farmed stock ensured that exploited populations would disease, particularly among hatchlings, although it can benefit from consistent recruitment of alligators likely to occur in older alligators, as well (Nevarez et al., 2011). survive to reproductive age (Elsey et al., 1994). Alligator Bacterial and fungal infections are the causative agents of ranching (hereafter included in the term “farming”) has dermatitis. The factors that predispose alligators to these been a successful model of public–private partnership, infections are unknown. Stress may be involved, but providing both economic and conservation benefits. there is lack of evidence that stressors are the primary While some crocodilians in other parts of the world cause (Nevarez et al., 2011). Advanced cases of dermati- are produced primarily or entirely by captive breeding, tis can cause most mortality among captive alligators most American alligators are produced from eggs taken and, unfortunately, there are no consistently effective from the wild (Lane and King, 1996; Moyle, 2013; treatments available. Avoiding outbreaks by maintaining TPWD, 2013). In Louisiana, growers collect eggs in areas good environmental conditions is important. American approved by LDWF after annual surveys of nest densi- alligator are also susceptible to West Nile virus (WNV) ties. Surveys are conducted along aerial transects to infection, which can produce high mortality depending determine number of nests per hectare in different habi- on the severity of an outbreak. Studies indicate that the tats (e.g., brackish water and freshwater marshes) on American alligator may serve as an “amplifying host” for both private and public lands. Results of these surveys WNV, with infected individuals serving as a direct are used in combination with other information to set source of WNV transmission to uninfected alligators egg-harvest quotas based on alligator abundance in dif- and other susceptible species, including humans (Klenk ferent parts of the state. The LDWF currently has more et al., 2004; Jacobson et al., 2005). than 50 such harvest quotas in place (LDWF, 2016b). Farmers take eggs from nests on properties they lease for Alligator culture methods this purpose. Care is taken to mark the top of each egg as it is removed from the nest to ensure that it remains The first alligator farms were established using captured upright during transport and incubation; the alligator alligators held in semi-natural enclosures. Eggs and embryo, which attaches to the top of the egg shell during hatchlings were produced by natural breeding (Wood- the second day of development, will die if the egg is ward, 1981, Shirley and Elsey, 2015). These enclosures turned over or handled roughly (Bock et al., 2004). At varied widely in size, water area, and composition of veg- the farm, eggs are transferred to an incubator—these are etation. Captive breeding facilities require substantial
REVIEWS IN FISHERIES SCIENCE & AQUACULTURE 91 capital investment to construct and maintain. Care and and minerals are supplemented into the animal carcasses preservation of captive alligators is time-consuming and (Joanen and McNease, 1971, 1981, 1987; Masser, 1993b). costly and consistent successful reproduction is problem- Alligators appear to develop a social structure within a atic because the social, nutritional, and environmental recognized group. Captured wild alligators can be very requirements of adult alligators are poorly understood aggressive when penned with unfamiliar individuals. (Masser, 1993a). It has been observed that adult alliga- Penned wild males have killed rival males and wild tors that have been raised exclusively in captivity (i.e., females will often not mate with unknown or unaccept- confinement) accept crowding and confinement consid- able males. Captive reared alligators are much less erably better than wild captured animals. Captive adults aggressive toward each other especially if penned that were raised together appear to develop a social together before three years of age. Courtship and breed- structure and breed more consistently than wild brood- ing occurs between April and July depending on the cli- stock (Masser, 1993a). mate. Courtship behavior includes vigorous activities Adult breeding enclosures have not had a consis- like rapid swimming and bellowing. Courtship usually tent size but smaller pens (4000 to 8000 m2) function occurs just after sunrise in deep water. Repeated copula- best if the animals need to be captured from the tion is common (Joanen and McNease, 1971; Masser, pens. States that allow holding alligators in captivity 1993a). Reproductive success of captive alligators has have specific regulations for pen design based on been problematic. telemetry studies of wild adults (Joanen and McNease, Nest building and egg laying takes place at night. The 1970, 1972). Maintaining adult alligators in pens female constructs the nest from the surrounding vegeta- requires exceptionally strong fencing with require- tion and soil. Nests are round, mounded structures and ments on welded wire mesh, height, post spacing, eggs are deposited in the center of the mound with vege- rounded corners, wooded frames along the fence bot- tation between layers of eggs and a 0.3 m covering of veg- tom and double hinged and latched gates. Man-made etation. The female guards and protects the nest from water structures include deep water courtship ponds predators and other nesting females. Clutch size varies (i.e., minimum 1.5 m) and small isolation ponds. with condition and age of the female. Larger females usu- Water to land ratio within the pens should be 1:3 ally lay more eggs. Clutch size averages 35 to 40 eggs and pond design should maximize shoreline area with fertility in the range of 70 to 95%. Embryo survival (e.g., “M,” “S,” “W,” or “Z” shapes). Males appear to varies from 70 to 95% and hatching rate from 50 to 90% fight less when they cannot see each other. Vegetation (Masser, 1993a). Eggs taken from wild alligator nests and was generally native marsh species with a rank grow- hatched have higher egg fertility, embryo survival, and ing grass 0.6 to 0.8 m tall preferred (Joanen and hatching rates than the eggs of captive alligators. McNease, 1987; Masser, 1993a). Some producers add While some farms that maintain captive broodstock hay bales in the nesting season to supplement natural as outlined above exist, few farms practice captive breed- vegetation and add shade awnings to prevent over- ing because of the land requirements, care and mainte- heating and reduce burrowing (Masser, 1993a). nance of the adults, and the capital and time investments Adult stocking density should be maintained at four (Shirley and Elsey, 2015). Today most alligator farms are to eight animals per hectare but higher or lower densities based on the “alligator ranching” concept. are preferred by some producers. Female to male ratios Alligator ranching revolves around collection of eggs in the pens is usually at 3:1. Adult alligators 6 to 20 years from alligator nests in the wild or in some cases captur- old are usually dependable breeders with females 8 to ing hatchings then rearing them in intensive grow-out 10 years old the most consistent breeders (Joanen and systems. Louisiana, Florida, and Texas allow eggs and/or McNease, 1987; Masser, 1993a). hatchlings to be removed from the wild under specific Pens should have several feeding stations maintained permits regulated by the state Wildlife, Game and Fish, near basking areas or near the edge of ponds that are eas- or Natural Resource agency (Shirley and Elsey, 2015). In ily accessible from regularly maintained roads or trails to these states, censuses at the end of the breeding and nest- assure the safety of staff. Breeding adults are feed at ing season are conducted to estimate the number of alli- 4–7% body weight per week when water temperatures gator nests and based on the number of nests permits are are above 20 C. Once per week is sufficient with particu- issued to the landowner for collection of a specific num- lar care not to disturb adults during breeding, nesting, ber of eggs (Masser, 2005; Shirley and Elsey, 2015). In and hatching periods (i.e., February through August). Florida and Texas, eggs can be collected from only 50% Diets of adults usually consist of legally captured fish, of the estimated nests. In Louisiana, permits issued to birds, or mammals as available with some commercial landowners have specific numbers of eggs collected from alligator diet. If no commercial diet is fed then vitamins each property and a percentage of the hatchlings must be
92 M. NICKUM ET AL. released back into the wild at age two (i.e., > 0.9 m in grow-out. Uniform sizing reduces competition among length). These management practices assure sustainable the hatchlings (Joanen and McNease, 1976). Density of wild population (Taylor and Neal, 1984; Shirley and hatchlings was maintained at 10 per m2 in the grow-out Elsey, 2015). chambers in the first year then reduced to 3.3 per m2 Eggs are collected generally from airboats or helicop- until age 3 (Joanen and McNease, 1977). ters with special care to keep the aggressive females at bay while the nest is opened and eggs collected for trans- port to grow-out facilities (Masser, 2005; Shirley and Production and markets Elsey, 2015). Collection of eggs is time sensitive because alligator embryos are easily killed by jarring particularly Growth of hatchling alligators to a marketable length from 7 to 28 days. After 28 days of incubation, the of approximately 1.5 m takes about 14 months on embryos are resistant to most handling damage. Eggs most farms, depending on air and water temperature must be kept in the position as laid and can only be repo- and food availability. Some producers have deep wells sitioned in the first 24 hr after being laid. Eggs are that provide a year-round supply of geothermally marked on top so the position can be maintained during heated water; others heat water prior to use. In most transport and incubation. Eggs are placed marks up on cases, growers will maintain temperatures of 29–32 C, 20 to 30 cm of moistened nesting material and another 5 with the highest temperature provided to hatchlings. to 12 cm of nest material on top for transport (Joanen Temperatures are gradually decreased as the animals and McNease, 1987). The age of eggs and where they are grow. Producers who can maintain optimum in development can be determined during incubation by temperature throughout the production period will candling them and observing opaque banding patterns produce a marketable alligator in the shortest time (Ferguson, 1981). (Figure 1 and 2). Some producers use insulated tanks The incubation period for the American alligator eggs for grow-out, although most utilize insulated build- is 65 days. Hatching rates in the wild are less than 60% ings comprising one or more pens with standing (Joanen, 1969). Hatching rates of eggs removed from the pools of water on a concrete floor, often adjacent to wild and artificially incubated usually exceeds 90% dry areas for basking. Alligator “houses” come in a (Masser, 2005). During incubation, the eggs are placed in variety of designs from Quonset types to long rectan- mesh trays in a single layer surrounded by nesting mate- gular sheds similar in shape to commercial poultry rial. Decomposition of the nesting material is critical to houses. The LDWF, and equivalent agencies in other aid in breakdown of the eggshell so hatchlings can pierce states, have specific requirements for alligator produc- the eggshell. The depth of the nesting material should be tion facilities (LDWF, 2011; TPWD, 2013; FFWCC, about 15 cm. The incubation baskets are positioned 7 to 2016). These may be updated periodically as the 8 cm above a heated water bath. The relative humidity agency’s experience with the industry warrants should be a minimum of 90% in the incubator. Nesting (LDWF, 2015). Masser (1993b) and Lane and Ruppert material is moistened with warm water as needed to (1998) provide brief descriptions of typical alligator maintain dampness (Joanen and McNease, 1976). Incu- bation temperature should be between 29.4 C and 32.7 C. After hatching, the hatchlings are maintained in the incubation chamber for 24 hr to allow complete sepa- ration from the egg and umbilical cord detachment (Joanen and McNease, 1979). Sex expression can be manipulated by temperature. Eggs incubated at 29.4 C to 32.7 C will be mixed sex animals. However eggs incu- bated above 33 C will become all males and those below 30 C will be females (Ferguson and Joanen, 1982). Baby alligators make peeping or chirping sounds dur- ing and after hatching. In the wild, this stimulates the female to open the nest so hatchings can escape. In the incubators, unhatched eggs can be opened to free the hatchling, if done without damaging or detaching the umbilical cord. Twenty-four hours after hatching, hatch- lings are sorted into uniform size groups and relocated Figure 1. Alligator Research Facility, Louisiana State University into environmentally controlled chambers for further Agricultural Center (photo by R. Reigh).
REVIEWS IN FISHERIES SCIENCE & AQUACULTURE 93 During the first few months of grow-out, juvenile alliga- tors are fed a high (e.g., 56%) protein diet composed pri- marily of animal tissues, such as slaughterhouse by- products and fishmeal. Farmers typically switch to a lower (e.g., 45—48%) protein diet about 90 days after hatching. Because the minimum dietary requirements of virtually all essential nutrients are unknown for the American alligator, the compounded diets currently used in the alligator-farming industry are based on known nutritional requirements of other farmed animals and the best guesses of commercial feed manufacturers regarding appropriate diet composition for a reptilian carnivore. Current diets are likely to be over fortified with all essential nutrients to ensure that no deficiencies exist. This provides a margin of safety for both the feed Figure 2. Juvenile alligators in temperature-controlled tank, Alli- manufacturer and the farmer, but also adds cost for gator Research Facility, Louisiana State University Agricultural nutrients that are not utilized and which contribute to Center (photo by R. Reigh). (Alternate photo provides a wider view of the tank; same caption as Figure 2; photo by R. Reigh). water quality problems in production systems (Reigh et al., 2013). production houses, although a wide variety of designs As in all intensive aquaculture operations, feed cost is are in use. a major component of alligator production cost. Farmers Regardless of the design of a farm, in all cases the are interested in identifying the nutritional requirements availability of abundant quantities of warm water is a of American alligator to support the development of less necessity. Alligator pens are drained, washed, and refilled expensive diets that will provide options for greater cost with clean water every few days to maintain adequate control. Some of the early work with alligator nutrition hygiene in the production house. Wastewater is directed involved academic studies of metabolism (Coulson and to storage ponds where it may be held for eventual appli- Hernandez, 1983), as well as practical studies of dietary cation to agricultural land or allowed to evaporate. protein-energy balance and suitable sources of energy for Sheffield et al. (2008) identified many considerations feeds (Staton et al., 1990a, 1990b). More recent studies involved in the storage and use of waste water from alli- have evaluated protein-energy ratios in compounded gator production facilities. The cost of heating water and diets (Reigh et al., 2013), determined the availability for the availability of water in sufficient quantity, and of ade- alligator of energy and amino acids in feedstuffs (Reigh quate quality, to meet production needs are among the and Williams, 2013), tested the first plant-based diets for primary concerns of persons designing or managing an alligator aquaculture (Reigh and Williams, 2014), and alligator farm. identified optimum feeding rates (Reigh and Williams, Besides the critical need for a warm, clean environ- 2016). However, much work remains to be done to ment, good quality food is essential for the profitable identify the nutritional needs of this poorly understood production of farmed alligator. In the early days of alliga- species. tor farming, producers fed whatever meat products they The Louisiana alligator industry utilizes best manage- could obtain—including red meat, poultry, and fish— ment practices in all aspects of alligator farming sometimes mixed with pelleted animal feeds and vitamin (LDWF, 2011), including the use of humane slaughter supplements (Joanen and McNease, 1971; Elsey et al., methods, which are regularly reviewed by veterinarians 1994). While such diets could be reasonably effective, and the LDWF and modified as necessary to ensure that they were difficult to store, unpleasant to handle, and the best available practices are adopted by producers prone to creating water quality problems. The need for (LDWF, 2015). Most farmed alligators are harvested at a dry, off-the-shelf alligator feeds was eventually addressed length of 1–1.5 m after 14–16 months of growth; how- with the advent of commercially manufactured, extruded ever, production times can vary considerably among diets produced in the same manner as dry pet foods and farms depending on culture conditions. The skins of ani- pelletized fish feeds. Formulated diets are now the indus- mals in this size range are used for watchbands, belts, try standard for alligator production. wallets, and other small leather items. Skins from larger When hatched, a young alligator may subsist on the animals may be suitable for handbags, footwear, and internal remnants of its yolk sac for several days, after similar products. The most valuable part of an alligator which it will accept a feed pellet of appropriate size. is the belly skin, which has an attractive scale pattern
94 M. NICKUM ET AL. and particular characteristics that are well suited to the American alligator is commonly found; however, all the tanning process. During slaughter, the belly skin is meat currently produced from farmed animals is sold. removed from the carcass, scraped of excess tissue, Meat production, as a by-product of the skin trade, fluc- salted, and rolled for storage. Skins are sold to tannery tuates with global demand for alligator skins. In 2015, representatives who visit farms to inspect, grade, and Louisiana farmers sold more than 445,000 kg of alligator purchase skins on-site. The majority of Louisiana- meat worth nearly $US7 million (LDWF, 2016b). As was produced skins are shipped to France or Italy for tan- the case with skin sales, meat sales in 2015 and 2014 ning. Domestically, one alligator tannery operates in the (465,000 kg that year) were the highest on record for the state of Louisiana, and three other U.S. tanneries, in Flor- state’s farmed alligator industry. ida, Georgia and New York also process alligator skins. An interesting value-added aspect of alligator aqua- culture is the production of novel compounds with potential biomedical applications. Alligator blood is Markets: Present and future known to possess antimicrobial properties that could Alligator skins are sold by quality grade and belly width. yield compounds useful as bacterial growth inhibitors Grade 1 skins have no discernible blemishes (e.g., for wound dressings and other medical applications scratches or scars) and command the highest price. Belly (Merchant et al., 2003). Research at Louisiana State width is measured at a standard point behind the front University has identified a number of useful compounds legs, running from the ventral midline to approximately in alligator tissues (e.g., collagens, elastin, proteoglycans) half-way up each side of the body. In 2015, more than that could have a variety of medical, cosmetic, and food 327,000 skins were sold in Louisiana for more than applications (Bogren, 2007). $US64.2 million (LDWF, 2016b). Average belly width of In 2013, the last year for which global market data skins sold that year was 26.2 cm, with an average selling have been published, the worldwide crocodilian skin price of $7.50 per centimeter. Skin sales in 2015 and trade totaled 1,888,634 skins, of which 878,332 skins 2014 (342,000 skins that year) were the highest recorded (46.5%) were “classic skins” derived from American alli- since Louisiana’s farmed-alligator harvests began. gator and seven species of crocodiles (Caldwell, 2015). In addition to skin sales, markets for alligator meat Caiman skins (four species) composed the remainder of have grown in the U.S. and internationally, primarily in the trade. Within the classic-skin category, American Asia. During eight years of the ten-year (2004–2013) alligator constituted 54.8% of the global market, followed period described by Caldwell (2015), the global market by Nile crocodile at 29.4%. The 2013 market for nearly for crocodilian meat from all sources averaged about 500 1.9 million skins was the largest observed during the ten- metric tons (mt) annually, with substantial increases — year period reported by Caldwell (2015). During this to nearly 1000 mt annually — in only two of the years on time (2004–2013), total global trade averaged 1,404,433 record (2006 and 2007). Alligator meat from the U.S. § 256,121 crocodilian skins per year; of this total, the was the primary trade item until 1992; exported to trade in American alligator averaged 342,517 § 74,167 Canada, Japan, Taiwan, China, and the United Kingdom. skins annually. U.S. exports began falling in the mid-1990s. In Alligator farming serves a particular segment of the 2011–2013, Canada and Hong Kong were primary skin trade. As such, farmed skins do not compete in export markets for U.S. alligator meat (Caldwell, 2015). the marketplace with skins obtained from wild alliga- Alligator meat is lean, averaging 20% protein and tors taken by licensed hunters. Original concerns 3–5% fat depending on cut (i.e., tail vs. body meat). Rela- about potentially negative impacts of alligator farming tive to beef and pork, it is a low-fat food containing pri- on management of the wild resource (e.g., by making marily unsaturated fats—69% in alligator vs. 47% and poaching more difficult to control) have proved to be 56% unsaturated fats in beef and pork, respectively (Leak unfounded. Alligator farming has, in fact, significantly et al., 2003). While consumption of unsaturated fats is contributed to conservation of the wild resource while recommended for human health, the chemical structure providing economic benefits to farmers and land- of these compounds makes them highly susceptible to owners (Moyle, 2013). oxidative rancidity when exposed to air. Thus, it is criti- It is difficult to estimate the growth potential of alliga- cal for alligator meat to be handled and stored properly tor farming, but the market for American alligator skins to retain quality. appears to have been relatively stable for more than a In most parts of the United States, alligator meat is an decade. In 2015, the number of skins sold by Louisiana unusual commodity. Given its novelty as a food item, a farmers, who produce the majority of alligator skins that market development campaign will be needed to sub- enter global trade, was not greatly different (327,228; stantially increase demand outside the areas where LDWF, 2016b) than the average number produced in
REVIEWS IN FISHERIES SCIENCE & AQUACULTURE 95 2004–2013 (342,517; derived from Caldwell, 2015). The sometimes were added. Today, formulated feeds current business model, based on exploitation of a man- designed specifically for alligators are the norm. Dis- aged, natural resource, is susceptible to impacts from ease is seldom a problem in alligator production natural disasters, such as hurricanes and floods, which operations. As with other forms of aquaculture, clean can destroy resources that support the farming industry. water, sanitary conditions, and high quality feed lead Producers are particularly exposed to the effects of eco- to few disease problems. nomic recession resulting from the high cost of luxury Skins, especially the underside, are the primary prod- products made with alligator skins; and the use of alliga- uct from alligator aquaculture; however, the meat has a tor skins for what some consider to be unnecessary prod- steady market as a novelty item in niche markets. Alliga- ucts is controversial among consumers (Summers et al., tor flesh is lean, firm, and mild-flavored, averaging only 2006). Given the nature of the natural, economic, and 3–5% fat. It is considerably richer in unsaturated fats societal constraints on industry growth, it would be pru- than beef or pork. Although leather products made from dent to expect that alligator farming will grow at a pace alligator skins have strong, steady consumer appeal, the similar to that experienced during the last decade. The fact that these products are found primarily in luxury development of new markets for alligator products, with markets is something of a mixed blessing. The demand is a wider range of price points, could stimulate additional relatively steady and predictable, but the size of the mar- growth within the limits that the natural resource can ket is limited in comparison to less exotic forms of support under current regulations. Growth beyond that leather. The effects of weather events on reproduction of limitation will require the development of a new para- wild alligators, the source of most eggs, are an uncontrol- digm for alligator production; one based on development lable factor for alligator farmers, as are economic condi- of a strain of genetically selected animals more similar to tions that can affect demand for products. The future, domesticated livestock than to the wild creatures upon nevertheless, for alligator aquaculture appears to be one which the industry now depends. of “steady as we go;” a future much like the experiences of the past 10–15 years; not marked by sudden drops in the market, nor rapid expansion. Summary and recommendations American alligator “farming” in the form of maintaining alligators in captivity has a history of more than 100 years; References however, it is only in the last 50 years that actual com- Anonymous. Crocodiles and alligator farms. Available from mercial operations designed to rear them from eggs to Americana-alligator.com (2014). harvest size animals have been in operation. Today, alliga- Bock, J. L., Woodward, A. R., Linda, S. B., Percival, H. F., and tor farming is an aquacultural industry worth tens of mil- Carbonneau, D. A. Hatching success of American alligator lions of dollars in the southern United States, practiced eggs when subjected to simulated collection trauma, pp. 323–335. In: Proceedings of the Annual Conference of the primarily in Louisiana, Florida, Georgia, and Texas. In Southeastern Association of Fish and Wildlife Agencies. 2014, farmers in Louisiana, the nation’s largest producer Southeastern Association of Fish and Wildlife Agencies of captive-reared alligators, sold more than 383,000 m of (2004). skins valued at more than $77 million. Florida, the second Bogren, R. C. Alligator collagen: New source for medical, cos- largest alligator-farming state, produced only one-tenth of metic uses. Louisiana Agric., 50(1): 29. Available from http://www.lsuagcenter.com/portals/communications/publi Louisiana’s output that same year. cations/agmag/archive/2007/winter/alligator-collagen-new- Most alligator farming operations can be consid- source-for-medical-cosmetic-uses (2007). ered as “hatch and grow” facilities. They do not Brattstrom, B. H. Body temperatures of reptiles. American maintain captive broodstock. Eggs are collected from Midland Naturalist, 73(2): 376–422 (1965). the wild under the authority of permits issued by Brien, M. L., Cherkiss, M. S., Parry, M. W., and Frank, J. M. State agencies. Typically, these permits include a Housing Crocodilians in Captivity: Considerations for Central America and Caribbean. Extension Circular 1513, requirement to return a percentage (e.g., 12%) of the University of Florida (2007). farm-reared animals to the same area where the eggs Caldwell, J. World trade in crocodilian skins 2011–2013. United were collected. Besides the critical need for a warm, Nations Environment Program–World Conservation clean environment, good quality food is essential for Monitoring Center (UNEP-WCMC) Technical Report, the profitable production of farmed alligator. In the Cambridge, United Kingdom. Available from http://www. alligatorfur.com/alligator/IACTS15.pdf (2015). early days of alligator farming, producers fed what- Chang, L. T., and Olson, R. Gilded age, Gilded cage. Nat. Geo. ever meat products they could obtain, such as, red Mag., 213(5): 1–194 (2008). meat, poultry, and fish. Pelleted animal feeds and Colbert, E. H., Cowles, R. B., Bogert, C. M. Temperature toler- vitamin supplements designed for other species ances in the American alligator and their bearing on the
96 M. NICKUM ET AL. habits, evolution, and extinction of the dinosaurs. Bull. Joanen, T. Nesting ecology of alligators in Louisiana, American Museum of Natural History, 86: 327–374 (1946). pp. 141–151. In: Proceedings of the 23th Annual Conference Coulson, R.A., and Hernandez, T. Biochemistry of the alligator: of the Southeastern Association of Game and Fish Commis- a study of metabolism in slow motion. Baton Rouge, LA: sioners (1969). Louisiana State University Press (1964). Joanen, T., and McNease, L. A telemetric study of nesting Coulson, R. A., and Hernandez, T. Alligator Metabolism: Stud- female alligators on Rockefeller Refuge, Louisiana, pp. 175– ies on Chemical Reactions in Vivo, pp. 182. New York, NY: 193. In: Proceedings of the 24th Annual Conference of the Pergamon Press (1983). Southeastern Association of Game and Fish Commissioners Dzoma, B. M., Sejoe, S., Segwagwe, B. V., and June, E. (1970). Commercial crocodile farming in Botswana. Trop. Anim. Joanen, T., and McNease, L. Propagation of the American alli- Health Prod., 40(5): 377–381 (2008). gator in captivity, pp. 106–116. In: Proceedings of the 25th Elsey, R. M., Joanen, T., and McNease, L. Captive breeding Annual Conference of the Southeastern Association of Game of alligators and other crocodilians, pp. 1–35 In: Croco- and Fish Commissioners (1971). diles. Proceedings of the 2nd Regional (Eastern Asia, Oce- Joanen, T., and McNease, L. A telemetric study of adult male ania, Australasia) Conference of the Crocodile Specialist alligators on Rockefeller Refuge, Louisiana, pp. 252–275. In: Group, International Union for Conservation of Nature Proceedings of the 26th Annual Conference of the Southeast- and Natural Resources, Gland, Switzerland. Available ern Association of Game and Fish Commissioners (1972). from http://www.rwrefuge.com/uploads/4/9/4/2/ Joanen, T., and McNease, L. Notes on the reproductive biology 49423019/elsey_et_al_1993_captive_breeding_of_alliga and captive propagation of the American alligator, pp. 407– tors.pdf (1994). 415. In: Proceedings of the 29th Annual Conference of the Farfan-Ali, J. A., Bradley, J. B., Nicole, L., Marıa, A~ no-Pino., , Southeastern Association of Game and Fish Commissioners Puerto-Manzano, F., Garcıa-Rejon, J. E., Rosado-Paredes, (1975). E. P., Flores-Flores, L. F., Jaidy Chaves-Medina, A. O.-S., Joanen, T., and McNease, L. Notes on the reproductive biology Cremieux-Grimaldi, J. C., Gerson Henandez-Gaona, F. C.- and captive biology of the American alligator, pp. 407–415. M., Mendez-Galvan, J. F., and Beaty, B. J. Antibodies to In: Proceedings of the 30th Annual Conference of the West Nile virus in asymptomatic mammals, birds, and rep- Southeastern Association of Game and Fish Commissioners tiles in the Yucatan Peninsula of Mexico. Am. J. Trop. Med. (1976). Hyg., 74(5): 908–914 (2006). Joanen, T., and McNease, L. Artificial incubation of alligator Ferguson, M. W. J. The application of embryological studies to eggs and post-hatching culture in controlled environmental alligator farming, pp. 129–145. In: Proc. Alligator Produc- chambers, pp. 483–490. In: Proceedings of the Annual Meet- tion Conf. Gainesville, Florida (1981). ing of the World Mariculture Society (1977). Ferguson, M. W. J., and Joanen, T. Temperature of egg incuba- Joanen, T., and McNease, L. Culture of the American alligator. tion determines sex in Alligator mississippiensis. Nature, Int. Zoo Yearbook, 19(1): 61–66 (1979). 296: 850–853 (1982). Joanen, T., and McNease, L. Reproductive biology of the FFWCC (Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commis- American alligator in southwest Louisiana, pp. 153–159. In: sion). Estimated producer value of alligator harvests on Flor- Reproductive Biology and Diseases of Captive Reptiles. Con- ida farms 1977–2014. Available from http://myfwc.com/ tributions to Herpetology Number 1, (J. B. Murphy and J. T. media/310191/alligator-farm-value.pdf (2015). Collins, Eds.). Oxford, Ohio: Society for the Study of FFWCC (Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commis- Amphibians and Reptiles (1980). sion). Alligator regulations and associated statutes 2016– Joanen, T., and McNease, L. Management of the alligator as a 2017. Available from http://myfwc.com/media/1531908/alli renewable natural resource in Louisiana. Georgia Dept. Nat. gator-rules-booklet.pdf (2016). Resour. Tech. Bull., 5: 62–72 (1981). Fuller, M. K., Smithson, P. C., and Doerr, P. D. Growth rates Joanen, T., and McNease, L. The management of alligators in and age of sexual maturity of American alligators in North Louisiana, U.S.A., pp. 33–42. In: Wildlife Management: Carolina. pp. 1–85. In: Status of the American alligator in Crocodiles and Alligators (G. J. W. Webb, S. C. Manolis, North Carolina. Raleigh, NC: North Carolina State Univer- and P. J. Whitehead Eds.). Chipping Norton: Surrey Beatty sity (1983). & Sons (1987). Heykoop, J., and Frechette, D. L. Gatornomics: Profitable and Joanen, T., McNease, L., Elsey, R. M., and Staton, M. A. sustainable use of alligators in the southeastern United Commercial consumptive use of the American alligator States. Mar. Resour. Econ., 16: 127–142 (2001). (Alligator mississippiensis) in Louisiana, pp. 466–506. In: Huchzermeyer, F. W. Public health risks of ostrich and croco- Harvesting Wild Species: Implications for Biodiversity Con- dile meat. Rev. Sci. Tech. Off. Int. Epiz. Sci. Tech. Rev. Off. servation (C. H. Freese, Ed.). Baltimore, MD: Johns Hop- Int. Epiz. (Paris), 16(2): 599–604 (1997). kins University Press (1997). Huchzermeyer, F. W. Diseases of farmed crocodiles and Klenk, K., Snow, J., Morgan, K., Bowen, R. A., Stephens, ostriches. Rev. Sci. Tech. Off. Int. Epiz. Sci. Tech. Rev. Off. M., Foster, F., Gordy, P., Beckett, S., Komar, N., Gubler, Int. Epiz. (Paris), 21(2): 265–276 (2002). D., and Bunning, M. L. Alligators as West Nile virus Jacobson, E. R., Ginn, P. E., Troutman, J. M., Farina, L., Stark, amplifiers. Emerg. Infect. Dis., 10(12): 2150–2155 Avail- L., Klenk, K., Burkhalter, K. L., and Komar, N. West Nile able from http://wwwnc.cdc.gov/eid/article/10/12/04- virus infection in farmed American alligators (Alligator mis- 0264 (2004). sissippiensis) in Florida. J. Wild. Dis., 41(1): 96–106. Avail- Lance, V. A. Alligator physiology and life history: the impor- able from http://digitalcommons.unl.edu/cgi/viewcontent. tance of temperature. Experimental Gerontology, 38(7): cgi?articleD2039&contextDicwdm_usdanwrc (2005). 801–805 (2003).
You can also read