Vietnam Property Market Brief - 1Q21 Research

Page created by Gloria Patel
 
CONTINUE READING
Vietnam Property Market Brief - 1Q21 Research
Vietnam | April 2021

Research

Vietnam Property
Market Brief
1Q21
Credit image: Vu Long / EyeEm
Vietnam Property Market Brief - 1Q21 Research
Contents
 VIETNAM’S ECONOMIC BACKDROP                                              3

 HO CHI MINH CITY                                                         5           HANOI                                                       10
 Office                                                                    5          Office                                                      10
    With new completions, vacancy rises in 4Q20                                         Two Grade B buildings enter the market
                                                                                         More weakening demand in Grade A than
    Negative net absorption recorded across the segment
                                                                                          Grade B
    Rents stabilise in 4Q20                                                             Rents decrease slightly across the market
 Retail                                                                    6          Retail                                                      11
    New supply comes from renovated department stores                                   One new completion enters the market
                                                                                         Demand shows signs of recovery with positive
    Occupancy rate varies across Prime and Non-Prime malls
                                                                                          net absorption
    Rents remain stable                                                                 Rents remain largely stable in 4Q20
 Apartment for Sale                                                        7          Apartment for Sale                                          12
    Limited new supply continues, yet signs of improvement                              Supply additions drop in 4Q20, following the
     are clearer                                                                          surge last quarter
                                                                                         Affordable and Mid-end segments continue to
    Thu Duc City now becomes the market spotlight
                                                                                          lead the sales
                                                                                         Price increment in suburban market records a
    Most developers remain confident in their pricing
                                                                                          new high
 SOUTHERN      [1]                                                        8           NORTHERN       [1]                                          13
 Ready-built Landed Property                                               8          Ready-built Landed Property                                 14
    New Supply volumes return to a low level                                            New Supply volumes return to a low level
    Buyers’ sentiment shows strong in the quarter                                       Buyers’ sentiment shows strong in the quarter
    Primary Prices remain at a high level                                               Primary Prices remain at a high level
 Industrial Land & Ready-built RBF                                        9           Industrial Land & Ready-built RBF                           15
    Most of the recent land transactions take place via online                          Most of the recent land transactions take place
     platform                                                                             via online platform
    Southern supply still takes the lead in Vietnam                                     Southern supply still takes the lead in Vietnam
    Land prices reach a new peak                                                        Land prices reach a new peak

IMPORTANT NOTES
[1] In this report, Southern RBL ma rket a nd Southern Industria l ma rket refers to HCMC, Binh Duong, Dong Na i, Ba Ria – Vung Ta u a nd Long An
ma rkets only. Mea nwhile, Northern RBL ma rket refers to Ha noi, Ha i Phong, Ba c Ninh, Hung Yen a nd Vinh Phuc ma rkets; a nd Northern Industria l
ma rket refers to Ha noi, Ha i Phong, Ba c Ninh, Hung Yen a nd Ha i Duong ma rkets only. .
Since the beginning
COPYRIGHT      © JONESofLANG
                         2021,LASALLE
                                JLL Resea
                                       IP,rch a pplies
                                           INC.        a new
                                                2020. All    graReserved
                                                          Rights ding system a nd methodology for processing ma rket da ta to better reflect the ma rket
situa tion. This might subsequently result in some cha nges in historica l da ta .
VIETNAM’S ECONOMIC BACKDROP
Vietnam continues to record a positive       Figure 1: Real GDP Growth (y-o-y)
GDP growth in 1Q21: Vietnam’s GDP
                                              %
expanded 4.48% y-o-y in 1Q21, higher         8
than the 1Q20’s level of 3.8%. This
                                             6
positive economic growth was attributed
                                             4
to the strong performances of all sectors.
                                             2
While manufacturing sector was still an
                                             0
engine of growth (6.3% y-o-y), the

                                                   Q1.14

                                                                 Q1.15

                                                                         Q1.16

                                                                                         Q1.17

                                                                                                    Q1.18

                                                                                                                   Q1.19

                                                                                                                                 Q1.20

                                                                                                                                                Q1.21
recovery of the services sector was also
noticeable (3.3% y-o-y), bolstered by the                                           Quarterly GDP              GDP YTD

strong containment of Covid-19 and the
effective EVFTA. Meanwhile, the              Figure 2: Retail Sales vs. International Arrivals Growth (year-to-date, y-o-y)
agriculture, forestry and fishery has
                                                  %                                                                                                         %
recorded a solid growth (3.2% y-o-
                                                 12                                                                                                     80
y)thanks to containment of African swine          9
                                                                                                                                                        60
fever and the fairly favorable climate.                                                                                                                 40
                                                  6                                                                                                     20
                                                                                                                                                        0
Amidst the third wave of Covid-19, the            3
                                                                                                                                                        -20
positive performance in 1Q21 has shown            0                                                                                                     -40
                                                            Jul-19

                                                            Jul-20
                                                           Jan-20

                                                           Jan-21
                                                           Nov-19

                                                           Nov-20
                                                           Apr-19

                                                           Feb-20

                                                           Apr-20

                                                           Feb-21
                                                           Mar-21
                                                           Mar-19

                                                           Mar-20
                                                           May-19

                                                           May-20
                                                           Jun-19

                                                           Jun-20
                                                           Oct-19

                                                           Oct-20
                                                           Dec-19

                                                           Dec-20
                                                           Aug-19

                                                           Aug-20
                                                           Sep-19

                                                           Sep-20
the great effort of the government and            -3                                                                                                    -60
                                                                                                                                                        -80
enterprises to sustain the economic               -6
                                                                                                                                                        -100
growth rate. However, in order to achieve         -9                                                                                                    -120
                                                                            Real Retail Sales           International Arrivals (RHS)
the target growth rate of 6.5% in 2021,
challenges remain ahead.                     Figure 3: FDI (year-to-date)

Retail sales show signs of                             USD million.
                                                 40
improvement whereas foreign visitors
                                                 30
to Vietnam continue to plunge: Though
                                                 20
new variants of Covid-19 has forced many
                                                 10
countries in the world into lockdown
                                                  0
again, including Vietnam, the country’s
                                                            Jul-19

                                                            Jul-20

                                                           Jan-21
                                                           Jan-19

                                                           Jan-20
                                                           Nov-19

                                                           Nov-20
                                                           Apr-20

                                                           Feb-21
                                                           Feb-19

                                                           Apr-19

                                                           Feb-20

                                                           Mar-21
                                                           Mar-19

                                                           Mar-20
                                                           May-19

                                                           May-20
                                                           Jun-19

                                                           Jun-20
                                                           Oct-19

                                                           Oct-20
                                                           Dec-19

                                                           Dec-20
                                                           Aug-19

                                                           Aug-20
                                                           Sep-19

                                                           Sep-20

retail sales and consumer services still
showed signs of improvement in 1Q21.                                               FDI Registered           FDI Disbursement

The total retail sales of consumer goods                                                                             Source: General Statistics Office
and services in 1Q21 were estimated to
rise by 5.1% y-o-y, indicating that the      Vietnam’s FDI bounced back: Total                      Electricity production and distribution
consumption demand has gradually             foreign investment amounted to USD                     industry took the lead at nearly USD 5
recovered. In tandem, goods                  10.1 billion in 1Q21, up 18.5% y-o-y.                  billion, accounting for 50% of the total
transportation activities in 1Q21            Specifically, FDI disbursement totalled                registered investment. Manufacturing
witnessed an increase of 10.2% y-o-y,        USD 4.1 billion, up 6.5% y-o-y. Even                   with USD 3.9 billion ranked in second
whereas domestic travelling was still        though the FDI influx has shown a                      place, equivalent to 39% of the total.
hindered due to the Covid-19 resurgence      rebound trend in comparison to the                     Following by real estate activities with
in late January. Number of passengers        previous year, the third wave of Covid-                USD 600 million. In terms of investment
travelling domestically declined by 11.8%    19 pandemic sweeping across the                        partners, Singapore lead in 1Q21 with
y-o-y in 1Q21.                               globe has forced countries to roll back                nearly USD 4.6 billion, accounting for
                                             the plans to ease the restrictions on                  45.5% of the total investment. This was
International visitors to Vietnam shrank     international travel and thus, hindered                followed by Japan and South Korea
by 98.7% y-o-y to just more than 48,000      the global capital movement.                           with USD 2.1 billion and USD 1.2 billion
as borders remained closed.                                                                         respectively.
                                             Of the 17 sectors invested in 1Q21, the                                                      3
VIETNAM’S ECONOMIC BACKDROP
CPI stabilises: Average CPI in 1Q21           Number of new businesses declines                                            were new and small enterprises who
increased 0.29% y-o-y, the slowest            but registered capital records an                                            are the most vulnerable to the Covid-
growth rate over the last 20 years.           improvement: In 1Q21, Vietnam has                                            19 pandemic.
                                              29,300 newly registered enterprises
The CPI increase in 1Q21 is attributed to:                                                                                 In the recent survey, manufacturing
                                              with a total registered capital of more
(1) the rice price increased 8.55% y-o-y                                                                                   enterprises have revealed solid
                                              than VND 447,800 billion, down 1.4% y-
owing to the increasing trend in                                                                                           confidence in the market prospects.
                                              o-y in the number of enterprises but up
exporting price and the peak demand                                                                                        68.6% of enterprises agreed that
                                              27.5 % y-o-y in registered capital. The
during the Tet holiday; (2) gas price also                                                                                 business performance in 1Q21 has
                                              average registered capital of a newly
saw an increase of 7.58% y-o-y attributed                                                                                  been improved compared to 4Q20,
                                              established enterprise reached VND
to the fluctuation of the global gas price;                                                                                and 85.1% of them were optimistic
                                              15.3 billion, up 29.3% y-o-y. Meanwhile,
and (3) due to the increase in tuition fee                                                                                 about the economic outlook in 2Q21.
                                              the number of terminated business
accordingly to decree 86/2015/NĐ-CP,
                                              increased by 28.2% y-o-y. Most of them
education cost grew at 4.49% y-o-y rate,
                                              Figure 4: CPI – Overall
which contributed to the overall increase
of CPI.                                         %                                                                                                                                 %
                                              8.0                                                                                                                                     8.0
In the opposite direction, a number of
                                              6.0                                                                                                                                     6.0
factors contributed to curbing CPI growth
                                              4.0                                                                                                                                     4.0
in 1Q21. The demand for travel and
                                              2.0                                                                                                                                     2.0
tourism went down amidst the epidemic,        0.0                                                                                                                                     0.0
causing a drop in transportation costs.
                                                      Jul-19

                                                      Jul-20
                                                     Jan-20

                                                     Jan-21
                                                     Nov-19

                                                     Nov-20
                                                     Apr-19

                                                     Feb-20

                                                     Apr-20

                                                     Feb-21
                                                     Mar-21
                                                     Mar-19

                                                     Mar-20
                                                     May-19

                                                     May-20
                                                     Jun-19

                                                     Jun-20
                                                     Oct-19

                                                     Oct-20
                                                     Dec-19

                                                     Dec-20
                                                     Aug-19

                                                     Aug-20
                                                     Sep-19

                                                     Sep-20
                                              -2.0                                                                                                                                    -2.0
Besides, the Government also rolled out
packages such as electricity price cuts to                                                           y-o-y                        m-o-m (RHS)
support enterprises during the outbreak
of Covid-19, which helped to suppress
                                              Figure 5: CPI – Housing & Construction Materials
CPI. A decline of petrol and oil prices in
1Q21 also constrained the CPI growth.
                                                 %                                                                                                                          %
Positive export-import turnover hints          5.0                                                                                                                                5.0
trade rebound in 1Q21: Thanks to the           4.0                                                                                                                                4.0
                                                                                                                                                                                  3.0
                                               3.0                                                                                                                                2.0
new FTAs in 2020, 1Q21 has seen a              2.0                                                                                                                                1.0
concrete performance of export and             1.0                                                                                                                                0.0
                                               0.0                                                                                                                                -1.0
import activities. Despite the gloom cast                                                                                                                                         -2.0
                                                                       Jul-19

                                                                                                                                     Jul-20

                                              -1.0
                                                                                                       Jan-20

                                                                                                                                                                Jan-21
                                                                                            Nov-19

                                                                                                                                                       Nov-20
                                                     Mar-19

                                                                                                                Mar-20

                                                                                                                                                                         Mar-21
                                                              May-19

                                                                                                                         May-20
                                                                                   Sep-19

                                                                                                                                              Sep-20

                                                                                                                                                                                  -3.0
by the new variants of Covid-19 virus,        -2.0                                                                                                                                -4.0

total export-import turnover stood at
USD 152.7 billion, up 24.1% y-o-y. Of                                                                y-o-y                        m-o-m (RHS)

which, export values were estimated at        Figure 6: Merchandise Trade Balance
USD 77.3 billion in 1Q21, up 22% y-o-y,
                                                USD billion                                                                                                                       %
while imports were at USD 75.3 billion, up      6.0                                                                                                                               15.0
26.3% y-o-y in 1Q21. The country                4.0                                                                                                                               10.0
remained in trade surplus of USD 2.03           2.0                                                                                                                               5.0
                                                0.0                                                                                                                               0.0
billion in 1Q21, mainly attributed to the      -2.0                                                                                                                               -5.0
trade surplus with EU. In terms of trade       -4.0                                                                                                                               -10.0
                                               -6.0                                                                                                                               -15.0
partners, the United States and China
                                                                       Jul-19

                                                                                                                                     Jul-20
                                                                                                       Jan-20

                                                                                                                                                                Jan-21
                                                                                            Nov-19

                                                                                                                                                       Nov-20
                                                     Mar-19

                                                                                                                Mar-20

                                                                                                                                                                         Mar-21
                                                              May-19

                                                                                                                         May-20
                                                                                   Sep-19

                                                                                                                                              Sep-20

were the two largest export partners,
whereas China and South Korea were the                                          Monthly Actual Levels                             % of Merchandise Exports (RHS)
leading import markets for products from
                                                                                            Source: General Statistics Office, General Department of Vietnam Custom
Vietnam.
                                                                                                                                                                                            4
HCMC
             Office Market
Rents[1]                Tight vacancy persists

USD 30.6                Two Grade B buildings and one Grade C buildings completed in 1Q21, adding nearly 35,000 sqm of
                        office space to the market. Location-wise, Go Vap District contributed nearly half of the new
per sqm per month,
net on NLA              supply with two new buildings, helping expand further the office cluster surrounding airport.
                        Following the completion of APC Building last quarter, Binh Thanh welcome one more Grade B
                        building namely CII Building. This project was leased out to one anchor tenant in 1Q21.

Rent Change y-o-y       Since most of the new Grade B buildings are small-scale with limited leasable area, coupled with

+2.1%                   no new Grade A buildings were added in the quarter, Grade A &B vacancy remained tight at 12.4%.

                        Large leases in new buildings drive net absorption
                        In 1Q21, Grade A and Grade B recorded net absorption of approx. 500 sqm each, driven by large
                        lease transaction (greater than 1,000 sqm each) in newly added buildings. Meanwhile, many
                        longstanding buildings continued to witness negative absorption amid soft demand caused by
Stage in Rent Cycle     economic uncertainty. Demand continued to be driven by technology and insurance companies in

Stable                  1Q21 and most of the transactions were signed for expansion purpose.

                        Rents remain resilient
                        The average rents of Grade A&B market remained stable at USD 30.6 per sqm per month in 1Q21,
                        inched up 0.5% q-o-q and 2.1% y-o-y. While most districts recorded stable asking rents, District 7,
                        home to many new completions recently, witnessed the asking rent increase by 2-3 % q-o-q. The
                        increasing activities in office developments in District 7 recently has gradually shaped a distinct
                        office cluster in this area with better rental level compared to District 1, the traditional office
                        cluster of the city. However, amid the currently soft demand, landlords of newly-completed
                        buildings has been under pressure to lease space and thus often offer favourable rental
                        concessions and flexible negotiation terms to support and attract tenants.

                        Outlook: Limited vacancy supports rental growth but at a slow pace
                        Very limited new supply is expected till 4Q21. Only two Grade B buildings in Non-CBD area will be
                        completed in the next nine months, adding nearly 20,000 sqm office space to the market. Grade A
                        market will remain tight since no new addition is expected and all existing buildings have posted
                        high occupancy rate. As the demand likely stays subdued until the virus is globally contained,
                        rents expected to grow at higher pace compared to 2020 yet still lower than 2017-19 period.

                        Figure 7: Office Total Stock                                                                   Figure 8: Office Average Rents
                        (‘000 sqm NLA)                                                                                 (USD/sqm/month)
                               3,000                                                                           100%    50
                               2,500                                                                           80%
                                                                                                                       40
                               2,000
                                                                                                               60%
                               1,500                                                                                   30
                                                                                                               40%
                               1,000
                                                                                                               20%     20
                                 500
                                    0                                                                          0%      10
                                         2013
                                                2014
                                                       2015
                                                              2016
                                                                     2017
                                                                            2018
                                                                                   2019
                                                                                          2020

                                                                                                        2021
                                                                                                 1Q21

                                                                                                                            1Q18
                                                                                                                            2Q18
                                                                                                                            3Q18
                                                                                                                            4Q18
                                                                                                                            1Q19
                                                                                                                            2Q19
                                                                                                                            3Q19
                                                                                                                            4Q19
                                                                                                                            1Q20
                                                                                                                            2Q20
                                                                                                                            3Q20
                                                                                                                            4Q20
                                                                                                                            1Q21
                                                                                                                            4Q21

                                        Grade A                                                  Grade B
                                        Grade C                                                  Total future supply                  Grade A                  Grade B
                                        A&B Occ. Rate (RHS)
                         Note:
                         [1] Rents refers to average net rent of the Grade A and B office markets, excluding VAT and service charges.
                         [2] Flexible space represents a variety of workspaces used by occupiers to increase their portfolio flexibility through short- to medium-term leases.
                         [3] CBD area refers to District 1. Non-CBD area refers to the rest of the city.
                         Source: JLL Research                                                                                                                                  5
HCMC
                     Retail Market
Prime Rents [1]                                   Vacancy rate stays stable with limited take-up recorded

USD 40.5                                          No new malls was completed in the quarter yet the re-layout work in Van Hanh Mall that enhanced
                                                  its ground floor efficiency has helped to add an extra 1,500 sqm NLA to the supply basket. As of
per sqm per month,
net on NLA                                        1Q21, total retail supply in HCMC stood at 1 mil sqm NLA, combining 40 malls classified as
                                                  Community center, Regional shopping center and Super regional center [2]. Of the total 40 malls,
                                                  only twelve are considered as Prime properties[1], yet these malls accounted for up to 49% of total
                                                  retail space.
Prime Rent Change y-o-y
-0.54%                                            With limited take-up in both City centre and City fringe [3], the vacancy rate remained unchanged q-
                                                  o-q, stood at 2.9% and 4.1 % in City Centre and City Fringe respectively.

                                                  Retail leasing remains challenging
                                                  Net absorption in 1Q21 stood at 1,229 sqm, lower than 2,447 sqm recorded in 4Q20. Since most
                                                  high-quality malls posted low vacancy rate, the take-up was limited. Uniqlo continued to open the
Stage in Rent Cycle                               HCMC’s fourth stores in Van Hanh Mall in the quarter. Sized of 2,000 sqm, this transaction was the

Stable                                            key contributor to the quarter’s net absorption.

                                                  Compared to Hanoi, the third outbreak less affected the HCMC retail market. However, challenges
                                                  remains to most retailers. The market still witnessed many retailers, especially in lifestyle, toys and
                                                  apparel categorises, for instance Mumuso, Funny Land and H:Connect, shutting down their stores
                                                  across the malls.
NOTES:
                                                  Rents hold stable q-o-q
As the market developed, we regularly review
and update our classification and grading
system as well as the methodology to ensure the   Prime rent held steady in 1Q21 at USD 76.8 per sqm per month in City centre and USD 34.5 per
relevance and focus of our research to the
actual market situation.
                                                  sqm per month in City Fringe. Led by firming occupier demand and limited availability of quality
                                                  retail space, Prime malls kept their rents stable despite prolonged market uncertainty.
Since 1Q21, in this report:
• Supply indicators to cover malls classified
  as Community center, Regional shopping          Outlook: Retail rent expected to remain resilient
  center and Super regional center.
• Performance indicators to cover Prime           Socar Mall – the first mall in Thu Thiem NUA is set to open in 3Q21 and expected to bring 38,000
  retail properties only (a subset of Supply
  basket above). This is one of the highly        sqm NLA to the market. Meanwhile, the retail podium of some completed mixed-use
  sought-after property types on the market.      developments are still looking for tenants and have yet to define the grand opening date.
Please refer to Terminology for detailed
definition of all above new terms.
                                                  Vacancy continues to be constraint given limited new supply expected, meanwhile rents hold flat
Subsequently this revision might result in some
changes in historical data.                       as the impacts of pandemic are still lingering.

                                                  Figure 9: Retail Total Stock                                                              Figure 10: Prime Retail Average Rents
                                                  (‘000 sqm NLA)                                                                            (USD/sqm/month)
                                                  1,500                                                                            120%     90
                                                                                                                                   100%
                                                                                                                                            70
                                                  1,000                                                                            80%
                                                                                                                                   60%      50
                                                    500                                                                            40%
                                                                                                                                            30
                                                                                                                                   20%
                                                       0                                                                           0%       10
                                                             2013
                                                                    2014
                                                                           2015
                                                                                  2016
                                                                                         2017
                                                                                                2018
                                                                                                       2019
                                                                                                              2020

                                                                                                                            2021

                                                                                                                                                                                                                  2021
                                                                                                                     1Q21

                                                                                                                                                   1Q19
                                                                                                                                                          2Q19
                                                                                                                                                                 3Q19
                                                                                                                                                                        4Q19
                                                                                                                                                                               1Q19
                                                                                                                                                                                      2Q20
                                                                                                                                                                                             3Q20
                                                                                                                                                                                                    4Q20
                                                                                                                                                                                                           1Q21

                                                           Prime                                                     Non-Prime
                                                           Total future supply                                       Occupancy rate (RHS)                    City Centre                       City Firnge

                                                  Note:
                                                  [1] Prime rents refer to average net effective rent of the Prime Mall across the city, excluding VAT and service charges. The definition of Prime malls
                                                  refer to terminology for more explanation
                                                  [2] The classification of shopping mall is provided in details in Terminology.
                                                  [3] City Centre refers to District 1. City Fringe refers to the rest of the city.                                                                       6
                                                  Source: JLL Research
HCMC
              Apartment for Sale Market
Primary Price [1]        New legal guidelines drive market recovery

USD 2,468                Inspire of the third Covid wave in February, the new official supply [2] in 1Q21 increased 7% q-o-q
                         73% y-o-y with total of 3,900 units, thanks to the issuance of new guidelines for legal issues. The
per sqm NFA
                         new launches was highlighted with the introduction of a Luxury project - Cove Residences with
                         136 units. Mid-end sector, represented by Vinhomes Grand Park and Sunshine Diamond River
                         projects, continued to dominate the newly launched basket with 80% in sum.

Price Change y-o-y       Lack of land bank in the inner city and the continuously improving infrastructure systems have

0.7%                     increasingly driven housing demand in the suburban areas.

                         Demand remained strong
                         In 1Q21, the total take-up was at 3,932 units, up by 98% y-o-y. The cumulative sales rate for
                         apartment sector has remained high at over 85% since 2017, showing a strong demand in the
                         sector with most of buyers was the first-time homeowners who are either the local or outer-
Stage in Price Cycle     provincial citizens.

Rising                   Meanwhile, since Covid 19 has limited the capital flows into manufacturing sector, and lending
                         rate was kept low to stimulate economic growth, residential segment has appeared to be
                         attractive for developers/investors, and thus boost transaction activities.

                         The upward trend still leads the market price
                         The overall primary price reached USD 2,468 per sqm in 1Q21, stabilized q-o-q, and increased
                         0.7% y-o-y as the majority supply from the mid-end basket with reasonable prices and
                         standardized quality favoring by mainstream buyers such as D'Lusso, ST Moritz, Eco Green Saigon.
                         Notably, in the quarter Masterise Group just soft launched its Grand Marina project at USD 16,000
                         per sqm, an all-time high level in the market.

                         Outlook: Bright future for suburban area
                         DONRE [4] has submitted proposal to resolve legal issues for real estate development , which will
                         likely boost the total supply in 2021 to between 20,000 to 25,000 units, most of project located in
                         the suburban area toward the East and the South corridors. Lack of land bank and limited supply
                         in inner-districts shifted both supply and demand source to the suburban area where has large
                         land bank and improving transportation network.

                         Primary price keeps increasing in line with market sentiment. The introduction of integrated
                         Figure 11: Apartment
                         development   projectsTotal
                                                with Launches  [2]
                                                     various necessary facilities willFigure
                                                                                       bode 12:
                                                                                             wellApt.  Average
                                                                                                  for the       Primary
                                                                                                          creation of Prices
                         (‘000 units)                                                                                        (USD/sqm)
                         communities in suburban area, hence, drive the market sentiment toward sustainable mode.
                           350                                                                           100%             10,000

                           280                                                                           90%               8,000

                           210                                                                           80%               6,000
                           140                                                                           70%               4,000
                            70                                                                           60%               2,000
                              0                                                                          50%
                                                                                                                               0
                                   2013
                                          2014
                                                 2015
                                                        2016
                                                               2017
                                                                      2018
                                                                             2019
                                                                                    2020

                                                                                                  2021
                                                                                           1Q21

                                                                                                                                    4Q13
                                                                                                                                           4Q14
                                                                                                                                                  4Q15
                                                                                                                                                         4Q16
                                                                                                                                                                4Q17
                                                                                                                                                                       4Q18
                                                                                                                                                                              4Q19
                                                                                                                                                                                     4Q20
                                                                                                                                                                                            1Q21
                                                                                                                                                                                                   4Q21

                                   Luxury                                                         Premium                                     Affordable                         Mid-end
                                   Mid-end                                                        Affordable
                                                                                                                                              Premium                            Luxury
                                   Future launches                                                Cumulative sales rates (RHS)[3]
                         Note:
                         [1] Prices exclude VAT and sinking fund.
                         [2] Official launch figures. Projects are considered as officially launched when the Sale Purchase Agreements are signed, typically upon foundation completion.
                         [3] Sale rate is end-of-period figure.
                         [4] Department of Natural Resources and Environment of HCMC                                                                                        7
                         Source: JLL Research
Southern[1]
               Ready-built Landed property (RBL) Market
Primary Price [2]         Improving infrastructure drive the new supply in satellite provinces of HCMC

USD 2,641                 The new launch [3] of HCMC remained limited with only 292 units launched in 1Q21, 51% of which
                          came from Amelie Villa project in the south of HCMC, the others were from small-scale townhouse
per sqm land
                          projects in District 12 and Binh Tan. Meanwhile, thanks to convenient legal process and improving
                          infrastructure, the satellite provinces of HCMC now became the spotlight for RBL supply with new
                          launch of 4 provinces reached with1,656 units. Dong Nai province recorded the highest new
                          launch, contributing half of the basket. with 828 units, which nearly tripled HCMC’s figures.
Price Change y-o-y
+11.0%                    Demand continues to be healthy, particularly demand from investors
                          The total take-up reached 1,937 units, up 45% q-o-q. Despite the Covid-19 outbreak and Tet
                          Holiday, the first quarter of 2021 still experienced strong demand from both owner-occupiers and
                          investor buyers. The sales volume primarily came from integrated projects in Dong Nai and BR-VT
                          (911 and 472 units, respectively), while Binh Duong, Long An and HCMC recorded lower sales
                          volume due to in tandem with fewer units launched. The majority of buyers were are mainly long-
Stage in Price Cycle
                          term investors who would benefit from the continuously increasing land price trend.
Prices Rising
                          Primary Prices keeps increasing strongly
                          In 1Q21, the RBL average primary price in Southern provinces was at USD 2,641 per sqm land
                          which is half price of HCMC’s average price. However, the whole Southern area achieved robust
                          performance in average primary price with the growth of 11.0% y-o-y. The increase was mainly
                          due to the new launch of later phases in some large-scale integrated projects in Thu Duc City and
                          Dong Nai province, where the developers have completed several supporting facilities such as
                          theme parks, international schools, river marina, and therefore successfully established a living
                          community.

                          Outlook: Strong demand support price growth in Greater HCMC area
                          Given that the current legal issues in HCMC will take more time to resolve, the total RBL supply of
                          HCMC for the remaining of 2021 is subject to uncertainty and will vary from 1,500 - 2,000 units.
                          Meanwhile, the surrounding provinces will record a total supply of nearly 5,800 units, mainly
                          located in the radius 30km from HCMC centre, so called Greater HCMC.

                          The improving infrastructure and limited land banks situation in HCMC expected to draw the
                          demand toward satellites provinces. Couple with the entering of quality township project, the
                          primary price of RBL in both HCMC and Greater HCMC is expected to upsurge increase.
                          Figure 13: RBL Total Launches [3]                        Figure 14: RBL Average Primary Prices
                          (‘000 units)                                                                             (USD/sqm land)
                         25,000                                                         100%                    6,000
                         20,000                                                                                 5,000
                                                                                        90%                     4,000
                         15,000
                                                                                                                3,000
                         10,000
                                                                                        80%                     2,000
                          5,000                                                                                 1,000
                              0                                                         70%                          0
                                    HCMC        Binh Dong          Long      BR-VT                                         HCMC       Binh       Dong Long An           BR -
                                               Duong Nai            An                                                               Duong        Nai                    VT
                                                                                            [4]
                                         RBL              Cumulative sales rates (RHS)                                                        Primary Price

                           Note:
                           [1] In this report, Southern RBL market refers to HCMC, Binh Duong, Dong Nai, Ba Ria – Vung Tau and Long An markets only.
                           [2] Prices exclude VAT and sinking fund. Price per sqm land = total unit value / size of the land plot on which the property is built.
                           [3] Official launch figures. Projects are considered as officially launched when the Sale Purchase Agreements are signed, typically upon infrastructure
                           completion.                                                                                                                                         8
                           [4] Sale rate is end-of-period figure.
                           Source: JLL Research
Southern[1]
              Industrial Land & Ready-built Factory (RBF) Market
Land Price [2]            Dong Nai & Binh Duong accounted the biggest supply of both sectors

USD 111                   No new supply of either IP or RBF was launched into the market in the review quarter. The other
                          localities still have a long journey to catch up Binh Duong and Dong Nai’s IP supply as these two
per sqm per lease term
                          are the oldest-developed industrial markets. Whilst in terms of RBF supply, Dong Nai
                          overwhelmed other provinces due to its well-developed industrial base and sufficient land bank
                          for RBF developers to penetrate.

Price Growth y-o-y        Transacted land acquisitions took place as lingering from last year
+8.2%                     Industrial properties in Southern area remained significantly desirable for manufacturers to
                          penetrate, although the pandemic still posting potential postpones to the market. Keeping the
                          healthy demand momentum, both Industrial land and RBF recorded high occupancy rate at nearly
                          86% and 82%, increased 0.60% and 0.76% compared to 4Q20, respectively. Of which, industrial
                          land recorded transactions which have been negotiated since last year, whilst RBF witnessed new
                          leasing expansions of existing tenants rather than newcomers.
Stage in Price Cycle
Rising                    Land price and rental rate kept increasing momentum
                          Industrial land remained the hottest sector for either newcomers or to meet the manufacturing
                          expansion needs of existing investors, backed by Vietnam’s strong manufacturing fundamentals.
                          Therefore, most IP developers in Southern markets still maintained the strong momentum to raise
                          land prices reaching new high at USD 111 per sqm per lease term, up 8.1% y-o-y in 1Q21. Whereas
                          RBFs rents averaged at USD 4.5 per sqm per month across the region, increased 3.1% y-o-y which
                          driven by the healthy demands of SMEs as they expanded operations.

                          Outlook: Strong supply keep pouring into the market
Rents[3]
                          Overall, the supply for industrial properties in the South is expected to rise further in the next five
USD 4.5                   years to capitalise the increasing demand in the region, and further strengthen its leading position
per sqm per month,        in terms of supply. By such bright visions, the provincial governments have shown further plans to
net on GFA                establish new IPs of roughly 23,400 ha in the future, which all stayed in the exiting notable markets
                          surrounding HCMC. RBF market also stay buoyant, with the expected new launch of roughly
                          897,000 sqm RBFs by the end of 2021.
Rent Growth y-o-y
+3.1%
                          Figure 15: Industrial Land & RBF Total Stock                                         Figure 16: Average Land and RBF Rents
                           (ha)                                                         (sqm)                  (USD/sqm/term)                                 (USD/sqm/month)
                         8,000                                                             14                 200                                                            6
                                                                                           12
                         6,000                                                             10                 150
                                                                                                                                                                             4
Stage in Rent Cycle                                                                        8
                         4,000                                                                                100
Rising                   2,000
                                                                                           6
                                                                                           4                   50
                                                                                                                                                                             2
                                                                                           2
                             0                                                             0                     0                                                           0
                                    Binh       Dong        BR -      Long      HCMC                                    Binh       Dong       BR -      Long       HCMC
                                   Duong        Nai         VT        An        [4]                                   Duong        Nai        VT        An         [4]

                                         Industrial Land                RBF (RHS)                                          Land Price                RBF Rent (RHS)

                           Note:
                           [1] In this report, Southern industrial market refers to HCMC, Binh Duong, Dong Nai, Ba Ria – Vung Tau and Long An markets only.
                           [2] The average land price excluding Infrastructure maintenance, service fees and VAT. Leasing term is the remaining years.
                           [3] Rents excluding VAT and service charges.
                           [4[ HCMC Industrial Land total supply and price excluding Saigon High-tech Park and Quang Trung Software Park owing to their special          9
                           characteristics.
                           Source: JLL Research
Hanoi
             Office Market
Rents[1]               No new supply enters the market

USD 18.87              The Hanoi office remained quiet with no new completion was added in 1Q21. A lack of
                       opportunities in the CBD of the city is forcing developer to explore options further afield.
per sqm per month,
net on NLA             Total vacant space of Hanoi Grade A&B office is about 221,000 sqm, an increase of 49% y-o-y. Of
                       the total vacancy, Grade A office accounted for 51%. The vacancy mainly came from new
                       completions in 2019 and several old longstanding buildings.
Rent Growth y-o-y      Demand slightly recovers
+0.64%                 In 1Q21, Hanoi Grade A&B witnessed an increase in the occupancy rate at 86.8%, up by 1.07 % q-
                       to-q. Despite the Covid-19 resurgence in early 1Q21 making tenants hesitate to visit sites, Grade
                       A&B market still recorded positive net absorption of around 17,915 sqm, much better than the
                       previous quarter's performance. Notable Grade A buildings with large deals in the quarter is
                       Capital and Thai Holding Towers. Meanwhile, around 70% of buildings in Grade B achieved
Stage in Rent Cycle    positive net absorption, thanks to their more affordable rents. Notably, demand from securities
                       and technologies showed resilience with many new take-ups in this quarter.
Stable
                       Rents keep constant across the market

                       The average net rent of Grade A kept constant at USD 26.7 per sqm per month and Grade B stayed
                       at USD14.8 per sqm per month. Most existing buildings either kept their asking rents constant or
                       slightly decreased, mainly triggered by a slowdown in the Grade A rent performance, as its
                       lingering vacancy led landlords to increase rent incentives by offering flexible leasing terms during
                       this challenging period.

                       Outlook: New supply to weigh on rent and vacancy trend

                       New supply in 2021 in Hanoi mainly from Non-CBD area mainly from notable building namely
                       Techno Park. With 117,000 sqm NLA, this is the largest office building in Hanoi and contribute up
                       to 73% of new supply in 2021. Notably, Techno Park aims to enrol in the top 10 smartest office
                       buildings in the world and this will help the area to appear on the map of new technology centres
                       of both Viet Nam and the region.

                       The vacancy rate in Grade A&B market probably continues to increase from a large supply of new
                       buildings. Hence, the average net rent is expected to remain stable or slightly decreased pushing
                       up the take-up area in the short to medium term.

                          Figure 17: Office Total Stock                                                                 Figure 18: Office Average Rents
                          (‘000 sqm NLA)                                                                                (USD/sqm/month)
                                2,500                                                                           100%    30

                                2,000                                                                           80%     25
                                                                                                                        20
                                1,500                                                                           60%
                                                                                                                        15
                                1,000                                                                           40%
                                                                                                                        10
                                  500                                                                           20%      5
                                     0                                                                          0%       0
                                          2013
                                                 2014
                                                        2015
                                                               2016
                                                                      2017
                                                                             2018
                                                                                    2019
                                                                                           2020

                                                                                                         2021

                                                                                                                             2021
                                                                                                  1Q21

                                                                                                                             1Q18
                                                                                                                             2Q18
                                                                                                                             3Q18
                                                                                                                             4Q18
                                                                                                                             1Q19
                                                                                                                             2Q19
                                                                                                                             3Q19
                                                                                                                             4Q19
                                                                                                                             1Q20
                                                                                                                             2Q20
                                                                                                                             3Q20
                                                                                                                             4Q20
                                                                                                                             1Q21

                                         Grade A                                                  Grade B
                                         Grade C                                                  Total future supply              Grade A                 Grade B
                                         A&B Occ. Rate (RHS)
                          Note:
                          [1] Rents refers to average net rent of Grade A and B office markets, excluding VAT and service charges.
                          [2] CBD area consists of Hoan Kiem (core CBD), Dong Da, Ba Dinh and Hai Ba Trung. Non-CBD area refers to the rest of the city.
                          Source: JLL Research
                                                                                                                                                                     10
Hanoi
                     Retail Market
Prime Rents [1]                                   No new completion enters the market

USD 32.34                                         Due to the third outbreak of Covid-19 in Hanoi, some community malls[2] had to delay their
                                                  opening day to the next quarter. Hence, the market stayed quiet with no new supply coming on
per sqm per month,
net on NLA                                        stream during 1Q21. There are only 14/35 shopping malls in Hanoi was qualified as a Prime mall [1]
                                                  standard, yet Prime mall projects accounted for 62% of the total leasable retail space of the city.
                                                  Of which, 10/14 Prime mall projects located in City Fringe[3] and targeting to middle-class visitors.

Rent Growth y-o-y                                 Demand shows a slight recovery
+0.4%                                             Most of Prime malls recorded positive net absorption in 1Q21. However, given the sudden
                                                  outbreak of Covid-19 in early January, demand slightly recovered with many small-to-medium
                                                  new take-up transactions recorded. Therein, occupancy of Prime malls was inched up by 0.37% q-
                                                  o-q to around 90.8% in this quarter. Landlords continued to carefully select tenant profiles
                                                  following the malls’ concept. Muji – a Japanese lifestyle brand entered the Hanoi market with its
                                                  first under construction store at Vincom Metropolis and became the key driver of the net
Stage in Rent Cycle
                                                  absorption across the market. Meanwhile, the F&B industry witnessed many weak performed
Stable                                            restaurants had to shut down their business given the affection of the third outbreak wave.

                                                  Rents remain stable in 1Q21
                                                  Due to the slow recovery of demand, landlords still kept rents stable, as the market still found it
                                                  challenging to attract new tenants. The average rent in Prime malls remained at USD 34.32 per
NOTES:                                            sqm per month in 1Q21. Particularly, City Centre and City Fringe stayed at USD 62.1 per sqm per
As the market developed, we regularly review      month and USD 28.5 per sqm per month respectively. Given the third outbreak in Hanoi, some
and update our classification and grading
system as well as the methodology to ensure the   landlords, especially those in City Fringe who are in difficulty attracting new tenants, are willing to
relevance and focus of our research to the
actual market situation.                          negotiate with tenants for better leasing terms.
Since 1Q21, in this report:                       Outlook: Rent to increase moderately
• Supply indicators to cover malls classified
  as Community center, Regional shopping
  center and Super regional center.
                                                  Vincom Mega Mall Smart City plans to enter Hanoi market in 2Q21 which will provide
• Performance indicators to cover Prime           approximately 40,800 sqm. This will be the largest shopping centre in Nam Tu Liem District and is
  retail properties only (a subset of Supply
  basket above). This is one of the highly        expected to become a new destination for residents in the area. Given new supply expected high
  sought-after property types on the market.
                                                  occupancy rate due to developer’s good track record while other prime malls recorded tight
Please refer to Terminology for detailed
definition of all above new terms.                vacancy coupled with the expected well-control of Covid-19, Hanoi retail market expects to push
Subsequently this revision might result in some   down the vacancy rate to a single-digit level. Demand signs of recovery is believed to be the
changes in historical data.
                                                  driving force of the mild rental growth amid limited quality supply.
                                                  Figure 19: Retail Total Stock                                                             Figure 20: Prime Retail Average Rents
                                                  (‘000 sqm NLA)                                                                            (USD/sqm/month)
                                                  1,400                                                                           100%      70
                                                  1,200
                                                                                                                                  80%
                                                  1,000                                                                                     50
                                                    800                                                                           60%
                                                    600                                                                           40%
                                                    400                                                                                     30
                                                                                                                                  20%
                                                    200
                                                      0                                                                           0%        10
                                                            2013
                                                                   2014
                                                                          2015
                                                                                 2016
                                                                                        2017
                                                                                               2018
                                                                                                      2019
                                                                                                             2020

                                                                                                                           2021
                                                                                                                    1Q21

                                                                                                                                                                                                                2021
                                                                                                                                                 1Q19
                                                                                                                                                        2Q19
                                                                                                                                                               3Q19
                                                                                                                                                                      4Q19
                                                                                                                                                                             1Q20
                                                                                                                                                                                    2Q20
                                                                                                                                                                                           3Q20
                                                                                                                                                                                                  4Q20
                                                                                                                                                                                                         1Q21

                                                              Prime                                                  Non-Prime
                                                                                                                                                           City Centre                       City Fringe
                                                              Total future supply                                    Occupancy rate (RHS)
                                                  Note:
                                                  [1] Prime rents refer to average net effective rent of the Prime Mall across the city, excluding VAT and service charges. The definition of Prime malls
                                                  refer to terminology for more explanation
                                                  [2] The classification of shopping mall refer to terminology for more explanation.
                                                  [3] City Centre refers to Hoan Kiem, part of Ba Dinh and Hai Ba Trung District. City Fringe refers to the rest of the city.                          11
                                                  Source: JLL Research
Hanoi
              Apartment for Sale Market
Primary Price [1]        Supply starts to rebound from a low level in 2020

USD 1,555                A total of 3,645 units were launched across submarkets in 1Q21, marking a notable rise of 36.6% q-
                         o-q. Major projects in the new supply pool include Panorama Hoang Van Thu in Hoang Mai
per sqm NFA
                         District, The Zen Park in Vinhomes Ocean Park and Grand Sapphire phase in Vinhomes Smart City,
                         accounting for 56% of the total. Apart from this, new launches in the quarter came in a small-scale,
                         ranging from 100 – 300 units each. It was highlighted that most of new supply in the quarter is
                         close to completion as they have been on the market under pre-launch sales for several quarters
Price Growth y-o-y
                         but only able to obtain all necessary legal documents to be officially launched in 1Q21.
+7.1%                    Investment demand remained muted
                         Sales momentum eased in 1Q21 with sales volume down by 12.6% q-o-q, a result of outbreak
                         resurgence and Lunar New Year seasonal effect. Investment activities in the premium segment,
                         particularly for buy-to-let purpose, have been adversely affected by the limited foreign arrivals.
                         Capital gain investment demand also shrunk as individual investors shifted to landed housing,
Stage in Price Cycle
                         especially in satellite provinces experiencing land fever, to enjoy a better capital gain given the
Growth Slowing           same investment amount. Yet, the market observed increasing transactions of institutional buyers
                         who look for en-block acquisition or joint venture opportunities in the township projects.

                         Apartment prices continue to grow, but show signs of slowing
                         Overall price growth slowed q-o-q, stood at USD 1,555 per sqm in 1Q21. While developers are
                         unlikely to lower primary market prices, zero interest plans, festival offers, and longer payment
                         schedule acted as a catalyst to improve sales. This has particularly been the case for higher end
                         projects since last year and continued in 1Q21 as the market remained relatively unmoved.

                         Outlook: Market sentiment expects to be sustained
                         The forecast pipeline for the rest of 2021 might vary around 20,000 -25,000 units, mainly
                         attributable from low priced segments. Market sentiment is expected to sustain till 4Q21. The
                         expected resumption of international commercial flights in 2Q21 may push up the investor
                         demand in high-end segment. Besides, the newly announced Red River Urbanisation project with
                         imaginable infrastructure upgrade is likely to spike investors’ interest in the city’s Northeast.

                         Selling price expected to continue to grow but at a slower pace. Projects, which are at advanced
                         stages of construction, will continue to offer various incentives to attract cautious perspective
                         buyers to offload inventory.
                         Figure 21: Apartment Total Launches [2]                     Figure 22: Apt. Average Primary Prices
                         (‘000 units)                                                                                        (USD/sqm)

                           350                                                                           100%             5,000

                           280                                                                           90%              4,000

                           210                                                                           80%              3,000
                           140                                                                           70%              2,000
                            70                                                                           60%              1,000
                              0                                                                          50%
                                                                                                                              0
                                   2013
                                          2014
                                                 2015
                                                        2016
                                                               2017
                                                                      2018
                                                                             2019
                                                                                    2020

                                                                                                  2021
                                                                                           1Q21

                                                                                                                                    4Q13
                                                                                                                                           4Q14
                                                                                                                                                   4Q15
                                                                                                                                                          4Q16
                                                                                                                                                                 4Q17
                                                                                                                                                                        4Q18
                                                                                                                                                                               4Q19
                                                                                                                                                                                      4Q20
                                                                                                                                                                                             1Q21
                                                                                                                                                                                                    4Q21

                                   Luxury                                                         Premium                                         Affordable                          Mid-end
                                   Mid-end                                                        Affordable
                                                                                                                                                  Premium                             Luxury
                                   Future launches                                                Cumulative sales rates (RHS)[3]
                         Note:
                         [1] Prices exclude VAT and sinking fund.
                         [2] Official launch figures. Projects are considered as officially launched when the Sale Purchase Agreements are signed, typically upon foundation completion.
                         [3] Sale rate is end-of-period figure.
                         Source: JLL Research                                                                                                                             12
Northern[1]
               Ready-built Landed property (RBL) Market
Primary Price [2]         Hanoi still leads the market, but few new launch in satellite provinces

USD 4,227                 The new launch [3] of Hanoi reached over 1,000 units, an increase of 25% q-o-q. Main supply
                          sources came from Vinhomes Ocean Park and Hinode Royal Park, which contributed 88% of total
per sqm land
                          supply basket. Meanwhile, the Covid-19 outbreak this quarter has impacted the launching plan of
                          many projects, several of which had were deferred to March or April. As a result, the total supply of
                          four selected Northern provinces totalled only 142 units coming from four projects in Bac Ninh,
                          Hung Yen and Vinh Phuc. Plus, Hai Phong province recorded no new launch project launched
Price Change y-o-y
                          during this quarter.
+14.9%                    Strong demand towards shophouse type
                          The total take-up in Hanoi reached 1,173 units with 45% of units sold coming from shophouses in
                          Gia Lam and Hoang Mai districts. In contrast to the usual demand of Hanoi residents for villa type,
                          shophouse type took over the trend appeared to be preferred, especially shophouses the one
                          within large-scale projects, thanks to large number their high number of internal residents, thus
Stage in Price Cycle
                          leading to high potential to lease back these units as restaurants, offices, coffee shops. Meanwhile,
Prices Rising             in line with limited supply, the units sold of the four satellite provinces were recorded at only 177
                          units. In addition, RBL demand in Hanoi and the surrounding provinces this quarter were highly
                          contested aligned with demand for land plot due to the land fever emerging recently. Therefore,
                          investor buyers would prioritize land plot to RBL product.

                          Primary prices keep on an upward trend
                          The average primary price in Northern provinces was recorded around USD 4,220 per sqm land,
                          equaled to 87% of Hanoi’s average price. The whole Northern area achieved a significant increase
                          of 14.9% y-o-y. On a project basis, the highest growth was recorded achieved (typically 15-20% y-
                          o-y) at nearly-completed projects in Ha Dong and Hoang Mai District.

                          Outlook: Supply will improve in 2021
                          Hanoi will continue to be the main supply source for Northern areas with a total RBL reaching
                          about 3,000 units, while the surrounding provinces will provide a total of about 1,700 units, mainly
                          in Hung Yen and Hai Phong province. Thanks to the announcement of the master plan for Red
                          River Urbanisation and Historic Inner Capital Zone, coupling with good infrastructure system, the
                          primary price of RBL is expected to enhance further.

                          Figure 23: RBL Total Launches [3]                                                        Figure 24: RBL Average Primary Prices
                          (‘000 units)                                                                             (USD/sqm land)
                         60,000                                                         100%                    6,000
                         50,000                                                                                 5,000
                         40,000                                                         90%                     4,000
                         30,000                                                                                 3,000
                         20,000                                                         80%                     2,000
                         10,000                                                                                 1,000
                              0                                                         70%                          0
                                    Hanoi       Hai      Bac       Hung      Vinh                                          Hanoi       Hai Bac Ninh Hung                Vinh
                                               Phong     Ninh       Yen      Phuc                                                     Phong          Yen                Phuc
                                                                                            [4]
                                         RBL              Cumulative sales rates (RHS)                                                        Primary Price

                           Note:
                           [1] In this report, Northern industrial market refers to Hanoi, Hai Phong, Bac Ninh, Hung Yen and Vinh Phuc markets only.
                           [2] Prices exclude VAT and sinking fund. Price per sqm land = total unit value / size of the land plot on which the property is built.
                           [3] Official launch figures. Projects are considered as officially launched when the Sale Purchase Agreements are signed, typically upon infrastructure completion.
                           [4] Sale rate is end-of-period figure.                                                                                                            13
                           Source: JLL Research
Northern[1]
              Industrial Land & Ready-built Factory (RBF) Market
                          No new supply entered the market in 1Q21
Land Price [2]
                          In 1Q21, no new supply in industrial land and RBF was introduced into the Northern market. The
USD 107                   cumulative leasable land area in the market achieved at roughly 9,500 ha, while the total supply of
per sqm per lease term    RBF stood at approximately 1.8 million sqm. Bac Ninh and Hai Phong dominated the total supply in
                          both sectors thanks to their strategic locations, strong footprints in the industrial market and
                          improving the business environment. RBF supplier has begun to adopt "The generation of
                          Industry 4.0 Factory” to better support users in facilitating RBF’s exercises. For instance, a “Virtual
Price Growth y-o-y        factory” tool to provide clients with RBF virtual tour; or a “Customer service” app to keep clients up-
8.1%                      to-date with current operation at RBF in a more timely manner.

                          Occupancy rate remained healthy despite the new wave of Covid-19 infections
                          The third wave of Covid-19 pandemic swept out the Northern area in late January has led to the
                          postponement of new investments into the region, especially the lockdown in Hai Duong has
                          frozen most of the transactions in IPs in 1Q21. Nevertheless, thanks to the strong influx of FDI in
Stage in Price Cycle      high-tech industries starting in 2H20, the average occupancy rate of IPs recorded a healthy rate,
Prices Rising             reaching 75%, whereas occupancy rate of RBF stood at 98% in 1Q21.

                          Land price and rent reached a new high
                          Girven healthy demands, backed by Vietnam's strong industrial fundamentals; combined with IP
                          developers’ strong confidence in potential long-term investments, land price continued its
                          momentum to reach a new peak of USD 107 per sqm per lease term in 1Q21, up 8.1% y-o-y.
                          Meanwhile, RBF rents also showed an increasing trend, at 5.8% y-o-y, of which Bac Ninh recorded
                          the strongest growth rate of nearly 9% y-o-y fuelled by the launch of high-quality RBFs.

Rents[3]                  Outlook: Strong pipeline across the region

USD 4.5                   Since technology conglomerates continue to eye Vietnam for production relocation, the demand
                          for industrial land and RBFs remains vibrant. To lure foreign investments, localities in the Northern
per sqm per month,
net on GFA                area have shown strong commitment to promote IPs system, with roughly 10,500 ha of additional
                          supply in the future. In addition to existing markets, second-tier provinces like Hung Yen, Hai Duong
                          or further North of Hanoi like Bac Giang, Vinh Phuc are emerging as potential destinations for
                          foreign investors, fostering the rents in those areas to speed up at an expected y-o-y growth of
Rent Growth y-o-y
                          about 8-10%. In tandem, RBF market remains upbeat, with the expected new launch of roughly
5.8%                      332,000 sqm RBFs by the end of 2021, predominantly in Hai Phong and Bac Ninh.

                          Figure 25: Industrial Land & RBF Total Stock                                          Figure 26: Land Price and RBF Rents
                          (ha)                                                          (sqm)                   (USD/sqm/term)                               (USD/sqm/month)

                         5,000                                                                8                150                                                       6
                         4,000
Stage in Rent Cycle                                                                           6
                                                                                                               100                                                       4
Prices Rising
                         3,000
                                                                                              4
                         2,000
                                                                                                                50                                                       2
                         1,000                                                                2

                            0                                                                 0                   0                                                      0
                                    Hai        Bac         Hung       Hai        Ha Noi                                  Hai       Bac        Hung       Hai  Ha Noi
                                   Phong       Ninh         Yen      Duong        [3]                                   Phong      Ninh        Yen      Duong  [3]

                                         Industrial Land                   RBF(RHS)                                        Land Price               Factory Rent (RHS)
                          Note:
                          [1] In this report, Northern industrial market refers to Hanoi, Hai Phong, Bac Ninh, Hung Yen and Hai Duong markets only.
                          [2] The average land price excluding Infrastructure maintenance, service fees and VAT. Leasing term is the remaining years.
                          [3] Rents excluding VAT and service charges.
                          [4] Hanoi total supply excluding Hoa Lac High-tech Park owing to its special characteristics.                                             14
                          Source: JLL Research
General Terminology
Chain-linked change
The quarter-on-qu arter ch ange in th e chain-linked basis illustrates th e chan ge in rents o r prices in properties that existed in the basket
during two consecutive quarters. This is different f rom the standard spot chan ge series, which is a weigh ted av erage of all buildings in
the market at that given moment.
The chain-linked chan ge can be u sed across time to show more accu rately the lev el of ren t growth achieved in a stabilised asset that is
acquired and held over that time period.
Property Clock
The clock diagram illustrates where JLL estimates the stage of each property market within its individual ren t/price cycle as at the end
of the review quarter and help to signify the expected RV/CV movements in the short-term, meaning in the next one to two quarters.

The diagram is a convenient method of comparing the rel ative po sition of markets in their ren t/price cycle. Their po sition is not
necessarily representative of the investment o r developmen t market pro spects. Th eir po sition ref ers to the prevailing rent o r price
tren d and its expected movement in the n ext quarter. G enerally, it’s n ormal for markets to mov e from one stage to ano ther; there are a
couple of markets that have previously been swinging pretty wildly.

The Property Clock is divided into four pies:
      Rents/Prices falling means the values are expected to start falling and the pace of fall is accelerating
      Rents/Prices decline slowing, means the values are expected to still fall, although the pace is slowing down
      Rents/Prices rising, means the values are expected to start rising and the pace of growth is accelerating
      Rents/Prices growth slowing, means the values are expected to still grow but the pace is slowing down

Figure 27: Vietnam Property Clock, 1Q21

                                  Hanoi Apartment

                                 Hanoi Office           GROWTH                 RENTS/PRICES
                                                        SLOWING                  FALLING

                             HCMC Office
                          HCMC Apartment

                                                      RENTS/PRICES               DECLINE
                                                         RISING                  SLOWING
                                     HCMC RBL
         Southern, Northern Industrial Land

                        Southern, Northern RBF, RBW

                                                                              HCMC Retail, Hanoi Retail

 Source: JLL Research
                                                                                                                                           15
Terminology
               Office market
Current supply
The total amount of cumulative office space (in NFA terms) that has been completed at a given time.
Future supply
The total amount of office space slated for completion in the future at a given time.
Vacant space
The to tal amount of av ailable office space that remains to be leased by the property owner(s) at a given time. This excludes space
available fo r sub-lease by ten ants (i.e., shadow space), space physically empty but al ready pre-l eased or reserv ed, and space to be
available for lease in the future.
Occupied space
Current supply less vacant space. “Net absorption” refers to the change in the occupied space from quarter to quarter.
Gross floor area (GFA)
The total amount of all covered areas including columns, walls, common passageways, lift, lobbies and toilets.
Net floor area (NFA)
The amount of usable floor areas excluding columns, walls, common passageways, lifts, lobbies and toilets. Net l ettable area o r n et
leasable area (NLA) refers to the amount of NFA that is available for lease.
Net rent
The amount of market rent receivable by landlords after deducting outgoings.
Market practices: Net rents may be quoted on an NLA or a GFA basis.
Outgoings
The estimated costs set aside by landlords for building maintenance that are passed on to tenants in the form of service charges or
management fees.
Market practices: Service charges/management fees may or may not be quoted separately from net rents.
Gross rent
The to tal achievable rent to be bo rne by ten ants, including service charges/management f ees. Gro ss rents equal n et ren ts plus
outgoings.
Market practices: Gross rents may be quoted on an NLA or a GFA basis.
Capital value
The market value or probable price of a property at a given time from a valuation point of view.
Yield
The percentage return on property investment at a given time from a valuation point of view. It is based on current market rents
assuming full occupancy.
Grade A
A Grade A property meets all of the f acto rs in a set of criteria regarding its off erings to a typical sophisticated occupier. Th ese criteria
are broadly concerned with the property’s overall profile, location, amenities, management standards and technical specifications.
Grade B
A Grade B pro perty meets some of th e facto rs in a set of criteria regarding its offerings to a typical sophisticated occupier. These criteria
are broadly concerned with the property’s overall profile, location, amenities, management standards and technical specifications.
Grade C
A Grade C property meets a set of criteria regarding its offerings to a typical non-sophisticated occupier. Th ese criteria are broadly
concerned with the property’s overall profile, location, amenities, management standards and technical specifications.
Terminology
               Retail market
Current supply
The total amoun t of cumulative modern (as opposed to traditional) retail space (in GFA terms) that has been completed at a given time.
This includes department stores, shopping centres and prime retail space.
Future supply
The total amount of modern retail space slated for completion in the future at a given time.
Vacant space
The total amoun t of av ailable modern retail space that remains to be leased by the property owner(s) at a given time. This excludes
space available fo r sub-lease by ten ants (i.e., shadow space), space physically empty but already pre-l eased or reserved, and space to
be available for lease in the future.
Occupied space
Current supply less vacant space. “Net absorption” refers to the change in occupied space from quarter to quarter.
Net leasable area (NLA)
The to tal amoun t of leasable floo r areas on which ren ts and service charges are based, which exclude common areas u sed for fo ot
traffic.
Net rent
The total achievable rent to be borne by tenants excluding service charges/managemen t fees and VAT.
Market practices: Net rents in the retail market are usually quoted on NLA basis.

Shopping centre
A shopping cen tre is a property housing commercial multi-branded rental units/sto res/establishmen ts and common areas. It is
planned, developed and operated. The property is classified in the hierarchy by function and/or size and by the area served.

Department store
Usually, a multi-level retail property varying in size f rom on e selling a variety of goo ds to one selling a full ran ge of different lines. A
distinctive featu re of a department sto re is that 90% of th e space is under a cen tralised paymen t system and it stocks a significant
number of cosmetics, fashion and household goods.
Supply Basket
A shopping centre is a landlord-developed and operated commercial project. Mo st of th e tenan t sto res hav e dividing walls and
frontage. A shopping centre operato r can lease ancho r space to department sto res/en tertainmen t operators/supermarkets and other
types of retail requiring large floor space.
Under shopping centre, we classified the retail centres in the hierarchy by function and/or size and by the area served as below:
Regional Shopping Centre
Specialty space of more than 30,000 sqm NLA o r 100 stores o r so specialty stores, anchored by one large department store and attract
more than 10,000 customers per day.
Super Regional Centre
Similarly defined as regional shopping centre, but comprising more than one department store.
Community Mall
Range of specialty space between 10,000-25,000 sqm NLA, housing 30 to 100 stores, which are mostly convenience and shopping
stores, targeting local residents.
Neighbourhood Centre
Similar features as community mall but smaller scale, housing 10 to 30 stores.

While Vietnam Retail market is widely diversified with a variety of product types including all types listed above, to stay relevant to our
target readers, since 1Q21 this report will cover Regional Shopping Centre, Super Regional Centre, Community Mall only.
Performance Basket
To ensure consistency in market performance observation, JLL selected 12 out of 40 retail center from Regional Shopping Centre,
Super Regional Centre, Community Mall to the occupancy rate and rental basket. All the demand-related indicators in this report refer
to Prime Mall if no further comments. The definition of Prime Mall was listed in our performance basket as below:

Prime Grade
Represent the High-quality retail space meeting v arious rigo rou s criteria fo r an excellent location & accessibility, developer reputation,
layout & ambience, management quality, and tenant mix.
Non-Prime Grade
Represents retail centres that do not meet our Prime Grade standards in terms of location & accessibility, developer reputation, layout
& ambience, management quality, tenant mix, or a combination.
Terminology
                Residential market
Commercial apartment for sale or Apartment for sale
The developer-built apartments that are available for sale widely on the market without any restriction on target buyers according to
the market mechanism.
According to JLL in-house classifica tion, the Vietnam apa rtment for sale market is ca tegorised as Lu xury, P remium, mid-end and
Affordable segments. The detailed classifications are provided on the following page.
Ready-built landed property for sale or Ready-built landed property
The dev eloper-built landed properties that are available for sale widely on the market without any restriction on target buyers
according to the market mech anism, where th e products comprise th e houses on their own grounds. The developers provide a land
plot with the necessary infrastructure, and the houses built based on the master plan and the design of the developer.
As per ma rket prac tices, there a re three types of Ready-buil t landed property, namely villa, townhouse and shophouse. The detailed
classifications are provided on the following page.
Branded residence
Refer to th e residential property available for sale on the market that is inco rporated with reco gnizable hotel-operato r brands.
Residences fo r sal e to individual buyers, which could be enjoyed for person al use o r pooled back into th e hotel’s ren tal pool as
investmen t vehicle. It could be eith er standalon e units, o r part of th e mixed-u se development f eaturing a ho tel compon ent. ef er to the
residential property available for sale on the market that is incorporated with recognizable hotel-operator brands.
Current supply
The total amount of supply available fo r sale, eith er throu gh the primary market o r the secondary market, rega rdless of construction
status.
Future supply
The total amount of supply to be launched for sale in the future.
Completed supply
The total amount of supply that has been physically completed and handed over for occupation. Also known as existing supply.
Uncompleted supply
The total amount of supply that h as no t been physically completed and handed over for occupation. Includes supply under
construction and supply planned for construction. Also known as supply in the pipeline.
Primary market
That part of the market comprising first-hand supply available for sale from developers.
Secondary market
That part of the market comprising second-hand supply available for resale from previous buyers.
Launches (Official launches)
The estimated amount of n ew supply (in units) officially launched for sale du ring a period. Projects are only considered as officially
launched when the Sale Purch ase A greements are signed, typically upon the completion of foundations fo r the apartmen t sector and
the completion of internal infrastructure according to the project schedule for Ready-built landed property.
Market practices: Many developers choose to launch their projects in phases which may or may not be publicly announced.
Take-up
The estimated amount of supply (in units) sold during a period. Includes sold units from new supply in the period and supply in
previous periods.
Market practices: Take-up may comprise units sold via capital contributions or sale and purchase agreements.
Total inventory
The total amount of unsold supply that has been launched for sale.
Cumulative sales rate
The percentage between cumulative units sold and cumulative units launched up to the specific time.
Primary asking price
The stock-weighted average asking price in the primary market.
Secondary asking price
The stock-weighted average asking price in the secondary market.
Non-chain-link changes
Q-o-Q and Y-o-Y changes include the effect of supply additions/removals.
Chain-link changes
Q-o-Q and Y-o-Y changes are adjusted to remove the effects of supply additions/removals.
Terminology
                 Residential market (cont.)
Luxury apartment
A luxury property meets all of the facto rs in a set of criteria regarding its offerings to a typical local wealthy hou sehold. Th ese criteria
are bro adly concern ed with the property’s overall profile, location, facilities, amenities and management standards. A majority of
luxury properties are located in or near the CBD of the city under review.
Typical price range: > USD 3,500 per sqm, excluding VAT and sinking fund
Premium apartment
A premium property meets some of the f acto rs in a set of criteria regarding its off erings to a typical local wealthy hou sehold. These
criteria are broadly concerned with th e property’s ov erall profile, location, f acilities, amenities and management standards. A majority
of premium properties are located in new urban areas outside the CBD of the city under review.
Typical price range: USD 2,500–USD 3,500 per sqm, excluding VAT and sinking fund
Mid-end apartment
A mid-end property meets all of the factors in a set of criteria regarding its offerings to a typical local middle-class hou sehold. These
criteria are broadly concerned with th e property’s ov erall profile, location, f acilities, amenities and management standards. A majority
of mid-end properties are located within the inner districts of the city under review.
Typical price range: USD 1,200 – USD 2,500 per sqm, excluding VAT and sinking fund
Affordable apartment
An affordable property meets some of the f acto rs in a set of criteria regarding its offerings to a typical local middle-class household.
These criteria are broadly concern ed with th e property’s ov erall profile, location, f acilities, amenities and management standards. A
majority of affordable properties are located in the outer districts of the city under review.
Typical price range: < USD 1,200 per sqm, excluding VAT and sinking fund
Note: The p ric e ranges provided above should not be understood as the sole and u tmost c riterion based on which p rojects a re assigned
grades.
High-end apartment: including Luxury and Premium segments
Low-end apartment: including mid-end and Affordable segments
Villa
A large and luxurious country house on its own grounds, generally having a maximum of three floors. The plot ratio is usually less than
70%, with a focus on a green area.
 Most popular villas are located on 200-300 sqm land plots. Some luxury villa plot areas may reach 500-1,000 sqm.
 The popular construction area/Gross Floor Area (GFA) is about 250-350 sqm while the land plot is large. For that reason, all things
    equal, the selling price per square metre of land is lower than that of townhouses.
 Typically, there are two types of villa, as shown below:
      − Detached villa: a single villa built on private land
      − Semi-detached villa: a single villa built as one of a pair that shares one common wall; often, each house layout is a mirror
          image of the other
Townhouse
A tall, narrow terraced house, generally having three or more floors. The plot ratio is usually more than 70% and is focused on the
construction floor area.
 Most popular townhouses have plot areas of 60-100 sqm
 The popular construction area/Gross Floor Area (GFA) is about 150-250 sqm
Shophouse
A townhouse opening on to the pavement for commercial purposes.
 The construction and design are similar to those of townhouses. The popular construction area/Gross Floor Area (GFA) of
    shophouses is about 250-400 sqm, with the upper 3-4 floors for living purposes and the ground floor (or middle floor, if applicable)
    for commercial purposes. It is larger than a townhouse.
 In one project, all things equal, the selling price per square metre of land is higher compared to townhouses because usually, in
    one project, shophouses have better locations and wider street frontage compared to other landed property units, for commercial
    purposes.
Note: The product classification provided above should not be understood as the sole and utmost criterion based on which projects are
assigned types.
Integrated project
Refers to a n eighbourh ood o r township dev elopmen t with mixed-u se componen ts such as, residential , retail, institution, leisu re and
more where residents can live, wo rk and pl ay. It comprises multifunctional and interconnected buildings, which focus on the
surrounding environment to ensure harmonious ‘street-scape’ and architecture.
Market practices: As the Vietnam real estate market is g radually maturing, a su stainable wholesome living environment is an important
factor for buyers to consider. Based on our real esta te expertise, the suitable size of an integ rated development should be in exc ess of 5ha
to ensure commercial viable facilities.
You can also read