UPDATE UN-Habitat Topic A: Developing Adequate Housing for Refugees in Latin America and the Caribbean Topic B: Fostering Sustainable Urban ...
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
UPDATE UN-Habitat PA P E R Topic A: Developing Adequate Housing for Refugees in Latin America and the Caribbean Topic B: Fostering Sustainable 2 0 2 1 Urban Development for Repatri- ated Refugees in East Africa
Email: info@imuna.org Phone: +1 (212) 652-9992 Web: www.nhsmun.org Secretary-General Dear Delegates, Maura Goss I would like to welcome you all to NHSMUN 2021 and the UN-Habitat committee. This is my first Directors-General year as an Assistant Director in NHSMUN, and I am very excited for the conference. I attended Rose Blackwell two NHSMUN conferences during High School and one SUSMUN conference in Atlanta in the JJ Packer 8th grade, so I know how it can be a very thrilling experience and a great opportunity to learn about Conference Services new issues you may not have read about before. I am from Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, and I currently Hannah Lilley attend the University of Miami (go ‘Canes!). I am majoring in Neuroscience and plan on possibly Alisa Wong minoring in microbiology and immunology. Apart from NHSMUN, I am also involved in dance, Delegate Experience theatre, and quiz bowl. Akanksha Sancheti John Wood This year’s topics are extremely relevant and interesting. The first topic on developing adequate housing for refugees in Latin America and the Caribbean is especially important to me coming from Global Partnerships Sofia Fuentes Brazil because I know how big of an issue inadequate housing is here. However, the second topic Salmaan Rashiq is also very current and significant, as fostering urban development for repatriated refugees in East Africa is a complex issue with many different aspects to be considered, such as water sanitation, Under-Secretaries- General food insecurity, and ensuring affordable housing. In the update paper, we tried to focus on the most Jon Basile current issues in the region, how they have been affected by the COVID-19 pandemic. Although Ankita Bhat the issue of housing may often be overlooked, ensuring that people have access to appropriate Beatriz Circelli and sustainable housing is a crucial part of enabling the progress, safety, and quality of life of the Caitlyn Johnson people of both of the regions we will address in the committee. Patrick Leong Kathy Li I hope that you were all able to enjoy the process of researching and writing on these issues until Pablo Maristany de now and that this update paper may guide your further searches on both topics. If you have any las Casas questions, please email us, as we all look forward to seeing the great ideas and solutions you bring McCall Olliff to debate in March. Abolee Raut Pranav Reddy Sincerely, Clare Steiner Ann Williams Marina Lamas Koria marina.koria@imuna.org United Nations Human Settlements Programme Session I
Email: info@imuna.org Phone: +1 (212) 652-9992 Web: www.nhsmun.org Secretary-General Dear Delegates, Maura Goss Welcome to NHSMUN 2021! My name is Mia Piazzi, and I am so honored and excited to serve as Directors-General one of your assistant directors for Session I of the United Nations Human Settlement Programme Rose Blackwell (UN-HABITAT). Along with your other assistant director, Marina Koria, we are happy to present JJ Packer this update paper to you, and we hope it will be a useful resource for your research. Conference Services Hannah Lilley I have lived in Queens, New York, my whole life and am currently a sophomore at the Fashion Alisa Wong Institute of Technology, where I major in Fashion Business Management with minors in Asian Delegate Experience Studies and International Politics. A lot of people might wonder what fashion and Model UN have Akanksha Sancheti to do with one another and if you can find a correlation, please tell me. Outside of school, I am John Wood currently double interning at a fashion PR company and a media group, and I am also volunteering on a city council campaign. When I have a bit of free time, I enjoy styling outfits, exploring new Global Partnerships Sofia Fuentes places in the city, and of course, shopping. I am also an avid music listener and enjoy anything from Salmaan Rashiq K-Pop (my favorite group is TWICE) to Italian Alpine songs. Under-Secretaries- I attended NHSMUN from 2017–2019. During these three years, I participated in SPECPOL, General OAS, and UNESCO. Being in fashion, I’ve realized many skills that I gained from NHSMUN Jon Basile have transferred over. I’ve had to do numerous presentations in class that required me to be very Ankita Bhat confident and assertive, which I learned from being in a large committee. Even my style has been Beatriz Circelli Caitlyn Johnson influenced by the business casual clothing I had to wear. All around, NHSMUN has had such a Patrick Leong large impact on who I am as a person, and I am so immensely grateful for that experience and to Kathy Li now serve the conference as an assistant director. A part of what made each conference so memo- Pablo Maristany de rable was my dais. Along with Marina and your director, Ana, we are all determined to make this las Casas committee equally enjoyable, even in this unconventional format. McCall Olliff Abolee Raut Like other update papers, we also focused on the impact of COVID-19, as it has undoubtedly Pranav Reddy changed all our lives and has also impacted the severeness of these topics, pushing back a lot of Clare Steiner initiatives and introducing a new hurdle to overcome. But we also discussed recent and futuristic Ann Williams solutions to the topic on hand that could possibly help improve the situation. They will provide for compelling debate throughout the sessions, and I am excited to see what you all will come up with. NHSMUN is a one-of-a-kind experience, and while it is unfortunate that we cannot all be in person, I am optimistic that you will still have a fantastic time in March. No matter if this is your first time at NHSMUN or your last, I want you all to succeed in committee and feel comfortable. With that being said, I am at your disposal for any questions, advice, or anything else that you might need. Please do not hesitate to contact me, and I look forward to meeting you all very soon! All the Best, Mia Piazzi mia.piazzi@imuna.org United Nations Human Settlement Programme Session I
Email: info@imuna.org Phone: +1 (212) 652-9992 Web: www.nhsmun.org Secretary-General Dear Delegates, Maura Goss Welcome to NHSMUN 2021! My name is Angela Dela Cruz, and I am super excited to be one of Directors-General your assistant directors for UN-Habitat Session II! Seiyon and I hope that this update paper ben- Rose Blackwell efits you as you continue to research the topics that will be debated in committee. JJ Packer Conference Services I was born in the Philippines but primarily grew up in Bay Shore, New York, on Long Island. I am Hannah Lilley a Freshman at Harvard University, concentrating in molecular and cellular biology with a secondary Alisa Wong in mind brain behavior on a pre-medical track. While I am a die-hard STEM gal, I often enjoy im- Delegate Experience mersing myself in the humanities and partaking in Model UN activities—aside from being an As- Akanksha Sancheti sistant Director for NHSMUN, I am also an Assistant Director for HMUN and HNMUN’s DISEC John Wood Committees! Outside of the Model UN World, I am an Event Coordinator for the Harvard Science Olympiad Organization and am also a Multimedia Editor working for the Harvard Crimson, our Global Partnerships Sofia Fuentes school newspaper. In the limited amount of free time I have, I enjoy geeking out about anime, Salmaan Rashiq practicing martial arts, and learning new languages. I am also a musician and an avid music listener; my favorite genres include any kind of rock (classic, blues, folk) and indie. Under-Secretaries- General Prior to becoming a NHSMUN Assistant Director, I previously participated as a delegate from Jon Basile 2018–2020 in SOCHUM, SPECPOL, and DISEC. In the three years that I was involved in high Ankita Bhat school Model UN, I was able to become a better leader and a student, as it allowed me to develop Beatriz Circelli Caitlyn Johnson my public speaking, leadership, and communication/collaboration skills. Serving as both delegate Patrick Leong and chair in high school is an eye-opening experience that I will never forget! NHSMUN 2021 will Kathy Li be the third conference I act as an assistant director in this year—I am both honored and excited to Pablo Maristany de hear everyone’s discussions and see all of your hard work and preparation come to fruition! las Casas McCall Olliff In our update paper, my fellow assistant director and I touch on issues related to COVID-19 that Abolee Raut have come to light within recent months. Such topics include natural disasters, housing and sanita- Pranav Reddy tion for refugees, and the economy—all of which are challenges that refugees and citizens of the Clare Steiner Latin American/Caribbean region face. In committee, it is crucial that you consider these updates Ann Williams when coming to a consensus and formulating solutions that will benefit the affected parties. Most of all, you must work together as the United Nations to ensure them access to safe and sustainable shelter. I am certain that this year’s debate will be both thrilling and engaging, and I eagerly await to hear everyone’s innovative ideas. If you have any questions, comments, and concerns, please do not hesitate to reach out to the other chairs or me. I look forward to meeting you all in March and wish you all the best of luck! Sincerely, Angela Dela Cruz angela.delacruz@imuna.org United Nations Human Settlement Programme Session II
Email: info@imuna.org Phone: +1 (212) 652-9992 Web: www.nhsmun.org Secretary-General Dear Delegates, Maura Goss Welcome to NHSMUN 2021! I’m Seiyon Kim, and I am an assistant director for the United Na- Directors-General tions Human Settlement Programme (UN-Habitat), Session II. My co-assistant director, Angela, Rose Blackwell and I are so excited to be your assistant directors, and we sincerely hope that this update paper JJ Packer serves as a guide to your research. Conference Services Hannah Lilley I am from East Brunswick, New Jersey, and the Model United Nations program was an integral part Alisa Wong of my high school experience. I have many cherished memories from both conferences, and I hope Delegate Experience your NHSMUN 2021 experience is just as enjoyable. I am a freshman at Rutgers University and am Akanksha Sancheti unsure about what the future holds, but I am leaning heavily towards nursing school. In my free John Wood time, I enjoy reading, taking pictures (especially of my cat, Luna), expending way too much mental and physical energy into doing puzzles and cooking. Global Partnerships Sofia Fuentes I am so excited to see the ideas and solutions you have regarding these unique and intricate topics. Salmaan Rashiq In our update paper, we discuss the effects of the COVID-19 and natural disasters on housing for Under-Secretaries- refugees, as well as ongoing efforts and challenges presented to creating sustainable housing. Being General as specific as they are, the topics provide a lot of room for creative thinking and innovative solu- Jon Basile tions. Since the background guides were published, there have been new projects and efforts to pro- Ankita Bhat vide shelters for refugees and create sustainable housing in Latin America, the Caribbean, and East Beatriz Circelli Caitlyn Johnson Africa. As refugee populations in both regions continue to grow, it is critical for the United Nations Patrick Leong and host countries to work together and ensure refugees can access safe, sustainable shelter. Kathy Li For the most productive debate, I encourage you to continue your research up until the conference Pablo Maristany de and stay updated on ongoing events. Please don’t hesitate to contact any of us with questions. I’m las Casas McCall Olliff looking forward to meeting all of you! Abolee Raut Sincerely, Pranav Reddy Clare Steiner Seiyon Kim Ann Williams seiyon.kim@imuna.org United Nations Human Settlement Programme Session II
UN-Habitat 6| Table of Contents Table of Contents Developing Adequate Housing for Refugees in Latin America and the Caribbean7 Fostering Sustainable Urban Development for Repatriated Refugees in East Africa13 Works Cited 18
UN-Habitat NHSMUN 2021 Topic A: Developing Adequate Housing for Refugees in Latin America and the Caribbean Photo Credit: Romério Cunha
Topic A: Developing Adequate Housing for Refugees in Latin America and the Caribbean 8| Introduction Political, economic, ecological, and social issues in Latin America and the Caribbean continue to exacerbate the region’s refugee crises. Overpopulated refugee camps face difficulties in providing adequate housing for the rising population. The situations in Venezuela and Nicaragua—the two largest sources of refugees in the region—show no signs of de-escalation or conclusion. As a result, more people will likely flee their country while currently displaced people will be unable to return. In existing temporary shelters, insufficient space for proper social distancing and severe scarcities of hygiene and sanitation supplies have made the COVID-19 pandemic particularly devastating. In recent months, external factors have forced many people to flee their homes. The 2020 hurricane season was particularly devastating to affected regions. Multiple high-level hurricanes caused wide- scale destruction of land and buildings, including the homes of people living in Latin America and the Caribbean.1 Countries like Nicaragua and Honduras were left with an unprecedented number of people in urgent need of shelter following the storms. The decreased economic activity only drives more people into poverty and further exacerbates suffering in the region. It is imperative that delegates research recent developments that have impacted housing for refugees to address the chal- lenges created by COVID-19 and recent natural disasters. Refugees and COVID-19 from facilities, cost of care, or legal status, which often pre- COVID-19 is currently the most daunting challenge that ref- vents refugees from accessing essential care. Now, COVID-19 ugees in Latin America and the Caribbean face. Social dis- has debilitated those existing healthcare systems making them tancing, frequent handwashing, and access to essential health even more difficult to access for refugees.4 services are crucial in mitigating the spread of COVID-19. Living conditions in refugee camps and informal shelters and However, for refugees living in refugee camps or temporary the lack of sanitation supplies further increase the likelihood shelters, these are unattainable luxuries. Many refugee camps of the spread of COVID-19. Refugee camps in major cit- are overcrowded, making it impossible to maintain a safe dis- ies are severely overcrowded; one camp in São Paulo, Brazil, tance from others. This same issue arises in urban shelters, where refugees live in close quarters. COVID-19 has also de- holds 8,100 people per square kilometer.5 In developing coun- creased access to necessary supplies such as food, water, and tries, nearly 75 percent of people do not have basic handwash- sanitation supplies.2 Urban shelters also have little access to ing facilities at home, and in refugee camps, soap and water testing for COVID-19, which has been severely limited in the are rarely accessible.6 More than 22 percent of refugee camps Latin American and the Caribbean regions.3 Refugees already and shelters lack access to adequate water supplies.7 At a min- lack access to proper healthcare because of physical distance imum, a person requires four gallons of water per day for 1 “Too Many Storms, Not Enough Names,” NPR, November 30, 2020, https://www.npr.org/2020/11/30/937986687/too-many-storms- not-enough-names/. 2 “COVID-19 Brief: Impact on Refugees,” U.S. Global Leadership Coalition, accessed December 4, 2020, https://www.usglc.org/corona- virus/refugees/. 3 Elizabeth Gonzales et. al, “The Coronavirus in Latin America,” Americas Society/ Council of the Americas, last modified November 18, 2020, https://www.as-coa.org/articles/coronavirus-latin-america. 4 United Nations Conference on Housing and Sustainable Urban Development, Habitat III Policy Papers: Policy Paper 10 Housing Policies (New York: United Nations, 2017), http://uploads.habitat3.org/hb3/Habitat%20III%20Policy%20Paper%2010.pdf. 5 “Space, shelter and scarce resources - coping with COVID-19,” United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees, accessed December 4, 2020, https://storymaps.arcgis.com/stories/e1da7d80fbcf4ce8a3a954910c1e7f37. 6 “Handwashing with soap, critical in the fight against coronavirus, is ‘out of reach’ for billions – UNICEF Statement on preventing COVID-19,” UNICEF, last modified March 13, 2020, https://www.unicef.org/eap/press-releases/handwashing-soap-critical-fight-against- coronavirus-out-reach-billions-unicef. 7 “Handwashing with soap, critical in the fight against coronavirus, is ‘out of reach’ for billions.”
Topic A: Developing Adequate Housing for Refugees in Latin America and the Caribbean |9 drinking, washing, cooking, and personal hygiene uses.8 For those of the general population. context, the average American uses 88 gallons of water per day.9 Not only is the lack of access to water detrimental for Natural Disasters basic hygiene and sanitation maintenance, but it exacerbates The 2020 hurricane season has wreaked havoc in Latin Amer- the spread of COVID-19. It is vital that refugees at risk of ica and the Caribbean with a total of 39 hurricanes, breaking contracting the COVID-19 virus are provided with adequate the record for the most named hurricanes in a season.11 Five housing conditions in order to promote health, sanitation, and storms between October 5, 2020, and November 18, 2020, safety. were particularly devastating to the region: Hurricanes Delta, While COVID-19 has impacted everyone, refugees have Zeta, Eta, Theta, and Iota.12 These storms left affected coun- had to face substantial challenges. As discussed in the back- tries with no time to fortify shelters before the next hurricane ground guide, refugees often cannot access proper medical came, and the effects of the storms on individuals in those care because of its high cost. Furthermore, because refugee countries were devastating, as upwards of a million people camps, slums, and temporary urban settlements are usually were forced to leave their homes, some of whom had pre- long distances away from healthcare facilities, it may not even viously been displaced.13 In Honduras, the United Nations be practical to travel for medical care, especially in the event Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (UN of a time-sensitive emergency. Additionally, the poor sanitary OCHA) estimated that out of the nearly 1.8 million Hondu- conditions and extreme population density of these shelters rans affected by Hurricane Eta, about 40 thousand were in increase the likelihood of becoming ill, especially in light of a shelters.14 highly contagious virus such as COVID-19. Medical challeng- es make it especially difficult for refugees to move to proper Numerous informal, temporary shelters have been created in housing, as their short-term focus on paying medical bills and places such as schools, but many are overcrowded.15 In San receiving proper treatment impedes them from saving the Pedro Sula, one of the largest cities in Honduras, there are funds to do so. COVID-19 creates a new challenge in that only 84 shelters to hold about 100,000 people.16 When these many refugees cannot continue doing the jobs they had before shelters reach their maximum capacity and are forced to close the pandemic, causing an increase in evictions for Venezuelan their doors, people are left with no choice but to seek shel- refugees in Colombia.10 Therefore, the focus should be on ter under bridges and near motorways.17 The temporary shel- housing and how the lack of access to sustainable housing has ters do not meet UN standards for adequate shelter.18 These created unique challenges during the pandemic separate from standards include “adequate privacy, adequate space, adequate 8 “Space, shelter and scarce resources - coping with COVID-19.” 9 “WaterSense: Statistics and Facts,” United States Environmental Protection Agency, accessed November 30, 2020, https://www.epa.gov/ watersense/statistics-and-facts. 10 Regional Refugee and Migrant Response Plan for Refugees and Migrants from Venezuela ( Geneva: UNHCR, December 10, 2020), https://data2. unhcr.org/es/documents/details/82927. 11 “Too Many Storms, Not Enough Names.” 12 “Too Many Storms, Not Enough Names.” 13 Allison Chinchar and Haley Brink, “Hurricane season ends historic as predicted by experts back in April,” CNN, November 30, 2020, https://www.cnn.com/2020/11/30/weather/record-breaking-atlantic-hurricane-season-wrap-up/index.html. 14 United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs, Central America: Tropical Storm Eta Situation Report No. 2 (New York : OCHA, November 9, 2020), https://reliefweb.int/sites/reliefweb.int/files/resources/20201109%20CA%20Eta%20SitRep%202.pdf. 15 “In pictures: Hurricanes leave Hondurans homeless and destitute,” BBC, November 29, 2020, https://www.bbc.com/news/world-latin- america-55064560. 16 Claudio Escalon, “Hundreds of thousands at Honduras’ shelters after hurricanes,” Associated Press, November 21, 2020, https://apnews. com/article/international-news-floods-honduras-coronavirus-pandemic-hurricanes-6ef26cf35c75c1e9ebc414a791ee3768. 17 Duncan Tucker and Encarni Pindado, “When it rains it pours: The devastating impact of hurricanes Eta and Iota in Honduras,” Am- nesty International, last modified December 13, 2020, https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2020/12/devastating-impact-hurricanes- eta-iota-honduras/. 18 United Nations, Fact Sheet No.21, The Human Right to Adequate Housing (Geneva :OHCHR, October 2009), https://www.un.org/ruleoflaw/ files/FactSheet21en.pdf.
10|T opic A: Developing Adequate Housing for Refugees in Latin America and the Caribbean security, adequate lighting and ventilation, adequate basic in- and the third phase will focus on sustainable development.25 frastructure and adequate location concerning work and basic It will take significant effort and aid from the government and facilities-all at a reasonable cost.”19 With the loss of land and the international community to complete the first and second infrastructure caused by the hurricanes, inhabitants have been phases to properly proceed with the third phase, making ev- left homeless, with their “shelters” often being no more than ery step critical to creating sustainable housing.26 While aid a mat and blanket.20 Sanitary conditions are poor, and over- from other countries and non-governmental organizations crowding is severe, increasing the spread of COVID-19.21 may make it possible to create temporary settlements and pro- vide tents, these countries face the daunting task of rebuilding For refugees from countries such as Guatemala and Hondu- their infrastructure and economies. Delegates should focus on ras, the state of their home after the hurricane made landfall creating solutions that will create adequate temporary hous- is likely unknown.22 The hurricanes’ torrential rains caused se- ing for those who will eventually return to their homes, as vere flooding and recurring landslides, making it difficult to well as permanent housing for those whose homes have been determine when it is safe to return.23 Many lost their homes destroyed. permanently, washed away in floodwaters or buried in mud as deep as 50 feet.24 Worse still, because of the dramatic changes The Economy in Latin America and the Carib- to the landscape, the land that their home was built on may bean no longer be suitable for rebuilding. Therefore, while many The COVID-19 pandemic has presented a considerable chal- people need temporary shelter until they can return to their lenge to the Latin American and Caribbean economies. Al- homes, others have permanently lost their homes and will though the gross domestic product (GDP) of Latin America need to find new ones. Considering that such people have was, at the beginning of the year, anticipated to grow at a lost most of their money and belongings in the hurricane, rate of 1.8 percent in 2020, updated projections expect an they may turn to inadequate shelter or slums. In doing so, 8.1 percent contraction.27 Due to the significant economic they will likely enter the cycle of poverty, as living in these downturn this fiscal year, income inequality and poverty slums decreases the availability of opportunities for work and are expected to rise considerably.28 According to the United education, further decreasing their ability to afford adequate Nations Economic Commission for Latin America and the housing in the future. The destruction and loss of land caused Caribbean (ECLAC), inequality will increase in all countries by the hurricanes also impact the governments’ ability to cre- in Latin America and the Caribbean, particularly those with ate sustainable housing. They have delayed plans for sustain- large economies such as Brazil, Mexico, and Argentina.29 Fur- able development to prioritize immediate humanitarian relief. thermore, a United Nations report from July 2020 stated that The Honduran government has created a three-phase plan: there would be an estimated 37.2 percent escalation in poverty the first phase will focus on humanitarian relief; the second rate by the end of 2020 for the region—6.9 percent higher phase will focus on rapid repair of homes, roads, and bridges; than in 2019—which ultimately accounts for an additional 45 19 United Nations, Fact Sheet No.21, The Human Right to Adequate Housing. 20 “Hurricanes leave Hondurans homeless and destitute.” 21 “Hurricanes leave Hondurans homeless and destitute.” 22 Natalie Gallón and Matt Rivers, “In Central America, a devastating storm and an uncertain future,” CNN, November 12, 2020, https:// www.cnn.com/2020/11/12/americas/hurricane-eta-guatemala-honduras-intl/index.html. 23 “In Central America, a devastating storm and an uncertain future.” 24 “In Central America, a devastating storm and an uncertain future.” 25 Delphine Schrank, “Battered by back-to-back hurricanes, Honduras braces for a long recovery,” The Washington Post, November 26, 2020, https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/the_americas/hurricane-eta-iota-honduras-central-america/2020/11/25/8cd11e98-2e75-11eb- bae0-50bb17126614_story.html. 26 “Battered by back-to-back hurricanes, Honduras braces for a long recovery.” 27 Joaquín Cottani, “The Effects of Covid-19 on Latin America’s Economy,” Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS), last modified November 18, 2020. https://www.csis.org/analysis/effects-covid-19-latin-americas-economy. 28 Cottani, “The Effects of Covid-19 on Latin America’s Economy.” 29 Mark P. Sullivan et al., Latin America and the Caribbean: Impact of COVID-19, Congressional Research Service, December 17, 2020, Ac- cessed December 20, 2020, https://fas.org/sgp/crs/row/IF11581.pdf.
Topic A: Developing Adequate Housing for Refugees in Latin America and the Caribbean |11 million people.30 shelter, get back up on their feet, and help re-stimulate the economy. While the concept of economic stagnation on its Latin American and Caribbean economies were greatly af- own does not fall under the jurisdiction of this topic, it is dis- fected by COVID-19 in 2020, and the pandemic has caused a tinctly linked to housing and must be addressed by delegates decline in the fiscal position of both regions. The economies looking to effectively improve housing availability and condi- of these regions have become hampered by and observed tions. As Latin American and Caribbean countries are able to an overall decrease in economic activity and increased gov- re-stimulate economic growth, they will also be able to dedi- ernment spending. Due to efforts to mitigate the spread of cate more resources towards improved housing for vulnerable disease, shutdowns, and social distancing have been imple- populations. mented at the cost of labor availability, which hinders the overall economy by slowing production and expenditure.31 Delegates must understand the current economic situation The aforementioned decline in aggregate demand has led to in the Latin American and Caribbean regions and consider a reduction in revenues and accompanies a sharp increase in how these countries might stimulate and repair their economy. unemployment. On the other hand, the decrease in aggregate While COVID-19 has played a significant role in the current supply could lead to a situation economists refer to as “stag- state of the region’s economies, it should not be the sole focus flation,” where growing inflation rates cause prices to increase when formulating possible solutions. Moreover, short-term while the economy still fails to grow.32 As a result, many of and long-term solutions will be crucial in jumpstarting these the citizens in Latin American and Caribbean countries will nations’ economic situations and giving them the tools neces- be feeling the financial impact of the shutdown, possibly in sary to maintain economic growth and prosperity for years the form of losing their houses and the ability to purchase to come. In committee, delegates must assess the issue and essential goods and services.33 determine what they, as the UN-Habitat, can do to aid Latin American and Caribbean nations and their economies so that Housing is an additional challenge for these countries already adequate housing may be profitable and financially attainable. experiencing economic hardship. Despite its importance, housing has been widely neglected in COVID-19 economic Conclusion responses in favor of other significant issues, such as access to job opportunities, production of goods and services, and The COVID-19 pandemic has proven to be a significant det- the provision of public services.34 Due to the lack of attention riment to Latin American and Caribbean countries in many that housing receives from policymakers, central governments ways. For refugees, in particular, their housing situations fail to distribute funding that would allow local and regional greatly increase the chances of spreading the virus. The pan- communities to create adequate housing while simultaneously demic has resulted in setbacks in sanitation for refugees as well allocating funds to urban services.35 Thus, any progress made as economic and infrastructural devastation to the countries is minute, and a significant proportion of the population, that house them. Natural disasters have proven crippling to mostly made up of the impoverished, must deal with what the overall welfare of these countries and have especially im- little inadequate shelter is provided.36 Improved policies de- pacted refugees whose homes have been destroyed. Although signed to alleviate financial concerns (on both governments these issues are multifaceted, delegates should be sure to focus and the constituents) could allow those in poverty to find on UN-Habitat’s mandate and come up with solutions that 30 Sullivan et al., Latin America and the Caribbean: Impact of COVID-19. 31 Regional Economic Outlook for Western Hemisphere (Washington DC : International Monetary Fund, October 2020), https://www.imf.org/en/ Publications/REO/WH/Issues/2020/10/13/regional-economic-outlook-western-hemisphere. 32 Ryan Williams, “Why Stagflation Is Back on Some Traders’ Radars,” August 14, 2020, https://www.bloomberg.com/news/arti- cles/2020-08-14/why-stagflation-is-back-on-some-traders-radars-quicktake. 33 Williams, “Why Stagflation Is Back on Some Traders’ Radars.” 34 Melanie McCrackin, “Housing in Latin America: The Problems, Policies and Potentials.” BORGEN Magazine, November 3, 2020, https://www.borgenmagazine.com/housing-in-latin-america-the-problems-policies-and-potentials/. 35 McCrackin, “Housing in Latin America: The Problems, Policies and Potentials.” 36 McCrackin, “Housing in Latin America: The Problems, Policies and Potentials.”
12|T opic A: Developing Adequate Housing for Refugees in Latin America and the Caribbean ensure sustainable housing and communities for those in the region. Despite the impediments, it is possible that through collaboration and meticulous planning, Latin American and Caribbean populations can find their footing with the imple- mentation of a thorough and comprehensive policy.s
UN-Habitat NHSMUN 2021 Topic B: Fostering Sustainable Urban Development for Repatriated Refugees in East Africa Photo Credit: diaznash
14|T opic B: Fostering Sustainable Urban Development for Repatriated Refugees in East Africa Introduction In 2020, the COVID-19 pandemic added significant stress to existing problems in the East Africa region for various groups, including women, minorities, and refugees. Strict lockdowns have fur- thered uncertainty for refugees and internally displaced persons (IDPs) already in transit to their home countries. These groups are now trapped in intermediary locations and are highly vulnerable due to a lack of resources and face heightened vulnerability to disease as a result of a lack of sanita- tion, social distancing, and health-related supplies. While many East African countries originally fared well regarding the COVID-19 outbreak, infections have begun to grow in many countries in which refugees reside. Furthermore, as the COVID-19 pandemic continues to draw resources and funding away from various programs that traditionally assist refugees in East Africa, conditions for refugees have begun to worsen. Repatriated refugees are facing a growing risk of their only viable housing op- tions being in dangerous urban slums. As such, it is more important now than ever for UN-Habitat to foster urban development in East Africa that provides the groundwork for health and success for all repatriated refugees. COVID 19’s Effect on Urban Resettled Refu- individuals in households without water, sanitation, and food gees storage are more likely to violate lockdown measures, empha- Due to COVID-19 and a lack of resources for refugee repa- sizing the important connection between food security, water, triation in the East African Community (EAC), it has become and habitation with the fight against the COVID-19 pandem- more difficult for refugees to access food and clean water.1 ic.6 Refugees returning to their home countries face settlements and camps with poor sanitation and access to basic health Together with South Africa, East African countries recorded supplies.2 As governments allocate funds to COVID-19 re- more than one million COVID-19 cases during October.7 A sponses and away from refugee resettlement, these groups total of 1,047,124 confirmed cases and 24,997 deaths (a case experience some of the greatest levels of food insecurity in fatality ratio of 2.4 percent) have been documented.8 In Ke- the region.3 Between 2018 and 2019, the number of people nya, for example, 25 percent of cases were recorded in Octo- in need of urgent food assistance rose by two percent (or ber alone.9 Moreover, flooding and conflicts in East African 650,000 people), with disproportionate effects on repatriated countries have hindered COVID-19 prevention measures, es- refugees and IDPs.4 This problem worsened in 2020 with the pecially among the displaced populations facing serious water, pandemic, adding more challenges to already overcrowded sanitation, and hygiene challenges.10 This can be troubling, as refugee camps, offering a low quality of life to repatriated it puts stress on already underfunded housing development refugees and IDPs.5 Additionally, researchers have found that projects. COVID-19 has also underscored the importance of 1 Salman Salman, “South Sudan road to independence: Broken promises and lost opportunities,” Pac. McGeorge Global Bus. & Dev. LJ 26, no. 2( January 2013): 344 -410, https://scholarlycommons.pacific.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1026&context=globe). 2 Salman, “South Sudan road to independence: Broken promises and lost opportunities.” 3 Salman, “South Sudan road to independence: Broken promises and lost opportunities.” 4 Phoebe Sleet, Food Security Declines in East Africa Following Economic, Climate and Conflict Shocks - Future Directions International (Nedlands :Fu- ture Directions International Pty Ltd, October 2020), https://www.futuredirections.org.au/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/Food-Security- Declines-in-East-Africa-Following-Economic-Climate-and-Conflict-Shocks.pdf. 5 Sleet, “Food Security Declines in East Africa Following Economic, Climate and Conflict Shocks - Future Directions International.” 6 Bernard Ekumah et al., “Disparate on-site access to water, sanitation, and food storage heighten the risk of COVID-19 spread in Sub- Saharan Africa,” Environmental research 189 (2020) : 1-12, https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7368919/pdf/main.pdf. 7 UNFPA, East and Southern Africa Region COVID-19 Situation Report No. 9., ( New York : UNFPA ESARO, October 2020),https://reliefweb. int/report/south-africa/east-and-southern-africa-region-covid-19-situation-report-no-9-1-31-october-2020. 8 UNFPA, East and Southern Africa Region COVID-19 Situation Report No. 9. 9 UNFPA, East and Southern Africa Region COVID-19 Situation Report No. 9. 10 UNFPA, East and Southern Africa Region COVID-19 Situation Report No. 9.
Topic B: Fostering Sustainable Urban Development for Repatriated Refugees in East Africa |15 proper water sanitation and supply, as handwashing is one of Violent conflicts, such as the South Sudanese civil war in 2013, the most basic prevention measures against the disease. Rapid have been a major factor in reducing food security, especially urbanization also strains the water supply. A recent World in Ethiopia and South Sudan in 2020. This happens because Bank tool for identifying pandemic “hotspots” found that cit- conflicts undermine these countries’ development, worsening ies’ crowded living conditions and inadequate public services, poverty, which in turn contributes to food insecurity. For ex- especially inadequate waste management and sanitation, are ample, 82 percent of South Sudan’s population lived under major sources of risk for transmitting the disease.11 Refugees the international poverty line in 2016, placing South Sudan returning to urban areas that lack adequate infrastructure face among the world’s poorest countries.14 This increase in the intersecting challenges of poor sanitation and food insecurity, number of families living under the poverty line led to a de- which further exacerbates the spread of COVID-19. cline in consumption levels from 2009–2016.15 The increase in poverty poses additional challenges to humanitarian agencies, COVID-19 also adds an extra obstacle to food security, which which fund programs for individuals internally displaced by is already an ongoing issue due to conflicts, climate shocks, conflicts and floods, forcing such agencies to cut food rations. and economic instability.12 Specifically, it has caused a rise in For example, the World Food Programme had to make cuts food prices and poverty in regions where there were already of 30 percent in April 2020 due to a lack of funding.16 concerns in the pre-pandemic period. One way in which this happens is through the implementation of lockdowns and All of these issues reinforce each other, as evidenced by the border closures.13 The latter may lead to a shortage of essen- situation in South Sudan in 2013, in which food insecurity tial food supplies. Closing borders limits the supply and in- rose after conflicts. Such conflicts have worsened social and creases the prices of other food-related products and services, political tensions and caused livestock displacement, early such as seeds, agrochemicals, pesticides, and fertilizers. Food depletion of food stocks, and poor access to markets.17 In security in the region decreased in 2020 due to two unusually addition, as COVID-19 exacerbates existing problems with wet, rainy seasons. These conditions have led to floods and food security and hygiene, so too do those problems further landslides, destroying crops and pastureland. Growing food increase the spread of COVID-19. As a vulnerable population insecurity presents an especially pressing challenge for repatri- moving into urban areas with little to no pre-existing support, ated refugees, who rely on low-cost food in the early stages refugees are particularly at risk when considering the effects of repatriation. Without food being readily available, refugees of poor food security and hygiene. Measures must be taken to may have to spend more to find food and, therefore, will have assist refugees and IDPs to protect them from the resulting little money to spend on safe housing. This dilemma furthers consequences of regional conflict and the spread of disease. the issues of slums, making safe housing in East Africa even Humanitarian workers, local leaders, and National Task Forc- more important. es on COVID-19, such as the one present in Uganda, may be 11 The World Bank Group, The Impact of COVID-19 on the Water and Sanitation Sector(Washington, D.C : World Bank Group, June 2020), https://www.ifc.org/wps/wcm/connect/126b1a18-23d9-46f3-beb7-047c20885bf6/The+Impact+of+COVID_Water%26Sanitation_fi- nal_web.pdf ?MOD=AJPERES&CVID=ncaG-hA. 12 Ayansina Ayanlade and Maren Radeny, “COVID-19 and food security in Sub-Saharan Africa: implications of lockdown during agricul- tural planting seasons,” nature partner journals 4, no. 1 (2020): 1-6, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/344245283_COVID-19_and_ food_security_in_Sub-Saharan_Africa_implications_of_lockdown_during_agricultural_planting_seasons. 13 Ayanlade and Radeny, “COVID-19 and food security in Sub-Saharan Africa: implications of lockdown during agricultural planting sea- sons,” 1-6. 14 The World Bank Group, South Sudan Economic Update, July 2018( Washington , D.C : The World Bank Group, July 2018), https:// openknowledge.worldbank.org/handle/10986/30294#:~:text=82%20percent%20of%20South%20Sudanese,to%20food%20insecurity%20 and%20displacement. 15 The World Bank Group, The Impact of Conflicts and Shock on Poverty, (Washington, D.C : The World Bank Group, June 2018), https:// documents.worldbank.org/en/publication/documents-reports/documentdetail/953201537854160003/impact-of-conflict-and-shocks-on- poverty-south-sudan-poverty-assessment-2017. 16 Sleet,”Food Security Declines in East Africa Following Economic, Climate and Conflict Shocks - Future Directions International.” 17 Sleet,”Food Security Declines in East Africa Following Economic, Climate and Conflict Shocks - Future Directions International.”
16|T opic B: Fostering Sustainable Urban Development for Repatriated Refugees in East Africa important sources of assistance.18 in slums.23 There is also a large housing deficit in the region due to the high prices of new homes and residential mortgages Recent Solutions to Improving Affordable that are hard to access.24 Additionally, “rapid urbanization and Housing and the Eliminate Slums lack of urban planning” have made affordable housing hard An ongoing challenge for regions that host millions of refu- to come by, and “ownership remains out of reach for many gees and IDPs is providing decent and affordable housing. households in the region.”25 Fortunately, some governments In the EAC, the provision of affordable housing and land have recognized this as a problem and have started coming up progressively becomes harder, making the quality of life for with ways to solve their housing deficits and develop sustain- the people living there lower and lower. Since September 30, able urban housing. 2020, East Africa has one of the highest numbers of dis- In Kenya, the government has taken on a more technologi- placed populations globally, with 6.4 million IDPs and 3.3 cal approach to building affordable homes. By utilizing ex- million refugees.19 These numbers are projected to rise as cli- panded polystyrene (EPS) panels, homes can be built in less mate change forcibly pushes people out of their homes and time and in a more sustainable fashion.26 To structure these produces wide-scale famine alongside a lack of clean water.20 buildings and make them secure, “EPS building technology Africa’s mass urbanization continues to spread infectious dis- entails building homes by assembling ready-made EPS panels, eases faster and makes response and containment measures sandwiched between a wire mesh that is sealed on both sides more difficult.21 With COVID-19 spreading rapidly through- with concrete.” Additional efficient and sustainable technolo- out the region, UN-Habitat quickly developed a COVID-19 gies also exist, such as Interlocking Stabilized Soil Blocks and Response Plan on April 22, 2020. This plan set out to help Compressed Agricultural Fiber.27 With these new advance- 64 developing and densely populated countries through ments, Kenya is looking towards a brighter future for sustain- awareness-raising campaigns, access to handwashing facilities, able housing, which could be used in other EAC countries. PPE, and large amounts of funding. Along with preventive These building technologies could also become an area of measures, UN-Habitat has also focused on countering the investment for businesses and lead to economic stimulation, pandemic’s economic impacts to help with recovery in these which may provide more funding towards affordable housing. countries. Focusing on “developing models for large scale Housing finance in the EAC has become an area of inter- public investments in affordable and adequate housing pro- est for governments and stakeholders in the region, allow- grammes and slum upgrading with a focus on water and sani- ing homebuyers to have more access to capital. In Uganda, tation and climate mitigation.”22 it is estimated that the housing deficit is at 2.1 million units.28 As of 2018, 58 percent of East Africa’s urban population live However, with housing finance, individuals can better afford 18 Willis Gwenzi, “Leaving no stone unturned in light of the COVID-19 faecal-oral hypothesis? A water, sanitation and hygiene (WASH) perspective targeting low-income countries,” Science of the Total Environment 753 (2021), 1-15, https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/ PMC7438205/pdf/main.pdf. 19 World Food Programme, WFP East Africa: Regional Refugee Update, November 2020 (Rome : World Food Programme, November 2020), https://reliefweb.int/sites/reliefweb.int/files/resources/RBN_RefugeeReport_NOV2020.pdf. 20 World Food Programme, WFP East Africa: Regional Refugee Update. 21 UN- Habitat, COVID-19 Response: Report of Activities, September 2020 ( Nairobi : UN - Habitat, September 2020), https://unhabitat.org/ sites/default/files/2020/10/covid-19_response_report_web26.10.20.pdf. 22 UN- Habitat, COVID-19 Response: Report of Activities, September 2020 23 Julia Faria,”Share of Slum Population in East Africa by Country,” Statista, last modified November 4, 2020, https://www.statista.com/ statistics/1171623/share-of-slum-population-in-east-africa-by-country/. 24 Faria,”Share of Slum Population in East Africa by Country,” 25 Centre for Affordable Housing Finance in Africa, “Housing Finance in East Africa,” accessed November 30, 2020, http://housingfi- nanceafrica.org/regions/east-african-community-eac/. 26 Eddy Mwanza, “Building a Home: New Technology Saving Kenyans Millions,” Kenyans.co.ke, last modified November 26, 2020, https://www.kenyans.co.ke/news/59519-building-home-new-technology-saving-kenyans-millions. 27 Mwanza, “Building a Home: New Technology Saving Kenyans Millions,” 28 Godfrey Ivudria, “Affordable Housing is Possible With Housing Finance Bank,” EABW News, November 14, 2020, https://www.busi- week.com/affordable-housing-is-possible-with-housing-finance-bank-babuwaire/.
Topic B: Fostering Sustainable Urban Development for Repatriated Refugees in East Africa |17 housing through a series of small payments without worrying East Africa. For now, it is important to consider all the factors about paying large amounts at once. Some of these solutions that are making sustainable urban development in the region include longer repayment periods, grace periods, and early difficult to achieve and to think about collaborative solutions loan redemption.29 With longer pay periods and fewer extra so that this issue can be under control as quickly as possible costs, buying a home in these countries has become much and as efficiently as possible.s more possible for people in countries like Uganda. Delegates should look to Uganda’s success when attempting to craft af- fordable housing solutions across the EAC. Developing adequate, affordable housing and the permanent elimination of slums is a challenge that requires innovative and futuristic solutions. This issue must be solved as soon as possible as the numbers of refugees and IDPs will only continue to rise in East Africa. The issue of slums and hous- ing requires not only short-term, humanitarian solutions like providing better access to necessities but long-term solutions that allow people to leave slums in favor of affordable and sustainable housing. It requires tackling the issue at the root to understand what causes people to live in slums instead of housing units. Conclusion In the period of one year, efforts to help refugees and IDPs repatriate in East Africa have been pushed to the side. A lack of funds and resources threatens to produce long-lasting con- sequences in the region. This pandemic has not stopped the growing rate of refugees and IDPs that are returning to the East African region. This will create a higher demand for af- fordable housing faster and will need modern and timely solu- tions. With millions fleeing their homes, housing is necessary to help repatriated refugees rebuild their new lives. Developing financial programs to help them afford homes and coming up with innovative solutions to make housing more afford- able and sustainable will help these populations in the long run to have a more stable and secure life. This is why it is so important to think ahead and plan for the future so that there will be housing when refugees and IDPs return to their East African countries of origin. Along with the hopeful prospects of a worldwide vaccine in 2021, perhaps efforts and previous plans can be put back on track to help these populations in 29 Ivudria, “Affordable Housing is Possible With Housing Finance Bank.”
18|UN-H W C orks abitat ited Works Cited Topic A UN Sources Regional Refugee and Migrant Response Plan for Refugees and Migrants from Venezuela. Geneva: UNHCR, December 10, 2020. https:// data2.unhcr.org/es/documents/details/82927. This report outlines the plan for December 2020 - January 2021 for Venezuelan refugees and migrants in other countries and includes details about challenges they currently face and plans to address them. UNICEF. “Handwashing with soap, critical in the fight against coronavirus, is ‘out of reach’ for billions – UNICEF Statement on preventing COVID-19.” Last modified March 13, 2020. https://www.unicef.org/eap/press-releases/handwashing- soap-critical-fight-against-coronavirus-out-reach-billions-unicef. This is a UNICEF report on statistics of access to soap, water, and handwashing facilities, distinguishing between developed and developing countries; it also explains how these resources are critical in reducing the spread of COVID-19. UN Habitat. “Housing policies.” Accessed June 20, 2020. http://habitat3.org/wp-content/uploads/Habitat%20III%20Poli- cy%20Paper%2010.pdf. This is a report from the United Nations Conference on Housing and Sustainable Urban Development that includes a comprehensive definition of sustainable housing and frameworks for creating adequate housing. UNHCR. “Identity Documents for Refugees.” Accessed January 4, 2020. https://www.unhcr.org/en-us/excom/scip/3ae68cce4/ identity-documents-refugees.html. This UNHCR webpage covers the documentation process for refugees, including documents and details they need to obtain legal documentation. United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees. “UNHCR joins response to victims of hurricane in Central America and Mexico.” November 13, 2020. https://www.unhcr.org/en-us/news/press/2020/11/5fae985b4/unhcr-joins-response- victims-hurricane-central-america-mexico.html?query=covid. This is a report from the UNHCR on Hurricane Eta’s effects and the current aid situation, including informal housing. United Nations, Fact Sheet No.21, The Human Right to Adequate Housing. Geneva : OHCHR, October 2009. https://www.un.org/ ruleoflaw/files/FactSheet21en.pdf. A UN publication that defines adequate housing and provides detailed information on precedents and proceedings to create this definition. United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees. “Space, shelter and scarce resources - coping with COVID-19.” Accessed December 4, 2020. https://storymaps.arcgis.com/stories/e1da7d80fbcf4ce8a3a954910c1e7f37. This is a website map that details how the quality of shelter and availability of space are affected by COVID-19 and how these changes limit the spread of the virus in refugee camps. United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs.Central America: Tropical Storm Eta Situation Report No. 2. New York : OCHA, November 9, 2020. https://reliefweb.int/sites/reliefweb.int/files/resources/20201109%20
UN-Habitat Works Cited |19 CA%20Eta%20SitRep%202.pdf. This is a UN publication on the effects of Hurricane Eta on Central America, focusing on Honduras and Guatemala. It gives detailed information about the hurricanes, statistics regarding the consequent damage, and the UN and NGOs’ ongoing efforts to help affected communities. Non-UN Sources BBC. “In pictures: Hurricanes leave Hondurans homeless and destitute.” November 29, 2020. https://www.bbc.com/news/ world-latin-america-55064560. This is a BBC article containing photos and descriptions of the aftermath of Hurricane Eta and descriptions of people’s temporary makeshift shelters. Chinchar, Allison and Haley Brink. “Hurricane season ends historic as predicted by experts back in April.” CNN. November 30, 2020. https://www.cnn.com/2020/11/30/weather/record-breaking-atlantic-hurricane-season-wrap-up/index.html. This CNN article contains statistics about the 2020 hurricane season, including details about effects on Latin American and Caribbean countries. Escalon, Claudio. “Hundreds of thousands at Honduras’ shelters after hurricanes.” Associated Press. November 21, 2020. https:// apnews.com/article/international-news-floods-honduras-coronavirus-pandemic-hurricanes-6ef26cf35c75c1e9eb- c414a791ee3768. This article describes the pressing issue of overcrowding in shelters following the extensive hurricane damage, as well as the effects this overcrowding is having on the spread of COVID-19. Gallón, Natalie and Matt Rivers. “In Central America, a devastating storm and an uncertain future.” CNN. November 12, 2020. https://www.cnn.com/2020/11/12/americas/hurricane-eta-guatemala-honduras-intl/index.html. CNN article containing statistics and details about Hurricane Eta and how it will increase migration, worsen the spread of COVID-19, and create a schooling crisis. Gonzales, Elizabeth, Katie Hopkins, Luisa Horwitz, Paola Nagovitch, Holly K. Sonneland, and Carin Zisses. “The Coronavirus in Latin America.” Americas Society/ Council of the Americas. Last modified November 18, 2020. https://www.as-coa. org/articles/coronavirus-latin-america. This is a report about the coronation in Latin America. It includes statistics and details about the government response, travel and school restrictions, and effects on each country’s economy. López, María Fernanda, Luisa Marín, Ernesto Romero, and David Smolansky. Situation of Venezuelans Who Have Returned and Are Trying to Return to Their Country in the Context of COVID-19. Washington. DC: Organization of American States, Septem- ber 2020. https://reliefweb.int/sites/reliefweb.int/files/resources/OAS_Venezuelan-Returnees_ENG.pdf. This is a report from the OAS about Venezuelan refugees who have been forced to return to Venezuela due to the pandemic; it includes details about their housing situation. NPR. “Too Many Storms, Not Enough Names.” November 30, 2020. https://www.npr.org/2020/11/30/937986687/too-ma- ny-storms-not-enough-names/. This NPR article of an earlier radio news report on the 2020 hurricane season highlights the devastation brought about by this year’s hurricanes.
You can also read