UK Public M&A Update 2019 REVIEW
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
UK Public M&A Update 2019 REVIEW
Contents Introduction Introduction 3 Welcome to Ashurst’s annual Public M&A Update – 2019 Review. Overview 4 As with our previous Updates, the overview provides an analysis of trends in the public M&A market in the UK during the year. Appendix 1 contains a summary of the key Practice & Panel Statements 12 features of the firm offer announcements we have reviewed in 2019. Contacts 13 The Q4 2019 Digest summarises recent news and developments from the UK Takeover Panel (the Panel) and any relevant court cases. Appendix: Announced UK takeover bids In the last quarter, Ashurst mandates have included advising: (1 January to 31 December 2019) 14 1. Amerisur Resources in relation to a recommended £242 million offer for the company by GeoPark Colombia S.A.S., following a formal sale process; 2. Goldman Sachs International in relation to the recommended partial offer for, and proposed share subscription in, Capital & Regional plc by Growthpoint Properties Limited; 3. Citigroup Global Markets Limited in relation to the £382 million recommended cash offer for Eland Oil & Gas PLC by Seplat Petroleum Development Company Plc; 4. Goldman Sachs International in relation to the US$3.8 billion recommended cash offer for Sophos Group plc by Surf Buyer Limited (a newly formed company owned by funds managed and/or advised by Thoma Bravo, LLC); 5. Wells Fargo in relation to Henderson Park’s €1.3 billion offer for Green REIT Plc; and 6. N.M. Rothschild & Sons Limited in relation to the £500 million recommended cash offer for Hansteen Holdings plc by Potter UK Bidco Limited (a newly formed company indirectly owned by investment funds advised by affiliates of The Blackstone Group Inc.). We hope you enjoy reading this Update and, as always, we would welcome your feedback. Best wishes The Ashurst Public M&A Team 3
Overview Deal values In contrast to deal volumes, deal values significantly decreased from a total of £120.4bn 2019 2018 2017 in 2018 to a total of £54.2bn in 2019. This is explicable in part by the decreased number of offers which exceeded £1bn and the absence of “mega deals”, such as 2018’s Takeda Announced bids1 74 45 46 Pharmaceutical Company Limited’s £46bn acquisition of Shire plc and Comcast Corporation’s £30.6bn acquisition of Sky plc. In contrast, the highest value offer Recommended 63 38 39 announced in 2019 was the recommended £6.26bn all-share merger of Takeaway.com N.V. and Just Eat plc. Schemes of arrangement 50 33 29 Overall, mid-market M&A powered the surge in deal volumes in 2019, with 43 (27) firm Average of bid premia offers having a deal value in excess of £100m, representing an increase from 2018. 13 (16) 54.6% 57.0% 33.3% (% unweighted) of those offers exceeded £1bn. 8 4 4 4 11 8 Bid consideration 4 4 4 Deal volume 11 Again, cash was king in 2019, reflecting healthy cash balances held by corporate buyers Of the deals we review (which excludes 31 minority offers by existing majority and the continuing availability of strong credit lines for debt financing including from shareholders), 2019 saw a large increase in the level of UK public bid activity in terms non-traditional lenders. 59 of the 74 firm offers announced were solely in cash. Several of deal volume as compared to 2018 with 74 firm offers (in excess of £1m) having been 31 bids saw a special dividend in respect of the financial year form part of the offer (for announced. There were 35 firm offers for Main Market targets (a 59% increase on the 22 example, Lovell Minnick Partners LLC’s offer for Charles Taylor plc, Seplat Petroleum Main Market bids in 2018) and 31 firm offers for AIM targets (a 3582% increase compared Development Company Plc’s offer for Eland Oil & Gas PLC and Sovereign Capital Partners to 17 in 2018). There were also six firm offers for unquoted targets, one firm offer for LLP’s 35 offer for Murgitroyd Group PLC). a target quoted on the NEX Exchange Growth Market and one firm offer for a target 59 66 quoted on NASDAQ Dubai. 11 bids included a share component, with four offering a mix and match facility. 59 66 The table below sets out the composition of bid consideration. Trading status of target company 4 Bid Consideration Recommendation status 8 4 4 11 Main Market Cash Trading status of target company Board recommendation on Bid Consideration Recommendation status 8 4 4 initial Rule 2.7 announcement 4 AIM Shares Main Market 11 Cash Board recommendatio 31 Unquoted/Other Markets Cash and Shares Hostile initial Rule 2.7 announ AIM Shares 31 No Recommendation Hostile Unquoted/Other Markets Cash and Shares 35 No Recommendation 59 66 35 59 66 Trading status of target company Bid Consideration Recommendation status A summary of the key features of these announced offers in 2019 is set out in the table Main Market Cash Board recommendation on in theAIM Appendix. Shares Trading status initial Rule 2.7ofannouncement target company Bid Consideration Recommendation status Main Market Hostile Cash Board recommendation on Unquoted/Other Markets Cash and Shares initial Rule 2.7 announcement NoAIM Recommendation Shares Unquoted/Other Markets Cash and Shares Hostile No Recommendation 1 This includes takeovers in respect of which a firm intention to make an offer has been announced under Rule 2.7 of the Code. It excludes offers by existing majority shareholders for minority positions. 4 5
Board 4 recommendation 4 4 Competing bids 11 66 of the 74 offers were recommended by the target board at the time of the initial Rule We have seen three competing bids in 2019 (as compared to two in 2018). 2.7 announcement (as compared to 38 of the 45 offers in 2018). As a result of higher competing bids, Macquarie Infrastructure and Real Assets (Europe) Eight bids were announced without the recommendation of the target board. These Limited succeeded in their offer for KCOM Group Public Limited Company, whilst were Thalassa Holdings Ltd’s unsolicited offer for The Local Shopping REIT plc, Non- Universities Superannuation Scheme Limited’s offer lapsed, and Berry Global Group, Standard Finance plc’s unsolicited offer for Provident Financial plc, Sports Direct Inc succeeded in their offer for RPC Group Plc, whilst Apollo Global Management, LLC’s International plc’s unsolicited offer for Findel plc, Spectre Holdings Limited’s mandatory offer lapsed. offer for Bonmarché Holdings plc, Sports Direct International plc’s mandatory offer for GAME Digital plc, Investindustrial Advisors Limited’s partial offer for Aston Martin The competing bids by Takeaway.com N.V. and Prosus N.V. for Just Eat pls saw various 59 66 bid tactics being used, including Takeaway.com switching structure from a scheme to Lagonda Global Holdings plc, Prosus N.V.’s unsolicited offer for Just Eat plc and Blake Holdings Limited’s mandatory cash offer for Hardy Oil and Gas plc. an offer and both parties increasing their initial offers and reducing their acceptance conditions. The recommended all-share merger of Takeaway.com N.V. and Just Eat Bid Consideration Recommendation status plc eventually prevailed as the board of Just Eat stood behind their recommendation 4 4 Cash Board recommendation on that shareholders reject Prosus’ offer on the basis that the board considers that the Shares initial Rule 2.7 announcement Takeaway.com combination provides Just Eat shareholders with greater value creation Hostile than the terms of the Prosus offer. Cash and Shares No Recommendation Private-equity backed bids There was a large increase in the number of private-equity backed bids (29) in 2019 66 compared to 2018 (10). Notably, four private-equity backed bids had a deal value of £1bn or more (Advent International Corporation’s £4bn bid for Cobham plc, TDR Capital LLP’s £1.906bn bid for BCA Marketplace plc, KIRKBI Invest A/S, funds advised by Blackstone BidRecommendation premia status Core Equity Advisors LLC and Canada Pension Plan Investment Board’s £4.766bn bid for Board recommendation on Bid premia (on2.7an initial Rule unweighted basis) on all announced deals saw a slight decrease in announcement Merlin Entertainments plc and Thoma Bravo, LLC’s US$3.82bn bid for Sophos Group plc). 2019 at 54.6% as compared to 57% in 2018. Unweighted premia in 2019 for bids in excess Hostile of £250m saw a decrease in 2019 to 35.4% from 46% in 2018. No Recommendation Break fees Break fees Bid structure 2019 saw the Panel consent to a target break fee in relation to GeoPark Limited’s offer Schemes of arrangement have remained the structure of choice for recommended for Amerisur Resources Plc as part of Amerisur’s formal sale process. bids in 2019. 50 of the firm offers announced in 2019 were structured as schemes of arrangement and 24 as contractual takeover offers, compared to 33 schemes and 12 Reverse break fees offers in 2018. In contrast to five bids with an agreed reverse break fee in 2018, in 2019 we saw only two bids which included reverse break fees. In relation to CK Asset Holdings Limited’s offer This underlines the view that there are still significant benefits to using a scheme, for for Greene King plc, CKA entered into a reverse break fee arrangement under which, example, the greater certainty of obtaining 100% control. among other things, if the CKA board withdrew its recommendation to its shareholders, it would be required to pay £53.1m to Greene King. In relation to FV Beteiligungs- GmbH’s offer for Low & Bonar PLC, FV Beteiligungs-GmbH undertook in the co-operation agreement to pay Low & Bonar a break fee payment in the amount of either £1.5 million or £750,000, if the acquisition lapses or is withdrawn as a result of FV Beteiligungs- GmbH invoking certain anti-trust conditions set out in the Rule 2.7 announcement. 6 7
Irrevocable undertakings News digest Irrevocable commitments were obtained on 62 bids. On 40 of those deals, the bidder Q4 was relatively quiet from a regulatory and legal news perspective. The main news obtained irrevocable undertakings from non-director shareholders. item concerned the Hearings Committee decision to cold-shoulder David King for a period of four years. Further details of this are set out as follows. Matching or topping rights: non-director shareholders Matching and/or topping rights were included in 16 of the 40 bids with irrevocables sought from non-director shareholders. This equates to approximately 21.6% of all firm Hearings Committee decision to cold-shoulder David King offers announced in 2019, a small decrease from the 26.7% in 2018. Background On 11 October 2019, the Panel published Panel Statement 2019/16. The statement sets Non-solicitation and notification undertakings: non-director shareholders out the ruling of the Hearings Committee (the “Committee”) against David King, Of the 40 deals on which non-director shareholder irrevocables were obtained, seven the Chairman of Rangers International Football Club PLC, in disciplinary proceedings (17.5%) included a non-solicitation undertaking. Of these seven deals, six contained initiated by the Executive of the Panel (the “Executive”). notification undertakings. Before agreeing notification undertakings, shareholders would be well advised to consider whether the information required to be notified Following a breach by Mr King of the obligation to announce a mandatory offer under constitutes inside information and therefore whether such an undertaking can be given Rule 9 of the Takeover Code (the “Code”) and other related contraventions of the Code, the in practice. Committee concluded that Mr King should be cold-shouldered for a period of four years. Cold-shouldering is a rare and severe penalty that has been imposed only four times in the Formal sale processes Panel’s history. During the period, no entity regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (“FCA”) will be able to act for him on any transaction subject to the Code. In 2019, of the 13 companies which announced formal sale processes, to date, one (7.7%) subsequently resulted in a firm offer being made (GeoPark Limited’s and Etablissements We previously reported on the various developments relating to Mr King’s offer for Maurel & Prom S.A.’s offer for Amerisur Resources Plc). This represents a decrease from Rangers Inter-national Football Club Plc (“Rangers”). Please see our Public M&A Update the 11 companies which announced formal sale processes in 2018 of which three (27%) for Q1 2017, Q2 2018 and Q3 2018, our 2017 Review and 2018 Review for further details on subsequently resulted in a firm offer. these developments. Breaches of the Takeover Code This decision related to the following breaches of the Code: 1. Failure to make mandatory offer (Rule 9) The alleged principal contravention was that, between 31 December 2014 and 2 January 2015, Mr King had acted in concert with others to acquire shares carrying more than 30% of the voting rights of Rangers. In contravention of Rule 9.1 of the Code, he then failed to make an offer to purchase the shares of Rangers not owned or controlled by him or by those with whom he had acted in concert. Mr King persisted in this failure notwithstanding a ruling of the Executive that he make a mandatory Rule 9 offer at the price of 20 pence per share and later rulings of the Committee and the Takeover Appeal Board upholding the Executive’s ruling. As an example of Mr King’s protracted non-compliance with the rule, the Executive had to commence proceedings under s 955 Companies Act 2006 to seek a court order compelling Mr King to comply with one of its rulings. 8 9
2. Providing incorrect and misleading statements to the Executive Sanctions (Section 9(a), Introduction) In deciding whether to take disciplinary action, the Committee asked the following The Committee further questioned if Mr King had done his best to answer the questions: (i) whether Mr King was an offender who was not likely to comply with the Executive’s questions truthfully during the course of its concert party investigations. Code and whose conduct merited cold-shouldering by professional bodies regulated by In particular, Mr King had denied to the Executive that communication had taken the FCA; and (ii) if so, for what period that sanction should apply. place between him and one of his concert parties regarding the acquisition of shares by said concert party, which the Committee later found out to be untrue. The Whether Mr King was likely to comply with the Code Committee therefore stated that the breach is serious, as investigating a potential The Committee concluded that Mr King’s behaviour showed a clear propensity concert party presents particular challenges for the Executive, which can only be to disregard the Code and to comply with its Rules only when forced to do so by addressed effectively if those to whom enquiries are directed (including in particular enforcement proceedings in the courts. Even though Mr King had offered to undertake potential members of a concert party) co-operate and answer questions fully and to comply with the Code in future, the Committee had to weigh that undertaking truthfully. This was not the case in Mr King’s situation. against the propensity revealed by his previous conduct and the practical difficulty in enforcing any such undertaking. 3. Failing to consult the Executive (Section 6(b), Introduction) The Committee also found that Mr King had been warned expressly by a party The Committee also seemed to give less weight to the fact that Mr King had acting in concert with him that he would be obliged to make a mandatory offer contravened Rule 24.8 of the Code relating to cash confirmation when determining Mr for the remaining shares of Rangers if the shares he was about to acquire pushed King’s likelihood of future non-compliance. In contrast, the Committee condemned Mr their aggregate holding to 30% or above. The Committee therefore considered that King’s prolonged refusal to procure a Rule 9 offer, along with his conduct in dealing with Mr King’s acquisition of further shares was made in the full knowledge that he the Executive during its initial investigation into a possible concert party, stating that at least risked triggering an obligation to procure the making of a Rule 9 offer. In these were “offences of the utmost seriousness for which a statement of public censure the circumstances, his failure to consult the Executive as to the implications of his would not be a sufficient sanction”. proposed course of conduct was a clear breach of section 6(b) of the Introduction to the Code, which imposes an obligation to consult the Executive whenever a Duration of the sanction person is in any doubt whatsoever as to whether a proposed course of conduct is in Testing its conclusions against only two previous cases in which the duration of a cold- accordance with the Code. shouldering sanction was fixed, the Committee concluded that Mr King should be cold- shouldered for a period of four years from the date of the ruling. 4. Failing to comply with cash confirmation requirements (Rule 24.8) Finally, where the offer is for cash, Rule 24.8 of the Code requires the offer document Notably, this was despite the following circumstances present in Mr King’s favour: to include a confirmation by an appropriate third party that resources are available to the offeror sufficient to satisfy full acceptance of the offer. When Mr King finally • Mr King had no previous disciplinary record and his investment in Rangers was at no made his Rule 9 offer, the Committee found that he failed to include such a cash stage motivated by the prospect of financial gain or commercial advantage; and confirmation. However, they also found that in the circumstances this contravention • it had not been clearly established that Mr King’s failure to procure a Rule 9 offer was by no means as serious as the prolonged failure to announce a Rule 9 offer or to prevented shareholders who would otherwise have taken the opportunity to exit deal with the Executive during its investigation in the manner required by the Code. and sell their shares from doing so (as the Rule 9 offer price was 20p per share, which was significantly below the prices at which Ranger shares were trading throughout the period in question). View the full Panel Statement. 10 11
Practice & Panel Statements Contacts The following Practice and Panel Statements were issued by the Panel during 2019 For more information about any of the issues raised in this update please contact: – in reverse chronological order: Rob Aird Partner London +44 (0)20 7859 1726 rob.aird@ashurst.com Practice Statements Simon Bullock Partner London +44 (0)20 7859 3115 simon.bullock@ashurst.com There were no Practice Statements issued during 2019. Michael Burns Partner London +44 (0)20 7859 2089 michael.burns@ashurst.com Panel Statements David Carter Partner London +44 (0)20 7859 1012 david.carter@ashurst.com Number Date Subject Summary Nick Cheshire Partner London +44 (0)20 7859 1811 nick.cheshire@ashurst.com Requirement for potential offeror to make Adrian Clark Senior Consultant London +44 (0)20 7859 1767 adrian.clark@ashurst.com 2019/18 11/11/19 Charles Taylor plc a Rule 2.7 announcement or announce no intention to bid by 15 November 2019 Karen Davies Partner, Head of London +44 (0)20 7859 3667 karen.davies@ashurst.com Corporate UK 2019/17 07/11/19 UK Finance Corporate Finance Committee Braeden Donnelly Partner London +44 (0)20 7859 2691 braeden.donnelly@ashurst.com Hearings Committee decision to cold- 2019/16 11/10/19 Mr David King shoulder Mr David King James Fletcher Partner London +44 (0)20 7859 3156 james.fletcher@ashurst.com 2019/15 11/09/19 Eddie Stobart Logistics plc Possible offer by DBAY Advisors Limited Bruce Hanton Partner London +44 (0)20 7859 1738 bruce.hanton@ashurst.com 2019/14 23/07/19 2019 Annual Report Publication of the Panel’s Annual Report Nicholas Holmes Partner London +44 (0)20 7859 2058 nicholas.holmes@ashurst.com 2019/13 12/07/19 KCOM Group plc Result of auction Hiroyuki Iwamura Partner London +44 (0)20 7859 3244 hiroyuki.iwamura@ashurst.com New Secretary for the Gaby Jones Partner London +44 (0)20 7859 3661 gaby.jones@ashurst.com 2019/12 12/07/19 Panel Executive appointment Takeover Panel Adam Levitt Partner London +44 (0)20 7859 1633 adam.levitt@ashurst.com 2019/11 04/07/19 KCOM Group plc Auction procedure under Rule 32.5 Tom Mercer Partner London +44 (0)20 7859 2988 tom.mercer@ashurst.com 2019/10 25/04/19 New Panel Members Panel Appointments 2019/9 15/04/19 Provident Financial plc Offer timetable extended David Page Senior Consultant London +44 (0)20 7859 1908 david.page@ashurst.com Instrument 2019/3 – The Partner, Head of 2019/8 04/04/19 United Kingdom’s withdrawal Amendments to the Takeover Code Jason Radford London +44 (0)20 7859 1145 jason.radford@ashurst.com Corporate from the European Union Nick Rainsford Partner London +44 (0)20 7859 2914 nick.rainsford@ashurst.com Publication of a revised version of the 2019/7 01/04/19 Revised Takeover Code Takeover Code Michael Robins Partner London +44 (0)20 7859 1473 michael.robins@ashurst.com Amendments to the Amendments to references to the UKLA and Aaron Shute Partner London +44 (0)20 7859 2411 aaron.shute@ashurst.com 2019/6 25/03/19 Takeover Code other matters Tara Waters Partner London +44 (0)20 7859 2755 tara.waters@ashurst.com 2019/5 11/03/19 Earthport plc Offer timetable extended Nick Williamson Partner London +44 (0)20 7859 1894 nick.williamson@ashurst.com Publication of RS 2018/1 (Asset Valuations) Publication of Response and RS 2018/2 (The United Kingdom’s María José Partner, Head of 2019/4 06/03/19 Statements and amendments Spain +34 91 364 9867 mariajose.menendez@ashurst.com withdrawal from the European Union) and Menéndez Corporate CEMEA to the Takeover Code amendments to the Takeover Code Partner, Head of Reinhard Eyring Germany +49 (0)69 97 11 27 08 reinhard.eyring@ashurst.com 2019/3 27/02/19 Change of address New address with effect from 11 March 2019 Germany Berry Global Group, Inc – deadline for Arnaud Managing Partner, Belgium +32 2 626 1914 arnaud.wtterwulghe@ashurst.com 2019/2 19/02/19 RPC Group clarification under section 4 of Appendix 7 Wtterwulghe Brussels of the Code Nick Terry Partner Australia +61 3 9679 3483 nick.terry@ashurst.com 2019/1 24/01/19 New Panel Members Panel Appointments 12 13
Appendix: Announced* UK takeover bids (1 January 2019 to 31 December 2019) undertaking Non-solicitundertaking Recommendation NoRecommendation shareholder forecast/QFBS inshareholder consideration Profittforecast/QFBS process Otherconsideration saleprocess rights**** Toppingrights**** vote Shareholdervote match Recommended premium** andmatch Recommended (L/U/A) arrangements Bidpremium** Shares(L/U/A) arrangements Offer-related Offer-related Offer irrevocables Shareholder PartialOffer offer irrevocables Formalsale Rule99offer Matching/ Non-solicit Matching/ value Hostile// Bidvalue Scheme Mixand Offer*** bidin Topping Scheme Offer*** Hostile Formal Shares Partial Other ofbid Cash Cash Profi Rule Mix Bid Bid No Target Target (Market) (Market) Bidder Bidder of Q4 2019 Hanover Hanover Active Active Equity Equity Fund Fund II, II, S.C.A. S.C.A. Brady Brady plc plc (AIM) (AIM) £15.3m £15.3m 171% 171% ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ● SICAV-RAIF SICAV-RAIF US$3.82b US$3.82b Sophos Sophos Group Group plc plc (Main (Main Market) Market) Thoma Thoma Bravo, Bravo, LLC LLC (approx. (approx. 37.1% 37.1% ● ● ● ● ● ● ●C1 ●C1 £3.012b) £3.012b) Seplat Seplat Petroleum Petroleum Development Development Eland Eland Oil Oil & & Gas Gas PLC PLC (AIM) (AIM) £382m £382m 28.5% 28.5% ● ● ● ● ●2 ●2 ● ● ●C ●C Company Company Plc Plc Capital Capital & & Regional Regional plc plc Growthpoint Growthpoint Properties Properties Limited Limited £72.5m £72.5m 100% 100% ● ● ● ● ●3 ●3 ●4 ●4 ● ● (Main (Main Market) Market) Elegant Elegant Hotels Hotels Group Group plc plc (AIM) (AIM) Marriott Marriott International, International, Inc. Inc. £100.8m £100.8m 57.1% 57.1% ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ● Murgitroyd Murgitroyd Group Group PLC PLC (AIM) (AIM) Sovereign Sovereign Capital Capital Partners Partners LLP LLP £62.8m £62.8m 6.3% 6.3% ● ● ● ● ●5 ●5 ● ● Just Just Eat Eat plc plc (Main (Main Market) Market) Prosus Prosus N. N.V V.. £5.5b £5.5b 26% 26% ● ● ● ● ● ● ●6 ●6 ● ● Netalogue Netalogue Technologies Technologies plc plc Accellos Accellos Holdings Holdings LLC LLC offer offer £5.73m £5.73m 151.7% 151.7% ● ● ● ● ● ● ((NEX NEX Exchange Exchange Growth Growth Market) Market) Amerisur Amerisur Resources Resources Plc Plc (AIM) (AIM) GeoPark GeoPark Limited Limited £242m £242m 58.8% 58.8% ● ● ● ● ● ● ●CR ●CR ● ● ● ● Meditor Meditor European European Master Master Fund Fund Carpetright Carpetright plc plc (Main (Main Market) Market) £15.18m £15.18m NP NP ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ● Limited Limited Consort Consort Medical Medical plc plc (Main (Main Market) Market) Recipharm Recipharm AB AB £505m £505m 39.1% 39.1% ● ● ● ● ● ● ●C ●C Hardy Hardy Oil Oil and and Gas Gas plc plc Richard Richard Griffi Griffiths ths £3.688m £3.688m NP NP ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ● (Main (Main Market) Market) Up Up to to Innovise Innovise Limited Limited (Unquoted) (Unquoted) Accel-KKR Accel-KKR LLC LLC NP NP ● ● ● ● ●7 ●7 ● ● ●8 ●8 ● ● ●T ●T £18.45m £18.45m Redde Redde plc plc (AIM) (AIM) Northgate Northgate plc plc £394m £394m 18% 18% ● ● ●L ●L ● ● ●C ●C ●B ●B ● ● Aggregated Aggregated Micro Micro Power Power Holdings Holdings plc plc Asterion Asterion Industrial Industrial Partners Partners SGEIC, SGEIC, £63.1m £63.1m 32.4% 32.4% ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ●T ●T (AIM) (AIM) S.A. S.A. US$212.1m US$212.1m BLME BLME Holdings Holdings plc plc (NASDAQ (NASDAQ Dubai) Dubai) Boubyan Boubyan Bank Bank K.S.C.P. K.S.C.P. (approx. (approx. 75% 75% ● ● ● ● ● ● £164m) £164m) hVIVO hVIVO plc plc (AIM) (AIM) Open Open Orphan Orphan plc plc £12.96m £12.96m 33.8% 33.8% ● ● ●A ●A ● ● ●B ●B Nasstar Nasstar plc plc (AIM) (AIM) Mayfair Mayfair Equity Equity Partners Partners LLP LLP £79.4 £79.4 million million 14.5% 14.5% ● ● ● ● ● ● ●C ●C ● ● Hansteen Hansteen Holdings Holdings PLC PLC The The Blackstone Blackstone Group Group Inc. Inc. £500 £500 million million 10.3% 10.3% ● ● ● ● ● ● (Main (Main Market) Market) £120.48 £120.48 Score Score Group Group plc plc (Unquoted) (Unquoted) SCF SCF GP GP LLC LLC NP NP ● ● ● ● ● ● ●9 ●9 million million Harwood Harwood Wealth Wealth Management Management Group Group The The Carlyle Carlyle Group Group £90.7 £90.7 million million -7.9% -7.9% ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ●C10 ●C10 PLC PLC (AIM) (AIM) 1. On 25 September 2019, Sophos, Bidco and their respective external legal counsels entered into a confidentiality and joint defence agreement to ensure that the 7. TEAM Bidco Limited, a wholly owned subsidiary of TEAM Software Inc., a portfolio company of Accel-KKR LLC, is presenting two recommended alternative cash offers Key exchange or disclosure of certain materials relating to the parties only takes place for the entire issued share capital of Innovise Limited. The basic offer is 58 pence * This table includes details of takeovers, set out in chronological order, in between their respective external legal counsels and external experts for the in cash for each Innovise ordinary share and 46 pence in cash for each Innovise B respect of which a firm intention to make an offer has been announced purposes of anti-trust and regulatory analysis, and does not diminish in any way the share, while the complex offer is 50 pence in cash for each Innovise ordinary share, under Rule 2.7 of the Code during the period under review. It excludes confidentiality of such materials and does not result in a waiver of privilege, right or 38 pence in cash for each Innovise B share and certain deferred payments subject to offers by existing majority shareholders for minority positions immunity that might otherwise be available. set-off and adjustments. ** Premium of the offer price over the target’s share price immediately 2. Eland shareholders on the register at the close of business on 18 October 2019 are 8. The Innovise directors and certain specified shareholders are required to accept the prior to the commencement of the relevant offer period entitled to receive and retain the interim dividend of 1 pence per Eland share to be complex offer and entered into a warranty deed on 27 November 2019, under which *** Standard 90% (waivable) acceptance condition, unless otherwise paid on 31 October 2019. they give warranties, specific indemnities and a tax covenant. Also in relation to the stated 3. This is a partial offer for 219,786,924 ordinary shares representing approximately complex offer, Innovise is selling the shares it owns in Cortex under a Cortex SPA, **** In shareholders’ irrevocables (unless indicated otherwise) 30.2% of the issued ordinary share capital of Capital & Regional. amounting to 92.59% of the issued share capital, with remaining shares being held ◊ Permitted agreements under Rule 21.2 of the Code by the senior management of Cortex. The consideration of £100,000 is payable by A AIM traded shares 4. In connection with the partial offer, Growthpoint and Capital entered into a the complex offer shareholders by way of a deduction in the first deferred payment subscription agreement under which Growthpoint (or any Growthpoint nominee) C Co-operation agreement/bid conduct agreement due to be paid to them. The Innovise leadership team has further been provided has agreed to subscribe for the subscription shares at a price of 25 pence per F Break fee given under formal sale process or white knight dispensation with the opportunity to subscribe for new shares in Teamster Topco LLC. subscription share. The share subscription is conditional, among other things, upon L Listed/traded shares the partial offer becoming unconditional and Capital shareholders approving the 9. In connection with the acquisition, SCF and Charles Richie’s Testamentary Trust NP No premium given in offer documentation or nil premium resolutions required to implement the proposed transaction. Growthpoint and (Family Trust) entered into: (i) an exclusivity agreement, under which the Family R Reverse break fee Capital have also entered into a relationship agreement, principally to ensure that, Trust agreed to grant SCF a period of exclusivity; (ii) a warranty and no leakage deed, under which the Family Trust agreed to grant Bidco a number of warranties S Standstill agreement for so long as Growthpoint and any of its nominee(s) hold at least 20% of the voting and indemnities in respect of the business and affairs of the Score Group and an U Untraded shares rights in Capital, Capital can carry on as an independent business as its main activity. This is conditional upon admission of the subscription shares to: (i) the premium indemnity to Bidco in relation to there being no leakage since 2 May 2019; (iii) a tax B Bidder shareholder approval listing segment of the Official List; (ii) trading on the London Stock Exchange’s Main deed of covenant, under which the Family Trust agreed to grant Bidco a number T Target shareholder approval Market; and (iii) listing and trading on the main board of the Johannesburg Stock of indemnities in respect of the tax position of Score Group; and (iv) a Family Trust Exchange. Loan, under which the Family Trust shall extend the Family Trust Loan to Score Group, which is a two-year non-amortising, non-interest bearing £5 million loan. 5. Murgitroyd shareholders on the register as at the close of business on 11 October 2019 will be entitled to receive and retain a proposed final dividend of 15 pence per 10. On 23 December 2019, certain of the Harwood directors entered into a separate Murgitroyd share. deed with Hurst Point Group Limited, under which such Harwood directors agreed to provide a limited indemnity in respect of certain contingent liabilities of the 6. On 4 October 2019, Bidco and Just Eat entered into a clean team confidentiality Harwood group. Prior to the effective date, Carlyle and the Bidco group will enter agreement which sets out how any confidential information that is competitively into an investment agreement and Bidco will adopt new articles of association each sensitive can be disclosed, used or shared for the purposes of due diligence, costs in the form to be made available to Harwood shareholders. Harwood shareholders benefits evaluation, integration planning and regulatory clearance. On 1 October who wish to accept the first alternative offer or the second alternative offer (as 2019, Bidco, Just Eat and their respective legal advisers also entered into a panel applicable) will be required to execute a deed of adherence to the investment confidentiality agreement relating to the exchange and/or disclosure of certain agreement. materials relating to the parties in relation to the anti-trust workstream. 14
Appendix: Announced* UK takeover bids (1 January 2019 to 31 December 2019) undertaking Non-solicitundertaking Recommendation NoRecommendation shareholder forecast/QFBS inshareholder consideration Profittforecast/QFBS process Otherconsideration saleprocess rights**** Toppingrights**** vote Shareholdervote match Recommended premium** andmatch Recommended (L/U/A) arrangements Bidpremium** Shares(L/U/A) arrangements Offer-related Offer-related Offer irrevocables Shareholder PartialOffer offer irrevocables Formalsale Rule99offer Matching/ Non-solicit Matching/ value Hostile// Bidvalue Scheme Mixand Offer*** bidin Topping Scheme Offer*** Hostile Formal Shares Partial Other ofbid Cash Cash Profi Rule Mix Bid Bid No Target Target (Market) (Market) Bidder Bidder of Q3 2019 FFI FFI Holdings Holdings plc plc (AIM) (AIM) 777 777 Group Group £39.5m £39.5m 28.2% 28.2% ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ● Telford Telford Homes Homes Plc Plc (AIM) (AIM) CBRE CBRE Group, Group, Inc. Inc. £267.4m £267.4m 11.1% 11.1% ● ● ● ● ● ● ●C ●C Ei Ei Group Group plc plc (Main (Main Market) Market) Stonegate Stonegate Pub Pub Company Company Limited Limited £1.273b £1.273b 38.5% 38.5% ● ● ● ● ● ● ●C11 ●C11 Aston Aston Martin Martin Lagonda Lagonda Global Global Holdings Holdings Investindustrial Investindustrial Advisors Advisors Limited Limited £68.4m £68.4m NP NP N/A N/A ● ● ● ● ●12 ●12 plc plc (Main (Main Market) Market) Acacia Acacia Mining Mining plc plc (Main (Main Market) Market) Barrick Barrick Gold Gold Corporation Corporation £951m £951m 53.5% 53.5% ● ● ●L ●L ● ● Cobham Cobham plc plc (Main (Main Market) Market) Advent Advent International International Corporation Corporation £4b £4b 34.4% 34.4% ● ● ● ● ● ● ●C13 ●C13 Sanderson Sanderson Group Group Plc Plc (AIM) (AIM) Aptean, Aptean, Inc. Inc. £90.1m £90.1m 9.8% 9.8% ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ● Just Just Eat Eat plc plc (Main (Main Market) Market) Takeaway.com Takeaway.com N. N.V V.. £4.98b £4.98b 15% 15% ● ● ●L ●L ● ● ●C ●C ●B ●B ● ● Ivanhoé Ivanhoé Cambridge Cambridge and and ICAMAP ICAMAP easyHotel easyHotel plc plc (AIM) (AIM) £138.7m £138.7m 34.8% 34.8% ● ● ● ● ● ● ●C ●C Investments Investments S.à.r.l S.à.r.l Catalis Catalis plc plc (Unquoted) (Unquoted) NorthEdge NorthEdge Capital Capital LLP LLP £89.8m £89.8m 179.6% 179.6% 14 14 ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ●T ●T Greene Greene King King plc plc (Main (Main Market) Market) CK CK Asset Asset Holdings Holdings Limited Limited £2.7b £2.7b 51% 51% ● ● ● ● ● ● ●C ●C ●B ●B Synnovia Synnovia plc plc (AIM) (AIM) Camelot Camelot Capital Capital Partners Partners LLC LLC £48.8m £48.8m 42.9% 42.9% ● ● ● ● ● ● ●15 ●15 ●T ●T Premier Premier Asset Asset Management Management Group Group Miton Miton Group Group plc plc (AIM) (AIM) £97.95m £97.95m 38% 38% ● ● ●A ●A ● ● ●B ●B ● ● PLC PLC APC APC Technology Technology Group Group Plc Plc (AIM) (AIM) Harwood Harwood Capital Capital LLP LLP £18.26m £18.26m 9.59% 9.59% ● ● ● ● ● ● ● ● Charles Charles Taylor Taylor plc plc (Main (Main Market) Market) Lovell Lovell Minnick Minnick Partners Partners LLC LLC £261m £261m 34.0% 34.0% ● ● ● ● ●16 ●16 ● ● ●C ●C StatPro StatPro Group Group plc plc (AIM) (AIM) Confluence Technologies, Confluence Technologies, Inc. Inc. £161.1m £161.1m 54.9% 54.9% ● ● ● ● ● ● Freudenberg Freudenberg & & Co. Co. Low Low & & Bonar Bonar PLC PLC (Main (Main Market) Market) £107m £107m 101% 101% ● ● ● ● ● ● ●C17 ●C17 ● ● Kommanditgesellschaft Kommanditgesellschaft 11. On 21 June 2019, Stonegate, EIG and their respective external legal counsels also entered into a joint defence agreement relating to the exchange or disclosure of certain materials. Key 12. Partial offer for 6,840,090 ordinary shares representing approximately 3% of the issued ordinary share capital of Aston Martin. * This table includes details of takeovers, set out in chronological order, in respect of which a firm intention to make an offer has been announced 13. On 24 June 2019, Advent International and Cobham also entered into a clean team agreement setting out certain procedures and principles to be followed to ensure adequate under Rule 2.7 of the Code during the period under review. It excludes treatment of certain sensitive confidential information. offers by existing majority shareholders for minority positions 14. The valuation of £89.8 million (equivalent to approximately €96.8 million) represented a premium of approximately 179.6% to the market capitalisation of Catalis of €34.6 ** Premium of the offer price over the target’s share price immediately million implied by the last price at which the ordinary shares in Catalis were traded on the Frankfurt Stock Exchange prior to its delisting (being €44.00 per share). prior to the commencement of the relevant offer period 15. On 3 September 2019, Camelot Cayman, Bidco and the management shareholders: (i) entered into a management share exchange agreement under which Camelot Cayman and *** Standard 90% (waivable) acceptance condition, unless otherwise the management shareholders (other than Faisal Rahmatallah) agreed to exchange their Synnovia shares for shares in Bidco on a one for one basis, conditional upon the offer stated becoming or being declared wholly unconditional and upon the passing of the management shareholder resolution; and (ii) entered into a shareholders’ agreement under which **** In shareholders’ irrevocables (unless indicated otherwise) they agreed various matters relating to the management of Bidco and their rights as shareholders. ◊ Permitted agreements under Rule 21.2 of the Code 16. In addition, under the terms of the offer, Charles Taylor shareholders will be entitled to receive the previously declared interim 2019 dividend of 3.65 pence per Charles Taylor A AIM traded shares share to be paid on 8 November 2019 to Charles Taylor shareholders on the register of members on 11 October 2019 without any consequential reduction in the offer price. C Co-operation agreement/bid conduct agreement 17. On 5 August 2019, Freudenberg SE and Low & Bonar, and Freudenberg SE and its external legal advisors, entered into respective due diligence clean team agreements relating to F Break fee given under formal sale process or white knight dispensation the ring-fencing of certain materials relating to Low & Bonar. L Listed/traded shares NP No premium given in offer documentation or nil premium R Reverse break fee S Standstill agreement U Untraded shares B Bidder shareholder approval T Target shareholder approval 15
Appendix: Announced* UK takeover bids (1 January 2019 to 31 December 2019) undertaking Non-solicit undertaking Recommendation No Recommendation shareholder in shareholder forecast/QFBS Profitt forecast/QFBS consideration Other consideration process sale process rights**** Topping rights**** vote Shareholder vote match Recommended and match Recommended premium** Bid premium** (L/U/A) arrangements Shares (L/U/A) arrangements Offer-related Offer-related Offer irrevocables Shareholder Partial Offer irrevocables offer Formal sale Rule 99 offer Matching/ Non-solicit Matching/ value Bid value Hostile // Scheme Mix and bid in Topping Scheme Offer*** Offer*** Hostile Formal Shares Partial Other of bid Cash Cash Profi Rule Mix Bid Bid No Target (Market) Bidder of Q2 2019 Bonmarché Holdings plc (Main 18 Spectre Holdings Limited £5.7m NP ●18 ● ● ● ● Market) Lighthouse plc (AIM) Quilter plc £46.2m 24.5% ● ● ● ●C19 19 ● KCOM Group Public Limited Company Universities Superannuation £504m 33.8% ●20 20 ● ● ●C ● (Main Market) Scheme Limited 21 22 EU Supply PLC (AIM) Mercell Holding AS £15.7m21 40.4% ● ● ● ●22 ● WYG plc (AIM) Tetra Tech, Inc. £43.4m 244.0% ● ● ● ●C ● SafeCharge International Group Nuvei Corporation £699m 25% ● ● ● ●C Limited (AIM) A&J Mucklow Group plc (Main Market) LondonMetric Property Plc £414.7m 19.7% ● ● ●L ● ● ●C ● ● ● Tarsus Group plc (Main Market) Charterhouse Capital Partners LLP £561m 36.2% ● ● ● eProp Services plc (Unquoted) Toscafund Asset Management LLP £17.85m NP ● ● ● ● Stride Gaming plc (AIM) The Rank Group Plc £115.3m 46% ● ● ● Patagonia Gold Plc (AIM) Hunt Mining Corp. £17.18m 35.9% ● ●L ● 23 ●23 ● KCOM Group Public Limited Company Macquarie Infrastructure and Real £562m 49% ● ● ● ●C (Main Market) Assets (Europe) Limited GAME Digital plc (Main Market) Sports Direct International plc £51.88m 27.4% ●24 24 ● ● ● Millennium & Copthorne Hotels plc City Developments Limited £2.227b 37% ● ● ● ●C (Main Market) Porta Communications plc (AIM) SEC S.p.A £4.46m 95.87% ● ●A ● ● 25 Lewmar Marine Limited (Unquoted) LCI Industries £33.286m NP ● ● ● ●25 Premier Technical Services Group Plc Macquarie Group Limited £265.3m 141.5% ● ● ● ● ● (AIM) BCA Marketplace plc (Main Market) TDR Capital LLP £1.906b 24.9% ● ● ● ●C26 26 ● ● KIRKBI A/S, The Blackstone Group Merlin Entertainments plc L.P., and Canada Pension Plan £4.766b 15.2% ● ● ● ●C (Main Market) Investment Board 18. The board of Bonmarché Holdings later recommended that shareholders accept the offer. Key 19. Quilter and Lighthouse entered into a letter agreement pursuant to which Quilter agreed to: (a) prepare and submit a briefing paper to the CMA as soon as reasonably practicable; (b) provide Lighthouse with a reasonable opportunity to comment on drafts of the briefing paper; and (c) notify Lighthouse when the CMA provides any material * This table includes details of takeovers, set out in chronological order, in response. respect of which a firm intention to make an offer has been announced under Rule 2.7 of the Code during the period under review. It excludes 20. Initially recommended. The board of KCOM Group subsequently withdrew its recommendation following the announcement by Macquarie Infrastructure and Real Assets offers by existing majority shareholders for minority positions (Europe) Limited of a higher competing offer. ** Premium of the offer price over the target’s share price immediately 21. The offer valued EU Supply at £13.1m, or £15.7m if all the holders of EU Supply Convertible Loan Notes convert into EU Supply Shares. prior to the commencement of the relevant offer period 22. Mercell and EU Supply entered into a clean team agreement on 9 April 2019, setting out how any information which is commercially and/or competitively sensitive to EU Supply *** Standard 90% (waivable) acceptance condition, unless otherwise could be shared with Mercell. stated 23. Patagonia Gold’s non-executive chairman and majority shareholder, Carlos Miguens and Cantomi (a company owned and controlled by Mr Miguens), together with Hunt’s **** In shareholders’ irrevocables (unless indicated otherwise) largest shareholder, Tim Hunt, will enter into a resulting issuer escrow agreement with Hunt and Computershare Canada, as escrow agent, in respect of the new Hunt shares to ◊ Permitted agreements under Rule 21.2 of the Code be issued to Carlos Miguens and Cantomi pursuant to the offer and, in respect of Tim Hunt, his existing Hunt shares. A AIM traded shares 24. GAME Digital’s board later recommended that shareholders accept the offer. C Co-operation agreement/bid conduct agreement F Break fee given under formal sale process or white knight dispensation 25. On 11 June 2019: (1) LCI entered into a warranty and indemnity deed with the Lewmar directors; (2) LCI entered into a deed of undertakings with the Lewmar directors that L Listed/traded shares prior to the date on which the scheme becomes effective the directors will carry on the Lewmar business in the ordinary course, in accordance with all applicable legal and administrative requirements and will maintain the Lewmar business as a going concern; and (3) Lewmar, LCI and Peter Tierney entered into a transition bonus letter. NP No premium given in offer documentation or nil premium R Reverse break fee 26. In addition, TDR and BCA put in place a regulatory clean team agreement setting out how confidential information that is competitively sensitive can be disclosed, used or S Standstill agreement shared between TDR’s external legal counsel and/or economists and BCA’s external legal counsel and/or economists for the purposes of obtaining the consent of competition authorities and/or regulatory clearances. U Untraded shares B Bidder shareholder approval T Target shareholder approval 16
Appendix: Announced* UK takeover bids (1 January 2019 to 31 December 2019) undertaking Non-solicit undertaking Recommendation No Recommendation shareholder in shareholder forecast/QFBS Profitt forecast/QFBS consideration Other consideration process sale process rights**** Topping rights**** vote Shareholder vote match Recommended and match Recommended premium** Bid premium** (L/U/A) arrangements Shares (L/U/A) arrangements Offer-related Offer-related Offer irrevocables Shareholder Partial Offer irrevocables offer Formal sale Rule 99 offer Matching/ Non-solicit Matching/ value Bid value Hostile // Scheme Mix and bid in Topping Scheme Offer*** Offer*** Hostile Formal Shares Partial Other of bid Cash Cash Profi Rule Mix Bid Bid No Target (Market) Bidder of Q1 2019 Stobart Group Limited; Virgin Flybe Group plc (Main Market) Atlantic Limited; Cyrus Capital £2.2m NP ● ● ● ●C ● Partners L.P. Nature Group plc (Unquoted) Port Invest B.V. £4.21m NP ● ● ● RPC Group Plc (Main Market) Apollo Global Management, LLC £3.323b 15.6% 27 ●27 ● ● ●C ● MedicX Fund Limited (Main Market) Primary Health Properties PLC £392.9m 14.3% ● ●L ● ●28 28 ● ● ● Earthport plc (AIM) Mastercard Incorporated £233m 343% ●29 29 ● ● C Ophir Energy plc (Main Market) PT Medco Energi Internasional Tbk £408.4m 73.2% ● ● ● ●C RhythmOne plc (AIM) Taptica International Ltd £135m NP ● ●A ● C ● ● The Local Shopping REIT plc 30 ● 31 (Main Market) Thalassa Holdings Ltd £27.1m 17.1% ● ● ●L ● ● 30 31 32 Tax Systems plc (AIM) Bowmark Capital LLP £102.3m 14.4% ● ● ● S ● ● ●32 Dairy Crest Group plc (Main Market) Saputo Inc. £975m 11.7% ● ● ● Provident Financial plc Non-Standard Finance plc £1.3b NP ● ●L ● ● ● (Main Market) 33 Findel plc (Main Market) Sports Direct International plc £139.2m NP ● ● ● ● 33 ● RPC Group Plc (Main Market) Berry Global Group, Inc. £3.34b 16% ● ● ● ●C ● Basalt Infrastructure Partners II GP Manx Telecom Plc (AIM) £255.9m 30.5% ● ● ● S Limited Charter Court Financial Services Group plc (Main Market) OneSavings Bank plc £730m NP ● ●L ● ●CS ● ● Footasylum plc (AIM) JD Sports Fashion Plc £90.0m 77.4% ● ● ● C Apax Partners LLP, Warburg Pincus International LLC, Canada Pension Inmarsat plc (Main Market) US$3.4b 27% ● ● ● ●C ● Plan Investment Board and Ontario Teachers' Pension Plan Board 27. Initially recommended. The board of RBC subsequently withdrew its recommendation following the announcement by Berry Global of a higher competing offer. Key 28. On 24 January 2019, MedicX, Octopus Healthcare Adviser Limited, Octopus AIFM Management Limited and Nexus Tradeco Limited entered into a transitional services agreement, under which, among other matters, MedicX’s existing investment manager would provide such transitional services as the parties may agree on arm’s length terms following * This table includes details of takeovers, set out in chronological order, in completion. respect of which a firm intention to make an offer has been announced under Rule 2.7 of the Code during the period under review. It excludes 29. Initially recommended. The board of Earthport subsequently withdrew its recommendation following the announcement by Visa Inc. of a revised offer. offers by existing majority shareholders for minority positions 30. Acceptance condition of 50% plus one share. ** Premium of the offer price over the target’s share price immediately 31. The board of The Local Shopping REIT plc convened a general meeting to seek shareholder approval for the directors to take appropriate action to liquidate the company in the prior to the commencement of the relevant offer period event Thalassa’s offer lapses or is withdrawn. *** Standard 90% (waivable) acceptance condition, unless otherwise stated 32. Arrangements agreed with certain of Tax System’s management required the approval of independent shareholders in accordance with Rule 16.2 of the Code. **** In shareholders’ irrevocables (unless indicated otherwise) 33. Acceptance condition of 50% plus one share, in line with Rule 9 of the Code. ◊ Permitted agreements under Rule 21.2 of the Code A AIM traded shares C Co-operation agreement/bid conduct agreement F Break fee given under formal sale process or white knight dispensation L Listed/traded shares NP No premium given in offer documentation or nil premium R Reverse break fee S Standstill agreement U Untraded shares B Bidder shareholder approval T Target shareholder approval 17
www.ashurst.com London Fruit & Wool Exchange, 1 Duval Square, London E1 6PW. T: +44 (0)20 7638 1111 F: +44 (0)20 7638 1112 ashurst.com. Ashurst LLP and its affiliates operate under the name Ashurst. Ashurst LLP is a limited liability partnership registered in England and Wales under number OC330252. It is a law firm authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority of England and Wales under number 468653. The term “partner” is used to refer to a member of Ashurst LLP or to an employee or consultant with equivalent standing and qualifications or to an individual with equivalent status in one of Ashurst LLP’s affiliates. Further details about Ashurst can be found at ashurst.com. © Ashurst LLP 2020 Ref D/R002591
You can also read