The remaking of Narendra Modi
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
INDIA
The remaking of
Narendra Modi
India’s most divisive politician
denies he has changed his
image. But his ability to reinvent
himself is central to the man
By Ross Colvin and
Satarupa Bhattacharjya
Gandhinagar, Gujarat, July 12, 2013
MAIN DRAW: Modi, here at this
year’s “Vibrant Gujarat summit,”
has boosted investment in his
state, though critics say its
performance on social indicators
lags.REUTERS/Amit Dave
SPECIAL REPORT 1
INDIA The remaking of Narendra Modi
T
he lunch guests were sworn to secrecy.
The European diplomats gath-
ered at the German ambassador’s
residence in New Delhi’s lush green em-
bassy enclave quizzed the guest of honour
on everything from the economy and com-
munal violence to his political ambitions.
But nobody, the representatives from most
of the 28 European Union states agreed,
could publicly mention the man they were
meeting that day: Narendra Modi, India’s
most controversial politician and, possibly,
the country’s next prime minister.
It was a moment that captures the para-
dox at the heart of Modi, and the caution
with which the outside world approaches
him. The January lunch at Ambassador
Michael Steiner’s residence ended a de-
cade-long unofficial EU boycott of the
62-year-old politician, who had just won CONVERSATION: Modi, here in the garden at his residence in Gandhinagar, Gujarat, after an interview
his third straight term as chief minister of with Reuters. REUTERS/Amit Dave
the state of Gujarat.
The boycott stemmed from 2002 riots
in Gujarat in which Hindu mobs killed at I’m a nationalist. I’m insisted that apparent contradictions were
least 1,000 people, most of them Muslims. patriotic. Nothing is wrong. no such thing. Sitting in his sparsely deco-
Human rights groups and political rivals rated office in a heavily guarded compound
have long alleged that Modi, a Hindu and Narendra Modi in the Gujarati capital Gandhinagar, Modi
a dominant force in the Hindu nationalist put his hand on his chest to emphasise
Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), allowed or that a public appearance with the politician that point. “I’m a nationalist. I’m patriotic.
even actively encouraged the attacks. Modi may serve as a kind of endorsement. Nothing is wrong. I’m a born Hindu. So
has always vehemently denied the charge, Modi is a polarising figure, evoking vis- yes, you can say I’m a Hindu nationalist,”
and a Supreme Court inquiry found no evi- ceral reactions across the political spectrum. he said. At the same time, “as far as pro-
dence to prosecute him. Critics call him an extremist and a dicta- gressive, development-oriented, workaholic
In the decade since, Modi has remade tor; supporters believe he could lift India’s ... there’s no contradiction between the two.
himself as a business-savvy, investor- economy out of the doldrums and make It is one and the same image.”
friendly administrator, a charismatic leader India an Asian superpower. The hour-long interview with Modi,
who has presided over a booming economy His profile is far bigger than almost any conducted mostly in Hindi, along with
and lured major foreign and Indian compa- other politician in India. He attracts media interviews withadvisers and aides, paint a
nies to invest in his sprawling coastal state, coverage normally reserved for Bollywood picture of a hard-working loner with few
famed for its spirit of entrepreneurship and A-listers. His face appears on magazines friends and an unusually small circle of col-
as the birthplace of Mahatma Gandhi. and newspapers and the covers of two new leagues and loyal officials around him.
Modi is now the head of the BJP’s cam- biographies. His comments and public ap- At times Modi appeared tense, though
paign to win back power in a national elec- pearances are regular fodder for television not defensive. He chose his words carefully,
tion due by next May, and is widely expected news shows. especially when talking about his role in the
to become the party’s prime ministerial can- Modi’s ability to remake himself is cen- 2002 riots.
didate. As he has grown in political impor- tral to understanding the man, even if he “A leader who doesn’t take a decision:
tance, foreign envoys have begun, cautiously, rejects any suggestion he has changed his who will accept him as a leader? That is a
to woo him. At the same time, many worry image. In a rare interview in late June he Text continues on page 4
SPECIAL REPORT 2
INDIA The remaking of Narendra Modi
India’s states by the numbers
By many economic measures, Gujarat has done well over the past decade; it is less impressive on social indicators
PER CAPITA INCOME FINANCIAL INCLUSION
Gujarat is one of India’s richest states How many people have access to banks?
Gujarat Gujarat
In thousands of rupees
50 75 100 30 40 50
LITERACY RATE INFANT MORTALITY RATE
Education levels are up, but lag other states Improved, but some way to go
Gujarat Gujarat
Number of deaths
In percent per1,000 live births
70 80 90 15 30 45
Note: The maps of India reflect state-by-state data. Frontier lines depict administrative lines of control; some borders are disputed..
Per capita income data for 2011 fiscal year, others for 2011 calendar year.
Sources: Planning Commission of India (mortality); Census of India (literacy); Central Statistical Organisation (income); CRISIL (finance)
SPECIAL REPORT 3
INDIA The remaking of Narendra Modi
RIOT: Hindus in Ahmedabad, Gujarat’s main city, during anti-Muslim riots in March 2002. REUTERS/Arko Datta
quality, it’s not a negative,” Modi said. “If and that “what work you get, do it well.” him on the official aircraft, Nathwani re-
someone was an authoritarian then how Modi joined the BJP in 1987. With a calls. But “he wanted to be the first to reach
would he be able to run a government for reputation as an efficient organiser he rose Kutch, to see and analyse what had hap-
so many years? Without a team effort how through the ranks, although his self-promo- pened so that he could make a report for
can you get success?” tion and ambition earned him enemies along the party leadership in Delhi.” Nathwani
He dismissed concerns about his style of the way, according to various biographies. lent him the jet – handing Modi a political
management. Parimal Nathwani, group president in victory over his nemesis.
“I always say the strength of democracy Gujarat of one of India’s biggest compa- Nearly four months after Modi’s swear-
lies in criticism. If there is no criticism that nies, Reliance Industries Limited, tells a ing-in, Gujarat was hit by another earth-
means there is no democracy. And if you story that captures Modi’s drive to succeed. quake. This one was man-made; the after-
want to grow, you must invite criticism. And In January 2001, nine months before Modi shocks can still be felt.
I want to grow, I want to invite criticism.” became chief minister, Gujarat was hit by On Feb. 27, 2002, a fire aboard a train in
one of the worst earthquakes in India’s the eastern Gujarat district of Godhra killed
“WE HAVE NO ORDERS TO SAVE YOU” recorded history. Modi, who was working 59 Hindu pilgrims. While there are still
The son of a tea-stall owner, Modi’s jour- at the BJP headquarters in Delhi, called questions over how it started, police blamed
ney into politics started young. As a teen- Nathwani at Reliance to ask if he could the blaze on local Muslims. That triggered a
ager he joined the Rashtriya Swayamsevak borrow the company jet to fly to Kutch, the wave of violence in which Hindu mobs at-
Sangh (RSS), a voluntary right-wing group hardest-hit district. tacked predominantly Muslim neighbour-
that serves both as the ideological incubator Modi did not think Gujarat’s then-chief hoods. India is a Hindu-majority nation;
for “Hindutva”, a hardline brand of Hindu minister Keshubai Patel – who was also some 138 million Muslims make up about
nationalism, and as the philosophical parent BJP but was Modi’s rival – would allow 13 percent of the population according to
of the BJP. Early on Modi was a “pracharak” the 2001 census, the latest available data on
or propagandist, living a monkish life and religious makeup.
evangelising from village to village to win Follow Reuters Special Reports The Indian government later put the
on Facebook:
new recruits. That experience taught him death toll at more than 1,000; human
facebook.com/ReutersReveals
“your life should be disciplined,” he said, rights activists estimate at least double that
SPECIAL REPORT 4
INDIA The remaking of Narendra Modi
number died. Activists and relatives of the
riot victims accused Modi and his govern-
Good but not top
ment of giving Hindu rioters a free hand. Foreign direct investment to India by state, or states
New York-based Human Rights Watch from April 2009 to Dec. 2012
said in a 2002 report entitled “We Have No
Arunachal Pradesh,
Orders to Save You” that at best police had Assam, Manipur, Meghalaya, $0.03 billion
been “passive observers, and at worst they Mizoram, Nagaland, Tripura
acted in concert with murderous mobs.”
In 2011, a Gujarati court convicted 31 Bihar, Jharkhand $0.03
Muslims for the initial attack on the train.
Separately, gynaecologist Maya Kodnani, Rajasthan $0.21
who Modi made a minister for woman and
children in 2007, was sentenced to 28 years
last August for handing out swords to riot- Orissa $0.24
ers and exhorting them to attack Muslims.
She is still serving her sentence.
Uttar Pradesh, Uttarakhand $0.32
Modi has always rebuffed demands for
an apology. He insists that he did all that he
could to stop the violence. “Up till now, we Goa $0.52
feel that we used our full strength to set out
to do the right thing,” he said.
A special investigation team (SIT) ap- Kerala $0.70
pointed by the Supreme Court to inves-
tigate the role of Modi and others in the Chhattisgarh, $0.78
violence said in a 541-page report in 2012 Madhya Pradesh
it could find no evidence to prosecute the
chief minister. Most importantly, it cleared Chandigarh, Haryana, $0.80
Modi of the most damaging allegation: Himachal Pradesh, Punjab
that he had told senior officials to allow
Sikkim, West Bengal $0.88
Hindu mobs to vent their anger.
“Everyone has their own view. I would
feel guilty if I did something wrong,” Modi Gujarat $2.98
told Reuters. “Frustration comes when you
think ‘I got caught. I was stealing and I got
caught.’ That’s not my case. I was given a
Andhra Pradesh $4.17
thoroughly clean chit.”
Asked if he regretted the violence, Modi Karnataka $4.63
compared his feelings to the occupant of
a car involved in an accident. If “someone
else is driving a car and we’re sitting be- Pondicherry, Tamil Nadu $5.28
hind, even then if a puppy comes under the
wheel, will it be painful or not? Of course Delhi $23.30
it is. If I’m a chief minister or not, I’m a
human being. If something bad happens
anywhere, it is natural to be sad.” Dadra and Nagar Haveli, $30.53
At the lunch at the German ambas- Daman and Diu, Maharashtra
sador’s house Modi was pointedly asked
by the gathered diplomats for reassurance Source:Reserve Bank of India
SPECIAL REPORT 5
INDIA The remaking of Narendra Modi
that the bloodshed of 2002 would not be
repeated. For years after the riots, EU am-
bassadors in New Delhi had largely kept
their distance from Modi, although the EU
never formally ostracised him.
Britain, which has a large Gujarati pop-
ulation, did impose a formal diplomatic
boycott on Modi for the deaths of three
British citizens in the riots, but ended it last
October. Washington maintains its ban,
despite pressure from some Republican
lawmakers in Congress. There has been
no move at the U.S. State Department
to reconsider its 2005 decision to revoke
Modi’s visa over the riots, a U.S. official
told Reuters. Indeed, a U.S. government
panel, the Commission on International
Religious Freedom, recommended last
May that Washington refuse any visa ap-
plication from Modi. TRADE: A cargo ship being loaded with wheat at Mundra port in Gujarat. REUTERS/Amit Dave
There has not been “full transparency
about (Modi’s) degree of involvement in
the violence and his responsibility for that,” Today a whole lot of people The difference is Modi and his sales
the commission’s chairwoman, Katrina in different parts of the country pitch. Economic success is important, he
Lantos Swett, told Reuters. seems to realise. But so is telling that story
at least know his name.
At the lunch, Modi occupied a central again and again. As chief minister, Modi has
seat at a long, rectangular dining room ta- Abraham Koshy embraced modern technology like no other
ble, with German ambassador Steiner sit- professor of marketing Indian leader. He is active on Facebook and
ting to one side. His reply to the question YouTube and has 1.8 million followers on
about the possibility of further riots: there state is the only one in India with a near Twitter, though aides say that number will
has been no communal violence in Gujarat 24/7 power supply – and slashed red tape to have to grow substantially for it to have
since 2002, unlike in other parts of India. attract companies like Ford, Maruti Suzuki any impact in an election. During his re-
and Tata Motors. election campaign last December, Modi
MARKETING MODI During Modi’s 10 years as chief min- used 3-D projection technology to appear
In the aftermath of the riots, Modi went to ister, Gujarat has grown an average of 10 simultaneously at 53 events – a world re-
work improving his reputation. percent a year. The state ranked fifth out of cord. He appears impeccably dressed, ei-
“What he has done is change the narra- 15 big states in 2010/2011 in terms of per ther in suits or stylish tailor-made kurtas,
tive and go for (economic) development,” capita income. Modi boasts it is the “engine a knee-length Indian shirt, rimless glasses
says Swapan Dasgupta, a New Delhi-based of India’s economic growth.” and a neatly trimmed white beard.
political analyst who has advised BJP lead- But opponents and some economists “In terms of brand recognition he has
ers on media strategy. “From 2002 onwards point out that Gujarat has a long tradi- succeeded eminently.Today a whole lot
he does not mention the riots any more. It tion of entrepreneurship and that the of people in different parts of the country
does not come into his speeches. This focus state was doing well economically before at least know his name,” said Abraham
on development was backed up by a very Modi took charge. Other states, including Koshy, professor of marketing at India’s top
powerful publicity machine.” Maharashtra, Karnataka, Andhra Pradesh, business management school, the Indian
Modi has built a reputation as an incor- Tamil Nadu and Delhi, attracted more for- Institute of Management in Ahmedabad,
ruptible and efficient technocrat who has eign investment than Gujarat between 2009 who nevertheless questions whether Modi
electrified Gujarat’s 18,000 villages – the and 2012, according to India’s central bank. can turn that recognition into votes.
SPECIAL REPORT 6
INDIA The remaking of Narendra Modi
The Indian media and the ruling Modi does not have a others, raised hands together as a packed
Congress party regularly claim that Modi PR agency. auditorium cheered. It was a powerful im-
has employed foreign help – in particular age, signalling Modi’s acceptance by major
APCO Worldwide, one of the largest PR Narendra Modi foreign powers and business leaders. Anil
agencies in the United States – to help him Ambani, head of India’s third-largest tele-
rehabilitate his image and make him more communications company, called him a
acceptable to voters at home and govern- “lord of men.”
ments abroad. In what many political analysts viewed
While politicians around the world as a breakthrough moment for Modi, he
use PR agencies, Modi’s political oppo- persuaded billionaire industrialist Ratan
nents hope to raise questions about Modi’s Tata in 2008 to move production of the
achievements, say analysts. Opponents are Nano, billed as the world’s cheapest car, to
trying to tell voters “appearance is not real- the state. “He is good for business in India,”
ity, what you see is very different from the says Ron Somers, head of the U.S.-India
real Modi,” said Pralay Kanungo, a profes- Business Council, a Washington-based
sor of politics and an expert on Hindu na- lobby group that represents major U.S.
tionalism at Jawaharlal Nehru University in FOREIGN CONNECTIONS: Britain’s Minister companies in India.
New Delhi. of State for the Foreign Office Hugo Swire with It is difficult to tell how much of the tens
Modi’s government hired APCO in Modi during a signing ceremony for a recent of billions of dollars pledged at the summits
2009 to promote Gujarat’s biannual busi- gas deal. REUTERS/Amit Dave end up being invested, but the gatherings
ness investment summits in India and achieve one thing: “Vibrant Gujarat sum-
abroad. But the Washington-based firm mits are basically media-focused events
has repeatedly denied any involvement the project, a propaganda exercise aimed where the media can see Ratan Tata and
with Modi’s political campaigns. When at erasing the black stain of the riots and the Ambanis,” with Modi, said a former
asked to comment, APCO pointed to a marketing Gujarat, and therefore Modi, to strategist who has worked with the govern-
statement they made earlier this year: “We India and the world. ment on the summits.
do not work on Chief Minister Modi’s “The image makeover was needed as At the same time, there is substance be-
publicity campaign; we are not engaged to Modi realised that as a hardliner, he would hind the glitz. Gujarat’s government has
help resolve the (U.S.) visa issue.” have limited acceptability in the politi- invested heavily in roads, ports, agriculture
The man himself says he has no need for cal spectrum,” said one of Gujarat’s top and power, creating visible signs of progress
image makers. “I have never looked at or civil servants. “So he started working on in contrast to other parts of India. Projects
listened to or met a PR agency. Modi does his image and the Vibrant Gujarat sum- that can take months or even years to be
not have a PR agency,” he said. mit of 2003 was a big step towards it. The cleared elsewhere are regularly approved in
Modi says he rises at about 5 a.m. every subsequent summits have further helped in days or weeks in Gujarat.
day to do yoga and meditate. He reads the shaping his image.”
news for 15 minutes via Twitter on his iPad. The event started small but is now mar- A LEGACY QUESTIONED
He has not taken a holiday in 12 years, he keted as a kind of mini-Davos with Japan Modi’s image is also helped by the mis-
said while walking Reuters around the gar- and Canada as partner countries. At the steps of the ruling Congress party. Prime
den outside his office. 2013 summit, 121 countries attended, ac- Minister Manmohan Singh’s national gov-
Modi lives alone and has little contact cording to the Gujarat government. ernment has struggled through a series of
with his mother, four brothers or sister. In one memorable moment, Modi, corruption scandals. Economic growth is at
India’s richest businessmen and diplomats a decade low.
VIBRANT GUJARAT from Japan, Canada and Britain among But as Modi moves closer to becoming
One key to the way Modi has transformed his party’s presumptive candidate for prime
his image is “Vibrant Gujarat”, a project minister, his model of economic develop-
he launched in 2003. The biennial event is Follow Reuters Special ment is coming under greater scrutiny by
Reports on Twitter:
aimed at attracting investment to his state. both opponents and the Indian media.
@SpecialReports
But it is also, say some of those involved in The biggest criticism is that he is too
SPECIAL REPORT 7INDIA The remaking of Narendra Modi
PRODUCTION LINE: Gujarat lured production of Tata’s small car the Nano in 2008. The car has sold poorly, but the moment was a coup for the state;
Right: a Modi fan during the 2011 Rath Yatra, or chariot procession, in Ahmedabad. REUTERS/Amit Dave (2)
pro-business and that poor and minor- to the marginalised sections of society,” the coalition government, especially with Modi
ity communities, especially Muslims, have Planning Commission said in its 2011 at its head.
been left behind. India Human Development Report. The man himself dismisses the notion
“I don’t think the people of India can Modi says he is tackling these issues. He he is divisive.
be fooled with the development plank of has proposed spending 42 percent of his “I’m not in favour of dividing Hindus
Modi or the model of Modi’s Gujarat,” said 2013/2014 state budget on education, nu- and Sikhs. I’m not in favour of dividing
Shakeel Ahmad, chairman of the Islamic trition, healthcare and other social welfare Hindus and Christians. All the citizens, all
Relief Committee in Gujarat, sitting in programmes – the Planning Commission the voters, are my countrymen,” Modi said.
his office in one of the poorer parts of says it would like him to spend even more “Religion should not be an instrument in
Ahmedabad, Gujarat’s largest city. – but complains that efforts to redress the your democratic process.”
Veteran human rights activist Nafisa imbalances are hampered by a lack of reli-
Barot believes “his pro-business policies able data. Additional reporting by Manoj Kumar, Sruthi
have hurt poor people and among them “We do believe in inclusive growth, we Gottipati and Suchitra Mohanty in New Delhi,
most are Muslims” – and gave that message do believe that the benefits of this develop- and Susan Cornwell in Washington
to EU officials recently. ment must reach to the last person. We’re Editing by Simon Robinson
India’s Planning Commission, which doing a good job, that’s why the expecta-
sets five-year economic plans for the coun- tions are high. As they should be. Nothing
try, has expressed concern about Gujarat’s is wrong,” Modi told Reuters.
performance on a number of social indica- Modi will now take his mantra of good FOR MORE INFORMATION
tors, such as malnutrition, maternal mortal- governance and development on the road Ross Colvin, Chief Correspondent, India
ity, access to health, education for girls and to try to convince voters to vote his party ross.colvin@thomsonreuters.com
minorities, and water, and says the state into power nationally for the first time in Simon Robinson, Enterprise Editor,
should be doing a better job on these issues 10 years. Pollsters expect a close election Europe, Middle East and Africa
given the size of its economy. with regional parties likely to be king-mak- simon.robinson@thomsonreuters.com
“It appears that the high growth rate ers. Even if the BJP wins the most votes it Michael Williams, Global Enterprise Editor
achieved ... over the years has not percolated could struggle to find partners to form a michael.j.williams@thomsonreuters.com
© Thomson Reuters 2013. All rights reserved. 47001073 0310. Republication or redistribution of Thomson Reuters content, including by framing or similar means, is prohibited without the prior written consent of
Thomson Reuters. ‘Thomson Reuters’ and the Thomson Reuters logo are registered trademarks and trademarks of Thomson reuters and its affiliated companies.
SPECIAL REPORT 8You can also read
