THE OFFICE OF THE OMBUDSMAN FOR THE POSTAL SECTOR - Annual Repor t 2016 - smspo
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
TABLE OF CONTENTS The team of the Office of the Ombudsman PART 5 is at your service 02 The relationship between the company and its client 38 This annual report by the Office of Points of attention highlighted by the Ombudsman for the Postal Sector covers the Office of the Ombudsman 40 the activities of the year 2016 04 PART 6 PART 1 The new postal legislation! 44 The activities of the Office of the Ombudsman What are postal services? 46 for the Postal Sector 06 The valid liability rules 47 Sharp rise in the number of requests The rights of the addressee 48 for mediation 07 The quality of universal postal services 48 The role of the Office of the Ombudsman PART 2 for the Postal Sector 49 The Office of the Ombudsman for the Postal Sector in 201610 PART 7 Results from the closed files in 2016 14 The budget 50 PART 3 Colofon54 Universal services and services of general economic interest 18 The daily postal delivery is under pressure 21 Mail redirection on change of address 24 Registered postal items 24 Invoice fraud: raising awareness, recovery and targeted investigation 27 The project BeSt Address 29 PART 4 The delivery of parcels and packages in a liberalized market 30 The rights of the addressee, also within the context of e-commerce 33 The e-tracker: a quality instrument for the consumer? 35 Parcels and packages outside the EU: customs formalities and costs 36 ANNUAL REPORT | 2016 The O f f ice of the Ombudsman for the Pos tal Sec tor Correct information and communication 37 Boulevard du Roi Albert II / Koning Albert II-laan 8 box 4 – 1000 Brussel www.omps.be 01
OUR TEAM The team The services of the Office of the Ombudsman for the Postal Sector are free. WEBSITE www.omps.be BY PHONE German/English 02/221.02.22 of the Office Dutch 02/221.02.20 We are a federal ombudsman’s service, and BY E-MAIL French 02/221.02.30 of the have been approved as an ADR entity by German/English info@omps.be Dutch info@omps.be BY FAX the European Commission. You can find our French info@smspo.be 02/221.02.44 Ombudsman rules of procedure online at www.omps.be BY POST OFFICES in accordance with the ADR directive*. is at your Boulevard du Roi Albert II / Our offices are open to the public Monday to Friday Koning Albert II-laan 8 box 4 – 1000 Brussel from 9 a.m. to 4 p.m. or by appointment. Koning Albert II-laan 8 – 1000 Brussel service ANNUAL REPORT | 2016 Sophie Elodie Eglantine Fabienne Luc Françoise Katelijne Paul Ivan Youssef Linda Joeri Ronny Nancy Danny * Directive 2013/11/EU of the European Parliament and the Council of 21 May 2013 on alternative dispute resolution for consumer disputes and amending Regulation (EC) no. 2006/2004 and Directive 2009/22/EC (Directive on consumer ADR). 02 03
FOREWORD This annual This annual report by the Office of the Ombudsman for the postal sector covers As an appeal body with legally guaranteed independence, the task of the Office of Ombudsman College we are committed to working together into the future with the report by the the activities of the year 2016. We give an the Ombudsman is to inform, advise and companies in the postal sector for a better Office of the overview of the complaints and provide mediate between customer and company. service provision. analysis based on the most prominent In the mediation process we strive to Ombudsman difficulties encountered by clients in the post and parcel sector in 2016. reach a settlement which is acceptable to all parties, based on the results of our We would like to thank our team members for their commitment and expertise in their for the Postal investigations. As well as an individual solution for the consumer's request, this handling of each request for mediation. Sector covers is also an opportunity for the company to maintain the customer's trust. Finally, we would like to thank Truus Lostrie, ombudswoman for the postal sector for the activities An independent appeal body provides the past 19 years, for her dedication to improving and advancing the Office of the of the year companies, on the basis of the complaints, Ombudsman to create the high quality 2016 a permanent audit of their organization. organization it is today. The individual complaints and the resulting investigations give a clear and extremely Paul De Maeyer & Katelijne Exelmans incisive picture of the reality in the field. Problems that sometimes remain hidden to managers, come to the fore, and provide a basis for improvement processes. These can lead to changes in the service provision, the legislation and also in the perceptions and expectations of the customer. This annual report aims to contribute to this. ANNUAL REPORT | 2016 The Office of the Ombudsman for the postal sector has a tradition of open communication and constructive consul tation with the different parties. As a new 04 05
PART 1 The activities Sharp rise in the number of requests for mediation of the Office In 2016 the Office of the Ombudsman for of the the postal sector received 15,856 new written complaints. This represents a sharp Ombudsman increase of 25% compared with 2015. for the Postal Sector OVERALL FIGURES 2016 2016 2015 2014 Complaints to be handled 17,196 13,486 13,373 - New complaints 15,856 12,616 12,301 - Amount from the previous year 1,340 870 1,072 Problems reported by telephone 4,818 3,301 3,048 Complaints handled by 31 December 14,916 12,146 12,503 inadmissible 5,554 4,610 5,075 admissible 9,362 7,536 7,428 Amount to be carried over 2,280 1,340 870 15,856 new written complaints ANNUAL REPORT | 2016 06 07
PART 1 EN DE 158 12 We conducted investigations into 17,196 complaints, NEW COMPLAINTS NEW COMPLAINTS PER COMPANY including 1,340 complaints carried over from 2015. 14,916 PER LANGUAGE 11,280 complaints were settled by 31 December 2016, and 2,280 Only the 10 companies with the highest number of complaints were carried forward to be handled in 2017. complaints will be mentioned here. The complete list can be found on our website (www.omps.be). As a public service, our work is carried out in the three 4,406 FR languages of the country: Dutch, French and German. Speakers of other languages are helped in English. NL NEW WRITTEN COMPLAINTS PER COMPANY 2016 2015 2014 bpost 14,683 11,524 11,234 TBC-Post 220 124 66 NEW COMPLAINTS PER CATEGORY PostNL 159 189 86 NEW WRITTEN COMPLAINTS PER LANGUAGE UPS 122 37 47 2016 2015 2014 Kiala 85 51 85 postal items DHL 70 100 43 Processing of postal items 9,189 7,021 6,641 DPD 70 96 33 Customer focus/relational 4,691 3,994 3,893 Mondial Relay 62 137 172 Contact points 622 404 458 FedEx 26 6 16 Regulations 478 467 510 GLS 23 11 10 Public services and non-postal services within the competence Other 42 23 121 of the Office of the Ombudsman for the postal sector Total sector 15,562 12,298 11,913 Financial post and duties of public services 335 248 294 COMPLAINTS OUTSIDE THE SECTOR Commercial services 210 155 114 bpost bank 183 212 321 bpost bank 15 7 20 Other 111 106 67 Complaints outside our authority General total 15,856 12,616 12,301 bpost bank 168 205 248 Other complaints 148 115 123 Total 15,856 12,616 12,301 As the historic postal company and in 2016 by far the Ombudsman for the postal sector. For Mondial Relay, the largest universal postal service provider, more than 90% decreasing trend has continued. We also see a decrease of the complaints involved bpost. The proportion of the in the number of complaints about PostNL, DHL and DPD. For complaints that fall within our competence, there The customer services at first instance always have total complaints attributable to bpost rose further in 2016. is a rise in the number of complaints in every category. the opportunity to maintain or restore the positive Particularly striking is the rise in the number of complaints relationship with the customer. However, the rising The growing universal postal service provider TBC Post ANNUAL REPORT | 2016 about the processing of postal items, the basic activity of number of complaints relating to customer focus suggests appeared in second place for the first time. the sector. The number of complaints about the processing that the complaints services do not always succeed in of both letters and parcels has increased, as is discussed accomplishing this. Complaints about the financial post For the other companies, we do not see a clear-cut later in this report. have also increased, after the decrease in 2015. picture. UPS, Kiala, FedEx and GLS have seen an increase in the absolute number of complaints to the Office of the 08 09
PART 2 The Office The Office of the Ombudsman for the postal sector is an independent federal public of the service, which was created in the Act of 21 March 1991, and which since February Ombudsman 2007 has become competent to handle complaints from all companies active in for the the Belgian postal market. Postal Sector As an appeal body, the Office of the Ombudsman for the postal sector has the following competences1 : in 2016 1° to investigate all complaints by the users in connection with: a) the activities of bpost, with the exception of: – complaints which are authorized for investigation by another independent sectorial dispute commission or independent mediator; – complaints relating to products or services provided by bpost in their role as subcontractor for third parties. b) the postal activities of the companies referred to in § 1, 2° and 3° of this article. Anybody can submit a request for mediation to the Office of the Ombudsman for the postal sector: a private individual, a company, a society, an organization, … both the sender and the recipient of the post, provided that the problem involves a company that is active in the Belgian post and parcel market and that a prior complaint has been submitted to the company in question in accordance with their internal procedure. ANNUAL REPORT | 2016 1. Article 43 of §3 of the Act of 21 March 1991 concerning the reform of certain economic public enterprises. 10 11
PART 2 The Office of the Ombudsman for the postal sector The figures given further in this report concern complaints does not handle complaints received by telephone. that were submitted in writing, via the electronic complaint Nevertheless, our first contact with complainants is often form2 or via e-mail. In exceptional cases, the Office of the by telephone. In 2016 there were 4,818 telephone reports. Ombudsman for the postal sector still receives complaints This represents a huge increase of 45% relative to the by post, fax or in person in our offices. previous year. During the initial telephone contact, the caller outlines their complaint and the case manager asks Each new complaint is codified based on the legal standard3. whether they have already contacted the post or parcel In accordance with this standard, every complaint must be company in question. A complaint may only be handled registered before it can be fully analysed. A single file by the Office of the Ombudsman if the customer has first can therefore contain multiple complaints. For instance: A approached the company in question in order to reach customer reports not only that their postal item took far too a solution. The case manager listens to the complaint long to be processed, but also that it was erroneously sent and refers the customer to the relevant customer service back, rather than delivered to the recipient; the customer department or informs them about the procedure for also expresses their dissatisfaction at the company's refusal submitting an admissible written complaint to the Office to offer a reimbursement. of the Ombudsman. This involves direct service provision. In accordance with the standard, we must take into account 45% Since the Office of the Ombudsman for the postal sector not only complaints about the postal item, but also was established in 1993, the number of new complaints relational complaints, complaints about the organization, and telephone reports has never been as high as it was in the service provision etc. 2016. The increase is spread across all the months of 2016 and cannot therefore be attributed to certain incidents On average, each file contains three complaints. After all, A strong increase of in the number of registered phone calls or specific periods of the year. Moreover, the increase in as an appeal body, a great many people who come to us complaints is also spread across all categories. This will already have a whole story behind them involving their be examined later in this report. complaint, and their frustration and disenchantment is great by the time they register with the Office of the Ombudsman. NEW COMPLAINTS & TELEPHONE REPORTS 20,674 16,742 15,917 15,349 14,739 14,400 14,061 13,571 12,840 12,283 12,108 11,546 11,227 7,696 7,332 6,850 5,729 ANNUAL REPORT | 2016 5,047 4,442 4,237 4,095 2,597 1,689 1,139 2. www.omps.be 3. Article 43 of §4 of the Act of 21 March 1991 concerning the reform of certain economic ’93 ’94 ’95 ’96 ’97 ’98 ’99 ’00 ’01 ’02 ’03 ’04 ’05 ’06 ’07 ’08 ’09 ’10 ’11 ’12 ’13 ’14 ’15 ’16 public enterprises. 12 13
PART 2 Results from the closed files Of the 14,916 complaints handled in 2016, 9,362 complaints NO REPARATION FOR THE CUSTOMER were admissible (compared with 7,536 in 2015). The The proportion of complaints which are understandable in 2016 admissible complaints are subject to further investigation from the perspective of the customer, but where the 9,362 and can be settled in six different ways: company has not made a mistake and did act in 87% of all complaints handled had been settled by accordance with the law or the company's general 31 December 2016 (compared with 90% in 2015). The sharp conditions, was 21%, a slight decrease relative to last increase in the number of complaints means that we have year (24%). This category also includes complaints that to carry forward more files to the next year. The average REPARATION FOR THE CUSTOMER are justified, but where the customer is not able to time taken to handle an admissible written complaint In 2016, the majority of complaints (70.8%) were settled receive compensation due to lack of evidence. remained at 32 working days for the third consecutive year. admissible complaints via reparation for the customer: financially or morally. handled The company acknowledges that a mistake occurred After the complaint is submitted, it is codified, registered or that the customer's complaint is justified, and issues and an investigation is initiated to see whether the complete or partial compensation. This can occur in complaint is admissible. This involves an initial analysis the form of damage compensation, reimbursement, with, if necessary, additional questions to the customer 3% extension of a contract without additional costs, a free Letters may be delivered at any time of the day. or the company in question. For every complaint, an parcel etc. Immaterial compensation is also often There is no latest time of delivery specified. After the acknowledgement of receipt is created for the customer. expressed. A written acknowledgement of the error, a reorganization of the services, your address came to be With inadmissible complaints, the complainant receives 3% 1% letter of apology, measures for preventing future at the end of the daily postal delivery round, which 71% advice on how to proceed further and we assist him or her mistakes or directly confronting a certain employee means that you now receive your correspondence in the by passing the complaint on to the correct party. 21% involved, restore faith in the company for many afternoon, and no longer in the morning as you did customers. previously. The company is acting entirely within the law in this matter.” Thank you: this morning the new copy of my UNJUSTIFIED COMPLAINT magazine came through the letter box. I hope that, from In 2016 we designated 314 complaints as unjustified. now on, I won't have to call on your help again.” These are complaints that, on investigation, prove to be unfounded. In most cases these complaints are due “I agree to the proposal to accept payment of 893.48 to a mistake or misinterpretation on the part of the euros to settle all accounts. The payment can be customer, only rarely we encounter a case of fraud. In ■ 6,627 problem resolved and/or compensation transferred to account number... We will take no further other cases, a third party is responsible for the for the customer steps in this matter. We would like to thank you for your problem, for example a publisher which issues its ■ 1,984 the postal company is not at fault or no proof intervention, and wish you the very best.” postal items late or in insufficient number, theft after available of the error delivery etc. ■ 314 unjustified complaints ■ 310 justified or understandable complaints but no solution ■ 127 interrupted complaints ANNUAL REPORT | 2016 ■ 0 recommendations You wrote an incorrect post code on the letter for your daughter. Therefore, the letter did not arrive at the correct sorting office and was returned to you due to an 'erroneous address'.” 14 15
PART 2 5,554 JUSTIFIED AND UNDERSTANDABLE, BUT NO SOLUTION INADMISSIBLE COMPLAINTS We also saw an increase in the number of complaints that were justified and understandable, but for which Every complaint is codified, registered and investigated there is no solution, for instance a postal item with a to see whether the complaint is admissible. The following unique, emotional value that is lost and can never by complaints are treated as inadmissible: (adequately) compensated by reimbursement. inadmissible > primary complaints; complaints handled > anonymous complaints; > personnel disputes; I'm very sorry, but the Christmas card from your > vigorous complaints; recently deceased aunt couldn't be found…” > complaints that are or that have been the subject of 1.5% a court case between the customer and the company; > requests for information; 3% > complaints outside our competence; 1% > lack of information, despite repeated requests by the 5 % 89.5% INCONCLUSIVE COMPLAINT Office of the Ombudsman for the postal sector; A complaint can be closed with status inconclusive, if > if the primary complaint was first submitted more the customer withdraws the complaint in the course than one year ago, the Office of the Ombudsman for of the investigation or if they take legal action. 127 files the postal sector can decide not to investigate the were closed at the request of the complainant, either case further. because there was no longer any cause for the complaint or because the customer realized that they were asking the impossible. With inadmissible complaints, the complainant receives settling the complaint. These people (again) receive a advice on how to proceed further and the complaint is clear explanation of the procedure and are referred on as passed on to the relevant company. The admissibility appropriate. For 2016, alongside the main group of primary investigation is generally completed within one or two complaints, we also added several new categories, namely: days. If additional information needs to be requested, 'outside our authority', 'lack of information after repeated To my astonishment, the postman delivered my this may extend to several weeks. New elements can also requests' and 'requests for information'. Complaints falling parcel yesterday. He also had no idea where it had been arise in the course of an investigation which give cause outside any of these categories have been grouped under for the last 4 weeks, but as far as I'm concerned, the to a complaint being registered as inadmissible. This can 'other'. ■ 4,979 first-line complaints case is closed. Thank you very much for your help, you mean that files still open on 31 December, are later closed ■ 272 not the competence of the Ombudsman can now close the file.” as inadmissible the following year. ■ 173 insufficient information ■ 88 requests for information After a decline in 2015, we again saw a rise in the number We have received your e-mail, but cannot yet ■ 42 other reasons of inadmissible complaints in 2016. Some of these were initiate an investigation. We will send your complaint due to a lack of knowledge about how the Office of the to the company's complaints service, requesting them RECOMMENDATIONS Ombudsman for the postal sector operates. In these to contact you directly. If you do not receive a response As stipulated in the law, the Ombudsman can make a cases, the Office of the Ombudsman immediately sends or if you are not satisfied with the handling of your recommendation when they believe that the complaint the complaint through to the relevant postal company complaint, you may submit an appeal free of charge is justified, but that no agreement will be reached with (in the case of primary complaints) or the authorized through our service. We are a federal public appeal ANNUAL REPORT | 2016 the company involved. In 2016, no recommendations Ombudsman, and informs the complainant about this. We body, competent for complaints about most activities were made in any complaint case. Through our dialogue also frequently see people who directly approach the Office of bpost and about the postal activities of other post with the companies we were always able to reach a of the Ombudsman with a primary complaint, because they and parcels companies.” solution. do not or no longer trust the company's complaints service, or because they think we can accelerate the process of 16 17
PART 3 Universal The universal postal service covers both national and international services and consists of: > the collection, sorting, transport and distribution of services and letters, addressed publicity material, newspapers and magazines up to 2kg; > the collection, sorting, transport and distribution of services postal parcels up to 10kg; > the distribution of postal parcels, received from other of general EU member states, up to 20kg; > services relating to registered postal items and insured (declared-value) postal items. economic Up until December 2018, bpost is designated by the interest government as the universal service provider. This means that bpost is obliged to guarantee the universal postal service throughout Belgian territory, at a certain level of quality and at an affordable price. The rules and conditions under which bpost executes these universal postal services, are stipulated in a management contract between the Belgian government and the company. Other companies may also request a permit to execute universal postal services. For now, bpost has only one competitor, TBC-Post. Receiving a permit is subject to subject to specific legal conditions. ANNUAL REPORT | 2016 18 19
PART 3 A management agreement with the government also In 2016 there were 7,404 complaints complaints concerning outlines other public duties of general economic interest, universal services and services of general economic interest. which until 31 December 2020 are designated to bpost. That is a large increase of 29% compared with 2015. This These include certain financial services, payment of covers a rise in the number of complaints for all types of pensions and allowances for people with disabilities, postal items: regular and registered deliveries, magazines, issuing fishing permits, delivering newspapers, the newspapers and public duties. However, complaints about financial and administrative processing of traffic fines the organization have seen the biggest rise. for the police. 7,404 EVOLUTION OF THE UNIVERSAL SERVICE AND SERVICES OF GENERAL ECONOMIC INTEREST 2016 2015 2014 Ordinary postal items 3,980 3,332 3,333 Registered postal items 1,217 786 556 complaints on universal services Organization 972 762 662 and services of general economic Magazines 510 385 328 interests Public duties 390 223 272 Newspapers 335 248 294 Total 7,404 5,736 5,445 5% 5% 54% 7% The daily postal delivery is under pressure Today is the third day in a row that I have received 13% In the annual report of 2015, the daily, correct delivery of no post whatsoever at the below address. This is letters (including invoices, postcards, personal letters etc.), completely unacceptable.” registered postal items, magazines and newspapers was already a key area requiring attention. In 2016, the number of complaints relating to the daily postal delivery increased still further. The Act of 21 March 1991 and the European The number of complaints submitted to the Office of the Postal Directive stipulate that bpost must guarantee the daily Ombudsman speaks for itself: an increase of 18% for errors postal delivery at least five days per week, to all residential in the delivery of regular postal items. The number of 16% addresses with a regulatory letter box. complaints relating to the erroneous delivery of newspapers ANNUAL REPORT | 2016 has even doubled. The number of complaints about lost The number of complaints received by the Office of the items has also risen: 12% compared with regular postal items. ■ 3,980 ordinary postal items ■ 510 magazines Ombudsman for the postal sector emphasizes the high ■ 1,217 organization ■ 390 newspapers degree of importance placed by citizens and companies on ■ 972 registered postal items ■ 335 public duties of bpost the daily and correct postal delivery. 20 21
PART 3 We see the biggest frustrations among customers when Problems with the daily postal delivery can have various After investigating a complaint, bpost often indicates that This morning, all kinds of things went wrong, errors in the daily delivery keep on recurring, even after causes. The ordinary postal items form by far the greatest on that particular day, a replacement or new post man mistakes that to my knowledge the regular postman repeated complaints. The customer would like to know why share: postmen and women who make careless mistakes or woman carried out the round, and errors occurred never makes.” the daily delivery keeps going wrong, and what measures (sometimes under time pressure), incomplete or incorrect because they are not so familiar with the work and the will be taken to correct this in the future. We receive addresses etc. Regarding the delivery of newspapers and environment. The Office of the Ombudsman for the postal “Until last year, Robert was our regular postman and repeated reports from customers that their post has been magazines, it can happen that publishers issue too few sector is explicit in this: employee inexperience cannot be there were never any mistakes; since he retired, we see delivered elsewhere in the street or municipality, or that copies to bpost or issue them late. an excuse for repeated or structural errors made by the a new postman every week, but none of them works for they receive deliveries not intended for them. In some company. Every customer has the right to correct delivery a single day without making mistakes.” cases it takes considerable time to reach a solution for Repeated erroneous deliveries can also originate from of their mail, both sender and addressee. human error and/or problems with the automatic sorting. the automatic sorting process. For example, where the automatic sorting based on house number differs from the route that the postman or woman follows. Or where streets get mixed up, e.g. the residents of Brusselsestraat receive the correspondence for Brusslsesteenweg and vice versa. When you read what efforts I have repeatedly In 2016 we saw a large increase in the number of made in an attempt to solve this problem, you will complaints linked to the organization of the operator understand that I have reached the end of my tether, itself, 1,217 complaints (compared with 786 in 2015). The since it seems the company is not able to find a solution following complaints fall into this category: the postman or to a problem that, to my mind, is quite a simple one. woman did not deliver today, in the past I always received My neighbour also complains about receiving the wrong my mail in the morning, and now in the afternoon, I have to mail…“ drive a long way to collect my registered mail or parcel, … “This is the sixth time this has happened; now I've really What is striking in this, is that the customer often thinks ERRORS WITH THE DELIVERY had enough. Reporting the problem to the complaints that no problems will occur if the regular postman or 2016 2015 2014 service online simply doesn't work, the problem keeps woman carries out their round. This man or woman knows on occurring. This situation is causing me enormous the recipients in his or her round, and can therefore correct Regular postal items 1,667 1,408 1,451 stress.” errors in presorting or address errors quite easily. There Newspapers 574 449 388 is often a good relationship between customers and the Magazines 284 136 204 regular postman or woman, and they easily talk to them, also when problems arise. The temporary and replacement Registered postal items 225 150 136 staff, and intern students who are increasingly being Bundles 2 6 3 deployed, don't have the same contact with the people on their round. Total 2,752 2,149 2,182 LOSS 2016 2015 2014 Regular postal items 1,318 1,178 1,334 ANNUAL REPORT | 2016 Newspapers 262 214 200 Magazines 156 131 159 Registered postal items 28 18 18 Total 1,764 1,541 1,711 22 23
PART 3 Mail redirection on change In this annual report, the Office of the Ombudsman of address for the postal sector would like to once again stress the importance of the maintaining the security and confidentiality of mail redirection requests. The number When a customer moves house temporarily or permanently, of complaints relating to this is fortunately limited, but they will naturally wish to keep receiving their mail at their the consequences can be very serious for those affected. new address. Then it is useful to enter into a contract This concerns situations where somebody requests mail with bpost or TBC-Post, who will not only redirect the direction on behalf of another person. We advise the mail to the new address, but will also, at the request of postal operators to thoroughly check the identity of the the customer, inform some of the other operators of the person requesting mail redirection. change of address. Finally, to take a proactive stance in this, we wish to point For every operator which provides universal services, it out that the presence of two universal service providers in is mandatory to offer a mail redirection service. TBC-Post the market calls for these companies to make permanent does provide this, but very few customers use it. All the agreements with regard to mail redirection. A customer complaints received by the Office of the Ombudsman who signs a redirection agreement with one operator, about mail redirection in 2016 concerned bpost. expects all their mail to be redirected, also the postal items 497 handled by a different operator. In response to a specific The number of complaints regarding mail redirection rose complaint, we have insisted that both operators make to 497 in 2016 (compared with 364 in 2015). agreements and put permanent arrangements in place to guarantee this. An agreement in principle has since been complaints on mail Customers reported a variety of problems with this: the signed by the operators. As Office of the Ombudsman for mail keeps arriving at the old address, the mail intended the postal sector, we will remain alert to this problem. redirection for the new residents of the old address is also redirected, the mail is lost: it doesn't arrive at either the old or the new address etc. Customers are often understanding at Registered postal items the beginning of the redirection, but become increasingly frustrated when problems keep occurring, even after the bpost and TBC-Post are the two companies in Belgium mistakes are repeatedly reported. As a last resort, they that accept, process and deliver registered postal items then contact the Office of the Ombudsman for the postal as part of the universal service provision. sector. The number of national registered postal items is falling (a decrease of 16.31% between 2010 and 2015 4) and an electronic alternative has already been announced. People who still choose to send a postal item via registered mail, consciously choose the legal and administrative value of To draw a line under a long period of stress and this. The sender then has evidence of the sending of the frustration, we agree to accept a reimbursement of four postal items and the signature on delivery also provides months' redirection costs, to be transferred to account evidence of delivery to the addressee. People pay extra number…” for this security and evidence, and there is therefore little ANNUAL REPORT | 2016 understanding on the part of the customer and the Office of the Ombudsman in cases of errors in the processing of registered mail. However, our investigations show that 4. Report from the Board of the BIPT of 30 November 2016 concerning the the proper monitoring of registered postal items is not observatory of the market for postal activities in Belgium for 2015, p. 20. always guaranteed. 24 25
PART 3 REGISTERED POSTAL ITEMS After we expressly requested them to address this issue, bpost agreed to write a letter confirming that an error did 2016 2015 2014 occur with the postal item. However, this often does not Errors with the delivery 574 449 388 have the same value to the sender. Loss 262 214 200 Among complaints about registered postal items, a growing Delays 92 72 44 group involves registered postal items from abroad, in Address change/ mail redirection 33 14 10 particular following a purchase from Asian webshops. Damage 11 13 20 While the mode of sending of these webshops used to be small packages, nowadays they are increasingly using Total 972 762 662 registered mail. The following situations gave particular cause for the issuer and bpost in 2015, both of whom took measures to complaint: address this. However, in view of the 69 complaints involving Invoice fraud: raising > not ringing the bell/knocking on the door, but ecocheques received by the Office of the Ombudsman in 2016 (20 complainants), we are requesting a reevaluation awareness, recovery and immediately leaving an absence note through the and additional measures until the electronic ecocheque has targeted investigation letter box (errors); been fully implemented. > if the nobody answers the door, no message is left The past few years, we have received several complaints behind (errors); In a similar context, we would like to point out an equivalent on invoice fraud. Invoice fraud means a gang of criminals > delivery to an unauthorized person (errors); problem with the disappearance of used meal vouchers that intercepting invoices, replacing the account number on the > if nobody answers the door, a second delivery is not were returned to the issuers by shops. In 2013, bpost tested invoice with a false one, and then returning the invoice attempted (errors); a 'cheque return service' which offered strong protection for to the postal circuit. The purchaser/recipient receives the > the registered postal item is lost (loss). shops. However, due to a lack of interest among shops, they invoice and pays it to the false account number. As soon discontinued this initiative after one year. as the payment enters the account, the gang ensures that the money disappears as quickly as possible.5 Specifically for TBC-Post we have received concerned In our investigations into registered postal items, we questions around the option of issuing authorization to sometimes encountered shortcomings in the electronic Although people often see through the fraud attempt, there a manager at TBC-Post. This option is automatically offered monitoring of these postal items. The tracking information are still many victims. In almost half of the cases the sum when the online programme is initiated. The recipient is sometimes erroneous reports the item as 'delivered'. Even involved is more than 10,000 euros. It often involves invoices given the choice: the registered postal item is delivered when it is clear that the postal item has not been correctly for a one-off payment, such as invoices from construction through the letter box in the same way as a regular postal delivered, bpost still doesn't change this status. This means companies to different clients. item, or the registered postal item is opened, and the content that the recipient cannot back up their story, should the is sent to the addressee by e-mail as an attachment. As registered item go missing or if a similar problem arises. In 2016, the Office of the Ombudsman for the postal Office of the Ombudsman, we are investigating further to sector received 43 written complaints from 13 different determine whether this method is lawful. complainants. Complaints about ecocheques keep occurring among the These figures are just the tip of the iceberg, since we are national registered postal items. Shops send the used I have a complaint about a registered postal items primarily an appeal body. ANNUAL REPORT | 2016 cheques back to the issuer for payment, but they are that has gone missing. It was a package from China. On intercepted in transit and the cheques either do not arrive checking the bar code, the status says 'delivered', but I at the issuer or the issuer receives an empty envelope. The never received the package.” ecocheques are reused and the original shop is not paid. This is a serious problem, that we brought to the attention of 5. There are other systems of invoice fraud, however the Office of the Ombudsman for the postal sector only investigates complaints with a postal link. 26 27
PART 3 Moreover, our investigations have determined that in that additional measures are being taken to secure letter The project BeSt Address the vicinity of an affected company there are often other boxes and to monitor the transport and sorting. The companies who have been victims of the same fraud. process is still ongoing. For several years now, the Office of the Ombudsman for the postal sector has been investigating complaints of With invoice fraud, there are multiple parties involved: the If somebody suspects a 'possible' case of fraud, a rapid people's postal address differing from their official sender/sellers, the postal operators, the buyers/recipients, response is crucial. After all, the perpetrators try to move address, as recorded in the National Register. Letters that the bank of the debtor, the bank of the beneficiary, the the money extremely quickly to locations where it cannot are sent by governmental authorities carry the official police and judicial services and the various interest be found. Once this happens, it is practically impossible address. However, in the postal circuit (automatic sorting groups, the professional bodies, the involved organizations to recuperate the money. Sometimes it is too late to stop or the relevant postman/woman), the sorting and delivery (financial Ombudsman, Office of the Ombudsman for the your own payment from going through, but payments from process occurs on the basis of the postal address, which postal sector) and the government. others can still be blocked. Good agreements between is also the address most often stated on the letter box. banks are therefore vital. When it is known which invoices Due to this, important items: letters from the tax office, In view of the large number of parties, coordinated action are being intercepted, the postal operator can also replacement I.D.card reminder letter, notice of upcoming was required. Following meetings and discussions with intervene and better secure the letter boxes, for example. elections etc. are incorrectly delivered. the involved parties, we joined the working group 'invoice fraud', chaired by the Federal Public Service Economy. Next to prevention and recovery, investigation into the Various factors lie at the root of this problem, such as: the perpetrators is the third aspect. This investigation naturally way in which house numbers are recorded in the national First and foremost, we must keep raising awareness: falls under the authority of the police. Speed also plays register, the autonomy of municipalities in designating inform people about the possible risks and offer tips an important role in this aspect. Rapid action leads to letter box and apartment numbers, reference lists for for preventing invoice fraud. This eventually led to a a better chance of success than lagging weeks behind. postal addresses at the level of the three regions, but communication campaign that was initiated at the end The police also need information about the lines of not at national level etc. Nevertheless, the cause may The project BeSt Address aims to put an end to these of 2016 during a press conference with Mr Peeters, Deputy communication. Who can they turn to for information still be a clear difference between the official address problems, by making available an authentic source for Prime Minister and Minister for Work, Economy and about account holders, for example? and the postal address, as seems to be the case from the all addresses in Belgium 7. Consumers, responsible for foreign trade, and Mr Borsus, complaints we have received. Minister for Medium-sized Companies, Self-employed The Office of the Ombudsman for the postal sector This is an ambitious project as part of administrative Persons, SMEs, Agriculture and Societal Integration.6 supports the concept of a central contact point, from where simplification: the creation of a complete and reliable all the necessary actions are immediately taken: banks source of address information for the emergency services, This working group proposed three main actions in the for blocking accounts and payments, bpost for securing for various public administrations, as a basis for GPS fight against invoice fraud: prevention, recovery and letter boxes, police for further investigation, retrieving EXAMPLE: applications etc. Naturally this is also extremely valuable investigation. camera images etc. The official address = Stationsstraat 2, box 2L, the for the optimal delivery of the post. 3 main actions postal address = Stationsstraat 1, residence 2, box 2L. A postman or woman who is not familiar with the This is an ambitious project in terms of the collaboration street, will not be able to find this letterbox to deliver between the federal entities, the regions, the municipalities, official documents. the National Register, the Database of Business Enterprises, the Social Security Database, the universal postal services in the fight against invoice etc. The regions, in consultation with the municipalities, fraud: prevention, recovery and should have created their address register by 1 January 2017. investigation. From 1 January 2018 at the latest, public bodies will then This invoice was posted, along with five other refer to these registers so that everyone uses the same An essential element of prevention is the security of the invoices, on Tuesday evening 10/05 at around 17h15. authentic source. We are currently aware that the project ANNUAL REPORT | 2016 postal circuit. In their contact with us, bpost has indicated Four of the invoices had been falsified. Copies of these is somewhat behind schedule, and will not be able to keep can be found in the attachment. The total loss for us is: 7. Cooperation agreement of 22 January 2016 between the Federal State, the to the above schedule. 10,190.07 euros.” Vlaamse Gewest, the Waalse Gewest and the Brusselse Hoofdstedelijk Gewest concerning the unification of the way in which reference is made 6. Tips can be found on the websites of the participants and at the end of this to addresses and the linking of address data, published on 15 February The Office of the Ombudsman for the postal sector will report. 2016. of course continue to follow the progress of this project. 28 29
PART 4 The delivery Along with the growth in e-commerce and the increase in the number of parcels and of parcels and packages being distributed, the number of complaints relating to parcel and package packages in distribution has also increased: a liberalized In 2016, the Office of the Ombudsman for the postal sector received 1,918 complaints concerning the treatment of parcels and packages, a substantial increase of 36% market compared with the previous year.8 PARCELS AND PACKAGES 2016 2015 2014 Mistakes with the delivery 809 593 548 Loss 617 468 484 Delays 342 253 228 Address change/ mail redirection 144 91 104 Damage 6 9 11 Total 1,918 1,414 1,375 1,918 complaints concerning the sending of parcels and packages ANNUAL REPORT | 2016 8. These figures also include a number of complaints about parcels that, strictly speaking, fall into the universal postal service category. However, the distinction is a theoretical one: when customers send a package, they don't look at universal service provision, but they choose the most suitable option for them, out of the various options on offer from the different companies (based on familiarity with the company, price, speed, protection against risk of loss/ damage etc.). 30 31
PART 4 The table below shows the distribution of the complaints The rights of the addressee, among the different companies. also within the context It concerns a parcel from China that would be of e-commerce delivered via a parcel service. The purchase was made over the internet, and all costs associated with the PARCELS AN PACKAGES PER POSTAL OPERATOR The Office of the Ombudsman sometimes faces difficulties import (VAT, import duties etc.) were paid. The delivery 2016 2015 2014 obtaining sufficient information from the companies within company claims that the parcel could not be delivered bpost 1,684 1,192 1,179 the postal sector to carry out a thorough investigation. because nobody was at home. Then they claim that only This is particularly true when it is the addressee who has the seller in China has the authority to arrange for a PostNL 64 79 44 submitted the complaint. Various companies argue that second delivery. This means that I have to contact DPD 35 35 13 they only have a contract with the sender, and therefore the seller in China, to ask them to give the delivery are only obliged to handle complaints made by them. company instructions to deliver the parcel again to my UPS 29 7 11 Addressees who contact the company's complaints service address.” Kiala 27 15 34 are invariably told to contact the sender involved. DHL 23 24 8 When the tracking system mentions that the parcel has Mondial Relay 20 43 77 been transferred to the postal operator who will deliver GLS 9 7 3 it within Belgium, the addressee rightly feels indignant TNT Express 5 2 4 when this operator does not wish to answer his questions As was the case on 28/9, there is still no change or complaints. in the mail tracker for parcel CExxxxxUS. I have received Bubble Post 4 – – your answer, that there is no further electronic trace of Diadem Logistic 3 – – the parcel. Considering the parcel already arrived in Record Express 2 1 – Belgium on 30/8, and since then has undergone no further processing for more than a month, can we FedEx 2 – – consider the parcel to be lost?.” TBC-Post – 1 2 This frequently leads to extremely perplexing situations, as the following examples illustrate: Casino Chez Vous – 1 – Kariboo – 1 – Unknown 11 6 – On 06/09/16 there was an attempted delivery of Total 1,918 1,414 1,375 a package to my address; nobody was home. On 19/09/16 I'm astonished at the fact that we, as addressees I went to the post office to collect the package, but was of a postal item, are not able to report a complaint told that it had never arrived there. On the website about loss of the parcel in question. The parcel deliverer I submitted a request for the package to be delivered informs me that only the sender can do this; we as again, which was confirmed, but on the day of the addressees, cannot open a complaint file. However, at planned delivery I received a text message that the the sender's end, there's no problem: the sender in Japan package would not be delivered and that I should call is not going to complain that the delivery company in the company. On 22/09/16 I called the company and Belgium has made a mistake!" was told that the package would be delivered the next ANNUAL REPORT | 2016 day or the next week. Nothing happened.” 32 33
PART 4 It is even worse when the e-tracker erroneously states that A user is defined in art. 131 as: The e-tracker: the parcel has been delivered to the correct address. In this case, the addressee has absolutely no evidence (the Member States shall also encourage the development of independent out-of-court schemes for the resolution “17° user: any natural or legal person benefiting from a quality instrument e-tracker) to back up their case to the sender. of disputes between postal service providers and users. postal service provision as a sender or an addressee.” for the consumer? It is totally absurd when the purchase, as in the last example, took place in China, and a private individual The European Postal Directive defines a user in exactly The track and trace system is for both sender and addressee has to go and negotiate with a Chinese company regarding the same way as the Belgian legislation. a highly valued and widely used instrument for tracking the a parcel which arrived in Belgium and subsequently went progress of a package. It is extremely important, therefore, missing in the postal circuit or was incorrectly delivered. Consequently, the Ombudsman for the postal sector that this e-tracker supplies the correct information. urgently requests every company to comply with the The rights of the addressee are expressly described in legislation by also handling complaints by addressees. A However, research shows that sometimes, even when a the legislation. The Act of 21 march 1991, art. 148bis states proper internal investigation by the company can result parcel or package has been lost or has not been delivered the following: in a quick solution, clarify what went wrong, where the to the correct address, the e-tracker still states that the parcel was last traced, where the delay occurred, which delivery has taken place correctly. In these cases, the Office § 2. The suppliers of postal services are obliged to service was involved etc. of the Ombudsman asks companies to adjust the status of comply with the following: the postal item in the track and trace system. With postal - to set up a transparent, straight-forward and The Ombudsman for the postal sector is not advocating items associated with a purchase of goods by a consumer inexpensive internal procedure for the rapid and fair automatic compensation for the addressee. We are asking from a professional vendor, a change in the track and trace handling of complaints by users concerning loss, that complaints by addressees are taken seriously and status can be used by the buyer to request a new item from theft, damage or failure to meet the quality standards, properly investigated, so that the complainant receives the vendor. including procedures for establishing responsibility in a response to the perfectly reasonable question: 'what cases where more than one operator is involved; has happened to my parcel?'. As regards compensation, Some companies, however, argue that adjusting the e-tracker the World Post Association specifies that financial is technically not possible, or not desired. The addressee compensation is payable to the sender, unless the sender is often the one who loses out in these cases: they haven't The same article can be found in the European Postal decides to transfer their rights to the addressee. Therefore, received their parcel and the seller assumes that the goods Directive : only at the very end of the line, when it is certain that the have been delivered. The buyer who then approaches the postal item has been delivered to the wrong person or parcel delivery company, is again referred to the sender, Article 19 is irrecoverably lost, does the question of compensation for possible reimbursement or a replacement parcel. This 1. Member States shall ensure that transparent, simple arise. sender rightly assumes that the data from the e-tracker is and inexpensive procedures are made available by correct and up to date. For the sender, this is evidence that all postal service providers for dealing with postal We would like to point out that some companies have the goods have been delivered, and they therefore consider users' complaints, particularly in cases involving loss, taken extra steps to respect the rights of recipients, for the issue to be closed. theft, damage or noncompliance with service quality example through launching a telephone number for standards (including procedures for determining where senders and addressees of postal items. In the best case scenario, after our intervention, a certificate responsibility lies in cases where more than one operator is issued whereby the parcel delivery company states that is involved), without prejudice to relevant international Since this is the reason for the existence of the Ombudsman the item probably was not delivered. For some senders, and national provisions on compensation schemes. for the postal sector, we defend the rights of every user however, this is not sufficient evidence if the e-tracker states of a post or parcel service. This is outlined in the Act of that the parcel was indeed delivered. Member States shall adopt measures to ensure that the 21 March 1991 as follows : ANNUAL REPORT | 2016 procedures referred to in the first subparagraph enable The Office of the Ombudsman for the postal sector disputes to be settled fairly and promptly with provision, “3° mediation to facilitate an amicable settlement of believes that it must be possible to change the status where warranted, for a system of reimbursement and/ disputes between the companies and the users referred of the e-tracker in cases where it is established that the or compensation. to in § 1 of this article.” 9 9. Article 43 of the Act of 21 March 1991 concerning the reform of certain economic postal item has not been delivered to the correct address public enterprises. or has been lost in the postal circuit. 34 35
PART 4 Parcels and packages outside items to destinations outside the EU. The Office of This issue was already raised in our annual report of the EU: customs formalities the Ombudsman for the postal sector therefore asks companies to pay due attention to correctly informing 2015. bpost then took initiatives to create more clarity (including a detailed list of delivery times per country, and costs their customers of these issues, both on their website divided according to whether the postal item contains and via the staff in their branches. documents or goods). However, our fundamental criticism, For postal items crossing the external EU-borders, it is namely the difference between the delivery time on the important that the customs have access to sufficient promotional pages of the website and the delivery time information about the content of the postal item. This in the general conditions, has not been addressed 14. The information is entered into a so-called CN23 form, that Correct information Office of the Ombudsman for the postal sector therefore must be affixed to the parcel. and communication repeats its explicit request to clarify the communication around delivery times and delays. CN 23 (FN) 5/3/11 2:18 PM Page 1 DECLARATION EN DOUANE CN23 The Office of the Ombudsman for the postal sector DOUANEVERKLARING No de l’envoi / colis (code à barres, s’il existe) Nr. van de zending (barcode als hij bestaat) Peut être ouvert d’office Mag ambtshalve worden geopend sporadically receives complaints about delays in the express postal items from bpost (bpack World Express DE Nom Eventuellement VAN Naam référence Société de l’expéditeur Firma Eventueel and bpack World Express Pro). Many customers do not Rue referentie Straat van de afzender Code postal Ville Postcode Stad realize that bpost promises a certain delivery time on the Pays Land A Nom AAN Naam promotional page of its website, while that same delivery Société Référence de l’importateur (si elle existe) no de TVA, facultatif Firma Referentie van de invoerder (indien dit bestaat) BTW Nr., facultatief Rue Straat time is negated in its general conditions. Code postal Ville No de téléphone/fax/e-mail de l’importateur (si connu) Postcode Stad Nr. telefoon/fax/e-mail van de invoerder (indien gekend) Pays Land Description détaillée du contenu (1) Quantité (2) Poids net (en kg) (3) Valeur (5) Pour les envois commerciaux seulement Beschrijving van de inhoud (1) Aantal (2) Netto gewicht (in kg) (3) Waarde (5) Enkel voor de commerciële zendingen No tarifaire du SH (7) Pays d’origine des marchandises (8) Tariefnr. volgens SH (7) Land van oorsprong van de goederen (8) Poids brut total (4) Valeur totale (6) Frais de port / frais (9) The general conditions of bpost unequivocally state that a postal item is only considered to be delayed if it arrives Totaal bruto gewicht (4) Totale waarde (6) Portokosten / kosten (9) Catégorie de l’envoi (10) Echantillon commercial Explication Bureau d’origine / date de dépôt Soort zending (10) Handelsmonster Uitleg Kantoor van oorsprong / datum van afgifte Cadeau Retour de marchandise at its destination after more than twice the delivery time Geschenk Terugzending van goederen Document Autre Document Andere Observations (11) : (marchandise soumise à la quarantaine / à des contrôles sanitaires, phytosanitaires ou à d’autres restrictions) that the customer was promised 10. Opmerkingen (11) : (goederen onderworpen aan quarantaine / sanitaire controles, phytosanitaire of andere beperkingen) Erp code 2500000010705 Licence (12) Certificat (13) Factures (14) Je certifie que les renseignements donnés dans la présente déclaration en douane sont exacts Licentie (12) Certificaat (13) Factuur (14) et que cet envoi ne contient aucun objet dangereux interdit par la réglementation postale. Hiermede bevestig ik dat alle gegevens van deze douaneverklaring juist zijn en dat deze zending The Office of the Ombudsman takes these practices No de la/des licence(s) No du/des certificat(s) No de la facture Nr. van de licentie(s) Nr. van het(de) certificaat(en) Nr. van de factuur geen enkel gevaarlijk voorwerp bevat welke verboden is door de postreglementering. Date et signature de l’expéditeur : CN 23 (FN) 5/3/11 2:18 PM Page 1 Datum en handtekening van de afzender : extremely seriously, because on its website, bpost sells CN23 DECLARATION EN DOUANE DOUANEVERKLARING No de l’envoi / colis (code à barres, s’il existe) Peut être ouvert d’office this form of postal item as an option to 'send items extra DE VAN Nom Naam Eventuellement référence Nr. van de zending (barcode als hij bestaat) Mag ambtshalve worden geopend quickly to an address abroad' 11. The customer pays a higher It is the sender's responsibility to complete the tariff because he believes that the parcel will arrive at its Société de l’expéditeur Firma Eventueel Rue referentie Straat van de afzender documentation correctly. If the Belgian customs do not destination more quickly. The general conditions totally Code postal Ville Postcode Stad Pays Land have the necessary information, they will contact the negate this essential difference between an express item A Nom AAN Naam Société Référence de l’importateur (si elle existe) no de TVA, facultatif Firma Referentie van de invoerder (indien dit bestaat) BTW Nr., facultatief intended addressee for further details. If this is not and a regular postal item, the distinguishing feature of Rue Straat Code postal Ville No de téléphone/fax/e-mail de l’importateur (si connu) Postcode Stad Nr. telefoon/fax/e-mail van de invoerder (indien gekend) possible, or if this information is not provided in time, the express product. Pays Land Description détaillée du contenu (1) Beschrijving van de inhoud (1) Quantité (2) Poids net (en kg) (3) Aantal (2) Valeur (5) Netto gewicht (in kg) (3) Waarde (5) Pour les envois commerciaux seulement Enkel voor de commerciële zendingen 10. Source: http://www.bpost.be/sites/default/files/pagina/Algemene_ the postal item will be returned to the sender. Insufficient Voorwaarden_Pakketten.pdf No tarifaire du SH (7) Pays d’origine des marchandises (8) Tariefnr. volgens SH (7) Land van oorsprong van de goederen (8) 11. Source: http://www.bpost.be/site/nl/verzenden/pakjes-verzenden/ information can also result in (high) import taxes being Catégorie de l’envoi (10) Echantillon commercial Poids brut total (4) Valeur totale (6) Totaal bruto gewicht (4) Totale waarde (6) Explication Frais de port / frais (9) Portokosten / kosten (9) Bureau d’origine / date de dépôt The second reason for the Office of the Ombudsman internationaal/bpack-world-express levied on the postal item. In TIPS, included with this annual making this a question of principle is that professional Soort zending (10) Handelsmonster Uitleg Kantoor van oorsprong / datum van afgifte Cadeau Geschenk Retour de marchandise Terugzending van goederen 12. Art. VI. 97 to VI (inclusive). Art. 100 of the Act of 21 December 2013 proposing Document Autre insertion of book VI 'Market practices and consumer protection' into the report, the customer will find further information about customers, such as webshops, also use this express Document Andere Observations (11) : (marchandise soumise à la quarantaine / à des contrôles sanitaires, phytosanitaires ou à d’autres restrictions) Opmerkingen (11) : (goederen onderworpen aan quarantaine / sanitaire controles, phytosanitaire of andere beperkingen) Code of Economic Law and proposing insertion of the definitions found in how to correctly complete the customs documentation. service. Consumer legislation protects private consumers Erp code 2500000010705 book VI, and of the law enforcement provisions found in book VI, into books from misleading information 12 and from the overt evading Licence (12) Certificat (13) Factures (14) Je certifie que les renseignements donnés dans la présente déclaration en douane sont exacts Licentie (12) Certificaat (13) Factuur (14) et que cet envoi ne contient aucun objet dangereux interdit par la réglementation postale. I and XV of the Code of Economic Law ANNUAL REPORT | 2016 No de la/des licence(s) No du/des certificat(s) No de la facture Hiermede bevestig ik dat alle gegevens van deze douaneverklaring juist zijn en dat deze zending Nr. van de licentie(s) Nr. van het(de) certificaat(en) Nr. van de factuur geen enkel gevaarlijk voorwerp bevat welke verboden is door de postreglementering. 13. Art. VI. 82 and Art. VI. 83 of the Act of 21 December 2013 proposing insertion As mentioned above, it is the sender's responsibility to of liability in the event of errors 13. Businesses, however, Date et signature de l’expéditeur : Datum en handtekening van de afzender : of book VI 'Market practices and consumer protection' into the Code of complete the customs documentation correctly. However, are not covered by consumer legislation and are therefore Economic Law and proposing insertion of the definitions found in book VI, we have observed from contact with consumers that referred to the Office of the Ombudsman for mediation in and of the law enforcement provisions found in book VI, into books I and XV of the Code of Economic Law most private individuals are not aware of the customs order to obtain a settlement. 14. Source: http://www.bpost.be/sites/default/files/product/ListePays_NL- formalities and customs costs associated with postal bpackWorldExpress.pdf 36 37
You can also read