The Musician Journal of the Musicians' Union Winter 2020 theMU.org - Musicians' Union
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
contacts Union HQ Regional Ofces General Secretary Head of Communications London Horace Trubridge & Government Relations Regional Organiser: Jamie Pullman Isabelle Gutierrez 33 Palfrey Place, London SW8 1PE Deputy General Secretary t 020 7840 5504 Naomi Pohl Equality, Diversity & Inclusion Ofcial e london@theMU.org John Shortell Assistant General Secretary East & South East England Phil Kear In-House Solicitor Regional Organiser: Paul Burrows Dawn Rodger 1a Fentiman Road, National Organiser London SW8 1LD Jo Laverty (Orchestras) Orchestras Ofcial t 020 7840 5537 Morris Stemp e eastsoutheast@theMU.org National Organiser Chris Walters PR & Marketing Ofcial Midlands (Education, Health & Wellbeing) Keith Ames Regional Organiser: Stephen Brown 2 Sovereign Court, National Organiser Campaigns & Social Media Ofcial Graham Street, Geof Ellerby (Recording & Broadcasting) Maddy Radclif Birmingham B1 3JR t 0121 236 4028 National Organiser Digital Development Ofcial e midlands@theMU.org Dave Webster (Live Performance) Katerina Baranova Wales & South West England Head of Finance Regional Organiser: Andy Warnock Beverley Dawes Transport House, 1 Cathedral Rd, Cardif CF11 9SD Live & Music Writers’ Ofcial t 029 2045 6585 Kelly Wood e cardif@theMU.org Sessions Ofcial North of England Sam Jordan Regional Organiser: Matt Wanstall 61 Bloom Street, Recording & Broadcasting Ofcial Manchester M1 3LY Union HQ Michael Sweeney t 0161 236 1764 60–62 Clapham Road e manchester@theMU.org London sw9 0jj Licensing & Distribution Ofcial Annie Turner Scotland & Northern Ireland t 020 7582 5566 Acting Regional Organiser: Barry Dallman f 020 7582 9805 Education Ofcial 2 Woodside Place, e info@theMU.org David Barnard Glasgow G3 7QF t 0141 341 2960 w theMU.org e glasgow@theMU.org @WeAreTheMU
REPORT Fighting For Our Members How your Union is working hard to get a fair fnancial deal for all musicians in the current pandemic, and preparing for life in the post-lockdown world In order to maximise the extremely limited While making money to pay the bills remains work opportunities available to members we the absolute priority, we all know that’s not have had to enter into interim agreements with why we became musicians in the frst place. many of the employers and engagers that we We became musicians because we wanted have collective bargaining agreements with, to perform and entertain audiences, and so and that has been a tortuous and demoralising many of you have been telling me that it’s what process. Like so many of you, we are anxious you miss most of all. We will continue to push not to allow an erosion of the hard-fought- the Chancellor to introduce a two-for-one for terms and conditions in our CBAs on a ticket scheme to enable socially distanced live permanent basis, and in trying to achieve performances to take place when we come that balance we have had to walk a paper out of the current lockdown. Much like the thin tightrope. scheme that Rishi Sunak introduced to help the restaurant trade in the Summer, a ‘Seat Hearing the harrowing stories of the sufering Out To Help Out’ scheme for the live music Photo: Joanna Dudderidge that some of our members are enduring industry would enable socially distanced brings the impact of the pandemic and this government’s lack of support for some sectors of the work force home to “We are doing 3 us in a truly personal way. We are doing everything we can to provide advice and everything we can to Horace Trubridge, General Secretary support to members who are not just trying to cope with the overwhelming provide advice and fnancial loss, but also the inevitable detrimental efect on their health and support to members” There is no point in trying to sugar coat wellbeing too, and we will continue to it, 2020 has been a bloody awful year for explore ways in which we can help you, the gigs, musical theatre and other performances our profession. COVID-19 has been every members, get through these dark days and to take place and not lose money, thereby musician’s annus horribilis, and the early remain in the profession. providing much needed work for musicians. part of 2021 is not looking much better. As I and my colleagues are saying to politicians Your ofcials, staf and the MU Executive Remarkable Ingenuity and civil servants every day, musicians just Committee have had to deal almost All this makes the stories of the creativity want to be able to work again, but they need exclusively with trying to minimise the of musicians striving to continue to work all investment to survive. damage that the pandemic has wrought the more remarkable. Whether it’s pop-up on members’ working lives, while also gigs, drive-ins, online teaching or pay-per- Working Together battering on the doors of Number 10 and view streamed performances, musicians Finally, I cling to the hope that this time next the Chancellor’s ofce to try to get this show time and time again that the skills they year, we will all be able to look back on what government to understand how our industry have learnt as musicians enable them to the profession has been through and give works and provide realistic universal be creative in business as well. Monetising thanks for our collective strength, unity, fnancial support for the workforce – not online performances is tricky. Nevertheless, resilience and ingenuity. Musicians are still just the institutions and buildings supported as we begin to scale the foothills of this new joining the MU in impressive numbers as they through the Cultural Recovery Fund. way of working I see initiatives springing recognise the importance of standing together up everywhere that should give us all hope. and fghting for our world beating industry. You can play your part in supporting the MU’s campaigns by writing to your MP and making our collective voice heard. More than anything, hang on in there and stay safe. TO HEAR MORE FROM HORACE, Very best wishes VISIT THEMU.ORG Horace Trubridge The Musician • Winter 2020
Contents Winter 2020 4 30 “To be in those studios with some of the best session musicians in the world, I find that to be an honour” Fiona Brice The Musician • Winter 2020
22 Frontline Feature 6 Members invited to join the 12 How the MU has supported Examining the call for new fast access fund members in the Covid crisis experience of 7 MU seeks guidance Black musicians on Brexit for musicians Advice since the rise 40 The pros and cons of signing of the BLM Reports a music publishing deal movement Photo: Ntando Brown 3 MU General Secretary 44 Sources of financial support 10 Deputy General Secretary 20 The Let Music Live protests Your Voice in London and Birmingham 9 Interacting with MU members 22 Assessing the achievements and supporters on Twitter Union Notices of Black History Month 2 Key contacts for 26 Tips on maintaining wellbeing Profile the Musicians’ Union during the winter months 30 Fiona Brice: composer, 50 MU Executive Committee 34 Acclaimed jazz musician arranger and violinist election results Arun Ghosh on clarinet care 51 Member benefits 36 How to promote your music Reviews using the latest online tools 46 New albums, EPs and 48 MU Delegate Conference downloads from members 5 MU Contributors Andrew Katie Rahel Gary Stewart Nicholls Aklilu Walker Andrew writes Katie is a Rahel is a Gary has been for The Times, The freelance journalist writer based in London a journalist for 20 Guardian, Classical and editor whose with a background years, most recently Music and BBC Music features and reviews in law, writing mostly editing Long Live Magazine, among have appeared in around music and Vinyl magazine. He’s others. He is also titles such as Mojo, culture for publications hopelessly addicted Director of Southwark The Guardian including gal-dem and to reverb pedals and Voices. p26 and Kerrang! p30 The Independent . p22 Gretsch guitars. p36 Roy Neil Neil Henry Delaney Churchman Crossley Yates Roy has Neil is an A journalist and Henry is a written for Metal experienced journalist editor who has written freelance writer from Hammer, Melody Maker in broadcasting and for The Independent, Gloucestershire who and TV’s Tipping Point, print. A former BBC The Daily Telegraph, has written for titles Photo: Joseph Branston. © Musicians’ Union and is the lead singer national newsroom The Guardian and as diverse as Classic and drummer with the assistant editor, he The Financial Times. Rock, Total Guitar, two-piece punk rock now writes on music Neil also fronts the NME and Record band Hacksaw. p46 and the media. p34 band Furlined. p20 Collector. p40 & 44 Cover: © sumnersgraphicsinc; JLVarga; Ko Hong-Wei / EyeEm / Getty Images The Musician • Winter 2020
BREXIT AND YOU The MU is fghting to protect musicians’ right to travel when ! working in the EU post-Brexit. We want to hear from you about how Brexit has afected your working plans for 2020. #WorkingInTheEU bit.ly/2AzdUAV frontline Winter 2020 The MU in action, working on behalf of professional musicians INVEST MU Calls On The Treasury To Invest In Musicians And IN Plug The Gaps MU members are invited to join the call for additional support for musicians through MUSICIANS 6 the Covid-19 pandemic. Under the title ‘Invest In Musicians’, the new campaign aims to activate members and supporters to build a sense of engagement and reframe the debate about the future of the UK music industry. MU research shows that 38% of musicians fall through gaps in government support. This is a highly skilled workforce and musicians’ jobs are viable – some are just temporarily on hold. While the fnancial commitment by the government to the infrastructure of our industry must be acknowledged, many musicians are not in a position to ride out opinion of the decision makers. The assets allow individuals to celebrate their talent and “This campaign is the the Covid-19 outbreak. By focusing on skills retention and genuine investment in people, experience while underlining their career fragility during lockdown and illustrating their next stage in ensuring and not just places, the government has the opportunity to deliver a thriving cultural value to our cultural landscape. our members’ needs environment in the future. Horace Trubridge, MU General Secretary says: “The Union has been lobbying are set squarely in front The MU is therefore calling for musicians to have more access to funding to ensure that government and highlighting the fnancial challenges facing our members since day of those in power” when the music industry opens back up, they one of lockdown. This campaign is the next Horace Trubridge are in a position to get back to work. ‘Invest stage in ensuring our members’ needs are In Musicians’ aims to elevate the status set squarely in front of those in power.” of musicians as a dynamic, enterprising workforce in the eyes of decision makers. Members will fnd a poster enclosed with their copy of The Musician for use at home, The Union is delivering a campaign toolkit at work, or at events in line with lockdown for members and supporters to tell their guidance. Materials to get involved online can stories, show their solidarity, and sway the be found at theMU.org/InvestInMusicians The Musician • Winter 2020
FRONTLINE Term Of Office For The government has offered few assurances to touring General Secretary musicians post-Brexit As reported in the summer 2020 issue of The Musician, an extension was granted by the Union’s Executive Committee to the term of ofce of current General Secretary, Horace Trubridge. This extension was approved to run through to his planned Photo: Image Source / Alamy Stock Photo retirement in January 2025. However, at the Executive meeting on 11 November, Horace requested that the letter extending his term be rescinded and that an election for the position of General Secretary be called in the autumn of 2021. “When I became MU General Secretary, I vowed that I would grow the Union’s membership to the point where the Union MU Seeks Government Guidance On Brexit could be self-sufcient and not have to rely on the diminishing licensing income,” he said. “The Union was on course at the beginning of this year to achieving that in time for With the Brexit negotiations running out procedures important to professionals in 7 my retirement. The pandemic has set this of time and the transition period, during the live music industry, including freelance ‘project’ back signifcantly and I have been which rules remain the same, set to end musicians and touring professionals. My concerned for some time now that we will in December, the MU has been pressing department will continue to engage with the not have enough time to reach the target the government to issue comprehensive creative industries to understand further the by January 2025. I asked the EC to rescind guidance for musicians wishing to tour specifc issues they may face.” the letter extending my current term, so in the EU from January 2021. We have that I can stand again for a full term at the asked numerous questions of ministers in The MU has pushed the government to ofer beginning of 2022 and they have agreed.” parliament via MPs such as Alison McGovern more than this, as the current advice is and Stephen Doughty. The response, woefully inadequate. It does, however, ofer Details of the election process will be regardless of the specifc question, has some signposting that members may fnd published in The Musician and on the always been along the same lines: useful so please see here for the referenced MU website in due course. guidance – gov.uk/transition “On 1 September 2020, the government New MU Website launched a comprehensive communications More useful is this online guide, which campaign to help the UK prepare for the end clarifes some of the requirements in diferent of the transition period,” said minister for EU countries. vivalavisa.co.uk/articles/ The MU’s new website is set for launch in digital and culture, Caroline Dinenage. “This brexit-and-beyond-what-lies-ahead-for- December and members are encouraged to includes guidance on customs and mobility touring-in-the-uk-and-eu visit the facility regularly to beneft from its comprehensive features, news and advice. Members are also reminded of the valuable Industry Stats Musicians’ Union Tax Savings Guide, which can now be found solely on our site. In addition, the latest terms and conditions of 86,148 £5.8bn 197,168 the MU insurance schemes, as administered People who have signed The amount contributed Full-time UK music industry by our preferred broker Hencilla Canworth, the Musicians’ Passport to the economy by the UK jobs in 2019, all now at are located online on the MU website. Please petition to date – and it’s music industry in 2019, risk from the government note that it is essential you are up to date rising fast. up 11% from 2018. lockdown restrictions. with your MU subscriptions to enjoy these (or any other) beneft of Union membership. For the latest news on how the Musicians’ Union is helping you visit theMU.org The Musician • Winter 2020
! ASK US FIRST Check through our list of promoters before agreeing to accept an engagement at tinyurl.com/askusfrst ABRSM Agreement Naomi’s work on MU To Relocate The London HQ the Safe Space service was The MU met with the Associated Board highlighted Photo: Jonathan Stewart. © Musicians’ Union of the Royal Schools of Music (ABRSM) to discuss our diversity concerns, and they The MU plans to move from its existing have agreed with some of our demands, London headquarters in the Oval in 2021. The including: Introducing a minimum of 20 move is made with a view to relocating to a new compositions or arrangements more fexible and appropriate ofce space from composers from underrepresented in the London area. The ofces at 60–62 backgrounds every year; Making sure that Clapham Road will therefore shortly be 20% of all syllabus content comes from available to rent. composers who are Black, Brown, and Indigenous People of Colour (BBIPOC); Horace Trubridge, MU General Secretary, Transforming the organisation itself through says: “The Union has undergone signifcant Naomi Pohl Selected a Diversity and Inclusion Group to lead modernisation and it is vital that we change across everything from staf training refect contemporary working methods For Industry Honour to governance and examination panels. and introduce administrative cost savings wherever possible. Value for members For more info visit: tinyurl.com/tabrsm remains at the heart of our work, a philosophy MU Deputy General Secretary, Naomi Pohl, that has never been more relevant than in the has been selected for Music Week’s Women light of the current economic circumstances.” Musicians’ Hearing in Music Roll of Honour, which celebrates the achievements of female executives. There Music For All Online are 24 names on this year’s list, drawn from 8 The Musicians’ Hearing Health Scheme, all sectors of the music industry. which ofers hearing check-ups, expert advice and custom earplugs at a discounted Naomi was nominated for all her work at The charity Music for All – which ofers rate to MU members, has reopened the Musicians’ Union – including the Fix fnancial support and donated instruments to selected clinics across the UK. This service Streaming campaign – but the main work music makers with limited access to musical is now booking hearing appointments for covered in her nomination is the Safe Space instruments and lessons – has recently scheme-registered musicians at selected scheme, which was created to provide a safe launched a new website. Music for All clinics across the UK, subject to change in space for all musicians to share instances promotes and highlights the well-established accordance with latest government advice. of sexism, sexual harassment and sexual physical, educational and health benefts of abuse in the industry. “My biggest sense making music – a particularly relevant beneft For more information on what the scheme of achievement has to be from leading the during the current pandemic. Please visit the can ofer, visit: hearformusicians.org.uk MU’s Safe Space service,” said Naomi. charity’s new website at: musicforall.org.uk Dates For The Diary 21-22 Jan 25-28 Jan 25-28 Jan 3-5 Feb Spring 21 What: International What: NY:LON Connect 2021 What: AmericanaFest UK What: London Music What: MU Music Teachers’ Conference on (global online music summit (showcase, events, Conference 2021 (panels, Conference (Members are Music Education and in London and New York panels and the annual talks, workshops, club welcome to email the MU Teaching Methods with debate and networking) UK Americana Awards) nights, and showcases with any suggestions) Where: Online Where: Online Where: Online Where: Various venues Where: Online Info: tinyurl.com/ICMETM Info: nylonconnect.com Info: theamauk.org Info: tinyurl.com/lonmconf Info: teachers@theMU.org The Musician • Winter 2020
FRONTLINE Your Voice THE TEAM Editor Keith Ames (MU) Consultant editor Neil Crossley This selection of tweets, emails and letters refects the Art editor Chris Stenner Writers Rahel Aklilu, diverse range of dialogue between the MU and its members. Keith Ames, Neil Churchman, Neil Crossley, Roy Delaney, Katie Nicholls, Andrew Stewart, Gary Walker, Henry Yates Excluded In The UK Production editor Roy Delaney Contact your MP to So we head to a second Director of content marketing increase awareness of the Clare Jonik lockdown. I can’t wait to issues with the industry Head of Fusion procurement and hear about all the money I production Matt Eglinton STILL won’t receive from the Senior account executive Nina Collins government even though I have Editorial director Mark Donald Art director Stuart Hobbs paid my taxes and NI etc since Photo: Guillem Lopez / Alamy Stock Photo Repro Gary Stuckey 2005. CAN’T WAIT. Printed at Precision Colour Printing Alice Fearn @alice_fearn See p2 for the contact details of Musicians’ Union ofces. Class Action Today I shall mostly be waiting for The MU to advise whether I have to lockdown and resume online lessons – after spending my half term ‘holiday’ All information contained in this journal is for informational purposes only and is, to the best rearranging my studio for face to of our knowledge, correct at the time of going to press. This journal is published by Future face lessons. Starting the term Publishing Limited on behalf of Musicians’ Union. 9 feeling this dejected is not good. Save Artists Mail Your MP Neither Future Publishing Limited nor Musicians’ Union accept any responsibility for errors or Liz Mitchell @saxylizbeth Proud to be at Parliament Musicians and their families inaccuracies that occur in such information. Readers are advised to contact manufacturers Square this morning for are sufering huge fnancial and retailers direct with regard to the price of Fix Streaming #WeMakeEvents campaign, hardship as a result of the products/services in the journal. Publication of an advertisement does not imply any form Campaigning works! The DCMS raising awareness of the poor provision of the of recommendation. Organisations ofering fnancial services or insurance are governed by is opening up an enquiry to look desperate situation of the UK government. Please email their relevant regulatory bodies and problems into streaming. Hats of to the arts, and protesting at our your MP and help raise the with such services should be taken up with those bodies. Neither Future Publishing Limited nor Ivors Academy and The MU’s government’s response. We profle of this campaign. Musicians’ Union accept any liability for the quality of goods and services ofered in advertisements. Fix Streaming campaign. are not a hobby. We contribute Karena @karenasoprano We do our best to avoid inaccuracies, but if you Hannah V @HannahV billions to the economy. believe that an error has been made, please contact the editor straight away before taking any Support the arts. Save artists. British Life other action and the Union will take appropriate Everyone matters Ashley Beauchamp So, anyone studying for steps. If you submit material to this journal, you automatically grant Future Publishing Limited For all those who’ve been told @ashbeauchamp UK Citizenship is taught and Musicians’ Union a licence to publish your submissions in whole or in part in any edition of your industry is unviable, your that ‘Since the 1960s British this journal that is published worldwide in any unique talent isn’t good enough Sad State pop music has made one of format or media throughout the world, and you grant Musicians’ Union a licence to publish your and you should retrain and get a It’s a sad state of afairs, isn’t the most important cultural submissions in whole or in part in any format or media for the purpose of promoting any products better job, this is for you. We see it, when your only regular contributions to life in the or services referred to in your submissions. Any material you submit is sent at your risk and you and your incredible value. gig these days is a protest in UK’ yet now seemingly neither Future Publishing Limited nor Musicians’ You are important to us all. Parliament Square. abandon it! Union nor their respective employees, agents or subcontractors shall be liable for any loss Dr Rosena Allin-Khan Sophie Gledhill Robin Rimbaud – Scanner or damage. © Future Publishing Limited and Musicians’ Union 2020. All rights reserved. No part @DrRosena @SophieGledhill @robinrimbaud of this journal may be used or reproduced without the written permission of Future Publishing Limited and Musicians’ Union. facebook.com/musicians.union soundcloud.com/musicians-union We are committed to only using magazine paper which is derived from responsibly managed, Follow us on Twitter @WeAreTheMU Find us at theMU.org certifed forestry and chlorine- free manufacture. The paper in this magazine was sourced Follow us on Instagram @WeAreTheMU Email us TheMusician@TheMU.org and produced from sustainable managed forests, conforming to strict environmental and socioeconomic standards. The manufacturing paper mill and printer hold full FSC and PEFC certifcation and accreditation. The Musician • Winter 2020
A Government Inquiry Into Streaming Economics The lockdown has only underlined how pitifully small the musician’s share of streaming revenue has always been. And at a time when every penny is precious, Naomi Pohl examines what the MU is doing to change all this In mid-October, the UK government’s Digital, To illustrate the issue, a survey of members Culture, Media and Sport Select Committee of the MU and The Ivors Academy on launched an inquiry into the economic impact streaming income in November 2020 (with of music streaming on artists, record labels 320 respondents) returned these results: and the sustainability of the wider music industry. While this may seem peculiar timing • More than 80% of respondents had earned given the government’s focus on getting the less than £200 from streaming in 2019 country through the Covid-19 pandemic, • 63% of respondents had earned less than there is a legitimate reason for it in the £50 from streaming in 2019 context of the UK music industry • 82% of respondents had earned less than 10 £50 from their most streamed track in 2019 Kevin Brennan MP, member of the CMS Select • Over 90% of respondents said less than 5% Committee says: “The pandemic and lack of of their earnings came from streaming any earnings from playing live has brought into sharper focus the dwindling pittance many Damning Statistics musicians make from recorded music, whilst By way of comparison, labels are reporting record profts are simultaneously being record profts. The IFPI’s Global Music Report generated by the huge corporations that 2019 showed that the recorded music market dominate the industry. As an MU member it grew by 9.7% worldwide in 2018, the fourth seemed to me that our Select Committee consecutive year of growth. Streaming should take this crisis and turn it into an revenue grew by 34% and accounted for opportunity to shine a light on the economics almost half (47%) of global revenue, driven by of streaming and why it is that the creators of a 32.9% increase in paid subscription recorded music are not better rewarded.” streaming. Growth in streaming more than ofset a 10.1% decline in physical revenue and a In our joint campaign with The Ivors Academy 21.2% decline in download revenue. So, why to #FixStreaming and #KeepMusicAlive, isn’t this streaming bonanza refected in the we have argued for a government review earnings of musicians? because the closure of the live industry has highlighted the woefully low royalties We see the key issues as follows: generated for musicians by music streaming. • Streaming royalties for performers aren’t Simultaneously, the #BrokenRecord campaign subject to collective management: this has involved artists in calling for reform of means no guaranteed income stream, unlike streaming economics via Twitter. Clearly our public performance and broadcast combined eforts have not gone unnoticed. • Bad deals: many artists are trapped in record deals which ofer a low royalty rate on streaming and/or where their advances “Growth in streaming more than offset a decline remain unrecouped, potentially for decades • Bad data: if songs and tracks aren’t in physical revenue. So, why isn’t this streaming registered with full lists of writers and performers then royalties won’t be paid bonanza reflected in the earnings of musicians?” out accurately The Musician • Winter 2020
PROFILE REPORT KT Tunstall is one of many artists who have criticised the current model of music streaming Photo: MusicLive / Alamy Stock Photo 11 • A few major players dominating the 1. Equitable, appropriate and proportionate diligence refers to the requirement for an marketplace and holding all the cards in remuneration for performers on streaming. organisation collecting royalties to do all they negotiation: the major labels control the We would like to see unwaivable streaming can to locate and pay individuals to whom major publishers and may own shares in royalties for performers paid via a collecting those royalties are due. While collective the main streaming platforms. They also society such as PPL. This would beneft management organisations such as PPL and have a signifcant control over playlists and featured artists who have not yet recouped PRS for Music are held to high standards of algorithms due to their market dominance. their label advances and also non-featured due diligence, labels and publishers are not. Oh, and the licensing deals are covered by (session and orchestral) musicians who We would also like to see data standards NDAs so we can’t see who pays what to who currently receive no streaming royalties. across the music industry signifcantly and why. There’s defnitely some conficts of improved upon to ensure that royalties are interest at play, and a government inquiry 2. The European Copyright Directive. paid out accurately. may be the only way to shed some light. Due to Brexit, we will not get the principles of the Directive transposed automatically The issues we have outlined here are likely Revenue Division into UK law. We lobbied hard for the to appear in the submissions of many creator At present streaming revenue is divided Copyright Directive when it was being and performer representative groups and, roughly as follows: 30% to the streaming discussed at EU level, and in particular for we hope, in the evidence submitted by platform; 55% to the label (which should pay a the articles covering fair remuneration of individual musicians. While priorities may royalty to artists, however this may be as low creators and performers, transparency, vary depending on a creator or performer’s as 10% if the artist has not ‘recouped’ their contract adjustment and rights revocation. main area of work, the general themes of advance); 15% to the music publisher and Introducing these principles into UK law unfair contracts, low royalties, bad data and songwriter (The songwriter will usually receive would help improve treatment of creators a lack of transparency will no doubt be 80% and the publisher will retain 20%). and performers by the record industry highlighted across the board. There are in particular. oral evidence sessions taking place before The Union’s written submission to the inquiry and after Christmas and we look forward to was submitted in mid-November and focused 3. Accurate payment of royalties. We would seeing the Select Committee’s full on the following key solutions: like to see music publishers and record recommendations in the New Year. labels held to the same standards of due diligence as collecting societies. Due The Musician • Winter 2020
We’re Together in this How the MU has supported its members through the biggest threat to musicians’ livelihoods for almost a century No UK musician contemplating the devastating mid-to late-1920s when the orchestras were all potential of Brexit back in January 2020 could sacked from the cinemas because of the talkies. have ever predicted that things were about to Even then live work existed and the studios were get a whole lot worse. The frst signs came in still open. The problem we have now is there’s early February with a trickle of cancellations by absolutely no live work and the studios are 12 major artists in Asia, Europe and the US. But by closed as well.” early March, musicians across genres and disciplines were pulling whole tours as the true MU Hardship Fund impact of the new Covid-19 virus dawned. Most musicians were facing a precarious fnancial future. The MU moved swiftly to assess the scale No-one was exempt from the fallout. From pub of the problem and to ofer help and support to its bands and function outfts through to A-list stars, 32,000 members, the bulk of whom are self- gigs and tours were cancelled, album releases employed freelance players. In March, the MU set shelved, PR campaigns wound down, studio up a £1m Coronavirus Hardship Fund, ofering sessions axed and teaching sessions cancelled. grants of up to £200 per member for members Almost overnight, tens of thousands of musicians who were experiencing extreme fnancial found themselves in limbo and facing extreme hardship due to loss of work. In April alone, the fnancial hardship. MU paid out over £700,000 to its members. Assessing The Impact “We hope this fund goes some way to providing “A disaster of gargantuan proportions” is how MU a small amount of relief to our members” said General Secretary Horace Trubridge summed up Horace, “but we urgently need the government to the impact. “The scale is astronomical,” he said. provide clarity on what wider support will be “This is without doubt the darkest hour for the available, and we call on the record industry to music profession. The last time we had play its part, too.” something as catastrophic as this was in the For those members experiencing a sudden loss of income, the grants proved a lifeline. “This is without doubt “Utterly grateful to be receiving a hardship the darkest hour for the grant from The MU,” tweeted member Amelia Rose. “This now means I can pay rent this month music profession” Photo: David Jackson and the relief is unmeasurable. To everyone who’s ofered both moral and fnancial support through Horace Trubridge all of this, I cannot thank you enough.” The Musician • Winter 2020
FEATURE The socially distanced LSO performing at St Luke’s in July 2020 13 The Musician • Winter 2020
Siân Monaghan rapidly moved her teaching business online, Photo: Thomas Dibbs Lucy May Walker was equally appreciative. setting up a new “Massive thank you to the MU for providing me business in lockdown with £200 through the Coronavirus Hardship Fund,” she tweeted. “It’s not a lot, but it’s the most I’ve been granted as a self-employed musician with no work. So grateful!” Other Sources Of Funding Top-up payments of £100 were subsequently made in June to almost 3,800 MU members who had previously received £200 from the MU Coronavirus Hardship Fund. Particular thanks were given to PPL for their contributions to the Fund totalling £200,000. The MU has also directed members towards the hardship funds set up by Help Musicians, MU Summer Bristol artist Lade Nade, PRS for Music, the Association of Independent who took part in the Music (AIM) and the Young Classical Artists second of the MU’s Trust (YCAT). Many of these organisations also provided a valuable fnancial lifeline for Summer of Live events Of Live Events members in dire fnancial need due to the In a drive to raise more money for complete loss of work. the MU Coronavirus Hardship As the second lockdown loomed in October Fund, the MU launched two events “Am so thankful right now for The MU and Help 2020, the MU ofered an additional three- under the title Summer Of Live. Musicians UK for supporting me during this month subscription holiday and have now The frst online fundraising event difcult time after my tours were cancelled,” extended the period that members can apply was hosted from Manchester by 14 tweeted Hannah White. “These hardship for this until the end of March 2021. radio presenter, producer and DJ funds are a lifeline to me and my family.” Shell Zenner, and featured MU Emails And Website – A Sense Of Support interviews and live performances MU Live and Music Writers Ofcial Kelly Wood The MU’s support for members has from four distinctly diferent established a fundraising eBid auction in April, extended to far more than just fnancial help. artists: rapper and poet, KinKai; to which author Sir Philip Pullman, rock band Throughout the pandemic, the MU sent out r‘n’b singer-songwriter and Garbage, and broadcaster and pianist Jay comprehensive emails to inform, advise, producer, Prima; singer, songwriter Rayner donated handmade craft, music prints empower and support members throughout Jack Curley; as well as singer- and books. The Union’s ofcial online the crisis. Under the banner ‘We’re All In This songwriter and Guildhall graduate, Crowdfunder also raised over £80,000, money Together’, the emails provided the latest news Eliza Shaddad. which has made a valuable contribution to and advice for musicians during the crisis. the MU Coronavirus Hardship Fund. MU General Secretary Horace Each email carried links to the online MU Trubridge said Summer Of Live MU Ofers Subscriptions Holiday Coronavirus Advice Hub where musicians was “a fantastic initiative”, and In a further attempt to ease the fnancial could monitor MU updates, keep in touch one that features hugely talented burden on members, the MU announced with relevant government announcements, performers. “At a time when we on 24 May that it would be ofering a fxed and comply with all guidance provided. The are desperately missing live music, three-month holiday on membership Hub consisted of a wealth of information it is great to see and hear subscription fees to members paying the full and guidance including dedicated areas performers of this calibre doing or partnership subs rate. Any member could focusing on: Financial support for musicians; what they do best, and all for beneft from the scheme and there was no Attending recording sessions; Government a very good cause,” he said. obligation to repay the balance at a later date, measures for the music industry; Self- with all the usual MU benefts and services Employment Income Support Scheme (SEISS) The second event, showcasing remaining available to members. In the frst grants; Domestic abuse support; Taking top-class British folk, spanned two days of the Subscriptions Holiday action to protect musicians; Music teaching, Shefeld, Devon, New Orleans and scheme, the MU received 674 applications and theatre work and orchestral work during the Montreal, and included artists processed 215 of these on the frst day, saving outbreak; Contracts and earnings; Insurance; such as Lady Nade, Chloe Foy, the members involved £9,500 in total. and staying connected and up to date. John Smith and Greg Russell, who Response from members suggests these also hosted the event. communications have been a valuable source The Musician • Winter 2020
FEATURE “The MU are doing such an amazing job of taking care of its members” Kerri Watt eligibility for government support. Indeed, 38% of respondents reported that they do not qualify for the government’s furlough or SEISS schemes for employed or self-employed workers respectively, and even those who did qualify said they would struggle to survive fnancially in the interim period before payments were made. Photo: Joseph Branston. © Musicians’ Union Gaps In Government Support The MU’s research identifed key gaps in the government’s support for self-employed workers facing fnancial hardship as a result of the impact of Covid-19: Those who are part self-employed (i.e. less than 50% of their total annual income); Those who are self-employed for less than a year; Those who run as a limited company; Those with annual profts of over £50,000. “We risk facing a devastating 15 impact on the music industry,” said Horace. of support throughout the crisis. “I feel the frst survey found that UK musicians had “We are calling on our government to take supported and not alone,” tweeted MU already lost an estimated £13.9m in earnings. action by reassessing its SEISS package and member Roxana Vilk. “If you are a musician The survey also reported that 90% of the 4,100 considering how else it can help a sector #joinaunion. Also loving the daily emails survey respondents said their income had that is so vital to our national community.” keeping us informed.” The regular been afected by the pandemic. communications from the MU were also MU Highlights Hardship highlighted by Kerri Watt. “Gotta say The The MU went on to commission two more The third impact survey, published in MU are doing such an amazing job of taking surveys, in April and September. The evidence September, made for equally stark reading, care of its members – daily updates/advice/ gathered by all three surveys has proved and its fndings received widespread help/funding,” she tweeted. “Thank you. It invaluable for the MU in its ongoing work in coverage in the mainstream media. It showed is so appreciated.” lobbying government and demonstrating the that 87% of musicians across all disciplines need for more focused fnancial support. were experiencing severe fnancial hardship One of the most notable features of the as most had little or no work since February pandemic has been the strong sense of The three impact surveys received 2020. The survey also concluded that a third mutual support among musicians, a point widespread national and regional media of British musicians were considering highlighted by double bassist Kate Addis. coverage, in broadsheets such as The Daily leaving the profession due to the impact “Thank you for helping us, MU,” she tweeted. Telegraph and The Guardian, trade of the pandemic. “It’s good to see how much musicians have publications such as Music Week, Record Of supported each other over the last weeks. The Day and Billboard, as well as in broadcast “We know from the Union’s recent research Makes me part of a much bigger family.” media such as the BBC and Sky News. just how many musicians are struggling fnancially and at real risk of leaving music MU Impact Surveys Despite chancellor Rishi Sunak’s claim that for good,” said Horace. “We appreciate Before the venues had even shut their doors the Self-Employment Income Support Scheme all the government has done to support our in the last week of March, the MU had already (SEISS) would cover 95% of the self-employed, members through the furlough and self- undertaken an impact survey to assess the this was not refected by the evidence extent of the hardship. Published on 23 March, gathered in the MU’s initial surveys. In fact, it was soon clear that many freelance musicians were falling through the cracks in terms of The Musician • Winter 2020
Case Study: Theatre In spring 2020, UK Theatre and the Society of London Theatre (SOLT) took the decision to close venues across the UK. The MU responded by issuing advice to its members on notice pay and, in the West End, the possibility of redundancy payments for musicians on long-running productions. Photo: Joby Sessions. © Musicians’ Union Naomi Pohl, Deputy General Secretary of the MU, said: “We have over three hundred musicians working in London’s West End who are facing the prospect of weeks or months Theatre musicians such as without paid work as a result of Matthew West have had this decision. Hundreds more are no work since March engaged on touring productions.” In May, the results of our survey of theatre musicians anticipated the employment income support schemes so far, to 80% for November. As SEISS is calculated 16 increasing fnancial hardship that but they must not abandon musicians now.” over three months, the total grant will increase their industry would face. With from 40% to 55% of trading profts for 53% of theatre musicians ineligible Musicians Left Out November to January and the maximum grant for the Self-Employed Income While a £1.57bn Culture Recovery Package will increase to £5,160. This clearly does not Support Scheme and 83% of announced by the government in July was achieve parity with employed people on musicians unaware of a restart welcomed by the sector – and the frst furlough. As The Musician went to press, date for the production on which tranche of £257m in state funding was shared the MU continued to lobby the government they are working, the future began out among 1,300 venues and arts and the Treasury consistently and hard on to look increasingly bleak. In fact, organisations across the UK in October – that point, and continued to argue that the over three in four theatre much of this funding is earmarked for venues many musicians who have been ineligible for musicians (77%) reported that they and arts organisations and is not expected to this scheme must now be included. were likely to be in fnancial directly reach freelance musicians. hardship before September. The MU’s Lobbying Work Horace said the funding has done “nothing for Lobbying lies at the core of the MU’s work on Matthew West, West End the workforce”. You need creators to create behalf of its members. In the eight months percussionist and Chair of the MU great art, he said, “but you need extremely since the outbreak of the pandemic, the MU Theatre Section, said: “I’ve been a skilled and talented musicians to deliver that has worked relentlessly behind the scenes to musician all my life and have creativity, and those are the people who have meet with government and the shadow worked in a thriving British theatre been left out of the equation. Those world- cabinet to put the case for more focused and industry for many years. On leading musicians who have spent all their inclusive fnancial support. Online meetings Monday 16 March all that stopped. lives perfecting what they do, there is no were promptly arranged with the newly I cannot work. There is no work. lifeline for them whatsoever. There is a lack of elected leader of the Labour Party, Kier Not for any theatre musician understanding of our profession, even within Starmer, and shadow Ministers, Jo Stevens anywhere. We don’t know when the Department for Digital, Culture, Media and and Tracey Brabin. we can work again or what will Sport (DCMS), and no understanding within greet us when we do. After the Treasury.” UK organisations in the creative sector devoting your entire life to this learned years ago that the best way of arguing craft, the mental repercussions As the UK entered the second lockdown in are incredibly challenging.” November, the government extended the furlough scheme from 40% of trading profts The Musician • Winter 2020
FEATURE “We know just how Music, the sector was able to persuade ministers that recorded music could continue engagement of our members through risk assessment advice, health & safety guidance, many musicians are to be played in pubs and bars, ensuring variation agreements and temporary income for musicians through PRS and PPL. streaming rates. All with the aim of allowing struggling financially” employers and engagers to operate and By May, it was blatantly clear that the continue to engage members in work. Horace Trubridge government response to the Covid-19 pandemic – in terms of its efect on musicians However, the challenges remain immense. – remained woefully inadequate, despite the Unless mitigating measures such as screens the case for the arts is to show evidence of headline announcements and fgures. This, and masks can be implemented then most of its fnancial worth to the Treasury. The music coupled with the delay to the expected return the options for live performance are industry contributes £5.2bn to the economy of indoor live music and the postponement of economically unviable. Horace reports that and this is powerful leverage when the pilot schemes that the MU was due to be we are currently at Stage Four of the negotiating with the government. involved in, was a real disappointment. government’s road map to bring live performance back safely, with Stage Five still Meetings With Ministers The MU called the government out on its some way of. Throughout the autumn, the MU In the early days of lockdown, Horace took failure to help musicians to survive this period called for a ‘2 for 1’ style scheme, which could part in a roundtable call with ministers from of income loss and demanded the Secretary ofer a discount or subsidy on tickets for live the DCMS, in which he argued strongly of State for Culture, Oliver Dowden, properly events, funded by the government. This could for measures to help newly self-employed engage with the music industry to solve help to encourage audiences back to theatres musicians, musicians whose self-employed inequities such as such as the 38% of MU and gigs, and also to book for festivals. Plus, it work is less than 50% of their total, for those members ineligible for either of the could enable some shows to get up and running a limited company, and those with government schemes. running under social distancing. ‘profts’ of over £50,000. The MU was also in contact with the Department for Business, Sadly, the government has too often The Way Forward Energy and Industrial Strategy, as well as the appeared reluctant to engage with the music The Musicians’ Union continues to lobby Treasury, and gave evidence to the DCMS industry, although the shadow secretary of hard and is working relentlessly to support Select Committee inquiry into the efect of state for culture, Jo Stevens, has had regular its members through this current crisis. 17 Covid-19 on the creative industries. meetings with the MU and raised a number The Union is preparing a campaign that Horace’s evidence to the Committee, of urgent questions in the House of will argue for government investment in regarding the poor return on streaming for Commons. On one such occasion more than musicians now, so that they can keep musicians, has helped lead to a full-blown 30 MPs spoke in parliament asking for gaps making music and return to work as soon DCMS Select Committee Inquiry into the in SEISS to be plugged. The MU continues to as is practically possible. ‘Economics of Streaming.’ Furthermore, he press for this on a daily basis and sincerely pushed for the wind and brass research to be thanks all members who are helping. “In Germany, the total package for the arts is conducted in the UK, the evidence from which Members who would like to help are urged worth £46.3bn, with the government also led to a relaxation of the social distancing to visit the Campaigns page on the MU promising fnancial support to micro needed in studios. Plus, working with UK website for information on how to get businesses of up to fve employees,” said involved in our lobbying work. Horace. “Sweden, Denmark, Norway and Finland have all announced funds and aid Photo: Alex Blades Singer-songwriter Abi Moore Making Venues Safe packages for the sector. We are calling on our has been streaming her live The creation of Covid-safe venues government to take action by reassessing its performances from home in the age of social distancing is support packages and considering how else obviously key to helping musicians it can help a sector that is so vital to our resume work. With this in mind national community.” Horace has attended several DCMS Venues Steering Group meetings to Writing to your MP remains one of the best explore options for a safe return to ways to make sure your voice is heard in performance for not only the decision-making, and the MU encourages musicians, technicians and venue members to do this. For more info, go to: staf, but the audiences who are theMU.org/take-action-pandemic paying to watch them, too. During lockdown the Union provided comprehensive support to studios, orchestra managers, venues and producers involved in the The Musician • Winter 2020
Photos: Andy Catlin; Sean Harkin / Alamy Stock Photo We’re In This Together Three Nations How MU Regional Ofces in Scotland, Northern Ireland and Wales worked to deal with the impact of the pandemic on their members Scotland In April 2020, MU Regional Organiser Caroline Sewell attended the Cross-Party Group on Music at the Scottish Parliament and met with the SFEU and Scottish government ofcials to discuss the efect of the Covid-19 crisis on MU members. The MU continued to meet regularly during the summer with Equity, BECTU, NUJ, the Scottish Artists’ Union and the Writers’ Guild to form a joint approach in raising matters with Scottish government advisors, 18 with whom the MU had arranged to meet on a bi-weekly basis. Caroline also made a submission on behalf of the MU to the Scottish New restrictions were implemented in government Culture, Tourism Europe And Scotland on 9 October, which then extended Economic Afairs Committee on the impact to 1 November. The measures applied to of Covid-19 on the sector. hospitality venues, particularly across the sector in the central belt of the country where In August, with schools returning in Scotland, bars and restaurants had been closed the MU team dealt with a huge number of completely. At the same time, face-to-face being given to those who have fallen enquiries in relation to peripatetic teachers private teaching was being permitted but not through the gaps of other funding sources. who did not feel their work had been encouraged, and so the MU was still advising In the autumn, there was some positive news adequately covered by risk assessments. teachers to exercise a cautionary approach when the Department for Communities Caroline continued to meet regularly with and continue to teach online where possible. minister Carál Ní Chuilín announced that £29m Scottish government advisors and MSPs, A £5m hardship fund for individuals was in emergency funding had been confrmed for including Claire Baker MSP and Cabinet launched and administered through Creative the arts, culture and heritage sector. This was Secretary Fiona Hyslop. The MU continued Scotland with the eligibility criteria announced from the initial £29m secured by the to call for urgent support for freelancers and on 22 October. In mid-November, the MU Department for Communities following a bid closer scrutiny of those organisations and worked with the MSPs Tom Arthur and Claire through the UK arts emergency support institutions in receipt of public money that Baker on a motion for a debate in the Scottish package. This brought welcome relief and were making redundancies. The Scottish Parliament on the impact of Covid-19 on £3m was allocated to go straight to creative government subsequently announced the musicians and the wider music sector. freelancers who had applied for the ACNI Grassroots Music Venues Stabilisation Fund, Individuals Emergency Resilience Programme, a £2.2m fund for venues of under 600 in Northern Ireland which had been hugely oversubscribed after it capacity, with grants available of £5k–£50k, During the summer, the MU was engaged in was initially launched in August. which was in addition to the £97m the Scottish regular meetings with the Department for government received for culture and heritage Communities in Northern Ireland. The NI MU Regional Organiser, Caroline Sewell, said: as a result of the UK government’s £1.57bn government subsequently announced the “This will come as a relief for many musicians, emergency relief fund. Individuals Emergency Resilience Programme artists and workers in the creative sector. We for those working in the creative economy, including freelance musicians, with priority The Musician • Winter 2020
FEATURE Welsh government and the sector has focused on funding and support, as well as restarting work. Selected Media Initial support in April from the Welsh Coverage government and the Arts Council of Wales The MU has been featured and (including funding for individuals) has been quoted regularly in the media since followed by a specifc Cultural Recovery Fund lockdown came into force, and (CRF), administered by Welsh government and below is a sample of this activity. Photo: Joseph Branston. © Musicians’ Union the Arts Council. This was initially based on Following February’s media launch £53m of funding, but with an additional £10.7m publicising the results of our latest of investment in November added after members’ survey, a total of over lobbying by the creative unions this is now 100 pieces were generated. These worth £63.7m – more than the £59m of extra included coverage by: funding received by the Welsh government from the UK government as a result of The Guardian investment in the CRF in England. (audience reach) 3,053,000 The Daily Telegraph 24,886,000 A real success for the creative unions’ BBC Breakfast 7,000,000 lobbying was the inclusion of a Freelancer (approx) Catrin Finch and Seckou Keita at Cardiff’s Royal Welsh College of Music and Drama Fund in the CRF. This was initially worth £7m The Times 5,326,380 (above). Giant Drag perform at Edinburgh’s distributed over two phases, but is now NME 5,569,320 iconic Sneaky Pete’s (far left). Gary Numan £10.5m in total, with the additional funding DJ Mag 1,022,850 played Belfast Limelight Club (left) added in November, which will be distributed Dazed 849,600 in a third phase. The Arts Council made Classic FM 505,080 decisions on its awards before the end Hot Press 294,540 of October, and awards from Welsh The Stage 252,810 are pleased that the government has government’s share of the funding should Music Week 178,140 19 listened to the industry and has responded have been fnalised by the end of November. to the need for sector specifc support, which The CRF includes a Cultural Contract for July 2020: The production also recognises the urgency of the matter. organisations, while the Freelancer Fund guidance we released in July, in We await further detail on the remaining is linked to the idea of a Freelancer Pledge partnership with the BPI, AIM and £26m allocated to the sector and look being developed by a working group the MPG, received widespread forward to continuing our discussions with including the Union. industry coverage, including via: the Department for Communities in the UK Music / Ivors Academy / MPG / months ahead.” The Welsh government has taken a cautious Making Music / Arts Council / approach to easing restrictions, particularly in Music Ally / Music Week / Record In October, Northern Ireland entered into relation to culture and live events. Thanks to of the Day / Music News a four-week lockdown. This came on top of regular, ongoing engagement with Welsh a ban on live music in all hospitality venues government ofcials and ministers, the Union May 2020: Horace Trubridge and imposed by the Executive. The MU responded has been able to raise members’ concerns MU teacher/member Sam Dunkley to the ban with an open letter, to which we and push for changes and clarifcations on the were interviewed live on air on received no response. Meanwhile, schools regulations and guidance, as well as issue Sky News highlighting how the were also closed with the extension of the specifc advice on work in Wales, and answer government schemes, although half-term break and re-opened on questions from members. There has been well-meant, were not supporting 2 November. The MU’s lobbying work has gradual progress, including on private all musicians. continued, with bi-weekly meetings taking teaching and teaching in schools, the use of place with the Department for Communities recording and rehearsal studios, and the use March 2020: Our initial survey, in Northern Ireland and other creative unions. of venues for broadcasts without an audience consisting of feedback from 4,100 present. Discussions are continuing to try and of the MU’s members, generated Wales make progress on restarting live events and 65 items of national and regional Since the start of the frst lockdown the performances with audiences, which is likely coverage over the subsequent 24 MU has been working in partnership with to be through further test events initially, so hour period. Examples included the other creative unions, Wales TUC, and that more members can return to work. Mail Online / The Guardian / Yahoo businesses to support members and the News / Belfast Telegraph / Jazz FM wider creative industries in Wales. The / Classic FM Union’s lobbying and engagement with The Musician • Winter 2020
You can also read