The Messenger No. 168 - June 2017 - European Southern Observatory

Page created by Darren Wang
 
CONTINUE READING
The Messenger No. 168 - June 2017 - European Southern Observatory
ELT First Stone ceremony
1st and 2nd generation ESO Public Surveys
Cherenkov Telescope Array
Highlights of the VIPERS survey
                                                                  The Messenger
                                            No. 168 – June 2017
The Messenger No. 168 - June 2017 - European Southern Observatory
The Organisation                                                                                               DOI: 10.18727/0722-6691/5018

A Long Expected Party — The First Stone Ceremony
for the Extremely Large Telescope

Tim de Zeeuw1

                                                                                                                                                      ePOD/J. P. Astorga
Fernando Comerón1
Roberto Tamai1

1
    ESO

The ceremony to seal the time capsule,
signalling the beginning of construction
of the dome and main telescope struc-
ture for the Extremely Large Telescope,
took place at the Paranal Observatory
on 26 May 2017, in the presence of the
President of Chile, Michelle Bachelet
and many international guests. Owing
to high winds, the ceremony could not
take place as planned on the levelled
site on Cerro Armazones, but instead
was held at the Paranal Residencia. A
brief report of the event and its organi-
sation is presented, and the welcome           cials from the governments of the latter       Figure 1. ELT Project Manager Roberto Tamai illus-
                                                                                              trates to President Bachelet the approximate real
speech by the ESO Director General is          two countries.
                                                                                              size of each of the nearly 800 segments that will
included.                                                                                     comprise the ELT primary mirror, in front of a model
                                               The significance of the event in the history   reproduction of the telescope and enclosure, flanked
                                               of ESO was symbolised by the p     ­ resence   by the Director of Operations, Andreas Kaufer (left),
                                                                                              and the Director General, Tim de Zeeuw.
Late May is becoming a time for major          of the former Directors General Lodewijk
highlights in the history of the Paranal       Woltjer, Harry van der Laan and Catherine
Observatory. On 26 May 2017, over two          Cesarsky, as well as the Director General      tion works. Despite sustained efforts
hundred guests from Europe, Chile and          designate Xavier Barcons (see Figure 8).       until the last possible minute, under
the rest of the world gathered at the          The leaders of major observatories and         nearly heroic conditions that involved
­Paranal Residencia to celebrate the First     astronomy organisations including the          crews staying at Armazones overnight
 Stone of the Extremely Large Telescope        Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter         waiting for the winds to abate, the day
 (ELT), as well as the connection of the       Array (ALMA), the Asso­ciation of Universi-    before the event it was decided to revert
 Observatory to the Chilean power grid.        ties for Research in Astronomy (AURA),         to a backup plan already prepared in
 This was exactly 19 years and one day         the Carnegie Insti­tution for Science,         cooperation with the Presidential team
 after Antu, the first Unit Telescope of the   Gemini, the Giant Magellan Telescope           and to host the ceremony at the Paranal
 VLT, saw first light, and one year and        (GMT), the Large Synoptic Survey Tele-         Residencia. This may well have been a
 one day after the signature of the largest    scope (LSST), the National Radio Astron-       blessing in disguise, as the comfortable
 contract in the history of ground-based       omy Observatory (NRAO), The University         environment of the Residencia made
 astronomy, for the construction of the        of Tokyo Atacama Observatory (TAO)             the ceremony much more interactive
 dome and main structure of the ELT.           and the International Astronomical Union       and protected the attendants from the
                                               (IAU) were also present. Managers of           hostile conditions on that day at Cerro
The date of the ceremony was carefully         companies that are key to the ELT con-         Armazones, although at the cost of
chosen to allow the presence of the            struction, most notably Astaldi and            reducing the obvious symbolism of a
­President of Chile, Michelle Bachelet,        SAESA, were among the p     ­ articipants as   ­ceremony on the summit where the ELT
 who had expressed a strong personal           well. Correspondents of numerous                will rise.
 interest in using this opportunity to pay     national and international media covered
 her first visit to an ESO site. The support   the ceremony, which was featured               Upon the arrival of President Bachelet
 of the Chilean government to ESO’s            around the world.                              and other senior dignitaries, an informal
 activities was made very visible by the                                                      welcome reception took place at the
 attendance of the Ministers of Economy,       The ceremony had been planned to take          Residencia which gave ample opportunity
 Mining and Energy, and of many other          place at the top of Cerro Armazones,           for interaction among the participants
 Chilean authorities. The ambassadors of       where the ELT will be located and where        and with the President (Figures 1–3). This
 12 of the 15 ESO Member States were           a large tent was being erected one week        included, as planned, the leadership
 present, as well as the Council President,    ahead of the event. However, in the days       of the Paranal Union, who presented the
 Patrick Roche, members of the ESO             before the event exceptional conditions,       President with a small vase containing soil
 ­governing bodies from the Netherlands,       with windspeeds much higher than usual,        from the five ESO sites in Chile (Vitacura,
  France, Spain and Italy, and higher offi-    prevented the completion of the prepara-       La Silla, APEX, Paranal and Armazones).

2           The Messenger 168 – June 2017
The Messenger No. 168 - June 2017 - European Southern Observatory
ePOD/J. P. Astorga

                                                                                                                                                                                             ePOD/J. P. Astorga
                     Figure 2. President Bachelet is shown posing for                                                                 Figure 3. Paranal Union leaders pose with President
                     selfies with children from Taltal during the First Stone                                                         Bachelet after presenting her with a vase containing
                     event in the Paranal Residencia.                                                                                 soil samples from the five ESO sites in Chile.

                     The formal ceremony started at 13:30                       which a vision of a large telescope                   the country. As President Bachelet noted
                     with the arrival of President Bachelet and                 advanced a century and a half ago by                  in her speech, “With the symbolic start
                     the ESO Director General in the lower                      Jules Verne was compared with the real-               of this construction work, we are building
                     area of the Residencia, where the attend-                  ity of the construction of the ELT. His               more than a telescope here: it is one
                     ees were already waiting. A sequence                       speech was followed by one from Paolo                 of the greatest expressions of scientific
                     of introductory videos was shown about                     Astaldi, President of the leading partner             and technological capabilities and of the
                     the ELT (Figure 4) and the companies                       in the ACe Consortium that is building the            extraordinary potential of international
                     Astaldi, Cimolai, REOSC and Schott,                        dome and the main telescope structure.                cooperation”.
                     which have so far signed large ELT con-                    Next was a speech by the internationally
                     tracts. Also included was a video pre-                     renowned astronomer María Teresa Ruiz,                The highlight of the ceremony came with
                     pared by SAESA, the company that has                       currently President of the Chilean Acad-              the filling and sealing of a time capsule
                     built the extension of the grid to Paranal                 emy of Sciences. The closing speech                   which had been manufactured in the
                     and Armazones.                                             was given by President Michelle Bachelet,             ­Paranal workshop by Patricio Alarcón
                                                                                who stressed the importance of astron-                 and his team. The Director General started
                     A welcome speech (presented on p. 5)                       omy for the development of Chile and the               by depositing a copy of the ELT Science
                     was given by the Director General, in                      great significance that the event had for              Case as foreseen in 2011. President

                                                                                                         Figure 4. (Left) Roberto
ePOD/J. P. Astorga

                                                                                                                                                                                             ESO/F. Comerón
                                                                                                         Tamai, Project Manager
                                                                                                         of the ELT; Paolo Astaldi,
                                                                                                         President of the Astaldi
                                                                                                         construction group; Tim
                                                                                                         de Zeeuw, ESO Director
                                                                                                         General; Michelle
                                                                                                         Bachelet, President of
                                                                                                         the Republic of Chile;
                                                                                                         and María Teresa Ruiz,
                                                                                                         President of the Chilean
                                                                                                         Academy of Sciences,
                                                                                                         watch the opening video
                                                                                                         at the ELT First Stone
                                                                                                         ceremony.

                                                                                                         Figure 5. (Right) The
                                                                                                         glass plate donated by
                                                                                                         President Michelle
                                                                                                         Bachelet to be included
                                                                                                         in the time capsule. The
                                                                                                         legend in Spanish reads:
                                                                                                         “Opening the sky of
                                                                                                         Chile to the questions of
                                                                                                         a whole planet”.

                                                                                                                                            The Messenger 168 – June 2017                3
The Messenger No. 168 - June 2017 - European Southern Observatory
The Organisation                                                    de Zeeuw T. et al., The First Stone Ceremony for the Extremely Large Telescope

                                                                                                                                                                  Figure 7. The ESO ELT
ESO/T. de Zeeuw

                                                                      ESO/M. Cayrel
                                                                                                                                                                  Team braving the wind
                                                                                                                                                                  on Cerro Armazones on
                                                                                                                                                                  the day after the official
                                                                                                                                                                 ­c eremony.

                  Figure 6. The time capsule that was filled during                   describing what the observatory means          Paranal, until the time when progress on
                  the ELT First Stone ceremony, manufactured at the
                                                                                      for them. The Press Release1 contains          the construction of the dome allows it
                  Paranal mechanical workshop. The cover includes
                  a 1:5 scale reproduction of a segment of the ELT                    more details of the event, with photo-         to be encased in one of the walls, where
                  ­p rimary mirror, made in Zerodur ®.                                graphs and videos.                             its cover will be left visible.

                                                                                      Finally the President deposited a pen          Following the ceremony many of the
                  Bachelet followed by depositing a copy                              made of Chilean copper and the last item       guests paid a visit to the VLT telescopes,
                  of the lavishly illustrated book, “Atacama”,                        to be added to the time capsule was an         which the President was unfortunately
                  coauthored by ESO staff member Gerd                                 elegant plate of glass, with the sentence      unable to join because of another com-
                  Hüdepohl. Next, the Director General                                “Opening the sky of Chile to the ques-         mitment. In parallel, the extension of the
                  unrolled two posters with the pictures                              tions of a whole planet” written in Spanish,   Chilean electrical grid, constructed by
                  and names of staff working at ESO at the                            from President Bachelet (Figure 5). The        SAESA with the support of the Chilean
                  time, which were held up by the Director                            time capsule was then closed with a            Government, was celebrated and the
                  General and the President to be shown                               cover that contains a 1:5 scale reproduc-      Armazones power station, that converts
                  to the audience, then rolled up again and                           tion of a segment of the ELT primary mir-      the voltage from 66kV to 23kV, was inau-
                  left inside the capsule. At that point, a                           ror made in Zerodur®, the same material        gurated.
                  group of six school children from the town                          of which the actual segments will be
                  of Taltal, in whose grounds Cerro Paranal                           made by Schott, with the flags of the ESO      The First Stone event was also the occa-
                  is located, were called upon to join the                            Member States and Chile engraved and           sion to introduce the team of the ELT
                  President and the Director General to                               a legend commemorating the ephemeris           Project Managers to Paranal colleagues.
                  place in the time capsule their drawings                            (Figure 6). The capsule is in storage at       The agenda of the four-day ELT Team
                                                                                                                                     visit included: the presentation of the ELT
                                                                                                                                     team and updated status to Paranal col-
                                                                                                                                     leagues; exchanges of experience and
                                                                                                                                     lessons learned, and discussions on sub-
                                                                                                                                     jects of mutual interest; an extensive visit
                                                                                                                                     to the telescopes and technical facilities;
                                                                                                                                     and a visit to Armazones (Figure 7). This
                                                                                                                                     contact will facilitate the assembly, inte-
                                                                                                                                     gration and verification of the ELT and its
                                                                                                                                     smooth integration into the operations of
                                                                                                                                     the Paranal Observatory.

                                                                                                                                     Figure 8. Past, present and future Directors General
                                                                                                                                     of ESO at the Paranal Residence. From left to right:
                                                                                                                                     Lodewijk Woltjer (1974–1987); Harry van der Laan
                                                                                                                                     (1988–1992); Catherine Cesarsky (1999–2007); Tim
                                                                                                                                     de Zeeuw (2007–2017); and Xavier Barcons (2017–).
                                                                                                                                     Regrettably, Riccardo Giacconi (1993–1999) could
                                                                                                                                     not attend the ceremony.

                  4            The Messenger 168 – June 2017
The Messenger No. 168 - June 2017 - European Southern Observatory
Figure 9. President Bachelet accom-
                                                                                                                              panied by most of the Paranal logistics
                                                                                                                              team who played a major role in
                                                                                                                              organising the ceremony.

The symbolic laying of the ELT First                 Acknowledgements                                         Jane Wallace, Priya Hein and María Adriana Arrau,
                                                                                                              for handling and coordinating the invitations, confir-
Stone coincided with the signature of
                                                     The success of the event and all the concurrent          mations and transport schedules of many of the
the Armazones site handover to the ACe               activities in the same week at the Paranal Obser­        guests; and to the production company, Macoffice,
Consortium, following resolution of a                vatory owes much more than can be described in           which took care of the hardware for the ceremony,
number of technical and legal matters.               this article to the Paranal logistics team led by        including the tent at Armazones whose installation
                                                     ­Christine Desbordes (pictured in Figure 9); to the      was ultimately prevented by the wind. ESO is also
From now on, access to Armazones will
                                                      Education and Public Outreach Department led by         indebted to the Presidential Avanzada team for their
have to be approved by ACe. In the next               Lars Christensen and by Laura Ventura in Chile; to      invaluable assistance and advice with the prepara-
few months, the on-site construction                  the many colleagues working at Paranal who agreed       tion of the ceremony.
activities will begin giving shape to the             to leave the comfort of their rooms at Paranal for a
                                                      couple of nights stay in Antofagasta, thus making
gigantic telescope and change the physi-
                                                      it possible for many important guests to stay at the    Links
ognomy of Armazones forever. All the                  Observatory on the nights before or after the First
hard work will eventually lead to another,            Stone event; to the executive assistants of the Cabi-   1
                                                                                                                   ress Release on ELT First Stone: http://www.eso.
                                                                                                                  P
even bigger, celebration; the First Light of          net and the Representation in Chile, Isolde Kreutle,        org/public/news/eso1716
the ELT in 2024.

Text of Speech

Welcome                                              It is unfortunate that the unusually inclement           in Colorado, in order to be able to see the
                                                     weather prevents access to the platform on               capsule orbiting the Moon. Verne calculated
                                                     Cerro Armazones, so we gather here in the                that this needed a telescope with a main
Tim de Zeeuw, ESO                                    Paranal Residence instead.                               ­mirror of 4.8 metres diameter, which was fully
                                                                                                               two and a half times larger than that of the
                                                     Let me start by taking you back about                     largest telescope at the time, Lord Rosse’s
President Bachelet, Ambassadors, Ministers           150 years. In 1865, Jules Verne published a               Leviathan of Parsonstown, Ireland. A bold
Céspedes, Rebolledo and Williams, Members            famous book entitled “The Journey to the                  step! Verne mentions that the telescope tube
of the Congress, Senator Giannini, State             Moon”. It turned out to be uncannily prophetic,           was 84 metres long and that the entire system
­Secretaries, Council President, Council dele-       describing an Apollo-sized capsule with three             was built in a single year. The site had of
 gates, Mr. Astaldi, Messrs Sammartano,              persons on board, launched by a monster                   course to be in the United States for reasons
 ­Marchiori, Diaz and Alliende, former Directors     cannon located near Tampa in Florida, very                of national pride.
  General Woltjer, van der Laan and Cesarsky,        close to Cape Canaveral. All at the initiative of
  Director General designate Barcons, other          an American gun club, with a key role for, yes,          It took a century before Borman, Lovell and
  distinguished guests, colleagues and friends,      a French scientist.                                      Anders orbited the Moon in Apollo 8 in
  it is a pleasure to welcome you on this historic                                                            December 1968. It took another eighty years
  occasion.                                          It is probably less well known that the story            before Verne’s giant telescope was built, not
                                                     also describes the construction of a giant tele-         in Colorado but instead on Mount Palomar in
                                                     scope at 4300 metres altitude on Longs Peak              California, and with an improved design. This

                                                                                                                      The Messenger 168 – June 2017                5
The Messenger No. 168 - June 2017 - European Southern Observatory
The Organisation                                    de Zeeuw T., Text of Speech

is the world-famous 200-inch telescope, often       The Chilean government carefully protects           because of the enormous scientific return and
referred to as the Big Eye, and inaugurated in      the quality of the night skies and realises that    ESO’s track record in delivering quality. The
1948.                                               the international observatories provide training    key authorisation for construction was granted
                                                    and employment for many Chileans: telescope         in 2014 under Council President Barcons, who
Only 40 years later, technology had already         operators, technicians, engineers, astrono-         is now the Director General designate.
advanced sufficiently to gain another factor        mers and administrative staff. Chilean univer-
of two in mirror diameter, and today a dozen        sities have developed internationally competi-      Two other giant telescopes are planned,
fully steerable 8–10-metre-class optical tele-      tive astronomy programmes, and some have            the Giant Magellan Telescope (GMT) on
scopes are in operation, including the world-       started engineering programmes for astro-           Las Campanas here in Chile, and the Thirty
leading Very Large Telescope (VLT) here on          technology, creating capabilities and know-         Meter Telescope (TMT) in the northern hemi-
Paranal. It is a distinct pleasure to recognise     how that will benefit Chilean society more          sphere. Together with the ELT, these tele-
Lo Woltjer, who initiated the VLT project and       generally. ESO is proud to be associated with       scopes will open a new era of discovery
got it funded and approved, Harry van der Laan      this impressive growth of capabilities, which       whose implications may well go beyond
who selected Paranal as the site, placed all the    is also reflected in the fact that the President    astronomy. The cooperation between these
major contracts and designed the ­successful        of the Chilean Academy of Sciences, María           three projects to address technological chal-
collaborative model for instrumentation devel-      Teresa Ruiz, who will also speak today, is an       lenges is yet another example of international
opment, and Catherine Cesarsky who brought          internationally acclaimed astronomer.               collaboration for the sake of science. I am
the VLT to full operation. Riccardo Giacconi                                                            pleased to acknowledge our colleagues from
had a key role during construction and first        Almost exactly a year ago, ESO signed the           GMT and TMT present here for this joint
light, but could unfortunately not be here today.   largest ever contract in ground-based astron-       endeavour, as well as for providing the frame-
                                                    omy with the ACe consortium, consisting             work of a stimulating and healthy competition
Nearly twenty years have passed since first         of Astaldi, Cimolai and the nominated sub-          from which we all benefit.
light of the Very Large Telescope. ALMA has         contractor EIE Group, for the construction of
meanwhile been constructed on Chajnantor            the giant dome and the 3000-tonne telescope         The size of the primary mirror of the ELT, and
in Chile by an international partnership            structure. Today’s event marks the official start   the revolutionary telescope design which
and is operational, and telescope technology        of the construction of the telescope structure      includes built-in adaptive optics to correct for
has advanced again. Today we officially             and dome of the ELT.                                the turbulence in the atmosphere, will make
start construction of the Extremely Large Tele-                                                         the ELT the world’s biggest and sharpest eye
scope (ELT). Its dome will have a diameter          Today also marks the connection of Paranal          on the sky for the foreseeable future. This
of 85 metres and a height of approximately          and Armazones to the Chilean electrical grid.       giant leap in capability is as large as that
80 metres, so that Verne’s telescope tube           The Chilean Government has helped ESO to            experienced by Galileo when he first turned
would fit. However, the ELT has a segmented         find a solution for the supply of power to the      his telescope to the heavens!
main mirror with a diameter of an astounding        Observatory, through the Comisión Nacional
39 metres. This is a jump of a factor four to       de Energía, la Superintendencia de Electricidad     The goal for its use is not that of Verne, to see
five over any existing telescope! The collecting    y Combustibles, and the Ministries of National      details on the Moon, or the developments
area of the ELT primary mirror is nearly 1000       Assets and Foreign Affairs and our consultants      in the Moon Village proposed by the European
square metres, which is larger than that of         from MegaRed. The connection to the central         Space Agency, or to watch all of Middle Earth,
all 8–10-metre-class telescopes in the world        grid in Paposo is managed by Grupo SAESA,           but instead to study the deep Universe, to
combined. Jules Verne would have liked it!          and I am very pleased that it is represented        resolve the light of nearby galaxies into that of
                                                    here today. The grid connection will reduce         its constituent stars, and above all to image
A revolutionary telescope needs an excellent        costs, provide greater reliability and stability,   and characterise the rocky planets that we
site, and the choice of Cerro Armazones             and will also reduce the Observatory’s carbon       now know orbit most stars. It is in fact possible
was the result of a world-wide site selection       footprint.                                          that the ELT will find evidence for life on other
process, chaired by Rene Rutten, who is                                                                 worlds. It is ironic that this would be done from
here today. The Chilean government gener-           It has taken 18 years to get to this point,         the magnificent desolation of the Atacama
ously extended the land donated to ESO in           thanks to the efforts of many people all over       Desert.
1995 towards the east, so that it now contains      the world, including former Italian delegate
both Paranal and Armazones, and ESO can             Nanni Bignami who unfortunately passed              The ELT construction effort is carried out by
operate the ELT as part of the Paranal Obser-       away very suddenly two days ago. Roberto            a large team with staff from across ESO, led
vatory. The first discussions on this topic were    Gilmozzi initiated the precursor 100-metre-         by Roberto Tamai who works closely with
with President Bachelet during her previous         diameter OWL project, Riccardo Giacconi pro-        ESO’s top management. Many team members
term. The process was completed under               moted it, Catherine Cesarsky oversaw the            are here. Roberto will make sure that the con-
­President Piñera, with key preparatory work        careful process that resulted in the start of a     struction will stay on schedule, so that what
 done by Ambassador Rodriguez of the Ministry       full design study in early 2007 for what was,       was once a dream becomes reality.
 of Foreign Affairs and by ESO’s previous rep-      by then, a single European project, and Jason
 resentative Massimo Tarenghi. Since then           Spyromilio led the extended design effort, car-     The ELT will no doubt produce discoveries
 ICAFAL, also represented here, have prepared       ried out with industry in the Member States.        that we simply cannot imagine today, and it
 the giant platform and a new access road, so                                                           will surely inspire numerous people around the
 that today we take the next step, again with       In the years that followed it was possible to       world to think about science, technology and
 President Bachelet. I am sure that the location    convince the 15 ESO Member States to ­commit        our place in the Universe. This will bring great
 of the ELT in Chile is a justified source of       significant additional funding for the ELT Pro-     benefit to the ESO Member States, to Chile,
 national pride, just as in Verne’s story.          gramme despite the financial crisis. I am very      and the rest of the world. For this reason we
                                                    grateful for this support, which was provided       seal the ELT time capsule today for all mankind.

6            The Messenger 168 – June 2017
The Messenger No. 168 - June 2017 - European Southern Observatory
Telescopes and Instrumentation
ESO/E. Vernet

                The Deformable Secondary Mirror being hoisted
                into its hub, already mounted on the top end of
                Unit Telescope 4.
The Messenger No. 168 - June 2017 - European Southern Observatory
Telescopes and Instrumentation                                                                                        DOI: 10.18727/0722-6691/5019

The Adaptive Optics Facility:
Commissioning Progress and Results

Robin Arsenault1                                          2017 and the GRAAL ground-layer              GRound-layer Adaptive optics Assisted
Pierre-Yves Madec1                                        adaptive optics mode by the end of the       by Lasers (GRAAL) in ground layer adap-
Elise Vernet1                                             year.                                        tive optics (GLAO) mode is planned by
Wolfgang Hackenberg1                                                                                   the end of 2017. Then only MUSE with
Paolo La Penna1                                                                                        GALACSI in Narrow Field Mode (NFM)
Jérome Paufique1                                          Introduction                                 will remain to be commissioned in 2018.
Harald Kuntschner1
Jean-François Pirard1                                     Towards the end of 2016, the only miss-
Johann Kolb1                                              ing pieces of the Adaptive Optics Facility   Installation of new M2 unit on UT4
Norbert Hubin1                                            (AOF) complex (see Arsenault et al., 2010,
                                                          2014a and 2016 for previous progress         In September 2016, the 14 crates con-
                                                          updates) were the new secondary mirror       taining the DSM system (Arsenault et al.,
1
    ESO                                                   (M2) unit — the Deformable Secondary         2013a; Manetti et al., 2014; Briguglio et
                                                          Mirror (DSM) — and the Ground Atmos-         al., 2014), totalling 9 tonnes and 50 cubic
                                                          pheric Layer Adaptive optiCs for Spectro-    metres, were unpacked in the New Inte-
All the Adaptive Optics Facility (AOF)                    scopic Imaging (GALACSI) adaptive            gration Hall (NIH) in Paranal. The system
subsystems are now in Paranal and                         optics (AO) module. The new M2 unit was      was re-assembled in the NIH and func-
the project team is working on com­                       installed in October 2016 during a shut-     tionalities tested. It was an opportunity
missioning activities on Unit Telescope                   down of Unit Telescope 4 (UT4 — Yepun)       to cross-train our Paranal colleagues
4 (UT4) of the Very Large Telescope.                      and the whole telescope was recommis-        and demonstrate several handling opera-
Excellent progress has been made; the                     sioned with the new M2 unit by December      tions, including the critical thin-shell mir-
new secondary mirror unit, the Deform-                    2016. Since then, UT4 has returned to        ror handling.
able Secondary Mirror (DSM), was                          operations and the Paranal telescope
installed in October 2016 and UT4 is                      and instrument operators (TIOs) and sci-     Before proceeding with the removal of
now operating routinely with the DSM in                   ence support staff have been trained to      the old Dornier M2 unit, a laser tracker
non-adaptive optics mode. The other                       use the telescope with this new second-      was installed on the telescope centre-
modules of the AOF, the Ground Atmos-                     ary mirror in non-adaptive optics mode.      piece and used to record reference
pheric Layer Adaptive optiCs for Spec-                    The AOF team remains in close contact        ­positions of markers on the telescope
troscopic Imaging (GALACSI), the                          with Paranal staff and closely monitors       structure and the M2 hub and spiders.
4 Laser Guide Star Facility (4LGSF) and                   any errors and issues to provide support      Additionally, reference measurements
the GRound-layer Adaptive optics                          and solutions.                                were taken to characterise the telescope
Assisted by Lasers (GRAAL), have been                                                                   optical behaviour and performance,
installed and are being qualified. The                    At the end of 2016, the GALACSI instru-       some of them using the GRAAL Mainte-
coupling with the High Acuity Wide                        ment was dismounted from the Adaptive         nance and Commissioning Mode (MCM)
field K-band Imager (HAWK-I) and the                      Secondary Simulator and InStrument            wavefront sensor. Close-out measure-
Multi Unit Spectroscopic Explorer                         Testbed (ASSIST) in the Garching integra-     ments were also taken for the instru-
(MUSE) has been tested and all ele-                       tion hall and packed for transport to         ments available at UT4 (the Spectrograph
ments are functional and ready to pro-                    Chile. After reintegration in Paranal, all    for INtegral Field Observations in the
ceed with their full commissioning.                       functionalities were recovered. In late       Near Infrared [SINFONI], HAWK-I, MUSE
The goal for the AOF is to complete                       March 2017, GALACSI was installed on          and the VLT Interferometer [VLTI]) with
GALACSI wide-field mode technical                         UT4 and was then ready to enter the           the support of Science Operation. These
commissioning by the end of summer                        commissioning phase.                          would later be used to verify that tele-
                                                                                                        scope and instrument performance had
                                                          The project is now fully involved in          not been degraded after the installation
ESO Project Team:
                                                          ­commissioning activities and these will      of the new M2 unit.
D. Bonaccini Calia, P. Duhoux, J.-L. Lizon, S. Guisard,    continue during 2017 and into part of
P. Lilley, L. Petazzi, P. Hammersley, I. Guidolin,         2018. Commissioning runs are scheduled      On 14 October 2016, the first transport
L. Kern, T. Pfrommer, C. Dupuy, R. Guzman, J.              almost every month during bright time.      took place to UT4 and the DSM hub
Quentin, M. Quattri, R. Hozlöhner, D. Popovic, M.
Comin, S. McClay, S. Lewis, F. Gago, M. Sarazin,
                                                           Some of them may be returned to science     was brought to the telescope. The next
P. Haguenauer, A. Jost, J. Argomedo, S. Tordo,             operations if commissioning progress is     day the DSM followed the same route.
R. Donaldson, R. Conzelmann, M. Lelouarn,                  rapid and if there are no technical prob-   Extreme care was taken during the trans-
R. Siebenmorgen, M. Downing, J. Reyes, M. Suarez           lems or bad weather. The intention is to    port and the load was accompanied on
Valles, S. Stroebele, S. Oberti, P. Gutierrez Cheetam,
M. Kiekebusch, C. Soenke, E. Aller-Carpentier,
                                                           complete the commissioning of the Multi     foot all the way to monitor the smooth-
P. Jolley, J. Vernet, A. Manescau-Hernandez, L.            Unit Spectroscopic Explorer (MUSE) with     ness of the ride. The replacement began
Mehrgan, G. Calderone, A. van Kesteren, G. Chiozzi,        the GALACSI Wide Field Mode (WFM) at        with the removal of the Beryllium M2 mir-
H. Sommers, D. Dorigo, T. Bierwirth, J.-P. Kirchbauer,     the end of the summer 2017, with Science    ror. Then within one day the Dornier hub
S. Huber, G. Fischer, A. Haimerl, S. Leveque, P.
Amico, G. Hubert, S. Brillant, P. Baksai, J.C. Palacio,
                                                           Verification planned for August 2017.       was removed and the new M2 hub, with
I. Munoz, E. Fuenteseca, P. Bourget, P. Hibon, F.          Commissioning of the High Acuity Wide       its DSM dummy weight, installed instead.
Selman, G. Hau, S. Egner, T. Szeifert, J.C. Guerra.        field K-band Imager (HAWK-I) and the        Three days later the DSM was installed in

8             The Messenger 168 – June 2017
The Messenger No. 168 - June 2017 - European Southern Observatory
Figure 1. A jubilant team   0.5 arcseconds at the time of the expo-
                                                                       after the installation of
                                                                                                   sure); see Figure 2, right. This measure-
                                                                       the DSM on UT4.
                                                                                                   ment demonstrates that the optical qual-
                                                                                                   ity of the DSM in non-adaptive optics
                                                                                                   mode allows seeing-limited observation
                                                                                                   even under excellent seeing conditions.

                                                                                                   The next step consisted of assessing
                                                                                                   the changes in the operation of the active
                                                                                                   optics. The strategy was to record the
                                                                                                   active optics aberration measurements of
                                                                                                   the telescope after application of the so-
                                                                                                   called “OneCal”, the look-up table for
                                                                                                   the primary mirror (M1) modes versus alti-
                                                                                                   tude. Comparisons were made between
                                                                                                   the Dornier and the DSM. The values
                                                                                                   are very similar between both, and the
                                                                                                   active optics functionality and operational
its hub (see p. 7). Using the laser tracker,    new M2 unit is fully comparable to that            aspects are preserved with the DSM as
it was possible to verify that the DSM hub      experienced with the old Dornier.                  well. The secondary chopping was also
ended up, after its installation on the tele-                                                      tested and behaved as expected. Only
scope, within 1 mm of the Dornier hub’s          The new magnitude zero points for                 two points remained to be examined —
position, while its longitudinal axis was        HAWK-I were found to be identical, within         the flexure of the DSM reference body
colinear within 1 arcminute. Calibrated          3 %, to the former values and the emis-           and the DSM flattening vector.
mechanical spacers and alignment tools           sivity was measured as 25 % for the
allowed this feat, as well as the expertise      Dornier and 24 % for the new M2 unit.             The trefoil and astigmatism terms evolve
of the optical engineers in Garching and         The plate scale change was measured at            with altitude as can be seen in Figure 3.
Paranal. The whole operation was led by          1.00047 ± 0.0005 on the Nasmyth B                 Only the terms along the altitude axis
the Paranal mechanical team under the            guide probe, which compares to 1.00067            show a variation. This does not come as
close supervision of the contractor Micro-       when measured directly on HAWK-I;                 a surprise as it was known that the refer-
gate and the Garching DSM team.                  these results mean that, for all practical        ence body of the DSM is subjected to
                                                 purposes, the plate scale change is               this sort of deformation. At the zenith, the
It is amazing to think that, after such an      ­negligible.                                       reference body is deformed in a threefold
intrusive and major operation on the tele-                                                         sag shape (trefoil) because of the system
scope, the first pointing on sky was suc-       A series of 10-second J-band images                of three supporting points. At the horizon
cessful, with pointing errors of the same       were taken of the globular cluster M30             this deformation evolves toward an astig-
magnitude as usual, and the active loop         using the new M2 unit. Figure 2 (left)             matism. The left plot in Figure 3 shows
was closed successfully after the first         shows one of the best images obtained              that this variation is seen by the active
iteration! Figure 1 illustrates the effect of   with the DSM, with a full width at half            optics of the telescope and corrected by
this achievement on the whole team.             maximum (FWHM) of the star images of               M1. However, the level is quite acceptable
                                                0.37 arcseconds (visual band seeing was            and, since the end of the commissioning,

Telescope re-commissioning

During the first nights after installation,
basic tests were carried out to verify
the behaviour of the DSM hexapod. The
focusing motion was as expected and
the three focal planes could be accom-
modated within the DSM focusing range.
The impact of M2 centring on the tele-
scope coma was measured using the
GRAAL MCM wavefront sensor. Excellent
agreement between the centring of the
old Dornier and the new M2 was achieved,
and the GRAAL MCM mode proved
                                                                                                   Figure 2. Left: A J-band image taken at a low airmass
extremely useful during all the telescope                                                          of part of the globular cluster M30. Right: An analysis
recom­missioning phases. It also shows                                                             of the point spread function from multiple star
that mechanical flexure introduced by the                                                          images; the FWHM is 2 pixels (0.37 arcseconds).

                                                                                                         The Messenger 168 – June 2017                  9
The Messenger No. 168 - June 2017 - European Southern Observatory
Telescopes and Instrumentation                                           Arsenault R. et al., The Adaptive Optics Facility

Figure 3. Left: The d­ ifference in                                      New M2 Unit w.r.t. Dornier                                                 Dornier w.r.t. Dornier (different nights)
OneCal residual aberrations                              1500                                                                            1500
between the DSM and the old
Dornier M2 unit as a function                            1000                                     trefoil                                1000
of zenith distance (ZD). Zernike
pairs of orthogonal modes for
                                      Aberration value

                                                                                                                      Aberration value
                                                         500                                                                             500
trefoil and astigmatism are
shown. Right: Same as left fig-
ure but for two different sets                              0                                                                               0
of measu­rements of the Dornier                                 0   10       20    30     40      50        60   70                             0   10     20      30      40     50      60    70
M2 unit on different nights,                             –500                                                                            –500
showing the typical noise level.
The DSM shows clear trends                        –1000                                                astigmatism                –1000
of the astigmatism and trefoil
aberrations with altitude (zenith
                                                  –1500                                                                           –1500
distance).                                                                        ZD (degrees)                                                                   ZD (degrees)

the active optics has managed this
                                                                         HD 49798        Before                                                       After
change without issue. Note that the cor-
responding mode amplitude applied in the                                 K
DSM flattening vector has been modified
to ensure that the horizontal axis crosso-
ver occurs at a typical operation airmass.

The same type of analysis reflected a
slightly higher scatter in the higher M1
mode amplitudes. We believe that this is
due to some high-order aberrations in
the DSM flattening vector. After these
measurements a calibration was carried
                                                                         H+K
out to optimise the DSM flattening vector
and reduce its content in high-order
aberrations.

Finally, a detailed analysis of the field
­stabilisation performance took place.
 Many small issues were encountered,
 resulting from the telescope environment
 and the somewhat different control
 parameters required by the DSM, but all
 were progressively resolved. The final per-                             H
 formance is certainly adequate. The only
 remaining issue is poorer performance
 when the telescope is facing into a strong
 wind. More data need to be recorded
 to fully understand the root cause of this
 problem before it can be fixed.

An analysis of the field stabilisation
closed-loop rejection transfer function
was performed. For a control frequency
                                                                         J
of 32 Hz, integration time of 0.01 s and
control parameters of Kp = 0.7, Ki = 1.5
and Koffload = 0.02 and a 3 Hz cutoff fre-
quency, a 6 dB overshoot (> 45° phase
margin) was observed.

Figure 4. PSF samples for the star HD 49798. The
“Before” and “After” columns refer to images obtained
with the Dornier M2 unit and the new DSM M2 unit,
respectively. The external seeing values were similar
in both cases.

10             The Messenger 168 – June 2017
UT4 instrument recommissioning                                2000                                           2000                                                10.0
                                                                                                                                                                 9.5
To complete the recommissioning
                                                                                                                                                                 9.0
­process, the instrument scientists of                        1500                                           1500
 HAWK-I, MUSE, SINFONI and the VLTI                                                                                                                              8.5
 performed a dedicated set of tests to
                                                 Y (pixels)

                                                                                                Y (pixels)
                                                                                                                                                                 8.0
 assess the behaviour of these instruments                    1000                                           1000
                                                                                                                                                                 7.5
 after the new M2 installation. These
 tests addressed several aspects of the                                                                                                                          7.0
 instruments’ performance; we show here                        500                                            500                                                6.5
 only a few excerpts from the recommis-                                                                                                                          6.0
 sioning reports. Figure 4 shows a sample
                                                                 0                                              0                                                5.5
 of S
    ­ INFONI PSFs and corresponding                                  0   500     1000 1500   2000                   0     500     1000 1500          2000
 Strehl ratios in different bands for the star                                 X (pixels)                                       X (pixels)                       5.0
 HD 49798. The results are essentially
 identical, except in the J-band where high        oped for this purpose; it is based on sin-                   Figure 5. Images of the behaviour of the FWHM
                                                                                                                across HAWK-I images in Y-band at airmass 1.0.
 spatial frequency residuals can be noticed        gle conjugate AO, making use of a 1 kHz
                                                                                                                Left: with the Dornier M2 unit; Right: with the DSM.
 (static speckles around the diffraction           – 40 × 40 subaperture wavefront sensor                       The scale shows the FWHM in pixels (pixel scale is
 limited core); these residuals are due to         (WFS) looking at a bright natural guide                      0.106 arcseconds) and annuli around the star posi-
 the high spatial frequency aberrations            star on-axis, therefore fully exploiting the                 tions indicate measured ellipticity.
 of the DSM optical surface. The situation         1172 actuators of the DSM. The tests
 was later improved by calibrating and             were carried out during a run in February                    t­ransported to UT4 and installed on the
 updating the reference vector position of         2017. Unfortunately, many nights were                         ­Nasmyth platform (Figure 7). Precautions
 the DSM when in non-AO mode.                      lost to high humidity and only slightly                        were taken to protect the MUSE hardware
                                                   more than half of the ten nights could be                      during installation (a special protective
The HAWK-I recommissioning report                  used for on-sky tests. The result is that                      fence was designed and manufactured).
also thoroughly reviewed several perfor-           less time was available to optimise the                        First light was obtained on 20 March
mance criteria for the instrument. The             performance. In particular, not enough                         on GALACSI, despite an emergency tele-
Two Micron All Sky Survey (2MASS)                  time was available to characterise the                         scope shutdown which delayed the
Touchstone Fields were observed and                non-common path aberrations and apply                          GALACSI installation by one week.
reduced using the new Cambridge                    an accurate offset for them on the DSM.
Astronomy Survey Unit (CASU) pipeline.             Nevertheless, excellent images and per-                      In April 2017, there was another on-sky
The variation of the FWHM across the               formance could be obtained and all the                       commissioning run during which many
whole field of view was compared and               servo-loops and offloads could be vali-                      technical tests were conducted to reliably
appeared as expected (see Figure 5).               dated in this technical mode (this is, how-                  enable the full adaptive optics correction
The ellipticity of the star images was also        ever, not a science observing mode; see                      performance of the GALACSI WFM,
examined in the different fields. The              Figure 6).                                                   ­making use of the DSM and the 4LGSF
report concluded that the installation of                                                                        (Hackenberg et al., 2014; Bonaccini Calia
the new M2 unit has had no impact                                                                                et al., 2014; Holzlöhner et al., 2008;
on the overall performance of HAWK-I.              First commissioning of the GALACSI                            ­Holzlöhner et al., 2010; Holzlöhner et al.,
                                                   Wide Field Mode                                                2012; Amico et al., 2015). The complete
The reports on MUSE and VLTI also                                                                                 automatic acquisition sequence was run
­concluded that the behaviour remained             On 12 March 2017, following re-integration                     on numerous occasions and timed. The
 similar before and after the installation of      and verification in the NIH, the GALACSI                       acquisition involves presetting the tele-
 the new M2 unit. Small differences were           module (La Penna et al., 2014; Arsenault                       scope to the target, acquiring the 4 Laser
 observed in behaviour, enough to realise          et al., 2013b; Stuik et al., 2012) was                         Guide Stars within the 5 arcsecond field
 that the M2 has been exchanged, but
 there was certainly no loss in performance
 with respect to the Dornier M2 unit.
                                                                                                                                            Figure 6. Left: K-band
                                                                                                                                            narrow filter image
DSM commissioning with the GRAAL                                                                                                            of a double star with
                                                                                                                                            0.2 arcsecond separa-
Maintenance and Commissioning Mode                                                                                                          tion, obtained with
                                                                                                                                            GRAAL MCM. Right:
The last step of the new M2 commis­                                                                                                         A bright star image
sioning was the verification of the per­                                                                                                    exhibiting 80 % Strehl
                                                                                                                                            ratio (also with K-band
formance of the DSM in AO mode. The                                                                                                         narrow filter). The seeing
GRAAL MCM mode (Arsenault et al.,                                                                                                           was 0.55 arcseconds
2014b; Paufique et al., 2012) was devel-                                                                                                    at the time.

                                                                                                                        The Messenger 168 – June 2017              11
Telescopes and Instrumentation                                               Arsenault R. et al., The Adaptive Optics Facility

   Figure 7. Left: GALACSI
   being hoisted through
   the azimuth hatch after
   transport from the
   ­Paranal New Integration
    Hall to UT4. Right: The
    very tight margin to
    manoeuver this sensitive
    module between the
    Nasmyth acquisition
    and image rotator unit
    and the MUSE fore-
    optics can be seen.

   of view of the four GALACSI wavefront                                        dation of the optical quality of the images        the atmospheric specification (~1.1 arc-
   sensors, performing the detection and                                        delivered by GALACSI to MUSE. Figure 8             seconds) and the target was low in the
   centering of the tip-tilt natural guide star,                                shows that, thanks to a rigid design and           sky (zenith distance 50°). This is a very
   and then closing all the loops. The final                                    good optical alignment, the stability of           good first sign that the GALACSI WFM
   results are impressive; after a few nights                                   the pupil shift is pretty good from zenith         performs as specified. The ratio of turbu-
   spent on improving the automatisation                                        down to 35° altitude, meaning that a               lence in the first 500 metres above the
   of this process, the overhead for the AOF                                    compensation strategy for this misalign-           telescope to the total turbulence given
   acquisition after the telescope is ready                                     ment may not be needed, thus simplify-             by the SLOpe Detection And Ranging
   (two active optics cycles) was measured                                      ing the GALACSI operations.                        (SLODAR) measurement and the internal
   to be less than one minute (50 seconds).                                                                                        estimation was ~ 90 % — i.e., quite high
   It should be remembered that the specifi-                                    Rejection transfer functions have been             — a situation which is best suited to
   cation for the overhead was 5 minutes                                        measured for both the high-order correc-           ground-layer AO correction (Kuntschner
   and the goal 2 minutes.                                                      tion loop and the tip-tilt loop. Both look         et al., 2012). Figure 9 illustrates this cor-
                                                                                good and can be fitted nicely by the               rection but much better results were
   Amongst many performance tests con-                                          model of the dynamic system with respec-           obtained later.
   ducted, one of them consisted of evalu­                                      tively 1.3 ms and 4.3 ms of pure delay.
   ating the stability of the registration                                                                                         The results obtained during later nights
   between the actuator pattern of the DSM                                      System performance has been finally                improved somewhat, and the statistics
   and the WFS sub-aperture pattern. Shifts                                     characterised. A gain of 1.5–2 in FWHM             showed much better performance. The
   with respect to one another are due to                                       at 750 nm was observed between open                gain between GLAO and non-GLAO
   mechanical flexure in the large distance                                     loop (with telescope field stabilisation)          depends strongly on the fraction of turbu-
   between them and could lead to a degra-                                      and full closed loop. The seeing matched           lence in the lower atmospheric layers.
                                                                                                                                   If a large fraction is concentrated below
                                   30                                                                                              500 metres, GALACSI will substantially
                                                                                                    WFS#1, X shift, 06/04/17
                                                                                                                                   improve the ensquared energy (a gain of
                                                                                                    WFS#1, Y shift
                                                                                                                                   four has been obtained). Conversely, if
                                   20                                                               WFS#2, X shift
                                                                                                                                   this fraction falls below ~ 20 %, the gain
Pupil shift (% of sub-aperture)

                                                                                                    WFS#2, Y shift                 will be lower and the observer must
                                                                                                    WFS#3, X shift                 decide whether seeing-limited observa-
                                   10
                                                                                                    WFS#3, Y shift                 tions must be conducted (with shorter
                                                                                                    WFS#4, X shift                 acquisition time and without lasers) or
                                    0                                                               WFS#4, Y shift                 simply another mode (MUSE NFM) or
                                                                                                    WFS#1, X shift, 11/04/17       instrument. This information is provided
                                                                                                    WFS#1, Y shift                 from Multi-Aperture Scintillation Sensor
                                  –10
                                                                                                    ...                            (MASS) and D   ­ ifferential Image Motion
                                                                                                    Figure 8. The shift in pupil   Monitor (DIMM) data at the Observatory.
                                  – 20                                                              alignment on the WFS sub-      Figures 10 and 11 demonstrate the ens-
                                                                                                    aperture in X and Y for all    quared energy performance with open
                                                                                                    four LGS sensors is plotted
                                  – 30                                                              for two dates (see legend).
                                                                                                                                   and closed loop, allowing a first assess-
                                      30      40        50       60         70      80       90     The shift is expressed in      ment of gains, but with limited statistics.
                                                     Telescope altitude (degrees)                   percent of a sub-aperture.     From Figure 11, one can determine that

   12                                      The Messenger 168 – June 2017
3000                                                                          Figure 9. The quality of
                                                                                                                                                                                    the image enhancement
                                                                                                      2500                                                                          by GLAO correction is
                                                                                                                                                                                    illustrated by before
                                                                                                                                                                                    and after images (left)
                                                                                                      2000                                                                          and profiles through the

                                                                                          Intensity
                                                                                                                                                                                    image centres (right).
                                                                                                      1500                                                                          See text for full descrip-
                                                                                                                                                                                    tion.
                                                                                                      1000

                                                                                                       500

                                                                                                                   0
                                                                                                                              0           10    20     30      40     50      60
                                                                                                                                                      Pixels

                       30                                                                                                     30
                                                                           Open loop
                       25                                                  Closed loop                                        25
                                                                                                       Number of occurences
Number of occurences

                       20                                                                                                     20

                       15                                                                                                     15

                       10                                                                                                     10

                        5                                                                                                         5

                        0                                                                                                         0
                            0       5       10       15      20         25        30      35                                          0             1            2              3             4
                                Percentage of ensquared energy in 0.2ೀ spaxel at 750 nm                                                        Ensquared energy gain in 0.2ೀ spaxel at 750 nm

 Figure 10. The distribution of values of ensquared                                                                                                      Figure 11. The distribution of gain in ensquared
 energy per 0.2 arcsecond spaxel with GLAO loop is                                                                                                       energy per 0.2 arcsecond spaxel with GLAO loop
 shown for closed loop (yellow) and open loop (blue;                                                                                                     correction is plotted.
 only with field stabilisation).

 a gain of 2.0 can be obtained about 69 %                             Finally, we could verify that the sensitivity                                      Conclusions: AOF is on-sky!
 of the time, a gain of 1.9 76 % of the time                          of GALACSI was consistent with that
 and a gain of 1.8 83 % of the time. We will                          measured on ASSIST in Garching. The                                                Since March 2017, the AOF has been
 closely follow up how these histograms                               tests were performed on an 18.6 mag­                                               fully installed on UT4. The 4LGSF was the
 evolve as more statistics are collected                              nitude star, the loop was closed and was                                           first AOF component to be bolted onto
 with successive commissioning runs.                                  stable, and the performance was within                                             the t­elescope and it is fully commissioned
                                                                      specification (the specified limiting mag­                                         on-sky (first light was in April 2016). Then
 During one of the commissioning nights,                              nitude of GALACSI is 17.5). Figure 13                                              the new M2 unit (DSM) was installed
 the patch of sky where we pointed                                    shows the raw image on which the loop                                              and replaced the old Dornier M2 unit in
 ­happened to have a nice target in the                               is closed (left), and the resulting images                                         October; since then, the new M2 unit is
  middle, so we couldn’t resist taking                                from averages of 50 frames (centre)                                                routinely being used by the TIOs to make
  images at 850 nm with the commission-                               and 12 000 frames (right). The 50-frames                                           science observations with the suite of
  ing camera (Figure 12). The left-hand                               average will be shown in the GALACSI                                               UT4 instruments. GRAAL was attached
  image of Saturn was taken with field sta-                           display panel, so that the user can                                                to the telescope in late 2016, but will not
  bilisation; the right hand image with                               be confident that the loop is locked on                                            be fully commissioned until the end of
  full GLAO. The seeing was fair (0.8 arc-                            a star.                                                                            2017. Last but not least, GALACSI is
  seconds) and the pointing was almost at                                                                                                                now also available at Paranal. GALACSI
  zenith for these observations.                                                                                                                         WFM commissioning has begun and the

                                                                                                                                                               The Messenger 168 – June 2017                13
Telescopes and Instrumentation                          Arsenault R. et al., The Adaptive Optics Facility

     Mag 18.6 – 1 frame                                50 frames                             12 000 frames or                   Figure 12. (Above) ­S aturn
         @ 200Hz                                        average                              1 minute average                   observed without (left) and with
                                                                                                                          25    (right) GLAO. The insets show the
                                    60                                          35                                              effect of the correction on some
                                    50                                          30                                              stellar images.
                                                                                                                          20
                                    40                                          25
                                    30                                          20                                        15
                                    20                                          15                                              Figure 13. Individual 200 Hz frame
                                                                                                                          10    showing the tip-tilt star s­ ignal (left),
                                    10                                          10
                                                                                                                                with 50 (centre) and 12 000 (right)
                                    0                                           5                                         5     frames averaged. The star magni-
                                    –10                                         0                                               tude is 18.6 and the spaxel size is
                                                                                                                          0     0.2 arcseconds.

performance is found to be extremely                                                                                                        Figure 14. The writing is
                                                                                                                                            on … the sky!
promising so far.

As an anecdote, the AOF team took the
picture shown in Figure 14, illustrating
better than a long speech and without
ambiguity that the AOF is now on sky
(for readers interested in the technical
details, each character is created using
one laser guide star by controlling its
associated 1 kHz jitter mirror; the image
was recorded during a 4 s exposure of
the Laser Pointing Camera installed on
the telescope top ring).

References

Amico, P. et al. 2015, The Messenger, 162, 19
Arsenault, R. et al. 2010, The Messenger, 142, 12
Arsenault, R. et al. 2013a, The Messenger, 151, 14
Arsenault, R. et al. 2013b, Third AO4ELT
  Conference, Florence, Italy                           Briguglio, R. et al. 2014, Proc. SPIE, 9148, 914845    Kuntschner, H. et al. 2012, Proc. SPIE, 8448,
Arsenault, R. et al. 2014a, Proc. SPIE, 9148, 914802    Hackenberg, W. et al. 2014, Proc. SPIE, 9148,            844808
Arsenault, R. et al. 2014b, The Messenger, 156, 2          91483O                                              La Penna, P. et al. 2014, Proc. SPIE, 9148, 91482V
Arsenault, R. et al. 2016, The Messenger, 164, 2        Holzlöhner, R. et al. 2008, Proc. SPIE, 7015, 701521   Manetti, M. et al. 2014, Proc. SPIE, 9148, 91484G
Bonaccini Calia, D. et al. 2014, Proc. SPIE, 9148,      Holzlöhner, R. et al. 2010, A&A, 510, A20              Paufique, J. et al. 2012, Proc. SPIE, 8447, 944738
  91483P                                                Holzlöhner, R. et al. 2012, Proc. SPIE, 8447, 84470H   Stuik, R. et al. 2012, Proc. SPIE, 8447, 84473L

14            The Messenger 168 – June 2017
Telescopes and Instrumentation                                                                              DOI: 10.18727/0722-6691/5020

ESO Public Surveys at VISTA: Lessons learned from
Cycle 1 Surveys and the start of Cycle 2

Magda Arnaboldi 1                             from the ultraviolet (0.33 micron) through     and extended wavelength coverage.
Nausicaa Delmotte1                            to the Ks-band (2.15 microns). In 2012,        These spectrographs will be used for
Dimitri Gadotti 1                             Public Spectroscopic Surveys also              ­follow-up studies of interesting candidates
Michael Hilker 1                              started using the spectrographs Ultra­          identified via their colours and/or morpho-
Gaitee Hussain1                               violet and Visual Echelle Spectrograph,         logical properties from the Public Surveys
Laura Mascetti 2                              UVES, GIRAFFE and the ESO Faint Object          and/or space missions (for example, the
Alberto Micol 1                               Spectrograph and Camera, EFOSC2.                ESA satellite, Gaia, and eROSITA). In the
Monika Petr-Gotzens1                          The spectroscopic surveys were further          current ESO instrument plan, the 4MOST
Marina Rejkuba1                               expanded in 2014 with the addition of           spectrograph will replace the wide field
Jörg Retzlaff 1                               two new surveys on Unit Telescope 3             near-infrared camera, VIRCAM, on VISTA,
Robert Ivison1                                (UT3) using the VIsible MultiObject Spec-       with commissioning being planned for the
Bruno Leibundgut 1                            trograph (VIMOS).                               end of 2020.
Martino Romaniello1
                                              As the first cycle of ESO Public Surveys
                                              with VISTA approached its sixth year           VISTA Cycle 1 surveys: time allocation
1
   ESO                                        of successful telescope operations in          and current status
2
  TERMA GmbH, Europahaus, Darmstadt,         2015, ESO opened the call for submis-
   Germany                                    sion of letters of intent for a second cycle   The first cycle of approved VISTA Public
                                              of Public Surveys to run until the end of      Surveys includes six imaging projects1
                                              2020, the expected date for the decom-         that began observations in April 2010.
The ESO Public Surveys on VISTA serve         missioning of the VISTA InfraRed CAMera        Figure 1 shows the completion fractions
the science goals of the survey teams         (VIRCAM). Thirteen letters of intent were      of the requested time in their observing
while increasing the legacy value of ESO      submitted by the community by the              plans with respect to time. An overview
programmes, thanks to their homoge-           deadline of October 2015; these involved       of each of the Cycle 1 surveys is given in
neity and the breadth of their sky cover-     more than thirteen Principal Investigators     Table 1 along with their full titles and
age in multiple bands. These projects         (PIs) and 517 co-investigators, with an        acronyms; a more complete description
address a variety of research areas:          oversubscription factor of over twice the      of each of these surveys is presented in
from the detection of planets via micro-      total available observing time. The joint      The Messenger 154 (2013).
lensing, to stars, the Milky Way and          VISTA /VST Public Survey Panel (PSP)
Local Group galaxies, to extragalactic        was asked to review these letters to iden-      The overall time allocations for these sur-
astronomy, galaxy evolution, the high-        tify a well-balanced scientific programme       veys are between 1500 and 2200 hours,
redshift Universe and cosmology. In           for VISTA. An important consideration           except for the VHS, which requires 4710
2015, as the first generation of imaging      for the VISTA Cycle 2 Public Surveys was        hours for completion. The VHS takes up
surveys was nearing completion, a             the exploration of scientific and observing     28 % of the allocated telescope time to
­second call for Public Surveys was           parameter space that had not been               date, while about 12 % goes to each one
 opened to define a coherent scientific       ­covered by the previous surveys. These         of the other surveys; additionally Chilean
 programme for VISTA until the com­            recommendations were passed to the             regular and other open-time programmes
 missioning of the wide-field multi-fibre      Observing Programmes Committee                 have been allocated 3 % and 4 % of time
 spectrograph, 4MOST, in 2020. This            (OPC) and the ESO Director General.            respectively. Figure 2 shows a pie chart
 article presents the status of the Cycle 1                                                   summarising the time committed to the
 surveys as well as an overview of the        In this article, we provide an overview of      VISTA surveys between Periods 85 and
 seven new programmes in Cycle 2,             the status of the VISTA imaging surveys         99, as a percentage of the total allocated
 including their science goals, coverage      that started in 2010 and their impact in       ­telescope time.
 on the sky and observing strategies.         terms of data releases and refereed
 We conclude with a forward look at the       ­publications. We then describe the selec-     Based on statistics gathered over three
 Cycle 2 data releases and the timelines       tion process of the new surveys and pro-      years (from October 2012 to September
 for their release.                            vide a summary of their science goals,        2015), the total execution time of suc-
                                               observing strategies, and the content and     cessfully observed OBs from the VISTA
                                               timelines of their planned data releases.     Cycle 1 surveys is 2340 hours per year.
Introduction                                                                                 The time for open and Chilean time
                                              Looking further ahead, the construction        amounts to about 6 % of the total time in
ESO has operated two telescopes that          and deployment of two wide-field spec-         that period. Thus, 2490 hours/year are
are mostly dedicated to Public Surveys        trographs is foreseen: the Multi Object        available for successful observations with
since 2010: namely, the 4-metre Visible       Optical and Near Infrared Spectrograph         VISTA. In 2015, the projected observations
and Infrared Survey Telescope for Astron-     (MOONS; Cirasuolo et al., 2011) and the        for the VISTA Cycle 1 surveys showed
omy (VISTA; Sutherland et al., 2015)          4-metre Multi Object Spectroscopic             that observing time would become availa-
and the 2.6-metre VLT Survey telescope        ­Telescope (4MOST; de Jong, 2011) on the       ble in certain right ascension (RA) ranges;
(VST; Arnaboldi et al., 1998; Capaccioli &     VLT and VISTA respectively. They have         hence the need to release a call for VISTA
Schipani, 2011). These provide coverage        large multiplexing wide field capabilities    Cycle 2 Public Surveys.

                                                                                                  The Messenger 168 – June 2017       15
Telescopes and Instrumentation                                                               Arnaboldi M. et al., ESO Public Surveys at VISTA

                                                                                                                                                                                            Table 1. General obser-
Survey ID,                                                                         Science              Area                     Filters          Magnitude       Observing time to
                                                                                                                                                                                            vational parameters for
title & homepage                                                                   topic                (square degrees)                          limits          1 April 2017 (hours)
                                                                                                                                                                                            the Cycle 1 VISTA Public
UltraVISTA                                                                         Deep high-z                   1.7 Deep           Y J H Ks        25.7 25.5                  1780         Surveys1. The columns
http://home.strw.leidenuniv.nl/~ultravista/                                                                                                         25.1 24.5                               illustrate the Public Sur-
                                                                                                          0.73 Ultra deep           Y J H Ks        26.7 26.6                               vey programme acronym
                                                                                                                                                    26.1 25.6                               (column 1), a broad
                                                                                                                                      NB118              26.0                               ­classification of the sci-
                                                                                                                                                                                             entific goal (column 2),
VHS — VISTA Hemisphere Survey                                                      All sky                         17800            Y J H Ks        21.2 21.1                 4490           the targeted total area
http://www.ast.cam.ac.uk/~rgm/vhs/                                                                                                                  20.6 20.0                                (column 3), the filters
VIDEO — VISTA Deep Extragalactic                                                   Deep high-z                           12       Z Y J H Ks        25.7 24.6                  1799          (column 4), the magni-
Observations Survey                                                                                                                                 24.5 24.0                                tude limits (10σ AB for
http://www-astro.physics.ox.ac.uk/~video                                                                                                                 23.5                                VMC; otherwise 5σ AB)
                                                                                                                                                                                             in the different filters
VVV — VISTA Variables in the Via Lactea                                            Milky Way                         560          Z Y J H Ks        21.9 21.1      2157/Completed            (column 5) and the
http://vvvsurvey.org/                                                                                                                               20.2 18.2                                observing hours com-
                                                                                                                                                         18.1                                pleted up to 1 April 2017
                                                                                                                                                                                             (column 6).
VIKING — VISTA Kilo-Degree Infrared                                                Extragalactic                    1500          Z Y J H Ks        23.1 22.3                 2384
Galaxy Survey                                                                                                                                       22.1 21.5
http://www.astro-wise.org/projects/VIKING/                                                                                                               21.2
VMC — VISTA Magellanic Clouds Survey                                               Resolved SFH                      180              Y J Ks        21.9 21.4                  1759
http://star.herts.ac.uk/~mcioni/vmc/                                                                                                                     20.3

                                 100 %                                                                                                                                                   Chile
                                                                                                                                                                                 Open               UltraVISTA
                                                     VHS                                                                                                                 VMC
Percentage of completion (OB hours)

                                      80 %           VIKING
                                                     VVV
                                                     VMC
                                      60 %           UltraVISTA                                                                                                 VIKING                                           VHS
                                                     VIDEO

                                      40 %

                                                                                                                                                                           VVV
                                      20 %                                                                                                                                                         VIDEO

                                                                                                                                                                Figure 2. Pie chart showing VISTA time allocation to
                                       0%                                                                                                                       the Cycle 1 and 2 surveys, as well as Chilean and
                                                                                                                                                                open time programmes, since Period 85.
                                        9

                                               10

                                                        0

                                                              11

                                                                       1

                                                                             12

                                                                                      2

                                                                                            13

                                                                                                      3

                                                                                                            14

                                                                                                                     4

                                                                                                                            15

                                                                                                                                     5

                                                                                                                                             16

                                                                                                                                                      6
                                                                     /1

                                                                                                                   /1
                                                                                    /1

                                                                                                    /1

                                                                                                                                   /1

                                                                                                                                                    /1
                                                      /1
                                        /0

                                                            5/

                                                                                                          5/
                                                                           5/

                                                                                          5/

                                                                                                                          5/

                                                                                                                                           5/
                                             5/

                                                                   11

                                                                                                                 11
                                                                                  11

                                                                                                  11

                                                                                                                                 11

                                                                                                                                                  11
                                                    11
                                      11

                                                                                                 Date

Figure 1. The percentage completion for the Cycle 1                                          the data centres2, 3, 4 provide for uniform                        science data products for VISTA, which
VISTA Public Surveys with respect to the allocated
                                                                                             data with many astrophysical applica-                              have been superseded by newer prod-
time. Note that completion fractions include the
observations taken during dry runs in 2009. The VVV                                          tions. The VISTA survey data are listed                            ucts but remain available on demand by
completed its observations in October 2015. VIKING                                           on the Phase 3 data release manager                                archive users, for example, for verification
completed observations by the end of 2016, but                                               page5 and can be searched using the                                purposes.
requires the re-observation of a few tiles that were
                                                                                             ESO ­Science Archive Facility6 (SA F,
found to be out of the specified constraints. Ultra-
VISTA, VHS, VMC and VIDEO all had completion                                                 see ­A rnaboldi et al., 2014; Retzlaff et al.,                     Astronomers have access to images,
fractions larger than 90 % by April 2017.                                                    2016).                                                             covering 11 × 103 square degrees area
                                                                                                                                                                in Y-, J- and Ks-bands from VHS, and
                                                                                             Current active releases provide more                               deep images plus ­catalogues from the
                                                                                             than 40 TB of science data products                                UltraVISTA, VIDEO and VIKING surveys.
The scientific impact of the VISTA surveys                                                   from the VISTA Cycle 1 surveys which                               For example, they can extract measure-
and legacy value of the data products                                                        have been delivered by the teams. These                            ments from the billion-source catalogue
                                                                                             products, including calibrated images,                             for stars in the Milky Way bulge from the
The VISTA surveys produce large, coher-                                                      source lists, photometric catalogues and                           VVV survey, or from the light curves of
ent data sets. The constant monitoring of                                                    light curves for multi-epoch observations,                         Cepheid stars in the Magellanic Clouds
the system stability and the observations                                                    are available to the community for their                           in VMC. Community use can be quanti-
of standard stars in combination with the                                                    independent scientific research. There                             fied by means of the downloaded volume
extensive data reductions carried out by                                                     are also approximately 12 TB of additional                         of the VISTA Cycle 1 survey data, and the

16                                             The Messenger 168 – June 2017
You can also read